Hr Toomas Tõniste
Minister
Rahandusministeerium 26.07.2018 Nr 10.1-13/1234-1
Pr Riina Sikkut
Minister
Sotsiaalministeerium
Austatud ministrid
Edastame teile Euroopa Komisjoni voliniku Marianne Thysseni kirja 24. juulist 2018
nr 3932968.
Lugupidamisega
Kaja Tael
alaline esindaja
Kersti Neeme
[email protected]
+32 2 227 4342
Rue Guimard 11/13 / B-1040 Brüssel / Belgia
Tel: +32 2 227 39 10 /
[email protected] / http://www.eu.estemb.be
Ref. Ares(2018)3932968 - 24/07/2018
Explanatory annex on amendments to the Estonian OP for Cohesion Policy
2014-2020
As you put forward in your letter, the good performance of the Estonian labour market
and the high employment participation are very positive developments. This is thanks to
the substantial measures taken by Estonia to address challenges in the labour market as
well as the general recovery trend in the EU. But the Commission also agreed with
Estonia in the European Semester that a falling labour supply imposed challenges for
Estonia. The good performance masks a real structural bottleneck caused by the
shrinking working age population. Recent improvements in the labour market should not
lead us to be complacent and reduce investments in that area, taking into account the
massive changes we are facing in the world of work and the different forms of transition
we need to ensure and anticipate.
The Work Ability Reform, a flagship of the ESF priorities for 2014-2020, is therefore a
key for increasing labour supply. As underlined in your parallel proposal to amend the
2018 intermediary milestones of the Performance Framework on this reform, the latter
started later than initially planned. The Workability Allowance Act was postponed twice.
The full roll-out of the reform started in January 2017. While it is understandable that
some costs originally foreseen may be lower, it is still a reform that needs further roll-out
and support from the ESF until the end of the programming period. The overall
performance of the EU funding and outputs will be assessed at that time. More
qualitative approaches could be developed in delivering certain services, taking into
account rising concerns on occupational health and safety.
Participation in active labour market policies appears to be low in Estonia. While
participation in adult learning has improved, reaching groups that are difficult to engage
in learning and upskilling remains a challenge. Efforts should be kept in bringing low-
skilled adults back into education including on digital, learning, social entrepreneurial
and language skills. The importance of vocational education (VET) remains high in
particular to improve the level of participation in apprenticeship training and reduce the
high level of dropout from initial VET programs and skills mismatches. Furthermore,
there are still measures needed to implement for increasing the attractiveness and quality
of the teaching profession, taking into account that almost half of Estonian teachers are
over 50.
That is why the Commission services already informally agreed, in the ESF re
programming framework, on adding as a new activity the Programme for the
International Assessment of Adult Competencies performed by the OECD. But the
Commission also raised serious concerns on the decrease proposed by Estonia to funding
for teacher training, digital learning resources, vocational education improvement and
adult education.
The Estonian health care reform is robustly supported by the ESI Funds. It is focusing,
within the part dedicated to social inclusion, to the main challenges regarding the
modernisation of competence centres of hospital network, investments in infrastructure
of primary health centres in local community centres as far as ERDF is concerned and
early detection of alcohol misuse and development and offering of counselling services
for alcohol abusers as far as ESF is concerned. This corresponds to the main priorities
and challenges identified for ESIF to bring added value. Against the background of this
intervention logic, the Commission services expressed openness for beefing up, through
an OP amendment, the amounts allocated under ERDF for the funding of the
modernisation of treatment units of Ida-Viru central hospital.
3
Both ESF and ERDF accompany as well the Estonian deinstitutionalisation policy and
the provision of quality alternative care for persons with disabilities or special needs.
The proposal to amend substantially the OP to finance personal medicine through the
ESF/Social Inclusion has been also carefully considered. Actions planned would finance
the collection of gene samples for a significant size of the Estonian population, the
compilation of personalised genetic risk score feedback forms, the development ot a
clinical decision tool for better prescribing treatment and medication and the training oí
doctors as well as awareness raising of the general public.
These are valuable objectives. But they are not within the scope and the intervention
logic of the ESF. Questions remain on the actual effect on the organisation of health care
delivery, as to how these measures actually address the health systems' challenges
highlighted in the Semester's country report and whether there would not be more cost
effective measures with potentially more immediate impact to address these challenges
e.g. to diminish waiting times and out of pocket payments and improve access to curative
and preventive health services. The Commission recognises the longer-term usefulness oí
genetic-based personalised and preventive medicine. It encourages cross-country
cooperation to facilitate their use for research and health policy1. However effective
integration of genetic data analysis in the day to day clinical practice is not to become
effective in the short term.
Furthermore, ¡he amounts potentially re-allocated with a view to finance them would be
diverted from important education, skills, labour market and employability policy areas
as mentioned above. The issue was never mentioned by Estonian authorities in the last
Annual Review Meeting for the management of the ESI Funds. It would be a drift away
from the principle of thematic concentration. Using ES1F for such a completely new type
of activity in the late part of the current programming period could encounter important
management risks. It could impact the absorption of funds without safety nets for delays
and possible changes of methodology.
Other proposals for amendments would deserve further work and are not yet ready for
approval. For example the proposed shift from the ERDF to the ESF of the ICT program
for smart specialisation (Business with potential of growth and supportive research and
development activities) has still to be examined. Commission services already informally
informed the managing authority that it could be open for some form of ESF support as
the Country Report underlines the ICT skills gap in companies and the bottlenecks in
human capital that weaken Estonia's innovation capacity. But the ESF does not finance
the same kind of activities the ERDF does. There is therefore a need to clarify and further
discuss these proposals.
Commission Communication on enabling the digital transformation of health and care in the Digital
Single Maikét COM(2018)233final. 25.4.2018 and Declaration of Cooperation signed by 14 EU
Membei States Towards access to at least I million sequenced genomes in the European Union bv
2022", 10 April 2018.
4
Ref. Ares(2018)3932968 - 24/07/2018
MARIANNE THYSSEN
MEMBER OF THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION
Brussels. -¿4 07 löi
Dear Ministers,
Thank you for your letter of 5 July providing useful information and clarifications.
Making the Estonian multi-fund ESF/ERDF/CF Operational Programme (OP) 2014-2020
a success is key for the Commission. The Estonian OP is a good example of a
combination of factors for this success: thematic concentration, support to key structural
reforms and the EU2020 agenda. It is crucial to continue with this defining feature. The
Commission, in the spirit of partnership, attaches much importance to providing the
adequate flexibility to adjust to key developments or emerging trends in Estonia.
Proposals for amendments are to be examined in view of their compliance with the legal
framework, the intervention logic, the principle of concentration and the alignment with
the challenges identified in the European Semester Country Reports and Country Specific
Recommendations.
The informal OP modification proposal submitted by Estonia includes major re
allocations of funds, including for novel areas. Further to the various meetings that took
place with you and your services and as explained in more detail in the annex to my
letter, some of the proposals entail significant changes to the logic of intervention. On
personalised medicine, the Commission recognises the longer-term usefulness of genetic-
based medicine, but the actions proposed are not within the scope and the intervention
logic of the ESF. It is not clear how the intervention can address the immediate
challenges of the Estonian health system highlighted in the country report of the
European Semester.
H.E. Mr.Toomas Tõniste
Minister of Finance
H.E. Ms. Riina Sikkut
Minister of Health and Labour
Estonia
ADDRESS: EUROPEAN COMMISSION, B-1049 BRUSSELS - TELEPHONE: 32.2.295 54 91 - E-MAIL:
[email protected]
The year 2018 is critical for the management of the ESIF and the Performance
Framework (PF). The deadline for Member States to submit requests to amend the
Performance Framework was 30 June 2018. As this date is now overdue, there is a high
risk that the 2018 milestones of the performance framework will not be modified in due
time. 1 therefore reiterate our recommendation to separate the proposed modification of
the Performance Framework and the proposed transfers of funds.
This would allow avoiding the risk of losing the performance reserve including for the
health sector. I note that the performance reserve for priority axis 2 amounts to EUR 8
million in the ESF and to EUR 12,5 million in the ERDF.
1 encourage you to swiftly finalise with our services the necessary steps on the
amendments to the Estonian Operational Programme. The priority is to safeguard the
performance reserve for the benefit of Estonia's citizens. I am hopeful that, thanks to the
good cooperation between our respective colleagues, a final agreement on the changes to
the Estonian performance framework can be reached quickly.
Marianne THYSSEN
Annex: 1
ex.: Commissioners Corina Creţu and Vytenis Andriukaitis
2
Electronically signed on 24/07/2018 18:15 (UTC+02) in accordance with article 4.2 (Validity of electronic documents) of Commission Decision 2004/563