Strictly Confidential
STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL
EUROPEAN INVESTMENT BANK
AAC/47/2022
APPOINTMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE (AAC)
OPINION
1. By virtue of Article 27.8 of the Rules of Procedure of the Bank, the Appointment Advisory
Committee (AAC) shall give a non-binding opinion on candidates’ suitability to perform the duties
of a full member or observer of the Audit Committee in light of the criteria set out in Articles 27.2,
27.6 and 27.7 of the Rules of Procedure and specified further in the operating rules of the AAC
before the Board of Governors makes the appointments referred to in Article 12.1 of the Statute,
and in Articles 27.1 and 27.6 of the Rules of Procedure.
2. The Appointment Advisory Committee (AAC) shall comprise five members external to the Bank,
appointed by the Board of Governors upon proposal of the President, having independence,
competence, high integrity and high reputation. As of the date of this opinion, the composition of
the AAC was the following: Ms Ariane Obolensky, Chairperson, M. Marek Belka, M. Pat Cox,
and Ms Danièle Nouy, members.
3. Pursuant to Art. 7 of the Operating Rules of the AAC, the Secretary General of the EIB sent to
the Chairperson of the AAC on 17 December 2021 a request to assess the proposal to appoint
Mr Ivan Šramko
as a full member of the Audit Committee of the EIB.
The AAC also received additional information on the candidate and on the composition of the
Audit Committee from the nominating Member State, the candidate and the Bank on 22 December
2021, 17 January 2022, 20 January 2022 and 28 January 2022. The AAC also hold a hearing
with the candidate on 2 February 2022.
4. The AAC has now completed the assessment of the suitability of the candidate according to the
criteria and procedures foreseen in the EIB Rules of Procedure and the AAC Operating Rules.
5. After deliberation, the AAC has concluded its assessment with an opinion of
NON-OBJECTION1
Further comments to the opinion of non-objection are summarised in the annex.
Date: 4 February 2022
The AAC Chairperson
(signed) A. OBOLENSKY
1 In case of statement of reservation, the Committee shall give reasons for its opinion. It shall set out the
principal grounds upon which the opinion is based. (AAC Operating Rules, Art. 11) Comments to the
opinion of non-objection are not mandatory.
Page 1 of 2
STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL
Strictly Confidential
STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL
EUROPEAN INVESTMENT BANK
AAC/47/2022
Annex: Comments to the opinion of non-objection
Pursuant to the EIB Rules of Procedure and the operating rules of the Appointment Advisory
Committee (AAC), the AAC has been requested to provide the Government of the Slovak Republic
with an opinion on the suitability of Mr Ivan Šramko to perform the duties of a full member of the
Audit Committee of the EIB.
In accordance with Article 8(2) of the operating rules of the AAC, the Chair of the Audit Committee
has been consulted on any potential specific need within the Audit Committee at the time of
appointment of the candidate. This information was provided in written form to the Committee before
its deliberations. The Audit Committee confirmed its genuine interest in a person with a strong and
practical experience in banking supervision in line with the requirements set out in Article 27.7 of the
Rules of Procedures.
In accordance with Article 9 of the operating rules of the AAC, the AAC decided on 20 January 2022
to hold a hearing with the candidate. This hearing took place on 2 February 2022.
On the basis of the above-mentioned information provided by the Chairman of the Audit Committee,
additional written information provided by the nominating Member State and the Bank’s Chief
Compliance Officer, and the hearing with the candidate, the AAC concluded the assessment of the
suitability of the candidate according to the criteria and procedures foreseen in the EIB Rules of
Procedure and the AAC Operating Rules.
The AAC considered that Mr Ivan Šramko’s track-record demonstrates a solid and long-standing
experience and expertise relevant to the Audit Committee, including on financial stability and
prudential supervision matters. In this regards, the AAC particularly considered Mr Šramko’s
experience as Deputy Governor and Governor of the National Bank of Slovakia (2002-2009) and as
an alternative member of the Administrative Board of Review of the European Central Bank (2016-
2021).
When considering the overall composition of the Audit Committee, the AAC welcomed this
nomination proposal, which contributes to addressing the current lack of micro-prudential experience
in overall composition of the Audit Committee in the field of supervising large and complex
institutions.
The AAC already underlined the importance of strengthening the Audit Committee competencies in
micro-prudential supervision to enable it to implement a standard compliant review and evaluation
process and therefore wholly supports the Audit Committee’s request.
Mr Šramko currently holds a number of mandates in both the private and public sectors. The AAC
has carefully considered these activities as they could impact on the required independence, on time
commitment and/or even generate possible conflict of interests and reputational risks for the Bank,
in particular when relating to counterparties of the Bank. Mr Šramko has confirmed that his role in
these mandates does not include executive management responsibilities and that his functions in
the private sector are more oriented towards representing the interests of the State. Furthermore,
he confirmed his willingness to comply with the applicable rules in force at the EIB should any conflict
of interest situation arise. Regarding time commitment, Mr Šramko reassured the AAC on this issue
by detailing his activities in this respect.
The AAC was not informed about any other integrity issue and no adverse information regarding Mr
Šramko’ profile and activities have been found in the course of this assessment based on information
provided by the nominating Member State.
Page 2 of 2
STRICTLY CONFIDENTIAL
Saatja: EIB Board of Governors Secretariat <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 03.03.2022 16:20
Adressaat: RAM Info <
[email protected]>; Andres Kuningas
<
[email protected]>; Riina Laigo <
[email protected]>
Koopia: EIB Board of Governors Secretariat <
[email protected]>; BOIS-
WILLAERT Emilie <
[email protected]>; GEORGES Yannick <
[email protected]>
Teema: CORRIGENDUM: Board of Governors Written Procedure: Appointment of
Mr Ivan Šramko as full Member to the EIB Audit Committee
Confidential
Dear Advisors to Governors,
Following our correspondence of 25 February 2022 regarding the procedure
for the appointment of Mr Ivan Šramko as Member of the Audit Committee,
we would like to draw your attention to the following correction in the
Voting letter.
In the introduction of the letter it should read:
The Slovak Republic has nominated, by common accord with the Republic of
Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, the Republic of Cyprus, the Republic of
Malta, the Republic of Slovenia, the Republic of Poland, Hungary and the
Republic of Croatia, Mr Ivan Šramko (former Governor of the National Bank
of Slovakia and former Alternate member of the Administrative Board of
Review of the European Central Bank) for appointment as a full Member of
the Audit Committee of the European Investment Bank.
In our version sent previously, the countries Republic of Poland, Hungary
and the Republic of Croatia were missing.
The Corrigendum version is available on the EIB Board Portal.
May we kindly ask for your assistance in forwarding the amended letter,
together with the related documents enclosed, to your Minister, and in
following up on this procedure. We would appreciate receiving the
completed voting form by scan (to ) by Friday, 11 March 2022 close of
business at the latest and the original by mail.
Thank you very much in advance for your cooperation.
Best regards,
Board of Governors Secretariat
General Secretariat / Governing Bodies Department
98-100 boulevard Konrad AdenauerL-2950 Luxembourg
P Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Les informations contenues dans ce message et/ou ses annexes sont
reservees a l'attention et a l'utilisation de leur destinataire et
peuvent etre confidentielles. Si vous n'etes pas destinataire de ce
message, vous etes informes que vous l'avez recu par erreur et que toute
utilisation en est interdite. Dans ce cas, vous etes pries de le detruire
et d'en informer la Banque Europeenne d'Investissement.
The information in this message and/or attachments is intended solely for
the attention and use of the named addressee and may be confidential. If
you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have
received this transmittal in error and that any use of it is prohibited.
In such a case please delete this message and kindly notify the European
Investment Bank accordingly.---------------------------------------------
-----------------------
Curriculum Vitae Ivan Šramko
PERSONAL INFORMATION Ivan Šramko
4, Jeseniova, Bratislava, 85104, Slovakia
+421 915 720 020
[email protected]
Sex: Male | Date of birth: 03/09/1957 | Nationality: Slovak
WORK EXPERIENCE
2012 – 2020 Chairman of the Council for Budget Responsibility
Council for Budget Responsibility, Imricha Karvaša 1, 81325 Bratislava, Slovakia, www.rrz.sk
▪ Monitoring and assessment of fiscal developments of Slovakia
Independent constitutional Institution
The Administrative Board of Review of the European Central Bank - Banking
2016 – 2021
Supervision – alternative member
The body established by the SSM Regulation to carry out an internal review of the ECB supervision
decisions
2010 – 2011 Ambassador to Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
OECD, 2, rue Andre Pascal, 75775 Paris Cedex 16, France, www.oecd.org
Economic diplomacy
2005 – 2009 Governor of the National Bank of Slovakia
National Bank of Slovakia, Imricha Karvaša 1, 81325 Bratislava, Slovakia, www.nbs.sk
Central Banking
2002 - 2005 Deputy Governor of the National Bank of Slovakia
National Bank of Slovakia, Imricha Karvaša 1, 81325 Bratislava, Slovakia, www.nbs.sk
Central Banking, responsible for banking supervision, regulation and payment systems
1997 - 2002 Board Member
Tatrabanka a.s., Hodžovo námestie 1, 81106 Bratislava, Slovakia, www.tatrabanka.sk
Subsidiary of Reiffeisen International Bank AG - Austria
Banking
1992 - 1997 CEO and Chairman of the Board
Istrobanka a.s., Laurinská 1, 83104 Bratislava, Slovakia
Joint ventures: Slovak insurance company and GiroCredit - Austria
Banking
EDUCATION AND TRAINING
1976 - 1980 Graduated with honors in Economics
© European Union, 2002-2013 | http://europass.cedefop.europa.eu Page 1 / 2
Curriculum Vitae Ivan Šramko
Economic University, Odbojárov 10, 85101 Bratislava, Slovakia
▪ Faculty of Management
1972 - 1976 School leaving examination
Gymnázium J.Hronca, Novohradská ul., Bratislava, Slovakia
▪ Comprehensive School
PERSONAL SKILLS
Mother tongue(s) Slovak
Other languages(s) English, German
Other functions / memberships in Chairman of Supervisory Board of Eximbanka, export - credit Agency, Slowakia 2020 -
the international institutions Member of Supervisory Board of Trinity Bank, commer.cial bank, Czech Republic, 2020 –
Deputy chairman of Supervisory Board of Slovenské elektrárne a.s. – electricity
Producer 2020 -
Member of the Supervisory Board of ASIROM – insurance company 2015 - 2017
– subsidiary of Vienna Insurance Group
Senior advisor to CEE & SEE regions, Intesa Sanpaolo:
Member of Supervisory Boards of: 2011 - 2013
CIB Bank, Hungary
Banka Koper, Slovenia
Banca Intesa Beograd, Serbia
Privredna Banka Zagreb, Croatia
Intesa Sanpaolo Banka d.d. Bosna i Hercegovina, Bosnia and Herzegovina
Member of the Governing Council, European Central Bank 2008 - 2010
Governor, International Monetary Fund in Washington 2005 - 2010
Chairman of the Board, University of Economics in Bratislava 2009 –
MIS Advisory s.r.o. 50% owner – occasional advice to consulting company and
Corporates in non-financial matters
© European Union, 2002-2013 | http://europass.cedefop.europa.eu Page 2 / 2
Board of Governors
Ms Keit PENTUS-ROSIMANNUS
Minister of Finance
Governor of the European Investment Bank
Ministry of Finance
Suur-Ameerika 1
EE - 15006 TALLINN
Luxembourg, 3 March 2022 SG/GB/SR/yg/ta
EIB – Strictly Confidential
Subject: Appointment of a full Member of the EIB’s Audit Committee
Mr Ivan Šramko
Dear Governor,
The Slovak Republic has nominated, by common accord with the Republic of Bulgaria, the
Czech Republic, the Republic of Cyprus, the Republic of Malta, the Republic of Slovenia,
the Republic of Poland, Hungary and the Republic of Croatia, Mr Ivan Šramko (former
Governor of the National Bank of Slovakia and former Alternate member of the
“Administrative Board of Review” of the European Central Bank) for appointment as a full
Member of the Audit Committee of the European Investment Bank. The opinion of the
Appointment Advisory Committee (AAC) and the curriculum vitae of Mr Ivan Šramko are
enclosed herewith.
On behalf of the Chairman of the Board of Governors, I should be most grateful if
you could vote on the proposed appointment in accordance with the written procedure
provided for in Article 5 of the Rules of Procedure. For your convenience, a corresponding
voting form is enclosed. May I kindly ask you to transmit your vote to the Board of Governors
Secretariat (
[email protected]) at your earliest convenience, if possible by Friday, 11
March 2021.
The new member of the Audit Committee is succeeding Mr László Balogh whose
mandate as Chairman and Member of the Audit Committee expired at the end of the day of
the Annual Meeting of the Board of Governors, that is on 18 June 2021. Consequently,
Mr Ivan Šramko will be appointed for a term of office expiring in 2027 at the end of the day
either of the Annual Meeting or of the approval of the financial statements for the previous
financial year, whichever is the later.
Yours faithfully,
Marjut Falkstedt
Secretary General
Enc.: 2
EUROPEAN INVESTMENT BANK
BOARD OF GOVERNORS
On the proposal concerning the appointment of
Mr Ivan Šramko
as a full Member of the Audit Committee of the European Investment Bank
as submitted by letter dated 23 February 2022 and a revised version dated 3 March 2022 from
the Bank’s Secretary General, I hereby
vote in favour abstain vote against
NAME (MINISTER): …………………………………………………………………………………
(Block capitals)
COUNTRY: …………………………………………………………………………………
SIGNATURE(*): …………………………………………………………………………………
DATE (*): …………………………………………………………………………………
OFFICIAL STAMP:
Please return the scanned version of the completed voting form by email to EIB Board of
Governors Secretariat (
[email protected]) and the original by post, to:
Board of Governors Secretariat
European Investment Bank
Office EKI-6510
100, boulevard Konrad Adenauer
L – 2950 Luxembourg
If possible, the signed voting form shall reach the EIB before close of business by Friday, 11
March 2022
(*) EIB Governors may digitally sign this voting form with a Qualified Electronic Signature (QES).
Please note that the EIB accepts only QES in the performance of a digital signing process.
A guidance note on signatures accepted by the Bank for voting forms signed by the EIB
Governors is annexed to this form.
Signatures accepted by the Bank for voting forms signed
by the EIB Governors
What is the Legal context?
The EIB digital signature process relies on the EU Regulation No 910/2014 on Electronic Identification,
Authentication and Trust Services (the eIDAS Regulation), which establishes an EU-wide legal
framework for electronic signatures and trusted services for electronic signatures. You may consult the
full text of eIDAS Regulation under this [link].
eIDAS Regulation is designed to create consistent regulations and standards across the EU for electronic
identities and for trust services supporting authentication and signatures. eIDAS Regulations ensures
that electronic transactions are secure, no matter where they take place within the EU.
By virtue of the eIDas Regulation, a qualified electronic signature (QES) has in all EU Member States an
equivalent effect to a wet ink signature.
The EIB accepts and signs only with qualified electronic signatures (QES) for digital transactions
governed by any laws of EU Member States and with external counterparties registered within the EU.
May Governors sign voting forms electronically?
Article 5(1) of the Rules of Procedure allows the Board of Governors to vote “by written or electronic
correspondence.” Voting by written correspondence is traditionally conducted by filling in and signing
a voting form as supplied by the Secretariat General.
Qualified electronic signatures as defined in Regulation (EU) No 910/2014 of 23 July 2014 (the “eIDAS
Regulation”) are accorded a legal effect equivalent to that of a handwritten signature. A qualified
electronic signature based on a qualified certificate issued in one Member State must be recognised as
a qualified electronic signature in all other Member States.
Given the importance of the decisions which the Board of Governors is called upon to take
(appointments and compulsory retirements, capital increases and authorisations for the launch of
Statute change procedures, approval or rejection of annual reports and of highest-order policies), it
appears appropriate to continue to afford the highest level of legal protection to the Bank where it must
attribute individual signatures to individual Governors. Hence, when a Governor chooses to replace
his/her handwritten signature by an electronic signature, the chosen method should be qualified
electronic signatures within the meaning of the eIDAS Regulation. In such case, no hardcopy version
shall follow to the EIB Board of Governors Secretariat.
May Governors delegate their vote to ministry staff?
The EIB’s legal framework does not provide for any explicit possibility for Governors to delegate their
vote to persons other than another Governor at meetings (Article 6 of the Rules of Procedure), and the
EIB’s Statute and Rules of Procedure do not provide for any explicit possibility for Governors to delegate
their written votes either.
Thus, in the case of electronic voting, the EIB will assume that incoming electronic votes have been cast
by the Governor to whom electronic access has been given.
It is for the Governors Advisors and/or the national administrations to decide on their internal working
arrangements and practicalities of how the casting of the Governor’s electronic vote should be
managed.
How does EIB validate a digitally signed document?
The eIDAS Regulation also covers the verification and validation of certificates for website
authentication.
Validation is the process of confirming the validity of QES, that is, that the certificate used to create the
signature was valid at the moment of creation (it was not revoked, suspended, or expired). Such a
process entails the verification that the requirements of the eIDAS Regulation are met by QES in order
to confirm its validity.
The EIB Board of Governors Secretariat will validate received digitally signed voting forms using:
a) the “Validate a signature” feature provided by EU Sign
b) Adobe Acrobat software with pre-loaded European Union trusted certificates recognition features
In case of non-compliance, the EIB Board of Governors Secretariat will inform the sender that the
electronically signed document received cannot be taken into account and will request to be provided
with a handwritten/wet-ink signed voting form by post (+scanned copy by email).
Summary table
Signature Type Explanation - Process EIB Validation
wet-ink signature Governors may continue to sign voting forms using a wet-ink Only the original received by post is legally binding.
signature. The scanned version of the completed voting form shall
be returned by email to EIB Board of Governors Secretariat
(
[email protected]) and the original by post to:
Board of Governors Secretariat
European Investment Bank
Office EKI-6510
100, boulevard Konrad Adenauer
L – 2950 Luxembourg
AES – advanced An electronic signature with following requirements: Documents signed using AES are not accepted by the Bank.
electronic
• Digital certificate associated to the signature
signature
• Guarantee that the document has not been modified
• Advanced identity verification system with the agreement
of the signatory (ex: verify ID card)
QES – All requirements of AES, in addition: EIB accepts only qualified electronic signature (QES) in the
qualified • Identity of the signatory is validated upstream by a QTSP performance of a digital signing process.
electronic (qualified certifying authority)
- Using a certificate from a Qualified Trust Service Provider listed
signature • The signature key is located in a qualified device for
in the EU Trusted List and able to provide the service:
creating an electronic signature (QSCD).
“Qualified Certificate for electronic signature” ; the e-signature
By virtue of eIDAS Regulation, only qualified electronic signatures must rely on a valid (i.e. not revoked or expired) signature
(QES), explicitly enjoys the equivalent legal effect to handwritten certificate;
(wet-ink) signature across all EU Member States.
- The digital signature should be placed in the document in the
In such case, no hardcopy version shall follow to the EIB Board of place a wet-ink signature would be placed and that it is visible.
Governors Secretariat.