QUESTIONNAIRE A RTICLE 12 ON CONSUMER INFORMATION AND EMPOWERING PROGRAMME Name [insert] Role [insert] Organisation [insert] Member State [insert] Type of stakeholder [insert] Date [insert] Context and background This questionnaire is part of the Technical assistance project for the ex-post evaluation and impact assessment of the review of the Directive 2012/27/EU on Energy Efficiency (EED) . The review takes place in the context of the European Green Deal and the Climate Target Communication which announced to increase the climate target to at least 55% in a responsible way by 2030. In this regard, the Commission has committed itself to review and possibly revise, if necessary, the energy and climate legislation to support a possible increase of the climate ambition. To this end, the purpose of the technical assistance study is to support the Commission services in assessing the overall performance, effectiveness of the implementation of the EED since its entry into force and particularly assess those articles that have not been revised as part of the Clean Energy for all Europeans Package . These articles include amongst others: Article 5 on the exemplary role of buildings, Article 6 on public purchasing, Article 8 on energy audits, Article 9-11 on metering and billing (of natural gas), Article 15 on transformation, transmission and distribution, Article 16 on qualification and accreditation, Article 18 on energy services, Article 19 on split incentives, Article 20 on financing and technical support. The Commission shall also asses possible modification related to the increase of energy efficiency targets in Article 1, Article 3 and in Article 7 (1) (b). For certain issues / weakness identified in relation to the implementation of specific articles, we would seek your views on what could be the potential solutions to improve the effectiveness of such articles in the future. Article 12 was included in the original EED to promote consumer empowerment and eventually promote the efficient use of energy by small energy customers. The Article is encouraging Member States to take measures to promote behavioural change and engage consumers during any roll-out of smart meters. It should be noted that Article 12 does not oblige Member States to specific activities but it encourages them to think specifically of the small and domestic energy consumers and take measures accordingly. Your written feedback and in some instances complementing interviews will serve as key input to the assessment of the implementation of the specific provisions of the EED and allowing to assess specific factors that have contributed to or held back the implementation of the EED and the achievement of the objectives of the EED. Furthermore, the aim is also to identify possible solutions to improve the framework of the EED. The questions are structured around five evaluation criteria: effectiveness, efficiency, relevance, coherence and added value in line with the Commission Better Regulation Guidelines. Logistics and timing The questionnaires is shared with you in advance of the targeted workshop that will be conducted with the aim of discussing the implementation and performance of the specific articles on 2 1 October 2020. We kindly ask to send your written response to the questions by 21 October 2020 . Please send your response to
[email protected] and
[email protected] . Please let us know should you need additional time to finalise your input. If similar information has already been sent to the Commission in another occasion by your country/organisation, we would like to acknowledge this by inviting you to also submit your previous contribution attached together with your answers to this questionnaire. To what extent has the EED c ontributed to informing and empowering (small) energy consumers ? Contributed to a large extent ☐ Contributed to a moderate extent ☐ Contributed to a small extent ☐ Did not contribute ☐ I do not know ☐ Please explain your answer How could the provisions in article 12 be reinforced to create larger impact? What should be different to enhance its role for energy consumers? Please explain your answer What energy efficiency issues and challenges should article 12 further address with regard to consumers? Please explain your answer
QUESTIONNAIRE A RTICLE 19 ON OTHER MEASURES TO PROMOTE ENERGY EFFICIENCY Name [insert] Role [insert] Organisation [insert] Member State [insert] Type of stakeholder [insert] Date [insert] Context and background This questionnaire is part of the Technical assistance project for the ex-post evaluation and impact assessment of the review of the Directive 2012/27/EU on Energy Efficiency (EED) . The review takes place in the context of the European Green Deal and the Climate Target Communication , which announced to increase the climate target to at least 55% in a responsible way by 2030. In this regard, the Commission has committed itself to review and possibly revise, if necessary, the energy and climate legislation to support a possible increase of the climate ambition . To this end, the purpose of the technical assistance study is to support the Commission services in assessing the overall performance, effectiveness of the implementation of the EED since its entry into force and particularly assess those articles that have not been revised as part of the Clean Energy for all Europeans Package . These articles include amongst others: Article 5 on the exemplary role of buildings, Article 6 on public purchasing, Article 8 on energy audits, Article 9-11 on metering and billing (of natural gas), Article 15 on transformation, transmission and distribution, Article 16 on qualification and accreditation, Article 18 on energy services, Article 19 on split incentives, Article 20 on financing and technical support. The Commission shall also asses possible modification related to the increase of energy efficiency targets in Article 1, Article 3 and in Article 7 (1) (b). For certain issues / weakness identified in relation to the implementation of specific articles, we would seek your views on what could be the potential solutions to improve the effectiveness of such articles in the future. Article 19 deals with the identification and removal of regulatory and non-regulatory barriers to energy efficiency in two specific cases: The split incentives among owners or between owners and tenants of buildings Public purchasing and annual budgeting and accounting In both cases, Member States shall evaluate the need and, if they conclude that it is necessary, shall take measures and lift barriers that would hinder investments in improving energy efficiency. Article 19 was included in the original EED and a first list of barriers and measures was included in the National Energy Efficiency Action Plans of 2014. Your written feedback and in some instances complementing i nterviews will serve as key input to the assessment of the implementation of the specific provisions of the EED and allowing to assess specific factors that have contributed to or held back the implementation of the EED and the achievement of the objectives of the EED . Furthermore, the aim is also to identify possible solutions to improv e the framework of the EED. The questions are structured around five evaluation criteria: effectiveness, efficiency, relevance, coherence and added value in line with the Commission Better Regulation Guidelines. Logistics and timing The questionnaire is shared with you in advance of the targeted workshop that will be conducted with the aim of discussing the implementation and performance of the specific arti cles on 21 October 2020. We kindly ask to send your written response to the questions by 21 October 2020 . Please send your response to
[email protected] and
[email protected] . Please let us know should you need additional time to finalise your input. If similar information has already been sent to the Commission in another occasion by your country/organisation , we would like to acknowledge this by inviting you to also submit your previous contribution attached together with your answers to this questionnaire. How do you perceive the existence of regulatory, legal or administrative barriers to energy efficiency in the following areas: Very significant Somewhat significant Not significant No opinion Split incentives between the owner and the tenant(s) of a building ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ Split incentives between owners in multi-owner properties ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ Investments in energy efficiency by individual public bodies prevented due to national rules on public purchasing , annual budgeting or accounting ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ Issuing relevant technical conditions , permits or approvals by public authorities for the actions increasing energy efficiency ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ Issuing relevant technical conditions, permits or approvals by authorities or network operators for the actions increasing energy efficiency ☐ ☐ ☐ ☐ Please explain your answer To what extent have the provisions of the EED contributed to addressing split incentives? Contributed to a large extent ☐ Contributed to a moderate extent ☐ Contributed to a small extent ☐ Did not contribute ☐ I do not know ☐ Please explain your answer To understand the evolution of split incentives, do you monitor the renovation rate per type of building (e.g. flat, single family house, semi-detached house) and per type of tenure status (e.g. owner-occupier or tenant)? Please mention relevant data or studies . Please explain your answer What could the EED do more to help overcoming split incentives and other regulatory barriers? Please explain your answer
Saatja: <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 12.10.2020 17:16
Adressaat: <
[email protected]>; <ENER-EED-
[email protected]>
Koopia: <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <Lelde.KIELA-
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>
Teema: Invitation to the expert workshop dedicated to Energy consumers
and Articles 12 and 19, 21 October 2020
Dear Sir/ Dear Madam,
In the context of the European Green Deal and the objective to make
Europe a carbon neutral continent by 2050, the Commission in its Climate
Target Plan has put forward an increased target for the greenhouse gas
emissions reductions of 55% in 2030. To achieve a higher climate ambition
he Commission committed to review and revise if necessary by June 2021
the Energy Efficiency Directive (2012/27/EU).
To this end, the Commission has launched the review and revision process
by publishing the evaluation roadmap/inception impact assessment
(Roadmap) on the review and the revision of the Energy Efficiency
Directive (EED) on 3 August 2020 (available on Europa Have Your Say
website).
To support the review and the revision processes, the Commission is
organising stakeholder consultation activities through a series of
targeted expert workshops on specific topics related to assessing
different provisions of the Directive , contributing to possible
solutions to the increased climate target for 2030 and also addressing a
potential ambition gap to the existing EU 2030 energy efficiency target
of 32.5%.
The Commission is organising these workshops in the period of September -
October 2020 in order to discuss the relevant topics with a wide range of
stakeholders, researchers and academia, and Member States experts
involved in the specific policy areas. The targeted stakeholder
consultation process has been supported by the COWI consortium (in the
framework of the dedicated evaluation and the impact assessment study for
the EED Review). So far, we have organised six workshops: on heating and
cooling and Article 14, energy efficiency in transmission and
distribution and Article 15, on financing and Article 20, energy
efficiency in public sector related to Articles 5, 6 and 18, energy
audits and Article 8, and energy efficiency targets and general issues.
We would like to invite you to the workshop dedicated to Energy consumers
and Articles 12 and 19. This workshop will be held on 21 October 2020,
14:00 15:30 CET as a webinar (through the WebEx application). More
details including connection information, and the agenda will be
circulated several days before the workshop to the registered
participants.
If you are interested to attend this workshop, we would like to ask you
to confirm your participation to this event to by 16 October 2020 the
latest.
For the purposes of data and information collection related to the
evaluation of the EED, we have prepared short questionnaires covering the
above-mentioned topics and articles. You can find them attached to this
email. Your answers to these questionnaires would provide a very valuable
input to the review of the EED. We would be very grateful if you could
find the time to fill them by 21 October 2020. The data collection
process is supported by the COWI consortium. Please send your response to
these questionnaires to and .
As an alternative to providing written answers to this evaluation
questionnaire, the consultant is organising phone interviews. We would
like to kindly ask you to indicate within two days from receiving this
email whether you would prefer to be interviewed on the basis of these
questionnaires. Please indicate your preference by replying to this email
and/or to and .
We look forward to your input to this very important initiative.
Thank you very much in advance.
Kind regards,
On behalf of Ms Claudia Canevari, Head of Unit C.3: Energy Efficiency,
Policy and Financing,
George Galita European CommissionDG Energy
Unit C3, Energy Efficiency
DM24 04/008
BE-1049 Brussels/Belgium
+32 229- 69493