dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
Otsing›Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium
Väljaminev kiriAvalik

Kiri

Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium · 6. oktoober 2020
Viit
16-1/2020/6141-1
Registreeritud
6. oktoober 2020
Dokumendi liik
Väljaminev kiri
Adressaat
Executive Agency for Small and Medium-sized Enterprises (EASME)
Saabumis/saatmisviis
post
Funktsioon
16 Elamupoliitika ja -majanduse korraldamine
Sari
16-1 Elamumajanduse arengustrateegiate ning programmidega seotud kirjavahetus (Arhiiviväärtuslik)
Toimik
16-1/2020
Vastutaja
Ivan Sergejev (Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium, Kantsleri valdkond, Ehituse valdkond, Ehitus- ja elamuosakond)

Failid

  • 📎Annex I - LTRS.pdf2658 KB
  • 📎Annex II.pdf500 KB
  • 📎BUILDEST_declaration_.pdf277 KB
  • 📎BUILDEST_KPI.pdf71 KB
  • 📎BUILDEST_KPI.xlsx
  • 📎LIFE_IP_BUILDEST_final_CN.pdf1268 KB

Sisu (failidest)

Long-term strategy for building renovation Tallinn July 2020 1 Summary The main goal of this long-term renovation strategy is the full renovation, by 2050, of buildings erected before 2000. The depth of full renovation is reflected in the minimum required energy performance of a building after a major renovation, which, according to the Estonian energy performance regulations, currently is class C1. The strategy has the following central principles:  Cost-effective application of energy efficiency requirements Energy and resource efficiency; in addition to the energy performance of buildings, taking into account the environmental impact of the construction materials and processes.  Regional balance Ensuring renovation and balanced volumes of living quarters in functional region and second-tier centres.  Quality of living and working environment Ensuring the healthy interior climate, improving accessibility and functionality as well as abiding by the basic principles for high-quality space2 in the solutions for buildings and public spaces during the renovation.  Technological development The development of renovation solutions and technologies to improve the sustainability of the renovated buildings and reduce renovation costs.  Climate change mitigation and adaptation Climate change mitigation, reduction of the carbon intensity of buildings, buildings that contribute towards climate neutrality. The strategy that ensures energy savings, the healthy interior climate The strategy is human- in buildings and a high-quality spatial environment is estimated to centred: the living and improve the living and working conditions of 80% of Estonian citizens. working conditions of 80% of The renovation of homes and workspaces as well as tearing down all Estonia’s citizens will derelict buildings will make the building stock safer, of better aesthetic improve in renovated, safe quality, better for health, better accessible for all population groups and affordable buildings. and more affordable. For towns with a shrinking population, the strategy points to the need and opportunities for taking into account the population and infrastructure development principles in zoning and opportunities for concentrating the town centres. In urban areas where the population is getting older and smaller, it is important to not only demolish underused buildings but also to ensure full functionality of the urban space, using demolition as an opportunity to improve the availability of public services and the functions needed for the functioning of urban areas, by gathering these into synergistic spatial ecosystems. Considering the number of existing buildings, the percentage of 141,000 buildings of already renovated buildings and the projected numbers of buildings 54 million square metres in falling out of use, the number of private houses needing renovation is total need renovation within ~100,000, their total floor area being 14 million square metres, 30 years. ~14,000 apartment buildings (18 M m2) and ~27,000 non-residential 2 buildings (22 M m2). To attain this target, it is necessary to establish, in addition to the final goal to be achieved in 30 years, the expected results and milestones of the strategy for 2030, 2040 and 2050. The introduction and large-scale launch of full renovation take time because this activity requires a learning process, qualified labour as well as the emergence of renovation-oriented enterprises and production. As the full renovation of buildings needs large investments, it is The removal of market important that as large a share of the renovation as possible be done failures will encourage on the initiative of building owners and be financed by them as well. property owners to make The current renovation market includes the construction volumes investments. needed for achieving this goal in all building categories except small residential buildings. However, in many cases, the renovation does not result in improved energy performance or the improvement is negligible. As to the cost-effective improvement of energy performance, the main bottlenecks that can be deemed to be the market failures the strategy will need to eliminate are:  The buildings are renovated not to save energy but for other reasons, e.g. to improve interior climate or functionality. When renovating a building due to other reasons, the work needed for improving its energy performance might not be done.  Property owners do not have enough financial capacity to renovate their buildings to achieve energy class C.  When renovating, property owners often do not simultaneously think of sustainability, health and energy efficiency in a 20- to 30- year perspective, and they have a legitimate expectation to receive government support for achieving the objective the government has set. To eliminate the problems, support measures and other stimulating measures are needed. The measures have to affect not the launch of Effective measures make renovation deeper. the renovation but the depth of it. If a property owner launches a renovation for some reason, the measure must help them with additional work needed to achieve energy class C. When applying these measures, the majority of the investments will be made by the private sector. The baseline situation in the main building categories is as follows:  For a private house of average size, the cost of full renovation is around €60,000, which is too big an investment for many households to make at once. Therefore, most owners of private houses renovate their property step by step. For private houses, the full renovation market has not developed yet, and renovation volumes need to grow by many times. 1 Tallinn University of Technology. Analysis of cost-optimal minimum energy efficiency requirements for buildings. 2017 2 Kvaliteetse ruumi aluspõhimõtted [Basic principles for high-quality space]: https://www.kul.ee/sites/kulminn/files/lisa_3_-_kvaliteetne_ruum_aluspohimotted.pdf 3 The success story of  Apartment buildings have been fully renovated in Estonia for 10 apartment building years already, allegedly with the best results compared to the rest renovations awaits repetition of the EU. The financing system, the technical solutions and in other building categories. apartment associations’ desire to renovate are there. The 50% energy savings achieved are accompanied by a healthy interior climate. Due to apartment building renovations, the energy consumption of dwellings has remained the same within the past 15 years, despite the construction of new buildings, i.e. increasing building stock. The main bottleneck has been the unstable financing of support measures.  In the public sector, the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive includes an obligation for central governments to renovate at least 3% of buildings that have a total useful floor area of over 250 square metres and do not comply with the minimum requirements, so that these meet the minimum requirements afterwards. The renovation of municipal buildings has primarily depended on the various support measures. The full renovation of commercial property has not  The commercial property sector renovates on market conditions. started yet. The main work done includes smaller renovation and work that offers quick returns on the investment, but the result is by far worse than class C, and as there is no carbon taxation on final consumption, the property owners have no motivation to invest in energy performance. However, the professional competence to design and implement the required solutions is there. The market situation shows that there is a need to motivate non-residential building owners in the private sector to invest in renovations that take longer to pay off. Financial support, loans and guarantees, the The possible renovation-related measures proposed in this strategy development of new include financial measures (loans, guarantees and financial support), technologies and know-how development of new technologies (prefabrication, digital tools, simple as well as investments into energy calculators for building owners), awareness raising (guidance residential buildings will materials, advice to property owners), demolition of buildings fallen create a viable renovation out of use, additional services from the KredEx Foundation for ecosystem. investments into residential buildings (renovation and construction of rental buildings) and research and development activities to ensure knowledgeable and efficient action. The strategy considers the full programme, i.e. the renovation, by Starting from the current 2050, of all buildings that have been built before 2000, although this level, the renovation might not be 100% possible in every building category. The total floor volumes will grow fivefold by 2035. area of the buildings needing renovation is 54 million square metres. According to the strategy, the percentage of this total area to be renovated by 2030 is 22%, by 2040, 64% and by 2050, 100%. In practice, it can be assumed that around 20% of buildings in private ownership will not fully reach the renovation depth target, i.e. class C, the effect of which could be set off by renovating other buildings better in the last decade of the strategy. 4 Table 1. Renovation volumes proposed by the strategy until 2050, by floor area. Area to be renovated, m2 2021-2025 2026-2030 2031-2035 2036-2040 2041-2045 2046-2050 TOTAL Private houses 400,000 950,000 1,900,000 3,100,000 3,900,000 3,800,000 14,000,000 Apartment buildings 2,280,000 3,200,000 4,000,000 3,900,000 3,000,000 1,800,000 18,000,000 Private-sector non- 840,000 1,800,000 3,200,000 4,200,000 4,100,000 2,900,000 17,000,000 residential buildings Local government 680,000 1,400,000 1,300,000 480,000 70,000 0 4,000,000 buildings Central-government 200,000 240,000 230,000 150,000 70,000 20,000 900,000 buildings 4,400,000 7,600,000 10,600,000 11,800,000 11,100,000 8,500,000 53,900,000 Keskvalitsuse hooned KOV hooned Üksikelamud Korterelamud Erasektori mitteeluhooned 2 500 000 AASTAS TERVIKLIKULT REKONSTRUEERITAV PINDALA, M 2 2 000 000 1 500 000 1 000 000 500 000 0 2 020 2 025 2 030 2 035 2 040 2 045 2 050 Figure 1. Cumulative annual renovation needs. Keskvalitsuse hooned Central-government buildings KOV hooned Local government buildings Üksikelamud Private houses Korterelamud Apartment buildings Erasektori mitteeluhooned Private-sector non-residential buildings Aastas terviklikult rekonstrueeritav pindala, m2 Fully renovated area per year, m2 The renovation of Considering the total annual renovation volumes of various building apartment buildings and categories, the most active renovation years will need to see the full public sector buildings is renovation of 2.3 M square metres a year, which is almost 5 times more progressing rapidly, but than currently. It is mostly achievable by adjusting the shares of new that of private houses and construction and renovation (see also 9.1 “Share of renovation in commercial property is construction sector”). just beginning to gain momentum. The renovation costs of the buildings were calculated in real terms on the basis of the full renovation costs in 2019. As to public sector buildings, it turned out to be necessary to divide the average full 5 The average renovation modernisation and conversion cost of €1100 per square metre into the price is €400 per square cost of energy-saving renovation work (€600 per m2) and that of other metre in current prices. work not related to improving energy performance. As the aim of the strategy is to attain the climate goals, only the cost of the work to achieve energy savings is taken into account. Regarding other building categories, data on energy performance improvement work was gathered during the preparation of this strategy: For example, in apartment buildings, basically all work done improves energy performance. As for private-sector non-residential buildings, the strategy takes into account the renovation cost of the building envelope and building services systems, which is €600 per square metre because two-thirds of the buildings need that kind of renovation. In the remaining one-third of the buildings, modernisation of the building services systems is enough, and that would cost €200 per square metre. Thus, the average renovation cost of private-sector non- residential buildings is 0.33 × 200 + 0.67 × 600 = 450 €/m2. So, the total cost of the full renovation of 54 million square metres, in 2019 prices, is around €22 billion, and the average full renovation cost of the buildings is €400 per square metre. If the full-renovation cost of public sector buildings is taken into account, the total cost would be €24 billion. Table 2. Costs of the renovations proposed by the strategy until 2050. Renovation cost, €M Cost, €/m2 2021-25 2026-30 2031-35 2036-40 2041-45 2046-50 TOTAL Private houses 400 161 381 776 1,236 1,541 1,504 5,600 Apartment buildings 300 683 953 1,189 1,160 886 530 5,400 Private-sector non- 450 379 811 1,437 1,884 1,828 1,312 7,650 residential buildings Local government 600 409 869 792 287 41 2 2,400 buildings Central-government 600 119 142 136 90 41 13 540 buildings 1,749 3,156 4,330 4,657 4,337 3,361 21,590 Annual renovation The annual renovation financing needs also increase almost 5 times: investments will reach from the current cost of under €200 M up to €900 M. To make building €900 M. owners want to invest almost five times as much as now, the measures proposed in the strategy will need to be applied. 6 1 000 900 927 REKONSTRUEERIMISE AASTANE MAKSUMUS, MLN € 915 800 808 754 700 600 572 500 400 431 300 200 187 100 0 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 Figure 2. Annual financing needs for the full renovation of the buildings. Rekonstrueerimise aastane maksumus, mln € Annual cost of renovation, €M The possible government aid will take into account the financial support for current measures and the renovation costs in 2019. The strategy proposes a new measure for private-sector non-residential buildings as there have been no renovation measures for these so far. The more specific aid projection for the country covers the period until 2030. It is practicable to specify the need for financial support in the upcoming periods later because during the step-by-step implementation of the strategy, the financing logic, market capacity and needs will change and savings due to development and innovation might occur. Table 3. Support needs until 2030. Renovation support, €M Support, % 2021-2025 2026-2030 Private houses 30 48 114 Apartment buildings 40 273 381 Private-sector non- 40 152 324 residential buildings Local government buildings 50 204 435 Central-government 100* 119 142 buildings 796 1,396 * This is not the usual financial support as the central government is the owner of the buildings. If the financial support amounts to €370 M a year, The financial support needed to launch investments in full renovation almost €300 M will be will grow from the current almost €90 M a year to the maximum of returned to the state €370 M in 2035. As the average tax revenue from renovation is 32%, budget as taxes each year. almost €300 million a year will be returned to the state budget as taxes 7 if the annual total investment in renovations is around €930 M. On the basis of this strategy, it is possible to prepare funding decisions when drawing up the state budget. 400 373 350 354 329 300 295 TOETUS AASTAS, MLN € 250 200 195 202 150 100 87 50 0 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 Figure 3. Annual financial support for the full renovation of the buildings. Toetus aastas, mln € Annual support, €M Besides financial support, the strategy proposes the creation of Balanced regional additional services by the KredEx Foundation. These should also development is possible significantly increase the investments in housing by involving private with the help of an €8.4- partners as financiers, thus reducing the load on the state budget. This billion fund that includes will speed up renovation of apartment buildings, increase the rental 10% of state resources. housing stock and use a counter-cyclical measure to even out the fluctuations in construction volumes. According to one possible scenario, for all the needs pointed out in this strategy to be covered, the following estimated prerequisites should be met:  The annual financing needs will be around €220 M in the beginning years, while the state contribution would presumably be 10%, i.e. the state should cover one-tenth of the amount.  The total financing need by 2050 will be €8.4 billion.  The state will get back around 30% of the construction costs as taxes, i.e. the related tax revenue would be 70-170 M a year. Loans and guarantees are Some financial costs will be incurred when the national renovation loan necessary for regions is launched and guarantees are provided for the renovation of private where the property values houses: are lower. 8  The loan measure would be meant for apartment associations to whom commercial banks are not willing to lend as much as needed for renovation. The capital needed to launch the loan measure is around €5 M a year.  To renovate private houses in regions where property values are lower, it must be possible to use state guarantees. These would allow banks to issue loans independent of the value of the collateral. The capital needed to launch the guarantee measure is around €1 M a year. During the implementation of the strategy, financial support needs to be given to demolition of buildings that have fallen out of use. It was projected that, by 2050, up to 10 M square metres of apartment Investments in R&D result buildings and non-residential buildings will fall out of use. As the in savings on renovation demolition cost of one square metre is €50, the financing needs for costs. demolition work might be up to €15 M a year. The R&D financing needs are estimated to be 1% of the state contribution. This should ensure the activities are knowledge-based Energy savings of 7 TWh/y and there will be savings on renovation costs in the long term. The means the final energy annual financing needs of the R&D&I activities are up to €4 M. consumption will shrink 60%. A final energy consumption reduction of around 7 TWh/y would be possible if the buildings were fully renovated. It would be possible to lower the heating consumption by up to 70% (~6.4 TWh/y) and electricity consumption by up to 20% (~0.5 TWh/y). The modest reduction in electricity consumption is due to the buildings where there is no compliant interior climate, but it can be achieved by the installation of the appropriate building services systems that use 4 M tonnes less CO2 electricity. The renewable electricity support measure helping to emissions a year means increase the electricity savings when necessary is not taken into 90% less GHG emissions. account here. Considering the renovation volumes proposed in the strategy and the reduction of the specific emissions of CO2 from the electricity and The implementation of the district heating, as estimated in the analysis of opportunities to raise strategy requires speedy Estonia’s climate ambitions, the CO2 emissions reduction potential of action; otherwise, the the existing buildings is around 90% (~4 M t CO2/y). targets set for the first decade will not be met. To sum up, the strategy presents the long-term vision for the renovation of buildings and describes the activities and volumes necessary for attaining the goal. On the basis of the strategy, it would be possible to start looking for the financing sources needed for implementing it and to plan detailed support measures. The projections in this strategy are needs-based and do not reflect the current volume of funds for this purpose. The prerequisites for implementing the activities foreseen in this strategy are their inclusion in the national strategic planning and budgeting processes and optimal use of the funds earmarked for this purpose. Due to the limited public- 9 sector resources, financing has to be found from various EU funds (funds planned in Estonia and central funds), revenues from trading GHG emission allowances, other state budget resources and private funds through market-based services. 10 2 Contents 1 Summary ......................................................................................................................................... 2 3 Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 13 4 Overview of final energy consumption ....................................................................................... 15 4.1 Energy consumption in buildings ......................................................................................... 16 5 Overview of building stock .......................................................................................................... 18 5.1 Residential buildings ............................................................................................................ 18 5.2 Number and location of private houses .............................................................................. 20 5.3 Number and location of apartment buildings ..................................................................... 21 5.4 Residential buildings, by location in functional regions ..................................................... 23 5.5 Residential buildings emptying and falling out of use ........................................................ 26 5.6 Non-residential buildings ..................................................................................................... 28 5.7 Public sector ......................................................................................................................... 30 5.8 Private sector........................................................................................................................ 36 5.9 Non-residential buildings falling out of use ........................................................................ 37 5.10 Architectural monuments and buildings of cultural and environmental value ................. 37 6 Renovation practices so far.......................................................................................................... 38 6.1 Renovation of private houses .............................................................................................. 38 6.2 Renovation of private houses with the help of financial aid .............................................. 40 6.3 Renovation of apartment buildings ..................................................................................... 41 6.4 Renovation of apartment buildings with the help of support ............................................ 44 6.5 Renovation of non-residential buildings ............................................................................. 47 6.6 Renovation cost .................................................................................................................... 49 6.7 Energy savings achieved by renovation............................................................................... 53 6.8 Conclusions on renovation activity to date ......................................................................... 55 7 Volumes until 2050....................................................................................................................... 58 7.1 Renovation need .................................................................................................................. 58 7.2 Financing needs .................................................................................................................... 60 8 New buildings ............................................................................................................................... 64 8.1 Volume of new residential building construction ............................................................... 64 9 Impact of renovation.................................................................................................................... 67 9.1 Share of renovation in construction sector ......................................................................... 67 9.2 Impact of building renovation ............................................................................................. 68 10 Measures .................................................................................................................................. 72 10.1 Adoption of new technological solutions ............................................................................ 72 10.2 Research and development ................................................................................................. 73 10.3 Awareness raising................................................................................................................. 75 10.4 Demolition of buildings falling out of use ........................................................................... 76 10.5 Financing measures .............................................................................................................. 77 10.6 Creating additional services for residential building investments ..................................... 79 11 Annexes .................................................................................................................................... 81 11.1 CO2 emission reduction-based support measure for renovating commercial properties . 81 11.2 Measures related to renovation of existing buildings ........................................................ 83 11.3 Results of interviews conducted among owners of private sector non-residential buildings ........................................................................................................................................... 84 11.4 Public consultation and inclusion of stakeholders in the preparation of the strategy ..... 86 11.5 Methodology for estimating residential building volumes. ............................................... 87 11 12 3 Introduction The energy and climate policy objectives of Estonia are stipulated in the National Development Plan of the Energy Sector until 2030 (NDPES 2030), the General Principles of Climate Policy until 2050 (GPCP 2050), the Climate Change Adaptation Development Plan until 2030 and Estonia’s 2030 National Energy and Climate Plan (NECP 2030). To improve the energy performance of the existing building stock, NDPES 2030 set targets for housing renovation and the demolition of apartment buildings fallen out of use. The targets were proposed to be achieved by the more active renovation of residential and non- residential buildings, encouraged by support and loan measures. Table 4. Targets set in NDPES 2030. Net area, m2 Quantity Residential buildings renovated with the help of financial support Apartment buildings 17 million Private houses 10 million Apartments and private houses with improved energy use 320,000 Renovated buildings in the total building stock Apartment buildings (class C) 50% Private houses (class C or D) 40% Demolition of apartment buildings fallen out of use 250 According to NECP 2030, the objective of Estonia for 2030 is to keep the final energy consumption at the current 32-33 TWh/y and to reduce the primary energy consumption up to 14%, both with the help of the proposed energy savings measure. To attain this objective, the following measures for the existing building stock have been proposed:  the renovation of public-sector and commercial buildings (HF1);  the renovation of private houses and apartment buildings (HF2);  the additional renovation of public-sector and commercial buildings (HF5);  the additional renovation of private houses and apartment buildings (HF6). The main aim of this long-term strategy for housing renovation is a cost- effective renovation of the existing building stock into nearly zero energy buildings by 2050. In Estonian laws and regulations on the energy performance of buildings, the cost-optimal energy performance level for a major renovation is energy class C.3 The objective is laid down in the renewed Energy Performance of Buildings Directive4, according to which the CO2 emissions of the building stock must be reduced by 2050. To achieve the energy performance targets, the average annual renovation rate has to be 3%; this would make the energy use of the building stock start to diminish. Whereas, it is important that the energy performance measures to be applied not focus only on building envelopes but also cover building services systems and ensure a healthy interior climate. Long-term renovation strategies focus on financial mechanisms and stimuli for removing market failures 13 and on involving financial institutions so that the private sector could make large investments in building renovation to improve their energy performance. The strategy includes measures such as facilitation of lending for improving the energy performance of buildings, facilitation of public sector investments in the building stock of high energy performance, public-private partnerships, reduction of possible investment risks, financial support and creation of a revenue base needed for financing the measures. The strategy has an extremely large social dimension as it is estimated that it would improve the living and working conditions of 80% of our population. The renovation of homes and workspaces as well as tearing down all derelict buildings will make the building stock safer, of better aesthetic quality, better for health, better accessible and more affordable. This building renovation strategy is also linked to the EU Circular Economy Action Plan5, one focus of which is construction, buildings and preparation of a holistic and sustainable strategy for the built environment, to promote circularity principles for buildings. In the future, buildings should be renovated in view of the circular economy principles (i.e. construction materials containing recycled material, building passports and green public procurements). To attain this objective, it is necessary to establish, in addition to the final goal, the expected results and milestones of the renovation strategy for 2030, 2040 and 2050. This project involved Jüri Rass, Ivo Jaanisoo, Ivan Sergejev and Regina Valt from the construction and housing department of the Estonian Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications as clients. The steering committee for preparing the strategy included Triin Reinsalu from the KredEx Foundation (SA Kredex), Raul Prank from the State Real Estate Company (Riigi Kinnisvara AS), Veronika Ilsjan, Eve Murumaa, Lauri Lelumees, Mari Lahtmets and Tarmo Kivi from the Ministry of Finance, and Hanna Jemmer and Irje Möldre from the energy department of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications. The report on the strategy was drawn up by the nearly zero energy building research team of the Civil Engineering and Architecture Department, Tallinn University of Technology (TalTech): Jarek Kurnitski, Kalle Kuusk, Helena Kuivjõgi, Lauri Lihtmaa, Aivar Uutar, Ergo Pikas, Targo Kalamees, Raimo Simson. 3 Tallinn University of Technology. Analysis of cost-optimal minimum energy efficiency requirements for buildings. 2017 4 Directive (EU) of the European Parliament and of the Council,, https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal- content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32018L0844&from=EN. 5 A new Circular Economy Action Plan. https://ec.europa.eu/environment/circular-economy/index_en.htm. 14 4 Overview of It has stayed between 31 TWh and 35 TWh for the recent 15 years.6 final energy Final consumption is more affected by business cycles than by the outdoor climate. The consumption was the biggest, 35.8 TWh, in 2007, consumption at the peak of the business cycle. Along with the downturn, the final consumption fell 12% in two years, reaching 31.4 TWh in 2009. The In 2018, the final energy winters of 2010 and 2012 were colder than average, and the energy consumption was 35 TWh consumption rose a bit then. The winter of 2015, which was warmer in Estonia. than average, did not affect final energy consumption. Since 2016, the final energy consumption has been rising and reached 35 TWh again in 2018. The years 2016, 2017 and 2018 have seen quite similar outdoor climate conditions. Lõpptarbimine, TWh 40 35 35,8 34,7 35,3 34,0 33,2 33,8 32,5 33,0 32,6 31,6 31,9 31,9 32,3 32,0 30 31,4 25 20 15 10 5 0 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Figure 4. Final Energy Consumption. Lõpptarbimine, TWh Final consumption, TWh Energy consumption by household accounts for the biggest part of the final energy consumption: 40%. Transport and industry each account for 21%. Commercial and public service sectors account for 15% of the final consumption. Table 5. Final Energy Consumption 2018, TWh. District Fuels heating Electricity Total Percentage Industry 2.60 2.06 2.65 7.3 21% Agriculture and Fisheries 0.83 0.07 0.17 1.1 3% Transport 7.23 0.04 0.09 7.4 21% Commercial and public services 0.64 2.20 2.53 5.4 15% Households 8.48 3.75 1.86 14.1 40% Final consumption 19.8 8.1 7.3 35.2 6 Statistics Estonia. KE024: ENERGY BALANCE SHEET BY TYPE OF FUEL OR ENERGY 15 Fuel consumption accounts for the biggest part of the consumption, compared to district heating and electricity. Fuels include, for example, woodfuels, gas, fuel oil, diesel fuel and petrol. Energy consumption 4.1 Energy consumption in buildings of residential buildings The data of Statistics Estonia regarding the commercial and public services is ~11 TWh and that of sector also include the consumption of diesel fuel and petrol not directly non-residential buildings, ~6 TWh. related to the energy consumption of buildings. Energy consumption of residential and non-residential buildings can be estimated after the final consumption of diesel fuel and petrol is moved from under households and commercial and public services sectors to the transport sector. Table 6. Final Energy Consumption 2018, TWh. Fuels District Electricity Total Percentage heating Industry 2.60 2.06 2.65 7.3 21% Agriculture and Fisheries 0.83 0.07 0.17 1.1 3% Transport 10.63 0.04 0.09 10.8 30% Non-residential buildings 0.45 2.20 2.53 5.2 15% Residential buildings 5.28 3.75 1.86 10.9 31% Final consumption 19.8 8.1 7.3 35.2 The annual energy consumption of residential buildings has been relatively stable, between 10 and 12 TWh. Around 85% of the consumption is heating (~9 TWh) and ~15%, electricity (~2 TWh). Over the years, the share of electricity consumption has increased in the energy consumption of residential buildings. The final energy consumption of non-residential buildings as increased as well. In 2004, non-residential buildings consumed 4 TWh of energy. By 2017, their consumption had increased 50%, reaching 6 TWh. Around 50% of the consumption of non-residential buildings is heat consumption (~3 TWh) and the other 50%, electricity (~3 TWh). The energy consumption of buildings is significantly affected by outdoor climate. The winters of 2010 and 2012, which were colder than average, caused the consumption to increase. The winter of 2015, which was warmer than average, reduced the energy consumption by buildings. 16 Eluhooned Mitteeluhooned 14 11,9 12 11,3 11,2 11,1 11,3 10,8 10,9 10,9 10,8 10,9 10,9 10,3 10,2 10,3 10,0 10 8 6 5,6 5,8 5,1 5,2 4,8 4,6 4,9 4,5 4,6 4,5 4,3 4,5 3,9 4,0 4,1 4 2 0 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Figure 5. Final energy consumption in buildings. Eluhooned Residential buildings Mitteeluhooned Non-residential buildings 17 5 Overview of 5.1 Residential buildings building stock Most of the Estonian residential buildings are in private ownership. According to the population and housing census of 20117, 97% of dwellings were in private ownership. State or local authorities owned just 2% of dwellings. Residential buildings are mostly privately owned. Välisriigi elanik Muu omanik 1% 1% Riik või kohalik omavalitsus 2% Eesti elanik 96% Figure 6. Residential buildings, by owner. The renovation strategy covers buildings constructed before 2000 (included). Buildings constructed later have higher energy performance. According to the survey of apartment buildings taken into use in the period from 1990 to 2010, their average space heating energy consumption was 102 kWh/m2/y.8 According to the survey of apartment buildings made of bricks, their average space heating energy consumption was 150 kWh/m2/y.9 The thermal conductivity of the building envelope of houses constructed after 2000 is significantly lower than that of those constructed before 1990. In general, the former do not need a full renovation that includes adding insulation to the envelope. The renovation would mostly cover modernisation of building services systems and addition of local renewable energy production. The strategy focuses on buildings that were erected before 2000 and need a full renovation. These account for the biggest part of the building stock. According to the population and housing census of 2011, 93% apartments and 89% of private houses of known construction date have been taken into use before 2000. Välisriigi elanik Foreign resident Riik või kohalik omavalitsus State or local government Muu omanik Other owner 7 Statistics Estonia. RL0206. Occupied conventional dwellings by type of building, owner and location. 18 Eesti elanik Estonian resident Korterid korterelamutes Väikeelamud 140 000 120 000 100 000 ELURUUMIDE ARV 80 000 60 000 40 000 20 000 0 Enne 1919 1919–1945 1946–1960 1961–1970 1971–1980 1981–1990 1991–2000 2001–2005 2006 või hiljem Figure 7. Dwellings, by year of taking into use. Korterid korterelamutes Apartments in apartment buildings Väikeelamud Small residential buildings Eluruumide arv Number of dwellings Enne 1919 Before 1919 2006 või hiljem 2006 or later According to the Building Registry, the number of energy performance certificates issued on the basis of consumption data for residential buildings taken into use before 2000 (included) amounts to 3 200. On the scale of energy performance, class A refers to nearly zero energy buildings and class C, energy performance after a major renovation. Class A, B or C has been awarded to only 22% of small residential buildings and 9% of apartment buildings with an energy performance certificate. 8 Tallinn University of Technology. Eesti eluasemefondi ehitustehniline seisukord – ajavahemikul 1990–2010 kasutusele võetud korterelamud [State of repairs of Estonian housing stock: apartment buildings constructed between 1990 and 2010]. 2012 9 Tallinn University of Technology. Eesti eluasemefondi telliskorterelamute ehitustehniline seisukord ning prognoositav eluiga [State of repairs and estimated life span of brick apartment buildings in Estonian housing stock] 2010. 19 Väikeelamud Korterelamud 800 706 700 600 527 500 HOONETE ARV 400 300 231 243 232 218 196 205 200 185 135 109 79 92 100 36 7 0 A B C D E F G H Figure 8. Energy performance certificates of residential buildings taken into use before 2000. Väikeelamud Small residential buildings Korterelamud Apartment buildings Hoonete arv Number of buildings 5.2 Number and location of private houses According to the Building Registry, the number of private houses of The number of private known area taken into use before 2000 (included) is 155,150, their total houses taken into use floor area amounting to 19,998,000 square metres. The percentage of before 2000 and still in use private houses is rather similar in all counties. The number and floor is 155,000, and their total area of private houses exceed 10% in three counties: Harju, Tartu and floor area amounts to Pärnu Counties. 20 million square metres. Table 7. Private houses, by counties. Number of private Net floor area, m2 houses Harju County 28,130 18% 4,003,000 20% Hiiu County 3,250 2% 347,000 2% Ida-Viru County 8,270 5% 876,000 4% Jõgeva County 7,930 5% 1,042,000 5% Järva County 7,200 5% 952,000 5% Lääne County 4,090 3% 487,000 2% Lääne-Viru County 13,400 9% 1,602,000 8% Põlva County 6,480 4% 743,000 4% Pärnu County 15,280 10% 2,024,000 10% Rapla County 8,100 5% 1,177,000 6% Saare County 8,350 5% 960,000 5% Tartu County 17,290 11% 2,512,000 13% Valga County 6,650 4% 710,000 4% Viljandi County 11,170 7% 1,564,000 8% Võru County 9,600 6% 1,001,000 5% Total 155,150 19,998,000 20 Figure 9. Private houses constructed before 2000 still in use (data based on the administrative divisions of 2019). Hiiumaa Hiiu County Saaremaa Saare County Läänemaa Lääne County Harjumaa Harju County Lääne-Virumaa Lääne-Viru County Ida-Virumaa Ida-Viru County Raplamaa Rapla County Järvamaa Järva County Jõgevamaa Jõgeva County Pärnumaa Pärnu County Viljandimaa Viljandi County Tartumaa Tartu County Valgamaa Valga County Põlvamaa Põlva County Võrumaa Võru County 5.3 Number and location of apartment buildings The number of apartment According to the Building Registry, the number of apartment buildings buildings taken into use of known floor area taken into use before 2000 (included) is 22,600, before 2000 still in use is their total area amounting to 28,378,000 square metres. The three 22,000, their total floor counties with the biggest area of apartment buildings (Harju, Ida-Viru area amounting to and Tartu Counties) account for 71% of their total floor area. Around 28 million square metres. one-third of apartment buildings and almost half of their floor area are in Harju County. 46% of their total floor area is in Harju County. 21 Table 8. Apartment buildings, by county. Number of Net floor area, m2 apartment buildings Harju County 8,060 36% 12,956,000 46% Hiiu County 160 1% 114,000 0.4% Ida-Viru County 2,140 9% 4,230,000 15% Jõgeva County 690 3% 559,000 2% Järva County 760 3% 715,000 3% Lääne County 520 2% 489,000 2% Lääne-Viru County 1,490 7% 1,361,000 5% Põlva County 460 2% 428,000 2% Pärnu County 2,110 9% 1,605,000 6% Rapla County 650 3% 564,000 2% Saare County 540 2% 454,000 2% Tartu County 2,480 11% 2,803,000 10% Valga County 600 3% 582,000 2% Viljandi County 1,270 6% 881,000 3% Võru County 690 3% 638,000 2% Total 22,600 28,378,000 Figure 10. Apartment buildings constructed before 2000 still in use (data based on the administrative divisions of 2019). Hiiumaa Hiiu County Saaremaa Saare County Läänemaa Lääne County Harjumaa Harju County Lääne-Virumaa Lääne-Viru County Ida-Virumaa Ida-Viru County Raplamaa Rapla County Järvamaa Järva County Jõgevamaa Jõgeva County 22 Pärnumaa Pärnu County Viljandimaa Viljandi County Tartumaa Tartu County Valgamaa Valga County Põlvamaa Põlva County Võrumaa Võru County 5.4 Residential buildings, by location in functional regions Based on their floor area, As for residential buildings, besides administrative divisions, functional 81% of the apartment regions10 need to be considered. The subdivisions of functional regions buildings are in county largely coincide with the property value regions11, and these and second-tier centres. subdivisions also reflect people’s ability to renovate their housing on market terms and conditions. The property value of apartments is an indicator of the economic capacity of the area. In areas further away from centres, renovation is more difficult because there are more residential buildings emptying in peripheries, smaller organisational capacity, smaller contributions to the renovation fund, etc. Renovation analyses regarding apartment buildings have indicated a correlation between renovation activity and property prices. As for small residential buildings, area-wise, these are distributed evenly throughout the subdivisions. Apartment buildings, however, have concentrated into centres of functional regions and second-tier centres: 81% of their floor area is there. Table 9. Residential buildings, by location in functional regions. Number of private Net floor area, m2 houses Centre of functional 34,500 22% 4,856,000 24% region Second-tier centre 15,900 10% 2,065,000 10% Immediate hinterland 40,400 26% 5,332,000 27% Transitional area 32,700 21% 3,953,000 20% Periphery 31,600 20% 3,792,000 19% TOTAL 155,100 19,998,000 Number of Net floor area, m2 apartment buildings Centre of functional 13,200 58% 20,133,000 71% region Second-tier centre 2,400 11% 2,822,000 10% Immediate hinterland 3,000 13% 2,312,000 8% Transitional area 2,100 10% 1,699,000 6% Periphery 1,900 8% 1,411,000 5% TOTAL 22,600 28,378,000 10 Toimepiirkondade määramine [Identification of Functional Regions]. Ministry of the Interior, Statistics Estonia. 2014 11 Korterelamute renoveerimistoetuste meetme arendus [Development of apartment building renovation measure]. MTÜ Tartu Regiooni Energiaagentuur [Tartu Regional Energy Agency, NGO]. 2018 https://www.mkm.ee/sites/default/files/trea_renoveerimismeetmete_uuring_lopparuanne.pdf. 23 Figure 11. Functional region subdivisions and centres. Kuressaare linn Kuressaare city Haapsalu linn Haapsalu city Rapla linn Rapla city Paide linn Paide city Rakvere linn Rakvere city Ahtme linnaosa Ahtme district Jõhvi linn Jõhvi city Narva linn Narva city Sillamäe linn Sillamäe city Jõgeva linn Jõgeva city Pärnu linn Pärnu city Viljandi linn Viljandi city Tartu linn Tartu city Põlva linn Põlva city Valga linn Valga city Võru linn Võru city Orissaare alevik Orissaare small town Haabneeme alevik Haabneeme small town Tabasalu alevik Tabasalu small town Maardu linn Maardu city Keila linn Keila city Loo alevik Loo small town Saue linn Saue city Saku alevik Saku small town Riisipere alevik Riisipere small town Kohila alev Kohila town Orgita küla Orgita village 24 Loksa linn Loksa city Kuusalu alevik Kuusalu small town Kehra linn Kehra city Kose alevik Kose small town Kunda linn Kunda city Kadrina alevik Kadrina small town Tapa linn Tapa city Tamsalu linn Tamsalu city Väike-Maarja alevik Väike-Maarja small town Kiviõli linn Kiviõli city Narva-Jõesuu linn Narva-Jõesuu city Mustvee linn Mustvee city Alatskivi alevik Alatskivi small town Järvakandi alev Järvakandi town Lihula linn Lihula city Türi linn Türi city Põltsamaa linn Põltsamaa city Suure-Jaani linn Suure-Jaani city Elva linn Elva city Räpina linn Räpina city Otepää linn Otepää city Antsla linn Antsla city Tõstamaa alevik Tõstamaa small town Häädemeeste alevik Häädemeeste small town Kilingi-Nõmme linn Kilingi-Nõmme city Abja-Paluoja linn Abja-Paluoja city Karksi-Nuia linn Karksi-Nuia city Tõrva linn Tõrva city Toimepiirkondade keskus Centre of functional regions Piirkondlik keskus Second-tier centre Toimepiirkonna vööndid: Functional region subdivisions Lähivöönd Immediate hinterland Siirdevöönd Transitional area Ääreline ala Periphery Lauri Lihtmaa Nov 2019 Lauri Lihtmaa Nov 2019 Andmete allikad: Maa-amet, Statistikaamet, SA Data sources: Land Board, Statistics Estonia, SA KredEx, Ehitisregister KredEX, Building Registry 25 Figure 12. Apartment value regions. 5.5 Residential buildings emptying and falling out of use Internal migration and Residential buildings getting empty and falling out of use is directly urbanisation are the main linked to demographic changes. According to the population causes of residential projection12 of Statistics Estonia, the population of Estonia will shrink buildings falling out of use. 2.7% by 2045. The age distribution of the population will also change. By 2060, the share of people aged 65+ will grow from the current 20% to 30%. Changes in counties vary. According to the projection, the population of Ida-Viru, Järva, Valga and Jõgeva counties will diminish by one-third. The population of Harju County will grow. Smaller increases in the population are expected for Tartu County as well. In addition, there will be changes within the counties. Settlements outside centres will gradually become empty due to urbanisation and regional immigration. 12 Statistikaameti rahvastikuprognoos aastani 2080 [Statistics Estonia’s population projection up to 2080]. https://www.stat.ee/news-release-2019-077. 26 30% 20% 10% 0% Valga Hiiu Rapla Võru Harju Pärnu Jõgeva Lääne Saare Tartu Järva Põlva Ida-Viru Viljandi Lääne-Viru -10% -20% -30% -40% Figure 13. Projection of population changes in counties by 2045. Empty apartment buildings create bigger problems than private houses. Apartment buildings are getting empty step by step until the remaining residents are no longer able to keep the building in a good state of repair or renovate it as needed. Emptying apartment buildings are a problem for local authorities and the central government as well. To solve the problem of emptying apartment buildings, a pilot project13 has been launched in three municipalities to find solutions to the problem of empty and half-empty apartment buildings, both for the municipalities and the locals. The project looks for solutions such as how to move people to sustainable apartment buildings and to tear down the empty apartment buildings that are partially in private ownership. Up to 25% of private According to the projections, around 40,000 private houses (~4.8 M m2) houses (~40,000) and up and 5,300 apartment buildings (~5 M m2) might fall out of use by 2050. to 23% apartment Changes in population numbers affect the peripheries of functional buildings (~5,300) might regions the most, as these are projected to be the first to become fall out of use. empty. While in centres, less than 10% of residential buildings is expected to fall out of use, this indicator might be as high as 80% in the peripheries of functional regions. As for empty private houses, it is likely that not all of them will be vacant. Instead, they will be seasonally used as a summer or country house. Table 10. Residential buildings falling out of use in functional region subdivisions. Number of private Net floor area, m2 houses Centre of functional 1,500 4% 160,000 3% region 13 https://www.rahandusministeerium.ee/et/eesmargidtegevused/riigivara/tuhjenevate-korterelamute- projekt. 27 Second-tier centre 700 5% 83,000 4% Immediate hinterland 2000 5% 200,000 4% Transitional area 11,000 34% 1,300,000 33% Periphery 25,000 80% 3,000,000 80% TOTAL 40,000 25% 4,800,000 24% Number of Net floor area, m2 apartment buildings Centre of functional 500 4% 1,100,000 6% region Second-tier centre 300 12% 300,000 11% Immediate hinterland 1,000 34% 700,000 30% Transitional area 1,700 80% 1,400,000 80% Periphery 1,800 95% 1,400,000 95% TOTAL 5,300 23% 4,900,000 18% 5.6 Non-residential buildings The Building Registry includes 375,000 non-residential buildings that are in use and have been taken into use before 2000 (included). Their There are 32,000 non- total floor area amounts to 62 M square metres. There are non- residential buildings with residential buildings with climate control (office, educational and climate control, their total floor area being 28 M commercial buildings, etc.) and without (ancillary buildings of square metres. residential buildings, agricultural buildings, pumping stations, etc.). The strategy focuses on non-residential buildings with climate control. There are around 32,000 such buildings with the total floor area of 28 M square metres. Table 11. Non-residential buildings with climate control. Quantity of buildings Net area, m2 OFFICE 4,010 13% 4,300,000 15% ACCOMMODATION 2,340 7% 1,020,000 4% COMMERCE AND SERVICES 6,710 21% 4,170,000 15% EDUCATION, RESEARCH 1,990 6% 3,890,000 14% HEALTHCARE 550 2% 1,050,000 4% WAREHOUSES 7,590 24% 4,100,000 15% INDUSTRY 7,920 25% 9,180,000 33% SPECIAL-PURPOSE BUILDINGS 740 2% 420,000 1% 31,850 28,130,000 28 The non-residential buildings are mainly in centres. Based on their floor area, 70% of non-residential buildings are in the centres of functional regions or in second-tier centres. Area-wise, 6% of non-residential buildings are in the peripheries of functional regions. Table 12. Non-residential buildings, by location in functional regions. Number of non- Net floor area, m2 residential buildings Centre of functional region 13,200 42% 16,790,000 60% Second-tier centre 3,700 12% 3,010,000 11% Immediate hinterland 6,220 20% 3,830,000 14% Transitional area 4,570 14% 2,580,000 9% Periphery 3,970 13% 1,760,000 6% TOTAL 31,800 28,000,000 Energy performance certificates issued on the basis of consumption data have been issued to 1700 non-residential buildings, i.e. 5% of all non-residential buildings with climate control. The biggest number of these certificates has been issued to office buildings (440), followed by nursery schools (390) and other schools (355). 27% of energy performance certificates issued to non-residential buildings are of class A, B or C. The biggest number of such certificates are of class D. To ensure the energy performance of non-residential buildings, the State Real Estate Company Riigi Kinnisvara AS has drawn up guidance on the energy performance of non-residential buildings14 and guidance for chief design engineers on ensuring energy performance of non- residential buildings15. 14 Riigi Kinnisvara AS. Madal- ja liginullenergiahooned [Low and nearly zero energy buildings]. https://rkas.ee/sites/default/files/public-uploaded-files/Uuringud/Madal_ja_liginullenergiahooned.PDF. 15 Riigi Kinnisvara AS. Energiatõhususe juhendmaterjal ja metoodika peaprojekteerijatele ning arhitektidele [Energy performance guidance material and methodology for chief design engineers and architects]. https://rkas.ee/sites/default/files/public-uploaded-files/juhendid/Juhendmaterjal%202017%2010.pdf. 29 Büroo Kaubandus ja teenindus Koolid Lasteaiad Muud hooned 140 133 120 120 110 99 100 100 86 83 HOONETE ARV 80 7576 72 65 65 60 50 50 44 45 42 41 40 40 37 37 26 26 27 27 22 20 1919 21 18 20 14 15 11 9 8 4 4 1 0 A B C D E F G H Figure 14. Energy performance certificates of non-residential buildings taken into use before 2000. Büroo Office Kaubandus ja teenindus Commerce and services Koolid Schools Lasteaiad Nursery schools Muud hooned Other buildings Hoonete arv Number of buildings 5.7 Public sector The data on the buildings of the central government is based on the data in the State Real Estate Registry.16 Such buildings also include residential buildings owned by the central government. The percentage of government- owned residential buildings is small, and a large part of these are apartment buildings that have to be demolished in Ida-Viru County. The Real Estate Registry data do not contain information on buildings used by state foundations (~660,000 m2) and buildings of bodies governed by public law (~800,000 m2). There is no central database on all public sector buildings yet.17 According to the State Real Estate Registry, the property is managed by ministries, the Government Office, the Chancellery of the Riigikogu, the Office of the President, the Office of the Chancellor of Justice, the Supreme Court and the National Audit Office. Authorised users include subordinate entities, such as schools, museums, the State Forest Management Centre, the Rescue Board, etc. In 2018, the central government sector used a total of 2.3 million square metres of floor area, 1.4 million m2 of which was owned by the central government and 860,000 m2 it rented. The floor area of real estate with climate control The strategy targets the buildings that are owned by the central government, owned by the central in use, have climate control, are not under protection as heritage or culturally 16 State Real Estate Registry. https://riigivara.fin.ee/kvr/. 17 Ministry of Finance. Riigi kinnisvara valitsemise koondaruanne 2015-2018 [Summary report on state real estate management 2015-2018]. 30 government amounts to and environmentally valuable and are located in Estonia. The Ministry of 820,000 square metres. Foreign Affairs has real estate in other countries, but this is not addressed in the present renovation strategy. The floor area of government-owned buildings with climate control is 820,000 m2. The majority of it is that of educational and research buildings, vocational schools accounting for the biggest part thereof. Of accommodation buildings, the majority are dormitories for students or pupils. Of commercial and service buildings, the majority are museums and sports buildings. Special-purpose buildings include internal security and defence forces buildings. The majority of such buildings are schools and TERVISHOID TÖÖSTUS ELUHOONED LAOD offices. 5% 2% 1% 1% MUUD ERIHOONED 7% KAUBANDUS, TEENINDUS HARIDUS, TEADUS 8% 46% MAJUTUS 14% BÜROO 16% A quarter of the floor area of central-government Figure 15. Real estate owned by the central government, by floor area. property has at least class C energy performance. Eluhooned Residential buildings Laod Warehouses Tervishoid Healthcare Tööstus Industry Muud erihooned Other special-purpose buildings Kaubandus, teenindus Commerce, services Majutus Accommodation Büroo Office Haridus, teadus Education, research The State Real Estate Registry has energy performance certificate information on 49% of the floor area of central-government-owned buildings with climate control. Based on floor area, 25% of government-owned property, i.e. 200,000 m2, with an energy performance certificate has been awarded class A, B or C. In addition to the energy performance certificate data on the property owned by the central government, the State Real Estate Registry has information on the energy performance certificates of premises rented by 31 the central government. Such information is known regarding 81% of rented premises with climate control. Pursuant to the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive (2012/27/EU)18, central governments should only buy or rent premises in buildings that meet at least the minimum energy performance requirements. Of the government-rented premises with climate control, 30%, i.e. 230,000 m2, comply with energy class A, B or C. The biggest percentage of class A premises the central government rents is in the joint ministerial building at Suur-Ameerika 1, Tallinn. Omand Renditud 140 000 133 000 129 000 126 000 120 000 98 000 REGISTRIVARA PINDALA, M2 100 000 91 000 80 000 68 000 59 000 58 000 60 000 53 000 51 000 45 000 45 000 40 000 34 000 20 000 17 000 15 000 11 000 0 A B C D E F G H Figure 16. Premises that have an energy performance certificate and are used by the central government, by energy class. Omand Owned Renditud Rented Registrivara pindala, m2 Area of registered property, m2 The State Real Estate Registry also has data on the state of repairs of the buildings: 5 – good, 4 – satisfactory, 3 – needing repairs, 2 – to be demolished. The accommodation and educational buildings have the best state of repairs. As the majority of the accommodation buildings are school dormitories, it can be inferred that so far, investments have been made mostly for educational buildings. Table 13. Premises with climate control owned by the central government. OWNED PROPERTY IN IN GOOD STATE OF NEEDING RENOVATION TOTAL REPAIRS AND OF AT LEAST CLASS C Quantity Area of Quantity Area of Quantity Area of registered registered registered property, property, property, m2 m2 m2 RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 257 40,100 4 400 253 39,700 OFFICE 104 70,100 1 2,200 103 67,900 ACCOMMODATION 106 108,100 14 37,700 92 70,400 18 Directive 2012/27/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal- content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELEX:32012L0027&from=EN. 32 COMMERCE AND 64 29,900 7 7,700 57 22,200 SERVICES EDUCATION, RESEARCH 109 318,600 21 115,500 88 203,100 HEALTHCARE 7 8,800 0 0 7 8,800 WAREHOUSES 102 19,200 0 0 102 19,200 INDUSTRY 14 6,100 0 0 14 6,100 OTHER SPECIAL-PURPOSE 99 63,300 0 0 99 63,300 BUILDINGS 862 660,000 47 160,000 815 500,000 In this renovation strategy, the property owned by the central government also includes 570,000 m2 of premises with climate control the government rents from the State Real Estate Company. The biggest part of such rented premises are offices, special-purpose buildings (buildings of the Rescue Board, prisons) and educational buildings (upper secondary and vocational schools). Table 14. Premises with climate control rented from State Real Estate Company. RENTED FROM STATE IN GOOD STATE OF NEEDING RENOVATION REAL ESTATE COMPANY REPAIRS AND OF AT LEAST CLASS C Quantity Area of Quantity Area of Quantity Area of registered registered registered property, property, property, m2 m2 m2 RESIDENTIAL BUILDINGS 50 7,200 1 100 49 7,100 OFFICE 147 258,000 10 54,900 137 203,100 ACCOMMODATION 10 8,400 8 4,500 2 3,900 COMMERCE AND 13 66,800 6 20,100 7 46,700 SERVICES EDUCATION, RESEARCH 31 66,600 8 26,300 23 40,300 HEALTHCARE 5 3,800 1 600 4 3,200 WAREHOUSES 0 0 0 0 0 0 INDUSTRY 3 1,400 0 0 3 1,400 OTHER SPECIAL-PURPOSE 110 158,700 19 57,800 91 100,900 BUILDINGS 369 570,000 53 160,000 316 410,000 There is no separate database on municipal real estate. The data on The buildings with climate municipal buildings comes from a report19 issued by the National Audit Office control owned by local in 2016. In 2015, municipalities used 6 300 buildings with the total floor area authorities have of 5.6 million square metres. Among others, these include ~5 000 buildings 5.3 million m2 of floor with climate control and the total floor area of 5.3 million m2. area. The majority of the municipal buildings with climate control are schools and nursery schools. Service buildings include libraries, local community centres, museums and sports buildings. Accommodation includes social housing and retirement homes. 19 Riigikontroll „Ülevaade omavalitsuste hoonestatud kinnisvarast ja selle haldamisest“ [National Audit Office. Overview of municipal real estate and its management]. 2016. 33 The majority of such TERVISHOID MAJUTUS buildings are schools and 5% 5% nursery schools. BÜROO 6% MUUD HOONED 12% HARIDUS, TEADUS 55% KAUBANDUS, TEENINDUS 17% Figure 17. Distribution of real estate owned by municipalities, by floor area. Tervishoid Healthcare Majutus Accommodation Büroo Office Muud honed Other buildings Kaubandus, teenindus Commerce, services Haridus, teadus Education, research Information on energy performance certificates is known about 1,600 municipal buildings, which account for 49% of the total floor area of municipal buildings with climate control. Based on floor area, 17% of municipal property, i.e. 900,000 m2, with an energy performance certificate have been awarded class A, B or C. 34 800 000 724 000 693 000 700 000 600 000 576 000 500 000 NETOPIND, M2 400 000 300 000 202 000 200 000 149 000 107 000 100 000 87 000 71 000 0 A B C D E F G H Figure 18. Municipal buildings with energy performance certificates, by energy class and floor area. Netopind, m2 Net area, m2 For the National Audit Office’s report, municipalities assessed the state of repairs of their buildings on a 5-point scale: very good, good, satisfactory, poor, and very poor. Around 4 million square metres need renovation. Municipal buildings estimated to be in a very good or good state of repairs and having at least energy class C are considered to not need renovation. The buildings in the best state of repairs are healthcare, educational and service buildings. Worse is the state of repairs of buildings municipalities classified under other buildings, i.e. mostly residential buildings, workshops and ancillary buildings. 10% of municipal buildings is estimated to fall out of use. Municipalities estimated that 90% of premises currently in use will also be in use after 5 years. Table 15. State of repairs of municipal buildings. BUILDINGS IN USE IN GOOD STATE OF NEEDING RENOVATION REPAIRS AND OF AT LEAST CLASS C Quantity Net area, m2 Quantity Net area, m2 Quantity Net area, m2 OFFICE 378 290,000 24 11,000 354 279,000 ACCOMMODATION 216 215,000 12 8,000 204 207,000 COMMERCE AND 1,130 825,000 112 113,000 1,018 712,000 SERVICES EDUCATION, RESEARCH 1,352 2,589,000 158 376,000 1,194 2,212,000 HEALTHCARE 138 258,000 13 53,000 125 205,000 OTHER BUILDINGS 847 476,000 36 49,000 811 427,000 4,061 4,700,000 355 610,000 3,706 4,000,000 35 5.8 Private sector In the analysis of this strategy, private-sector non-residential buildings There are 22 million include such buildings with climate control, taken into use before 2000 square metres of (included) and not owned by the central government or municipality. The private-sector non- residential buildings. quantity of these buildings is 27,000, their total floor area being 22 million square metres. The biggest part of private-sector non-residential buildings are industrial buildings, warehouses, offices, commercial and services buildings. TERVISHOID; 3% MAJUTUS; 3% ERIHOONED; 1% HARIDUS, TEADUS; 4% KAUBANDUS, TEENINDUS; 15% TÖÖSTUS; 41% BÜROO; 17% LAOD; 18% Figure 19. Private-sector non-residential buildings, by floor area. Tervishoid Healthcare Majutus Accommodation Erihooned Special-purpose buildings Haridus, teadus Education, research Kaubandus, teenindus Commerce, service Tööstus Industry Büroo Office Laod Warehouses Table 16. Commercial property with climate control. Quantity of buildings Net area, m2 OFFICE 3,400 13% 3,680,000 17% ACCOMMODATION 2,000 7% 690,000 3% COMMERCE AND 5,500 20% 3,250,000 15% SERVICES EDUCATION, RESEARCH 500 2% 920,000 4% HEALTHCARE 400 1% 780,000 3% WAREHOUSES 7,500 28% 4,080,000 18% INDUSTRY 7,900 29% 9,170,000 41% SPECIAL-PURPOSE 500 2% 200,000 1% BUILDINGS 26,900 22,300,000 36 5.9 Non-residential buildings falling out of use It is estimated that up to The percentage of non-residential buildings to fall out of use is 6 million m2 of non- estimated to be of the same magnitude as for apartment buildings. In residential buildings might peripheries, up to 90% of non-residential buildings might fall out of use; fall out of use. in transitional areas, this indicator might be 80%; in the immediate hinterland, 30%, second-tier centres, 10%; and in functional region centres, 5%. Quantity-wise, up to 30% and area-wise, up to 20% of non- residential buildings are projected to fall out of use. Table 17. Non-residential buildings estimated to fall out of use. Quantity of Net floor area, m2 buildings Centre of functional region 700 800,000 Second-tier centre 400 300,000 Immediate hinterland 1,900 1,100,000 Transitional area 3,700 2,100,000 Periphery 3,600 1,600,000 10,300 5,900,000 5.10 Architectural monuments and buildings of cultural and environmental value Pursuant to the Building Code, the minimum energy performance requirements do not apply to buildings that have been declared to be architectural monuments, that are used primarily for religious purposes and that are of cultural and environmental value. Nevertheless, the number and floor area of buildings mentioned in this strategy partially include architectural monuments and buildings of cultural and environmental value. The scope of this strategy excludes buildings that, according to the Building Registry, are defined as cult or sacramental buildings and according to the State Real Estate Registry, as heritage or buildings of the cultural and environmental value belonging to the central government. The number of architectural monuments is 527620, i.e. 2% of the total number of buildings covered by this strategy (~210,000). There is no central registry for buildings of the cultural and environmental value. A built-up area of the cultural and environmental value is an area 20 National Heritage Board. National Registry of Cultural Monuments. https://register.muinas.ee/public.php?menuID=statistic. 37 determined by local authorities in the zoning plan, and special renovation requirements apply there. The renovation requirements are more detailed for very valuable and valuable buildings; for less valuable buildings, the renovation requirements are not very restrictive. Architectural monuments and buildings of cultural and environmental value also need to be renovated, but often it is not possible or reasonable to strive for energy class C. Thus, there could be separate measures for the renovation of architectural monuments and buildings of cultural and environmental value. These could include lower energy performance targets than class C in this renovation strategy. The renovation analysis of wooden apartment buildings of environmental value21 indicated that it is possible to achieve 20%-30% energy savings in such buildings if just smaller works aimed at saving energy are carried out. 6 Renovation 6.1 Renovation of private houses practices so far The database of Statistics Estonia shows the total amount of renovation-related building permits and notices as renovation- related building permits. The data on use permits also reflects the total of renovation-related use permits and notices. According to Statistics Estonia22, the renovation of private houses has been increasing between 2011 and 2018. In the last five years, Renovation work is done in renovation-related building permits/notices have been issued for around 500 to 700 private houses 610 and use permits/notices for 300 private houses per year on a year. average. Ehitusload ja ehitusteatised Kasutusload ja kasutusteatised 800 697 702 700 652 581 600 Lubade ja teatiste arv 500 461 449 426 405 400 364 375 300 278 277 200 158 135 114 109 100 0 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Figure 20. Building permits/notices and use permits/notices for the renovation of private houses. 21 Arumägi, Endrik. Renovation of Historic Wooden Apartment Buildings. 2015. https://digikogu.taltech.ee/et/Item/da192f05-1fd6-4079-92e5-4c69ef74df43. 22 Statistics Estonia. Table EH045: Granted building permits and completed dwellings by type of construction, county and type of residential building (quarters). 38 Ehitusload ja ehitusteatised Building permits and building notices Kasutusload ja kasutusteatised Use permits and use notices Lubade ja teatiste arv Number of permits and notices The number of actual renovations of private houses is likely to be of the same magnitude as the number of building permits/notices because not all owners submit a building notice and not all those who have submitted it will renovate. The volume of renovations not recorded in the Building Registry could be considerable in the recent decade, but the amount of unrecorded work should diminish as the national building data is being digitised. Around 500 to 700 private houses are estimated to be renovated each year. The recent five-year average net area of private houses with building permits/notices for renovation is 86,000 m2, i.e. 0.4%, and that of private houses with renovation-related use permits/notices is 52,000 m2, i.e. 0.3% of the area of private houses taken into use before 2000. According to the Building Registry, 39% of building permits for private house renovation have covered the whole house, which means that the total floor area fully renovated each year is 35,000 square metres. The average annual area that needs to be renovated to achieve the target specified in this strategy is 470,000 square metres, i.e. ~13 times bigger than it is estimated to be today. Rekonstrueerimise ehitusload ja ehitusteatised Hinnanguline tervikliku rekonstrueerimise maht 500 000 450 000 Strateegia eesmärgi täitmiseks vajalik keskmine 400 000 aastane tervikliku rekonstrueerimise pindala Netopind, m2 350 000 300 000 250 000 200 000 150 000 100 000 50 000 0 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Figure 21. Building permits/notices for private house renovations, by net area. Rekonstrueerimise ehitusload ja ehitusteatised Building permits and building notices for renovation Hinnanguline tervikliku rekonstrueerimise maht Estimated volume of full renovation Strateegia eesmärgi täitmiseks vajalik keskmine Average annual full renovation area required aastane tervikliku rekonstrueerimise pindala for fulfilling the purpose of the strategy Netopind, m2 Net area, m2 39 The long-term strategy for renovation requires renovation to achieve at least energy class C. For private houses, this means:  insulation of outer walls (e.g. 15–20 cm of mineral wool);  insulation of the roof or attic (e.g. 20–30 cm of mineral wool);  replacement of windows (triple-glazed);  modernisation of the heating system (geothermal or air-water heat pump, pellet boiler, etc.);  installation of a ventilation system with heat recovery (a ventilation unit with supply and extract piping). The renovation volumes of private houses with use permits/notices received after renovation are not known, but it could be presumed that a large part of renovated private houses does not reach energy class C because, usually, this is not the aim of the owner. Instead, renovations are done step by step, as financial resources allow. 6.2 Renovation of private houses with the help of financial aid With the measure of financial aid for increasing energy performance of small residential buildings23, aid has been given for the renovation of more than 500 private houses since October 2016. The aid has been granted for energy-saving improvements. The aid covers 30% of eligible costs, and the maximum amount of aid for one private house is €15,000. With the example of the terms and conditions of the measure, which were reviewed in the spring of 2020, it is possible to regionally adjust the scope of the renovation as well as the share and size of the aid, to address the financing market failures. Aid requests cover mainly isolated energy-saving improvements, such as heating system replacement, building envelope insulation and installation of solar panels for local electricity generation. Private houses are not renovated just to save energy. There are other reasons for the renovation. For example, to install a more comfortable heating system (heat pumps instead of stoves). A full renovation also might include work to increase the size of the living area (the attic is taken into use). Renovation support for private houses is evenly distributed among regions. Aid requests have been received from all counties. 23 https://kredex.ee/en/services/elamistingimuste-parandamiseks/private-home-renovation-support. 40 90 80 78 70 69 60 56 50 40 39 30 35 34 30 27 20 23 23 21 17 17 16 10 14 13 12 0 Figure 22. Distribution of renovation support requests regarding private houses, November 2019. Harjumaa Harju County Tallinn Tallinn Pärnumaa Pärnu County Viljandimaa Viljandi County Lääne-Virumaa Lääne-Viru County Tartumaa Tartu County Raplamaa Rapla County Järvamaa Järva County Jõgevamaa Jõgeva County Saaremaa Saare County Läänemaa Lääne County Ida-Virumaa Ida-Viru County Tartu linn Tartu city Põlvamaa Põlva County Valgamaa Valga County Hiiumaa Hiiu County Võrumaa Võru County 6.3 Renovation of apartment buildings Around 400 apartment The number of renovations of apartment buildings has increased too.24 buildings are renovated a In the last five years, renovation-related building permits/notices have year. been issued for 880 and use permits/notices for 380 private houses per year on average. Around 400 apartment buildings are renovated a year. 24 Statistics Estonia. Table EH045: Granted building permits and completed dwellings by type of construction, county and type of residential building (quarters). 41 Ehitusload ja ehitusteatised Kasutusload ja kasutusteatised 1200 1115 994 1010 1000 Lubade ja teatiste arv 800 676 639 625 613 600 503 480 415 425 400 321 294 246 183 200 145 0 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Figure 23. Renovation-related building and use permits of apartment buildings. Ehitusload ja ehitusteatised Building permits and building notices Kasutusload ja kasutusteatised Use permits and use notices Lubade ja teatiste arv Number of permits and notices Use permits/notices are obtained after renovation regarding 1.3 M m2 of apartment buildings, i.e. 4% of the floor area of apartment buildings taken into use before 2000. If to presume that full renovation is mainly done with the help of support, the average net area of apartment buildings that have been fully renovated between 2011 and 2018 amounts to 280,000 m2, i.e. 1% of the area of apartment buildings taken into use before 2000. The average annual area that needs to be renovated to achieve the target specified in this strategy is ~600,000 square metres, i.e. ~2 times bigger than it is estimated to be today. Thus, there is no need to increase the number of apartment buildings that are renovated; instead, the percentage of a full renovation should be increased. 42 Rekonstrueerimise kasutusload ja kasutusteatised Toetusega terviklikult rekonstrueeritud 1,8 1,6 1,4 Netopind, mln m2 1,2 1,0 Strateegia eesmärgi täitmiseks vajalik 0,8 keskmine aastane tervikliku rekonstrueerimise pindala 0,6 0,4 0,2 0,0 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Figure 24. Renovation-related use permits/notices of apartment buildings, by net area. Rekonstrueerimise kasutusload ja Use permits and use notices for renovation kasutusteatised Toetusega terviklikult rekonstrueeritud Fully renovated with support Netopind, m2 Net area, m2 Strateegia eesmärgi täitmiseks vajalik keskmine Average annual full renovation area required aastane tervikliku rekonstrueerimise pindala for fulfilling the purpose of the strategy The long-term strategy for renovation requires renovation to achieve at least energy class C. For apartment buildings, this means:  insulation of outer walls (e.g. 15–20 cm of mineral wool);  insulation of the roof or attic (e.g. 30–40 cm of insulation);  replacement of windows (triple-glazed);  replacement of the heating system (for district heating, the installation of a new two-pipe system with thermostatic valves on radiators);  installation of a ventilation system with heat recovery (either a central unit with pipelines within wall insulation or an extraction heat pump). The volume of renovation done on apartment buildings that have received a use permit/notice after renovation is not known, but it may be presumed that not all of these achieve energy class C. However, the apartment associations have incurred renovation costs or taken out loans for bigger work, and it is likely that in the near future, they will not launch another renovation. 43 6.4 Renovation of apartment buildings with the help of support Apartment building renovation support25 has been granted to 453 buildings with a total area of 1.2 million square metres since April 2015. 1,100 apartment buildings As part of the support measure26 implemented between 2010–2014, have been renovated with 661 apartment buildings with a total area of 1,6 M m2 were renovated. the help of support since A total of 1,114 apartment buildings have received a positive decision 2010. to their support request. The average is 110 apartment buildings a year. Support rates depend on the energy class achieved and the location of the building. In Tallinn and Tartu, the support rate is 30%. In other cities where apartment values exceed €500 per square metre (mostly county centres), the support rate is 40%. In regions where the average apartment value is below €500 per m2, the rate is 50%. To receive the bigger support rate, energy class C must be achieved. For that purpose, the building envelope must be insulated, old windows must be replaced, the heating system must be renovated and a ventilation system with heat recovery must be installed. Pursuant to the terms and conditions of the support, new technical solutions for renovating apartment buildings have been taken into use. Mechanical ventilation systems with heat recovery have become the norm. In addition, windows are placed into the insulation layer to eliminate the cold bridge between windows and external walls. Also, solar panels are installed for local electricity generation, although this is not required to receive the support. Also, guidance material has been compiled regarding the technical solutions for renovation.27 Figure 25. Ventilation pipelines in the external wall insulation, wooden frames to take windows in between the insulation layer (left) and PV panels (right). Outside Tallinn and Tartu, it is possible to request a 10% lower support rate. Then there is no heat recovery requirement for the ventilation 25 Korterelamute rekonstrueerimise toetuse andmise tingimused ja kord [Terms, conditions and procedure for granting renovation support for apartment buildings]. https://www.riigiteataja.ee/akt/126042019007. 26 Rohelise investeerimisskeemi „Korterelamute rekonstrueerimise toetus” kasutamise tingimused ja kord [Terms, conditions and procedure for using the green investment scheme ‘Renovation support for apartment buildings’]. https://www.riigiteataja.ee/akt/110022015002. 27 SA KredEx. Korterelamute välispiirete lisasoojustamise sõlmejoonised ja tüüpkorterite ventilatsioonilahendused [Drawings of junctions for additional insulation of apartment buildings and ventilation solutions for standard apartments]. https://kredex.ee/en/increasing-awareness-energy- performance/energy-performance-existing-buildings. 44 system and energy class D is acceptable. More than 90% of applications were for the higher support rate, which means they aimed for class C. In the event of a full renovation, other important work that does not provide energy saving but is necessary for the safe use of the building is done as well. This includes the renovation of balconies, electrical systems, water supply and sanitation systems. Between 2010 and 2014, the support measure for apartment buildings helped save 60 GWh of heating energy a year28. This equals the annual district heat consumption of the city of Haapsalu. The presumable annual energy savings made with the help of the 2015-2019 support measure for apartment buildings are around 80 GWh. On average, the renovation of an apartment building usually results in ~55% of heat savings and 5% greater electricity consumption. The problem with the renovation support for apartment buildings is that its financing is unstable. When the support measure opens, the number of applications is lower (in 2010 and 2015). In the next couple of years, the number of applications increases until the budget for the measure runs out. More stable financing would prevent renovation volumes from heaping up and the resulting price increases. Positiivsete toetuse otsuste arv 300 269 250 209 200 191 Toetuse otsuste arv 148 150 110 100 52 51 45 50 39 0 0 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 Figure 26. The number of successful support applications regarding the renovation of apartment buildings. Positiivsete toetuse otsuste arv Number of positive support decisions Toetuse otsuste arv Number of support decisions The rate of applying for renovation support for apartment buildings Successfully renovated apartment buildings in the varies by regions. Harju, Tartu and Lääne-Viru Counties are much more neighbourhood have an active than others. The experience with the renovation measures for important influence on apartment buildings has indicated that new renovations are often near previously renovated apartment buildings. Renovations in the 28 SA KredEx. Korterelamute renoveerimisturu ülevaade ja perioodi 2010-2014 korterelamute rekonstrueerimistoetuse mõju analüüs [Overview of apartment building renovation market and impact analysis of the renovation support measure for apartment buildings between 2010 and 2014]. 45 the launch of new neighbourhood are an incentive for other apartment associations to renovations. start renovating as well. In addition, there are already several technical consultants in the region who have helped apartment associations with their renovation. Their experience is valuable for other apartment associations during their renovation process. Figure 27. The number of successful support applications regarding the renovation of apartment buildings, by counties. Hiiumaa Hiiu County Saaremaa Saare County Läänemaa Lääne County Harjumaa Harju County Lääne-Virumaa Lääne-Viru County Ida-Virumaa Ida-Viru County Raplamaa Rapla County Järvamaa Järva County Jõgevamaa Jõgeva County Pärnumaa Pärnu County Viljandimaa Viljandi County Tartumaa Tartu County Valgamaa Valga County Põlvamaa Põlva County Võrumaa Võru County 46 6.5 Renovation of non-residential buildings The number of renovation-related use permits/notices29 for non- residential buildings has been relatively similar throughout the years. The sharp increase in the number in 2012 was caused by the renovation programme for public-sector buildings, which was financed from the proceeds from the sales of emission allowances. Büroo Majutus Kaubandus ja teenindus Haridus ja teadus Tervishoid Laod Tööstus 250 200 Kasutuslubade arv 150 100 50 0 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Figure 28. Renovation-related use permits/notices of non-residential buildings. Büroo Office Majutus Accommodation Kaubandus ja teenindus Commerce and service Haridus ja teadus Education and research Tervishoid Healthcare Laod Warehouses Tööstus Industry Kasutuslubade arv Number of use permits On average, 320 use permits/notices for the renovation of non- Around 300 non- residential buildings are residential buildings have been granted in the recent five years. The renovated each year. annual average net area of non-residential buildings with renovation- related use permits/notices is 860,000 m2, i.e. 3% of the area of non- residential buildings taken into use before 2000. According to the Building Registry, 21% of building permits for the renovation of non- residential buildings have covered the whole building in the recent three years, which means that the total floor area fully renovated each year is around 170,000 square metres. The average area that needs to be renovated each year to achieve the target specified in this strategy is ~730,000 square metres, i.e. ~4 times bigger than it is estimated to be today. Thus, there is no need to increase the number of non- 29 Statistics Estonia. EH046: Granted building permits and completed non-residential buildings by type of construction, county and type of buildings (quarters). 47 residential buildings that are renovated; instead, the percentage of a full renovation should be increased. Rekonstrueerimise kasutusload ja kasutusteatised Hinnanguline tervikliku rekonstrueerimise osakaal 2,0 1,8 1,6 1,4 Netopind, mln m2 1,2 Strateegia eesmärgi täitmiseks vajalik keskmine aastane tervikliku rekonstrueerimise pindala 1,0 0,8 0,6 0,4 0,2 0,0 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Figure 29. Renovation-related use permits/notices of non-residential buildings with climate control, by net area. Rekonstrueerimise kasutusload ja Use permits and use notices for renovation kasutusteatised Hinnanguline tervikliku rekonstrueerimise Estimated share of full renovations osakaal Netopind, mln m2 Net area, M m2 Strateegia eesmärgi täitmiseks vajalik keskmine Average annual full renovation area required aastane tervikliku rekonstrueerimise pindala for fulfilling the purpose of the strategy Each year, the central The Energy Performance of Buildings Directive applies to the buildings government must of the central government and stipulates an obligation for them to renovate 3% of the area of renovate each year at least 3% of buildings that have over 250 square their buildings. metres of useful floor area and do not comply with the minimum requirements so that these meet the minimum requirements afterwards. Estonia has honoured the 3% obligation.30 On average, more than 4% of buildings covered by the obligation have been made compliant with the minimum requirements between 2015 and 2018. To meet the 3% obligation, it is necessary to renovate around 25,000 m2 a year. The majority of the buildings made compliant with the requirements belong to the State Real Estate Company Riigi Kinnisvara AS. The analysis of renovations made on private-sector non-residential buildings, as made for this strategy, indicated that the renovations do not result in energy class C. People mostly make easier and faster energy-saving improvements that do not hinder the use of the building during the work and that are paid off in 5 to 7 years. A full renovation 30 Ministry of Finance. Riigi kinnisvara valitsemise koondaruanne 2015-2018 [Summary report on state real estate management 2015-2018]. 48 that includes insulation of the building envelope usually has too long a pay-off period for commercial property owners. 6.6 Renovation cost The renovation cost data is based on the period from 2015 to 2019. The renovation cost data regarding private houses are based on the The average cost of a full information on the respective support measure between 2016 and renovation of a private 2019. The analysis of support requests covered a selection of house is around €400/m2. applications that covered insulation of the building envelope, replacement of windows, replacement of the heating system and installation of a new ventilation system. The cost of the full renovation was between €210 and €560 per square metre (VAT included). The average full-renovation cost was €360 per square metre of a private house. The renovations made by the owner cost less. The average cost of renovations made at least partially by the owner was €297 per square metre. The average cost of private-house renovations done by construction companies was €397 per square metre. For this strategy, the estimated full-renovation cost of a private house is €400/m2, presuming that most private-house owners will not renovate themselves. Thus, the renovation cost of a medium-sized private house (150 m2) is around €60,000. 600 TERVIKLIKU REKONSTRUEERIMISE MAKSUMUS, €/M2 500 400 300 200 100 0 TERVIKLIKU REKONSTRUEERIMISE VALIMI PROJEKTID ESITATUNA MAKSUMUSE JÄRJEKORRAS Figure 30. Full-renovation cost of private houses per metre of net area. Tervikliku rekonstrueerimise maksumus, €/m2 Cost of full renovation €/m2 Tervikliku rekonstrueerimise valimi projektid Projects of the full renovation sample in the esitatuna maksumuse järjekorras order of cost The cost data regarding the renovation of apartment buildings is based The average cost of the on the information on the respective support measure. The average full renovation of an full-renovation cost of apartment buildings that received support between 2015 and 2017 is €285 per square metre (VAT included). Apartment buildings where some of the energy-saving improvements 49 apartment building is have already been done earlier (e.g. the heating system has been around €300/m2. renovated) and those with the larger net area have lower renovation costs. Renovation of smaller apartment buildings (fewer than 10 apartments) and those of the cultural and environmental value costs more. The average apartment building that has applied for full- renovation support has 2,600 m2 of net area (40 apartments), which means that the average cost of a full renovation of one building is ~€800,000. 700 TERVIKLIKU REKONSTRUEERIMISE MAKUSMUS, €/M2 600 500 400 300 200 100 0 TERVIKLIKU REKONSTRUEERIMISE VALIMI PROJEKTID ESITATUNA MAKSUMUSE JÄRJEKORRAS Figure 31. Full-renovation cost of apartment buildings per metre of net area. Tervikliku rekonstrueerimise maksumus, €/m2 Cost of full renovation, €/m2 Tervikliku rekonstrueerimise valimi projektid Projects of the full renovation sample in the esitatuna maksumuse järjekorras order of cost The data on the apartment-building renovation measure shows that the increasing numbers of renovations are accompanied by increasing costs. In addition to the increased demand, the cost increases are the result of the increased renovation volumes ordered by apartment associations. After gaining more experience with renovating, the measure will cover more apartment buildings that, besides required improvements, make other improvements needed for the functioning of the building, such as replacement of the electrical, water and sanitation systems, installation of solar panels, construction of new balconies to replace the old ones, etc. For this strategy, the full- renovation cost of an apartment building is estimated to be €300/m2. Table 18. Apartment building renovation cost dynamics. Full renovation applications Renovation cost, €/m2 Average Median 2015 30 249 230 2016 124 264 251 2017 173 300 287 The renovation cost of public-sector buildings is based on the data of the 2019 support measure for energy performance of central- government buildings. The renovation costs are between €700 and 50 €2,000 per square metre (VAT included). Projects with higher renovation costs also include building extensions. The average renovation cost, extensions excluded, is around €1,100/m2, whereas the energy-saving improvements account for ~€600/m2 of it. The cost of energy-saving improvements made during the renovation and that of other improvements are shown in the table below. Energiasäästu tööd Muud ehitustööd 2500 TERVIKLIKU REKONSTRUEERIMISE MAKSUMUS, €/M 2 2000 1500 1049 1369 726 1338 1000 346 319 146 980 500 385 908 840 737 719 748 658 491 355 354 0 TERVIKLIKU REKONSTRUEERIMISE PROJEKTID ESITATUNA MAKSUMUSE JÄRJEKORRAS Figure 32. Full-renovation cost of public-sector buildings per metre of net area. Energiasäästu tööd Energy saving work Muud ehitustööd Other construction work Tervikliku rekonstrueerimise maksumus, €/m2 Cost of full renovation, €/m2 Tervikliku rekonstrueerimise projektid Projects of the full renovation sample in the esitatuna maksumuse järjekorras order of cost The renovation costs of private-sector non-residential buildings have been calculated on the basis of the analysis of such work. In private- sector buildings (mostly offices, commercial and service buildings), energy savings are the most cost-effectively achievable by replacing the building services systems. On market terms, so far, mostly just smaller work costing €10 to €20 per m2 has been done. Table 19. Energy performance improvement measures for non-residential buildings. System/structural Minimum renovation Maximum renovation Cost, €/m2 part Building Upgrade/adjustment of the System replacement/creating a new 2-25 automation system system Ventilation Ventilation unit replacement Replacement of the unit and system 15-60 and configuration with a new unit and system, increasing functionality, needs-based management, etc. or installing the system if the building did not previously have climate control Illumination Replacement of fluorescent Replacement of the illumination of the 5-30 tubes with LED tubes whole building with LED lamps and needs-based management Heating system Balancing of the system, Creating a new comprehensive system 5-30 replacement of the heat and/or replacement of the heat source source 51 Cooling system Balancing of the system, Creating a new comprehensive system 15-35 replacement of the cooling or adding one if the building did not unit previously have climate control Monitoring Measurement of the actual Measurement of the actual 1-10 consumption consumption, establishing a web-based cost calculation system, monitoring/analysis Commercial cooling Using residual heat, fitting Creating a new comprehensive system 15-50 systems31 refrigerators with doors Window/glass Sun control film installation Window or glass facade replacement 5-50 facade In buildings where upgrading the building services system is sufficient A full renovation of a commercial property costs for achieving energy class C, renovation work costs around €200/2 (VAT around €200/m2 if only the included). Upgrading the building services system is sufficient in building services systems buildings where electricity accounts for the majority of energy are upgraded and around consumption. For example, offices and service buildings where 600 €/m2 if the building illumination, appliances, cooling and ventilation account for the envelope is also upgraded. majority of energy consumption. In buildings where heating accounts for the majority of energy consumption, the building envelope must also be insulated and windows replaced in order to achieve energy class C. These include schools, nursery schools, hospitals and accommodation establishments. In the case of buildings whose building envelopes also require upgrading during renovation, the cost of work related to energy savings in public sector building renovations of €600/m2 is considered as the cost of renovation. Office buildings and commercial buildings form 1/3 of the floor area of private sector non-residential buildings. The average renovation cost of private sector non-residential buildings calculated in the strategy is 0.33 × 200 + 0.67 × 600 = €450/m2. Building demolition costs are based on the local government support The cost of demolishing disused buildings is measure, the purpose of which is to demolish residential buildings and around €50/m2. non-residential buildings that have fallen out of use. The cost of demolition has ranged from €10 to €140/m2 (VAT included). The cost of demolition per square metre of the net area is higher in the case of small buildings (under 100 m2). The average demolition cost is €43/m2. The strategy considers €50/m2 as the cost of demolition. 31 In the energy performance calculation methodology, cooling systems are process energy, which is not taken into account in the building’s energy performance, but those used in commerce are large energy-intensive systems. 52 160 140 120 Lammutamise maksumus, €/m2 100 80 60 40 20 0 Lammutamise maksumused esitatuna maksumuse järjekorras Figure 33. The cost of demolishing disused buildings per square metre of net area. Lammutamise maksumus, €/m2 Cost of demolition, €/m2 Lammutamise maksumused esitatuna Costs of demolition in the order of cost maksumuse järjekorras 6.7 Energy savings achieved by renovation Full renovation of buildings can lead to heat energy savings of around 50% on average. Renovation may increase electricity use in buildings that did not previously have mechanical ventilation systems (private houses, apartment buildings and educational buildings), because the building services systems required for climate control consume electricity. Renovation reduces the use of electricity in office buildings and commercial and service buildings where electricity accounted for the majority of energy consumption also before renovation. The use of primary energy is reduced by 32% on average. The values of heating, electricity and weighted specific energy use (the so-called WSEU label that is based on measured consumption data) are presented in the table below. The values are given for two heat sources: efficient district heating (weighting factor 0.65) and natural gas (weighting factor 1.0). The electricity weighting factor is 2.0. Private houses differ from other building types, as in this case, stove heating is considered in the pre-renovation stage (the weighting factor of woodfuels is 0.65) and a geothermal heat pump in the post- renovation stage. As the electricity consumption increases significantly, the total reduction of primary energy consumption is considerably lower than in the case of other building types. Table 20. Changes in energy use. Before renovation, kWh/(m2y) After renovation, kWh/(m2y) Reduction, % 53 Efficient Heating Electricity WSEU Heating Electricity WSEU Heating Electricity WSEU district heating Private 190 25 174 0 65 130 100% -160% 25% house* Apartment 170 35 181 70 38 122 59% -9% 33% building Office 130 70 225 70 45 136 46% 36% 40% Commerce 80 140 332 55 85 206 31% 39% 38% Education 140 30 151 55 40 116 61% -33% 23% Natural gas Before renovation, kWh/(m2y) After renovation, kWh/(m2y) Reduction, % Heating Electricity WSEU Heating Electricity WSEU Heating Electricity WSEU Private 190 25 174 0 65 130 100% -160% 25% house* Apartment 170 35 240 70 38 146 59% -9% 39% building Office 130 70 270 70 45 160 46% 36% 41% Commerce 80 140 360 55 85 225 31% 39% 38% Education 140 30 200 55 40 135 61% -33% 33% *transition from a stove to a heat pump is taken into account in the case of private houses A final energy consumption reduction of up to 6.9 TWh (59%) could be The final energy consumption reduction possible if the buildings covered with the strategy were fully renovated. potential is around 60%. Heating consumption can be lowered up to 6.4 TWh (70%) and electricity consumption up to 0.5 TWh (20%). The use of electricity changes considerably less compared to heating because buildings that previously lacked compliant climate control must be fitted with appropriate building services systems, which results in a slight increase in electricity consumption. In addition to renovation, the final energy consumption of buildings addressed in the strategy reduces on the account of buildings falling into disuse. As at 2020, the total area of buildings in use is 76 M square metres. The total area of buildings that are not fully renovated is 70 M square metres. Considering the forecasted abandonment (around 20% of the area), 54 M square metres will need renovation by 2050. Table 21. Change in final energy consumption. Final Final consumption 2020 Final consumption 2050 Reduction, % consumption TWh/y TWh/y Heating Electricity TOTAL Heating Electricity TOTAL Heating Electricity TOTAL Private house* 2.9 0.4 3.2 0.5 0.6 1.1 82% -49% 67% Apartment 3.1 0.6 3.8 1.0 0.5 1.6 68% 15% 59% building Office 0.4 0.2 0.7 0.2 0.1 0.3 58% 49% 55% Commerce 0.3 0.4 0.7 0.1 0.2 0.4 45% 51% 49% Education 0.4 0.1 0.5 0.1 0.1 0.2 66% -15% 52% Other 1.9 0.9 2.8 0.7 0.6 1.3 64% 34% 55% buildings 9.0 2.7 11.7 2.7 2.1 4.8 70% 20% 59% *in the case of private houses it is considered that 50% of private houses will install a heat pump and 50% a boiler as a heat source In 2020, the total CO2 emissions of the buildings addressed in the The CO2 emission reduction potential is strategy are 4.4 M t CO2/y. Considering the renovation volumes around 90%. proposed in the strategy and the estimated reduction of the specific emissions of CO2 from the electricity and district heating until 2050, the 54 CO2 emissions reduction potential of renovation of existing buildings is around 3.9 M t CO2/y, which forms 89% of current CO2 emissions. The 2020 specific emission factors of energy carriers are based on the study “Energiakandjate kaalumistegurid” [Weighting Factors for Energy Carriers]32. Electricity has a specific emission factor of 1.15 t CO2/MWh and heating 0.15 t2/MWh. The specific emission factors for the period 2020-2050 are based on the study “Eesti kliimaambitsiooni tõstmise võimaluste analüüs” [Reaching Climate Neutrality in Estonia]33. The average specific emission factors for the period 2020-2030 are 0.83 t CO2/MWh for electricity and 0.12 t CO2/MWh for heating. The average specific emission factors for the period 2030-2040 are 0.31 t CO2/MWh for electricity and 0.09 t CO2/MWh for heating. The average specific emission factors for the period 2040-2050 are 0.16 t CO2/MWh for electricity and 0.05 t CO2/MWh for heating. Table 22. Changes in CO2 emissions. CO2 emissions CO2 emissions in 2020, t/y CO2 emissions in 2050, t/y Reduction, % Heating Electricity TOTAL Heating Electricit TOTAL Heatin Electricit TOTA y g y L Private house* 429,000 432,000 860,000 25,000 90,000 120,00 94% 79% 86% 0 Apartment 467,000 737,000 1,200,00 50,000 88,000 140,00 89% 88% 88% building 0 0 Office 66,000 270,000 340,000 9,000 19,000 30,000 86% 93% 91% Commerce 38,000 515,000 550,000 7,000 35,000 40,000 82% 93% 93% Education 62,000 102,000 160,000 7,000 16,000 20,000 89% 84% 88% Other 288,000 1,030,00 1,320,00 34,000 94,000 130,00 88% 91% 90% buildings 0 0 0 1,350,00 3,086,00 4,430,00 132,00 342,000 480,00 90% 89% 89% 0 0 0 0 0 *in the case of private houses it is considered that 50% of private houses will install a heat pump and 50% a boiler as a heat source The analysis of final energy consumption and CO2 emission reduction of the buildings does not include buildings erected after 2000 and new buildings erected between 2020-2050. 6.8 Conclusions on renovation activity to date Current renovation activities have not been sufficient for renovating the existing buildings by 2050. If current trends continue, 80% of private houses, 68% of apartment buildings and 60% of non-residential buildings will remain unrenovated by 2050. Of the buildings addressed in the strategy, only the buildings owned by the central government will be renovated in the volume required per year, the total area of which forms a very small share (~1.5%) of all of the buildings that need renovation. Renovation of private houses mainly depends on the owner’s wish to commence renovation work and their capacity to make investments. Many 32 Tallinn University of Technology. Energiakandjate kaalumistegurid [Weighting Factors for Energy Carriers]. 2017 33 SEI Tallinn. Eesti kliimaambitsiooni tõstmise võimaluste analüüs [Reaching Climate Neutrality in Estonia]. 2019. https://www.sei.org/publications/eesti-kliimaambitsiooni-tostmise-voimaluste-analuus/ 55 private house owners do not have the financial capacity to undertake a full renovation all at once. The cost of a full renovation of a medium-sized private house (~160 m2) is around €60,000. Incomes do not allow many owners of private houses to make larger investments at once and renovation is conducted step by step. Apartment buildings have been renovated in full in Estonia for already 10 years. The financing system, the technical solutions and apartment associations’ desire to renovate are there. The main bottlenecks to date have been the unstable financing of support measures and uneven regional distribution of aid. Apartment buildings located outside centres require more support in terms of both financing and advice. 50% support is not always sufficient in regions with low-value real estate as banks may not grant apartment associations loans in the amount required for a full renovation. Energy costs are low compared to the cost of renovation, which affects the cost-efficiency of renovation. Even with a 40% support the total expenses of apartment owners (energy, renovation loan and maintenance) increase around 20% after renovation. The owner’s initiative is paramount when renovating residential buildings. A survey by Statistics Estonia34 on the energy consumption of households highlighted that 38.1% of the surveyed households have not improved the heat retention of their homes. Around a half (46.4%) reported lack of money as the reason. 17.1% considered the existing heating sufficient and 14.6% lived in recently built buildings, which did not require insulation. 58% of households that had not improved heat retention were not planning to insulate their homes in the future. Central-government buildings are subject to the obligation to renovate 3% of the floor area per year according to the energy efficiency directive. Estonia has fulfilled this obligation. As a bottleneck, the summary report on state real estate management highlighted that making central-government buildings comply with the minimum energy performance requirements for buildings has not previously been a planned or managed activity, as there is no long-term investment plan. Local governments renovate using both support and their own funds, but the volume of renovation with own funds and the specific link between renovation with both own funds and support and energy savings cannot be assessed on the basis of data available. The State Audit Office report35 that analysed the condition of buildings owned by local governments highlighted insufficient volume of aid allocated for renovation and the fragmentation of support as the main deficiencies of support measures designed for local government buildings. A third of buildings that received support are still in poor condition, as small aid amounts allowed buildings to be renovated only partially. 34 Statistics Estonia. Leibkondade energiatarbimise uuring [Household Energy Consumption Survey]. 2012 35 State Audit Office. Problems related to the use of European Union and other infrastructure support in local governments. 2017 56 Interviews conducted with owners of private sector non-residential buildings show that the current functioning logic of the commercial property market is not conducive to carrying out full renovations. The tenant covers the building management expenses and energy costs form a small share of the total expenses. Conscious tenants are more interested in good interior climate than the building’s energy performance. Renovation work is mainly initiated due to a change in the building’s use, change of ownership, change of tenant and other activities rather than high energy costs. Energy costs are generally covered by the tenant. Thus, the owner of the real estate does not have a direct motivation to improve energy performance. People are not yet interested in or are unable to look at the indirect benefit and the bigger picture. At the same time, commercial property owners are aware that buildings are aging and property owners are forced to upgrade their buildings in order to stay on the market. The volume of renovation is the main question upon planning work. Larger projects with a payback period of over 20 years are not attractive to owners. Owners of commercial real estate expect the payback period of the investment to be less than 10 years. Owners of private sector non-residential properties highlighted constant changes to energy performance regulations as another major problem. Requirements that are amended every five years and changes in calculation methodology (e.g. changes in weighting factors) make preparing a long-term view more difficult. Future energy performance requirements for buildings are unknown. Property owners would like to know the changes to be introduced in building energy performance regulations and implementation time of new requirements at least 10 years in advance. Additionally, changes resulting from energy calculation methodology (e.g. changes in weighting factors) do not affect the building’s actual energy use and energy use-related costs to the property owner. 57 7 Volumes until 7.1 Renovation need 2050 Considering the number of residential buildings currently in use, the volume of renovations completed to date and the estimated residential building abandonment rate, 105,000 private houses with a total area of 14 M m2 and 14,000 apartment buildings with a total area of 18 M m2 should be renovated in full by 2050. A full renovation means a renovation that results in at least energy class C. Table 23. Residential building renovation volume up to 2050. Existing Renovated Falling into disuse In need of renovation Quantity Area, m2 Quantity Area, m2 Quantity Area, m2 Quantity Area, m2 Private houses 155,000 19,998,000 10,000 1,500,000 40,000 4,800,000 105,000 14,000,000 Apartment 22,600 28,378,000 3,000 5,000,000 5,300 5,000,000 14,000 18,000,000 buildings 0.9 M square metres of central-government buildings and 4 M square metres of local government buildings in the non-residential sector and 17 M square metres of buildings in the private sector need renovation. The total area of residential buildings that need renovation is 22 M square metres. According to the central-government building energy performance inventory36, as at 2017, 812,000 m2 needed to be brought in line with the minimum energy performance requirements. In the strategy, the area of central-government buildings is somewhat larger than what is reported in the energy performance inventory because the strategy includes buildings that are not covered by the inventory (e.g. the buildings of the State Forest Management Centre that are entered in the State Real Estate Registry). The difference between the total area of buildings in need of renovation and the areas provided in the central government building energy performance inventory and the strategy is 6%, which does not significantly affect the required annual renovation volume of central-government buildings. Table 24. Renovation need of non-residential buildings until 2050. Central Local government Private sector Total government Area, m2 Area, m2 Area, m2 Area, m2 OFFICE 271,000 279,000 2,760,000 3,310,000 ACCOMMODATION 74,000 207,000 520,000 801,000 COMMERCE AND 69,000 712,000 2,440,000 3,221,000 SERVICES 36 Ministry of Finance. Energiatõhususe inventuuri aruanne [Energy Performance Inventory Report]. 2017 https://www.rahandusministeerium.ee/et/eesmargidtegevused/riigi-kinnisvararegister/portfelli- ulevaade/energiatohususe-inventuur 58 EDUCATION, RESEARCH 243,000 2,212,000 690,000 3,145,000 HEALTHCARE 12,000 205,000 590,000 807,000 WAREHOUSES 19,000 3,060,000 3,079,000 INDUSTRY 7,000 6,880,000 6,887,000 SPECIAL-PURPOSE 164,000 150,000 314,000 BUILDINGS OTHER 427,000 0 427,000 860,000 4,000,000 17,100,000 22,000,000 Taking into account all private houses (14 M square metres), apartment buildings (18 M square metres) and non-residential buildings (22 M square metres), a total of 54 M square metres of buildings are in need of renovation by 2050. A full renovation can immediately be undertaken in building sectors that already have functioning full renovation processes: central-government buildings, local government buildings and apartment buildings. Building sectors, where the full renovation market is still waiting to be built, such as private sector non- residential buildings and private houses, will likely taken up at a later time. The creation of processes required for full renovation of these buildings should also commence immediately, but since the implementation of solutions and processes takes time, the majority of the renovation activity is estimated to take place between 2035-2045. Üksikelamud Korterelamud Erasektori mitteeluhooned KOV hooned Keskvalitsuse hooned 1 000 000 AASTAS TERVIKLIKULT REKONSTRUEERITAV PINDALA, M 2 900 000 800 000 700 000 600 000 500 000 400 000 300 000 200 000 100 000 0 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 Figure 34. Renovation need by building sectors. Üksikelamud Private houses Korterelamud Apartment buildings Erasektori mitteeluhooned Private sector non-residential buildings KOV hooned Local government buildings Keskvalitsuse hooned Central-government buildings Aastas terviklikult rekonstrueeritav pindala, m2 Fully renovated area per year, m2 When looking at the total annual volumes of different building sectors, the area of buildings that should be fully renovated between 2035-2040 is ~2.3 M square metres, which constitutes around a fivefold increase compared to the current volumes. 59 Keskvalitsuse hooned KOV hooned Üksikelamud Korterelamud Erasektori mitteeluhooned 2 500 000 AASTAS TERVIKLIKULT REKONSTRUEERITAV PINDALA, M 2 2 000 000 1 500 000 1 000 000 500 000 0 2 020 2 025 2 030 2 035 2 040 2 045 2 050 Figure 35. Cumulative annual renovation needs. Keskvalitsuse hooned Central-government buildings KOV hooned Local government buildings Üksikelamud Private houses Korterelamud Apartment buildings Erasektori mitteeluhooned Private sector non-residential buildings Aastas terviklikult rekonstrueeritav pindala, m2 Fully renovated area per year, m2 Upon distributing renovation volumes, the average annual volumes of renovations completed to date are regarded as the situation as at 2020. Upon preparing calculations, the full programme is considered, i.e. all of the existing buildings are renovated by 2050. 22% of the area of unrenovated buildings would be renovated by 2030, 64% by 2040 and 100% by 2050. In practice, it can be assumed that around 20% of privately owned buildings (private houses, apartment buildings, private sector non-residential buildings) will remain unrenovated, because the owners do not wish to renovate their buildings. Table 25. Renovation volumes proposed by the strategy until 2050, by floor area. Area to be renovated, m2 2021-2025 2026-2030 2031-2035 2036-2040 2041-2045 2046-2050 TOTAL Private houses 400,000 950,000 1,900,000 3,100,000 3,900,000 3,800,000 14,000,000 Apartment buildings 2,280,000 3,200,000 4,000,000 3,900,000 3,000,000 1,800,000 18,000,000 Private-sector non- 840,000 1,800,000 3,200,000 4,200,000 4,100,000 2,900,000 17,000,000 residential buildings Local government 680,000 1,400,000 1,300,000 480,000 70,000 0 4,000,000 buildings Central-government 200,000 240,000 230,000 150,000 70,000 20,000 900,000 buildings 4,400,000 7,600,000 10,600,000 11,800,000 11,100,000 8,500,000 53,900,000 7.2 Financing needs The renovation costs of the buildings is calculated using the 2019 costs The full renovation of all of full renovation and the annually renovated areas provided in the buildings costs around €22 previous chapter. The renovation cost of public sector buildings takes B. 60 into account the cost of renovation work related to energy savings of €600/m2. Renovation of public sector buildings is often initiated on grounds other than energy saving and the average cost of full renovation of the buildings is around €1,100/m2. As the aim of the strategy is to attain the climate goals, only the cost of the work to achieve energy savings is taken into account when calculating the costs. In the case of the cost of renovating private sector non-residential buildings, it is considered that the cost is €600/m2 even in the case of buildings whose building envelopes also need upgrading (approximately 2/3 of the buildings). The cost of renovation of buildings where upgrading building services systems will suffice is around €200/m2 (approximately 1/3 of the buildings). The average renovation cost of private sector non-residential buildings calculated in the strategy is 0.33 × 200 + 0.67 × 600 = €450/m2. The annual renovation funding need will increase 4 to 5 times from the current around 200 M euros per year to around 900 M euros per year. On the basis of the cost of 2019 renovations, the total cost of the full renovation of buildings in need of renovation would be around €22 B. The average cost of the full renovation of all buildings is around €400/m2 (€24 B / €54 M square metres). In the coming years, the measures of the long-term renovation strategy will be implemented using the state’s tax revenue, the funds of the European Union budget framework for 2014-2020 (above all, the funds of the European Regional Development Fund, the Cohesion Fund and, to a smaller extent, Horizon 2020) and the auctioning revenue from the European Union scheme for greenhouse gas emission allowance trading (in accordance with the objectives listed in Article 10 (3) of directive 2003/87/EC117, subsection 161 (4) of the Atmospheric Air Protection Act and the state’s budgetary strategy). A more specific distribution of measures, the schedule and state budget funds allocated for execution thereof are, among other things, decided upon preparing the state mid-term budgetary strategy. Considering the high importance of the renovation wave in the documents of the European Green Deal and the European Union Recovery Plan, it would be reasonable to ensure respective Union financial instruments for Member States. Table 26. Costs of the renovations proposed by the strategy until 2050. Renovation cost, €M Cost, €/m2 2021-25 2026-30 2031-35 2036-40 2041-45 2046-50 TOTAL Private houses 400 161 381 776 1,236 1,541 1,504 5,600 Apartment buildings 300 683 953 1,189 1,160 886 530 5,400 Private-sector non- 450 379 811 1,437 1,884 1,828 1,312 7,650 residential buildings Local government 600 409 869 792 287 41 2 2,400 buildings Central-government 600 119 142 136 90 41 13 540 buildings 1,749 3,156 4,330 4,657 4,337 3,361 21,590 61 1 000 900 927 REKONSTRUEERIMISE AASTANE MAKSUMUS, MLN € 915 800 808 754 700 600 572 500 400 431 300 200 187 100 0 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 Figure 36. Annual financing needs for the full renovation of the buildings. Rekonstrueerimise aastane maksumus, mln € Annual cost of renovation, M € The support rates of the current support measure are considered as possible support for full renovation. For renovating with the help of support, the annual need for support would be up to €400 M based on the 2019 costs. The more specific forecast covers the period until 2030. The financial needs for the support for subsequent periods are to be specified later, as the nature and implementation of measures change over time – at first, the proportion of support will likely be higher in order to get the renovation process going, while later implementation will focus on loans and other measures that are more suitable for the market logic and have a smaller effect on the state budget. The financial needs for the support will be specified during the merging of the Estonian National Energy and Climate Plan and the building renovation strategy and the subsequent regular updating thereof. The final decisions on financing the support required for implementing the strategy are made during the state budgetary strategy preparation process. Table 27. Support needs until 2030. Renovation support, €M Support, % 2020-2025 2026-2030 Private houses 30 48 114 Apartment buildings 40 273 381 Private-sector non- 40 152 324 residential buildings Local government buildings 50 204 435 Central-government 100* 119 142 buildings 796 1,396 * This is not the usual financial support as the central government is the owner of the buildings. 62 400 373 350 354 329 300 295 TOETUS AASTAS, MLN € 250 200 195 202 150 100 87 50 0 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 Figure 37. Annual financial support for the full renovation of the buildings. Toetus aastas, mln € Annual support, M € 63 8.1 Volume of new residential building construction 8 New The construction of new residential buildings shows an upward trend. buildings In the last five years, building permits have been issued for 1,600 and use permits for 1,200 private houses per year on average. The annual On average, 1,200 new average net area of new private houses with use permits is 200,000 m2, private houses are taken which forms 1% of the area of private houses taken into use before into use per year. 2000. Ehitusload Kasutusload 2 500 2 000 1 908 1 745 1 606 1 500 1 436 1 386 1 329 1 277 1 228 1 168 1 068 950 960 1 000 766 808 788 632 500 0 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Figure 38. Building and use permits of new private houses. Ehitusload Building permits Kasutusload Use permits 53% of new private houses taken into use are located in Harju County, New private houses are built all across Estonia. but new private houses that have been authorised for use can be found in every county. 64 Figure 39. Distribution of private houses that have been granted use permits as of 2011 by counties (based on the 2019 administrative division). Hiiumaa Hiiu County Saaremaa Saare County Läänemaa Lääne County Harjumaa Harju County Lääne-Virumaa Lääne-Viru County Ida-Virumaa Ida-Viru County Raplamaa Rapla County Järvamaa Järva County Jõgevamaa Jõgeva County Pärnumaa Pärnu County Viljandimaa Viljandi County Tartumaa Tartu County Valgamaa Valga County Põlvamaa Põlva County Võrumaa Võru County In the last five years, building permits have been issued for 180 and use An average of 125 new apartment buildings are permits for 125 apartment buildings per year on average. The annual taken into use annually. average net area of new apartment buildings with use permits is 1.2 m2, which forms 0.4% of the area of apartment buildings taken into use before 2000. 65 Ehitusload Kasutusload 250 201 200 185 172 163 153 150 125 121 102 96 100 89 75 88 63 65 52 50 42 0 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Figure 40. Building and use permits of new apartment buildings. Ehitusload Building permits Kasutusload Use permits New apartment buildings are mainly built in three regions: Harju, Tartu New apartment buildings are mainly built in Harju and Pärnu Counties. 70% of new apartment buildings taken into use are County and Tartu County. located in Harju County (52% in Tallinn) and 23% in Tartu County. Six counties have not taken into use any new apartment buildings in the last nine years. Figure 41. Distribution of apartment buildings that have been granted use permits as of 2011 by counties (based on the 2019 administrative division). Hiiumaa Hiiu County Saaremaa Saare County 66 Läänemaa Lääne County Harjumaa Harju County Lääne-Virumaa Lääne-Viru County Ida-Virumaa Ida-Viru County Raplamaa Rapla County Järvamaa Järva County Jõgevamaa Jõgeva County Pärnumaa Pärnu County Viljandimaa Viljandi County Tartumaa Tartu County Valgamaa Valga County Põlvamaa Põlva County Võrumaa Võru County 9 Impact of 9.1 Share of renovation in construction sector renovation According to Statistics Estonia, in 2018, Estonian construction companies performed construction work in Estonia and foreign countries in the total amount of €3 B, of which buildings accounted for €1.9 B and civil engineering works €1.1 B. The financial volumes of construction work have increased significantly over the recent years, but the number of workers employed by the sector has remained at around 60,000. Temporary workers from other countries used in the construction sector are not fully reflected in the official statistics. In addition to temporary workers, an increase in productivity can also be expected on the account of achievement of economies of scale from larger projects. Hõivatute arv (töötajat) Ehitustegevus, mld € 70 000 3,5 60 000 3,0 50 000 2,5 Ehitustegevus, miljard € Hõivatute arv 40 000 2,0 30 000 1,5 20 000 1,0 10 000 0,5 0 0,0 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Figure 42. Construction activity and number of workers employed in the construction sector. Hõivatute arv (töötajat) Number of employed (workers) Ehitustegevus, mld € Construction activity, B € Hõivatute arv Number of employed Ehitustegevus, miljard € Construction activity, B € 67 Construction activity develops inertly in the general economic environment, i.e. people build more if the economy is generally doing well and less when it is not. Considering that construction hit the lowest point in 2010 and peaked in 2019, the 2015 building construction volume of €1.3 B could be regarded as the average. Full renovations account for approximately €200 M of this. Provided that 17 jobs are created for every €1 M investment37, the number of workers employed in full renovation is around 3,400. Full renovation of all unrenovated buildings would require an investment of up to a billion euros per year, which in turn requires around 17,000 workers to be employed in full renovation. Workers added to those engaged in full renovation do not constitute all of the extra workers needed in the construction sector. Workers who have been engaged in constructing new buildings would be redistributed in the sector to renovate buildings. The prioritisation of renovation must therefore also be taken into account in construction decisions. The purpose of the gradual increase of the renovation volumes presented in the strategy is to shape the market without overheating it, incl. by avoiding a disproportionate increase of construction prices. The need for workers can be covered by an increase in productivity arising from the adoption of new technologies. 9.2 Impact of building renovation Renovation of buildings is a regional and social measure that has a long- term effect on shaping the living environment. In addition to a direct reduction of energy consumption, other important factors must be taken into account when renovating buildings. Energy poverty is not currently a widespread problem in Estonia. According to the European Energy Poverty Observatory data38, 2.9% of households reported problems with heating their homes and 6.3% of households had energy bill debts. When planning full renovation of existing buildings, it must be remembered that some households are not capable of carrying out renovation. Renovation of a building requires the owner to make a financial contribution even if there are support measures available and households with lower incomes are not able to provide that. Vulnerable households need additional support for participating in energy saving measures. The ways of ensuring accessibility in buildings are currently very different. Users of buildings change and therefore it must be ensured during renovation that the building can be used by all population groups (parents with prams, children, elderly and disabled people). In order to ensure the accessibility of public spaces and buildings to all 37 Pikas, E.; Kurnitski, J.; Liias, R.; Thalfeldt, M. (2015). Quantification of economic benefits of renovation of apartment buildings as a basis for cost optimal 2030 energy efficiency strategies. 38 Bouzarovski, S. & Thomson, H. (2019) Transforming Energy Poverty Policies in the European Union: Second Annual Report of the European Union Energy Poverty Observatory. 68 people and increase accessibility awareness, the Government Office has set up the Accessibility Task Force39. In the case of towns with a shrinking population, there is a need to take into account the population and infrastructure development principles in zoning and for concentrating the town centres. According to a doctoral thesis defended in the Tallinn University of Technology in 201940, shrinking local governments should above all focus on the quality of life of their residents and attractiveness of urban space is important for achieving this goal. In urban areas where the population is getting older or smaller, it is therefore important to not only demolish underused buildings but also to ensure full functionality of the urban space, using demolition as an opportunity to improve the availability of public services and the functions needed for the functioning of urban areas, by gathering these into synergistic spatial ecosystems. Moreover, abandoned and underused buildings affect the lives of people living nearby, as they have a strong negative symbolic value. Therefore, in shrinking towns, buildings should above all be renovated in the town centre (defined with zoning) and sustainable residential areas planned in the zoning. Renovation of buildings plays an important role in designing good public spaces. By approaching each building individually without considering the whole picture, renovated buildings located in the same area will end up looking like an architectural patchwork. Therefore, in order to ensure a regional architectural whole and develop a good public space, it is necessary to follow the basic principles for high- quality space41, zoning plans of local governments and architectural guidelines for renovating buildings in different regions. Broader use of local renewable energy along with renovation of buildings. The best technical solution for densely populated areas is the installation of solar panels for producing electricity. The electricity consumption of buildings previously without ventilation systems that are fitted with mechanical heat recovery ventilation systems will increase as a result of the renovation. The increase in electricity consumption due to ventilation systems can be set off by producing electricity locally using solar panels. The CO2 emissions of private houses where stove heating is replaced with a heat pump will also increase as a result of the renovation, because previously emission-free woodfuel is replaced by specific emission-intensive electricity. The increase in electricity use can be set off by installing solar panels. Renovation allows buildings to be brought in line with contemporary safety requirements in order to ensure safety of buildings. The post- design life cycle of a majority of buildings has either ended or coming 39 Accessibility Task Force https://www.riigikantselei.ee/et/ligipaasetavuse-rakkeruhm 40 Jiří Tintěra, 2019. Urban Regeneration Strategies for Shrinking Post-Soviet European Communities: A Case Study of Valga, Estonia. 41 Kvaliteetse ruumi aluspõhimõtted [Basic principles for high-quality space]: https://www.kul.ee/sites/kulminn/files/lisa_3_-_kvaliteetne_ruum_aluspohimotted.pdf 69 to an end, which has created an immediate need to repair their load- bearing structures (such as balconies and shelters). According to a survey conducted by the Technical Regulatory Authority in 2012 and 201342, 53% of the balconies of the 26 surveyed buildings showed severe structural deficiencies. Only 16% of balconies met all of the requirements. In addition to structures, the electrical systems and water and sanitation piping of buildings require safety upgrades. When renovating buildings, attention must also be paid to the fire safety of the building (fire doors, building services system penetrations, gas equipment safety, shutdown of installed ventilation systems in the event of a fire, etc.). Work required to ensure the safety of the building must be considered eligible in support measures. For instance, installation of fire doors, replacement of indoor air-dependent gas water heaters with a centralised hot water supply system and automation required for ensuring fire safety. In the case of national renovation support measures, areas located outside of the Tallinn region should be prioritised in order to ensure regional balance. If support measures are distributed on similar market conditions, they are concentrated in more capable areas, which exacerbates the uneven development of regions. The Estonian regional economy scenarios prepared by the Foresight Centre43 point out that for the regional economy to function, changes are also required in regional living environments – renovation and upgrading of buildings and availability of high-quality office spaces. In addition to giving an advantage to regions outside the capital in support measures, extra measures, such as state guarantees for home loans and renovation loans outside larger cities and greater inclusion of the local government level in measures supporting renovation of buildings, should be taken. In urban areas where the population is getting older or smaller, it is important to ensure full functionality of the urban space, using renovation and demolition as an opportunity to improve the availability of public services and the functions needed for the functioning of urban areas, by gathering these into synergistic spatial ecosystems where possible. Renovation of buildings also has a considerable impact on the energy sector. The use and import of fossil fuels and sales volumes of district heating companies will diminish. The need to invest in new energy production capacities will reduce. Buildings requiring less energy also allow for harnessing the potential of renewable energy solutions and distributed energy and an increase in energy independence and the security of the energy supply. 42 Technical Regulatory Authority. 1960-1990 ehitatud korterelamute rõdude ja lodžade raudbetoonist eenduvate esipiirdepaneelide uuring [A Study of Reinforced Concrete Front Panels of Balconies and Loggias of Apartment Buildings Built between 1960-1990]. 2013 43 Foresight Centre (2019). Eesti regionaalse majanduse stsenaariumid 2035 [Estonian Regional Economy Scenarios 2035]. https://www.riigikogu.ee/wpcms/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Eesti-regionaalse- majanduse-stsenaariumid-2035.pdf 70 71 10.1 Adoption of new technological solutions 10 Measures In order to increase renovation volume, technological solutions need to be developed. This must be done in terms of both construction work and preparatory work. Provided that the volume of new buildings will remain on the same level, technologies that are currently used make it very difficult to achieve around a fivefold increase in renovation volume. There is not enough labour to cover a rapid increase in volumes. Renovation capacity increases in periods when the volume of new construction temporarily decreases, but the labour challenge will re-emerge once the volume of new construction is restored. Labour shortage also occurs in the preparatory stage of renovation (energy auditors, designers, owner’s consultants, etc.). In addition to solving the labour problem, new technological solutions also allow to speed up processes and reduce the increase in the cost of construction arising from increased demand (see also 7.2 “Financing needs”). For instance, use of prefabrication allows for the achievement of economies of scale when renovating standard buildings and speeds up the renovation process. A quicker process allows more buildings to be renovated with the same amount of labour, and another important positive social impact is that in the case of residential buildings, buildings are not covered with scaffolding and netting for a long period of time. Use of prefabricated external wall and roof elements to insulate the building envelope. Prefabrication could first be used for renovating standard buildings (e.g. apartment buildings). In larger cities, such as Tallinn and Tartu, there are many apartment buildings that were constructed in the Soviet era by residential construction combines on the basis of standard designs. For instance, the Tallinn Residential Construction Combine standard reinforced concrete panel apartment building designs 1-464 (Mustamäe) and 111-121 (Õismäe and Lasnamäe) or Tartu Residential Construction Combine standard design 111-133 (Annelinn and county centres). Standard design 1-317 (so- called Khrushchyovka) built from bricks or concrete panels is also common. Apartment buildings prefabricated on the basis of standard projects could also be renovated using solutions prefabricated on the basis of standard solutions. Use of prefabrication would allow the renovation process to be automated and accelerated and ensure better quality. Digital tools for preparing energy labels and energy audits. Development of virtual tools could be the next step in the digitalisation of the field. Use of virtual tools would help to reduce the time spent on preparing energy labels and energy audits and therefore also the costs. For instance, the tools in the Building Registry which automatically prepare documents or make calculations simpler (calculating the heating costs for a normal year, energy costs per square metre, etc.) would allow not only energy labels but also energy audits to be standardised. The added value would be the possibility to analyse the data of the labels prepared and audits performed. Current energy 72 labels and energy audits are generally presented as documents in PDF format, which are not machine-readable and cannot therefore be easily used for analysis. In the environment, which is part of the Building Registry, audits could be linked to the data of the Building Registry and the energy use data entered in the audit would be automatically usable by the system for analysing the bigger picture of the energy use of buildings. Simplified digital tools for building owners. The most important condition for renovating a building is the owner’s will to renovate. Simpler virtual tools would enable building owners to think through the initial versions themselves without incurring any costs. For example, a tool for private house owners that is based on technical solutions, where the user can enter the parameters of an existing building (wall type, window type, heating system, ventilation system) and choose between different options for improving energy performance (thickness of the external wall and roof insulation, new triple-glazed windows, replacement of the heating system and installation of a ventilation system and solar panels). An energy performance assessment tool that is based on energy costs could be developed for owners of commercial properties. Owners of commercial properties are not generally aware of the building’s energy consumption in units like kWh or kWh/(m2y). The energy costs in euros are known. A building’s energy consumption could be assessed on the basis of energy bills provided by the accountant and the cost of the energy unit. It would also be possible to offer general suggestions for reducing energy costs on the basis of the building’s general technical specification and the main energy cost component (electricity or heating) determined on the basis of energy bills. 10.2 Research and development Research and Development allows the quality to be improved and the processing of data collected about buildings to be automated, the problem of labour shortages to be alleviated, productivity to be increased and the total cost of renovation to be reduced. Development of state registries improves the monitoring of renovation activities. The main bottleneck of preparing the renovation strategy was the lack of data. For instance, the Building Registry should allow data to be processed in order to answer the following questions:  What is the share of full renovations in renovations completed?  Which of the buildings to be renovated are owned by local governments and the central government?  Which of the buildings in the Building Registry are protected under heritage conservation or of cultural or environmental value? 73 Mapping of decision-making processes provides the opportunity to understand why and when property owners decide to start renovation work. Support measures have provided a certain insight of the owner’s perspective in terms of apartment buildings and public sector buildings. The processes of renovating private houses and commercial properties have not yet been thoroughly mapped. It is impossible to successfully guide renovation processes without knowing why and on what conditions property owners decide to start renovation work. Development of strategic spatial planning allows to apply the basic principles for high-quality space44 when renovating buildings. There is a need to develop general architectural guidance materials for renovating different types of buildings and local government guidance materials for renovating buildings in certain regions. Analysis of the broader impact of renovation of buildings . The economic impact of building renovation measures, the impact of global warming on potential energy savings of buildings, the impact of building renovation on the achievement of climate neutrality, the options for broad-based implementation of innovative solutions, the results of pilot projects conducted in other countries and the potential to transfer international practices should be analysed in detail. The impact of global warming requires an analysis in terms of renovation solutions and the longevity of materials used. Solutions can be found to reduce changing climate burdens and risks and avoid a new renovation wave arising from insufficient weatherproofing in the future. New technical expertise that is obtained as a result of development activity must be implemented both internally in the construction sector and on a cross-sectoral basis (property management, insurance, urban planning, etc.), which requires, among other things, training of specialists and guidance materials. Development of technical expertise allows to renovate with sustainable, healthy and real energy savings, which do not come at the expense of the interior climate. Having guidance materials and expertise allows designers and construction workers to know what is expected from them and contractors to develop economical and affordable standard solutions. To date, more than 10 doctoral theses have been defended on the topic of renovation of buildings and the results are well-implemented. Good results have already been achieved in the case of apartment buildings and public sector buildings. The situation of private houses is the most complicated because the structures of older buildings may pose difficulties due to moisture and mould, but there is essentially no technical literature on renovation of small residential buildings. Renovation of commercial properties has also mostly involved individual energy saving works, which is why there is a lack of general experience of full renovation. The practice of improving the energy 44 Kvaliteetse ruumi aluspõhimõtted [Basic principles for high-quality space]: https://www.kul.ee/sites/kulminn/files/lisa_3_-_kvaliteetne_ruum_aluspohimotted.pdf 74 performance of buildings that have cultural or environmental value or are acknowledged as architectural monuments also requires the development of expertise because the requirements for renovating valuable buildings are more detailed and achieving energy class C is not often possible or even reasonable. Increasing renovation volume creates a new challenge on the market in the form of labour shortage. This creates a need for development work that would allow more renovation using the existing workforce, i.e. to improve productivity. Currently, the only known way to significantly improve productivity is to transfer as much of the on-site work as possible to factories and start renovating using pre-fabricated components which are assembled on site. The following research, development and innovation activities are required to increase technical expertise:  Development of technical solutions and guidance materials for renovating small residential buildings. Taking into account the market situation, both renovation by individual work and full renovation must be enabled because both are conducted depending on the situation and needs of families.  Cost-effective solutions for significant renovation of commercial properties. Currently, office or commercial buildings are not generally renovated to correspond to energy class C. There is a need to monitor the energy use of existing buildings and develop and test solutions that ensure real energy savings with a reasonable investment.  Renovation using prefabricated components. In order to alleviate the labour shortage resulting from an increase in renovation volumes, there is a need to increase productivity and, in the long term, cost-efficiency. Industrial production in its simplest form is made possible by lightweight external wall and roof elements, which include the necessary building services system piping. Such solutions currently exist on larger markets where labour is more expensive.  Reduction of CO2 emissions achieved by the measures of the strategy and comparative analysis of measures in terms of emission reduction efficiency, i.e. marginal cost. The current analyses have been based on final energy consumption and the energy performance indicator (primary energy), but in the future, there is a need to determine the exact impact on emissions in the context of climate neutrality. 10.3 Awareness raising In order to boost renovation of private houses, guidance materials on renovation aimed at owners of private houses must be developed. There are currently no comprehensive Estonian handbooks on renovating private houses. Guidance materials should be freely 75 available on the internet. The same internet address should also include information on possible support measures and web-based energy performance calculators aimed at owners of private houses. Renovation of apartment buildings requires working with apartment associations that have not participated in existing renovation measures. According to apartment building support statistics, support is mainly applied for buildings with 30-40 apartments that are mostly located in centres. Smaller apartment buildings and those located outside of centres must also be included in the planning of further renovation measures. Apartment buildings that do not have a functioning apartment association also require attention in terms of raising awareness. Apartment associations were created automatically for apartment buildings that did not have an apartment association as at 1 January 2018. The estimated number of automatically created apartment associations is around 10,000. Supporting the performance of energy audits would help to raise awareness among owners of private sector commercial properties. The purpose of this is to increase the awareness of commercial property owners of the energy consumption of buildings under their management and the possible energy savings and related benefits. A detailed energy audit would provide the property owner an overview of the possibilities of reducing energy costs, the work schedule, the costs and later changes in energy costs. Support could be applied for energy audits that have been used to carry out energy saving work. As an added value of the measure, a dataset on the energy use of non- residential buildings, the measures applied and the cost of measures would be created. Publishing of the dataset (in a format that does not allow specific buildings to be identified) would give owners and tenants the opportunity to compare the energy performance of their building with that of other buildings. The audit must include the cost and feasibility of the measures, i.e. feasibility by stages. Additionally, the audit must specify the measures for later surveillance, monitoring and certification. If there is a wish to use the audit as a source document for investment support, economic calculations that take into account the partially related costs associated with renovation work must also be made together with the audit. 10.4 Demolition of buildings falling out of use According to forecasts, up to around 5,000 apartment buildings and up to 10,000 non-residential buildings will fall into disuse by 2050. Demolition of disused buildings is mainly impeded by the resolution of ownership issues. In the case of apartment buildings, it is also hindered by the last residents of half-empty buildings moving to renovated buildings. In urban areas where the population is getting older or smaller, it is important to not only demolish underused buildings but also to ensure full functionality of the urban space. As a result, demolition can be used as an opportunity to centralise public services 76 and functions required for the functioning of urban areas and improve their availability. 10.5 Financing measures Financing measures include loans, guarantees and support. In order to facilitate renovation of private houses, it is important to address the market failure resulting from low property value. To finance renovation with a loan in regions where property values are lower, it must be possible to use state guarantees that are valid until the state loan agreement maturity date, which would allow banks to issue loans independent of the value of the collateral and against a state guarantee. In order to increase the private house renovation activity, the support measure for private houses must be continued in order to address the market failure due to low financing capacity and target technical solutions used in renovation. The support rates of the support measure should be differentiated in accordance with the comprehensiveness of the planned renovation. A greater support rate for full renovation and a smaller support rate for individual works. The focus of apartment building renovation must differ by region. Full renovation must above all be targeted at the centres of functional regions and second-tier centres. The measures for apartment buildings that are located in the immediate hinterland of cities and the periphery would depend on the capacity of apartment associations. Loans and support are either used for more comprehensive renovation of building envelopes and building services systems or renovation by individual works. In the case of apartment buildings that are in a more complicated situation (very low property value, partially emptied, the apartment association’s capability to conduct renovation processes is very low), it should be able to renovate by individual work with the purpose of ensuring safe use (e.g. replacement of the old electrical or heating system) or preservation (e.g. replacement of a leaking roof) of buildings. Apartment associations that are located outside of centres may require a state-funded loan measure for carrying out renovation work. Loans would be available to apartment associations to whom commercial banks are not ready to grant renovation loans in the required amount. One possibility to facilitate renovation of private sector commercial properties is renovation support that is based on the CO2 emissions arising from the building’s energy use. The support is based on the energy savings achieved as a result of renovation and the related CO2 emission reduction. Upon supporting investments it is also considered that the CO2 equivalent of coolants used in the equipment to be installed (refrigerators, heat pumps) is as small as possible. The support amount can be up to 50% of the total investment. The principle of the measure is that the reduction of CO2 emissions resulting from the investment should be as big as possible. The more efficient the 77 measures, the larger the support. Support for achieving a 30% reduction of CO2 emissions is smaller than the support for achieving a 50% reduction of CO2 emissions. Support, loans or guarantees are applied on the basis of the energy audit of the building, which includes the following information:  the list of measures required to reduce the energy cost together with a detailed description of application thereof;  a financial plan that takes into account all potential related costs;  changes in the building’s energy costs by measures and later total energy cost;  CO2 emissions reduced;  a plan for monitoring changes in energy use and the method of proof. The payback period of the whole investment for property owners must be less than 30 years (life cycle of building services systems), but a large part of the market considers renovation only if the payback period is less than 10 years. In addition to the payback period, the size of the building must be taken into account. In the case of the current measure, the proportion of the support (e.g. 30%, 40% or 50%) would not only depend on the amount of reduced CO2 emissions, but also the size of the building. The smaller the building, the more expensive its renovation per square metre. Energy saving work should be carried out in full and a part of the support (e.g. 15%) paid out after a one-year monitoring period, when it is proved that the established energy saving goal was achieved. The example of the calculation of a CO2 emission reduction-based support measure is provided in Annex 11.1. The support measures for renovation of public sector buildings are not built on a certain proportion of support, but on supporting energy saving work performed during renovation. The analysis of budgets of fully renovated public sector buildings showed that around 50% of the renovation cost is related to energy saving work. The rest of the work is related to changing the functionality, spatial planning and interior finishing of the building, etc. Processes for renovating public sector buildings have been established. Provided that there is funding, the renovation volume of public sector buildings can be quickly increased by completing a prior analysis of its broader effects, incl. market capability, impact on the materials industry, jobs, etc. In the case of a rapid increase in the renovation volume of local government buildings, the process may be hindered by the local government’s creditworthiness. Less capable local governments are allowed to take a loan of up to 60% of the costs of the main activity. More capable local governments are allowed to take a loan of up to 100% of the costs of the main activity. According to the 78 Ministry of Finance, in 2018, the average net debt burden of local governments was 28%45. Thus, upon the existence of support measures, many local governments would have the financial capacity to increase the volume of full renovation of local government buildings. 10.6 Creating additional services for residential building investments One possible measure is making investments via the KredEx Foundation, so as to involve private partners as financers while minimising the burden on the state budget. To this end, there is a need to create capacity in the form of services that follow market-based rules, the main purpose of which is to facilitate renovation of apartment buildings, increase the number of rental houses and reduce the fluctuation of construction market volumes in time (counter- cyclical measure). According to one possible scenario, for all the needs pointed out in this strategy to be covered, the following estimated prerequisites should be met:  The annual financing needs will be around €220 M in the first years. The state should cover around one-tenth of the amount.  The total financing need until 2050 for renovating apartment buildings and constructing new buildings would be 7.9 billion euros. The financing needs may change depending on the adoption of new technologies, the market’s adjustment to increased renovation volumes, etc.  The state will get back around 30% of the construction costs as taxes, i.e. the related tax revenue would be 70-170 M euros a year. In the case of apartment building renovation, these services could be used to offer loans, guarantees and counselling services in combination with existing measures applied by KredEx Foundation. Guarantees and guarantees in combination with long-term loans could be offered as financial measures. Upon applying a 3% interest rate, the annual loan payment would reduce by about a quarter in the case of annuity payments if the term of the loan is extended from 20 years to 30 years. Thus, a longer loan term would be comparable to offering financial support, even though it would not reduce the total cost (interest payments would ultimately be even larger). All of the required preparatory work – mapping of the apartment association’s wishes, offering solutions and organising the designing and construction process – can also be treated as a support measure. The organisational side is a significant obstacle to getting started with renovation. 45 Ministry of Finance. 2019. https://blogi.fin.ee/2019/07/kohalike-omavalitsuste-finantstervis-on-hea/ 79 All of the required preparatory work made by the buildings – mapping of the apartment association’s wishes, offering and promoting solutions (together with the estimated savings) and organising the designing and construction process – can also be treated as a support measure. The organisational side is a significant obstacle to getting started with renovation. The KredEx Foundation as an external party and renowned competence provider with references could reach an agreement with apartment association members more quickly upon explaining the need for renovation work and possible solutions. Construction of rental buildings in areas where new apartment buildings are not built on market terms. Considering the increasing mobility of people and changes in needs throughout the life cycle, renting allows for a greater flexibility in choices. Increasing the offering of rental houses with the help of KredEx Foundation’s new services is also important for smoothing construction market fluctuations. While demand can be increased to a certain degree by renovating apartment buildings, in difficult times, it is more easier to support the construction volumes by building rental houses. Renovation of apartment buildings may be more cost-effective during a market slump (work costs less), but the readiness of apartment association members to commence with work may be hampered by the uncertainty of their financial situation and income. 80 11 Annexes 11.1 CO2 emission reduction-based support measure for renovating commercial properties In the example, calculation of a CO2 emission reduction-based support measure is provided for office, commercial and service buildings. The calculation example is prepared on the basis of the average indicators for the energy use and renovation costs of buildings. Basic data for calculation:  Electricity cost €100/MWh, heating cost €60/MWh  Electricity has a specific emission factor of 0.83 t CO2/MWh and heating 0.12 tCO2/MWh. The calculations proceed from the assumption that energy class C is achieved as a result of renovation. Table 28. Changes in the energy use, CO2 emissions and energy costs of office, commercial and service buildings. Office Before renovation Reduction after renovation Building area, Heating, Electricity, CO2, Energy Heating, Electricity, CO2, Energy m2 kWh/(m2y) kWh/(m2y) t/y cost, €/y % % t/y cost, €/y 1,000 140 80 83 16,400 50% 44% 46 7,700 3,000 130 70 221 44,400 46% 36% 137 18,300 5,000 110 70 357 68,000 36% 36% 229 24,500 Commerce Before renovation Reduction after renovation and services Building area, Heating, Electricity, CO2, Energy Heating, Electricity, CO2, Energy m2 kWh/(m2y) kWh/(m2y) t/y cost, €/y % % t/y cost, €/y 1,000 80 140 126 18,800 31% 39% 77 7,000 3,000 80 140 377 56,400 31% 39% 231 21,000 5,000 80 140 629 94,000 31% 39% 386 35,000 The question of return on investment is important to property owners. The proportion of the support should ensure a payback period of more than 20 years. Table 29. Investments required for renovating office, commercial and service buildings and payback period. Office Investment Ordinary payback period Building area, Investment, Investment, Investment for Without Support, Support, Support, m2 €/m2 € reducing CO2, €/t support 30% 40% 50% CO2 1,000 400 400,000 8,700 52 36 31 26 3,000 300 900,000 6,600 49 34 30 25 5,000 250 1,250,000 5,500 51 36 31 26 Commerce Investment Ordinary payback period and services Building area, Investment, Investment, Investment for Without Support, Support, Support, m2 €/m2 € reducing CO2, €/t support 30% 40% 50% CO2 1,000 400 400,000 5,200 57 40 34 29 3,000 300 900,000 3,900 43 30 26 21 5,000 250 1,250,000 3,200 36 25 21 18 In the case of the renovation options given in the example, the support for an investment made in order to reduce one tonne of CO2 emissions 81 could be between €1,000-2,600 at a support rate of 30%, €1,300-3,500 at a support rate of 40% and €1,600-4,400 at a support rate of 50%. 82 11.2 Measures related to renovation of existing buildings This chapter provides an overview of measures related to buildings that underwent renovation in 2019. The measures are presented by institutions carrying out the measures. Environmental Investment Centre  Replacement of an apartment building’s heating unit that runs on biomass or fossil fuel or a heating unit that partially uses electrical heating with a heating unit that uses renewable fuel or connecting an apartment building with the district heating network.  Installation of local heating to replace the district heating system of an existing building and demolishing the parts of the district heating system that falls into disuse as a result thereof. SA KredEx  Housing loan guarantee for purchasing a new home or renovating an existing one.  Renovation support for small houses for improving their energy performance.  Home support for families with many children, who can use the support to purchase, construct, expand or renovate their home.  Loan guarantee for apartment associations for financing renovation-related work.  Renovation support for conducting full renovation.  Electrical system renovation support for buildings in Tallinn that use the old voltage system with the purpose of changing the buildings over to the new voltage system.  Solar panel investment support for apartment associations, companies and local governments.  Demolition support for local governments for demolishing residential buildings and non-residential buildings that have fallen into disuse. State Shared Service Centre  Support for improving the energy performance of central- government buildings in order to renovate an existing building or building a new building to replace an existing one.  Support for making local government buildings energy efficient. 83 11.3 Results of interviews conducted among owners of private sector non-residential buildings In the course of preparing the strategy, interviews were conducted with six representatives of companies owning and developing commercial properties and representatives of the Estonian Association of Construction Entrepreneurs. The purpose of the interviews was to determine the conditions on which owners of commercial properties decide to invest in energy savings-related renovation. The functioning logic of the commercial property market is not conducive to full renovations, because the tenant covers the main costs, of which only a fraction are energy costs. Conscious tenants are more interested in interior climate rather than energy performance. There are also investors who keep buildings in their portfolio for a short period of time. As there is no intention of using the building for the long-term, the investor does not deem it necessary to invest in improving the building’s condition. It is known that buildings age in 30 years and property owners are forced to upgrade their buildings in order to stay on the market. The question is, in what extent will renovation work be undertaken? Larger projects with a payback period of over 20 years are not attractive to owners, because by then the building services systems installed will need to be replaced again. The investment payback period should be less than 10 years. As the return on investments made is important in the case of renovations, property owners have to be informed and require specific and realistic savings in order to make decisions. Assessments on the possibilities of saving energy and full renovation plans prepared by specialists would help to achieve this. In the case of commercial properties that are located outside of centres, tenants do not have much of a choice in terms of rental spaces and do not therefore have any particular demands in relation thereto. Additionally, areas outside centres lack energy performance-related awareness and the capability to carry out full renovation projects. The main problems commercial property owners face when renovating are as follows: • long investment payback period; • investment is made by the property owner, while the tenant benefits; • the reduction in energy costs achieved as a result of renovation may not be attractive to tenants; • energy performance requirements are changing too fast. Requirements that are constantly amended and changes in calculation methodology (e.g. changes in weighting factors) make preparing a long-term view more difficult. Future energy performance requirements for buildings are unknown. 84 • Full renovation requires temporary closure of the building, which reduces the property owner’s rental income. • The construction company carrying out the construction or renovation work is not interested in future use of the building and its operating costs. Solutions proposed by owners of commercial properties: • Planned changes in building energy performance requirements must be announced as early as possible. Property owners would like to know the changes to be introduced in the building energy performance regulations and the implementation time of the new requirements at least 10-20 years in advance. • The energy class boundaries must be stable. A system where energy class boundaries change every five years is too unstable to base investment decisions on. A building energy performance assessment system that is more stable and easier for the public to understand. • In the case of energy savings support, a requirement to prove the achievement of the energy savings goal must be added to the support measure. For instance, achievement of the goal must be proved a year after the completion of the renovation work. • Carrying out commercial property renovation pilot projects to demonstrate best practices. • More attention should be paid on IT solutions of buildings: automation, remote management, troubleshooting, monitoring of use profiles and building services system monitoring. • Energy audits should be more detailed and renovation work proposed therein should consider the feasibility and additional costs of the work. • Preparation of an energy consumption survey of the commercial property sector. For instance, preparing an additional query to property owners about the energy consumption of properties owned by them. This can be used to obtain an overview of existing buildings. 85 11.4 Public consultation and inclusion of stakeholders in the preparation of the strategy In order to include and inform stakeholders, two workshops were organised in the rooms of and at the invitation of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications. The first workshop on 10 December 2019 focused on the condition of residential buildings and possible measures. 44 people from 23 organisations participated in the workshop, which indicates a great interest in renovating apartment buildings and small residential buildings. The second workshop on 19 February 2020 addressed market-based renovation of non-residential buildings, market failures and possible measures. 26 people from 22 organisations participated in the workshop. The workshops provided important feedback and also proposals. The most important of these are: • reflecting the need to develop new buildings outside Tallinn, Tartu and Pärnu in order to set off the buildings that fall into disuse and are likely demolished in the strategy; • imposition of energy class C requirement on all spaces used by the public sector; • considering factors other than energy savings when renovating buildings (building accessibility, building safety, the shrinking of cities). Five steering group meetings were held when preparing the strategy: on 26 September 2019, 21 October 2019, 13 November 2019 and 19 February 2020. The steering group involved the representatives of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of the Environment, KredEx Foundation, State Real Estate Company Riigi Kinnisvara AS, the Estonian Environmental Research Centre and Tallinn University of Technology. The strategy was introduced to a wider audience at the Ehituse Treff 2019 event on 5 December 2019 (110 participants) and the round table on housing on 29 January 2020 (80 participants). 86 11.5 Methodology for estimating residential building volumes. In the next few decades, renovation needs will be shaped by demographics and migration. It is not practical to renovate buildings in areas that are shrinking and where buildings will fall into disuse in the future. According to the population projections of Statistics Estonia, the Estonian population is decreasing (statistics tables RV086, RV088 2019). The renovation volume of buildings that fall into disuse is estimated on the basis of the basic population projection scenario (RV086), which Statistics Estonia considers the most likely. More positive and negative scenarios have not been used in calculations of building abandonment rates, because 1) these are less likely and 2) Statistics Estonia has not prepared a population projection by county for these scenarios. Migration, which follows global trends, is much more important than population dynamics in the context of buildings falling into disuse. The main trend is the continuation and acceleration of the urbanisation process. This means that the periphery empties and larger centres grow on the account of rest of the areas. This in turn increases the housing need in centres and contributes to the emptying of residential buildings in other areas. In Estonia, urbanisation is mainly expressed in the movement of people to larger centres with well-paid jobs. These centres are the urban areas in mainly Harju County and, to a smaller extent, Tartu County. Population is in decline in other regions. The population projections of Statistics Estonia take migration into account. Thus, if a more positive demographic scenario becomes a reality, the population grows and the share of external migration increases, it is still of marginal importance compared to the impact of urbanisation. Considering 1) the research volume, 2) availability of existing data and 3) the need for the strategy to be precise, the volume of buildings was projected using the distribution of functional regions by Statistics Estonia as the regional population density system model (Statistics Estonia 2014). The distribution of functional regions is based on commuting data, which characterises the link between population distribution and destinations that are mainly related to work and study. Estonia is divided into functional regions with one centre. This mainly 87 coincides with the county centre, but in several counties additional centres have occurred as a result of migration. All of the hinterlands of the centres of functional regions are divided into three zones: immediate hinterland, transition zone and periphery. The zones of a functional region correlate well with other regional development indicators, such as the transaction value of apartment buildings, which is why it is appropriate to use the functional region model in the renovation strategy. In addition to centres of functional regions, the analysis also discerns second-tier centres and other urban areas in accordance with the 2019 small settlements study. Data, prerequisites and methods 1. Data related to residential buildings originate from the Building Registry; KredEx Foundation renovation database; the public database of 2000 and 2011 population and housing census; the transaction value register of the Land Board; the database of 2019 small settlements study; public databases of Statistics Estonia. 2. The population projection by counties prepared by Statistics Estonia until 2045 is, within the context of the study, linearly extended by five years to bring it in line with the target deadline of 2050 of the renovation strategy. 3. When estimating the housing abandonment rate it is presumed that upon shrinking of regions, residential buildings fall into disuse on the basis of the following regional hierarchy: the periphery of functional regions will empty first, followed by transitional areas. In some regions (e.g. Ida-Viru County and Valga County), where there are fewer residential buildings outside centres, but the population projection indicates a decrease, residential buildings fall into disuse also in centres. 4. The ratio of residents of apartment buildings and small residential buildings is determined by urban areas using public statistics from Statistics Estonia. Even though the population and housing census enables the distribution of residents of each building to be determined on the basis of the building type, such an approach was not practical considering the volume of the analysis and the need for the strategy to be precise. 5. Upon analysing the abandonment rate of residential buildings, it is presumed that most of the impact of the decrease in population is expressed in the emptying of apartment buildings. Small residential buildings may also remain in seasonal use in the periphery. Apartment buildings in sparsely populated regions, e.g. apartments of former Soviet agricultural holdings, however, fall into disuse. 88 6. The abandonment rate of residential buildings in functional regions is determined on the basis of urban areas taking into account 1) the number of small residential buildings and apartment buildings and 2) the area per residents. 7. The paper assumes that private houses that are no longer in permanent use may remain in seasonal use and are not generally demolished. Demolition is unavoidable in the case of emptying apartment buildings at least in urban centres. 8. Housing abandonment is not a linear process. It is presumed that abandonment is likely exponential and cyclical. Housing abandonment cycles are likely linked to economic cycles, which have not been forecasted in the current work. 89 LIFE Integrated projects 2020 Climate Action Stage 1 - Concept Note (CN) forms 1 LIFE Integrated Projects 2020- CNa LIFE 2020 FOR ADMINISTRATION USE ONLY LIFE20 IPC/ PROJECT Project title (max. 120 characters): PURSUING ESTONIAN NATIONAL CLIMATE AMBITION THROUGH SMART AND RESILIENT RENOVATION Project acronym (max. 25 characters): LIFE IP BUILDEST The project will be implemented in the following Country(ies) and/or Administrative region(s): Estonia – all regions (see the map in form CNe) Expected start date: 01.10.2021 Expected end date: 31.12.2029 PROJECT POLICY AREA You can only tick one of the following options: Climate Change Adaptation LIFE Integrated Project: Integrated project contributing to the implementation of a national, regional or local specific adaptation strategy or action plan; Urban Climate Change Mitigation and/or Adaptation LIFE Integrated Project: Integrated project contributing to the implementation of a urban or community- based action plan pioneering the transition to a low carbon and/or climate resilient society Climate Change Mitigation LIFE Integrated Project: Integrated project contributing to the implementation of a national, regional or industry-/sector-specific X greenhouse gas mitigation strategy or low carbon economy roadmap The project aims at implementing the following action plan/strategy/ roadmap (full copy is provided in attachment): ESTONIAN BUILDING’S LONG-TERM RENOVATION STRATEGY (LTRS), which was approved by the Estonian Government on the 9th of July 2020. The requirement for EU countries to adopt a long-term renovation strategy is set out in the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive (2010/31/EU), which was revised in 2018 (2018/844/EU). These strategies comprise a part of the respective EU countries’ integrated national energy and climate plans (NECPs). Estonian NECP was approved on the 19th of December 2019. Annexes: Annex I – Estonian Long-term renovation strategy (LTRS) https://ec.europa.eu/energy/sites/ener/files/documents/ee_2020_ltrs_official_translation_en.pdf Annex II – Figures describing the project (2 pages, A3): Figure II-1. Project pert chart and Figure II-2. Project network (beneficiaries and stakeholders) 2 LIFE Integrated Projects 2020- CNa BENEFICIARIES Name of the coordinating beneficiary (1): Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications (MKM) Name of the associated beneficiary (2): Ministry of Finance (RaM) Name of the associated beneficiary (3): Ministry of Environment (KeM) Name of the associated beneficiary (4): Foundation KredEx (KredEx) Name of the associated beneficiary (5): Environmental Investments Centre (KIK) Name of the associated beneficiary (6): State Real Estate Ltd (RKAS) Name of the associated beneficiary (7): Tallinn University of Technology (TalTech) Name of the associated beneficiary (8): Estonian Academy of Arts (EKA) Name of the associated beneficiary (9): Tallinn City Government (Tallinn) Name of the associated beneficiary (10): Tartu City Government (Tartu) Name of the associated beneficiary (11): Rakvere Town Government (Rakvere) Name of the associated beneficiary (12): Võru Town Government (Võru) Name of the associated beneficiary (13): The Estonian Union of Co-operative Housing Associations (EKYL) Name of the associated beneficiary (14): Centre of Rural Architecture (MARK) Name of the associated beneficiary (15): Estonian Association of Construction Entrepreneurs (EEEL) Name of the associated beneficiary (16): Estonian Circular Economy Industries Association (ERMEL) Not a complete list, further beneficiaries are to be added with the full proposal, also the exact roles of beneficiaries are to be determined during the development of full proposal. PROJECT BUDGET AND REQUESTED EU FUNDING Total integrated project budget: 19 200 000 € Total eligible project budget: 19 200 000 € EU LIFE financial contribution requested: 11 520 000 € (= 60 % of total eligible budget) AUTHORISATION TO INFORM NATIONAL CONTACT POINT The consortium authorises EASME to share with the LIFE National Contact Point the project title and coordinating beneficiary name: Yes X No 3 LIFE Integrated Projects 2020- CNb Coordinating Beneficiary Profile Information Short Name MKM Beneficiary n° 1 Legal information on the Coordinating Beneficiary Legal Name Ministry of Economic Affairs and Legal Status Communications VAT No EE100113619 X Public body Legal Registration No 70003158 Private commercial Private non- commercial Registration Date 28.12.1998 Legal address of the Coordinating Beneficiary Street Name and No Suur-Ameerika tn 1 PO Box Post Code 10122 Town/City Tallinn Country Code EE Country Name Estonia Coordinating Beneficiary contact person information Function Head of Sustainable Construction Surname Sergejev First Name Ivan E-mail address [email protected] Department / Service Construction and Housing Department Street Name and No Suur-Ameerika tn 1 PO Box Post Code 10122 Town/City Tallinn Country Estonia Telephone No (+372) 639 7638 Fax No (+372) 631 3660 Coordinating Beneficiary details Website https://mkm.ee/en Brief description of the Coordinating Beneficiary's activities and experience in the area of the proposal In Estonia, the overall objective of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications (MKM) is to increase the competitiveness of Estonian companies and thus the prosperity of people. In that capacity, MKM is the competent authority responsible for developing and implementing policy pertaining to construction and housing, energy, economic development, transport, tourism, foreign trade and foreign financing, European Union and international co-operation, the internal market of the European Union, the information society and cyber security. Hence, MKM is the public body responsible for the full implementation of the Estonian Long-term Renovation Strategy (LTRS) and linking it to the overall Estonian housing, energy, and climate policies. Within LIFE IP BUILDEST, MKM is responsible for: • Coordinating the overall process of LIFE IP BUILDEST; • Establishing partner networks and engaging stakeholders with the goal of implementing both the LTRS and LIFE IP BUILDEST; • Integrating actions foreseen in view of implementing LTRS and general housing, construction, energy, and climate policies; • Developing policy schemes and measures needed for the LTRS, assessing, and improving relevant existing regulations, proposing new motivational schemes and driving the needed sectoral capacity building. YOU MAY NOT DUPLICATE THIS PAGE 4 LIFE Integrated Projects 2020 - CNd SUMMARY DESCRIPTION OF THE PROJECT 1. Overall context/background/geographical scope OVERALL CONTEXT: HOW ESTONIA’S LTRS AND LIFE IP CONTRIBUTE TO THE EUROPEAN AND ESTONIAN CLIMATE POLICY The European Union has set a target to develop a sustainable, competitive, secure, and decarbonised energy system by 2050, and the built environment has a major role to play in accomplishing this goal. Majority of the existing European building stock originates from the period of low requirements on energy performance that followed World War II, and at present almost 75% of buildings are highly inefficient, consuming about 40% of total energy produced in Europe. 80% of today’s building stock projected to still be in use in 2050, but presently only about 1% of it is renovated each year. Therefore, existing buildings have large potential for energy performance improvement, especially in colder regions. As energy savings are generally proportional to reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive (EPBD) requires EU member states to carry out broad renovation programs of existing buildings by 2050 in order to achieve a carbon neutral economy. In view of this, as part of the commitments in the European Green Deal, the European Commission is preparing a ‘Renovation Wave’ for public and private buildings to address the twin challenge of energy performance and affordability. This initiative will set a vision for the short, medium, and long term to kick- start and deliver different levels of renovation of the existing building stock, with accompanying financial instruments and mechanisms. The ‘Renovation Wave is supposed to double the rate of building renovation in the EU from 1% to at least 2% annually. An integrated approach to building renovation means boosting energy performance of buildings by applying the ‘energy efficiency first’ principle, deploying renewables, preparing for climate impacts, deploying urban green and blue infrastructure and incorporating circular economy, waste treatment and pollution prevention principles. The expected benefits are broad and include lowering energy bills, alleviating energy poverty, increasing resilience to climate change, contributing to human health, safety and improved indoor air quality and providing habitats for biodiversity, as well as boosting the construction sector and, in doing so, supporting small and medium size entrepreneurs and local jobs. Considering the labour intensiveness of building renovation and combining repairing the short-term economic damage induced by the COVID19 crisis with investing in our long-term future, the Renovation Wave initiative is seen as a major tool for relaunching EU’s post-COVID19 economy. All the money raised through Next Generation EU will be channelled through EU programmes in the revamped long- term EU budget. Here the European Green Deal is planned as the EU's recovery strategy, where the massive renovation wave of buildings will boost economy, bringing local jobs, improving welfare and better living conditions. Also, the synergies of the renovation wave with the renewable energy projects, will kick-starting a clean economy in Europe. In Estonia even faster rates of renovation are required because of bad construction quality and energy performance of soviet era buildings as well for large renovation debt. Estonia’s LTRS projects that the renovation rate must increase up to 5 times on average, with certain sectors needing even steeper improvements e.g. the rate of deep renovation of single-family residences needs to increase 11 times over the next 30 years (from 70 000 m²/year during 2020 – 2025 to 800 000m²/year during 2040 – 2050); from) and the renovation rate of private non-residential buildings needs to increase 6 times over the next 20 years (from 140 000 m²/year during 2020 – 2025 to 800 000m²/year during 2035 – 2045), see Figure 3. This signifies an urgent need for raising capacities, providing technical, social, and financial solutions, and establishing technical competences, to guarantee that the renovation initiative will pursue its main goal – improvement of climate mitigation and energy performance. Currently, the construction sector is unable to deliver such rates of renovation, and so a drastic change in renovation technology and aggressive capacity building measures are needed to achieve our climate mitigation and energy performance targets. The Estonian National General Principles of Climate Policy until 2050 postulate that by 2050 Estonia will be a competitive economy with low GHG emissions, reducing its emissions by 80% compared to the level of 1990. As the country moves towards this target, emissions will need to be reduced by about 70% by 2030 and by 72% by 2040. In addition, the decarbonization of Estonia’s building stock is stressed 5 in the national Climate Change Adaptation Development Plan until 2030 and in the National Development Plan of the Energy Sector until 2030. With the complete renovation of buildings, it is possible to achieve a reduction in final energy consumption of ~7 TWh/yr, including savings of up to 70% (~6.4 TWh/yr) in thermal energy consumption compared to today’s levels and up to 20% (~0.5 TWh/yr) in electricity consumption. The 2020 COVID19 crisis has proven that Estonia is vulnerable, when it comes to stable and secure supply of energy. The dependency on importing energy from the neighbouring countries, especially when dissociating from the use of oil shale, is a severe risk for Estonia’s energy security. The improvement of energy performance of buildings reduces energy consumption, thus mitigating the risks related to energy security. It has been confirmed that investment in renovation of buildings is not only environmentally important but provides economic benefits on an individual and government budget level. For example, in Estonia 1 M€ of annual investment in renovation generated 17 jobs per year and direct tax revenue was between 32-33%, depending on the renovation project. Renovation also holds other benefits. For example, upgrading the built environment with the natural environment in mind e.g. through the use of NBS-s (passive cooling, improving natural water circulations) and accounting for biodiversity (incl. Natura 2000 birds and habitats directive species, e.g. bat species) establishes synergies with EU’s Biodiversity Strategy. To achieve Estonia’s climate mitigation targets, the Nationwide report for reaching climate neutrality in Estonia [1] suggests focusing first on the “low-hanging fruit” in key sectors that have highly cost-effective possibilities of reducing GHG emissions. The report emphasizes the buildings sector, as improving the energy performance of buildings will not only reduce GHG emissions but will also lead to financial savings and a decrease in the need to invest in new energy generation capacities. Hence, renovation of buildings is one of the most cost-efficient means for reaching Estonia’s climate goals [2]. [1] Reaching climate neutrality in Estonia, 2019, url: https://www.sei.org/publications/eesti-kliimaambitsiooni-tostmise-voimaluste- analuus/#tutvu-raportiga (English summary available); [2] Kulutõhusaimate meetmete leidmiseks kliimapoliitika ja jagatud kohustuse määruse eesmärkide saavutamiseks Eestis, url: https://www.envir.ee/sites/default/files/news-related-files/aruanne_kliimapoliitika_kulutohusus.pdf TARGETED STRATEGY Overview The Estonian building’s long-term renovation strategy (LTRS) developed according to the EPBD targets the deep renovation of Estonian national building stock into highly energy-efficient and decarbonised buildings by 2050, facilitating the cost-effective transformation of existing buildings into nearly zero- energy buildings (NZEB), corresponding by Estonian regulations to energy class “C”. The LTRS forms a part of Estonian integrated national energy and climate plan (NECP). The full implementation of LTRS is expected to decrease the CO₂ emissions of Estonian building stock up to 90% and contribute significantly to achieving the Estonian overall climate ambition. Considering that as of 2019 Estonia’s national GHG emissions stand at 19 million tCO 2e/yr (of which ~4 million tCO2e/yr are contributed by buildings), improving energy performance of buildings via deep renovations plays a key role in reaching Estonia’s climate goals. On top of that, the full implementation of LTRS will produce vast social benefits, improving the living and working conditions of approximately 80% of the Estonian population and enabling Estonia to holistically upgrade the quality of its spatial environment. The renovation of homes and working places as well as demolition of underutilized buildings will improve the safety, aesthetic quality, health and accessibility of the built environment as well as reduce cost of energy thus yielding direct societal benefits. Analysis of the existing situation The analysis of the existing situation carried out as part of LTRS has shown that existing building stock contributes to about half of total energy consumption in Estonia with some ¾ of it originating from the period between 1961 – 1990. Estonia has a good track record when it comes to the renovation of the deep reconstruction of apartment buildings, which has been successfully carried out for more than 10 years. By now, there has emerged a demonstrated interest in performing reconstruction from apartment associations, an efficient financing system as well as technical solutions that allow to achieve both over 50% energy savings and a healthy 6 indoor climate. Thanks to the reconstruction, the energy consumption of residential buildings has remained at the same level for the last 15 years, despite the addition of new buildings. Estonia has also successfully implemented a national energy performance certificate (EPC) system, with all new buildings required to be NZEB (corresponding by Estonian regulations to energy class “A” in case of new construction) as of the beginning of 2020. However, despite these advancements, LTRS indicates that the present renovation mechanisms are not sufficient to achieve the climate ambition of 2050. With the current trends, it is expected that about 80% of the private residential, 68% of the apartment buildings and 60% of the non-residential buildings will not be renovated. When considering the building stock addressed in the strategy it could be expected that only the state-owned real-estate would become renovated as required. The present gaps and shortcomings that hinder the implementation of LTRS (summarized, as in detail different building types have specific barriers): • Technical barriers: 1) Lack of standardized renovation methods, techniques and integrated solutions; 2) Available technical solutions are laborious and time consuming, do not take into account climate change, circular solutions or ensure the efficiency and capacity necessary to achieve the renovation objectives; 3) Technical complexity of deep renovation is discouraging to owners; 4) Owners lack information on how to combine deep renovation with other building improvements (retrofitting for functionality, accessibility etc). • Financial barriers: owners do not have sufficient financial resources to renovate their real estate, neither do they have access to loans, mortgages etc that would cover the needed investments. This is especially relevant for the rural and suburban areas, where real estate value is low. Financial barriers vary depending on the owner and building type, but the most essential ones are: 1) Owners are reluctant to finance the high up-front costs of deep renovation; 2) The pay-back time of investments needed for improving energy performance is too long; 3) Lack of investors’ confidence in the stability of funding and grants schemes; 4) Difficulties with covering mortgage co-financing based on regional differences in real-estate value; 5) Existing grant schemes are not sufficient to finance the full implementation of LTRS. • Social barriers: Even when owners have full understanding of what needs to be done in view of improving energy performance of their real estate and have access to financing, there is a significant number of owners who do not act. Main reasons for this are: 1) Renovation causes inconveniences such as having to move out and pay for rental spaces, the process of finding suitable workforce and having to coordinate the work is complicated; 2) Ownership or owner-tenant conflicts hinder the effective approval of needed intervention (passive owners, owners with low cost acceptance, tenants expect better environment, but do not wish to have increased rent payment etc); 3) Bureaucracy and regulations seem cumbersome and the decision making process long and complex; 4) Low awareness of energy efficiency and carbon footprint of operating buildings; 5) Avoiding renovation due to its wider environmental impact (assessing negative impacts to natural environment to be higher than positive impact of improved energy performance); 6) Conflicting renovation policies and interests (eg improvement of buildings due to reasons other than energy performance, reduces owners interest and financial capacity to later “redo” deep renovation). In addition to the barriers hindering renovation, possible side-effects of an ambitious renovation program need to be considered, pertaining to both market performance and natural environment. Though mitigating the climate change by improvement of operational energy performance of buildings is severely needed, it must not be done at the cost of environmental damage. Issues like handling increased amounts of construction waste, understanding the wider impacts of the renovation to wildlife and natural environment in general have to be considered. See figure 1 for the preliminary analysis of the problems hindering the renovation of Estonian building stock as well as the causes arising from renovation itself that need to be dealt with. 7 Figure 1 Problem tree analysis of planned implementation of LTRS Regional differences The analysis carried out as part of LTRS shows that the uptake of renovation grants varies greatly between different regions. Ignoring regional and social aspects in policy application might result in social polarisation, hence implementation of LTRS is tightly intertwined with Estonian regional policy, addressing migration and demographical trends. On the one hand, energy performance-oriented renovation subsidies must be aimed at the low-performing regions where market-based solutions give little effect. On the other hand, LTRS admits rural decline and will not accelerate renovation in building stock with no sensible purpose. For such buildings demolition is foreseen. Different strategies are needed for advancing the deep renovation in Estonia depending on regional development (see figure 2). 8 Figure 2 The value zones of real estate, affecting renovation loan capacity of building owners, describing different financial support approaches needed to accelerate owners demand for deep renovation. Low performing rural areas: Regions outside the biggest cities (or located in close proximity to them), are less developed, communities have lower population density and lower incomes, real-estate values are also lower. This causes rural regions to be less capable of financing renovation with their own funding (savings, regular loans, mortgages) and makes them more dependent on state subsidies. Declining towns: In the case of declining urban settlements, the strategy highlights the need of compacting urban centres (often with historically valuable buildings). In settlements with an ageing and declining population, it is important not only to demolish underused buildings, but also to ensure the full functionality of the settlement, using demolition as an opportunity to improve the availability of public services by bringing them together in synergetic spatial communities. Target renovation volumes foreseen by LTRS Considering the number of existing buildings, the share of already renovated buildings and the projected decommissioning of buildings, in order to achieve LTRS goals outlined above the existing building stock of ~ 54 million m² must be renovated by 2050 (see also figure 3), including: ~ 100,000 detached houses with a total floor area of 14 million m², ~ 14,000 apartment buildings with a total floor area of 18 million m², ~ 27,000 non-residential buildings with a total floor area of 22 million m². Achieving these goals requires a five-fold average annual increase in the volume of deep renovation (incl. ~ 2 times in the case of apartment buildings, ~ 4 times in the case of commercial buildings and ~ 11 times in the case of detached houses) compared to the current level. The total investment required amounts to ~ 21.6 billion euros, or an average of ~ 720 million euros per year over the next 30 years. The public sector measures needed to implement the strategy and boost reconstruction will total € 2.2 billion over the next 10 years. The financial need for future grants will be 9 further specified as the implementation of the strategy will gradually change the funding logic, market capacity, needs and potential savings from innovation. The LTRS established the following milestones: • by 2030, 22% of the floor area of non-reconstructed buildings needs to be reconstructed, • by 2040 - 64% • by 2050 - 80-100%1 Figure 3 The renovation wave is expected to reach its maximum in 2035, where annually more than 2,3 million m 2 of buildings need to be completely renovated. To prepare for this, capacity building among other things is needed. Actions foreseen in view of implementing LTRS The list of measures proposed for the full implementation of LTRS consists of: • design of new (and development of existing) financial instruments (loans, warranties, grants etc); • development of new renovation technologies (climate resilience, flood resilience technologies, innovations of building materials, digital tools etc); • increase of competences and awareness of key stakeholders on the renovation (guidelines, technical counselling, environmental labelling systems etc); • demolition of underused buildings, along with measures to improve circularity of building materials; • considering the embodied energy and environmental impact in assessment of buildings; • to achieve all this, significant capacity building of the involved authorities and stakeholders is needed as well as efforts concerning research and development. The introduction and large-scale start-up of comprehensive renovation takes time because it is characterized by a steep learning process, a need for qualified labour, and the emergence of companies and supply-chains aimed at renovation. Life IP BUILDEST will be essential in calibrating how Estonia approaches this massive endeavour. COMPLIANCE WITH LIFE INTEGRATED PROJECT PRIORITIES The present project will help accelerate the renovation of Estonia’s building stock by building capacity of the main agents engaged in renovation in Estonia. LIFE IP BUILDEST is designed to drive the full implementation of LTRS. The project aims at establishing multi-purpose mechanisms, synergies and integration: the proposal presents a comprehensive set of actions that will deliver on their core objective – improvement of the energy performance of the Estonian 1 in practice, it can be assumed that up to 20% of privately owned buildings will not be reconstructed because the owner of the building does not want to do so 10 building stock – and do so in a way that also delivers benefits for other environmental and climate objectives. The project is implemented on a national scale, engaging the whole of Estonia. As the LIFE IP BUILDEST project to be developed is oriented towards contributing to the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions of buildings, the priority area of the project is Climate Change Mitigation and it shall have the following specific objectives according to the Article 14 of LIFE REGULATION: (a) Project contributes to the implementation and development of EU policy and legislation on climate change mitigation, including mainstreaming across policy areas, in particular by developing, testing and demonstrating policy or management approaches, best practices and solutions for climate change mitigation. • Planned IP project aims to establish mechanisms for the full implementation of LTRS. In addition, decarbonization of Estonia’s building stock is also stressed in National Energy and Climate Plan (required according to the regulation on the governance of the energy union and climate action (EU/2018/1999)). The importance of energy performance of buildings and efforts needed to improve it in the EU are stressed in the Energy Roadmap 2050 and the foreseen project objectives link with the aims of the National Development Plan of the Energy Sector until 2030. • Project also aims to contribute to the implementation of the Sustainable Energy and Climate Action Plans (SECAPs) of Estonian climate leader municipalities in the field of energy performance of buildings. Need to consider the changing climate when building new houses and carrying out renovation is stressed in the national Climate Change Adaptation Development Plan until 2030, a document stemming from the EU Strategy on adaptation to climate change. Project concept development has been steered by the Ministry of the Environment (KeM) and coordination and cooperation is ongoing between LIFE IP BUILDEST (sub-programme mitigation) and LIFE IP AdaptEst (sub-programme adaption) project development teams. The core team developing the project concept of LIFE IP BUILDEST has introduced the project content (including the draft and final versions of CN) to representatives developing AdaptEst project to avoid any overlapping of the content of proposals. • LIFE IP BUILDEST project contributes to the aims of the freshly published EU GREEN DEAL, more specifically its initiatives: Renovation wave: a policy presently under development (to be announced mid-October 2020 and integrated into the project by Full proposal; EU circular economy strategy. Construction and demolition waste make up just over one third of total waste generation in the EU. More precisely the project objectives will have to correspond to the principles of the strategy for a sustainable built environment (expected to be finalized in 2021). Based on this, the national framework and practices need to be developed as well as put to practice. Circular approaches are key to increasing the quality and quantity of recycling and reuse of construction and demolition materials. (b) Project improves the knowledge base for the development, assessment, monitoring, evaluation and implementation of effective climate change mitigation actions and measures and to enhance the capacity to apply that knowledge in practice. LIFE IP BUILDEST works out building typology and ownership-based renovation measures to decrease energy consumption and CO2 emission as well as to extend the service life of buildings that would minimize additional renovation of already renovated or constructed buildings in the future. The project will also increase the awareness about improving the quality of indoor climate and health aspects through energy renovation and building performance improvements, highlighted by EU policy makers in the 2nd EPBD review. (c) Project facilitates the development and implementation of integrated approaches, such as for climate change mitigation strategies and action plans, at local, regional, or national level. LIFE IP BUILDEST project establishes framework for the full implementation of LTRS, by developing necessary mechanisms and combining and engaging additional complementary measures for the deep renovation of buildings and mainstreaming the initiative across sectors and streamlining the renovation across the country, both on the national and regional levels. 11 (d) Project contributes to the development and demonstration of innovative climate change mitigation technologies, systems, methods, and instruments that are suitable for being replicated, transferred, or mainstreamed. Innovations will be developed in the field of developing proven plug & play prefab deep renovation solutions using building elements and building services. To support the climate change mitigation ambitions, a step towards holistic circular renovation products and concepts as well more efficient use of physical infrastructure (buildings and associating systems) will be taken through real-time control and automated monitoring. New solutions will provide low cost monitoring of indoor climate conditions by specific energy flows related to behaviour e.g. ventilation, domestic hot water (DHW) and indoor temperature. Periodically providing energy information related to behaviour of the occupants. Digital solutions will be developed to engage more effectively with the stakeholders, local administrations, and the changing environment (both physical environment as well as the economy, welfare issues etc). Emphasis is put on participation and co-design. As existing renovation concepts are mainly based on operational energy performance of dwellings, embedded energy and circularity will also now be considered. Holistic approach is planned to be adopted for evaluating built environments carbon footprint, which learns, adapts, and innovates and thereby responds more effectively and promptly to changing circumstances. Renovation innovation approaches will be tested and monitored for development of best practices (incl. use of prefabricated elements, low carbon, and biobased materials etc). 2. Project objectives OBJECTIVES OF LIFE IP The primary objective of the current project is to pave the way for reducing CO₂ emissions of Estonia’s existing building stock by up to 90% (~4 million tCO₂/yr) by 2050 thus mitigating the effect energy performance of buildings has on climate change. That, in turn, is accomplished via building capacity and aggregating demand for implementing Estonia’s LTRS. LIFE IP BUILDEST will raise capacity, increase experiences, and develop the necessary toolset for improving energy performance and reducing carbon emissions of Estonian building stock in required rate and depth set in LTRS (LTRS, pg 2). LIFE IP BUILDEST will also provide national framework for carrying out the EU Renovation Wave Initiative. Sectorial capacity building foreseen in the LIFE IP project will help to adopt the initiative effectively by avoiding negative consequences (possible market failures and negative environmental impacts), establish a national framework for fast adoption of the regulations and financing measures, and improve cross-sectoral mainstreaming of the renovation mechanisms. To achieve this strategic goal, the IP will tackle the following sub-targets: Sub-target 1: Develop, test and demonstrate tools for decarbonizing Estonian existing building stock, such as develop renovation guidelines, establish best practices and demo showcases, propose and pilot innovative motivational schemes and business models. The first sub-target is directly focused on the mitigation of the effects of climate change caused by low performing buildings and substantial share of project funds are designated for implementing actions foreseen under this section. Sub-targets 2-3 will contribute improved technical knowhow and deliver capacities related with longevity of the effects (planning for circularity) and resilience of the interventions (accepting and adapting to climate risks). Sub-targets 4-5 are aimed to streamline the replication of the effects of the project during and after the project. Sub-target 2: Establish climate risk evaluation criteria for deep renovation, and so ensuring climate resilience of buildings by designing and renovating them to last longer, avoid numerous renovations, improve their preparedness to withstand extreme weather conditions and consider the reduced cost for heating, cooling and hygrothermal performance of buildings due to changing climate, flood resilience technologies; Sub-target 3: Apply resource efficiency and circularity principles for renovation (and construction sector as whole), such as circular use of materials, use of biobased materials, and high-quality recycling 12 of construction materials, phasing out hazardous substances, incorporate waste treatment and pollution prevention principles, as well as considering the embodied energy and environmental impact of building in assessment of buildings; Sub-target 4: Advance digital technologies for renovation, including development e-building platform appliances for energy performance, smart readiness of building renovations, energy performance monitoring and assessment and calculators and other tools for advancing deep renovations among building owners; Sub-target 5: Increase capacity of relevant stakeholders and aggregate demand both among private owners of residential buildings as well as managers of commercial and public real estate. The project will develop demonstration buildings for deep renovation and climate resilient renovation, raise awareness among general public to improve the public perception towards preferring renovation. Figure 4: Diagrammatic summary of Life IP BUILDEST objectives and work packages. OBJECTIVES OF COMPLEMENTARY MEASURES The objective of engaging complementary measures is to mainstream project results to the Estonian renovation wave, replicating the best practices of the project in renovations of Estonian buildings during and after the project and adopting the developed toolset by wider audience (local municipalities, companies, building owners etc). Additionally, the project aims to intertwine the project with additional complementary projects for elaborating the advancement of the know-how, technologies, and innovative solutions by research activities. Also, aside to mainstreaming the project results geographically, the project aims to engage thematic complementary measures, which are expected to engage and develop also healthy living environment (access issues for disabled, insolation etc), greening built environment with nature based solutions, energy system infrastructure improvement and mainstreaming renewable energy sources in renovations. Ministry of Environment, whilst also participating as beneficiary in the current project, is also developing a LIFE Clima IP AdaptEst proposal to the adaption sub-programme, which will implement the Climate Change Adaptation Development Plan until 2030 (NAP). The current LIFE IP BUILDEST would perform as significant complementary for the aforementioned project taking into practice the issues related to adapting the Estonian building stock to the changing climate. LIFE AdaptEst will develop long-term climate scenarios (according to the IPCC methodology) that will be used by IP BUILDEST for developing detailed construction specific climate models to be used for baseline computing parameters in building standards and guidelines (the parameters presently based on historical data). No overlapping of actions between two IP-s, as cooperation between the two proposal development teams has been active and is aimed to continue. 13 The content and aim of involving complementary measures are more specifically described under sub- targets in the following section. HEALTHY LIVING ENVIRONMENT AS A RESULT OF RENOVATIONS Strategies for minimising the risk of contagion in building spaces whilst likewise minimising energy usage are of importance to the healthy, safe and efficient operation of buildings going forward. Ensuring proper ventilation with outside air can help reduce airborne contaminants indoors, including the virus that causes COVID-19. The same COVID-19-vulnerable population would be the same group of people who are also vulnerable to overheating. The double impacts of risk of exposure to COVID-19 and indoor overheating become a serious concern, especially for senior people. Within building spaces the use of 100% outdoor air would help minimise the risk to contagion however, this is not always possible given that currently existing HVAC systems cannot cope with the increased cooling loads during the summer periods should this degree of recirculation be used. The BUILDEST project provides specific information on building service systems strategies to optimize the performance of HVAC or passive ventilation systems in buildings and to identify potential gaps in their performance. The assessment process is carried out using a simulation of both archetypal buildings and specific buildings. In addition, the available air cleaning equipment will be evaluated as possible solutions for installation in existing buildings, thus helping to ensure that the risk of contamination through airborne contamination of the buildings under investigation is minimized. 3. Actions and means involved: The LIFE IP BUILDEST project will tackle the objectives described above via a series of actions to achieve the aimed results (described below). The planned intervention logic of LIFE IP BUILDEST (see figure 5 below) is capacity building focused, whereas project actions are selected based on their scalability with available complementary funding and synergies developed during the project. Raising the capacity necessary for the full implementation of LTRS consists of advancement of toolset of deep renovation (sub-target 1), climate resilience (s-t 2), resource efficiency (s-t 3) and digitalization of the processes. The developed toolset (financial models, technical standards, computing parameters for future climate and resource efficiency solutions, smart renovation tools and outputs provided by competence cluster) will be tested on the renovation showcase buildings. The latter will be used to promote the developed mechanisms and aim to mainstream the deep renovation via replication of the project results. Specific actions described below as parts of work packages are structured according to the Life IP regulation, with A being preparatory; C concrete, D monitoring, E dissemination and F management actions. See the intertwining of project actions and main outputs of the LIFE IP BUILDEST project in Annex II, figure II-1 14 Figure 5 The planned intervention logic of LIFE IP BUILDEST project focuses capacity building of renovation, whereas selected core themes corresponding with the project objectives are expected to be given development leap. 15 SUB-TARGET 1: DEVELOP, TEST AND DEMONSTRATE TOOLS FOR DECARBONIZING ESTONIA’S EXISTING BUILDING STOCK Work package 1: Development of stakeholder specific financial models and policy instruments for deep renovation Actions foreseen in LTRS: Corporate buildings, pg 77-78; Private residential buildings, pg 77; Residential apartment buildings: pg 77; Industrialized renovation, pg 72; Fitness checks for policy and decision procedures pg 74. Financed in LIFE The work-package will analyse and propose a fitness check for the existing grant schemes presently available. LTRS has indicated the issues to be tackled on most available schemes but proposes further questions to be solved prior to reforming the schemes. Project will also analyse the suitability of different innovative renovation business models (cost-sharing etc) for Estonian market and proposes the adoption of the most appropriate models for all building types. Analysis of socio-economic impacts of pollution-based taxation of energy performance of buildings is planned to be carried out and measures will be proposed based on that. Based on the preliminary analysis described above, regulation is established for applying the financial mechanisms, policy documentation will be developed for supporting renovation for corporate buildings, improvements will be proposed to the existing schemes for private residential and apartment buildings. Cooperation models will be encouraged, examined, and monitored to accelerate the renovations on regional (district or settlement) level. Market regulation will be assessed and rationalized if needed to improve the adoption of high-potential business models. The activities foreseen in the work-package will mostly be carried out by project staff, in some specific fields of expertise external consultants will be engaged. For transferring existing best practices study visits and international meetings will be carried out and for the replication of developed Estonian policy international seminar will be arranged, which both will include travel and seminar cost. Actions foreseen in the WP1: A1.1 Fitness check of existing grant schemes; Analyses of innovative renovation business models; A1.2 Fitness check of renovation policy; A1.3 Development of new and improved financing instruments for deep renovation, incl. • Support scheme for corporate buildings; • Improvement of existing schemes (detached houses, apartment buildings) (based on A1.1); • Development of new business models (based on A1.1); • Development of community led cooperation model and complex grant for district bases deep- renovation; A1.4 Analysis of socio-economic impacts of pollution-based taxation of energy performance of buildings; A1.5 Development of communication driven, and socially responsible motivation set for deep renovations; C1.1 Improvement of national renovation policy: development and approval of legislative documentation for the financial instruments developed, facilitating national implementation of Renovation Wave initiative across sectors; D; E tbd by full proposal Potential complementary Project will analyse the existing ongoing financial schemes available for deep renovation of Estonian building stock. The schemes include internal management resources for monitoring the application rate, quality, and efficiency. For the overall fitness check carried out within the project, these results will be used. Also, project will monitor the application and socio-economic impacts of the mechanisms available, for which it will be needed to review the monitoring data of separate schemes. • KredEx renovation grant for renovation of apartment buildings; • KredEx reconstruction grant for small residences; • KredEx Housing Loan Guarantee; • KredEx industrial renovation grant; 16 • KredEx support for home renovation for large families; • KIK Resource Efficiency Grant for Industries; • Financial support schemes and business developed within project will also include the internal monitoring; Related research and development activities of project beneficiaries (ongoing and planned) • EKYL: POWERPOOR - Empowering Energy Poor Citizens through Energy Cooperative Initiatives (ongoing); • EKYL: SMART FINANCE EST – Estonian National Roundtable to Implement Smart Financing for Smart Buildings (requested); • Different research and innovation project are foreseen to be submitted to various financing instruments during project period to advance policy improvement in Estonia. Work package 2: Development of building and stakeholder type specific technical solutions and guidelines to streamline the renovation Action foreseen in LTRS: New technological solutions pg 72; Advancement of technical know-how pg 74. Financed in LIFE This work-package will include development of building type specific technical solutions for deep renovations, including deep renovation solutions for typical building envelopes and technical systems of residential buildings, corporate and public buildings. Specific attention will be given to valuable historical buildings, for which technical energy performance improvement solutions will be proposed (eg interior insulation, façade concealed insulation, adaptive indoor climate systems, restoration principles etc). Greening solutions applicable in renovations and suitable for Estonian buildings and climate (incl: nature-based solutions (NBS) inclusion, adopting renewable energy solutions, biodiversity considerations etc) will be formulated and published. Advancing prefabricated renovation solutions (digitalization of workflows and improvement of service delivery) will be carried out. Stakeholder specific recommendations on how to comply with the terms of reference for contracting renovation will be developed based on the technical solutions developed within the project. Also, based on the above, demo designs will be prepared for typical building envelopes used in Estonia and renovation info-charts will be developed and published (online) for self-learned private builders. Improved renovation solutions will be adapted to the existing guidelines and training programmes for professional builders. The activities foreseen in the work-package will mostly be carried out by project staff, in some specific fields of expertise external consultants will be engaged. For transferring existing best practices available in EU study visits and international meetings will be carried out and for the replication of developed technical solutions the results have to made available for the target audience by different publication options (eg demonstrating solutions on building oriented tv-programs, newspapers and professional social media channels as well as publishing the results on scientific journals), for which communication costs will be budgeted. Actions foreseen in the WP2: A2.1 Development of building type specific technical solutions for deep renovations, incl technical solutions for deep renovation of: • detached and terraced houses; • apartment buildings; • corporate and public buildings; • valuable historical buildings (eg interior insulation, façade concealed insulation, adaptive indoor climate systems, restoration principles etc); A2.2 Preparation of demo designs for typical building envelopes and service systems; A2.3 Development of guidelines for greening buildings during renovations A2.4 Advancement of prefabricated renovation solutions E2.1 Compilation and publishing of renovation info-charts E2.2 Inclusion of improved renovation solutions into the guidelines and training programmes for professional builders (based on A2.1, A2.2); E2.3 Delivery of stakeholder specific recommendations how to comply terms of reference for contracting renovation. 17 D; E tbd by full proposal Potential complementary Project will combine the best practices related to technical solutions for renovation developed externally in different research and innovation projects: Related research and development activities of project beneficiaries (ongoing and planned), incl: • TalTech: Moisture safety of interior insulation, constructional moisture and thermally efficient building envelope (ongoing); • TalTech: Zero energy and resource efficient smart buildings and districts (ongoing); • TalTech: FINEST TWINS: Establishment of Smart City Center of Excellence (ongoing); • TalTech: TRAC4Serial – Serial Refurbishment for typical multi-family buildings (requested); • Different research and innovation project are foreseen to be submitted to various financing instruments during project period to advance energy performance oriented renovation with innovative solutions (planned, not submitted). Work package 3: Renovation showcase: pilots, demos, and best-practices buildings Action foreseen in LTRS: renovation of buildings pg 58-60. Financed in LIFE Work-package will create a renovation showcase, which includes renovation of buildings according to the best available knowledge and by piloting the solutions developed in WP2, WP4 and WP5. The renovation showcase will also be used for demonstration purposes (detached houses, apartment buildings prefabricated offsite renovation, non-residential private and public buildings primarily in lighthouse towns Tallinn, Tartu, Võru and Rakvere). Renovation showcase renovated within the project is in the ownership of project beneficiaries (RKAS, municipalities) and residence owners, but agreements might be needed with building tenants. For the building types for which the showcase will be created using complementary funding (private residential, corporate, apartment buildings), also agreements must be established with building owners, who agree to go through the process of testing available complementary schemes. Here the business models developed in WP1 and capacity building foreseen in WP7-8 will be combined for best results. Based on the results of WP2, building specific technical designs (also for selected renovations to be carried out with complementary funding) will be developed and permits will be acquired for carrying out the renovations. The preparation and monitoring activities foreseen in the work-package will mostly be carried out by project staff, in some specific fields of expertise external consultants will be engaged. Actions in the WP related to concrete renovations will include investments as well as prototype costs (consideration has been given to the budget restrictions no exceeding the investment cost of single item over 500 000 eur). Other costs like permit fees, life notices for communication etc are to be budgeted. Actions foreseen in the WP3: A3.1 Establishing agreements with building owners, tenants; A3.2 Developing building specific technical designs; A3.3 Acquiring permits for renovations; C3.1 Renovation of local municipality and state-owned buildings; C3.2 Task specific renovation pilots in residential buildings; D3.1 Monitoring the efficiency of renovation to reduce the use of operational and embodied energy; D; E tbd by full proposal. Potential complementary Best practices developed within the project will be implemented also on the renovations financed with complementary measures: Pilots TalTech: FINEST TWINS: Establishment of Smart City Center of Excellence (ongoing); Renovation to be carried out with complementary funding (listed also under WP1): • KredEx renovation grant for renovation of apartment buildings; • KredEx reconstruction grant for small residences; • KredEx Housing Loan Guarantee; • KredEx industrial renovation grant; • KredEx support for home renovation for large families; 18 • KIK resource efficiency Grant for industries; • Renovation of corporate buildings by private owners (TBD); • Financial support schemes and business developed within project. SUB-TARGET 2: ESTABLISH CLIMATE RISK EVALUATION CRITERIA FOR DEEP RENOVATION Work package 4: Modelling climate risks, adopting the results in renovation standards and regulations and testing smart adaptation solutions Action foreseen in LTRS: Advancement of technical know-how pg 74. Financed in LIFE Work-package will be oriented towards developing technical competences for adapting renovations with changing climate. Presently the computing parameters used in construction engineering, which consider the climatic conditions the buildings operate in, use historical climate information (Estonian climate 1970- 2000). Future climate scenarios need to be considered so that the renovated building would be climate resilient and operate efficiently. To achieve this, it is firstly needed to develop target specific future climate models and computing parameters (using national climate scenarios developed project according to IPCC methodology). Based on that technical solutions will be prepared for mitigating the climate stresses to the building envelopes. It is also planned to develop planning tools and control interfaces for mitigating flood risks on buildings. Specifically, flooding resilient engineering solutions planned to be developed provide advice on how to design or modify building envelope, in order to promote fast drying and to minimise the extent of necessary renovation works in case of flood water is entering the building. The climate resilience specific solutions will be included to the technical guidelines developed (WP2) and piloted on renovation showcase buildings (WP3). Also, specifically smart flooding control measures will be piloted in the districts where renovation initiative is hampered by regular urban flooding (incl. stormwater flooding and raise of water table in natural waterbodies). The preparation and monitoring activities foreseen in the work-package will mostly be carried out by project staff, in some specific fields of expertise external consultants will be engaged. Actions in the WP related to pilot actions will include investments as well as prototype costs (consideration has been given to the budget restrictions no exceeding the investment cost of single item over 500 000 eur). Other costs like permit fees, life notices for communication etc are to be budgeted. Actions foreseen in the WP4: A4.1 Development of target specific future climate models and computing parameters; A4.2 Preparation of technical solutions for mitigating climate risks for building envelopes (to be included to the technical guidelines A2.1) and piloted on renovation showcase buildings (C3.1 and complementary); A4.3 Development of planning tools and control interfaces for mitigating flood risks to buildings; A4.4 Fitness check for urban stormwater regulation; C4.1 Adopting climate risk considerate renovation principles in existing building standards and regulations; C4.2 Piloting the real-time control systems (MPC; RBC) for smart and cost-efficient flood control and dry-proofing strategy of building envelope; C4.3 Improvement of national urban flood policy and planning tools; D; E tbd by full proposal Potential complementary The technical solutions developed within the project related to the renovation of the buildings will be mainstreamed by adoption of the solutions to standards and guidelines and requirements related to the subsidy schemes (see WP1). Specific solutions related to urban flooding and reducing the flooding duration and intensity damaging to buildings will be mainstreamed by using the KIK grant scheme for urban flood management; where developed smart solutions will be promoted. KeM (planned, submitted as CN): LIFE Clima IP AdaptEst, actions concerning development of improved climate scenarios for Estonia. 19 Also, related research and development activities of project beneficiaries (ongoing and planned) will be used to develop the project toolset: • TalTech: NOAH, Protecting Baltic Sea from untreated wastewater spillages during flood events in urban areas (ongoing); • TalTech: Depart, Decentralized real-time control platform for urban drainage systems in climate proof smart cities (ongoing); • TalTech: CleanStormwater, Testing new storm water treatment solutions for reduction of hazardous substances and toxins inflows into the Baltic Sea (ongoing); • TalTech: TraiNBS, Transition Route to Achieve Integrated Nature Based Solutions for water quality improvement across urban water cycles (requested) • Different research and innovation project are foreseen to be submitted to various financing instruments to advance climate resilience oriented renovation with innovative solutions (planned, not submitted). SUB-TARGET 3: APPLY RESOURCE EFFICIENCY AND CIRCULARITY PRINCIPLES FOR RENOVATION Work package 5: Advancing resource efficiency and circular solutions for renovation Action foreseen in LTRS: Advancement of technical know-how pg. 74; Demolition of abandoned buildings pg. 76. Financed in LIFE Work-package is aimed to reduce the environmental impact of renovation wave concerning vast amounts of construction waste derived from the enforced retrofitting. Firstly, it is aimed to develop national building type specific methodologies for carbon footprint assessment, by transfer and replication of existing experiences available in EU to be adopted in Estonian regulation. The EU Circular Economy Strategy foresees aims to publish the sub-document of Sustainable Built Environment Strategy, according to which a national roadmap is planned to be developed. The roadmap will include a list of complementary measures engaged for its further implementation. Besides developing regulatory and strategical directions in the field, also improvement of technical circularity solutions is needed to design the renovations carried out with the LIFE IP and complementary measures for circularity (design for disassembly, develop technical solutions for reuse of demolished materials etc). The circularity oriented technical solutions will be included to the technical guidelines developed (WP2) and piloted on renovation showcase buildings (WP3). Specifically, additional circularity pilots are to be developed based on the demolition of abandoned buildings. The different circularity-oriented uses of materials demolished during renovations will be piloted in frame of interdisciplinary student workshops to boost creative uses and innovative solutions without practical obstacles. Aside for creativity-oriented student workshops, the repurposing of demolished materials will also be practiced industrially scalable level. Actions foreseen in the WP5: A5.1 Developing national building type specific methodologies and materials database for carbon footprint assessment; A5.2 Developing national roadmap based on Sustainable Built Environment Strategy (sub-document of EU Circular Economy Strategy to be published 2021) A5.3 Assessment of circularity, reuse, and recycling potential of the building materials in typical demolished buildings; A5.4 Preparation of market uptake of circularity, reuse, and recycling solutions of construction waste: applying innovative procurements (incl. GPP), improving regulation on end of waste criteria, mainstreaming product passports etc); A5.5 Developing technical recommendations for improving material circularity in construction (to be included to the technical guidelines A2.1, and dissemination materials E2.1, E2.2) and piloted on renovation showcase buildings (C3.1, C3.2, C3.3) C5.1 Applying building carbon footprint methodology in regulation; C5.2 Demo circularity/reuse/recycle renovations D; E tbd by full proposal 20 Potential complementary Hereby it is needed that project helps to raise relevant complementary funding for the implementation of developed Estonian national roadmap for Sustainable Built Environment Strategy. For this the LIFE IP BUILDEST consortium has to make a joint effort to allocate both national funds as well as to aim for the use of available EU funding. Roadmap and its implementation plan (incl financial plan) will be developed and agreed with relevant authorities. For promoting market uptake of technical solutions advancing circularity in renovations it is planned to engage the ERMEL: Competence centre of circular use of waste; Best practices are expected to be developed using the funds of RaM: Initiative for demolition of abandoned apartment buildings; Related research and development activities of project beneficiaries (ongoing and planned): • TalTech: Drive0, Driving decarbonization of the EU building stock by enhancing a consumer centred and locally based circular renovation process (ongoing); • Different research and innovation project are foreseen to be submitted to various financing instruments to advance circularity and resource efficiency oriented renovation with innovative solutions (planned, not submitted) SUB-TARGET 4: ADVANCE DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES Work package 6: Smart renovation tools Action foreseen in LTRS: Digital tools for energy audits and energy labelling pg 72; Advancement of building registry pg 73; Digital tools for owners pg 73; Advancement of technical know-how pg 74; Fitness checks for policy and decision procedures pg 74. Financed in LIFE Improvement of digital technologies is needed to streamline the deep renovation, as this helps to simplify processes, reach wider audiences, and deliver better results with the same workforce. The digital tools developed are aimed to 1) increase capacity of competence cluster; 2) help building owners understand the need for deep-renovation and develop first idea how the energy performance of their property could be improved; 3) help building owners adopt digital technologies, which aim for improved energy performance of buildings; 4) advance the understanding of the wider impacts of renovations. The work-package includes preparatory work (eg business analyses and development of functional and non-functional requirements) as well as programming and making the developed digital toolset available for the target audience. Actions foreseen in the WP6: A6.1 Development of national principles for applying smart readiness indicator toolset for renovations, piloting the toolset on renovation showcase buildings (C3.1 and complementary); A6.2 Proposing and developing performance-based energy use monitoring system for buildings; A6.3 Preparatory work for development of stakeholder based digital tools for building owners; C6.1 Advancement of e-construction platform with energy performance certificate module; C6.2 Piloting performance-based energy use monitoring system in the Estonian Register of Buildings; C6.3 Producing carbon footprint Building Information Modelling (BIM) resources (“Green BIM”); C6.4 Programming the stakeholder based digital tools for building owners: • Building type specific energy performance calculators (corporate real-estate, detached houses and apartment buildings); • Renovation planning tools for building owners (detached houses and apartment buildings); • Energy performance monitoring tools for state, municipal and corporate real-estate; E6.1 Development of visualization tools for building energy performance combining digital twins for motivating investments; D; E tbd by full proposal Potential complementary It is foreseen that different MKM initiatives related to e-construction platform not directly related to energy performance of buildings and renovation will be linked to the advancement of digital technologies in the 21 LIFE IP BUILDEST (eg digitalization of system networks, advancement of the digital twin of Estonian building stock, etc), the exact synergy is to be developed by full proposal. Related research and development activities of project beneficiaries (ongoing and planned): • TalTech: FinEstTwins smart solutions for energy performance of built environment; • TalTech: Towards a new generation of user-centred Energy Performance Assessment and Certification; facilitated and empowered by the EPB Center (ongoing) • EKYL - VIRTUOUS – Virtualization of Buildings, Prosumers and Users for Improved Comfort and Efficiency • Different research and innovation project are foreseen to be submitted to various financing instruments to advance renovation digitalization with innovative solutions (planned, not submitted). SUB-TARGET 5: INCREASE CAPACITY OF RELEVANT STAKEHOLDERS AND AGGREGATING DEMAND Work package 7: Increasing competences of renovation Action foreseen in LTRS: Fitness checks for policy and decision procedures pg 74; Mainstreaming renovation pg 74; Advancement of technical know-how pg 74. Financed in LIFE Although the whole intervention logic of LIFE IP BUILDEST is based on capacity building, this work- package is specifically dedicated to developing a competence cluster, which will tune and mainstream deep renovation across policies and establish synergies between policy sectors. The competence cluster will be comprised of: • KredEx deep-renovation competence unit, which will hold different (eg technical engineering, financial, social and climate policy) competences and participate in policymaking (WP1) and establishing synergies across policies. The unit will be responsible for monitoring the implementation of LTRS; • RKAS procurement unit, which will advance the local municipality governments competences on how to achieve most cost-optimal solutions for deep renovations initiated on regional levels; • EKÜL and MARK deep renovation unit, which will motivate the private owners to renovate their properties; • Regional units in municipalities (energy agencies, building officials, NGO-s). The work-package will include actions, which will aim to mainstream the deep-renovation with complementary measures – train the relevant stakeholders, promote the measures available, develop documentation how to carry out renovation procurements, provide consultations for application procedures. Also, the action will include the improvement of LTRS and development of long-term operational plan and roadmap to achieve the goals set for 2050. Actions foreseen in the WP7: A7.1 Tuning and mainstreaming renovation across policies: creation of synergies, detaching renovation initiative from ‘siloed’ policies, simplifying processes, and raising awareness of decisionmakers; A7.2 Preparation of long-term operational plan for LTRS to improve the quality of LTRS; A7.3 Developing demo procurement documentation for renovation, including qualification and success criteria for: • Improvement of renovation circularity; • Improvement of climate resilience; • Maximizing cost-efficiency of energy performance. • Piloting the procurements in showcase renovation buildings (C3.1, C3.2, C3.3) E7.1 Training key stakeholders (municipal building officials, technical regulation officers etc); 22 E7.2 Renovation innovations competition D; E tbd by full proposal Potential complementary Related research and development activities of project beneficiaries (ongoing and planned): • EKYL - SHEERenov – Seamless services for Housing Energy Efficiency Renovation (ongoing); • EKYL - POWERPOOR - Empowering Energy Poor Citizens through Energy Cooperative Initiatives ; (ongoing); • EKYL - EnergyTakeaway - Enabling and Supporting Householders to Tackle Energy Poverty (requested); • EKYL - WE NERGY - Living Labs for Consumer Empowerment and Collectively Driven Energy Actions (requested); Work package 8: Aggregation of demand Action foreseen in LTRS: Awareness raising (pg 75). Financed in LIFE As described above, in section “1. Overall context”, there are a wide variety of barriers hindering the full implementation of LTRS and it is expected that with present mechanisms the aimed renovation rate will not be achieved. This project will provide solutions or toolset for most of the identified barriers, but in addition significant attention has to be given to raising the building owner’s awareness about the possibilities made available for them. Work-package will include campaigning as well as direct consultations to key stakeholders representing the low performing target-groups. Actions foreseen in the WP8: E8.1 Cross-media campaigns to raise awareness on the renovation policy among key target groups incl • Private residential building owners and self-taught builders; • Low performing apartment building associations; • Business real-estate owners; • Real estate managing companies; • Local municipality governments. E8.2 Consulting services for low performing target-groups with high impact on improvement of energy performance, incl: • Low performing apartment building associations; • Local municipality governments. Potential complementary Related research and development activities of project beneficiaries (ongoing and planned): • EKYL: SMART FINANCE EST – Estonian National Roundtable to Implement Smart Financing for Smart Buildings (ongoing); • EKYL - EnergyTakeaway - Enabling and Supporting Householders to Tackle Energy Poverty (requested); • EKYL - WE NERGY - Living Labs for Consumer Empowerment and Collectively Driven Energy Actions (requested); Work package 9: LIFE IP project management Financed in LIFE The purpose of the work package is to manage the project in a well-coordinated manner to ensure that it is implemented according to its purpose. To achieve this, the project will be managed transparently with efficient and open decision-making and communication process. Efficient project execution will be joint responsibility of project beneficiaries and will be carried out in a supervision of coordinating beneficiary. Coordinating beneficiary will be responsible for the general grant management (administrative, technical, and financial aspects) and for fulfilling the reporting obligation set in grant agreement. The 23 Coordinator will also act as a permanent helpdesk for all project participants, providing practical support particularly for the compilation of Financial Statements in compliancy with the LIFE regulation and the Grant Agreement and its annexes, where necessary. Also, disseminating project results according to LIFE communication rules, project communication strategy and replication plan. Project overall communication will be achieved by launching and regularly updating a website (with members only section, stakeholder specific content, references to relevant LIFE, EC, project network information etc). Management team will be established between project beneficiaries in the start of the project for the operational coordination of the project. Coordinating beneficiary will employ general project manager and technical assistant for fulfilling the grant management duties. Other beneficiaries will decide whether to employ separate (part-time) manager for the project or use existing staff also for the grant management related tasks. The work routines and rules of the project management team will be agreed in the beginning of the project and different working documents will be developed for simplifying the further work, these are • project management wiki: agreements, example documents, establishing network of contact persons; • communication strategy; • transferability and replication strategy; • tuned monitoring program (including KPI and complementary monitoring); Project management team will be jointly responsible for monitoring of KPI and impacts of complementary measures. In the frame of project management work-package also international cooperation with EU projects is foreseen, in which it is foreseen that all beneficiaries participate. Steering panel. Considering the importance of the project and its relevance to several policy fields, a high level steering panel will be set up consisting coordinating beneficiary (MKM, ministries of finance (RaM) and environment (KeM), research institution (TalTech) and representative of demand side (EKÜL). The Steering Committee will be responsible for cording the long-term planning of the project and steering the progress, also it will direct projects coherence with overall policy and initiatives in the sector and additionally guard background rights, foreground rights and protection of knowledge, if necessary. Actions foreseen in the WP9: A9.1 Development of project management wiki: agreements, example documents, establishing network of contact persons; A9.2 Preparing and agreeing internal plans for the beneficiaries, including: • communication strategy; • tuned monitoring program; • transferability and replication strategy. D9.1 Monitoring of KPI; D9.2 Monitoring of impacts of complementary measures; E9.1 Disseminating project results according to LIFE communication rules, project communication strategy and replication plan, web, media, etc E9.2 Project networking with similar projects and international cooperation; F9.1 Grant management among all beneficiaries: operational management, steering, reporting, auditing etc (F). F9.2 Engaging additional complementary funding to increase renovation rate and depth; Potential complementary Distributing project experiences via different projects (list of projects provided in CNf). 24 4. Expected results (main outputs and achievements, qualitative and quantitative): Sub-target 1: DEVELOP, TEST AND DEMONSTRATE TOOLS FOR DECARBONIZING ESTONIA’S EXISTING BUILDING STOCK WP1: Development of stakeholder specific financial models and policy instruments for deep renovation Result Relates Immediate effect Replication potential to actions of project Deep renovation policy improvement A1.1- 10-15 regulative Whole Estonia (financial measures regulation, A1.5 acts improved coherence between sectoral C1.1 regulations etc) Efficient stakeholder specific financial A1.3- 6-10 financial Whole Estonia instruments developed/improved and A1.5 models implemented as complementary to finance deep renovations during and after the project Complementary: Processing (managing payments, internal monitoring, gathering data) the existing financial schemes (6 instruments), further use of complementary tbd by full proposal. WP2: Development of building and stakeholder type specific technical solutions and guidelines to streamline the renovation Result Relates Immediate effect Replication potential to actions of project Technical solutions for deep A2.1, 4 sets of building ~ 100,000 detached houses (14 million renovations (considering also results A2.2 type specific m²) from WP4 and WP5) with demo guidelines ~14,000 apartment buildings (18 million designs m²) ~27,000 non-residential buildings (of 22 detached and terraced houses, million m²) apartment buildings, corporate and ~5,300 historical monuments, ~ 10,000 public buildings, and valuable building in milieu valuable areas. historical buildings Development of guidelines for A2.3 1 guideline greening buildings during renovations Advancement of prefabricated A2.4 3 reports ~ 7,000 apartment buildings (9 million renovation solutions m²) ~ 3000 public buildings (3 million m²) Compilation and publishing renovation E2.1 20-50 charts ~ 100,000 detached houses (14 million info-charts m²) ~ 5,000 apartment buildings (6 million m²) Training materials for professional E2.2 10 training 20 000 specialists / workers in builders programs, construction sector involved with guideline renovation Stakeholder specific examples for E2.3 4 sets of building ~ 100,000 detached houses (14 million technical terms of reference type specific m²) guidelines ~ 14,000 apartment buildings (18 million m²) ~ 27,000 non-residential buildings (of 22 million m²) ~ 5,300 historical monuments, ~ 10,000 building in milieu valuable areas. Complementary: Best practices related to technical solutions for renovation developed externally in separate research and innovation projects (10 technical reports). Further use of complementary tbd by full proposal. WP3: Renovation showcase: pilots, demos, and best-practices buildings Result Relates Immediate effect Replication potential to actions of project Preparation (permits, agreements A3.1- 30-40 buildings ~ 100,000 detached houses (14 million etc), technical designs A3.3 prepared for m²) renovation (project ~ 14,000 apartment buildings (18 million + complementary) m²) 25 Renovated buildings C3.1 10-20 buildings ~ 27,000 non-residential buildings (of 22 C3.2 renovated in million m²) innovative way ~ 5,300 historical monuments, ~ 10,000 building in milieu valuable areas. Complementary: Pilot renovations immediately prepared by IP: • District level deep renovation of multistorey buildings: 1-2 city blocks; • Improvement of energy performance of historical buildings, street-level approach: 1 street; • Piloting cooperation models and business solutions: 5-10 buildings. Deep renovation carried out for >8000 buildings; Further use of complementary tbd by full proposal. Sub-target 2: ESTABLISH CLIMATE RISK EVALUATION CRITERIA FOR DEEP RENOVATION WP4: Modelling climate risks, adopting the results in renovation standards and regulations and testing smart adaption solutions Result Relates Immediate effect Replication potential to actions of project Specific climate models and A4.1 4-6 task specific Whole Estonia (new buildings and computing parameters for buildings models renovations); eg hygrothermal performance of buildings (1), indoor climate (1-2), energy efficiency Selection methods are replicable in all (1), service systems (1-2), material countries in cold climate region resilience (1) Technical solutions for addressing A4.2, 5-7 construction Whole Estonia (new buildings and climate risks for buildings developed C4.1 standards renovations) improved based on renewed computing parameters Planning tool for urban stormwater A4.3 1 GIS-integrated Whole Estonia (urban settlements with control and prevention tool UDS) The tool applied will be replicable in urban areas with temperate climate; Piloting the real-time control systems C4.2 1-3 pilot sites Whole Estonia (urban settlements with (MPC; RBC) for smart and cost- UDS) efficient flood control Improvement of national urban flood C4.3 1-2 regulative acts Whole Estonia policy and planning tools improved 1 Guideline for Guideline developed will be replicable in urban stormwater urban areas with temperate climate; management improved Complementary: Smart solutions for urban stormwater management replicated in other regions (3-5 projects). Further use of complementary tbd by full proposal. Sub-target 3: APPLY RESOURCE EFFICIENCY AND CIRCULARITY PRINCIPLES FOR RENOVATION WP5: Advancing resource efficiency and circular solutions for renovation Result Relates Immediate effect Replication potential to actions of project National building type specific A5.1 1 regulative act Whole Estonia (new buildings and methodologies for carbon footprint C5.1 (established/impro renovations) assessment applied in regulation ved) Developing national roadmap based A5.2 1 approved Whole Estonia (new buildings and on Sustainable Built Environment roadmap renovations) Strategy Circularity, reuse, and recycling A5.3 1 report Reuse, recycling, and circular use of potential assessment report for >70% materials of renovated buildings, demolished buildings 0.9 mil. tons / year. Export potential to other countries 26 Market uptake of circularity, reuse, A5.4 1 – 3 end of waste 0.9 mil. Tons construction waste / year and recycling solutions of construction criteria improved; reduced in renovations carried out in waste 1 procurement Estonia guidelines Circularity, reuse, and recycling pilots A5.5, 5 educational Export potential to other countries & demos C5.2 pavilions 1-3 – pilot building Complementary: Measures engaged and developed to implement national sustainable built environment roadmap (tbd during project). Operation of EKÜL competence centre for circular use of building waste. Further use of complementary tbd by full proposal. Sub-target 4: ADVANCE DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES WP6: Smart renovation tools Result Relates Immediate effect Replication potential to actions of project Smart readiness indicator toolset for A6.1 1 report ~ 100,000 detached houses (14 million renovations 3-5 building m²) specific designs ~ 14,000 apartment buildings (18 million for C3.1 buildings m²) ~ 27,000 non-residential buildings (of 22 million m²) ~ 5,300 historical monuments, ~ 10,000 building in milieu valuable areas. Performance-based energy use A6.2 1 report All buildings heated by electricity and/or monitoring system for buildings C6.2 1 monitoring district heating module E-construction web platform A6.3, 1 platform Whole Estonia (new buildings and development for renovations C6.1 renovations) Export potential to other countries Carbon footprint Building Information C6.2 1 set of resources Whole Estonia (new buildings and Modelling (BIM) resources (“Green renovations) BIM”); Export potential to other countries Stakeholder based digital tools for A6.3, 5-10 different Whole Estonia (new buildings and building owners: incl building type C6.4 tools; renovations) specific energy performance calculators (private, business, Export potential to other countries apartment buildings); renovation planning tools for residential buildings (apartment buildings and private houses); energy performance monitoring tools for municipal real- estate. Visualization tools for building energy E6.1 1 web application Whole Estonia (new buildings and performance combining digital twins renovations): services related to real- for motivating investments developed estate, insurance, etc Export potential to other countries Complementary: Advanced digital twin of Estonian building stock (incl relevant datasets of networks etc). Advanced e-construction platform. Established digital twin of Estonian urban stormwater drainage (USD). Further use of complementary tbd by full proposal. Sub-target 5: INCREASE CAPACITY OF RELEVANT STAKEHOLDERS AND AGGREGATING DEMAND WP7: Increasing competences of renovation Result Relates Immediate effect Replication potential to actions of project Renovation consultants cluster A7.1- Increased Regional consultancies may be involved A7.2 capacities and to the competence cluster. synergies on renovation policy implementation 27 across sectors and stakeholders Improved procurement documentation A7.3 10-30 - Demo All public building stock procurements prepared Training of key stakeholders E7.1 50 expert/year 20 000 specialists / workers in construction sector involved with renovation Renovation innovations competition E7.2 Innovation Whole Estonia (new buildings and competition (3-5 renovations) times) Export potential to other countries Complementary: MKM initiatives on long-term view to construction policy; Development of vocational education programmes. Advancement of renovation skills in construction vocational education (tbd). Further use of complementary tbd by full proposal. WP8: Aggregation of demand Result Relates Immediate effect Replication potential to actions of project Cross-media campaigns to raise E8.1- 2000 building ~ 100,000 detached houses (14 million awareness on the renovation policy E8.2 owners reached m²) among key target groups via project / year ~ 14,000 apartment buildings (18 million m²) min 10 000 people ~ 27,000 non-residential buildings (of 22 reached / year million m²) ~ 5,300 historical monuments, ~ 10,000 building in milieu valuable areas. Complementary: MKM initiatives on long-term view to construction policy; Development of vocational education programmes. Further use of complementary tbd by full proposal. WP9: Project management Result Relates Immediate effect Replication potential to actions of project Project management wiki A9.1 1 members-only Not relevant section in web Internal project management A9.2 3-5 guidelines Not relevant guidelines for beneficiaries, incl: developed • communication strategy; • tuned monitoring program; • transferability and replication strategy. KPI monitoring D9.1 4 reports Not relevant Complementary monitoring D9.2 4 reports Not relevant Project communication E9.1 1 webpage Not relevant 1 Laymans report 20-30 info boards Tbd Project networking E9.2 10-15 visits to Not relevant similar project; 10-30 guest tours accepted Grant management F.1 3 progress Not relevant reports; 1 final report; Project audits; Overall coordination Engagement of additional F.2 5-10 projects Not relevant complementary funding 28 5. Expected contribution to the implementation of the target plan/strategy LIFE IP BUILDEST is a crucial tool for calibrating the implementation of the Estonian long-term renovation strategy (LTRS) and create positive impacts to economy and environment (figure 6). The project consortium initiatives will be tuned to maximize the joint effort across sectors to achieve the planned renovation depth and rate. Also, the coordinated framework established by LIFE IP BUILDEST is expected to efficiently use already reserved finances and generate new funding for the LTRS implementation. The LIFE IP BUILDEST will augment the renovation with digital advancements, capacity building, knowledge-based decisions and processes, cross-cutting synergies. Development of demonstration objects as well as testing pilots and awareness raising are needed to accelerate demand. LTRS is ambitious and sets high aims in achieving an energy efficient building stock in Estonia, but it lacks operational context and clear roadmap. LIFE IP BUILDEST will promote the adaptivity of LTRS, by developing the long-term operational plan for achieving goals set in the strategy. The short-term operational plan is to be submitted with the full proposal. During the project, the funds of IP and complimentary will aim to implement 25% of the LTRS, but the project will lay out the path for the full implementation as it will solve the main obstacles hindering the process. In addition, actions of LIFE IP BUILDEST contribute to the implementation of other national strategies and roadmaps such as NECP, NAS, SECAPs etc. LIFE IP BUILDEST is expected to use both LIFE IP project funding as well as a variety of complementary funding to achieve the aims of LTRS. Figure 6 A capacity building oriented LIFE IP BUILDEST project will direct the national policy, provide necessary toolset and establish necessary examples for smooth and steady growth of renovation rate to achieve the necessary target without minimal negative impacts. 6. Main stakeholders involved in the project: PROJECT BENEFICIARIES Project beneficiaries are expected to be involved in the implementation of the project actions (exact role is to be determined by full proposal). 29 Present consortium consists of the organizations, which play a key role in coordinating the implementation of LTRS. The ministries (MKM, RaM, KeM) involved in the project direct the policymaking in the sector, state agencies (KredEx, KIK, RKAS) apply the respective policy in practice. The involved NGO-s 1) represent the construction markets supply side (EEL) and will spread the project results to the sector, while also influencing the policymaking by their practical insights; 2) represent the renovation demand and participate in development of socially responsible policy (EKÜL – apartment buildings, MARK – detached houses and rural architecture); 3) represent the circular building industry (ERMEL) and provide the sectoral know-how to the resource efficient renovation sub-theme. Research institutions involved to the project represent the top Estonian Universities (TalTech and EKA) in the field of building engineering, architecture, and cultural heritage in the built environment and climate modelling. Local municipalities selected to the project as beneficiaries all act as renovation leaders in Estonia (having previous replicable experiences in coordination of renovation). See each beneficiaries’ specific competences described below. Project consortium is co-operation oriented and has good experiences with working with expert networks expected to be engaged via direct consultations, revision panels and thematic think-tanks. Also, all the project consortium members have previous experiences in participating in EU projects and have proven as reliable partners. The involvement of beneficiaries to the work-packages of different sub-targets of the project is preliminarily explained in Annex II, figure II-2. Ministries Name of the associated beneficiary (2): MINISTY OF FINANCE (RaM) The area of government of the Ministry of Finance includes planning and implementation of the budgetary, resource management, tax, and financial policies of the state. In LIFE IP BUILDEST RaM is expected to participate in the development, piloting and testing of policy instruments for renovation wave in Estonia. Name of the associated beneficiary (3): MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT (KeM) The area of government of the KeM includes: organising of national environmental and nature protection, organising the use, protection, re-production and accounting for natural resources, performing tasks related to decrease of climate change, environmental supervision, /…/, organising the use of external tools for environmental protection, as well as compiling strategic documents and draft legislation. In LIFE IP BUILDEST KeM is expected to be responsible for participating in advancement of climate adaption of built environment and resource efficiency of renovations. State subordinated organizations Name of the associated beneficiary (4): FOUNDATION KREDEX (KredEx) KredEx is a foundation set up by the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications with the aim of providing financial solutions for implementing national policies. For companies, KredEx offers loans, venture capital, credit insurance and state-backed guarantees for faster development and safe expansion into foreign markets. For private individuals and apartment associations, KredEx offers state- backed guarantees and grants for purchasing dwellings and improving their energy efficiency. In LIFE IP BUILDEST KredEx is expected to be responsible for: Development of financial motivation schemes and measures for implementation of LTRS; Advancement of the consultation service for building owners and competence centre; Replicating the project results with complementary funding; etc. Name of the associated beneficiary (5): ENVIRONMENTAL INVESTMENTS CENTRE (KIK) KIK is a foundation subordinated by Ministry of Environment of Estonia. It acts as one of the main financiers of environmental projects in Estonia. In LIFE IP BUILDEST project KIK is expected to be responsible for: Establishing links of LTRS implementation to Estonian smart and climate resilient city initiatives; Advancing motivation schemes for deep renovations; Participating in the circular building interventions; Contributing thematic complementary funding (field of circular building; energy networks). Name of the associated beneficiary (6): STATE REAL ESTATE Ltd (RKAS) RKAS is a real estate development and management company established for the efficient management of state real estate in 2001. The company is 100% owned by the Republic of Estonia and its shares are controlled by the Ministry of Finance. In LIFE IP BUILDEST RKAS is expected to be responsible for: Developing and carrying out pilot renovations; Demonstrating best practices with complementary 30 initiatives; Development and showcasing digital tools and technologies; Leading the renovation process among municipalities and providing necessary competences (procurements etc). Research institutions Name of the associated beneficiary (7): TALLINN UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY (TalTech) TalTech, the only university of technology in Estonia, is the flagship of Estonian engineering and technology education. In LIFE IP BUILDEST TalTech is expected to be responsible the technical competence in the project implementation, including: Renovation technical knowledge: deep renovations of different buildings, energy performance of buildings; building physics, building structures, climate modelling and mitigation the climate risks in built environment, civil engineering for circular buildings etc; Preparing the interventions, monitoring project results and offering expert knowledge for dissemination of project results. Name of the associated beneficiary (8): ESTONIAN ACADEMY OF ARTS (EKA) Estonian Academy of Arts is the only public university in Estonia providing higher education in fine arts, design, architecture, media, visual studies, art history, and conservation. In LIFE IP BUILDEST EKA is expected to be responsible the technical competence in the project implementation, including: Renovation technical knowledge on historical buildings, architectural design favouring circularity and energy efficiency of buildings etc; Preparing the interventions, monitoring project results, and offering expert knowledge for dissemination of project results. Local municipalities In LIFE IP BUILDEST project local municipalities acting as lighthouse towns are the renovation leaders and will replicate its experiences to other local municipalities that will participate the project as external stakeholders. The listed municipalities are expected to host several concrete actions, whereas the municipalities will each lead different scalable cooperation models, exact roles tbd by full proposal. Name of the associated beneficiary (9): Tallinn City Government (Tallinn) Tallinn being the largest city and capital of Estonia is an important leader in terms of climate ambition initiatives. Name of the associated beneficiary (10): Tartu City Government (Tartu) Represents the large settlements of Estonia. Tartu aims to drive district level deep renovation initiative for multi-storey apartment buildings and participate in the initiatives developed for detached buildings and push forward the renovation of public buildings. Name of the associated beneficiary (11): Rakvere Town Government (Rakvere) Represents the medium sized growing settlements. Rakvere aims to advance the energy performance oriented renovation of historical buildings and smart solutions to control urban floods. Name of the associated beneficiary (12): Võru Town Government (Võru) Represents the medium sized declining settlements. Võru will lead the change for small apartment buildings and detached houses and propose circular solutions for renovations to be used in declining municipalities. NGO’s Name of the associated beneficiary (13): The Estonian Union of Co-operative Housing Associations (EKYL) EKYL is an independent non-profit working across Estonia to support apartment associations and to represent their interests on local, national and international level. The Union has more than 1400 members (apartment associations). In LIFE IP BUILDEST EKYL is expected to be responsible (exact role is to be determined by full proposal) for: Aggregating demand among its members, enforcing and consulting the low performing housing associations; Developing digital tools for energy efficiency in performance of apartment building and their maintenance. Name of the associated beneficiary (14): Centre of Rural Architecture (MARK) 31 Centre of Rural Architecture (MARK) is a department of the Estonian Open-Air Museum. Its main activities include researching Estonian vernacular rural architecture and landscapes, organizing practical trainings, seminars and public events, co-ordinating house counsellors´ network. In LIFE IP BUILDEST MARK is expected to be responsible for: Aggregating demand among the owners of historical buildings and promote the use of solutions developed within the project; Participating in the process of developing technical guidelines for renovations. Name of the associated beneficiary (15): Estonian Association of Construction Entrepreneurs (EEEL) EEEL is a voluntary association of construction enterprises created to support and co-ordinate its members actions in matter of industry related economic issues and relations with employees and employee unions. In LIFE IP BUILDEST EEEL is expected to be responsible for Representing construction companies in policy development; Informing construction companies, campaigning about renovation policies. Name of the associated beneficiary (16): Estonian Circular Economy Industries Association (ERMEL) Estonian Circular Economy Industries Association (ERMEL) was established in 1996 as non – profit association by 26 waste management companies. ERMEL has 30 members (majority private waste management companies). ERMEL is a member of FEAD (European Federation of Waste Management and Environmental Services) since 2008. In LIFE IP BUILDEST EJKL is expected to be responsible for: Development of circularity of buildings, advancement of best practices for typical buildings and materials demolished in renovations; Participating in awareness raising. 32 TABLE 1: Most relevant Stakeholder groups planned to be engaged with the project Organization Field of expertise Type of involvement Specific technical experiences, eg Association of Architects; Association of Civil Engineers; Woodhouse Association; Association of Construction Material Cooperation (meetings, consultations) Producers; Society of Heating and Ventilation needed for improvement of technical PROFESSIONAL Engineers; Union of Roofers and Facade solutions and disseminating them via ASSOCIATIONS OF Makers; Association of Architectural and guidelines. In some field’s involvement is EXPERTS Consulting Engineering Companies etc needed also as external expertise. PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATIONS Cooperation (meetings, consultations) AND CLUSTERS OF needed for improvement of technical REAL ESTATE Market know-how on corporate and residential solutions and disseminating them via ENTREPRENEURS real-estate market, renovation interest etc guidelines Cooperation (meetings, consultations) Market know-how on renovation supply, needed for improvement of technical CONSTRUCTION market-demand, potential for the innovations to solutions and disseminating them via COMPANIES be adopted by the market guidelines. Expertise on resource efficient and energy Cooperation (meetings, consultations) is performance-oriented renovation. foreseen in the field of developing Different fields of expertise: Stockholm renovation guidelines, sustainable Environmental Institute Tallinn, University of building roadmap etc. In some field’s RESEARCH, Tartu, Technopolis consult, Municipal Energy involvement is needed also as external SCIENCE Agencies, Tallinn Technical School etc expertise. Cooperation (meetings, consultations) is ASSOCIATION OF foreseen in the field of developing ESTONIAN CITIES Involvement of local municipalities and raising renovation guidelines, sustainable AND their capacities on coordinating deep building roadmap etc. Potential MUNICIPALITIES renovation beneficiary tbd by full proposal. Cooperation (meetings, consultations) is Renovation of historical buildings: state foreseen with the national cross-sectoral MINISTRY OF initiatives, regulation; Spatial Design Expert Group, renovation CULTURE Spatial Design coordination of heritage buildings etc Renovation of historical buildings: expertise on specific requirements for pilot buildings, Cooperation (meetings, consultations) is NATIONAL expertise for the guidelines, replication of foreseen in the field of renovation of HERITAGE BOARD guidelines; heritage buildings; ESTONIAN Possibly engaged as external ENVIRONMENTAL Assessing the possibilities to reducing consultant, or involved as beneficiary by LAW CENTER renovation impact on environment by the full proposal if proves necessary and (EELC): improvement of legislation can be agreed; Synergies with renovation and green ENTERPRISE Expertise on entrepreneurship grants available, recovery and innovation procurements, ESTONIA (EAS): developing procurement innovations etc cooperation (meetings, consultations) THE CONSUMER Cooperation (meetings, consultations) is PROTECTION AND foreseen in the field of developing TECHNICAL renovation guidelines. Also, practical REGULATORY Expertise on market regulation and technical cooperation is needed on the renovation AUTHORITY (TTJA): requirements in the construction sector showcase buildings. MEDIA CHANNELS Dissemination of project results to wider public. SPECIALIZED ON Promoting the project outputs and progress. Cooperation in implementing the CONSTRUCTION ehitusuudised.ee, TV program “Nurgakivi”, communication plan developed within ISSUES building related annexes of main newspapers the project. Transferring existing best practices to Estonia, replication of the experience gained via IP BUILDEST to other EU countries. EU LEVEL Housing Europe, BuildUp platform, eu.ESCO, PROFESSIONAL European Association of Energy Service NETWORKS Companies etc Experience exchange EU Policy on renovation (and the impacted Experience exchange. Contributing to EU AGENCIES sectors) EE policymaking, reporting etc. EASME, EEIG Communication on grant management: NEEMO LIFE regulation, Grant management etc reporting, monitoring, consultations 33 The table above does not represent a complete list of stakeholders and is to be elaborated by Full Proposal. Significant stakeholders influencing the LTRS thematically and contributing relevant know- how are to be involved as external stakeholders (see thematic involvement also on figure 7). TARGET AUDIENCE Project dissemination is targeted to the following audience: • Owners of private residential buildings: cross media campaign explaining the need and introducing possible solutions is foreseen. The campaign involves on site events, social media campaign, pitches in traditional media, dissemination of renovation info-charts etc; • Cooperative housing associations management: the target group is aimed to be reached with info events, direct consultation with low performing owners associations, mentoring program; • Owners of corporate buildings: real-estate fairs, establishment of consultant network, direct consultation with real-estate management companies etc; • Individual experts (architects, engineers, local municipality officials – construction, waste, planning etc), Construction, engineering and architecture students: organizing and participating thematic professional seminars, conferences, training programs, publishing project results in scientific and professional journals and info-channels; • General public – exhibitions, general media work (appearance in TV; magazines and newspapers etc). 7. Long term sustainability (including capacity building, replication and transfer): The strategy foresees the need to renovate ~100 000 private residential buildings with the total area of 14 mln m², 14 000 apartment buildings with the total area of 18 mln m² and 27 000 non-residential (corporate and public) buildings with the total area of 22 mln m². LTRS has indicated without clear intervention it is expected that about 80% of the private residential, 68% of the apartment buildings and 60% of the non-residential buildings would not be renovated. The present project aims to develop needed mechanisms to pave the way towards full implementation of LTRS and engage needed funds to mainstream the renovation across country. The LIFE IP BUILDEST project includes measures, which have a substantial effect for guiding the renovation towards a knowledge based, industrially scalable and efficiency-oriented nation-wide renovation program. Key factors of success to achieve long term sustainability: • Project involves key authorities influencing renovation policy in Estonia: Main stakeholders responsible for the implementation of LTRS will be participating the project as beneficiaries and contributing the competences and available funds to achieve the successful full implementation of LTRS also after the project is completed. Project is planned and implemented in a high-level steering of 3 ministries: MKM, KeM and RaM. The project consortium includes state and private entities and both authorities active in relevant policymaking, as well as representatives of demand and supply chain. • Project sets a significant focus on the measures oriented for capacity building: developing stakeholder specific guidelines for different building types, development of national standards and improving regulation (national and regional legislation, both on financial measures as well as requirements level), training of experts and providing them the necessary digital tools to fasten the processes and improve the needed services, developing financial models and subsidy schemes; • Project will be establishing demonstration and best-practice showcase, development and testing of pilots to prove that the renovation solutions are tangible and provide evident effect for the owners. The project aims to develop renovation best practices that are easily scalable across the whole country and have replication potential also in other countries – these are prefabricated offsite renovation of large, multi-storey buildings (apartment buildings, public houses etc), energy efficient conservation of historic buildings, climate resilient solutions for typical building envelopes, climate adaption solutions for technical systems, circular renovation 34 possibilities (NB design for future disassembly) and adopting certified reused/recycled materials; • Best practices developed within the project can be prolonged for the full implementation of LTRS and engaged complementary measures (presently available as well as planned) guarantee the necessary funding. • Project will engage additional complementary funding (funds from EU budget period 2021-2027 and beyond, also national funding and private investments). • Project will improve the national long-term renovation strategy and develop a long-term feasible operational plan for LTRS. • Project beneficiaries will commit to the dissemination of project results after the project. The vision of achieved impact after LIFE IP BUILDEST Building owners are informed about the need for deep renovation and have access to the information about the financial and technical solutions how to retrofit their properties into highly energy efficient buildings. Funding mechanisms for full implementation of LTRS are in place, procedures are rational, processes smooth and requirements made understandable and accessible for the stakeholders. Developed measures consider social and regional differences and different financial capacities. Standardized technical solutions used in renovations ensure safer, climate resilient and more environmentally friendly building stock. Entrepreneurs offering renovation solutions have adopted the innovative sustainability and climate resilience oriented technical solutions. Agencies responsible for implementing LTRS have needed tools (guidelines, databases, smart applications etc). 8. Expected major constraints and risks of the: Renovations are grant dependant Relevance IP/Complementary: specific to complementary Risk level: high Actions affected: work-package 1 Description: Present process of preparing the LTRS has shown that Estonian construction market, real- estate situation and energy pricing policies do not motivate owners to renovate unless grants cover significant share of the needed investment. Solution: Project aims to develop business models, innovative financing schemes and motivations other than grants that should develop market-based initiative for renovation. Renovation will generate massive amounts of construction waste and produce negative environmental impact possibly larger than the benefit gained from improvement of energy performance (during and after the LIFE IP) Relevance IP/Complementary: Affects IP & Complementary Risk level: high Actions affected: work-package 5 Description: When not considering the environmental impacts of the renovation, the increased use of embodied energy of buildings, waste of materials, need for extraction of virgin materials all will affect public perception towards renovation and reduce owners willingness to carry out the needed deep- renovations in expense of using increased amounts of energy. Solution: Project will advance circular building concept and adopt carbon footprint concept for building regulation, which will aim to reduce the negative environmental impacts of the renovation initiative. “Siloed” policies Relevance IP/Complementary: Affects IP & Complementary Risk level: medium 35 Actions affected: all Description: Main responsibility in implementing LTRS lays in the jurisdiction of Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, still the success of the actuation and quality of the implementation depends on the coherence of several policies (financial, environmental, educational etc). Solution: Project capacity building activities as well as shared initiatives between different ministries and their jurisdictions is expected to develop tuned operation also for wider success of LTRS, both during project as well as follow-ups foreseen with After-life schemes. Low initiative of owners Relevance IP/Complementary: Affects IP & Complementary Actions affected: all Description: Low performing companies, local municipalities and also private owners with no interest in carrying out deep renovations hinder the needed improvement of Estonian building sock energy performance, even if there are solutions available in the market to help finance the needed investments. Solution: Project will aim to increase demand, develop relevant regulations, financial schemes and promote good examples that is expected impel also the low performing owners. Coordination challenges Relevance IP/Complementary: Specific to IP Risk level: medium Actions affected: all Description: Project actions are not independent sub-projects, but interlinked system of mechanisms that should be developed in coordination, to achieve best results (renovation guidelines, technical solutions (industrialization/climate resilience solutions etc), policy mechanisms, climate modelling, circular building concept etc). Solution: Good planning, communication and coordination is needed for the development intertwined mechanisms, which is considered already presently while negotiating potential content, timeframe, and volume of planned project actions. Long-term commitment to 8-year project (policy risk) Relevance IP/Complementary: Specific to IP Risk level: low Actions affected: all Description: Project duration exceeds the regular 4-year state budget planning timeframe. For the development of financial plan of the project and reserving the needed own contribution, exemptions are required. Solution: Project development is carried out in close coordination of high-level steering of relevant state authorities, ensuring the necessary financial commitment to the project. Long-term commitment to Full implementation of LTRS (political risk) Relevance IP/Complementary: Affects IP & Complementary Risk level: low Actions affected: all Description: Long-term commitment to a strategy aiming the ambitious improvement of energy performance of Estonian building stock can be hindered by different oriented political interest. Solution: Project development is carried out in close coordination of high-level steering of relevant state authorities, ensuring the necessary financial commitment to the project. Involvement of relevant stakeholders (EU and national) keeps the priority of the initiative. Administrational challenges Relevance IP/Complementary: Specific to IP Risk level: low Actions affected: all Description: LIFE IP project management is a resource demanding joint effort of project beneficiaries. Inexperienced and uncommitted staff can undermine the project overall effect. Solution: Voluminous LIFE project coordination is carefully planned during proposal preparation to provide possibilities for good communication and coherence of operation between project beneficiaries, experts, stakeholders, and general public. Project will develop administrational guidelines (project management wiki, communication strategy, replication plan etc) for project beneficiaries to be followed 36 for successful project management. All project beneficiaries are competent and skilled with implementation of international projects. Long-term sustainability of the project actions Relevance IP/Complementary: Specific to IP Risk level: low Actions affected: all Description: If the project should remain as a collection of single actions with no established connections to the wider policy and continuity via complementary measures in the future, it would diminish the effect of the project. Solution: We have addressed the sustainability already in the current phase of project development via action development towards wide implementation of best practices: we will use and develop best practices, educate key stakeholders, deliver improved policy and ensure that best practices for renovation are reasoned and worth of being continued and full implementation of LTRS is achieved. 9. a) Is your project significantly climate related? Yes X No b) Is your project significantly biodiversity-related? Yes No X If you consider your project to be significantly climate or biodiversity-related (you marked 'yes'), please explain why: The building sector is the largest single energy consumer in Estonia, as also in Europe general. The operation of buildings is responsible for 36% of the EU’s carbon dioxide (CO₂) emissions a key greenhouse gas (GHG) that is causing planetary warming and climate change. The GHG emissions from material extraction, manufacturing of construction products, and the construction and renovation of buildings are estimated at between 5-12% of total national GHG emission. Full implementation of LTRS that the current LIFE IP BUILDEST project will target helps to reduce the CO ₂ emissions in housing stock up to 90%. LIFE IP BUILDEST aims to reduce wider environmental impact of renovation. It does not specifically focus on reducing biodiversity loss related to the renovation but consider the impact in guidelines and raise the public awareness on the issue. The project will propose possibilities to adopt green building solutions in renovations (green roofs, green walls etc) and develop guidelines how to handle biodiversity related issues in renovations (human settlement dependent wildlife – bats, birds etc, including Natura 2000 species listed in the directives 2009/147/EC and 92/43/EEC). 37 LIFE Integrated Projects 2020 - CNe MAP OF THE GENERAL LOCATION OF THE PROJECT AREA(S) IN THE COUNTRY/REGION Figure 7: The LIFE IP BUILDEST project will tackle the whole Estonia as the project site. Demo and Pilot sites are to be developed mainly in selected partner towns (lighthouse towns have marked with LIFE flag), which operate as centres of excellence in terms of leading deep renovation of buildings and implementing LTRS. Concrete actions that base on the best practices of the project and are funded by complementary funding are to be implemented in whole Estonia. The project has included renovation motivated municipalities as beneficiaries from different types of regions. Tallinn as the national capital and the largest city in Estonia, Tartu as an excellent representative of a large growing town, Rakvere as a representative of a small growing town and Võru as a representative of a small shrinking town. Cities and towns engaged as project beneficiaries are expected to act as renovation leaders in Estonia, representing different sized municipalities with unique competences that can be replicated to the whole Estonia. Other local municipalities will be included to the project as key stakeholders, to learn from the project experiences and initiate renovations with the available complementary funding. 38 LIFE Integrated Projects 2020 – CNf Financial Plan Sources of financing Actions/ Amount of Status/date of Authority/ measures to funding Funding entity managing be financed (EUR) granted/ the fund to be granted/ not yet requested LIFE PROJECT: EU contribution NA 11 520 000 NA NA Contribution by NA 7 680 000 NA NA beneficiaries Contribution by cofinancers 0 TOTAL LIFE IP 19 200 000 EU FUNDS: H2020: Drive0 - WP 5 100 000 Granted, H2020 / TalTech Driving decarbonization of the 01.10.2019 EU building stock by enhancing a consumer centred and locally based circular renovation process H2020: FINEST TWINS WP 3; WP 6 1 000 000 Granted, H2020 / TalTech Establishment of Smart City 01.12.2019 Center of Excellence H2020: U-CERT - WP 6 40 000 Granted H2020 / TalTech Towards a new generation of 01.09.2019 user-centred Energy Performance Assessment and Certification; facilitated and empowered by the EPB Center H2020: CityxChange Positive WP 3; WP 6 500 000 Granted, H2020 / Võru City ExChange 1.11.2018 H2020: SHEERenov – WP 5 120 000 Granted, H2020 / EKYL Seamless services for 1.06.2020 Housing Energy Efficiency Renovation H2020: POWERPOOR - WP 2 100 000 Granted, H2020 / EKYL Empowering Energy Poor WP8 1.09.2020 Citizens through Energy Cooperative Initiatives H2020: EnergyTakeaway - WP 2 170 000 Requested, 2020 H2020 / EKYL Enabling and Supporting WP 7 Householders to Tackle Energy Poverty H2020: WE NERGY - Living WP 7 130 000 Requested, 2020 H2020 / EKYL Labs for Consumer WP 8 Empowerment and Collectively Driven Energy Actions H2020: SMART FINANCE WP 1 160 000 Requested, 2020 H2020 / EKYL EST – Estonian National WP 8 Roundtable to Implement Smart Financing for Smart Buildings H2020: VIRTUOUS – WP 2 70 000 Requested, 2020 H2020 / EKYL Virtualization of Buildings, WP 6 Prosumers and Users for Improved Comfort and Efficiency 39 H2020: TraiNBS - Transition WP 4 200 000 Requested, 2020 H2020 / TalTech Route to Achieve Integrated Nature Based Solutions for water quality improvement across urban water cycles TOTAL (eg. H2020) 2 590 000 Innovative solutions increase WP 1; WP3; 34 500 000 Funds approved for KIK resource productivity of scheme, enterprises** Innovative solutions increase WP 1; WP 3; Tbd* planned KIK resource productivity of 145 000 000 enterprises ** KIK grant scheme for urban WP 4 14 500 000 Funds approved for KIK flood management** scheme, Total: Cohesion Policy Funds: 194 000 000 KredEx renovation grant for WP 1; WP 3; 366 000 000 planned KredEx renovation of apartment buildings** Total: Recovery and 366 000 000 Resilience Facility Interreg BSR: NOAH - WP 4 500 000 Granted, Interreg BSR / TalTech Protecting Baltic Sea from 01.01.2019 untreated wastewater spillages during flood events in urban areas Interreg BSR: WP 4 150 000 Granted, Interreg CB / TalTech CleanStormwater - 01.02.2020 Testing new storm water treatment solutions for reduction of hazardous substances and toxins inflows into the Baltic Sea TOTAL (eg. Interreg) 650 000 Subtotal EU: 563 240 000 OTHER FUNDS ETAG: DEPART - WP 4 100 000 Granted, 1.01.2020 ETAG / TalTech Decentralized real-time control platform for urban drainage systems in climate proof smart cities ETAG: PRG483 - Moisture WP 2 100 000 Granted, ETAG / TalTech safety of interior insulation, 1.01.2019 constructional moisture and thermally efficient building envelope SA Archimedes: TAR16012 - WP 2 1 000 000 Granted, SA Archimedes / Zero energy and resource 01.10.2015 TalTech efficient smart buildings and districts KIK scheme: renovation of WP 3; 1 000 000 Funds approved for KIK housing affected by oil-shale scheme, excavation KredEx reconstruction grant WP 1; WP 3; 6 500 000 Funds approved for KredEx for small residences scheme, (2021-2024)** KredEx renovation loan for WP 1; WP 3; 22 000 000 Funds approved for KredEx apartment buildings (2021- scheme, 2024)** KredEx support for home WP 1; WP 3; 16 000 000 Funds approved for KredEx renovation for large families scheme, (2021-2024)** KredEx Housing loan WP 1; WP 3; 35 000 000 Funds approved for KredEx guarantee (2021-2024)** scheme, KredEx support schemes WP 1; WP 3; Tbd* planned KredEx (2024-…) to be 1 500 000 000 40 developed/continued within project** Climate resilience, Renovation WP 4 Tbd* planned KIK circularity schemes to be WP 5 500 000 000 developed within project** Subtotal public: 2 046 700 000 KIK grant scheme for urban WP 4 1 388 888 Funds approved for KIK flood management (Own scheme, contribution of the investment paid by applicants) Innovative solutions increase WP 1; WP3; 281 470 588 planned KIK resource productivity of enterprises (Own contribution of the investment paid by applicants) KredEx renovation grant for WP 1; WP 3; 366 000 000 planned KredEx renovation of apartment buildings (Own contribution min 50% of the investment paid by applicants) KredEx reconstruction grant WP 1; WP 3; 26 000 000 planned KredEx for small residences** (Own contribution 80% of the investment paid by applicants) (2021-2024) KredEx renovation loan WP 1; WP 3; 14 250 000 planned KredEx warranty for apartement buildings (Own contribution 80% of the investment paid by applicants) (2021-2024) Subtotal private: 689 109 476 KredEx support schemes WP 1; WP 3; Tbd* planned KredEx (exact plans (2024-…) to be 1 500 000 000 for financial period developed/continued within 2021-2027 are project (Own contribution min presently under 50% of the investment paid by negotiations, tbd by full applicants) proposal)*** Climate resilience, Renovation WP 4 Tbd* planned KIK (exact plans for circularity etc schemes to be WP 5 500 000 000 financial period 2021- developed within project 2027 are presently under negotiations, tbd by full proposal)*** Cost-sharing financing WP 1; WP3; Tbd* planned Tbd* services / cooperation models 50 000 000 developed within project for deep renovations Subtotal TBD* 2 050 000 000 planned Tbd* International funds: 0 Total complementary: 4 771 559 476 Notes (if applicable): Tbd* – project aims to develop financial schemes and business models that need to cover deep renovation of Estonian housing stock for the project period (and beyond), present financial plan acknowledges the needed funds, but has not secured the funding. Private, EU and national funds are to be considered. ** Schemes involved as complementary, which include grant funds and expected own contribution (listed under private) from applicants; *** Exact fianancial plans for budget period 2021-2027 are presently under negotiations, therefore financial plan of the project will be elaborated by full proposal. 41 ANNEX 2 Figure II-1 Preliminary pert chart of the LIFE IP BUILDEST project ANNEX 2 Figure II-2: Project management structure and the involvement of beneficiaries to the work packages under different sub-targets of the project Executive Agency for Small and Medium Sized Enterprises (EASME) LIFE Key Project Level Indicators LIFE Call for Proposals 2020 At the end of the project Please comment and give brief explainations of assumptions used for the calculation. Estimated Impact Estimated Impact Objective Indicators (absolute values) (in %)* For all values below: the exact ambition will be developed by Full Proposal * Change expected (in %) compared to the initial situation. Please explain reference data used to set the initial situation. This is normally directly linked to the baseline you have developed in the proposal. Reduction of operational energy of buildings from 4.4 t/year on CO2 1.4 mln tons 32 % change 2020 Reduction of greenhouse gas Avoiding impacts of waste of embodied energy in buildings emissions (GHG) (designing for circularity, long-term resilience to the climate risks, CO2 0.2 mln tons / year 100% change renovating instead on demolition and new construction). Saving 800 000 t/materials/year. Emissions of primary TSP Decrease of heating need because of additional insulation and half (total suspended particles) 6600 tons / year 43% change of detached houses install a heat pump as a heating source istead from heating of stove. Air quality and Decrease of heating need because of additional insulation and half Emissions of primary emissions 5100 tons / year 41% change of detached houses install a heat pump as a heating source istead PM10 from heating Improved Environmental and of stove. Climate Performance (including Decrease of heating need because of additional insulation and half Emissions of primary resilience to climate change) 5000 tons / year 41% change of detached houses install a heat pump as a heating source istead PM2.5 from heating of stove. Reuse, recycling and circular use of >70% materials of renovated Waste Reduction 0.9 mil. tons / year 70% buildings Prevention: Renovation as is aims to waste reduction, using the existing construction as much as possible rather than replacing it Waste Reduction 1.1 mil. tons / year 70% with a new building. Waste management Exact ambition to be declared with Full Proposal Long-term prevention: At least half of the renovations carried out, will follow the design guidelines that aim for pure material flows in Waste Reduction 0.1 mil. tons / year 90% change future dissassembly and design the materials used for renovations for future circularity Exact ambition to be declared with Full Proposal 20% of inhbitants Improved resilience to More resilient renovations carried out taking into account the Water living in flood risk 100% change flooding increased flooding risks due the changed climate. areas Reduced resource Reuse, recycling and circular use of >70% materials of renovated Raw materials 0.9 mil. tons / year 70% consumption buildings Reduced water Decrease of hot water consumption because of more effcient Water 72000 m3 / year 5 % change consumption systems Better use of natural resources Energy from Renewable kwh / year % change Energy Sources Energy Reduced energy 1.4 TWh / year 12 % change consumption Increase in the number of employees in construction companies Employment Jobs created FTE % change based on previous dynamics 2000 - 2007 N . of replication / Replication / Transfer Transfer buildings 8 000 50% Whole Estonia renovated Full implementation of Policy measures LTRS taking into Replication / Transfer developed with LIFE IP 100% Estonia account LIFE IP BUILDEST are continued BUILDEST results Economic Performance, Market Uptake, Replication Disseminating toolset Replication / Transfer developed within the 50% Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Germany, Finland, Sweden project Expected revenues Euros not applicable Market uptake market size in number of customers not applicable customers Reduction of cost per in Euros / unit % change unit or process capital invested / net Payback Time in years not applicable income Number of owners Awareness raising 2000 / year 50% change reached/ made aware Number of general public Awareness raising 10 000 / year 50% change reached/ made aware Communication, dissemination, Number of projects awareness rising reached/ made aware Project networking 10-30 projects n/a Cooperation with different EU funded projects (projects contacted, visited, hosted) Website Number of visits >100 000 n/a Web tools developed within project Number of visits >100 000 n/a integrated to different web pages BUILDEST_KPI Page 1 of 2 Executive Agency for Small and Medium Sized Enterprises (EASME) LIFE Key Project Level Indicators LIFE Call for Proposals 2020 3 or 5 years after the project Select → 3 years after the project (5 years mandatory for Nature Projects) Please comment and give brief explainations of assumptions used for the calculation Estimated Impact Estimated Impact Objective Indicators (absolute values) (in %)* For all values below: the exact ambition will be developed by Full Proposal * Change expected (in %) compared to the initial situation. Please explain reference data used to set the initial situation. This is normally directly linked to the baseline you have developed in the proposal. Reduction of operational energy of buildings from 4.4 t/year on CO2 2,1 mln tons 47 % change 2020 to 2 t/year on 2029 Reduction of greenhouse gas Avoiding impacts of waste of embodied energy in buildings emissions (GHG) CO2 0.8 tons / year % change (designing for circularity, long-term resilience to the climate risks, renovating instead on demolition and new construction) Emissions of primary TSP Decrease of heating need because of additional insulation and half (total suspended particles) 5400 tons / year 41% change of detached houses install a heat pump as a heating source istead from heating of stove. Air quality and Decrease of heating need because of additional insulation and half Emissions of primary emissions 5100 tons / year 41% change of detached houses install a heat pump as a heating source istead PM10 from heating Improved Environmental and of stove. Climate Performance (including Decrease of heating need because of additional insulation and half Emissions of primary resilience to climate change) 5000 tons / year 41% change of detached houses install a heat pump as a heating source istead PM2.5 from heating of stove. Reuse, recycling and circular use of >70% materials of renovated Waste Reduction 0.9 mil. tons / year 70% buildings Prevention: Renovation as is aims to waste reduction, using the existing construction as much as possible rather than replacing it Waste Reduction 1.1 mil. tons / year 70% with a new building. Waste management Exact ambition to be declared with Full Proposal Long-term prevention: At least half of the renovations carried out, will follow the design guidelines that aim for pure material Waste Reduction 0.1 mil. tons / year 90% change flows in future dissassembly and design the materials used for renovations for future circularity Exact ambition to be declared with Full Proposal 20% of inhbitants Improved resilience to More resilient renovations carried out taking into account the Water living in flood risk 100% change flooding increased flooding risks due the changed climate. areas Reduced resource Reuse, recycling and circular use of >70% materials of renovated Raw materials 0.9 mil. tons / year 70% consumption buildings Reduced water Decrease of hot water consumption because of more effcient Water 72000 m3 / year 5 % change consumption systems Better use of natural resources Energy from Renewable kwh / year % change Energy Sources Energy Reduced energy 1.4 TWh / year 12 % change consumption Increase in the number of employees in construction companies Employment Jobs created FTE % change based on previous dynamics 2000 - 2007 N . of replication / Replication / Transfer Transfer buildings 12 000 50% Whole Estonia renovated Full implementation of Policy measures LTRS taking into Replication / Transfer developed with LIFE IP 100% Estonia account LIFE IP BUILDEST are continued BUILDEST results Economic Performance, Market Uptake, Replication Disseminating toolset Replication / Transfer developed within the 50% Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Germany, Finland, Sweden project Expected revenues Euros not applicable Market uptake market size in number of customers not applicable customers Reduction of cost per in Euros / unit % change unit or process capital invested / net Payback Time in years not applicable income Number of owners Awareness raising 1000 / year 50% change Will be continued by competence cluster reached/ made aware Number of general public Awareness raising 3 000 / year 50% change Will be continued by competence cluster reached/ made aware Number of projects reached/ made aware Project beneficiaries continue to transfer project experience to Project networking 20-40 projects n/a (projects contacted, interested parties visited, hosted) Website Number of visits >100 000 n/a Web tools developed within project Number of visits >150 000 n/a integrated to different web pages BUILDEST_KPI Page 2 of 2
Allikas: Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium dokumendiregister →
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel