dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel
Otsing›Rahandusministeerium
Sissetulev kiriAvalik

Report

Rahandusministeerium · 3. veebruar 2022
Viit
13-5.1/1374-1
Registreeritud
3. veebruar 2022
Dokumendi liik
Sissetulev kiri
Adressaat
Embassy of the Republic of Azerbaijan to the Republic of Estonia
Saabumis/saatmisviis
e-post
Funktsioon
13 FINANTSPOLIITIKA KUJUNDAMINE
Sari
13-5.1 Kirjavahetus rahapesu ja terrorismi rahastamise tõkestamise küsimuses (Arhiiviväärtuslik)
Toimik
13-5.1/2022
Vastutaja
Toomas Vapper (Rahandusministeerium, Kantsleri vastutusvaldkond, Finants- ja maksupoliitika valdkond, Rahandusteabe poliitika osakond)

Failid

  • 📎E-kiri.pdf68 KB
  • 📎Report.pdf745 KB

Sisu (failidest)

UPDATED REPORT ARMENIA'S ABUSE OF NON-PROFIT ORGANIZATIONS AND CHARITY ENTITIES FOR CORRUPTION, MONEY LAUNDERING AND TERRORiST FINANCING PURPOSES 1. Overview During the 44 days of war between Armenia and Azerbaijan which lasted from September 27 to November 10, 2020, Armenia mobilized its Diaspora organizations around the world to raise funds. These organizations operated in other countries under the guise of charities or non-governmental entities to collect funds purportedly for "humanitarian" purposes. As the Prime Minister of Armenia and Armenian Ministry of Finance recently admitted, however, these funds were instead transferred to the general state budget of Armenia. This blatant abuse of charitable status-which further heightens the serious risk of corruption, money laundering, and terrorism financing-implicates independent obligations on other States as a matter of international law, in addition to provisions of their own domestic laws intended to combat such illegal activity. The US-based Hayastan AII-Armenian Fund (the "Fund"), established back in 1992 and tasked primarily with raising and coordinating financial contributions from the diaspora, coordinated the donation campaign across multiple countries.1 This is not the first time that the Fund has been involved in corrupt practices. There is a criminal case currently pending in Armenian court against Ara Vardanyan, the former Executive Director of the Fund, for misappropriation and embezzlement of the collected funds, which he allegedly spent on online gambling.2 The other accused in the case is Avetik Harutyunyan, an Armenian official who allegedly abetted the embezzlement.3 1 For example, the affiliated Armenia Fund has branches in 16 countries, including the United States, Canada, Brazil, Argentina, Great Britain, France, the Netherlands, Germany, Switzerland, Austria, Sweden, Greece, Cyprus, Lebanon, Syria, and Australia. 2 See News.am, Case regarding Hayastan AII-Armenian Fund's former executive director inscribed to Yerevan court judge, 27 April 2021, available at: https://news.am/eng/news/641091.html ("The criminal case related to former Executive Director of Hayastan AII-Armenian Fund Ara Vardanyan has been inscribed to Judge Armine Meliksetyan of the Yerevan Court of General Jurisdiction, əs reported the Judicial-lnformation System."). See also Asbarez, Hayastan Al/ Armenian Fund Director Arrested for Embezzlement, 3 July 2018, available at: https ://asba rez. co m/173346/hayasta n-a 11-a rmen ia n-fu nds-d irector-a rrested-for-e m bezzlement/ ( "Armenia's National Security Service {NSS) on Tuesday placed Ara Vardanyan, the director Hayastan AII Armenian Fund under arrest on charges of embezzlement and misuse of funds. The NSS səid that Vardanyan has confessed to misappropriating the organization's funds, including using Armenia Fund money for online gambling."). 3 See News.am, Case regarding Hayastan A/1-Armenian Fund's former executive director inscribed to Yerevan court judge, 27 April 2021, available at: https://news.am/eng/news/641091.html ("The other accused under the case is Avetik Harutyunyan, who is charged under the case according to which he, starting from March 22, 2004, serving əs director of a company with 100% management of the Hayastan AII-Armenian Fund established by Armenia, that is, an official, committed official fraud and assisted Ara Vardanyan in embezzling the particularly large amounts of property."). 2 Despite this history, the Fund spearheaded the "We Are Our Borders - AII for Artsakh" Campaign (the "Campaign") without oversight or transparency.4 The Fund assured donors on the donation page of its website that "all donations received are so/ely for humanitarian purposes and shall be distributed in accordance with our mission statement and charter."5 In total, the Fund raised around 170 million USD from 73 countries for the Campaign between the start of the war on 27 September 2020 and 10 November 2020, when Azerbaijan, Armenia, and the Russian Federation signed the Trilateral Statement that put an end to military hostilities. The Prime Minister of Armenia has since admitted, however, that the majority of the collected funds-52 billion Armenian Drams or approximately 110 million USD, nearly 65% of the amount reportedly collected-was transferred to Armenia's state budget.6 Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan conceded that this amount constitutes almost 50% of the total spending (120 billion Armenian Drams or approx. 230 million USO) of the Armenian Government during the period of martial law.7 Armenian Minister of Finance Atom Janjugazyan also confirmed that the "donations were transferred to the state budget from the fund's accounts, based on martial law and new expenses caused in connection with this."8 This transfer of the funds from the Campaign, which directly contravenes the Fund's Charter, was approved by the Fund's Board of Trustees.9 The Board includes the highest 4 The name "Artsakh" is used by Armenia to refer to the illegal puppet regime that had existed in the formerly occupied territories of the Republic of Azerbaijan. Any donation campaign with the word "Artsakh" in its title or content indicates a clear intent to unlawfully violate the sovereignty and territorial integrity of the Republic of Azerbaijan. 5 Hayastan AII-Armenian Fund, We Are Qur Borders, available at https://www.himnadram.org/en/we-are-our-borders­ all-for-artsakh. 6 See The Prime Minister of the Republic of Armenia, Press Releases: Government Approves 2020 State Budget Performance Report, 22 April 2021, available at: https://www.primeminister.am/en/press­ release/item/2021/04/22/Cabinet-meeting-22-04/ ("I would like to call your attention to the fact that the government spent as much as 120 billion drams during the martial law. Of these 120 billion, only 52 billion was allocated from the Hayastan AII-Armenian Fund, that is, less than 50% of expenses ... "). 7 See ld. 8 Alexandr Avanesov, RA Minister of Finance: The decision to transfer part of the "Hayastan" AII-Armenian Fund's funds to the state budget of Armenia was made on the basis of the decision of the Fund's Board of Trustees, ARM lnfo, 9 December 2020, available at: https://arminfo.info/full news.php?id=59107&Iang=3. See alsa Fact lnvestigation Platform, How much money did the Hayastan Ali Armenian Fund donate to the Government? Why?, 24 November 2020, available at; https://fip.am/en/13889 9 See Diana Ghazaryan, Hayastan Al/ Armenian Fund Director: Some Money Transferred to Government to Speed Procurement Process, 19 November 2020, available at: https://hetq.am/en/article/124490 ("[Hayastan AII Armenian Fund Director Haykak] Arshamyan səid the Fund's Board of Trustees decided to transfer some of the money raised to the government to make the procurement process faster and more optimal."}; Alexandr Avanesov, RA Minister of Finance: The decision to transfer part of the "Hayastan" AII-Armenian Furıd's funds to the state budget of Armenia was made on the basis of the decision of the Furıd's Board of Trustees, ARM lnfo, 9 December 2020, available at: 3 political figures of Armenia, such as the President, Prime Minister, President of the National Assembly, Foreign Minister, Minister of Finance and others."? The Fund has repeatedly failed to provide any transparency into the transfer of so-called charitable donations for humanitarian purposes to the Armenian treasury. On 19 November 2020, the Fund's Executive Director Haykak Arshamian refused to provide any details, telling reporters: "Let's not talk about the amount of money at this moment, until the fund is audited."11 On 18 December 2020, Arshamian stated that he had asked the Ministry of Finance to specify in writing "how that money has been used and will be used," admitting that the Fund had not yet received an adequate response.12 On 29 January 2021, the Fund acknowledged "the public's need to know and the concerns raised about the Fund's good name," claiming that it would conduct an independent "audit of the monies raised by the Fund in 2020," which would be made public.13 The Fund did not provide any information about when the audit would take place or the report would be published, 14 and has reportedly failed to comply with Armenian regulations requiring it to "publish a report on donations and expenditures no later than March 25."15 The Republic of Azerbaijan has repeatedly called attention to these unlawful actions. During the war, the Republic of Azerbaijan submitted reports detailing the Armenian diaspora organizations' abuse of their charity status to all countries and international organizations, and urged them to take preventive measures consistent with their international obligations. The Republic of Azerbaijan also appealed to the banks and international payment networks offering financial services to the Fund, as well as companies contributing to its so-called "humanitarian campaign," to immediately end their collaboration with the Fund. Asa result, https://arminfo.info/full news.php?id=59107&Iang=3 ("The decision to transfer part of the "Havastarı" Ali- Armenian Fund's funds to the state budget of Armenia was made on the basis of the decision of the Fund's Board of Trustees."). 10 See Hayastan Ali Armenian Fund, Our Trustees, available at: https://himnadram.org/en/trusties. 11 Diana Ghazaryan, Hayastan Al/ Armenian Fund Director: Some Money Transferred to Government to Speed Procurement Process, 19 November 2020, available at: https://hetq.am/en/article/124490. 12 Narine Ghalechian, Sarkissian Sti/1 Awaiting Government Report On $100 Million Donation, Azatutyaun, 18 December 2020, available at: https://www.azatutyun.am/a/31007743.html 13 Tatev Khachatryan and Ani Hovhannisyan, AII-Armenian Fund Allocated 60% of the $170 Million Raised to the Armenian Government: Financial Report Sti/1 Not Published, hetq lnvestigative Journalists, 5 March 2021, available at: https ://hetq. am/en/a rticle/12807 5 14 See id. 15 ld. ("According to Article 39 of the RA Law on Foundations, foundations are required to publish a report on donations and expenditures no later than March 25 of each reporting year. This means that by the end of March, the Fund must publish a detailed report on donations and expenditures. In case of non-publication or incomplete publication of the report within the established period, the Ministry of Justice shall apply the measures of accountability əs provided by the RA Code on Administrative Offenses, up to filing a lawsuit with the court."). See also Hayastan AII-Armenian Fund, Reports, available at: https://www.himnadram.org/en/reports (listing the last audit report in 2019). 4 based on irrefutable evidence of the Fund's abuse of its charity status, several banks and payment networks ceased their cooperation with the Fund and launched due diligence reviews of its accounts. Many reputable companies provided written assurances to the Republic of Azerbaijan that they had discontinued their support of the Fund's so-called "humanitarian actions." In response, the Fund has only engaged in further deception. The Fund removed its bank account details in various currencies from its website, changed the motto of its campaign by removing the phrases "AII for Artsakh," and blocked all users from Azerbaijan from entering its website (www.himnadram.org). The Armenian diaspora organizations similarly modified their fund raising slogans by adjusting them to emphasize the "humanitarian context" to try to avoid any repercussions for their abuse of their charity status. Even after the signing of Trilateral Statement, the Fund has continued its illegal activities by raising a significant amount of donations from the Armenian community and other taxpayers in different countries, purportedly to meet the "humanitarian needs" of people of Armenian origin displaced as a result of recent war. Around 30 million USD have been raised in just two telethons organized in USA and France. The latest telethon was held on 25 November 2021 in Los-Angeles, USA where the total amount of 12.531.000 USD were raised mainly from Armenian communities living in USA, Canada and France16. 2. Armenian Diaspora Organizations involved in the Hayastan Ali Armenian Fund's "We Are Qur Borders - AII for Artsakh" fundraising campaign The following Armenian Diaspora organizations have contributed to the campaign: 2.1. Armenia Fund The Armenia Fund is currently the biggest fund that collects donations for the campaign. it has several affiliate branches in 16 countries (United States, Canada, Brazil, Argentina, Great Britain, France, Netherlands, Germany, Switzerland, Austria, Sweden, Greece, Cyprus, Lebanon, Syria and Australia). Some of its current partners in fundraising activities are the following: Hayastan Foundation Canada lnc., Canada Hayastan Foundation Toronto lnc., Canada Fundaciôn Armenia, Argentina Fonda Nacional Armenia, Argentina Vereniging Arrnerıiefonds Nederland, the Netherlands Fonds Arrnenien de France, France 16 https://www.armeniafund.org/feature/telethon2021-press-release/ 5 Comite Brasileiro para a Reconstruçao da Arrnenia, Brazil Cornite Suisse du Fonds Arrnenie / Armenien Fonds Schweizer Ausschuss, Switzerland Armenian Community, Belgium Armenien Fonds Hayastan - Deutschland, Germany Hayastan Ali Armenian Fund Australian, Australia Österreich-Komiteezur Unterstützung der Armenien-Fonds der Republik Armenien, Austria Hayastan AII Armenian Charitable Trust Great Britain, United Kingdom Xayıaornv navapµEvıK~Opyavworı AAArıAEyyurı - Panarmenian organization of solidarity, Greece Hayastan AII-Armenian Fund Sweden Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation, Portugal 2.2. One Armenia Fund One Armenia Fund is based both in the USA (Santa Monica, CA) and Armenia (Yerevan). it has raised around 3 million USD in donations for the Campaign. 2.3. Armenian General Benevolent Union - AGBU The Fund is based in the USA (New York, NY) and ran a campaign - #Aid4Artsakh to raise funds for the campaign. The Fund has raised around 11 million USD for that purpose. 2.4. Armenian Canadian Medical Association of Ontario - ACMAQ The ACMAQ is based in Ontario, Canada. Despite being a medical association, the membership is only expanded to those professionals or students that have Armenian origin and share the views and values of Armenian heritage. it ran a fundraising campaign, "Donate to Artsakh," which was accompanied by highly politicized anti-Azerbaijani rhetoric during the war. it currently runs a "Rehabilitation and Recovery: Medical Help to Artsakh and Armenia" campaign. 2.5. Fund for Armenian Relief - FAR The Fund has offices both in the USA (New York, NY) and Armenia (Yerevan). The motto of the Fund is "FAR stands with Armenia and Artsakh". One of the placards shared in social media by the FAR affiliated organizations says: "Any activity that will save you money to help our banag". Banag is "army" in Armenian language. 6 During his interview with the Armenia Media - Australia on 24 October 2020, the Chairperson of FAR in Australia, Kevork Vartanian, openly admitted to FAR's participation in the military hostilities between Armenia and Azerbaijan through "volunteer bands." 2.6. Armenian Relief Society - ARS Based in the USA (Massachusetts, MA), ARS is well-known for its regular illicit financial transactions to the illegal separatist entity that existed in the formerly occupied territories of the Republic of Azerbaijan. 2.7. Tufenkian Foundation The Tufenkian Foundation operates in Armenia (Yerevan). it has been directly involved in the illegal settlement and economic development efforts in the formerly occupied territories of the Republic of Azerbaijan. Most of the donations through this Foundation during the war period were marked as "for army" or "for army needs". 2.8. Armenian Youth Federation of Western United States - AYF One of the founders of the AYF is famous Nazi general Garegin Nzdeh, who is considered a national heroin Armenia. The Federation announced a "With our Soldiers" campaign. 2.9. Americans for Artsakh Americans for Artsakh is a tax-exempt charity foundation based in Washington D.C., which supports the illegal separatist entity that had existed in the formerly occupied territories of Azerbaijan. it is currently raising funds under the motto "Supporting the Cause of the People of Artsakh". 2.10. Jinishian Memorial Foundation - JMF Jinishian Memorial Foundation17 registered in Armenia asa local foundation in 1999 raised funds for the campaign between September 30 - October 31, 2020 and donated 50.000 USD towards it. JMF is primarily sponsored by the Jinishian Memorial Program (JMP) of the Presbyterian Church USA. A charitable trust established in 1966, JMP has representation offices in Lebanon, Syria and USA. 2.11. Center for Armenian lnformation and Advice (CAIA) UK CAIA is a registered charity in England and Wales founded in 1986 by Armenian refugees and immigrants in the UK. In October 2020 CAIA's website18 called UK Armenians to 17 https://www. j in ishia n. org/We-Are-Ou r-Borders-AII-For-Artsa kh 18 htt ps ://ca i a. o rg. u k/we-a re-o ur-bord ers-a 11-fo r-artsa kh-rel i ef-fund/ 7 donate to the campaign and according to its 2020 report, CAIA contributed f:300019 from its unrestricted funds towards the "humanitarian" efforts in the context of war. 3. Abuse of AmazonSmile platform Armenian Diaspora organizations do not shy away from abusing global charity initiatives for their own malicious purposes. For instance, Armenian Diaspora organizations misused the AmazonSmile platform, which was designed to collect charity donations. Specifically, Armenian community members called on all potential donors through social media (Annex 10) networks to choose the Armenia Fund as a charity foundation at AmazonSmile with a view to directing the collected amount to the Campaign. 4. Abuse of bank and payment network services for collection and transfer of the illicit funds The services of following banks and payment networks have been misused and continue to be abused for collection and transfer of the funds raised through above-referred donation campaigns that undermine the territorial integrity and sovereignty of the Republic of Azerbaijan: >"' Banks - Chase Bank (for donations in USD) - Deutsche Bank (for donations in EURO) - Commerzbank, Frankfurt (for donations in EURO)20 - HSBC Bank (for donations in GBP) - Republican Bank Armenia (for donations in Russian Ruble and Armenian Dram) - Allianz Bank Bulgaria - Postbank Bulgaria (Eurobank Bulgaria AD) - DSK Bank Bulgaria - WESTPACK Bank (Australia) - St. George Bank (Australia) - Me)KrocyAapcTBƏHHblVI 5aHK, Moscow, Russian Federation (for donations in Russian ruble) >"' Payment networks - Mastercard - ViSA - Paypal 19 https://caia.org. uk/a bout-us/our-h istory/ 20 https://en. jah.am/news/7793#ad-i mage-0 8 Azerbaijan has appealed to the above mentioned banks to conduct due diligence to verify the beneficial owners, source of funds, nature and intended purpose of funds to address potential terrorism financing as required by international regulations. 5. Commitments of UN Member States in preventing and countering the abuse of non-profit organizations, corruption, money laundering, and terrorism financing it is an undeniable fact-now confirmed by Armenian Government officials-that funds raised through these so-called "charity campaigns" for humanitarian purposes were, in fact, transferred directly to the Armenian state budget without oversight or transparency. The managers of such charity entities abuse the power entrusted to them by the respective national authorities and trust of the donating taxpayers. These actions constitute grave violations of the national laws of countries granting charity status to such entities, and should be prosecuted as such. These acts also implicate anti-corruption, money laundering, and terrorism financing obligations of both the source and destination countries of the collected donations. Such obligations derive from international conventions,21 UN Security Council resolutions,22 and the recommendations of standard setting organizations, such as the Financial Action Task Force. lndeed, the Financial Action Task Force recently recognized that the misuse of alleged non-profit organizations for the purpose of financing of terrorism is a crucial weak point in the global struggle to stop such funding at its source.23 Therefore, the Republic of Azerbaijan urges all UN Member States to exercise due diligence in relation to such entities registered in their territories, and to take all practicable measures consistent with their international obligations to prevent corruption, money laundering, and terrorism financing, actions that would undermine the sovereignty and territorial integrity of the Republic of Azerbaijan. Such measures include, but are not limited 21 see, e.g., international Convention for the Suppression of Financing of Terrorism; United Nations Convention against Corruption; United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime. 22 See, e.g., UN Security Council resolutions 1373 (2001), 2178 (2014), 2195 (2014) and 2347 (2017). 23 See, e.g., Financial Action Task Force, international Standards on Combating Money Laundering and the Financing of Terrorism & Proliferation: The FATF Recommendations, as amended October 2020, available at: https://www.fatf­ gafi.org/publications/fatfrecommendations/documents/fatf-recommendations.html, Recommendation 8 ("Countries should review the adequacy of laws and regulations that relate to non-profit organisations which the country has identified as being vulnerable to terrorist financing abuse. Countries should apply focused and proportionate measures, in line with the risk-based approach, to such non-profit organisations to protect them from terrorist financing abuse, including: (a) by terrorist organisations posing as legitimate entities; (b) by exploiting legitimate entities as conduits for terrorist financing, including for the purpose of escaping asset-freezing measures; and (c) by concealing or obscuring the clandestine diversion of funds intended for legitimate purposes to terrorist organisations."). 9 to, identifying and freezing or seızıng such funds, exchanging information about such activities with the Republic of Azerbaijan, and prosecuting the offenders. 10 Saatja: Embassy of the Republic of Azerbaijan to the Republic of Estonia <[email protected]> Saadetud: 03.02.2022 09:48 Adressaat: 'Kaie Kork' <[email protected]>; <[email protected]>; RAM Info <[email protected]>; <[email protected]> Teema: Report Tähtsus: Kõrgeim Dear colleagues, Please see the attached report entitled Armenias abuse of non-profit organizations and charity entities for corruption, money laundering and terrorist financing purposes, prepared by the respective Azerbaijani authorities. The Embassy would be grateful if the enclosed report could be transmitted accordingly. In case any possible charity campaign directed against Azerbaijans territorial integrity and sovereignity is discovered in Estonia, the Government of Azerbaijan would be highly appreciate for taking necessary preventive measures by the Estonian competent authorities. Thank you for your attention and assistance. Regards, Emin Teymurov First SecretaryAzerbaijani Embassy Tallinn
Allikas: Rahandusministeerium dokumendiregister →