Project title: Health Sense Project Promoter : Estonian Ministry of Social Affairs Project Partner(s ): Health and Welfare Information Systems Center, Tallinn University of Technology, Software Technology and Applications Competence Centre Donor project partner (s ): Helse West IK T; Western Norway University of Applied Sciences Total maximum eligible project cost: 2 000 000€ Project grant rate: 100% Project grant amount : 2 000 000€ Estimated duration: 24 months Project summary The goal of the predefined project Health Sense is to develop a secur e data storage, integration , access and analysi s toolkit in order to provide large , complex and detailed sets of health and lifecycle data for the public sector, private sector and R&D institutions. T he ultimate aim of the project is to raise the availability of health and lifecycle data in order to enhance the creation of new products, services and solutions by the private sector, novel interventions by the public sector and relevant scientific knowledge by the R&D communities in order to raise life expectancy and prolong healthy life years of people . It is accounted for, that while the user community is likely to broaden even further in the future, then this data is delicate, which means priva cy and security of developed/procured components is key. However in addition to technical security, compliance to strict data protection regulations is crucial as well. Thus, a key activity stream will aim to develop data collection procedures, tools and analyse regulations that meet limitations and responsibilities described in the G eneral D ata P rotection R egulation (GDPR) to ensure usability of developed ICT components and thus ensure project success . Health Sense is a virtual environment used to collect health, health cycle and lifestyle data for research and service development purposes. In addition, it also provides a toolbox that enables the creation of data analysis - based solutions for prolonging a healthy human life. As the data handled in the environment is sensitive , the tools for safe collection, storage, access and processing of data are an essential part of the provided toolbox. Project background and justification Estonian governmental information system today has sufficiently good e-ability to collect and handle personal data in different areas including healthcare, social care and labor area that are managed by Ministry of Social Affairs. Mostly these abilities today are used on an operational level to provide services for individuals, and for reporting and simple analyses. The better use of data, to provide the steering process with predictive and calculated supporting data, is planned but not yet implemented. Today a couple of domain - based separated data warehouses are used, and data relations between different areas are built, but only on a data mart level. This leads to limited possibilities in data analysis and AI development. Today many different count r ies have the same problem – services are being provided and data is be ing collected, but separately and by areas with very simple loop back to steering process. Even when the data collected by different areas is gathered to the same environment, the data from different sources is connected on a person level and no additional relations are calculated nor defined. In many circumstances, legal constraints prevent interconnecting person level data . Estonia is small and dynamic enough to build data integration, analy sis models, and solutions to experiment with data warehouse environment architecture and development tools. We have all the necessary electronic data sources for supporting th is process. Furthermore , we have years of experience in developing forward-thinking digital solutions and in simultaneously building/updating our regulatory framework for these solutions to be implemented. Estonia, being the near perfect testbed for spearheading new e-governance initiative s , can provide here great value by d evelop ing models and solutions , which can later be expanded further to la r ger data volumes in larger countries, Norway being one of the main consideration s . It is paramount to find committed partners , that are interested in projects of this kind as well as who comply with ethics and the principles of data security . There are several interested groups in the public sector, R&D institutions and private sector . The Department of Data Analysis has been set up under the Ministry of Social Affairs , however the need for health and lifecycle data continuously exists in other public sector institutions in the health and social domain (e.g. Health Insurance Fund, Health Development Institute, Estonian Health Board, Social Insurance Board, Unemployment Insurance Fund) and other public sector domains as well (e.g. Ministry of Defense, Defense Resources Agency, Ministry of Interior, Ministry of Education and Research etc ) . R&D institutions (e.g. Tartu University and Tallinn University of Technology and Technology Competence Centers ) are interested in using humans’ lifecycle data in their research , development and teaching processes, in cooperation with the governmental authorities. Various lifecycle and health data interested communities (e.g. Estonian HealthTech Cluster, Open Knowledge Estonia) are set up so that they connect individuals, research organizations, companies and startups. In addition, in recent years international interest by global (multi-national) companies (mainly pharmaceuticals and health technology) has grown exponentially. All these groups are interested in having access to person’s lifecycle data. Some of them produce human lifecycle data, and through that expand the variety of data collected. Due to the high level of IT coverage in Estonia , many international companies have become interested in using health and lifecycle data in their R&D efforts . This can provide value as additional resources to the project. Implementing the modern methods of person’s lifecycle - based data collecting, analysis and AI tools will lead to a longer and healthier life and reducing costs per unit in health- and social care. Thus, supporting the goal of the welfare technologies concept – staying independent in activities of daily living while receiving tailored support from various care services when needed. Health Sense is a central (root) project for the redevelopment of data utilization in health, work and social care area , where the polices and services are intertwined and thus should be combined to provide maximum effectiveness and cost-efficiency. The latter is currently hindered by the scatteredness of data in these areas which leads to deficiencies in accessing and utilizing data for revising and building services. Thus , the toolkit developed through Health Sense would enable to modify, create and provide invisible and/or preventive services to citizens based on evidence gather through complex data analysis/findings . The project will be implemented as a predefined project because it requires the coordination between several public and private actors, many of which have very specific knowledge in the project area . Without the successful implementation of th is project today, the push for combined evidence and data-led improvement of human social and health wellbeing, w ill be delayed for years. Objective, expected outcome(s) and list of outputs Project activit y streams : Project management Data collecting environment Data storage with pseudonymization and obfuscation tools Warehouse data structures and ETL process Data Analysis and visualization environment for third parties ( e.g. private sector, R&D institutions) Building data flows in cooperation with third parties ( e.g. private sector, R&D institutions) Analysis of legal regulations to foster the results of the project For more detail ed activities see timetable/milestone plan (e). For budget overview see sheet accompanied with this document. Expected outputs: data collect ion environment from different sources (governmental and non-governmental) data pseudonymization, obfuscation and long text extraction tools partly encrypted data storage with encryption/decryption tools and methodology d ata flows from runtime information system to data warehouse (built on needs of third parties ) . Illustrated with more detail in Appendix 2 and 3. user rights and consent management system data analys is environment for third parties Analysis of legal regulations to ensure project outcomes data warehouse environment for Ministry of Social Affairs and other governmental institutions ( for reporting and analysis purposes ) Expected outcomes : to create a data management platform for developing innovative solutions for healthcare and welfare service providers to develop and experiment new innovative products and services ; to e ncourage the emergence of new health, welfare and lifestyle businesses and data driven business models ; to create a launch pad for new healthcare and welfare services for their emergence to the market in cooperation with SMEs and start-ups; to promote scientific thinking and provide new inputs for resea r ch, development and innovation in SMEs and start-ups in the delivery of health and welfare services and educate highly skilled workforce in cooperation with universities. Expected project result Indicator Unit of measurement Source of verification Frequency of reporting Baseline value Baseline year Target value Health Sense data management platform developed and operating Data analysis procedures/tools in place and documented Binary Documentation available on HWISC website, software hosted at HWISC or state cloud infrastructure Semi-annually No 2018 Yes Data collection and publishing procedures/tools in place and documented Binary Documentation available on HWISC website, software hosted at HWISC or state cloud infrastructure Semi-annually No 2018 Yes Data collection, and publishing environment architecture and data analysis environment architecture developed and published Binary Documentation available on HWISC website, software hosted at HWISC or state cloud infrastructure Semi-annually No 2018 Yes Number of data mining/Artificial Intelligence pilot projects successfully finished Number D ocumentation outlining projects and results available on HWISC website Semi-annually 0 N/A 3 Number of professional staff train ed Number Attendance sheets Semi-annually 0 N/A 10 Project sustainability All results created during the project will be maintained by Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre and Ministry of Social Affairs . All software created during the project will be hosted and maintained by Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre . The necessary resources to maintain and host results will be applied from the annual state budget of Estonia . Intellectual property Unless stipulated otherwise in the agreements between project promoter and project partners , i ntellectual property rights of the results of the p roject shall be owned by the p arty generating it . When results are generated jointly , it shall be jointly owned , unless the p arties in question agree on a different solution . The method of defining joint ownership shall be based on their contributing efforts towards the result in shares proportionate to their scope of work / budget for that result . After completion of the p roject , project promoter shall have the non- exclusive , royalty-free right to use , modify , copy , transfer or make derivative results of the p roject . The rights of the project promoter shall not be limited with regard to certain rights or to the purpose , term, territory , extent , manner or means of using the results of the p roject . Information on the project promoter and project partner(s) Ministry of Social Affairs is a governmental institution that operates in the field of social security. For ministry have been set five strategic objectives - ensure people's economic prosperity and their good work, ensure people's social coping and development, support the well-being of children and families, promote people's mutual care, equal opportunities and gender equality, and ensure people's long and high-quality life. Ministry of Social Affairs emerges objectives through compiling development plans for the fields being under control of ministry, as well as organization-based development plans. Ministry of Social Affairs as project promoter, will ensure seamless project coordination. Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre ( HWISC ) is info technology competence centre of Ministry of Social Affairs. HWISC is involved in the development, and management of ICT services in the health, social and labour fields within the area of government of the Ministry of Social Affairs. HWISC is a representative of the Ministry of Social Affairs in the „Health Sense “ project as the project manager. HWISC will take upon the leading role in most of the project activities including procuring the necessary licensed software and hosting as well as designing the technical architecture of components and maintaining the solutions developed during Health Sense project. HWISC will assist in project coordination and in organising meetings as well as in analysis of legal regulations to ensure the success of the project. Tallinn University of Technology ( TalTech ), the second largest university in Estonia, i s international university teaching the knowledge and skills necessary for today’s international and competitive marketplace. TalTech is the top centre of science in Estonia. With strong emphasis on internationalization, TalTech has a strong multicultural student body, many international professors (11% foreign staff members), great cooperation with the world's top universities (e.g. Stanford, Technische Universität München, Del University of Technology and KTH Royal Institute of Technology in Europe) and with international companies (e.g., Microsoft, ABB, IBM. etc.). There are over 30 fully accredited international degree programmes (4 Bachelor programmes, 18 Master programmes and 10 PhD programmes) that are available fully in English. TalTech will develop the appropriate model for digital health care data that c ould be used for data collection and storage in new generation Estonian Health Information System with the feasibility to implement the same model in other large scale Electronic Health Records (EHR). TalTech will d evelo p the data model for digital medical data capture and storage to achieve semantic interoperability and d evelo p universal continuity of care process standard . Software Technology and Applications Competence Centre (STACC ) is a research and development organization with the mission to conduct applied research in cooperation with a consortium of scientific and industrial partners. The founding members of STACC are University of Tartu and Tallinn University of Technology as the top centres of science in Estonia. STACC is the leading data science centre in Estonia that develops machine learning models and data analytics solutions. STACC is engaged in creating tools for predicting the outcome of a business process, machine breakdowns, potential new customers, and for providing recommendations on which steps and to what extent to take. STACC is also developing tools for predicting the outcome of a business process, machine breakdowns, potential new customers, and for providing recommendations on which steps and to what extent to take. STACC is one of the six currently operating competence centres financed by Enterprise Estonia. The centres aim to motivate companies to develop innovative products through cooperating with research and development institutions, thereby, bridging the gap between scientific and economic innovation. STACC will undertake the development of pseudonymization and obfuscation toolkit. Helse W est IKT and Western Norway University of Applied Sciences are cooperating in building infrastructure for Intromat ( https://intromat.no/ ), a project on introducing e-health in mental health . As Intromat requires designing of architecture , API-s, interfaces , pseudonimization / synonimization tools similar to the aim of Health Sense proposal , then it provides an ample opportunity to build synergies for both projects and future collaborations . Helse Vest IKT supplies all IT services to specialized health services in the counties of Rogaland , Hordaland and Sogn og Fjordane . Helse Vest customers include the public hospitals in Helse Vest, and several private health service providers in the region . Both Helse Vest IKT and Western Norway University of Applied Sciences have extensive experiences in designing and building software architecture . Bilateral partners will provide consultations and best practice exchange on the following topics : warehousing architecture ( e.g . c omponent architecture , p rocesses , r elations with other warehouses , ETL principles and relations with data providers , standards ), licensed components ( d atabase environment , ETL tools , a nalytical tools , d ata virtualization environments ) and developed tools ( s ynonymization tools , o bfuscation tools , t ools for long text extraction , d ata encryption / decryption ). The bilateral partnership is crucial to ensure , that solutions developed in Estonia a re state -of- the -art, internationall y relevant and to gauge the potential for sharing components with Norwegian counterparts . Timetable / Milestone plan *) Extensive timetable is also visualized in a separate excel sheet Activity (see attached timetable) Activity stream Leader Timeframe (week from project starting date) Project kick-off: 1 st October 2020 (or as soon as possible) Staffing the project team 1.1 Ministry of Social Affairs, Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 1-6 A communication campaign and negotiations to select third party projects 1.1 Ministry of Social Affairs, Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 1-63 Building overall system architecture 1.1 – 1.7 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre (incl. project consortium*) 1-17 Analysis of legal regulations to ensure project success 1.7 Ministry of Social Affairs, Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 5-102 Selecting and describing projects for develompent with third parties (private sector, R&D institutions) 1.1 , 1.5-1.6 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 6-63 Building hardware architecture 1.1 – 1.7 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre (incl. project consortium*) 4-9 Describing the criteria and restrictions for the Initial software components to be procured (ETL, DW database, NoSQL. Encryption/decryption, obfuscation, pseudonymisation, user permissions, virtualization etc. 1. 1 – 1.7 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre (incl. project consortium*) 1-14 Installation of initial hardware environment to infrastructure (probably Estonian state cloud “ Riigipilv ”) 1.1 - 1. 6 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 8-11 Compone n t selection, installation, and testing (Data collecting environment – ETL, BIW tool s ) 1.1, 1.4, 1.5 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 9-14 Building virtual working environment for third parties (closed enviro n ment for ETL, data marts, and analyse tools) 1.1, 1. 5 - 1.6 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 12-19 Tenders of licenced tools 1. 1 – 1.5 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 9-16 Completing initial environment (tender result installations) – central DW and data lake environment 1.1 – 1.5 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 17-21 Testing of environment 1. 1 – 1.5 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 22-25 Description of initial environ me nt, user manuals 1. 1 – 1.5 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 9-25 Development/detailing of architecture 1.4 Project consortium* 5-75 Bui l d ing BIW for IS-s 1.1 – 1.5 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 26-90 Development of logical data structur e s for DW 1.4 Tallinn University of Technology 2-64 Building data flows from BIW to central DW (ETL) 1.1 - 1.5 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 17-90 Development of u ser rights environment 1.1 – 1.5 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 22-34 API, REST etc. interfaces to access data 1.5 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 40-60 Third party projects testing the built toolkits and environment - 1.6 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 26-102 Development of t ools for collection of ag greg ated data 1.5 - 1.6 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 52-60 Environment for publishing data sets and statistical results (Open Data) 1.5 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 58-70 Development of p seudonymisation toolset 1.3 Software Technology and Applications Competence Centre 9-47 Development of o bfu s cation toolset 1.3 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 9-97 Development of l ong text extraction tool 1.3 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 9-97 Meetings with partners (in Estonia) 1.1 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre, Helse-West IKT, Western Norway University of Applied Sciences 6, 26, 46, 66, 96 Meetings with partners (in Norw a y) 1.1 Helse-West IKT, Western Norway University of Applied Sciences, Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 16, 36, 56, 76, 86 Final descriptions of environment, user manuals 1.1 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 90-100 Promotion of project results 1.1 Health and Welfare Information Systems Centre 95-102 End of project : 30 th September 2022 * Project consortium includes project promoter and all project partners (incl. donor partners). Budget Included in separate Excel sheet. Overview of risks: Legal frame obstacles to be followed in order to merge the different datasets. Probability: Likely Impact: Moderate Response : Development of legal framework (incl. revising current regulations) will go in strong cooperation with the project team and project objective s. Revising regulations is part of not only major, but also minor e-government initiatives in Estonia. This is done regularly, routinely and simultaneously for all new governmental ICT-related initiatives as well as for minor modifications in existing digital infrastructure. Breech of principles and laws regarding privacy, data safety and ethics. Probability: Unlikely Impact: Major Response: Apply strict data security measures and methods throughout d ata storage and transfer infrastructure . Provide third-party access to only pseudonymized data only within the secure environment with access to analytical tools. Log all actions, which are done with the data in the secure environment. Allow only aggregated/analysed data to be exported out of the secure environment after logs have been checked for any suspicions. Additional principles regarding data privacy and trust to minimize this risk are detailed in Appendix 1. Procurements for hardware and/or software fail or will be delayed that leads to difficulty to support requested activities. Probability: Unlikely Impact: Major Response: Thorough preparation of the procurement documents Lack of interest from SMEs and/or academia that leads to underuse of the Health sense capability. Probability: Unlikely Impact: Moderate Response: Engage additional entities to promote the capability. Provide additional operational support from governmental agencies (e.g. datasets that can be used to solve specific problems). R eputation damage to the project owner and project partners Probability: Unlikely Impact: Minor Response: Carefully plan, prepare and staff the project before the official start to mitigate planning fallacies. Carefully select partners based on their showcased skills, interest, past commitments and adherence to data privacy and ethical principles. Postponement of welfare technology open call projects Probability: Likely Impact: Moderate Response: Include also projects/partners with reliable funding outside of welfare technology open call in addition to the open call projects . APPENDIX 1 – Privacy and trust requirements and related responses R equirements The results of the project require the application of high-level data protection and sensitivity rules to prevent data misuse and privac y breaches. All data processing activities must be verifiable at a later stage. D ata processing must take place on the basis of legislation . Only deal with ethical and technically capable partners who can provide a secure data storage environment and trusted team . Responses Data storages are divided to two securely separated areas: data owner area and researchers area; personalized data can be stored only at the data owner area; at the researchers area data can be stored in pseudonymized and aggregated manner; pseudonymized and aggregated data can also be stored at the data owner area. (requirement a) Data owner area is also divided to two separated areas: personalized data area and impersonalized data area. This allows better to separate users who need personal information from users who do not need them. (requirement a) Access to the personal and pseudonymized data can only be done through secure environments using highest-level authorization tools (corresponding to EIDAS “high”). (requirement a) E ach dataset must be compiled using the different pseudonym for the same person. (requirement a) Along with data pseudonymizing, obfuscation is always applied. (requirement a) “Aggregated data” is in most cases the synonym of “open data”; h owever, this is only possible if a sufficient amount of data is aggregated o n one line; the minimum number of aggregated rows must be defined for each data set (requirement a) It is mandatory to create isolated sandbox-like environments where res earchers can analyse (anonymized or aggregated) data; o nly aggregated (statistical) data can be extracted from these environments . (requirement a) All activities with the data must be stored in logs; i t is necessary to build a log analysis environment to detect misuse of data . (requirement b) At the first stages of the project, it is necessary to find solutions for the creation of data processing activities in accordance with current legislation; a t the same time, it is necessary to identify regulatory shortcomings that prevent data processing in the interests of individuals and initiate changes to these laws. (requirement c) The background, intent and goals of all partners must be verified every time when data usage permission is granted ; all data usage is monitored on the basis of log analysis ; w hen the misuse of data is detected, the misusers accounts will be closed until the decision is made (requirement e) APPENDIX 2 – Health Sense overall component architecture APPENDIX 3 – Health Sense overall data flow chart
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement
Norwegian Financial Mechanism 2014-2021
PROGRAMME AGREEMENT
between
The Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs
and
The Estonian State Shared Service Center (SSSC),
hereinafter referred to as the “National Focal Point”,
representing Estonia,
hereinafter referred to as the “Beneficiary State”
together hereinafter referred to as the “Parties”
for the financing of the Programme “Competitiveness”
hereinafter referred to as the “Programme”
1
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement
Chapter 1 Article 1.4
Scope, Legal Framework, and Definitions Annexes and hierarchy of documents
Article 1.1 1. Annexes attached hereto form an integral part of
Scope this programme agreement. Any reference to this
programme agreement includes a reference to its
This programme agreement between the Norwegian annexes unless otherwise stated or clear from the
Ministry of Foreign Affairs (hereinafter referred to context.
as the NMFA) and the National Focal Point lays
down the rights and obligations of the Parties 2. The provisions of the annexes shall be interpreted
regarding the implementation of the Programme and in a manner consistent with this programme
the financial contribution from the Norwegian agreement. Should the meaning of any provision of
Financial Mechanism 2014-2021 to the Programme. the said annexes, so interpreted, remain inconsistent
with this programme agreement, the provisions of
the annexes shall prevail, provided that these
Article 1.2 provisions are compatible with the Regulation.
Legal Framework 3. Commitments, statements and guarantees, explicit
1. This programme agreement shall be read in as well as implicit, made in the preparation of the
conjunction with the following documents which, programme are binding for the National Focal Point
together with this programme agreement, constitute and the Programme Operator unless otherwise
the legal framework of the Norwegian Financial explicitly stipulated in the annexes to this
Mechanism 2014-2021: programme agreement.
(a) Agreement between the Kingdom of Norway and
the European Union on the Norwegian Financial Chapter 2
Mechanism 2014-2021 (hereinafter referred to as the
The Programme
Agreement);(b) the Regulation on the
implementation of the Norwegian Financial Article 2.1
Mechanism 2014-2021 (hereinafter referred to as the Co-operation
“Regulation”) issued by Norway in accordance with
1. The Parties shall take all appropriate and
Article 10(5) of the Agreement;
necessary measures to ensure fulfilment of the
(c) the Memorandum of Understanding on the obligations and objectives arising out of this
Implementation of the Norwegian Financial programme agreement.
Mechanism 2014-2021 (hereinafter referred to as the
2. The Parties agree to provide all information
“MoU”), entered into between Norway and the
necessary for the good functioning of this
Beneficiary State; and
programme agreement and to apply the principles of
(d) any guidelines adopted by the NMFA in implementation as set out in the Regulation.
accordance with the Regulation.
3. The Parties shall promptly inform each other of
2. In case of an inconsistency between this any circumstances that interfere or threaten to
programme agreement and the Regulation, the interfere with the successful implementation of the
Regulation shall prevail. Programme.
3. The legal framework is binding for the Parties. An 4. In executing this programme agreement the
act or omission by a Party to this programme Parties declare to counteract corrupt practices.
agreement that is incompatible with the legal Further, they declare not to accept, either directly or
framework constitutes a breach of this programme indirectly, any kind of offer, gift, payments or
agreement by that Party. benefits which would or could be construed as
illegal or corrupt practice. The Parties shall
immediately inform each other of any indication of
Article 1.3 corruption or misuse of resources related to this
Definitions programme agreement.
Terms used and institutions and documents referred
to in this programme agreement shall be understood
Article 2.2
in accordance with the Regulation, in particular
Main responsibilities of the Parties
Article 1.6 thereof, and the legal framework referred
to in Article 1.2 of this programme agreement. 1. The National Focal Point is responsible and
accountable for the overall management of the
Norwegian Financial Mechanism 2014-2021 in the
Beneficiary State and for the full and correct
2
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement
implementation of this programme agreement. In agreement shall be interpreted in conjunction with
particular, the National Focal Point undertakes to: the agreement regulating that support.
(a) comply with its obligations stipulated in the 3. The financial plan annexed to this programme
Regulation and this programme agreement; agreement shall:
(b) ensure that the Certifying Authority, the Audit (a) contain a breakdown between the Programme’s
Authority, the Irregularities Authority and the budget headings;
Programme Operator properly perform the tasks
(b) indicate the agreed advance payment, if any.
assigned to them in the Regulation, this programme
agreement and the programme implementation 4. The management cost of the Programme Operator
agreement; shall not exceed the amount specified in this
programme agreement.
(c) take all necessary steps to ensure that the
Programme Operator is fully committed and able to
implement and manage the Programme;
Article 2.5
(d) take the necessary measures to remedy Special conditions and programme specific rules
irregularities in the implementation of the
Programme and ensure that the Programme Operator 1. This programme agreement shall list any
takes appropriate measures to remedy irregularities conditions set by the NMFA with reference to
in Projects within the Programme, including paragraph 2 of Article 6.3 of the Regulation. The
measures to recover misspent funds; National Focal Point shall ensure compliance with
these conditions and take the necessary steps to
(e) make all the necessary and appropriate ensure their fulfilment.
arrangements in order to strengthen or change the
way the Programme is managed. 2. The National Focal Point shall ensure compliance
with any other programme specific rules laid down
2. The NMFA shall, subject to the rules stipulated in in this programme agreement.
the legal framework referred to in Article 1.2 of this
programme agreement, make available to the
Beneficiary State a financial contribution Article 2.6
(hereinafter referred to as “the programme grant”) to Programme implementation agreement
be used exclusively to finance the eligible cost of the
Programme. With reference to Article 6.8 of the Regulation and
without prejudice to paragraph 2 thereof, the
National Focal Point shall, before any payment is
Article 2.3 made to the Programme, sign a programme
Objective and outcomes of the Programme implementation agreement with the Programme
Operator. The National Focal Point shall notify the
1. This programme agreement sets out the objective, NMFA of such signing.
outcome(s), outputs, indicators and targets for the
Programme.
2. The National Focal Point shall ensure that the Article 2.7
Programme Operator implements and completes the Reporting
Programme in accordance with the objective, The National Focal Point shall ensure that the
outcome(s), outputs, indicators and targets set for Programme Operator provides financial reports,
the Programme. annual programme reports and a final programme
report in accordance with Chapter 9 and Articles
6.11 and 6.12 of the Regulation as well as statistical
reporting in accordance with guidelines adopted by
the NMFA.
Article 2.4
Programme grant Article 2.8
External monitoring
1. The maximum amount of the programme grant,
the programme grant rate, and the estimated eligible The external monitoring and audit referred to in
cost of the Programme shall be as specified in this Articles 11.1, 11.2, 11.3 and 11.4 of the Regulation
programme agreement. shall not in any way relieve the National Focal Point
or the Programme Operator of their obligations
2. In case the Programme is also supported by the
under the legal framework regarding monitoring of
EEA Financial Mechanism, this programme
3
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement
the Programme and/or its projects, financial control Telephone: +32 (0)2 286 1701
and audit. Telefax (general): +32 (0)2 211 1889
E-mail:
[email protected]
3. Changes of or corrections to the contact
Article 2.9
information referred to in this article shall be given
Modification of the Programme
in writing without undue delay by the Parties to this
1. Unless otherwise explicitly stipulated in this programme agreement.
programme agreement, any modification of the
Programme is subject to prior approval by the
NMFA. Article 2.12
Representations and Warranties
2. Programme specific exceptions from paragraph 1,
if any, are set in the annexes to this programme 1. This programme agreement and the awarding of
agreement. the programme grant is based on information
provided by, through, or on behalf of the National
3. Expenditures incurred in breach of this article are
Focal Point to the NMFA prior to the signing of this
not eligible.
programme agreement.
4. Should there be a doubt as to whether the
2. The National Focal Point represents and warrants
proposed modifications require approval by the
that the information provided by, through, or on
NMFA, the National Focal Point shall consult the
behalf of the National Focal Point, in connection
NMFA before such modifications take effect.
with the implementation or conclusion of this
5. Requests for modifications shall be submitted and programme agreement are authentic, accurate and
assessed in accordance with Article 6.9 of the complete.
Regulation.
Chapter 3
Article 2.10 Projects
Communication
Article 3.1
1. All communication to the NMFA regarding this Selection of projects and award of grants
programme agreement shall take place in English
and be directed to the Financial Mechanism Office 1. The National Focal Point shall ensure that the
(hereinafter referred to as the FMO), which Programme Operator selects projects in accordance
represents the NMFA towards the National Focal with Chapter 7 of the Regulation and this
Point and the Programme Operator in relation to the programme agreement.
implementation of the Programme. 2. Eligibility of project promoters and project
2. To the extent that original documents are not partners is stipulated in Article 7.2 of the Regulation
available in the English language, the documents and, in accordance with paragraph 4 thereof, subject
shall be accompanied by full and accurate only to the limitations stipulated in this programme
translations into English. The National Focal Point agreement.
shall bear the responsibility for the accuracy of the 3. Pre-defined projects shall be outlined in this
translation that it provides and the possible programme agreement.
consequences that might arise from any inaccurate
translations. 4. The National Focal Point shall take proactive
steps to ensure that the Programme Operator
complies fully with Article 7.5 of the Regulation.
Article 2.11
Contact information
Article 3.2
1. The contact information of the Programme Project contract
Operator is as specified in this programme
agreement. 1. For each approved project a project contract shall
be concluded between the Programme Operator and
2. The contact information for the NMFA and the the Project Promoter.
Financial Mechanism Office are:
2. In cases where a project contract cannot, due to
Financial Mechanism Office provisions in the national legislation, be made
Att: Director between the Programme Operator and the Project
EFTA Secretariat Promoter, the Beneficiary State may instead issue a
Rue Joseph II, 12-16 legislative or administrative act of similar effect and
1000 Brussels content.
4
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement
3. The content and form or the project contract shall Regulation and fall within the categories and fulfil
comply with Article 7.6 of the Regulation. the conditions of direct eligible expenditure set in
Article 8.3 of the Regulation, the conditions
4. The National Focal Point shall ensure that the
regarding the use of standard scales of unit costs set
obligations of the Project Promoter under the project
in Article 8.4 of the Regulation as well as indirect
contract are valid and enforceable under the
costs in accordance with Article 8.5 of the
applicable law of the Beneficiary State.
Regulation.
4. The first date of eligibility of expenditures in
Article 3.3 projects shall be set in the project contract in
Project partners and partnership agreements accordance with Article 8.13 of the Regulation. The
first date of eligibility of any pre-defined projects
1. A project may be implemented in a partnership shall be no earlier than the date on which the
between the Project Promoter and project partners as National Focal Point notifies the NMFA of a
defined in paragraph 1(w) of Article 1.6 of the positive appraisal of the pre-defined projects by the
Regulation. If a project is implemented in such a Programme Operator in accordance with paragraph
partnership, the Project Promoter shall sign a 3 of Article 6.5 of the Regulation.
partnership agreement with the project partners with
the content and in the form stipulated in Article 7.7 5. The maximum eligible costs of the categories
of the Regulation. referred to in paragraph 1 are set in this programme
agreement. Programme specific rules on the
2. The partnership agreement shall be in English if eligibility of expenditure set in this programme
one of the parties to the agreement is an entity from agreement shall be complied with.
Norway.
3. The eligibility of expenditures incurred by a
project partner is subject to the same limitations as Article 4.2
would apply if the expenditures were incurred by the Proof of expenditure
Project Promoter.
Costs incurred by Programme Operators, Project
4. The creation and implementation of the Promoters and project partners shall be supported by
relationship between the Project Promoter and the documentary evidence as required in Article 8.12 of
project partner shall comply with the applicable the Regulation.
national and European Union law on public
procurement as well as Article 8.15 of the
Regulation. Article 4.3
Payments
5. The National Focal Point shall ensure that the
Programme Operator verifies that the partnership 1. Payments to the Programme shall be made when
agreement complies with this article. A draft all relevant conditions for payments stipulated in
partnership agreement or letter of intent shall be this programme agreement and the Regulation have
submitted to the Programme Operator before the been fulfilled.
signing of the project contract.
2. Payments to the Programme shall take the form of
an advance payment, interim payments and payment
of the final balance and shall be made in accordance
Chapter 4 with Articles 9.2, 9.3 and 9.4 of the Regulation.
Finance
3. Payments of the project grant to the Project
Article 4.1 Promoters may take the form of advance payments,
Eligible expenditures interim payments and payments of the final balance.
1. Subject to Article 8.7 of the Regulation, eligible The level of advance payments and their off-set
expenditures of this Programme are: mechanism is set in this programme agreement.
(a) management costs of the Programme Operator in 4. The National Focal Point shall ensure that
accordance with the detailed budget in the financial payments are transferred in accordance with
plan; paragraph 2 of Article 9.1 of the Regulation.
(b) payments to projects within this Programme in 5. Chapter 9 of the Regulation shall apply to all
accordance with the Regulation, this programme aspects related to payments, including currency
agreement and the project contract. exchange rules and handling of interests on bank
accounts.
2. Eligible expenditures of projects are those
actually incurred by the Project Promoter or project
partners, meet the criteria set in Article 8.2 of the
5
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement
Article 4.4 have the financial capacity to continue with the
Transparency and availability of documents implementation of the Programme; or
The National Focal Point shall ensure an audit trail (e) the Programme Operator has, in the opinion of
for financial contributions from the Norwegian the NMFA, been engaged in corruption, fraud or
Financial Mechanism 2014-2021 to the Programme similar activities or has not taken the appropriate
in accordance with Article 9.8 of the Regulation. measures to detect or prevent such activities or, if
they have occurred, nullify their effects.
2. This programme agreement can be terminated by
Article 4.5
mutual agreement between the Parties.
Irregularities, suspension and reimbursements
3. Termination does not affect the right of the Parties
The NMFA has the right to make use of the remedies
to make use of the dispute settlement mechanism
provided in the Regulation, in particular Chapter 13
referred to in Article 5.1 or the right of the NMFA
thereof. The National Focal Point has a duty to take
to make use of the remedies provided in Chapter 13
all necessary measures to ensure that the provisions
of the Regulation.
in Chapter 12 and 13 of the Regulation regarding
irregularities, suspension of payments, financial
corrections and reimbursement are complied with.
Article 5.3
Chapter 5 Waiver of responsibility
Final provisions 1. Any appraisal of the Programme undertaken
Article 5.1 before or after its approval by the NMFA, does not
Dispute settlement in any way diminish the responsibility of the
National Focal Point and the Programme Operator
1. The Parties waive their rights to bring any dispute to verify and confirm the correctness of the
related to the programme agreement before any documents and information forming the basis of the
national or international court, and agree to settle programme agreement.
such a dispute in an amicable manner.
2. Nothing contained in the programme agreement
2. If a demand for reimbursement to the NMFA is shall be construed as imposing upon the NMFA or
not complied with by the Beneficiary State, or a the FMO any responsibility of any kind for the
dispute related to a demand for reimbursement arises supervision, execution, completion, or operation of
that cannot be solved in accordance with paragraph the Programme or its projects.
1, the Parties may bring the dispute before Oslo
Tingrett. 3. The NMFA does not assume any risk or
responsibility whatsoever for any damages, injuries,
or other possible adverse effects caused by the
Article 5.2 Programme or its projects including, but not limited
Termination to inconsistencies in the planning of the Programme
or its projects, other project(s) that might affect it or
1. The NMFA may, after consultation with the that it might affect, or public discontent. It is the full
National Focal Point, terminate this programme and sole responsibility of the National Focal Point
agreement if: and the Programme Operator to satisfactorily
(a) a general suspension decision according to address such issues.
Article 13.6 of the Regulation or a decision to 4. Neither the National Focal Point, the Programme
suspend payments according to paragraph 1(h) of Operator, entities involved in the implementation of
Article 13.1 of the Regulation has not been lifted projects, nor any other party shall have recourse to
within 6 months of such a decision; the NMFA for further financial support or assistance
(b) a suspension of payments according to Article to the Programme in whatsoever form over and
13.1 of the Regulation, other than under paragraph above what has been provided for in the programme
1(h), has not been lifted within one year of such a agreement.
decision; 5. Neither the European Free Trade Association, its
(c) a request for reimbursement according to Article Secretariat, including the FMO, its officials or
13.2 of the Regulation has not been complied with employees, nor the NMFA, its officials or
within one year from such a decision; employees, can be held liable for any damages or
injuries of whatever nature sustained by the National
(d) the Programme Operator becomes bankrupt, is Focal Point or the Beneficiary State, the Programme
deemed to be insolvent, or declares that it does not Operator, Project Promoters or any other third
6
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement
person, in connection, be it direct or indirect, with Article 5.4
this programme agreement. Entry into force and duration
6. Nothing in this programme agreement shall be 1. This programme agreement shall enter into force
construed as a waiver of diplomatic immunities and on the date of the last signature of the Parties.
privileges awarded to the European Free Trade
2. This programme agreement shall remain in force
Association, its assets, officials or employees.
until five years have elapsed after the date of the
acceptance of the final programme report.
********
This programme agreement is drawn up in two originals in the English language.
For the Donors For the National Focal Point
Signed in Tallinn, Estonia on 26/04/2018 Signed in Tallinn, Estonia on 26/04/2018
...................................................................... ......................................................................
Audun Halvorsen Jaak Aab
State Secretary, Norwegian Ministry of Minister of Public Administration, Ministry of Finance
Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Estonia
7
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement - Annex I
Annex I to the Programme Agreement
Programme Operators and Partners
Ministry of Economic Affairs and
Programme Operator:
Communications
Donor Programme Partner: Innovation Norway (IN)
IPO: -
Other Programme Partner(s): -
Programme
Increased value creation and sustainable growth
Objective
Expected Frequency
Unit of Source of Baseline Baseline Target
PA Outcome/Output programme Indicator Disaggregation of
measurement verification values year value
results reporting
Estimated annual CO2 Energy
Annual Annually
emissions reductions (tons of N/A audits, 0 N/A 25000
number (APR)
CO2 equivalent per year)1 energy bills
Increased Estimated annual growth in
Business Annually
competitiveness turnover of supported N/A Percentage N/A N/A 5%
report (APR)
of Estonian enterprises2
companies Estimated annual growth in
Business Annually
within focus net operational profit of N/A Percentage N/A N/A 5%
PA01 Outcome 1 report (APR)
areas Green supported enterprises3
Industry Estimated annual decrease of
Innovation, ICT Energy
energy consumption of Annually
and Welfare N/A Percentage audits, 0 N/A 5%
supported enterprises (in (APR)
Technology energy bills
MWh)4
Attendance
Number of Annually
N/A Number sheets/ 0 N/A 10
products/services/processes (APR)
registrations
1 CO2 emissions reductions will be verified by project promoter by performing independent audit or using other reliable method.
2 Definition of “turnover”: Enterprise’s net revenue for a fiscal year (after deduction of VAT, trade reductions and other indirect taxes).
3 Definition of “profit”: Difference between operating income and operating expenses.
4 Decrease of energy consumption will be verified by project promoter by performing independent energy audit or using other reliable method.
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement - Annex I
Expected Frequency
Unit of Source of Baseline Baseline Target
PA Outcome/Output programme Indicator Disaggregation of
measurement verification values year value
results reporting
tested in the Open Cyber
Range security platform5
Number of new
products/services/processes Project
Annually
applied (new-to-the- N/A Number promoters 0 N/A 20
(APR)
enterprise) (disaggregated by records
sector)
Copy of
Number of registered application
Annually
applications for Intellectual N/A Number for 0 N/A 5
(APR)
Property Protection registering
IPR
Semi-
annually
Employment
Number of jobs created6 Gender, Age Number (APR and 0 N/A 100
contracts
September
IFR)
Number of new
Project
products/services/processes Annually
N/A Number promoters 0 N/A 25
developed (disaggregated by (APR)
records
sector)7
Enterprises Semi-
supported to Number of large enterprises annually
Financing
Output 1.1 develop or apply supported in SGS to prepare N/A Number (APR and 0 N/A 15
decisions
innovative green projects for main call8 September
products, IFR)
5 OCR is a virtual environment that is used for cybersecurity training and cyber technology development. Enterprises can test their products, services or processes against cyber threats in virtual testing
environment to guarantee the real life security of products, services and processes.
6 The definition of a job created will follow the definition set out in the Core indicators guidance document: “All jobs (positions) supported or generated during programme implementation, irrespective of
the duration and as a direct result of the EEA and Norway Grants support. Data on the job positions where the salary is not supported by the grants and the position is likely to continue after grant support
has ended, i.e. the number of permanent jobs created – which will be a subset of the total number – may also be kept and reported if needed.
7 Definition of “developed”: Projects where the main activities are user driven R&D, i.e. validation or demonstration of technologies in relevant (industrial) environment, prototypes demonstrated in
operational environment, system completed and qualified. With other words Technology Readiness Level (TRL) 5-8 (EU Commission’s scale used to describe the maturity of a technology). These types of
projects will typically be cooperation between an enterprise and a research institution or similar.
8 Definition of “large enterprise”: The enterprise is considered large when it is characterized by at least one of the three elements mentioned above: employ more than 250 persons, has annual turnover
which exceeds EUR 50 million, and/or an annual balance sheet total exceeding EUR 43 million.
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement - Annex I
Expected Frequency
Unit of Source of Baseline Baseline Target
PA Outcome/Output programme Indicator Disaggregation of
measurement verification values year value
results reporting
services and Semi-
Number of large enterprises
processes annually
supported to apply new Financing
N/A Number (APR and 0 N/A 5
green decisions
September
products/services/processes
IFR)
Semi-
Number of SMEs supported annually
Financing
in SGS to prepare projects N/A Number (APR and 0 N/A 30
decisions
for main call September
IFR)
Semi-
Number of SMEs supported
annually
to apply new green Financing
N/A Number (APR and 0 N/A 15
products/services/processes decisions
September
(new-to-the-enterprise)9
IFR)
Semi-
Number of SMEs supported annually
Financing
to develop new green N/A Number (APR and 0 N/A 5
decisions
products/services/processes September
IFR)
Semi-
Number of large enterprises
annually
supported to develop new Financing
N/A Number (APR and 0 N/A 2
green decisions
September
products/services/processes
IFR)
Semi-
Enterprises Number of SMEs supported annually
supported to Financing
in SGS to prepare projects N/A Number (APR and 0 N/A 25
develop decisions
for main call September
Output 1.2 innovative ICT IFR)
products,
Number of SMEs supported Semi-
services and Financing
to develop ICT products, N/A Number annually 0 N/A 8
processes decisions
services and processes10 (APR and
9 Definition of “SME-s”: SMEs are enterprises which employ fewer than 250 persons and which have an annual turnover not exceeding EUR 50 million, and/or an annual balance sheet total not exceeding
EUR 43 million.
10
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement - Annex I
Expected Frequency
Unit of Source of Baseline Baseline Target
PA Outcome/Output programme Indicator Disaggregation of
measurement verification values year value
results reporting
September
IFR)
Semi-
Number of large enterprises annually
Financing
supported in SGS to prepare N/A Number (APR and 0 N/A 6
decisions
projects for main call September
IFR)
Semi-
Number of large enterprises
annually
supported to develop ICT Financing
N/A Number (APR and 0 N/A 5
products, services and decisions
September
processes
IFR)
Semi-
Number of large enterprises annually
Financing
supported in SGS to prepare N/A Number (APR and 0 N/A 2
decisions
projects for main call September
IFR)
Copies of
contracts
Enterprises
signed with
supported to Semi-
Project
develop Number of enterprises annually
Promoters;
Output 1.3 innovative supported in SGS to prepare N/A Number (APR and 0 N/A 8
Project
welfare products, projects for main call September
Promoters’
services and IFR)
reports,
processes
partnership
agreements
Semi-
Number of SMEs supported
annually
to develop new welfare Financing
N/A Number (APR and 0 N/A 5
technology decisions
September
products/services/processes
IFR)
Semi-
Number of SMEs supported
Open Cyber Attendance annually
to test new
Output 1.4 Range (OCR) is N/A Number sheets/ (APR and 0 N/A 30
products/services/processes
operational registrations September
in the Open Cyber Range
IFR)
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement - Annex I
Expected Frequency
Unit of Source of Baseline Baseline Target
PA Outcome/Output programme Indicator Disaggregation of
measurement verification values year value
results reporting
Semi-
Attendance annually
Number of professional staff
Gender, Roma Number sheets/ (APR and 0 N/A 100
trained
registrations September
IFR)
Data collection, and
Semi-
publishing environment To be
annually
architecture and data specified
N/A Binary (APR and No 2019 Yes
analysis environment with PDP
September
architecture developed and promoter
IFR)
published
Semi-
To be
Data collection and annually
specified
publishing procedures/tools N/A Binary (APR and No 2019 Yes
with PDP
in place and documented September
promoter
Health Sense IFR)
data Semi-
To be
management Data analysis annually
Output 1.5 specified
platform procedures/tools in place and N/A Binary (APR and No 2019 Yes
with PDP
developed and documented September
promoter
operating IFR)
Semi-
Number of data To be
annually
mining/Artificial Intelligence specified
N/A Number (APR and 0 N/A 3
pilot projects successfully with PDP
September
finished promoter
IFR)
Semi-
annually
Number of professional staff Attendance
Gender, Roma Number (APR and 0 N/A 10
trained sheets
September
IFR)
Enhanced Level of satisfaction with the Survey Annually
Bilateral Bilateral Outcome State type Scale 1-7 711 2020 ≥4.512
collaboration partnership results (APR)
11 Survey carried out on behalf of the FMO
12 And an increase on the baseline
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement - Annex I
Expected Frequency
Unit of Source of Baseline Baseline Target
PA Outcome/Output programme Indicator Disaggregation of
measurement verification values year value
results reporting
between Level of trust between
beneficiary and cooperating entities in Survey Annually
State type Scale 1-7 713 2020 ≥4.514
donor state Beneficiary States and results (APR)
entities involved Donor States
in the Share of donor business
programme partnerships which continue Survey Annually
N/A Percentage N/A N/A 50 %
after project implementation results (APR)
period
Copy of
Number of jointly registered application
Annually
applications for Intellectual Donor State Number for 0 N/A 3
(APR)
Property Protection registering
IPR
Share of cooperating
organisations that apply the Survey Annually
State type Percentage N/A N/A ≥50%
knowledge acquired from results (APR)
bilateral partnership
Semi-
Number of projects annually
Financing
involving cooperation with a Donor State Number (APR and 0 N/A 45
decisions
donor project partner September
Bilateral IFR)
Bilateral Output 1 partnerships
supported Semi-
annually
Number of staff from donor Gender, Donor Attendance
Number (APR and 0 N/A 5
states in exchanges State sheets
September
IFR)
13 Survey carried out on behalf of the FMO
14 And an increase on the baseline
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement - Annex I
Conditions
General
1) The National Focal Point shall ensure that the Programme Operator, prior to signing a project
contract for pre-defined project no. 1 “Open Cyber Range (OCR)” and no. 2 “Health Sense”, carries
out an external and independent appraisal of the project, in order to verify its quality and contribution
to the objectives of the Programme as well as compliance with EU and national legislation.
Pre-eligibility
1) No costs shall be eligible under pre-defined project no. 1 “Open Cyber Range (OCR)” and no. 2
“Health Sense” before the detailed descriptions and budgets for these pre-defined projects have been
submitted to and approved by the NMFA.
Pre-payment
1) The Programme Operator shall submit the summary description of the procedure for the selection
of projects to the NMFA for approval, prior to the publication of the small grant scheme and call for
proposals foreseen under this programme. The programme agreement shall be amended accordingly.
2) The Programme Operator shall submit a communication plan for the programme to the NMFA for
approval, prior to the publication of the small grant scheme and call for proposals foreseen under this
programme.
Pre-completion
Not applicable
Post-completion
Not applicable
Eligibility of costs - period First date Final date
Eligibility of costs 10/05/2017 31/12/2024
Grant rate and co-financing
Programme eligible expenditure (€) € 27,058,824
Programme grant rate (%) 85.00 %
Maximum amount of Programme grant - EEA Financial Mechanism (€) -
Maximum amount of Programme grant - Norwegian Financial Mechanism (€) € 23,000,000
Maximum amount of Programme grant - Total (€) € 23,000,000
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement - Annex I
Norway Programme Programme co- Programme eligible Advance
PA Budget Heading Total grant
Grants grant rate financing expenditure payment
Programme
PM € 1,723,000 € 1,723,000 85.00 % € 304,059 € 2,027,059 n/a
management
Outcome 1 (Norway €
PA01 € 21,277,000 85.00 % € 3,754,765 € 25,031,765 n/a
Grants) 21,277,000
€
Total € 23,000,000 85.00 % € 4,058,824 € 27,058,824 €0
23,000,000
Retention of management costs
Retention of management costs - percentage of the management costs 10.00 %
Retention of management costs - planned Euro value € 202,706
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement - Annex II
Competitiveness
Operational rules (Annex II)
1. Programme summary
This Annex sets out the operational rules for the programme. The programme agreement is based on
the MoU, the concept note and comments made by the NMFA. Commitments, statements and
guarantees, explicit as well as implicit, made in the concept note, are binding for the National Focal
Point and the Programme Operator unless otherwise explicitly stipulated in the annexes to this
programme agreement.
The Programme Operator is the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications of Estonia. Certain
tasks of the Programme Operator may be delegated to the Enterprise Estonia (EE), however this does
not in any way reduce or restrict the responsibility of the Programme Operator. Innovation Norway (IN)
shall act as Donor Programme Partner.
The programme shall support the outcomes “Increased competitiveness of Estonian companies within
focus areas Green Industry Innovation, ICT and Welfare Technology,” by way of one open call for
proposals, one small grant scheme (SGS), and two pre-defined projects.
The programme has three focus area, Green Industry Innovation, ICT, and Welfare Technology, with
ICT as a horizontal issue across Green Industry Innovation and Welfare technology.
The Programme targets 50% of funds to be allocated into Green Industry Innovation (through ICT-
related projects) and ensures that minimum 75% of the funding goes to SMEs.
2. Eligibility
2.1 Eligible applicants:
The rules on eligibility of applicants are set in Article 7.2 of the Regulation. In accordance with Article
7.2.4, the following entities shall be eligible:
* For the open call and the small grant scheme, eligible applicants are companies registered in the
Estonian Commercial Register. Eligible project partners are legal entities established in Estonia or in
Norway.
2.2 Special rules on eligibility of costs:
Costs are eligible in accordance with chapter 8 of the Regulation.
3. Bilateral relations
3.1 Bilateral relations
The Programme shall contribute to strengthening bilateral relations between Estonia and Norway.
The Programme shall as appropriate facilitate donor partnership projects by carrying out, inter alia,
match-making events and activities in conjunction with launching calls for proposals, as well as by
encouraging donor partnership projects in call texts.
The further use of the funds for bilateral relations allocated to the programme shall be agreed in the
Cooperation Committee.
4. Selection of projects and financial parameters
4.1 Open calls and availability of funds (including number of calls, duration of calls, and estimated size):
Indicative Minimum/Maximum grant
Outcome Modality Total available amount
timing applied for
16
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement - Annex II
Increased Call for 2019 €18,500,000
competitiveness of proposals
Estonian companies Green Industry Innovation
within focus areas and ICT:
Green Industry (Green Industry Innovation and
Innovation, ICT and ICT: €14,075,000) €200,000 – €700,000
Welfare Technology
(Welfare Technology: Welfare Technology:
€4,425,000)
€200,000 – €1,250,000
Small Grant 2018 €1,200,000 €10,000 – €20,000
Scheme
One call for proposals will be launched under the programme. The call will make available €14,075,000
to the focus areas Green Industry Innovation and ICT and €4,425,000 to the focus area Welfare
Technology. The call will remain open until the funds have been exhausted.
4.2 Selection procedures:
The project evaluation and award of grants shall be in accordance with Article 7.4 of the Regulation.
The Programme Operator shall be responsible for the project evaluation and the award of grants.
Small grant scheme:
The small grant scheme will be administered by Enterprise Estonia.
Enterprise Estonia shall review the applications received for compliance with the administrative and
eligibility criteria.
Each application that meets the administrative and eligibility criteria shall be reviewed by two impartial
experts appointed by Enterprise Estonia. The experts shall separately score the applications from 0-4,
according to the selection criteria published with the call for proposals. For the purpose of ranking the
applications, the average of the scores awarded by the experts shall be used. Applications receiving an
17
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement - Annex II
average score of less than 2.50, or if the average score within one criterion is less than 2.00, shall be
rejected. If the evaluation results with one expert scoring the application above and the other expert
scoring the application below the thresholds, a third expert shall be commissioned by the Enterprise
Estonia to score the application independently. In such cases, the average score of the two closest scores
shall be used for the ranking of applications.
A ranked list of the projects recommended for funding shall be prepared for the management board of
Enterprise Estonia, which shall make the decision on which projects shall be supported.
Open call for proposals:
The programme agreement shall be amended following submission of the summary description of the
procedure for the selection of projects under the open call to the NMFA.
4.3 Project grant rate:
Grants from the programme may be up to 75% of total eligible expenditure of the project. The grant
rates for the pre-defined projects are set in section 5.1. The project grant rate shall in all cases be set at
a level that complies with the State Aid rules in force and takes into account any and all other forms of
public support granted to projects. Any remaining costs of the project shall be provided by the Project
Promoter.
5. Additional mechanisms within the Programme
5.1 Pre-defined projects
There will be two pre-defined projects implemented under the Programme:
1) "Open Cyber Range (OCR)"
Project Promoter: Estonian Ministry of Defence
Donor project partner(s): Norwegian University for Science and Technology (NTNU)
Other project partner(s): Tallinn University of Technology
Total maximum eligible costs: € 3,331,765
Project grant rate: 100.00 %
Maximum project grant amount: € 3,331,765
Programme outcome the project contributes to: “Increased competitiveness of Estonian companies
within focus areas Green Industry Innovation, ICT and Welfare Technology”.
The pre-defined project shall create an environment for companies to test, experiment and validate
newly developed products to meet the growing need for enhanced cybersecurity. Activities will include
creating a platform for (new) cybersecurity companies to develop, test and validate innovative products,
create a launch pad for new products to emerge to the market, promote security thinking in private
sector and educate better workforce for the private companies.
The programme agreement shall be amended following submission of the detailed description and
budget for this project to the NMFA.
2) "Health Sense"
Project Promoter: Ministry of Social Affairs - Estonia
Donor project partner(s): Norwegian Directorate of Health (HDIR)
Norwegian University for Science and Technology (NTNU)
18
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement - Annex II
Other project partner(s): Health and Welfare Information Systems Center
Tallinn University of Technology
Tartu University
Software Technology and Applications Competence Centre
Total maximum eligible costs: € 2,000,000
Project grant rate: 100.00 %
Maximum project grant amount: € 2,000,000
Programme outcome the project contributes to: “Increased competitiveness of Estonian companies
within focus areas Green Industry Innovation, ICT and Welfare Technology”.
The pre-defined project shall create a virtual environment to collect health, health cycle and lifestyle
data for research and services development purposes supporting Estonian companies in the development
of new products, services and processes in area of welfare technologies.
The programme agreement shall be amended following submission of the detailed description and
budget for this project to the NMFA.
5.2 Financial Instruments
Not applicable.
6. Programme Management
6.1 Payment flows
The Programme Operator shall ensure that payments to projects are made in a timely manner.
Payments of the project grant shall take the form of interim payments and a final payment. The interim
payments shall be paid after the approval of project interim reports and final payments after the approval
of project final report. The interim payments shall be paid within 1 month after the approval of project
interim reports. Upon approval of the final project report a final balance payment, if applicable, shall
be made within 1 month.
The approval of project interim and final reports shall take place within 2 months from the submission
of the required information.
The periodicity of reporting periods, and deadlines for reporting will be further detailed in the
description of the Programme Operator’s management and control systems.
In case of euro-denominated contracts with entities from Donor States or with intergovernmental
organizations, the Programme Operator shall transfer the amounts in euro.
6.2 Verification of payment claims
The Programme Operator verifies that the expenditures declared by the project promoters have actually
been incurred and complies with the Regulation, the Programme Agreement as well as applicable
national and European Union law and that the financial contribution is used exclusively for the purpose
of the programme and its projects and according to the Programme Agreement.
Payments to projects are made on the basis of approved payment claims. Payment claim, submitted as
integral part of the interim and final project reports, will be reviewed by the Programme Operator.
Verification and approval of the payment claim will be based on information on incurred costs, financial
status and project's progress described in reports, and on additional information to be submitted together
with reports, if required by the Programme Operator.
19
EE-INNOVATION – Norwegian FM
Programme Agreement - Annex II
In line with point i) of Article 5.6.2 of the Regulation incurred expenditure reported shall be subject to
administrative verifications before the report is approved. Verifications to be carried out shall cover
administrative, financial, technical and physical aspects of projects, as appropriate and be in accordance
with the principle of proportionality.
Additionally, in line with point ii) of Article 5.6.2 of the Regulation on–the-spot verifications of
projects, which may be carried out on a sample basis, shall be carried out.
The verification of costs will be based on sample methods taking into account results of the project
implementation risk analysis. After approval of the payment claim the disbursement of the grant to the
project promoter is made.
The detailed procedure for verification of payment claims, periodicity of reporting periods, and
deadlines for reporting will further be outlined in the description of the programme rules of procedure
and Programme Operator’s management and control systems.
6.3 Monitoring and reporting
The Programme Operator shall monitor, record and report on progress towards the programme’s
outcomes in accordance with the provisions contained in the legal framework. The Programme Operator
shall ensure that suitable and sufficient monitoring and reporting arrangements are made with the
project promoters in order to enable the Programme Operator and the NFP to meet its obligations to the
donors.
When reporting on progress achieved in Annual and Final Programme Reports, the Programme
Operator shall disaggregate results achieved as appropriate and in accordance with instructions and
templates received from the FMO.
6.4 Programme administrative structures
The programme is operated by the Estonian Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications.
Enterprise Estonia will act as the implementing agency and will be involved in the selection process
as well as take on tasks related to verification of payments, payments to project promoters, monitoring
of the projects and preparing the interim financial reports to be submitted to the Certifying Authority
by the Programme Operator. Monitoring of financial management and budgeting will be followed by
general state budget rules. The organisational structure of the Programme Operator shall ensure
independence and functional separation of the division responsible for verification of incurred
expenditure and approval of payments from other divisions responsible for the implementation of the
programme.
7. Communication
The Programme Operator shall comply with Article 3.3 of the Regulation, the Information and
Communication Requirements in Annex 3 of the Regulation and the Communication plan for the
programme.
8. Miscellaneous
Not applicable.
20
Maris Juha
Andmekaitse Inspektsioon
[email protected] Meie 05.10.2020 nr 24.4-7/17-0504/5688-3
Programmi „Green ICT“ projekti „Health Sense“
taotlusele hinnangu andmine
Austatud Maris Juha
Viime programmi operaatorina ellu Eesti-Norra finantsmehhanismi 2014-2021 programmi „Green
ICT“, mille peamiseks eesmärgiks on toetada Eesti ettevõtjate jätkusuutlikku arengut ning
suurendada Eesti ja Norra innovatsioonialast koostööd ja ettevõtete lisandväärtust.
Lisaks avatud taotlusvoorude kaudu Eesti ettevõtjate algatatud projektide toetamisele on
programmi osaks ka eelnevalt kindlaks määratud projektide elluviimine. Üheks nimetatud
projektidest on Sotsiaalministeeriumi poolt algatatud projekt „Health Sense“, mille peamine
eesmärk on välja töötada turvaline andmete salvestamise, integreerimise, juurdepääsu ja analüüsi
tööriistakomplekt, et pakkuda suuri, keerukaid ja üksikasjalikke tervishoiu- ja elutsükliandmete
kogumeid avalikule sektorile, erasektorile ning teadus- ja arendusasutustele.
Projekti elluviija peab esitama taotluses järgmise olulise info:
- Projekti nimi;
- Projekti elluviija nimi ja organisatsiooni kirjeldus;
- Projekti partneri nimi ja organisatsiooni kirjeldus;
- Projekti Norra partneri nimi ja organisatsiooni kirjeldus;
- Eelneva projektide rakendamise kogemuse kirjeldus;
- Projekti kogumaksumus (€);
- Toetuse määr (%);
- Toetuse summa (€);
- Projekti kestus (kalendrikuud);
- Selgitus projekti eesmärgi ja vajalikkuse kohta;
- Põhjendus, miks peab projekti ellu viima eelnevalt kindlaks määratud projektina;
- Projekti sihtrühma kirjeldus (kellele projekt on suunatud);
- Projekti mõju otsesele sihtrühmale;
- Projekti tegevuste ja väljundite kirjeldus;
- Projekti oodatava tulemuse kirjeldus;
- Võimalike riskide ja nende maandamise meetmete kirjeldus;
- Projekti detailne eelarve;
- Soovi korral muu oluline teave projekti kohta.
Programmi rakendamise reeglite kohaselt peab eelnevalt kindlaks määratud projekti sobivusele
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 625 6342 /
[email protected] / www.mkm.ee
Registrikood 70003158
hinnangu andma programmi operaatorist ning eelnevalt kindlaks määratud projekti kavandajast ja
elluviijast sõltumatu pädev hindaja.
Hindaja peaks kogu projektikirjelduses toodud info alusel andma projekti sobivuse kohta
kokkuvõtliku hinnangu, vastates järgmistele küsimustele:
1) kas kavandatava projekti kvaliteet on piisav;
2) kas kavandatava projekti tulemused aitavad saavutada programmi eesmärki;
3) kas kavandatav projekt on kooskõlas Euroopa Ühenduse ja Eesti seadusandlusega.
Oleksime äärmiselt tänulikud, kui saaksite anda hinnangu, kas nimetatud projekti raames
kavandatavad tegevused ja soovitavad tulemused on kooskõlas Euroopa Ühenduse ja Eesti
seadusandluses sätestatud isikuandmete kaitse põhimõtetega.
Palun andke hinnang võimalusel hiljemalt 19.10.2020. Võimalikele küsimustele vastab Tanel
Tomson (
[email protected]; 639 7642).
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Keit Kaadu
juhataja
Lisad:
1) Programmileping.pdf (sh eesmärk, tulemused ja indikaatorid);
2) Projekti Health Sense kirjeldus.zip.
Tanel Tomson
639 7642
[email protected]
2 (2)