20, AVENUE APPIA – CH-1211 GENEVA 27 – SWITZERLAND – TEL CENTRAL +41 22 791 2111 – FAX CENTRAL +41 22 791 3111 – WWW.WHO.INT
Ref.: C.L.37.2018
Appointment of External Auditor of the World Health Organization
for financial years 2020 to 2023
The World Health Organization (WHO) presents its compliments to Member States and
has the honour to invite Member States to nominate a candidate fulfilling the conditions of
Regulation 14.1 of WHO’s Financial Regulations, whom they may wish the World Health
Assembly to consider for appointment as the External Auditor of WHO for the four-year period
from 2020 to 2023.
Member States may recall that, in May 2015 the Sixty-eighth World Health Assembly, by
resolution WHA68.14, re-appointed the holder of the Commission on Audit of the Republic of
the Philippines to be the External Auditor of the WHO for the four-year period from 2016
to 2019. Pursuant to Regulation 14.1 of WHO’s Financial Regulations, the term of office shall be
four years, covering two budgetary periods, and can be renewed for an additional term of four
years. It will be necessary for the Seventy-second World Health Assembly in May 2019 to
appoint an External Auditor, who shall be the Auditor-General (or an officer holding equivalent
title or otherwise qualified) of a Member State, for the four-year period from 2020 to 2023.
... The full text of Regulation XIV of the Financial Regulations and the Additional Terms of
Reference governing the External Audit of WHO are enclosed herewith as Annex I. Annex II
lists the External Auditors of WHO appointed during the period 1948 to present, and Annex III
provides background information on WHO’s financial operations. The 2017 Audited Financial
Statements, (document A71/29) is available on WHO website:
http://www.who.int/about/finances-accountability/reports/A71_29-en.pdf?u.
Should a Member State wish to propose a candidate, the name of the candidate should
reach the Organization no later than 14 December 2018, 23:59 Central European Time, to allow
time for the preparation of the submission to the Seventy-second World Health Assembly.
The nomination should include, in respect of the proposed External Auditor:
(a) curriculum vitae, without photographs, with details of the national and international
activities of the nominee noting the range of audit specialties that can be of benefit to the
Organization (not to exceed 500 words);
(b) a summary description of the audit approach, procedures and standards that the
nominee would apply, having regard to the Organization’s accounting principles and
... ENCLS: (3)
Page 2
C.L.37.2018
practices, its Financial Regulations and Financial Rules and following International Public
Sector Accounting Standards (IPSAS) (not to exceed 500 words);
(c) estimates of the overall number of auditor-work-months which would be devoted to
carrying out the audit for each financial year from 2020 to 2023; and
(d) for each financial year (2020 to 2023), a proposed audit fee expressed in US dollars
(and summarized on a single page). This fee should cover the worldwide audit of
WHO activities as well as activities of non-consolidated entities administered by WHO. In
estimating the cost of the audit, all secretarial and other ancillary costs, and all travel costs
and living expenses of the External Audit staff should be included in the audit fee proposed.
Travel costs should include travel from the country of residence to Geneva and to other
offices of the Organization, as required by the External Auditor for the purposes of the
audit.
The Secretariat will undertake to translate the curriculum vitae mentioned in (a), the
summary referred to in (b) and the one page summary of the fees mentioned in (d) in the
six official languages for submission to the World Health Assembly.
The nomination, along with its accompanying documents, must be sent electronically to
the mailbox
[email protected] and submitted in both pdf and Word formats.
The World Health Organization avails itself of this opportunity to renew to the Member
States the assurance of its highest consideration.
GENEVA, 30 October 2018
Annex I
C.L.37.2018
THE WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION
EXTRACT FROM FINANCIAL REGULATIONS
Regulation XIV – External Audit
14.1 External Auditor(s), each of whom shall be the Auditor-General (or officer holding equivalent title or
status) of a Member government, shall be appointed by the Health Assembly. The term of office shall be four
years, covering two budgetary periods, and can be renewed once for an additional term of four years.
External Auditor(s) appointed may be removed only by the Assembly.
14.2 Subject to any special direction of the Health Assembly, each audit which the External Auditor(s)
performs/perform shall be conducted in conformity with generally accepted common auditing standards and
in accordance with the Additional Terms of Reference set out in the Appendix to these Regulations.
14.3 The External Auditor(s) may make observations with respect to the efficiency of the financial
procedures, the accounting system, the internal financial controls and, in general, the administration and
management of the Organization.
14.4 The External Auditor(s) shall be completely independent and solely responsible for the conduct of the
audit and, except as permitted under Regulation 14.7 below, any local or special examination.
14.5 The Health Assembly may request the External Auditor(s) to perform certain specific examinations
and issue separate reports on the results.
14.6 The Director-General shall provide the External Auditor(s) with the facilities required for the
performance of the audit.
14.7 For the purpose of making a local or special examination or for effecting economies of audit cost, the
External Auditor(s) may engage the services of any national Auditor-General (or equivalent title) or
commercial public auditors of known repute or any other person or firm that, in the opinion of the External
Auditor(s), is technically qualified.
14.8 The External Auditor(s) shall issue a report on the audit of the annual financial statements prepared by
the Director-General pursuant to Regulation XIII. The report shall include such information as he/she/they
deem(s) necessary in regard to Regulation 14.3 and the Additional Terms of Reference.
14.9 The report(s) of the External Auditor(s) shall be transmitted through the Executive Board, together
with the audited financial statements, to the Health Assembly not later than 1 May following the end of the
financial year to which the final accounts relate. The Executive Board shall examine the annual financial
statements and the audit report(s) and shall forward them to the Health Assembly with such comments as it
deems necessary.
1
APPENDIX
ADDITIONAL TERMS OF REFERENCE GOVERNING THE EXTERNAL AUDIT OF
THE WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION
1. The External Auditor(s) shall perform such audit of the accounts of the World Health Organization,
including all Trust Funds and special accounts, as deemed necessary in order to satisfy
himself/herself/themselves:
(a) that the financial statements are in accord with the books and records of the Organization;
(b) that the financial transactions reflected in the statements have been in accordance with the rules
and regulations, the budgetary provisions, and other applicable directives;
(c) that the securities and moneys on deposit and on hand have been verified by the certificates
received direct from the Organization’s depositories or by actual count;
(d) that the internal controls, including the internal audit, are adequate in the light of the extent of
reliance placed thereon;
(e) that procedures satisfactory to the External Auditor(s) have been applied to the recording of all
assets, liabilities, surpluses and deficits.
2. The External Auditor(s) shall be the sole judge as to the acceptance in whole or in part of certifications
and representations by the Secretariat and may proceed to such detailed examination and verification as
he/she/they choose(s) of all financial records including those relating to supplies and equipment.
3. The External Auditor(s) and staff shall have free access at all convenient times to all books, records
and other documentation which are, in the opinion of the External Auditor(s), necessary for the performance
of the audit. Information classified as privileged and which the Secretariat agrees is required by the External
Auditor(s) for the purposes of the audit, and information classified as confidential, shall be made available
on application. The External Auditor(s) and staff shall respect the privileged and confidential nature of any
information so classified which has been made available and shall not make use of it except in direct
connection with the performance of the audit. The External Auditor(s) may draw the attention of the Health
Assembly to any denial of information classified as privileged which, in his/her/their opinion, was required
for the purpose of the audit.
4. The External Auditor(s) shall have no power to disallow items in the accounts but shall draw to the
attention of the Director-General for appropriate action any transaction that creates doubt as to legality or
propriety. Audit objections, to these or any other transactions, arising during the examination of the accounts
shall be immediately communicated to the Director-General.
5. The External Auditor(s) shall express and sign an opinion on the financial statements of the
Organization. The opinion shall include the following basic elements:
(a) identification of the financial statements audited;
(b) a reference to the responsibility of the entity’s management and responsibility of the External
Auditor(s);
(c) a reference to the audit standards followed;
(d) a description of the work performed;
2
(e) an expression of opinion on the financial statements as to whether:
(i) the financial statements present fairly the financial position as at the end of the period and
the results of the operations for the period;
(ii) the financial statements were prepared in accordance with the stated accounting policies;
(iii) the accounting policies were applied on a basis consistent with that of the preceding
financial period;
(f) an expression of opinion on the compliance of transactions with the Financial Regulations and
legislative authority;
(g) the date of the opinion;
(h) the External Auditor’s(s’) name and position;
(i) the place where the report has been signed;
(j) should it be necessary, a reference to the report of the External Auditor(s) on the financial
statements.
6. The report of the External Auditor(s) to the Health Assembly on the financial operations of the period
should mention:
(a) the type and scope of examination;
(b) matters affecting the completeness or accuracy of the accounts, including where appropriate:
(i) information necessary to the correct interpretation of the accounts;
(ii) any amounts that ought to have been received but which have not been brought to account;
(iii) any amounts for which a legal or contingent obligation exists and which have not been
recorded or reflected in the financial statements;
(iv) expenditures not properly substantiated;
(v) whether proper books of accounts have been kept; where in the presentation of statements
there are deviations of a material nature from a consistent application of generally accepted
accounting principles, these should be disclosed;
(c) other matters that should be brought to the notice of the Health Assembly such as:
(i) cases of fraud or presumptive fraud;
(ii) wasteful or improper expenditure of the Organization’s money or other assets
(notwithstanding that the accounting for the transaction may be correct);
(iii) expenditure likely to commit the Organization to further outlay on a large scale;
(iv) any defect in the general system or detailed regulations governing the control of receipts
and disbursements, or of supplies and equipment;
3
(v) expenditure not in accordance with the intention of the Health Assembly, after making
allowance for duly authorized transfers within the budget;
(vi) expenditure in excess of appropriations as amended by duly authorized transfers within
the budget;
(vii) expenditure not in conformity with the authority that governs it;
(d) the accuracy or otherwise of the supplies and equipment records as determined by stocktaking
and examination of the records.
In addition, the report may contain reference to:
(e) transactions accounted for in a previous financial period, concerning which further information
has been obtained, or transactions in a later financial period concerning which it seems desirable that
the Health Assembly should have early knowledge.
7. The External Auditor(s) may make such observations with respect to his/her/their findings resulting
from the audit and such comments on the financial report as he/she/they deem(s) appropriate to the Health
Assembly or to the Director-General.
8. Whenever the External Auditor’s(s’) scope of audit is restricted, or insufficient evidence is available,
the External Auditor’s(s’) opinion shall refer to this matter, making clear in the report the reasons for the
comments and the effect on the financial position and the financial transactions as recorded.
9. In no case shall the External Auditor(s) include criticism in any report without first affording the
Director-General an adequate opportunity of explanation on the matter under observation.
10. The External Auditor(s) is/are not required to mention any matter referred to in the foregoing which is
considered immaterial.
4
Annex II
C.L.37.2018
THE WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION
EXTERNAL AUDITORS 1948 TO 2019
Period No. of years Name Nationality
1.9.1948 to 31.12.1966 18 Mr Uno Brunskog Swedish
1.1.1967 to 31.12.1973 7 Mr Lars Breie Norwegian
1.1.1974 to 31.12.1977 4 Mr Lars Lindmark Swedish
1.1.1978 to 31.12.1981 4 Sir Douglas Henley British
1.1.1982 to 31.12.1995 14 Holder of the Office of Comptroller British
and Auditor-General of the United
Kingdom of Great Britain and
Northern Ireland
1.1.1996 to 31.12.2003 8 Holder of the Office of South African
Auditor-General of the Republic
of South Africa
1.1.2004 to 31.12.2011 8 Holder of the Office of Comptroller Indian
and Auditor-General of India
1.1.2012 to 31.12.2019 8 Holder of the Commission on Audit Philippines
of the Republic of the Philippines
1
Annex III
C.L.37.2018
THE WORLD HEALTH ORGANIZATION
APPOINTMENT OF EXTERNAL AUDITOR
Background Information
1. General audit approach expected
The World Health Organization seeks to obtain an effective audit carried out to a high technical
standard. The audit should be directed at important questions of financial policy and practice, with
appropriate importance being given to efficiency (value-for-money) audits.
2. Nature of audit assignment
2.1 An appreciation of the magnitude of the financial operations of the World Health Organization, and
thus of the nature of the audit, may be obtained from the detailed financial report headed “Financial Report
and Audited Financial Statements for the year ended 31 December 2017”, available on request or via the
World Health Organization (WHO) website on:
http://www.who.int/about/finances_accountability/reports/en/.
In addition, document A68/43 dated 8 May 2015, entitled “Appointment of the External Auditor”,
provides the bids submitted for the past periods 2016–2019. This is available on request or via the
WHO website on:
http://apps.who.int/gb/e/e_wha68.html.
2.2 The main centres of financial activity are the World Health Organization headquarters of
Geneva, Switzerland, the six regional offices located at Cairo, Brazzaville, Copenhagen, Manila, New Delhi
and Washington, DC (see also paragraph 8 below). The World Health Organization also has a presence in
over one hundred and fifty countries through a representative or liaison office, as well as resident staff and
projects in other locations, where expenditure is incurred locally.
2.3 A separate audit on IARC, ICC, SHI, UNAIDS and UNITAID is required, entities which are further
described below.
3. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC)
In accordance with Article VI, paragraph 6.2, of the IARC Financial Regulations, the External Auditor
of the World Health Organization is required to act also as the External Auditor of IARC in Lyon, France.
Therefore, the candidate nominated for appointment as External Auditor of WHO should be prepared to
undertake also the audit of IARC. A copy of the latest audited financial statements for IARC is available on
the IARC website as follows:
https://www.iarc.fr/en/about/funding_financialframework_reporting.php.
1
4. The International Computing Centre (ICC)
The External Auditor of the World Health Organization is required also to perform a separate audit on
ICC. A copy of the latest available audited financial statements for ICC is available on the ICC website as
follows:
https://www.unicc.org/Pages/WhatWeDo/WhatWeDo.aspx.
5. Staff Health Insurance (SHI)
The Staff Health Insurance is a self-funded and self-administered fund to provide for the
reimbursement of a major portion of the expenses for medically recognized health care incurred by the staff
member and other persons admitted as participants to the insurance. SHI covers insurance for WHO, IARC,
ICC, PAHO, UNAIDS and UNITAID staff. In accordance with this principle, the External Auditor of the
World Health Organization is required to act as the External Auditor of SHI. A copy of the latest audited
financial statements for SHI is available on the WHO website as follows:
http://www.who.int/about/finances-accountability/reports/en/.
6. Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS)
The Memorandum of Understanding that governs the establishment of UNAIDS notes that WHO shall
provide administration for UNAIDS. In accordance with this principle, the External Auditor of the World
Health Organization is required to act as the External Auditor of UNAIDS. A copy of the latest audited
financial statements for UNAIDS is available on request.
7. UNITAID
In line with the Memorandum of Understanding signed between UNITAID and WHO, the operations
of the UNITAID secretariat are administered in accordance with the Constitution of UNITAID and
WHO rules. In accordance, the External Auditors of the World Health Organization is required to act as the
External Auditor of the UNITAID. Furthermore, UNITAID applies supplemental internal guidance of the
financial analysis and there are authorized adaptations or exceptions to the WHO administrative procedures
and practices in order to meet UNITAID’s specific needs. A copy of the latest auditors financial statements
and the supplemental internal guidance for UNITAID is available on the UNITAID website and is available
as follows:
https://unitaid.org/publications/?cat=all&type=financial-statement&search=#en.
8. The Regional Office for the Americas
The Pan American Health Organization (PAHO), whose headquarters are located in Washington, DC,
also serves as the Regional Office for the World Health Organization in the Americas. PAHO appoints its
own External Auditor who may be the same as that appointed by WHO, or who may be another, in which
case close collaboration is required between the two auditors.
9. Internal Oversight Services (lOS)
The World Health Organization maintains an office of internal oversight services. The internal
auditors are staff members of the World Health Organization and the director reports directly to the
Director-General. The main responsibility of the unit, as stated in Regulation XII of the WHO Financial
Regulations, is to provide an effective review, evaluation and monitoring of the adequacy and effectiveness
of the Organization’s overall systems for internal control. Various other types of reviews are carried out. The
internal and external auditors are expected to coordinate their work to avoid duplication and promote
efficiency in audit.
2
10. Independent Expert Advisory and Oversight Committee (IEAOC)
Please refer to the WHO website for further background:
http://www.who.int/about/finances-accountability/accountability/en/.
The IEAOC meets three times per year and the external auditor is expected to participate in the regular
meetings, provide updates on external audit status and also receive inputs to audit work from the IEAOC.
11. External audit fee
The all-inclusive World Health Organization external annual audit fee for the 2016–2019 period was
US$ 428 180 per year for 2016 and 2017 and US$ 433 680 per year for 2018 and 2019.
12. Project Audits
The External Auditor could be requested to perform audits on certain projects for which an additional
fee would be agreed upon with the Secretariat (including for example, the Pandemic Influenza Preparedness
(PIP) audit).
In summary, this invitation to submit names of candidates for consideration for appointment as
External Auditor relates only to the World Health Organization, IARC, ICC, SHI, UNAIDS and UNITAID.
3
Dear Member States of the World Health Organization,
Please find attached, in the six official languages, C.L.37.2018 regarding the appointment of the
External Auditor of the World Health Organization for financial years 2020-2023.
Best regards,
Department of Governing Bodies
World Health Organization