Mr Martin Helme
Minister of Finance of the Republic of Estonia
Suur-Ameerika 1
10122 Tallinn
Estonia
Sent via email; in copy: Taavi Aas (Minister of Economic Affairs); Sven Sester (Member of the
Parliament of Estonia)
RE: Consultation input from Airbnb regarding your consideration to require online
platforms to share personal host data in Estonia
9 October 2020
Dear Finance Minister Mr Helme,
With great interest, we have been closely following the ongoing legislative discussion about the
revision of the Tourism Act in Estonia and learned about your latest amendment that would
introduce a new obligation for online platforms to share personal host data about their incomes.
Below I am providing you with more detailed comments and setting out initial thoughts on how
we typically address some of the topics that you have been seeking to address with your
amendment. For ease of reference, I am noting our main points here:
● We believe in a coordinated, scalable and standardized data reporting approach at the
EU level (e.g. through the DAC 7 regime) as well as globally, such as the one led by the
OECD. A unilateral national approach will not help you achieve your intended goals, and
will only constitute legal and reputational challenges as well as significant costs and
burdensome processes for local companies.
● In the interim, we would be happy to discuss with you reasonable options for educating
hosts in Estonia to help them follow their tax obligations, on top of our existing
collaboration with the Estonian Tax and Customs Board.
To start off, Airbnb has been designed to allow individuals to share their homes or underutilised
space. It is an online platform, a marketplace that connects hosts and guests. Home sharing
provides much needed extra income for normal people - our host community includes seniors,
students and freelance users - and it opens a new world of previously inaccessible destinations
to guests from around the world. Considering that guests on Airbnb typically stay longer
(average trip length is approx. 3 nights in Estonia) than guests staying in more traditional
accommodation facilities, and thus spend more money in the neighborhoods in which
they stay, their contribution to the local economy is quite significant.
1
Airbnb Germany GmbH
Alexanderstr. 7
10178 Berlin
Germany
This goes without saying that the vast majority of each euro spent on Airbnb flows
directly to hosts, who keep up to 97 percent of the amount they charge to rent their
space. Hosts then spend and reinvest their earnings in a number of ways including household
expenses, rent or mortgage payments, cleaners, home improvement, healthcare and education.
In many cities and countries around the world, we understand that there are local rules for home
sharing as well as tourist and income taxes to be collected. Even though it is ultimately the
responsibility of hosts to comply with local obligations, we have a role as a responsible
platform to help them follow the rules. We strongly believe that non-compliance of platform
operators is often a result of lack of knowledge and clarity about the applicable tax rules.
Platforms can help inform and educate platform sellers about the rules.
As per our already published Community Compact1, in places that respect the right of people to
share their homes and where the Airbnb community has a significant presence, we work to
ensure that the community pays its fair share of taxes while honoring our commitment to
protect our hosts’ and guests’ privacy in line with applicable data privacy laws such as
the GDPR. In addition, we are working with cities and governments to promote clear rules for
existing and new partners of the short-term accommodation sector, incl. home sharers and
short-term rental professionals - ensuring proportionality, transparency, diversity in the
accommodation offering as well as vibrant local communities and positive economic impact.
As you might be aware, Airbnb has been automatically collecting and remitting the tourism
tax in the City of Vilnius in Lithuania on behalf of hosts since 1 February 2020.2 Airbnb has
become the first and only online platform to do this in the Baltic States. To date, we have
concluded around 500 agreements with local and national governments and organizations
around the world on the automated collection of tourism taxes. Globally, Airbnb has already
collected more than $2 billion in tourist-related taxes through such agreements.
In terms of income tax and corresponding data exchange with tax authorities, we
understand and acknowledge the importance of effective taxation of income that
individuals and entrepreneurs generate through platforms, and the complexity that this
entails. We are motivated to support the governments and tax authorities in their efforts to
ensure correct taxation. In this spirit, we agreed with the Estonian Tax and Customs Board
(ETCB) on a unique collaboration in December 2018 that gives an option to hosts on
Airbnb in Estonia to automatically report their earnings to the ETCB at the click of a
button.3 In line with Estonia’s advanced e-governance and part of Airbnb’s vision to spread the
benefits of home sharing to everyone, this tool makes it easier for hosts on Airbnb in Estonia to
report their incomes and pay their fair share of tax.
1
https://www.airbnbcitizen.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/11/Airbnb-Community-Compact.pdf
2
https://news.airbnb.com/airbnb-signs-first-tax-collaboration-in-central-and-eastern-europe/
3
https://www.emta.ee/eng/estonia-and-airbnb-sign-unique-agreement-host-income-tax
2
Airbnb Germany GmbH
Alexanderstr. 7
10178 Berlin
Germany
Moving forward, the digital economy and associated data reporting is becoming a global
issue that needs a global solution, and both platforms and countries must work together.
As more tax authorities are looking into data reporting and also approaching us and other online
platforms with exactly the same ideas and inquiries, we are actively partaking in this discussion
and would also like to share our suggestions on how to move forward. While we have
proactively engaged with numerous local, regional and national regulators on everything from
data-sharing agreements to providing online tools to make it easier for hosts on Airbnb to share
such information directly, it is becoming unmanageable for online platforms in the longer
term to follow multiple unique and different reporting systems in more than 200
jurisdictions globally. As platforms are increasingly exposed to a realm of overly-complex and
often-times legally contradictory reporting and data privacy regulations today, the complexity is
further multiplied by fragmented rules – not only at national, but also at regional and municipal
levels – that also apply to the users of platforms such as ours. In addition, platforms must also
take into account GDPR and data privacy laws. Violations of these can have substantial
penalties and business impact - particularly on local SMEs.
To that end, we believe in a coordinated, scalable and standardized data reporting
approach at the EU level (e.g. through the DAC 7 regime) as well as globally, such as the
one led by the OECD to which we have expressed our support. A consistent regime such as
DAC 7 will provide sufficient data for Member States to use for user tax purposes. Since
reporting the data occurs by platforms reporting to their Member State of Incorporation (in our
case Irish Revenue) and the local authority sharing the data with the other Member States, that
alleviates GDPR-related risk as opposed to unilateral laws on the national level. In addition, the
DAC 7 regime is written broadly to capture all platforms in all sectors, so the governments will
have the data for users regardless of how many platforms on which they provide their services.
This gives each government full visibility over every user.
As the trend is moving in the direction of a universal data reporting regime, we believe that there
is currently no need for a unilateral law - this would in our view be a clear step backwards,
especially in such progressive and innovative countries like Estonia. Therefore, we would be
obliged if you could hold off and wait for some more time until the final framework is
finalized and enacted shortly on the EU Member State level.
In the interim, we would be happy to discuss with you reasonable options for notifying hosts of
any specific information or requirements that they need to be aware of in Estonia. As per our
global experience with working with more than 500 local governments and cities, this can
practically entail a 2-stepped approach.
1. Updating the Estonian responsible hosting page and communicating it in our
collaboration:
3
Airbnb Germany GmbH
Alexanderstr. 7
10178 Berlin
Germany
From our experience, we have learned that dedicated pages on responsible hosting in
local language and proactive communication about the pages are particularly impactful
and welcomed by cities, tax authorities and governments around the world. We would
be happy to discuss this in a further conversation if you feel it would be useful. Typically
we would include a summary of the actual home-sharing law and tax, and provide
hyperlinks to official websites for more information, update the content and share
existing income tax guides4 prepared by an independent third-party accounting firm. For
reference, see our existing responsible hosting page in Estonia5.
2. Sending out an annual tax reminder to hosts:
To make sure that our host community is aware of their obligations particularly around
critical deadlines such tax reporting, we can also send tailored annual reminders that
typically include custom information and hyperlinks to our local responsible hosting page
or official websites (both in English and Estonian/Russian). This is an incredibly powerful
tool as a direct email campaign produces higher interest and response rates. Some tax
authorities also wish to share a video presentation or support a tax workshop with hosts
directly.
I believe that the above mentioned stepped approach will not only respond to your immediate
needs in tax and tourism policy, but also allow local people to partake in the sharing economy
and as such benefit their household, cities, and Estonia as a whole. We have already built
strong relationships with a number of destinations on policy, rules, and partnerships, and we
also seek to build further on the great foundations we have built with you in Estonia. Please let
me know your thoughts.
Kind regards,
Dr. Vladimir Beroun
Public Policy Manager
Central and Eastern Europe (CEE)
Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS)
4
Estonia - Tax Considerations On Short-Term Lettings
5
https://www.airbnb.com/help/article/2431/?locale=et
4
Airbnb Germany GmbH
Alexanderstr. 7
10178 Berlin
Germany
Saatja: Taavi Aas <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 09.10.2020 08:27
Adressaat: MKM info <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: Airbnb's consultation input regarding Tourism Act in Estonia
From: Vladimir Beroun <
[email protected]> Sent: Friday, October
9, 2020 7:00 AMTo: Martin Helme <
[email protected]>Cc:
[email protected]; Taavi Aas <
[email protected]>; Tuuli Koch
<
[email protected]>; Kati Kikas <
[email protected]>; Kersti Kracht
<
[email protected]>; Artur Lundalin <
[email protected]>Subject:
Airbnb's consultation input regarding Tourism Act in Estonia
Dear Finance Minister Mr Helme,My name is Vladimir Beroun and I am
leading Public Policy at Airbnb in the region of Central and Eastern
Europe & the Baltic States.
Please see attached a letter from Airbnb with our reaction to the latest
regulatory considerations in relation to the Tourism Act and associated
data reporting element that you have proposed.
Thank you very much for taking this into consideration. Do not hesitate
to reach out to me in case you have any questions or comments.
With respect,
Vladimir
Dr. Vladimir Beroun
Public Policy Manager
Central and Eastern Europe (CEE)
The Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS)