EU industry as an engine for economic growth and
recovery in the EU: delivering on innovation for the
green & digital transition and gaining from a level
playing field
Background paper for the informal meeting of the Competitiveness Council on 23 October 2020
From its outset, the COVID-19 pandemic has had a major impact on European industry: interrupted
supply chains, travel restrictions and falling demand. At the same time, European industry with its
strong, efficient and highly innovative SMEs, was able to contribute to a quick economic recovery. All
this whilst the overarching aim remains to make European industry greener, more digital and more
resilient, just as Member States highlighted in their Joint Statement of 12 June 2020.
Europe’s industrial sector is already playing a pioneering role in the green and digital transition: Many
firms have recognised the opportunities, potential productivity and business gains which can derive
from green and digital innovations. The European Green Deal and the EU’s Digital Strategy show us
the way ahead and the European Industrial Strategy contains the specific initiatives for industry to
master it. It is important to note that European industry is rightfully attributed its central role: With
its economic weight and innovative power it will be a central enabler of the transition. In order to
play this role, companies face large-ranging decisions on substantial investments. It is now our task
to ensure that framework conditions work for industry and that the right incentives for investment
are set. Innovation should feel at home in Europe.
The new European industrial strategy – an innovation strategy at heart
The European Industrial Strategy itself states that, if the European Union is to be a pioneer of the
twin transition, the industrial strategy will have to be an innovation strategy at heart. It is therefore
crucial to embed an innovative spirit into every aspect of industrial policy. That way we achieve to be
the lead provider of digital, green and disruptive technologies, standards, solutions and industrial
products. The following principles should therefore be applied:
(1) Ensuring a level playing field for innovation and investment
Since the Treaties of Rome, the EU’s competition rules, in tandem with the various national rules,
have formed the basis for fair competition in the Single Market. Innovation and investment are
undertaken by industry itself. The prime task for industrial and competition policy, therefore, is to
establish a policy environment which permits rules-based and fair competition. The European Union
must continue its work to modernize EU competition law and ensure that companies can do business
Informal video conference of ministers responsible for Competitiveness | Page 1
on a level playing field both in the internal market and in the face of international competition. Fair
competition on the internal market requires that companies from third countries are subject to
similar rules as European companies. This applies with regard to state aid as well as to the access to
procurement markets. The European Commission has presented a white paper proposing a new
instrument to level the playing field as regards foreign subsidies.
(2) Facilitating moonshot missions for industrial innovation
In addition to a general business friendly environment with well working and fit-for-purpose
competition rules, industry also benefits from a well-organized, technology-neutral innovation
infrastructure which facilitates the development, introduction and use of technologies, e.g. the
European Digital Innovation Hubs in the Member States. The problem many innovative companies,
in particular SME and start-ups, in Europe face is that of commercialisation, especially that of
financing needed in this regard. We therefore pledge to pay special attention providing financing
possibilities.
Echoing the new European industrial strategy, Europe must pool its strengths to do collectively what
no one can do alone. In the spirit of a moonshot mission, which entails high initial costs and risks,
but can pay off for generations to come, open up entirely new possibilities and develop long-lasting
growth trajectories, Europe industrial policy needs to be more ambitious. We should in particular
concentrate on advancing disruptive game-changing technologies with cross-sectoral impacts and
long-lasting growth projections. Member States recognized in their Joint Statement that the
instrument of Important Projects of Common European Interest (IPCEIs) could be suitable in this
respect. ICPEI are used to realize cross-border cooperation in highly innovative technologies and
value chains. Industrial alliances, an equivalent to IPCEI on the much broader level of industrial
ecosystems, on the other hand offer an appropriate forum for discussing and advancing whole
industrial eco-systems.
Significant industrial projects in the form of IPCEI have already been established: The first IPCEI
Microelectronics with its a proven track record of regaining market share. That is why another IPCEI
for Connectivity and Microelectronics is already underway. Within the world of digital and data
infrastructure a possible Cloud-IPCEI is one way to make progress in developing strong and safe
data platforms. The two IPCEIs in the field of batteries, one of which has already been approved, will
play a vital part in the transition to sustainable mobility sectors and in ensuring that the relevant jobs
are retained or created in the EU. Special attention is required to take care of the energy-intensive
industrial sector. It will be one of the greatest challenges of the coming years – and hydrogen
technology can possibly add greatly to the solution. Clean hydrogen technology can be used to
decarbonise industrial production processes for which no other decarbonisation technologies are
available at present. It can make the green transition both economically viable and sustainable and
by achieving a technological advantage. In July, the Commission launched the European Clean
Hydrogen Alliance to realise the goals of its Hydrogen Strategy. Further to this, the Member States
are aiming to build up initial hydrogen value chains via the Hydrogen IPCEI.
Informal video conference of ministers responsible for Competitiveness | Page 2
(3) Ensure transparency, involve SMEs and advance pan-European cooperation in value networks
If the green and digital transition of Europe’s industry is to succeed and if the crisis is to become an
opportunity for everyone it is important to shape the process ahead with inclusivity. This starts with
making it a transparent process through general availability of information and travels via integrating
companies of all sizes, passing fitting networks and clusters and making sure, that all regions and
Member States with interest in the innovative technology have a chance of participation. Long-term
success will depend on how the flexibility and agility of SMEs can be integrated into this project and
vision of cooperation in European value networks. The key question here is therefore one of
governance and management of cooperation endeavors and Member States commitment to engage
in stronger cooperation. Efforts could be kicked-off by establishing common and clear information
platforms.
Questions for discussion
1. In what areas of the White Paper on levelling the playing field as regards foreign subsidies –
general distortions of competition (module 1), corporate acquisitions (module 2), procurement
(module 3) – do you see a need for new instruments to counter distortions of competition on the
Single Market caused by foreign subsidies?
2. This paper is all about innovation in Europe, how to commercialise it and its context with
industrial competitiveness. In line with the transition processes in front of all of us and our
common striving for more competitiveness:
a. Our goal is the perfect enabling and operating framework for European industry: What
measures and reforms can in your view be taken – at MS and/or EU-Level – to improve the
area of investment in innovation?
b. From your perspective: What technologies will be frontrunning the race for most promising
innovation in the next decade, where and in which sectors do you see Europe leading in the
close future and what do you see as your most challenging task in making this happen?
Informal video conference of ministers responsible for Competitiveness | Page 3
Federal Ministry
for Economic Affairs
and Energy
Invitation
Informal video conference of Ministers responsible for
Competitiveness (Internal Market and Industry)
23 October 2020 ј 09:00 a.m. to 12:00 p.m.
Dear Colleague,
It is my pleasure to invite you to our Informal Meeting of Ministers responsible for
Competitiveness (Internal Market and Industry) which will take place as a video
conference from 09:00 a.m. to 12:00 p.m. on Friday, 23 October.
Regrettably, the Informal Meeting originally scheduled for 22 and 23 October will have
to be held in a virtual format due to the latest increases in the rate of COVID-19
infections in the European Union. I sincerely ask for your understanding for this
decision.
The informal video conference is entitled 'EU industry as an engine for economic growth
and recovery in the EU: delivering on innovation for the green & digital transition and
gaining from a level playing field '. It will focus on the role of industry as a main driver
for economic growth and recovery, in the context of the EU industrial strategy as well as
the twin transition and strategic resilience. I would also like to expand our view on the
external competitiveness and how we can ensure a level playing field in the Internal
Market.
Attached you may find a corresponding Presidency background paper which will
provide you with a more detailed input on what could be discussed and questions to
steer our debate. The programme for the video conference is also enclosed.
The meeting will start with an introductory speech by Executive Vice President of the
European Commission, Margrethe Vestager, followed by introductory remarks by
Commissioner Breton. Mrs Vestager will focus on the `White Paper on levelling the
playing field as regards foreign subsidies', adopted by the European Commission on
17 June 2020. We will also hear keynote speeches by Joe Kaeser, CEO of Siemens, and
Dr Markus 5teilemann, CEO of Covestro and president of PlasticsEurope. Both speakers
represent internationally operating companies that promote digital and sustainable
technologies.
We would all like to make our video conference as lively and productive as possible. My
experience is that the working level in each country puts a great deal of effort into
making their minister's statements as comprehensive as possible. However, this can
turn video conferences into rather cumbersome exercises. Please limit your
interventions to 3 minutes only, and please omit points that could be just as easily
discussed at working level.
Also, ahead of our informal video conference, I would like to give all of us the
opportunity to have a virtual get-together on 22 October from 20:30 to 22:30. Please
only log in personally. The virtual get-together for ministers and participants from the
European Commission (1+0) will also be held as a video conference. There will be no
rules as to what topic you might want to address but, in my view, the EU industrial
strategy, its envisaged update in the first half of 2021 and its application to the twin
transition as well as the latest on industrial policy by the European Council are worth
being discussed. I would ask you to please confirm your attendance by 12:00 on
Monday, 19 October by email to
[email protected].
Further organisational information on the proceedings will be provided to you in
due time.
For any further information please do not hesitate to contact the Head of
Division responsible for the EU Internal Market, Ms Monika Ottemeyer
(phone: + 49 (0)3018 615-6390, email:
[email protected]).
I look forward to continuing our exchange on European competitiveness with you!
Yours sincerely,
Peter Altmaier
Federal Minister for Economic Affairs and Energy
г
Informal video conference of ministers responsible for
Competitiveness (internal market, industry)
23 October 2020 | 9:00 am - 12:00 pm
9:00 – 9:20 Opening of the informal video conference
Welcome and Introduction by Minister Peter Altmaier
Introduction by Executive VP Margrethe Vestager
Introduction by Commissioner Thierry Breton
9:20 – 9:40 Plenary session
[Interpretation DE / EN / ES / FR / IT]
EU industry as an engine for economic growth and recovery in the
EU: delivering on innovation for the green & digital transition and
gaining from a level playing field
Keynote by Joe Kaeser, CEO Siemens AG
Keynote by Dr. Markus Steilemann, CEO Covestro AG
9:40 – 10:30 Tour de table: Reactions by Ministers - 1st part
[Interpretation DE / EN / ES / FR / IT]
10:30 – 11:00 Coffee break
11:00 – 11:45 Tour de table: Reactions by Ministers - 2nd part
[Interpretation DE / EN / ES / FR / IT]
11:45 - 12:00 Wrap-up & summary
Closing remarks by Executive VP Margarethe Vestager
Closing remarks by Commissioner Thierry Breton
Wrap-up & summary by Minister Peter Altmaier
12:30 – 13:00 Press conference of the Presidency and the European Commission
[Interpretation DE / EN / FR]
Agenda Informal COMPET
Saatja: <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 14.10.2020 19:55
Adressaat: MKM info <
[email protected]>
Teema: Official invitation for the Informal video conference of the
Ministers responsible for Competitiveness (Internal Market and Industry)
23 October 2020
Tähtsus: Kõrgeim
Dear Excellency,
It is our pleasure to present to you enclosed the invitation for the
Informal video conference of the Ministers responsible for
Competitiveness (Internal Market and Industry) on Friday, 23 October
2020.
Furthermore, please find attached the agenda as well as the background
paper of the conference.
We are looking forward to a successful and fruitful conference and
remain,
Yours sincerely,
The Protocol of the Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy
________________________
Department LA3 EXTERNAL
On behalf of the Federal Ministry for Economic Affairs and Energy
Scharnhorststr. 34-37, 10115 Berlin
Tel: +49-(30)-18-615-5116
E-Mail:
Internet: