Council of the
European Union
Brussels, 1 September 2020
(OR. en)
10363/20
JUR 391
INST 178
COVER NOTE
From: Secretary-General of the European Commission,
signed by Mr Jordi AYET PUIGARNAU, Director
date of receipt: 31 July 2020
To: Mr Jeppe TRANHOLM-MIKKELSEN, Secretary-General of the Council
of the European Union
No. Cion doc.: COM(2020) 350 final
Subject: REPORT FROM THE COMMISSION Monitoring the application of
European Union law 2019 Annual Report
Delegations will find attached document COM(2020) 350 final.
Encl.: COM(2020) 350 final
10363/20
EN
EUROPEAN
COMMISSION
Brussels, 31.7.2020
COM(2020) 350 final
REPORT FROM THE COMMISSION
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
{SWD(2020) 147 final}
EN EN
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
FOREWORD ................................................................................................................................................... 2
I. A NEW BOOST FOR JOBS, GROWTH AND INVESTMENT ................................................................ 3
Ensuring fair working conditions across the EU .......................................................... 3
Enforcing environmental rules ................................................................................. 4
Enforcing agricultural rules ...................................................................................... 5
Enforcing rules on maritime affairs and fisheries ........................................................ 5
Enforcing rules on regional policy ............................................................................. 6
Fighting fraud against the EU budget ........................................................................ 6
II. A CONNECTED DIGITAL SINGLE MARKET ........................................................................................ 7
Improving connectivity ........................................................................................... 7
Guaranteeing cybersecurity and trust in online transactions ........................................ 8
Better accessibility for people with disabilities............................................................ 8
III. A RESILIENT ENERGY UNION WITH A FORWARD-LOOKING CLIMATE CHANGE POLICY ........... 9
Implementing the Paris Agreement on climate change .............................................. 10
IV. A DEEPER AND FAIRER INTERNAL MARKET WITH A STRENGTHENED INDUSTRIAL BASE ..... 12
Ensuring undistorted competition ........................................................................... 12
Ensuring free movement of workers ....................................................................... 12
Ensuring free movement of goods .......................................................................... 13
Ensuring freedom of establishment and free movement of services ............................ 14
Improved information and assistance for citizens and businesses ............................... 15
Enforcing the Capital Markets Union, financial services rules and free movement of capital ......... 15
Enforcing rules on taxation and customs ................................................................. 16
Ensuring a high level of protection for consumers .................................................... 18
Ensuring a high level of protection of public health ................................................... 19
Enforcing rules on mobility and transport ................................................................ 20
V. A DEEPER AND FAIRER ECONOMIC AND MONETARY UNION ..................................................... 22
Enforcing Banking Union rules ............................................................................... 22
VI. AN AREA OF JUSTICE AND FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS BASED ON MUTUAL TRUST .................... 23
Upholding rule of law and fundamental rights .......................................................... 23
Cross-border cooperation in criminal and civil justice ................................................ 24
Improving the protection of personal data ............................................................... 24
Enforcing rules on security .................................................................................... 25
VII. TOWARDS A NEW POLICY ON MIGRATION .................................................................................... 26
1
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
2
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Foreword
The European Union is founded on the respect of the rule of law. It was no coincidence that
the first President of the European Commission, Walter Hallstein, referred to the European
Union as a Community of law (Rechtsgemeinschaft) – bound by rules that Member States
agree upon as co-legislators and subscribe to implement in their national systems. As
Guardian of the Treaties, it is the Commission’s task to ensure that these rules are upheld
to the benefit of our citizens. Whether it concerns clean air, food safety or access to health
care abroad, the cooperation of Member States is key to ensure that EU policies become a
reality for people in their every day lives.
This annual report provides an account of the Commission’s work to ensure the correct
application, implementation and enforcement of EU law in 2019.
The year 2019 marked the end of the Juncker Commission and, as of 1 December, the
beginning of my team’s mandate. In many ways, 2019 has thus been a year of transition. A
new team of Commissioners took up their duties, working under new Political Guidelines
and steering new initiatives, such as the European Green Deal and the Digital Agenda.
Throughout this transition, the foundations that keep our Union together have not changed.
The correct application and enforcement of EU law, including the respect of fundamental
rights and the rule of law remains a shared responsibility of Member States and EU
institutions. Upholding EU law can never be a one-way street but is based on the sincere
cooperation of our Member States – in the interest of the citizens whom we serve. Nurturing
this special partnership, the Commission will continue to provide support and issue
guidance to Member States to help them implement EU law. We will nevertheless remain
vigilant and we will be ready to take determined legal action if EU law is breached. There
can be no compromise when it comes to the application and enforcement of EU law to
uphold citizens’ rights that derive from it.
President of the European Commission
Ursula von der Leyen
3
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
I. A new boost for jobs, growth and investment
The Commission’s first priority last year was to stimulate investment to create jobs and
strengthen Europe’s competitiveness. However, creating the right regulatory environment to
support businesses and job creation is undermined if Member States do not implement EU
rules correctly and on time.
Ensuring fair working conditions across the EU
The European Pillar of Social Rights, proclaimed in November 2017 by the European
Parliament, the Council and the European Commission, expresses the joint political
commitment to a number of principles and rights that are essential for fair and well-
functioning labour markets and welfare systems in 21st century Europe. One key element is
fair working conditions, which includes the prevention of employment relationships that lead
to precarious working conditions.
In July 2019, the Commission took action against Italy, as it considered that public sector
workers are not sufficiently protected against abusive successive fixed-term contracts
and discrimination, as required under EU rules (Council Directive 1999/70/EC).
During 2019, the Member States, the Commission and social partners continued their
cooperation to make EU occupational safety and health legislation future-proof and to
ensure proper compliance. A strong focus was on ensuring that Member States have in
4
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
place binding occupational safety and health rules in their national legislation and that they
communicate them to the Commission.
The Commission also regularly updates the Interpretative Communication on the Working
Time Directive in line with important developments in the case-law of the Court of Justice.
Enforcing environmental rules
In 2019, the Commission continued its legal action to combat air pollution, which remains a
priority. The Commission also promoted implementation through discussions with the
Member States on this important topic – a clean air dialogue was held in Italy in 2019.
In 2019, the Commission took another three Member States to the Court of Justice over
excessive levels of nitrogen dioxide (NO2) or sulfur dioxide (SO2) in the air (Italy, Spain
and Bulgaria).
The Court of Justice upheld the action brought by the Commission against France over
nitrogen dioxide (NO2) pollution and, in another ruling, the Court provided an important
interpretation of the Ambient Air Quality Directive - national courts have jurisdiction to
review the choice of location of air quality measuring stations.
The Commission organises events on circular economy in Member States that are at risk of
not reaching the new waste recycling targets and other requirements of EU waste
legislation. In 2019, such events were held in Athens, Lisbon and Budapest, and top
experts offered recommendations on how best to implement the rules that were revised in
2018.
The Commission referred Italy, Cyprus and Sweden to the Court of Justice in 2019 for
failing to meet their obligations on urban waste water treatment. Under EU legislation,
5
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
proper waste water collecting systems must be in place, and this water must be
adequately treated.
Member States must complete the Natura 2000 network of protected areas and put in place
the necessary conservation measures for all sites. This is key for the conservation of
protected habitats and species. In parallel, the Commission took action in 2019 to remedy
structural flaws in national laws on nature protection and to stop illegal bird hunting. The
Commission is also focused on ensuring that logging and forest management activities are
carried out in compliance with nature protection requirements.
The Commission launched infringement procedures against 17 Member States in March,
October and November to improve the implementation of the EU Environmental Impact
Assessment Directive, which was updated in 2014 to reduce administrative burden and
improve the level of environmental protection, while making public and private
investment decisions more sound, predictable and sustainable.
Enforcing agricultural rules
The common agricultural policy (CAP) is built on a partnership between agriculture and
society, and between the EU and its farmers. Its purpose is to support farmers and improve
agricultural productivity, to ensure a stable supply of affordable food and to make sure that
European Union farmers make a reasonable living. The CAP also addresses environmental
challenges, including climate change. It aims at managing natural resources in a
sustainable manner, maintaining rural areas and landscapes across the EU, and keeping
the rural economy alive by promoting jobs in farming and related sectors.
Geographical indications protect the name
of specific products and promote their
unique characteristics, which are linked to
their geographical origin as well as
traditional know-how and are a key part of
maintaining high food quality and
standards.
In 2019, the Commission took action to
address the incorrect implementation of
EU rules on the protection of designations
of origin and geographical indications.
Denmark allowed Danish companies to produce and export white cheese to non-EU
countries as ‘feta’, even though it does not comply with the product specification for this
protected designation of origin.
Bulgaria has maintained its own national register of geographical indications for
agricultural products and foodstuffs since 2008, contrary to the exclusive character of
the EU-wide registers for quality schemes.
Enforcing rules on maritime affairs and fisheries
6
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
The primary goal of the common fisheries
policy (CFP) is to ensure that the fishing and
aquaculture sectors are environmentally,
economically and socially sustainable. The
CFP therefore includes measures to restrict
the fishing fleet capacity and to impose limits
on catches and fishing activities. In this
regard, all Member States have agreed to
bring commercial fishing down to sustainable
levels by 2020. In 2019, a particular focus was
placed on verifying compliance with rules on
by-catches of sensitive species such as whales, dolphins and other marine mammals.
The Commission launched a series of informal dialogues on issues such as engine power
verification systems and control of the EU fleet fishing outside EU waters.
The success of the CFP requires the design and implementation of an effective and
coherent system of control and enforcement. For this reason, the Commission’s
enforcement strategy in 2019 continued to focus on fisheries conservation, control and
enforcement by Member States.
The Commission followed up on its infringement procedure against Denmark over its
failure to enforce several important provisions of the EU Control Regulation. The most
serious issues concern fisheries for industrial purposes. Proper controls are essential to
make sure that catch registration documents are accurate, which is necessary to
prevent overfishing.
The CFP also offers specific tools for enforcement, such as control action plans and
administrative inquiries. On the basis of verifications and audits carried out by the
Commission, the Commission adopted and followed up on a variety of control action plans.
Enforcing rules on regional policy
The European Structural and Investment Funds support investments in key growth-
generating policy areas across the EU.
In 2019, the Commission continued to
ensure that irregular expenditure is
withdrawn from co-financing, either by
suspending payments or by applying
financial corrections in some cases.
On 14 May 2019, the Commission adopted
a Decision laying down the guidelines for
determining financial corrections to be made
to expenditure financed by the Union if
public procurement rules are not followed.
This Decision offers more legal certainty for
all actors and a more proportionate approach in the complex area of public procurement,
which remains a major source of irregularities and financial corrections for Cohesion Funds.
Fighting fraud against the EU budget
7
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
The means to combat crime affecting the EU budget have significantly improved with the
adoption of the Directive on the protection of the EU’s financial interests. The Directive will
also be the substantive base for the work of the European Public Prosecutor's Office. The
Commission is working closely with the Member States to ensure that the Directive is
implemented properly. On 19 September 2019 it opened infringement procedures against
14 Member States for late transposition.
In two cases brought to the Court by the Commission against the United Kingdom and
the Netherlands, the Court held that these countries had not complied with their duty of
sincere cooperation under the Treaty as they had failed to compensate for the loss of
own resources resulting from the wrongful issue of export certificates by the local
authorities of their Overseas Countries and Territories (OCT). The Court concluded that
the two Member States concerned are liable, vis-à-vis the European Union, for any error
committed by the authorities of their OCTs that led to a shortfall of traditional own
resources.
II. A connected digital single market
The digital single market strategy addresses the challenges and opportunities of the digital
transformation by reducing market fragmentation, increasing data flows and market fluidity,
and adapting existing rules to the digital age. Consumer access has improved through the
ban on unjustified Geo-blocking, portability of content, the end of roaming charges, and
WiFi4EU. Market framework conditions have been bettered through the new European
Electronic Communications Code, the Directive on Audio-visual and Media Services, the
updated copyright legislation and the Regulation on Platforms. Enforcing these rules will be
essential over the coming years.
Improving connectivity
High-speed digital communications foster
innovation and better services for the
economy and for society as a whole. The
development of 5G connectivity is a
priority for the Commission. The aim is to
ensure that 5G radio spectrum is
available in the whole of the EU by 2020.
The effective application of rules
concerning the Europe-wide emergency
number 112 will deliver safe and effective
access to emergency services for end
users, including for those with disabilities.
In 2019, the Commission launched infringement proceedings against Czechia,
Germany, Greece, Spain and Croatia because they had failed to ensure equivalent
access for users with disabilities, as required by the rules on the 112 emergency
number.
Building high-speed electronic communications infrastructure can be very costly. Therefore,
it is important to implement the rules that make deployment cheaper and more efficient, to
the benefit of the public.
8
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
In 2019, the Court imposed, at the request of the Commission, a daily penalty on
Belgium for having only partially transposed measures to reduce the cost of deploying
high-speed electronic communications networks in the Brussels region.
9
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Guaranteeing cybersecurity and trust in online transactions
In an increasingly digitised economy and society, cybersecurity threats are a growing
concern. The Directive on the Security of Network and Information Systems (NIS Directive)
improves the Union’s overall level of cybersecurity. The Commission launched
infringements against 6 Member States in 2019 for not having identified operators of
essential services under that Directive. At the end of 2019, infringement procedures on the
NIS Directive were still ongoing against the following Member States: Belgium, Hungary,
Austria, Romania and Slovenia.
Better accessibility for people with disabilities
People with disabilities, especially those with vision or hearing impairments, may have
difficulty accessing websites and mobile applications of public bodies. The aim of the Web
Accessibility Directive is to improve access to these information tools for people with
disabilities. Throughout 2019, the Commission actively pursued the ongoing infringement
procedures against 19 Member States for their failure to implement the Web Accessibility
Directive and eventually closed cases against 12 Member States. As a result, 7 cases
remained open at the end of 2019, against Belgium, Bulgaria, Germany, Ireland, Hungary,
Austria and Slovakia.
10
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
III. A resilient Energy Union with a forward-looking climate change policy
The success of the European Green Deal, a priority area of the Political Guidelines of
President von der Leyen, relies on the solid foundations of the Energy Union. The EU has a
comprehensive set of energy rules. The ‘Clean Energy for All Europeans’ package,
completed in 2019, is central to developing and delivering the Energy Union and the
European Green Deal. It will help to lead the energy transition towards a safe, secure and
sustainable energy sector with the consumer at the centre.
The Commission’s role as guardian of the Treaties in ensuring the correct implementation
and application of EU energy rules is vital to achieve EU energy policy goals. The
enforcement action in 2019 focused on the following main areas: the internal energy
market, energy efficiency, renewable energy sources and security of gas supply.
The Commission decided to refer Czechia and Slovenia to the Court of Justice for the
incorrect transposition and application of certain provisions of the Energy Performance of
Buildings Directive. The Commission also decided to refer Spain to the Court of Justice
for failure to comply with the Energy Efficiency Directive and Belgium for the incorrect
transposition of directives on the internal market for electricity and gas.
The Commission launched new procedures against 13 Member States, in January, July
and November, for failure to adopt and/or notify transposition measures under the
Indirect Land Use Change Directive and launched infringement procedures against 15
Member States for failure to correctly implement the EU rules on energy efficiency.
Moreover, infringement procedures were used to ensure a high level of safety in the nuclear
sector and to enforce EU rules on nuclear safety, responsible and safe management of
spent fuel and radioactive waste and the radiation protection of workers, patients and the
general public.
11
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
In 2019, the Commission further pursued
the infringements against 5 Member States
and decided to refer Italy to the Court of
Justice for failure to transpose measures
under the Basic Safety Standards
Directive. The Court of Justice also upheld
the Commission’s claims in a judgment
against Italy for having breached the
requirement under the Radioactive Waste
Directive to notify a final adopted national
programme for radioactive waste and
spent fuel management.
With the entry into force of the ‘Clean Energy for all Europeans’ package, attention will
focus on monitoring the Member States’ progress in reaching the EU’s 2030 targets for
renewable energy and energy efficiency. The Commission will also monitor their integrated
national energy and climate plans for 2021 to 2030. Enforcing EU energy rules will remain
an essential pillar of the Energy Union strategy.
Implementing the Paris Agreement on climate change
The Political Guidelines of the von der Leyen Commission call upon Europe to become the
world’s first climate-neutral continent by 2050. Published in December 2019, the
Communication on the European Green Deal sets out an ambitious action plan in a number
of policy areas to achieve this goal. In March 2020, the Commission proposed that the 2050
climate neutrality be enshrined in a new climate law and later in the year will present a plan
to increase, in a responsible way, the current 2030 target for reducing greenhouse gas
emissions to at least 50% and towards 55% (from 1990 levels).
12
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Fully implemented and enforced legislation is essential to reach the current 2030 target of
at least a 40% reduction (from 1990 levels) and build a solid basis for raising the level of
ambition. By October 2019, Member States were meant to have transposed the Directive to
enhance cost-effective emission reductions and low-carbon investments in order to prepare
for phase 4 of the EU emission trading system (EU ETS) for 2021-2030. The Commission is
currently reviewing the state of transposition and will, where not already under way, take
enforcement action as necessary.
For shipping, in 2019 the Commission published, for the first time, comprehensive
information on CO2 emissions from ships calling at ports in the European Economic Area.
For aviation, in 2019 the Commission laid down a framework allowing for implementation in
the EU of the rules for monitoring, reporting and verification of emissions from airplanes
under the global market-based measure (CORSIA) of the International Civil Aviation
Organisation.
For protection of the ozone layer, in 2019 the Commission completed the evaluation of the
implementation and performance of the Ozone Regulation, and in 2020 it will start an
impact assessment to examine if and how this Regulation could be further improved. In
2020, the Commission will also start the evaluation and impact assessment of the F-Gas
Regulation.
13
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
IV. A deeper and fairer internal market with a strengthened industrial base
The EU single market remains Europe’s most precious asset for citizens and businesses. It
provides enormous opportunities for businesses, and a greater choice and better prices for
consumers. It enables people to travel, live, work and study wherever they wish. But these
benefits cannot be enjoyed if single market rules are not applied or implemented, or if they
are undermined by other barriers.
Ensuring undistorted competition
The Commission’s infringement work in the field of competition strengthens the internal
market by promoting a level playing field.
In 2019, after having verified the completeness and conformity of the transposing measures
of the Directive on certain rules governing actions for damages under national law for
infringements of the competition law provisions of the Member States and of the European
Union, the Commission concluded that the Directive was fully and correctly transposed, and
closed all the infringement proceedings it had started in this context.
The consistent enforcement of negative State aid decisions is essential for the credibility of
the Commission's State aid control. Proceedings that require a Member State to recover
irregular State aid are an important part of the Commission’s infringement work in the field
of competition.
The Commission decided to refer Greece to the Court of Justice for failing to comply
with a 2017 ruling. The Court had condemned Greece for failure to implement a 2014
Commission Decision requiring it to recover EUR 135.8 million of incompatible State aid
from Larco General Mining & Metallurgical Company S.A. More than 5 years after the
adoption of the Commission Decision and following the Court's judgment and the
Commission's reminder, Greece had still not recovered the incompatible State aid. The
Commission has now requested that the Court of Justice impose financial sanctions on
Greece for having failed to implement the Court’s ruling.
Ensuring free movement of workers
The EU has developed an extensive body of rules on the free movement of workers, the
posting of workers and social security coordination. If these rules are not followed, trust and
fairness in the single market are undermined. In particular, concerns have been voiced
about mobile workers being vulnerable to abuse or being denied their rights, and about
businesses having to operate in an uncertain, unclear or unfair business environment.
The Commission received complaints about Austrian legislation making family benefits
and family tax reductions paid for children residing in another Member State dependent
on the cost of living of that Member State. This means that many EU citizens who work
in Austria and contribute to its social security and tax system in the same way as
domestic workers receive fewer benefits simply because their children are living in
another Member State. The Commission found that this indexation mechanism is not
compatible with EU law. It therefore launched an infringement procedure against
Austria.
14
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
In 2019, the Commission continued infringements proceedings against Cyprus, France,
Ireland, and Romania for failing to implement on time in their national legislation the
obligations deriving from the Directive on minimum requirements for enhancing worker
mobility between Member States by improving the acquisition and preservation of
supplementary pension rights. Following the notification by these Member States and the
assessment that they had completely transposed the Directive, the Commission closed the
proceedings against them.
On 25 September 2019,
the Commission published
a report on the application
and implementation of the
Enforcement Directive on
Posting of Workers in the
EU Member States.
The Commission also
published a Practical
Guide on Posting of
Workers. To help workers,
employers and national
authorities understand the
rules on posting of
workers. It ensures that workers are aware of their rights and that the rules are correctly
and consistently applied by national authorities and employers throughout the EU.
In 2018, the Commission proposed the creation of a European Labour Authority (ELA) to
promote the fair, simple and effective enforcement of EU rules on labour mobility. The
European Parliament and the Council reached an agreement on this proposal in 2019. The
Labour Authority’s activities started in mid-October 2019 with the first meeting of the ELA
Management Board.
Ensuring free movement of goods
The Commission works to
ensure that the European
single market delivers its full
benefits, that EU citizens
have a greater choice of
products and better prices,
and that European
businesses – small and
large – can expand their
customer base and trade
products more easily across
the EU. For example, in
2019, the Commission took action on restrictions affecting both the retail sale of agricultural
and food products, and the placing on the market of lightning conductors.
The Commission referred Hungary to the Court of Justice because its national rules on
the retail sale of agricultural and food products provide that the profit margin on these
products must be the same, irrespective of their country of origin. This rule violates EU
law on the free movement of goods, as it discourages sales of imported products in
15
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
comparison to domestic products.
In the pharmaceutical sector, the Commission took action to ensure that Member States
comply with EU rules on the free movement of goods.
In 2019, the Commission sent a reasoned opinion to Germany regarding its rules on
fixed prices for prescription medicines, which hampers the sale of products by
pharmacies established in other EU Member States.
The Commission’s enforcement activities also led to the successful closure of several
infringement cases related to free movement of goods in the areas of food supplements,
right-hand drive passenger vehicles, sale of imported second-hand ambulances or national
accreditation bodies.
Ensuring freedom of establishment and free movement of services
The Services Directive requires that national authorities review their existing legislation to
ensure that any requirements they impose on market access are justified by a legitimate
objective. To support the implementation of that Directive, one-stop shops are set up,
namely points of single contact (PSCs), to make it easier for businesses to establish
themselves and expand in other Member States. In 2019, the Commission took action
against all 28 Member States to improve the service provided by the PSCs, as required by
the Services Directive and the Professional Qualifications Directive. Problems were found
related, in particular, to the online availability and quality of information on the requirements
and procedures that service providers and professionals have to fulfil if they want to do
business abroad. The Commission also drew attention to problems with accessing and
completing procedures online through the PSCs.
To create a level playing field for businesses across Europe, the EU has adopted rules on
public procurement that apply in all Member States. These rules govern the way public
authorities and certain public utility operators across Europe purchase goods, works and
services.
In 2019, the Commission took action
against 8 Member States for not
awarding hydropower authorisations
or concessions in line with EU law. All
eight Member States failed to respect
the principles of transparency and
equal treatment in awarding those
authorisations and concessions.
The Commission considered that the
procedures followed in France and
Portugal to award hydropower
concessions did not comply with EU
rules on public procurement.
The Commission also took the view that Austria, Germany, Italy, Poland, Sweden and
16
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
the United Kingdom, hydropower authorisations were not awarded in accordance with
the Services Directive, which requires that when authorisations for a service activity are
limited in number because natural resources are scarce, the authorisations must be
granted for a limited period following an impartial and transparent selection procedure.
These authorisations must not be automatically renewable.
Freedom of establishment requires that the qualifications of professionals, such as doctors
or architects, be recognised abroad, enabling them to set up a practice anywhere in the EU.
The Commission launched infringement procedures against all Member States (except
Denmark) in 2019 for not bringing their legislation into line with the Professional
Qualifications Directive.
Improved information and assistance for citizens and businesses
The Single Market will only function well if citizens and businesses have good access to
information and assistance about their rights under EU law. In 2019, the Commission
stepped up efforts to make Single Market rules better known by upgrading the Your Europe
portal, in view of its transition to the future single digital gateway in 2020. Your Europe
Advice also continued to provide tailor-made legal advice to citizens and businesses. The
Commission further focused on actions to boost the administrative capacity and legal
expertise of SOLVIT in order to effectively implement the new business-friendly problem-
solving procedure, where SOLVIT helps businesses in case mutual recognition of their
product is denied. This new procedure started to apply from April 2020. Building on
preparatory work done in 2019, the internal market information system will, as of 2020,
support administrative cooperation under the new Consumer Protection Cooperation (CPC)
Regulation. This information system will help the CPC Network of national consumer
authorities to protect consumers even better. Finally, the Commission started the process of
upgrading the Single Market Scoreboard to cover more policy areas and to give a fuller
picture of the state of the single market.
In the field of justice, the Commission regularly updates the e-Justice portal, which provides
a wealth of information and links on laws and practices in all EU countries.
Enforcing the Capital Markets Union, financial services rules and free movement of capital
The directives adopted in the wake of the financial crisis must be properly implemented to
increase the resilience and stability of the financial sector and to improve investor
protection. The implementation of some of these directives is also important for completing
the Capital Markets Union. The implementation of these directives (for example the
Solvency II Directive, the revised Markets in Financial Instruments Directive, the
Occupational Retirement Provisions Directive, the Payment Services Directive, the
Insurance Distribution Directive) is also central to the goal of achieving the Capital Markets
Union, which will improve access to finance, in particular for innovative companies, start-
ups or small and medium-sized enterprises. It also makes capital markets more attractive
for retail and institutional investors, and facilitates cross-border investment. In 2019, the
Commission launched infringement procedures as 17 Member States had failed to
implement the Occupational Retirement Provisions Directive in their national legislation on
time.
17
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
The Commission pursued the infringement procedure against Romania for not aligning
its legislation on third-party liability motor insurance with EU rules. Romania's national
rules impose strict conditions on insurers in setting their premiums. The Commission
considered that these obligations are contrary to the Solvency II Directive, regarding the
principle of the freedom of tariffs. The Romanian legislation also obliges insurers to
issue, for certain categories of vehicles, a policy valid only on Romanian territory. These
provisions were considered contrary to the Motor Insurance Directive, which requires the
policies to cover the whole territory of the Union based on a single insurance premium.
On the free movement of capital, the Commission had opened infringement procedures
against 5 Member States already in 2015, requesting them to terminate intra-EU bilateral
investment treaties between them (‘intra-EU BITs’) because of their incompatibility with EU
law. BITs are agreements establishing the terms and conditions for private investment that
apply between two EU Member States.
The Court of Justice in the Achmea case confirmed that investor-State arbitration clauses in
intra-EU BITs are not compatible with EU law. In 2019, the vast majority of EU Member
States endorsed the text of a plurilateral agreement to terminate the intra-EU bilateral
investment treaties among them. In May 2020, twenty-three Member States signed the
agreement for the termination of such treaties.
Hungary had adopted a law which terminated certain so-called ‘usufruct rights’ –
entailing the right to use a property and to profit from it - held by investors in Hungary.
The law deprived in particular foreign investors of their lawfully acquired rights on
farmland, and of the value of their investments, without any compensation. The
Commission decided to refer Hungary to the Court of Justice. In 2019, the Court ruled
that by adopting legislation depriving persons of their right of usufruct on farmland,
Hungary infringed both the principle of free movement of capital and the right to property
guaranteed by the Charter of Fundamental Rights.
Fighting against money-laundering and counter terrorism financing
The Commission’s enforcement activities in this field are focused on ensuring the timely
and correct transposition of the 4th and the 5th Anti-Money Laundering Directive on the
prevention of the use of the financial system for the purposes of money laundering or
terrorist financing. Both directives promote the highest standards for anti-money laundering
and to counter terrorism financing. During 2019, the Commission continued moving forward
with infringement cases as several Member States had still failed to implement the 4th Anti-
Money Laundering Directive in their national legislation.
The Commission also adopted the Communication: Towards better implementation of the
EU's anti-money laundering and countering the financing of terrorism framework, which was
accompanied by four reports to support European and national authorities in better
addressing money laundering and terrorist financing risks. The Communication and reports
stress the need for the full implementation of these two directives while underlining that a
number of structural shortcomings in the implementation of the Union's rules on anti-money
laundering still need to be addressed.
18
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Enforcing rules on taxation and customs
On indirect taxation, the Commission gave priority in its enforcement efforts to pursuing
infringements that distort competition in the internal market, that go against fair taxation or
that hamper EU climate objectives.
Following the revelations in the Paradise Papers of widespread evasion in the yacht and
aircraft sectors, the Commission continued infringement procedures against Italy and
Cyprus. These Member States had set up tax measures favourable to the pleasure yacht
and aircraft industries that run counter to EU law and fair taxation.
Poland is currently exempting from energy taxes highly polluting industries on the ground
that this is covered by the exceptions under the EU’s emission trading scheme (EU ETS).
The Commission decided to refer Poland to the Court because its actions are contrary to
EU law and to EU climate objectives.
The Commission’s enforcement action in 2019 focused on ensuring that Member States
transposed important amendments to the Directive on administrative cooperation into
national law. These amendments concern areas such as access to anti-money laundering
information, mandatory automatic exchange of information in the field of taxation, or the
automatic exchange of financial account information.
One of the benefits of the internal market is that citizens and businesses have the freedom
to move, operate and invest across national borders. As direct taxation is not harmonised
across the EU, this freedom can mean that some taxpayers can avoid or evade tax in their
country of residence. Tax authorities in the EU have therefore agreed to cooperate more
closely to ensure that taxes are paid and to fight tax fraud and tax evasion.
In addition, the Commission focused on ensuring the proper transposition of the Directive
on rules against tax avoidance practices that directly affect the functioning of the internal
market and the Directive on dispute resolution.
The Commission took action against Spain for failing to implement measures on the
mandatory automatic exchange of tax information. The Commission also took action
against Austria and Ireland for failing to transpose the interest limitation rule, as required
by the rules against tax avoidance practices that directly affect the functioning of the
internal market.
In 2019, the Commission closed infringement procedures against Czechia, Greece,
Poland and Romania on access to anti-money laundering information. The Commission
also closed infringement procedures against Belgium, Czechia, Greece, France, Cyprus,
Portugal, the United Kingdom and Latvia on rules against tax avoidance practices that
directly affect the functioning of the internal market, since they had completely transposed
these rules into their national legislation.
19
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
The Commission's enforcement strategy for customs focused on the correct and uniform
application of the Union Customs Code (UCC) and on detecting charges with equivalent
effect to customs duties, even within the EU.
In 2019, the Commission launched an enquiry across all Member States, investigating
national provisions on the time limitation for notifying a customs debt and the compatibility
of these provisions with the UCC, in order to provide more legal certainty for traders.
Following an infringement procedure launched by the Commission, Bulgaria amended its
provisions to comply with EU customs law in relation to sanctions for the non-declaration
of cash and in relation to customs duty relief for certain US products.
Ensuring a high level of protection for consumers
The Directive on better enforcement and modernisation of EU consumer protection rules
was adopted in November 2019. It strengthens consumer rights online, tackles dual quality
of products and provides for deterrent fines for 'widespread infringements' of consumer
rights.
Furthermore, the Commission launched the #YourEURight campaign to raise the
awareness of consumers of their rights.
In July 2019, the Commission issued guidance on the application of the Unfair Contract
Terms Directive. It covers the case law of the Court of Justice on, for instance, the
transparency of contract terms, the effect of finding contract terms unfair and on
requirements for procedures before national courts, such as for the review of unfair contract
terms.
20
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
By the end of 2019, 13 of the 14 infringement procedures launched for late transposition
of the 2015 Package Travel Directive had been closed. The Commission has started
assessing for all Member States whether the national measures correctly transpose this
Directive.
The Commission supported the enforcement of EU consumer law by national enforcement
authorities under the Consumer Protection Cooperation (CPC) Regulation. It assisted these
authorities in addressing misleading practices of major online operators (Facebook, Airbnb
and booking.com) to improve the transparency of their offers and the fairness of their terms
and conditions. In addition, the Commission assisted Member States in preparing for the
application of the revised CPC Regulation from January 2020, including through
workshops.
The European framework for alternative dispute resolution (ADR) and online dispute
resolution (ODR) was made more effective, including through an improved version of the
European ODR platform. The Commission also released its first implementation report on
the ADR/ODR framework.
For product safety, the Commission continued to facilitate cooperation among enforcement
authorities by financing sampling and testing activities on specific products in connection
with the rapid alert system, RAPEX. RAPEX allows for a quick, Europe-wide exchange of
information between authorities on products that pose a risk to the health and safety of
consumers.
Ensuring a high level of protection of public health
Monitoring the implementation of the Tobacco Products Directive in Member States’
national laws remained a priority for the Commission in 2019. This Directive aims at putting
in the Single Market context efforts to reduce tobacco use, particularly discouraging young
people from taking up smoking, and to ensure that the public is fully aware of the harmful
effects of tobacco. Tobacco consumption is the single largest avoidable health risk, and the
most significant cause of premature death in the EU. In 2019, the Commission carried out
conformity checks of the national laws transposing the Directive and organised structured
dialogues with the Member States to ensure its better implementation.
In 2019, the Commission closed infringement procedures against Czechia, Croatia,
Spain and Sweden, as the Member States took measures to implement the Tobacco
Products Directive in their national law.
Ensuring patients’ rights to access cross-border healthcare remained a priority for the
Commission in 2019. The Commission closely monitored the Cross-Border Healthcare
Directive and carried out structured dialogues with the Member States to ensure better
implementation of the Directive.
21
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
The Cross-Border Healthcare Directive lays down patients' rights to choose to receive
healthcare in another Member State and to claim reimbursement for it when returning
back home. The level of reimbursement must be up to the level of the costs that would
have been covered by the patient's own Member State if the healthcare had been
provided there, without exceeding the actual costs. The Commission launched
infringement procedures against Austria and the Netherlands because of reduced
reimbursement for cross-border health services.
For the Directive on the sustainable use of pesticides (SUD), the Commission undertook a
series of initiatives through the SUD Working Group, through audits, and through the Better
Training for Safer Food training in order to facilitate the Directive’s implementation.
22
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Enforcing rules on mobility and transport
In 2019, the Commission pursued its monitoring of the implementation of EU transport
legislation. Its enforcement work covered, in particular, the rules on completing the single
market, developing intelligent transport systems and defining common requirements for
safety in all modes of transport.
The Commission also monitored the national implementing measures aimed at creating a
single European rail area. In particular, it monitored competition issues, the regulatory
oversight and financial architecture of the railway sector, the power of national regulators,
the improved framework for investment in rail, and the fair and non-discriminatory access to
rail infrastructure and rail-related services.
The Commission decided to launch infringement procedures against Denmark, Germany,
Ireland, the Netherlands and Poland for failing to transpose certain provisions of the EU
rules on establishing a single European railway area. The procedures against France and
Spain were pursued further for their failure to fully comply with specific provisions, notably
those regarding access to rail-related services and guarantees of independence for the
station manager. The Commission also pursued further the infringement procedures
launched against Greece and Ireland for failing to communicate national measures to
transpose EU rules on the opening of the market for domestic passenger transport services
by rail and the governance of the railway infrastructure.
The European Registers of Road Transport Undertakings (ERRU) allows for the exchange
of information between Member States on road transport undertakings set up within the EU.
It is an essential instrument to ensure that the relevant EU legislation is properly enforced.
The implementation of a new and enhanced version of the ERRU requires Member States
to adapt their national systems. The Commission pursued infringement cases against
Belgium, Cyprus, Czechia, Denmark, Hungary, Malta, the Netherlands, Portugal, and the
United Kingdom to upgrade the connection between their national registers on road
transport undertakings and the new version of ERRU, as required by the relevant
regulation.
23
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Safety and security are of primary concern for any transport system. Creating an
environment for safe transport is essential for European citizens. One of the Commission’s
roles is to respond to these expectations by ensuring that there are satisfactory standards
in the whole EU for safety and security in all modes of transport. Europe’s railways are
among the safest in the world. EU policies aim to maintain high standards and to align
safety requirements across the EU.
The Commission launched an infringement procedure against Spain for its failure to fully
transpose EU legislation on railway safety. The Directive requires Member States to
establish an independent safety authority and an independent accident and incident
investigation body. It also requires Member States to allocate tasks and safety
responsibilities coherently. Moreover, Member States are required to define common
railway safety principles. The independence of investigation bodies is crucial to ensure
effective investigations and prevent future accidents.
Road transport is the most widely used means of travel and a primary cause of accidents.
The Commission has been very active in promoting rules, technical standards, and
awareness-raising campaigns to decrease the number of fatalities caused by road
accidents. The Commission monitored, in particular, the safety requirements for tunnels
and decided to pursue Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Italy and Spain for not complying with the
Directive on minimum safety measures relating to the infrastructure and operation of
tunnels
In maritime transport, the safety of both passenger and merchant ships is of paramount
importance. The common EU safety rules concern equipment, such as life jackets, sewage
cleaning systems and radars, on board EU-flagged ships.
The Commission launched infringement procedures against Malta and Bulgaria for their
failure to comply with EU law on marine equipment. Malta and Bulgaria had notably
failed to ensure that marine equipment (on board their flagged vessels) was always
accompanied by a declaration of conformity and had not conducted market surveillance
on an adequate scale.
Aviation is a form of transport requiring dedicated safety rules. EU air safety policy ensures
a high level of safety for passengers.
The Commission further pursued the infringement procedure against Hungary for its
failure to comply with EU rules on technical requirements and administrative procedures
related to air operations. These rules address in detail air operations with aeroplanes,
helicopters, balloons and sailplanes, including ramp inspections of aircraft of operators
under the safety oversight of another state. Due to a lack of sufficient personnel,
Hungary had failed to verify compliance with the safety requirements applicable to
organisations or to types of operations.
24
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
V. A deeper and fairer Economic and Monetary Union
A ‘deeper and fairer Economic and Monetary Union’ is a fundamental part of the
Commission’s response to the need to promote growth and jobs. This policy aims at
strengthening the EU economy in a way that creates more employment and improves
people’s living standards.
Enforcing Banking Union rules
Under the Banking Union, the Commission continued to check the Member States’
implementation of the Capital Requirements Directive IV, the Deposit Guarantee Schemes
Directive , the Bank Recovery and Resolution Directive and the Bank Creditor Hierarchy
Directive. These EU instruments are set up to ensure that banks are stronger and better
supervised and that problems can be resolved more easily without using taxpayers’ money.
In 2019 the Commission adopted a report assessing the implementation of the Bank
Recovery and Resolution Directive.
In 2019, the Commission launched infringement procedures against 12 Member States
for failing to adopt the necessary measures to fully transpose the Bank Creditor
Hierarchy Directive.
25
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
26
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
VI. An area of justice and fundamental rights based on mutual trust
Full respect for the rule of law and the Charter of Fundamental Rights is at the heart of
Commission priorities. Specific rights must also be ensured, such as the right of free
movement, the protection of personal data, gender equality, non-discrimination, victims’
rights and the right to a fair trial in criminal proceedings. These topics are high on the
Commission’s agenda as they directly affect people’s lives.
Under the European Semester exercise, the Commission continued to encourage Member
States to improve the effectiveness of their enforcement capacities. This particularly
concerns the independence, quality and efficiency of their national justice systems. To this
end, the Commission proposed country-specific recommendations for seven Member
States. Through the EU Justice Scoreboard, the Commission monitors the independence,
quality, and efficiency of the Member States’ justice systems.
Upholding rule of law and fundamental rights
In April 2019, the Commission set out its reflections on strengthening the rule of law in the
EU, sparking contributions from over 60 stakeholders contributed. The results were
reflected in the July Communication on Strengthening the rule of law within the Union - A
blueprint for action, which put forward a new rule of law mechanism. The Commission’s
Political Guidelines announced a new annual rule of law review cycle and an annual report,
which will summarise the situation in each Member State. The Commission also announced
that it will pursue a strategic approach to infringement proceedings and build on the case
law of the Court of Justice.
On 24 June and 5 November 2019, the Court of Justice issued rulings in infringement
proceedings initiated by the Commission against Poland, confirming that Polish
legislation lowering the retirement age of Supreme Court judges and ordinary court
judges is in violation of EU law requirements regarding judicial independence.
On 10 October 2019, the Commission referred Poland to the Court of Justice in
infringement proceedings concerning the new disciplinary regime for judges, as this
regime undermines judicial independence by not offering the necessary guarantees to
protect Polish judges from political control.
Negotiations on the Commission’s proposal for a regulation on the protection of the Union’s
budget in case of generalised deficiencies as regards the rule of law are ongoing in the
Council. Respect for the rule of law is essential to ensure sound financial management and
to protect the Union’s budget.
27
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Cross-border cooperation in criminal and civil justice
The Commission
continued its efforts to
monitor the complete
transposition of the
Procedural Rights
Directives. In 2019, the
main focus was on the
Directive on procedural
safeguards for children
and the Directive on
legal aid for suspects
and accused persons in
criminal proceedings
and for requested
persons in European
arrest warrant
proceedings.
In 2019, the Commission launched infringement procedures against 7 Member States for
not communicating their national transposition measures on the Directive on procedural
safeguards for children and against 4 Member States for not doing so for the Directive on
legal aid.
The Commission continued infringement procedures against 16 Member States and
launched infringement procedures against 9 Member States which had not
communicated all the national measures necessary to transpose the Victims’ Rights
Directive. The Commission also continued its infringement procedures against 2 Member
States in relation to mutual recognition instruments for transfers of prisoners, probation
measures, supervision measures and cross-border enforcement of financial penalties.
Improving the protection of personal data
Following the entry into application of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in
May 2018, the Commission focused on implementing the new data protection rules in 2019
through a multi-faceted approach. In particular, it engaged in bilateral dialogues with
national authorities on the compliance of national legislation with the GDPR, worked closely
with the data protection authorities cooperating within the European Data Protection Board,
and exchanged with stakeholders notably through a dedicated multi-stakeholder group. The
Commission also continued to financially support national data protection authorities
through grants, and conducted awareness-raising campaigns for citizens and businesses.
The Commission also carried out a stock-taking exercise of the first year of implementation
of the GDPR, the results of which were presented in a communication issued in July 2019.
Member States were required to transpose the Data Protection Law Enforcement Directive
by May 2018, and the Commission has begun assessing the compliance of the national
transposition legislation notified by the Member States with this Directive. In 2019 the
28
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Commission closed several of the 19 infringement procedures launched in 2018 for non-
communication of the transposing measures, while it launched an infringement procedure
against Germany and took Spain and Greece to Court (in the meantime Greece has notified
the Directive’s full transposition). At the end of 2019, infringement procedures were pending
against four Member States.
Enforcing rules on security
In 2019, enforcement work continued
under the European agenda on
security and the development of the
Security Union. The implementation of
EU rules in this area is key to ensuring
a high level of security throughout the
EU. The regular progress reports on
the Security Union reflect the ongoing
efforts to ensure full and correct
implementation of the rules.
Furthermore, the Commission monitored the implementation of the Directive on the
inclusion of new psychoactive substances in the definition of ‘drug’ and of the first
delegated directive adopted under the latter. The Commission also continued infringement
procedures for the failure to notify national transposition measures for two key directives on
security and on the fight against serious crime: the Passenger Name Records Directive and
the Directive on Combatting Terrorism. The Commission further pursued cases against
Spain, the Netherlands and Finland on the Passenger Name Records Directive. On the
Combatting Terrorism Directive, the Commission further pursued infringement cases
against Greece and Luxembourg.
The Commission also launched infringement procedures to safeguard the Union’s exclusive
external competence for security under the EU rules in this area.
Infringement procedures were launched against Bulgaria, Hungary, Austria and Romania
for having signed a multilateral international agreement on the exchange of DNA,
fingerprints and vehicle registration data, which contain provisions in violation of the EU’s
exclusive external competence by virtue of the Prüm Decisions. These decisions provide
for a mandatory automatic exchange and comparison of DNA data between national
databases to combat terrorism and cross-border crime.
29
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
VII. Towards a new policy on migration
The Commission’s migration policy seeks to equip the EU with the tools to better manage
migration in the medium and long term. It covers the full range of relevant issues, including
border management, visa policy, irregular migration, asylum and legal migration.
Consistent, humane and effective implementation is critical to the success of the policy.
In 2019, the Commission continued to monitor Member State implementation of EU
migration and asylum law, in particular the Asylum Procedures Directive, the Reception
Conditions Directive, the Qualification Directive and the Return Directive. These Directives
establish rules on processing asylum claims, guarantee a dignified standard of living for
asylum seekers in the EU, lay down rules for recognising third-country nationals as
refugees and set common standards and procedures under which non-EU nationals staying
illegally may be removed from the territories of EU countries.
The Commission referred Hungary to the Court of Justice for legislation which effectively
criminalises activities intended to assist persons initiating applications for asylum in
Hungary. The law is considered incompatible with the right of asylum applicants to
access counselling or legal advice offered in particular by non-governmental
organisations. It prevents anyone who is subject to a criminal procedure for having
provided such assistance from approaching the transit zones at Hungary's borders,
where asylum seekers are held. The Commission concluded that the Hungarian
legislation does not comply with the Asylum Procedures Directive and the Reception
Conditions Directive.
30
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
On legal migration, the Commission’s priority is to ensure that there are genuine legal
pathways to the EU, namely by improving the EU’s ability to attract and retain highly-skilled
workers as well as students and researchers. It is therefore important to ensure that the
directives on legal migration are implemented fully and correctly. They establish common
conditions for the admission and residence of non-EU nationals, simplify and harmonise
migration procedures and provide rights to equal treatment as EU nationals in a number of
areas.
In 2019, the Commission further pursued the pending infringements for failure to notify
national measures to implement the Students and Researchers Directive, for which five
Member States (Belgium, Greece, France, Slovenia and Sweden) still had cases open at
the end of the year.
An infringement procedure was launched against Sweden for its incorrect
implementation of several directives on legal migration as regards the processing of
applications for permits, and for restrictions to equal treatment of certain categories of
non-EU nationals.
The correct application of Union rules on Schengen borders and visas was also a priority
for the Commission in 2019.
The Commission further pursued an infringement case against Estonia because its ‘Go-
Swift’ queue management system is considered incompatible with the Schengen Borders
Code. It also took further steps in the infringement procedure against Czechia on the
right to appeal against a decision refusing, revoking or annulling a Schengen visa.
31
Saatja: Kirke Härma-Tamme <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 10.09.2020 17:24
Adressaat: <
[email protected]>
Koopia: HM <
[email protected]>; Age Inkinen <
[email protected]>; info
kaitseministeerium ee <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; MKM info <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; RAM Info <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; SM
Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: REPORT FROM THE COMMISSION Monitoring the application of European
Union law 2019 Annual Report
Tere
Edastan delegaatide portaali kaudu saabunud aruande ning palun see
edastada oma ministeeriumis antud teema eest vastutavatele nõunikele.
Lugupidamisega
Kirke Härma-Tamme
Sekretär-asjaajaja
Õiguspoliitika osakond
Justiitsministeerium
620 8201
Council of the
European Union
Brussels, 1 September 2020
(OR. en)
10363/20
ADD 1
JUR 391
INST 178
COVER NOTE
From: Secretary-General of the European Commission,
signed by Mr Jordi AYET PUIGARNAU, Director
date of receipt: 31 July 2020
To: Mr Jeppe TRANHOLM-MIKKELSEN, Secretary-General of the Council
of the European Union
No. Cion doc.: SWD(2020) 147 final
Subject: COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT Part I: General
Statistical Overview Accompanying the document Report from the
Commission Monitoring the application of European Union law 2019
Annual Report
Delegations will find attached document SWD(2020) 147 final.
Encl.: SWD(2020) 147 final
10363/20 ADD 1
EN
EUROPEAN
COMMISSION
Brussels, 31.7.2020
SWD(2020) 147 final
PART 1/4
COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT
Part I: General Statistical Overview
Accompanying the document
Report from the Commission
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
{COM(2020) 350 final}
EN EN
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
I. Working with Member States to ensure proper implementation of EU law............................................. 2
1. Explanatory documents: state of play ...................................................................................................... 2
2. Guidelines ................................................................................................................................................. 7
3. Implementation plans: state of play ......................................................................................................... 8
4. Meeting-based compliance tools .............................................................................................................. 8
4.1. Committees, networks, expert groups and workshops ........................................................................ 8
4.2. Package meetings .............................................................................................................................. 11
4.3. Other compliance tools ...................................................................................................................... 11
II. Infringement procedures ........................................................................................................................ 13
III. Before an infringement procedure is started .......................................................................................... 15
1. Complaints .............................................................................................................................................. 15
2. Petitions .................................................................................................................................................. 16
3. EU Pilot ................................................................................................................................................... 17
IV. Stages in infringement procedures ......................................................................................................... 19
1. Pre-litigation phase ................................................................................................................................. 19
2. Referrals and judgments of the Court of Justice under Articles 258 and 260(2) TFEU ............................ 23
V. Transposition of directives ...................................................................................................................... 24
1. EU directives to be transposed in 2015-2019 ......................................................................................... 24
2. Transposition deadlines .......................................................................................................................... 25
3. Transparency .......................................................................................................................................... 25
VI. Late transposition infringements ............................................................................................................ 25
4. Referrals and judgments of the Court of Justice under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU............................ 27
VII. Methodology and explanations ......................................................................................................... 28
1
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
I. WORKING WITH MEMBER STATES TO ENSURE PROPER IMPLEMENTATION
OF EU LAW
The Member States and the European Commission share responsibility for ensuring compliance
with EU law. In line with the principle of sincere cooperation set out in Article 4(3) of the Treaty on
European Union, they should ‘in full mutual respect, assist each other in carrying out tasks which
flow from the Treaties’.
The ultimate purpose of the Commission’s enforcement actions is to ensure compliance with EU
law, and in this sense infringement procedures are an option of last resort to achieve that
purpose. In many cases, good cooperation and communication between the Commission and the
Member States is more conducive to reaching compliance at an early stage than having to resort
to infringement procedures. In its Communication ‘EU law: Better results through better
application’1, the Commission committed to strengthening its partnership with Member States.
In line with this approach, the Commission has developed a number of tools to help Member
States transpose, apply and implement EU law correctly and on time. These include guidance
documents, implementation plans, expert groups, explanatory documents, providing training,
organising workshops and holding package meetings. Some of these tools are used to avoid
(‘prevent’) breaches of EU law, while others are intended to be used in parallel with infringement
procedures to resolve (‘correct’) breaches of EU law and to avoid having to refer the matter to the
Court of Justice of the European Union. The Commission often uses a combination of these tools
to address problems and promote compliance with EU law.
The Commission is committed to better explaining its role as guardian of the treaties and its work
with Member States on issues concerning the application and implementation of EU law.
Information provided in this section of the report goes beyond the dialogue engaged with the
Member States during the formal infringement procedures. It gives a brief overview of other types
of action taken by the Commission in 2019 to assist Member States in implementing and applying
EU law.
1. Explanatory documents: state of play
The EU institutions and the Member States agreed in 2011 that Member States, when notifying
national transposition measures to the Commission, may also have to provide documents
explaining how they have transposed directives into their law 2. The Commission can ask Member
States to submit these ‘explanatory documents’ in justified cases 3.
Explanatory documents play an essential role in allowing the Commission to understand how
Member States transpose EU directives. They help to make monitoring compliance easier:
without these documents, the Commission would need considerable resources and numerous
contacts with national authorities to track the methods of transposition in all Member States.
Often, transposing measures must fit into a complex legal framework. The resulting transposition
exercise thus produces hundreds of measures that the Commission needs to examine.
1 C(2016)8600; adopted on 13 December 2016 and published in the Official Journal on 19 January 2017.
2 This was established by (1) a Joint Political Declaration of 28 September 2011 between the Commission and
the Member States (OJ 2011/C 369/02) and (2) a Joint Political Declaration of 27 October 2011 between the
European Parliament, the Council and the Commission (OJ 2011/C 369/03).
3 The standard recital in such directives reads as follows: Member States ‘undertake to accompany the
notification of transposition measures with one or more explanatory documents, which can take the form of
correlation tables or other documents serving the same purpose’. The Commission will have ‘to justify on a
case-by-case basis, when submitting the relevant proposals, the need for, and the proportionality of,
providing such documents’.
2
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
In 2019, the Commission submitted only one proposal for a directive to the European Parliament
and the Council. The proposal included a request for explanatory documents. The 66 directives
that the Parliament and the Council adopted during this year included 26 directives for which the
Commission had asked for explanatory documents. For all 26 directives, the agreed recital on the
need for such documents was maintained in the final text.
During 2019, Member States had to transpose 42 directives. They undertook to submit
explanatory documents for 36 directives4. In total, Member States notified 238 explanatory
documents. The process of assessing the national transposition measures for these directives is
under way.
Nine of the 36 directives for which the Member States undertook to provide explanatory
documents in 2019 concerned the environment. Member States notified to the Commission the
following numbers of explanatory documents:
• 1 Member State notified 2 explanatory documents for the Directive on the restriction to use
certain hazardous substances in electrical equipment5.
• 3 Member States notified 3 explanatory documents for the Directive on exemption for certain
electrical components containing lead in glass or ceramic6.
• 3 Member States notified 3 explanatory documents for the Directive on exemption for lead in
solders7.
• 3 Member States notified 3 explanatory documents for the Directive on exemption for lead in
cermet-based trimmer potentiometer elements8.
• 3 Member States notified 3 explanatory documents for the Directive on exemption for lead as
an alloying element in steel9.
• 3 Member States notified 3 explanatory documents for the Directive on exemption for lead as
an alloying element in aluminium10.
• 3 Member States notified 3 explanatory documents for the Directive on exemption for lead as
an alloying element in copper11.
• 3 Member States notified 3 explanatory documents for the Directive on exemption for lead as
an alloying element in high melting temperature solders 12.
• 3 Member States notified 3 explanatory documents for the Directive on exemption for lead in
bearings and bushes13.
Another 4 of the 36 directives are in the field of justice and consumers. The Commission
received:
• 27 explanatory documents for the Directive on procedural safeguards for children who are
suspects or accused persons in criminal proceedings 14, submitted by 13 Member States.
• 12 explanatory documents for the Directive on legal aid for suspects and accused persons in
criminal proceedings15, submitted by 7 Member States.
4 The report takes into account the explanatory documents submitted for these directives between 1 January
and 22 December 2019.
5 Directive (EU) 2017/2102.
6 Directive (EU) 2018/736.
7 Directive (EU) 2018/737.
8 Directive (EU) 2018/738.
9 Directive (EU) 2018/739.
10 Directive (EU) 2018/740.
11 Directive (EU) 2018/741.
12 Directive (EU) 2018/742.
13 Directive (EU) 2019/178.
14 Directive (EU) 2016/800. This directive is not applicable to Denmark, Ireland and the United Kingdom.
15 Directive (EU) 2016/1919.
3
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
• 23 explanatory documents for the Directive as regards the encouragement of long-term
shareholder engagement16, submitted by 16 Member States.
• 13 explanatory documents for the Directive on the fight against fraud to the Union’s financial
interest by means of criminal law17, submitted by 11 Member States.
In addition, 6 of the 36 directives concern transport. Member States notified to the Commission
the following numbers of explanatory documents:
• 4 explanatory documents for the Directive on the interoperability of the rail system18, notified
by 4 Member States;
• 4 explanatory documents for the Directive on railway safety19 provided by 4 Member States.
• 2 explanatory documents for the Directive on safety rules and standards for passenger
ships20, provided by 2 Member States.
• 2 explanatory documents for the Directive on the registration of persons sailing on board
passenger ships and on reporting formalities for ships 21, provided by 2 Member States.
• 4 explanatory documents for the Directive on a system of inspection for the safe operation of
roll-on roll-off passenger ships and high-speed passenger craft in regular service22, provided
by 3 Member States.
• 4 explanatory documents for the Directive on the inland transport of dangerous goods 23,
provided by 3 Member States.
One of the 36 directives concerns financial services. The Commission received 21 explanatory
documents from 18 Member States for the Directive on activities and supervision of institutions
for occupational retirement provision.
Another 1 of the 36 directives is on climate. The Commission received 11 explanatory
documents from 9 Member States for the Directive to enhance cost-effective emission reductions
and low-carbon investments24.
In the field of employment, the Commission received 5 explanatory documents for the Directive
implementing the Agreement concerning the implementation of the Work in Fishing Convention 25,
from 5 Member States.
In the field of energy, the Commission received 10 explanatory documents from 8 Member
States for the Directive as regards the methods for calculating stockholding obligations 26.
There were also 3 Directives in the field of health and safety for which the explanatory
documents were submitted:
• 6 explanatory documents for the Directive as regards minimum conditions for examining
certain varieties of agricultural plant species and vegetable species 27, notified by 6 Member
States.
• 1 explanatory document for the Directive as regards the environmental risk assessment of
genetically modified organisms 2018/350/EU, notified by 1 Member States.
16 Directive (EU) 2017/828.
17 Directive (EU) 2017/1371.
18 Directive (EU) 2016/797.
19 Directive (EU) 2016/798.
20 Directive (EU) 2017/2108.
21 Directive (EU) 2017/2109.
22 Directive (EU) 2017/2110.
23 Directive (EU) 2018/1846.
24 Directive (EU) 2018/410.
25 Directive (EU) 2017/159.
26 Directive (EU) 2018/1581.
27 Directive (EU) 2019/114.
4
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
• 1 explanatory document for the Directive on protective measures against the introduction of
organisms harmful to plants or plant products 2019/523/EU, notified by 1 Member State.
5
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
In the area of the internal market, Member States submitted to the Commission explanatory
documents for 4 Directives:
• 4 explanatory documents for the Directive on electronic invoicing in public procurement 28 from
4 Member States.
• 2 explanatory documents for the Directive on approximation of the laws of the Member States
regarding trade marks29 from 2 Member States.
• 2 explanatory documents for the Directive on control of the acquisition and possession of
weapons30 from 2 Member States.
• 14 explanatory documents for the Directive as regards the list of defence-related products31
from 13 Member States.
There were also explanatory documents notified by Member States in the field of taxation for 6
Directives:
• 17 explanatory documents notified for Directive as regards the treatment of vouchers 32, by 16
Member States.
• 8 explanatory documents notified for the Directive laying down the rules against tax avoidance
practices33, by 5 Member States.
• 4 explanatory documents notified for the Directive as regards hybrid mismatches with third
countries34, by 4 Member States.
• 5 explanatory documents notified for the Directive on tax dispute resolution mechanisms 35 by
4 Member States.
• 2 explanatory documents notified for the Directive as regards mandatory automatic exchange
on information36, by 2 Member States.
• 4 explanatory documents notified for the Directive as regards the harmonisation and
simplification of certain rules in the value added tax system for the taxation of trade between
Member States37, by 4 Member States.
The Commission considers that the current framework gives sufficient flexibility on the use of
explanatory documents. Unfortunately, in 2019 Member States did not deliver in all cases on their
commitment to provide explanatory documents together with the national measures transposing
the directives into their legal order. Moreover, the Commission’s initial assessment of the
explanatory documents it received indicates that their quality is uneven.
In its judgment of 8 July 2019,38 the Court of Justice clarified that, when notifying national
transposition measures to the Commission, Member States must provide sufficiently clear and
precise information, and identify, for each provision of the directive, the national provision(s)
ensuring its transposition. If they fail to provide documents explaining the correlation between the
provisions of a directive and the corresponding provisions of national law, the Commission will
pursue the infringement procedures under Article 260(3) TFEU. This Treaty provision allows the
Commission to request the Court to impose financial penalties if a Member State fails to fulfil its
obligation to notify measures transposing a directive adopted under a legislative procedure.
28 Directive (EU) 2014/0055.
29 Directive (EU) 2015/2436.
30 Directive (EU) 2017/853.
31 Directive (EU) 2019/514.
32 Directive (EU) 2016/1065.
33 Directive (EU) 2016/1164.
34 Directive (EU) 2017/952.
35 Directive (EU) 2017/1852.
36 Directive (EU) 2018/822.
37 Directive (EU) 2018/1910.
38 Commission v Belgium, C-543/17.
6
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
The Court’s judgement does not impose an obligation on the Member States to notify explanatory
documents to the Commission in the form of correlation tables. Member States remain free to
choose the form of their explanatory documents. The Commission will continue to explore with
Member States the benefit of providing guidance on how to draft and submit explanatory
documents. This could include the need for a common template and clear rules on the
presentation of the relevant information by the Member States.
The Commission will continue to report in its annual report on the explanatory documents
received from the Member States.
7
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
2. Guidelines
The Commission often provides written guidance to Member States on how to implement and
apply certain EU legal instruments.
In 2019, the Commission issued guidelines on interpreting and implementing EU law in the
following policy areas.
Regarding the common agricultural policy, the Commission completed the guide on how to
register a protected designation of origin or protected geographical indication for wine.
Furthermore, the Commission provided guidance on additional controls on organic products from
China, Russia, Ukraine, Moldova and Kazakhstan. The Commission updated the guidance on
direct payments and rural development. Through the Expert Group on ESIF and platforms such
as InfoRegio, the Commission provided guidance on issues related to the European Structural
and Investments Funds.
In the area of employment and social affairs, the Commission published the Practical Guide on
Posting of Workers in 2019. This document aims to assist workers, employers and national
authorities in understanding the rules on posting of workers, as revised by the Directive on
posting of workers39. This understanding is essential to ensure that workers are aware of their
rights and that the rules are correctly and consistently applied by national authorities and
employers throughout the EU.
In order to improve the application of consumer legislation, in July 2019, the Commission issued
guidance40 on applying the Unfair Contract Terms Directive41. It covers the rich case law of the
Court of Justice, for instance, on the transparency of contract terms, the effect of finding contract
terms unfair and requirements for procedures before national courts, such as the ex officio review
of unfair contract terms.
In the field of energy, the Commission adopted three recommendations to help Member States to
implement the different elements of the new amending Directive on Energy Efficiency 42 in national
law. They cover the energy savings obligation, the revised metering and billing provisions for
thermal energy and the revised provisions for efficiency in heating and cooling. The Commission
has also published two recommendations43 on both the building renovation and building
modernisation aspects of the new rules in the amended Energy Performance of Buildings
Directive44.
In the field of the environment, the Commission published guidance on the application of
exemptions under the Environmental Impact Assessment Directive 45. It aims to help national
administrative and judicial authorities apply the Environmental Impact Assessment Directive.
Furthermore, the Commission completed the first ever habitat action plan for the conservation of
wild pollinators46 in November 2019. The action plan provides comprehensive information on the
status and trends of the relevant species and habitats, the pressures and threats acting on them
and the measures needed to address them in order to achieve the Nature Directive’s objectives.
The implementation of the Water Framework Directive raises a number of shared technical
challenges, which are addressed at regular meetings of the Strategic Coordination Group and its
sub-groups, gathering Member States and stakeholders. This has resulted in extensive guidance,
which is regularly updated.
39 Directive (EU) 2018/957.
40 Commission notice — Guidance on the interpretation and application of Council Directive 93/13/EEC on
unfair terms in consumer contracts
41 Directive 93/13/EEC.
42 Directive (EU) 2018/2002.
43 Recommendations (EU) 2019/786 and (EU) 2019/1019.
44 Directive 2018/844/EU.
45 C(2019)8014; Directive 2011/92/EU.
46 See https://ec.europa.eu/environment/nature/conservation/species/pollinators/index_en.htm
8
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
9
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
3. Implementation plans: state of play
The Commission prepares implementation plans for certain legislative proposals for directives
and regulations. An implementation plan identifies the challenges that the Member States will
face and which need to be taken into account when they prepare to transpose and implement the
respective directive or regulation. The plans also provide for a wide range of tools to help Member
States implement EU laws, such as guidance documents, expert groups and dedicated websites.
Implementation plans could also include actions and monitoring arrangements by the Member
States to track progress and report on their implementation.
The Commission prepared one implementation plan for the revised Capital Requirements
Directive47 later in the legislative process, as the Directive entered into force on 27 June 2019.
The main objective of the Directive is to strengthen the current regulatory framework and to align
it with international regulatory standards set by the Basel Committee.
Taking into account these findings, the Commission will continue to explore avenues for
improving the effectiveness of the implementation plans together with the Member States.
4. Meeting-based compliance tools
The Commission deploys a wide range of meeting-based tools, such as committees, networks,
expert groups and workshops, to promote the good implementation of EU law across policy
areas.
4.1. Committees, networks, expert groups and workshops
The Commission regularly discussed the implementation of the energy legislation with Member
States in various committee meetings. In the field of energy efficiency, the Commission held
several meetings of the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive 48.
In the field of nuclear safety and radiation protection, the Commission held several meetings of
the European Nuclear Safety Regulators Group (ENSREG).
In the area of climate change policy, the Commission organised four Technical Working Groups
with experts from all Member States on the implementation of the Governance Regulation49 and
notably on the preparation of the national energy and climate plans.
In the area of financial services, the Commission organised meetings of an Expert Group on
Payments to support Member States to ensure compliance with the Payment Services
Directive50. This expert group advised the Commission on payments and assisted the
Commission in preparing legislative acts and policy initiatives regarding payments, including fraud
prevention issues related to the payment industry and users.
Since the introduction of the common agricultural policy, the Commission has made intensive
use of committees and expert groups to ensure compliance. Apart from their institutional role in
adopting implementing acts, the committees in the agricultural sector51 provide an important
forum for discussing, explaining, clarifying and interpreting the applicable rules. In 2019, the
47 Directive (EU) 2019/878.
48 Directive (EU) 2018/844.
49 Regulation (EU) 2018/1999.
50 Directive (EU) 2015/2366.
51 Such as the Committee for the Common Organisation of the Agricultural Markets, the Rural Development
Committee, the Committee on the Agricultural Funds, the Committee for Direct Payments, the Agricultural
Product Quality Policy Committee, the Regulatory Committee on Organic Production, the Committee on Spirit
Drinks.
10
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Commission services held nearly 160 committee and expert meetings. The discussions covered a
broad range of topics with a particular focus on the correct application and implementation of EU
law and the exchange of best practices between Member States. The Commission used the
Committee for the common organisation of agricultural markets to discuss the requirements for
the new regulation on market transparency52. The Expert Group for Agricultural Markets was a
forum to share experience gained through Commission audits. The Expert Group for Animal
Products discussed the outcome of the on-the-spot checks by the Union Inspection Committee on
carcass classification, and management and control issues regarding the EU school fruit,
vegetables and milk scheme. The technical clarifications provided in the context of the Rural
Development Committee concerned the agri-environmental-climate measure, the annual
implementation reports, the voluntary agricultural certification schemes, the financial instruments,
the outcomes of the performance reserve, those provided in the context of quality policy
concerned the control and practical implementation of rules on the protection of protected
designations of origin and protected geographical indications. Finally, following the adoption of
the Unfair Trade Practices Directive 53, expert group meetings provided several opportunities to
assist Member States in transposing the Directive into national law.
In the area of the environment and in particular waste management, the Commission
Directorate-General for Environment held 13 technical committee meetings and 10 expert group
meetings as well as several other meetings (e.g. a stakeholders’ meeting under the Restriction of
Hazardous Substances Directive, an environmental directors’ meeting, a meeting of waste
shipment correspondents under the Waste Shipment Regulation). These meetings concerned
both the preparation of new legislation and the implementation of existing directives.
Under Action 6 of the EU action plan for nature, people and the economy54, the Commission has
further supported the Natura 2000 biogeographical process. This is a process of cooperation
between various stakeholders at the level of a biogeographical region. The Member States in
which the region lies are involved in improving the implementation, management, monitoring,
financing and reporting for the Natura 2000 network on the basis of agreed roadmaps. Two
Natura 2000 biogeographical seminars were organised in 2019, for the Atlantic region and the
Boreal region.
As regards the area of working conditions, the Commission has established a Member State
expert group to facilitate the transposition of the Directive on Transparent and Predictable
Working Conditions in the European Union55. In October 2019, in the Expert Group on European
Works Councils, the Commission presented the results of its evaluation of the Directive 56 and
discussed how to address weaknesses in the redress and sanctions regimes in Member States.
The Commission also participates regularly in the sectoral Social Dialogue Committee on
Temporary Agency Work, with frequent discussions on the enforcement of the Directive on
Temporary Agency Work57, as well as in the Social Dialogue Committees on Maritime Transport
and on Fishing.
In the field of occupational health and safety, in 2019 the Commission made regular use of
committees and expert groups to discuss the appropriate implementation and application of EU
labour legislation on the safety and health of workers. The Advisory Committee on Safety and
Health met twice in plenary and several times in various working groups. It adopted several
opinions, namely on future priorities in the field of occupational safety and health. The Technical
Progress Committee met four times in 2019 to discuss possible technical updates to the annexes
to three occupational safety and health directives (on biological agents, personal protective
equipment and medical treatment on board vessels) and the adoption of a fifth list of indicative
occupational exposure limit values. Following this work, the Commission adopted four directives
in October 2019. The Senior Labour Inspectors’ Committee adopted guidance on addressing
52 Regulation (EU) 2019/1746.
53 Directive (EU) 2019/633
54 https://ec.europa.eu/environment/nature/legislation/fitness_check/action_plan/communication_en.pdf .
55 Directive (EU) 2019/1152.
56 Directive 2009/38/EC.
57 Directive 2008/104/EC.
11
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
health risks from welding fumes and started discussion on future enforcement priorities in
occupational safety and health.
The Commission had a first meeting with representatives of Member States responsible for the
transposition of the Directive on accessibility of products and services 58 to support them in their
efforts.
The Committee of Experts on Posting of Workers held several meetings in 2019 and established
a working group for the transposition of the Directive on the Posting of Workers.59
The Administrative Commission on the Coordination of Social Security Systems met four times in
2019, enabling national authorities to discuss topics linked to the application of the Regulation on
the Coordination of Social Security Systems60. Moreover, the network of social security experts
(MoveS network) contributed to the correct application of the Regulation via information tools, ad
hoc analyses, reports on specific issues and seminars in Member States.
Following the adoption of the Unfair Trade Practices Directive 61, two expert group meetings took
place and provided answers to Member States on how to interpret the Directive. Moreover, the
Commission set up a dedicated web space to allow for an exchange of information.
In the area of justice and consumers, the Commission continued its efforts to ensure proper
application of the new data protection rules. It received feedback from stakeholders on
implementation of the General Data Protection Regulation 62 through a dedicated multi-
stakeholder group composed of representatives from industry, civil society, practitioners and
academics. In parallel, the Commission is actively contributing to the work of the European Data
Protection Board, composed of the national authorities who are the enforcers of data protection
rules.
In February 2019, the Regulation simplifying the circulation of certain public documents between
Member States63 became applicable. The Commission and the Member States met within the
Committee on Public Documents to discuss the Regulation’s application. Discussions showed
that Member State authorities are not yet fully familiar with the new provisions and as a result
further training for authorities at national level is planned.
In the area of free movement and Union citizenship, the Expert Group on Free Movement met
once in 2019 to discuss several implementation issues and in particular compliance with the
Coman judgement64. In 2019, the consular protection expert group discussed the Directive’s
implementation and the collection of statistical data.
Regarding gender equality, following the adoption in June 2019 of the Directive on Work-Life
Balance65, the Commission started the preparatory work on its implementation in the Member
States. An informal kick-off general meeting with all Member States on 10 and 11 December
58 Directive (EU) 2019/882.
59 Directive (EU) 2018/957.
60
Regulation (EC) 883/2004.
61 Directive (EU) 2019/633
62 Regulation (EU) 2016/679.
63 Regulation (EU) 2016/1191. The Regulation aims at cutting red tape and costs for citizens who need to
present to the authorities of a Member State a public document issued by the authorities of another Member
State, such as public documents on civil status (for example, a birth or a marriage certificate) and the
absence of a criminal record. While recognition of the effects of the public documents depends on the law of
the receiving Member State, a multilingual standard form avoids the need for translations. Member State
authorities started using the internal market information system to check the authenticity of public documents
when they have a doubt.
64 Case Coman and Others, C-673/16.
65 Directive (EU) 2019/1158. This Directive provides: fathers the right to 10 working days of paid paternity leave;
each parent the right to 2 months of reserved and paid parental leave (with a further 2 months of non-paid
leave that may be transferred to the other parent); carers the right to 5 working days of leave per year per
worker; and parents and carers the right to request flexible working arrangements.
12
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
2019 discussed issues of interpretation of the Directive’s provisions. This was followed by several
bilateral meetings in the days that followed.
The Commission regularly discussed implementation of the security and migration legislation
with Member States in various committee meetings, and expert groups remained an essential
framework for discussion and exchanging expertise, namely in the area of legal migration,
prevention of radicalisation and information systems for borders and security.
4.2. Package meetings
On transport, the Commission organised 7 package meetings in 2019. These meetings have
generally led to a swifter handling of a number of files and, in certain cases, to a substantial
reduction of the number of infringements.
On environment, the Commission organised 9 package meetings in 2019 to discuss ongoing
infringements and other issues related to the implementation of environmental legislation in the
Member States. Before the meeting with the state authorities, the Commission usually meets with
the local environmental non-governmental organisations.
In the area of migration and home affairs, 1 package meeting took place in 2019 to discuss
pending infringement and EU Pilot procedures.
4.3. Other compliance tools
In enforcing the EU’s maritime affairs and fisheries legislation, the Commission relies heavily
on a system of verifications, inspections and audits by Commission inspectors 66. In addition, the
control action plans adopted by the Commission in close cooperation with the Member State
concerned are a strong tool to promote the correct enforcement of EU legislation and of the
sanctioning system. In 2019, the Commission adopted new action plans for several Member
States and actively monitored their implementation. On the common organisation of the markets
in fishery and aquaculture products, the Commission ensures that Member States carry out
regular checks on the proper implementation of the relevant EU legislation 67.
In the agricultural sector, the Commission uses audits and financial correction procedures to
check whether the Member States have set up control systems ensuring that payments to
beneficiaries from the EU funds are made correctly. In addition, the Commission verifies the
fulfilment of the organic legislation through audits and the monitoring of the organic farming
information system (OFIS)68. Furthermore, Member States regularly have to notify the
Commission of their policy decisions as well as data on their annual implementation of direct
payments, greening and cross-compliance. The Commission uses these notifications to guide
Member States towards more uniform implementation. When the Commission detects systemic
deficiencies in the control systems for direct payments, it requests that Member States set up
remedial action plans. If a Member State fails to comply with the action plan, the Commission
may decide to suspend or reduce payments. As a result of the above activities, compliance has
improved in the domains concerned. For instance, notifications from Member States received in
2019 on the annual review of voluntary coupled support for 2020 and on the implementation of
decoupled direct payments in 2018 showed general consistency with the relevant legal
framework and required less clarifications and corrections compared to previous years.
In the field of energy, the Commission continued to use the Concerted Action Forum, which
gathers representatives of Member States and other interested parties, to exchange best
practices when applying specific EU instruments. Key discussion topics concerned the
66 Regulation (EC) 1224/2009.
67 Regulation (EU) 1379/2013.
68 Organic farming - controls and enforcement.
13
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
implementation of the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive 69 and the Energy Efficiency
Directive70.
In the area of the environment and in particular waste management, three events were held in
Athens, Lisbon and Budapest in 2019, building on the Virtuous Circles events organised in Malta,
Romania and Bulgaria in 2018. These events are organised in Member States identified as being
at risk of not reaching the new recycling targets and other requirements of the waste legislation,
as revised in 2018. They emphasise the potential of good waste management in generating value
from circular activities including remanufacturing, re-use, symbiosis, repair and recycling. In
addition to recommendations on the way forward from top experts, these events are designed to
offer and seek commitment on concrete financial and technical measures and assistance to
implement EU waste policies.
In the area of urban waste water treatment, the Commission Directorate-General for Environment
organised six country visits in 2019 in cooperation with the OECD. These allowed for in-depth
dialogues on governance, financing possibilities and potential solutions to anticipate financing
gaps and avoid infringements.
The Commission organises air quality dialogues to consult Member States on the main air quality
challenges and to explore further action to address them. In 2019 the air quality dialogue was
held in Italy.
Eleven Natura dialogues took place under the EU action plan for nature, people and the
economy71 in 201972. These bilateral dialogues have been set up to promote discussions with
individual Member States on key challenges in the implementation of the Nature Directives and
involve the nature authorities as well as other relevant authorities and stakeholders. These
meetings are being followed up through agreed implementation roadmaps, with milestones and
actions to be delivered.
In the area of occupational safety and health, the Commission continued its cooperation with
Member States and social partners to make the EU occupational safety and health legislative
framework future-proof and ensure proper compliance and enforcement in line with its 2017
Communication73. In this context, the Commission supported two initiatives: i) a joint action
between the Commission and other stakeholders on a ‘roadmap on carcinogens’ a voluntary
action scheme to raise awareness about the risks arising from exposure to carcinogens in the
workplace and ii) an exchange of good practices between companies and organisations as well
as a peer review process with Member States on the legislation and practical management of
psychosocial risks at work, which took place in Sweden.
In the area of justice and home affairs, Union law has created the Schengen Evaluation
Mechanism as a specific monitoring mechanism designed to verify the application of the
European Union's so-called Schengen acquis. This is a body of legislation spanning borders,
visas, returns, police cooperation, information systems and data protection. It aims to ensure that
high uniform standards are applied in practice by those European Union countries in the
Schengen area - an area comprising 26 countries, 22 of which are EU countries 74 and 4 of which
69 Directive 2010/31/EU.
70 Directive 2012/27/EU.
71 Communication - An Action Plan for nature, people and the economy and the accompanying staff working
document.
72 Estonia (6-7 February 2019), Croatia (4-5 March 2019), Greece (28-29 March 2019), Malta (3-4 June 2019),
Latvia (17-18 September 2019), Luxembourg (14 -15 October 2019), Denmark (23-24 October 2019),
Sweden (4-5 November 2019), France (12 November 2019), Spain (21-22 November 2019), Belgium (27-28
November 2019).
73 Safer and Healthier Work for All - Modernisation of the EU Occupational Safety and Health Legislation and
Policy:
74 Ireland does not belong to the Schengen area; however, in line with Protocol 19 annexed to the Treaties it
has been authorised to participate in certain aspects of the Schengen acquis, in practice those related to
security, judicial cooperation in criminal matters and police cooperation. The same is true for the United
Kingdom. Bulgaria, Croatia, Cyprus and Romania are Member States whose internal border controls have
14
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
are non-EU countries associated to the Schengen area75. In this area, no internal border controls
are applied. The Schengen evaluation mechanism is a multi-layered tool involving the
Commission and the Member States (as well as the Schengen associated countries) and also
engages the European Parliament. It is without prejudice to the Commission’s powers to initiate
infringement procedures. Countries belonging to the Schengen area are subject to monitoring
and evaluation according to an evaluation programme.
not yet been abolished. Therefore, although the Schengen acquis is fully binding upon them, they do not
apply it yet in its totality.
75 Iceland, Norway, Switzerland and Liechtenstein.
15
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
II. INFRINGEMENT PROCEDURES
There are four main types of infringements of EU law:
a) failure to notify: a Member State does not notify the Commission on time of its measures to
transpose a directive;
b) non-conformity/non-compliance: the Commission considers that a Member State’s
legislation is not in line with the requirements of EU directives;
c) infringement of the Treaties, regulations or decisions: the Commission considers that a
Member State’s legislation is not in line with the requirements of the Treaties, EU regulations
or decisions;
d) incorrect application: EU law is not applied correctly, or not applied at all, by national
authorities.
Infringements may be detected by the Commission’s own investigations or brought to its attention by
complaints or petitions from members of the public, businesses, NGOs or other organisations.
The Commission actively informs complainants of the decisions taken throughout all stages of the
procedure.
The infringement procedure under Article 258 TFEU is divided into a pre-litigation phase and a
litigation phase.
In the pre-litigation phase, the Commission first sends a letter of formal notice to the Member State
requesting an explanation within a given time limit. If the Member State’s reply is unsatisfactory or if
the Member State does not reply at all, the Commission sends a reasoned opinion asking the
Member State to comply within a given time limit.
Should the Member State not comply with the reasoned opinion, the Commission may open the
litigation procedure by bringing the case to the Court of Justice under Article 258 TFEU.
When it brings a case before the Court against a Member State for failing to fulfil its obligations to
notify measures transposing a directive adopted under a legislative procedure, the Commission may
propose financial penalties under Article 260(3) TFEU.
The Court may agree with the Commission and rule that the Member State has breached its
obligations under EU law. If the Court does so but the Member State still has not taken the steps
needed to comply, the Commission may continue the infringement procedure under Article 260(2)
TFEU. This involves referring the Member State to the Court again, after sending it a letter of formal
notice under Article 260(2) TFEU. In such cases the Commission can propose, and the Court can
impose, financial sanctions in the form of a lump sum and penalties per day or another specified
period.
At the request of national courts, the Court of Justice may also issue preliminary rulings under
Article 267 TFEU addressing issues of conformity of national laws with EU legislation. While
preliminary rulings are distinct from infringement judgments, they give the Commission an additional
opportunity to ensure that violations of EU law deriving from national legislation or its application are
remedied. The Commission systematically follows up on preliminary rulings where the Court identifies
situations of non-conformity of national legislation with EU law.
Over recent years, the Commission has taken concrete measures to improve the transparency of its
monitoring activities and decisions on infringement procedures. It has set up a centralised platform for
disseminating infringement-related information on the Europa portal. This provides detailed
information on the decisions the Commission takes on infringement procedures, including press
material on specific cases. Since 2017, the press material covers all formal steps of the infringement
procedure.
16
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
In addition, every year the Commission provides information in its annual reports on monitoring the
implementation of EU legislation, on the follow-up given to complaints and on parliamentary petitions
and infringement procedures.
The Commission remains committed to improving the transparency of its enforcement action. At the
same time, it has to give due account to the legitimate need for confidentiality with regard to the
Member States in infringement procedures, as recognised by the Court of Justice.
Trends in complaints and investigations about potential breaches
of EU law
3 450 3 783 3 786
3 715 3525
881 790 797
716 644
986 190
742 110
178
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
New complaints registered New EU Pilot files New infringement cases
Time taken to investigate potential breaches of EU law
4000 150
3750 140
3500 146
116 130
3250 120
3000 110
2750 99 91 109 100
Total number of files
2500 87 109
90 Number of weeks
2250
69 90 80
2000 3882
60 3611 3813 70
1750 3458
3315 47 60
1500
1250 39 44 50
37 37
1000 40
750 30
500 968 875 967
20
721 814 805
250 512 397 632 244 10
0 0
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Total number of complaints
Total number of EU Pilot files
Total number of infringement cases
Average time for handling complaints (in weeks)
Average time for handling EU Pilot (in weeks)
Average time for handling infringement cases (in weeks)
17
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
III. BEFORE AN INFRINGEMENT PROCEDURE IS STARTED
1. Complaints
The Commission registered 3525 new complaints in 2019.
Public complaints open at year-end
3594 > Complaints open at end-2018
3525 > New complaints registered in 2019
3813 > Complaints handled in 2019
= 3306 > Complaints open at end-2019
The three Member States against which the Commission received the most complaints were
Spain, Italy and Germany.
• Spain: 542 complaints, especially in connection with: justice and consumers (243
complaints); the environment (70 complaints); and employment (64 complaints);
• Italy: 375 complaints, mainly related to: industry, entrepreneurship and SMEs (90
complaints); employment (61 complaints); and taxation and customs (53 complaints); and
• Germany: 319 complaints, most of them related to: the environment (106 complaints);
justice and consumers (63 complaints); and industry, entrepreneurship and SMEs (40
complaints).
The following chart shows the main policy areas for which new complaints were registered in
2019. Together they account for 88% of all complaints received in 2019.
The Commission handled 3813 complaints in 2019. Once it has assessed complaints, the
Commission may launch an investigation using the EU Pilot mechanism or through formal
infringement procedures to clarify whether EU rules have been breached. Not all complaints in
18
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
2019 led to such investigations, because either no EU laws were breached (2712 complaints)
or the correspondence did not qualify as a complaint (829) 76. The Commission did not pursue
112 cases as the complainants withdrew their complaint. It also transferred 10 complaints to
other redress mechanisms, such as SOLVIT. The Commission therefore closed 3663
complaints.
In 2019, the Commission pursued 150 complaints further and launched investigations using
the EU Pilot mechanism or the formal infringement procedure.
Complaints leading to investigations
185 150
441 135
458
3882
3611 3813
3315 3458
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Complaints closed Complaints pursued
Complaints leading to investigations using the EU Pilot mechanism were most frequently
related to taxation and the customs union; financial stability, financial services and the Capital
Markets Union; agriculture and rural development; the environment; and mobility and
transport. These complaints mainly concerned Italy, Bulgaria, Malta and Spain.
In 2019, complaints leading to formal infringement procedures were most frequently related to
taxation and the customs union; the internal market, industry, entrepreneurship and SMEs;
and employment. These new infringements mainly concerned Austria, Belgium and Germany.
2. Petitions
Through petitions and questions, the European Parliament alerted the Commission to
shortcomings in the way some Member States were implementing and applying certain EU
laws in 2019. The Commission systematically ensures follow-up to the petitions received.
However, not all petitions lead to investigations about breaches of EU law, because either no
EU laws were breached or the Commission had no power to act. In many cases, the situation
presented in a petition is already being investigated by the Commission through EU Pilot or a
formal infringement procedure.
This section provides an overview of the follow-up the Commission gave to petitions in 2019 in
the policy areas most concerned.
With regard to the environment, the Commission received 58 petitions linked to complaints or
infringements in 2019. While many of those petitions were linked to complaints or to structural
infringements, no investigations were started as a direct result of a petition. This was often
76 According to the conditions set out in point 3 of the Annex on administrative procedures for the handling of
relations with the complainant regarding the application of European Union law to the Communication EU
law: Better results through better application (C(2016)8600).
19
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
because a number of petitions raised individual grievances of incorrect application, which are
no longer pursued as a matter of priority by the Commission in line with the Communication
‘EU law: Better results through better application’.
In the areas of financial services and the Capital Markets Union, the Commission received
5 petitions concerning the implementation and application of EU law. Of these, the subject
matter of 1 petition is being dealt with by the Commission in the context of complaints about a
possible breach of EU law and still being assessed. This relates to the free movement of
capital, especially the administrative and judicial practice related to restitution of property in
several Member States. In the other 4 cases in relation to financial services, the Commission
did not pursue the petitions as investigations because either had no competence or no breach
of EU law could be established.
In the area of the internal market, the Commission received 33 new petitions in 2019
concerning the implementation and application of EU law. The matters raised were not
identified as a systemic and serious breach of the Union law falling under the criteria of the
Commission’s infringement priorities. At the same time, the Commission has given follow up to
some of the petitions by putting the issue forward for a discussion with the Member States at
the working groups and also is considering a White paper to launch a debate on some other
issues.
In the area of maritime affairs and fisheries, the Commission received 2 petitions
concerning the implementation and application of EU law. The issues raised were already
covered by ongoing investigations.
In the area of migration and home affairs, the Commission received 19 petitions and
launched 1 investigation as a follow up to a petition from the European Parliament concerning
the incorrect implementation of the Directive on combating the sexual abuse and sexual
exploitation of children and child pornography77. The relevant infringement procedure is still
pending.
In the customs and taxation field, the Commission received 27 petitions concerning the
implementation and application of EU law. The petitions concerned cases already opened by
the Commission.
3. EU Pilot
The EU Pilot dialogue between the Commission and Member States was set up to quickly resolve
potential breaches of EU law at an early stage in appropriate cases. However, the recourse to EU
Pilot should not add a lengthy step to the infringement process, which in itself is a means to enter
into a problem-solving dialogue with a Member State. In line with the Communication EU law:
Better results through better application, the Commission launches infringement procedures
without relying on the EU Pilot mechanism, unless recourse to EU Pilot is seen as useful in a
given case.
The Commission opened 190 new EU Pilot files in 2019. Of these, 37 were triggered by
complaints and 153 were opened by the Commission on its own initiative (against 86 in 2018).
EU Pilot files open at year-end
553 > EU Pilot files open at end-2018
190 > New EU Pilot files registered in 2019
244 > EU Pilot files handled in 2019
77 Directive 2011/93/EU.
20
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
= 499 > EU Pilot files open at end-2019
21
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
The following pie chart shows the policy areas in which the Commission opened the most new
EU Pilot files in 2019:
EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy areas
Migration and home
affaris
32 Environment
22
Maritime affairs and Taxation and
fisheries customs union
35 18
Agriculture and
rural development
12
Other
25
Energy
46
The Commission handled 244 EU Pilot files in 2019. It closed 187 of these after receiving
satisfactory answers from the Member States concerned. This gives a resolution rate of 77%,
which is above the 2018 level.
Altogether, 57 EU Pilot files were closed because the Commission rejected the responses
provided by Member States. Of these, 42 were followed up by formal infringement procedures.
While 8 of these procedures were based on complaints, the Commission launched the remaining
34 on its own initiative.
Most EU Pilot files which led to formal infringement procedures concerned the policy areas of
environment (22 cases). Latvia and Poland had the highest number of files in EU Pilot which were
pursued further through infringement procedures (4 files each), followed by Italy and Ireland (3
files each).
EU Pilot files (2015-2019)
969
875
512
397
244
75% 72% 77% 73% 77%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Average resolution rate EU Pilot files handled
22
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
At the end of 2019, 499 EU Pilot files were open. The main Member States concerned were
Italy (45), Spain (31) and France (31). The main policy area concerned continued to be the
environment (128 open files), followed by justice and fundamental rights (61), migration and
home affairs (60) and energy (50).
EU Pilot files and infringement cases (2015-2019)
1657
1559 1571 1564
1368
986
881 797
716
644
790
742
178 190
110
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Infringement cases open at year-end New EU Pilot files
New infringements cases
IV. STAGES IN INFRINGEMENT PROCEDURES
1. Pre-litigation phase
The Commission launched 797 new procedures by sending a letter of formal notice in 2019. Out
of these, the Commission launched procedures on its own initiative in 397 cases.
The following chart gives the breakdown by Member State.
New infringement cases at
31 December 2019
43
39 39
38 38
37
35
32 33 33
31 31
30
28 28 28
26 26
25 25 25
22
20 20
19
17
16
13
LT NL FI LU DK SK LV DE EE SE HR SI AT IT MT UK CZ ES FR BE HU PT PL IE RO BG EL CY
23
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Most new infringement cases are for late transposition of EU directives.
Trends in new infringement procedures
847
543 558
292
419 406
151
128
112 129
99
71 74
27 29
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Late transposition
Other (incorrect application and non-conformity)
Treaties, regulations & decisions
The following chart shows the main policy areas in which new procedures were opened.
New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
Justice and
consumers
Mobility and 78 Taxation and
Transport customs
83 65
Health and food
safety
60
Internal market,
industry,
entrepreneurship Migration and home
and SMEs affairs
147 58
Energy
52
Financial stability,
financial services
Environment Others and capital markets
175 38 union
41
24
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
The Commission also sent 316 reasoned opinions to Member States in 2019. The main policy
areas concerned were the internal market, industry, entrepreneurship and SMEs (83), the
environment (45), justice and consumers (44) and taxation and customs (34).
The following chart gives the breakdown by Member State.
Reasoned opinions sent to Member States in 2019
21
19 19
17
16 16
14 14 14 14
13
12 12
11 11
10 10 10
9
8 8 8
7
6 6
4 4
3
EE HR MT DK UK FI LT LV SE LU CZ FR NL AT IT RO SK HU BE BG PT SI DE EL ES IE PL CY
At the end of 2019, 1564 infringement cases remained open. This is a slight decrease from the
previous year, as the following chart shows.
Infringement cases open at year-end (2015-2019)
1657
1559 1571 1564
1368
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
25
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
The following chart shows the number of open infringement cases by Member State at the end of
2019:
The following chart shows the breakdown of the infringement cases open at the end of 2019, by
policy area:
26
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
1564 infringement cases open at end-2019: policy areas
Justice and
consumers Migration and
Internal market, 164 home affairs
industry,
139
entrepreneurship
and SMEs
241 Financial stability,
financial services
and capital
markets union
116
Mobility and Taxation and
transport customs
203 106
Energy
109
Communication
Employment networks
Environment 25 34
327 Health and food
Other safety
59 41
Even after it has launched an infringement procedure, the Commission continues its dialogue with
the Member State in order to seek compliance. Statistics confirm that Member States make
serious efforts to settle their infringements before the Court hands down its ruling.
In 2019, the Commission closed:
• 604 infringements after sending letters of formal notice 78;
• 160 cases after sending reasoned opinions;
• 13 cases after deciding to refer the case to the Court but before submitting the application and
19 cases following a Court judgment. In addition, the Commission withdrew 9 cases from the
Court before the latter handed down its ruling. The Commission withdrew these cases as the
Member States concerned took the necessary measures to comply with EU law.
2. Referrals and judgments of the Court of Justice under Articles 258 and 260(2)
TFEU
In 2019, the Commission referred 31 cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU and 2 cases
under Article 260(2) TFEU
In 2019, the Court issued 24 judgments under Article 258 TFEU, 1 judgment under Article 260(2)
TFEU. Of these, 23 were in the Commission’s favour, 2 were in the Member State’s favour 79.
Italy (6), Poland (3), and Germany, (Greece, and Spain (2 each) were the subject of the most
Court judgments under Article 258 TFEU in 2019.
78 This includes 4 letters of formal notice under Article 260 TFEU and 1 letter of formal notice under Article 106
TFEU
79 Commission v. Spain, C-642/18 and Commission v. Czech Republic, C-399/17.
27
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Member States frequently take the measures needed to comply with a Court judgment promptly.
However, at the end of the year, 98 infringement procedures were still open after a Court ruling
because the Commission considered that the Member States concerned had not yet complied
with judgments under Article 258 TFEU. The main Member States concerned were Greece (16)
Italy (11) and Germany, Spain and the United Kingdom (each 8) These cases mainly related to
the environment (52), transport and mobility (12), taxation and customs (9), and the internal
market, industry, entrepreneurship and SMEs (8).
Of these 98 cases, the Commission referred 2 cases to the Court for the second time. When the
Court imposes financial penalties under Article 260(2) TFEU, the defaulting Member State must
pay the lump sum immediately and continue to pay the periodic penalty until it complies fully with
the first and second Court judgments. In 2019, the Court delivered one judgment under
Article 260(2) TFEU. It imposed penalty payments on Ireland 80. At the end of 2019, 9 infringement
procedures were still open after a Court ruling under Article 260(2) TFEU.
In addition, the Court imposed penalties in 3 judgments handed down under Article 260(2) TFEU
in the area of competition81.
V. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. EU directives to be transposed in 2015-2019
In 2019, the Parliament and the Council adopted 66 directives. Most of these directives modify
existing laws; there were 4 new directives and 1 codifying directive (which does not impose a new
transposition deadline). The main policy areas concerned were: the environment (13), justice (10)
and employment (8). Explanatory documents were required for 26 directives.
At the same time, 42 directives had to be transposed in 2019, which is less than in 2018 (50). For
these directives, Member States notified 3014 national transposition measures to the
Commission by the end of 201982. On average, Member States notified 71 measures per
directive.
80 Commission v. Ireland, C-261/18.
81 These are cases in which the Commission action as a first step is a formal letter of notice under Article
260(2) TFEU.
82 There is a difference between the number of all measures notified by the Member States to the Commission
and the number of measures visible on EUR-Lex. Not all measures notified by the Member State are visible
28
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
National transposition measures notified per year
5000
4231 4193
3084 3014
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Number of notified transposition measures
In 2019, the highest number of notifications was submitted by Hungary (259), Czechia (237) and
Finland (209). The lowest number of notifications was submitted by Cyprus (28), Spain (42) and
Ireland (44).
The transposition of the Directive on procedural safeguards for children who are suspects or
accused persons in criminal proceedings triggered the highest number of notifications (503
notifications)83. The two directives with the next highest number of notifications were the
Directive on the fight against fraud to the Union's financial interests by means of criminal law (221
notifications)84 and the Directive on legal aid for suspects and accused persons in criminal
proceedings and for requested persons in European arrest warrant proceedings (206
notifications)85.
2. Transposition deadlines
Out of 42 directives to be transposed in 2019 there were 9 directives whose transposition
deadline was shorter than 1 year from the time of their publication (same as in 2018).
The average period to transpose directives remained 19 months. The directive with the longest
transposition period and deadline in 2019 (59 months) was the Directive on electronic invoicing
in public procurement86. This Directive, however, had two different transposition deadlines 87.
A short transposition period does not always result in an increased number of infringements for
late transposition. Out of 4 directives with a transposition period of less than 5 months, 2
directives triggered a small number of infringements88, whereas 2 triggered a higher number of
late transposition infringement cases (12 cases — Directive on protective measures against the
introduction into the Community of organisms harmful to plants or plant products and against their
on the EUR-Lex website: the explanatory documents and administrative provisions that are not public in the
Member States are not sent for publication.
83 Directive 2016/800/EU.
84 Directive 2017/1371/EU.
85 Directive 2016/1919/EU.
86 Directive 2014/55/EU.
87 The first transposition deadline concerned the majority of the Directive’s provisions. The second transposition
deadline concerned provisions related to the duration of the examination procedure for asylum applications at
the national level.
88 These are Directive (EU) 2019/514 (9 infringement cases) and Directive (EU) 2019/178 (4 infringement
cases).
29
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
spread within the Community89 and 11 cases – Directive regarding the establishment of
harmonised risk indicators90).
3. Transparency
To further encourage Member States to be more transparent with the national measures
transposing EU directives, the Commission invited Member States to agree to the publication of
the text of these measures on EUR-Lex. To date, 12 Member States have agreed to do so:
Austria, Czechia, Cyprus, Estonia, France, Greece, Malta, Latvia, Luxembourg, Slovakia, Spain
and Poland. The Commission also invited Member States to make their declaration of
transposition public on EUR-Lex91, which accompanies the national transposition measures
notified to the Commission. Only Greece has so far agreed to do so.
In line with the commitments taken in the Inter-Institutional Agreement on Better Law-making, the
Commission encouraged Member States to identify which provisions stem from an EU directive
and which are in no way related to that Union legislation. Members of the public have an interest
in knowing which national transposition measures go beyond the requirements of EU directives.
Up to now, only 2 Member States provided this information to the Commission 92.
VI. LATE TRANSPOSITION INFRINGEMENTS
Combatting late transposition is a long-established priority for the Commission. The Commission
therefore proposes financial sanctions whenever it refers a Member State to the Court of Justice
under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU for not having communicated on time its measures to
transpose a directive adopted under a legislative procedure (see details in subsection V.5).
89 Directive (EU) 2019/523.
90 Directive (EU) 2019/782.
91 With this declaration, the Member State informs the Commission whether it considers that the transposition is
complete.
92 Belgium for Directive 2010/63/EU and the United Kingdom for Directives 2016/680/EU and 2016/681/EU.
30
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
The number of new late transposition infringements decreased from 419 in 2018 to 406 in 2019 93.
Directives and late transposition infringement cases
847
543 558
419 406
56 70 36 36 50
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Number of directives with transposition deadline in a given year
New late transposition infringements
At the end of 2019, 599 late transposition infringement cases were still open, a 21%
decrease from the 758 cases open at the end of 2018.
758 > Late transposition cases open at end-2018
406 > New late transposition cases registered in 2019
565 > Late transposition cases closed in 2019
= 599 > Late transposition cases open at end-2019
The following chart shows the number of late transposition infringement cases open at the end of
2019 (599 in total), by Member State, irrespective of the year in which the case was opened and
new late transposition infringement cases (406 in total) opened in 2019, by Member State.
93 The current annual report does not cover the late transposition infringement cases opened for directives that
had a transposition deadline in November and December 2019 (17 directives). The Commission launched
these cases in January 2019. Therefore, they will be included in the next annual report.
31
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Late transposition infringement cases in 2019
35
33
31
27 29
26 27 27
24 25 25 25
22 23 23 22
29
22
20 20
17 17 17 18 19 19 20 19 20
15 15 16 17 17 17
11 14 14
13 13 12 13 12 13
12 12 11 11 10 10
9 10
7 7 8
5
DK IT LT EE FI NL DE FR SK ES HR MT LV SE PT HU LU RO AT CZ UK PL IE SI CY EL BE BG
New late transposition infringement cases in 2019
Late transposition infringement cases open at the year-end
The policy areas in which the new cases were launched in 2019 are shown in the following chart:
4. Referrals and judgments of the Court of Justice under Articles 258 and 260(3)
TFEU
Under Article 260(3) TFEU, the Commission may propose financial penalties even when it refers
a case for the first time to the Court of Justice under Article 258 TFEU on the ground that a
Member State has failed to transpose a legislative Directive. This innovation, introduced in the
Treaty of Lisbon, aims to incentivise the Member States to transpose directives on time. The
Commission proposes the level of financial penalty to the Court in line with the policy laid down in
32
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
its Communications on the implementation of Article 260(3) TFEU and on the calculation method
for lump sum payments and daily penalty payments94.
In 2019, the Commission continued to bring late transposition infringement cases to the Court of
Justice with a request for daily penalties under Article 260(3) TFEU. It referred 1 Member State
(Spain) to the Court95.
In its judgment of 8 July 2019, Commission v Belgium 96, the Court of Justice applied for the first
time the sanction scheme of Article 260(3) TFEU. It imposed a daily penalty on Belgium of
EUR 5 000 from the date of the judgment for the Member State’s failure to adopt and
communicate all the measures necessary for the transposition of the Directive on measures to
reduce the cost of deploying high-speed electronic communications networks97. The Court upheld
the Commission’s position and clarified that the sanction scheme of Article 260(3) TFEU may also
be applied to cases of partial failure to adopt and communicate transposition measures. In
addition, when notifying national transposition measures to the Commission, Member States must
provide sufficiently clear and precise information, and identify, for each provision of the directive,
the national provision(s) ensuring its transposition98.
94 OJ, C 12, 15.01.2011, p.1-5.
95 Commission v. Spain, C-658/19
96 Commission v. Belgium, C-543/17.
97 Directive 2014/61/EU.
98 See section on explanatory documents of this report.
33
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
VII. METHODOLOGY AND EXPLANATIONS
Infringement procedures
First chart: Trends in complaints and investigations about potential breaches of EU law
This chart shows aggregated data over a five-year period covering new complaints registered, new EU
Pilot files and new infringement cases.
Second chart: Time taken to investigate potential breaches of EU law
This shows the total number of files (complaints, EU Pilot and infringement cases) closed in a given
year with the average time in weeks needed before taking a decision to close them. This means that
certain files are potentially counted in all three categories, if the initial complaint becomes an
infringement.
Before an infringement procedure is started
Complaints
First chart: Complaints open at year-end
This starts with the number of open complaints at the end of 2018 (first line) 99. The second line shows
the number of new complaints registered in 2019. The third line shows the number of complaints for
which the Commission took a decision in 2019. The fourth line shows the number of complaints open
at the end of 2019 (calculated by taking the first figure, adding the second and subtracting the third).
Second chart: New complaints registered in 2019 (main policy areas) 100
This shows the main policy areas for which new complaints were registered in 2019.
Third chart: Complaints leading to investigations
This shows the number of complaints which the Commission pursued further by launching an
investigation about breaches of EU law (via the EU Pilot mechanism or launching a formal
infringement procedure).
EU Pilot
First chart: EU Pilot files open at year-end
This starts with the number of open EU Pilot files at the end of 2018 (first line). The second line shows
the number of new EU Pilot files opened in 2019. The third line shows the number of files on which the
Commission took a decision in 2019. The fourth line shows the number of EU Pilot files open at the
end of 2019 (calculated by taking the first figure, adding the second and subtracting the third).
99 In some instances a difference between the figures from the preceding annual report may be due to delayed,
double or erroneous registration at the moment of extracting statistical data.
100 The data on policy areas referred to in the main report and in the sections on the Member States is based on
information provided by the European Commission’s Directorates-General. The policy areas are referred to
as follows: agriculture and rural development; budget; climate action; communication networks, content and
technology; competition; education and culture; economic and financial affairs; financial stability and Capital
Markets Union; neighbourhood and enlargement negotiations; employment; energy; environment; migration
and home affairs; justice and consumers; maritime affairs and fisheries; internal market, industry,
entrepreneurship and SMEs; mobility and transport; regional policy; health and food safety; taxation and
customs; trade.
34
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Second chart: EU Pilot files opened in 2019 (main policy areas)
This shows the policy areas in which the new EU Pilot files were opened in 2019.
Third chart: EU Pilot files (2015-2019)
This shows the number of EU Pilot files processed in a given year and the resolution rate in that year.
The resolution rate is the percentage of EU Pilot files handled for which the Commission accepted the
Member States’ responses.
Fourth chart: EU Pilot files and infringement cases
This compares the number of new EU Pilot files and new infringement cases in an overlay with the
total number of infringement cases open at the year-end.
Stages in infringement procedures
First chart: New infringement cases at 31 December 2019
This shows the number of new infringement cases opened in 2019, by Member State.
Second chart: Trends in new infringement procedures
This shows comparison — over a five-year period — between different types of infringement cases
originating as late transposition cases, breaches of regulations and treaties and incorrect application
or non-conformity with directives.
Third chart: New infringement cases opened in 2019 (main policy areas)
This shows the main policy areas in which the new infringement cases were opened in 2019.
Fourth chart: Reasoned opinions sent to Member States in 2019
This shows the number of reasoned opinions sent to Member States in 2019.
Fifth chart: Infringement cases open at year-end (2015-2019)
This shows the number of infringements that remained open on 31 December of each year from 2015
to 2019.
Sixth chart: Infringement cases open on 31 December 2019
These figures show all procedures that the Commission has started against each Member State by
sending a letter of formal notice under Article 258 TFEU. It covers letters sent in 2019 or before,
irrespective of the stages the cases have reached. Only cases which have not yet been closed by a
formal decision are shown. For each Member State, the chart distinguishes between infringements for
incorrect transposition and/or bad application of EU law, late transposition infringements and breaches
of regulations and treaties.
Accordingly, the numbers include all cases that, on 31 December 2019:
• were in the pre-litigation phase (letter of formal notice, reasoned opinion or decision on referral to
the Court under Article 258 TFEU);
• were pending before the Court under Article 258 TFEU or Article 260(3) TFEU;
35
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
• the Court had ruled on but where the Commission could not yet confirm that the Member State had
implemented the judgment correctly;
• were in the second pre-litigation procedure (letter of formal notice or referral decision under
Article 260(2) TFEU);
• were pending before the Court due to a second referral; or
• the Court had ruled on for the second time but where the Commission could not yet confirm that
the Member State had implemented the second judgment correctly.
This figure does not include, for example, open EU Pilot files. It also does not include EU Pilot files for
which the Commission rejected the Member State’s response but had not yet sent a letter of formal
notice under Article 258 TFEU.
Seventh chart: Infringement cases open at end-2019: policy areas
This shows the breakdown, by policy area, of the infringement cases open on 31 December 2019.
Eighth chart: Court of Justice judgments under Article 258 and 260(2) TFEU in 2019
This shows the total number of Court of Justice judgments and the number of judgments in favour of
the Commission and the Member States.
Transposition of directives
Late transposition infringements
First chart: National transposition measures notified per year
This shows the total number of national transposition measures submitted by Member States to the
Commission in a given year.
Second chart: Directives and late transposition infringement cases
This shows how many directives had to be transposed in the years 2015-2019 and how many new
infringement cases for late transposition were opened in that period.
Third chart: Late transposition infringement cases open at year-end
This starts with the number of late transposition infringements at the end of 2018 (first line). The
second line shows the number of new late transposition infringements registered in 2019. The third
line shows the number of infringement cases on which the Commission took a decision in 2019. The
fourth line shows the number of late transposition infringements open at the end of 2019 (calculated
by taking the first figure, adding the second and subtracting the third).
Fourth chart: Late transposition infringement cases in 2019
This shows the number of late transposition infringements open at year-end for each Member State,
irrespective of the year in which the infringement was opened. In addition, it also shows new late
transposition infringement cases opened in 2019 for each Member State.
Fifth chart: New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019 (main policy areas)
This shows the main policy areas in which the procedures for late transposition were launched in
2019.
36
Council of the
European Union
Brussels, 1 September 2020
(OR. en)
10363/20
ADD 2
JUR 391
INST 178
COVER NOTE
From: Secretary-General of the European Commission,
signed by Mr Jordi AYET PUIGARNAU, Director
date of receipt: 31 July 2020
To: Mr Jeppe TRANHOLM-MIKKELSEN, Secretary-General of the Council
of the European Union
No. Cion doc.: SWD(2020) 147 final
Subject: COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT Part II: Policy areas
Accompanying the document Report from the Commission Monitoring
the application of European Union law 2019 Annual Report
Delegations will find attached document SWD(2020) 147 final.
Encl.: SWD(2020) 147 final
10363/20 ADD 2
EN
EUROPEAN
COMMISSION
Brussels, 31.7.2020
SWD(2020) 147 final
PART 2/4
COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT
Part II: Policy areas
Accompanying the document
Report from the Commission
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
{COM(2020) 350 final}
EN EN
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
AGRICULTURE AND RURAL DEVELOPMENT ............................................................................................. 2
COMMUNICATIONS NETWORKS, CONTENT AND TECHNOLOGY ............................................................ 6
EMPLOYMENT, SOCIAL AFFAIRS AND INCLUSION ................................................................................. 13
ENERGY ....................................................................................................................................................... 19
ENVIRONMENT ............................................................................................................................................ 29
FINANCIAL STABILITY, FINANCIAL SERVICES AND CAPITAL MARKETS UNION .................................. 46
HEALTH AND FOOD SAFETY...................................................................................................................... 54
INTERNAL MARKET, INDUSTRY, ENTREPRENEURSHIP AND SMES ..................................................... 61
JUSTICE AND CONSUMERS ....................................................................................................................... 69
MARITIME AFFAIRS AND FISHERIES ........................................................................................................ 79
MIGRATION AND HOME AFFAIRS .............................................................................................................. 82
MOBILITY AND TRANSPORT ...................................................................................................................... 92
TAXATION AND CUSTOMS UNION ........................................................................................................... 102
1
This document provides an overview of the policy areas in which the most significant developments
related to infringements of EU law took place in 2019.
2
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Agriculture and rural development
Agriculture and rural development
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints received from members of the public (2015 -2019)
105
97
91 90
42
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints open at year-end
38 ► Complaints open at end-2018
42 ► New complaints registered in 2019
67 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 13 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy sectors
42 complaints in 2019
Rural Direct payments
development 17
11
Common market
organisation
(Wine)
4
Other
10
3
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Agriculture and rural development
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files (2015-2019)
36
25
12
7 7
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. EU Pilot files open at year-end
At the end of 2019, 15 EU Pilot files remained open.
3. EU Pilot files: resolution rate for policies (2015 -2019)
100%
95%
89%
81% 80%
75% 77% 73% 77%
72%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Agriculture and rural development General rate for all policy areas
III. OWN-INITIATIVE CASES
New own-initiative infringement cases
In 2019, the Commission did not open own-initiative infringement cases in this area.
IV. INFRINGEMENT CASES
Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a) The Commission did not open new infringement cases in 2019 in this area.
4
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Agriculture and rural development
Major ongoing infringement cases include the following:
• Bulgaria: maintaining a national framework on geographical indications, which is not
compatible with the EU rules on quality schemes for agricultural products and foodstuffs1;
• Denmark: unlawful use of the protected designation of origin ‘Feta’, in violation of the EU
rules on quality schemes for agricultural products and foodstuffs2.
b) The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU.
c) The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.
V. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. New late transposition infringement cases (2015 -2019)
11
8
0 0 0
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy
sectors
The Commission did not open any new late transposition infringement cases.
VI. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
There were no major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019 in this area.
VII. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
There were no major Court rulings in 2019 in this area.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court gave the following preliminary rulings:
• Germany: Where EU customs regulations require providing a specific indication of the
country of origin for a product (in the present case, cultivated mushrooms that had been
relocated during the growing process), the country of origin is that where the product was
harvested and that indication as such cannot be regarded as misleading consumers. In
such circumstances, no obligations may be imposed on the food business operators to
1 Regulation (EU) No 1151/2012, MEMO/19/462
2 Regulation (EU) No 1151/2012, IP-19-6312
5
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Agriculture and rural development
provide information additional to the indication of the country of origin in order to prevent
any alleged risk of misleading consumers3.
• Germany: The protection of the name ‘Aceto Balsamico di Modena (PGI)’, entered in the
register of protected designations of origin and protected geographical indications, does
not extend to the use of the individual non-geographical terms of that name, namely ‘aceto’
and ‘balsamico’4.
• Lithuania: A national legislation aiming to combat unfair commercial practices may prohibit
buyers of raw milk to pay a different purchase price to producers who, on the basis of the
daily quantity of raw milk sold that is of identical composition and quality and delivered via
the same method, must be regarded as belonging to the same group, in so far as those
rules are appropriate to attain the objective pursued and do not go beyond what is
necessary to achieve that objective 5.
• Spain: Figurative signs may trigger directly in the consumer’s mind the image of products
whose designation of origin is protected, on account of their ‘conceptual proximity’ to such
a designation. Consequently, a protected designation of origin, such as ‘queso manchego’,
may be evoked through the use of figurative signs, including where such figurative signs
are used by a producer established in the geographical area associated with the
designation of origin, but whose products, similar or comparable to those protected by the
designation of origin, are not covered by it 6.
VIII. OUTLOOK
Important implementation work in 2020 includes:
• focusing on infringements that challenge the application of important mechanisms of the
common market organisation7 or affect the correct application of the direct payments regime8 or
the implementation of the Organic and Quality Regulations9;
• monitoring compliance with recent rulings of the Court of Justice;
• continuing to use the clearance of accounts procedure in the agricultural sector to convince
Member States to adapt their management and control systems if an infringement is detected
through conformity audit mechanisms.
• preparing the transposition of the Unfair Trading Practices Directive 10.
3 Zentrale zur Bekämpfung unlauteren Wettbewerbs Frankfurt am Main, C-686/17.
4 Consorzio Tutela Aceto Balsamico di Modena, C-432/18 and Court press release 150/19.
5 Lietuvos Respublikos Seimo narių grupė, C-2/18.
6 Fundación Consejo Regulador de la Denominación de Origen Protegida Queso Manchego, C-614/17 and
Court press release No 55/19.
7 Regulation (EU) No 1308/2013.
8 Regulation (EU) No 1307/2013.
9 Regulation (EU) No 834/2007 and Regulations (EU) No 1151/2012, (EC) No 110/2008 and (EU) No
251/2014 and Regulation (EU) 2019/34.
10 Directive (EU) 2019/633.
6
Monitoring the application of European law
2019 Annual Report
Communications networks, content and technology
Communications networks, content and technology
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints received from members of the public (2015 -2019)
84
78
66 68
50
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints open at year-end
127 ► Complaints open at end-2018
68 ► New complaints registered in 2019
94 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 101 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy sectors
68 complaints in 2019
Copyright
46
Electronic
communications
8
Audiovisual & Media
Services Policy
5
Cybersecurity and
digital privacy
4
Policy outreach, international affairs eCommerce
1 4
7
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Communications networks, content and technology
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files (2015-2019)
30
12
2 0
0
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. EU Pilot files open at year-end
At the end of 2019, 7 EU Pilot files remained open.
3. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy sectors
The Commission did not open new files in this area in 2019.
4. EU Pilot files: resolution rate for policies (2015 -2019)
94%
75% 77%
72% 73%
77%
56%
53%
42%
14%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Communications networks, content and technology
III. OWN-INITIATIVE CASES
New own-initiative infringement cases
In 2019, the Commission opened own-initiative infringement cases over:
• lack of compliance with the rules governing the European emergency number ‘112’ 11;
• the Geo-blocking Regulation12,. ^
11 Directive (EU) 2002/22.
12 Regulation (EU) 2018/302.
8
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Communications networks, content and technology
• failure to submit information about operators of essential services identified under the EU law on
the security of network and information systems13.
IV. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases open on 31 December (2015 -2019)
67
58
42
34
31
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Infringement cases open on 31 December 2019: main policy sectors
34 infringement cases in 2019
Cybersecurity and digital privacy
5
Copyright
Accessibility, 5
Multilingualism
and Safer
Internet
e-Commerce &
7
Platforms
4
Implementation Other
of the 3
Regulatory
Framework
10
13 Directive (EU) 2016/1148, INF/19/4251.
9
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Communications networks, content and technology
3. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy sectors
17 new infringement cases in 2019
e-Commerce &
Platforms
6
Implementation
of the
Regulatory
Framework
5
Cybersecurity
6
10
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Communications networks, content and technology
4. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a) The Commission opened 17 new infringement cases in 2019. These, and other major
ongoing infringement cases, include the following:
• Czechia, Germany, Greece, Spain and Croatia for failure to effectively implement the
rules on the 112 emergency number, in particular by not ensuring equivalent access
for disabled users14.
• France, Spain, Cyprus, Poland, Romania and Slovakia for delays in the
implementation of the Geo-blocking Regulation., by failing to provide for measures
and mechanisms for consumer protection15.
• Belgium, Greece, Hungary, Austria, Romania and Slovenia: failure to submit
information about operators of essential services identified under the EU law on the
security of network and information systems16.
b) The Commission referred one case to the Court under Article 258 TFEU. This concerns:
• Portugal: failure to align its system of financing universal services to the Universal
Service Directive17.
c) The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU..
V. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. New late transposition infringement cases (2015 -2019)
53
50
17
0 0
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy
sectors
The Commission did not open any new late transposition infringement cases.
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
The Commission did not open any cases for late transposition in 2019 in this area.
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3).
14 Directive (EU) 2002/22; INF/19/4251.
15 Regulation (EU) 2018/302 ; INF/19/4251.
16 Directive (EU) 2016/1148, INF/19/4251.
17 Case Commission v Portugal, C-49/19.
11
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Communications networks, content and technology
VI. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
There were no major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019.
VII. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
The Court gave the following ruling:
• Belgium did not fulfil its obligations under EU law by notifying to the Commission only
partial transposition measures for the Directive on measures to reduce the cost of
deploying high-speed electronic communications networks18 with respect to the region of
Bruxelles-Capitale. The Court applied for the first time the sanction mechanism of Article
260(3) TFEU. This Treaty provision allows the Commission to request the Court to impose
financial penalties if Member States fail to fulfil their obligation to notify measures
transposing a directive adopted under a legislative procedure. In addition to clarifying that
the sanction scheme of Article 260(3) TFEU may also be applied to cases of partial failure
to adopt and communicate transposition measures, the Court held that, when notifying
national transposition measures to the Commission, Member States must provide
sufficiently clear and precise information and state, for each provision of the directive, the
national provision(s) ensuring its transposition 19.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court gave the following preliminary rulings:
• Belgium: SkypeOut service should be considered an electronic communications service.
As a result, SkypeOut is subject to telecoms legislation, in particular to the general
authorisation regime. Services offered via software, such as SkypeOut, which allow calling
numbers in a national numbering plan, constitute electronic communication services 20.
• Germany: freedom of information and freedom of the press cannot justify a derogation from
the author’s exclusive rights of reproduction and of communication to the public going
beyond the exceptions or limitations provided for in EU law21.
• Germany: a phonogram producer can prevent the use of a sound sample of his or her
phonogram in another phonogram. However, such a sample can be used, if it is included in
the phonogram in a modified form unrecognisable to the ear22.
• Germany: The Gmail service should not be considered as consisting wholly or mainly in the
‘conveyance of signals’. As a result, Gmail is not an electronic communications service,
and is therefore not subject to the general authorisation regime under the current EU
telecoms legislation23.
• France: Airbnb provides an information society service separate from accommodation
services to which it relates. Such a service does not aim only at providing immediate
accommodation services, but rather it consists essentially of providing a tool for presenting
and finding accommodation for rent, thereby facilitating the conclusion of future rental
agreements. Therefore, that type of service is not merely ancillary to an overall
accommodation service. Second, an intermediation service, such as the one provided by
Airbnb Ireland, is in no way indispensable to the provision of accommodation services,
18 Directive 2014/61/EU.
19 Commission v Belgium, C-2017/543, C-2017/543.
20 Skype Communcation, case C-142/18.
21 Funke Medien NRW, case C-469/17.
22 Pelham and others, case C-476/17.
23 Google, case C-193/18.
12
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Communications networks, content and technology
since the guests and hosts have a number of other channels in that respect, some of which
are long-standing. Finally, there is no indication that Airbnb sets or caps the amount of the
rents charged by the hosts using that platform 24.
• Lithuania: A Member State may, on grounds of public policy, such as in the specific
circumstances combating the incitement to hatred of the Baltic States based on nationality,
impose a requirement to temporarily distribute or retransmit a television channel from
another Member State only in pay-to-view packages25.
• Lithuania: Telecommunications companies are required to transmit location information for
free to the 112 emergency call authorities, even if the call is received from a mobile phone
which is not equipped with a SIM card. When determining accuracy and reliability criteria,
Member States need to ensure that the location information is useful for emergency
services to intervene26.
• The Netherlands: The sale of second-hand e-books through a website constitutes a
communication to the public that is subject to authorisation by the author 27.
• Portugal: Member States cannot add additional requirements (such as a specific,
aesthetically significant visual effect) for granting copyright protection to designs, such as
the clothing designs of jeans, which already meet the requirements for copyright protection
under EU law 28.
VIII. OUTLOOK
Important implementation work in 2020 includes monitoring the complete and correct
implementation of:
• the European Electronic Communications Code 29;
• the Decision on the use of the 470-790 MHz frequency band in the Union30 and the timely
allocation of the spectrum by Member States beforehand, which is a precondition for the roll-out
of 5G in the EU;
• the Audio Video Media Services Directive31;
• the Platforms-to-business Regulation32.
24 Airbnb Ireland, case C – 390/18.
25 Baltic Media Alliance, case C-622/17.
26 AW and Others, case C- 417/18.
27 Nederlands Uitgeversverbond and Groep Algemene Uitgevers, case C-263/18.
28 Cofemel, case C-683/17.
29 Directive (EU) 2019/1972.
30 Decision (EU) 2017/89.
31 Directive (EU) 2018/1808.
32 Regulation (EU) 2019/1150.
13
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Employment, social affairs and inclusion
Employment, social affairs and inclusion
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints received from members of the public (2015 -2019)
679
612
484 487
390
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints open at year-end
287 ► Complaints open at end-2018
390 ► New complaints registered in 2019
442 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 235 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy sectors
390 complaints in 2019
Disability and inclusion
Social security 58
102
Health & Safety
at work
24
Free movement
of workers
17
Working conditions
108 Other
81
14
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Employment, social affairs and inclusion
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot cases (2015-2019)
40
37
1 2
0
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. EU Pilot files open at year-end
At the end of 2019, 12 EU Pilot files remained open.
3. EU Pilot files: resolution rate for policies (2015 -2019)
100% 100%
92% 93%
75%
77% 73% 77%
72% 72%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Employment policies General rate for all policy areas
III. OWN-INITIATIVE CASES
New own-initiative infringement cases
15
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Employment, social affairs and inclusion
In 2019, the Commission opened an own-initiative infringement case concerning the indexation of
family benefits33.
IV. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases open on 31 December (2015 -2019)
83
75
60
46
25
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Infringement cases open on 31 December 2019: main policy sectors
25 infringement cases in 2019
Working conditions
17
Social security
3
Health & Safety
Free movement of workers at work
2 3
33 Regulation (EU) 492/2011.
16
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Employment, social affairs and inclusion
3. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy sectors
3 new infringement cases in 2019
Working
conditions
2
Social security
1
4. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
The Commission opened three new infringement cases in 2019.
These concerned the following:
• Austria: breach of the rules on the free movement of workers and social security by
indexing the amount of eligible family allowances, child tax credit and family tax deduction
for children who are not permanently resident in Austria34.
• Spain: incompatibility of national rules on paid annual leave with EU labour legislation 35.
• Italy: insufficient protection of public sector workers against abusive successive fixed-term
contracts and discrimination as required under EU rules 36.
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU.
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU..
V. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. New late transposition infringement cases (2015 -2019)
39
20
18
14
0
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
34 Regulation (EC) 883/2004, Regulation (EU) 492/2011, IP/19/463.
35 Directive 2003/88/EC, INF/19/4251.
36 Directive 1999/70/EC, INF/19/4251.
17
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Employment, social affairs and inclusion
2. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy
sectors
The Commission did not open any new late transposition infringement cases in 2019.
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
The Commission did not open any cases for late transposition in 2019 in this area.
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
VI. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• Ireland, France, Cyprus and Romania: non-communication of measures on minimum
requirements for enhancing worker mobility between Member States by improving the
acquisition and preservation of supplementary pension rights37.
• Bulgaria, Czechia, Germany, Estonia, Luxembourg, Poland, Romania and Finland: non-
communication of measures on working time in inland waterway transport 38.
• Ireland, Greece, Croatia, Italy, Poland, Portugal and Romania: non-communication of
measures on labour rights for seafarers39.
VII. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
There were no major Court rulings in 2019 in this area.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court gave the following preliminary rulings:
• Italy: the Court of Justice confirmed that Member States are obliged, under the Fixed-Term
Work Directive, to provide effective measures designed to prevent and punish the misuse
of successive fixed-term employment contracts.40
• Belgium: the Court of Justice ruled that the circumstance that the transferee has a choice
whether to dismiss employees goes against the objective of the Directive on transfer of
undertakings, which provides that dismissals due to the transfer are prohibited 41.
• Slovenia: the Court of Justice clarified that a transfer of financial instruments and other
client assets between stock exchange intermediaries may constitute a transfer within the
meaning of the Directive on transfer of undertakings where there is a transfer of clients 42.
• Greece: the Court of Justice concluded that the Directive on transfer of undertakings may,
under certain conditions, apply in a situation where the transferor, the transferee or both
envisage not only the pursuit of the activity transferred, but also the future liquidation of the
transferee itself43.
37 Directive 2014/50/EU.
38 Directive 2014/112/EU.
39 Directive (EU) 2015/1794.
40
Case C-494/17 Rossato.
41 Case C-509/17 Plessers.
42 Case C-194/18 Dodič.
43 Case C-664/17 Ellinika Nafpigeia.
18
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Employment, social affairs and inclusion
• Germany: the Court of Justice stated that, in case of insolvency of the employer, a
reduction in a former employee’s old-age benefits must be regarded as being manifestly
disproportionate if that person is living, or would have to live, below the at-risk-of-poverty
threshold determined by Eurostat for the Member State concerned 44.
• Spain: the Court of Justice ruled that, on the basis of the Working Time Directive and in the
light of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the EU, the Member States must require
employers to set up an objective, reliable and accessible system enabling the duration of
time worked each day by each worker to be measured45.
• Spain: calculating the length of service of a part-time worker whose working hours are
‘distributed vertically’ over the whole year (a vertical cyclical part-time worker) solely on the
basis of periods actually worked when it comes to the right to pay rise and promotion, while
not doing the same for comparable full-time workers, may be discriminatory and therefore
breach the Framework Agreement on Part-Time Work and the Equal Treatment Directive46.
• Austria: the Court of Justice stated that the limitation on the recognition of previous periods
of professionally relevant experience completed in another Member State for determining
the entry salary for the migrant worker is possible only if the limitation applies equally to
national and migrant workers and the work-related experience from another Member State
is not fully comparable with the new employment position 47.
• Austria: the fact that part-time workers, who would otherwise have been employed on
open-ended contracts, could be employed on fixed-term contracts for longer periods of
time than comparable full-time workers, could be contrary to the Framework Agreement on
Part-Time Work (principle of non-discrimination). Such a situation may also constitute an
indirect discrimination based on sex, to the extent that women are substantially
overrepresented in the group of part-time workers on a fixed term contract under the Equal
Treatment Directive48.
• The Netherlands: The Court of Justice concluded that third-country nationals legally staying
(but not residing) and working in a Member State are to be issued A1 certificates for their
posting in other Member States 49.
• The Netherlands: the Court of Justice clarified in its judgment that a person residing in
his/her own Member State, employed in another Member State but working in international
waters falls under the applicable legislation of the Member State of residence of that
person50.
• Ireland: The Court of Justice clarified that it is not necessary for a person to pursue an
activity as an employed person in a Member State in order to be entitled to family benefits
if his or her children are living in another Member State 51.
VIII. OUTLOOK
Important implementation work in 2020 includes:
• In relation to occupational safety and health legislation, monitoring the complete transposition of
and performing conformity checks on the Directive on the protection of workers from the risks
44 Case C-168/18 Pensions-Sicherungs-Verein.
45 Case C-55/18 CCOO.
46 Joined cases C-439/18 and C-472/18, OH/ER v AEAT.
47 Case C-703/17 Krah
48
Case C-274/18, Schuch-Ghannadan.
49 Case C-477/17 Balandin
50 Case C-631/17 SF v Inspecteur van de Belastingdienst.
51 Case C-322/17 Bogatu.
19
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Employment, social affairs and inclusion
related to exposure to carcinogens or mutagens at work52 and performing conformity checks on
the Directive establishing a fourth list of indicative occupational exposure limit values 53.
• Finalising and adopting a report on the application of the Directive on minimum requirements for
enhancing worker mobility between Member States by improving the acquisition and
preservation of supplementary pension rights 54.
• Monitoring the timely and complete transposition of the Directive concerning the posting of
workers in the framework of the provision of services55.
• Monitoring the compliance of national legislation and administrative practices concerning the EU
free movement of workers.56
52 Directive 2017/2398/EU.
53 Directive 2017/164/EU.
54 Directive 2014/50/EU.
55 Directive 2018/957/EU.
56 Regulation (EU) 492/2011.
20
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Energy
Energy
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints received from members of the public (2015 -2019)
91
58
60 58
37
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints open at year-end
82 ► Complaints open at end-2018
58 ► New complaints registered in 2019
43 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 97 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy sectors
58 complaints in 2019
Internal energy market and consumer protection
18
Energy efficiency
9
Renewable
energy
23 Other (security of
supply, radiation
protection and
nuclear safety)
8
21
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Energy
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files (2015-2019)
88
65
44 46
33
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. EU Pilot files open at year-end
At the end of 2019, 50 EU Pilot files remained open.
3. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy sectors
46 EU Pilot files opened in 2019
Energy
Renewable efficiency
energy 23
1
Hydrocarbons
6
Internal market
for electricity
and natural gas
16
4. EU Pilot files: resolution rate for policies (2015 -2019)
89%
75% 77%
72% 73%
77%
66% 68%
51%
45%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Energy General rate for all policy areas
22
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Energy
III. OWN-INITIATIVE CASES
New own-initiative infringement cases
In 2019, the Commission opened own-initiative infringement cases over:
• energy efficiency;
• energy performance of buildings;
• internal energy market and consumer protection;
• radioactive waste.
IV. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases open on 31 December (2015-2019)
109
93
73
56 54
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Infringement cases open on 31 December 2019: main policy sectors
109 infringement cases in 2019
Energy efficiency
31
Security of
supply
14
Euratom
44 Renewable energy
12
Internal energy market and consumer protection
8
23
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Energy
3. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy sectors
4. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a) The Commission opened 52 new infringement cases in 2019. These, and other major
ongoing infringement cases, include the following:
• Croatia, Italy, Greece, Belgium, Bulgaria, Czechia, Estonia, France, Lithuania,
Luxembourg, Latvia, Poland, Denmark and Portugal: non-compliance with the
requirements of the Energy Efficiency Directive 57;
• Croatia, Luxembourg, Malta, Portugal and Romania: failure to submit their second
cost-optimal report required by the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive 58;
• Romania: failure to correctly implement certain requirements of the Third Energy
Package (the Gas Directive) and the Security of Gas Supply Regulation 59;
• Romania: non-compliance of national measures restricting the export of natural gas
with the requirements of the Third Energy Package (the Gas Directive) and Articles 35
and 36 TFEU60;
• Poland: failure to comply with the EU requirements on the security of gas supply 61;
• Latvia: failure to correctly transpose certain requirements of the Radioactive Waste
Directive62;
• Belgium and Spain: failure to adopt a national programme for the implementation of a
spent fuel and radioactive waste management policy that is compliant with the
requirements of the Radioactive Waste Directive 63.
b) The Commission referred five cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU. They concern:
• Belgium: incorrect transposition of the Third Energy Package Directives (Electricity
and Gas Directives)64;
57 Directive 2012/27/EU, MEMO/19/462.
58 Directive 2010/31/EU, MEMO/19/462, MEMO/19/1472 and INF/19/4251.
59 Directive 2009/73/EC, Regulation (EU) 2017/1938, MEMO/19/1472.
60 Directive 2009/73/EC, INF/19/4251.
61 Regulation (EU) 2017/1938, INF/19/6304.
62 Council Directive 2011/70/Euratom, MEMO/19/462.
63 Council Directive 2011/70/Euratom, INF/19/6304.
64 Directives 2009/72/EC and 2009/73/EC, Commission v Belgium, C-767/19; IP/19/4254.
24
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Energy
• Czechia and Slovenia: incorrect transposition and application of certain provisions of
the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive 65;
• Spain: failure to comply with the requirements on individual metering in multi-
apartment and multi-purpose buildings laid down in the Energy Efficiency Directive 66;
• Italy: failure to notify transposition measures under the Basic Safety Standards
Directive67.
c) The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.
V. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. New late transposition infringement cases (2015 -2019)
31
22
15
11
4
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy
sectors
31 late transposition infringement cases in 2019
Security of
supply
13 Radiation
protection and
nuclear safety
5
Renewable
energy
13
65 Directive 2010/31/EU, Commission v Czechia, C-305/19 and Commission v Slovenia, C-413/19; IP/19/464.
Slovenia subsequently took the necessary steps to ensure compliance with EU law, and the Commission
has therefore withdrawn this case from the Court.
66 Directive 2012/27/EU, Commission v Spain, C-347/19; IP/19/1473.
67 Directive 2013/59/Euratom, Commission v Italy, C-744/19.
25
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Energy
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
The Commission opened 31 cases for late transposition in 2019.
They concern the:
• Indirect Land Use Change Directive68
• amendment to the Oil Stocks Directive as regards the methods for calculating stockholding
obligations69
• Basic Safety Standards Directive70.
• The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
VI. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019.
These concerned:
• Greece, Ireland, Latvia, Malta, the Netherlands and Slovenia: non-compliance with the
Energy Performance of Buildings Directive71;
• Luxembourg and Romania: failure to submit their second cost-optimal report required by
the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive72;
• Czechia, Ireland and Malta: failure to correctly transpose certain requirements of the
Radioactive Waste Directive73;
• Croatia: failure to notify the national programme for the implementation of a spent fuel and
radioactive waste management policy74;
• Bulgaria, Cyprus, Estonia, Spain and Sweden: incorrect transposition of the Third Energy
Package Directives75;
• Spain and Poland: non-communication of national measures transposing the Offshore
Safety Directive76;
• Romania: non-compliance with the Oil Stocks Directive77;
• Austria, Bulgaria, Cyprus, Denmark, Finland, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, France,
Portugal and Romania: failure to adopt all transposition measures for the Indirect Land Use
Change Directive78;
• Finland and Malta: non-compliance with the Energy Efficiency Directive79;
• Belgium, Poland and Spain: failure to adopt all transposition measures for the Nuclear
Safety Directive80.
68 Directive (EU) 2015/1513.
69 Directive (EU) 2018/1581.
70 Directive 2013/59/Euratom.
71 Directive 2010/31/EU.
72 Directive 2010/31/EU.
73 Directive 2011/70/Euratom.
74 Directive 2011/70/Euratom.
75 Directives 2009/72/EC and 2009/73/EC.
76 Directive 2013/30/EU.
77 Directive 2009/119/EC.
78 Directive (EU) 2015/1513.
79 Directive 2012/27/EU.
80 Directive 2014/87/Euratom.
26
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Energy
VII. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
The Court gave the following rulings:
• Italy has failed to comply with the Radioactive Waste Directive since it has not notified a
final adopted national programme for radioactive waste and spent fuel management 81.
• The General Court annulled a 2016 Commission decision amending the conditions for an
exemption granted by an earlier decision to the gas pipeline Ostseepipeline-
Anbindungsleitung from the rules on third-party access and unbundling set out in the Gas
Directive. The Court found that the Commission had failed to examine the impact of the
revised exemption conditions on energy solidarity to determine whether they could
negatively impact the interests of other Member States or the Union 82.
• The General Court annulled on procedural grounds the decision of the European Agency
for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators (ACER) on the capacity calculation regions which
led to the split of the German-Austrian bidding zone, based on the reason that the Austrian
regulatory authority had asked for an amendment of the proposal for the capacity
calculation regions before the expiry of the six-month period during which the national
regulatory authorities may approve the proposal83.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court gave the following preliminary rulings:
• Bulgaria: National legislation obliging apartment owners in buildings in co-ownership to pay
for the thermal energy used by the common parts and the internal installation of the
building is compatible with EU law, even though the owners do not use that thermal energy
in their own apartments. In such buildings, the bills for thermal energy consumption by the
internal installation are calculated for each property owner in the building in proportion to
the heated volume of their apartment84.
• Bulgaria: The Court gave guidance as to the relevant criteria under the Electricity Directive
to distinguish between transmission and distribution systems85.
• Finland: The Energy Efficiency Directive does not prevent energy companies from giving
customers discounts to encourage the uptake of electronic billing delivery methods 86.
• France: The Gas Directive allows a regulatory authority settling a dispute between energy
companies to extend the effects of its decision to the situation of the parties before the
emergence of that dispute, by requiring one party to bring a contract for the transmission of
natural gas in line with EU law for the entire contractual period87.
• Italy: National legislation under which the amount of royalties payable by holders of
licences for the extraction of natural gas is calculated on the basis of an index based on the
prices of oil and other fuels in the medium and long term and not an index that reflects the
short-term market price of natural gas is not incompatible with EU law 88.
81 Directive 2011/70/Euratom, Commission v Italy, C-434/18,
82 Directive 2009/73/EC, Poland v Commission, T-883/16 and Court press release No 107/2019.
83 E-Control v ACER, T-332/17.
84 Joined cases: EVN Bulgaria Toplofikatsia, C-708/17 and Toplofikatsia Sofia, C-725/17.
85 Directive 2009/72/EC, Elektrorazpredelenie Yug, C-31/18.
86 Directive 2012/27/EU, Oulun Sähkömyynti, C-294/18.
87 Directive 2009/73/EC, GRDF, C-236/18.
88 Directive 94/22/EC, joined cases: Eni, C-364/18 and Shell Italia, C-365/18.
27
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Energy
• Spain: A financial contribution imposed on certain electricity generating undertakings to
finance savings and energy efficiency plans managed by a public authority does not
constitute a public service obligation under the Electricity Directive 89.
• Spain: National legislation may set taxes on the production and storage of nuclear fuel and
waste which apply only to electricity-generating undertakings using nuclear energy and
whose main objective is to increase the amount of revenue for the electricity financial
system. Such legislation does not violate the principle of non-discrimination provided for by
the Electricity Directive90.
• Spain: EU law does not prohibit a tax on the use of inland waters for the production of
electricity which does not incentivise the efficient use of water, nor establish mechanisms
for the preservation and protection of public water resources, as it is focused solely and
exclusively on the income-generating capacity of hydroelectricity producers. A tax on the
use of inland waters to produce electricity which exclusively affects hydroelectricity
generators operating in river basins encompassing more than one autonomous community
and not those operating in river basins encompassing a single autonomous community is
not considered discriminatory 91.
VIII. OUTLOOK
Important implementation work in 2020 includes:
• assessing the national energy and climate plans adopted by the Member States pursuant to the
Governance Regulation92;
• taking legal action to ensure correct and complete transposition of the Electricity and Gas
Directives93, the Indirect Land Use Change Directive 94, the Energy Efficiency Directive95, the
Energy Performance of Buildings Directive96, the Oil Stocks Directive97, the Radioactive Waste
Directive98, the Nuclear Safety Directive99, the Basic Safety Standards Directive 100, the Euratom
Drinking Water Directive101;
• assessing the Member States reports on the implementation of the Nuclear Safety Directive,
due to be submitted to the Commission by 22 July 2020;
• taking legal action to ensure the correct application of the Governance Regulation 102, the
Ecodesign and Energy Labelling Regulations, the Risk Preparedness Regulation103, the
Electricity Regulation104, the Network Codes105 and the Security of Gas Supply Regulation 106.
89 Directive 2009/72/EC, Engie Cartagena, C–523/18.
90 Directive 2009/72/EC, joined cases: UNESA, C‑80/18, Endesa Generación, C-81/18, Endesa Generación,
C-82/18 and Iberdrola Generación Nuclear, C‑83/18.
91 Joined cases: UNESA, C-105/18, Engasa, C-106/18, Duerocanto, C-107/18, Acciona, C-108/18, Associació
de Productors i Usuaris d’Energia Elèctrica, C-109/18, Burgos Pérez and Guinea Bueno, C-110/18, Endesa
Generación, C-111/18, APPA, C-112/18, Parc del Segre and Others, C-113/18.
92 Regulation (EU) 2018/1999.
93 Directives 2009/72/EC and 2009/73/EC.
94 Directive (EU) 2015/1513.
95 Directive 2012/27/EU as amended by(EU) 2018/2002.
96 Directive 2010/31/EU as amended by Directive (EU) 2018/844.
97 Directive (EU) 2018/1581.
98 Directive 2011/70/Euratom.
99 Directive 2009/71/Euratom, as amended by 2014/87/Euratom.
100 Directive 2013/59/Euratom.
101 Directive 2013/51/Euratom.
102 Regulation (EU) 2018/1999.
103 Regulation (EU) 2019/941.
104 Regulation (EU) 2019/943.
105 Regulation (EU) 2015/1222.
28
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Environment
Environment
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints received from members of the public (2015 -2019)
518
443
363 348 339
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints open at year-end
546 ► Complaints open at end-2018
443 ► New complaints registered in 2019
422 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 567 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy sectors
443 complaints in 2019
Impact
Nature assessment
protection 97
146
Water protection
and
management
58
Other Air Quality
57 44
Waste management
41
106 Regulation (EU) 2017/1938.
29
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Environment
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files (2015-2019)
151
101
63
21 22
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy sectors
22 EU Pilot files opened in 2019
Waste management
14
Nature
protection
5
Other Impact assessment
2 1
3. EU Pilot files open at year-end
At the end of 2019, 128 EU Pilot files remained open.
4. EU Pilot files: resolution rate for policies (2015 -2019)
76% 77%
77% 73%
75%
72% 73%
65%
65% 65%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Environment General rate for all policy areas
30
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Environment
III. OWN-INITIATIVE CASES
New own-initiative infringement cases
In 2019, the Commission opened own-initiative infringement cases over:
• incorrect transposition of the revised Environmental Impact Assessment Directive 107;
• failure to complete the Natura 2000 network and to ensure protection of this network;
• incorrect transposition of the Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment Directive 108;
• incorrect transposition of the SEVESO III Directive 109;
• failure to share spatial information, in line with the INSPIRE Directive 110;
• non-compliance with the Industrial Emissions Directive 111;
• incorrect transposition of the Directive on the protection of animals used for scientific
purposes112;
• failure to ensure adequate protection of certain bird species and of certain natural habitats;
• bad application of the Birds Directive in relation to the hunting of certain bird species 113;
• failure to set dissuasive penalties and to adopt specific lists of invasive alien species for
outermost regions, in breach of the Invasive Alien Species Regulation 114;
• non-compliance with reporting obligations under EU waste legislation.
IV. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases open on 31 December (2015-2019)
327
307
298
276
269
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
107 Directive 2011/92/EU, as amended by Directive 2014/52/EU.
108 Directive 2012/19/EU.
109 Directive 2012/18/EU.
110 Directive 2007/2/EC.
111 Directive 2010/75/EU.
112 Directive 2010/63/EU.
113 Directive 2009/147/EC.
114 Regulation (EU) 1143/2014.
31
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Environment
2. Infringement cases open on 31 December 2019: main policy sectors
327 infringement cases in 2019
Water protection and management
50 Impact
assessment
Nature protection 35
57
Chemicals
16
Other
34
Air quality
61
Waste
management
74
3. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy sectors
175 new infringement cases in 2019
Waste
management
71
Nature protection
21
Air quality
Other
19
27
Chemicals Impact assessment
9 Water protection and management 19
9
4. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a) The Commission opened 175 new infringement cases in 2019. These, and other major
ongoing infringement cases, include the following:
• United Kingdom: failure to comply with a Court judgment finding that the United
Kingdom had breached its obligations under EU law as regards collection and
treatment of urban waste water in London and Whitburn115;
• Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Slovakia and Spain: failure to ensure that urban waste water is
adequately collected and treated116;
• Poland and Slovakia: failure to comply with EU rules on landfills117;
• Greece: lack of measures to address waste problems on the island of Corfu 118;
115 Directive 91/271/EEC, MEMO/19/462, Commission v United Kingdom, C-301/10.
116 Directive 91/271/EEC, INF/19/4251, MEMO/19/462 and INF/19/6304.
117 Directive 1999/31/EC, MEMO/19/1472.
32
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Environment
• Germany: failure to comply with a Court judgment finding that Germany was in breach
of its obligations under the Nitrates Directive by failing to revise an action programme
whose measures had proved insufficient 119;
• Belgium: failure to protect waters from nitrates pollution120;
• Belgium and Poland: non-compliance with key provisions of the Noise Directive 121;
• Czechia, Latvia, Slovakia, Poland, Portugal and Romania: failure to ensure adequate
protection of habitats and species of EU interest by designating nature protection
areas to complete the NATURA 2000 network122;
• Slovenia: incorrect transposition of the Habitats and Birds Directives 123;
• Cyprus: general and persistent failure to ensure that plans and projects undergo an
appropriate assessment of their implications on Natura 2000 sites, as required by the
Habitats Directive124;
• Slovakia: failure to provide for an appropriate assessment of the effects that projects
within Natura 2000 sites, such as forest logging activities, may have on the protected
areas, which resulted in a significant fall in bird numbers 125;
• Bulgaria, Italy and Germany: failure to establish Special Areas of Conservation, as
well as conservation objectives and measures to maintain or restore the protected
species and habitats to a favourable condition, as required by the Habitats
Directive126;
• France: authorisation of non-selective hunting practices which are not in line with the
Birds Directive127;
• France and Spain: failure to take the necessary measures to enhance protection of
the species of the Turtle dove as required by the Birds Directive 128;
• Germany and Slovenia: failure to ensure adequate protection of grasslands, as
required by the Habitats Directive129;
• Poland: failure to establish adequate safeguards to protect forests and its plant and
animal species, as required under the Birds and Habitats Directives. Also, failure to
provide access to justice with regard to forest management plans 130;
• Austria, Denmark, Finland, Latvia, Germany, Slovenia and Poland: incorrect
transposition of the Directive on the protection of animals used for scientific
purposes131;
• Greece: incorrect transposition of the Industrial Emissions Directive and failure to
protect citizens from noxious air pollution from several power plants, as required by
the said Directive132;
• Romania: failure to ensure that installations under the Industrial Emissions Directive
operate with appropriate permits133;
118 MEMO/19/1472.
119 Directive 91/676/EC, INF/19/4251, Commission v Germany, C-543/16.
120 Directive 91/676/EC, INF/19/6304.
121 Directive 2002/49/EC, INF/19/4251 and MEMO/19/462.
122 INF/19/6304 and INF/19/4251.
123 Directives 92/43/EEC and 2009/147/EC, INF/19/4251.
124 Directive 92/43/EEC, INF/19/6304.
125 MEMO/19/462.
126 Directive 92/43/EEC, MEMO/19/462.
127 Directive 2009/147/EC, INF/19/4251.
128 Directive 2009/147/EC, INF/19/4251.
129 Directive 92/43/EEC, INF/19/4251.
130 Directives 92/43/EEC and 2009/147/EC, INF/19/4251.
131 Directive 2010/63/EU, INF/19/5950 and INF/19/4251.
132 Directive 2010/75/EU, INF/19/4251.
33
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Environment
• Poland: failure to comply with a Court judgment finding that Poland had breached its
obligations under the Ambient Air Quality Directive 134;
• Greece: failure to comply with the nitrogen dioxide (NO 2) limit values set by the Air
Quality Directive, failure to put in place adequate sampling points to properly monitor
NO2 concentrations and failure to make available a complete air quality report 135;
• Romania: systemic failure to monitor air pollution as required by EU legislation on
ambient air quality136;
• France: non-conformity of national legislation with the Directive on public access to
environmental information137;
• Croatia: non-conformity of the Croatian Water Act with the Environmental Impact
Assessment Directive, the Habitats Directive and the Water Framework Directive 138;
• Austria: failure to provide for a strategic environmental assessment of plans in the
energy sector as required by the Strategic Environmental Assessments Directive 139;
• Austria, Bulgaria, Croatia, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Greece, Hungary,
Luxembourg, Malta, the Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Slovenia, Slovakia and
Sweden: incorrect transposition of the revised Environmental Impact Assessment
Directive140;
• Austria: restrictions regarding access to justice in environmental procedures, not in
line with the Environmental Impact Assessment Directive141;
• Poland: failure to fully comply with the EU rules on reviewing environmental decisions
142;
• Ireland: failure to apply the Environmental Impact Assessment Directive to peat
extraction operations143;
• Croatia: non-conformity of national legislation with the Groundwater Directive144;
• Croatia: non-conformity of national legislation with the Drinking Water Directive 145;
• Luxembourg: incorrect transposition of the Environmental Quality Standards
Directive146;
• France: failure to comply with the Water Framework Directive concerning the
ecological continuity of the Rhine River147;
• Bulgaria, Cyprus, Ireland, Lithuania and Malta: late reporting on the environmental
status of marine waters under the Marine Strategy Framework Directive 148;
• Ireland: incorrect transposition of the Water Framework Directive149.
b) The Commission referred nine cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU. They concern:
133 Directive 2010/75/EU, INF/19/4251.
134 Directive 2008/50/EC, INF/19/4251, Commission v Poland, C-336/16.
135 Directive 2008/50/EC, MEMO/19/462.
136 Directives 2004/107/EC and 2008/50/EC, INF/19/4251.
137 Directive 2003/4/EC, MEMO/19/462.
138 Directives 2011/92/EU, 92/43/EEC and 2000/60/EC.
139 Directive 2001/42/EU, INF/19/4251.
140 Directive 2011/92/EU, as amended by Directive 2014/52/EU; INF/19/5950, MEMO/19/1472, INF/19/4251
and INF/19/6304.
141 Directive 2011/92/EU, INF/19/4251.
142 Directive 2011/92/EU, MEMO/19/1472.
143 Directive 2011/92/EU, INF/19/4251.
144 Directive 2006/118/EC, MEMO/19/1472.
145 Council Directive 98/83/EC, MEMO/19/1472.
146 Directive 2008/105/EC, INF/19/6304.
147 Directive 2000/60/EC, INF/19/4251.
148 Directive 2008/56/EC, INF/19/5950.
149 Directive 2000/60/EC, MEMO/19/462.
34
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Environment
• Bulgaria: exceedance of sulphur dioxide (SO2) limit values set by the Air Quality
Directive150;
• Greece: failure to establish the necessary conservation measures and objectives for
all sites designated as Special Areas of Conservation under the Habitats Directive 151;
• Spain: failure to take adequate measures to protect the groundwater bodies that feed
the Doñana wetlands and to prevent the deterioration of protected habitats in these
wetlands, in violation of the Water Framework Directive and the Habitats Directive 152;
• Spain: absence of flood risk management plans, required under the Floods Directive,
for all seven river basin districts in the Canary Islands153;
• Italy: failure to ensure that all agglomerations with a population of more than 2,000 are
provided with collecting systems for urban waste water and that urban waste water
entering collecting systems is adequately treated before discharge, as required by the
Urban Waste Water Treatment Directive154;
• Cyprus: lack of proper collection and treatment of urban waste waters of various
agglomerations in breach of the Urban Waste Water Directive155;
• Italy: exceedance of nitrogen dioxide (NO2) limit values set by the Air Quality
Directive156;
• Finland: illegal spring hunting of male eiders in the province of Åland, in violation of
the Birds Directive157;
• Austria: hunting of woodcock during its reproductive period in the Land of Lower
Austria, in breach of the Birds Directive158.
c) The Commission referred one case to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU. It concerns
• Greece: failure to comply with a Court judgment establishing that Greece had failed to
protect its waters against pollution caused by nitrates from agricultural sources159.
150 Directive 2008/50/EC, Commission v Bulgaria, C-730/19, IP/19/4256.
151 Directive 92/43/EEC, Commission v Greece, C-849/19, IP/19/4257.
152 Directives 2000/60/EC and 92/43/EEC, Commission v Spain, C-559/19, IP/19/466.
153 Directive 2007/60/EC, Commission v Spain, C-384/19, IP/19/465.
154 Directive 91/271/EEC, Commission v Italy, C-668/19, IP/19/1475.
155 Directive 91/271/EEC, Commission v Cyprus, C-248/19, IP/19/1474.
156 Directive 2008/50/EC, Commission v Italy, C-573/19, IP/19/1475.
157 Directive 2009/147/EC, Commission v Finland, C-217/19, IP/18/1446.
158 Directive 2009/147/EC, Commission v Austria, C-161/19, IP/18/3449.
159 Commission v Greece, C-298/19, MEMO/19/1472.
35
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Environment
V. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. New late transposition infringement cases (2015 -2019)
113
88
59
50
41
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy
sectors
59 new late transposition infringement cases in 2019
Waste
management
39
Air quality
12
Water protection and management
8
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a) The Commission opened 59 cases for late transposition in 2019. They included the:
• Directive concerning the indicative lists of elements to be taken into account for the
preparation of marine strategies160
• Directive establishing common noise assessment methods 161.
b) The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3)
TFEU.
160 Directive (EU) 2017/845.
161 Directive (EU) 2015/996.
36
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Environment
VI. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned mainly:
• Belgium: bad application of the Timber Regulation 162 by not carrying out a significant number of
verifications;
• Denmark: exceedances of the nitrogen dioxide (NO2) limit values set by the Air Quality
Directive163;
• Greece: failure to establish a general system for the protection of wild birds, prohibiting, in
particular, their deliberate killing through poison baits;
• Spain: trapping of five species of wild finches beyond the strict conditions set by EU rules on the
conservation of wild birds164;
• Croatia: incorrect transposition of the Habitats Directive 165;
• Croatia: incorrect transposition of the Birds Directive 166;
• Estonia, Hungary and Spain: incorrect transposition of the Directive on the protection of animals
used for scientific purposes167;
• Austria: incomplete Natura 2000 network;
• Poland: incorrect application of the Habitats Directive by authorising and commencing the
construction of a coal mine near Natura 2000 sites 168;
• Slovenia: incorrect transposition of the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Directive169;
• Slovakia: incorrect transposition and implementation of the Nitrates Directive170.
VII. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
The Court gave the following rulings:
• Ireland has failed to comply with an earlier Court judgment171 requiring a remedial
environmental impact assessment to be carried out for a large windfarm development in
Derrybrien. The Court ordered Ireland to pay a lump sum of €5,000,000 and a periodic
penalty payment of €15,000 for every day of delay until compliance is achieved172.
• Ireland has not complied with the requirements of the Urban Waste Water Treatment
Directive in multiple agglomerations as it had failed to put in place compliant waste water
collecting systems to tackle excessive spills from storm water overflows and failed to
provide adequate treatment of urban waste waters173.
• Spain has not adopted on time, as required by the Water Framework Directive, the second
round of river basin management plans for Lanzarote, Fuerteventura, Gran Canaria,
Tenerife, La Gomera, La Palma and El Hierro174.
162 Regulation (EU) n° 995/2010.
163 Directive 2008/50/EC.
164 Directive 2009/147/EC.
165 Directive 92/43/EEC.
166 Directive 2009/147/EC.
167 Directive 2010/63/EU.
168 Directive 92/43/EEC.
169 Directive 2011/92/EU.
170 Council Directive 91/676/EEC.
171 Commission v Ireland, C-215/06.
172 Commission v Ireland, C-261/18 and Court press release No 142/2019.
173 Directive 91/271/EEC, Commission v Ireland, C-427/17.
174 Commission v Spain, C-556/18.
37
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Environment
• France has systematically and persistently exceeded the limit values for nitrogen dioxide
(NO2) since 2010 in 12 agglomerations and air quality zones. It has also failed to take the
appropriate measures to keep the exceedance period as short as possible 175.
• Croatia has breached the Waste Framework Directive as it did not classify as waste a large
amount of stone-like material deposited in Biljane Donje, it did not take the necessary
measures to ensure that waste management is carried out without endangering human
health and harming the environment, and it did not ensure that the waste is properly
treated by the waste holder176.
• Italy has not fulfilled its obligations under the Landfill Directive as regards 44 landfills, by
having failed to adopt all measures necessary to close or to bring those landfill sites into
line with the Directive177.
• Portugal has failed to fulfil its obligations under the Habitats Directive as it had not
designated its Sites of Community Interest as Special Areas of Conservation and it had not
established the necessary conservation measures for these zones 178.
• The Court dismissed the Commission’s action against Czechia concerning its refusal to
ensure the take-back of 20,000 tonnes of a mixture called TPS-NOLO (Geobal) shipped
from Czechia to Poland. The Court found that the Commission did not provide sufficient
evidence that the respective mixture constitutes waste and, thus, that its shipment
constitutes a shipment of waste179.
• The Court dismissed the Commission’s action against Spain concerning the adoption
and/or revision of waste management plans. The Court found that the Commission had
prematurely opened the pre-litigation stage of the infringement procedure and,
consequently, dismissed the action as inadmissible180.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court gave the following preliminary rulings:
• Belgium: A decree by which a body of a Member State establishes, at regional level for its
Natura 2000 network, conservation objectives which have an indicative value whereas the
conservation objectives at site level have a statutory value is not a ‘plan or programme’,
within the meaning of the Strategic Environmental Assessment Directive, for which an
assessment under this Directive is mandatory181.
• Belgium: A decree whereby a Member State designates a Special Area of Conservation
and makes provision for conservation objectives and certain preventive measures is not a
‘plan or programme’, within the meaning of the Strategic Environmental Assessment
Directive, for which an assessment under this Directive is required182.
• Belgium: National courts have jurisdiction to review the choice of location of air quality
measuring stations and to take all necessary measures against the national authority
concerned. In assessing whether limit values have been complied with, the pollution level
at each sampling point must be taken into account individually183.
• Belgium: The Belgian law extending the operating life of nuclear power stations Doel 1 and
Doel 2 was adopted without the required environmental assessments being carried out
first. However, it is not excluded that the effects of the law on extension may provisionally
175 Commission v France, C-636/18 and Court press release No 132/2019.
176 Directive 2008/98/EC, Commission v Croatia, C-250/18.
177 Directive 1999/31/EC, Commission v Italy, C-498/17 and Court press release No 37/2019.
178 Commission v Portugal, C-290/18.
179 Commission v Czech Republic, C-399/17 and Court press release No 29/19.
180 Commission v Spain, C-642/18.
181 Directive 2001/42/EC, Terre wallonne, C-321/18.
182 Directive 2001/42/EC, CFE, C-43/18.
183 Craeynest and Others, C-723/17 and Court press release No 82/2019.
38
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Environment
be maintained where there is a genuine and serious threat of an interruption to electricity
supply184.
• Estonia: In the absence of criteria set at EU level to determine end-of-waste status for a
specific type of waste, such end status depends on the existence of criteria laid down in a
generally applicable national legal act concerning that type of waste 185.
• Germany: The coercive detention of a person at the head of the Land of Bavaria for the
purpose of enjoining them to adopt measures to improve ambient air quality in Munich can
be ordered only if a national legal basis, which is sufficiently accessible, precise and
foreseeable in its application, exists and if the detention is proportionate 186.
• Germany: Residues in the form of scrap metal and fire-extinguishing water mixed with
sludge and cargo residues, attributable to damage occurring on board a ship at sea, must
be regarded as waste generated on board ships, within the meaning of the Regulation on
shipments of waste. Such waste is, therefore, excluded from the said Regulation’s scope
until it is offloaded in order to be recovered or disposed of 187.
• Greece: When the public is not put in a position to actually participate in the environmental
impact assessment for a project, a time limit cannot be imposed on the public to bring
proceedings against the decision granting consent for the project 188.
• Italy: The Waste Framework Directive189 and the Directive on the promotion of the use of
energy from renewable sources190 do not prevent national legislation which refuses the
replacement of methane, as a power source for an electric power plant producing
atmospheric emissions, with a substance derived from the chemical treatment of used
vegetable oils, on the ground that the respective substance is not included in the list of
categories of biomass fuels authorised for that purpose 191.
• Italy: National legislation which classifies waste incineration facilities as ‘strategic
infrastructure and installations of major national importance’ is compatible with the ’waste
hierarchy’ principle under the Waste Framework Directive 192 as long as that legislation is
compatible with the other provisions of that Directive which lay down more specific
obligations. National legislation which revises upwards the capacity of existing waste
incineration facilities and provides for the construction of new installations of that kind
constitutes, within the meaning of the Strategic Environmental Assessment Directive 193, a
‘plan or programme’ likely to have significant environmental effects and must,
consequently, be subject to a prior environmental assessment 194.
• The Netherlands: The shipment to a third country of a consignment of electrical and
electronic appliances, initially intended for retail sale but returned by the consumer or sent
back by the retailer to its supplier, constitutes a ‘shipment of waste’ within the meaning of
the Regulation on shipments of waste read in conjunction with the Waste Framework
Directive, where that consignment contains appliances whose good working condition has
not been previously ascertained or which are not adequately protected from transport
damage. Such goods, which have become redundant in the seller’s product range and
184 Inter-Environnement Wallonie and Bond Beter Leefmilieu Vlaanderen, C-411/17 and Court press release No
100/2019.
185 Tallinna Vesi, C-60/18.
186 Deutsche Umwelthilfe, C-752/18 and Court press release No 164/2019.
187 Regulation (EC) No 1013/2006, Conti 11. Container Schiffahrt, C-689/17.
188 Flausch and Others, C-280/18 and Court press release No 137/2019.
189 Directive 2008/98/EC.
190 Directive 2009/28/EC.
191 Prato Nevoso Termo Energy, C-212/18.
192 Directive 2008/98/EC.
193 Directive 2001/42/EC.
194 Associazione "Verdi Ambiente e Società - Aps Onlus" and Others, C-305/18.
39
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Environment
which are in their unopened original packaging, must not, unless otherwise indicated, be
regarded as waste195.
• Austria: Natural and legal persons directly concerned by the pollution of groundwaters can
rely, before national courts, on certain provisions of the Nitrates Directive 196.
• Finland: Wolf hunting for population management purposes, the objective of which is to
combat poaching, is not compliant with the Habitats Directive where the strict conditions for
derogations from the protection system are not fulfilled. There are very strict limitations to
the use of derogations for the hunting of wolves and other large carnivores, and the
possibility to use hunting as a management tool for wolf conservation is very limited 197.
195 Regulation (EC) No 1013/2006 and Directive 2008/98/EC, Tronex, C-624/17.
196 Directive 91/676/EEC, Wasserleitungsverband Nördliches Burgenland and Others, C-197/18.
197 Directive 92/43/EEC, Luonnonsuojeluyhdistys Tapiola, C-674/17.
40
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Environment
VIII. OUTLOOK
Important implementation work in 2020 includes:
• continuing enforcement action to ensure full compliance with the Air Quality Directive 198 as
regards PM10 and nitrogen dioxide (NO2) limit values, addressing non-compliance in relation to
other pollutants, especially fine particulate matter (PM2.5) and benzo(a)pyrene, and continuing to
address shortcomings in monitoring and reporting under the Ambient Air Quality Directives 199.
• enhancing enforcement action addressing non-conformity with and bad application of the
National Emission Ceilings Directive200;
• giving follow up to the assessment of the second river basin management plans under the
Water Framework Directive to ensure good status for all water bodies by 2027 at the latest 201;
• action to ensure finalisation of the Natura 2000 network, by designating new protected areas
and adopting the necessary conservation objectives and measures;
• legal action to ensure that strategic noise maps and action plans pursuant to the Noise Directive
cover all agglomerations, major roads, major railways and major airports202;
• continuing action to ensure correct transposition of the revised Environmental Impact
Assessment203;
• pursuing cases concerning illegal landfills of waste;
• legal action to address incorrect transposition of the SEVESO III Directive204 and the Industrial
Emissions Directive205.
198 Directive 2008/50/EC.
199 Directives 2008/50/EC and 2004/107/EC.
200 Directive (EU) 2016/2284.
201 Directive 2000/60/EC.
202 Directive 2002/49/EC.
203 Directive 2011/92/EU, as amended by Directive 2014/52/EU.
204 Directive 2012/18/EU.
205 Directive 2010/75/EU.
41
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Financial stability, financial services and Capital Markets Union
Financial stability, financial services and Capital Markets Union
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints received from members of the public (2015 -2019)
155
139 135
88 86
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints open at year-end
110 ► Complaints open at end-2018
86 ► New complaints registered in 2019
86 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 110 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy sectors
86 complaints in 2019
Retail financial Capital markets
services and 19
payments
30
Free movement
of capital
14
Other
7
Insurance and
Banking pensions
4 12
42
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Financial stability, financial services and Capital Markets Union
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files (2015-2019)
42
12
6
1 2
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy sectors
6 EU Pilot files opened in 2019
Payments
2
Insurance and
pension funds
4
3. EU Pilot files open at year-end
There were 10 EU Pilot files open at end-2019.
4. EU Pilot files: policies’ combined resolution rate in 2015-2019
75% 77% 77%
72% 73%
80%
45%
62%
54% 50%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Environment General rate for all policy areas
43
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Financial stability, financial services and Capital Markets Union
III. OWN-INITIATIVE CASES
New own-initiative infringement cases
In 2019, the Commission opened own-initiative infringement cases over the incorrect transposition
of the Solvency II Directive206.
IV. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases open on 31 December (2015-2019)
230
226
172
144
116
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Infringement cases open on 31 December 2019: main policy sectors
116 infringement cases in 2019
Capital markets Retail financial
29 services
20
Banking
13
Other
Insurance and 14
pensions
40
206 Directive 2009/138/EC, INF/19/4251.
44
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Financial stability, financial services and Capital Markets Union
3. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy sectors
41 new infringement cases in 2019
Banking
13
Retail financial
services
Insurance and 4
pensions
24
4. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a) The Commission opened 41 new infringement cases in 2019. These, and other major
ongoing infringement cases, include the following:
• Bulgaria, Czechia, Germany, Ireland, Greece, Spain, France, Cyprus, Latvia,
Luxembourg, Malta, the Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Sweden and
Slovenia: non-communication of national measures transposing the Directive on the
activities and supervision of institutions for occupational retirement provision (IORPs II
Directive)207;
• Bulgaria, Ireland, Spain, France, Croatia, Cyprus, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland, Portugal,
Romania and Slovenia: non-communication of national measures transposing the
Bank Creditors Hierarchy Directive208;
• Belgium, Croatia, Poland, Estonia and Sweden: the incorrect transposition of the
Solvency II Directive209;
• Poland, Greece and Latvia: incorrect implementation of the SEPA Regulation 210;
• Cyprus: incorrect application of the Investor Compensation Scheme Directive 211;
• Romania: A national law sets limitations for the distribution of insurance products in
Romania by insurance distributors from other Member States, which is contrary to the
freedom to provide services212.
• Hungary: non-communication of transposition measures for the Mortgage Credit
Directive213;
• Greece: non-conformity of certain provisions with the third Motor Insurance
Directive214.
b) The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU.
c) The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.
207 Directive 2016/2341/EU.
208 Directive 2017/2399/EU.
209 Directive 2009/138/EC, INF/19/4251.
210 Regulation (EU) 260/2012, MEMO/19/1472.
211 Directive 97/9/EC, MEMO/19/1472.
212 INF/19/5950.
213 Directive 2014/17/EU, INF/19/4251.
214 Directive 2009/103/EC.
45
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Financial stability, financial services and Capital Markets Union
V. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. New late transposition infringement cases (2015 -2019)
125
116
84
30 30
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy
sectors
30 new late transposition infringement cases in 2019
Banking
12
Insurance and
pensions
17 Retail financial
services
1
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a) The Commission opened 30 cases for late transposition in 2019. Most of these concern
the:
• Bank Creditors Hierarchy Directive215
• IORPs II Directive216.
b) The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3)
TFEU.
215 Directive 2017/2399/EU.
216 Directive 2016/2341/EU.
46
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Financial stability, financial services and Capital Markets Union
VI. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019217
Some of the most important cases concerned:
• Bulgaria, Estonia, Greece, Spain, France, Croatia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Romania, Sweden
and Slovakia: failure to communicate national measures transposing the Markets in Financial
Instruments Directive (MiFID II)218 ;
• Croatia: national law on the privatisation of Industrija Nafte d.d. (INA): A law granting special
powers to the Croatian State in INA219.
• Slovakia and Lithuania: national legislation on the acquisition of agricultural land that violated
the free movement of capital and freedom of establishment220.
• Belgium, Spain, Cyprus, Malta, the Netherlands, Portugal and Slovenia: failure to communicate
national measures transposing the Mortgage Credit Directive 221;
• Austria, Belgium, Czechia and Croatia: incorrect transposition of the Solvency II Directive 222.
VII. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
The Court gave the following ruling:
Hungary: The Court ruled that by cancelling the rights of usufruct over agricultural land in its
territory that are held, directly or indirectly, by nationals of other Member States, Hungary has
failed to fulfil its obligations arising from the principle of the free movement of capital and the
right to property guaranteed by the Charter of Fundamental Rights. A Member State seeking
to justify a restriction of a fundamental freedom under the TFEU must also ensure compliance
with the fundamental rights guaranteed by the Charter of Fundamental Rights 223.
2. Preliminary rulings
There were no major preliminary rulings in 2019 in this area.
VIII. OUTLOOK
Important implementation work in 2020 includes:
• Monitoring the timely implementation of the fifth Anti-Money Laundering Directive224.
• Assessing the conformity of national transposition measures (or implementing measures in case
of Regulations) with a number of financial services directives and regulations. These include the
IORPs 2 Directive225, the Bank Creditors Hierarchy Directive226; the Payment Services
Directive227, the Insurance Distribution Directive228, the 4th Anti-Money Laundering Directive229,
the Prospectus Regulation230 and the Securitisation Regulation231.
217 Infringement cases related to the non-communication of the national measures of transposition of the 4th
Anti-Money Laundering Directive fell under the Directorate-General for Justice and Consumers until the end
of 2019 and can be found under its chapter. As of 2020, they have moved to the Directorate-General for
Financial Stability, Financial Services and Capital Markets Union.
218 Directive 2014/65/EU.
219 IP/17/1949.
220 MEMO/16/1823.
221 Directive 2014/17/EU.
222 Directive 2009/138/EC.
223 Case Commission v Hungary, C-235/17, EU:C:2019:432.
224 Directive 2018/843/EU.
225 Directive 2016/2341/EU.
226 Directive 2017/2399/EU.
227 Directive 2015/2366/EU.
47
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Financial stability, financial services and Capital Markets Union
• Ensuring that Member States take appropriate measures to implement the Achmea ruling 232. In
2020, the Member States are expected to terminate all their intra-EU bilateral investment
treaties, either by signing the plurilateral treaty for the termination of intra-EU bilateral
investment treaties or by terminating those treaties bilaterally.
228 Directive 2016/97/EU.
229 Directive 2015/849/EU.
230 Regulation (EU) 2017/1129.
231 Regulation (EU) 2017/2402.
232 Case Achmea, C-284/16.
48
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Health and food safety
Health and food safety
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints received from members of the public (2015 -2019)
198
120
109
94
74
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints open at year-end
73 ► Complaints open at end-2018
120 ► New complaints registered in 2019
107 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 86 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy sectors
120 complaints in 2019
Animal
welfare/animal
health
26
Public health
75
Food safety
19
49
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Health and food safety
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files (2015-2019)
17
9
2
1
0
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. EU Pilot open at year-end
At the end of 2019, 10 EU Pilot files remained open.
3. EU Pilot files: resolution rate for policies (2015 -2019)
100% 100%
91%
83% 83%
77% 77%
75%
72% 73%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Health and food safety General rate for all policy areas
III. OWN-INITIATIVE CASES
New own-initiative infringement cases
In 2019 the Commission opened own-initiative infringement cases over:
• patient rights under the Cross-border Health Directive233.
233 Directive 2011/24/EU.
50
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Health and food safety
IV. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases open on 31 December (2015-2019)
107
41
34
25 47
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Infringement cases open on 31 December 2019: main policy sectors
41 infringement cases in 2019
Food safety Plant health
31 5
Public health
5
3. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy sectors
60 new infringement cases in 2019
Food safety
46
Plant health
12
Public health
2
51
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Health and food safety
4. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a) The Commission opened 60 new infringement cases in 2019. These, and other major
ongoing infringement cases, include the following:
• The Netherlands and Austria: incorrect transposition of the Cross-border Health
Directive234; as these countries do not appear to reimburse patients who seek
healthcare in another Member State to the same level of the costs, if the healthcare
had been provided in these countries235;
• Czechia: systematic official controls targeting certain foodstuffs coming from another
Member State each time such foodstuffs enter Czechia, in breach of EU rules on
ensuring compliance with feed and food law, animal health and animal welfare
rules236;
• Ireland: non-communication of national measures transposing the Directives on
human tissues and cells237;
• Romania: failure to adopt fees for the processing of applications on biocidal products,
as required by EU rules. As a result, applications for the national authorisation of
biocidal products could not be processed238. [
b) The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU and under
Article 260(2) TFEU.
V. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. New late transposition infringement cases (2015-2019)
147
62
56
50
18
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy
sectors
There are 56 new late transposition cases, all concerning directives on food safety.
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
The Commission opened 56 cases for late transposition in 2019. Most concern the:
• Directive on the environmental risk assessment of genetically modified organisms 239
234 Directive 2011/24/EU.
235 Directive 2011/24/EU, MEMO-19-462.
236 Regulation (EC) No 882/2004, MEMO-19-462, INF-19-4251.
237 Directive (EU) 2015/565 and Commission Directive (EU) 2015/566), MEMO-19-462.
238 Regulation (EU) No 528/2012, MEMO-19-462.
52
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Health and food safety
• Directive on the establishment of harmonised risk indicators on sustainable use of
pesticides240
• Directive on protective measures against the introduction into the Community of organisms
harmful to plants241
• Directive setting out implementing measures as regards the characteristics to be covered
as a minimum by the examination and the minimum conditions for examining certain
varieties of agricultural plant species and vegetable species 242.
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
VI. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• Belgium and the United Kingdom: non-communication of national measures transposing the
Directive on extraction solvents used in the production of foodstuffs 243;
• Belgium, Cyprus, Latvia, Luxembourg, Portugal, Slovakia and the United Kingdom: non-
communication of national measures transposing the Commission Implementing Directive as
regards isolation distances for Sorghum spp.244 ;
• Bulgaria, Ireland, Cyprus, Luxembourg, Malta, the Netherlands, Romania; Slovakia and the
United Kingdom: non-communication of national measures transposing the Commission
Implementing Directive on minimum conditions for examining certain varieties of agricultural
plant species245;
• Czechia, Croatia, Spain and Sweden: non-communication of national measures transposing the
Directive on tobacco products246;
• Czechia, Denmark, Ireland, Hungary, Malta and Portugal: non-communication of national
measures transposing the Commission Implementing Directive on characteristics to be covered
as a minimum by the examination and the minimum conditions for examining certain varieties of
agricultural plant species247;
• Czechia, Denmark, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, Hungary, Malta and Portugal: non-
communication of national measures transposing the Commission Implementing Directive on
protective measures against the introduction into the Community of organisms harmful to
plants248;
• Ireland: non-communication of national measures transposing the Directives on human tissues
and cells249;
• Greece: shortage of staff assigned to the services responsible for veterinary controls;
• Portugal: measures to prevent the spread within the Union of the pine wood nematode.
239 Directive (EU) 2018/350.
240 Directive (EU) 2019/782.
241 Directive (EU) 2019/523.
242 Directive (EU) 2019/114.
243 Directive (EU) 2016/1855.
244 Directive (EU) 2018/1027.
245 Directive (EU) 2018/100.
246 Directive 2014/40/EU.
247 Directive (EU) 2019/114.
248 Directive (EU) 2019/523.
249 Directive (EU) 2015/565 and Directive (EU) 2015/566.
53
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Health and food safety
VII. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
The Court gave the following rulings:
• Italy failed to fulfil its obligations under the EU Directive on testing of human tissues and
cells by failing to adopt the required national transposition measures 250;
• Italy failed to adequately prevent further spread of the quarantined harmful organism
Xylella fastidiosa in Apulia251;
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court gave the following preliminary rulings:
• France: the Court held that the procedural rules applicable to the authorisation of plant
protection products, in particular products containing glyphosate, are valid; therefore, there
are no grounds to question the validity of the regulation on the placing of plant protection
products on the market252;
• France: The organic production logo of the EU cannot be placed on products derived from
animals that have been slaughtered in accordance with religious rites without first being
stunned. The organic logo of the EU aims to reassure consumers that products bearing it
have been obtained in observance of the highest standards, in particular in the area of
animal welfare253.
• Germany: the EU Regulation on shipments of waste254 does not apply to shipment mixtures
of animal by-products and other substances transported between Member States 255;
• The Netherlands: the meat after slaughter must be chilled in the slaughterhouse until it has
reached a temperature throughout of 7 °C before being loaded into a refrigerated truck 256
• United Kingdom: the marketing authorisation relied on in support of an application for a
supplementary protection certificate concerning a new formulation of an old active
ingredient, cannot be regarded as being the first marketing authorisation for the product
concerned as a medicinal product. This is the case where that active ingredient has
already been the subject of a marketing authorisation as an active ingredient. 257
VIII. OUTLOOK
Important implementation work in 2020 includes:
a) Monitoring the timely and correct implementation of Directives on:
- the manufacture, presentation and sale of tobacco and related products 258;
- the application of patients’ rights in cross-border healthcare259;
b) Following up on enforcement by national authorities of EU rules in the plant health sector, in
particular the monitoring of cases of Xylella fastidiosa;
250 Commission v Italy, C-481/18.
251 Commission v Italy, C-443/18
252 Procureur de la République v Blaise and Others, C-616/17.
253 Oeuvre d’assistance aux bêtes d’abattoirs, C-497/17 and Court press release 15/19.
254 Regulation (EC) No 1013/2006.
255 ReFood GmbH & Co. KG v Landwirtschaftskammer Niedersachsen, C-634/17.
256 T. Boer & Zonen BV v Staatssecretaris van Economische Zaken, C-98/18.
257 Abraxis Bioscience, C-443/17.
258 Directive 2014/40/EU.
259 Directive 2011/24/EU.
54
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Internal market, industry, entrepreneurship and SMEs
c) Following up on enforcement by national authorities of EU rules on pesticides and their
sustainable use260 and on animal welfare issues.
Internal market, industry, entrepreneurship and SMEs
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints received from members of the public (2015 -2019)
The Commission received 382 complaints from members of the public concerning the internal
market, industry, entrepreneurship and SMEs in 2019, compared with 627 in 2018 and 476 in
2017.
2. Public complaints open at year-end
733 ► Complaints open at end-2018
382 ► New complaints registered in 2019
682 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 433 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints register in 2019: main policy sectors
382 complaints in 2019
Services
102
Regulated
professions
130
Public
procurement
61
Industry sectors
23
Other Chemical and health
SME policy 12
43
11
260 Directive 2009/128/EC.
55
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Internal market, industry, entrepreneurship and SMEs
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files (2015-2019)
107 111
9
2 1
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. EU Pilot files open at year-end
At the end of 2019, 34 EU Pilot files remained open.
3. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy sectors
In 2019, the Commission opened one EU Pilot file in the area of services.
4. EU Pilot files: resolution rate for policies (2015 -2019)
75% 77% 77%
72% 73%
73%
74% 69%
62%
50%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Internal market, industry, entrepreneurship and SMES
General rate for all policy areas
III. OWN-INITIATIVE CASES
New own-initiative infringement cases
In 2019 the Commission opened own-initiative infringement cases over:
• points of single contact in services 261.
• recognition of professional qualifications 262.
• public procurement and concessions 263.
261 Directive 2006/123/EC and Directive 2005/36/EC, as amended by Directive 2013/55/EU.
262 Directive 2005/36/EC, as amended by Directive 2013/55/EU.
263 Directives 2014/23/EU, 2014/24/EU and 2014/25/EU.
56
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Internal market, industry, entrepreneurship and SMEs
• Penalty systems for industry sectors264.
264 Regulations 2016/424, 2016/425 and 2016/426.
57
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Internal market, industry, entrepreneurship and SMEs
IV. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases open on 31 December 2019
241
270
172
158
129
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Infringement cases open on 31 December 2019: main policy sectors
241 infringement cases in 2019
Public
Services procurement
53 46
Regulated
professions
Other 61
81
3. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy sectors
147 new infringement cases in 2019
Services
Public
39
procurement
33
Others
5
Space and
defence Regulated professions
9 30
Industrial policy and
innovation
11 Sustainable Industry and Mobility
20
58
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Internal market, industry, entrepreneurship and SMEs
4. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a) The Commission opened 147 new infringement cases in 2019. These, and other major
ongoing infringement cases, include the following:
• Bulgaria, Czechia, Denmark, Finland, Germany, Croatia, Italy, Cyprus, Hungary,
Poland, Romania, and Sweden: non-conformity of national legislation with EU rules on
public procurement and concessions265;
• Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, and Portugal: non-conformity of national legislation with EU
rules on public procurement and concessions266;
• Germany, France, Italy, Poland, Portugal, Austria, Sweden and the United Kingdom:
failure to award authorisations and concessions in the hydroelectric power sector in
line with the Services Directive and public procurement rules267;
• Bulgaria: a national law provision that defines the duration for the temporary cross-
border provision of services268;
• Bulgaria: restrictions on the temporary cross-border provision of private security
services269;
• Germany: rules on fixed prices for prescription medicines negatively affect the sale of
products by pharmacies established in other EU Member States in violation of Articles
34 and 36 TFEU 270;
• Germany: restrictions on the import of coffee in violation of the principle of the free
movement of goods271;
• Germany: non-conformity of national law with EU public procurement rules, forbidding
health insurance funds to use procurement procedures to obtain assistive medical
devices272;
• Germany: Application of the Directive on Mobile Air-Conditioning;273
• Greece: national legislation and administrative practice not complying with EU rules on
recognition of professional qualifications 274.
• Greece: the duration of the process for recognition of qualifications from other Member
States275.
• Croatia: restrictions for lawyers to provide multidisciplinary services, advertising
restrictions and limitations on the right to practice276;
• France: unjustified restrictions on providers of services related to energy efficiency, in
breach of the Services Directive277;
• Cyprus: specific rules concerning the access to activities of engineers and
architects278;
• The Netherlands: Dutch housing authorities are in breach of EU public procurement
rules, as they are not considered as contracting authorities279;
265 INF/19/6304, MEMO/19/462; Directives 2014/24/EU, 2014/25/EU and 2014/23/EU.
266 INF/19/5950; Directives 2014/24/EU, 2014/25/EU and 2014/23/EU.
267 IP/19/1477; Directives 2006/123/EC and 2014/23/EU.
268 INF 19/4251, Directive 2006/123/EC and Article 56 TFEU.
269 INF 19/4251, Article 56 TFEU.
270 MEMO/19/1472; Articles 34-36 TFEU and C-148/15.
271 MEMO/19/462.
272 INF/19/4251; Directive 2014/24/EU.
273 INF 19/4251, Directive 2006/40/EC.
274 INF 19/4251; Directive 2005/36/EC, as amended by Directive 2013/55/EU.
275 INF 19/4251; Directive 2005/36/EC, as amended by Directive 2013/55/EU.
276 IP 19/467, Directive 98/5/EC.
277 Directives 2006/123/EC, 2009/28/EC and 2012/27/EU.
278 IP 19/467, Directive 2013/55/EU.
279 MEMO/19/462; Directives 2014/23/EU and 2014/24/EU.
59
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Internal market, industry, entrepreneurship and SMEs
• Hungary: failure to comply with a judgment of the Court of Justice, in which the Court
ruled that Hungarian legislation on the provision of mobile payment services did not
comply with the principles of the freedom of establishment and the freedom to provide
services280;
b) Portugal: non-conformity of rules concerning the acquired rights of engineers281;The
Commission referred 2 cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU. They concern:
• Hungary: obstacles to retailers of imported agricultural and food products in breach of
EU law on the free movement of goods 282;
• Austria: breach of EU public procurement rules due to construction without prior
competition283.
c) The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.
V. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. New late transposition infringement cases (2016 -2019)
267
60
34
7
2016 2017 2018 2019
280 INF 19/4251, Directive 2006/123/EC.
281 IP 19/467, Directive 2005/36/EC.
282 Case Commission v Hungary, C-400/19.
283 Case Commission v Austria, C-537/19.
60
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Internal market, industry, entrepreneurship and SMEs
2. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy
sectors
34 new late transposition infringement cases in 2019
Space &
Defence
Innovation 9
11
Chemicals &
Health
2
Public
procurement
12
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
The Commission opened 34 cases for late transposition in 2019. They included the:
• Directive on electronic invoicing in public procurement284
• Directive on Trademarks285
• Directive on the list of defence-related products286.
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3)
TFEU.
VI. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned mainly:
• Belgium: incorrect application of EU rules concerning quantitative restrictions, by refusing
German commercial plates for trucks transiting via Belgium to other Member States 287.
• Belgium: incompatibility of Belgian advertising legislation in the health sector with EU
advertising rules288.
• Germany: incorrect application of the freedom of establishment and of the free provision of
services of other service providers due to reservation of certain approval services for some
types of motor vehicles in favour of certain technical testing centres289.
• Germany: incompatibility of national legislation with EU rules on national accreditation bodies 290;
284 Directive 2014/55/EU.
285 Directive 2015/2436/EU.
286 Directive 2019/514/EU amending Directive 2009/43/EC.
287 Article 34 TFEU.
288 Directive 2000/31/EC.
289 Directive 2007/46/EC.
290 Regulation (EU) 765/2008.
61
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Internal market, industry, entrepreneurship and SMEs
• Spain: obstacles to the free movement of food supplements291.
• Croatia: unjustified requirements imposed on the activities of driving schools 292
• Latvia: restrictions to registration of right hand drive cars 293.
• Czechia: non-conformity of national legislation with the Professional Qualifications Directive 294;
• Austria: incompatibility of the national legislation with the Remedies Directive 295;
• Poland: application of EU defence procurement rules296;
• Portugal: application of EU defence procurement rules297.
VII. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
• Germany: the Court ruled against Germany, which was in breach of EU law by maintaining
fixed tariffs for the planning services of architects and engineers 298.
• Germany: restricted the free movement of goods by introducing both an infrastructure-use
charge and relief from a motor vehicle tax for vehicles registered in Germany 299.
• Greece introduced illegal additional requirements to the training of mediators, in breach of
EU rules300.
• Italy: failed to publish a notice on the extension of a motorway concession, thus breaching
public procurement legislation301.
• Austria302 failed to fulfil its obligations under EU law by setting restrictions on the location of
seat, legal form and shareholding requirements for professional companies of architects,
engineers, patent attorneys, veterinarians303.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court gave the following preliminary rulings:
• Germany breached EU law by prohibiting commercial providers of search engines and
commercial service providers which edit content of online press products, from making
press products or parts of them available to the public 304.
• Greece: Greek legislation prohibiting a monk who has the status of lawyer in another
Member State from registering at the bar, on account of the incompatibility between the
status of monk and the profession of lawyer, is contrary to EU law 305.
• Lithuania: the Court clarified the conditions upon which in-house transactions concluded by
public authorities are compatible with EU public procurement legislation 306.
291 Article 34 TFEU.
292 Directive 2006/123/EC.
293 Directive 2007/46/EC.
294 Directive 2005/36/EC.
295 Directive 89/665.
296 Directive 2009/81/EC.
297 Directive 2009/81/EC.
298 Commission v Germany, Case C-377/17.
299 Austria v Germany, Case C-591/17.
300 Commission v Greece, Case C-729/17.
301 Commission v Italy, Case C-526/17.
302 Commission v Austria, Case C-209/18.
303 Directive 2006/123/EC.
304 VG Media, Case C-299/17.
305 Monachos Eirinaios, Case C-431/17 and Court press release No 56/2019.
306 Irgita, Case C-285/18.
62
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Internal market, industry, entrepreneurship and SMEs
• Hungary307: EU law does not require a national court to set aside domestic rules of
procedure conferring finality on a judgment, even if to do so would make it possible to
remedy a domestic situation which is incompatible with EU law.
• Hungary: Minor restrictive effects, provided they are neither too indirect nor too uncertain,
suffice to show the existence of a measure having equivalent effect within Article 35 TFEU.
Such a measure needs to be justified on grounds relating to the protection of public health,
and dispensing medicinal products on the basis of order forms other than nominative
medical prescriptions may undermine public health 308.
• Poland: National legislation cannot exempt commercial transactions financed with EU
funds from the scope of the Late Payments Directive 309.
• Poland: The issuance of a parallel import license cannot be conditional upon the imported
medicine and domestic reference products sharing the same ‘registration status’, whether
as reference or generic medicinal products. If the Member State of import can establish
that the imported medicine and domestic reference product, ‘without being totally identical’,
are manufactured with the same formulation, using the same active substance and have
the same therapeutic effects, then the imported product may be granted a parallel import
license on the basis of existing national marketing authorisation 310.
VIII. OUTLOOK
Important implementation work in 2020 includes:
• The Commission will continue to monitor the implementation of EU rules in the hydropower
sector.
• Building on the work already launched in 2019, the Commission will keep assessing compliance
of the measures adopted by the Member States to transpose the 2014 Public Procurement and
Concessions Directives. It should be noted that Spain still has to complete transposition for both
the Concessions and Utilities Directives (cases still pending before the Court) and that the
compliance check for the Concessions Directive for Slovenia, which was delayed due to late
transposition, still has to be completed.
307 Hochtief, Case C–620/17.
308 VIPA, Case C-222/18.
309 KROL, Case C-722/18.
310 Delfarma, Case C-387/18.
63
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Justice and consumers
Justice and consumers
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints received from members of the public (2015 -2019)
986
943
919
864
524
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints open at year-end
689 ► Complaints open at end-2018
986 ► New complaints registered in 2019
932 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 743 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy sectors
986 complaints in 2019
Free movement and citizenship rights
Other 176
79
Criminal law
Civil Justice and judicial
67 cooperation in
criminal matters
158
Consumer
legislation
76 Fundamental
rights
Rule of law and justice 144
system
89 Data protection Gender equality
95 102
64
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Justice and consumer
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files (2015-2019)
103
50
0 0 0
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. EU Pilot files open at year-end
At the end of 2019, 61 EU Pilot files remained open.
3. EU Pilot files: resolution rate for policies (2015 -2019)
96%
88%
80% 79%
75%
79%
77% 77%
72% 73%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Justice and Consumers General rate for all policy areas
III. OWN-INITIATIVE CASES
New own-initiative infringement cases
In 2019, the Commission opened own-initiative infringement cases over:
• The incorrect transposition of the Directive on criminal sanctions for market abuse 311;
• The violation of rule of law by the new disciplinary regime for judges in Poland;
• The non-compliance with obligations set by the Regulation establishing a European
Account Preservation Order procedure 312;
311 Directive 2014/57/EU.
312 Regulation (EU) No 655/2014.
65
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Justice and consumer
• The violation of free movement rights as regards the delivery of residence documents and
the rights of family members;
• Partial non-communication of the national measures of transposition of the 4th Anti-Money
Laundering Directive313.
IV. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases open on 31 December (2015-2019)
164
160
125
88
80
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Infringement cases open on 31 December 2019: main policy sectors
164 infringement cases in 2019
Judicial Criminal law
cooperation in 20
criminal matter
69
Consumer and
marketing law
19
Other Financial crime
38 18
313 Directive 2015/849/EU.
66
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Justice and consumer
3. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy sectors
78 new infringement cases in 2019
Company law
19
Criminal law
20
Others
14
Judicial
cooperation in
criminal matters
25
4. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
The Commission opened 28 new infringement cases in 2019.
These, and other major ongoing infringement cases, include the following:
• Bulgaria: inadequate protection of consumers against unfair terms in contracts, in
particular in payment order proceedings; certain creditors can obtain orders for
immediate enforcement quasi automatically, with very limited possibilities for the
consumers to prevent or challenge the enforcement based on unfair contract terms 314;
• France: the incorrect transposition of the free movement Directive 315 as regards the
delivery of residence documents 316;
• Austria, Bulgaria, Greece, Spain, Italy and France: incorrect transposition of the
Directive on criminal sanctions for market abuse 317;
• Poland: the new disciplinary regime for judges in Poland, which undermines the
judicial independence of Polish judges by not offering necessary guarantees to protect
them from political control318;
• Slovakia: Racial discrimination against Roma children in education 319.
The Commission referred one case to the Court under Article 258 TFEU.
The case concerned the violation of the rule of law principles and Article 19 TFEU by the
new disciplinary regime for judges in Poland320.
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.
314 MEMO/19/462.
315 Directive 2004/38/EC.
316 INF/19/4251.
317 Directive 2014/57/EU; INF/19/4251,
318 IP/19/1957.
319 INF/19/5950.
320 Commission v Poland, C-791/19, IP/19/6033.
67
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Justice and consumer
V. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. New late transposition infringement cases (2015 -2019)
66
41 52
30 34
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy
sectors
66 new late transposition infringement cases in 2019
Cooperation in
criminal justice
25
Criminal law
14
Others
8
Company Law
19
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
The Commission opened 66 cases for late transposition in 2019. Among the directives
concerned were the:
• Directive on shareholders’ rights 321;
• Directive on the fight against fraud to the Union's financial interests by means of
criminal law322;
• Directive on victims’ rights323;
• Directive on procedural safeguards for children who are suspects or accused persons
in criminal proceedings324;
321 Directive 2017/828/EU.
322 Directive 1371/2017/EU.
323 Directive 2012/29/EU.
324 Directive 2016/800/EU.
68
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Justice and consumer
• Data Protection Law Enforcement Directive325.
The Commission referred one case to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
The case concerned the failure to transpose the Data Protection Law Enforcement
Directive326 by Spain.
VI. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• Croatia, Italy, Portugal, Slovakia and Sweden: incorrect transposition of the Directive on
unfair commercial practices327;
• Spain: incompatibility of the Spanish procedural law with the Directive on unfair contract
terms and breach of Article 47 of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights (NIF
2015/2200)328;
• Austria and Poland: incorrect transposition of the Consumer Rights Directive 329;
• Belgium: incorrect application of EU rules concerning civil judicial cooperation and requiring
review procedures for the recognition of other Member States’ executive measures 330.;
• Croatia, Cyprus, Estonia, Germany, Greece, Luxembourg, Malta, Poland, Portugal,
Slovenia, and Spain: partial non-communication of the national measures of transposition
of the 4th Anti-Money Laundering Directive331.
VII. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
The Court gave the following rulings:
• Poland failed to fulfil its obligations under EU law, first, by establishing a different
retirement age for men and women who were judges or public prosecutors in Poland
and, second, by lowering the retirement age of judges of the ordinary courts while
conferring on the Minister for Justice the power to extend the period of active service
of those judges332.
• Poland failed to fulfil its obligations under EU law by lowering the retirement age of
judges of the Supreme Court333.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court gave the following preliminary rulings:
325 Directive 2016/680/EU.
326 Commission v Spain, C-658/19, IP/19/4261. The Commission has decided to refer Spain and ask both
for the payment of a daily penalty (EUR 89 548.20 per day) and a lump sum: EUR 21 321.00 per day,
with a minimum of EUR 5 290 000.
327 Directive 2005/29/EC.
328 Directive 93/13/EEC.
329 Directive 2011/83/EU.
330 Regulations (EC) No 805/2004, (EC) No 1896/2006 and (EC) No 4/2009.
331 Directive 2015/849/EU. Infringement cases related to the non-communication of the national measures
of transposition of the 4th Anti-Money Laundering Directive fell under the Directorate-General for
Justice and Consumers until the end of 2019. As of 2020, they have moved to the Directorate-General
for Financial Stability, Financial Services and Capital Markets Union.
332 Commission v Poland, C-192/18, Court press release No 134/19.
333 Commission v Poland, C-619/18; Court press release No 81/19.
69
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Justice and consumer
• Bulgaria: the Procedural Rights Directives 334 apply to judicial proceedings leading to
compulsory medical internment of persons having committed acts representing a
danger to society. Because of their mental state, these persons are to be considered
vulnerable persons for the purpose of the Directives. Persons suspected of having
committed a criminal offence must be informed of their rights as soon as possible
upon deprivation of liberty and, at the latest, before their first questioning by the police.
A Member State’s national legislation cannot prevent the exercise of the right to an
effective remedy in case of violation of the procedural rights protected by the
Directives 335.
• Germany: the Austrian system of issuing a European arrest warrant, in which both the
public prosecutor’s offices and the courts are involved, is compatible with EU law336.
• Germany: EU law does not designate directly, or by analogy, the law applicable to the
third-party effects of the assignment of claims337.
• Germany: the operator of a website that features a Facebook ‘Like’ button can be a
controller jointly with Facebook in respect of the collection and transmission to
Facebook of the personal data of visitors to its website 338.
• Germany: a pre-ticked box cannot be considered valid consent to the processing of
personal data. The information that the service provider must give to a user includes
the duration of the operation of cookies and whether or not third parties may have
access to those cookies339.
• Ireland: although a third-country national who is married to a Union citizen may lose a
right of residence in a Member State following the departure of the Union citizen from
the host Member State, the procedural safeguards laid down in the Free Movement
Directive apply to the expulsion of that third-country national from the host Member
State340.
• Ireland: an EU citizen who acquired in another Member State the status of worker for
the activity he pursued there for a period of 2 weeks before becoming involuntarily
unemployed retains this status for a further period of no less than 6 months. The
citizen must register as a jobseeker with the relevant employment office. Any
entitlement under national law to social security benefits or social assistance may be
conditional upon a specified period of employment, if the same condition is applicable
to nationals of the Member State concerned341.
• Ireland: the public prosecutor’s offices of a Member State, such as those of Germany,
which may be subject, directly or indirectly, to directions or instructions from the
executive, such as a Minister for Justice, in the issuing a European arrest warrant
cannot be regarded as an ‘issuing judicial authority’ 342.
• Ireland: the Prosecutor General of a Member State, such as that of Lithuania, whose
legal position affords him or her a guarantee of independence from the executive
when issuing a European arrest warrant, is an ‘issuing judicial authority’. When the
competent issuing judicial authority under national law is not itself a court, the decision
334 Directive 2012/13/EU, 2013/48/EU and 2016/343/EU.
335 EP, C-467/18.
336 NJ, C-489/19 PPU.
337 BNP Paribas, C-548/18.
338 Fashion ID, C-40/17.
339 Planet 49, C-673/17.
340 Directive 2004/38/EC; Nalini Chenchooliah v Minister for Justice and Equality, C-94/18.
341 Neculai Tarola v Minister for Social Protection, C-483/17.
342 OG and PI, C-508/18 and C-82/19.
70
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Justice and consumer
to issue such a European arrest warrant must be subject to court proceedings, which
meet the requirements of effective judicial protection343.
• Spain: the requirements stemming from the principles of effectiveness and ex officio
review of unfair contract terms apply also to proceedings for a European payment
order. Therefore, the courts seized with a request to issue a European order for
payment must request from the creditor additional information on the contract terms in
order to assess the possible unfairness of such terms344.
• Spain: immunity implies lifting the pre-trial detention measure imposed prior to the
election of the person concerned as member of the European Parliament, allowing
him or her to take part in the inaugural session of the European Parliament. However,
if the competent national court considers that the detention measure should be
maintained after that person has become member of the European Parliament, it
must, as soon as possible, request that the European Parliament waive that
immunity345.
• France: mortgage loans reserved for employees of an undertaking and granted for
private purposes fall within the scope of the Directive on unfair terms in consumer
contracts346. The Court confirmed that the notion of ‘seller or supplier’ has to be
interpreted broadly, and it is not necessary that the contract reflect a person’s main
activity347.
• France: the prohibition on processing certain categories of sensitive personal data
applies also to operators of search engines. The search engine operator has in
principle the obligation to de-reference, if asked by the person concerned. To this end,
the search engine operator must carry out a case-by-case assessment to verify if the
publication of the ‘sensitive’ data and personal data on criminal convictions is strictly
necessary to protect the freedom of information of internet users potentially interested
in accessing this web page by means of such a search 348.
• France: the right to be forgotten applies within the EU. Search engine operators have
to take sufficiently effective measures to ensure the effective protection of this right,
which does not necessarily apply outside the EU349.
• Latvia: the recording of a video of police officers in a police station while a statement is
being made, and the publication of that video on a video website on which users can
send, watch and share videos, are covered by the EU rules on data protection.
Further, such recording and such publication on a video website may constitute a
processing of personal data solely for journalistic purposes 350.
• Luxembourg and the Netherlands: the French public prosecutor’s office is regarded as
an ‘issuing judicial authority’, since the independence of French public prosecutors is
not called into question351.
• Poland: In a case concerning loan contracts concluded in Poland and indexed to a
foreign currency, the unfair contract terms relating to the difference in exchange rates
cannot be replaced by general provisions of Polish civil law in order to preserve the
validity of the contract352.
343 PF, C-509/19.
344 Bondora, C-453/18 and C-494/18.
345 Junqueras Vies, C-502/19.
346 Directive 93/13/EEC.
347 Pouvin Dijoux, C-590/17.
348 Google 2, C-136/17.
349 Google 3, C-507/17.
350 Buivids, C-345/17.
351 JR and YC, C-566/19 PPU and C-626/19 PPU.
352 Dziubak, C-260/18.
71
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Justice and consumer
• Poland: the lack of transparency of a contract term is an important element in the
assessment of its unfairness. The national courts must examine the unfairness of
contract terms. Thus, in payment order proceedings based on a promissory note,
national courts need to assess the promissory note agreement, even where national
law or case law does not permit this353.
• Poland: a notary who draws up a certificate of succession at the unanimous request of
all the parties to the procedure conducted by the notary does not constitute a ‘court’,
and consequently, such a deed does not constitute a ‘decision’ but an ‘authentic
instrument’354.
• Slovenia: when enforcing mortgages based on a directly enforceable notarial
instrument, the preventive checks by notaries cannot replace effective judicial
protection. Obstacles for effective remedies against such enforcement can be, for
instance, costs for legal representation, the absence of legal aid or strict conditions for
suspending the enforcement355.
• The United Kingdom: In assessing whether a Union citizen who is a minor has
sufficient resources not to become an unreasonable burden on the social assistance
system of the host Member State during his period of residence account is to be taken
of resources placed at his or her disposal stemming from income obtained from the
employment of his third-country national parent following the expiry of his residence or
work permit356.
• The United Kingdom: the concept of a ‘direct descendant’ of a citizen of the Union
does not include a minor who has been placed in permanent legal guardianship under
the Algerian kafala system, because that placement does not create any parent-child
relationship between them. However, where the EU citizen has exercised his/her right
to free movement to a Member State other than the one of which he/ she is a national,
the citizen’s Member State of residence must facilitate the minor’s entry to and
residence in its territory as one of the ‘other family members’ pursuant to the Free
Movement Directive357.
VIII. OUTLOOK
Important implementation work in 2020 includes:
• closely monitoring the application of the:
o General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) 358 and evaluation of the application of the
GDPR (Article 97 GDPR);
o Rule of law, notably Article 19(1) second subparagraph TEU and Article 267(2) and (3)
TFEU;
o Framework Decision on European arrest warrant 359.
• closely monitoring that Member States complete transposition of the:
o Directive on victims’ rights360;
o Directives related to procedural rights in the context of criminal justice 361;
353 Profi Credit Polska, C-419/18 and C-483/18.
354 WB, C-658/17.
355 Kuhar, C-407/18.
356 Bajratari, C-93/18.
357 Directive 2004/38/EC; SM v Entry Clearance Officer, UK Visa Section, C-129/18.
358 Regulation (EU) No 2016/679.
359 Council Framework Decision, 2002/584/JHA.
360 Directive 2012/29/EC.
72
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Justice and consumer
o Directive on shareholders’ rights 362.
• assessing that Member States correctly transpose the:
o Directive on criminal sanctions for market abuse363;
o Directive on the fight against fraud to the Union's financial interests by means of
criminal law364;
o Directive on the coordination and cooperation measures to facilitate consular protection
for unrepresented citizens of the Union in third countries365;
o Data Protection Law Enforcement Directive366;
o Directives on procedural rights in the context of criminal procedures 367;
o Directive on the interconnection of central, commercial and companies registers and the
Implementing Regulation368;
o Directive on package travel and linked travel arrangements 369.
• ensuring appropriate follow-up to the Court’s preliminary rulings on the:
o Directive on unfair terms in consumer contracts 370.
361 Germany, Greece, Croatia, Malta.
362 Directive 2017/828/EU.
363 Directive 2014/57/EU.
364 Directive 1371/2017/EU.
365 Directive 2015/637/EU.
366 Directive 2016/680/EU.
367 Directive 2010/64/EU, 2012/13/EU and 2013/48/EU.
368 Directive 2012/17/EU and Regulation (EU) No 2015/884.
369 Directive 2015/2302/EU.
370 Directive 93/13/EEC.
73
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2018 Annual Report
Maritime affairs and fisheries
Maritime affairs and fisheries
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints received from members of the public (2015 -2019)
12
12 12
8
6
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints open at year-end
8 ► Complaints open at end-2018
12 ► New complaints registered in 2019
14 ► Complaints handled in 2019
=6 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy sectors
12 complaints in 2019
Other
2
Fisheries
10
74
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Maritime affairs and fisheries
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU-Pilot files (2017-2019)
35
16 15
2 1
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy sectors
35 EU Pilot files opened in 2019
Engine power
verification system
15
Other
5
Follow up audit
Mitigation measures for
external fleet
cetacean's bycatch
7
8
3. EU Pilot files open at year-end
At the end of 2019, 36 EU Pilot files remained open.
75
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Maritime affairs and fisheries
4. EU Pilot files: policies’ combined resolution rate in 2015-2019
88%
100%
90% 75%
75% 77% 77%
72% 73%
50%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Maritime affairs and fisheries General rate for all policy areas
III. OWN-INITIATIVE CASES
New own-initiative infringement cases.
In 2019, the Commission did not open own-initiative infringement cases in this area.
IV. INFRINGEMENT CASES
Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
The Commission did not open new infringement cases in 2019 in this area.
Major ongoing infringement cases include the following:
• Denmark: failure to enforce several important provisions of the EU Control Regulation 371. The
Commission considers that Denmark fails to ensure that all fishery products are weighed at
landing and that mandatory catch registration documents record the quantities of each species
present, including industrial by-catches. The most serious issues concern fisheries for industrial
purposes. These deficiencies significantly undermine the accuracy of catch registration
documents, which are necessary for quota deduction purposes and to prevent overfishing. In
addition, Denmark does not ensure that the Commission is notified of the quantities of stocks
actually landed, with a consequent risk to the sustainability objectives of the common fisheries
policy372.
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU.
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.
V. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
They were no major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019 in this area.
371 Regulation (EC) No 1224/2009.
372 MEMO/19/462.
76
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Migration and home affairs
VI. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
There were no major Court rulings in 2019 in this area.
2. Preliminary rulings
There were no major Court preliminary rulings in 2019 in this area.
VII. OUTLOOK
Important implementation work in 2020 includes:
• following up on EU Pilot dialogues;
• following up on audits and investigations performed under the EU Control Regulation 373,
including addressing through action plans certain systemic irregularities in Member States’
fisheries control systems, where appropriate; monitoring the implementation of existing action
plans;
• following up on the implementation of the constituent components of the common fisheries
policy, such as the application of the landing obligation set out in the Common Fisheries Policy
Regulation374;
• taking action to ensure the correct transposition by the Member States of the Maritime Spatial
Planning Directive375.
Migration and home affairs
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints received from members of the public (2015 -2019)
212
151
137
100
90
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints open at year-end
156 ► Complaints open at end-2018
151 ► New complaints registered in 2019
373 Regulation (EC) No 1224/2009.
374 Regulation (EU) No 1380/2013.
375 Directive 2014/89/EU.
77
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Migration and home affairs
196 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 111 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy sectors
151 complaints in 2019
Asylum
31
Visa policy
Legal Pathways
12
and
Integration
33
Other
24
Police Cooperation and Borders and
Information Exchange Schengen
24 27
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files (2015-2019)
60
35
32
16
6
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. EU Pilot files open at year-end
At the end of 2019, 60 EU Pilot files remained open.
78
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Migration and home affairs
3. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy sectors
32 EU Pilot files opened in 2019
Information
Systems for
Borders,
Migration
and Security
1
Cybercrime
27
Legal Pathways
and
Integration
4
4. EU Pilot files: resolution rate for policies (2015 -2019)
81%
80% 77% 95%
72%
75% 77%
73%
65% 62%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Migration and Home Affairs General rate for all policy areas
III. OWN-INITIATIVE CASES
New own-initiative infringement cases
In 2019, the Commission opened own-initiative infringement cases regarding the:
• Directive on combating the sexual abuse and sexual exploitation of children 376;
• Directive on attacks against information systems377;
• Single Permit Directive378;
• Violation of the EU external exclusive competence;
• Return Directive379;
• Asylum Procedures Directive380;
376 Directive 2011/93/EU.
377 Directive 2013/40/EU.
378 Directive 2011/98/EU.
379 Directive 2008/115/EC.
79
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Migration and home affairs
• Accreditation of forensic service providers 381.
IV. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases open on 31 December (2015-2019)
145
138 139
129
109
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Infringement cases open on 31 December 2019: main policy sector
139 infringement cases in 2019
Legal Pathways
and Organised
Integration crime and
22 Drugs Policy
22
Police
Cybercrime Cooperation
27 and
Information
Exchange
22
Other
Asylum
23
23
359 Directive 2013/32/EU.
381 Framework Decision 2009/905/JHA.
80
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Migration and home affairs
3. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy sectors
58 new infringement cases in 2019
Police Cooperation
and
Information Exchange
5
Organised crime
and Legal Pathways and
Drugs Policy Integration
19 3
Asylum
4
Cybercrime
27
4. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a) The Commission opened 58 new infringement cases in 2019. These, and other major
ongoing infringement cases, include the following:
• Hungary: non-provision of food to persons held in the Hungarian transit zones at the
border with Serbia, in breach of the Charter of Fundamental Rights 382;
• Estonia: imposition of additional obligations on persons crossing the external EU
border, in breach of the Schengen Borders Code383;
• Romania: incorrect implementation of provisions relating to the rejection of
applications for residence permits and the obligation to justify the reasons for refusal
under the EU Directives on legal migration 384;
• Portugal: excessive and disproportionate fees for issuing residence permits 385;
• Sweden: incorrect transposition of several directives in the field of legal migration 386, in
particular as regards the processing applications for permits, as well as restrictions to
equal treatment of certain categories of non-EU nationals387;
• Spain388, Finland and the Netherlands 389: non-communication of national measures
transposing the Directive on the use of passenger name records 390;
• Greece391, Belgium, France, Sweden and Slovenia 392: non-communication of national
measures transposing the Directive on conditions of entry and residence of third-
country nationals for research and studies393;
382 IP/19/5994.
383 Regulation (EU) 2016/399 ; MEMO/19/462.
384 INF/19/4251.
385 INF/19/4251.
386 Directive 2011/98/EU; Directive 2003/86/EC, Directive 2003/109/EC, Directive 2009/50/EC, Directive
2014/36/EU, Directive 2014/66/EU.
387 INF/19/4251.
388 MEMO/19/462.
389 MEMO/19/1472.
390 Directive (EU) 2016/681.
391 MEMO/19/462.
392 INF/19/4251.
393 Directive 2016/801/EU.
81
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Migration and home affairs
• Greece and Luxembourg: non-communication of national measures transposing the
Directive on combating terrorism394;
• Austria, Bulgaria, Hungary and Romania: breach of the EU’s exclusive competence in
the automated exchange of DNA, fingerprint and vehicle registration data 395;
• Italy, Slovenia396, Bulgaria and Portugal397: incorrect implementation of the Directive
on Attacks against Information Systems398;
• Hungary, Poland and Slovenia: non-communication of national measures transposing
the Directive on standards for the qualification of third-country nationals as
beneficiaries of international protection399;
• Bulgaria and Spain: non-communication of national measures transposing the Asylum
Procedures Directive400;
• Lithuania401 and Slovenia402: non-communication of national measures transposing the
Reception Conditions Directive403;
• Bulgaria, Belgium, Czechia, France, Croatia, Germany, Spain, Portugal, Italy, Malta,
Lithuania, Sweden, Slovakia, Romania, Austria, Estonia, Greece, Finland, Hungary,
Luxembourg, Latvia, Poland and Slovenia: incorrect transposition of the Directive on
combating the sexual abuse and sexual exploitation of children 404.
394 Directive (EU) 2017/541; INF/19/4251.
395 INF/19/5950.
396 INF/19/4251.
397 INF/19/5950.
398 Directive 2013/40/EU.
399 Directive 2011/95/EU ; MEMO/19/462
400 Directive 2013/32/EU; INF/19/4251
401 INF/19/4251
402 INF/19/5950
403 Directive 2013/33/EU.
404 Directive 2011/93/EU, MEMO/19/462 INF/19/4251 and INF/19/5950.
82
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Migration and home affairs
b) The Commission referred two cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU. They concern:
• Hungary: exclusion of non-EU nationals with long-term resident status from exercising
the veterinary profession, in breach of EU legislation on long-term residence 405;
• Hungary: incorrect implementation of EU asylum rules by adopting legislation that
criminalises activities in support of asylum applications and further restricts the right to
request asylum406.
c) The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.
V. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. New late transposition infringement cases (2015 -2019)
50
48
39
23
17
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: policy sectors
23 new late transposition infringement cases in 2019
Organised crime and
Drugs Policy
19
Police Cooperation and
Information Exchange
Asylum 1
3
405 Case Commission v Hungary, C-761/19; IP/19/4260.
406 Case Commission v Hungary, C-821/19; IP/19/4260
83
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Migration and home affairs
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a) The Commission opened 23 cases for late transposition in 2019. They concern the:
• Psychoactive Substances Directive (EU) 407;
• Illicit Drugs Directive408;
• Directive on standards for the qualification of third-country nationals as beneficiaries of
international protection409;
• Asylum Procedures Directive410;
• Accreditation of Forensic Laboratories Framework Decision 411.
b) The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3)
TFEU.
VI. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• Belgium, Czechia, Germany, the Netherlands, Poland, Portugal, Slovenia and Slovakia: non-
communication of national measures transposing the Seasonal Workers Directive 412;
• Greece and the Netherlands: disproportionate charges for the issuance of residence permits;
• Poland and Slovenia: non-communication of national measures transposing the Directive on
standards for the qualification of third-country nationals as beneficiaries of international
protection413;
• Cyprus, Spain and Poland: non-communication of national measures transposing the Directive
on conditions of entry and residence of third-country nationals for research and studies414;
• Greece, Slovenia and Austria: non-communication of national measures transposing the Long-
Term Residents Directive415;
• Bulgaria, Spain, France, Poland and Slovenia: non-communication of national measures
transposing the Directive on standards for the qualification of third-country nationals as
beneficiaries of international protection416;
• Austria, Belgium, Bulgaria, Cyprus, Czech Republic, Germany, Estonia, Greece, Spain, France,
Luxembourg, Latvia, Malta, Poland, Romania and Sweden: non-communication of national
measures transposing the Reception Conditions Directive 417;
• Belgium, Cyprus, Czechia, Germany, Estonia, Greece, France, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Latvia,
Malta, Poland, Romania, Sweden, Slovenia, Bulgaria, Germany and Latvia: non-communication
of national measures transposing the Asylum Procedures Directive 418;
407 Directive (EU) 2019/369.
408 Directive(EU) 2017/2103.
409 Directive 2011/95/EU.
410 Directive 2013/32/EU.
411 Framework Decision 2009/905/JHA.
412 Directive 2014/36/EU.
413 Directive 2011/95/EU ; MEMO/19/462
414 Directive 2016/801/EU.
415 Directive 2011/51/EU.
416 Directive 2011/95/EU; INF/19/4251.
417 Directive 2013/33/EU; INF/19/4251.
418 Directive 2013/32/EU.
84
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Migration and home affairs
• Portugal and Croatia: failure to meet EU obligations on stepping up cross-border cooperation,
particularly in combating terrorism and cross-border crime419.
VII. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings 420
There were no major Court rulings in 2019 in this area.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court gave the following preliminary rulings:
• Belgium: if within 6 months the national authorities have not decided on the application for
family reunification, they cannot automatically issue a residence permit to the applicant as
they have to establish whether the applicant meets the requirements for residence in the
host Member State in accordance with EU law 421.
• Belgium: in case of serious breaches of the rules of the accommodation centres, as well as
violent behaviour by an applicant, a Member State cannot provide for a sanction consisting
in the withdrawal, even temporary, of material reception conditions relating to housing, food
or clothing in so far as it would have the effect of depriving the applicant of the possibility of
meeting his or her most basic needs 422.
• Czechia and Belgium: The formal recognition of the status of refugee implies that the
refugee concerned is a beneficiary of international protection for the purpose of the
Qualification Directive so that he is entitled to all the rights and benefits provided for in this
Directive. This Directive contains both rights equivalent to those set out in the Geneva
Convention and rights providing greater protection which have no equivalent in that
Convention423.
• Germany: an applicant ‘absconds’ within the meaning of the Dublin Regulation if he
deliberately evades the reach of the national authorities in order to prevent the transfer. It
may be presumed that that is the case if the transfer cannot be carried out due to the fact
that the applicant has left the accommodation allocated to him without informing the
competent national authorities, provided that he has been informed of his obligations in that
regard424.
• Ireland: the fact that a Member State, designated as responsible for the examination of an
application for international protection pursuant to the rules set out in the Dublin
Regulation, has notified its intention to withdraw from the European Union in accordance
with Article 50 TEU does not oblige the Member State with which the application was
lodged to itself examine the application.425.
• Hungary: Member States may authorise the family reunification of a refugee’s sister only if
she is, on account of her state of health, unable to provide for her own needs, provided that
that inability is assessed having regard to the special situation of refugees and at the end
of a case-by-case examination taking into account all the relevant factors, and that the
refugee is providing the material support required 426.
419 Council Decisions 2008/615/JHA and 2008/616/JHA.
420 These rulings are almost exclusively handed down on infringement procedures.
421 X, Case C-706/18
422 Zubair Haqbin, Case C-233/18
423 M and Others, Joined cases C-391/16, C-77/17 et C-78/17
424 Abubacarr Jawo, Case C-163/17
425 M.A. and Others, Case C-661/17
426 TB, Case C-519/18
85
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Migration and home affairs
• The Netherlands: the Member State can withdraw residence permits from family members
of a third-country national who have obtained their permits further to submitting falsified
documents. The fact that the beneficiaries of those permits were unaware of the fraud is
irrelevant 427.
• The Netherlands: an EU country may withdraw the supplementary benefit to a Turkish
national who returns to Turkey and who holds, at the date of his departure from the host
EU country, long-term resident status428.
• The Netherlands: applications for family reunification by a beneficiary of international
protection cannot be rejected solely on the ground of the fact that the sponsor has not
provided official documentary evidence of the death of the minor’s biological parents and,
consequently, that the sponsor has an actual family relationship with the minor, without
taking into consideration the specific circumstances of the sponsor and the minor and the
particular difficulties they have encountered before and after fleeing their country of
origin429.
•
The Netherlands: the competent authorities may, on grounds of public policy, reject an
application for entry and residence on the basis of a criminal conviction imposed during a
previous stay on the territory of that Member State concerned; in addition, they could
withdraw a residence permit or refuse to renew it where a sentence sufficiently severe in
comparison with the duration of the stay has been imposed on the applicant provided that
the offence which warranted the criminal conviction is sufficiently serious to establish that it
is necessary to rule out residence of that applicant and that those authorities carry out an
individual assessment430.
• The Netherlands: national authorities may issue a return decision to a third-country national
not subject to a visa requirement, who is present on the territory of the Member States for a
short stay; such a decision could be justified if that national is considered to be a threat to
public policy because he or she is suspected of having committed a criminal offence,
provided that the offence is sufficiently serious in the light of its nature and of the
punishment which may be imposed, to justify that national’s stay on the territory of the
Member States being brought to an immediate end and, second, those authorities have
consistent, objective and specific evidence to support their suspicions 431.
• Austria: a Member State which granted subsidiary protection status when the conditions for
granting it were not met based on incorrect facts must revoke it; the fact that the person
concerned cannot be accused of having misled the Member State is irrelevant 432.
• The United Kingdom: a third-country national who in the past has been tortured by the
authorities of his or her country of origin but no longer faces a risk of being tortured if
returned to that country, but whose physical and psychological health could, if so returned,
seriously deteriorate, leading to a serious risk of him committing suicide on account of
trauma resulting from the torture he was subjected to, is eligible for subsidiary protection.
This is the case if there is a real risk of this person being intentionally deprived, in his or her
country of origin, of appropriate care for the physical and mental after-effects of that
torture433.
427 Y.Z. and Others, Case C-557/17
428 M. Çoban, Case C-677/17
429 E, Case C-635/17
430 G.S. and V.G., Joined Cases C-381/18 and C-382/18.
431 EP, Case C-380/18.
432 Mohammed Bilali, Case C-720/17
433 MP, Case C-353/16.
86
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Migration and home affairs
VIII. OUTLOOK
Important implementation work in 2020 includes:
• closely monitoring that Member States transpose on time the:
• Directive on combating money laundering by criminal law434;
• assessing that Member States correctly and completely transpose and implement the:
o Directives on seasonal workers and on intra-corporate transfer435;
o Directives on asylum procedures and on reception conditions436;
o Directive against trafficking in human beings 437;
o Directive on standards for the qualification of third-country nationals as beneficiaries of
international protection438;
o Directive on the freezing of proceeds of crime and confiscation of assets439;
o Directive against sexual exploitation of children 440;
o Directive on attacks against information systems 441;
o Directive on the conditions of entry and residence of third-country nationals for the purposes
of research, studies, training, voluntary service, pupil exchange schemes or educational
projects and au pairing442;
o Directive on the use of passenger name record data for the prevention, detection,
investigation and prosecution of terrorist offences and serious crime 443;
o Directive on combating terrorism444;
o Directive on new psychoactive substances445.
• ensuring appropriate follow-up to the Court’s preliminary rulings on, among other things, data
retention446.
434 Directive (EU) 2018/1673.
435 Directives 2014/36/EU and 2014/66/EU.
436 Directives 2013/32/EU and 2013/33/EU.
437 Directive 2011/36/EU.
438 Directive 2011/95/EU.
439 Directive 2014/42/EU.
440 Directive 2011/93/EU.
441 Directive 2013/40/EU.
442 Directive 2016/801/EU.
443 Directive 2016/681/EU.
444 Directive 2017/541/EU.
445 Directive (EU) 2017/2103.
446 Tele2 Sverige, C-203/15 and C-698/15.
87
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Mobility and transport
Mobility and transport
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints received from members of the public (2015 -2019)
193
173
161
155
135
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints open at year-end
93 ► Complaints open at end-2018
161 ► New complaints registered in 2019
86 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 168 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy sectors
161 complaints in 2019
Road safety
Road transport
53
28
Passengers
rights
22
Other
58
88
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Mobility and transport
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files (2015-2019)
123
106
5 4 8
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. EU Pilot files open at year-end
At the end of 2019, 18 EU Pilot files remained open.
3. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy sectors
8 EU Pilot files opened in 2019
Ports
1
Aviation policy
1
Road safety
3
Maritime transports and
logistics
1
Road transport
2
4. EU Pilot files: resolution rate for policies (2015 -2019)
84%
76% 75%
73%
77% 77%
75%
72% 71%
57%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Mobility and transport General rate for all policy areas
89
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Mobility and transport
III. OWN-INITIATIVE CASES
New own-initiative infringement cases
In 2019, the Commission opened own-initiative infringement cases over:
• Sustainable transport:
o Deployment of the interoperable EU-wide e-Call service447;
o Information services for safe and secure parking places for trucks and commercial
vehicles448.
• Road sector:
o Interconnection of the national electronic registers to the European Registers of Road
Transport Undertakings (ERRU) messaging system 449;
o Tachographs in road transport450;
o European Electronic Toll Service (EETS) and its technical elements 451;
o Minimum requirements for controlling compliance by drivers and road transport operators
regarding driving and resting times and on the use of tachographs 452.
• Road safety:
o Incorrect implementation of the Directive on minimum safety requirements for tunnels in the
trans-European road network453;
o Failure to submit the comprehensive report as provided by the Directive on cross-border
exchange of information on road safety-related traffic offences454.
• Rail sector:
o Non-compliance with the Directive establishing a single European railway area 455;
o Incorrect implementation of EU legislation on railway safety 456;
o Lack of submission of national implementation plans on the technical specifications for
interoperability of the rail system457.
• Maritime sector:
o Training of seafarers458;
o Marine equipment459.
447 Decision 585/2014/EU.
448 Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 885/2013.
449 Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) 2016/480.
450 Regulation (EU) No 165/2014.
451 Commission Decision 2009/750/EC.
452 Directive 2006/22/EC.
453 Directive 2004/54/EC.
454 Directive 2015/413/EU.
455 Directive 2012/34/EU.
456 Directive 2004/49/EC, Commission Regulation (EU) No 1158/2010, Commission Regulation (EU)1077/2012.
457 Commission Regulation (EU) No 1300/2014, Commission Regulation (EU) 2015/995.
458 Directive 2008/106/EC.
459 Directive 2014/90/EC.
90
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Mobility and transport
IV. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases open on 31 December (2015 -2019)
241 248 244
191 203
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Infringement cases open on 31 December 2019: main policy sectors
203 infringement cases in 2019
Rail sector
44
Other
92
Road safety
43
Road transport
24
3. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy sectors
83 new infringement cases in 2019
Other
5
Road transport
20 Rail sector
36
Road safety
22
4. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a) The Commission opened 83 new infringement cases in 2019. These, and other major
ongoing infringement cases, include the following:
91
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Mobility and transport
• Belgium, Cyprus, Czechia, Germany, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, Hungary, Italy,
Malta, the Netherlands, Portugal, Romania, Slovakia, Spain and the United Kingdom:
failure to upgrade the connection of their national electronic registers on road hauliers
to the new version of European Registers of Road Transport Undertakings (ERRU) 460;
• Belgium, Bulgaria, Croatia, Italy and Spain: failure to comply with minimum safety
requirements for tunnels in the trans-European road network461;
• Bulgaria and Malta: incorrect application of the Directive on marine equipment 462;
• Denmark, France, Germany, Ireland, the Netherlands, Poland and Spain: failure to
fulfil the obligations under the EU rules establishing a single European railway area463;
• Belgium: failure to comply with the Directive on the minimum level of training of
seafarers464;
• Belgium: incorrect implementation of the Airspace Regulation and the Regulation on
common rules for the flexible use of airspace 465;
• Belgium: incorrect implementation of the Directive on driving licences 466;
• Germany: failure to comply with the principles of fair and non-discriminatory
remuneration for European Electronic Toll Service providers 467;
• Greece: failure to comply with the minimum requirements of control on driving and
resting times, and on the use of tachographs 468;
• Spain: incorrect implementation of EU legislation on railway safety 469;
• Hungary: failure to put in place effective penalties for infringements related to the use
of tachographs in road transport470;
• Hungary: non-implementation of technical requirements and administrative procedures
related to air operations 471.
• Poland: incorrect application of common rules for access to the international market
for coach and bus services472;
b) The Commission referred three cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU. They
concern:
• Bulgaria: failure to transpose and comply with EU rules on railway safety as regards
the independence of the investigating body473;
• Austria: failure to comply with several provisions of the Train Drivers Directive474;
• Ireland: failure to correctly implement EU law establishing the fundamental principles
governing the investigation of accidents in the maritime transport sector 475.
c) The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.
460 Regulation (EU) 2016/480, INF/19/4251, INF/19/5950, INF/19/6304.
461 Directive 2004/54/EC, INF/19/5950.
462 Directive 2014/90/EU, INF/19/4251 and INF/19/5950.
463 Directive 2012/34/EU, INF/19/5950, MEMO/19/462, INF/19/4251,
464 Directive 2008/106/EC, INF/19/4251.
465 Regulation (EC) No 2150/2005, Regulation (EC) No 551/2004, MEMO/19/1472.
466 Directive 2006/126/EC, INF/19/5950.
467 Commission Decision 2009/750/EC, INF/19/4251.
468 Directive 2006/22/EC, Regulation (EC) No 561/2006, Regulation (EU) 165/2014, MEMO/19/1472.
469 Directive 2004/49/EC, MEMO/19/462.
470 Regulation (EU) No 165/2014, INF/19/4251.
471 Commission Regulation (EU) Nº 965/2012, INF/19/5950.
472 Regulation (EC) No 2009/1073, MEMO/19/462.
473 Directive 2004/49/EC, Commission v Bulgaria, C-33/19, IP/18/6252.
474 Directive 2007/59/EC, Commission v Austria, C-796/19, IP/19/4262.
475 Directive 2009/18/EC, Commission v Ireland, C-257/19, IP/18/4492.
92
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Mobility and transport
V. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. New late transposition infringement cases (2015 -2019)
129
94
54
45
38
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy
sectors
45 new late transposition infringement cases in 2019
Rail sector
31
Road safety
14
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a) The Commission opened 45 cases for late transposition in 2019. They concerned the:
• amending Directive concerning the opening of the market for domestic passenger
transport services by rail and the governance of the railway infrastructure 476
• Single European Railway Area Directive 477
• Directive on the interoperability of the rail system within the European Union 478
• Railway Safety Directive479
• directives amending the Directive on inland transport of dangerous goods 480.
476 Directive (EU) 2016/2370.
477 Directive 2012/34/EU.
478 Directive (EU) 2016/797.
479 Directive (EU) 2016/798.
480 Commission Directive (EU) 2018/217, Commission Directive (EU) 2018/1846.
93
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Mobility and transport
b) The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3)
TFEU.
VI. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These included the following:
• Croatia, Cyprus, Czechia and the United Kingdom: failure to provide the required quality
management system for operational parts of the flag State-related activities481;
• Germany and the Netherlands: incorrect transposition of the Driving Licences Directive 482;
• Belgium and Sweden: incorrect application of the provisions on access to the groundhandling
market at EU airports483.
• Italy and Malta: incorrect application of the Directive on the minimum level of training of
seafarers484;
• Czechia: non-compliance of national legislation with the provisions of the Train Drivers
Directive485;
• Denmark: incorrect implementation of the Combined Transport Directive486;
• Greece: incorrect implementation of EU rules on civil aviation security487;
• Hungary: failure to submit the national implementation plans required by EU legislation on the
technical specifications concerning accessibility of the Union's rail system for persons with
disabilities and persons with reduced mobility, and the operation and traffic management of
rail systems488;
• Portugal: incorrect implementation of EU legislation on the investigation of accidents in the
maritime sector489;
VII. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
The Court gave the following rulings:
• Germany: failed to fulfil its obligations under EU law, at the 25th session of the Revision
Committee of the Intergovernmental Organisation for International Carriage by Rail, by
having voted against the position of the EU, and having publicly opposed that position and
the arrangements for the exercise of voting rights 490.
• Poland: failed to fulfil its obligations under the Directive on weights and dimensions in
national and international traffic. The restrictions set on access to the Polish road network
481 Directive 2009/21/EC.
482 Directive 2006/106/EC, as amended by Directive (EU) 2015/653.
483 Directive 96/67/EC.
484 Directive 2008/106/EC, as amended by Directive 2012/35/EU.
485 Directive 2007/59/EC.
486 Directive 92/106/EEC.
487 Regulation (EC) No 300/2008.
488 Regulations (EU) No 1300/2014 and (EU) No 2015/995.
489 Directive 2009/18/EC.
490 Decision 2014/699/EU, Commission v Germany, C-620/16.
94
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Mobility and transport
for vehicles complying with the maximum axle weights laid down in the Directive are not
justified491.
491 Directive 96/53/EC, Commission v Poland, C-127/17.
95
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Mobility and transport
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court gave the following preliminary rulings:
• Belgium: The closure of an airport runway due to petrol spillage constitutes an
‘extraordinary circumstance’ when the petrol in question does not originate from an aircraft
of the carrier operating that flight. It is a circumstance that could not have been avoided
even if all reasonable measures had been taken492.
• Belgium: When a passenger boards a train without a ticket, he concludes a contract with
the carrier. This covers the situation where access to the train is free493.
• Czechia: Connecting flights that are the subject of a single reservation departing from a
Member State to a non-Member State via another non-Member State: the air carrier of the
first flight is, in principle, liable to pay compensation to passengers who suffered a long
delay in the arrival of the second flight performed by a non-Community air carrier494.
• Germany: An exception from the use of tachographs does not apply to vehicles used for
the carriage of live animals directly from farms to local slaughterhouses 495.
• Germany: A Member State may refuse to recognise a driving licence which has been
issued by another Member State, without a test of fitness to drive, on the basis of a driving
licence issued by another Member State based on the exchange of a driving licence
issued by a third country496.
• Germany: The direct award of contracts for public passenger transport services by bus
that do not take the form of service concessions is not subject to the Regulation on public
passenger transport services by rail and road 497.
• Germany: An air carrier is only required to compensate passengers for a long delay
caused by damage to an aircraft tyre if it fails to prove that it deployed all means at its
disposal for limiting the delay of the flight498.
• Germany: The system of airport charges is to be approved by an independent supervisory
authority and must be mandatory for all airport users 499.
• Germany: Exception from the application of certain social legislation covers only vehicles
that are used exclusively, during a particular transport operation, for the purpose of
delivering items as part of the universal postal service 500.
• Italy: The provisions of the Regulation on public passenger transport services by rail and
road, which govern the award of public service contracts, do not apply to award
procedures carried out before 3 December 2019501.
492 Regulation (EC) No 261/2004, Moens, C-159/18.
493
Regulation (EC) No 1371/2007, joined cases: Kanyeba, C-349/18, Nijs, C-350/18, Dedroog, C-351/18 and
Court press release No 136/2019.
494 České aerolinie, C-502/18 and Court press release No 95/2019.
495 Regulation (EC) No 561/2006, Regulation (EU) No 165/2014, NK, C-231/18.
496 Directive 2006/126/EC, Meyn, C-9/18.
497 Regulation (EC) No 1370/2007, joined cases: Verkehrsbetrieb Hüttebräucker and BVR Busverkehr
Rheinland, C-266/17 and Rhenus Veniro, C-267/17, Court press release No 46/2019.
498 Regulation (EC) No 261/2004, Germanwings, C-501/17 and Court press release No 45/2019.
499 Directive 2009/12/EC, Deutsche Lufthansa, C-379/18.
500 Regulation (EC) No 561/2006, joined cases: Deutsche Post and Leymann, C-203/18 and UPS Deutschland
and Others, C-374/18.
501 Regulation (EC) No 1370/2007, joined cases: Mobit, C-350/17 and Autolinee Toscane, C-351/17.
96
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Mobility and transport
• Italy: The jurisdiction of a Member State court with respect to rights of passengers in the
event of denied boarding and of cancellation or a long delay of flights must be assessed in
light of the Regulation on jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of judgments in
civil and commercial matters502.
• Italy: National legislation providing for the automatic termination of the employment
relationship at the age of 60 for aircraft pilots engaged in activities associated with
protecting the national security of a Member State is compatible with EU law if it is
necessary for public security and does not go beyond what is necessary to achieve this
objective503.
• Italy: National authorities which intend directly to award a public service contract for the
transport of passengers by rail are not required to publish or communicate to any
interested economic operators all the information necessary in order to enable them to
submit a sufficiently detailed offer which may be subject to a comparative assessment, or
to carry out such an assessment of all bids that may have been received following
publication of that information504.
• Hungary: A Member State is acting in breach of EU law if it imposes lesser penalties to
resident road transport enterprises than to non-resident road transport enterprises for
infringements to the rules on the use of tachographs that have the same degree of
gravity505.
• The Netherlands: Passengers who have the right to hold their tour organiser liable for
reimbursement of the cost of their air tickets cannot also claim reimbursement of the cost
of those tickets from the air carrier506.
• Austria: An airline is liable for the harm caused by a spilt cup of hot coffee. It is not
necessary for that accident to relate to a hazard typically associated with flight507.
• Austria: Workers providing services on board international trains, pursuant to a contract
concluded between their employer and an undertaking established in another Member
State, are not posted workers if they carry out a significant part of the work inherent to
those services in the Member State where their employer is established and if they begin
or end their shifts there508.
• Austria: The use of passenger platforms is part of the ‘minimum access package’ under
the Single European Railway Directive, and infrastructure managers are required to make
them available to all train operators 509.
• Romania: The amount of the compensation provided by EU rules for cases of denied
boarding or cancellation of a flight is not intended to compensate for damage such as loss
of earnings, and that damage may be the subject of further compensation. In case of
denied boarding, it is the responsibility of the operating air carrier to provide complete
502 Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012, Guaitoli, C-213/18.
503 Regulation (EU) No 1178/2011, Directive 2000/78/EC, Cafaro, C-396/18.
504 Regulation (EC) No 1370/2007, Autorità Garante della Concorrenza e del Mercato, C-515/18.
505 Regulation (EU) No 165/2014, UTEP 2006, C-600/18.
506 Aegean Airlines, C-163/18 and press Court release No 91/2019.
507 Niki Luftfahrt, C-532/18 and Court press release No 163/2019.
508 Directive 96/71/EC, Dobersberger, C-16/18.
509 Directive 2012/34/EU, WESTbahn Management, C-210/18.
97
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Mobility and transport
information to passengers on their right to reimbursement or re-routing. The passengers
have no obligation to actively contribute to the search for information to that effect510.
510 Regulation (EC) No 261/2004, Rusu, C-354/18.
98
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Mobility and transport
VIII. OUTLOOK
Important implementation work in 2020 includes:
• Monitoring and assessing national measures transposing the Directives on:
o railway safety511;
o the opening of the market for domestic passenger transport services by rail and the
governance of the railway infrastructure512;
o the rail sector513;
o safety rules and standards for passenger ships 514;
o registration of persons sailing on board passenger ships and reporting formalities for
ships515;
o inspections for the safe operation of roll-on roll-off passenger ships and high-speed
passenger craft516.
• Closely monitoring restrictions to market access and development of sustainable transport and
safety and security in all modes of transport.
511 Directive 2016/798.
512 Directive 2016/2370.
513 Directives 2012/34/EC and 2016/2370/EU.
514 Directive (EU) 2017/2108.
515 Directive (EU) 2017/2109.
516 Directive (EU) 2017/2110.
99
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Taxation and customs union
Taxation and customs union
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints received from members of the public (2015-2019)
423
406
378
350
308
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints open at year-end
331 ► Complaints open at end-2018
350 ► New complaints registered in 2019
321 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 360 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy sectors
350 complaints in 2019
Indirect taxation - others
Indirect taxation 58
- VAT
66 Customs
36
Indirect taxation - excise
duties
14
Indirect taxation -
energy taxation
3
Indirect taxation
- car taxation Direct taxation
73 100
100
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Taxation and customs union
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files (2015-2019)
106
90
18 18
10
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. EU Pilot files open at year-end
At the end of 2019, 35 EU Pilot files remained open.
3. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy sectors
18 EU Pilot files opened in 2019
Indirect taxation Indirect taxation
- VAT - excise duties
5 2
Direct taxation
1
Customs
10
101
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Taxation and customs union
4. EU Pilot files: resolution rate for policies (2015 -2019)
88%
77%
79% 80%
77%
75% 75%
72% 73%
69%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Taxation and customs General rate for all policy areas
III. OWN-INITIATIVE CASES
New own-initiative infringement cases
In 2019, the Commission opened own-initiative infringement cases on the:
• Directive on tax dispute resolution mechanisms in the European Union 517;
• Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive (ATAD1) 518;
• Directive on value-added tax obligations for supplies of services and distance sales of goods 519;
• Directive on the treatment of vouchers 520.
IV. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases open on 31 December (2015-2019)
118
108 106
100
90
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
517 Directive (EU) 2017/1852.
518 Directive (EU) 2016/1164.
519 Directive (EU) 2017/2455.
520 Directive (EU) 2016/1065.
102
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Taxation and customs union
2. Infringement cases open on 31 December 2019: main policy sectors
3. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy sectors
65 new infringement cases in 2019
Direct taxation
39
Indirect taxation -
excise duties…
Customs
Indirect taxation 1
- car taxation
3 Indirect taxation - VAT
20
4. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a) The Commission opened 65 new infringement cases in 2019. These, and other major
ongoing infringement cases, include the following:
• Germany: national rules on VAT for distance sales of goods sold through digital
marketplaces521;
• Germany: Impossibility to fulfil formal requirements for qualifying as a group company
for German tax consolidation purposes522;
• Greece: Payment of a fee by importers of medical devices, which has an equivalent
effect to a customs duty pursuant to Article 30 TFEU;
• Spain: Obligation to appoint a fiscal representative in Spain523;
• Spain: Incorrect application of the Merger Directive 524;
521 IP/19/5950.
522 IP/19/4251.
523 IP/19/4251.
524 IP/19/462.
103
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Taxation and customs union
• Italy: Preferential taxation on property for Italians abroad525;
• Hungary: Discriminatory tax treatment of foreign foundations 526;
• Portugal: heavier taxation on used cars imported from other Member States than on
used cars purchased on the national market in breach of Article 110 TFEU527;
• Romania: time limit for the notification of customs debts;
• Finland: legislation on tax deductibility of group contributions between affiliated
domestic companies in breach of freedom of establishment 528.
b) The Commission referred six cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU, namely the
following:
• Spain: failure to fulfil obligations under Articles 21, 45, 56 and 63 TFEU, and Articles
28, 31, 36 and 40 of the EEA Agreement as regards certain features of the obligation
to provide information on assets located abroad (Modelo 720) 529;
• Germany: rejecting certain applications for VAT refunds for businesses in other
Member States530.
• Italy: failure to comply with the rules on the taxation of energy products and electricity
by applying in regional legislation a reduction to excise duty for petrol and gas oil used
as motor fuel531.
• Hungary: failure to apply an excise duty on cigarettes below the minimum EU
threshold of 60% of the applicable weighted average retail price, despite the end of
the transitional period allowed for the gradual increase of that duty 532;
• Austria: failure to correctly apply the special VAT scheme for travel agents 533;
• United Kingdom: extending the scope of a VAT derogation for certain commodity
markets534;
c) The Commission referred one case to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.
• Belgium: failure to comply with a judgment of the Court of Justice in which the Court
had found that Belgian provisions for rental income are in breach of EU law 535.
525 IP/19/462.
526 IP/19/1472.
527 INF/19/6304.
528 IP/19/1472.
529 Case C-788/19 Commission v Spain, IP/19/2774.
530 Case C-371/19 Commission v Germany.
531 Case C-63/19 Commission v Italy.
532 Case C-856/19 Commission v Hungary.
533 Case C-787/19 Commission v Austria.
534 Case C-276/19 Commission v United Kingdom.
535 Case C-842/19 Commission v Belgium.
104
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Taxation and customs union
V. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. New late transposition infringement cases (2015 -2019)
47
34
16 14
11
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy
sectors
47 new late transposition infringement cases in 2019
Indirect
taxation - VAT
16
Direct taxation
31
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
The Commission opened 47 cases for late transposition in 2019. They included the:
• Directive on value-added tax obligations for supplies of services and distance sales of
goods536;
• Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive (ATAD1)537;
• Directive on tax dispute resolution mechanisms in the European Union 538;
• Directive on the treatment of vouchers 539.
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
VI. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
536 Directive (EU) 2017/2455.
537 Directive (EU) 2016/1164.
538 Directive (EU) 2017/1852.
539 Directive (EU) 2016/1065.
105
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Taxation and customs union
These concerned the following:
• Belgium, Czechia, Greece, France, Cyprus, Latvia, Portugal and the United Kingdom: Non-
communication of national measures transposing the Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive (ATAD1)540;
• Czechia, Greece, Poland and Romania: Non-communication of national measures transposing
the Directive as regards access to anti-money laundering information (DAC5) 541;
• Belgium: Taxation of redistributed income in the form of dividends;
• Bulgaria: Customs duty relief for certain US goods in breach of the Community system of
reliefs from customs duty542;
• Bulgaria: Proportionality of sanctions for not declaring the movement of cash in breach of
controls of cash entering or leaving the Community543;
• Czechia: Non-conform implementation of the Directive as regards mandatory automatic
exchange of information in the field of taxation (DAC2) 544;
• Estonia: Non-conform implementation of the Directive on administrative cooperation in the
field of taxation (DAC1)545;
• Italy: Fast Customs Corridors regarding compliance with Articles 139, 144 and 148(5) of the
Union Customs Code546;
• Latvia: Discriminatory taxation of real estate in Riga City;
• Lithuania: Non-communication of national measures transposing the Directive on tax dispute
resolution mechanisms in the European Union547.
• Hungary: Discriminatory taxation of spirit drinks in violation of Article 110 TFEU by exempting
from the public health tax fruit distillates and herbal drinks produced predominantly on its
territory;
VII. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
The Court gave the following ruling:
• Greece: The Court of Justice ruled that Greece’s application of a reduced excise duty rate
on the spirit drinks, Tsipouro and Tsikoudia, produced by systematic distilleries, as well as
the application of a super-reduced rate to those spirits produced by small occasional
distillers, are both incompatible with EU law548.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court gave the following preliminary rulings:
• Denmark: The Court of Justice clarified that EU law cannot be relied on for abusive or
fraudulent objectives. In such cases, national authorities and courts must refuse a taxpayer
the exemption from withholding tax on profits distributed by a subsidiary to its parent
540 Directive (EU) 2016/1164.
541 Directive 2016/2258/EU.
542 Regulation (EC) 1186/2009.
543 Regulation (EC) 1889/2005.
544 Directive 2011/16/EU.
545 Directive 2014/107/EU.
546 Regulation (EU) 952/2013.
547 Directive 2017/1852/EU
548 Case C-91/18 Commission v Greece, EU:C:2019:600.
106
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Taxation and customs union
company, even if there are no domestic or agreement-based provisions providing for such
a refusal549.
• Germany: the Court of Justice clarified that the VAT exemption for school and university
education does not cover driving school tuition provided by a driving school for the purpose
of acquiring driving licences for vehicles in categories B and C1, even if the objective of
such tuition is not purely recreational, since possession of such licences is liable to meet,
among other things, professional needs550.
• Germany: The Court of Justice clarified that customs authorities may require that an
applicant for the status of an ‘authorised economic operator’ provide them with the tax
identification numbers concerning solely the natural persons who are in charge of the
applicant or who exercise control over its management and those who are in charge of the
applicant’s customs matters, and the details of the tax offices responsible for the taxation of
all those persons551.
• Germany: The Court of Justice clarified that legislation of a Member State which effectively
taxes dividends paid to foreign pension funds at a higher rate than dividends paid to
domestic pension funds is contrary to the free movement of capital as established by
Article 63 TFEU552.
• Germany: Where EU customs regulations require providing a specific indication of the
country of origin for a product (in this case, cultivated mushrooms that had been relocated
during the growing process), the country of origin is that where the product was harvested
and that indication as such cannot be regarded as misleading consumers. In such
circumstances, no obligations may be imposed on the food business operators to provide
information additional to the indication of the country of origin in order to prevent any
alleged risk of misleading consumers553.
• Latvia: The Court of Justice clarified that where the customs value of goods, such as the
medicinal products at issue in the dispute in the main proceedings, is calculated by
applying the deductive method (this is one of the methods used for calculating the customs
value), the competent national customs administration must, in order to identify ‘similar
goods’, take into account any relevant element.554.
• Lithuania: The Court of Justice clarified that the exemption from excise duty applies to
denatured ethyl alcohol contained in cosmetics or mouthwashes which are nevertheless
consumed as alcoholic beverages, although not intended for human consumption, even if
the importer of products from another Member State labelled them with a view to
increasing the sales555.
• Lithuania: The Court of Justice held that Member States should tax as cigars or cigarillos
tobacco products with an outer wrapper of natural tobacco partially covered, at the filter, by
an additional paper layer, which may make them visually similar to cigarettes556.
VIII. OUTLOOK
Important implementation work in 2020 includes:
Indirect taxation:
549 Joined cases C-116/16 and C-117/16 Skatteministeriet v T Danmark and Y Denmark Aps, EU:C:2019:135
550 Case C-449/17 A & G Fahrschul-Akademie, EU:C:2019:202.
551 Case C-496/17 Deutsche Post AG v Hauptzollamt Köln, EU:C:2019:26.
552 Case C-641/17 College Pension Plan of British Columbia, EU:C:2019:960.
553 Case C-686/17 Zentrale zur Bekämpfung unlauteren Wettbewerbs Frankfurt am Main, EU:C:2019:659.
554 Case C-1/18 SIA Oribalt Rīga v Valsts ieņēmumu dienests, EU:C:2019:519.
555 Case C-567/17 Bene Factum, EU:C:2019:158.
556 Case C-638/17 Skonis ir kvapas, EU:C:2019:316.
107
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Taxation and customs union
• focus on infringements with a strong impact on ensuring fair and effective taxation and the
climate and health objectives of the EU;
• monitoring cases affecting the economic situation of businesses or aiming at removing
distortions of competition in the internal market.
Direct taxation:
• assess the conformity of national measures with EU rules on exchange of information on
taxation. This will concern in particular the Directives on:
o the automatic exchange within the EU of information relative to financial income, including
dividends and capital gains, and account balances 557;
o the mandatory automatic exchange of information in the field of taxation558;
o country-by-country reporting of information by multinationals to tax authorities 559;
o access to anti-money laundering information560;
o mandatory automatic exchange of information in the field of taxation in relation to reportable
cross-border arrangements561.
• assess the conformity of national rules against tax avoidance and practices that directly affect
the functioning of the internal market562;
• assess the conformity of national rules on tax dispute resolution mechanisms in the EU 563.
Customs:
• carry out a series of monitoring activities in cooperation with the Member States to help them
implement the Union Customs Code, which now has been applicable for more than 3 years;
• focus on cases and subject matters where there is a significant financial impact and where it is
considered that our exclusive competence in the area of customs needs to be defended.
557 Directive 2014/107/EU.
558 Directive 2015/2376/EU.
559 Directive 2016/881/EU.
560 Directive 2016/2258/EU.
561 Directive 2018/0822/EU.
562 Directive 2016/1164/EU.
563 Directive 2017/1852/EU.
108
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Methodology and explanations
I. METHODOLOGY AND EXPLANATIONS
ANNEX I — POLICY AREAS
1. Complaints
First chart: New complaints received from members of the public (2015-2019)
This shows the number of public complaints the Commission registered in the given policy
field in 2015-2019.
Second chart: Public complaints open at year-end
This starts with the number of open complaints at the end of 2018 (first line) 564. The second
line shows the number of new complaints registered in 2019. The third line shows the number
of complaints on which the Commission took a decision in 2019. The fourth line shows the
number of complaints open at the end of 2019 (calculated by taking the first figure, adding the
second and subtracting the third).
Third chart: New complaints registered in 2019: main policy sectors
The number of registered complaints for the current reporting year is broken down by policy
sector. In general, this breakdown shows the three policy sectors in which the most complaints
were received in 2019. Four (or more) policy sectors are mentioned if two (or more) policy
sectors attracted the third highest number of complaints. The number of sectors covered
varies according to the breadth of each policy area.
2. EU PILOT
First chart: New EU Pilot files (2015-2019)
This shows the number of EU Pilot files the Commission opened in the given policy area in
2015-2019.
Second chart: New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy sectors
The number of new EU Pilot files opened in the current reporting year is broken down by
policy sector. This breakdown shows the three policy sectors in which the most EU Pilot files
were opened in 2019.
Third chart: EU Pilot files: resolution rate for policies in 2015-2019
The resolution rate in the given policy field is the percentage of EU Pilot files handled in that
field for which the Commission accepted the Member States’ responses. The chart shows the
resolution rate for the last 5 years.
564 In some instances a difference between the figures from the preceding annual report may be due to
delayed, double or erroneous registration at the moment of extracting statistical data.
109
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Methodology and explanations
3. OWN-INITIATIVE CASES
New own-initiative cases
This section contains a list of the most important infringement cases the Commission
launched in the given policy area in 2019. The list is not exhaustive.
4. INFRINGEMENT CASES
First chart: Infringement cases opened on 31 December (2015-2019)
These figures include all procedures the Commission initiated in the policy area by sending a
letter of formal notice under Article 258 TFEU. It covers letters sent in 2019 or before,
irrespective of the stages the cases have reached. Only cases which have not yet been closed
by a formal decision are shown.
Accordingly, this number includes all cases that, on 31 December of the years 2014 to 2019:
• were in the pre-litigation phase (letter of formal notice, reasoned opinion or decision on
referral to the Court under Article 258 TFEU);
• were pending before the Court under Article 258 TFEU and Article 260(3) TFEU;
• the Court had ruled on but where the Commission could not yet confirm that the Member
State had implemented the judgment correctly:
• were in the second pre-litigation procedure (letter of formal notice or referral decision under
Article 260(2) TFEU);
• were pending before the Court due to a second referral; and
• the Court had ruled on for the second time but where the Commission could not yet confirm
that the Member State had implemented the second judgment correctly.
This figure does not include, for example, open EU Pilot files in the policy area. It also does
not include EU Pilot files for which the Commission had already rejected a Member State’s
response but had not yet sent a letter of formal notice under Article 258 TFEU.
Second chart: Infringement cases open on 31 December 2019: main policy sectors
This shows, for the given policy area, the sectors in which the most infringement cases were
still open on 31 December 2019. The number of sectors shown varies according to the
breadth of each policy area.
Third chart: New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy sectors
This shows, for the given policy area, the sectors in which the most infringement cases were
launched in 2019.
Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
This section has three parts:
Part a) shows the number of new infringement cases launched in the policy area in 2019 and
lists the most important new cases under Article 258 TFEU.
110
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Methodology and explanations
Part b) lists the cases which the Commission referred to the Court solely under Article 258
TFEU by 31 December 2019. The cases submitted to the Court under Article 258 and 260(3)
TFEU are discussed in the ‘transposition of directives’ section (see below).
Part c) contains the cases which the Commission referred to the Court under Article 260(2)
TFEU by 31 December 2019.
5. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
First chart: New late transposition infringement cases (2015-2019)
This shows the number of letters of formal notice sent to Member States under Article 258
TFEU for missing or partial notification of national measures transposing directives in the
given policy area. This figure is already included in the total number of new infringement cases
initiated in the policy area in 2019, so it should not be added to the figure shown in the first
chart of the general statistics section.
Please note that not all of these new infringement cases for late transposition were
necessarily still open on 31 December 2019. For example, if the Commission opened a late
transposition infringement procedure in March 2019 by sending a letter of formal notice, this
would be added to the new infringement cases even if the Commission closed the case in
October 2019 as a result of the Member State notifying complete transposition.
Second chart: New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy sectors
This shows the policy sectors in which the most late transposition procedures were launched
in 2019.
Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
This section has two parts:
Part a) lists, for the given policy area, the most important directive(s) over which the
Commission had to launch infringement procedures against a relatively high number of
Member States.
Part b) lists the cases which the Commission referred to the Court under Article 258 TFEU and
Article 260(3) by 31 December 2019.
6. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
This section contains a list of the most important infringement cases the Commission closed in
the given policy area in 2019 without a Court judgment. The list is not exhaustive.
7. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
This section contains two lists:
• The first list contains the Court’s most important judgments in the given policy area in 2019.
These judgments are almost exclusively handed down under Article 258 or Articles 260(2)
TFEU.
111
Monitoring the Application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Methodology and explanations
• The second list contains the most important preliminary rulings that the Court issued to the
Member State’s judiciary in the given policy area.
These lists are not necessarily exhaustive.
112
Council of the
European Union
Brussels, 1 September 2020
(OR. en)
10363/20
ADD 3
JUR 391
INST 178
COVER NOTE
From: Secretary-General of the European Commission,
signed by Mr Jordi AYET PUIGARNAU, Director
date of receipt: 31 July 2020
To: Mr Jeppe TRANHOLM-MIKKELSEN, Secretary-General of the Council
of the European Union
No. Cion doc.: SWD(2020) 147 final
Subject: COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT Part III: Member States
Accompanying the document Report from the Commission Monitoring
the application of European Union law 2019 Annual Report
Delegations will find attached document SWD(2020) 147 final.
Encl.: SWD(2020) 147 final
10363/20 ADD 3
EN
EUROPEAN
COMMISSION
Brussels, 31.7.2020
SWD(2020) 147 final
PART 3/4
COMMISSION STAFF WORKING DOCUMENT
Part III: Member States
Accompanying the document
Report from the Commission
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
{COM(2020) 350 final}
EN EN
Belgium .................................................................................................................................................... 2
Bulgaria.................................................................................................................................................. 10
Czechia .................................................................................................................................................. 17
Denmark ................................................................................................................................................ 24
Germany ................................................................................................................................................ 30
Estonia ................................................................................................................................................... 39
Ireland .................................................................................................................................................... 45
Greece ................................................................................................................................................... 52
Spain...................................................................................................................................................... 59
France.................................................................................................................................................... 68
Croatia ................................................................................................................................................... 75
Italy ........................................................................................................................................................ 81
Cyprus ................................................................................................................................................... 89
Latvia ..................................................................................................................................................... 95
1
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Belgium
Belgium
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints made against Belgium by members of the public (2015-2019)
134
126
106
101
92
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints against Belgium open at year-end
125 ► Complaints open at end-2018
92 ► New complaints registered in 2019
116 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 101 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy areas
92 complaints made against Belgium
Taxation and
customs
28
Justice and
consumers
16
Other
39
Mobility and
transport
9
2
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Belgium
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files opened against Belgium (2015-2019)
34
30
7 7
3
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: policy areas
7 EU Pilot files opened against Belgium
Martime affairs and fisheries
2
Environment
1
Taxation and
customs union
2
Migration and
home affairs
Energy 1
1
3. Files relating to Belgium open in EU Pilot at year-end
52
48
36
19 18
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Belgium
4. EU Pilot files: Belgium’s resolution rate in 2015-2019
86%
78% 77%
75%
72%
77%
73%
70% 71%
59%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Belgium General rate for all Member States
III. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases against Belgium open on 31 December (2015-2019)
87
81
79
69
65
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
33 new infringement cases against Belgium
Mobility and
transport
6
Energy
Environment
4
10
Internal market, industry,
entrepreneurship and
SMEs
3
Health and food
Other safety
7 3
4
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Belgium
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a. The Commission opened 33 new infringement cases against Belgium in 2019. These,
and other major ongoing infringement cases, include:
• incorrect transposition of the:
o Directive on combating the sexual abuse and sexual exploitation of children 1
o Solvency II Directive 2
o Directive on driving licences 3
o Airspace Regulation and the Regulation on common rules for the flexible use
of airspace 4
o Directive on the minimum level of training of seafarers 5;
• non-compliance with key provisions of the Noise Directive 6;
• failure to protect waters from nitrates pollution 7;
• failure to submit information about operators of essential services identified
under the EU law on the security of network and information systems 8;
• non-compliance with the requirements of the Energy Efficiency Directive 9;
• failure to adopt a national programme for the implementation of spent fuel and
radioactive waste management policy that is compliant with the requirements of
the Radioactive Waste Directive 10;
• failure to upgrade the connection of their national electronic registers on road
hauliers to the new version of European Registers of Road Transport
Undertakings (ERRU) 11;
• failure to comply with minimum safety requirements for tunnels in the trans-
European road network 12;
• non-communication of national measures transposing the
o Directive on conditions of entry and residence of third-country nationals for
research and studies 13
o Indirect Land Use Change Directive 14
o Directive amending the Oil Stocks Directive as regards the methods for
calculating stockholding obligations 15
o Basic Safety Standards Directive 16.
1
Directive 2011/93/EU, INF/19/5950.
2
Directive 2009/138/EC, INF/19/4251.
3
Directive 2006/126/EC, INF/19/5950.
4
Regulation (EC) No 2150/2005, Regulation (EC) No 551/2004, MEMO/19/1472.
5
Directive 2008/106/EC, INF/19/4251.
6
Directive 2002/49/EC, INF/19/4251.
7
Directive 91/676/EC, INF/19/6304.
8
Directive (EU) 2016/1148, INF/19/4251.
9
Directive 2012/27/EU, MEMO/19/462.
10
Directive 2011/70/Euratom, INF/19/6304.
11
Regulation (EU) 2016/480, INF/19/6304.
12
Directive 2004/54/EC, INF/19/5950.
13
Directive 2016/801/EU, INF/19/4251.
14
Directive (EU) 2015/1513, INF/19/6304.
15
Directive (EU) 2018/1581.
5
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Belgium
b. The Commission referred one case to the Court under Article 258 TFEU. It concerns
• incorrect transposition of the Third Energy Package Directives (Electricity and Gas
Directives) 17.
c. The Commission referred one case to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU. It
concerns:
• Failure to comply with a judgment of the Court of Justice, which found that
Belgian provisions for rental income are in breach of EU law 18.
IV. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. Late transposition infringement cases against Belgium open on 31 December
(2015-2019)
46
48 41
33
23
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases against Belgium (2015-2019)
43
28
23 22
20
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
16
Council Directive 2013/59/Euratom, INF/19/6304.
17
Commission v Belgium, C-767/19; Directives 2009/72/EC and 2009/73/EC, IP/19/4254.
18
Commission v Belgium, C-842/19.
6
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Belgium
V. REFERRALS TO THE COURT
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
7
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Belgium
VI. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• incorrect transposition of the Solvency II Directive 19
• incorrect application of EU rules concerning civil judicial cooperation and requiring review
procedures for the recognition of other Member States’ executive measures 20;
• incorrect application of the Timber Regulation 21 by not carrying out a significant number of
verifications;
• taxation of redistributed income in the form of dividends;
• incorrect application of the provisions on access to the groundhandling market at EU
airports 22.
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Seasonal Workers Directive 23
o Reception Conditions Directive 24
o Asylum Procedures Directive 25
o Directive on extraction solvents used in the production of foodstuffs 26
o Commission Implementing Directive as regards isolation distances for Sorghum spp. 27
o Mortgage Credit Directive 28
o Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive (ATAD1) 29
o Single Permit Directive 30
o Nuclear Safety Directive 31.
VII. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
The Court ruled that:
• Belgium did not fulfil its obligations under EU law by notifying to the Commission only
partial transposition measures for the Directive on measures to reduce the cost of
deploying high-speed electronic communications networks 32 with respect to the region
19
Directive 2009/138/EC.
20
Regulations (EC) No 805/2004, (EC) No 1896/2006 and (EC) No 4/2009.
21
Regulation (EU) No 995/2010.
22
Directive 96/67/EC.
23
Directive 2014/36/EU.
24
Directive 2013/33/EU, INF/19/4251.
25
Directive 2013/32/EU.
26
Directive (EU) 2016/1855.
27
Directive (EU) 2018/1027.
28
Directive 2014/17/EU.
29
Directive (EU) 2016/1164.
30
Directive 2011/98/EU.
31
Directive 2014/87/Euratom.
32
Directive 2014/61/EU.
8
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Belgium
of Bruxelles-Capitale. The Court applied for the first time the sanction mechanism of
Article 260(3) TFEU. This Treaty provision allows the Commission to request the Court
to impose financial penalties if Member States fail to fulfil their obligation to notify
measures transposing a directive adopted under a legislative procedure. In addition to
clarifying that the sanction scheme of Article 260(3) TFEU may also be applied to cases
of partial failure to adopt and communicate transposition measures, the Court held
that, when notifying national transposition measures to the Commission, Member
States must provide sufficiently clear and precise information and state, for each
provision of the directive, the national provision(s) ensuring its transposition 33.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court addressed the following preliminary rulings to the Belgian judiciary:
• SkypeOut service should be considered an electronic communications service. As a
result, SkypeOut is subject to telecoms legislation, in particular to the general
authorisation regime. Services offered via software, such as SkypeOut, which allow
calling numbers in a national numbering plan, constitute electronic communication
services 34.
• If, within 6 months, national authorities have not decided on the application for family
reunification, they cannot automatically issue a residence permit to the applicant as it
must be established whether the applicant meets the requirements for residence in
the host Member State in accordance with EU law 35.
• In case of serious breaches of the rules of the accommodation centres, as well as
violent behaviour by an applicant, a Member State cannot provide for a sanction
consisting in the withdrawal, even temporary, of material reception conditions, relating
to housing, food or clothing in so far as it would have the effect of depriving the
applicant of the possibility of meeting his or her most basic needs 36.
• The formal recognition of the status of refugee implies that the refugee concerned is a
beneficiary of international protection for the purpose of the Qualification Directive so
that he is entitled to all the rights and benefits provided for in this Directive. This
Directive contains both rights equivalent to those set out in the Geneva Convention
and rights providing greater protection which have no equivalent in that Convention 37.
• The closure of an airport runway due to petrol spillage constitutes an ‘extraordinary
circumstance’ when the petrol in question does not originate from an aircraft of the
carrier operating that flight. It is a circumstance that could not have been avoided even
if all reasonable measures had been taken 38.
33
Commission v Belgium, C-543/17.
34
Skype Communcation, C-142/18.
35
X, C-706/18.
36
Zubair Haqbin, C-233/18.
37
Joined cases M and Others, C-391/16, C-77/17 and C-78/17.
38
Moens, C-159/18, Regulation (EC) No 261/2004.
9
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Belgium
• When a passenger boards a train without a ticket, he concludes a contract with the
carrier. This covers the situation where access to the train is free 39.
• The circumstance that the transferee has a choice whether to dismiss employees goes
against the objective of the Directive on transfer of undertakings, which provides that
dismissals due to the transfer are prohibited 40.
• A decree by which a body of a Member State establishes, at regional level for its
Natura 2000 network, conservation objectives which have an indicative value, whereas
the conservation objectives at site level have a statutory value, is not a ‘plan or
programme’, within the meaning of the Strategic Environmental Assessment Directive,
for which an assessment under this Directive is mandatory 41.
• A decree whereby a Member State designates a Special Area of Conservation and
makes provision for conservation objectives and certain preventive measures is not a
‘plan or programme’, within the meaning of the Strategic Environmental Assessment
Directive, for which an assessment under this Directive is required 42.
• National courts have jurisdiction to review the choice of location of air quality
measuring stations and to take all necessary measures against the national authority
concerned. In assessing whether limit values have been complied with, the pollution
level at each sampling point must be taken into account individually 43.
• The Belgian law extending the operating life of nuclear power stations Doel 1 and Doel
2 was adopted without the required environmental assessments being carried out
first. It is not, however, excluded that the effects of the law on extension may
provisionally be maintained where there is a genuine and serious threat of an
interruption to electricity supply 44.
39
joined cases: Kanyeba, C-349/18, Nijs, C-350/18, Dedroog, C-351/18, Regulation (EC) No 1371/2007, Court
press release No 136/2019.
40
Plessers, C-509/17.
41
Terre wallonne, C-321/18, Directive 2001/42/EC.
42
CFE, C-43/18, Directive 2001/42/EC.
43
Craeynest and Others, C-723/17 and Court press release No 82/2019.
44
Inter-Environnement Wallonie and Bond Beter Leefmilieu Vlaanderen, C-411/17 and Court press release No
100/2019.
10
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Bulgaria
Bulgaria
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints made against Bulgaria by members of the public (2015-2019)
179
147
142
131
126
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints against Bulgaria open at year-end
114 ► Complaints open at end-2018
126 ► New complaints registered in 2019
141 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 99 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy areas
126 complaints made against Bulgaria
Environment
18
Taxation and
customs
Justice and 12
consumers
40
Internal market,
industry,
entrepreneurship
and SMEs, services
Other and capital markets
48 union
8
11
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Bulgaria
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files opened against Bulgaria (2015-2019)
35
28
8 9
5
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy areas
9 EU Pilot files opened against Bulgaria
Agriculture and rural development
2
Environment
1
Energy
4
Taxation and
customs union
1
Migration and home affairs
1
3. Files relating to Bulgaria open in EU Pilot at year-end
12
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Bulgaria
48
43
30
22
20
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
4. EU Pilot files: Bulgaria’s resolution rate in 2015-2019
84% 82%
76% 78%
73%
77% 77%
75%
72% 63%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Bulgaria General rate for all Member States
III. INFRINGEMENT CASES
5. Infringement cases against Bulgaria open on 31 December (2015-2019)
74
60
55
53
39
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
6. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
13
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Bulgaria
39 new infringement cases against Bulgaria
Justice and
consumers
Mobility and
6
transport
6
Internal market,
industry,
entrepreneurship
and SMEs Migration and
6 home affairs
5
Energy
2
Health and food safety
Environment 2
8
Financial stability, financial
Other services and capital markets union
2 2
7. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a. The Commission opened 39 new infringement cases against Bulgaria in 2019. These,
and other major ongoing infringement cases, include:
• inadequate protection of consumers against unfair terms in contracts, in
particular in payment order proceedings; certain creditors can obtain orders for
immediate enforcement quasi automatically, with very limited possibilities for
the consumers to prevent or challenge the enforcement based on unfair contract
terms 45;
• incorrect transposition of the Directive on criminal sanctions for market abuse 46;
• breach of the EU’s exclusive competence in the area of automated DNA,
fingerprint and vehicle registration data exchange 47;
• non-conformity of national legislation with EU rules on public procurement and
concessions 48;
• incorrect implementation of the Directive on Attacks against Information
Systems 49;
• incorrect transposition of the Directive on combating the sexual abuse and
sexual exploitation of children 50;
• a national law provision that defines the duration for the temporary cross-border
provision of services 51;
• restrictions on the temporary cross-border provision of private security
services 52
45
MEMO/19/462.
46
Directive 2014/57/EU; INF/19/4251,
47
INF/19/5950.
48
Directives 2014/24/EU, 2014/25/EU and 2014/23/EU, INF/19/6304.
49
Directive 2013/40/EU, INF/19/5950.
50
Directive 2011/93/EU, MEMO/19/462, INF/19/4251 and INF/19/5950.
51
INF 19/4251, Directive 2006/123/EC and Article 56 TFEU.
52
INF 19/4251, Article 56 TFEU.
14
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Bulgaria
• non communication of national measures transposing the:
o Asylum Procedures Directive 53
o Directive on the freezing and confiscation of instrumentalities and proceeds of
crime in the European Union 54
o Directive on the activities and supervision of institutions for occupational
retirement provision (IORPs II Directive) 55
o Bank Creditors Hierarchy Directive 56
o Directive amending the Oil Stocks Directive as regards the methods for
calculating stockholding obligations 57;
• maintaining a national framework on geographical indications, which is not
compatible with the EU rules on quality schemes for agricultural products and
foodstuffs 58;
• incorrect transposition of the revised Environmental Impact Assessment
Directive 59;
• late reporting on the environmental status of marine waters under the Marine
Strategy Framework Directive 60;
• non-conform transposition of the Industrial Emissions Directive 61;
• incorrect implementation of the INSPIRE Directive 62;
• failure to establish Special Areas of Conservation, as well as conservation
objectives and measures to maintain or restore the protected species and
habitats to a favourable condition, as required by the Habitats Directive 63;
• non-compliance with the requirements of the Energy Efficiency Directive 64;
• incorrect application of the Directive on Marine Equipment 65;
• failure to comply with minimum safety requirements for tunnels in the trans-
European road network 66;
• incorrect application of the Directive on Marine Equipment 67.
b. The Commission referred two case(s) to the Court under Article 258 TFEU.
They involve the following infringements:
• failure to transpose and comply with EU rules on railway safety as regards the
independence of the investigating body 68;
53
Directive 2013/32/EU; INF/19/4251
54
Directive 2014/42/EU.
55
Directive 2016/2341/EU.
56
Directive 2017/2399/EU.
57
Directive (EU) 2018/1581.
58
Regulation (EU) 1151/2012, MEMO/19/462.
59
Directive 2011/92/EU, MEMO/19/1472.
60
Directive 2008/56/EC, INF/19/5950.
61
Directive 2010/75/EU.
62
Directive 2007/2/EC, MEMO/19/1472.
63
Directive 92/43/EEC, MEMO/19/462.
64
Directive 2012/27/EU, MEMO/19/462.
65
Directive 2014/90/EU, INF/19/5950.
66
Directive 2004/54/EC, INF/19/4251.
67
Directive 2014/90/EU, INF/19/5950.
68
Commission v Bulgaria, Case C-33/19, Directive 2004/49/EC, IP/18/6252.
15
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Bulgaria
• exceedance of sulphur dioxide (SO2) limit values set by the Air Quality
Directive 69.
c. The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.
IV. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. Late transposition infringement cases against Bulgaria open on 31 December
(2015-2019)
34 35 35
31
18
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases against Bulgaria (2015-2019)
27
20 26
18 20
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
69
Commission v Bulgaria Case C-730/19, Directive 2008/50/EC, IP/19/4256.
16
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Bulgaria
20 new late transposition infringement cases against
Bulgaria
Migration and home affairs…
Justice and
consumers Health and food safety
4 2
Financial stability, financial
services and capital
markets union
2
Environment
Mobility and 2
transport
4
Other
4
4. Referrals to the Court
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
V. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Reception Conditions Directive 70
o Commission Implementing Directive on minimum conditions for examining certain
varieties of agricultural plant species 71
o Directive on standards for the qualification of third-country nationals as beneficiaries of
international protection 72
o Reception Conditions Directive 73
o Asylum Procedures Directive 74
o Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID II) 75
o Directive on antitrust damages actions 76;
o Directive on certain aspects of the organisation of working time in inland waterway
transport 77.
• customs duty relief for certain US goods in breach of the Community system of reliefs from
customs duty 78;
• Proportionality of sanctions for not declaring the movement of cash in breach of controls
of cash entering or leaving the Community 79;
70
Directive 2013/33/EU, INF/19/4251.
71
Directive (EU) 2018/100.
72
Directive 2011/95/EU; INF/19/4251.
73
Directive 2013/33/EU; INF/19/4251.
74
Directive 2013/32/EU.
75
Directive 2014/65/EU.
76
Directive 2014/104/EU.
77
Directive 2014/112/EU.
78
Regulation (EC) 1186/2009.
17
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Bulgaria
• incorrect transposition of the Third Energy Package Directives 80;
• failure to adopt all transposition measures for the Indirect Land Use Change Directive 81.
VI. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
There were no major Court rulings in 2019.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court addressed the following preliminary rulings to the Bulgarian judiciary:
• The Procedural Rights Directives 82 apply to judicial proceedings leading to compulsory
medical internment of persons having committed acts representing a danger to
society. Because of their mental state, these persons are to be considered vulnerable
persons for the purpose of these Directives 83.
• National legislation obliging apartment owners in buildings in co-ownership to pay for
the thermal energy used by the common parts and the internal installation of the
building is compatible with EU law, even if the owners do not use that thermal energy
in their own apartments. In such buildings, the bills for thermal energy consumption
by the internal installation are calculated for each property owner in the building in
proportion to the heated volume of their apartment 84.
• The Court gave guidance as to the relevant criteria under the Electricity Directive to
distinguish between transmission and distribution systems 85.
79
Regulation (EC) 1889/2005.
80
Directives 2009/72/EC and 2009/73/EC.
81
Directive (EU) 2015/1513.
82
Directives 2012/13/EU, 2013/48/EU and 2016/343/EU.
83
EP Case C-467/18.
84
Joined cases C-708/17 and C-725/17 EVN Bulgaria Toplofikatsia and Toplofikatsia Sofia.
85
Elektrorazpredelenie Yug Case C-31/18, Directive 2009/72/EC.
18
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Czechia
Czechia
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints made against Czechia by members of the public (2015-2019)
70
68
67
63
58
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints against Czechia open at year-end
49 ► Complaints open at end-2018
58 ► New complaints registered in 2019
50 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 57 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy areas
58 complaints made against Czechia
Justice and Internal market,
consumers industry,
20 entrepreneurship
and SMEs
7
Employment
6
Other
25
19
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Czechia
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files opened against Czechia (2015-2019)
21
19
6
4
2
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy areas
4 EU Pilot files opened against Czechia
Financial
stability,
financial
Energy services and
1 capital markets
union
1
Agriculture and
rural Migration and home affairs
development 1
1
3. Files relating to Czechia open in EU Pilot at year-end
45
39
24
17
11
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
20
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Czechia
4. EU Pilot files: Czechia’s resolution rate in 2015-2019
82%
77% 78%
75%
72%
77%
73%
70%
60%
44%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Czechia General rate for all Member States
III. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases against Czechia open on 31 December (2015-2019)
73
67
60 59
46
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
21
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Czechia
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a. The Commission opened 31 new infringement cases against Czechia in 2019. These,
and other major ongoing infringement cases, include:
• non communication of national measures transposing the:
o Directive on the activities and supervision of institutions for occupational
retirement provision (IORPs II Directive) 1
o Indirect Land Use Change Directive 2
o Directive amending the Oil Stocks Directive as regards the methods for
calculating stockholding obligations 3;
• failure to effectively implement the rules on the 112 emergency number, in
particular by not ensuring equivalent access for disabled users 4;
• non-conformity of national legislation with EU rules on public procurement and
concessions 5;
• systematic official controls targeting certain foodstuffs coming from another
Member State each time such foodstuffs enter Czechia, in breach of EU rules on
ensuring compliance with feed and food law, animal health and animal welfare
rules 6;
• incorrect transposition of the Directive on combating the sexual abuse and
sexual exploitation of children 7;
• failure to ensure adequate protection of habitats and species of EU interest by
designating nature protection areas to complete the NATURA 2000 network 8;
• failure to upgrade the connection of their national electronic registers on road
hauliers to the new version of European Registers of Road Transport
Undertakings (ERRU) 9;
• failure to establish penalties in accordance with the Invasive Alien Species
Regulation 10;
• non-compliance with the requirements of the Energy Efficiency Directive 11.
b. The Commission referred one case to the Court under Article 258 TFEU. It involves
the following infringement:
• incorrect transposition and application of certain provisions of the Energy
Performance of Buildings Directive 12;
c. The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.
1
Directive 2016/2341/EU.
2
Directive (EU) 2015/1513.
3
Directive (EU) 2018/1581.
4
Directive (EU) 2002/22; INF/19/4251.
5
Directives 2014/24/EU, 2014/25/EU and 2014/23/EU, INF/19/6304.
6
Regulation (EC) 882/2004, MEMO/19/462, INF/19/4251.
7
Directive 2011/93/EU, MEMO/19/462 INF/19/4251 and INF/19/5950.
8
Directive 92/43/EEC, INF/19/6304.
9
Regulation (EU) 2016/480, INF/19/6304.
10
Regulation (EU) 1143/2014, INF/19/6304.
11
Directive 2012/27/EU, MEMO/19/462.
12
Directive 2010/31/EU, Commission v Czechia, C-305/19.
22
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Czechia
IV. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. Late transposition infringement cases against Czechia open on 31 December
(2015-2019)
40
33
29
25
17
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases against Czechia (2015-2019)
33
25
21 20
17
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: policy areas
20 new late transposition infringement cases against
Czechia
Taxation and customs Health and food safety
4 3
Mobility and
transport
2
Justice and consumers
5
Energy
2
Other
4
23
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Czechia
4. Referrals to the Court
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
V. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major c a ses closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Reception Conditions Directive 13
o Commission Implementing Directive on minimum conditions for examining certain
varieties of agricultural plant species 14
o Commission Implementing Directive on protective measures against the introduction
into the Community of organisms harmful to plants 15
o Directive on tobacco products 16
o the Seasonal Workers Directive 17
o Asylum Procedures Directive 18
o Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive (ATAD1) 19
o Directive on certain aspects of the organisation of working time in inland waterway
transport 20.
• Directive as regards access to anti-money laundering information (DAC5) 21;
• non-conform implementation of the Directive as regards the mandatory automatic
exchange of information in the field of taxation (DAC2) 22;
• failure to correctly transpose certain requirements of the Radioactive Waste Directive 23;
• non-compliance of national legislation with the provisions of the Train Drivers Directive 24;
• non-conformity of national legislation with the Professional Qualifications Directive 25;
• failure to provide the required quality management system for operational parts of the flag
State-related activities 26.
VI. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings 27
13
Directive 2013/33/EU, INF/19/4251.
14
Directive (EU) 2018/100.
15
Directive (EU) 2019/523.
16
Directive 2014/40/EU.
17
Directive 2014/36/EU.
18
Directive 2013/32/EU.
19
Directive (EU) 2016/1164.
20
Directive 2014/112/EU.
21
Directive 2016/2258/EU.
22
Directive 2011/16/EU.
23
Council Directive 2011/70/Euratom.
24
Directive 2007/59/EC.
25
Directive 2005/36/EC.
26
Directive 2009/21/EC.
27
These rulings are almost exclusively handed down in infringement procedures.
24
M o nit o ri n g t h e a p pli c ati o n of E u r o p e a n U ni o n l a w
2 0 1 9 A n n u al R e p o rt
C z e c hi a
T h e C o urt:
• di s mi s s e d t h e C o m mi s si o n ’s a cti o n a g ai n st C z e c hi a c o n c e r ni n g it s r ef u s al t o e n s u r e t h e
t a k e-b a c k of 2 0 0 0 0 t o n n e s of a mi xt u r e c all e d T P S -N O L O ( G e o b al) s hi p p e d f r o m
C z e c hi a t o P ol a n d. T h e C o u rt f o u n d t h at t h e C o m mi s si o n di d n ot p r o vi d e s uffi ci e nt
e vi d e n c e t h at t h e r e s p e cti v e mi xt u r e c o n stit ut e s w a st e a n d, t h u s, t h at it s s hi p m e nt
c o n stit ut e s a s hi p m e nt of w a st e 2 8 .
2. P r eli mi n a r y r uli n g s
T h e C o urt a d dr e s s e d t h e f oll o wi n g pr eli mi n ar y r uli n g s t o t h e C z e c h j u di ci ar y:
• T h e f o r m al r e c o g niti o n of t h e st at u s of r ef u g e e i m pli e s t h at t h e r ef u g e e c o n c e r n e d i s a
b e n efi ci a r y of i nt e r n ati o n al p r ot e cti o n f o r t h e p u r p o s e of t h e Q u alifi c ati o n Di r e cti v e s o
t h at h e i s e ntitl e d t o all t h e ri g ht s a n d b e n efit s p r o vi d e d f o r i n t hi s Di r e cti v e. T hi s
Di r e cti v e c o nt ai n s b ot h ri g ht s e q ui v al e nt t o t h o s e s et o ut i n t h e G e n e v a C o n v e nti o n
a n d ri g ht s p r o vi di n g g r e at e r p r ot e cti o n w hi c h h a v e n o e q ui v al e nt i n t h at C o n v e nti o n 2 9 ;
• C o n n e cti n g fli g ht s t h at a r e t h e s u bj e ct of a si n gl e r e s e r v ati o n d e p a rti n g f r o m a
M e m b e r St at e t o a n o n -M e m b e r S t at e vi a a n ot h e r n o n-M e m b e r St at e: t h e ai r c a r ri e r of
t h e fi r st fli g ht i s, i n p ri n ci pl e, li a bl e t o p a y c o m p e n s ati o n t o p a s s e n g e r s w h o s uff e r e d a
l o n g d el a y i n t h e a r ri v al of t h e s e c o n d fli g ht p e rf o r m e d b y a n o n-C o m m u nit y ai r
c a r ri e r 3 0 .
28
C o m mi s si o n v C z e c h R e p u bli c, C a s e C- 3 9 9/ 1 7 a n d C o u rt p r e s s r el e a s e 2 9/ 1 9 .
29
M a n d Ot h er s , J oi n e d c a s e s C- 3 9 1/ 1 6, C -7 7/ 1 7 a n d C- 7 8/ 1 7 .
30
Č e s k é a er oli ni e, C a s e C- 5 0 2/ 1 8 a n d C o u rt p r e s s r el e a s e 9 5/ 2 0 1 9.
25
ion of Euro
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Denmark
Denmark
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints made against Denmark by members of the public (2015-2019)
68
61 61
56
53
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints against Denmark open at year-end
40 ► Complaints open at end-2018
61 ► New complaints registered in 2019
58 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 43 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy areas
61 complaints made against Denmark
Taxation and
customs Neighbourhood and
7 enlargement negotiations
5
Environment
5
Justice and
consumers
19
Other
25
26
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Denmark
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files opened against Denmark (2015-2019)
25
18
6
3
2
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Files relating to Denmark open in EU Pilot at year-end
32
24 16
9 10
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy areas
6 EU Pilot files opened against Denmark
Energy
2
Maritime affairs
and fisheries2
3
Environment
1
27
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Denmark
4. EU Pilot files: Denmark’s resolution rate in 2015-2019
82% 83%
80% 80%
72%
75% 77% 77%
73%
65%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Denmark General rate for all Member States
III. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases against Denmark open on 31 December (2015-2019)
32
34
28 31
23
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
20 new infringement cases against Denmark
Internal market,
industry,
entrepreneurship
and SMEs Environment
6 5
Taxation and
customs
1
Health and food
Energy safety
2 3
Mobility and transport
3
28
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Denmark
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a. The Commission opened 20 new infringement cases against Denmark in 2019. These,
and other major ongoing infringement cases, include:
• unlawful use of the protected designation of origin ‘Feta’, in violation of the EU
rules on quality schemes for agricultural products and foodstuffs 1;
• failure to enforce several provisions of the EU Control Regulation 2.
• non-conformity of national legislation with EU rules on public procurement and
concessions 3;
• incorrect transposition of the:
o Directive on the protection of animals used for scientific purposes 4
o revised Environmental Impact Assessment Directive 5
o Energy Efficiency Directive 6;
• failure to upgrade the connection of their national electronic registers on road
hauliers to the new version of European Registers of Road Transport
Undertakings (ERRU) 7;
• failure to fulfil the obligations under the EU rules establishing a single European
railway area 8.
b. [The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU.]
c. [The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.]
IV. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. Late transposition infringement cases against Denmark open on 31 December
(2015-2019)
18 14
13
9
8
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
1
Regulation (EU) No 1151/2012, IP-19-6312.
2
MEMO/19/462, Regulation (EC) No 1224/2009.
3
INF/19/6304, MEMO/19/462; Directives 2014/24/EU, 2014/25/EU and 2014/23/EU.
4
Directive 2010/63/EU, INF/19/5950.
5
Directive 2011/92/EU, as amended by Directive 2014/52/EU, INF/19/5950.
6
Directive 2012/27/EU, MEMO/19/462.
7
Regulation (EU) 2016/480, INF/19/6304.
8
Directive 2012/34/EU, INF/19/4251,
29
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Denmark
2. New late transposition infringement cases against Denmark (2015-2019)
28
15
15
11
9
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
11 new late transposition infringement cases against
Denmark
Health and food Mobility and
safety transport
3 2
Internal market,
industry, Other
entrepreneurship 3
and SMEs
3
4. Referrals to the Court
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court concerning Denmark under Articles 258
and 260(3) TFEU.
V. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Commission Implementing Directive on characteristics to be covered as a minimum by
the examination and the minimum conditions for examining certain varieties of
agricultural plant species 9
o Commission Implementing Directive on protective measures against the introduction
into the Community of organisms harmful to plants 10
o Indirect Land Use Change Directive 11;
9
Directive (EU) 2019/114.
10
Directive (EU) 2019/523.
30
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Denmark
• exceedances of the nitrogen dioxide (NO2) limit values set by the Air Quality Directive 12;
• incorrect implementation of the Combined Transport Directive 13.
VI. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings 14
There were no major Court rulings in 2019.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court addressed the following preliminary ruling to the Danish judiciary:
• EU law cannot be relied on for abusive or fraudulent objectives. In such cases, national
authorities and courts must refuse a taxpayer the exemption from withholding tax on
profits distributed by a subsidiary to its parent company, even if there are no domestic
or agreement-based provisions providing for such a refusal 15.
11
Directive (EU) 2015/1513.
12
Directive 2008/50/EC.
13
Directive 92/106/EEC.
14
These rulings are almost exclusively handed down in infringement procedures.
15
Skatteministeriet v T Danmark and Y Denmark Aps, joined cases C-116/16 and C-117/16.
31
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Germany
Germany
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints made against Germany by members of the public (2015-2019)
297 319
308
274
250
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints against Germany open at year-end
274 ► Complaints open at end-2018
319 ► New complaints registered in 2019
227 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 366 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy areas
319 complaints made against Germany
Environment
106
Justice and
consumers
63
Other Internal market, industry,
110 entrepreneurship and
SMEs
40
32
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Germany
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files opened against Germany (2015-2019)
49
33
8
5 6
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy areas
6 EU Pilot files opened against Germany
Environment
1
Energy
1
Health and food
safety
1
Maritime affairs
and fisheries Migration and
2 home affairs
1
3. Files relating to Germany open in EU Pilot at year-end
68
51 35
47
29
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
33
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Germany
4. EU Pilot files: Germany’s resolution rate in 2015-2019
92%
75% 77% 77%
72% 73%
72% 71%
67%
64%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Germany General rate for all Member States
III. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases against Germany open on 31 December (2015-2019)
91
88
80
74
70
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
25 new infringement cases against Germany
Internal market, industry,
Justice and
entrepreneurship and SMEs
consumers 5
6
Mobility and
transport
4
Other
4
Taxation and
Environment customs union
2 4
34
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Germany
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a. The Commission opened 25 new infringement cases against Germany in 2019. These,
and other major ongoing infringement cases, include:
• non communication of national measures transposing the:
o Directive on the activities and supervision of institutions for occupational
retirement provision (IORPs II Directive) 1
o Directive amending the Oil Stocks Directive as regards the methods for
calculating stockholding obligations 2;
• rules on fixed prices for prescription medicines negatively affecting the sale of
products by pharmacies established in other EU Member States in violation of
Articles 34 and 36 TFEU 3;
• failure to award authorisations and concessions in the hydroelectric power
sector in line with the Services Directive and public procurement rules 4;
• restrictions on the import of coffee in violation of the principle of the free
movement of goods 5;
• non-conformity of national legislation with EU rules on public procurement and
concessions 6;
• non-conformity of national law with EU public procurement rules, forbidding
health insurance funds to use procurement procedures to obtain assistive
medical devices 7;
• failure to effectively implement the rules on the 112 emergency number, in
particular by not ensuring equivalent access for disabled users 8;
• incorrect transposition of the Directive on combating the sexual abuse and
sexual exploitation of children 9;
• Germany’s national rules on VAT for distance sales of goods sold through digital
marketplaces 10;
• impossibility to fulfil formal requirements for qualifying as a group company for
German tax consolidation purposes 11;
• failure to ensure adequate protection of grasslands, as required by the Habitats
Directive 12;
• incorrect transposition of the Directive on the protection of animals used for
scientific purposes 13;
1
Directive 2016/2341/EU.
2
Directive (EU) 2018/1581.
3
MEMO/19/1472 and C-148/15.
4
Directives 2006/123/EC and 2014/23/EU, IP/19/1477.
5
MEMO/19/462.
6
MEMO/19/462; Directives 2014/24/EU, 2014/25/EU and 2014/23/EU.
7
Directive 2014/24/EU, INF/19/4251.
8
Directive (EU) 2002/22; INF/19/4251.
9
Directive 2011/93/EU, MEMO/19/462 INF/19/4251 and INF/19/5950.
10
IP/19/5950.
11
IP/19/4251.
12
Directive 92/43/EEC, INF/19/4251.
35
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Germany
• application of the Directive on Mobile Air-Conditioning; 14
• failure to comply with the principles of fair and non-discriminatory remuneration
for European Electronic Toll Service providers 15;
• failure to upgrade the connection of their national electronic registers on road
hauliers to the new version of European Registers of Road Transport
Undertakings (ERRU) 16;
• failure to fulfil the obligations under the EU rules establishing a single European
railway area 17;
• failure to comply with a Court judgment finding that Germany was in breach of
its obligations under the Nitrates Directive by failing to revise an action
programme whose measures had proved insufficient 18;
• failure to establish Special Areas of Conservation, as well as conservation
objectives and measures to maintain or restore the protected species and
habitats to a favourable condition, as required by the Habitats Directive 19;
• non-compliance with the requirements of the Energy Efficiency Directive 20.
b. The Commission referred one case to the Court under Article 258 TFEU. It involves
the following infringement:
• Rejections of certain applications for VAT refunds for businesses in other
Member States 21.
c. [The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.]
IV. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. Late transposition infringement cases against Germany open on 31 December
(2015-2019)
13
Directive 2010/63/EU, INF/19/4251.
14
INF 19/4251, Directive 2006/40/EC.
15
Commission Decision 2009/750/EC, INF/19/4251.
16
Regulation (EU) 2016/480, INF/19/5950.
17
Directive 2012/34/EU, INF/19/5950.
18
Directive 91/676/EC, INF/19/4251, C-543/16 Commission v Germany.
19
Directive 92/43/EEC, MEMO-19-462.
20
Directive 2012/27/EU, MEMO-19-462.
21
Case C-371/19 Commission v Germany.
36
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Germany
31
26
24 25
17
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases against Germany (2015-2019)
22
21
19
13
11
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
11 new late transposition infringement cases against
Germany
Justice and
consumers
6
Taxation and
customs union
2
Other
3
4. Referrals to the Court
The Commission did not refer any case to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
37
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Germany
V. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Seasonal Workers Directive 22
o Reception Conditions Directive 23
o Asylum Procedures Directive 24;
o Directive on certain aspects of the organisation of working time in inland waterway
transport 25.
• incorrect application of the freedom of establishment due to the reservation of certain
approval services for some types of motor vehicles in favour of certain technical testing
centres 26
• failure to adopt all transposition measures for the Indirect Land Use Change Directive 27;
• incorrect transposition of the Driving Licences Directive 28;
VI. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings 29
The Court ruled that:
• Germany breached EU law by maintaining fixed tariffs for the planning services of
architects and engineers 30;
• Germany restricted the free movement of goods by introducing an infrastructure use
charge and simultaneous relief from motor vehicle tax for vehicles registered in
Germany 31;
• Germany failed to fulfil its obligations under EU law, at the 25th session of the Revision
Committee of the Intergovernmental Organisation for International Carriage by Rail, by
having voted against the position of the EU, and having publicly opposed that position
and the arrangements for the exercise of voting rights 32;
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court addressed the following preliminary rulings to the German judiciary:
22
Directive 2014/36/EU.
23
Directive 2013/33/EU; INF/19/4251.
24
Directive 2013/32/EU.
25
Directive 2014/112/EU.
26
Directive 2007/46/EC.
27
Directive (EU) 2015/1513.
28
Directive 2006/106/EC.
29
These rulings are almost exclusively handed down in infringement procedures.
30
Commission v Germany, Case C-377/17.
31
Austria v Germany, Case C-591/17.
32
Commission v Germany, Case C-620/16, Decision 2014/699/EU.
38
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Germany
• prohibiting commercial providers of search engines and commercial service providers,
which edit content of online press products, from making press products or parts of
them available to the public is a breach of EU law 33;
• freedom of information and freedom of the press cannot justify a derogation from the
author’s exclusive rights of reproduction and of communication to the public going
beyond the exceptions or limitations provided for in EU law 34;
• a phonogram producer can prevent the use of a sound sample of his or her
phonogram in another phonogram. However, such sample can be used if it is included
in the phonogram in a modified form unrecognisable to the ear 35;
• the Gmail service should not be considered as consisting wholly or mainly in the
“conveyance of signals”. As a result, Gmail is not an electronic communications service,
and is therefore not subject to the general authorisation regime under the current EU
telecoms legislation 36;
• the EU Regulation on shipments of waste 37 does not apply to shipment mixtures of
animal by-products and other substances transported between Member States 38;
• the Austrian system of issuing an European arrest warrant, in which both public
prosecutor’s offices and courts are involved, is compatible with EU law 39;
• EU law does not designate directly, or by analogy, the law applicable to the third-party
effects of the assignment of claims 40;
• the operator of a website that features a Facebook ‘Like’ button can be a controller
jointly with Facebook in respect of the collection and transmission to Facebook of the
personal data of visitors to its website 41;
• a pre-ticked box cannot be considered as valid consent to the processing of personal
data. The information that the service provider must give to a user includes the
duration of the operation of cookies and whether or not third parties may have access
to those cookies 42;
• in case of insolvency of the employer, a reduction in a former employee’s old-age
benefits must be regarded as being manifestly disproportionate if that person is living,
or would have to live, below the at-risk-of-poverty threshold determined by Eurostat
for the Member State concerned 43;
• an applicant ‘absconds’ within the meaning of the Dublin Regulation if he deliberately
evades the reach of the national authorities in order to prevent the transfer. It may be
presumed that that is the case if the transfer cannot be carried out due to the fact that
33
VG Media, Case C-299/17.
34
Funke Medien NRW, Case C-469/17.
35
Pelham and others, Case C-476/17.
36
Google, Case C-193/18.
37
Regulation (EC) No 1013/2006.
38
ReFood GmbH & Co. KG v Landwirtschaftskammer Niedersachsen, Case C-634/17.
39
NJ, Case C-489/19 PPU.
40
BNP Paribas, C-548/18.
41
Fashion ID, Case C-40/17.
42
Planet 49, Case C-673/17.
43
Pensions-Sicherungs-Verein, Case C-168/18.
39
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Germany
the applicant has left the accommodation allocated to him without informing the
competent national authorities, provided that he has been informed of his obligations
in that regard 44;
• the VAT exemption for school and university education does not cover driving school
tuition provided by a driving school for the purpose of acquiring driving licences for
vehicles in categories B and C1, even if the objective of such tuition is not purely
recreational, since possession of such licences is liable to meet, among other things,
professional needs 45;
• the customs authorities may require that an applicant for the status of an ‘authorised
economic operator’ provide them with the tax identification numbers concerning
solely the natural persons who are in charge of the applicant or who exercise control
over its management and those who are in charge of the applicant’s customs matters,
and the details of the tax offices responsible for the taxation of all those persons 46;
• the legislation of a Member State which effectively taxes dividends paid to foreign
pension funds at a higher rate than dividends paid to domestic pension funds is
contrary to the free movement of capital as established by Article 63 TFEU 47;
• where EU customs regulations require providing a specific indication of the country of
origin for a product (in this case, cultivated mushrooms that had been relocated
during the growing process), the country of origin is that where the product was
harvested, and that indication as such cannot be regarded as misleading consumers.
In such circumstances, no obligations may be imposed on the food business operators
to provide information additional to the indication of the country of origin in order to
prevent any alleged risk of misleading consumers 48;
• the protection of the name ‘Aceto Balsamico di Modena (PGI)’, entered in the register
of protected designations of origin and protected geographical indications, does not
extend to the use of the individual non-geographical terms of that name, namely
‘aceto’ and ‘balsamico’ 49;
• in relation to the greenhouse gas emission allowance trading system (EU ETS), the
Court of Justice confirmed the literal interpretation of an ‘electricity generator’, which
includes an industrial plant even if the main activity of that plant does not fall under
the scope of the EU ETS, the plant produces electricity mainly for its own use, and the
amount of electricity sold to third parties is minimal 50;
• an exception from the use of tachographs does not apply to vehicles used for the
carriage of live animals directly from farms to local slaughterhouses 51;
• A Member State may refuse to recognise a driving licence which has been issued by
another Member State, without a test of fitness to drive, on the basis of a driving
44
Abubacarr Jawo, Case C-163/17.
45
A & G Fahrschul-Akademie, Case C-449/17.
46
Deutsche Post AG v Hauptzollamt Köln, Case C-496/17.
47
College Pension Plan of British Columbia, Case C-641/17.
48
Zentrale zur Bekämpfung unlauteren Wettbewerbs Frankfurt am Main, Case C-686/17.
49
Consorzio Tutela Aceto Balsamico di Modena, Case C-432/18 and Court press release 150/19.
50
ExxonMobil Production Deutschland, Case C-682/17.
51
NK, C-231/18, Regulation (EC) No 561/2006, Regulation (EU) No 165/2014.
40
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Germany
licence issued by another Member State based on the exchange of a driving licence
issued by a third country 52;
• the direct award of contracts for public passenger transport services by bus that do
not take the form of service concessions is not subject to the Regulation on public
passenger transport services by rail and road 53;
• an air carrier is only required to compensate passengers for a long delay caused by
damage to an aircraft tyre if it fails to prove that it deployed all means at its disposal
for limiting the delay of the flight 54;
• the system of airport charges is to be approved by an independent supervisory
authority and must be mandatory for all airport users 55;
• exception from the application of certain social legislation covers only vehicles that are
used exclusively, during a particular transport operation, for the purpose of delivering
items as part of the universal postal service 56;
• the coercive detention of a person at the head of the Land of Bavaria for the purpose
of enjoining them to adopt measures to improve ambient air quality in Munich can be
ordered only if a national legal basis, which is sufficiently accessible, precise and
foreseeable in its application, exists and if the detention is proportionate 57;.
• residues in the form of scrap metal and fire-extinguishing water mixed with sludge and
cargo residues, attributable to damage occurring on board a ship at sea, must be
regarded as waste generated on board ships, within the meaning of the Regulation on
shipments of waste. Such waste is, therefore, excluded from the said Regulation’s
scope until it is offloaded in order to be recovered or disposed of 58.
52
Meyn, C-9/18, Directive 2006/126/EC.
53
Joined cases: C-266/17 and C-267/17 Verkehrsbetrieb Hüttebräucker and BVR Busverkehr Rheinland, Court
press release 46/2019, Regulation (EC) 1370/2007.
54
Germanwings, Case C-501/17, Court press release 45/2019, Regulation (EC) 261/2004.
55
Deutsche Lufthansa, Case C-379/18, Directive 2009/12/EC.
56
Joined cases Deutsche Post and Leymann and UPS Deutschland and Others C-203/18 and C-374/18,
Regulation (EC) 561/2006.
57
Deutsche Umwelthilfe, Case C-752/18 and Court press release 164/2019.
58
Conti 11. Container Schiffahrt, Case C-689/17, Regulation (EC) 1013/2006.
41
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Estonia
Estonia
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints made against Estonia by members of the public (2015-2019)
31
28
22
14
12
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints against Estonia open at year-end
16 ► Complaints open at end-2018
New complaints registered in
28 ►
2019
20 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 24 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy areas
28 complaints made against Estonia
Environment
6
Justice and
consumers
10
Other
12
42
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Estonia
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files opened against Estonia (2015-2019)
22
15
4
5
3
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Files relating to Estonia open in EU Pilot at year-end
25
21
11
9
8
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy areas
43
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Estonia
4. EU Pilot files: Estonia’s resolution rate in 2015-2019
100%
88%
77% 73%
74%
75% 77%
72% 73%
40%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Estonia General rate for all Member States
III. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases against Estonia open on 31 December (2015-2019)
33
30 30
27
26
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
44
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Estonia
25 new infringement cases against Estonia
Energy
4
Migration and
home affairs
2
Mobility and
Internal market, transport
industry, 2
entrepreneurship
and SMEs
6
Environment
4
Others
4 Justice and consumers
3
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a. The Commission opened 25 new infringement cases against Estonia in 2019. These,
and other major ongoing infringement cases, include:
• imposition of additional obligations on persons crossing the external EU border,
in breach of the Schengen Borders Code 1:
• incorrect transposition of the :
o Directive on combating the sexual abuse and sexual exploitation of children 2
o EU rules on public procurement and concessions 3
o Solvency II Directive 4
o revised Environmental Impact Assessment Directive 5
o Energy Efficiency Directive 6;
• failure to upgrade the connection of their national electronic registers on road
hauliers to the new version of European Registers of Road Transport
Undertakings (ERRU) 7;
• non-compliance with the requirements of the Energy Efficiency Directive 8;
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Indirect Land Use Change Directive 9
o Directive amending the Oil Stocks Directive as regards the methods for
calculating stockholding obligations 10
o Basic Safety Standards Directive 11.
1
Regulation (EU) 2016/399 ; MEMO/19/462.
2
Directive 2011/93/EU, MEMO/19/462 INF/19/4251 and INF/19/5950.
3
Directives 2014/24/EU, 2014/25/EU and 2014/23/EU, INF/19/5950.
4
Directive 2009/138/EC, INF/19/4251.
5
Directive 2011/92/EU, as amended by Directive 2014/52/EU, INF/19/4251.
6
Directive 2012/27/EU, MEMO/19/462.
7
Regulation (EU) 2016/480, INF/19/4251.
8
Directive 2012/27/EU, MEMO/19/462.
9
Directive (EU) 2015/1513.
10
Directive (EU) 2018/1581.
45
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Estonia
b. [The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU.]
c. [The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.]
IV. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. Late transposition infringement cases against Estonia open on 31 December
(2015-2019)
27
23
18
16 15
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases against Estonia (2015-2019)
18
16
15
13
6
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
11
Council Directive 2013/59/Euratom.
46
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Estonia
13 new late transposition infringement cases against
Estonia
Justice and
consumers
3 Climate action
1
Environment
1
Migration and
Energy home affairs
1
3
Mobility and
Internal market, transport
industry, 1
entrepreneurship and Taxation and Health and food
SMEs customs union safety
1 1 1
4. Referrals to the Court
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
V. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• failure to communicate national measures transposing the:
o Reception Conditions Directive 12
o Asylum Procedures Directive 13
o Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID II) 14;
o Directive on certain aspects of the organisation of working time in inland waterway
transport 15.
• incorrect transposition of the:
o Third Energy Package Directives 16
o Directive on the protection of animals used for scientific purposes 17
o Directive on administrative cooperation in the field of taxation (DAC1) 18.
VI. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
12
Directive 2013/33/EU; INF/19/4251.
13
Directive 2013/32/EU.
14
Directive 2014/65/EU.
15
Directive 2014/112/EU.
16
Directives 2009/72/EC and 2009/73/EC.
17
Directive 2010/63/EU.
18
Directive 2014/107/EU.
47
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Estonia
There were no major Court rulings in 2019.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court addressed the following preliminary ruling to the Estonian judiciary:
• In the absence of criteria set at EU level to determine the end-of-waste status of a
specific type of waste, such end status depends on the existence of criteria laid down
in a generally applicable national legal act concerning that type of waste 19.
19
Tallinna Vesi, C-60/18.
48
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Ireland
Ireland
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints made against Ireland by members of the public (2015-2019)
162
130
99
79
71
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints against Ireland open at year-end
178 ► Complaints open at end-2018
79 ► New complaints registered in 2019
100 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 157 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy areas
79 complaints made against Ireland
Environment
7
Mobility and Employment
transport 7
17
Health and food
safety
5
Other
Justice and
18
consumers
25
49
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Ireland
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files opened against Ireland (2015-2019)
31
25
6 3 6
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Files relating to Ireland open in EU Pilot at year-end
38 39
26
14
14
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: policy areas
50
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Ireland
6 EU Pilot files opened against Ireland
Health and food
Environment safety
1 1
Migration and home
affairs
1
Maritime affairs
and fisheries
2
Mobility and
transport
1
4. EU Pilot files: Ireland’s resolution rate in 2015-2019
79%
77% 77%
72% 73%
75%
71%
63%
60%
50%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Ireland General rate for all Member States
III. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases against Ireland open on 31 December (2015-2019)
61
56
53 52
35
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
51
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Ireland
38 new infringement cases against Ireland
Mobility and
Internal market, industry, transport
entrepreneurship and SMEs 3
4 Health and food safety
2
Taxation and customs
2
Justice and
consumers Martitime affairs
6 and fisheries
2
Other
4
Environment
15
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a. The Commission opened 38 new infringement cases against Ireland in 2019. These,
and other major ongoing infringement cases, include:
• failure to apply the Environmental Impact Assessment Directive to peat
extraction operations 20;
• incorrect transposition of the Water Framework Directive 21;
• late reporting on the environmental status of marine waters under the Marine
Strategy Framework Directive 22;
• failure to fulfil the obligations under the EU rules establishing a single European
railway area 23;
• failure to establish penalties in accordance with the Invasive Alien Species
Regulation 24;
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Directives on human tissues and cells 25
o Basic Safety Standards Directive 26
o Directive on the activities and supervision of institutions for occupational
retirement provision (IORPs II Directive) 27
o Bank Creditors Hierarchy Directive 28.
20
Directive 2011/92/EU, INF/19/4251.
21
Directive 2000/60/EC, MEMO/19/462.
22
Directive 2008/56/EC, INF/19/5950.
23
Directive 2012/34/EU, INF/19/4251,
24
Regulation (EU) No 1143/2014, INF/19/6304.
25
Directive (EU) 2015/565 and Directive (EU) 2015/566, MEMO/19/462.
26
Directive 2013/59/Euratom, MEMO/19/1472.
27
Directive 2016/2341/EU.
28
Directive 2017/2399/EU.
52
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Ireland
b. [The Commission referred one case to the Court under Article 258 TFEU. It concerns:
• failure to correctly implement EU law establishing the fundamental principles
governing the investigation of accidents in the maritime transport sector 29.
c. [The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.]
IV. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. Late transposition infringement cases against Ireland open on 31 December
(2015-2019)
30
28
27
23
14
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
29
Directive 2009/18/EC, Commission v Ireland, C-257/19, IP/18/4492.
53
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Ireland
2. New late transposition infringement cases against Ireland (2015-2019)
36
21
27
15
13
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
27 new late transposition infringement cases against
Ireland
Financial stability, financial services
Justice and and Capital Markets Union
consumers 2
6 Migration and home
affairs
2
Mobility and transport
2
Taxation
and customs
2
Environment
8 Health and food
safety
Other 2
3
4. Referrals to the Court
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
V. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• non-compliance with the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive 30;
• failure to correctly transpose certain requirements of the Radioactive Waste Directive 31;
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Commission Implementing Directive on minimum conditions for examining certain
varieties of agricultural plant species 32
30
Directive 2010/31/EU.
31
Directive 2011/70/Euratom.
54
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Ireland
o Commission Implementing Directive on characteristics to be covered as a minimum by
the examination and the minimum conditions for examining certain varieties of
agricultural plant species 33
o Commission Implementing Directive on protective measures against the introduction
into the Community of organisms harmful to plants 34
o Directives on human tissues and cells 35
o minimum requirements for enhancing worker mobility between Member States by
improving the acquisition and preservation of supplementary pension rights 36
o labour rights for seafarers 37
o Indirect Land Use Change Directive 38.
VI. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
The Court ruled that:
• Ireland has failed to comply with an earlier Court judgment 39, which required that a
remedial environmental impact assessment be carried out for a large windfarm
development in Derrybrien. The Court ordered Ireland to pay a lump sum of
EUR 5 000 000 and a periodic penalty payment of EUR 15 000 for every day of delay
until compliance is achieved 40.
• Ireland has not complied with the requirements of the Urban Waste Water Treatment
Directive in multiple agglomerations as it had failed to put in place compliant waste
water collecting systems to tackle excessive spills from storm water overflows and
failed to provide adequate treatment of urban waste waters 41.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court addressed the following preliminary rulings to the Irish judiciary:
• Although a third-country national who is married to a Union citizen may lose a right of
residence in a Member State following the departure of the Union citizen from the
host Member State, the procedural safeguards laid down in the Free Movement
Directive apply to the expulsion of that third-country national from the host Member
State 42.
• An EU citizen who acquired in another Member State the status of worker for the
activity he pursued there for a period of 2 weeks before becoming involuntarily
32
Directive (EU) 2018/100.
33
Directive (EU) 2019/114.
34
Directive (EU) 2019/523.
35
Directive (EU) 2015/565 and Directive (EU) 2015/566.
36
Directive 2014/50/EU.
37
Directive (EU) 2015/1794.
38
Directive (EU) 2015/1513.
39
Commission v Ireland, C-215/06.
40
Commission v Ireland, C-261/18 and Court press release No 142/2019.
41
Commission v Ireland, C-427/17, Directive 91/271/EEC
42
Nalini Chenchooliah v Minister for Justice and Equality, C-94/18, Directive 2004/38/EC.
55
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Ireland
unemployed retains this status for a further period of no less than 6 months. The
citizen must register as a jobseeker with the relevant employment office. Any
entitlement under national law to social security benefits or social assistance may be
conditional upon a specified period of employment if the same condition is applicable
to nationals of the Member State concerned 43.
• The public prosecutor’s offices of a Member State, such as those of Germany, which
may be subject, directly or indirectly, to directions or instructions from the executive,
such as a Minister for Justice, in the issuing a European arrest warrant cannot be
regarded as an ‘issuing judicial authority’ 44.
• The Prosecutor General of a Member State, such as that of Lithuania, whose legal
position affords him a guarantee of independence from the executive when issuing a
European arrest warrant is an ‘issuing judicial authority’. When the competent issuing
judicial authority under national law is not itself a court, the decision to issue such a
European arrest warrant must be subject to court proceedings, which meet the
requirements of effective judicial protection 45.
• The fact that a Member State, designated as responsible for the examination of an
application for international protection pursuant to the rules set out in the Dublin
Regulation, has notified its intention to withdraw from the European Union in
accordance with Article 50 TEU does not oblige the Member State with which the
application was lodged to itself examine the application 46.
• It is not necessary for a person to pursue an activity as an employed person in a
Member State in order to be entitled to family benefits if his or her children are living
in another Member State 47.
43
Neculai Tarola v Minister for Social Protection, C-483/17.
44
OG and PI, C-508/18 and C-82/19.
45
PF, C-509/19.
46
M.A. and Others, Case C-661/17.
47
Bogatu, C-322/17.
56
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Greece
Greece
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints made against Greece by members of the public (2015-2019)
172
166
144
136
121
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints against Greece open at year-end
121 ► Complaints open at end-2018
121 ► New complaints registered in 2019
139 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 103 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy areas
121 complaints made against Greece
Internal market, industry,
entrepreneurship and
SMEs
Employment 22
28
Other Taxation and
23 customs
16
Health and food Justice &
safety Environment consumers
5 12 15
57
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Greece
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files opened against Greece (2015-2019)
42
37
9 8 8
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: policy areas
8 EU Pilot files opened against Greece
Energy
1
Environment
1 Financial stability,
financial services and
Capital Markets Union
1
Taxation and
customs
2 Maritime affairs
and fisheries
1
Economic and
Migration and home affairs financial affairs
1 1
3. Files relating to Greece open in EU Pilot at year-end
65 65
39
25
22
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
58
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Greece
4. EU Pilot files: Greece’s resolution rate in 2015-2019
86%
82%
77%
75% 73%
72%
77% 77%
62%
68%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Greece General rate for all Member States
III. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases against Greece open on 31 December (2015-2019)
86 85
82
78
76
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New infringement cases opened in 2019: policy areas
59
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Greece
39 new infringement cases against Greece
Internal market, industry, entrepreneurship and
SMEs
6
Environment
8 Justice and
consumers
6
Climate change
1
Mobility and
Financial stability, financial transport
services and Capital Markets 4
Union
3
Taxation and
Migration and home affairs customs
2 4
Communication networks Energy
2 3
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a. The Commission opened 39 new infringement cases against Greece in 2019. These,
and other major ongoing infringement cases, include:
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Directive on conditions of entry and residence of third-country nationals for
research and studies 1
o Directive on combating terrorism 2
o Directive on the activities and supervision of institutions for occupational
retirement provision (IORPs II Directive) 3
o Basic Safety Standards Directive 4
o Directive amending the Oil Stocks Directive as regards the methods for
calculating stockholding obligations 5;
• failure to effectively implement the rules on the 112 emergency number, in
particular by not ensuring equivalent access for disabled users 6;
• failure to submit information about operators of essential services identified
under the EU law on the security of network and information systems 7;
• incorrect transposition of the Directive on criminal sanctions for market abuse 8;
• incorrect transposition of the Directive on combating the sexual abuse and
sexual exploitation of children 9;
1
Directive 2016/801/EU, MEMO/19/462.
2
Directive (EU) 2017/541, INF/19/4251.
3
Directive 2016/2341/EU, INF/19/5950.
4
Directive 2013/59/Euratom, INF/19/6304.
5
Directive (EU) 2018/1581.
6
Directive (EU) 2002/22, INF/19/4251.
7
Directive (EU) 2016/1148, INF/19/4251.
8
Directive 2014/57/EU, INF/19/4251.
9
Directive 2011/93/EU, INF/19/5950.
60
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Greece
• obstacles to the recognition of professional qualifications 10;
• incorrect implementation of the SEPA Regulation 11;
• non-conformity of certain provisions with the third Motor Insurance Directive 12;
• lack of measures to address waste problems in Corfu Island 13;
• incorrect transposition of the Industrial Emissions Directive and failure to protect
citizens from noxious air pollution from several power plants, as required by the
said Directive 14;
• failure to comply with the nitrogen dioxide (NO2) limit values set by the Air
Quality Directive, to put in place adequate sampling points to properly monitor
NO2 concentrations and to make available a complete air quality report 15;
• incorrect transposition of the revised Environmental Impact Assessment
Directive 16;
• failure to comply with the minimum requirements of control on driving and
resting times, and on the use of tachographs 17;
• non-compliance with the requirements of the Energy Efficiency Directive 18;
• failure to establish penalties in accordance with the Invasive Alien Species
Regulation 19.
b. [The Commission referred one case to the Court under Article 258 TFEU. It concerns:
• failure to establish the necessary conservation measures and objectives for all
sites designated as Special Areas of Conservation under the Habitats Directive 20.
c. [The Commission referred one case to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU. It
concerns:
• failure to comply with a Court judgment establishing that Greece had failed to
protect its waters against pollution caused by nitrates from agricultural
sources 21.
IV. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. Late transposition infringement cases against Greece open on 31 December
(2015-2019)
10
Directive 2005/36/EC, as amended by Directive 2013/55/EU and TFEU, INF/19/4251.
11
Regulation (EU) 260/2012, MEMO/19/1472.
12
Directive 2009/103/EC.
13
MEMO/19/1472.
14
Directive 2010/75/EU, INF/19/4251.
15
Directive 2008/50/EC, MEMO/19/462.
16
Directive 2011/92/EU, as amended by Directive 2014/52/EU, INF/19/5950.
17
Directive 2006/22/EC, Regulation (EC) No 561/2006, Regulation (EU) 165/2014, MEMO/19/1472.
18
Directive 2012/27/EU, MEMO/19/462.
19
Regulation (EU) No 1143/2014, INF/19/6304.
20
Directive 92/43/EEC, Commission v Greece, C-849/19, IP/19/4257.
21
Commission v Greece, C-298/19, MEMO/19/1472.
61
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Greece
32 33 32
29
24
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases against Greece (2015-2019)
36
32
22
19
17
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
62
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Greece
3. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: policy areas
19 new late transposition infringement cases against
Greece
Transport and Taxation and
mobility customs
3 4
Energy
2
Internal market,
industry,
entrepreneurship
and SMEs
2
Other
Justice and 4
consumers
4
4. Referrals to the Court
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU..
V. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Long Term Residents Directive 22
o Reception Conditions Directive 23
o Asylum Procedures Directive 24
o labour rights for seafarers 25
o Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID II) 26
o Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive (ATAD1) 27
o Directive as regards access to anti-money laundering information (DAC5) 28
o Directive on antitrust damages actions 29
o Indirect Land Use Change Directive 30;
22
Directive 2011/51/EU.
23
Directive 2013/33/EU, INF/19/4251.
24
Directive 2013/32/EU.
25
Directive (EU) 2015/1794.
26
Directive 2014/65/EU.
27
Directive (EU) 2016/1164.
28
Directive 2016/2258/EU.
29
Directive 2014/104/EU.
30
Directive (EU) 2015/1513.
63
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Greece
• disproportionate charges for issuance of residence permits;
• failure to establish a general system for the protection of wild birds, prohibiting, in
particular, their deliberate killing through poison baits;
• shortage of staff assigned to the services responsible for veterinary controls;
• non-compliance with the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive 31;
• incorrect implementation of EU rules on civil aviation security 32..
VI. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
The Court ruled that:
• Greece introduced illegal additional requirements to the training of mediators, in
breach of EU rules 33.
• Greece’s application of a reduced excise duty rate on the spirit drinks, Tsipouro and
Tsikoudia, produced by systematic distilleries, and the application of a super-reduced
rate to those spirits produced by small occasional distillers are both incompatible with
EU law 34.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court addressed the following preliminary rulings to the Greek judiciary:
• The Directive on the transfer of undertakings may, under certain conditions, apply in a
situation where the transferor, the transferee or both envisage not only the pursuit of
the activity transferred, but also the future liquidation of the transferee itself 35.
• When the public is not put in a position to actually participate in the environmental
impact assessment for a project, a time limit cannot be imposed on the public to bring
proceedings against the decision granting consent for the project 36.
• Greek legislation prohibiting a monk who has the status of lawyer in another Member
State from registering at the bar, on account of the incompatibility between the status
of monk and
the profession of lawyer, is contrary to EU law 37.
31
Directive 2010/31/EU.
32
Regulation (EC) No 300/2008.
33
Commission v Greece, C-729/17.
34
Commission v Greece, C-91/18.
35
Ellinika Nafpigeia, C-664/17.
36
Flausch and Others, C-280/18 and Court press release No 137/2019.
37
Monachos Eirinaios, C-431/17 and Court press release No 56/2019.
64
Monitoring the application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Spain
Spain
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints made against Spain by members of the public (2015-2019)
553 542
486
437
424
342
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints against Spain open at year-end
395 ► Complaints open at end-2018
542 ► New complaints registered in 2019
537 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 400 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy areas
542 complaints made against Spain
Justice and
consumers
243
Environment
70
Other
165
Employment
64
65
Monitoring the application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Spain
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files opened against Spain (2015-2019)
53
49
11
9
7
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy areas
9 EU Pilot files opened against Spain
Maritime affairs
and fisheries
3
Agriculture and
rural
development
Taxation and 2
customs unio,
1
Environment
1 Employment
1
Energy
1
66
Monitoring the application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Spain
3. Files relating to Spain open in EU Pilot at year-end
78
74
55
39
31
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
4. EU Pilot files: Spain’s resolution rate in 2015-2019
80% 80% 88%
75% 75%
77% 77%
72% 73%
69%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Spain General rate for all Member States
III. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases against Spain open on 31 December (2015-2019)
97
93
91
85
83
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
67
Monitoring the application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Spain
68
Monitoring the application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Spain
2. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a. The Commission opened 31 new infringement cases against Spain in 2019.
These, and other major ongoing infringement cases, include:
• incorrect transposition of the:
o Directive on criminal sanctions for market abuse 1
o Directive on combating the sexual abuse and sexual exploitation of children 2
o Energy Efficiency Directive 3
o EU legislation on railway safety 4
o Directive on minimum safety requirements for tunnels in the trans-European
road network 5
o Universal Service Directive, in particular by not ensuring equivalent access for
disabled users to the 112 emergency number 6;
• incompatibility of national rules on paid annual leave with EU labour legislation 7;
• delays in the implementation of the Geo-blocking Regulation, by failing to
provide for measures and mechanisms for consumer protection 8;
• failure to ensure that urban waste water is adequately collected and treated9;
• incorrect application of the Merger Directive 10;
1
Directive 2014/57/EU; INF/19/4251,
2
Directive 2011/93/EU, MEMO/19/462 INF/19/4251 and INF/19/5950.
3
Directive 2012/27/EU, INF/19/4251.
4
Directive 2004/49/EC, MEMO/19/462.
5
Directive 2004/54/EC, INF/19/5950.
6
Directive (EU) 2002/22; INF/19/4251.
7
Directive 2003/88/EC, INF/19/4251.
8
Regulation (EU) 2018/302 ; INF/19/4251.
9
Directive 91/271/EEC, INF/19/6304.
69
Monitoring the application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Spain
• failure to take the necessary measures to enhance protection of the species of
the turtle dove as required by the Birds Directive 11;
• failure to adopt a national programme for the implementation of a spent fuel
and radioactive waste management policy that is compliant with the
requirements of the Radioactive Waste Directive 12;
• discrimination on the taxation of rental income of non-resident individuals in
breach of Article 63 TFEU 13;
• obligation to appoint a fiscal representative in Spain in violation of Articles 45, 49
and 56 of TFEU 14;
• failure to upgrade the connection of their national electronic registers on road
hauliers to the new version of European Registers of Road Transport
Undertakings (ERRU) 15;
• failure to fulfil the obligations under the EU rules establishing a single European
railway area 16;
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Directive on the use of passenger name records 17
o Asylum Procedures Directive 18
o Directive on the activities and supervision of institutions for occupational
retirement provision (IORPs II Directive) 19
o Bank Creditors Hierarchy Directive 20
o the Basic Safety Standards Directive 21.
b. The Commission referred four case(s) to the Court under Article 258 TFEU.
They involve the following infringements:
• failure to take adequate measures to protect the groundwater bodies that feed
the Doñana wetlands and to prevent the deterioration of protected habitats in
these wetlands, in violation of the Water Framework Directive and the Habitats
Directive 22;
• absence of flood risk management plans, required under the Floods Directive,
for all seven river basin districts in the Canary Islands 23;
• failure to comply with the requirements on individual metering in multi-
apartment and multi-purpose buildings laid down in the Energy Efficiency
Directive 24;
10
Directive 90/434/EEC, IP/19/462.
11
Directive 2009/147/EC, INF/19/4251.
12
Directive 2011/70/Euratom, INF/19/6304.
13
IP/19/1472.
14
IP/19/4251.
15
Regulation (EU) 2016/480, INF/19/4251.
16
Directive 2012/34/EU, INF/19/5950,
17
Directive (EU) 2016/681; MEMO/19/462.
18
Directive 2013/32/EU; INF/19/4251.
19
Directive 2016/2341/EU.
20
Directive 2017/2399/EU.
21
Council Directive 2013/59/Euratom.
22
Directives 2000/60/EC and 92/43/EEC, Commission v Spain, C-559/19, IP/19/466.
23
Directive 2007/60/EC, Commission v Spain, C-384/19, IP/19/465.
70
Monitoring the application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Spain
• failure to fulfil obligations under Articles 21, 45, 56 and 63 TFEU, and Articles 28,
31, 36 and 40 of the EEA Agreement as regards certain features of the obligation
to provide information on assets located abroad (Modelo 720) 25.
c. The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.
24
Directive 2012/27/EU, Commission v Spain, C-347/19; IP/19/1473.
25
Case C-788/19 Commission v Spain, IP/19/2774.
71
Monitoring the application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Spain
IV. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. Late transposition infringement cases against Spain open on 31 December
(2015-2019)
36
32 32
21
18
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases against Spain (2015-2019)
32
34
17
16 10
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
72
Monitoring the application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Spain
3. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
10 new late transposition infringement cases against
Spain
Financial stability, financial services and Capital
Markets Union
2
Energy
1
Internal market,
industry,
entrepreneurship
and SMEs Justice and
2 consumers
1
Taxation and
customs union
2
Environment
2
V. REFERRALS TO THE COURT
The Commission referred one case to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
• concerned a failure to transpose the Data Protection Law Enforcement Directive 26.
VI. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• incorrect transposition of the Third Energy Package Directives 27;
• incompatibility of the Spanish procedural law with the Directive on unfair contract terms
and breach of Article 47 of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights 28;
• obstacles to the free movement of food supplements 29;
• trapping of five species of wild finches beyond the strict conditions set by the Directive on
the conservation of wild birds30;
• incorrect transposition of the Directive on the protection of animals used for scientific
purposes31;
26
Commission v Spain, C-658/19, IP/19/4261. The Commission has decided to refer Spain and ask both for
the payment of a daily penalty (EUR 89 548.20 per day) and a lump-sum: EUR 21 321.00 per day, with a
minimum of EUR 5 290 000.
27
Directives 2009/72/EC and 2009/73/EC.
28
Directive 93/13/EEC.
29
Article 34 TFEU.
30
Directive 2009/147/EC.
31
Directive 2010/63/EU.
73
Monitoring the application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Spain
• failure to communicate national measures transposing the:
o Directive on tobacco products 32
o Directive on conditions of entry and residence of third-country nationals for research
and studies 33
o Directive on standards for the qualification of third-country nationals as beneficiaries of
international protection 34
o Reception Conditions Directive 35
o Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID II) 36
o Mortgage Credit Directive 37
o Offshore Safety Directive 38
o Nuclear Safety Directive 39.
VII. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings 40
The Court ruled the following:
• Spain has not adopted on time, as required by the Water Framework Directive, the
second round of river basin management plans for Lanzarote, Fuerteventura, Gran
Canaria, Tenerife, La Gomera, La Palma and El Hierro 41.
• The Court dismissed the Commission’s action against Spain concerning the adoption
and/or revision of waste management plans. The Court found that the Commission
had prematurely opened the pre-litigation stage of the infringement procedure and,
consequently, dismissed the action as inadmissible 42.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court addressed the following preliminary rulings to the Spanish judiciary:
• The requirements stemming from the principles of effectiveness and ex officio review
of unfair contract terms apply also to proceedings for a European payment order.
Therefore, the courts seized with a request to issue a European order for payment
must be able to request from the creditor additional information on contract terms, in
order to assess the possible unfairness of such terms 43.
• Figurative signs may trigger directly in the consumer’s mind the image of products
whose designation of origin is protected, on account of their ‘conceptual proximity’ to
32
Directive 2014/40/EU.
33
Directive 2016/801/EU.
34
Directive 2011/95/EU; INF/19/4251.
35
Directive 2013/33/EU; INF/19/4251.
36
Directive 2014/65/EU.
37
Directive 2014/17/EU.
38
Directive 2013/30/EU.
39
Directive 2014/87/Euratom.
40
These rulings are almost exclusively handed down in infringement procedures.
41
Commission v Spain, C-556/18.
42
Commission v Spain, C-642/18.
43
Bondora, C-453/18 and C-494/18.
74
Monitoring the application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Spain
such a designation. Consequently, a protected designation of origin, such as ‘queso
manchego’, may be evoked through the use of figurative signs, including where such
figurative signs are used by a producer established in the geographical area associated
with the designation of origin, but whose products, similar or comparable to those
protected by the designation of origin, are not covered by it 44.
• On the basis of the Working Time Directive and in light of the Charter of Fundamental
Rights of the EU, the Member States must require employers to set up an objective,
reliable and accessible system enabling the duration of time worked each day by each
worker to be measured 45.
• A financial contribution imposed on certain electricity generating undertakings to
finance savings and energy efficiency plans managed by a public authority does not
constitute a public service obligation under the Electricity Directive 46.
• National legislation may set taxes on the production and storage of nuclear fuel and
waste which apply only to electricity-generating undertakings using nuclear energy and
whose main objective is to increase the amount of revenue for the electricity financial
system. Such legislation does not violate the principle of non-discrimination provided
for by the Electricity Directive 47.
• EU law does not prohibit a tax on the use of inland waters for the production of
electricity which does not incentivise the efficient use of water, nor establish
mechanisms for the preservation and protection of public water resources, as it is
focused solely and exclusively on the income-generating capacity of hydroelectricity
producers. A tax on the use of inland waters to produce electricity which exclusively
affects hydroelectricity generators operating in river basins encompassing more than
one autonomous community and not those operating in river basins encompassing a
single autonomous community is not considered discriminatory 48.
• Immunity implies lifting the pre-trial detention measure imposed prior to the election
of the person concerned as member of the European Parliament, allowing him or her
to take part in the inaugural session of the European Parliament. However, if the
competent national court considers that the detention measure should be maintained
after that person has become member of the European Parliament, it must, as soon as
possible, request that the European Parliament waive
that immunity 49.
• Calculating the length of service of a part-time worker whose working hours are
‘distributed vertically’ over the whole year (a vertical cyclical part-time worker) solely on
44
Fundación Consejo Regulador de la Denominación de Origen Protegida Queso Manchego, C-614/17 and
Court press release No 55/19.
45
CCOO, C-55/18.
46
Directive 2009/72/EC, Engie Cartagena, C–523/18.
47
Directive 2009/72/EC, joined cases: UNESA, C-80/18, Endesa Generación, C-81/18, Endesa Generación, C-
82/18 and Iberdrola Generación Nuclear, C-83/18.
48
Joined cases: UNESA, C-105/18, Engasa, C-106/18, Duerocanto, C-107/18, Acciona, C-108/18, Associació de
Productors i Usuaris d’Energia Elèctrica, C-109/18, Burgos Pérez and Guinea Bueno, C-110/18, Endesa
Generación, C-111/18, APPA, C-112/18, Parc del Segre and Others, C-113/18.
49
Junqueras Vies, C-502/19.
75
Monitoring the application of European Union Law
2019 Annual Report
Spain
the basis of periods actually worked when it comes to the right to pay rise and
promotion, while not doing the same for comparable full-time workers, may be
discriminatory and therefore breach the Framework Agreement on Part-Time Work
and the Equal Treatment Directive 50.
50
OH/ER v AEAT, joined cases C-439/18 and C-472/18.
76
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
France
France
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints made against France by members of the public (2015-2019)
383
325
316
291
267
245
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints against France open at year-end
280 ► Complaints open at end-2018
291 ► New complaints registered in 2019
331 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 240 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy areas
291 complaints made against France
Justice and
consumers
80
Employment
48
Other
73 Internal market,
industry,
entrepreneurship and
SMEs
Migration and Health and food 35
home affairs safety
23 32
77
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
France
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files opened against France (2015-2019)
53
46
14
8 6
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy areas
14 EU Pilot files opened against France
Migration and home affairs
3
Mobility and
transport
Maritime affairs 2
and fisheries
4
Other
3
Environment
2
3. Files relating to France open in EU Pilot at year-end
78
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
France
73
62 50
31
26
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
4. EU Pilot files: France’s resolution rate in 2015-2019
89%
84%
80%
77%
75% 74%
77%
72% 73%
68%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
France General rate for all Member States
III. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases against France open on 31 December (2015-2019)
83
80
65
62
59
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
79
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
France
32 new infringement cases against France
Internal market,
industry,
Environnement entrepreneurship
11 and SMEs
9
Justice and
consumers
Other 4
4 Energy
2
Financial stability, financial services and capital markets union
2
80
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
France
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a. The Commission opened 32 new infringement cases against France in 2019. These,
and other major ongoing infringement cases, include:
• failure to award authorisations and concessions in the hydroelectric power
sector in line with the Services Directive and public procurement rules 1;
• unjustified restrictions on providers of services related to energy efficiency, in
breach of the Services Directive 2;
• delays in the implementation of the Geo-blocking Regulation, by failing to
provide for measures and mechanisms for consumer protection 3;
• incorrect transposition of the Free movement Directive 4 as regards the delivery
of residence documents 5;
• authorisation of non-selective hunting practices which are not in line with the
Birds Directive 6;
• failure to take the necessary measures to enhance protection of the species of
the turtle dove as required by the Birds Directive7;
• failure to comply with the Water Framework Directive concerning the ecological
continuity of the Rhine River8;
• failure to fulfil the obligations under the EU rules establishing a single European
railway area9;
• tax disadvantages related to personal care and ‘help at home' services
concerning some resident and non-resident taxpayers10;
• incorrect transposition of the:
o Directive on criminal sanctions for market abuse 11
o Directive on combating the sexual abuse and sexual exploitation of children 12
o Directive on public access to environmental information 13
o revised Environmental Impact Assessment Directive 14;
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Directive on conditions of entry and residence of third-country nationals for
research and studies 15
o Directive on the activities and supervision of institutions for occupational
retirement provision (IORPs II Directive) 16
1
Directives 2006/123/EC and 2014/23/EU ; IP/19/1477.
2
Directives 2006/123/EC, 2009/28/EC and 2012/27/EU.
3
Regulation (EU) 2018/302 ; INF/19/4251.
4
Directive 2004/38/EC.
5
INF/19/4251.
6
Directive 2009/147/EC, INF/19/4251.
7
Directive 2009/147/EC, INF/19/4251.
8
Directive 2000/60/EC, INF/19/4251.
9
Directive 2012/34/EU, MEMO/19/462,
10
IP/19/462.
11
Directive 2014/57/EU; INF/19/4251,
12
Directive 2011/93/EU, MEMO/19/462 INF/19/4251 and INF/19/5950.
13
Directive 2003/4/EC, MEMO/19/462.
14
Directive 2011/92/EU, as amended by Directive 2014/52/EU, MEMO/19/1472.
15
Directive 2016/801/EU, INF/19/4251.
81
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
France
o Bank Creditors Hierarchy Directive 17
o Energy Efficiency Directive 18.
b. [The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU.]
c. [The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.]
IV. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. Late transposition infringement cases against France open on 31 December
(2015-2019)
35
26 26
24
17
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases against France (2015-2019)
33
22
17
15
11
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
16
Directive 2016/2341/EU.
17
Directive 2017/2399/EU.
18
Directive 2012/27/EU, MEMO/19/462.
82
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
France
11 new late transposition infringement cases against
France
Internal market,
industry, Justice and
entrepreneurship and consumers
SMEs 2
3
Financial stability,
financial services and
Capital Markets Union
2
Other
4
4. Referrals to the Court
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
V. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• failure to communicate national measures transposing the:
o Directive on standards for the qualification of third-country nationals as beneficiaries of
international protection 19
o Reception Conditions Directive 20
o Asylum Procedures Directive 21
o minimum requirements for enhancing worker mobility between Member States by
improving the acquisition and preservation of supplementary pension rights 22
o Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID II) 23
o Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive (ATAD1) 24
o Indirect Land Use Change Directive 25.
VI. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings 26
The Court ruled that:
19
Directive 2011/95/EU; INF/19/4251.
20
Directive 2013/33/EU; INF/19/4251.
21
Directive 2013/32/EU.
22
Directive 2014/50/EU.
23
Directive 2014/65/EU.
24
Directive (EU) 2016/1164.
25
Directive (EU) 2015/1513.
26
These rulings are almost exclusively handed down in infringement procedures.
83
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
France
• France has systematically and persistently exceeded the limit values for nitrogen
dioxide (NO2) since 2010 in 12 agglomerations and air quality zones. It has also failed
to take the appropriate measures to keep the exceedance period as short as
possible 27.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court addressed the following preliminary rulings to the French judiciary:
• Airbnb provides an information society service separate from accommodation services
to which it relates. Such a service does not aim only at providing immediate
accommodation services, but rather it consists essentially of providing a tool for
presenting and finding accommodation for rent, thereby facilitating the conclusion of
future rental agreements. Therefore, that type of service is not merely ancillary to an
overall accommodation service. Second, an intermediation service, such as the one
provided by Airbnb Ireland, is in no way indispensable to the provision of
accommodation services, since the guests and hosts have a number of other channels
in that respect, some of which are long-standing. Finally, there is no indication that
Airbnb sets or caps the amount of the rents charged by the hosts using that
platform 28.
• The procedural rules applicable to the authorisation of plant protection products, in
particular products containing glyphosate, are valid; therefore, there are no grounds to
question the validity of the regulation on placing plant protection products on the
market. 29.
• The organic production logo of the EU cannot be placed on products derived from
animals that have been slaughtered in accordance with religious rites without first
being stunned. The organic logo of the EU aims to reassure consumers that products
bearing it have been obtained in observance of the highest standards, in particular in
the area of animal welfare 30.
• Mortgage loans reserved for employees of an undertaking and granted for private
purposes fall within the scope of the Directive on unfair terms in consumer
contracts 31. The Court confirmed that the notion of ‘seller or supplier’ has to be
interpreted broadly, and it is not necessary that the contract reflect a person’s main
activity 32.
• The prohibition on processing certain categories of sensitive personal data applies also
to operators of search engines. The search engine operator has, in principle, the
obligation to de-reference, if asked by the person concerned. To this end, the search
engine operator must carry out a case-by-case assessment to verify if the publication
of the ‘sensitive’ data and personal data on criminal convictions is strictly necessary to
27
Commission v France, C-636/18 and Court press release No 132/2019.
28
Airbnb Ireland, case C – 390/18.
29
Procureur de la République v Blaise and Others, C-616/17.
30
Oeuvre d’assistance aux bêtes d’abattoirs, C-497/17 and Court press release 15/19
31
Directive 93/13/EEC.
32
Pouvin Dijoux, C-590/17.
84
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
France
protect the freedom of information of internet users potentially interested in accessing
this web page by means of such a search 33.
• The right to be forgotten applies within the EU. Search engine operators have to take
sufficiently effective measures to ensure the effective protection of this right, which
does not necessarily apply outside of the EU 34.
• The Gas Directive allows a decision of a regulatory authority settling a dispute between
energy companies to extend its effects to the situation of the parties before the
emergence of that dispute, by requiring one party to bring a contract for the
transmission of natural gas in line with EU law for the entire contractual period 35.
33
Google 2, C-136/17.
34
Google 3, C-507/17.
35
Directive 2009/73/EC, GRDF, C-236/18.
85
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Croatia
Croatia
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints made against Croatia by members of the public (2015-2019) 1
89
70
65
60
50
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints against Croatia open at year-end
51 ► Complaints open at end-2018
70 ► New complaints registered in 2019
64 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 57 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy areas
70 complaints made against Croatia
Justice and
consumers
28
Environment
7
Employment
6
Other
16 Regional and urban
policy
Internal market, industry, 5
entrepreneurship and SMEs Taxation and customs union
4 4
1
Croatia joined the EU on 1 July 2013.
86
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Croatia
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files opened against Croatia (2015-2019)
35
30
9
6 6
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Files relating to Croatia open in EU Pilot at year-end
36
34
29
15
12
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: policy areas
6 EU Pilot files opened against Croatia
Energy
3
Agriculture and
rural
development
1 Migration and
Taxation and home affairs
customs union 1
1
87
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Croatia
4. EU Pilot files: Croatia’s resolution rate in 2015-2019 2
77% 77%
75% 85%
72%
71% 73%
67% 67%
65%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Croatia General rate for all Member States
III. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases against Croatia open on 31 December (2015-2019)
56
48 48
44
21
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New infringement cases opened in 2019: policy areas
2
Croatia joined the EU Pilot system in July 2015.
88
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Croatia
26 new infringements made against Croatia
Environment Internal market, industry,
8 entrepreneurship and SMEs
4
Energy
2
Other Migration and home
4 affairs
2
Justice and consumers Mobility and transport
2 2
Financial stability, financial services and Capital Markets Union
2
v
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a. The Commission opened 26 new infringement cases against Croatia in 2019. These,
and other major ongoing infringement cases, include:
• failure to effectively implement the rules on the 112 emergency number, in
particular by not ensuring equivalent access for disabled users 3;
• incorrect transposition of the Directive on combating the sexual abuse and
sexual exploitation of children 4;
• non-communication of national measures transposing the Bank Creditors
Hierarchy Directive 5;
• the incorrect transposition of the Solvency II Directive 6;
• non-compliance with the requirements of the Energy Efficiency Directive 7;
• failure to submit Croatia’s second cost-optimal report required by the Energy
Performance of Buildings Directive 8;
• non-conformity of the Croatian Water Act with the Environmental Impact
Assessment Directive, the Habitats Directive and the Water Framework
Directive 9;
• incorrect transposition of the revised Environmental Impact Assessment
Directive 10;
• non-conformity of national legislation with the Groundwater Directive 11;
• non-conformity of national legislation with the Drinking Water Directive 12;
3
Directive (EU) 2002/22, INF/19/4251.
4
Directive 2011/93/EU, INF/19/5950.
5
Directive 2017/2399/EU.
6
Directive 2009/138/EC, INF/19/4251.
7
Directive 2012/27/EU, MEMO/19/462.
8
Directive 2010/31/EU, MEMO/19/462.
9
Directives 2011/92/EU, 92/43/EEC and 2000/60/EC.
10
Directive 2011/92/EU, as amended by Directive 2014/52/EU, MEMO/19/1472.
11
Directive 2006/118/EC, MEMO/19/1472.
12
Directive 98/83/EC, MEMO/19/1472.
89
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Croatia
• non-conformity of Croatian legislation with the amended Ambient Air Quality
Directive 13;
• non-conformity of national legislation with EU rules on public procurement and
concessions 14;
incorrect transposition of the SEVESO III Directive 15;
• late reporting on the environmental status of marine waters under the Marine
Strategy Framework Directive 16;
• failure to fulfil obligations under the Ship Recycling Regulation 17;
• restrictions for lawyers to provide multidisciplinary services, advertising
restrictions and limitations on the right to practice 18;
• failure to comply with minimum safety requirements for tunnels in the trans-
European road network 19.
b. [The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU.]
c. [The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.]
13
Directive 2008/50/EC, as amended by Directive (EU) 2015/1480, INF/19/4251.
14
Directives 2014/24/EU, 2014/25/EU and 2014/23/EU, MEMO/19/462;.
15
Directive 2012/18/EU.
16
Directive 2008/56/EC, MEMO/19/1472.
17
Regulation (EU) No 1257/2013, MEMO/19/2772.
18
IP 19/467, Directive 98/5/EC.
19
Directive 2004/54/EC, INF/19/5950.
90
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Croatia
IV. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. Late transposition infringement cases against Croatia open on 31 December
(2015-2019)
34
25 26
19
6
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases against Croatia (2015-2019)
25 26
9 8
7
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: policy areas
91
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Croatia
4. Referrals to the Court
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
V. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Directive on tobacco products 20
o labour rights for seafarers 21
o Markets in Financial Instruments Directive (MiFID II) 22;
• unjustified requirements imposed on the activities of driving schools 23;
• incorrect transposition of the Directive on unfair commercial practices 24;
• failure to meet EU obligations on stepping up cross-border cooperation, particularly in
combating terrorism and cross-border crime 25;
• the national law on the privatisation of Industrija Nafte d.d. (INA), which granted special
powers to the Croatian State in INA in violation of Art.icles 49 and 63 TFEU 26;
• incorrect transposition of the Solvency II Directive 27;
• incorrect transposition of the Habitats Directive 28;
• incorrect transposition of the Birds Directive 29;
• failure to notify the national programme for the implementation of a spent fuel and
radioactive waste management policy 30;
• failure to provide the required quality management system for operational parts of the flag
State-related activities 31.
VI. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
The Court ruled that:
• Croatia has breached the Waste Framework Directive as it did not classify as waste a
large amount of stone-like material deposited in Biljane Donje, it did not take the
necessary measures to ensure that waste management is carried out without
20
Directive 2014/40/EU.
21
Directive (EU) 2015/1794.
22
Directive 2014/65/EU.
23
Directive 2006/123/EC
24
Directive 2005/29/EC
25
Decisions 2008/615/JHA and 2008/616/JHA.
26
IP/17/1949.
27
Directive 2009/138/EC.
28
Directive 92/43/EEC.
29
Directive 2009/147/EC.
30
Directive 2011/70/Euratom.
31
Directive 2009/21/EC.
92
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Croatia
endangering human health and harming the environment, and it did not ensure that
the waste is properly treated by the waste holder 32.
2. Preliminary rulings
No major preliminary rulings were addressed to the Croatian judiciary in 2019.
32
Directive 2008/98/EC, Commission v Croatia, C-250/18.
93
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Italy
Italy
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints made against Italy by members of the public (2015-2019)
753
637 633
533
375
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints against Italy open at year-end
732 ► Complaints open at end-2018
375 ► New complaints registered in 2019
679 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 428 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy areas
375 complaints made against Italy
Employment
61
Internal market,
industry,
entrepreneurship
and SMEs
90 Taxation and
customs
53
Other
50 Environment
49
Mobility and
transport Justice and consumers
27 45
94
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Italy
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files opened against Italy (2015-2019)
68
52
16 18
3
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Files relating to Italy open in EU Pilot at year-end
111
99
70
45 45
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: main policy areas
95
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Italy
18 EU Pilot files opened against Italy
Mobility and transport Migration and
2 home affairs
2
Energy
3
Environment
3
Maritime affairs
and fisheries
2
Other
4
Taxation and customs
2
4. EU Pilot files: Italy’s resolution rate in 2015-2019
89% 88%
76% 77%
73%
77% 79%
75%
72% 71%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Italy General rate for all Member States
III. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases against Italy open on 31 December (2015-2019)
89
77
70 70
62
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
96
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Italy
28 new infringement cases against Italy
Environment Justice and
4 consumers
4
Internal market, industry,
entrepreneurship and
SMEs
4 Taxation and
customs
3
Mobility and
transport
Other 3
7
Migration and home affairs
3
97
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Italy
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a. The Commission opened 28 new infringement cases against Italy in 2019. These, and
other major ongoing infringement cases, include:
• incorrect transposition of the:
o Directive on criminal sanctions for market abuse 1
o Directive on combating the sexual abuse and sexual exploitation of children 2
o Directive on Attacks against Information Systems 3
o EU rules on public procurement and concessions 4
o Energy Efficiency Directive 5
o Fixed-term Work Directive 6
o Road Tunnel Safety Directive 7;
• failure to award authorisations and concessions in the hydroelectric power
sector in line with the Services Directive and public procurement rules 8;
• failure to establish Special Areas of Conservation, as well as conservation
objectives and measures to maintain or restore the protected species and
habitats to a favourable condition, as required by the Habitats Directive 9;
• failure to upgrade the connection of national electronic registers on road
hauliers to the new version of European Registers of Road Transport
Undertakings (ERRU) 10;
• preferential taxation on property on Italian soil for Italians living abroad 11;
• failure to adopt measures on penalties for infringements of the Regulation on
fluorinated greenhouse gases 12;
• failure to ensure that urban waste water is adequately collected and treated 13;
• Non-communication of the:
o Seafarers Directive 14
o Basic Safety Standards Directive 15.
b. The Commission referred four cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU. They
involve the following infringements:
1
Directive 2014/57/EU; INF/19/4251,
2
Directive 2011/93/EU, MEMO/19/462 INF/19/4251 and INF/19/5950.
3
Directive 2013/40/EU, INF/19/4251.
4
Directives 2014/24/EU, 2014/25/EU and 2014/23/EU, INF/19/6304.
5
Directive 2012/27/EU, MEMO/19/462.
6
Directive 1999/70/EC, INF/19/4251.
7
Directive 2004/54/EC, INF/19/5950.
8
Directives 2006/123/EC and 2014/23/EU, IP/19/1477.
9
Directive 92/43/EEC, MEMO/19/462.
10
Regulation (EU) 2016/480, INF/19/4251.
11
IP/19/462.
12
Regulation (EU) 517/2014.
13
Directive 91/271/EEC, INF/19/4251, MEMO/19/462 and INF/19/6304.
14
Directive (EU) 2015/1794.
15
Directive 2013/59/Euratom, Commission v Italy, C-744/19.
98
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Italy
• failure to ensure that all agglomerations with a population of more than 2 000
are provided with collecting systems for urban waste water and that urban waste
water entering collecting systems is adequately treated before discharge, as
required by the Urban Waste Water Treatment Directive 16;
• exceedance of nitrogen dioxide (NO2) limit values set by the Air Quality
Directive 17;
• failure to comply with the rules on the taxation of energy products and electricity
by applying a reduction to excise duty for petrol and gas oil used as motor fuel in
regional legislation 18;
• failure to notify transposition measures under the Basic Safety Standards
Directive 19.
c. The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.
IV. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. Late transposition infringement cases against Italy open on 31 December (2015-
2019)
20
14
12
9 9
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New late transposition infringement cases against Italy (2015-2019)
16
Directive 91/271/EEC, Commission v Italy, C-668/19, IP/19/1475.
17
Directive 2008/50/EC, Commission v Italy, C-573/19, IP/19/1475.
18
Case C-63/19 Commission v Italy, IP/19/4265.
19
Directive 2013/59/Euratom, Commission v Italy, C-744/19.
99
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Italy
18
15
11
10
7
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
100
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Italy
3. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
10 new late transposition infringement cases against Italy
Health and food
safety
2
Justice and
Taxation and
consumers
customs
3
2
Climate action
1
Energy Environment
1 1
4. Referrals to the Court
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
V. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• failure to adopt all transposition measures for the Indirect Land Use Change Directive 20;
• failure to comply with Articles 139, 144 and 148(5) of the Union Customs Code regarding
Fast Customs Corridors 21;
• incorrect transposition of the Directive on unfair commercial practices 22:
• incorrect application of the Directive on the minimum level of training of seafarers 23;
• Non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Commission Implementing Directive on protective measures against the introduction of
organisms harmful to plants 24
o Seafarers Directive 25.
VI. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings 26
The Court ruled that Italy:
20
Directive (EU) 2015/1513.
21
Regulation (EU) 952/2013.
22
Directive 2005/29/EC.
23
Directive 2008/106/EC, as amended by Directive 2012/35/EU.
24
Directive (EU) 2019/523.
25
Directive (EU) 2015/1794.
26
These rulings are almost exclusively handed down in infringement procedures.
101
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Italy
• failed to fulfill its obligations under the Directive on testing of human tissues and cells
by failing to adopt the required national transposition measures 27;
• failed to adequately prevent further spread of the quarantine harmful organism Xylella
fastidiosa in Apulia 28;
• failed to comply with the Radioactive Waste Directive, since it has not notified a final
adopted national programme for radioactive waste and spent fuel management 29;
• had not fulfilled its obligations under the Landfill Directive as regards 44 landfills, by
having failed to adopt all measures necessary to close or to bring those landfill sites
into line with the Directive 30;
• failed to fulfil its obligations under Article 8 of the Decision on the system of own
resources and Articles 6, 10, 12 and 13 of the Regulation on making own resources
available 31;
• failed to publish a notice on the extension of a motorway concession, thus breaching
public procurement legislation 32.
2. Preliminary rulings
The Court addressed the following preliminary rulings to the Italian judiciary:
• Member States are obliged, under the Fixed-Term Work Directive, to provide effective
measures designed to prevent and punish the misuse of successive fixed-term
employment contracts 33.
• National legislation under which the amount of royalties payable by holders of licences
for the extraction of natural gas is calculated on the basis of an index based on the
long- and medium-term market prices of oil and other fuels rather than short-term
market prices is not incompatible with EU law 34.
• The Waste Framework Directive 35 and the Renewable Energy Directive 36 do not prevent
national legislation from refusing the replacement of methane with a substance
derived from the chemical treatment of used vegetable oils, as a power source for an
electric power plant producing atmospheric emissions, on the ground that the
respective substance is not included in the list of categories of biomass fuels
authorised for that purpose 37.
• National legislation which classifies waste incineration facilities as ‘strategic
infrastructure and installations of major national importance’ is compatible with the
27
Commission v Italy, C-481/18.
28
Commission v Italy, C-443/18.
29
Council Directive 2011/70/Euratom, Commission v Italy, C-434/18,
30
Directive 1999/31/EC, Commission v Italy, C-498/17 and Court press release No 37/2019.
31
Decision 2014/335/EU, Euratom Regulation (EU, Euratom) 609/2014, Case Commission v Italy, C-304/18.
32
Commission v Italy, Case C-526/17.
33
Rossato, C-494/17.
34
Directive 94/22/EC, joined cases: Eni, C-364/18 and Shell Italia, C-365/18.
35
Directive 2008/98/EC.
36
Directive 2009/28/EC.
37
Prato Nevoso Termo Energy, C-212/18.
102
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Italy
’waste hierarchy’ principle under the Waste Framework Directive 38 as long as that
legislation is compatible with the other provisions of that Directive which lay down
more specific obligations. National legislation which revises upwards the capacity of
existing waste incineration facilities and provides for the construction of new
installations of that kind constitutes a ‘plan or programme’, within the meaning of the
Strategic Environmental Assesment Directive 39, likely to have significant environmental
effects and must, consequently, be subject to a prior environmental assessment 40.
• The provisions of the Regulation on public passenger transport services by rail and
road which govern the award of public service contracts do not apply to award
procedures carried out before 3 December 2019 41.
• The jurisdiction of a Member State court with respect to passenger rights in the event
of denied boarding and of cancellation or long delay of flights must be assessed in
light of the Regulation on jurisdiction and the recognition and enforcement of
judgments in civil and commercial matters 42.
• National legislation providing for the automatic termination of employment at the age
of 60 for aircraft pilots engaged in activities associated with protecting the national
security of a Member State is compatible with EU law if it is necessary for public
security and does not go beyond what is necessary to achieve this objective 43.
• National authorities which intend directly to award a public service contract for the
transport of passengers by rail are not required to publish or communicate to any
interested economic operators all the information necessary 44.
38
Directive 2008/98/EC.
39
Directive 2001/42/EC.
40
Associazione "Verdi Ambiente e Società - Aps Onlus" and Others, C-305/18.
41
Regulation (EC) No 1370/2007, joined cases: Mobit, C-350/17 and Autolinee Toscane, C-351/17.
42
Regulation (EU) No 1215/2012, Guaitoli, C-213/18.
43
Regulation (EU) No 1178/2011, Directive 2000/78/EC, Cafaro, C-396/18.
44
Regulation (EC) No 1370/2007, Autorità Garante della Concorrenza e del Mercato, C-515/18.
103
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Cyprus
Cyprus
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints made against Cyprus by members of the public (2015-2019)
90
62
57
51
43
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints against Cyprus open at year-end
54 ► Complaints open at end-2018
51 ► New complaints registered in 2019
40 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 65 ► Complaints open at end-2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy areas
51 complaints made against Cyprus
Employment
12 Migration and
home affairs
5
Environment
5
Justice and
consumers
13
Other
16
104
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Cyprus
II. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files opened against Cyprus (2015-2019)
31
27
7
4
1
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: policy areas
One new EU Pilot file opened in 2019, in the area of energy.
3. Files relating to Cyprus open in EU Pilot at year-end
40
36
24
14
10
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
4. EU Pilot files: Cyprus’s resolution rate in 2015-2019
105
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Cyprus
87%
82%
75% 75% 100%
77% 77%
72% 72% 73%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Cyprus General rate for all Member States
III. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases against Cyprus open on 31 December (2015-2019)
68 67
61
54
47
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
43 new infringement cases against Cyprus
Environment
Internal market, industry,
15
entrepreneurship and
SMEs
6
Health and food
Other safety
9 5
Taxation and
Mobility and transport customs
3 5
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
106
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Cyprus
a. The Commission opened 43 new infringement cases against Cyprus in 2019. These,
and other major ongoing infringement cases, include:
• delays in the implementation of the Geo-blocking Regulation., by failing to
provide for measures and mechanisms for consumer protection 1;
• incorrect application of the Investor Compensation Scheme Directive 2;
• general and persistent failure to ensure that plans and projects undergo an
appropriate assessment of their implications on Natura 2000 sites, as required
by the Habitats Directive 3;
• late reporting on the environmental status of marine waters under the Marine
Strategy Framework Directive 4;
• failure to upgrade the connection of their national electronic registers on road
hauliers to the new version of European Registers of Road Transport
Undertakings (ERRU) 5;
• non-compliance with the requirements of the Energy Efficiency Directive 6;
• incorrect application of the VAT rules on the lease of yachts 7;
• non-conformity of national legislation with EU rules on public procurement and
concessions 8;
• specific rules concerning the access to activities of engineers and architects 9;
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Directive on the activities and supervision of institutions for occupational
retirement provision (IORPs II Directive) 10
o Bank Creditors Hierarchy Directive 11
o Directive amending the Oil Stocks Directive as regards the methods for
calculating stockholding obligations 12
o Basic Safety Standards Directive 13.
b. [The Commission referred one case to the Court under Article 258 TFEU. It concerns:
• lack of proper collection and treatment of urban waste waters of various
agglomerations in breach of the Urban Waste Water Directive 14.
c. [The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.]
1
Regulation (EU) 2018/302, INF/19/4251.
2
Directive 97/9/EC, MEMO/19/1472.
3
Directive 92/43/EEC, INF/19/6304.
4
Directive 2008/56/EC, INF/19/5950.
5
Regulation (EU) 2016/480, INF/19/6304.
6
Directive 2012/27/EU, MEMO/19/462.
7
IP/19/4265.
8
Directives 2014/24/EU, 2014/25/EU and 2014/23/EU, MEMO/19/462;
9
IP 19/467, Directive 2013/55/EU.
10
Directive 2016/2341/EU.
11
Directive 2017/2399/EU.
12
Directive (EU) 2018/1581.
13
Directive 2013/59/Euratom, INF/19/6304.
14
Directive 91/271/EEC, Commission v Cyprus, C-248/19, IP/19/1474.
107
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Cyprus
IV. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. Late transposition infringement cases against Cyprus open on 31 December
(2015-2019)
48
42 43
29
25
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
108
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Cyprus
2. New late transposition infringement cases against Cyprus (2015-2019)
44
38
35
31
27
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
31 new late transposition infringement cases against
Cyprus
Health and food safety
5
Environment Taxation and
11 customs
4
Justice and
consumers
3
Other
8
4. Referrals to the Court
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
V. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Commission Implementing Directive as regards isolation distances for Sorghum spp. 15
o Commission Implementing Directive on minimum conditions for examining certain
varieties of agricultural plant species 16
15
Directive (EU) 2018/1027.
109
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Cyprus
o Directive on conditions of entry and residence of third-country nationals for research
and studies 17
o Reception Conditions Directive 18
o Asylum Procedures Directive 19
o minimum requirements for enhancing worker mobility between Member States by
improving the acquisition and preservation of supplementary pension rights 20
o Indirect Land Use Change Directive 21
o Mortgage Credit Directive 22
o Anti-Tax Avoidance Directive (ATAD1) 23;
• incorrect transposition of the Third Energy Package Directives 24;
• failure to provide the required quality management system for operational parts of the flag
State-related activities 25.
VI. IMPORTANT JUDGMENTS
1. Court rulings
There were no major Court rulings in 2019.
2. Preliminary rulings
No major preliminary rulings were addressed to the Cyprus judiciary in 2019.
16
Directive (EU) 2018/100.
17
Directive 2016/801/EU.
18
Directive 2013/33/EU; INF/19/4251.
19
Directive 2013/32/EU.
20
Directive 2014/50/EU.
21
Directive (EU) 2015/1513.
22
Directive 2014/17/EU.
23
Directive (EU) 2016/1164.
24
Directives 2009/72/EC and 2009/73/EC.
25
Directive 2009/21/EC.
110
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Latvia
Latvia
I. COMPLAINTS
1. New complaints made against Latvia by members of the public (2015-2019)
35
31
26
20
17
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Public complaints against Latvia open at year-end
20 ► Complaints open at end-2018
31 ► New complaints registered in 2019
27 ► Complaints handled in 2019
= 24 ► Complaints open at end 2019
3. New complaints registered in 2019: main policy areas
31 complaints made against Latvia
Justice and Taxation and
consumers customs
8 5
Financial stability,
Other financial services
13 and Capital Markets
Union
5
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Latvia
I. EU PILOT
1. New EU Pilot files opened against Latvia (2015-2019)
20
17
9
4
2
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. Files relating to Latvia open in EU Pilot at year-end
26 26
21
17
13
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New EU Pilot files opened in 2019: policy areas
4 EU Pilot files opened against Latvia
Energy
1
Maritime affairs
and fisheries
2
Migration and
home affairs
1
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Latvia
4. EU Pilot files: Latvia’s resolution rate in 2015-2019
79%
78%
73% 73%
77% 77%
75%
73%
72%
50%
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Latvia General rate for all Member States
II. INFRINGEMENT CASES
1. Infringement cases against Latvia open on 31 December (2015-2019)
40
38 37
35
28
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
2. New infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Latvia
22 new infringement cases against Latvia
Internal market,
industry,
entrepreneurship and Environment
SMEs 4
5
Other
2
Taxation and
customs
4
Energy
2
Migration and Financial stability, financial services
home affairs and Capital Markets Union
2 3
3. Key infringement cases and referrals to the Court
a. The Commission opened 22 new infringement cases against Latvia in 2019. These,
and other major ongoing infringement cases, include:
• failure to ensure adequate protection of habitats and species of EU interest by
designating nature protection areas to complete the NATURA 2000 network 1
• failure to ensure that urban waste water is adequately collected and treated 2
• incorrect implementation of the SEPA Regulation 3;
• incorrect transposition of the:
o Directive on combating the sexual abuse and sexual exploitation of children 4
o EU rules on public procurement and concessions 5
o Directive on the protection of animals used for scientific purposes 6
o Energy Efficiency Directive 7
o Radioactive Waste Directive 8;
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Directive on the activities and supervision of institutions for occupational
retirement provision (IORPs II Directive) 9
o Bank Creditors Hierarchy Directive 10.
b. [The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 258 TFEU.]
1
INF/19/6304.
2
Directive 91/271/EEC, MEMO/19/462.
3
Regulation (EU) 260/2012, MEMO/19/1472.
4
Directive 2011/93/EU, MEMO/19/462 INF/19/4251 and INF/19/5950.
5
INF/19/5950; Directives 2014/24/EU, 2014/25/EU and 2014/23/EU.
6
Directive 2010/63/EU, INF/19/5950.
7
Directive 2012/27/EU, MEMO/19/462.
8
Directive 2011/70/Euratom, MEMO/19/462.
9
Directive 2016/2341/EU.
10
Directive 2017/2399/EU.
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Latvia
c. [The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Article 260(2) TFEU.]
III. TRANSPOSITION OF DIRECTIVES
1. Late transposition infringement cases against Latvia open on 31 December
(2015-2019)
32
28
23
20 20
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Latvia
2. New late transposition infringement cases against Latvia (2015-2019)
20
19
16
12 12
2015 2016 2017 2018 2019
3. New late transposition infringement cases opened in 2019: main policy areas
12 new late transposition infringement cases against
Latvia
Internal market, industry, Financial stability,
entrepreneurship and SMEs financial services and
2 capital markets union
2
Migration and home affairs
1
Taxation and customs Justice and consumers
union 1
4 Environment
1
Mobility and transport
1
4. Referrals to the Court
The Commission did not refer any cases to the Court under Articles 258 and 260(3) TFEU.
IV. EARLY RESOLUTION OF INFRINGEMENT CASES
Major cases closed without a Court judgment in 2019
These concerned:
• restrictions to registration of right hand drive cars 11;
• discriminatory taxation of real estate in Riga City;
• non-compliance with the Energy Performance of Buildings Directive 12;
• non-communication of national measures transposing the:
o Commission Implementing Directive as regards isolation distances for Sorghum spp. 13
11
Directive 2007/46/EC.
12
Directive 2010/31/EU.
13
Directive (EU) 2018/1027.
Monitoring the application of European Union law
2019 Annual Report
Latvia
o Reception Conditions Directive 14
o Asylum Procedures Directive 15
o Anti-tax avoidance Directive 16.
14
Directive 2013/33/EU; INF/19/4251.
15
Directive 2013/32/EU.
16
Directive (EU) 2016/1164.
M o nit o ri n g t h e a p pli c ati o n of E u r o p e a n U ni o n l a w
2 0 1 9 A n n u al R e p o rt
L at vi a
V. I M P O RTA NTJ U D G ME NTS
1. C o u rt r uli n g s 1 7
T h e r e w e r e n o m aj o r C o u rt r uli n g s i n 2 0 1 9.
2. P r eli mi n a r y r uli n g s
T h e C o u rt a d d r e s s e d t h e f oll o wi n g p r eli mi n a r y r uli n g s t o t h e L at vi a n j u di ci a r y:
• r e c o r di n g of a vi d e o of p oli c e offi c e r s i n a p oli c e st ati o n, w hil e a st at e m e nt i s b ei n g
m a d e, a n d t h e p u bli c ati o n of t h at vi d e o o n a vi d e o w e b sit e, o n w hi c h u s e r s c a n s e n d,
w at c h a n d s h a r e vi d e o s, a r e c o v e r e d b y t h e E U r ul e s o n d at a p r ot e cti o n. F u rt h e r, s u c h
r e c o r di n g a n d s u c h p u bli c ati o n o n a vi d e o w e b sit e m a y c o n stit ut e a p r o c e s si n g of
p e r s o n al d at a s ol el y f o r j o u r n ali sti c p u r p o s e s 18
.
• w h e r e t h e c u st o m s v al u e of g o o d s s u c h a s m e di ci n al p r o d u ct s i s c al c ul at e d b y a p pl yi n g
t h e d e d u cti v e m et h o d (t hi s i s o n e of t h e m et h o d s u s e d f o r c al c ul ati n g t h e c u st o m s
v al u e), t h e c o m p et e nt n ati o n al c u st o m s a d mi ni st r ati o n m u st, i n o r d e r t o i d e ntif y
‘si mil a r g o o d s ’, t a k e i nt o a c c o u nt a n y r el e v a nt el e m e nt. S u c h el e m e nt s c o u l d b e t h e
r e s p e cti v e c o m p o siti o n of t h e s e g o o d s, t h ei r s u b stit ut a bilit y wit h r e g a r d t o t h ei r eff e ct s
a n d t h ei r c o m m e r ci al i nt e r c h a n g e a bilit y 1 9 .
17
T h e s e r uli n g s a r e al m o st e x cl u si v el y h a n d e d d o w n i n i nf ri n g e m e nt p r o c e d u r e s.
18
B ui vi d s, C- 3 4 5/ 1 7 .
19
SI A O ri b alt Rī g a v V al st s i e īīm u m u di e n e st s, C- 1 / 1 8.