Innovation Laboratory
Building and strengthening institutional capacity to support companies in
financial difficulties in Baltic States and Poland
For policy makers, civic society, and industry representatives
23-26 November 2020
AGENDA
23 November 2020 | 13:00 pm- 17:45 pm| Opening of the Innovation Laboratory
Please join https://us02web.zoom.us/j/89518588179?pwd=Ly9SNEkxVTQzeWl2cmNPT091TGJnZz09
13:15 – 13:20 Importance of SMEs support in financial difficulties – actual as never before
COVID-19 – Welcome and Introduction
13:20 – 14:00 Building and strengthening institutional capacity to support companies in
financial difficulties in Baltic States and Poland – organization “Lower Silesian
Intermediate Body” and Design School Kolding
14:00 – 15:00 Building SMEs support capacity in Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia, and Poland –
project RESTART BSR representatives
15:00 – 15:30 Coffee break
15:30 – 16:30 Ecosystems assessment of businesses support in financial difficulties, early
warning and second chance in the Baltic States and Poland – University of
Latvia researcher PhD. oec. cand. Liga Braslina
16.30 – 17.30 Tour de table: Reactions by Participants
17:30 – 17.45 Wrap-up & summary. Closing remarks
24 November 2020 | 9:00 am- 13:00 pm| Design Thinking Sessions – Estonia
Please join https://us02web.zoom.us/j/82518063908?pwd=R1dsQXE3OGlETTVqVFZIUUp5eitTUT09
9:10 – 9:15 Building and strengthening institutional capacity to support companies in
financial difficulties in Estonia. Keynote by RESTART BSR Estonia
representative
9:15 – 9:45 Recommendations for Estonia SMEs ecosystem support for companies in
financial difficulties, early warning and second chance arising from the
Research - University of Latvia researcher PhD. oec. cand. Liga Braslina
9:45 – 11:00 Innovation Laboratory Design Thinking Session – Estonia Support system
Innovation Laboratory| 23 - 26.11.2020| AGENDA 1
11:00 – 11:30 Coffee break
11:30 – 12:30 Session group presentations
12:30 – 12.45 Wrap-up & summary of Session
24 November 2020 | 13:00 pm- 17:45 pm| Design Thinking Sessions - Latvia
Please join https://us02web.zoom.us/j/83719665415?pwd=Q2d0VTBpQXpYYXdDL2MrYS9QajJYdz09
14:10 – 14:15 Building and strengthening institutional capacity to support companies in
financial difficulties in Latvia. Keynote by RESTART BSR Latvia representative
14:15 – 14:45 Recommendations for Latvia SMEs ecosystem support for companies in
financial difficulties, early warning and second chance arising from the
Research – University of Latvia researcher PhD. oec. cand. Liga Braslina
14:45 – 16:00 Innovation Laboratory Design Thinking Session – Latvia Support system
16:00 – 16:30 Coffee break
16:30 – 17:30 Session group presentations
17:30 – 17.45 Wrap-up & summary of Session
25 November 2020 | 9:00 pm- 13:00 pm| Design Thinking Sessions - Lithuania
Please join https://us02web.zoom.us/j/84628962764?pwd=RHVtcndXQm05dWw0UzhpOVFGWFQ4UT09
9:10 – 9:15 Building and strengthening institutional capacity to support companies in
financial difficulties in Lithuania. Keynote by RESTART BSR Lithuania
representative
9:15 – 9:45 Recommendations for Lithuania SMEs ecosystem support for companies in
financial difficulties, early warning and second chance arising from the
Research - University of Latvia researcher PhD. oec. cand. Liga Braslina
10:00 – 11:00 Innovation Laboratory Design Thinking Session – Lithuania Support system
11:00 – 11:30 Coffee break
11:30 – 12:30 Session group presentations
12:30 – 12.45 Wrap-up & summary of Session
Innovation Laboratory| 23 - 26.11.2020| AGENDA 2
25 November 2020 | 13:00 pm- 17:45 pm | Design Thinking Sessions - Poland
Please join https://us02web.zoom.us/j/83589756625?pwd=QVNYbXNyNXgxVXR1N0VHQ3cvSUZXZz09
14:10 – 14:15 Building and strengthening institutional capacity to support companies in
financial difficulties in Poland. Keynote by RESTART BSR Poland
representative
14:15 – 14:45 Recommendations for Poland SMEs ecosystem support for companies in
financial difficulties, early warning and second chance arising from the
Research - University of Latvia researcher PhD. oec. cand. Liga Braslina
14:45 – 16:00 Innovation Laboratory Design Thinking Session – Poland Support system
16:00 – 16:30 Coffee break
16:30 – 17:30 Session group presentations
17:30 – 17.45 Wrap-up & summary of Session
26 November 2020 | 9:00 pm- 13:00 pm| Recommendations for building and
strengthening institutional capacity to support companies in financial
difficulties in the Baltic States and Poland
Please join https://us02web.zoom.us/j/83547119602?pwd=ZmxwYndSSzRzTjVVOVJaN2htUFdQZz09
9:15 – 9:30 Summary of Innovation Laboratory Design Thinking sessions
9:30 – 10:00 Innovation Laboratory session recommendations for support of businesses in
financial difficulties, early warning, and second chance policies in Estonia
10:00 – 10:30 Innovation Laboratory session recommendations for support of businesses in
financial difficulties, early warning, and second chance policies in Lithuania
10:30 – 11:00 Innovation Laboratory session recommendations for support of businesses in
financial difficulties, early warning, and second-chance policies in Poland
11:00 – 11:30 Coffee break
11:30 – 12:00 Innovation Laboratory session recommendations for support of businesses in
financial difficulties, early warning, and second chance policies in Latvia
12:00 – 12:40 Tour de table: Reactions by Participants
12:40 – 13.00 Wrap-up & summary. Closing remarks
P.S. Agenda might slightly change due on keynote speaker’s availability and design thinking sessions durations.
Innovation Laboratory| 23 - 26.11.2020| AGENDA 3
Building and strengthening institutional capacity – engine to support
companies in financial difficulties in Baltic States and Poland
COVID-19 creates insolvencies time bomb, even if economies are supported by the state. Insolvency analysts
(Allianz Research,1 Euler Hermes2) forecast that insolvency processes are still ahead for countries in 2021,
reaching an insolvency increase of up to 35% in 2021. In European business culture, closing a business is seen as
a failure that leaves a negative impression on further business. Following the business liquidation or bankruptcy,
entrepreneurs in the EU mostly opt for a paid professional job rather than re-establishing their business.3
However, the experience of liquidation is inspiring - those entrepreneurs who re-establish their business after
bankruptcy are experiencing faster growth than start-ups. Research shows that entrepreneurs who have failed
are more successful than start-ups.4 This points out that an early warning and second chance policy that supports
companies in difficulty or bankrupt entrepreneurs to start a new business as soon as possible is one of the most
promising ways to strengthen existing and create new successful companies and thus jobs after COVID-19 crisis.
Several early warning and second chance support organizations for SMEs are already operating successfully in
Europe, while there are no such support systems in the Baltic States.
On 2019 the Republic of Latvia Ministry of Economics signed a cooperation agreement with the Polish business
support organization “Lower Silesian Intermediate Body” (the leading partner of the Interreg Baltic Sea Region
project “Restart BSR”) with the aim to build institutional capacity to support companies in financial difficulties
(hereinafter referred to as the Restart BSR project). The Restart BSR project is very closely linked to Directive
(EU) 2019/1023 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 June 2019 on preventive restructuring
regulation, debt cancellation and disqualification with target to increase the efficiency of restructuring,
insolvency and debt cancellation proceedings, which requires all Member States of the European Union to
provide an early warning tool (s). The Restart BSR project has united 6 partners - the Ministry of Economics of
the Republic of Latvia, the Latvian Technological Centre Foundation, the Polish business support organization
“Lower Silesian Intermediate Body”, Design School Kolding, Vilnius Gediminas Technical University and the
Estonian business support organization “Harju County Entrepreneurship and Development Consultancy” in
order to facilitate the implementation of a business support model in four pilot countries - Latvia, Estonia,
Lithuania and Poland, that would meet both the requirements of the above Directive and be the most effective
solution for financially distressed companies and its development, implementation, institutions, persons
involved in maintenance.
The Innovation Laboratory is convened to develop recommendations for policy makers in four pilot countries-
Latvia, Estonia, Lithuania, and Poland on building and strengthening institutional capacity to support
companies in financial difficulties.
The Innovation Laboratory includes presentations on the results of the research of the best European support,
early warning and second chance systems transferability in the Baltic Sea region countries, Design Thinking
working groups to develop recommendations for policy makers in four countries, experienced experts visions
and also a discussion on the overall conclusions and proposals developed.
In economics, an early warning system is generally interpreted as a system, used to forecast the future
performance of a company or country, possible deviations from the plan and to mitigate risks in times of crisis.
1 https://www.acredia.at/fileadmin/04_news-presse/01_meldungen/2020_07_20_InsolvencyTimeBomb.pdf
2 https://www.eulerhermes.co.uk/newsroom/covid-19-to-drive-43percent-rise-in-uk-insolvencies.html
3 Global Entrepreneurship Report, GEM 2019/2020
4 E. Stam, D. B. Audretsch and J. Meijaard, "Renascent Entrepreneurship", ERIM, 2006.
Innovation Laboratory| 23 - 26.11.2020| Background Paper 1
An early warning system refers to operations, systems, phenomena, people and other elements that constitute
an economic system (ecosystem5). The early warning system can identify the current situation and potential
risks both qualitatively and quantitatively (Ozgulbas & Koyuncugil, 2010). 6
The European Commission points out7 that insolvency rules cover a wide range of measures, from early
intervention before a company is in serious difficulties, to timely restructuring to ensure that viable companies
are maintained, to liquidation of assets where companies cannot otherwise be rescued and, last, the so-called
“second chance” for honest businessmen in the form of debt relief.
Until mid-2020, no unified definition of support for companies in financial difficulties, early warning and
“second chance”, binding for all EU Member States and parties involved, has been identified at EU level. As
other related definitions from the academic, partly governmental and civic sectors point out, legal insolvency
proceedings are only a part of a wider system of support, early warning and “second chance”.
Academic researches point to the dual systemic nature of the early warning system - one early warning system
refers to the determination of the object’s indicators (tools, models, subsystems, etc.) and the other interacts
as a support system for the first system to activate it. Both systems interact with political, civic, academic and
industrial environment. Only by interaction of the two systems an efficient result can be achieved. It is not
enough to have increasingly efficient tools, models and subsystems in place to be able to identify the companies
that need preventive actions to avoid insolvency. It is equally important to create a support system(s) that
launches these tools on a regular basis.
The previous researches of support, early warning and “second chance” in most of cases have been focused
primarily on the research of the legal framework of insolvency from legal point of view, with a secondary and
fragmented assessment of the business environment that directly affects the causes of a company’s crisis.
A complete and efficient early warning system supports four main functions: risk analysis, supervision and
warning; distribution and communication and responsiveness.
The EC puts forward four successive sub-sectors that constitute the process of a company in financial difficulty,
taking into account its broadest possible role: from the moment a company is established, its possible warning,
in situations where serious financial problems arise, from the moment when the company is finally reorganized
or liquidated, and the subsequent effects of the company’s bankruptcy on the businessman. Thus, the EC
conceptual framework has four main sections: (1) prevention (early warning systems, support mechanisms), (2)
out-of-court settlements, (3) trials, followed by restructuring or liquidation of the company, (4) attitude of the
businessman towards bankruptcy and “second chance” conditions (liquidation, termination of activity, debt
relief and other consequences). This conceptual approach, as found in the Research, is also shared by most pf
government experts of the Baltic countries and Poland.
When assessing the most appropriate potential support for companies in a crisis situation, it is also necessary to
distinguish separately what types of crises the companies experience in their different life cycles. Studies show
that all companies periodically go through life-cycle caused crises of different origins and, depending on how
they manage to handle it, this can lead to financial difficulties and consequent insolvency. Different solutions
are possible for each crisis, and the solutions are largely determined by the internal ability and energy of the
company’s manager to cope with the crisis. This academic conclusion is confirmed by the statements of
experienced mentors and experts of EWE, “Team-U”, “Dyzo”, “MKB Doorstart”, “60,000 Rebonds”, expressed in
5 In economic terms, the term socio-economic ecosystem has become widespread over the last decade, referring to interinfluence and
interdependence of all participants involved in the system, when changes pertaining to one participant affect the functioning of the rest of
the system in the same way as it is in natural ecosystems. The term “economic ecosystem” is not unanimously accepted by economists due
to several considerations. The term “ecosystem” is used in the research, but with the remark that there are differences in opinions on its
applicability and some of the authors and experts of the Research have suggested replacing the term “ecosystem” with “economic system”.
6 Ozgulbas, N., & Koyuncugil, A. S. (2010) Financial early warning system for risk detection and prevention from financial crisis. In Surveillance
Technologies and Early Warning Systems: Data Mining Applications for Risk Detection. In A. S. Koyuncugil, & N. Ozgulbas (Eds.). Surveillance
Technologies and Early Warning Systems: Data Mining Applications for Risk Detection (pp. 76–108). New York: Idea Group Inc.
7 EU Proposal for the Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on preventive restructuring frameworks, second chance and
measures to increase the efficiency of restructuring, insolvency and discharge procedures, 2016/0359 (COD).
Innovation Laboratory| 23 - 26.11.2020| Background Paper 2
the course of the Research. The aspects of the reason of the crisis of business need to be taken into account
when assessing the most appropriate support, early warning and “second chance” mechanisms in each country.
None of the in-depth interviews with EWE and other public organizations providing support to companies in
difficulty in EU Member States, carried out in scope of the Research, mentions the distinction between the
company and the businessman, thus all of them express the opinion, existing in expert practice, that the owner
and/or manager of a SME and its vision are the grounds of the company that determine the direction of the
company and its ability or inability to cope with the crisis. It was repeatedly emphasized in the interviews that
the struggle of a company in financial difficulties is fought by one person or a small group of people - company
owners and/or board members. In 28 interviews with businessmen from different countries, the opinion was
unanimous that in the face of financial difficulties, the businessman is left alone and the severity and
responsibility of the current crisis should be borne by the businessmen personally, finding the strength to solve
them, whether the company continues to exist or is being liquidated, leaving the debt burden.
The EC Annual Report on SMEs 2018/2019 shows that more than 110 policy initiatives have been adopted in the
EU in accordance with the “second chance” principle since 2011, including ten in 2018 and in the first quarter of
2019. The registered number of policy initiatives, aimed at promotion of the “second chance” and “single
market” principles, in the period from 2011 to Q1 2019 has been the smallest.
In most of the EU member states, it is still impossible to complete legal insolvency proceedings within one
year and to release a company from insolvency proceedings within three years. Similarly, half of bona fide
businessmen in EU member states do not have an automatic discharge following liquidation or accelerated
insolvency proceedings. Post-insolvency companies are generally defined the same way as start-ups in most og
EU member states. However, just over half of EU member states have timely warning and assistance service
mechanisms in place to help prevent businessmen bankruptcy. 8
The new EC Directive (EU) 2019/1023 on a preventive restructuring scheme and the “second chance” 9 adopted
on 20 June 2019 lays down rules (Article 21) that all member states must ensure that over-indebted companies
have access to at least one procedure which may lead to their debt being repaid in full within a maximum
period of 3 years. This will facilitate the “second chance” to start a new business.
The Directive provides for a significant restructuring of the insolvency proceedings by shifting the scales from
company liquidation process to company restructuring process. This is a fundamental difference that
transforms the existing insolvency paradigm from a “how to better liquidate” to “how to better restore”
approach.
The Directive assumes specific and detailed actions to be taken in the “Preventive restructuring” and
“Insolvency” phases. “Preventive restructuring” is a new, hitherto unregulated phase to which most of the
Regulation’s directives are devoted. In turn, the main improvements for the “Insolvency” phase are related to
the provision of well-ordered and efficient processes, which are maximally synchronized between the EU
member states.
On the other hand, just one point of the Directive is devoted to the early warning issue, stating that EU member
states need to develop one or more tools to detect circumstances that could lead to the possibility of insolvency.
This fact largely indicates the Directive’s primary focus on improving the legal framework for restructuring or
liquidation of a company in financial difficulty, leaving prevention support initiatives secondary. The new
Directive emphasizes mainly the need to disclose the circumstances, while the positive experience of EU
organizations so far points to the provision of mentoring as the most efficient tool.
8 EU Proposal for the Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council on preventive restructuring frameworks, second chance and
measures to increase the efficiency of restructuring, insolvency and discharge procedures, 2016/0359 (COD).
9 Directive (EU) 2019/1023 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 June 2019 on preventive restructuring frameworks, on
discharge of debt and disqualifications, and on measures to increase the efficiency of procedures concerning restructuring, insolvency and
discharge of debt, and amending Directive (EU) 2017/1132 (Directive on restructuring and insolvency)
Innovation Laboratory| 23 - 26.11.2020| Background Paper 3
Questions for discussion
This paper is all about supporting competivness in Europe in context to restructure and/or give second chance
for enterpreneurships in financial difficulties, how to strengthen ecosystem and its context with industrial
competitiveness.
How do you understand and define the concept of early warning, support and second chance in your country?
What measures and reforms can in your view be taken - at country and / or EU-Level - to improve the area of
early warning, support and second chance?
Which of the conceptual stages of early warning, support and second chance needs improvement the most in
your country?
1. Early warning stage
2. In the pre-litigation stage, in the debt and / or asset restructuring stage
3. In the insolvency and / or restructuring proceedings with the involvement of the court
4. After the insolvency and / or restructuring of the individual into the business environment stage
From your perspective: What existing support mechanisms are currently working most effectively? What new
tools, organizational changes would be needed?
From your perspective: What support will be the most effective for companies in financial difficulties
in the next decade, where and in which sectors/ stages do you see the most productive support and what do
you see as most challenging task in making this happen?
Innovation Laboratory| 23 - 26.11.2020| Background Paper 4
Saatja: Elīna Pētersone <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 17.11.2020 12:56
Adressaat: henriknoes . <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
Eleni Tzoka Stecka Fundacja Firmy Rodzinne <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; Kai Kalmann <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; Kaarel Lehtsalu <
[email protected]>; MKM
info <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>
Koopia: Sigita Siliņa <
[email protected]>
Teema: Invitation to Innovation Laboratory “Building and strengthening
institutional capacity to support companies in financial difficulties in
the Baltic States and Poland”
Dear colleagues,
On behalf of the Restart BSR team and the Ministry of Economy of the
Republic of Latvia it is my pleasure to invite you to Innovation
Laboratory Building and strengthening institutional capacity to support
companies in financial difficulties in the Baltic States and Poland which
will take place as a webinar conference from Monday, 23rd of November to
Thursday, 26th of November. The webinar conference will consist of three
parts: Opening of the Innovation Laboratory on the 23rd of November,
workshops and Closing of the Innovation Laboratory on the 26th of
November. The goal of the first part of the conference is to introduce
partners, associated partners, experts, policy makers and colleagues from
2nd Wave countries to the activities made within the Restart BSR project.
The goal of the last part of the conference is to introduce partners,
associated partners, experts, policy makers and colleagues from 2nd Wave
countries to results of the innovation laboratory and recommendations for
policy makers for the support and second chance.
I would like to inivite you to take the opportunity and to participate in
the first and last part of the conference - on the 23rd of November and
26th of November.
The themes and work discussions of the Innovation Laboratory will focus
on the assessment of institutional support for companies in difficulties,
including financial difficulties in the Baltic States and Poland. In
order to ensure a productive and lively discussion, we will be looking
forward to your views, vision. We would much appreciate, if you would
share with your experience during the Innovation Laboratory.
Please find attached corresponding Research background paper which will
provide you with a more detailed input on discussion topics, as well as
the Innovation Laboratory Programme.
Please join the following seminars and discussions:
Topic: Opening of the Innovation Laboratory
Time: Nov 23, 2020 01:00 PM Helsinki
Topic: Recommendations for building and strengthening institutional
capacity to support companies in financial difficulties in the Baltic
States and Poland
Time: Nov 26, 2020 09:00 AM Helsinki
I look forward to a productive mutual exchange of experience so that we
can jointly improve the competitiveness of the business environment of
the Baltic Sea States.
Best regards,
ELÎNA PÇTERSONE
Ministry of Economics
Republic of Latvia
Entrepreneurship Competitiveness Department
Senior expert
55 Brivibas Street, Riga, LV-1519, Latvia
E-mail: ,