Open Public Consultations as part of the
Evaluation Study of Council Directive 2008/114
on the identification and designation of
European critical infrastructures and the
assessment of the need to improve their
protection
Fields marked with * are mandatory.
Introduction
The European Critical Infrastructure Protection Directive (2008/114/EC) of 8 December 2008 establishes a
procedure for identifying and designating European Critical Infrastructures (ECI) in the energy and
transport sectors, as well as a common approach for assessing the need to improve their protection. It is
a key pillar of the European Programme for Critical Infrastructure Protection (EPCIP), which aims to
protect critical infrastructures against a range of threats using an all-hazards approach.
Critical infrastructure is defined as an asset, system or part thereof located in a Member State which is
essential for the maintenance of vital societal functions, health, safety, security, economic and/or social
well-being of people. The disruption or destruction of said infrastructure would have a significant impact in
a Member State as a result of the failure to maintain the aforementioned vital societal functions.
The objectives of the European Critical Infrastructure Directive are to:
- Identify European Critical Infrastructures (ECI), defined as those infrastructures, which, if subjected to
disruption or destruction, would have a significant impact on at least two Member States;
- Ensure that all identified European Critical Infrastructures are protected, particularly through the creation
of an Operator Security Plan (OSP), which should be appropriately and regularly reviewed.
In the years since its introduction in 2008, various issues concerning the current Directive have been
identified. These include, for instance, a narrow sectoral scope (limited to the energy and transport
sectors), and the slow pace of the ECI identification and designation process on the part of the Member
States. For these and other reasons, the Commission recently launched an external evaluation of the
Directive that will assess its effectiveness, efficiency, relevance, coherence and EU added value. The
evaluation covers all EU Member States and takes account of a heightened terrorist threat since 2008, an
awareness of hybrid threats, but also the emergence of new threats, including, for instance, the unlawful
use of unmanned aerial vehicles (“drones”).
1
As part of this evaluation, the European Commission has launched an public consultation, which aims to
collect the views of all stakeholders, including European citizens, as to whether the Directive has met and
is currently meeting its objectives, namely to improve the protection and ensure the resilience of critical
infrastructures. The evaluation will be available for twelve weeks.
Please submit your responses via the online questionnaire below. The questionnaire will be made
available first in English and then in French and German as translations come available. Respondents
may answer the questionnaire in any official EU language, regardless of the language of the
questionnaire that the respondent selects. (Should you wish to provide your contribution by other means
than online, please contact the European Programme for Critical infrastructure Protection (EPCIP)
through its functional mailbox:
[email protected].)
All individual replies will be made available for analysis by the contractor carrying out the evaluation. They
will also be published on the European Commission’s consultations webpage (https://ec.europa.eu/info
/consultations). The contractor’s final report, which will account for the public consultation and other forms
of consultation as part of the evaluation, will form the basis for a Staff Working Document produced by the
Commission, which will be published on DG Migration and Home Affairs’ (HOME’s) website (https://ec.
europa.eu/home-affairs/) during the spring of 2019.
More information concerning the ongoing evaluation is available via the following link on DG HOME’s
website: https://ec.europa.eu/home-affairs/what-is-new/work-in-progress/initiatives/evaluation-council-
directive-2008-114_en. Information concerning the European Programme for Critical Infrastructure
Protection (EPCIP) specifically and critical infrastructure protection more generally can be found here:
https://ec.europa.eu/home-affairs/what-we-do/policies/crisis-and-terrorism/critical-infrastructure_en.
About you
* Language of my contribution
Bulgarian
Croatian
Czech
Danish
Dutch
English
Estonian
Finnish
French
Gaelic
German
Greek
Hungarian
Italian
Latvian
Lithuanian
Maltese
Polish
Portuguese
Romanian
Slovak
2
Slovak
Slovenian
Spanish
Swedish
* I am giving my contribution as
Academic/research institution
Business association
Company/business organisation
Consumer organisation
EU citizen
Environmental organisation
Non-EU citizen
Non-governmental organisation (NGO)
Public authority
Trade union
Other
* First name
* Surname
* Email (this won't be published)
* Scope
International
Local
National
Regional
* Organisation name
255 character(s) maximum
* Organisation size
Micro (1 to 9 employees)
Small (10 to 49 employees)
Medium (50 to 249 employees)
Large (250 or more)
Transparency register number
3
Transparency register number
255 character(s) maximum
Check if your organisation is on the transparency register. It's a voluntary database for organisations seeking to influence EU decision-
making.
* Country of origin
Please add your country of origin, or that of your organisation.
Afghanistan Djibouti Libya Saint Pierre
and Miquelon
Åland Islands Dominica Liechtenstein Saint Vincent
and the
Grenadines
Albania Dominican Lithuania Samoa
Republic
Algeria Ecuador Luxembourg San Marino
American Egypt Macau São Tomé and
Samoa Príncipe
Andorra El Salvador Madagascar Saudi Arabia
Angola Equatorial Malawi Senegal
Guinea
Anguilla Eritrea Malaysia Serbia
Antarctica Estonia Maldives Seychelles
Antigua and Ethiopia Mali Sierra Leone
Barbuda
Argentina Falkland Islands Malta Singapore
Armenia Faroe Islands Marshall Sint Maarten
Islands
Aruba Fiji Martinique Slovakia
Australia Finland Mauritania Slovenia
Austria Former Mauritius Solomon
Yugoslav Islands
Republic of
Macedonia
Azerbaijan France Mayotte Somalia
Bahamas French Guiana Mexico South Africa
Bahrain French Micronesia South Georgia
Polynesia and the South
Sandwich
Islands
Bangladesh French Moldova South Korea
Southern and
Antarctic Lands
Barbados Gabon Monaco South Sudan
Belarus Georgia Mongolia Spain
Belgium Germany Montenegro Sri Lanka
Belize Ghana Montserrat Sudan
Benin Gibraltar Morocco Suriname
Bermuda Greece Mozambique Svalbard and
4
Bermuda Greece Mozambique Svalbard and
Jan Mayen
Bhutan Greenland Myanmar Swaziland
/Burma
Bolivia Grenada Namibia Sweden
Bonaire Saint Guadeloupe Nauru Switzerland
Eustatius and
Saba
Bosnia and Guam Nepal Syria
Herzegovina
Botswana Guatemala Netherlands Taiwan
Bouvet Island Guernsey New Caledonia Tajikistan
Brazil Guinea New Zealand Tanzania
British Indian Guinea-Bissau Nicaragua Thailand
Ocean Territory
British Virgin Guyana Niger The Gambia
Islands
Brunei Haiti Nigeria Timor-Leste
Bulgaria Heard Island Niue Togo
and McDonald
Islands
Burkina Faso Honduras Norfolk Island Tokelau
Burundi Hong Kong North Korea Tonga
Cambodia Hungary Northern Trinidad and
Mariana Islands Tobago
Cameroon Iceland Norway Tunisia
Canada India Oman Turkey
Cape Verde Indonesia Pakistan Turkmenistan
Cayman Islands Iran Palau Turks and
Caicos Islands
Central African Iraq Palestine Tuvalu
Republic
Chad Ireland Panama Uganda
Chile Isle of Man Papua New Ukraine
Guinea
China Israel Paraguay United Arab
Emirates
Christmas Italy Peru United
Island Kingdom
Clipperton Jamaica Philippines United States
Cocos (Keeling) Japan Pitcairn Islands United States
Islands Minor Outlying
Islands
Colombia Jersey Poland Uruguay
Comoros Jordan Portugal US Virgin
Islands
Congo Kazakhstan Puerto Rico Uzbekistan
Cook Islands Kenya Qatar Vanuatu
Costa Rica Kiribati Réunion Vatican City
5
Costa Rica Kiribati Réunion Vatican City
Côte d’Ivoire Kosovo Romania Venezuela
Croatia Kuwait Russia Vietnam
Cuba Kyrgyzstan Rwanda Wallis and
Futuna
Curaçao Laos Saint Western
Barthélemy Sahara
Cyprus Latvia Saint Helena Yemen
Ascension and
Tristan da
Cunha
Czech Republic Lebanon Saint Kitts and Zambia
Nevis
Democratic Lesotho Saint Lucia Zimbabwe
Republic of the
Congo
Denmark Liberia Saint Martin
* Publication privacy settings
The Commission will publish the responses to this public consultation. You can choose whether you would like your details to be made
public or to remain anonymous.
Anonymous
Only your type, country of origin and contribution will be published. All other
personal details (name, organisation name and size, transparency register
number) will not be published.
Public
Your personal details (name, organisation name and size, transparency
register number, country of origin) will be published with your contribution.
* I agree with the personal data protection provisions
Questions concerning the ECI Directive
1.1) In your view, to what extent do the following incident types pose a serious
threat to critical infrastructures in the EU?
To To a To a
Not To a
No some fairly large
at small
opinion extent large extent
all extent
extent
Natural disasters (earthquakes,
fires, floods, etc.)
Cyberattacks/cyber-enabled attacks
Supply chain disruptions
6
Energy supply disruptions
Terrorist attacks
Transportation accidents
Accidents involving hazardous
materials
Insider infiltration
Unlawful intrusion (including by
unmanned aerial vehicles ("drones"))
Attacks of different kinds
orchestrated by state-sponsored
actors
Other
1.2) If you have identified other serious threats to critical infrastructures (“other” in
the question above), please describe them here.
2.1) In your opinion, to what extent are the provisions of the European Critical
Infrastructure (ECI) Directive still relevant and needed to ensure a common level of
protection of critical infrastructures across the EU?
No To a small To some To a fairly To a large
Not
opinion extent extent large extent extent
at all
In the energy
sector
In the
transport sector
2.2) Please elaborate on your responses to the previous question.
3) Do you believe that additional specific measures should be taken at EU level to
better protect critical infrastructures from the threats listed in Question 1.1, or from
other threats that you independently identified in Question 1.2?
7
4.1) Have you seen any improvement in the level of protection of critical
infrastructures in the EU over the last decade?
No
opinion Yes No
In the energy sector
In the transport sector
4.2) If you indicated "yes" to the previous question, to what extent has the level of
protection in the energy and transport sectors increased in your view?
To a small To a fairly large
To some To a large
extent extent
extent extent
In the energy sector
In the transport
sector
4.3) Assuming you answered Question 4.2, what in your view are the factors that
have contributed to an increase in the level of protection of critical infrastructures?
4.4) In case you have not seen any improvement in the level of protection of
critical infrastructures, what in your view explains this?
8
5) To what extent do you agree with the following statements?
Neither
No
Strongly agree Strongly
opinion Disagree Agree
disagree nor agree
disagree
The ECI Directive has
contributed to achieving
common levels of protection for
critical infrastructures in the EU.
The ECI Directive has
contributed to defining similar
and clear responsibilities and
obligations for critical
infrastructure protection
stakeholders in all Member
States.
The ECI Directive has
contributed to a higher level of
protection of the internal market
from the effects of any
disruption/destruction of critical
infrastructures.
The ECI Directive has
produced observable
operational changes
concerning measures and
procedures for the protection of
critical infrastructures.
9
The ECI Directive has
enhanced cooperation between
Member States on matters
related to critical infrastructure
protection.
The sectoral scope of the ECI
Directive (pertaining to the
transport and energy sectors) is
appropriate in light of the
desired impact.
The exclusion of the
information and communication
technology (ICT) sector from
the scope of the ECI Directive
has not limited its impact.
10
6.1) In your view, is the current approach based on the designation of European
Critical Infrastructures (ECI) by Member States appropriate and effective?
No opinion
Not at all
To a small extent
To some extent
To a fairly large extent
To a large extent
6.2) Please elaborate on your response to the previous question. If you feel that
the current ECI designation approach is not/minimally appropriate and effective,
please explain why, and how the approach might be improved.
7.1) In your view, is the current approach calling for Member States to designate
ECI in agreement with those Member States that may be significantly affected
appropriate and effective?
No opinion
Not at all
To a small extent
To some extent
To a fairly large extent
To a large extent
7.2) Please elaborate on your response to the previous question.
8.1) In your opinion, to what extent has the ECI Directive provided added value
compared to what Member States could achieve in the field of critical infrastructure
protection in the absence of the ECI Directive?
To some To a large
No Not To a small To a fairly large
extent extent
opinion at all extent extent
In the energy
sector
In the
transport sector
8.2) Please elaborate on your response to the question above.
11
8.2) Please elaborate on your response to the question above.
12
9.1) In your opinion, have the costs (administrative, budgetary, in terms of
personnel, etc.) related to the transposition and application of the ECI Directive
been proportionate to its contribution in terms of the protection of critical
infrastructures?
No Very Very
Disproportionate Proportionate
opinion disproportionate proportionate
In the energy
sector
In the
transport sector
13
9.2) Based on your response to the previous question, please explain why you
deem the costs related to the ECI Directive to be proportionate or disproportionate
in relation to the demonstrated effects.
10.1) In your opinion, would the effects of the ECI Directive on the protection of
critical infrastructures be likely to remain in the years to come were the Directive to
be repealed?
No, Yes, to
No Yes, to a Yes, to a fairly Yes, to a
not at some
opinion small extent large extent large extent
all extent
In the
energy
sector
In the
transport
sector
10.2) Please elaborate on your response to the previous question.
11.1) In your opinion, to what extent is the ECI Directive coherent with
/complementary to other existing measures/mechanisms aimed at enhancing
critical infrastructure protection?
To a To a
Not To
No small To a fairly large
at some
opinion extent large extent extent
all extent
In the energy sector (besides
the ECI Directive)
In the transport sector
(besides the ECI Directive)
14
Space-based services sector
Banking sector
Health sector
Drinking water/food
supply sector
Land-based digital
infrastructure sector
11.2) If applicable, please elaborate on your responses to the previous question.
11.3) Can you identify other relevant measures/mechanisms in sectors not listed
above? If so, to what extent are they coherent with/complementary to the ECI
Directive?
12.1) In your view, is the current scope of the Directive, limited to the energy and
transport sectors, effective in protecting the most important critical infrastructures
in the EU?
No opinion
Yes
No
12.2) Please elaborate on your response to the question above.
Final comments and document upload
If you wish to provide additional comments or suggestions within the scope of this
evaluation, please feel free to do so here.
Here you may upload a document containing additional remarks related to the
evaluation of the ECI Directive.
The maximum file size is 1 MB
Only files of the type pdf,txt,doc,docx,odt,rtf are allowed
15
16
Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium
Sotsiaalministeerium 05.12.2018 nr 9-4/32-1
Rahandusministeerium
Eesti Pank
Euroopa elutähtsate infrastruktuuride kaitse
direktiivi 2008/114 avalik konsultatsioon
Austatud koostööpartner
Euroopa Komisjon algatas Euroopa elutähtsate infrastruktuuride kaitse direktiivi
(2008/114/EÜ) avaliku konsultatsiooni, mis kestab 11. veebruarini 2019. a. Siseministeerium
koostab avalikule konsultatsioonile riigi ühtse vastuse.
Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeeriumil on otsene puutumus direktiiviga, kuna see
reguleerib energeetika- ja transpordisektori taristu kaitset. Sotsiaalministeeriumil,
Rahandusministeeriumil ja Eesti Pangal on puutumus läbi hädaolukorra seaduses sätestatud
elutähtsate teenuste regulatsiooni. Palume teie tagasisidet hiljemalt 31.12.2018. a.
Esmane direktiivi hindamine toimus 2012. a. Selle hindamise käigus kerkisid ülesse mitmed
probleemid, näiteks liiga kitsas direktiivi reguleerimisala, mis piirdub üksnes energia- ja
transpordisektoriga ning Euroopa elutähtsate infrastruktuuride identifitseerimise ja määramise
aeglane tempo.
Käesoleva direktiivi hindamise käigus on kavas hinnata direktiivi tõhusust, asjakohasust,
sidusust ning direktiiviga seotud eesmärkide saavutamist. Hindamisel võetakse arvesse 2012.
aasta läbivaatamise tulemusi. Ühtlasi hinnatakse direktiivi tõhusust suurenenud terrorismi ohu
kontekstis, võttes arvesse kõiki rünnakute liike, sealhulgas ebaseaduslikku droonide kasutamist
ja hübriidohte.
Hindamine ei hõlma Euroopa elutähtsate infrastruktuuride kaitse programmi (EPCIP) ja muid
(õiguslikke) elemente.
Oma arvamuse kujundamisel võite võtta abiks Komisjoni poolt ettevalmistatud küsimused
(lisatud kirja manusena). Kindlasti palume mõelda järgmistele küsimustele:
1. Kas Teie hinnangul peab direktiivi laiendama ka muudele sektoritele? Hetkel kohaldub
direktiiv ainult energeetika ja transpordisektorile.
2. Kas direktiiv peab kohalduma üksnes Euroopa elutähtsale infrastruktuurile (selline
infrastruktuuri, mille katkemisel on mõju vähemalt kahele liikmesriigile) või reguleerima
ka riigisisese taristu toimepidevust ja kaitset?
Pikk 61 / 15065 Tallinn / 612 5008 /
[email protected] / www.siseministeerium.ee
Registrikood 70000562
3. Kas Teie hinnangul võib Eestil olla lähitulevikus vajadus sellise direktiivi järgi? Kui jah,
siis mida see direktiiv peaks reguleerima?
Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeeriumil palume täiendavalt mõelda selle peale, kas
direktiivil oli positiivne mõju energeetika ja transpordisektori taristu kaitsele ja
toimepidevusele.
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Katri Raik
siseminister
Lisa: Euroopa Komisjoni avaliku konsultatsiooni küsimustik
Galina Danilišina 6125146
[email protected]
Pikk 61 / 15065 Tallinn / 612 5008 /
[email protected] / www.siseministeerium.ee
Registrikood 70000562