Estonia-Latvia
Cross-Border Co-operation Programme
2014-2020
Project No: Est-Lat 51
Project name: Valga – Valka Twin Town Centre
Development
Project Partners Name (LP/PP): Valga Vallavalitsus (PP)
Fund: European Regional Development Fund
Target objective: SO 2.3: More integrated Valga-Valka central
urban area
Audit No: ELP-18/2021
Audit organisation: Ministry of Finance
Final audit report
23.02.2022
SUMMARY OF AUDIT RESULTS
Audit outcome:
Based on the audit work performed, the auditors have concluded that the implementing project partner
Valga Municipality Government has not carried out public procurement with a reference no 206895 in
compliance with the Public Procurement Act.
Audit opinion1:
Finding No 4.1: The implementing project partner Valga Municipality Government has not carried
out a public procurement with a reference no 206895 in compliance with the Public Procurement
Act.
1.Total ineligible costs of project partner Valga Municipality Government €484,647.97, within the
audit scope €435,642.84 and outside the audit scope €49,005.13.
2. Total ineligible costs of lead partner Valka Municipality Council €744,326.91, within the audit
scope of audit no 23-2021/06/DR2 €655,959.54 and outside the audit scope €88,367.37.
The project audit has been carried out in compliance with the International Standards for the Professional Practice
of Internal Auditing.
We wish to thank the auditee for the assistance and cooperation provided during the audit.
We confirm that the final audit report consists of 27 pages.
1 Significant findings are those that have or may have a financial impact (i.e. ineligible expenditure). Non-significant findings are those that have no financial
impact but whose correction will help the beneficiary to lower risks while implementing the project.
2
Audit carried out by Ministry of Environmental Protection and Regional Development of Latvia.
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SUMMARY OF AUDIT RESULTS ................................................................................................................................... 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS .................................................................................................................................................. 3
PART A ......................................................................................................................................................................... 4
1. AUDIT OBJECT AND AUDITED EXPENSES ................................................................................................ ……4
2. LIMITATIONS ......................................................................................................................................... 5
PART B ......................................................................................................................................................................... 7
AUDIT FINDINGS ...................................................................................................................................... 7
3
PART A
1. Audit object and audited expenses
1.1 GENERAL INFORMATION ABOUT THE AUDIT
Project name: Valga – Valka Twin Town Centre Development
Project number: Est-Lat 51
Priority and target objective: SO 2.3: More integrated Valga-Valka central urban area
Beneficiary (LP/PP): Valga Vallavalitsus (PP)
Contact person: Anni Teetsmann, project manager
Date of subsidy contract: 13.11.2017
Audit scope and period: Report 8.1, period 01.10.2019 – 31.01.2020, € 9,094.77
Report 9.1, period 01.02.2020 – 31.05.2020, € 419,687.15
Report 10.1, period 01.06.2020 – 30.09.2020, € 1,323,633.35
1.2 INFORMATION ABOUT THE AUDIT
Basis: - Article 127(1) of the Regulation (EU) No 1303/2013 of the
European Parliament and of the Council of 17 December
2013.
- Audit Authority’s work plan for 2021.
Objective: To provide an audit opinion that:
- the operation was selected in accordance with the
selection criteria for the operational programme;
- the expenditure declared to the Commission corresponds
to the accounting records and that the required
supporting documentation demonstrates an adequate
audit trail;
- for expenditure declared to the Commission, outputs and
results underpinning payments to the beneficiary have
been delivered.
Person(s) carrying out the audit:
Merle Oagu, Financial Control Department, Audit Unit I,
auditor
Elis Kõrvek, Financial Control Department, Audit Unit II, lead
auditor
Kaisa Kallas, Financial Control Department, Audit Unit II, audit
supervisor
Audit duration: 16.08.-23.02.2022
Methodology: Audit manual of the Estonia-Latvia Programme
Audit procedures performed: During the desk-based check due to the Covid-19 public
health situation in 2021, interviews were conducted
4
electronically with the persons involved in project
implementation and analysis/evaluation was made of the
following:
- project’s actual implementation,
- documentation related to project implementation,
- eligibility of costs,
- arrangement of book-keeping related to the project,
- existence of co-financing,
- use of the logos.
Sampling methodology (if applicable, then Not applicable
information shall be provided by the AA ):
1.3 AUDITED EXPENSES
Total amount of certified expenses subject Report 8.1, period 01.10.2019 – 31.01.2020, € 9,094.77
to auditors’ opinion on the basis of cost
documents: Report 9.1, period 01.02.2020 – 31.05.2020, € 419,687.15
Report 10.1, period 01.06.2020 – 30.09.2020, € 1,323,633.35
Size of the sample (EUR; %)3: €1,752,415.27, 100%
1. Total ineligible expenditure identified (EUR), project partner Valga Municipality Government:
€484,647.97, within the audit scope €435,642.84
National
EU Private sector
public Total
contribution contribution
contribution
Ineligible amount (EUR): 306,082.66 129,560.18 0.00 435,642.84
Ineligible amount outside the audit scope 34,431.00 14,574.13 0.00 49,005.13
(EUR):
Error rate (%)4: 24,85%
2. Total ineligible expenditure identified (EUR), lead partner Valka Municipality Council: €744,326.91,
within the audit scope of audit no 23-2021/06/DR €655,959.54
National
EU Private sector
public Total
contribution contribution
contribution
Ineligible amount (EUR): 311,318.40 344,641.14 0.00 655,959.54
Ineligible amount outside the audit scope 14,939.15 46,428.21 0.00 88,367.37
(EUR):
Error rate (%)5: 24.90%
3 If a sample was not used for auditing, the size of the sample is the total population in euros and the share of audited expenses to total population is 100%.
4 Share of ineligible expenses to audited expenses (%) 435,642.84*100/1,752,415.27
5 Share of ineligible expenses to audited expenses (%) of audit no 23-2021/06/DR; 655,959.54*100/2,634,700.56.
5
2. Limitations
The audit procedures were carried out in compliance with internationally accepted auditing standards6 and the
audit report was prepared using the principles of independence and objectivity.
The costs of the project lead partner Valka Municipality Council according to the cost-sharing agreement (signed
19.12.2019) related to the procurement with a reference no 206895 were not in this audit scope as the assessment
of costs related to part II of this procurement was done by Ministry of Environmental Protection and Regional
Development of Latvia in the scope of the audit no 23-2021/06/DR. The assessment of the procurement with a
reference no 206895 part II is in the audit scope (referred as a limitation in the audit no 23-2021/06/DR) as the
implementing project partner of the procurement was Valga Municipality Government and the procurement with a
reference no 206895 was carried out electronically in the Estonian e-procurement register in accordance with the
Estonian Public Procurement Act.
Auditors conclude that all data presented during the audit and other oral and written information made available
during the audit presents a true and fair view of the activities performed during the project implementation and are
sufficient to provide an opinion about the project. In case of additional information that was not provided or was
not known to auditors, the conclusions reached by auditors might have been different.
3. Audit follow-up activities
The beneficiary shall take into account the findings and recommendations made in Part B and the decisions made
by the MA. The AA shall monitor the implementation of recommendations made by the auditors.
6 The International Professional Practices Framework (IPPF) of the Institute of Internal Auditors.
6
PART B
AUDIT FINDINGS
1. Use of funding as intended
The funding has been used in material aspects in the intended manner, in a reasonable and efficient way and in
accordance with the objectives and requirements laid down in the subsidy contract and the programme manual.
2. Accuracy of book-keeping records
The book-keeping records for the project are in all material aspects in compliance with the current legislation.
3. Amount and timing of funding
The granting of funding has in all material aspects been made available in the amount foreseen and on time, and
the co-financing has been guaranteed.
4. Carrying out of public procurements
According to the Cooperation Programme Interreg V-A — Estonia–Latvia Programme Manual point 5.5.2 public
procurements should be done according to the Public Procurement Act7. All Estonian project partners, who are
contracting authorities of public sector in accordance with the Public Procurement Act, must follow the procedure
provided for in the Public Procurement Act (henceforth PPA). Implementing project partner Valga Municipality
Government is local authority and therefore contracting authority of public sector pursuant to clause 2 of
subsection 2 of § 5 of the PPA.
Significant finding no 4.1 – The implementing project partner Valga Municipality Government has
not carried out public procurement with a reference no 206895 in compliance with the Public
Procurement Act (detected ineligible amount 435,642.84 EUR and outside the audit scope
49,005.13 EUR).
Project partner Valga Municipality Government has carried out an open procurement with a reference no 206895
“Construction of a common urban space in the Valga-Valka twin city (Valga- Valka kaksiklinna ühise linnaruumi
ehitamine)” electronically in the Estonian e-procurement register (published 6.05.2019). The contract was awarded
to tenderer AS TREV-2 Grupp with a total contract amount of 4 076 080,01 EUR (4 095 836,23 EUR after
completion of works).
Auditors have identified following several non-compliances with the Estonian Public Procurement Act:
1. The procurement contract notice contains restrictive selection criteria – turnover requirement per lot is more
than allowed
PPA § 100 subsection 1 clause 4 states that to verify where economic and financial standing of the tenderer meets
the selection criteria, the contracting authority may demand the submission of a statement of the tenderer’s or
candidates overall net turnover or of net turnover in the field covered by the public contract or to the extent
corresponding to its subject-matter for a maximum of the last three financial years available by the time of
commencement of the public procurement, depending on the date on which the tenderer or candidate was set up
or started trading and on the availability of information on the minimum yearly turnover required, including in the
7
Link to Public Procurement Act: https://www.riigiteataja.ee/akt/113032019145
7
field covered by the public contract. Subsection 3 stipulates that under clause 4 of subsection 1 of this section, the
contracting authority is not allowed to require the tenderer or candidate to have a net turnover exceeding the
estimated value of the public contract more than twice. Where due to the risks related to the performance of the
public contract it is necessary to set a higher yearly turnover requirement, the contracting authority must state the
reasons for the requirement in the procurement documents.
Procurement contract notice point III.1.2) Economic and financial capacity: 1) of the contract notice states that the
tenderer's turnover in construction must be at least 6 000 000 EUR on average over the last three financial years.
According to the point II.1.6) of contract notice tenders could be submitted for all lots and maximum number of lots
for which one contract may be awarded to a tenderer is 2. The contract will be awarded to the tenderer who submits
the most favourable tender to a lot.
Procurement was divided into two lots with estimated cost for lot 1 (in Estonia) 1,46 million EUR and for lot 2 (in
Latvia) 2,2 million EUR. Estimated total cost of the procurement (incl. lots) was 3,66 million EUR.
Contracting authority explained (on 1.12.2021) that the term 'turnover' and 'net turnover' are intended to cover the
same thing and the criteria is set for net turnover. Part B of the selection criteria about economic and financial
capacity is supplemented by the reference to § 100 subsection 1 clause 4 of the PPA. 6 million EUR is based on
the estimated total cost of the procurement. The works consisted of nine stages, which were divided into two lots
(Valga and Valka lots). The contracting authority reserved the right to award contracts as a combination of stages
and priorities. Setting the turnover requirement for the lots of the procurement is not justified. Because before
submitting the tenders the contracting authority does not know which lots correspond to the budget and
possibilities and will go into work. It is not reasonable to impose a turnover requirement if, in the worst case, the
value of the contract would be only a small part of the estimated cost and scope of the contract. At the same time,
the company's turnover gives the most realistic picture of the company's ability to perform works, as it is an
unambiguously measurable value. In the case of the Valga-Valka project, the procurement was also divided in lots
in order to expand the range of potential tenderers. However, the object is one whole. Therefore, it is not
reasonable to impose different selection criteria on the whole and on separate lots. Building a lot is not easier
compared to the whole.
Single Procurement Document selection criteria part B does have a reference to § 100 subsection 1 clause 4 of the
PPA, where it is stated that it applies to net turnover. Point VII.2) other additional information in the contract notice
states: The net turnover requirement was relocated from terms and conditions of suitability of tenders to selection
criteria. Thus, in combination with the contracting authority’s explanation it can be concluded that the selection
criteria was set for net turnover and that all the potential tenderers had to have understood it in a similar way.
However, division to lots loses its purpose to expand the range of potential tenderers if the selection criteria are
not proportional to the size of each lot. Smaller companies are unable to meet the criteria and therefore cannot
participate in the procurement. Proportionality is defined in § 100 subsection 3 as a net turnover exceeding the
estimated value of the public contract no more than twice. For lot 1 this would have been 2,92 million EUR and for
lot 2 this sum is 4,4 million EUR. Thus, the set requirement that tendere’s turnover in construction must be at least
6 million EUR is too restrictive and disproportionate as from 17 companies who registered to the procurement in
the e-procurement register only two companies submitted their bids.
Therefore, the selection criteria is non-compliant with § 100 subsection 3 of the PPA and is restrictive. The impact
on the resources of EU cannot be excluded. Due to the nature of the irregularity, it is not possible to precisely
quantify the financial impact as it is not possible to ascertain what the price of potential tenderers’ tenders would
have been. Thus, the amount of the correction to apply is based on flat-rates.
8
Annex to the COMMISSION DECISION 14.5.2019 (C(2019) 3452 final) section 2 subsection 2.1 point 11: use of -
criteria for selection that are not discriminatory in the sense of the previous type of irregularity but still restrict
access for economic operators. Cases in which restrictive criteria/conditions/specifications were applied but still a
minimum level of competition was ensured, i.e. a number of economic operators submitted tenders that were
accepted and fulfilled the selection criteria, the rate of correction is 5%. Since there were two tenderers and both
were verified as correspondent to the selection criteria, this correction rate applies.
Auditee response to p. 1:
The contracting authority does not agree with the audit conclusion that the turnover requirement exceeds twice the
rate of the public contract. The contracting authority has required an average annual turnover of 6 million euros in
part B Economic and financial standing of the selection criteria. This requirement generally applies to the
procurement. No turnover requirement has been set for the parts of the procurement. The contracting authority
has previously justified why the general requirement has been established. The object is complex in nature and
even the construction of this part on a general contract basis requires the company to have relevant experience.
Considering the estimated cost of the procurement and the volume of the contract awarded, the overall turnover
requirement could have been also over seven million euros. As stated above, no turnover requirement was imposed
on the parts of the procurement. In a situation where a potential tenderer would have wanted to submit a tender for
only one part, this would undoubtedly have been possible. The construction of the object was very closely linked
and entailed high overheads and fixed costs. The contracting authority considered it unlikely that the tender would
be submitted for only one part. The terms of the procurement did not exclude that a tender could also be
submitted for one part. No such issue arose during the procedure. All potential tenderers who registered for the
procurement exceeded the criterion by an order of magnitude. If there was a question about the part of the
contract, the contracting authority would have specified this criterion and provided the relevant information.
It was not unreasonable to set a general criterion. The audit states that setting a criterion is restrictive,
disproportionate and burdensome. The audit is based on incorrect data and principles. The audit states that only
two tenders were submitted due to the criterion set and the others are deterred by the disproportionate
requirement. What is the basis for such a conclusion? It is expected that the audit has checked the turnover figures
of the subcontractors registered in the public procurement register and made the conclusion on the tenderers
based on the latter. In addition to the ones who have submitted a tender, for example, Nordecon AS, whose
turnover is greater than required in the procurement – the company actively participated in the procedure, Mapri
Ehituse OÜ, whose turnover is many times higher than the required criterion based on public information, have
registered. The companies having registered for the procurement are largely subcontractors who do not qualify as
the main contractor in any case. During the works, within the period for fulfilment of the contract, the
subcontractors who participated in the procurement were registered by the contracting authority itself for the
purpose of their control. These companies do not have to qualify for procurement in terms of turnover. Looking at
the field of activity of the registered companies, only four or five companies could have submitted a tender out of
the selection, taking into account the sectoral activity and not the turnover requirement. The companies that are
obviously engaged in electrical work or demolition of buildings are not main contractors for the construction of
urban space. In addition, the procurement criteria allow for a joint tender where tenderers can rely on each other's
indicators.
The result of the audit is based on incorrect facts and, as a result, the conclusions cannot be correct.
9
State Shared Service Centre’s (hereafter ‘SSSC’) joint response includes the opinions of the Financial Control,
Managing Authority and Joint Secretariat to p. 1:
Pursuant to the Article 58 (3) of the Directive 2014/24/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26
February 2014 the economic and financial standing, contracting authorities may impose requirements ensuring
that economic operators possess the necessary economic and financial capacity to perform the contract. For that
purpose, contracting authorities may require, in particular, that economic operators have a certain minimum yearly
turnover, including a certain minimum turnover in the area covered by the contract. In addition, contracting
authorities may require that economic operators provide information on their annual accounts showing the ratios,
for instance, between assets and liabilities. They may also require an appropriate level of professional risk
indemnity insurance.
SSSC admits that the word "average" is not the most appropriate in the context of this particular sentence, but to
argue that the average annual net turnover should have been € 6 000 000 for each year separately, the wording
should have been "at least € 6 000 000 on average for each financial year” ("vähemalt 6 000 000 eurot keskmiselt
iga majandusaasta kohta“). The contracting authority has not formulated the condition as such.
Even if the procurement term is regarded as ambiguous, it must be interpreted in such a way as to increase
competition, that is to say, in such a way as to increase the number of potential tenderers. The same position has
been emphasized by the Tallinn Circuit Court in cases no. 3-16-1970 and 3-18-2338.
The selection criteria was that the turnover of the tenderer in construction sector must be at least € 6 000 000 on
average for the last three financial years, which, taking into account the reasoning above, makes the average
annual claim amount to € 2 000 000.
Article 100 (3) of the Estonian Public Procurement Act allows the tenderer to require the existence of net turnover
in an amount that may not exceed the estimated value of the contract twice. The estimated total value of the
contract was € 3 660 000 00, specifically €1 460 000 00 for Lot I and €2 200 000 00 for Lot II.
Final comment from the auditors to p. 1:
The possibility mentioned by the auditee to specify this criterion is not included in the contract notice or
procurement documents. Therefore no potential tenderers had a way of knowing that. Nor would such
clarifications during procurement been in compliance with PPA § 46 subsection 3: Clarifications or documents
allowing for clarification submitted regarding procurement documents must not contain new information, without
it is not possible to submit tenders or without it the submitted tenders would become non-compliant with the
procurement documents or their content would change. It is prohibited to modify the procurement documents
based on the clarifications and documents allowing for clarification.
Contract notice in the Estonian e-procurement register can be read without registering with the procurement.
Therefore the deterrence to companies cannot be ruled out solely on the basis of analysis on registered companies
data. Burden of proof about compliance with the grant regulation lies with the beneficiary. While applying for a
grant beneficiary has to confirm compliance with all the applicable rules, laws and regulations.
As for the SSSC’s claim that the criterion should be read as at least 6 million for the last three financial years as a
whole, the contract notice does not state that. The word average makes it clear that this sum is meant for each
year so that on average it is at least 6 million per year. For the criterion to be ambiguous it has to have at least two
equally logical ways of understanding it. The word average makes no sense in any other interpretation. Also the
auditees response does not state the same interpretation as the SSSC. The auditee has stated that the contracting
authority has required an average annual turnover of 6 million euros in part B Economic and financial standing of
the selection criteria.
Since the procurement was divided into two lots per contract notice and it was also stated there that the
contracting authority will award the contract to the tenderer who submits the most favorable tender to a lot. And
also that there can be maximum of two contracts per tenderer. Therefore the estimated value of the public
10
contract has to be based on the lots values and not on the value of the contracts as a whole. Only reason for one
contract was that one tenderer made best tenders for both lots.
In conclusion auditors remain in the opinion that there is non-compliance with PPA § 100 subsection 3.
2. Substantial modifications of the contract ‒ contract’s terms of performance have been extended by 33% and
the final payment has been made without obtaining permits of use.
2.1 Contract’s terms of performance have been extended by 33%
According to the contract notice and procurement documents the term for performance of the contract was nine
months from the signing of the contract. Contract no. 8-1.10/183 has been signed on 09.12.2019 and therefore the
end date was 09.09.2020. Annex 1 to procurement contract states that pursuant to point 15 of the contract, § 123
subsection 1 clause 1 of the Public Procurement Act and based on the application and justifications submitted by
AS Trev-2 Grupp, the parties shall take a technical break during the period from 20.12.2019 to 16.03.2020. The
deadline for performance of the procurement contract was set on 07.12.2020. That is approximately 3 months
later than the original deadline and 33% of the contract’s original performance period.
Annex 1 to procurement contract does not comply with § 123 subsection 1 clause 1 of the Public Procurement Act.
This can only be used if the change has measurable monetary value. If the modification consists only of the term
of the contract which does not have a financial effect (it is not possible to give monetary value), the procurement
contract cannot be modified on this basis. Assessment of the modification’s substantiality and admissibility must
be assessed on the basis of § 123 subsection 2. If the procurement documents provide the possibility to change
the performance period of the contract then § 123 subsection 1 clause 2 of the PPA can be applied.8.
Point III.2.2) of the contract notice includes the following specification: As the performance period covers winter
months and most of the work is outdoor, the contractor may extend the time limit for performance of the contract
provided that: The average daily (24 h) temperature is below - 10°C for more than 15 calendar days.
The procurement contract was signed on 09.12.2019 and Annex 1 was signed on 20.12.2019. December of 2019
was exceptionally warm: the average air temperature in Estonia was 2,6°C9. Therefore, the § 123 subsection 1
clause 2 of the PPA cannot be used as a basis for contract amendment.
Contracting authority explained (on 1.12.2021) that time limit for submission of the tenders was 3.07.2019 and the
term for performance of the contract was nine months. The tenderer expected that the contract would be signed
within a reasonable time and majority of groundworks would be done in the first months before the winter. It was
not possible to conclude the agreement immediately as Valka municipality did not have the opportunity to sign the
agreement without the respective permission of the state. That was possible in December and tenderer was no
longer prepared to sign the contract, because they expected to carry out the groundworks in significantly
favourable conditions from August rather than mid-December. The tenderer also stated that they were not able to
guarantee the required quality in winter conditions. In the changed situation, the contracting authority decided to
postpone the performance of the contract, which is not the same as extension of the performance of the contract.
The start time of performance was postponed to the nearest possible period. The Contracting Authority does not
agree that the tenderer has obtained any more favourable terms.
8
See Ministry of Finance FAQ: https://www.rahandusministeerium.ee/en/kkk/1183 - point 4
9 http://www.ilmateenistus.ee/2020/01/2019-aasta-ilma-ulevaade/
11
Since there is no subsection 7 in the § 123 of the PPA and subsection 4 sets rules for indexing of the public
contracts, it can be concluded that the contracting authority meant § 123 subsection 1 clauses 4 and 7 of the PPA.
Auditors are in the opinion that neither can be used. The 4th clause states that the contracting authority has the
right to modify a public contract without carrying out new public procurement where the modification is caused by
circumstances unforeseeable to a diligent contracting authority where the overall nature of the public contract is
not altered and the value of any modification does not exceed 50 percent of the original value of the public
contract. The 7th clause states the right to modify a contract if irrespective of the value of the modification, the
modification is not substantial.
Furthermore, date for the submission of tenders was 03.07.2019 and the original term for performance of the
contract was 9 months. This means that all the tenderers had to take into account the fact that some performance
of the contract had to be done during winter. According to the procurement documents the works were to be done
outside (roads, streets, squares, facilities, special sections). Also the contracting authority has foreseen this
because point III.2.2) of the contract notice includes the possibility to extend the time limit for performance of the
contract provided that the average daily (24 h) temperature is below - 10°C for more than 15 calendar days. If it
turned out this condition was too strict and works had to be stopped at higher temperatures, then this is not an
unforeseen circumstance but planning error on the contracting authority’s side.
A postponement of the works by approximately 3 months means the contractor has been able to start work
significantly later than originally foreseen. This is a substantial change to the contract. With such a large delay in
the term for the performance of the contract (so that the contract period is no longer winter), it cannot be ruled out
that this could have attracted additional participants in the procurement procedure or made the prices of tenders
more favourable if this had been known during the procurement. With such a large extension (33%) in the
execution of the contract it cannot be ruled out that this could have attracted additional participants in the
procurement procedure or made the prices of tenders more favourable if this had been known during the
procurement. Some possible tenderers may have been overbooked for the year 2019, but willing to participate in
the procurement if they had known the extension would give them extra time in year 2020. If it is taken into
consideration that the works ended on 10.11.2020, then the extension was still 22%, which is still a substantial
difference. Thus, all conclusions still stand and contract annex 1 is non-compliant with the Estonian Public
Procurement Act.
2.2 The final payment has been made without obtaining permits of use
Point 6.5 of the contract stated that the final payment shall be made on the basis of an invoice prepared after
signing the act of acceptance of works and issuance of the permit of use.
The act of acceptance of works is dated 10.11.2020. The permits of use no 2112371/11090, 2112371/11092,
2112371/11094, 2112371/11096, 2112371/11098 have all been issued on 03.02.2021. The last payment for lot 1
one works has been made on 10.12.2020. That is almost 2 months before the contract allows. This means that the
contract has been substantially modified. The contractor has received payments earlier than originally entitled.
Contracting authority explained (on 12.12.2021) that the building documentation (including the documentation
necessary for the permit of use) was handed over to the Valga Municipality Government on 27.11.2019. After their
verification, the last payment was made. Thus, the payment was made after the proper performance of the work,
signing of the acts, submission of the documentation and their verification. The essence of the requirement to
issue a permit of use is that all the requirements for obtaining a permit of use must be met. The requirements were
met before the last payment was made.
The auditors have found that according to the register of construction works the application for permit of use no
2011371/24391 was submitted on 29.01.2021. According to the Valga Municipality Government 3.02.2021
12
regulation no 30 the Estonian Rescue Board approved the draft for the issue of a permit of use for water and storm
water pipelines (hydrants) through the register of construction works on 2.02.2021. Rest of the works did not
require approval by the Estonian Rescue Board. Thus, the documentation submitted by the contractor were not
sufficient to obtain an permit of use immediately upon submission. Since the approval of Estonian Rescue Board
was also required it cannot be interpreted as the delay was only due to entering the data in the register. The
contract stipulates that the final payment shall be made only after the permit of use has been issued not applied
for. All tenderers had to take into account this requirement and the time needed for obtaining the permit of use.
The contractor has received the final payment approximately 2 months earlier (from 10.12.2020 to 03.02.2031)
and thus the contract modification has resulted in a change of the ratio of contractual obligations arising from the
public contract in favour of a tenderer in a manner not provided for in the public contract (§ 123 subsection 2
clause 2 of the PPA). None of the clauses in subsection 1 in § 123 of the PPA apply and thus this modification is
non-compliant with the Estonian Public Procurement Act.
Summary of point 2.
The impact on these modifications to the contract on the resources of EU cannot be excluded. Due to the nature of
the irregularities, it is not possible to precisely quantify the financial impact as it is not possible to ascertain what
the price of (potential) tenderers’ tenders would have been, had these conditions been stated in the procurement
documents. Thus, the amount of the correction to apply is based on flat-rates.
Annex to the COMMISSION DECISION 14.5.2019 (C(2019) 3452 final) section 2 subsection 2.3 point 23:
Modifications of the contract elements set out in the contract notice or tender specifications, not in compliance
with the Directives. There are modifications to contract (including reduction in the scope of the contract) not in
compliance with Article 72(1) of Directive. Rate of correction is 25% of the initial contract and the new
works/supplies/services (if any) resulting from the modifications.
Auditee response to p. 2:
2.1 The contracting authority has previously justified the extension of the contract. The extension of the contract
was not due to the cold weather, but related to the need for the contracting authority to find additional sources of
financing. The technological break was due to the postponement of the excavation work. As this took time, the
contracting authority proposed to both tenderers to extend the deadline for tenders up to 1 March 2020. Both
tenderers agreed to extend the deadline. After finding the funds, it was decided to sign the contract. The contract
could have been also concluded as at 1 March 2020, but neither the contracting authority nor the tenderer
preferred such uncertainty. The reason for postponing the contract was related to the excavation work, which
should have started in the middle of winter. The tenderer did not agree with this, as the terms of the procurement
allowed it to be assumed that the excavation work could be completed before winter. The conditions for
excavation work are similar in autumn and spring. The contracting authority maintains that no advantage was
conferred on the tenderer. It would not have been reasonable as to the use of public money to cancel the
procurement and organize the new procurement. Considering the situation in the construction market and price
pressure, the new procurement would have proved to be 20% more expensive. In that case the work could not have
been carried out at all. The contracting authority made the only possible decision and postponed the period of
fulfilment of the contract.
2.2 The contracting authority has explained that the documents on which the permit for use is based were
submitted by the contractor on time, before the last act was signed. The documents on which the permit procedure
was based were in order and there were no additional comments after the act was signed. The requirement for a
permit for use is in the procurement primarily in order to guarantee the orderliness of the documents. The
procedure for the permit itself depends on the procurement and non-contractual circumstances. As the permit for
13
use is processed by the contracting authority itself, the contracting authority also applied for the permit. When the
required documents were handed over and checked, the requirement was considered fulfilled. The last part of the
contract fee was also paid when the criteria were met. The interpretation that the contractor has received money
unreasonably early is incorrect. The audit process has not checked the permit process at all, so it is not possible to
conclude that there has been a material breach. It can be seen from the record of construction work, reports of
covered works, submitted as-built drawings and their dates that the documentation has been submitted.
State Shared Service Centre’s (hereafter ‘SSSC’) joint response includes the opinions of the Financial Control,
Managing Authority and Joint Secretariat to p. 2:
2.1 Contract’s terms of performance have been extended by 33%
As a result of the public procurement, the amount of costs of the construction works turned out to be remarkably
higher than was foreseen in the project application form. Valka Municipality Government was therefore forced to
request a loan from Latvian State Treasury to cover the costs of the procurement. Information about receiving the
loan was known by the end of October; on programme level respective amendment of the project application was
approved by the Monitoring Committee on 15 November 2021. After that the project partners were able to
conclude contract with the winner of the construction procurement. As regards the conditions set for receiving the
loan, starting works in 2019 was one of the conditions set by Latvian State Treasury and therefore, as requested,
the contract had to be signed in 2019.
The procurement contract was signed on 9 December 2019. The proposal to establish a technological break for
the performance of contract work until 16 March 2020 was submitted by the contractor on 10 December 2019.
SSSC has reviewed the justifications of TREV and finds that the justifications for technological break to postpone
the excavation work are objectively adequate. It was clear to both parties that the work could not be started in
winter because according to regulation 101 the Quality Requirements for Road Construction of the Minister of
Economic Affairs and Infrastructure of Estonia, certain soil body works cannot be performed in winter
temperatures, due to remarkable decrease of the quality, as the soil melts. As an average, the temperatures in
winter are below zero, the builder was not able to ensure high quality of the work; and it was not known in the
beginning of December 2019 that the winter period 2019-2020 as an average would actually be warmer. SSSC
agrees, that in the contract notice, it was added, that if he temperatuures are below -10°C for more than 15 days,
the contract can be extended, but it was foreseen, that by that time (winter months: December, January, February),
the groundworks would have been completed and the added condition was meant for the following works, that
could have been done also during winter until -10°C outside. However, as the works did not start in the late
summer, as planned, this condition was not relevant and was not related to the need to take the technical break
and postpone the start of construction works. Therefore, to ensure the required quality of works, the technical
break until March 16th was necessary.
All the proposed bidders would have been in the same situation, where the conclusion of the contract was
unforeseenly long and the winter period was not included in the work schedule as planned. Thus the conditions
that were created were not favorable for the successful tenderer, rather the opposite – the successful tenderer
was forced to perform the contract longer than expected and thus had to re-plan both its human and other
resources to ensure the performance of the contract during the summer.
According to the deeds of transfer and acceptance, the contractor carried out the works within the 9-month time-
period from March to November 2020, as foreseen in procurement documents and the contract, including the 4
days on 17-20 December 2019, when some demolition works were carried out on Valka side, deriving from the
requirements of the Latvian State Treasury. In terms of time, these 4 days would remain in total within the 9-
months time period, since the activities in March started on 16 March 2020.
2.2 The final payment has been made without obtaining permits of use
Pursuant to the point 6.5 of the Procurement Contract: The final settlement shall be made on the basis of an
invoice prepared after signing the deed of transfer and acceptance of the works, which are the object of the
14
contract and within ten calendar days after receipt of the invoice. The final invoice issued by the Contractor shall
not be less than 10% of the contract price in order to cover any claims of the Contracting Authority.
The purpose of setting the amount of the final payment in the contract is to ensure that the contracting authority's
rights are protected in such a way that the contractor retains its interest in carrying out all the work involved in the
contract. The performance guarantee during construction and the performance guarantee during the warranty also
serve the same purpose. The SSSC agrees that according to the technical specifications, the Contractor did have
the obligation to apply for a permit of use, but finds that this was an insignificant change according to the Article
123 (1) 7) of the Estonian Public Procurement Act. All the construction works that were the subject of the contract
had been completed on time, there were no deficiencies and therefore no risk for not obtaining the permit of use,
which also became evident when getting permission from Estonian Rescue Board. All documents attached to the
work complied with the terms of the contract, no respective claims have been submitted to the contractor. The
fulfillment of the obligations related to the permit of use was guaranteed for the customer by other guarantees of
the contract. The condition for applying for the permit of use was only a small part of the total amount of the
contractor's obligations, the subsequent fulfillment of which did not change the contractual obligations arising
from the contract in favor of the tenderer, nor did it extend the scope of the contract. As the contracting authority
was also the administrative body issuing the permit of use, the documentation necessary for applying for the
permit of use was submitted by the contractor to the contracting authority before the final payment was made on
27 November 2020. Given the small amount of work involved in applying for the permit of use in relation to the
total amount of the contractor's obligations, the absence of this condition would not have extended the number of
potential tenderers or the cost of the tenders.
It is the opinion of the SSSC that it is insignificant change and has no financial impact.
Final comment from the auditors to p. 2:
2.1 Auditors find that it is not relevant if the extension of the contract was due to cold weather or finding additional
financing, modifications to the contract have to be in compliance with the regulation detailed in PPA § 123. Works
contract point 4.1. states that the term of performance of the contract is nine months from the signing of the
contract between the parties and the contract was signed on 09.12.2019. As previously stated all the tenderers
had to take into account the fact that some performance of the contract had to be done during winter. This
modification of the contract means that the contractor was allowed to start work significantly later than originally
foreseen (so that the contract period does not include winter). It cannot be ruled out that this could have attracted
additional participants in the procurement procedure or made the prices of tenders more favourable if this had
been known during the procurement. Thus, all conclusions still stand and contract annex 1 is non-compliant with
the Estonian Public Procurement Act.
Latvian State Treasurys conditions for additional financing of the project cannot be used as justification for
procurements non-compliance with the laws. Regulation 101 the Quality Requirements for Road Construction was
approved on 03.08.2015. That is approximately four years before the procurement. A diligent contracting authority
should have taken that into account when planning the procurement and also should have allowed some room for
delays.
With such a large extension (33%) in the execution of the contract it cannot be ruled out that this could have
attracted additional participants in the procurement procedure or made the prices of tenders more favourable if
this had been known during the procurement. In addition to that in the application submitted by AS Trev-2 Grupp is
stated that during the technological break, the Contractor shall prepare necessary project documents and approve
materials with the Contracting Authority to ensure the smoothest possible construction process after the end of
the technological break. Contracting authority has confirmed to the managing authority (on 17.08.2020) that the
approval of materials and drawing up of necessary documentation started during the technological break. In
conclusion this break did not mean the works had stopped altogether, but rather the contractor got extra time for
some of the works. This means that effectively the term for the performance of the contract was extended and not
only postponed.
15
Thus, all conclusions still stand and contract annex 1 is non-compliant with the Estonian Public Procurement Act.
2.2
Point 6.5 of the contract stated that the final payment shall be made among others on the basis of issuance of the
permit of use. If the contracting authority only wanted necessary documents for the permit to be handed over and
checked by the contracting authority, then it should have stated that in the contract. All tenderers had to take into
account requirement stated in the contract and the time needed for obtaining the permit of use. Even if there was
no material breach in the end it does not invalidate the fact that the last payment was made before the conditions
stated in the contract were met. The final invoice issued by the Contractor was to be no less than 10% of the
contract price (point 6.5 of the contract), which is considerable sum. This payment was received almost 2 months
before the contract allows. Therefore, the SSSC’s assessment that it did not change the contractual obligations
arising from the contract in favor of the tenderer or that the absence of this condition would not have influenced
the cost of the tenders, is arbitrary. Receiving payments earlier and with less requirements is a significant contract
modification. The provisions governing the contracting authority's financial obligations are essential terms of the
contract, since the latter govern the contracting authority's obligation to pay for the work performed. Auditors are
in the opinion that changing the terms of contract after concluding the procurement contract places the tenderers
in an unequal position, violates the principles of equal treatment of tenderers and free competition. It can be
assumed that financial conditions set in the draft contract influence the potential tenderers decision whether to
participate in the procurement procedure and the tender price.
As none of the clauses in subsection 1 in § 123 of the PPA apply, then this modification is non-compliant with the
Estonian Public Procurement Act.
Auditors would like to point out that as the procurement with a reference no 206895 was divided into two lots, then
the following paragraph concerns the lot 1 and the final payment made without obtaining permit of use for the
works completed in Estonia. But the auditors also identified that regarding lot 2 for the works completed in Latvia,
the last payment10 (in amount of 60 764.86 EUR on 09.12.2020) has been made before the permit of use was
issued on 28.04.2021, that is almost 5 months before the contract allows. It should be futher investigated by the
SSSC. The last payment for lot 2 should have been 10% of the contract, but the invoice presented on 09.12.2020
was for a smaller amount. The cost of Part 2 (excluding VAT) was in the amount of 2,460,584.80 euros, thus 10%
of the amount is 246,058.48 euros. Therefore, 3/4 of the planned final payment was paid in advance even earlier
and this should also be considered as substantial contract modification.
Auditors would also like to clarify the SSSC’ s question that the amount of correction to apply is based on the
Annex to the COMMISSION DECISION 14.5.2019 (C(2019) 3452 final) section 2 subsection 2.3 point 2311.
3. Incomplete verifications of the absence of grounds for exclusion of successful tenderer and subcontractors
PPA § 95 subsection 1 clauses 1 to 3 stipulate that the contracting authority does not award a public contract to a
tenderer and excludes from the procurement procedure a tenderer:
1) who or whose member of an administrative, management or supervisory board or another legal representative
or a contractual representative involved in the public procurement has been convicted by final judgment for
participating a criminal group, violating the duty of integrity, corrupt practice, fraud, terrorist act, other criminal
offence linked to terrorist activities or inciting or aiding or abetting or attempting to commit an offence, money
laundering offence, or terrorist financing;
11
Modifications of the contract elements set out in the contract notice or tender specifications, not in compliance with the Directives. There are
modifications to contract (including reduction in the scope of the contract) not in compliance with Article 72(1) of Directive. Rate of correction is 25% of the
initial contract and the new works/supplies/services (if any) resulting from the modifications.
16
2) who or whose member of an administrative, management or supervisory board or another legal representative
or a contractual representative involved in the public procurement has been convicted by final judgment for
enabling an illegal alien to work or for enabling a breach of the criteria applicable to the work performed by an alien
in Estonia, including for payment of a salary below the statutory rate;
3) who or whose member of an administrative, management or supervisory board or another legal representative
or a contractual representative involved in the public procurement has been convicted by final judgment for illegal
use of child labour or another form of trafficking in human beings.
PPA § 95 subsection 4 clause 11 stipulates that the contracting authority may exclude from the procurement
procedure a tenderer who or whose member of an administrative, management or supervisory board or another
legal representative has been convicted by final judgment for tax offences.
PPA § 104 subsection 8 states that before awarding a public contract, the contracting authority demands that the
tenderer submit documents corresponding to all the relevant declarations made in the Single Procurement
Document. After verifying the absence of grounds for exclusion regarding the successful tenderer and whether the
successful tenderer meets the established selection criteria, the contracting authority makes a decision to exclude
or not to exclude and to qualify or not to qualify the successful tenderer.
According to the Business Register persons related to the company AS TREV-2 Grupp were among others: Xavier
Bernard Neuschwander (chairman of the supervisory board), Chadi Khaled (member of the supervisory board),
Grégoire François Jean Pinasseau (member of the supervisory board), Luc Axel Christian Camille Bodson (member
of the supervisory board). The tender was signed by Ott Kevvai under a power attorney proving the right of
representation. In the Estonian e-procurement register queries to the Criminal Records Database about the
absence of grounds for exclusion of successful tenderer (§ 95 subsection 1 clauses 1 to 3 and subsection 4 clause
11 of the PPA) do not include aforementioned persons. This is non-compliant with § 104 subsection 8 of the PPA.
PPA § 95 subsection 1 clause 5 stipulates that the contracting authority does not award a public contract to a
tenderer and excludes from the procurement procedure a tenderer who or whose member of an administrative,
management or supervisory board is a subject of an international sanction within the meaning of the International
Sanctions Act. PPA § 122 subsection 5 stipulates that in the case of a public works contract, the contracting
authority verifies, during the procurement procedure, the absence of the grounds for exclusion specified in
subsection 1 of § 95 of this Act regarding the subcontractors specified in the tender and, upon performance of the
public contract following the contract award, regarding an added subcontractor.
The contracting authority has submitted no evidence that the absence of international sanctions has been verified
for the tenderer (and its member of an administrative, management or supervisory board) or subcontractors. This
is non-compliant with the PPA § 104 subsection 8 and § 122 subsection 5.
Annex 6. Guidelines to Financial Corrections point 2.3.3. financial correction in case of irregularity related to non-
compliance with the general rules on procurement when the Estonian partner is a contracting authority for the
purposes of the procurement. If Estonian beneficiary or partner is a contracting authority for the purposes of the
public procurement and the estimated value of a service, goods or building works is equal to or in excess of simple
procurement threshold has violated the obligation to comply with the general principles of procurement the
financial correction rate of 5, 10, 25 or 100 percent may be applied depending on the severity of the violation by
using the financial correction principles according to the EC Guidelines. There is no corresponding financial
correction rate for this irregularity listed in Annex to the COMMISSION DECISION 14.5.2019 (C(2019) 3452 final)
section 2. Auditors are of the opinion that applicable correction rate is 5%. Although there is no proof that
successful tenderer or its subcontractors had no grounds for exclusion, there is also no proof that such grounds
existed.
17
Auditee response to p. 3:
The contracting authority has explained this in advance by answering the questions. The inspection was carried
out, but as it turned out that there were no subjects of international sanctions in Estonia at that time, it was not
thoroughly documented and the result of the inspection could not be found.
State Shared Service Centre’s (hereafter ‘SSSC’) joint response includes the opinions of the Financial Control,
Managing Authority and Joint Secretariat to p. 3:
The SSSC is of the opinion that the Tenderer must make the missing inquiries afterwards. If the inquiries show that
there are no grounds for exclusion, then this is not a breach of law and there is no financial impact, as this
shortcoming has not affected the outcome of the public procurement or otherwise restricted the competition. This
is a formal shortcoming which also has no potential financial implications, because TREV operated in parallel in
other procurements, so it is unlikely that it had grounds for exclusion.
Final comment from the auditors to p. 3:
In response to the auditee, if there is no proof of corresponding inspections via documentation, then the
compliance with the PPA § 104 subsection 8 and § 122 subsection 5 cannot be proven. As for the proposal of the
SSSC, queries to the Criminal Records Database can only be made for the present date. Therefore, the inquires
would not prove lack of grounds for exclusion during the procurement procedure. Also the page for verification of
the absence of international sanctions12 does not allow to choose a specific date for verifications. The SSSC
cannot know that successful tenderer had no grounds for exclusion without proof.
In conclusion auditors remain in the opinion that there is non-compliance with PPA § 104 subsection 8 and § 122
subsection 5.
4. The tenderers have not received notice of the qualification decision
PPA § 120 subsection 2 stipulates that the contracting authority cannot grant acceptance to the awarding of the
public contract before 14 days have passed from the non-exclusion of the successful tenderer specified in
subsection 8 of § 104 of this Act and submission of a notice on the qualification decision (hereinafter standstill
period). In public procurement whose estimated value is below the international threshold, the contracting
authority or entity applies a ten-day standstill period. Subsection 3 clarifies that the standstill period does not need
to be applied in the event where a tender was submitted by only one tenderer.
There were two bids submitted by tenderers in the procurement with a reference no 206895. In the Estonian e-
procurement register there is no notice of the non-exclusion of the successful tenderer or of a notice on the
qualification decision to the tenderers.
The contracting authority has submitted no evidence the notice of the non-exclusion of the successful tenderer or
of a notice on the qualification decision was sent to the tenderers. Also, the contracting authority’s argument that
notifications cannot be made through the Estonian e-procurement register, is untrue. User guide for the contracting
authority's representative (created: 10.22.2018)13 explain the notification process on page 188.
13 https://www.rahandusministeerium.ee/sites/default/files/Riigihangete_poliitika/register/kasutajajuhend_-_hankijale_v11.pdf
18
Annex 6. Guidelines to Financial Corrections point 2.3.3. financial correction in case of irregularity related to non-
compliance with the general rules on procurement when the Estonian partner is a contracting authority for the
purposes of the procurement. If Estonian beneficiary or partner is a contracting authority for the purposes of the
public procurement and the estimated value of a service, goods or building works is equal to or in excess of simple
procurement threshold has violated the obligation to comply with the general principles of procurement the
financial correction rate of 5, 10, 25 or 100 percent may be applied depending on the severity of the violation by
using the financial correction principles according to the EC Guidelines. There is no corresponding financial
correction rate for this irregularity listed in Annex to the COMMISSION DECISION 14.5.2019 (C(2019) 3452 final)
section 2.
Auditee response to p. 4:
The contracting authority has explained that in the course of the reverse procedure the separate conformity
decision and the decision to declare the tender successful have been prepared. The tenderers have been notified
of the latter. If a qualification decision is prepared after that, only the successful tenderer can be notified via the
register. This was the case for at least 2019 in case of all procurements. Therefore, the compliance with the
selection criteria was checked in the public procurement register. The decision was circulated as an extract from
the minutes by e-mail. Unfortunately, due to a change of staff, an email confirming the notification could not be
found.
The contracting authority does not agree with the audit findings. The contract notice was published in the public
procurement register in accordance with the applicable procedure. In order to reach potential tenderers, the
procurement data were published together with a link to the public procurement register on the websites of both
Valga and Valka local governments. The procurement guarantee was in accordance with the provisions of the
Public Procurement Act. Extending the contract was the only possible solution and did not damage the interests of
potential tenderers. Payments were made in accordance with the terms of the contract and all insurance contracts
comply with the terms of the procurement.
Public funds have been used prudently. The procurement has been carried out without the reserve of the
contracting authority. The work has been performed within the framework of the public contract. The amount of
unforeseen work is non-existent, which refers to good and systematic planning. There have also been no
complaints about the organization of the procurement and the fulfilment of the contract during previous audits.
State Shared Service Centre’s (hereafter ‘SSSC’) joint response includes the opinions of the Financial Control,
Managing Authority and Joint Secretariat to p. 4:
The SSSC is of the opinion that this not a breach of law and there are no financial impact, as in essence inquiries
have been made to show that there are no grounds for exclusion (with the exception of the inquiries referred to in
point 4, which must be made ex post) and the qualifications have also been checked. As these are conditions that
are easily identifiable and the successful tenderer met all the conditions, ie there were no grounds for exclusion, it
is clear that the failure to formalize and notify the decisions is a formal mistake, which could not affect the
outcome of the contract or otherwise restrict the competition. The purpose of the retention period is to ensure for
a person, whose rights have been violated by a decision, to be able to lodge an appeal. In the present case, it is
clear that the other tenderer had no grounds and no need to lodge a challenge, nor did the tenderers ask the
contracting authority any questions, and the contract was awarded with a significantly longer retention period. It is
therefore a formal defect with no potential financial impact.
19
Final comment from the auditors to p. 4:
In response to the auditee, if there is no corresponding documentation, then notification of the tenderers cannot be
proven. As for the SSSC’s opinion, the missing inquires about the grounds for exclusion to the Criminal Records
Database cannot be made for the dates of the procurement procedure. Also the page for verification of the
absence of international sanctions14 does not allow to choose a specific date for verifications. Therefore, there is
no proof that successful tenderer met all the conditions and the other tenderer had no ground for complaints. So
this cannot be considered only a formal mistake. Thus, original assessment of non-compliance stands.
Auditors thank the auditee Valga Municipality Government for the comments provided via email on 05.01.2022 and
the State Shared Service Centre for the comments provided via email on 14.01.2022 to the findings presented in
the audit report.
The notification is necessary for unsuccessful tenderer to lodge a complaint with the Public Procurement Review
Committee. A tenderer can contest actions of the contracting authority by filing a respective request for review
with the Review Committee if it finds that an infringement of the Public Procurement Act by the contracting
authority infringes its rights or adversely affects its interests. A request for review cannot be submitted after the
award of the public contract. Thus, not notifying tenderers of the contracting authority’s decisions as demanded in
PPA’s § 120 subsection 2 is a serious irregularity. The seriousness is reflected in § 120 subsection 2 of the PPA,
which states that public contract awarded before the expiry of the standstill period is ineffective. Auditors are of
the opinion that applicable correction rate is 10%.
The auditors remain in the opinion that the procurement with a reference no 206895 does not comply with the §
120 subsection 2 of the PPA, therefore with the applicable legislation.
Finding no 5 without financial impact:
5. The contract notice has not been published in Tenders Electronic Daily15 (henceforth TED) although there is a
certain cross border interest due to the geographic location of the place of performance, object of the works
and value of the contract.
According to the point 1.2.2 of Annex to the Commission Decision 14.5.201916 in so far as the Directives do not
apply, but the procurement falls within the scope of the Treaty and under national public procurement law, these
guidelines apply provided there is a certain cross border interest, within the meaning of point 1.2.3 and the award
of such contracts does not respect the principles of transparency and nondiscrimination enshrined in the Treaty.
Point 1.2.3 specifies the factual elements that would in conjunction substantiate cross border interest, including
the following: (i) the subject-matter of the contract, (ii) its estimated value, (iii) the technical requirements of the
contract, (iv) the geographic location of the place of performance, (v) evidence of tenders from other Member
States or expressed interest by economic operators from a different Member State.
According to the European Court of Justice judgements17 even if the estimated value of the public contract does
not exceed the international threshold it is still necessary to assess whether there may be certain cross border
interest. Criteria to indicate such interest could be, inter alia, the fact that the contract in question is for a
significant value, in conjunction with the place where the work is to be carried out. Account must be taken of the
14 https://www.politsei.ee/et/rahapesu
15 Tenders Electronic Daily is the online version of the 'Supplement to the Official Journal' of the EU, dedicated to European public procurement.
16 COMMISSION DECISION of 14.5.2019 laying down the guidelines for determining financial corrections to be made to expenditure financed by the Union for
non-compliance with the applicable rules on public procurement
17 See judgment C-507/03 Commission v. Ireland, [2007] ECR I-9777, paragraphs 32 and 34. See also cases C412/04 Commission v. Italy [2008] ECR I-619;
joined cases C-147/06 and C-148/06, SECAP SpA and Santorso Soc. V. Comune di Torino [2008] ECR I-3565.
20
fact that the borders straddle conurbations which are situated in the territory of different Member States and that,
in those circumstances, even low-value contracts may be of certain cross border interest.
The international threshold for works contract in the year 2019 was 5 548 000 EUR. Estimated cost of the
procurement (incl. lots) was 3 660 000 EUR and the actual cost of the procurement was 4 095 836,23 EUR.
Auditors are in the opinion that there is certain cross border interest in the procurement with a reference no
206895, because of the geographic location of the works, object of the works and value of the contract. Works
were located both in Estonia and in Latvia. Works consisted of construction and reconstruction of a common
border area in Valga and Valka cities - roads, streets, squares, facilities, special sections. Procurement was divided
into two lots with estimated cost for lot 1 (in Estonia) 1,46 million EUR and for lot 2 (in Latvia) 2,2 million EUR. As
the estimated and real value of the contract is significant, it can be assumed that the Latvian construction
companies are by default interested in works in Latvian territory. According to the information available in the
Estonian e-procurement register the contract notice was not published in TED. Thus, there is an infringement of the
principle of transparency as equal access to information about the procurement was not granted to undertakings
from other Member States.
Contracting authority explained to the auditors that choosing a more complex procurement type wastes resources.
publication of the notice in TED does not add any transparency to the procurement. The practice of the contracting
authority confirms that in case of interest, the tender is submitted regardless of the type of proceedings and the
place of publication. Tenders have also been received from outside Estonia for procurements organized below the
simplified procurement threshold, the cost of which is a few thousand. For example, last four largest service
procurements in Valga municipality have been won by companies located outside Estonia (Latvia, Spain, Italy).
Auditors are in the opinion that as the relevant information can be forwarded automatically through the Estonian e-
procurement register, no additional resources are needed to publish the contract notice in TED. Procurement
procedure was already an open procedure. Even if in case of previous procurements potential tenderers have
found the relevant information although the contract notice was not published in TED, then it does not exclude the
possibility that this time the procurement may have been overlooked by some potentially interested parties. The
contracting authority’s explanations show that there has been a certain cross border interest in the previous
procurements where the value has been below the international threshold. According to the information available
in the Estonian e-procurement register 17 Estonian companies have registered to the procurement. If construction
works with a considerable cost take place on both sides of the border between two countries, the contracting
authority should assume that there is a cross border interest in the procurement and ensure that all interested
parties are able to participate in the procurement via publishing the contract notice in TED.
Auditee response to p. 5:
Auditee has overviewed the draft audit report. Therefore Auditee gives it`s comments about Significant finding no
4.1 – where Auditors give their opinion that The implementing project partner Valga Municipality Government has
not carried out public procurement with a reference no 206895 in compliance with the Public Procurement Act.
Here are our standpoints:
The Auditee do not agree with the conclusions provided in the audit, which are mostly incomplete and made
arbitrarily. The Public Procurement Act clearly sets the thresholds. It is formally and rigidly defined in which way
and which activities need to be carried out by using the chosen type of procedure. The contracting authority has
chosen an open procurement procedure. The cost of the procurement was 4 076 078 euros, which is well below
the international threshold. The contracting authority has complied with all requirements related to the publication
of the procurement. § 183 of the Public Procurement Act provides, inter alia, "Where the estimated value of the
public procurement equals or exceeds the international threshold or in another event where the contracting
authority or entity so requests, the register communicates the data contained in public procurement notices to the
21
Publications Office of the European Union in accordance with Commission Implementing Regulation“. In this case
the discretion is left to the contracting authority. The directives of the European Commission are not directly
applicable to national procurements. The court decisions are not laws, but the interpretations of the law. The
principle of legal separation applies in the European judicial area. However, the contracting authority can only
comply with the applicable legislation. The inspection report states that according to the judgment "... should be
assessed". The contracting authority considered a number of ways how the procurement should be carried out.
The most transparent would be to conduct the procurement in the Estonian and Latvian registers at the same time.
Unfortunately, the legislation does not provide for this possibility. It is not even possible to publish a contract
notice with a reference to another country's register. The possibility of conducting the procurement in different
parts in Estonia and Latvia separately was also considered. This was hampered by the close involvement of the
construction project. The principle of bridges, sidewalks, lighting and general design required the same approach,
both in the choice of materials and in the execution of the work. This also proved difficult due to different
construction legislation.
The contracting authority has already replied that, in case of small procurements, the international interest in the
procurement is not linked to the publication of the contract notice in TED. Based on the practice of Valga rural
municipality it has become clear that regardless of the type of procedure, tenders are submitted by foreign
companies for procurements that are of interest. Tenders are even submitted for small procurements below the
simple procurement threshold. However, all procurements carried out in recent years that have exceeded the
international threshold and have been published in TED have not resulted in any cross-border procurement
registration, let alone the submission of a tender. Obviously, the international interest depends primarily on the
nature of the procurement and not on where it is published. In case of construction procurements, the international
threshold is clearly justified. Due to their complexity, small-scale and especially very complex procurements
consisting of several construction projects with special components, are not of international interest. The tender
has been submitted by two international companies that operate on a daily basis in both Latvia and Estonia. Such
companies can find staff relatively quickly and at lower cost who are able to operate in the different construction
jurisdiction. The procurement consists of nine different parts, which are divided into two parts for the purposes of
the procedure. The parts of the procurement are so closely connected that the main contractor needs to know both
Estonian and Latvian construction legislation.
It is not necessary to register with the procurement to view the procurement documents. To the knowledge of the
contracting authority, at least two companies registered only in Latvia inspected the procurement documents. At
the same time the contracting authority itself has registered the subcontractors of the contract partners for the
purpose of controlling them. Based on the number of companies registered for the procurement, no conclusions
can be drawn from the wish to submit a tender. The majority of the ones having registered for the procurement are
interested in providing subcontracting services to tenderers and registering for the procurement on the basis of
such interest. Three companies have registered who have shown a real interest in submitting a tender (asked
questions about the tender during the procedure). All these three companies operate in both Estonia and Latvia
and are the only ones out of the sample able to fulfil the contract. The latter three are also the only ones having
asked clarifying questions during the procedure. Two of them have submitted a tender.
Public procurement legislation is formal and requires strict compliance. The findings of the audit require punctual
accuracy. The need of the publication of the notice in TED in case of the procurement below the international
threshold is clearly left to the contracting authority to decide. The need for this only has to be considered. The
legislator has defined the course of procedure, threshold, etc. in the law very precisely. In case of the procurement
below the international threshold, the publication of a contract notice in TED is not defined by law and the directive
22
only talks about discretion. The contracting authority does not agree with the audit conclusion that the information
was difficult to obtain for the potential tenderers interested in the procurement. In addition to the public
procurement register, all information was also published on the websites of Valka and Valga local governments,
which are monitored by all sectoral companies operating in both countries. There was also a link to the public
procurement notice on the website of both local governments. The contract notice is published in a completely
correct manner and complies with all laws and directives.
State Shared Service Centre’s (hereafter ‘SSSC’) joint response includes the opinions of the Financial Control,
Managing Authority and Joint Secretariat to p.5:
SSSC is of the opinion that there was no violation of law as regards the publishing of the procurement
“Development of Valga-Valka Twin City Center” (identification number 206895), because the procurement was
carried out in accordance with Estonian Public Procurement Act that does not refer to or require additional
publishing of tenders in TED in case of cross border impact.
The estimated contract price was EUR 3,6 million and the eventual contract price is EUR 4,09 million. According to
the reference to the EC Guidelines (Commission Decision 14.5.2019), if there is a notion of cross-border interest (it
arises not only from the actual location in the border area, but also from factors such as the subject of the
procurement, the value of the contract, the specifics of the relevant sector, etc.), the customer must follow certain
principles: transparency, competition measures, adequate publicity (internet, national or local newspapers, TED)
and an effective review procedure.
The explanation concerns below the threshold procedures of procurement directive (i.e. applicable to cases below
directive thresholds where a member state has not set its own lower thresholds for the application of procurement
procedures), but Estonia as a Member State has introduced lower thresholds for the application of procurement
procedures and ensures all the preconditions laid down in the EC Guidelines. The public procurement directives lay
down specific types of contract and specific contract price thresholds, from which procurement is to be
announced in the Official Journal of the European Union, and consequently there is no apparent justification for
publishing in the Official Journal of the European Union also notices for which such a mandatory obligation does
not arise from EU laws and regulations in the field of public procurement (including the caselaw of the EST). The
above is also supported by the European Commission's Guidelines on Community Law applicable to the award of
contracts which are not covered or only partially covered by the provisions of the public procurement directives
(2006/C 179/02) 2.1.2.the article provides, inter alia, that publication in the Official Journal of the European Union
is not an obligatory condition in the context of the provision of publicity, but is an adequate and generally usable
means and an good opportunity, particularly in the case of larger contracts.
According to Estonian 2014-2020 Structural Assistance Act Article 54. Eligibility of costs, verification thereof and
conduct of financial correction, if the procedure for financial correction established nationally in the states
participating in the programme shall be taken as a basis for making the financial correction decision pursuant to
the ETC programme, the basis, conditions and procedure for the making of the financial correction decision shall
be established by a regulation of the minister responsible for the area. In case of Estonia - Latvia Programme, there
are programme-level guidelines, described in accordance with the Regulation (EU) 1303/2013 and EC Guidelines
(Commission Decision 14.5.2019). According to Estonia - Latvia Programme Manual Annex 6. Guidelines to
Financial Corrections, one of the principles for carrying out a financial correction decision by the programme is
where national public procurement rules are not followed or are violated. However, the Annex 6. Guidelines to
Financial Corrections, when referring to EC Guidelines (Commission Decision 14.5.2019), is not applicable for the
project partners when preparing and carrying out public procurements, because the aim of the document is to be a
basis for making financial correction decisions on programme level. According to Estonian Public Procurement Act
additional publishing of tenders in TED in case of cross border impact is not required. EC Guidelines (Commission
Decision 14.5.2019) is EU-level secondary legislation, which is quasi-legal policy instrument of the European Union
for relevant EC services and not legally binding instrument for the Member States. In the field of public
procurements the Estonian Public Procurement Act is national level legal act, that provides for the rules of public
23
procurement, the rights and obligations of persons involved, the rules of exercising supervision, review procedure
etc to ensure the transparent, practical and economic use of the funds, equal treatment of persons, and effective
use of competition.
The procurement has been carried out pursuant to the Article 44 (4) of the Estonian Public Procurement Act:
several contracting authorities or entities of different Member States of the European Union may agree on the joint
organisation of public procurement by concluding an agreement that serves as the basis for their cooperation,
determining the division of responsibilities between the contracting authorities or entities and the relevant
applicable national provisions arising therefrom, which must be published in the procurement documents, and the
organisational details of the procurement procedure. According to Article 44 (3) Centralised purchasing activities
are conducted in accordance with the law of the Member State where the central purchasing body is located.
According to the Article 45 (6) upon submission of a notice to the register for the purpose of commencement of
public procurement, the contracting authority or entity indicates whether the estimated value of the public
procurement equals or exceeds the international threshold or whether the contracting authority or entity would like
to have the notice optionally forwarded to the Publication Office of the European Union. The public procurement
number 206895 was below the international threshold, and there are no references to cross-border interest in in
Estonian Public Procurement Act, thus there was no need to publish the procurement outside the Estonian register.
Pursuant to the Article 183 where the estimated value of the public procurement equals or exceeds the
international threshold or in another event where the contracting authority or entity so requests, the register
communicates the data contained in public procurement notices to the Publications Office of the European Union
in accordance with Commission Implementing Regulation (EU) No 842/2011 establishing standard forms for the
publication of notices in the field of public procurement and repealing Regulation (EC) No 1564/2005 (OJ L 22,
27.08.2011, pp 1–187). This is not relevant, as the public procurement was below the international threshold.
In accordance with the actual circumstances of the case, the implementing project partner has organised an open
procurement procedure “Valga – Valka Twin Town Centre Development” (identification number 206895) in
accordance with the Public Procurement Law, including the publicity requirements. References to publications of
the procurement in Latvian media:
http://www.valka.lv/lv/valkas-novads-1/pasvaldiba-1/projekti-2/valkas-valgas-centrs/izsludinats-projekta-valgas-
valkas-dvinu-pilsetas-centra-attistiba-buvdarbu-iepirkums
https://visitvalgavalka.com/lv/izsludinats-projekta-valgas-valkas-dvinu-pilsetas-centra-attistiba-buvdarbu-
iepirkums/
The SSSC finds that there is no violation of the law, the finding is considered to be formal and, accordingly, should
be eliminated.
Final comment from the auditors to p. 5:
The auditors have consulted the Ministry of Finance’s Department of Public Procurement and State Aid and the
European Commission regarding the publication of the procurement notice in the TED18, both were in the opinion
that tender publication in the TED is not specifically necessary. However, the European Commission stated that
given the clear cross-border interest, an adequate publicity would have been if a publication were done at both
Estonian and Latvian procurement registers and there is grounds for a financial correction if the publication was
done only at the Estonian national register.
„Public Procurement Guidance for Practioners states that: “In addition, contracts whose value is below EU
thresholds but which may have potential cross-border interest should also be advertised in the OJEU. /…/ Where
contracts below the EU thresholds have potential cross-border interest, the safest course of action to avoid any
risk of irregularity and possible financial corrections is to advertise the contract in the OJEU and in a national
18
Online version of the supplement to the official journal of the EU
24
public procurement web-site or a well-known public procurement web-site. If in any doubt for instance about
thresholds or about the potential for cross-border interest in a contract, advertising in the OJEU is recommended
as a way of ensuring EU-wide competition.” 19
As the auditee has pointed out it is not possible to conduct the procurement in the Estonian and Latvian registers
at the same time and it is not even possible to publish a contract notice with a reference to another country's
register. Therefore, the viable option to ensure adequate publicity was to send the tender notice to TED.
The SSSC has sent references to publications of the procurement in Latvian media. First is the homepage of Valka
Municpality and the second tourism information page. Neither of these are Latvian procurement registers or a well-
known public procurement web-sites. Furthermore, both advertisements about the procurement have been made
public 30.05.2019, but the tender was published in Estonian procurement register on 06.05.2019. Both
advertisements also state that tenders must be submitted in Estonian procurement register by 19.06.2019. The
final submission date for tenders in the procurement register was 03.07.2019. So if an interested party read the
advertisements after 19.06.2019 it would have falsely appeared as the procurement had already ended. Therefore,
it cannot be concluded that this is adequate publication of the procurement in Latvia.
Auditors partly agree with the comments presented by the auditee and the SSSC, therefore this finding is without
financial impact. Auditors recommend that the SSSC will initiate a discussion with the Ministry of Finance’s
Department of Public Procurement and State Aid regarding the publication requirements that contracting authority
needs to follow in case of certain cross-border interest. At the moment it is not clear what is required from the
beneficiary as the Ministry of Finance’s Department of Public Procurement and State Aid is in the opinion that
tender publication in the TED is not necessary for tenders below international threshold although there is certain
cross-border interest, but the European Commission standpoint is that tender publication only at the Estonian
national register cannot be considered adequate publicity. Thus, there is a contradiction between the requirements
set in the Estonian Public Procurement Act and the EU Public Procurement Guidance for Practioners. The
provisions of publicity in case of certain cross-border interest should be clarified and adequate guidance should be
given to the beneficiaries.
Conclusion and Recommendations from the auditors:
In auditors opinion the abovementioned requirements are restrictive, thus not ensuring equal access for tenderers
and have the effect of creating unjustified obstacles to the opening up of public procurement to competition.
According to the Annex 6. Guidelines to Financial Corrections point 2, where a number of irregularities are detected
in the same tender procedure, the rates of correction are not cumulated, the most serious irregularity being taken
as an indication to decide the rate of correction (up to 5 %, 10%, 25% or 100%). The above findings will result in a
financial correction of 25% of eligible costs related to this contract.
1) Risk and recommendation to the auditee:
Risk: Failure by the beneficiary to comply with its legal obligations may lead to the partial or full recovery of the
grant.
Recommendation:
1.Auditors recommend that the implementing20 project partner Valga Municipality Government reimburse
340,513.66 EUR (incl. 306,082.66 EUR in the scope of the audit) for the identified ineligible ERDF costs and deduct
144,134.31 EUR (including 129,560.18 EUR in the scope of the audit) from the eligible co-financing of the project.
19
page 81, https://ec.europa.eu/regional_policy/sources/docgener/guides/public_procurement/2018/guidance_public_procurement_2018_en.pdf
20
Cost-sharing agreement signed 19.12.2019 between Valga Municipality Government and Valka Municipality Council p. 2.3. The costs arising from
the contract will be shared between the partners.// With this Agreement, all relevant partners accept the detailed specification for dividing of common
costs as specified in Annex 1.
25
2. Auditors recommend that the project lead partner Valka Municipality Council according to the cost-sharing
agreement (signed 19.12.2019) reimburse 341,392.55 EUR (incl. 311,318.40 EUR in the scope of the audit) for the
identified ineligible ERDF costs and deduct 377,934.35 EUR (including EUR 344,641.14 in the scope of the audit no
23-2021/06/DR, audit carried out by Ministry of Environmental Protection and Regional Development of Latvia)
from the eligible co-financing of the project.
2) Risk and recommendation to the Financial Control and the Managing Authority:
Risk: If the Financial Control and the Managing Authority do not execute necessary checks on the beneficiary’s
compliance to public procurement rules, there is a risk that the grant will not be used legally and that the grant will
have to be recovered in part or in whole.
Recommendation: We recommend that the Managing Authority initiate the recovery process for ineligible costs
identified in the audit related to the procurement with a reference no 206895 and apply financial correction of 25%
to the declared expenditure. Checks carried out regarding compliance of public procurements should be enhanced.
Person responsible for implementation of the recommendation and date- (the MA did not include information)
5. Granting of state aid
The project does not involve state aid.
6. Communication and publicity
When informing and disclosing the use of funding, the beneficiary has in all material aspects followed the current
legislation.
We confirm that the final audit report has 26 pages.
Audit manager: Audit supervisor:
(Signed electronically) (Signed electronically)
Elis Kõrvek Kaisa Kallas
Lead Auditor of Audit Unit II Head of Audit Unit II
Financial Control Department Financial Control Department
Tallinn, 23/02/2022
26
Pr Monika Rogenbaum Meie 23.02.2022 nr 10-5/1987-1
Valga Vallavalitsus
[email protected]
Auditi aruande edastamine
Austatud proua Rogenbaum
Edastame Teile Eesti-Läti INTERREG V-A programmi projekti Est-Lat 51 „Valga – Valka
Centre“ projektiauditi lõpparuande.
Täname Teid koostöö ja abi eest auditi läbiviimise ajal.
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Kaur Siruli
Finantskontrolli osakonna juhataja
Lisa: Auditi lõpparuanne kahekümne kuuel (26) leheküljel
Teadmiseks:
Pr Ege Ello, Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus (
[email protected]);
Pr Imbi Uusjärv, Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus (
[email protected]);
Hr Urmo Merila, Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus (
[email protected]);
Pr Karin Viikmaa, Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus (
[email protected]).
Merle Oagu 6113121
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 611 3558 /
[email protected] / www.rahandusministeerium.ee
registrikood 70000272