Majandus- ja
Kommunikatsiooniministeerium Our Ref: 09.10.2020 No 1.1-17/201394
[email protected]
Evaluation of project «Health Sense» of the programme «Competitiveness» under the
Norwegian Financial Mechanism 2014-2021
Scope of the Evaluation
On request by Estonian Ministry of Economics and Communications (letter 4.4-7/17-0504/5688-
1 from September 15, 2020) we evaluate project «Health Sense», hereafter "Project" from the
following aspects:
quality of the Project
contribution of Project outcomes to goals of the Programme
correspondence of the Project to EU and Estonian national legislation.
Estonian Information System Authority is the leading national authority on state information
system, IT infrastructure and cyber security.
Sources
Our evaluation is based on the following documents:
Detailed project description (14 p), prepared by Estonian Ministry of Social Affairs
Programme agreement between Norwegian Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Estonian State
Shared Service Center for financing the Programme «Competitiveness».
We also had a meeting and held e-mail correspondence with officials of Health and Welfare
Information Systems Center, to get additional information on technical aspects of the planned data
management platform.
Also, we had e-mail and in-person discussions with officials at Estonian Data Protection
Inspectorate, to get expert advice on data protection aspect of the Project.
Findings
In our opinion:
(1) Project directly and significantly contributes to Programme objectives PA01. In particular the
data management platform contributes to Outcome 1.5 "Health Sense data management platform
developed and operating".
Pärnu mnt 139a / 15169 Tallinn / Estonia / + 372 663 0200 /
[email protected] / www.ria.ee /
registry code 70006317
In addition to that, Project indirectly contributes to Programme Outcome 1.1 "Increased
competitiveness of Estonian companies within focus areas [...] ICT and Welfare Technology". It
is reasonable to expect that Project will work towards indicators "Estimated annual growth in
turnover of supported enterprises", "Estimated annual growth in net operational profit of supported
enterprises" and "Number of products/services/processes".
Target values set for the Outcome indicators look realistic and well achieveable.
(2) Project creates technical capabilities to to provide large, complex and detailed sets of health
and lifecycle data held in governmental databases to a broad variety of service providers and
researchers from public and private sectors.
This opens up virtually endless opportunities to new, innovative services. Impact from new
services to both Estonian economy, international competitiveness of Estonian enterprises and
benefits for service consumers would be significant.
(3) Data protection concerns in the project are very important. These concerns are addressed
adequately at that point. Government sharing or even selling people's personal data is very
sensitive, perhaps even a contentious issue.
Technical solution envisioned in Project puts data pseudonymisation, anonymisation and use
consent to keystones of the platform.
It has to be noted, that advances in national legislation and maybe even on EU level legislation are
needed put the capabilities of the platform into full use. Liaison activities with legislators are
planned in the Project.
Technical platform, and tools (access control mechanism, pseudonymisation machines etc.)
planned in the project allow fine-grained control over access and use of data. The platform is
architected to be quite flexible. The privacy protection tools can be combined in many ways.
Specific data uses and services created on the platform are subject to appropriate permits and
supervision by respective authority (Estonian Data Protection Inspectorate), in compliance with
the national law.
As theses uses of data in services can be very different, legality of these services have to be
evaluated case-by-case. Estonia has data protection law as well as permission and supervision
procedures in place to handle these cases.
(4) Architecture of the technical solution is sound.
(5) Project partners, in our opinion, are well suited for the project and capable to achieve planned
outcomes.
In particular, R&D institutions involved in the Project (Tallinn University of Technology,
Software Technology and Applications Competence Centre) have internationally renowned
expertise in privacy protection technologies - one of the focus points of the Project.
One can mention, among many others, an innovative Estonian COVID-19 forewarning app,
development of Consent Management infrastructure, and national Data Lake Initiative.
2 (3)
Conclusion
On the basis of detailed project description and supplementary communication with the leading
Project partner (Health and Welfare Information Systems Center) we find that the Project suites
well with the intent and provisions of the Programme.
Project plan is prepared well. There are also several completed and on-going development projects
by Estonian Information System Authority, Health and Welfare Information Systems Center a.o.
agencies that create supportive context for the Project.
Project would be a significant advancement in Estonian digital economy.
In conclusion, the Project is of high quality and, in our opinion, contributes well to the Programme
outcomes. Data protection concerns, that are important in the Project, are also addressed
adequately.
Respectfully,
(signed digitally)
Margus Noormaa
Director General
3 (3)