The Estonian principles of patient consent for treatment, participation in
scientific research and disclosing data for other purposes
Primary sources:
CONTENTS
ESTONIA
1. Is there “general consent” for treatment, scientific research and
disclosing data for other purposes?
1a. If no, how does consent differ?
Treatment
Scientific research
Disclosing data for other purposes
2. Is the consent associated with activities?
2a. If yes, how?
2b. Is consent divided into consent for the disclosure/retrieval of
“wet” data (biological/genetic) and “dry” data (data on treatment)?
3. Does the citizen have the option of withdrawing consent?
3a. If yes, under which conditions?
4. Should the consent be verbal or written?
4a. Give examples.
5. Is there IT system support for consent management?
5a. Is consent limited by IT systems?
5b. If yes, for what reasons, for example legal or practical?
6. Is consent time-limited?
6a. If yes, for how long?
7. Is consent limited to a legal entity?
7a. If yes, how?
7b. Are there different consent requirements for different
authorities/parties?
8. Do citizens have access to see who uses data and for what
purposes?
1
The Danish principles of patient consent for treatment, participation
in scientific research and disclosing data for other purposes
Primary sources: executive orders on informed consent, on the right to hospital treatment and on involuntary psychiatric
commitment CONTENTS DENMARK (example)
1. Is there “general consent” for treatment, scientific research and No, there is no general consent that is common for the three usages.
disclosing data for other purposes?
Consent for treatment is to be given for specific purposes and at the present point in time. Research participation requires consent unless it concerns
1a. If no, how does consent differ? research based on Danish national registers. All health research with individuals requires the approval of the Danish National Committee on Health
Research Ethics and the Danish Data Protection Agency and, in some cases, the Danish Patient Safety Authority. Authorities generally have access to data
usage in relation to quality assurance and operational support information.
Treatment
Scientific research
Disclosing data for other purposes
2. Is the consent associated with activities? Consent must be given for treatment voluntarily, The consent must relate to a specific The consent must relate to a specific purpose.
specifically and in connection with the current disease research project.
2a. If yes, how? situation. This may be done together with several Consent to obtain and disclose data – if it
elements in one course of examination and treatment. must be obtained – must be in accordance
2b. Is consent divided into consent for the disclosure/retrieval of
“wet” data (biological/genetic) and “dry” data (data on treatment)? with the current needs.
The consent rules may be waived by coercive measures
in cases of psychiatric hospitalisation.
Consent for disclosing data must be obtained in
connection with the current needs.
3. Does the citizen have the option of withdrawing consent? Yes. There are no conditions attached to this (apart from
Yes – except for research based on
Yes, if the usage initially required individual
the patient being competent). national registers which does not require consent – otherwise, no.
3a. If yes, under which conditions? individual consent and therefore, cannot be
withdrawn.
4. Should the consent be verbal or written? As a rule, verbal consent is sufficient. The responsible
Consent must be in writing, if it is to be
Consent must be in writing, if required,
healthcare provider may request written consent in obtained. however, this may be waived in some cases.
4a. Give examples. cases of major interventions and complicated treatment,
or if there is a presumption that doubts may be raised
about the provision and scope of the consent.
5. Is there IT system support for consent management? A cautious yes – however, the question is whether this Depends on the IT support of the research
Depends on the IT support of the project.
applies to all EHRs, EMRs, electronic citizen records or study. Probably rarely. Probably rarely.
5a. Is consent limited by IT systems? practice systems?
5b. If yes, for what reasons, for example legal or practical? The systems used to limit access to consent, but the
use of more extensive IT systems has made them less
restrictive.
6. Is consent time-limited? Consent must be given “at the present point in time”, The duration of the research project. If consent is required, it will expire after one
which does not have a fixed definition. year.
6a. If yes, for how long?
7. Is consent limited to a legal entity? There are special rules for disclosing data to third
The project’s usage, i.e. the associated
Yes, it is the responsibility of each data
countries. organisation. processor to ensure notification to the Danish
7a. If yes, how? Data Protection Agency. Governmental
authorities have prior approval for the overall
7b. Are there different consent requirements for different usage and must simply report the purposes of
authorities/parties? the contract. Non-governmental authorities
must seek approval from the Danish Data
Protection Agency.
8. Do citizens have access to see who uses data and for what Partly. Via www.sundhed.dk,citizens can see which
No.
No.
purposes? healthcare providers have read their records, but not for
what purpose. 2
Dear Ministry of Social Affairs
On behalf of Danish health authorities, we are mapping the principles of different countries for patient
consent for treatment, participation in scientific studies and data transmission for other purposes. Patient
consent is currently a disputed topic in Denmark in relation to personal medicine, genetics, digitalization
of public service and data usage in general.
We will ask if you – or a college – will briefly describe the national principles for patient consent in Estonia
in the attached chart (requires less than a page). As a help, we have attached the description of the
national principles for patient consent in Denmark to illustrative what we have in mind.
Otherwise we would ask if you could guide us to documents, webpages etc. where we can read about the
principles in Estonia.
We apologize for the short deadline but hope that it can be done in the period from now until 6 July.
Please contact me if you have any questions.
Best Regards,
Karen Balle
+45 3085 8021 |
[email protected]
IMPLEMENT
CONSULTING GROUP_
implementconsultinggroup.com | Legal notice
LinkedIn | Facebook | Twitter | YouTube | SlideShare
| SlideShare