Veiko Tali Teie 02.07.2020 nr 12.1-3/4805-1
Rahandusministeerium
[email protected] Meie 02.09.2020 nr 1.1-16/20-0007/4364-2
Suur-Ameerika 1
10122, Tallinn
Reply to inquiry in case SA.57432
Austatud Veiko Tali
Käesolevaga edastame vastuse Euroopa Komisjoni Konkurentsi Peadirektoraadi esitatud
päringule asjas SA.57321. Palume vastus edastada Euroopa Komisjonile.
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Timo Tatar
energeetika asekantsler
Lisad: vastus üheksal leheküljel
Rein Vaks
625 6347
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 625 6342 /
[email protected] / www.mkm.ee
Registrikood 70003158
Annamaria Marchi Your Ref: 30.06.2020 No
Directorate B Energy, B3 COMP.B3/MS/ZT*2020/080027
Directorate General for Competition
Place Madou, Madouplein 1 Our Ref: 02.09.2020 No 1.1-16/20-
0007/4364-2
1210 Saint-Josse-ten-Noode /Sint-
Joost-ten-Noode
Belgium
Reply to inquiry in case SA.57432
Dear Ms. Marchi,
The Ministry of Finance forwarded the complaint of Circle K Eesti AS on the statistics trading
system for biofuels in Estonia (SA.57321). The complaint was forwarded to the Ministry of
Finance on the 30th June 2020. Herewith the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications
replies to the complaint as follows.
In the complaint, Circle K Eesti AS argues that the Republic of Estonia has created an unfair
market situation on the liquid fuel retail market. In detail, the root of the issue seems to be the fact
that the biofuel obligation that has been set on the fuel suppliers may be met not only by the
physical blending of the fuel but also with the statistics purchased from other suppliers of biofuel
or the consumers of biomethane or renewable electricity. The complainant suggests that such
statistics are being given to some of the market participants for free by the State. This, however,
is not true.
Introduction to the biofuel obligation
Estonia set the biofuel obligation to the market participants in May 20181. The obligation is
specifically set on only petrol and diesel. In May 2018, the obligatory share of biofuel in diesel
fuel and petrol was 3.1% (in energy content). From 1st of April 2019, the share raised to 6.4% (in
energy content). From 1st of January 2020, the obligatory share of biofuel is 10%. In the beginning
of the obligation in 2018, the share may be archived by full blending of biofuels to the diesel fuel
or petrol released for consumption. From 2019, the possibility to fulfill the obligation by statistics
entered into force. Both possibilities were discussed with the market participants of the liquid
biofuel sector between 2016-2018 while the scheme was under development. From the beginning
of 2019, all fuel suppliers have had had the following possibilities to fulfill the biofuel obligation:
1) by a physical blend of biofuel and petrol of diesel or
2) by purchasing biofuel statistics from other suppliers of biofuel (i.e. ethanol, FAME, HVO,
biomethane etc.) or
3) by the mix of physical blending and statistics.
1
Liquid Fuel Act enforced from 1.05.2018 - https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/511042018003/consolide#para2b1
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / ESTONIA
Phone: +372 625 6342 / Fax: +372 631 3660 / E-mail:
[email protected] / http://www.mkm.ee
As of 1st of April 2020, the renewable part of electricity used in the transport sector may also be
included towards meeting the biofuel obligation.
As stated above, the principles of the liquid biofuels regulation were developed in cooperation
with all the market participants of the liquid fuel sector, the complainant included. This gave the
liquid fuel companies a choice whether to start importing liquid biofuels from or to invest into
biofuel production by themselves. No company was prohibited from investing into biofuel
production.
Today Estonia has ca 20 biomethane filling stations. In 2019 these filling stations were used to
transfer 63 GWh of biomethane to the transport sector. These filling stations were built by some
of the competitors of the complainant. In addition to that, there are ca 200 charging stations for
charging electrical vehicles. Such charging stations are used to charge electrical vehicles with ca
7 GWh of electricity. The liquid fuel market has an annual capacity of 9000 GWh. To fulfill the
biofuel obligation, some 900 GWh of biofuels must be released for consumption.
The need for a platform to trade with the statistics
Over time, fulfilling the biofuel obligation with statistics has proven to be rather attractive. In
2019, all of the available biofuel statistics for transport sector for that year were used up. As this
type of market was just starting, some market participants did have some issues with trading with
the statistics.
The market participants did not have an overview about the potential owners of the statistics nor
an understanding of the unsold quantities of the statistics. Therefore, the Ministry of Economic
Affairs and Communications decided to develop a uniform platform where all the owners of
transport statistics can meet and purchase the statistics through a competitive tender.
The price of the statistics and the price of fulfilling the biofuel obligation
The tradable statistics can be produced only by someone who uses renewable energy in the
transport sector. By doing so, it does not matter if the statistics were produced from using liquid
biofuel, gaseous biomethane or renewable electricity. As a precondition for producing such
statistics, the needed infrastructure must be built and commissioned. For example, for producing
electricity statistics one must build an electricity charging point. For producing biomethane
statistics, one must build a compressed natural gas (CNG) filling station. In addition to the cost of
the infrastructure, the cost of the fuel or energy must also be added to the cost of the statistic.
Therefore, such statistics are not given for free to the statistics owner. The State is merely
regulating the selling and buying of such statistics. The production and therefore the cost of the
statistics is always dependent on the investment cost of the relevant infrastructure and the cost of
the fuel used.
Gaseous transport fuels and electricity do not have a biofuel obligation
The goal of the Estonian regulation is to provide the liquid fuel supplier as many possibilities as
possible to fulfill the biofuel obligation. Although the biofuel obligation is set only on diesel fuel
2 (9)
and petrol, the supplier of such fuels may also use the statistics of biomethane or renewable
electricity to fulfill the obligation. This leaves sufficient flexibility for the supplier to decide on
the model according to which the obligation should be fulfilled.
The point of such a regulation is to fulfill the obligation with a minimal cost and a maximum
benefit for the region. A comprehensive analysis has indicated that the costliest manner to fulfill
the obligation is by physical blending of biofuels into diesel or petrol. The statistics of biomethane
and electricity are, as a rule, cheaper than the cost of the purchased and physically blended biofuel.
According to the GBER Art 41 (4), aid must not be granted for production of biofuels which are
subject to a supply of blending obligation. The aim of such regulation is to withhold the investment
support from a distortion of the functioning of the market. In case there was a direct supply or
blending obligation for biomethane, the needed quantities of biomethane would be on the market
without the investment support.
Estonia does not apply supply or blending obligation on biomethane. The blending obligation is
set only on diesel fuel and petrol. Although the biomethane statistics can be used towards fulfilling
the diesel fuel and petrol biofuel obligation, the price of the statistics is not enough to initiate the
production of biomethane. This would not be the case if Estonia had the obligation to supply
biomethane or the obligation to blend biomethane in CNG. Therefore, we have assessed that the
measure notified under SA.49198 is fully in line with the GBER requirements.
Please find below the answers to the case-specific questions in your submission.
1) Please provide a list of all the existing measures in Estonia for the support of
production/distribution of biogas and biofuels and provide a short description of each
measure (i.e. eligibility, legal basis, duration, under GBER/notified to the Commission etc.
Schemes that address the consumption of biomethane:
In 2015, the government set up a scheme for deployment of biomethane fueling stations,
with the subsidy for each station limited to EUR 350 000 based on 35% of project
construction costs. Support is given under structural fonds. The support scheme is managed
by the Estonian Environmental Investments Centre
In 2015, the government set up a scheme for public transport systems to purchase
biomethane vehicles, with the subsidy limited to EUR 4 million per transit system based
on 30% of the total cost of all vehicles purchased. Support is given under structural fonds.
The support scheme is managed by the Estonian Environmental Investments Centre.
Scheme that address the production of biomethane:
In 2014, the Supervisory Board of the Environmental Investment Center decided to finance
the construction of Estonia's first biomethane production complex in Viljandi County with
2,997,479 euros, as a pilot project.
In 2018, the government set up a scheme to provide financial support for domestic
biomethane production. Under the scheme, companies may request state subsidies for their
biomethane production by submitting applications on a rolling basis from 2018 to 31
December 2023. Elering, the TSO, manages the direct payment of the subsidies based on
the level of production and consumption. Support rates are: EUR 100 per MWh, minus the
3 (9)
average market price of natural gas from the previous month, for biomethane delivered to
the final consumer as transport fuel; EUR 93 per MWh, minus the average market price of
natural gas from the previous month, for biomethane delivered to the final consumer in the
natural gas system.
The aid granted to support of this support scheme and to reimburse the eligible costs
constitutes operating aid for small scale installations within the meaning of Article 43 of
Commission Regulation (EU) No 651/2014 of 17 June 2014 declaring certain categories
of aid compatible with the internal market in application of Articles 107 and 108 of the
Treaty (OJ L 187, 26.06.2014, pp. 1–78).
This multipronged approach addresses demand, logistics and supply of biomethane, and
could increase the renewable share in transport based on domestic fuel.
2) Please explain whether you see a risk of overcompensation of the biogas/biofuel
producers/retailers, when combining the existing support measures and the use of the statistics
We do not see the risk of overcompensating the biogas/biofuel producers/retailers when
combining the existing support measures and the use of the statistics.
The price of biomethane is more expensive than the price of natural gas but still cheaper then the
price of imported biofuels. Allowing suppliers that have reached their renewable energy targets
for transport fuels (RES-T) to sell their exceeded share at market-based prices in the statistics
platform, will facilitate uptake of renewables in transport. This also supports domestic
biomethane production and reduce the use of imported fuels.
We see that despite the fact that the parties are to some extent related to each other, they are still
three different parties, with different cash flows and competing in different markets (fuel
consumers compete with other fuel suppliers; biomethane producers compete with other
biomethane producers, etc).
In addition, as required by the state aid regulations, the implementation entities of the measures
monitor the conditions and fulfillment of the criteria under the General Block Exemption
Regulation.
3) We understand that Estonia has a supply obligation in place. Could you please explain:
Estonia has a biofuel supply obligation in place as required by the Renewable Energy Directive.
It is set with the Liquid Fuel Act § 21 (1). According to that, the petrol or diesel fuel supplier
must guarantee that over a calendar year the petrol and diesel, that has been released for
consumption, energy content must include at least 10% of biofuels (from the energy content). In
addition to the physical blending of biofuels, the supplier may fulfill the obligation partially or
fully with purchasing relevant transport statistics from other suppliers. Such statistics may
originate from supply of liquid biofuels (also as a blend within petrol or diesel fuel), biomethane
or renewable electricity.
a. who is bound by such obligation and which penalties are applied in case of non-compliance.
4 (9)
The obligation is set on petrol and diesel fuel suppliers. Such suppliers are defined as entities
that release petrol and diesel fuel for consumption or in other terms – are responsible for paying
the excise duty of petrol and diesel.
The penalty for non-compliance with the biofuel requirement is up to 10 million euros. The
subject of the penalty is the fuel supplier that failed to meet the 10% target on an annual basis.
b. the terms of the obligation.
The biofuel supply obligation may be met whether by blending physical biofuel to petrol of
diesel fuel or by using the transport statistics purchased via the trading system. Please see the
scheme below:
c. since when the obligation has been in place.
The biofuel obligation has been in place in Estonia from 1st of May 20182. The obligation
started with the biofuel obligation of 3.1%. From 1st of January 2020, the obligation is 10% of
the quantity of petrol and diesel fuel that has been released for consumption.
d. the relation between the supply obligation and the statistics trading system.
The biofuel supply obligation may be met whether by blending physical biofuel to petrol of
diesel fuel or by using the transport statistics purchased from another supplier. In the future,
such transactions will be made via the trading system. Therefore, using the statistics trading
system is not obligatory to fulfill the biofuel obligation – with the physical blending option
there is always an alternative possibility to deliver the obligation.
However, when the petrol or diesel fuel supplier chooses to fulfill the obligation through using
statistics, the platform at hand would be the only possibility to purchase the statistics. Even if
the statistics were obtained based on a bilateral agreement, the agreement must be registered
in the statistics trading system. The reasoning for that is simple. The statistics trading system
is the platform where all the statistics that has been produced in the trading sector is collected
2
Liquid Fuel Act enforced from 1.05.2018 - https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/511042018003/consolide#para2b1
5 (9)
and traded. The system collects all the data of the consumed biofuels and renewable energy
and stores it in one platform. This helps to mitigate any possible frauds of manipulating with
the transport statistics data.
4. Please explain how the statistics trading system works. In particular:
The statistic trading system works through an electronic database (platform) that will be created
by Elering AS (www.elering.ee). It connects the stakeholders: producers, gas sellers and liquid
fuel sellers. In the future, also the consumers (under development). The platform for providing
guarantees of origins (GOs) for the produced biomethane and their trading and enables issuing and
trading of transport statistic certificate (TS certificates), also reporting to Environment Agency by
the liquid fuel sellers to meet their RES obligations.
- The GO provides proof that the producer has produced biomethane. The cancellation of
GO goes against real gas consumption certifies biomethane consumption to consumers
(GO system is based on a mass balance principle). Then an electronic document issued by
the national issuing body Elering in Biomethane Information System. Standard energy unit
of GO is 1 megawatt-hour (MWh) determined based on the higher heating value of biofuel.
- The TS certificate is issued when biofuel (biomethane, renewable electricity or liquid
biofuel additives) has been consumed in the transport sector. Liquid fuel sellers can fulfill
their RES obligations with TS certificates of biofuel consumed in the same year.
So, the GOs and TS certificates are strongly related, as GO provides a basis for creating TSs,
please look the schemes below:
6 (9)
Please see below an example of life cycle of GOs and TS certificates:
a. Which companies are eligible to receive the statistics? Which companies have already received
such statistics since the system was put in place?
Every company can acquire the statistics. According to the information provided to the Ministry
of Economic Affairs and Communications, most of the market participants have been able to buy
statistics from the market. The complainant, Circle-K Eesti AS has also purchased some statistics
in Q4 of 2019.
b. Under which circumstances are the statistics granted and used?
The circumstances that the statistics are granted and used are mostly up to the market participants.
The regulation states that the statistics can exchange owners only when the original data about the
release for consumption has been submitted to the authority responsible for gathering such data,
the Environmental Board. After that, the statistics can be sold to the party willing to purchase the
statistics. Only such statistics can be sold that meet the sustainability criteria as set in Directive
2009/28/EU.
c. Are the statistics based on purchase of guarantees of origin?
The statistics are not directly linked to the guarantees of origin. The criteria for producing the
statistics requires the fuel to be physically consumed in Estonia. Since biomethane is physically
identical to natural gas, the guarantees of origin are only needed to verify that the gaseous fuel that
was released for consumption was of renewable origin.
d. Is the statistical platform provided and managed by the State and how?
7 (9)
The statistics purchase platform is not functioning, yet. It is estimated that it will be functional
from October 2020. The platform will be run and managed by State owned gas and electricity
system operator Elering AS (www.elering.ee).
The idea of the platform is simple – the owners of the statistics offer their product for purchase
and the buyers buy the offered statistics. It functions as a market platform to introduce the owners
and buyers of statistics. In addition, all the data about the statistics if included in the platform –
there is no possibility to transfer statistics that are not present in the platform.
e. Do all the statistical transfers take place on the platform or there are also off-platform
transactions?
Once the platform starts operation, all transactions must be made through the platform. This,
however, does not mean that the market participants cannot have bilateral agreements on
purchasing the statistics. In case of a bilateral statistical agreement, the agreement must be
registered in the platform and the transferring of the statistics can be completed.
5. Please clarify how do you ensure compliance with the requirements under the Renewables Energy
Directive regarding the accounting use of biomethane as renewable transportation fuel.
Biomethane production units must be certified by accredited certification bodies. The certification
also assesses the origin and quality of the raw materials needed for biomethane production and the
compliance of biomass sustainability criteria. So, if a producer produces biomethane, a certificate
on and guarantees of origin is issued for its production, which also states what kind of raw
materials the biomethane was produced, and a confirmation that the production meets the
established biomass sustainability criteria.
6. Please clarify how the introduction of the new statistical transfers for biogas affects the existing
schemes supporting biomethane, namely:
The biomethane production and consumption support schemes described above and below were
set up separately to create a comprehensive biomethane market. Now that biomethane production
and consumption are picking up (and the conditions for this are favorable because of RES target
and objectives of the Clean Vehicles Directive), we see that, once the support measures will come
to an end in 2023, we can move towards a market-based approach based on statistics trading via
platform.
a. SA.49198 Biometaanituru arendamise toetamine (Support for the development of the
biomethane market).
The beneficiary under this scheme is the biomethane producer. According to the scheme, all the
additional revenues collected from the market in form of price of guarantees of origin or higher
price of biomethane shall be deducted from the subsidy. Hence, by earning some guarantees of
origin revenue, the subsidy rate will be decreased accordingly.
b. SA.43899 Biometaani transpordisektoris tarbimise toetamise tingimused (Conditions for
supporting the consumption of biomethane in the transport sector).
8 (9)
This measure has no effect on the statistical transfer scheme. The beneficiary of the transfer is the
fuel supplier. Therefore, the beneficiary of measure SA.43899 and the beneficiary of the statistical
transfer is not the same.
c. SA.40745 Kütteainena kasutatud biogaasi aktsiisvabastus (Excise duty exemption for biogas
used as heating fuel).
This measure was one of the first measures that was introduced to boost the biomethane market in
Estonia. The cumulation of aid regarding the measures that followed have been analyzed
accordingly. The only beneficiary of the cumulation of the current scheme and the statistical
transfer is the fueling station owner. However, the fueling station revenue is well below the
anticipated revenue (the gas prices have plummeted) when the scheme was developed. This, on
the other hand, means that the amount of aid granted has not been as high anticipated. Therefore,
the cumulation of aid is within the boundaries of the GBER.
We hope that the information provided is sufficient. We shall remain at your disposal in case you
have further questions. If this is the case, feel free to propose a telephone conference at your earliest
convenience.
Respectfully,
Timo Tatar
Deputy Secretary General for Energy
9 (9)