Saatja: CME-EA <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 14.12.2018 13:56
Adressaat: SM Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: CME-EA 2018: independence of CME
Manused: The future of accreditation of continuing medical education CME
continuing professional development CPD in Europe harmonisation through
dialogue and.pdf; Position Paper on Accreditation of CME-CPD and
Independence-f.pdf
Dear all,
On behalf of CME-EA we would like to take the opportunity to wish you a
joyful festive season and a healthy, successful, and in particular
peaceful New Year 2019.
Following its mission (s. attachment), in 2018, CME-EA has initiated a
position paper on independence of CME, to be adopted by European national
as well as international accreditors. This paper has so far been adopted
by
- Austrian Academy of Physicians
- European Boards for Accreditation in Cardiology, Haematology, and
Pneumology (CME-EA members)
- German Medical Association,
with further organizations having announced to present the paper to their
constituent bodies for approval in the next few months.
This paper, which responds to an industry initiative (originally directed
at UEMS-EACCME) to accept industry as a direct provider of accredited
CME,
is still open for approval, also by your organization. Please let us know
whether you need any additional information to be further engaged in this
process. This is a landmark project in Europe, gathering for the first
time European accreditation organizations from the national as well as
international level in a joint activity. Thus, let your voice be heard
and
join!
All the best and warm regards
Fabiola de Andrade Reinhard Griebenow
Chair, CME-EA Vice-chair, CME-EA
Position paper
Independent Continuing Medical Education
(CME)/Continuing Professional Development (CPD) means at
first independent information
Authors: European accreditation bodies
(national/international)
Physicians have committed themselves to always act in the best interest of their patients
(1), this includes their approach to continuing medical education (CME) as well as
continuing professional development (CPD) which are cornerstones for the maintenance
of professional competence (MOC). For many years professional codes, and in some
countries also the (professional) law, have defined that CME/CPD must be independent
of commercial interests (1, EU-national).
Over the last few decades numerous national bodies have introduced CME/CPD
accreditation to ensure that the planning and conduct of CME/CPD follows a set of
defined standards, with independence of commercial interests as one of the leading
principles (EU-national, 2, 3).
In Europe, this is augmented by an additional type of accreditor, the European
international accreditor. These accreditors include members of CME-EA, EACCME and
other organisations and are devoted to accreditation of CME/CPD activities in Europe
that have primarily international attendance.
However, accreditation has little value in and on its own, it is almost entirely dependent
on having clear and transparent definitions, rigorous application of appropriate
principles and rules, and being in the position to enforce its own standards.
With regard to enforcement , only a few European national accreditation systems are
officially legitimated by national jurisdictions (e.g. DE, AT, IT). This enables the
accreditor to impose accreditation on all providers nationwide (but vice-versa also
imposing legal liability on the accreditor).
But still many accreditors in Europe (including all European international accreditors)
are institutions based on civil law, and thus lack official legitimation.
Despite the sometimes uncertain legal basis CME/CPD accreditation still serves as an
important component of quality assurance in medicine. Accreditation safeguards the
credibility of the medical profession in one of the most important areas in medicine, i.e.
maintenance of our intellectual basis in medical decision-making by life-long learning.
Thus, irrespective of the variable legal status, accreditors will only be able to convince
the (medical) public, and prove their legitimacy by comprehensible and rigorous
application of their transparent principles and rules.
All major accreditation systems grant accreditation prior to the start of the CME/CPD
activity. This implies that accreditation relies on professional honesty, and self-
commitment of the medical professionals involved in delivery of CME/CPD, to align their
presentations with the principles and rules as outlined by the accreditor.
There are several key principles in medical education to be followed by providers
(which should also be used by participants to evaluate a given CME/CPD activity):
It all starts with independence of information itself as well as independence of
interpretation of information in the appropriate clinical context. Other criteria like
educational efficacy of a CME/CPD activity are of secondary importance in light of the
fundamental bias introduced by use of framed information in life-long learning.
Fully transparent and timely provision of data can obviously collide with the commercial
interests of industry (4, 5, 6), as driven by the market economy’s framework set by
governments in most developed countries. This limitation weighs even more in the light
of the fact that currently about 80% of all trial patients are in clinical trials sponsored by
industry (7).
Whilst the development and provision of drugs and devices continues to follow the
fundamental principles of a market economy with its inbuilt difficulties of accessing
information, then if we were to accept industry as a provider of accredited CME/CPD, as
recently proposed in the Journal (8), then we would open the door for the introduction
of an inevitable bias in CME/CPD. It is for this reason that major accreditors have
recently reiterated in a global consensus document that “the content, as well as persons
and organizations in control of the content, of the accredited CME/CPD activity is
developed/selected independently, with no influence, control or involvement from a
commercial interest...” (9).
Many accreditors go one step further by defining the details of communication to
participants to avoid any misperceptions with regard to promotion (10, EU-national), in
particular in sponsored CME/CPD.
Accreditors are well aware that in CME/CPD there are further threats to independent
alignment of evidence with current strategies in diagnosis and treatment of particular
conditions (interpretation), and discussion on how to apply evidence in the individual
patient (implementation):
- This includes a long list of (potential conflicts of) interests, including issues
related to career development and/or welfare of individuals involved in planning
and delivery of CME, but also institutional interests e.g. of hospital owners,
insurance companies etc. Thus, fully transparent communication of interests to
participants in CME/CPD as well as management of the conflicts of interest are
indispensable supportive strategies in planning and delivery of independent
CME/CPD, but they can never outweigh the negative effects of information
compromised by commercial interests. This also applies to the principles of
evidence based medicine, whose practice has been further facilitated by
development of elaborate methods for post-processing of information to design
tools to support clinical decision-making by recommendations based on grading
of the strength of evidence (11), or by provision of systematic reviews and meta-
analyses (12). Major accreditors recommend the systematic use of these tools in
the provision of accredited CME/CPD (EU-national, -international). However, the
value of such tools also critically depends on timely and complete availability of
data to obtain a realistic estimate of benefit-risk ratios of diagnostic and/or
therapeutic interventions.
- CME/CPD should always be designed to help participants to close gaps in
knowledge and/or professional performance. The underlying gap analysis as well
as definition of “learning objectives” mark another area, in which commercial
interests should never be involved to avoid direct agenda setting by industry,
although accreditors are well aware that indirect agenda setting currently occurs
by allocation of sponsoring: Evidence is available that CME with industry
involvement has a narrower range of topics and more product-related content
than CME without direct industry involvement even when funding is unrestricted
(13).
The primary importance of independence in accreditation should not override the
consideration of the role of different educational formats for the delivery of effective
CME/CPD. Although overall educational quality may be considered as satisfactory (EU-
national, -international), accreditors have always wanted to stimulate improvement, as
demonstrated by initiatives to stimulate providers to further develop their educational
formats (EU-national, -international).
CME/CPD accreditation has been designed to mark the difference between independent,
strictly evidence based CME/CPD and interest driven CME/CPD. If there were to be no
differences in requirements for independence any more, accreditation alone will not be
able to resolve the issue and may be seen as no longer needed.
In certain jurisdictions (Germany, 14) commercially driven CME/CPD may also be
considered as providing inadequate independence in influencing opinion formation, and
decision-making. This mixing up of CME/CPD with commercial interests may introduce
further difficulties with differentiating medical education from advertising.
Accreditation of CME/CPD currently serves several different purposes, but its fate will
be decided by whether it can retain its ability to differentiate independent CME/CPD
from provision of commercially framed information.
References
1. World Medical Association Declaration of Geneva,
accessed on Jan. 18th, 2018: https://www.wma.net/policies-post/wma-
declaration-of-geneva/
2. ACCME Standards for Commercial Support: Standards to Ensure Independence in
CME Activities
Accessed on Jan. 18th, 2018: http://www.accme.org/requirements/accreditation-
requirements-cme-providers/standards-for-commercial-support
3. National Standard for Support of Accredited CPD Activities
Accessed on Jan. 18th, 2018:
http://www.royalcollege.ca/rcsite/cpd/providers/tools-resources-accredited-
cpd-providers/national-standard-accredited-cpd-activities-e
4. Köhler M, Haag S, Biester K, et al. Information on new drugs at market entry:
retrospective analysis of health technology assessment reports versus regulatory
reports, journal publications, and registry reports. Bmj. 2015;350:h796.
5. Anderson ML, Chiswell K, Peterson ED, et al. Compliance with results reporting at
clinical trials.gov. N Engl J Med. 2015;372:1031–1039.
6. European Medicines Agency: Clinical Trial Regulation
Accessed on Jan. 18th, 2018:
http://www.ema.europa.eu/ema/index.jsp?curl=pages/regulation/general/gene
ral_content_000629.jsp
7. Flacco ME, Manzoli L, Boccia S, et al. Head-to-head rando- mized trials are mostly
industry sponsored and almost always favor the industry sponsor. J Clin
Epidemiology. 2015;68:811–820.
8. Tamara Allen, Nina Donde, Eva Hofstädter-Thalmann, Sandra Keijser, Veronique
Moy, Jean-Jacques Murama & Thomas Kellner (2017) Framework for industry
engagement and quality principles for industry-provided medical education in
Europe, Journal of European CME, 6:1, 1348876, DOI:
10.1080/21614083.2017.1348876
9. International Academy for CPD Accreditation:
Consensus Statement for Independence and Funding of Continuing Medical
Education (CME)/ Continuing Professional Development
Accessed on Jan. 18th, 2018:
https://academy4cpdaccreditation.files.wordpress.com/2018/01/consensus-
statement-for-independence-and-funding-of-cme_cpd_final.pdf
10. Daiana Stolz, Reinhard Griebenow, Andre Tichelli, Andrew J. Ullmann, Richard
Costello, Lampros Michalis, Margarita Guenova, Sandy Sutter, Fabiola De Andrade
& Robert Schaefer (2017) Position paper on current aspects of sponsoring in
accredited CME, Journal of European CME, 6:1, 1312062, DOI:
10.1080/21614083.2017.1312062
11. The Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development and Evaluation
(GRADE) working group
Accessed on Jan. 18th, 2018: http://www.gradeworkinggroup.org
12. Cochrane Library
Accessed on Jan. 18th, 2018: http://www.cochranelibrary.com
13. Katz HP, Goldfinger SE, Fletcher SW. Academia-industry collaboration in
continuing medical education: description of two approaches. J Contin Educ
Health Prof. 2002;22(1):43–54.
14. Gesetz zur Bekämpfung von Korruption im Gesundheitswesen (Law against
corruption in the health-care system)
Accessed on Jan. 18th, 2018:
https://www.bmjv.de/SharedDocs/Gesetzgebungsverfahren/Dokumente/BGBl_
Bekaempfung_Korruption_Gesundheitswesen.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=3
Journal of European CME
ISSN: (Print) 2161-4083 (Online) Journal homepage: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/zjec20
The future of accreditation of continuing
medical education (CME)-continuing professional
development (CPD) in Europe: harmonisation
through dialogue and consensus
Fabiola de Andrade, Reinhard Griebenow, Richard W. Costello, Margarita
Guenova, Robert Schaefer, James D. Chalmers, Andre Tichelli, Drazen Raguz
& Joerg Steinon behalf of CME-EA
To cite this article: Fabiola de Andrade, Reinhard Griebenow, Richard W. Costello, Margarita
Guenova, Robert Schaefer, James D. Chalmers, Andre Tichelli, Drazen Raguz & Joerg Steinon
behalf of CME-EA (2018) The future of accreditation of continuing medical education (CME)-
continuing professional development (CPD) in Europe: harmonisation through dialogue and
consensus, Journal of European CME, 7:1, 1506202
To link to this article: https://doi.org/10.1080/21614083.2018.1506202
© 2018 The Author(s). Published by Informa
UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis
Group.
View supplementary material
Published online: 03 Sep 2018.
Submit your article to this journal
View Crossmark data
Full Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at
http://www.tandfonline.com/action/journalInformation?journalCode=zjec20
JOURNAL OF EUROPEAN CME
2018, VOL. 7, 1506202
https://doi.org/10.1080/21614083.2018.1506202
The future of accreditation of continuing medical education (CME)-continuing
professional development (CPD) in Europe: harmonisation through dialogue
and consensus
Fabiola de Andrade , Reinhard Griebenow, Richard W. Costello , Margarita Guenova, Robert Schaefer,
James D. Chalmers, Andre Tichelli, Drazen Raguz and Joerg Steinon behalf of CME-EA*
Continuing Medical Education - European Accreditors (CME-EA) Registered Association, Cologne, Germany
ABSTRACT ARTICLE HISTORY
In Europe, there are currently some 30 different jurisdictions and no overarching legislation Received 30 March 2018
regarding CME-CPD accreditation, since legislative competency related to national health-care Accepted 23 July 2018
systems lies with national authorities. Thus, public demonstration of professional agreement KEYWORDS Continuing
regarding the principles, rules and practice of CME-CPD as well as its accreditation is a highly medical education (CME);
desirable professional and political objective in Europe, where free movement and freedom to continuing professional
offer professional (medical) services is a key feature of the EU vision of the single market. The development (CPD);
newly formed association of independent European accreditors, Continuing Medical Education - accreditation; Europe;
European Accreditors (CME-EA) is committed to offering a platform for dialogue between continuing medical
individuals and organisations involved in definition of professional codes in general, and accred- education-European
itation of CME-CPD in particular on the national level. The aim is to reach a European consensus accreditors (CME-EA)
on principles and rules applied in planning and delivery of CME-CPD. This includes consensus on
constituent characteristics of accreditors as well as principles and practice of accreditation.
In Europe, there are currently some 30 different jurisdic- CME-CPD activities, as practised by medical profes-
tions and no overarching legislation regarding continuing sionals in their home country, are similar in EU countries,
medical education-continuing professional development this is at present not obvious to the profession or to the
(CME-CPD) accreditation, since legislative competency public due to lack of a unifying approach to documenta-
related to national health-care systems lies with national tion and external assessment (accreditation) of CME-
authorities. In the past, this has favoured an inward CPD activities. We are well aware that this is mainly
perspective, which encouraged each country to act in because physicians have to refer to and are bound to the
isolation and take non-harmonised approaches towards national legal framework in the country in which they are
CME-CPD accreditation practices [1]. However, regard- practising.
less of differences in the legal, professional and political However, the lack of an international, Europe-wide
framework in which they are currently working, transparent approach carries risks that doubts may be
European physicians still all belong to the same profes- raised, as to whether medical professionals in Europe
sion and share the same ethical values and principles of really align their professional practice in the field of
professional practice [2]. Thus, to demonstrate profes- CME-CPD to an agreed set of principles, as laid down
sional consensus on this point should be an important in country-specific professional codes and that politi-
professional political objective to achieve, particularly cians, though themselves responsible for legal fragmen-
because mutual recognition of professional qualifications tation of regulations on CME-CPD, may conceive the
represents a basic requirement for free movement and medical profession to be similarly fragmented regard-
freedom to provide services, both cornerstones of the ing national frameworks for principles and rules for
single European Union (EU) market [3]. CME-CPD. Therefore, the political power of the pro-
Although we probably can assume that the principles fession will inevitably be weakened, and commercial
and rules for planning and conducting independent
CONTACT Reinhard Griebenow
[email protected] Continuing Medical Education- European Accreditors (CME-EA)Registered Association,
Cologne, Germany
*
The authors are members of Continuing Medical Education − European Accreditors (CME-EA, registered association, Cologne, Germany).
Supplemental data for this article can be accessed on the publisher’s website.
© 2018 The Author(s). Published by Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which
permits unrestricted non-commercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
2 F. DE ANDRADE ET AL.
Table 1. The credibility cascade. professional codes. This may be the only level of the
1.Self-commitment cascade relevant to countries which have no formal
2.Publicising professional practice
3.External assessment definitions in place for planning and conducting
4.Commitment to a unifying approach CME-CPD, or in which accreditors cover only a small
part of all national CME-CPD activities.
The authors strongly agree with a recent statement
players might take the lead by a Europe-wide coordi- from the World Medical Association on Quality
nated and unifying approach [4]. Assurance in Medical Education, that “. . . a better out-
Thus, since CME-CPD constitutes the longest per- come will more likely be achieved by also including a
iod of learning in a medical professional’s life, how to second dimension of review that includes an external
deal with CME-CPD represents a cornerstone of cred- perspective” [5].
ibility for the profession, not only in a particular Thus, publicising national activities in a format accep-
European home country, but also on the EU level. table for international discussions is the next inevitable and
The newly formed not-for-profit association of inde- logical level in the Credibility Cascade. This may include a
pendent European accreditors, Continuing Medical European CME-CPD calendar and access to major
Education – European Accreditors (CME-EA, www. national documents relevant for planning and delivery of
cme-ea.eu) aims to harmonise planning and delivery CME-CPD.
of CME-CPD by dialogue and consensus. In this However, the more developed form of assessment is
regard, it proposes a model for individuals as well as represented by accreditation, which also occupies the next
institutions, involved in standard setting, for planning level of the Credibility Cascade. Accreditation merely
and delivery of CME-CPD on the European national describes a process of assessment and approval [6], and
level, and for European international accreditors to its value is entirely dependent on rigorous application of
align to a “credibility cascade” (see Table 1). This appropriate principles and rules. Thus, the International
cascade offers several development steps: Association of Medical Regulatory Authorities recom-
mends CME-CPD accreditation, whenever “robust, inde-
● from private to public commitment, to external pendent accreditation is available and affordable” [7].
assessment of the commitment (accreditation), and Implementation of accreditation nowadays is a
participation in the development of a Europe-wide highly justified professional demand, since the medical
approach to define principles and rules for planning profession in many countries is under pressure to
and delivery of CME-CPD including its accreditation demonstrate that its practice aligns to professional
● from a highly fragmented approach, related to the codes which include lifelong learning. Accreditation
fundamental differences between EU countries, to a will also attest to the independence of the CME-CPD
harmonised vision, and harmonised principles and and to its relevance to clinical decision-making.
rules for the planning and delivery of CME-CPD As long as the EU Commission does not issue any
● from no political influence of the profession to the regulation on CME-CPD including accreditation, imple-
development of unified principles, to be used in poli- mentation of an accreditation system is primarily at the
tical lobbying for the creation of a Europe-wide har- national level in Europe, where it is up to national autho-
monised standard, which will probably be limited by rities to approve accreditors. However, the legal status of
the regulations of national authorities in several EU organisations involved in accreditation on the national
countries. level in Europe shows wide variation [1].
Organisations offering supranational accreditation
Thus, the Credibility Cascade ranges from attitude of the (so-called European international accreditors like
individual (self commitment) to making professional prac- members of CME-EA, other European Specialty
tice public, then making it amenable to external assessment Accreditation Boards, or the European Accreditation
(accreditation), and finally participating in a structured Council for CME, EACCME) similarly lack a legal
process to define a consensus approach, which will be mandate either to define the principles and rules of
applied to all activities on the national level. accreditation or to centralise CME-CPD accreditation
Self-commitment of the individual physician is on the European international level.
indeed the most important requirement in this model The key objective therefore is to harmonise princi-
and is key to the translation of recognised principles ples, rules and their application in national accredita-
into individual behaviour. However, in the context of tion procedures through consensus based on dialogue
public discussion of professional principles, it remains on a Europe-wide basis and not to centralise the
a private action, at best documented by national accreditation process itself at the European level.
JOURNAL OF EUROPEAN CONTINUING MEDICAL EDUCATION 3
To achieve this objective, there is a need for com- someone on, or withdraw someone from the
mitment of individuals/organisations from European accreditor, regardless of the position he or she
nations to contribute to and apply a unifying approach holds. Rules and standard operating procedures of
(as defined in the last part of the Credibility Cascade). the accreditor have to ensure that accreditation
In recent years, there have been several initiatives, occurs independently of any third-party influence,
which have addressed selected aspects of the frame- in particular of professional political and/or scien-
work and practice of CME-CPD accreditation, e.g. the tific organisations and/or providers and/or spon-
International Academy for CPD Accreditation [8], an sors and/or other commercial interests.
informal network of accreditors with global attendance, (2) Finances: Accreditors finance themselves by fees
and also informal collaboration of so-called European paid by those seeking accreditation. Donations
Speciality Accreditation Boards [9], or the Cologne from any commercial interest in medicine (includ-
Consensus Conference [10], and the UEMS-EACCME ing individuals representing or having a role in a
Education Conference. Thus, the mission of CME-EA commercial interest [9], as well as from providers)
is to devote its activities to offering a platform to all are not acceptable. Donations from any public
organisations/individuals involved in accreditation on authority or professional political body or scientific
the national level, to meet for dialogue and to work on organisation may be acceptable as long as they do
consensus. Fragmentation should not be the European not compromise the independence of decision-
answer to the global community of providers and making by the accreditor.
mobile learners in CME-CPD [11]. (3) Accreditation procedure: Accreditation decisions
Furthermore, harmonisation of the conceptual fra- should be exclusively identifiable with the accredi-
mework of accreditation relates to the role of the tor. Thus, rules and procedures for accreditation
accreditor itself. Thus, we would also like to offer a need to be defined in a way that accreditation deci-
unifying definition of the constitutional characteristics sions can solely be made by the legitimate members
of accreditors as well as of the accreditation procedure. of the accreditation body themselves. Third parties
Accreditation in CME-CPD is a process of assessment can never be involved in individual accreditation
of educational activities and/or CME providers, attesting decisions.
that a defined set of requirements has been met to ensure
independent, high quality and learner-centred CME-CPD
In summary, public demonstration of professional agree-
[6]. Clearly the independence of the accreditor itself is
ment regarding the principles, rules and practice of CME-
critical to maintaining the integrity and value of the accred-
CPD as well as its accreditation is a highly desirable profes-
itation [6].
sional and political objective in Europe, where free move-
Currently, CME-CPD accreditors in Europe have
ment and freedom to offer professional (medical) services
mostly been created according to applicable national
is a key feature of the EU vision of the single market.
law or as non-governmental organisations based on
The newly formed not-for-profit association of inde-
civil law (the latter applies to all European interna-
pendent European accreditors, CME-EA, is committed to
tional accreditors).
offering a platform for dialogue between individuals and
While in the former case, public authorities define
organisations involved in definition of professional codes
terms and conditions regarding composition, princi-
in general, and accreditation of CME-CPD in particular on
ples and rules as well as regulation of the accreditor,
the national level. The aim is to reach a European consen-
the latter mainly rely on self-commitment.
sus on principles and rules applied in planning and delivery
The independence of accreditation bodies in CME-CPD
of CME-CPD. This includes consensus on constituent
relates (particularly with regard to those based on civil law)
characteristics of accreditors as well as principles and prac-
to the following:
tice of accreditation.
As a first step, corresponding to level 2 of the Credibility
(1) Statutory issues: All decision makers involved in
Cascade, CME-EA suggests establishing a European CME-
corporate governance including accreditation need
CPD calendar, publicly to demonstrate the multiple pro-
to be independent. They should have experience in
fessional activities in the field of CME-CPD in Europe.
professional self-regulation. As reviewers, they
should also be experts in their field, and they should
have an acceptable record of interests. Professional ORCID
political and/or scientific organisations in medicine Fabiola de Andrade http://orcid.org/0000-0003-1472-2824
may propose candidates for any position with the Richard W. Costello http://orcid.org/0000-0003-1179-
accreditor, but may never be able to impose 6692
4 F. DE ANDRADE ET AL.
References [6] International academy for CPD accreditation: glossary of
terms. [cited 2018 Mar 28]. Available from: https://acade
[1] EAHC/2013/Health/07: Study concerning the review my4cpdaccreditation.files.wordpress.com/2016/11/iacpda-
and mapping of continuous professional development glossary-final-2016.pdf
and lifelong learning for health professionals in the EU. [7] IAMRA statement on continued competency. [cited
[cited 2018 Mar 3]. Available from: https://ec.europa.eu/ 2018 Mar 28]: Available from: http://www.iamra.com/
health/workforce/key_documents/continuous_profes resources/Pictures/IAMRA%20Statement%20on%
sional_development_en 20Continued%20Competency.pdf
[2] World Medical Association Declaration of Geneva.
[8] Consensus statement for independence and funding of
[cited 2018 Mar 3]. Available from: https://www.wma.
continuing medical education (CME)/Continuing pro-
net/policies-post/wma-declaration-of-geneva/
fessional development (CPD). [cited 2018 Mar 3].
[3] Professional qualifications directive 2013/55. [cited 2018
Available from: https://academy4cpdaccreditation.files.
Mar 16]. Available from: http://eurlex.europa.eu/
wordpress.com/2018/01/consensus-statement-for-inde
LexUriServ/LexUriServ.do?uri=OJ:L:2013:354:0132:0170:
pendence-and-funding-of-cme_cpd_final.pdf
en:PDF
[9] Stolz D, Griebenow R, Tichelli A, et al. Position paper on
[4] Allen T, Donde N, Hofstädter-Thalmann E, et al.
current aspects of sponsoring in accredited CME. J Euro
Framework for industry engagement and quality prin-
CME. 2017;6(1):1312062.
ciples for industry-provided medical education in
Europe. J Euro CME. 2017;6(1):1348876. [10] More information, including presentations, can be found on
the homepage of the European Cardiology Section
[5] World Medical Association Declaration of Chicago on Foundation (ECSF). Available from: http://e-cs-f.org/en/
Quality Assurance in Medical Education. [cited 2018 Mar about-ecsf/activities-and-projects.html
3]. Available from: https://www.wma.net/policies-post/
wma-declaration-of-chicago-on-quality-assurance-in-medi [11] Murray R. Report on proceedings of the tenth annual
cal-education/ European CME Forum, Dublin, Ireland, November
2017. J Euro CME. 2018;7(1):1421376.