,
Our Ref: 06.10.2020 No 24.1-2/2020/6136-
1
Dear Commissioner Didier Reynders,
Estonian vision on EU’s New Consumer Agenda
In response to the European Commission’s consultations regarding EU’s New Consumer Agenda
we would like to share Estonian vision with you. I hope you could take note of our views and
positions in advance of the new possible legislative proposals.
We are looking forward to constructive negotiations in the future.
Kind regards,
Taavi Aas
Minister of Economic Affairs and Infrastructure
Appendix: Position paper of Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications of Estonia
on EU’s New Consumer Agenda
Riina Piliste
+372 625 6420
[email protected]
Risto Jõgi
+372 6256428
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / ESTONIA
Phone: +372 625 6342 / Fax: +372 631 3660 / E-mail:
[email protected] / http://www.mkm.ee
Position paper of
Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications of Estonia
on EU’s New Consumer Agenda
The European Commission has launched its consultation to gather views of the public,
including public authorities, on four initiatives in the EU consumer policy that the Commission
is planning to propose in 2020 and 2021.1
The consultation is organised in four sections, each corresponding to one initiative: 1) A New
Consumer Agenda; 2) Empowering the consumer for the green transition; 3) Review of the
Directive on credit agreements for consumers (2008/48/EC); 4) Review of the Directive on
General Product Safety (2001/95/EC).
Below you will find our views in regard respective initiatives.
1) A New Consumer Agenda
In relation to reimbursements in travel sector, we are in opinion that specific rules should
apply to a situation where worldwide travel restrictions have caused almost a standstill of travel,
such as during the Covid-19 pandemic. Henceforth we are open to ideas put forward by
Commission in this regard, such as longer reimbursement deadlines or reimbursement in the
form of vouchers. In our view a fair balance should be stricken between the interests of
consumers and traders. Having more flexible rules on reimbursements could be helpful for
traders, as it could prevent travel companies from going out of business, which would probably
not be in the consumer’s economic interests either. On the other hand, consumer’s rights should
also be safeguarded, especially in the current economic climate.
As to the deadlines for reimbursements in case of cancelled transport services, we consider
that such deadlines could be aligned as much as possible between different transportation types
(e.g. flight, train, bus). We believe it to be in the interests of consumer to have as simple and
uniform reimbursements systems as possible, as this would create the premise where consumers
would be more confident in standing for their rights. Similarly, it should be considered if those
deadlines could be aligned with package travel as well, although we note that package travel
with its multitude of services bundled together (transport, accommodation, rent, leisure etc)
could very well justify the use of different deadlines.
As regards to insolvency protection, we do not see the need to extend the system of package
travel to transport services as we consider the risks of going insolvent in transport area much
lower than that in travel sector. In addition, transport service providers normally have their own
assets which could cover losses incurred by consumers.
We are open to consider the idea to harmonize consumer protection rules in case of
cancellation of services for all sectors in situation of “force majeure” (like Covid-19). We
believe it to be in the interests of consumers to have as simple and uniform systems as possible,
as this would create the premise where consumers would be more confident in standing for their
rights. However, it should be borne in mind, that potential future crises might not be similar to
1
https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12464-A-New-Consumer-
Agenda/public-consultation
1
the Covid-19 pandemic. Therefore, the need for any new rules should be carefully weighed and
if such new rules are deemed necessary, they should provide sufficient flexibility in order to be
suitable for a range of different circumstances.
EU consumer policy strategy priorities for medium-long term should be set on more effective
enforcement of consumer rights by empowering them with stronger, quicker and affordable
tools to ensure their rights are abided by. First and foremost, it is for the consumers to stand for
their rights and if we are able to create as simple and understandable system as possible and we
provide consumers with proper tools to foresee that those rights are upheld, then market
surveillance would be much more effective. In addition, EU wide market surveillance tools
could be created in order to enhance enforcement of consumer rights. For example, the
Commission could create “web crawlers” to screen online marketplaces operating at EU for
infringements and ask sellers to rectify the situation. In addition, priorities should include
seeking co-operation agreements with large online marketplaces through which majority of
products are sold to EU consumers similarly to what has been done in “Product Safety Pledge”2.
We believe that children and elderly people are and continue to be the most vulnerable
consumer group as often those are the groups where many vulnerability sources tend to stack
up: social isolation, personal health situation, insufficient digital and financial literacy, low
education level, lack of practical knowledge or skills in understanding complex contract
conditions and offers etc – these are all somewhat age-related vulnerability sources.
2) Empowering the consumer for the green transition
In our opinion, the most relevant obstacles for enhanced consumer participation in the
circular economy and towards more sustainable consumption behaviour are overload of
information and its complexity, trustworthiness of environmental claims, non-repairable goods,
general disinterest in adopting more sustainable consumption behaviour and perceived higher
prices of environmentally-friendly products compare to less environmentally-friendly
alternatives.
In order to elevate trustworthiness of environmental claims and in order to empower
consumers to assume a stronger role in the green transition we consider it necessary to have
as simple and as uniform set of rules as possible for providing information about environmental
claims, including comparable information that is understandable for consumers. Therefore,
transparency in relation to environmental claims, providing a stronger protection against
greenwashing (i.e. claims on environmental qualities of products or services that are
exaggerated, too vague, false or impossible to prove) and raising consumers’ awareness about
their role in circular economy and green transition are the prerequisites for consumers’ green
transition. In this regard we should use more digital solutions, e.g. electronic product passport.
Consumers no matter where they are living in the EU should not be put into a situation where
the preference of greener products or services would have significally higher cost and
alternatives are not provided. This is especially relevant for the peripheral geographical zones
of Europe and in the context of the connectivity, i.e transport and mobility. We should avoid
the situation were due to green transition, it becomes difficult for consumers to exercise their
freedom of movement, for example in the situation, where air connection becomes more
expensive than rail connection on the same itinerary. This is especially important for Member
States that are situated at the border regions of the EU. Additionally, communication campaigns
2
https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/info/files/voluntary_commitment_document_4signatures3-web.pdf
2
that would influence consumer behaviour should be undertaken, so that consumers would be
empowered make informed environmentally-friendly choices.
Additional information could be useful for enhancing consumers’ participation in the
circular economy and to choosing sustainable products. In this respect it could be analysed,
whether the consumers could receive information about “expected” product lifespan and about
the reparability of the product. However, it should be further analysed how such pre-contractual
information would fit with principles of directive (EU) 2019/771 on certain aspects concerning
contracts for the sale of goods. Particularly concerning the liability of the seller and the remedies
for lack of conformity.
Furthermore, enforcement action could be stepped up by providing more EU-funded training
for enforcement authorities and judges on these matters, by providing detailed EU guidance for
enforcement bodies against greenwashing and obsolescence practices and on enforcing
consumer information rules and by setting up at EU level an advisory system to ensure
sustainability claims on products are based on reliable information (similar to the system set up
in food sector for nutritional and health claims).
3) Review of the Directive on credit agreements for consumers (2008/48/EC)
Directives scope should be extended to credits below EUR 200, credits above EUR 75 000 for
purposes other than the renovation of residential immovable property and loans obtained by
individuals form other individuals, through online platforms (peer-to-peer lending).
In Estonia we have not applied the exemptions for above mentioned credit agreements. We
have also applied most of the rules deriving from the CCD to leasing agreements, where there
is no obligation to purchase the object of the agreement, the only rules that do not apply in this
case is the right for early repayment.
Also, regarding credit agreements, which are the outcome of a settlement reached in court or
before another statutory authority, we have chosen not to apply the rules on withdrawal and
linked agreements, but the rules on information requirements and creditworthiness assessment
were deemed necessary also in such cases.”
Obligation to provide consumers with standard information at pre-contractual stage is
highly valuable as it allows consumers to compare different credit offers. Before signing a
contract, consumers should be given enough time to get acquainted with pre-contractual
information. We consider that pre-contractual information should be provided in a reasonable
time period before signing a contract. The reasonable time period could be at least one hour till
one day.
In addition, it would be more useful to provide consumers with pre-contractual information in
a standardised format (SECCI). Regarding to the information provided in a standardised format
the essential part of the information (key features and cost of the loan) could be highlighted in
comparison with other information.
Considerations should be given to reducing the amount of information that has to be given in
the advertisements hence we are not supportive of ideas that move to the opposite direction,
such as the idea to set up an obligation to accompany advertisements with warning messages
on the implications of the credit decision such as “borrowing money also costs money”.
3
Upholding the requirements of the directive’s obligations vis-à-vis responsible lending
practices are highly valuable from the perspective of safeguarding the economic interest of
consumers. Therefore, we are supportive of the ideas to introduce binding principles on
responsible lending such as an obligation to consider target consumers’ interests, objectives and
characteristics when designing credit products and harmonise the creditworthiness assessment
process across Member States. Hence, we agree that EU law should provide for common
standards on data/methodology for creditworthiness assessments. In Estonia we have already
specified those rules compared to the CCD. We have more specific rules on the creditor’s
obligations for carrying out the creditworthiness assessment and also the consequences of a
negative outcome of this assessment, in this case the creditor may not enter in a contract with
the consumer, if he does so, a statutory interest rate will apply. If these rules were also specified
in EU law, then in our opinion it is important to ensure that consumer protection level would
be at least as high as it is currently in our law.
Furthermore, in relation to online credit offers, we find that there should be measures put in
place in order to prevent online credit purchasing without enough time for reflection (e.g credit
obtained “in one-click”), as in reality it would not be possible to fulfil the different obligations
set forth in the CCD this way. Additionally, before purchasing online credit consumer could be
given a warning message about the implications of the credit decision.
In situations of exceptional and systemic economic disruption, such the one caused by the
Covid-19, we consider reasonable to use flexibility embedded in the prudential framework for
banks to facilitate lending to support consumers and businesses in the crisis period.
4) Review of the Directive on General Product Safety (2001/95/EC)
In general, we consider that current Directive on General Product Safety (GPSD) rules are
adequate to protect consumers. Nevertheless, legal definitions (such as “product”, “safe
product” or “placing on the market”) should be reviewed in order to make it clear whether and
to what extent they apply to new technology products (e.g connected devices). For example,
when considering whether a product is safe the definition of a product in the GPSD should
encompass also the software incorporated into it as the latter can make a difference in terms of
judging if a product has a safety issue or not. The same is true in cases when software is already
installed into the product when sold and in cases where software is downloaded into the device
after it has been sold. The same applies to cases where software is updated or changed (for
example evolved via use of AI) after they are sold, i.e these products should remain safe
throughout their lifetime.
We agree with the statement that online marketplaces that enable companies to sell to EU
consumer should have a legal obligation to remove dangerous products listed on their websites
when notified to them. At the same time, we agree that online marketplaces should prevent
reappearance of those dangerous products in their listings once they have been removed, but
we do not believe that such an obligation should be written in law as it would be very difficult
or in some cases even impossible to enforce.
We do not support the idea to oblige online marketplaces to identify products within their
systems that likely do not comply with safety rules as such an obligation should be on the seller.
Similarly, online marketplaces should not be obliged to inform consumers when a dangerous
product has been removed from the marketplace. However, considering that sellers must have
4
in their possession the information about to whom products have been sold, it should be their
responsibility in cooperation with the producer to inform those consumers who have bought the
defective product.
We do not support the idea to force 3rd country businesses to set up responsible persons
established in the EU in order to sell their products to EU market as such an obligation should
be reserved for high risk product categories such as those listed in the new enforcement
regulation no 1020/2019. In our opinion it would be disproportionate to set up such a
requirement to all products entering EU market.
As to enforcement rules applicable to market surveillance, we consider it necessary to align
those rules between harmonised and non-harmonised products as in terms on market
surveillance actions it should not make a difference to which category a dangerous product
specifically falls. A dangerous product is a dangerous product and hence the enforcement
actions taken or tools available for market surveillance authorities should be the same.
As a final note, one of the EU priorities in the product safety area should be on the
enhancement of cooperation between the EU market surveillance authorities and large (online)
marketplaces through which majority of products are sold to EU consumers. Here, the European
Commission led initiative “Product Safety Pledge” is highly appreciated and valuable and
should be continued. However, the value of such an undertaking lies in the cooperation and
hence we would not like to see developments moving towards writing the agreement into EU
law. In addition, EU wide market surveillance tools should be created in order to enhance
enforcement of product safety rules. For example, the Commission could create “web crawlers”
to screen online sales for infringements, ask sellers to rectify the situation and in case further
action is needed, inform relevant market surveillance authorities in respective Member States.
5