CC(22)1756:1 – UDP/JE/iq Economy and Finance
Ministers of the European
Union
Brussels, 28th March 2022
RE: Proposal for a Council Directive on ensuring a global minimum level of
taxation for multinational groups in the Union
Dear Minister,
In view of the discussions with Member States on the proposed Council Directive on ensuring a
global minimum level of taxation for multinational groups in the Union, Copa and Cogeca would
like to share their first assessment of the proposed directive and its implications for EU
cooperatives.
Firstly, it must be stated that cooperatives formed, organized and developed on regulations that
acknowledge the specific characteristics of a cooperative, their specificities and ensure they are
on a level playing field with other types of business. Agri-cooperatives are composed of member-
farmers and not shareholders. Members of a cooperative act as users, workers, and producers of
the cooperative’s activities and therefore, unlike shareholders, do not pursue purely economic
goals through their participation.
Agri-cooperatives also play a critical role in the EU food and agriculture supply chain due to
their strong link with territories and horizontal cooperation between farmers helps balance the
economic asymmetry within the supply chain, leading to better market access, greater
contractual leverage, and more efficient food production.
We support the objectives of the historic global tax reform agreement reached by the OECD/G20
Inclusive Framework on Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS), including legally binding rules
that will ensure large groups in the EU pay a 15% minimum rate for every jurisdiction in which
they operate. We cannot support documentation and reporting obligations, which are
disproportionate and administratively heavy. The burden for cooperatives and for companies in
general does not measure up with the benefits of the regulations.
The proposed directive in its current form will have serious negative impacts on the cooperative
system and applied taxation. The proposal poses significant harm to the fundamental building
stones of the agricultural cooperative business model.
We are also aware of the 750 million euro threshold. This limit for European cooperatives
operating in the internal market can be reached through SME operators acting jointly in the
cooperative system.
Furthermore, the tax system for cooperatives has been recognized on several occasions by the
European authorities, as being proportionate to these legal constraints.
Taxation of cooperatives is dependent on the law and context of each Member State. However,
common to cooperatives e.g., in Italy, the Netherlands, France, Germany, Ireland and Denmark
is that the proposed directive in its current form will have serious negative impacts on the
cooperative system and taxation.
Copa - Cogeca | European Farmers European Agri-Cooperatives
61, Rue de Trèves | B - 1040 Bruxelles | www.copa-cogeca.eu
EU Transparency Register Number | Copa 44856881231-49 | Cogeca 09586631237-74
It is imperative for cooperatives in the EU that the interpretation of the council directive
regarding minimum taxation e.g., article 19, 37 and 38 will be amended to ensure that such
future taxes deemed to be paid by the members of the cooperatives – members being both
natural persons and other entities - of the cooperative on the time of release from the
cooperatives are fully acknowledged in the council directive regarding global minimum taxation,
without any timing limitations.
Copa and Cogeca underline that, to ensure the viability of cooperative enterprises and diversity
of enterprise forms across Europe, safeguarding specific tax treatment for cooperatives is
essential.
We remain fully engaged in making the global minimum level of taxation for multinational
groups in the Union reality and look forward to cooperating with EU and national Authorities to
safeguard the European cooperative model.
Yours sincerely,
Pekka Pesonen
Secretary General
2|2
Saatja: Keit Pillak <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 29.03.2022 12:45
Adressaat: RAM Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: Proposal for a Council Directive on ensuring a global minimum
level of taxation for multinational groups in the Union + amendments
From: Isabella Quaglia <
[email protected]> Sent:
Tuesday, March 29, 2022 12:03 PMSubject: Proposal for a Council Directive
on ensuring a global minimum level of taxation for multinational groups
in the Union + amendments
Dear Minister,
Further to our previous email and letter, please also find attached the
proposed amendments of Copa and Cogeca to the OECD model commentary.
Thank you for also taking these amendments into consideration.
Yours faithfully,
On behalf of Pekka Pesonen
Secretary General of Copa and Cogeca
Isabella Quaglia
Events Manager
Copa-Cogeca
Rue de Trèves 61
1040 Brussels
Tél: +32(0)2 287 27 15
QJ(22)1707:1 – UDP/JE/iq Brussels, 25th March 2022
Global minimum taxation
Commentary to the Global Anti-Base Erosion Model Rules
(Pillar Two)
Copa and Cogeca suggest the following amendments to the OECD commentary:
1) Art. 3.2. (19)
Text proposed by the Commission Text proposed by the Commission
17. Once the Financial Accounting Net Income 17. Once the Financial Accounting Net Income
or Loss of a Constituent Entity is determined, or Loss of a Constituent Entity is determined,
it is adjusted for certain book to tax it is adjusted for certain book to tax differences
differences (that is, differences between (that is, differences between financial
financial accounting results and taxable accounting results and taxable income results)
income results) that are common in Inclusive that are common in Inclusive Framework
Framework jurisdictions. Differences between jurisdictions. Differences between financial
financial accounting standards and tax accounting standards and tax accounting rules
accounting rules generally can be categorised generally can be categorised as giving rise
as giving rise either to permanent differences either to permanent differences that will not
that will not reverse in a future period or reverse in a future period or temporary
temporary differences (i.e., timing differences) differences (i.e., timing differences) that will
that will reverse in a future period. The reverse in a future period. The adjustments
adjustments required in Article 3.2 are required in Article 3.2 are generally related to
generally related to permanent differences permanent differences between the treatment
between the treatment required under required under financial accounting rules and
financial accounting rules and local tax rules. local tax rules. Temporary differences are
Temporary differences are addressed in addressed in Chapter 4.
Chapter 4. 18. In the commentary below, the adjustments
18. In the commentary below, the adjustments are described as either positive amounts or
are described as either positive amounts or negative amounts. An adjustment described
negative amounts. An adjustment described below as a positive amount will increase the
below as a positive amount will increase the financial accounting net income and decrease
financial accounting net income and decrease the financial accounting net loss. These items
the financial accounting net loss. These items are generally attributable to an adjustment
are generally attributable to an adjustment that has the effect of increasing revenue or
that has the effect of increasing revenue or other income or decreasing an expense. An
other income or decreasing an expense. An adjustment described below as a negative
adjustment described below as a negative amount will decrease the financial accounting
amount will decrease the financial accounting net income and increase the financial
net income and increase the financial accounting net loss. These items are generally
accounting net loss. These items are generally attributable to an adjustment that has the
attributable to an adjustment that has the effect of reducing revenue or other income or
effect of reducing revenue or other income or increasing an expense. Many of the categories
Copa - Cogeca | European Farmers European Agri-Cooperatives
61, Rue de Trèves | B - 1040 Bruxelles | www.copa-cogeca.eu
EU Transparency Register Number | Copa 44856881231-49 | Cogeca 09586631237-74
increasing an expense. Many of the categories of adjustments described below are an
of adjustments described below are an aggregate of several similar adjustments, some
aggregate of several similar adjustments, some of which may be positive amounts and others
of which may be positive amounts and others negative amounts. Only two categories reliably
negative amounts. Only two categories reliably produce a positive or negative adjustment:
produce a positive or negative adjustment: Policy Disallowed Expenses (positive) and
Policy Disallowed Expenses (positive) and Excluded Dividends (negative). Although some
Excluded Dividends (negative). Although other categories will tend toward a consistently
some other categories will tend toward a positive or negative adjustment, they may
consistently positive or negative adjustment, produce the opposite adjustment depending
they may produce the opposite adjustment upon the facts in the particular Fiscal Year.
depending upon the facts in the particular 19. To the extent an adjustment required by
Fiscal Year. Article 3.2 excludes an amount of income from
19. To the extent an adjustment required by the GloBE Income or Loss computation, any
Article 3.2 excludes an amount of income from Covered Taxes associated with that income
the GloBE Income or Loss computation, any must also be excluded from Adjusted Covered
Covered Taxes associated with that income Taxes pursuant to Article 4.1.3(a).
must also be excluded from Adjusted Covered Income in cooperatives, subject to a tax regime
Taxes pursuant to Article 4.1.3(a). in the jurisdiction, in which it is located that is
designed to ensure tax neutrality on income
and distributions that immediately or later can
reasonably be expected to be taxed at a rate
that at least equals the minimum taxation, can
be excluded from Globe Income, provided the
income is excluded from Globe Income
calculation according to art. 4.2.
Justification
Imposing a minimum tax-rate on profits retained for delayed payments for deliveries in
cooperatives will effectively cause a double taxation on an income string earned in a cooperative
which is not in line with the aim of obtaining tax-neutrality by introducing global minimum
taxation. This double taxation must be avoided given the tax burden lies at the level of the
members.
2) Art. 4.2 (38)
Text proposed by the Commission Amendment
38. Paragraphs (a) through (c) exclude Top-up 38. Paragraphs (a) through (c) exclude Top-up
Taxes under the GloBE Rules from the Taxes under the GloBE Rules from the
definition of Covered Taxes. Covered Taxes definition of Covered Taxes. Covered Taxes are
are an essential element in determining the an essential element in determining the Top-
Top-up Tax, if any, under the GloBE Rules. up Tax, if any, under the GloBE Rules.
Including GloBE Top-up Taxes in Covered Including GloBE Top-up Taxes in Covered
Taxes would result in a circular computation Taxes would result in a circular computation in
in the Fiscal Year that the Top-up Taxes arise. the Fiscal Year that the Top-up Taxes arise.
Including them in Covered Taxes for Including them in Covered Taxes for
subsequent Fiscal Years would undermine the subsequent Fiscal Years would undermine the
agreed Minimum Rate because it would agreed Minimum Rate because it would
effectively include them in the numerator of effectively include them in the numerator of
the ETR computation which would effectively the ETR computation which would effectively
reduce the amount of Top-up Tax that would reduce the amount of Top-up Tax that would
need to be paid for the jurisdiction in the need to be paid for the jurisdiction in the
subsequent year. Qualified Domestic subsequent year. Qualified Domestic
Minimum Top-up Taxes are excluded from the Minimum Top-up Taxes are excluded from the
definition of Covered Taxes for the same definition of Covered Taxes for the same
reasons. However, such taxes are creditable reasons. However, such taxes are creditable
against GloBE Top-up Tax under Article 5.2.3. against GloBE Top-up Tax under Article 5.2.3.
On the other hand, an ordinary domestic On the other hand, an ordinary domestic
minimum tax that is not a Qualified Domestic minimum tax that is not a Qualified Domestic
Minimum Top-up Tax is a Covered Tax if it Minimum Top-up Tax is a Covered Tax if it
otherwise meets the definition of a Covered otherwise meets the definition of a Covered
Tax. Tax. Taxes paid by cooperatives are excluded
from the definition of Covered Taxes, provided
it can be reasonably expected that
distributions from these companies
immediately or later will be subject to taxation
either in the company or in the hands of the
recipient that at least equals the minimum
taxation, pursuant to art. 3.2.
Justification
Assuming the proposed amendments to art. 3.2. are adopted our proposal in art. 4.2. must be
adopted as well.