Saatja: François-Régis Mouton <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 30.09.2020 13:43
Adressaat: MKM info <
[email protected]>
Koopia: <
[email protected]>
Teema: Council - Informal Meeting of Energy Ministers - IOGP
recommendations
Dear Minister, dear Mr Aas,
Ahead of the informal council meeting of the energy ministers on 5 and 6
October, Im pleased to send you the attached letter and the IOGP
recommendations on the hydrogen strategy.
IOGP stands available to provide you with any further input you may need.
We trust you will take these recommendations in due consideration and we
ara available to further discuss them should you wish so.
Sincerely yours,
________________________________
François-Régis Mouton International Association of Oil &
Gas Producers
IOGP Regional Director Europe Avenue de Tervuren 188 A
email: 1150 Brussels, Belgium
reception: +32 2 790 7762 website:
François-Régis Mouton
Regional Director Europe
18 September 2020
IOGP recommendations to the Informal Council of the energy
Ministers in the context of discussions on the Hydrogen Strategy
The International Association of Oil & Gas Producers’ (IOGP) member companies account for
approximately 90% of oil and gas produced in Europe. IOGP supports the goals of the Paris
Agreement and the EU’s objective of climate neutrality by 2050 upon the implementation of
enabling measures. Many challenges must be overcome to meet this objective, and the energy
transition requires significant investments in technologies that enable hydrogen production and
effective policies driving its uptake such as carbon pricing policies.
In light of the Council’s ongoing discussions on the EU’s Hydrogen Strategy,1 we would like to share our
recommendations for policy actions on renewable and low-carbon hydrogen, including hydrogen from
natural gas with carbon capture, use or storage (CCUS) and pyrolysis. IOGP recommends the Council
to:
1. STRESS the importance of a consistently integrated, inclusive and technology neutral
approach to all initiatives stemming from the Hydrogen Strategy.
Justification: We welcome the intention to promote synergies by linking the gas and electricity markets,
as gases are an essential part of the solution to deliver on the EU’s climate objectives. Although the share
of electrification across various sectors is expected to increase, certain parts of the EU economy will be
difficult, if not impossible to electrify. Eurelectric estimates that electrification can reach 50% or more (up
to 60%) in order to reach deep decarbonisation of the economy 2050.2 This indicates that at least 40% of
the economy will not be electrified. More cost-effective emission reductions may be achieved by using
low-carbon liquids and gases in hard-to-decarbonise sectors. The existing gas infrastructure can be
leveraged for low-carbon gases such as renewable and low-carbon hydrogen and therefore avoid
significant build out of electricity infrastructure. Furthermore, 25 Member States’ National Energy and
Climate Plans (NECPs) foresee a role for hydrogen from various sources (including from natural gas with
CCS/CCUS) in the decarbonisation of their energy system.3 Different national strategies are contingent
upon different economic and geographical conditions (e.g. offshore energy or CCS/CCUS potential). We
therefore believe the EU should respect this diversity and remain open to all renewable and low-carbon
hydrogen production technologies. A consistently integrated, inclusive and technology neutral approach
which combines renewable electricity with other technologies such as low-carbon liquids and gases can
deliver decarbonisation faster and at a lower cost. The upcoming regulatory framework should enable the
development and deployment of all these options.
2. CALL on the European Commission to establish a comprehensive terminology and
certification system in a single legislative instrument that covers both renewable and
low-carbon fuels, based on full life-cycle GHG emission savings across the entire
value chain.
Justification: While the Hydrogen Strategy aims to prioritise the development of renewable hydrogen, it
acknowledges that other forms of low-carbon hydrogen are needed in the short and medium term. The
1
Hydrogen Strategy: https://ec.europa.eu/energy/sites/ener/files/hydrogen_strategy.pdf
2
Eurelectric (2018): Decarbonisation Pathways.
3
See IOGP (2020) assessment of NECPs: http://www.oilandgaseurope.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/NECPs-Factsheet-v2.pdf
1
life-cycle GHG emissions of electricity-based hydrogen largely depend on the source of the electricity
used, and for low-carbon hydrogen produced from natural gas with CCS/CCUS they largely depend on
the carbon capture rate. Establishing a comprehensive terminology in a single legislative instrument that
covers both renewable and low-carbon fuels would facilitate the use of natural gas-based hydrogen
production with CCS/CCUS and support the parallel and future uptake of renewable hydrogen. We believe
REDII should be amended to establish such a comprehensive terminology. In the case that the REDII
cannot accommodate a terminology and a subsequent system of certification which recognises both
renewable and low-carbon fuels, we insist that policy makers assess the possibility for a better-suited
certification framework based on the life-cycle GHG emission savings of hydrogen production.
3. EMPHASISE the importance of market-based solutions for creating a market and a
level playing field for low-carbon technologies, and of ensuring that all policy options
(including possible targets such as shares or quotas) are consistent with other policy
measures and inclusive of all forms of renewable and low-carbon hydrogen.
Justification: We note that the Commission will consider establishing targets such as minimum shares
or quotas for hydrogen in specific end-use sectors. Although this could help create a market by driving
demand for hydrogen, we believe that the approach should be carefully assessed as it may lead to
diversion of renewable electricity to hydrogen production simply to meet the target, without delivering
additional GHG savings. We strongly recommend that all policy options (including targets) are assessed
in order to ensure their consistency with other policy measures and that all forms of renewable and low-
carbon hydrogen are considered eligible.
4. STRESS the importance of parallel development of a dedicated hydrogen
infrastructure and the possibility to blend hydrogen with natural gas; ENCOURAGE the
integration of hydrogen infrastructure planning in the TEN-E and TYNDP frameworks.
Justification: The EU should leverage existing assets and using the natural gas infrastructure for
renewable and low-carbon gases can save time and costs compared to substantial power transmission
expansion. To compliment this, the development of a dedicated hydrogen infrastructure (through for
example repurposing existing natural gas pipelines to hydrogen where parallel natural gas pipelines exist
today) and the ability to blend hydrogen with natural gas is important. Blending can provide an initial
demand and should be accepted in the natural gas system provided that it is compatible with the quality
requirements of end users. We support the integration of renewable and low-carbon gas infrastructure
planning in the TEN-E and TYNDP frameworks, and would draw attention to possible synergies between
hydrogen and CO2 transport infrastructure to achieve low-carbon hydrogen production at large scale while
tackling hard-to-abate emissions (e.g. in port areas and industrial clusters).
5. EMPHASISE the importance of ensuring the EU’s leading role in the development of
innovative, low-carbon technologies; CALL on the Commission to establish an annual
European CCUS Forum to further study options aimed at fostering CCS/CCUS projects
in Europe and to address barriers to the transport of CO2 for use or storage.
2
Justification: The EU Strategy for Energy System Integration4 published in parallel with the Hydrogen
Strategy stresses the importance of CCS/CCUS, as do several modelling scenarios by the IPCC,5 the
IEA6 and the Commission in its “Clean Planet for all” Communication also in the context of enabling
negative emissions. 7 CCS/CCUS should also be stressed in the context of hydrogen, as it enables
the production of low-carbon hydrogen from natural gas at large scale, leveraging proven
technologies. We welcome the Commission’s consideration of establishing an annual European CCUS
Forum and strongly encourage its establishment at the latest in 2021. The Energy System Integration
Strategy further points out that barriers to CCS/CCUS development in Europe still exist, and in this context
we would draw attention to the importance of recognising the transport of CO 2 by other modes than
pipeline and the capture and storage of biogenic CO2 in the forthcoming review of the EU ETS Directive,
Monitoring and Reporting Regulation and the TEN-E Regulation.
6. UNDERLINE the importance of undertaking, in line with Better Regulation guidelines,
thorough, transparent, inclusive and science-based impact assessments of initiatives
stemming from the Hydrogen Strategy.
Justification: Regular impact assessments are needed in order to take into account new developments
and ensure that all objectives are being progressed through the transition. For example, the COVID-19
pandemic has unleashed an unprecedented socioeconomic crisis which affects all citizens and economic
activities and must be addressed. Uncertainties related to R&D, technology, international climate policy
and other macroeconomic and geopolitical developments between now and 2050 will require the EU to
commit, in line with Better Regulation guidelines, to thorough, transparent and inclusive impact
assessments. As pointed out in the recent Court of Auditors’ publication “Law-making in the European
Union after almost 20 years of Better Regulation”,8 there is a need to improve the evidence base for
decision-making and application of EU law. We note that the Hydrogen Strategy has not been subject to
a thorough, transparent, inclusive and science-based impact assessment. Moreover, in upcoming
assessments, there will be a need to incorporate information on the national hydrogen strategies of the
Member States. In view of future initiatives, we therefore underline the importance of impact assessments
in line with Better Regulation guidelines.
4
EU Strategy for Energy System Integration: https://ec.europa.eu/energy/sites/ener/files/energy_system_integration_strategy_.pdf
5
IPCC (2018): Mitigation Pathways Compatible with 1.5°C in the Context of Sustainable Development, p. 135. In: Global Warming
of 1.5°C. An IPCC Special Report
6
IEA (2019): World Energy Outlook
7
European Commission (2018). COM(2018) 773 final. A Clean Planet for all – A European strategic long-term vision for a
prosperous, modern, competitive and climate neutral economy
8
European Court of Auditors (2020): Law-making in the European Union after almost 20 years of Better Regulation
3
Brussels, 30 September 2020
Dear Minister,
The International Association of Oil & Gas Producers (IOGP) supports the goals of the Paris Agreement
and the EU’s objective of climate neutrality by 2050 and will work with the EU policymakers to help
create the essential measures to enable this energy transition.
In that context, and ahead of the upcoming informal Energy Council meeting taking place on 5-6 October
2020, IOGP– which represents companies producing 90% of Europe’s oil and gas – would like to share
with you some recommendations (attached to this letter) for policy actions on renewable and low-carbon
hydrogen, including hydrogen from natural gas with carbon capture, use or storage (CCUS) and
pyrolysis.
IOGP recommends the Council notably ahead of its discussion next week and ahead of its
conclusions on the hydrogen strategy due by mid-December to:
1. STRESS the importance of a consistently integrated, inclusive and technology neutral approach
to all initiatives stemming from the Hydrogen Strategy.
2. CALL on the European Commission to establish:
a. A comprehensive terminology and certification system in a single legislative
instrument that covers both renewable and low-carbon fuels, based on full life-
cycle GHG emission savings across the entire value chain.
b. An annual European CCUS Forum to further study options aimed at fostering
CCS/CCUS projects in Europe and to address barriers to the transport of CO2 for use
or storage and the necessary policy tools to overcome them
3. EMPHASISE the importance of market-based solutions for creating a market and a level playing
field for low-carbon technologies, and of ensuring that all policy options (including possible targets
such as shares or quotas) are consistent with other policy measures and inclusive of all forms of
renewable and low-carbon hydrogen.
4. STRESS the importance of parallel development of a dedicated hydrogen infrastructure and the
possibility to blend hydrogen with natural gas; ENCOURAGE the integration of hydrogen
infrastructure planning in the TEN-E and TYNDP frameworks.
5. EMPHASISE the importance of ensuring the EU’s leading role in the development of innovative, low-
carbon technologies.
6. UNDERLINE the importance of undertaking, in line with Better Regulation guidelines, thorough,
transparent, inclusive and science-based impact assessments of initiatives stemming from the
Hydrogen Strategy.
We trust you will take the attached proposals into consideration while discussing the Commission’s
Hydrogen Strategy and for the Council Conclusions on this topic.
We further look forward the Member States to working with all stakeholders on developing enabling
policies that will ensure reaching the climate neutrality by 2050.
A company limited by guarantee. Registered in England No. 1832064 VAT No. 241 240 903
Yours sincerely,
François-Régis Mouton
Regional Director Europe