Initial outline for a national designated spatial plan for the Suur Strait
fixed link and its strategic impact assessment
On 18.06.2020 the Government of Estonia initiated a national designated spatial plan (hereinafter:
plan) and its strategic environmental assessment (hereinafter: SEA) for a fixed link over the Suur Strait.
As a first step, initial outline for the planning procedure and the SEA procedure (hereinafter: initial
outline) has been drawn up. In addition to environmental impacts, socioeconomic and cultural impacts
will be assessed during the planning process.
The initial outline provides an overview of the objectives of the preparation of the plan and serve as
guidelines for the further preparation of the plan and the assessment of impacts of its implementation.
It defines the purpose of planning the fixed connection of the Suur Strait, provide an overview of the
general principles to be followed in the planning process as well as in the implementation of the plan,
summarize the main tasks to be solved in the planning process, map the necessary research and mark
expected significant and relevant impacts, which may be involved in the design of the Suur Strait fixed
link. Task of compiling the pre-selection of the location corridor and structure alternative are
described.
Planning area
Planning area covers both land and sea areas. The planning area on land is located in the territories of
Võiküla village, Kuivastu village, Mõega village, Oina village, Rässa village, Tusti village and Võlla village
in Saare county, Muhu municipality, and in the territories of Virtsu, Hanila village and Esivere village in
Pärnu county, Lääneranna municipality. The marine area covers part of the Suur Strait, which is located
in the Väinameri Conservation Area, which is part of the Natura 2000 network. The size of the planning
area is approx. 9200 ha.
Figure 1. Planning area in Suur Strait.
1
The aim of national designated spatial plan
The purpose of the plan is to increase the competitiveness of the regions and reduce peripherality by
planning a fixed link from the mainland over Suur Strait to Muhu island. The proposed fixed link must
ensure a reliable and efficient connection to achieve economic and demographic balance of the
regions. The uniqueness and natural, social, and cultural specificities of the area must be taken into
account when planning the fixed link.
The most suitable alternative for ensuring a permanent connection - a bridge or a tunnel - is identified
based on the results of research, modern engineering knowledge and the need to ensure a balanced
approach to sectoral interests.
Fixed link alternatives
During the preparation of the plan, it shall be determined whether the establishment of a permanent
connection in the form of a bridge or tunnel is possible in view of the described objectives or whether
it is more sustainable to continue with a ferry connection. The most suitable connection method across
the Suur Strait will be decided by the end of the pre-selection stage of the location of the plan. If the
preference for the alternative of a bridge or tunnel becomes clear, a comprehensive spatial solution
covering the sea area and adjoining land will be prepared for the fixed connection and the buildings
that function operatively with it (light traffic roads, communications, accesses, etc.).
The possibilities for crossing the Suur Strait are:
• Ferry connection (improved)
The significantly improved ferry service is described in the 2011 „Plan for the Prospective
Management of Passengers and Freight across the Suur Strait”1. The improved ferry
connection described in the plan will be completed by 2021. In the first phase of site pre-
selection, a significantly improved alternative to the ferry service needs to be formulated in
cooperation with the relevant authorities.
• Bridge
According to the plan, two main technical solutions have been considered for the bridge: a
cantilever bridge or a cable-stayed bridge. Other solutions were also studied but were not
optimal.
• Tunnel
According to the 2011 plan, a tunnel would be built under the seabed. Two mining techniques
can be used for this purpose: the drilling and blasting method or the drilling method using a
tunnel penetration complex. The immersed tunnel option has not been considered in the 2011
plan, but this will also be considered as a possible alternative to the fixed link in the further
preparation of the national plan.
The 2011 plan and its SEA report compared three fixed connection corridors. These corridors will be
the basis for the preparation of the national plan, but during the process, through results of research
and SEA, additional corridors and alternatives might be additionally considered.
1 The work done in 2011 was carried out for the sole purpose of finding the most optimal solution for a fixed link between mainland and
Muhu island. The final report and its SEA was not officially enforced. The current planning procedure is initiated as a follow-up to officially,
in accordance with the Planning Act, Building Act and other relevant legal acts, select the most optimal solution for crossing Suur Strait.
2
Figure 2. Initial corridor alternatives for Suur Strait fixed link.
Planning procedure and timeline
Figure 3. Timeline of the planning and SEA procedure
3
The compilation of the plan is divided into two stages - the pre-selection stage for the corridor and the
subsequent stage of compiling a detailed solution. During the pre-selection phase, the most suitable
alternative for establishing a fixed link is found. To this end, possible location alternatives for the
corridors are outlined, they are compared on the basis of quantitative and qualitative indicators, and
the location alternative that is most favourable for establishing a fixed link is decided. Sector studies
and impact assessment (environmental, social, economic) provide important input for the choice of
the preferred route alternative. Alternatives to the fixed link (bridge or tunnel) will be assessed against
the background of continuing the ferry service, including the improved ferry service. At the end of the
site pre-selection phase, a decision is made to proceed with the best possible connection, which may
be a bridge or tunnel or a ferry connection.
In the second stage of the plan - compiling a detailed solution - the construction right is determined
for the most suitable fixed link alternative selected in the pre-selection stage and other tasks provided
in the Planning Act are solved, including traffic management conditions, landscaping requirements,
easements, etc. Thus, in the second stage, a plan is prepared in the level of a detailed plan, which is
the basis for the preparation of the construction project. In parallel with the preparation of the detailed
solution, a design project will be prepared for the most suitable alternative to the fixed link and an
impact assessment will be carried out. The purpose of the impact assessment here is to assess the
effects of a specific technical solution and to develop mitigation measures.
Research and analyses
During the preparation of the plan, a number of studies and analyses will be carried out to select route
alternatives, compare them and assess the effects of the proposed activities. Research is differentiated
according to whether the surveys are necessary for corridor selection or the detailed solution.
In the location selection phase, research is needed to be convinced that the chosen location alternative
is the most suitable to ensure a permanent connection.
Research to be carried out during site selection:
• Traffic forecast
• Geological study
• Study of marine mammals
• Study of amphibians and reptiles
• Study of fish and fisheries
• Study of bats
• Study of birds
• Terrestrial mammal survey
• Study of terrestrial plants
• Economic and financial impact assessment
• Noise survey
• Vibration study
• Social and cultural impact assessment
• Seabed biota and habitat survey
• Air pollution study
• Underwater noise assessment
• Water column measurements and modelling
• Visualization
• Underwater archaeological research
4
More detailed research and analyses or additional research may be carried out during the detailed
planning phase – the second stage of the planning procedure. The necessity and terms of references
for that research will be established during the site selection phase of the planning and SEA procedure.
The impact assessment is carried out at a level of accuracy corresponding to the level of accuracy of
the preparation of the plan. The impact assessment of the detailed solution is carried out at the
accuracy level of the environmental impact assessment (EIA). In the planning process, the impact
assessment monitors whether the implementation of the planned activities supports the achievement
of strategic objectives and whether the planned activity entails any appropriate impacts. Considering
the different degrees of accuracy at the site selection stage and at the stage of a detailed solution,
appropriate measures will be taken at both stages to contribute to the achievement of strategic
objectives or to prevent, reduce or mitigate relevant effects, to remedy and, if necessary, to monitor
them. In addition, the planning process pays close attention to the relevant positive impact and the
possibilities for amplifying them.
Possible cross-border environmental impacts cannot be ruled out at this stage. The proposed activities
(depending on the alternative) may affect the migratory routes of birds and the habitats and routes of
seals (including ringed seals). It is also an EBSA (Ecologically or Biologically Significant Area) area within
the framework of the UNITED NATIONS Convention on Biological Diversity.
Future activities and timeline
STAGE ACTIVITY INITIAL DEADLINE
Public display of initial outline July – August 2021
INITIAL Public discussions of initial outline October 2021
OUTLINE OF
THE PLAN Invitation to present proposals regarding the initial
November – December 2021
AND SEA outline of the pre-selection of the location and the SEA
Approval of initial outline March 2022
Procurements for planning, SEA and research March 2022 – March 2023
Sketching of corridors September 2022 – December 2022
Methodology for corridor comparison January – March 2023
In parallel with the planning and SEA
Design project for alternatives
PRE- process
SELECTION
Research and analyses March 2022 – December 2024
OF THE
LOCATION Planning report on pre-selection of sites April 2023 – May 2025
Impact assessment April 2023 – May 2025
Public displays and discussions, consultations with
June 2025 – June 2026
authorities, including international consultations
Approval of site selection October 2026
DETAILED Preparation of a detailed planning solution for the
January 2027 – December 2029
SOLUTION selected site and its impact assessment
5
Keskkonnaministeerium
[email protected] Meie 29.04.2022 nr 15-5/3784-1
Suure väina püsiühenduse riigi
eriplaneeringu piiriülese
keskkonnamõju esinemise
võimalikkusest naaberriikide
teavitamine
Austatud härra Heinma
Vabariigi Valitsus algatas 18.06.2020 korraldusega nr 213 Suure väina püsiühenduse ja selle
toimimiseks vajaliku taristu riigi eriplaneeringu koostamisel ning selle mõjude hindamise, sh
keskkonnamõju strateegilise hindamise.
01.04.2022 valmis Rahandusministeeriumil riigi eriplaneeringu esimese etapina Suure väina
püsiühenduse riigi eriplaneeringu lähteseisukohad ja selle elluviimisega kaasnevate mõjude
hindamise väljatöötamise kavatsuse dokument. Töö koostamise käigus ilmnes, et
püsiühenduse võimalike alternatiivide puhul (sild või tunnel) ei saa välistada rahvusvahelist
(naaberriikide) huvi kavandatava Suure väina püsiühenduse vastu seoses võimaliku piiriülese
keskkonnamõjuga. Eelkõige tuleb selle all mõelda erinevaid silla lahendusi, mis võivad
mõjutada lindude rändeteid ning hüljeste (sh ohustatud liigi viigerhülge) elupaiku ja
liikumisteid. Kas eriplaneeringuga kavandatava tegevusega (sõltuvalt alternatiivist) võib
naaberriikidele kaasneda oluline piiriülene keskkonnamõju, tuleb välja selgitada mõju
hindamise käigus ja see selgub esmajoones erinevate valdkonnaekspertide hinnangutest.
Arvestades eeltoodud aspekte, on asjakohane, et ettevaatusprintsiibist lähtuvalt teavitatakse
naaberriike ja tehakse nendega koostööd. Piiriülese keskkonnamõju esinemise korral näeb
keskkonnamõju hindamise ja keskkonnajuhtimissüsteemi seadus ette naaberriikide
võimalikult varajast teavitamist. Käesolevas etapis ei ole selle esinemise kohta piisavalt infot,
kuid samas ei saa piiriülest keskkonnamõju praegu üheselt välistada ning soovitav on
naaberriike kavandatavast tegevusest teavitada.
Palume Keskkonnaministeeriumil Suure väina püsiühenduse riigi eriplaneeringuga
kavandatavast tegevusest teavitada Rootsit, Soomet, Lätit ja Leedut ning edastada neile kirja
lisas olev Suure väina püsiühenduse riigi eriplaneeringu kohta käiv inglise keelne kokkuvõte.
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 611 3558 /
[email protected] / www.rahandusministeerium.ee
registrikood 70000272
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Kaia Sarnet
regionaalvaldkonna asekantsler
Lisa: Suure väina püsiühenduse riigi eriplaneeringu kokkuvõte
Siim Orav 611 3233
[email protected]
2