LV/MM/GC/cg
Brussels, 8 March 2022
Economic and Financial Affairs Council
(Ecofin)
[Letter sent by e-mail]
Dear Ministers of the EU,
Considering the ongoing discussions on the future of the EU Economic Governance, we would like to
outline the ETUC priorities on this issue.
For quite some time the ETUC has been calling for a thorough revision of the Stability and Growth Pact,
and the subsequent legislations. Moreover, the current economic and geopolitical environment makes
the strengthening of the European Union’s strategic autonomy an additional argument for such revision.
The ETUC shares the 2019 assessment of the European Fiscal Board (EFB) on the EU fiscal
framework. It points out two of the main problems within the EU fiscal rules: the six-pack legislation and
the subsequent changes have not reduced the procyclicality of fiscal policy; and have not prevented
severe cuts in public investment over the past decade in some Member States. It also identified multiple
sources of unnecessary complexity, calling for a simplification of the existing fiscal framework.
In fact, the ETUC would go a step further, stating that the strengthening of the fiscal rules, following the
global financial crisis (2010), had detrimental economic consequences with dubious effects on public
debt sustainability. It made the EU very reliant on exports, leaving the EU in a dependent geopolitical
position. Moreover, estimations by the EFB (2020) show that if unchanged EU fiscal rules were
activated after lifting the General Escape Clause (GEC), the foreseen debt ratio reduction path would
overburden some Members States. Resulting in significant negative economic, social and political that
would jeopardise the economic recovery in the EU.
A reform of the EU fiscal rules is not only necessary to have a short to medium term stabilisation of the
economy. It is also vital in financing the socio-ecological transformation of our economy, guaranteeing
full employment, high quality jobs and just transitions. To achieve the EU climate targets, an extensive
modernisation of the capital stock is needed.
The ETUC is therefore proposing a set of new fiscal rules that would counter the main deficiencies of
the current framework, especially their procyclical nature, while supporting economic stabilisation and
debt sustainability. In particular, and without changing EU Treaties, the ETUC:
• Supports country-specific fiscal targets, with different adjustment paths, for Member
States. A country-differentiation of debt to GDP reduction strategies should be based on a
comprehensive economic analysis, taking into account: the initial level of debt and its composition;
the interest rate-growth differentials as a matter of sustainability; inflation perspectives; the
projected costs of ageing and environmental challenges; unemployment and poverty levels;
internal and external imbalances; and, primarily, whether the fiscal adjustment is realistic. It is of
upmost importance to develop country-specific plans that enable Member States to effectively
manage their public spending and investment over the long-term, bearing in mind a broad range
of economic, social and environmental factors.
• Calls for the implementation of a golden rule for public investment. As a very first step, the
ETUC suggests that the “investment clause” of the Stability and Growth Pact should be interpreted
more broadly. So far, it has been rarely invoked, primarily because of its restrictive eligibility criteria.
The ETUC suggests a broader definition of public investments. The European Commission’s
guidance to Member States in the context of the Recovery and Resilience Facility (RRF) and the
definition of investments therein, constitutes a good starting point, as it includes investments in
tangible assets but also investments in health, social protection, education and training, and
European Trade Union Confederation | Luca Visentini, General Secretary | Bld du Roi Albert II, 5, B - 1210 Brussels | +32 (0)2 224 04 11 |
[email protected] | www.etuc.or
LV/MM/GC/cg
Brussels, 8 March 2022
investments aiming at the green and digital transition. At the very least, investment projects
financed by the RRF should be included in this list.
• Suggests complementing the golden rule for public investment with an expenditure rule for
current budgets. It means abandoning the contested concepts of structural deficit/balance and
instead, implementing a public expenditure rule in a revised fiscal framework. Unlike the cyclically
adjusted deficit, public expenditures are observable in real time and are directly controlled by the
government. Public investment should be favoured by separating current and investment budgets,
submitting only the current budget to limits for nominal expenditure growth. This way, the golden
rule approach could be combined with an expenditure rule. Nominal public expenditures would
then be calculated net of interest payments, of unemployment spending and spending related to
minimum incomes schemes, and of the estimated impact of any new discretionary revenue
measures; especially since particularly urgent measures are required to address the substantial
staff shortages in health and social care and the related problem of low wages in these sectors.
• Demands, until the new fiscal framework is in place, that the Commission provides guidelines for
a transition period, whereby no excessive deficit procedure should be activated and with the
possibility to use the “unusual event clause” on a country specific basis.
• Reiterates its demand for a permanent fiscal capacity and new own resources. The ETUC
positively assesses, as a breakthrough, the launch of the RRF, financed thought a common
European indebtedness capacity as way to increase the investments needed for the socio-
economic transformation of our economies and promotion of economic, social and territorial
cohesion, employment creation and sustainable growth. The ETUC, calls for a permanent central
fiscal capacity at European level, allowing the European debt to be rolled over, paying interest
through increased own resources, repaying old debts and issuing new ones, which would alleviate
Member States’ contributions to the EU budget without debt transfers. This is consistent with the
ECB, which stated that the “EMU still lacks a permanent fiscal capacity at supranational level for
macroeconomic stabilisation in deep crises”, and with the EFB (2020).
• Finally, the ETUC demands to introduce, in a renewed European Semester and as a
complement of the Macroeconomic Imbalances Procedure, a mechanism to identify,
prevent and address the social imbalances that could negatively affect the working and living
conditions in a Member State, and in turn having a spill over effect on the EU. An “Excessive Social
Imbalances Procedure” should be established to rebalance the economic and social dimensions
of the economic governance. The identification of social imbalances should lead to (i) country
specific recommendations, for national imbalances; and (ii) revisiting the Employment Guidelines
and issuing Euro Area Recommendations to address structural issues (i.e. employment policies),
in case of social imbalances at EU level. A social imbalances procedure (SIP) would represent the
third pillar of (and finally complete) the social dimension of the Semester: besides the principles
and targets set in the European Pillar of Social Rights and in its Action Plan, and data provided by
the Social Scoreboard, the SIP would be the tool needed to achieve those targets and aiming at
an upward social convergence. Actions aiming at supporting the Member States in addressing
excessive social imbalances (incentives) have to be preferred over punitive initiatives from the EU.
A “supportive arm” will entail the EU to intervene and help MS to correct the excessive imbalances
identified.
We hope these proposals will receive your careful attention and be positively assessed.
We are looking forward to hearing from you and having an exchange on this matter.
Best regards,
Luca Visentini Liina Carr
ETUC General Secretary ETUC Confederal Secretary
European Trade Union Confederation | Luca Visentini, General Secretary | Bld du Roi Albert II, 5, B - 1210 Brussels | +32 (0)2 224 04 11 |
[email protected] | www.etuc.or
Saatja: Keit Pillak <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 09.03.2022 09:26
Adressaat: RAM Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: ETUC Letter on the Review of the European economic governance
From: General Secretary <
[email protected]> Sent: Tuesday,
March 8, 2022 3:44 PMTo: General Secretary
<
[email protected]>Cc: GLORIEUX, Coline
<
[email protected]>; Bonacina Emanuela <
[email protected]>;
Carr Liina <
[email protected]>; YETNA, Emmanuella
<
[email protected]>; Casale Giovanni <
[email protected]>;
REPETTI, Lorenzo <
[email protected]>; Cilento Marco
<
[email protected]>Subject: ETUC Letter on the Review of the
European economic governance
Dear Ministers of the EU,
Considering the ongoing discussions on the future of the EU Economic
Governance, we would like to outline the ETUC priorities on this issue.
For quite some time the ETUC has been calling for a thorough revision of
the Stability and Growth Pact, and the subsequent legislations. Moreover,
the current economic and geopolitical environment makes the strengthening
of the European Union’s strategic autonomy an additional argument
for such revision.
The ETUC shares the 2019 assessment of the European Fiscal Board (EFB) on
the EU fiscal framework. It points out two of the main problems within
the EU fiscal rules: the six-pack legislation and the subsequent changes
have not reduced the procyclicality of fiscal policy; and have not
prevented severe cuts in public investment over the past decade in some
Member States. It also identified multiple sources of unnecessary
complexity, calling for a simplification of the existing fiscal
framework.
In fact, the ETUC would go a step further, stating that the strengthening
of the fiscal rules, following the global financial crisis (2010), had
detrimental economic consequences with dubious effects on public debt
sustainability. It made the EU very reliant on exports, leaving the EU in
a dependent geopolitical position. Moreover, estimations by the EFB
(2020) show that if unchanged EU fiscal rules were activated after
lifting the General Escape Clause (GEC), the foreseen debt ratio
reduction path would overburden some Members States. Resulting in
significant negative economic, social and political that would jeopardise
the economic recovery in the EU.
A reform of the EU fiscal rules is not only necessary to have a short to
medium term stabilisation of the economy. It is also vital in financing
the socio-ecological transformation of our economy, guaranteeing full
employment, high quality jobs and just transitions. To achieve the EU
climate targets, an extensive modernisation of the capital stock is
needed.
The ETUC is therefore proposing a set of new fiscal rules that would
counter the main deficiencies of the current framework, especially their
procyclical nature, while supporting economic stabilisation and debt
sustainability. In particular, and without changing EU Treaties, the
ETUC:
· Supports country-specific fiscal targets, with different
adjustment paths, for Member States. A country-differentiation of debt to
GDP reduction strategies should be based on a comprehensive economic
analysis, taking into account: the initial level of debt and its
composition; the interest rate-growth differentials as a matter of
sustainability; inflation perspectives; the projected costs of ageing and
environmental challenges; unemployment and poverty levels; internal and
external imbalances; and, primarily, whether the fiscal adjustment is
realistic. It is of upmost importance to develop country-specific plans
that enable Member States to effectively manage their public spending and
investment over the long-term, bearing in mind a broad range of economic,
social and environmental factors.
· Calls for the implementation of a golden rule for public
investment. As a very first step, the ETUC suggests that the
“investment clause” of the Stability and Growth Pact should
be interpreted more broadly. So far, it has been rarely invoked,
primarily because of its restrictive eligibility criteria. The ETUC
suggests a broader definition of public investments. The European
Commission’s guidance to Member States in the context of the
Recovery and Resilience Facility (RRF) and the definition of investments
therein, constitutes a good starting point, as it includes investments in
tangible assets but also investments in health, social protection,
education and training, and investments aiming at the green and digital
transition. At the very least, investment projects financed by the RRF
should be included in this list.
· Suggests complementing the golden rule for public
investment with an expenditure rule for current budgets. It means
abandoning the contested concepts of structural deficit/balance and
instead, implementing a public expenditure rule in a revised fiscal
framework. Unlike the cyclically adjusted deficit, public expenditures
are observable in real time and are directly controlled by the
government. Public investment should be favoured by separating current
and investment budgets, submitting only the current budget to limits for
nominal expenditure growth. This way, the golden rule approach could be
combined with an expenditure rule. Nominal public expenditures would then
be calculated net of interest payments, of unemployment spending and
spending related to minimum incomes schemes, and of the estimated impact
of any new discretionary revenue measures; especially since particularly
urgent measures are required to address the substantial staff shortages
in health and social care and the related problem of low wages in these
sectors.
· Demands, until the new fiscal framework is in place, that
the Commission provides guidelines for a transition period, whereby no
excessive deficit procedure should be activated and with the possibility
to use the “unusual event clause” on a country specific
basis.
· Reiterates its demand for a permanent fiscal capacity and
new own resources. The ETUC positively assesses, as a breakthrough, the
launch of the RRF, financed thought a common European indebtedness
capacity as way to increase the investments needed for the socio-economic
transformation of our economies and promotion of economic, social and
territorial cohesion, employment creation and sustainable growth. The
ETUC, calls for a permanent central fiscal capacity at European level,
allowing the European debt to be rolled over, paying interest through
increased own resources, repaying old debts and issuing new ones, which
would alleviate Member States’ contributions to the EU budget
without debt transfers. This is consistent with the ECB, which stated
that the “EMU still lacks a permanent fiscal capacity at
supranational level for macroeconomic stabilisation in deep
crises”, and with the EFB (2020).
· Finally, the ETUC demands to introduce, in a renewed
European Semester and as a complement of the Macroeconomic Imbalances
Procedure, a mechanism to identify, prevent and address the social
imbalances that could negatively affect the working and living conditions
in a Member State, and in turn having a spill over effect on the EU. An
“Excessive Social Imbalances Procedure” should be established
to rebalance the economic and social dimensions of the economic
governance. The identification of social imbalances should lead to (i)
country specific recommendations, for national imbalances; and (ii)
revisiting the Employment Guidelines and issuing Euro Area
Recommendations to address structural issues (i.e. employment policies),
in case of social imbalances at EU level. A social imbalances procedure
(SIP) would represent the third pillar of (and finally complete) the
social dimension of the Semester: besides the principles and targets set
in the European Pillar of Social Rights and in its Action Plan, and data
provided by the Social Scoreboard, the SIP would be the tool needed to
achieve those targets and aiming at an upward social convergence. Actions
aiming at supporting the Member States in addressing excessive social
imbalances (incentives) have to be preferred over punitive initiatives
from the EU. A “supportive arm” will entail the EU to
intervene and help MS to correct the excessive imbalances identified.
We hope these proposals will receive your careful attention and be
positively assessed.
We are looking forward to hearing from you and having an exchange on this
matter.
Best regards,
Luca Visentini Liina
Carr
ETUC General Secretary ETUC Confederal
Secretary