ERAELU KAITSE JA RIIGI LÄBIPAISTVUSE EEST
SA Latvia Yours: 25.07.2022
Elijas Street 17 Our: 25.08.2022 nr 2.1.-1/22/1829
LV-1050 Riga
[email protected]
Answer to request
Estonian Data Protection Inspectorate received your request for information (GDPR Art. 61,
VMN 421993) regarding processing personal data on social networking platforms, notably, on
Facebook.
Please see below Estonian DPI´s comments:
1. Are there other authorities in your country, besides national courts of law, who are
assessing complaints and/or cases in relation to publications of personal data on
Internet (on social media sites, online news, other web pages and social networking
sites), especially, but not exclusively, in the context of freedom of speech and
expression?
Answer: We have web police whose main obligation is to advise citizens on topics
like internet harassing/bullying, sexual abuse, identity thefts etc. They do not process
offences themselves. We do not have authorities who would independently assess
publications of personal data on Internet in the context of freedom of speech and
expression. It is only possible to go to court against a publisher.
2. Are there any national laws and regulations in your country, besides GDPR and any
possible national laws transposing GDPR provisions, that limit, broaden or have
impact on your SA’s powers to assess cases of personal data processing on social
networking platforms (notably, Facebook)? If so, please describe in more detail, for
example, do you have powers to request or to take down publications containing
personal data or erase the personal data from them on these social networking
platforms?
Answer: We have additionally Personal Data Protection Act1 (it elaborates and
supplements the provisions contained in Regulation (EU) 2016/679 of the European
Parliament and of the Council), which provides for procedure for exercise of state
supervision over compliance with the requirements for the processing of personal data.
Chapter 2 sets specific grounds for processing of personal data (§ 4 - Processing of
personal data for journalistic purposes). In this case we assess whether the publishing
of personal data could be justified by journalistic purposes and whether the
prerequisites of such publishing have been met (public interest occurs; principles of
journalism ethics have been met; does not cause excessive damage to the rights of any
data subject). During the assessment of such cases we evaluate freedom of speech
1
https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/523012019001/consolide
Tatari tn 39 / 10134 Tallinn / 627 4135 /
[email protected] / www.aki.ee Registrikood 70004235
versus protection of personal data.
§ 10 of the same Act regulates the processing of personal data in connection with
violation of an obligation and § 11 processing of personal data in public places.
3. Does your SA commonly collaborate with other state authorities and bodies (e.g.,
police institutions) in order to try to identify and contact owners of anonymous
publications that contain or display personal data online?
Answer: No, we usually don´t.
4. To what extent does your SA analyse and evaluate the argued publication itself, for
example, in the context of freedom of speech and expression?
Answer: We evaluate the publications in the view of personal data publishing – e.g
what kind of personal data has been published, what are the possible consequences,
how damaging is the publication to the data subject etc. (in accordance to Personal
Data Protection Act § 4 - Processing of personal data for journalistic purposes). We
assess whether the publishing of personal data could be justified by journalistic
purposes and whether the prerequisites of such publishing have been met (public
interest occurs; principles of journalism ethics have been met; does not cause
excessive damage to the rights of any data subject). During the assessment of such
cases we evaluate freedom of speech versus protection of personal data.
We do not evaluate reputational damage – this is done by county courts.
5. What is your most typical type of response to the data subject when he/she complains
about his/her personal data being published on Facebook or another social
networking/online platform? Do you mostly reply to the data subject by encouraging
him/her to contact in writing Facebook or the administration of the respective social
networking/online platform and to ask for erasure of his/her personal data (and later,
if the situation has not been resolved, send it to the respective LSA via IMI system), or
do you have some other tools and/or methods for resolving issues regarding online
publications of personal data?
Answer: First of all we do encourage the data subject to contact Facebook (or any
other platform) themselves and ask for the erasure of the data. If the data subject has
already tried that and the problem still exists, we assess the situation and depending on
the outcome contact the platform ourselves. If the situation is urgent and the breach of
GDPR is on a larger scale, we take action ourselves.
6. More specifically, what are your considerations, most typical procedures within your
SA or other previous experience, when assessing complaints or cases of:
6.1. Internet bots, digital/cyber bullying and fake accounts on Facebook, which are
by definition usually used and/or owned by anonymous users;
Answer: We are assessing the complaints individually based on the breach of
GDPR. In the case there is a violation and it is solvable between the complainant
and Facebook/other platform, we only give suggestions. If the problem cannot
be solved and data subject´s rights are in danger, we do take action ourselves.
6.2. Online publications of State officials, e.g., police officers (additionally, do you
have any national laws prohibiting such publications containing their personal
data, including, live streaming online);
2 (3)
Answer: We do not observe them on day-to-day basis and only intervene when
there is a complaint made.
6.3. Situations when the personal data of another person is revealed in the comment
sections next to a certain publication on Facebook, especially in the context of
different beliefs and division of opinions, e.g., most recently, about war in
Ukraine, vaccination/antivaccination movement of Covid-19, political views
etc.;
Answer: If the problem lies between two individuals we urge them to find a
solution between themselves or by contacting Facebook. We do not intervene in
arguments between two private persons unless an obvious violation of GDPR
exists.
6.4. Defamation claims, where also personal data is published, in the context of
freedom of speech and expression;
Answer: We do not assess the context of defamation claims in the context of
freedom of speech and expression; however if there is a breach of GDPR we can
intervene.
6.5. Situations when Facebook user account profiles, individual photos or other
information have been obtained (e.g. downloaded) without data subject’s
knowledge (consent) and reposted on various other online platforms, including
also pornographic sites, e.g., as a means of revenge;
Answer: We study complaints individually, there is no common or typical
response in this matter.
6.6. Live streaming online and/or publications containing personal data that
disappear automatically after certain time, e.g., “stories” on Instagram that are
available only for 24h.
Answer: We have not had similar cases in our practice.
Best regards
Annika Kaljula
jurist
authorized by Director General
3 (3)