Ref. Ares(2022)3299998 - 28/04/2022
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
Report by the Wise Persons Group on the Reform of the EU Customs Union – Brussels March 2022
1
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 1 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
INDEX
Letter from the Wise Persons .............................................................................................................................. 3
Introduction....................................................................................................................................................... 6
The Customs Union We Want.............................................................................................................................. 9
The Customs Union Today ................................................................................................................................ 11
1. The Customs Union: over 50 years powering the European Single Market ............................................................................................................... 11
2. The Customs Union has undergone reforms over time .............................................................................................................................................. 15
3. However, the Customs Union has not evolved at the same pace as the transformations in the world economy.................................................... 16
4. How did we get here? The root causes of this problem............................................................................................................................................... 20
5. The Urgent Need for Structural Change ...................................................................................................................................................................... 23
Ten Recommendations for a “Moon-Shot” for Customs .................................................................................... 27
Appendix 1: Glossary ....................................................................................................................................... 36
Appendix 2: Timeline for implementation......................................................................................................... 37
Appendix 3: Summary of Public Consultation.................................................................................................... 38
Appendix 4: Summary of the hearings of invited experts................................................................................... 41
Appendix 5: Estimation of taxes collected at the EU borders.............................................................................. 48
2
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 2 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
LETTER FROM THE WISE PERSONS
T
he words of European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen back in However, despite the overall success of the Customs Union, the world economy,
2019 “It is time to take the customs union to the next level, equipping it with international trade and geopolitics have evolved in a dramatic way and have in fact
a stronger framework that will allow us to better protect our citizens and our moved on much faster than the adaptations of the Customs Union. Security and safe-
single market” resonate strongly today as the EU mounts a resolute response against ty concerns have risen to the fore. Brexit and the Covid-19 pandemic have been two
Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. accelerators of these changes. Evidence gathered by the Wise Persons Group on Cus-
toms shows that dangerous, non-compliant products still enter the EU market every
By sharing one external border with third countries, the EU’s Customs Union is the day and that we leave billions of Customs duties and taxes uncollected. The reality
foundation of its single market and its might in international trade. Under existing is also that European Customs do not yet currently function “as one”. This leaves the
arrangements, responsibility for customs policy is at the level of the European Union Customs Union at the mercy of its weakest link. Incremental changes introduced over
whereas implementation and controls on the ground are the responsibility of Mem- the years were necessary and our group notes the real and important efforts made
ber States. Customs facilitate legitimate trade, collect customs revenues, and protect in recent years to strengthen both the legal and technical framework for customs
European citizens against safety and security risks including smuggling, crime, ter- administration, which will make a difference to the strength of the Customs Union.
rorism and illicit financial flows. Nonetheless, in a fast-changing world, these are insufficient to address the scale of
the challenges faced by Customs. The Customs Union is not “fit for purpose”.
Since its birth in 1968 the Customs Union has seen changes both in the form of legis-
lative reforms – through the Union Customs Code – as well as common investments This report identifies the root causes of the problem:
in IT to better connect European customs. More recently, the EU has significantly
increased its budget to finance investments in IT infrastructure and equipment for First, the last decade has witnessed major changes in trade and technology, which
national customs. Customs have also benefited from national reforms to help them have exacerbated pre-existing difficulties. The volumes of trade have significantly in-
cope with change. Customs have demonstrated incredible responsiveness to address creased, and the nature of trade has changed with the expansion of e-commerce in
the challenges generated by Brexit and the COVID-19 crisis. the form of millions of small packages to be processed at the EU borders.
Customs are essential also in managing crises at the European borders, as we see Second, the expectations on Customs’ role have evolved from those related to rev-
today. They are the custodians of many of the sanctions imposed on third countries, enue collection to include citizens demands to ensure that the values that they cher-
such as the recent ones on Russia and Belarus. By working together with other bor- ish - sustainability, safety, human rights, health – as well as security concerns are
der agencies and law enforcement authorities, Customs today protect European bor- upheld, and in recent years this trend has been accelerating.
ders against risks related to the war in Ukraine and help facilitate the delivery of hu-
manitarian support. A strong Customs Union with a protective “one external border”
is essential to Europe’s strategic autonomy and to Europe’s security and defence.
3
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 3 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
Third, the vast majority of – if not all – stakeholders interviewed for this report com- among administrations, and better used for EU risk management. Clarify which private
plain about a systematic absence of common implementation of customs measures, actors – including e-commerce platforms - must provide data, with costs for non-com-
different control practices across border entry points, both within and across Mem- pliance. Provide businesses with a single data entry point for customs formalities and
ber states, differences in control priorities, and differences in methods and sanctions a single window/portal.
for non-compliance. These challenges speak of 27 borders rather than one common
border. The poor availability and quality of the data submitted to Customs and the 3/ Set up a comprehensive framework for cooperation, including data sharing between
insufficient level of data sharing across Customs and with other administrations has European Customs, with Market Surveillance Authorities, other Law Enforcement
led to fragmentation and makes it extremely difficult to properly manage risks at both bodies and tax authorities for a comprehensive management of risks at EU level.
national and EU level. Finally, investments in Customs capacity have not followed the
4/ A European Customs Agency should be set up to provide EU value-added services
pace and size of increasing requirements placed on them.
to the Commission and the Member States. Its governance should respect the
These shortcomings call for an urgent structural change, which, building on the existing allocation of competences.
reforms already undertaken, would bring the Customs to the next level. The recom-
5/ Introduce a System-Based Approach centred on a reformed Authorised Economic
mendations contained in this report constitute a sort of “moonshot” – a highly am-
Operator scheme expanded in scope, multi-layered and more effective, to better
bitious programme – to ensure the Customs Union is fit for a more geopolitical world
facilitate trade with confidence.
in which revenue is secured, trade is easy, fair, sustainable and safe, and citizens are
protected against security risks. 6/ Build a new framework of Responsibility and Trust: an ABC model (Authorised,
Bonded or subject to greater Control), in which operators would seek Authorised
We make ten recommendations, which, taken together, address the two main short-
Economic Operators status to gain commercial access to the EU market. Failing this,
comings we have identified – how to manage electronic commerce and how to ensure
a bond provided to an AEO, against which the EU authorities may levy a significant
a strong management of EU-wide risks. In doing so, we have respected the existing
charge for mis-declaration or rule breaches. Small non-commercial consignments
allocation of competences in the EU. They comprise the following:
would continue to be sent through the usual processes, but without priority and
1/ The European Commission should by the end of 2022 table a package of reform subject to a level of controls that reflects their “non-trusted” status.
proposals, including of the Union Customs Code, implementing the recommenda-
7/ Remove the customs duty exemption threshold of EUR 150 for e-commerce
tions contained in this report, relating to processes, responsibilities and liabilities,
and provide some simplification for the application of Customs duties rates for
and governance of the European Customs Union.
low value shipments.
2/ A new approach to data: rather than relying principally on customs declarations,
introduce a new approach to data, focussed on obtaining better quality data based
on commercial sources, ensuring it is cross-validated along the chain, better shared
4
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 4 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
8/ Implement a package of measures to green EU Customs.
9/ Properly resource, skill and equip Customs to ensure their capacity to fulfil their MEMBERS OF CUSTOMS WISE PERSONS GROUP
missions.
Chair: Mrs. Arancha González Laya, Dean of Paris School of International Affairs
10/ Introduce an annual Customs Revenue Gap Report based on an agreed meth- and former Minister of Foreign Affairs, European Union and Cooperation of Spain.
odology and data framework to better manage Customs revenues collection. Vice chair: Mrs Mateja Vraničar Erman, Adviser to the Slovenian Minister of
Foreign Affairs and former Minister of Finance of Slovenia.
These recommendations – taken as a package given the manner in which they are
inter-related – would provide for the resilient Customs Union that the EU needs. Mr Emmanuel Barbe, Préfet at French Ministry of the Interior and former Deputy
Secretary General for European Affairs at the French Prime Minister´s office.
Our task ends here and now is the time for the European Commission, Member
States and the European Parliament, within their respective roles and prerogatives, Mrs Manon van Beek, CEO of TenneT.
to show political leadership and expeditiously follow up on these recommendations, Mr Kevin Cardiff, non-executive Director at KBC Bank Ireland, former Member
for which we are proposing a timetable. We thank Commissioner Gentiloni for the of the European Court of Auditors and former Secretary General of the Finance
trust he has placed in us and stand ready to provide support in taking forward these Department of Ireland.
recommendations.
Mr Martti Hetemäki, Professor at the Helsinki Graduate School of Economics and
former Secretary of State at Ministry of Finance of Finland.
Mrs Vendulka Holá, former Deputy Director General of the Czech Customs.
Mrs Katarína Kaszasová, Managing Director of the Auditing Oversight Authority of
Slovakia and former Director General at the Slovak Ministry of Finance.
Mrs Gerda Koszinowski, Head of Directorate at the German Central Customs
Authority.
Mr Kris Peeters, Vice-President of the European Investment Bank (EIB) and
former Deputy Prime Minister of Belgium.
Mr Sérgio Vasques, Professor at Universidade de Lisboa and former Secretary of
State for Tax Affairs in Portugal.
Mr Vincenzo Alfonso Visco, President of Nuova Economia Nuova Società (NENS)
and former Minister of Finance of Italy.
5
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 5 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
INTRODUCTION
I n her Agenda for Europe, the European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen
identified the reform of the Customs Union as a political priority for her mandate
The group also considered the stakeholders’ comments received via the open public
consultation as well as a series of reports that have been recently published, includ-
ing the foresight exercise Customs2040 by the European Commission2 and the report
“It is time to take the customs union to the next level, equipping it with a stronger on Customs controls by the European Court of Auditors.3
framework that will allow us to better protect our citizens and our single market. I will
propose a bold package for an integrated European approach to reinforce customs risk The present report looks at the success of the Customs Union in providing the foun-
management and support effective controls by the Member States”.1 dations to the Single Market and to the EU´s formidable international trade perform-
ance. An efficient Customs Union is fundamental to protect citizens from non-com-
In September 2021, Paolo Gentiloni, EU Commissioner for Economy, invited a Wise pliant and dangerous goods, to remove from the EU market goods that do not meet
Persons Group on Challenges facing the Customs Union to provide innovative European environmental and labour standards, to protect European companies from
ideas and suggestions on how to tackle the challenges facing the Customs Union. unfair competition, to protect the EU and Member States’ budgets, to contribute to
The present report is addressed to the Commission, through Commissioner the Green and Digital transitions. In sum, to contribute to Europe’s prosperity and
Gentiloni, to the European Parliament and to the Council for their consideration. security and to building its strategic autonomy.
The Wise Persons Group composed of twelve members from across the EU audi- However, a combination of forces is today putting these objectives at risk. A number
tioned representatives of relevant stakeholders during more than 50 hours to identify of external factors such as the changing volumes and nature of trade with the ex-
challenges and possible recommendations. The Group has conducted hearings with plosion of e-commerce, advances in technology, increased expectations on security,
a wide range of public and private sectors’ experts, including online platforms, con- safety and sustainability by Europeans, geopolitical tensions and conflicts, constitute
sumers associations, NGOs, seaports, airports, postal operators and express courier priorities to be urgently addressed by Customs. At the same time, intrinsic character-
companies, logistics companies, academics, international organisations (WTO, WCO, istics of the Customs Union, such as its fragmented governance, weight on its capacity
World Bank), third countries Customs Administrations, as well as EU Member States to adapt to those changes.
and European Commission’s services.
1) V on der Leyen, Ursula (2019), A Union that Strives for More – My agenda for Europe, https://www.europarl.europa.eu/resources/library/media/20190716RES57231/20190716RES57231.pdf , page 16.
2) European Commission, Joint Research Centre, Ghiran, A., Hakami, A., Bontoux, L., et al., The future of customs in the EU 2040: a foresight project for EU policy, Publications Office, 2020, https://data.
europa.eu/doi/10.2760/978164
3) European Court of Auditors (2021), Special Report 04/2021: Customs controls: insufficient harmonisation hampers EU financial interests, https://www.eca.europa.eu/en/Pages/DocItem.aspx?did=58256
6
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 6 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
In the last years, a set of incremental reforms have been adopted, which although
helpful, have been insufficient to address these fundamental transformations that
have accelerated with Covid and Brexit and have taken a new meaning with the war
in Ukraine. Customs’ transformation has lagged in comparison with other policy
areas such as police and justice, which have put more Union at their core. As a result,
we are approaching the limits of the current incremental approach. There is a need
for systemic change both in terms of Customs processes and in putting more Union
in the European Customs. This is today an urgent matter of strategic sovereignty and
reinforced resilience.
The COVID crisis, Brexit and the war in Ukraine show the crucial role that Customs
play in protecting the European borders and contributing to its strategic autonomy.
This is the time to go for an ambitious reform that will help Customs better deal with
crises and protect citizens against security threats, that will be future-proof and that
will contribute to the twin green and digital transitions. This report is intended to be
a catalyst for systemic change, centred around a set of recommendations for the Cus-
toms Union of the future and for the national Customs and other agencies working to
protect the EU´s borders while facilitating trade, EU competitiveness and structural
changes wished for by EU citizens. Their horizon is 2030.
7
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 7 30/03/22 09:21
The Customs
Union
We Want
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 8 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
The Customs Union We Want Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
THE CUSTOMS UNION WE WANT
I
n these troubled geopolitical times, the EU is committed to build its strategic Customs must also be future-proof by making today the investments that will al-
sovereignty and reinforce its resilience. Protecting the European borders low Europe to have the capacity and the tools to respond to long-term challenges.
through the strengthening of the Customs Union would be an important
contribution toward this endeavour. More broadly, Customs must contribute to the Green Deal and Digital Transition by
ensuring the effective implementation of the EU´s legislation on sustainability and
The EU crucially depends on a well-functioning Customs Union to protect its cit- climate change and by contributing to emissions reduction through more stream-
izens against harmful and dangerous products, to maintain the integrity of the lined customs procedures, among others; the digitalisation of customs would reflect
internal market, to promote an ambitious trade agenda with third country part- the EU´s choice for making this transformation work for people and business; final-
ners, to ensure a level playing field for business and to collect revenues for EU and ly Customs should also contribute to EU business competitiveness by ensuring
Member States’ budgets. The success of the EU ambitions related to people’s wel- a level playing field between domestic and foreign economic operators, for which
fare, sustainable societies and trade prosperity may be jeopardised if Customs fail a public-private partnership approach would be crucial.
to properly protect the EU border at all its entry points. The Union’s border is as
strong as its weakest entry point. Finally, a reformed European Customs Union can lead the way internationally
to promote global reforms of customs rules and procedures.
To effectively respond to these expectations, the Customs Union needs to guar-
antee having one European customs border – instead of 27 – that provides better
protection for European citizens, ensures seamless trade and improves effective
revenue collection.
To fulfil its mission, Customs must be resilient, future-proof and make their full
contribution to the EU policy agenda such as the Green Deal, Digitalisation, and the
EU business competitiveness.
It must be resilient to crises, to sudden increases of volumes of goods and rapid
changes of trade patterns. It must also be capable to respond to new demands
stemming from the need to protect EU core values and principles.
9
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 9 30/03/22 09:21
The Customs
Union Today
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 10 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
The Customs Union Today Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
THE CUSTOMS UNION TODAY
1. THE CUSTOMS UNION: OVER 50 YEARS POWERING THE EUROPEAN The European Commission also organises the framework of cooperation with Market
SINGLE MARKET Surveillance Authorities and their interactions with Customs. A similar role is played
by the European Commission to organise the cooperation between Customs and rel-
The Customs Union was one of the European Union’s earliest achievements and re- evant Law Enforcement authorities. Customs are a vital partner for the European Po-
mains a crucial asset in the global environment of the 21st century. Born in 1968, lice Office, Europol, in battling organised crime. To that aim, they also liaise with the
it means that all EU members apply the same tariffs to goods imported into their European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF), with Frontex, the European border and coast guard
territory from the rest of the world and apply no tariffs internally among themselves. agency, and with Eurojust, the European network of judicial authorities that underpins
They also apply a common set of rules to handle the trade of goods that arrive, leave, European cooperation on criminal justice cases. The recent creation of the European
or transit via the European Union´s borders and they have completely removed all Public Prosecutor’s Office increases their duty to cooperate. Finally, the European
controls in trade between them. The fact that goods can enter the EU market through Commission also works with Customs to ensure the collection of own resources.
any point also means that controls at that entry point by a national Customs author-
ity is de facto done on behalf of all Member States. The Customs Union is the basis of Implementation of Customs Union rules is the responsibility of Member States.
the EU’s internal market, allowing goods to move freely internally by controlling their Over 90,000 customs officers working in more than 2,000 customs offices across the
external import and export. Non-EU Member States like Monaco and San Marino are EU Member States, manage the day-to-day operations, in the spirit of acting as if they
also part of the Customs Union, as are partly Andorra and Turkey. were one.4
Responsibility for Customs policy is at the level of the European Union: it is one Implementing the Customs Union relies on close partnerships with and between
of the exclusive competences of the EU. The European Commission proposes EU Cus- Member States, including primarily national Customs but also on other actors such
toms legislation and monitors its implementation. The main vehicle to do this is the as Market Surveillance Authorities and Law Enforcement Authorities.
Union Customs Code (UCC). It also works to ensure the development and implemen-
tation of IT systems and training materials, the effective interconnection of national Customs are responsible for revenue collection: Traditionally, national Customs
Customs administrations and the coordination of Customs laboratories. The Com- offices collect customs duties and indirect taxes at import (excise duties, VAT and
mission proposes legislation both on fiscal and non-fiscal matters and supervises its other national indirect taxes and duties). Import duties remain an important
implementation which is more structured for fiscal matters. source of income for the EU.
4) https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/customs-4/eu-customs-union-facts-and-figures/eu-customs-union-unique-world_en..
11
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 11 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
The Customs Union Today Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
In 2020, close to EUR 25 billion were collected in customs duties, of which about EUR CUSTOMS AND OWN RESOURCES
20 billion went to the EU budget, representing around 11 % of it.5 In total, an esti-
mated EUR 82.8 billion were collected in taxes and duties on imports, including B2C Customs protects the EU and Member States’ budgets by ensuring the ef-
VAT.6 This highlights the broader financial interest of Member States to have efficient fective collection of own resources8, a revenue flowing automatically to the
border controls. European Union budgets. They include
(a) The traditional own resources,
The role of customs has evolved over time to cover controls related to the safety and
security of European citizens. Customs officers supervise goods traffic in the EU, mainly (b) The own resources based on value added tax (VAT), and
at external borders, which means seaports, airports, and land border crossing points, but
(c) The own resources based on GNI.
also within the EU territory. By so doing, they protect consumers from non-compliant,
dangerous and counterfeited goods, from health hazards, or from animal diseases. They Traditional own resources include mostly customs duties on goods imported into
prevent accidents and provide a first line of defence against risks in the supply chain, the EU as well as levies and anti-dumping duties. Member States are allowed to
including the fight against organised crime, smuggling, drug trafficking and terrorism. In keep 25 % of customs duties for administration costs and to serve as an incentive
fact, security aspects were first introduced into EU customs legislation in the aftermath of to ensure a diligent collection of the amounts due. The remaining part goes to the
the terrorist attacks in September 2001 in the United States.7 Customs are indeed vital to EU budget. The Commission has a supervisory role in the proper collection of own
counter the resurgence of terrorist threats. Among those, the use of containers to smuggle resources, supporting the reinforcement of customs controls to combat fraud, and
nuclear material or radiological devices could have devastating direct effects and would carrying out audits and inspections in the Member States to ensure that the col-
bring international trade to a halt. Imported goods sold in Europe, from toys to food and lection of traditional own resources is carried out in accordance with EU customs
medicines, are safer thanks to Customs. Customs also keep an eye on sensitive exports legislation, the financial rules laid down in the Own Resources Decision (Council
such as dual use goods or cultural products. Furthermore, as part of the EU’s respons- Decision No 2020/2053) and the Council Regulation on implementing measures
ibility towards the rest of the world, they also prevent illegal exports of waste. Indeed, for own resources. Moreover, Member States are financially responsible for any
protecting the environment features among the many tasks performed by Customs. This losses due to possible administrative errors on their side. An additional layer of
includes for example controlling trade in rare species of animals as well as exotic timber control is ensured by the European Court of Auditors. The European Anti-Fraud
from endangered forests. This role will be greatly expanded under environmental and Office, which is part of the European Commission, further investigates fraud
social legislation being considered in Europe, in particular a European carbon border against the EU budget. The European Public Prosecutor’s Office has competence
adjustment mechanism and a ban on products made by child and forced labour. to investigate, prosecute and bring to judgment crimes against the EU budget.
5) https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/customs-4/eu-customs-union-facts-and-figures/customs-duties-mean-revenue_en
6) See appendix.
7) https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/customs-4/customs-security/customs-security_en
8) https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/default/files/about_the_european_commission/eu_budget/eu-budget-glossary-2019_en.pdf
12
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 12 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
The Customs Union Today Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
Customs cooperate with Market Surveillance Authorities. These authorities are a con- That means close to 33 items declared every second for a customs value of about
stellation of more than 600 bodies, placed under the responsibility of a dozen con- EUR 150,000. In 2020, the four main trading partners (China, US, UK, and Switzerland)
cerned national Ministries – from environment to industry or health - with a regulatory account for half of EU external trade. The largest part of this trade is done by sea (over
framework that depends on the topic, and with limited cooperation among them. There 50 %), followed by air (around 30 %) and road (around 20 %).9
are two main regimes for controlling goods – food and health products, and non-food
products. In the former – more uniform, centralised and largely digitalised with cen- The European Commission, together with Member States and in a dialogue with the
tralised IT systems – Sanitary and Phyto-Sanitary authorities and EU-level inspectors business community, has made efforts to simplify and harmonise customs proced-
execute the whole or most of the elements of controls and they notify Customs when ures, it has helped Customs automatise and it has worked to advance a one-stop-
a consignment can be released. In the non-food sector – less uniform – controls are shop for traders. Trusted traders that make specific efforts related to customs com-
generally carried out by Customs, and Market Surveillance Authorities are notified by pliance, record-keeping, financial solvency and security and safety standards may
Customs of suspected non-compliance and serious risks and take a decision that will apply for certification as ‘Authorised Economic Operators’ (AEO) and hereby benefit
then be enforced by Customs. Customs control priorities at EU borders remain defined from simpler procedures.10
at national level and there is no prioritization at the EU level.
The Customs Union also has an important international dimension. EU rules relat-
Customs also play a vital role in collecting trade statistics, essential to the proper ed to the Customs Union are framed by the relevant international disciplines of the
understanding and management of our economies. World Trade Organisation (WTO) and the World Customs Organisation (WCO). The
numerous trade agreements negotiated by the EU also contain provisions related to
For businesses involved in international trade, the Customs Union means the cooperation in the area of Customs with third countries.
promise of common and streamlined procedures across the EU. Regardless of
where in the EU the goods are declared, common rules should be applied in the same The Customs Union is therefore a key pillar of the EU´s Single Market and trade suc-
way and, once the goods have cleared customs, they can circulate freely or be sold cess contributing to create jobs and growth and protecting citizens and EU businesses.
anywhere within the EU Customs territory. Customs are at the heart of this success. The dedication and flexibility of Customs offi-
cers have been key to this success. They have also been crucial to the management of
The EU is the world’s largest trading block, accounting for about 15 % of world trade, two recent major disruptions in trade: the Covid-19 pandemic and the impact of Brexit.
worth close to EUR 4 trillion. So, in global terms, the EU Customs Union is a heavy- They are today being challenges by geopolitical tensions, including the war in Ukraine.
weight in international trade. Its negotiating position thus outweighs that of any
single Member State acting on its own. Each year, close to 700 million items enter A group of Customs are moving ahead in establishing a structured operational
the EU, more than 350 million are declared for export to third countries and another coordination around a central service provider: 11 Member States have decided to
15 million transit via the Customs Union. structure their operational coordination on Customs matters by setting up CELBET.
9) https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/customs-4/eu-customs-union-facts-and-figures/eu-customs-union-unique-world_en
10) https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/authorised-economic-operator-aeo_en
13
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 13 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
The Customs Union Today Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
NON UNION GOODS UNION GOODS
Other goods ▶ wholly (or partially) obtained/produced in the
customs territory of the Union (CTU) or;
▶ brought into the CTU from third country and released
for free circulation.
1. DISPATCH OF GOODS IN THIRD COUNTRY
The different IT systems are often not interconnected
PRE-ARRIVAL/ENTRY
Security
Goods brought into the customs territory of the EU have to be covered by an entry SUMMARY DECLARATION (ENS) to be lodged by the
2. carrier at the customs office of first entry before the arrival of the goods. The time-limits and data elements required depend on the mode
and safety
risk
of transport. The ENS has to be lodged in the ICS2 system.
analysis
Data are not transferred from a declaration
ARRIVAL OF THE MEANS OF TRANSPORT
3. The operator must inform the customs office of first entry of its arrival (NOTIFICATION OF ARRIVAL). Depending on the Member States it
can be done via the port system or another system.
PRESENTATION OF THE GOODS/TEMPORARY STORAGE
4. Goods have to be presented to the Customs Authority. There are several ways of presenting the goods: VIA A TEMPORARY STORAGE
DECLARATION (for non-union goods), through a CUSTOMS DECLARATION (if goods are placed under a customs procedure) or via a PROOF
OF UNION STATUS (for union goods). Non-Union goods, are held in temporary storage and remain under customs supervision of the
Customs Authority where the goods have been unloaded, until they are placed under a customs procedure or re-exported.
TRANSIT, IF APPLICABLE Risk
5. When non EU-goods need to move from the temporary storage place to another place(e.g. to clear the goods at another place), it can be done analysis
in several ways. One of them is via the transit procedure. A TRANSIT DECLARATION must be filled in in the transit system. on transit
PLACING GOODS UNDER A CUSTOMS PROCEDURE
to another
When the operator chooses to place the goods under a customs procedure, a CUSTOMS DECLARATION MUST BE LODGED. A regular import
will be covered by the release for free circulation procedure (standard procedure) and the declaration must be lodged in the declaration Risk
system of the Member States where the goods are cleared (27 different systems). The UCC foresees also the use of special procedures such as analysis on
transit, storage, specific use and processing, depending on the needs of the operator. financial
6. The TYPE AND NUMBER OF DATA ELEMENTS NEEDED in the declaration will depend on the type of customs procedure chosen and the risks, P&R,
level of simplifications granted to the operator. Information in the standard declaration are related to the goods, the transport, the value, remaining
the accompanying documents, the calculation of taxes and duties and the seller and the buyer. security
The Customs Authority will calculate the applicable CUSTOMS DUTIES based on the customs value of the goods, the origin of goods and the and safety
applicable tariff. A financial cover is required to ensure the collection of the customs duties and other charges. Customs authorities will verify issues
that the goods COMPLY WITH EU CUSTOMS AND OTHER EU LEGISLATION.
14
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 14 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
The Customs Union Today Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
2. THE CUSTOMS UNION HAS UNDERGONE REFORMS OVER TIME
CELBET: COOPERATION IN ACTION Over the years Customs have engaged in reforms to adapt to changing circumstances.
Customs Eastern and South-Eastern Land Border Expert Team (CELBET) is an initiative
One of them was the modernisation of Customs rules through the adoption of the
of 11 EU Member States: Finland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Hungary, Slo-
Union Customs Code (UCC)11, together with its corresponding Delegated and Imple-
vakia, Croatia, Romania, Bulgaria and Greece under the Customs 2020 programme.
menting Acts. The UCC package entered into force on 1st May 2016, replacing the
The main objective of the expert team is to strengthen and improve operational previous framework for Customs legislation. The UCC aims at modernising and sim-
co-operation using a new way of working, deeper sharing of information and pooling plifying Customs procedures and offering more uniformity to businesses. The UCC
of human resources. is accompanied by an ambitious IT Work Programme to better connect Customs.
While the substantive provisions of the UCC entered into force on 1st May 2016, a
The Expert Team uses work done by various project groups, elaborating these out-
transition period (now lasting until 31st December 2025) was introduced to fully
comes further to achieve synergy between different activities at the regional level.
implement the required IT transformations.
The expert team, working under the supervision of DG TAXUD, provides expertise to
member Customs and makes proposals based on practical experience of operation- By engaging in the UCC reform, Member States and the European Commission have
al co-ordination and results achieved for further improvement of the operational shown their ability to partner to implement much needed reforms. In addition, and
management of EU Eastern and South-Eastern land border. to support these reforms, the budget allocated for the transformation of Customs
More specifically, the expert team provides solutions for better targeting of risks, has increased to EUR 2 billion in the Multiannual Financial Framework 2021-2027,
uniform performance measurement standards, flexible use and sharing of resources, to cover IT costs and a new customs control equipment programme.
training of customs officers, interaction and coordination with relevant border services
The forthcoming evaluation of the UCC underlines that the possibilities for synergies
(including those of third, neighbouring countries) and last, but not least, addressing
need to be more exploited, including interoperability of systems and complementar-
funding challenges related with control infrastructure and equipment.
ity of rules especially in the field of non-fiscal risks where goods must show compli-
CELBET helps to improve the control of external border and preventing the entry of ance at the border with legislation that is formulated by other actors than Customs.
dangerous goods that could be harmful to people or to our environment or to the It also underlines the need for increased cooperation at both national and EU level.
EU’s, the Member States’ and citizens’ financial interest. The improved controls also
contribute to smoother and faster border crossing. In 2020, the Commission services, with the expertise of its Joint Research Centre, have
engaged with Member States and other stakeholders in a discussion on “The future of
The expert team is working in six areas: risk management, customs controls, equip-
customs in the EU 2040 – A foresight project for EU policy”.
ment and procurement, training, evaluation/performance measurement, co-operation
with border guards and neighbouring countries.
Source: https://www.celbet.eu/about
11) https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/customs-4/union-customs-code_en
15
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 15 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
The Customs Union Today Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
The report includes a vision for EU Customs in 2040 suggesting among others to 3. HOWEVER, THE CUSTOMS UNION HAS NOT EVOLVED AT THE SAME
have a centralised, joint governance structure to operationally manage the Customs PACE AS THE TRANSFORMATIONS IN THE WORLD ECONOMY
Union, to harmonise IT systems and in the longer term to have one EU IT system as
well as the development of a “single window” for customs procedures.12 In the last decade, the world economy and international trade have undergone
enormous changes, in particular with the significant increase in trade of China
In late 2020, the European Commission proposed the establishment of an and other Asian economies. Events have in fact moved on much faster than the
“EU Single Window Environment for Customs”13, that will make it easier for differ- adaptations of the Customs Union. In addition, the promise of harmonised rules
ent authorities involved in goods clearance to exchange electronic information and procedures to be applied by all Member States has not yet materialised.
submitted by traders.
Serious divergences remain between national Customs authorities in the appli-
On 1st July 2021, the Import One-Stop Shop (IOSS) was introduced. This electronic cation of rules and procedures and customs face growing difficulties to control
portal can be used by businesses to comply with their VAT e-commerce obligations borders. As a result, there is a growing gap between the legislative ambitions of
on distance sales of imported goods. The IOSS allows suppliers and e-commerce the European Union to fulfil the expectations of its citizens both in terms of offer-
platforms selling imported goods to buyers in the EU to collect, declare and pay the ing protection, safety and security and moving towards a greener and more digital
VAT to the tax authorities, instead of making the buyer pay the VAT at the moment the
goods are imported into the EU. If the seller is not registered in the IOSS, the buyer
has to pay the VAT directly on importation.
All these are steps in the right direction that were designed taking into account the
THE VOICE OF THE CONSUMER: BEUC
reality of over a decade ago but that today fall short of the quantum leap needed to
In 2020, several BEUC members conducted a pan-European test of 250 electrical
adjust to the change in circumstances.
products sold by major e-commerce platforms (incl. toys, smoke detectors,
and phone chargers). 66 % of the purchased products sold on e-commerce
platforms – many of which imported – did not comply with basic EU product
safety rules. In some cases, they could result in electric shock, fire or suffocation.
BEUC, Is it safe to shop on online marketplaces? Consumer research finds
66 % of 250 tested products to be unsafe, February 2021
12) The future of customs in the EU 2040 – A foresight project for EU policy, Luxembourg, publication office of the European Union, 2020
13) https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/eu-single-window-environment-customs_en
16
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 16 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
The Customs Union Today Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
CEFIC – CHEMICAL INDUSTRY THE EUROPEAN CHEMICALS AGENCY (ECHA)
92 % of chemicals non-compliant with REACH in consumer products “the majority of inspected products sold online breach EU chemicals
come from outside the EU/European Economic Area (EEA). This is the key laws”. 78 per cent of the nearly 6,000 online products they inspected were
finding of the CEFIC analysis of data reported through the EU’s rapid non-compliant with at least one requirement under relevant European
alert system (RAPEX) ‘Safety Gate’. Restricted phthalates, mostly found Union (EU) chemicals legislation. The products included both professional
in children’s toys, are the most frequent case of non-compliance at 25 %. and consumer products and articles, including textiles, leather, childcare
articles, toys and jewellery.
The finding confirms an urgent need for EU member states to step up
enforcement of REACH in imported goods. ECHA, December 2021.
Sylvie Lemoine, Cefic Executive Director Product Stewardship: “We have the
strictest chemical legislation in the world. But it will only fully work to the
benefit of people and environment if properly enforced”.
CEFIC, Newsroom, More Than 90 % Of All Chemicals In Consumer Products Non-Compliant
With REACH Come From outside of the EU
economy, on the one hand, and the current operational capacity of Customs
on the ground on the other hand. There is a growing gap between what the Cus-
toms Union should or wants to deliver and what it actually delivers. As a result, the
EU´s Single Market is at risk, and this could be a matter of sovereignty for Europe.
Customs represent the authority to control financial fraud, illegal traffic, and
non-compliant products. However, fraudsters, traffickers, and malevolent operators
are constantly challenging this ambition. Evidence gathered during the work of
the Wise Persons Group shows that dangerous, non-compliant products still
enter the EU market every day.
Reports by the EU´s anti-fraud office - OLAF - and audits performed by the European
Court of Auditors show that fraud remains large and serious.
17
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 17 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
The Customs Union Today Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
December 2020, a cross-border investigation into the In 2021, an investigation of a sophisticated EU-wide fraud
illicit production of cigarettes, prevented the loss of scheme involving the import of goods from China and
approximately €80 million in duties and taxes in five impacting at least 11 Member States revealed a suspected
EU countries and led to the seizure of 95 million illegal €14 million fraud in underpaid custom duties and
cigarettes and 300 tonnes of tobacco. a estimated €93 million in VAT evaded.
1 week operation (with EUROPOL) covering European customs and police authorities
15 Member States resulted in the seizure have seized nearly 1.8 million litres of
of at least 2100 cylinders of illicit HFCs – wine and alcoholic beverages suspected
hydrofluocarbons – for an estimated value to be counterfeited in a targeted action
of over 10 millions euros. Illicit imports OLAF led by OLAF, coordinating the action of
of these gases circumvent EU rules and Pay-off of 19 EU Member States.
can cause significant damage to climate. acting together
In March 2021, 5 million dangerous toys worth over €16 million seized in operation supported by OLAF in cooperation
with 20 Member States.
COVID-19 fake and sub-standard medical 19 pandemic stopped (fake test kits, substandard face
products seized under OLAF’s investigation masks, hand sanitiser, spray cans, counterfeit antiseptic
Over 100 million medical supplies related to the COVID- disinfectants etc.). Source: OLAF
18
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 18 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
The Customs Union Today Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
EUROPEAN COURT OF AUDITORS The gross loss of Traditional Own Resources relating to import
in the EU of textiles and footwear from the People’s Republic of China
Customs controls: insufficient harmonisation hampers EU was estimated by the Commission at almost EUR 2.7 billion
financial interests* (including collection costs) for the period 2011-2017.
source: https://ec.europa.eu/anti-fraud/media-corner/news/olaf-welcomes-european-court-justice-ruling-
“The framework (for tackling financial risks) is not leading to uniform uk-undervaluation-case-2022-03-10_en
application of customs controls. The rules for Member States are
not sufficiently stringent. Member States still have different risk
management practices, they do not systematically share information The reality is that European Customs do not yet function “as one”. Important incre-
on risky importers with other Member States, they identify and treat mental changes introduced over the years, including the UCC initiative, have proven ne-
risk signals in different ways. The current framework sets general cessary but insufficient to address the scale of the challenges faced by Customs. There
criteria and indicators for Member States to apply in their risk analysis, is an urgent need for a systemic change to move to the next stage and ensure that
leaving it up to them to create detailed risk profiles to select imports for the Customs Union is “fit for purpose”.
controls. In some Member States, a significant number of EU imports
are not subject to an automated risk analysis.”
“There is no appropriate EU-wide analysis of financial risks in customs,
based on data from all EU imports. The framework has not yet changed
Member States’ processes sufficiently to properly safeguard the EU’s
financial interests.”
*European Court of auditors, Special Report Customs controls: insufficient
harmonisation hampers EU financial interests, 04/2021
19
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 19 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
The Customs Union Today Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
4. H
OW DID WE GET HERE? With the expansion of e-commerce, Customs face an increasingly difficult task. For cit-
THE ROOT CAUSES OF THIS PROBLEM izens and businesses, e-commerce means greatly expanded new opportunities, as we
have witnessed during the covid-19 crisis. For Customs, however, e-commerce means
First, the last decade has witnessed major changes in trade and technology, which an exponential and unmanageable flow of millions of small individual consignments to
have exacerbated pre-existing difficulties. The volumes of trade have significantly be controlled and checked for fiscal and non-fiscal requirements. Many “buyers” and
increased. Between 2010 and 2020, extra-EU imports have increased by 16.5 percent “sellers” on digital platforms have limited knowledge of customs regulations and are
while exports have grown by 34.6 percent.14 generally unknown to customs authorities. The declared value of B2C shipments is fre-
quently incomplete or inaccurate, often intentionally, with many falling below the “de
But the type of trade has also changed with the expansion of e-commerce. Busi-
minimis” value threshold of €150 for customs duties. These misdeclarations of value do
ness, trading partner, logistics actors and consumers have quickly seen the many
not only affect the assessment of customs duties but also VAT to be collected on those
opportunities created by the digital transformation of the last decades. The trad-
goods. Evidence also suggests that the probability that small consignments will con-
itional containerised goods brought in big quantities via sea, air or road has now
tain non-compliant or dangerous goods is very high. It is not only that checking each
been accompanied by an exponential rise in e-commerce with millions of small con-
parcel is impossible; it is that even checking all those that are identified as presenting
signments coming primarily via air and rail. From July to December 2021 – the first
a risk is unmanageable. This is a major game changer for Customs’ capacity to protect
six months of compulsory customs declaration for all goods imported into the EU
citizens and the financial interests of the EU and its Member States.
irrespective of their value – traditional trade in goods represented over 220 million
import declaration for a value of EUR 1,250 billion. In contrast, it is estimated that Second, Customs are usually known for collecting duties and taxes. The persistent
e-commerce represented 490 million customs declarations for a total value of EUR undervaluing of goods imported, misdeclarations of values, and splitting of consign-
4.8 billion.15 So, e-commerce represents more than twice the number of traditional ment to stay below the threshold, all of this aggravated by the increase in trade vol-
transactions for only 0.4 % of the value. umes, are depriving the EU from substantial revenues. Unfortunately, despites serious
attempts on the part of the Wise Persons Group, the available data does not allow to
The wave of cross-border e-commerce has swept over an unprepared world, and
estimate the gap in revenues collected by Customs. As already stated by the European
it is adding to the pre-existing difficulties for Customs. In the past, Customs were al-
Parliament, “the measurement presents difficulties first and foremost because there are
ready facing difficulties in managing an increased volume of trade and were struggling
not yet reliable and comprehensive data sets available to measure the customs gap”.16
to carry out the necessary controls. However, at least, the detection of a suspicious
product very often allowed stopping the entire consignment.
14) Source: Eurostat. https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/images/4/46/Extra-EU_main_features_2020.xlsx
15) Source: DG TAXUD using Surveillance data. This is the number and value of goods below EUR 150 declared using the simplified declaration “H7”, which is mostly used to declare parcels up to EUR
150 under the IOSS scheme. Note that e-commerce goods can also be declared with the standard customs declaration ‘H1’ declaration, but the calculation here excludes them, so the proportion of
e-commerce can be seen here as a low-bound estimate.
16) European Parliament (2019), DG for Internal Policies, Protection of EU financial interest on customs and VAT:
Cooperation of national tax and customs authorities to prevent fraud, March 2019, page 43. https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2019/636470/IPOL_STU(2019)636470_EN.pdf
20
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 20 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
The Customs Union Today Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
This in itself should be a matter of concern since as the saying goes “what you can’t Evolution of EU prohibitions and restrictions legislation
measure, you can’t manage”. Anecdotal evidence on recoveries made by Member
States following controls and audits suggest that it could potentially be in billions
16 28 378
of euros. 44
164
The conservative estimate of duties not collected on imports of a declared value below
EUR 150 is close to EUR 1.5 billion. The abolition of the threshold for VAT but not for
#Legislation
customs duties on low-value goods seems inconsistent and may raise issues of fairness.
In addition, as already touched on, the expectations on Customs’ role have dramatically
97
evolved to include many additional dimensions. There are growing additional expect-
ations regarding security (bombs, weapons, explosives, ammunitions, dual use
TOTAL
goods, drugs and drug precursors, etc.), regarding the safety of goods (compliance
15
with food, feed and phytosanitary and medicinal standards, with product compli- 3 5 6
ance and safety obligations, etc.), regarding the fight against cigarette smuggling
9 9 9 9 9 9 1 th &
and illicit cash flows, regarding illicit trade in cultural goods or regarding the pro- -196 -197 -198 -199 -200 -201 02 wi to als d
65 75 -2 edry in ion os nce es
85 95 05 15 20 t p
op t at Pro nou ativ
tection of intellectual property rights. Over the years, the number and complexity of 19 19 19 19 20 20 20 Ad re enplic an initi
tu ap
fu
sectoral legislation has been rapidly increasing. Back in the 1990s, the legislation on Pro- Period
hibitions and Restrictions was limited to a set of well-defined bans and authorisations
Source: compilation by DG TAXUD
(for nuclear substances, firearms, drug precursors, etc.) and the compliance and safety
requirements of products focused essentially on three key categories: toys, medicines
and foodstuffs. Nowadays, there are more than 350 pieces of EU legislation dealing with Third, the vast majority of – if not all – stakeholders interviewed for this report com-
prohibitions and restrictions and covering a wide range of diverse policy areas. It is ex- plain about a systematic absence of common implementation of customs meas-
pected that more will come in the near future with the policy agenda on the EU Green Deal ures, different control practices across border entry points, both within and
and the EU desire to contribute to fairer working conditions worldwide by fighting against across Member states, differences in control priorities, differences in investi-
imports made by child and forced labour. This exponential growth of legislation on gative capacities (control deliveries, undercover activities), and differences in
non-fiscal risks rightly responds to the increasing wishes of EU citizens to ensure methods and sanctions for non-compliance. The same consignment of goods sub-
that the values that they cherish (sustainability, safety, security, human rights, ject to antidumping measures or to prohibitions and restrictions may be checked or
peace and security, health, etc.) are upheld. This is nevertheless not without con- not depending on where it enters the EU. Some Customs authorities appear to apply
sequences as Customs struggle to cope with such a wide range of specialised risks. more stringent controls than others do, and sanctions applied in case of irregularities
21
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 21 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
The Customs Union Today Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
differ from one Member State to another. Fraudsters are quick, sophisticated, and Surveillance and Law Enforcement Authorities acting at the borders, notably when
agile at identifying gaps and loopholes and they will seek to find the weakest link. it comes to prohibitions and restrictions. The lack of alignment of procedures and
The uneven implementation of customs rules in the EU sadly offers plenty of oppor- standards (notably for data collection and sharing) is also an obstacle for digitalisation.
tunities for abuse (such as mis-declaring goods, providing fake invoices, misusing
free zones, and abusing simplifications). These divergences also undermine the cred- Fifth, Customs administrations struggle to perform their duties because they often lack
ibility of the EU with respect to its trading partners. Customs are not acting as one. the skills required to use modern technologies for analytics, detection and con-
Today the level of protection of citizens and Member States depend on the place trols, which now also have to cover a wider range of risk areas. In many instances,
where goods are controlled, and fraudulent and negligent businesses enjoy a they do not have access to state-of-the-art equipment and technology. Investments in
significant low-risk advantage over honest and compliant firms and individuals. customs capacity have not followed the increasing requirements placed on Customs
This is a serious issue. and staffing has been broadly constant over time.
In terms of cooperation, it is interesting to make the comparison between the func- Brexit and the Covid-19 pandemic have further challenged Customs: the former
tioning and responsibility in the Schengen agreement for the movement of people and has increased the burden of Customs in neighbouring countries and the volume of
those resulting from the existence of an EU Customs Union for the control of imported traffic to be checked; the latter has led to a massive increase of trade in low-value
goods. There is also a very strong link between the setup of the Schengen area and the consignments and of traffic of sub-standard and dangerous goods in the health area,
internal market: it is partly because the waiting time at the borders for carriers (the from personal protective equipment, masks, and from medicines to medical devices.
identity of truck drivers had to be checked) had become unbearable that it was decided Thanks to valiant efforts on the part of Customs officers, Customs have been able to be
to create the Schengen area. But, unlike the Customs Union, the Schengen area has responsive and efficient and dealing with these changes. However, the Brexit and the
experienced innovative mechanisms for more union and cooperation, even though its Covid-19 have somewhat diverted the attention and slowed down the pace of reforms.
creation is more recent (1990) and the applicable substantive law much less unified.
More recently, Customs are also been challenged to address the multiple impli-
A fourth area that poses significant problems is that of data. The poor availability cations of the war in Ukraine at the European border, including ensuring that the
and quality of the data submitted to Customs, the lack of a common data sanctions are being properly implemented. The crisis has shown the need to strength-
warehouse, and the low level of data sharing across Customs administrations en security at the border by addressing existing shortcomings and to improve the co-
leads to fragmentation and makes it extremely difficult to properly manage ordination between Customs and other border agencies, law enforcement authorities
risks through data analytics at both national and EU level. This is a major inhibitor and tax administrations to protect the European interests, support the humanitarian
in a digital world where any transformation is highly dependent on the quality and efforts and more broadly to provide a holistic response to a crisis.
availability of data. While the implementation of the UCC legal provisions is overall
on track, the implementation of the IT systems still lags behind. This delay bears
on the anticipated benefits of the changes introduced by the UCC. It also inhibits
the synergies and coordination between Customs authorities and other Market
22
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 22 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
The Customs Union Today Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
5. THE URGENT NEED FOR STRUCTURAL CHANGE There is in addition a serious problem with the incentives of the different players
in the value chain. Those with the most information – producers, exporting firms,
The above-mentioned root causes have resulted in a Customs Union that is not fit for wholesalers, commercial platforms – are all remote and insulated from the Customs
purpose. EU and national leaders cannot stand over the current situation: if Customs offices that will make decisions and from the consequences of mis-declaration. The
continue to operate in the current manner, we cannot expect radically different re- people who work most closely with Customs – like customs agents, shipping hand-
sults. The current system – if not brought to the next level – represents too high a risk lers, logistics firms, truck drivers and shipping companies – are mostly working for
of a major security or safety threat materialising. European businesses that respect hire, and while they know how to present the forms, they do not validate the infor-
the legislation are unfairly disadvantaged compared to non-compliant third country mation they present, mainly because they are not allowed themselves to verify the
imports. We should also not underestimate the risk of discrediting the EU legislator if contents of the shipment. Even where risks are identified and goods are stopped,
the legislation adopted has a limited impact given the shortcomings on enforcement the consequences for fraudsters may be negligible. This is a problem exponentially
or even enforceability on the ground. There is an urgent need for systemic change. increased in e-commerce, since any loss due to goods seized or returned is small,
and prosecutions or fines are unlikely and burdensome for Customs.
The areas that are most in need of repair relate to the following:
Customs processes and data requirements are burdensome. Data requirements
■D
ata: the information base - the data - is deficient and EU-wide IT tools still
are often redundant, collecting data that is not always relevant for controlling risks
underdeveloped. Despite considerable efforts by the Commission and the Member
while missing data needed to effectively fulfil Customs tasks.
States, customs systems are still mostly used to make more effective a traditional
approach to customs clearance. Data currently used is declarative, often flawed, not A number of data and information required for customs clearance (e.g. certificates
easily cross-validated against other data sources, sometimes inconsistently shared, of conformity, certificates of origin, invoices) are still not digitalised.
and not available when required to all parts of the system.
Data between, within and across Members States is also inconsistently shared. Na-
Customs clearance works based on the information provided by economic operators, tional IT systems are still fragmented and not connected. The EU has not yet complet-
largely of a declaratory nature, often unrelated to commercial documentation and ed its Single Window. Businesses cannot benefit from a single data entry point and
reality. Exporters can and do make incorrect declarations. Importers may be firms or Customs administrations are not sharing their data in a common data warehouse.
individuals without the capacity or interest to ensure that declarations are accurate.
While a lot of information is available from different parts of the end-to-end trade ■ The reliance on a cumbersome Transaction-Based as opposed to a System-Based
chain, from producers, to importers, sellers, buyers, logistics operators and inter- Approach: where Customs procedures and controls revolve primarily around indi-
mediaries, in invoices and trade, transport, finance and insurance contracts, these vidual transactions rather than operators. The system today is “bunged up” by having
are not connected into data points and the intelligence that can be generated is lim- to process huge numbers of small transactions.
ited. As a result, Customs currently spend too much time and resources checking the
correctness of “declarative” information and is often unable to confirm the correctness
of the data and is certainly incapable of controlling all suspicious cases.
23
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 23 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
The Customs Union Today Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
In addition, the current system allows too many untrustworthy operators to send relation to trade, security, safety, and relationships with the rest of the world are
consignments not meeting EU requirements without serious consequences for put into effect. It is already clear that purely national approaches to implemen-
their actions. In fact, the incentives in the system do not promote trust neither tation will not deliver the required protection of borders, citizens or common
between operators and national Customs nor between national Customs offices. values for the EU Customs Union. The coordination mandate currently entrusted
There are few incentives for accurate declaration and few disincentives for inaccur- to the Commission has proven insufficient and inadequate to address the kind of
ate declaration. In this respect, the “Authorised Economic Operator” status needs community-based risk management that a Customs Union requires. Member States
a revamp as it is narrowly defined, does not provide sufficient incentives, and is must act in a more coordinated way to avoid benefits – or inefficiencies – arising in
not fit for addressing the challenges posed by e-commerce. Binding information one Member State being at the expense of others.
procedures on tariff and origin also require a review.
It is one thing if firms choose to route their business through the most efficient Cus-
■ There are 27 Customs in the EU, but no EU Customs “acting as one”. There is a toms hubs – one could even argue that there is some real public benefit in that – but
widespread lack of uniform implementation of customs legislation by Member there cannot be a public benefit in non-compliant or dangerous goods being
States with different interpretation of the same rules, differences in control shipped through the Customs route that is least likely to be effective in its con-
procedures and different sanctions for non-compliance. It is recognised that trols. If a Customs administration identifies a risk and addresses it through more
the EU aims to be strong in its diversity and that the subsidiarity principle – which effective enforcement, it cannot be in the future that the exporters will simply send
requires that authority be exercised at the national level where appropriate – is an their goods into the EU via a different route. The assessment and understanding
important tenet of the EU’s legal and political framework. This must be respect- of risks, and intelligence about risks arising in practice, must be commonly shared
ed, and Customs policies must be developed in sympathy rather than in conflict and EU policies and their implementation must ensure that equivalent customs
with the reality that EU borders are also national borders, that Customs admin- risks, wherever they arise in the EU, are met with equivalent levels of enforcement.
istrations are sometimes deeply integrated with national taxation, and cooperate Sanctions for non-compliance vary between Member States, notably because of
closely with Market Surveillance Authorities and other Law Enforcement systems different judicial systems.
while also serving the EU policy imperatives. Policy must reflect this dual nature,
while remaining in sympathy with the broad political preferences of citizens and
their representatives.
But, as in most other policy areas, the EU approach of acting to generate EU add-
ed value through policy making, co-ordination and action at the Union level,
is a key to enhance the welfare of citizens. Customs deal with the physical point
of contact between the EU and its markets, and the rest of the world. Customs con-
trols are in many ways the “moment of truth” in which EU values and EU policy in
24
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 24 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
The Customs Union Today Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
Also, in this respect, data poses a particularly acute challenge. Data sharing within ■ Customs are in need of serious investments. The exponential increase in the de-
the Customs Union, among national Customs offices and with the EU and with mands on Customs has not been accompanied with commensurate investments in
Market Surveillance Authorities, is still incomplete, fragmented and uncoord- people, relevant skills, in particular those related to the use of big data analytics,
inated, and response is at the whim of Member States which themselves have systems and equipment. The lack of means for Customs is likely to discourage staff,
some mixed incentives. As a result, there is yet no central data warehouse or data decrease the attractiveness of customs as employer and deter the best from en-
sharing mechanism that can support a European-wide risk management system. tering the career, thus worsening the situation. This is also taking place in a context
Such absence cannot be argued on grounds of data protection: an EU-wide data of ageing Customs officers.
sharing mechanism can be made compatible with common protocols on data pro-
tection as was done for instance for administrative cooperation and combatting ■ It should finally be noted that European legislation proposed by the Commis-
fraud in the field of value-added tax17 and direct taxation.18 sion should also see the coordination ab initio of the relevant services dealing
with Customs matters to ensure legislative design fully incorporates an ad-
Legitimate attempts to recoup monies from administrations, which have not equate implementation dimension, and to avoid applying responsibilities to
gathered revenues as they should, come years after the fact and there is a dis- Customs services without considering the means to address them.
incentive for administrations to identify their own failings, since to do so risks
inviting penalties at the national level.
■ Customs contribution to the Green Deal lacks visibility. Being at the heart of the
supply chain movement of goods, Customs has a responsibility and a unique pos-
ition to contribute to the EU political agenda on the Green Deal. It will effectively
have to ensure that the objective of sustainability is respected. Moreover, it can lead
internationally in the efforts to reform the WCO harmonised system nomenclature so
that it can promote trade in environmentally-friendly goods.
17) See for instance article 55(5) of Council Regulation 904/2010 of 7 October 2010.
18) See article 25 of Council Directive 2011/16/EU on administrative cooperation in the field of taxation and repealing Directive 77/799/EEC, lastly modified by Council Directive (EU) 2018/822 of 25 May 2018.
25
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 25 30/03/22 09:21
10 Recommendations
for a “Moon-Shot”
for Customs
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 26 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten Recommendations for Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
a “Moon-Shot” for Customs
TEN RECOMMENDATIONS FOR A “MOON-SHOT” FOR CUSTOMS
T
his section outlines a set of recommendations for reforms duties and to import goods that do not meet
that – taken as a package given the way they are inter-re- EU standards, it is clear that asking each RECOMMENDATION 1
lated – would provide for the Customs Union that the EU Member State to develop its own systems
needs. They call for the European Commission to bring forward will not be a sufficient basis for progress. The European Commission by the end of
a package of reform proposals that include these fundamental A fundamental re-design is required for EU 2022 tables a package of reforms, including of
changes. Given the urgency, the implementation should begin Customs and will need to be applied on an the Union Customs Code, implementing the
in 2022 and have 2030 as a set horizon. EU-wide basis. recommendations contained in this report, relating
to processes, responsibilities and liabilities, and
Customs provide important services also at
RELAUNCHING THE CUSTOMS UNION governance of the European Customs Union.
a national level. They are each managed on
a model designed nationally, and often are
Customs’ legislative structure, methods of operation and cap-
engaged in tasks in one Member State that go beyond the range
acity are facing enormous challenges. Huge efforts to cope
of tasks assigned to Customs in other Member States. For this
with the e-commerce explosion and more recently with Brex-
reason, the principle of subsidiarity should apply within the
it, Covid-19 and the war in Ukraine have showed the strengths
new design. In introducing its reforms, the EU should engage in
and reactivity of Customs. We do not believe that failings are in
a dialog with its trading partners, and in particular with those
general arising from a lack of resolve. And a set of reforms have
with whom it is in a Customs Union.
been introduced and are being rolled out. But these are simply
not enough.
A CHANGE OF PARADIGM ON DATA
Already, the EU is entrusting more and more responsibilities to
Customs and this will only increase the challenges. However Data is at the heart of many of the issues arising in relation to EU
dedicated are the various Member States’ Customs, we cannot customs at present. A system needs to be designed around a mod-
expect them to meet their challenges by simply applying the ex- ern understanding of the possibilities of data systems to deliver
isting, now insufficient, techniques with more vigour. Moreover, added value, much more than the sum of the parts. The new sys-
given the evidence we have heard that Customs rules are at tem, for reasons of economy, efficiency and effectiveness for the
best applied inconsistently, and that traders are systematically EU mission, should be managed centrally and shared in common.
seeking to use weak points among the Member States to evade
27
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 27 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten Recommendations for Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
a “Moon-Shot” for Customs
It should provide a service to the Member States’ Customs, as The time has come to re-imagine what can be
well as receiving data from them. In the long-term, data shall done with data. In doing so we must of course en- RECOMMENDATION 2
be transmitted by those who hold it into a central data ware- sure that data is used properly, that privacy rights
house accessible to Customs administrations. An obligation for and protections are respected, and that data col- Introduce a new approach to data, focussed on
national Customs authorities to provide the data to the central lection should be made more efficient by ensur- obtaining better quality data based on commer-
level should also be adopted. It should be protective of privacy ing that unnecessary data are not collected. But cial sources, ensuring it is cross-validated along
rights but determined to protect the EU’s borders and citizens. we should aim for the following, at least: the chain, better shared among administrations,
Businesses should have a one point of data entry and access and better used for EU risk management. Clarify
to a single window/portal. The system could benefit from third ■ Better primary data: Collect data from those
who have control of it and make them liable which private actors – including e-commerce
countries’ data sharing agreements.
for accurate declarations. platforms - must provide data, with costs for
Moreover, the EU needs to be in a position to trust the data it re- non-compliance. Provide businesses with a
ceives, and it currently cannot do so with confidence in all cases. ■
Better Validation of data: Collect data from single data entry point for customs formalities
Existing Authorised Economic Operator status allows for firms to those who have information which can be used and a single window/portal. Data to be stored
apply for a more trusted status, but it is entered into by only a lim- to validate declarations (manufacturers, ship- and properly managed in a central data ware-
ited number of firms and many firms choose not to seek this status pers, agents, and especially e-commerce plat-
house. The existing budget for 2021-2027 could
as they perceive the costs to be higher than the benefits. It does forms and payment systems). Their data can be
be refocused for these goals.
not include many of the platforms, which are the hub of modern used to cross-check, reducing the incentive or
e-commerce, and adherence to AEO requirements is monitored opportunity for exporters to mis-declare.
inconsistently. If data is to be at the centre of a new system, it
■ Better data sharing: enhance data sharing arrangements with-
needs to be generated by trusted, verified firms, and there needs
in the European Customs administration system for better EU-
to be a significant cost, including loss of trusted status, for repeated
wide risk management; one single window/portal.
breaches. For firms too small or unwilling to operate as AEOs, there
will need to be some trusted operator to vouch for them, including ■ Develop advanced tracing systems over time (product pass-
by willingness to act as guarantor/bonder for the good behaviour ports, blockchain based solutions), that will greatly assist
of the non-authorised firms. Details are provided below. traders, and Customs, by tracking packages through the value
chain but also facilitate data for compliance with prohibitions
and restrictions requirements19.
19) This may be a longer-term project, but in a future where Customs will be expected to understand not just a product, but its composition, its origins
and the context of its manufacture, such tracking will become important.
28
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 28 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten Recommendations for Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
a “Moon-Shot” for Customs
Such enhanced data systems will generate considerable benefits: FOSTERING COOPERATION BETWEEN CUSTOMS AND MARKET
SURVEILLANCE AUTHORITIES, LAW ENFORCEMENT BODIES AND
■ Data will be better quality because collected closer to the source.
TAX ADMINISTRATIONS
■ Data will be more accurate because of new cross-validation systems with errors
Cooperation is essential for ensuring the proper functioning of the Customs
and fraud much reduced.
Union. It starts with good cooperation within the European Commission among
■ Data will be entered through a single data entry point – stored in a central data services relevant for Customs matters. Any legislation with an impact on Customs
warehouse – and all relevant information for operators will be available in proposed by the Commission should reflect the feasibility of its implementation
a single window/portal. at the border. The cooperation and complementarities between Customs and
Market Surveillance Authorities, other Law Enforcement bodies and tax admin-
■ Data will be better used for risk management through data analytics and data istrations, including on data sharing, is also of the essence. The tasks of Cus-
modelling ensuring consistency across the EU. toms have grown more complex with the increase in the number of legislation
on prohibitions and restrictions, which require specific expertise and the need
A new approach to data is required to coordinate with a large and increasing number of Market
Surveillance Authorities. There is a need for a system that
TRADITIONAL DATA APPROACH ensures a holistic management of risks at EU level, while re-
specting that there may be national specific risks, a certainty
► Customs data is generated for customs purposes and it is separate from commercial data of economic actors
► Comes from operators (shippers/customs agents etc) not familiar with the contents of consignments
that risky consignments are adequately checked with similar
► Fraudulent/negligent data cannot be penalized because not coming from the source of fraud vigour across border entry points and the organisation of the
► No cross-verification against other systems cooperation with Market Surveillance Authorities and other
► Managed mostly on a national basis, so not verifiable with other customs authorities Law Enforcement Authorities.
► Risk data does not feed into EU systems directly, and is not informing Member States’ customs on an ongoing
basis – information sharing is not complete
RECOMMENDATION 3
NEW DATA APPROACH
► Customs data will come from the business systems of AEOs and be based on underlying commercial data
Setting up of a comprehensive framework for
► Other data will be gathered from other sources (platforms, payment systems, etc) to cross-chack anomalies cooperation, including data sharing between
for risk assessments, using blockchain when appropriate European Customs, with Market Surveillance
► Data will be integrated on common/shared systems, so that all Member States’ customs can access Authorities, other Law Enforcement bodies and
► Penalties/costs applied for fraudulent or negligent data
tax authorities for a comprehensive management
► Economies of scale for customs services, and more effective, less variation
► Benefits at EU and national level in less fraud, better risk management, less unfair competition of risks at EU level
29
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 29 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten Recommendations for Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
a “Moon-Shot” for Customs
REBUILDING THE ROLE OF THE CENTRE: THE NEED to develop and implement the new systems,
FOR A EU CUSTOMS AGENCY in cooperation with the Member States, and to
RECOMMENDATION 4
manage the systems on behalf of the EU and
It has become clear that the efforts of Member States’ Customs the Member States in the future. The role of the A European Customs Agency should be set up to
services, however serious, are inconsistently applied according to Centre must change. It is unlikely that the am- provide EU value-added services to the Com-
different administrative procedures and standards. This must of bitions of the EU and its Member States for the mission and the Member States. Its governance
course have regard to local conditions, but EU duties and protec- Customs system, for border protection and for
should respect the existing allocation of
tions must apply in a consistent manner. Who is responsible for the Single Market can be met otherwise. The
competences.
this? Who is responsible for helping Member States to apply the option to assign this responsibility to an exist-
rules, where they have capacity issues? Who is responsible for en- ing body (for example Frontex) was dismissed
suring that the equipment and facilities, including scarce IT and given the different nature of the tasks as well as the focus of
data technologies, that will be required by Customs services are the later on operations on the ground.
going to be available and procured in the most appropriate and
We envisage that the Commission would initiate the work re-
economical way?
quired to meet the recommendations of this group and would
The European Commission provides an obvious answer, and it continue to be responsible – as per the Treaty – to propose new
already takes on some of these responsibilities. But its special legislation as required, including common standards and risk
position, both as proposer of legislation and surveyor of the work appetite for the European Customs administration system as a
of the Member States’ Customs services’ efforts, together with the whole. Moreover, its central task to provide thought leadership
nature of the capacities and resources within the Commission are on the future of Customs in the EU would remain.
not designed to fill all these roles. We need the Commission, of
But there would also be a new central body responsible for the
course, but there is also a need for a new entity at the centre,
following main tasks:
to service and co-ordinate the efforts of Member States. Many
European policies, some more recent than the Customs Union ■ Implement the EU-wide Risk management framework, including
such as Schengen, have faced similar problems and specific en- contributing to identification of priority fiscal and non-fiscal risks.
tities – agencies, authorities or otherwise – have been set up to
ensure a more integrated cooperation. In the Customs domain, ■ Supervision of Authorised Economic Operators.
11 Member States – under the CELBET initiative – are already
moving in this direction on their own initiative. ■
Data management: including processes for ensuring trust-
worthiness of data, rigorous validation and control systems; de-
But more importantly, still, the new approach to data outlined veloping and managing a centralised data warehouse system
above simply requires a central entity – such as an agency – and coordinating data sharing.
30
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 30 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten Recommendations for Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
a “Moon-Shot” for Customs
■ Development and financing of future IT infrastructure underpinning the data and de- The governance of the entity should reflect the existing allocation of competences be-
ployment of AI - powered analytical capacities; protection against cybercrimes. tween the Commission and the Member States. The design could be inspired by the ex-
amples of similar bodies, such as the European Authority for Anti-Money Laundering and
■ Joint procurement of equipment. Countering the Financing of Terrorism.
■ Supporting the competence of Members States´ Customs administrations in human Clear boundaries and complementarities would need to be agreed between this agency
capacity development and training. and other EU authorities (e.g. EUROPOL, FRONTEX, Market Surveillance Authorities).
■ Operating a rapid reaction mechanism to respond to crises.
RESPONSIBILITY AND TRUST – TOWARDS
■ Providing a forum for exchange of experience and knowledge-sharing as well as for
A SYSTEM-BASED APPROACH
peer reviews.
The current system of Customs clearance based on transactions should be replaced
■ Contributing to the global discussion on operational customs matters in inter-
by a System Based Approach centred on a reformed Authorised Economic Operators
national fora.
scheme, who in exchange for greater facilitation (some sort of fast lane) assumes more
■ Supporting Customs on the ground upon request by the Member State. responsibilities for compliance.
Such an agency would complement the role of the Commission and support the A new system needs:
work of the Member States. The existing practices of customs shopping would greatly
■ To reform the Authorised Economic Operators scheme and include a broader range of
reduce; EU added value would be delivered through better co-ordination and doing
economic actors.
at the centre those tasks that need to be integrated, while guarding subsidiarity; it
would ensure cost effectiveness through economies of scale and better revenue col- ■ Beneficiaries should be able to deal with customs services on a per entity, not per
lection. Most important, however, is that the required new approach to data cannot transaction basis. While it will continue to be necessary to identify, in advance,
work without central support. shipments that are being sent into the EU, especially so that dangerous goods
can be prohibited from entry in advance, other aspects of the relationship be-
We are not recommending that the new entity would deploy operational capacities on the
tween actors and Customs can be dealt with on an account management basis.
ground taking over the border protection work of the Member States’ Customs, because
Trade data, payments and the like can all be arranged on a periodic rather than
of the principle of subsidiarity. We believe that, appropriately, the new central body can
per transaction basis, with some cash-flow advantage to the trusted partner, and
drive EU added value, while respecting the roles of the Member States. Everyone should
an administrative advantage to the Customs system.
benefit. Citizens would be better protected and businesses would gain in legal certainty.
31
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 31 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten Recommendations for Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
a “Moon-Shot” for Customs
actors exporting to the EU would
RECOMMENDATION 5 either be trusted directly or would RECOMMENDATION 6
be treated as trusted because they
Introduce a System-Based Approach centred on a reformed Au- are “represented” by another AEO Introduce a new ABC model (Au-
thorised Economic Operator scheme expanded in scope, multi-layered which vouches for them financial- thorised, Bonded or subject to greater
and more effective, to better facilitate trade with trust. ly. This is particularly relevant for Control), in which operators would
e-commerce platforms. seek Authorised Economic Operators
■ Beneficiaries should get fast Customs processing, but subject to ongoing external
audit, and risk-based Customs control, and with financial costs or loss or suspen- Economic actors will lose money, status to gain commercial access to
sion of the AEO status in case of consistent rule-breaking or mis-declaration. The or a valued AEO status, or both, if the EU market. Failing this, a bond
basis for the trust should be ongoing verification of their systems, and occasional they show themselves to be dis- provided to an AEO, against which
checks by Customs systems. Rule breaking noted by Member States’ Customs au- honest or negligent.20 the EU authorities may levy a signifi-
thorities would be reported into the central data warehouse systems, so that the cant charge for mis-declaration or
■
In reforming the AEO scheme, rule breaches, may allow access to
risk attached to any given trusted partner can be scored on an ongoing basis.
three issues need to be con-
the market. Small non-commercial
■ Strong liability schemes, with strong penalties in case of non-compliance. sidered. One is the network of
consignments would continue to be
Mutual Recognition Agreements
■ Non-beneficiaries of the reformed AEO system would need some arrangement to sent through the usual processes,
(MRA) that the EU has with some
ensure that they are trustworthy to trade with the EU market. As an exception to the third countries on AEOs. The
but without priority and subject to
AEOs, they would be able to trade with the EU by providing a bond in relation to the second is the IOSS system intro- a level of controls that reflects their
goods they move across EU borders. The bond would require to be guaranteed by duced in 2021. Third, the specific “non-trusted” status
a AEO and mis-declaration will be reported by controlling Member States’ Customs needs of SMEs.
authorities to the central body, which will make a charge against the bond. Such a
charge would be considerably greater than the amount of the misdeclaration, to There will remain a small number of personal or non-commercial packages which are
reflect the likelihood that the mis-declared item caught by a Customs control is in not appropriate for commercial treatment. But these will likely be higher risk and will be
fact representative of a significantly larger number of consignments which were not subject to a higher level of control.
checked, to ensure that there is a real disincentive to the traders being prepared to
accept losses on a small number of mis-declared items, while taking the profit on
a much larger number of items which were not sampled for checking. AEOs who
consistently allowed fraudulent operators to avail of their bond guarantee services
will be liable and will be removed from the Authorised list. In this way, commercials
20) There will have to be appeal arrangements, fair treatment rules and so forth. But these will be operated on an entity basis, not a per transaction basis.
32
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 32 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten Recommendations for Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
a “Moon-Shot” for Customs
SO, IT’S ABC – AUTHORISED, BONDED OR SUBJECT fied and validated, (3) Customs authorities will perform checks
TO GREATER CONTROL based on risk analysis on data submitted by the operators.
The management of AEOs and the levying of charges against bonds
EXEMPTION THRESHOLDS
and guarantees, would be managed by the agency. This means that
the costs of non-compliance would be levied on a consistent basis RECOMMENDATION 8
At present, supplies of goods over EU borders
at the EU level. Criminal sanctions for customs offences or for ser- below the threshold of EUR 150 are not subject To implement a package of measures to green
ious crimes like drug or smuggling of weapons would be available to customs duties. This reflects a desire not to EU Customs
to the national authorities exactly as at present. penalize non-commercial activities and to keep
the system relatively simple for individual cit-
If we are putting so much trust in AEOs, how can we be sure that
izens. However, since a customs declaration is nonetheless
they will comply with the rules – especially since many of them
required, it is arguable that the thresholds do not achieve the
may be outside the EU? Well, it is already the case that many pub-
desired aim in terms of simplification. Indeed, since there is no
lic systems rely on putting trust into the hands of operators, then
similar VAT exemption, the customs exemption does not even
verifying compliance and applying costs for non-compliance. The
save the importing person the trouble of making a payment
model proposed would be inspired by the three lines of defence
with their credit card via the relevant shipping company.
model and be composed of several layers of controls. (1) Trust-
ed operators who want to retain status and avoid financial costs At the same time, the thresholds do create an incentive for export-
would develop and execute their own internal controls over goods ers to the EU to break consignments down into smaller packages
crossing borders, (2) The design, implementation and effective- so that they can effectively trade free of customs duties. This cre-
ness of these internal controls will be periodically externally veri- ates an unfair competition and provides the wrong incentives both
in terms of trade and in terms of environmental sustainability.
Simplification might nonetheless be assisted by providing for a
RECOMMENDATION 7
simplification in the application of Customs duties rates for low-
Remove the customs duty exemption threshold of value shipments.
EUR 150 for e-commerce and provide some simpli-
fication for the application of Customs duties rates
for low value shipments
33
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 33 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten Recommendations for Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
a “Moon-Shot” for Customs
GREEN CUSTOMS of environmentally friendly products that the EU wants to
promote in international trade.
Customs have an important role to play in helping the EU de-
livering its Green Deal agenda. It goes without saying that Cus-
EU CUSTOMS FIT TO LEAD THE
toms themselves need to contribute via the greening of their
CHANGES RECOMMENDATION 10
own operations. The digitalization of procedures described
above will also be an element of this contribution. The uniform With the exponential growth of new
application of Customs rules across the European Union would Introduce an annual Customs Revenue Gap Report
non-fiscal responsibilities, Member
remove the incentives for customs shopping and the associat- based on an agreed methodology and data frame-
States and the EU have the responsibil-
ed transport goods across the EU. The removal of the de mini- work to better manage Customs revenue collection.
ity to ensure that Customs are proper-
mis threshold should also remove the perverse incentive to ly resourced, trained, and equipped to
split consignments (in particular those from e-commerce) into have the capacity to fulfil their mission,
small packages leading to a higher emissions footprint. Finally, including proper investigative powers. It also requires a hu-
Customs have an important role to play by ensuring that pro- man resource policy which is able to attract new talents and
hibitions and restrictions related to sustainability are properly new skills to the job, whilst providing adequate reskilling to
implemented on imported products. The tracing of goods for customs officers who have to be state of the art in complex
environmental purposes could take advantage of new technol- matters as diverse as chemicals, drug precursors, electronics,
ogies such as blockchain, which could progressively be made food composition, complex fiscal schemes, etc.
mandatory in European legislation.
But this agenda could also be broadened. The EU could take BETTER MANAGE REVENUE COLLECTION
the lead in the reform of the WCO Harmonized System Nomen-
clature, the global common system to classify goods for cus- Efforts at calculating the Customs Gap by the Wise Persons
toms purposes, to ensure it is kept up to date and relevant. Group have failed due to the poor quality of data and the ab-
Part of these reforms would allow for the proper classification sence of methodology. It is of particular concern as one cannot
manage what one cannot measure. It should be noted that such
computation is done for VAT.
RECOMMENDATION 9
Properly resource, skill and equip Customs to en-
sure their capacity to fulfil their missions.
34
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 34 30/03/22 09:21
Appendices
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 35 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Appendices Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
APPENDIX 1: GLOSSARY
AEO: Authorised Economic Operator
BEUC : European Consumer Organisation
CEFIC: European Chemical Industry Council
CELBET: Customs Eastern and South-Eastern Land Border Expert Team
Eurojust: European Union Agency for Criminal Justice Cooperation
Frontex: European Border and Coast Guard Agency
OLAF: European Anti-Fraud Office
UCC: Union Customs Code
VAT: Value-Added Tax
WCO: World Customs Organisation
WTO: World Trade Organisation
36
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 36 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
APPENDIX 2: TIMELINE FOR
IMPLEMENTATION
TIMELINE FOR IMPLEMENTING THE PROPOSED
In considering the implementation of the recommendations, the following should RECOMMENDATIONS
be considered:
Greening customs
1) A budget of EUR 1 billion has already been allocated under the existing MFF Data and IT systems
(2021-2027) which should be refocused to implement the recommendations
Reformed AEO scheme
of this report, in particular those related to data and IT systems. The next MFF
should include allocations for the full implementation of the package of reforms Set up of an EU Customs agency
Customs fit to lead the changes
to be implemented by 2030.
Reform of UCC
2) A set of measures can be frontloaded, in particular those related to revenue removal of the “de minimis”
collection (the estimated value of the removal of the “de minimis” threshold is
around EUR 1,5 billion). new framework for
cooperation
ABC model
customs revenue gap
Package
of reforms
proposed
2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030
37
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 37 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Appendices Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
APPENDIX 3: SUMMARY OF PUBLIC CONSULTATION
The Wise Persons Group opened a webpage for the public to share their views on on governance, many respondents call for more centralisation at the EU level. Here
the reform of the European Customs Union. The webpage was opened between 5th again, the non-uniformity in the application of rules and procedures (including tariff
October 2021 and 31st January 2022. classification) across Member States is of major concern.
36 contributions were received. 11 contributions come from individual persons and
25 from companies, associations and international organisations. The respondents WE NOW TURN IN MORE DETAILS INTO THE RESPONSES.
come from sectors as diverse as postal and express courier, customs services agents,
On the issue of e-commerce, some participants suggest better data sharing between
port systems, logistic companies, e-commerce, business associations or inter-
Customs authorities and economic operators and among Customs authorities, in-
national organisations.
cluding from third countries. The suggestion has also been made to increase the lia-
Most contribution points to problems linked to the non-uniformity of Customs rules and bility and responsibility of platforms, while the alternative suggestion is been made
procedures across Member States. Those procedures are seen by most respondents as to increase the liability and responsibility of carriers. Some respondents suggest
burdensome and disconnected from business trade operations. An increased use of decoupling the collection of customs duties and the collection of VAT (in addition,
IOSS, a reassessment of the de minimis threshold and a simplification of the duty col- some respondents suggest to have one single import VAT rate), to make the IOSS
lection system are the points most raised for e-commerce. For risk management, the system compulsory for B2C, and to reassess the de minimis threshold (as to possibly
issue of access to the right data from the right party at the right time is seen as crucial. increase it to corresponding levels in third countries or to decrease it to counter il-
There is a perceived inadequate integration process between market participants and licit trade). A simplified duty collection system is also been proposed (with buckets),
Customs when it comes to data. Many respondents suggest more responsibilities from notably for low value B2C and C2C shipments. The idea is raised that more efficient
actors in the chain, notably platforms or carriers. At the same time, many respondents and quicker clearance would have a positive impact on customer’s satisfaction and
are concerned by the difficulty for these actors to know the content of packages and could reduce the number of returned items, having a positive environmental impact.
parcels. Many respondents suggest streamlining, rationalising and expanding the scope
Some respondents point nevertheless to a number of problems with the current
of data collected by Customs. For the review of procedures and data collection, it is sug-
functioning of the IOSS, such as the recognition of IOSS numbers in declarations
gested to take advantage of the possibilities created by modern technologies. Several
and potential misuses of IOSS numbers (Customs authorities can only recognize the
respondents also report on the need to better segment low-risk trade and increase the
validity of an IOSS number, not the actual holder). The numbers can then be used for
role of AEOs. Turning to non-fiscal risks, the main concern of respondents is the lack
fraud and avoiding VAT payments at the border.
of a harmonised list of prohibitions and restrictions at the EU level and that national
lists not only differ across Member States but are also difficult to access. Respondents
also stressed that Single Windows are not always interoperable and integrated. Finally,
38
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 38 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Appendices Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
On the issue of risk management, the suggestion to separate aviation security pro- Some inconsistencies are been pointed such as the need to clear goods in a customs
cedures from other customs risk is made. Some participants also suggest that more office of the Member States of destination instead of in the entering hub, which leads
controls could be made at source, on the export side. Another respondent stresses according to some respondents to unnecessary and environmentally-detrimental
the need to integrate transit better into current processes. Some respondents also movements of goods by trucks and planes. Some respondents stress the need for
voice the difficulty/impossibility of (some) customs declarants to verify the safe- Customs to be part of strategic and disaster management plans given their role at the
ty and conformity of goods as the information is provided by shippers and these borders. The opinion that low-risk trade is not enough segmented is voiced. Turning
customs declarants do not have access to the physical packages without customs to AEOs, some respondents suggest allowing them to arrange import through the
supervision. Several respondents stress the crucial need for better data and addition- whole EU. One respondent also proposes to include as AEO criteria the IP licensing
al data sources (for example, intermediaries, platforms) and access to commercial management criteria.
data. Closer looks at current private initiates to exchange commercial data between
commercial operators could lead to opening these data exchanges to Customs. There On the issue of non-fiscal risks, the lack of a harmonised list of prohibitions and
is an inadequate integration process between market participants and Customs. One restrictions is raised as a particular problem as rules may differ across Member
participant names the goal “getting the right data from the right party at the right States. In addition, the lists are not transparently available in each Member State.
time”. It is also shared by some respondents that risk management needs to build Respondents also flag the fact that multiple systems and data requirements exist
on modern technologies such as deep learning, video analytic platforms, web crawl- even under Single Windows and that some Single Windows are stand-alone, without
ing and dark web investigations, smart containers, etc. New payment data reporting cross-country integration. In terms of non-compliant products, some respondents
obligations on payment service providers could also be of use. Some respondents voice the idea that the current legislative framework is not adapted for protecting
indicate the difficulty to obtain end-to-end data from third country suppliers (which consumers under e-commerce and that the responsibility of platforms needs to be
may command multilateral trade agreements at countries’ level) and the need to strengthened, notably under the product liability directive. It is also suggested to
ensure that the data collection process does not interfere with the speed of trade. study the situation of EU food legislation that has introduced a system of fees cal-
Some replies express that false sustainability and environmental claims will need to culated to reward operators with consistently good records of compliance. In addi-
be looked at more closely, others stress the growing need to control IP infringements tion, it is further suggested that customs duties could directly fund Customs offices
of imported products. as incentive. Respondents also suggest improving safety controls by establishing a
systemic cooperation between of the Consumer Safety Network with other European
Some respondents complain that they must fill at least 5 declarations (one on safe- networks and to follow the example of the EU-Canada administrative arrangement
ty and security prior to loading, one data declaration on safety and security and a for cooperation, which allows exchange of data and joint investigations.
presentation of the good on arrival at the entry point, the presentation of the good
at the Member States of destination, and finally the filing of the import clearance
in the Member States of destination). They also complain that the clearing process
is still mostly real time and manual, which is time-inefficient and prone to errors.
39
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 39 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Appendices Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
Some respondents stress the disconnection between customs procedures and the re-
ality of business. This leads to extra requirements and procedures to bridge commer-
cial processes and customs requirements. In addition, some respondents complain
about the fact that the procedures under the UCC have been digitalised one-to-one
(even if they still imply many papers and PDFs) instead of having been redesigned
to take advantage of modern technologies (including blockchain and artificial intel-
ligence). The rules are also seen as too complex, increasing in number and leading
to high compliance costs.
Respondents indicated that a clear mandate for change shall be given and that the
process shall be piloted to coordinate interagency cooperation, operational process-
es, data sharing and the development of systems. It also entails a planning process
and resources.
On the issue of governance, the non-uniformity of the application of rules and proced-
ures (including tariff classification) across Member States is also stressed. Some re-
spondents voice the need for a European Customs Agency, a uniform application of the
Customs rules and procedures as well as a single customs system where declarations
could be made in any language of the EU at any entry point. Some comments extend
to the need to include excise duties in the EU standardisation process. One respondent
suggests studying the example of Switzerland, which has eliminated customs duties for
industrial products.
40
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 40 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Appendices Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
APPENDIX 4: SUMMARY OF THE HEARINGS OF INVITED EXPERTS
The Wise person group auditioned stakeholders to gather stakeholder views be- There is a call by invited experts for simplified, modernised and future-proof legis-
fore tabling a set of recommendations. Seven meetings were held in Brussels from lation better able to cope with new developments. Several experts pointed that
September 2021 to March 2022 to discuss key topics for the modernization of customs: e-commerce and new business opportunities need to be accompanied by corres-
the rise of e-commerce, the future of risk management, the effective management of ponding responsibilities from the actors along the value chain, that real disincen-
customs’ increasing range of non-financial tasks, and the future governance of Cus- tives for fraudulent or negligent declarations and trade facilitation for honest players
toms. During the meetings, the Group has been informed by the Commission about the (through the revision of the AEO system, new customs declaration processes and/or
work already carried out by existing project groups and subgroups, and recent relevant a system-based approach) should be developed. In addition, the hearings point at a
studies. The Group has conducted hearings with public and private sector experts (in need for a new data and risk management system, taking advantages of the possibil-
IT and data management) and relevant stakeholders along the entire value chain, such ities created by modern technologies, in full compliance with data protection. Equal-
as representatives of businesses (large and SMEs), individual companies including ly, non-fiscal risks need to be dealt with to better match the EU ambition to become
e-commerce, consumers associations, NGOs, airports, seaports, postal operators and environmentally and climate-friendly as well as to protect its citizens and businesses.
express courier companies, logistics companies, academics, international institution- This would require a change of governance, sometimes leading participants to call
al partners (WTO, WCO, World Bank), and Member States; (the list of invited experts for an EU customs agency, in full respect with subsidiarity principle.
and associations is included in annex). Extensive summaries of the hearings have been
made available at the official webpage.
THE NEED FOR A SIMPLIFIED, MODERNISED AND FUTURE PROOF
As a summary from the hearings, the pace of change in trade, the explosion of LEGISLATION
e-commerce, new advances in technology, increased expectations on security, safety
The hearings have indicated that rules are outdated and needs to be modernised.
and sustainability by European citizens has not quite been matched by evolutions in
customs processes and systems. The above-mentioned root causes have resulted in The sequence of customs steps is too complicated and operators must provide
a Customs Union that is growingly dysfunctional, too static, and not able to deal with the same information at multiple time for different systems. More user-friendly
emerging threats. A common complaint is the lack of uniform implementation of Cus- forms would improve voluntary compliance. A Single Window would, according
toms legislation by Member States, with different interpretation of the common rules, to invited experts, offer a (1) single submission of data, (2) single and synchron-
differences in control procedures and differences in sanctions for non-compliance. In ous processing, and (3) single decision for release and a single mechanism for
addition, Customs goals have changed, with a much greater role in non-fiscal protec- trader communication.
tion, and regulation has become more complex. There is also today a greater need for
near-real-time analysis, as distinct from post-release analysis with historical data.
41
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 41 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Appendices Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
Some invited experts also see binding information procedures on tariff and ori- of reliable trader should not only look at the activities of the trader, but also at the
gin as in need of review. Businesses are particularly concerned with the multiplica- networks where it operates (i.e. the entire trade and supply chain). They find that
tion of rules and call for a drastic simplification of customs procedures, a simpler tar- the benefits/incentives of reliable trader programs are less controls at clearance, a
iff and duty rate system. The existing combined nomenclature is also not considered broader use of post-release controls and a more predictable, fast and resilient supply
fit for new technology and new products. Most EU regulations on products require chain. They voiced that reliable traders could help customs to detect new risks and
specific expertise (and there are often divergent interpretation of the same meas- illicit goods.
ures), which also put SMEs at disadvantage. Compliance can put a disproportionate
burden on trade. Therefore, several experts call for making the legislation clear Several business experts ask for a system-based approach to be considered as
and coherent (“better written rules”) as vital to allow for good faith compliance an alternative approach to a transaction-based approach. This would entail more
by all traders. They consider that Customs legislation must be more dynamic possibilities to apply self-assessments and, when operators are compliant, busi-
and future-proof to adapt to new products and new business processes. When nesses would benefit from periodical submission of data and automatic release of
rules are complex, guidance and due diligence instructions could help companies to the goods instead of having to submit declarations for every transaction. Businesses
know what needs to be done. also think that controls do not necessarily have to occur at the borders (unless
there is a risk for health) and could occur at the importer’s premises to avoid trade
It was proposed by some experts that the EU could consider issuing binding tar- disruption and overload at border posts.
iff information at central level to resolve tariff classification issues. Several invit-
ed experts have also called for a simplification of the duty rules for low-value import. A large number of stakeholders suggest that access to data that exists in busi-
nesses’ databases or in their invoices but are currently not available to Cus-
Some stakeholders also suggested consideration of synergies between the VAT/ toms, because outside of the declaration, could be a game-changer. However,
IOSS and Customs processes, both in relation to the value assessment aspects accessing this data requires a change of paradigm away from traditional customs
and to the declaration and data processing work. Discussions included whether declarations towards an integrated chain of business data available to Customs
the IOSS scheme could be extended to cover consignments over the EUR 150 thresh- authorities to control where and when necessary.
old, whether VAT rates could be adapted for e-commerce, and whether Customs and
VAT data could all be fed by operators into a single system. Finally, many stakeholders mentioned that the Customs Union need to adapt
more quickly to the fast-changing trade environment. It was expressed that de-
Businesses plead for a better exploitation of the existing possibilities for sim- velopments of new structures and systems have been quicker in the field of law en-
plifications in the UCC. Business facilitation schemes need in their view a revamp. forcement policies than in Customs. Many experts see an urgent need to build in-
The tools for simplification may be fit for large companies but are too costly for SMEs. centives for national systems to connect to the center and an urgent need for a clear
The “Authorized Economic Operator” status” shows promise but needs to expand, mandate to define common risk appetite as a guarantee to EU citizens Security.
be multi-layered and rendered more effective. The concept of reliable trader should
make more use of risk segmentation. Also, some experts proposed that the concept
42
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 42 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Appendices Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
ADDRESSING NEW RISKS CREATED BY E-COMMERCE Some experts expressed concerns that trade is being (in part) routed to adapt
AND RETHINKING PLATFORMS’ RESPONSIBILITIES to non-uniform risk management and control conditions, leading to logistical
inefficiencies (additional transport and CO2 emissions) on top of weakening con-
The hearings have indicated that the digitalisation of the economy raises chal- trols. E-commerce is offering large possibilities to shift traffic into small quantities
lenges for Customs. In particular, the fragmentation of consignments into low- which are much harder to control and are beyond the threshold for duties.
value individual shipments and the issue of responsibility and liability of online
platforms are issues raised by many experts as in need of solution. The non-financial risks are also very important – both in terms of serious (pot-
entially fatal) harm and security threats caused by dangerous products. There
E-commerce operators declare that they feel responsible for the products sold is also economic and social damage to consider: where EU industries have to work
on their platform and carry out strong due diligence checks. Reference was made to high standards (e.g. consumer, environmental and employment protection) and
to strict on-boarding of suppliers for Customs and stringent checks against counter- e-commerce imports do not respect these standards, competition is unfair and sys-
feit goods. However, when it comes to ensuring product safety, experts stressed dif- tematically damages Union and national interests, including jobs and innovation.
ferences (possibly linked to the role of the platform).
Some participants reported that there is in fact very little incentive for operators DIGITALISATION OF CUSTOMS
in general to improve compliance because there are very few adverse conse-
A recent survey conducted by the WTO and the WCO showed that data analytics
quences in case of non-compliance. It was suggested that platforms could take
and artificial intelligence were having the biggest impact on customs oper-
greater responsibilities for the compliance of the traffic flows which they enable
ations, including on dealing with non-fiscal risks.
(including those based outside the EU). Some experts consider that they should be
registered in EU, with liability/responsibility for Customs matters. Members noted that the majority of data that could be useful for customs risk
analysis and controls is already collected and available in external non-Customs
The planned Digital Services Act is expected to have a positive effect by request-
systems (e.g. IT systems of companies) and that IT techniques and tools to col-
ing online marketplaces to apply the “know your customer” principle. Further, it
lect them exists as well. Improving access to data can be done by providing incen-
was suggested that the future revision of the Product Liability Directive could make
tives for the exchange. One obstacle concern privacy/security rules.
it clear that all professionals involved in the supply chain (including online market-
places) are jointly liable when products are not compliant and that online market- The Commission is active in developing a framework for a European Digital Identity
places should no longer be seen as passive intermediaries as they have an important aiming at increasing interoperability and re-use of models. Digital passports for products
role when it comes to limiting the circulation of defective products. from third country could be established within a reciprocity framework.
43
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 43 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Appendices Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
NEW DATA AND RISK MANAGEMENT Another discussed difficulty is that Customs are generally unable to confirm the
correctness of the declared data without opening the consignment. The informa-
Many participants to the hearings mentioned that the lack of a common EU ap- tion currently collected by Customs seems largely insufficient to assess the compliance
proach in tackling financial risks and the persistence of an unequal implementation of products. Important information is not available in the customs declaration. To add
of controls at the EU borders create opportunities for fraudsters to abuse the to the difficulty, there is little if no match between the customs nomenclature and prod-
system and illegally evade the payment of taxes and duties. uct classification. The nomenclature is not dynamic enough and not connected to the
reality of business world.
Evidence presented to the group suggests that data sharing within the Customs
Union is incomplete and uncoordinated. Data sharing between operators and au- The experts voiced a need for an effective data-driven approach, implying clarity
thorities was cited as key element to be improved by the large majority of experts. on the data needed, on who can and must provide it, and on how best to collect it. It
Some experts believed that IT is not the problem to obtain data – as technical solu- is seen important to collect data as early in the supply chain as possible so that risk
tions are available – and that the issue is a legislative and political one. It was noted analysis can be carried out and customs interventions arranged in advance. It is also
that a major inhibitor is the lack of trust between Member States when it comes important to provide for effective sharing and use of the data in harmonised processes
to sharing data, sharing intelligence, relying on each other’s IT tools. The current (in particular, linking all available data to a specific consignment declaration).
legislative framework is not perceived as necessarily facilitate data sharing and the
current exchange between authorities is limited by competitive concerns. Improving the quality of data is also presented by experts as essential. Data
quality can be improved by developing algorithms for checking the accuracy of data
Consequently, there is yet no central data sharing mechanism that can support submitted or by creating incentives for filling in accurate data. Customs procedures
a European-wide risk management system. This leads to a limited focus when ad- also need to be simplified and data required from trade must be assessed and ration-
dressing risks (mainly isolated at national level) and the use of IT tools exclusively alised by deleting unnecessary data requests, eliminating redundant requests and
developed to respond to national needs (without cross-border dimension). The key adding the necessary but missing data elements.
point would be to have all necessary data from operators along the supply chain, to
foster exchanges of data between customs and e-commerce platforms, and between Members acknowledged that Customs risk analysis can be improved via the use
countries of export and import. Data would be available centrally to Customs, other of data analytics by (1) developing IT platforms for data sharing, (2) developing sta-
market surveillance and law enforcement authorities to allow a real-time mapping of tistical methods to find anomalies/fraud patterns and (3) improving the use of data
risks in the EU and a quick common response. analytics in detection technology tools. Two main challenges were noted. First, auto-
mated customs data analytics accuracy is not 100 % and efficient detection remains
Some experts expressed the opinion that risk analysis is only harmonized in the text- partly dependent on human judgement. It requires combining data analysis exper-
books but that there remain large divergences of interpretation on the ground. tise with customs risk expertise and therefore require investing in specific trainings.
A minimum standard of controls was suggested, taking account of differences in Secondly, data are currently very fragmented (for instance logistic data on rail, road
control rates. etc.) and IT systems have each their own standards.
44
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 44 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Appendices Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
PROHIBITIONS AND RESTRICTIONS the responsibilities of economic operators in particular platforms), the prioritization
of risks and actions (taking account of practical control capacities and the need for
Over time, new concerns have been added to the traditional customs tasks, such deep sectoral knowledge), and the use and interoperability of IT systems and data
as the interception of dangerous and counterfeit products, or products that do and of new technologies.
not comply with health or environmental standards. Nowadays, goods still make
up more than two-thirds of the value of EU external trade and Customs need to en-
GOVERNANCE
sure that imported goods respect all EU standards (IPR, product safety, etc.).
From the perspective of the Customs Union to deliver outcomes “as one”, the
Experts said that ambitious EU policy objectives (trade, environment in-
current governance configuration involves several important challenges. The
dustrial policy) cannot be implemented without a strong, harmonised and
large majority of interviewed stakeholders complain about a systematic absence of
uniform EU customs.
common implementation of customs measures and different control practices across
The Members were informed by consumer associations of alarming recent stud- border entry points within and across Member states. There is a call from these stake-
ies showing that consumers are confronted with a constant increase of dangerous holders for a uniform and forward-looking approach in the EU based on more har-
and counterfeit goods due to the lack of compliance of safety standards or the monized and simplified procedures, with similar approaches to customs controls
use of chemicals in products. and an increased use of modern technology and use of data.
The cooperation and complementarities between the Customs authorities and At the strategic level, the current division of roles and responsibilities across all in-
Market Surveillance Authorities (MSAs) was also discussed as their role will con- volved bodies does not provide for a specific focal point for prioritisation and organi-
tinue to increase in the future. The hearings suggest that cooperation is not always sation of a common delivery, for clarifying the customs contribution in multi-agency
working optimally and the compliance of goods to safety and other rules is not al- risks and threats, or for developing and implementing bilateral and multilateral
ways adequately checked. The system in the non-food area suffers from a multiplicity international co-operation.
of measures and regimes of controls depending on the type of goods. The number of
At the operational level, some differences in national approaches to customs con-
regulations related to products has increased exponentially in recent years and
trols and significant weaknesses in fraud protection were noted. MSAs are the second
require high standards and compliance measures to be respected by EU business. If
line of defense but are constituted of more than 600 bodies, under the responsibility
goods coming from third countries do not respect those standards, this generates
of a dozen of concerned Ministries and a regulatory framework that depends on the
unfair competition for legitimate EU business.
topic, with limited cooperation across MSAs with different focusses. Customs admin-
E-commerce is a catalyzer for these problems as it puts into question the current istrations also struggle to perform their duties given the resource limitations in terms
logic of controls. Controls can indeed be performed either at the border or with- of staff, equipment and capacity to use new technologies for detection and controls.
in the single market. Some themes for reflection presented in the auditions include
roles and responsibilities (what needs to be done at the border by customs versus
what could be done in the internal market by the market surveillance authorities,
45
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 45 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Appendices Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
THERE IS A NEED TO IMPROVE THE INCENTIVES TO MAKE More broadly on compliance issues, the Members discussed with stakeholders
THE SYSTEM WORK whether priorities for controls could be better coordinated and managed at EU
level. Defining common priorities is tricky because each Member State has its own
Taking account of the current Customs Union Governance conditions, inter- national priorities. If it is impossible to define EU priorities, the EU could at least de-
viewed stakeholders also reflected on the importance of considering contents fine common criteria on how to prioritise. Members also discussed the opportunity
(what activities should be done at EU level versus what at Member State level; to consider a dispute settlement mechanism to address divergence of approaches
what is the best structure for the strategic and operational problems) before turn- between Member States and allocate responsibilities for non-compliance.
ing to the appropriate form (and learning in that context about experience of other
EU actions). It was proposed that this should be accompanied by more investment in MSAs/
Customs cooperation by linking people (mentoring programme, building mutual
Stakeholders discussed areas of customs activity that would benefit from the understanding) and systems (creating interface between MSA and customs by
Customs Union acting as one, and what would be the best structure, scope and identifying inter–operability needs between existing systems).
approach for a future governance model to achieve this (taking account also of
data governance issues, as these are foundational). Some Customs authorities have used public-private partnerships to enhance their
capacity to fulfil their dual role as trade facilitators and enforcers of trade rules at the
The data and risk management and IT aspects seem prima facie to emerge as border in the context of electronic commerce.
key issues. IT tools are fragmented with the sprawling of different IT interfaces to ad-
dress specific risks. Fragmentation is a cost on business and adds to the inefficiency The Wise Persons Group also discussed the experience of CELBET where 11 Mem-
of integrated controls. Customs IT systems development requires many parallel pro- ber States have set up an expert team to build up and strengthen operational
jects which inter-connect national, common and external systems. Customs data is cooperation actions at the Eastern and south-eastern land border to act as one.
accordingly divided across different systems and controllers, limiting visibility and Within 5 years, CELBET has reached substantive results. These 5 years of experience
common risk analysis. Centralised systems have proven to be highly cost-efficient has also shed light on some problems, such as the difficulties to share data and risk
from an overall EU-perspective compared to distributed, hybrid and decentralised management results between Member States, the persistence of differences of rate
systems which entail lengthy processes (sometimes twice the time) and a multiplica- of controls between border crossing points, and differences in performance between
tion of costs. One needed development relates to an improved interoperability Member States, also due to different resources capacity and level of training of staff.
and use of information systems. It also points to the differences between Member States on the priorities to implement
prohibitions and restrictions and the lack of common approach to sanctions, which
In addition, experts expressed the opinion that it is not possible to manage EU- hinder the effectiveness of joint actions. CELBET claims for the development of a
wide risks without an EU risk analysis capacity. More cooperation and trust are permanent separate customs entity, encompassing all Member States and all bor-
crucially needed between customs administrations if we want to succeed. ders (land, sea, air) and enabling customs to act as one.
46
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 46 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Appendices Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
LIST OF INVITED EXPERTS
(INVITED ASSOCIATIONS) DG SANTE (European Commission) Piraeus Port Authority / COSCO SHIPPING Lines
(Greece) S.A.
DG TAXUD (European Commission)
Accenture Port of Marseille
DG TRADE (European Commission)
AFSCA – Belgian Federal Agency for the Safety Port of Rotterdam
of the Food Chain DHL
Posta Slovenije
Allegro Estonia Customs
Mr. Andrea Renda (Centre for European Policy Studies)
BEUC – The European Consumer Organisation European Court of Auditors
Singapore Customs
BusinessEurope Europol
SMEUnited
CEFIC – European Chemical Industry Council Frontex
Swiss customs
CELBET Genoa Sea Port Authority
TRAFFIC
Delft Technical University Global Express Association
UPS
DG BUDG (European Commission) Lego
Václav Havel Airport Prague
DG CCRF – French Ministry for Economy Leipzig Halle Airport
World Bank
DG CONNECT (European Commission) Liège Airport
World Customs Organisation
DG ENV (European Commission) Lisbonne Airport (ANA - Aeroportos de Portugal)
World Trade Organisation
DG GROW (European Commission) Maersk Trade and Customs Consulting
Zalando
DG HOME (European Commission) Mc Kinsey
ZZI
DG OLAF (European Commission) Paypal
47
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 47 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Appendices Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
APPENDIX 5: ESTIMATION OF TAXES COLLECTED AT THE EU BORDERS
This appendix makes an estimation of the taxes collected at EU borders. They however seem to have so far little to do with trade of goods and are unlikely to
be collected or assessed by Customs.
The Tax Revenue Statistics collected by Eurostat contain data on tax and duties collection
by Member States.21 The aggregated information is also available in the Taxation Trends The other important tax that is collected at borders is VAT. A rough estimate of the
Report published by DG Taxation and Customs Union of the European Commission.22 amount of VAT collected at borders is obtained by multiplying the value of extra-EU
imports of goods24 by the respective national standard VAT rates.25 Indeed, imports
The statistics provide information on taxes and duties on imports excluding VAT23 usually concern goods that are not subject to a reduced VAT rate. This amounts to
as % of GDP. In 2020, it represented for the EU27 0.5 % of GDP (stable over the reporting EUR 360.5 billion for EU27.
period 2008-2020). In monetary terms, this amounts to EUR 72.7 billion.
However, the system of VAT is such that we need to distinguish between B2C trans-
Note that this category includes both import duties (category D2121) and excises actions for which the VAT payment is final and B2B transactions for which the VAT
duties collected at borders (category D2122C) but excludes excises duties within the paid by the VAT-registered importer is deductible as input VAT. C2C transactions are
Member State (which are included in the other taxes on products, category D.214). not subject to VAT. For a fair estimate, one needs to select B2C transactions only. To
Note that excises duties collected at borders include those levied on imports from the best of our knowledge, the share of B2C in total transactions is not directly avail-
other Member States. It also does not include some export duties and monetary able in the statistics. We can reasonably assume that the share of extra-EU C2C trade
compensatory, (category D.214k), which are recorded as capital taxes. Based on the in goods is negligeable so that the market is split between B2B and B2C. Statista of-
National Tax Lists provided by Member States to Eurostat, we can see that category fers the share of B2B in e-commerce for a selection of developed countries for 201926.
D.214k is in reality zero/non-existent in all Member States. In addition, taxes on inter- It varies between 72 % and 95 %. We shall stress that the share of B2C in e-commerce
national transactions (D.29d), taxes on pollution (D.29f) and the under-compensa- is likely to be higher than its share in total trade of goods, that englobes industrial
tion of VAT (flat-rate system) (D.29g) have been considered as consumption taxes not and chemical goods for example.
part of this category.
21) https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=Tax_revenue_statistics. The cut-off data is February 2022.
22) https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/taxation-1/economic-analysis-taxation/taxation-trends-european-union_en
23) Category D.212 in the ESA2010 classification system.
24) Intra and Extra-EU trade by Member State and by product group [EXT_LT_INTRATRD__custom_2099317] https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/products-datasets/-/EXT_LT_INTRATRD Data extracted
on 15/02/2022
25) https://ec.europa.eu/taxation_customs/taxation-1/economic-analysis-taxation/data-taxation_en
26) https://www.statista.com/statistics/1242150/b2b-ecommerce-share-in-total-ecommerce-sales/
48
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 48 30/03/22 09:21
PUTTING MORE UNION IN THE EUROPEAN CUSTOMS
Appendices Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a Geopolitical Europe
EU import of products is split in different categories. Food and drinks, raw materi- Other
2% Food and drink
als, energy, chemicals and machinery and vehicles are unlikely to be subject to B2C
7%
extra-EU trade. Hence, only the categories ‘other manufactured goods’ and ‘others’, 26% Raw materials
totalling 28 % of trade are possibly containing B2C transactions. If we consider as Other 5%
manufactured
an upper bond that B2C transactions for those is 10 %, we obtain 2.8 % of the trade.
goods
We apply this coefficient to our figures27 to obtain a B2C import VAT collected of
EUR 10.1 billion for EU27. Energy
13%
This gives a grand total of EUR 82.8 billion for the EU27 for the tax, duties and
VAT collected on imports.
2020
2020 Taxes and Estimated Estimated Total
Chemicals
duties on import VAT import VAT 34% Machinery 14%
imports (million (million and vehicles
excluding VAT EUR) – all EUR) – B2C
(million EUR) transactions transactions
(a) (b) (a)+(c)
Source: Eurostat, https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/statistics-explained/index.php?title=Extra-
EU-27 72,752 360,565 10,096 82,848 EU_trade_in_goods#Evolution_of_extra-EU_trade based on Comext DS-06332.
27) Assuming here that the share is similar across Member States.
49
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 49 30/03/22 09:21
TAX-20-002-Future customs-REPORT-C-bis.indd 50 30/03/22 09:21
Saatja: Keit Pillak <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 28.04.2022 19:09
Adressaat: RAM Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: Commissioner's Gentiloni letter to Min Le Maire and ECOFIN
Ministers on the Wise Persons Group Report
From:
[email protected] <CAB-GENTILONI-
[email protected]> Sent: Thursday, April 28, 2022 6:55 PMTo: FOVET
Corinne <
[email protected]>Cc:
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected]; Keit Pentus-Rosimannus
<
[email protected]>; Keit Pillak
<
[email protected]>;
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected]; BENGTSSON Sabina
<
[email protected]>Subject: Commissioner's Gentiloni
letter to Min Le Maire and ECOFIN Ministers on the Wise Persons Group
Report
Dear Ms Fovet,
On behalf of Commissioner Gentiloni, please kindly find attached the
letter and report addressed to Minister Le Maire.
Thank you very much.
Kind Regards,
Commissioners office
European CommissionBERL 10/026
B-1049 Brussels/Belgium
Ref. Ares(2022)3299998 - 28/04/2022
European
Commission
PAOLO GENTILOMI Rue de la Loi, 200
MEMBER OF THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION B 1049 Brussels
Tel. +32-2 295 02 50
ECONOMY
[email protected]
Brussels,
Ares (2022) 2752061
Dear Minister,
With pleasure I share with you, in your capacity as President of the ECOFIN Council, the
final report by the Wise Persons Group on the future of Customs, entitled "'Putting more
Union in the European Customs: Ten proposals to make the EU Customs Union fit for a
Geopolitical Europe”.
More than five weeks after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, their attempts to weaken and divide
the Union have only been met with unity and determination, and with our Customs Union at
the forefront responsible for implementing the decisions taken.
This is not the first time that European Customs have effectively reacted to unforeseen
events. However, such crises, as well as the longer-term trends shaping our economies,
highlight the need for a structural modernisation of our Customs Union.
The Wise Persons Group chaired by former Spanish Foreign Minister Arancha Gonzalez
Laya and former Slovenian Finance Minister Mateja Vraničar Erman sought to identify
innovative solutions to help European Customs better respond to new trade models, growing
trade volumes, the green transition and new geopolitical and security risks. These are distilled
in the ten recommendations put forth in the enclosed report.
I am convinced this report will be a valuable contribution to the work that lies ahead.
Yours sincerely,
Ce: EU ECOFIN Ministers
Mr Bruno LE MAIRE
Ministre de l'économie
139, rue de Bercy
TELEDOC 151
FR-75572 Paris cedex 12,
France
Electronically signed on 28/04/2022 16:12 (UTC+02) in accordance with Article 11 of Commission Decision (EU) 2021/2121