29 September 2020
Mr Raul Siem
Minister of Foreign Trade and Information Technology
Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications
Suur-Ameerika 1
Tallinn, 10122
Estonia
RE: Ensuring open, fair, and non-discriminatory cloud market access as the EU builds the next
generation of cloud supply in Europe
Honourable Minister Siem:
I am writing to you as part of the on-going discussion on the Council’s draft Joint Declaration on “Building the
next generation cloud supply for Europe”.
The Computer & Communications Industry Association (CCIA) supports policies which seek to promote open
and fair competition in the cloud infrastructure, platform and service markets in the European Union. We
therefore appreciate efforts to foster interoperability between cloud service providers that can enable
customer control over their data and drive competitive offerings across Europe.
More generally, CCIA supports the establishment of a “cloud rulebook” that compiles existing legislation and
the development of common, non-discriminatory, and open European cloud services marketplace and duly
proportionate requirements for the public procurement of data processing services.
However, we are concerned that the draft Joint Declaration is reportedly pursuing regulatory isolationism
and erects artificial and protectionist barriers to entry into the European market. Requiring that “EU cloud
capacities should not be subject to the laws of foreign jurisdiction” would affect both global and EU-based
cloud providers operating abroad and significantly reduce cloud offerings in the EU. It could also discredit the
EU’s efforts to remove unjustified market restrictions abroad and harm EU cloud exports as a result.
By requiring that “EU cloud capacities and services should not be subject to the laws of foreign jurisdiction”,
the draft Declaration would discriminate against non-EU cloud providers and EU-based service providers
which operate internationally and exclude them from participating into the European Cloud Federation.
Those providers are naturally subject to applicable laws in the countries where they are headquartered, the
countries where they operate, as well as to international law.
To exclude non-EU cloud providers and EU-based providers operating abroad would entail a considerable
reduction of cloud supply in Europe and would severely limit the choice for EU organizations, especially
SMEs, and their ability to innovate and compete in a global market using cutting-edge cloud technologies that
an open market offers.
The reach of law will always be lawmakers’ sovereign decision, which service providers have a duty to respect,
and it would be unfair to restrict EU and non-EU based service providers access from the EU market, in
whole or in part, over laws which they have no control over.
Lastly, this requirement alone would also reduce opportunities for EU-based companies with no
international footprint to expand their business operations abroad. In the long run, CCIA cautions against
any requirement that would comfort EU’s partners in establishing or maintaining unjustified data localisation
and protectionist requirements, especially as the EU considers adopting its own extraterritorial law
enforcement data access law.
CCIA supports reforms on law enforcement and government data access laws in Europe and elsewhere
around the world, and we strongly encourage the European Union to pursue bilateral and multilateral
governmental solutions to pre-empt potential conflicts of extraterritorial laws. That is why we support the on-
going transatlantic negotiations on law enforcement access to electronic evidence and the reform of the
Budapest Convention within the Council of Europe, in respect of privacy, security, and democratic values.
In parallel, we believe that the EU can build the next generation of cloud supply in Europe by maintaining
open, fair and non-discriminatory cloud market access, fostering greater competition in the market, and
leverage this approach with its trade partners and create opportunities for EU-based service providers.
CCIA believes that the solid foundations established by existing European laws and regulations such as GDPR,
the NIS Directive, and industry-recognised standards and frameworks on data protection and security should
serve as the criteria to determine access to, participation, and provision of cloud services in Europe. We also
agree that transparency can help cloud customers conduct a meaningful risk assessment on legal, technical,
and organisational measures offered by a provider to mitigate any residual risks as they plan their journey to
the cloud.
We hope these suggestions will be useful as part of the discussion with your European partners on building
the next generation cloud supply for Europe, and we stand ready to provide further information and
suggestions.
Yours faithfully,
Christian Borggreen
Vice President & Head of Office
Computer & Communications Industry Association (CCIA)
Rue de la Loi 227, 1st floor, 1040 Brussels, Belgium
Email:
[email protected]