Saatja: Anu Aaspõllu <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 26.06.2020 17:03
Adressaat: Anu Aaspõllu <
[email protected]>
Teema: STOP projekti küsitlus - ülekaaluslised lapsed
Tere,
Tervise Arengu Instituut osaleb Euroopa Komisjoni poolt rahastatud
Horizon 2020 STOP projektis (Science and Technology in childhood Obesity
Policy - Teadus ja tehnoloogia lapseea ülekaalulisuse poliitikas; projekt
nr. 774549; http://www.stopchildobesity.eu), mis on suunatud lapseea
ülekaalulisuse leviku hindamisele ja poliitikate kujundamisele selle
epideemia kontrollimise meetmete kavandamiseks ja tõhusaks rakendamiseks
nii Eestis, Euroopas, aga ka ülemaailmselt.
Kutsume Teid panustama eksperditeadmisega toidukeskkonnapoliitika indeksi
(Food-Environment Policy Index) indikaatorite hindamisse. Lisatud failis
on ka täiendav info hindamise kriteeriumite kohta. Kuna tegemist on
Euroopa Komisjoni poolt rahastatud projektiga, on nii hindamisdokument
kui ka selgitav materjal inglise keeles.
Indikaatorid hinnangute andmiseks on 13 eri leheküljel Exceli tabelis.
Kui te ei soovi/taha mingit domääni hinnata, siis palume märkida see
vastava lehe märkuste veergu.
Ootame Teilt tagasisidet ja palume täidetud küsimustik saata tagasi
hiljemalt 10. augustiks 2020.
Meeldivat koostööd soovides,
Lugupidamisega,
Anu Aaspõllu
Vanemteadur
Toitumisuuringute osakond
Tervise Arengu Instituut
Hiiu 42, 11619 Tallinn
telef: 6593986
e-post:
Effectiveness of existing policies for lifestyle
interventions - Policy Evaluation Network
(PEN)
Work package 1: Policy mapping and EPI development
Milestone 1.1.2: Food-EPI indicators have been set in each country
This document contains the finalised revised indicators which will be used in
all PEN and STOP countries conducting a Food EPI.
DOMAIN 1 - FOOD COMPOSITION - Food composition targets/standards/restrictions for processed foods: There are
government systems implemented to ensure that, where practicable, processed foods minimise the energy density and
the nutrients of concern (salt, saturated fat, trans fat, added sugar)
Indicator definitions - please take these into account in the SCOPE (FOR INFORMATION ONLY)
rating process This colum provides the type evidence collected for this
indicator (as well as the evidence that will not be taken into
account).
INDICATOR (COMP) 1: Food composition Includes packaged foods manufactured in country X
targets/standards/restrictions have been established by or manufactured overseas and imported to country
the government for the content of the nutrients of concern X for sale.
(trans fats, added sugars, salt, saturated fat) in industrially Includes packaged, ready-to-eat meals sold in
processed foods, in particular for those food groups that supermarkets.
are major contributors to population intakes of those Includes mandatory or voluntary targets, standards
nutrients of concern (e.g., reduce by X%, maximum mg/g per 100g or per
serving).
Includes legislated ban on nutrients of concern.
Excludes legislated restrictions related to other
ingredients (e.g. additives).
Excludes mandatory food composition regulation
related to vitamins and micronutrients (e.g. folic acid
or iodine fortification)
Excludes food consumption standards/targets for
fibre, healthy ingredients like fruits and vegetables
Excludes food composition of ready-to-eat meals
sold in food service outlets (see COMP2)
Excludes general guidelines advising food companies
to reduce nutrients of concern.
Excludes the provision of resources or expertise to
support individual food companies with
reformulation.
Industrially processed foods are the processed and
ultra-processed foods according to the NOVA
classification (please find the complete definitions
here: https://world.openfoodfacts.org/nova):
Processed foods, such as bottled vegetables, canned
fish, fruits in syrup, cheeses and freshly made
breads, are made essentially by adding salt, oil, sugar
or other substances from Group 2 (processed
culinary ingredients) to Group 1 (unprocessed or
minimally processed) foods.
Ultra-processed foods, such as soft drinks, sweet or
savoury packaged snacks, reconstituted meat
products and pre-prepared frozen dishes, are not
modified foods but formulations made mostly or
entirely from substances derived from foods and
additives, with little if any intact Group 1
(unprocessed or minimally processed foods) food.
The overall purpose of ultra-processing is to create
branded, convenient (durable, ready to consume),
attractive (hyper-palatable) and highly profitable
(low-cost ingredients) food products designed to
displace all other food groups.
DOMAIN 1 - FOOD COMPOSITION - Food composition targets/standards/restrictions for processed foods: There are
government systems implemented to ensure that, where practicable, processed foods minimise the energy density and
the nutrients of concern (salt, saturated fat, trans fat, added sugar)
Indicator definitions - please take these into account in the SCOPE (FOR INFORMATION ONLY)
rating process This colum provides the type of evidence collected for this
indicator (as well as the evidence that will not be taken into
account).
INDICATOR (COMP) 2: Food composition Meals sold at food service outlets include foods sold
targets/standards/restrictions have been established by at quick service restaurants, dine-in restaurants and
the government for the content of the nutrients of concern take-away outlets, coffee, bakery and snack food
(trans fats, added sugars, salt, saturated fat) in meals sold outlets (both fixed outlets and mobile food vendors).
from food service outlets, in particular for those food This also includes foods from catering operations
groups that are major contributors to population intakes of and delivery meals.
those nutrients of concern. Includes legislated bans on nutrients of concern
Includes mandatory or voluntary targets, standards
(i.e. reduce by X%, maximum mg/g per 100g or per
serving)
Excludes legislated restrictions related to other
ingredients (e.g. additives)
Excludes mandatory out-of-home meal composition
regulations related to vitamins and micronutrients,
e.g. folic acid or iodine fortification
Excludes food consumption standards/targets for
fibre, healthy ingredients like fruits and vegetables
Excludes general guidelines advising food service
outlets to reduce nutrients of concern
Excludes the provision of resources or expertise to
support food service outlets with reformulation
DOMAIN 2 - FOOD LABELLING - There is a regulatory system implemented by the government for consumer-oriented
labelling on food packaging and menu boards in restaurants to enable consumers to easily make informed food choices
and to prevent misleading claims.
Indicator definitions - please take these into account in the SCOPE (FOR INFORMATION ONLY)
rating process This colum provides the type evidence collected for this
indicator (as well as the evidence that will not be taken into
account).
INDICATOR (LABEL) 1: Ingredient lists and nutrient Includes packaged foods manufactured in Country X
declarations in line with Codex recommendations are or manufactured elsewhere and imported to
present on the labels of all packaged foods. Country X for sale.
Nutrient declaration means a standardized
statement or listing of the nutrient content of a food
Excludes health and nutrition claims (see ’LABEL 2’)
Includes trans fats and added sugar which are not
part of the standard seven elements generally part
of mandatory nutrient declarations (energy, total fat,
saturated fat, trans fat, carbohydrates, sugar,
protein, sodium)
INDICATOR (LABEL) 2: Evidence-based regulations are in Nutrition claims include references to the nutritional
place for approving and/or reviewing claims on foods, so content on food (e.g. low in fat).
that consumers are protected against unsubstantiated and Health claims include function claims, such as
misleading nutrition and health claims. ‘calcium strengthens bones’) and disease risk
reduction and therapeutic claims, such as ‘A healthy
diet rich in a variety of vegetables and fruit may help
reduce the risk of some types of cancer’) claims that
relate to the relationship between a diet, a food or a
property of a food and a health effect.
Includes the use of a nutrient profiling system to
classify food products into permitted/not permitted
to carry health claims and/or nutrition claims
‘Evidence-based’ refers to regulations that are based
on an extensive review of up-to-date research and
expert input or a validated nutrient profiling model
to inform decision-making about nutrition or health
claims
INDICATOR (LABEL) 3: One or more interpretive, evidence- Nutrition information systems include traffic light
informed front-of-pack supplementary nutrition labelling (overall or for specific nutrients); Warning
information system(s) endorsed by the Government, which labels; Nutriscore; star or points rating; percent daily
readily allow consumers to assess a product’s healthiness, intake.
is/are applied to all packaged foods (examples are the Keyhole and Finish heart symbol are not considered
Nutriscore and traffic lights). FOP labelling systems (but rather claims).
‘Evidence-informed’ refers to systems that utilise
robust criteria (based on an extensive review of up-
to-date research and expert input) or a validated
nutrient profiling model to inform decision-making
about the product’s healthiness
INDICATOR (LABEL) 4: A simple and clearly-visible system Quick service restaurants: In the ' (Country name)'
of labelling the menu boards of all quick service context this definition includes fast food chains as
restaurants (i.e. fast food chains) is applied by the well as gas stations, kiosks, coffee, bakery and snack
government, which allows consumers to interpret the food chains. It may also include supermarkets where
nutrient quality and energy content of foods and meals on ready-to-eat foods are sold.
sale. Definition Euromonitor: Fast food outlets offer
limited menus that are prepared quickly. Customers
order, pay and pick up their order from a counter.
Outlets tend to specialize in one or two main entrees
such as hamburgers, pizza, ice cream, or chicken, but
they usually also provide salads, drinks, dessert etc.
Food preparation is generally simple and involves
one or two steps, allowing for kitchen staffs
generally consisting of younger, unskilled workers.
Other key characteristics include: • A standardised
and restricted menu; • Food for immediate
consumption; • Tight individual portion control on all
ingredients and on the finished product; • Individual
packaging of each item; • Counter service; • A
seating area, or close access to a shared seating
area, such as in a shopping centre food court • For
chained fast food, chained and franchised operations
which operate under a uniform fascia and corporate
identity. • Take out is generally present, as is drive-
through in some markets.
Labelling systems: Includes any point-of-sale (POS)
nutrition information such as total kilojoules;
percent daily intake; traffic light labelling; star rating,
or specific amounts of nutrients of concern, salt
warning labels.
Includes endorsement schemes (e.g., accredited
healthy choice symbol) on approved menu items
DOMAIN 3 - FOOD PROMOTION - There is a comprehensive policy implemented by the government to reduce the
impact (exposure and power) of promotion of unhealthy foods to children across all media.
- Exposure of food marketing concerns the reach and frequency of a marketing message. This is dependent upon the
media or channels which are used to market foods.
- The power of food marketing concerns the creative content of the marketing message. For example, using cartoons
or celebrities enhances the power (or persuasiveness) of a marketing message because such strategies are
attractive to children.
Indicator definitions - please take these into account in the SCOPE (FOR INFORMATION ONLY)
rating process This colum provides the type evidence collected for this
indicator (as well as the evidence that will not be taken into
account).
INDICATOR (PROMO) 1: Effective policies are implemented Includes mandatory policy (i.e. legislation or
by the government to restrict exposure and power of regulations) or voluntary standards, codes,
promotion of unhealthy foods to children including guidelines set by government or by industry where
adolescents through broadcast media (TV, radio). the government plays a role in development,
monitoring, enforcement or resolving complaints
(i.e. co-regulation).
Includes free-to-air and subscription television and
radio only (see PROMO2, PROMO3 and PROMO5 for
other forms of media).
Effective means that the policies are likely to reduce
overall exposure of children, including adolescents to
unhealthy food advertising over the day.
INDICATOR (PROMO) 2: Includes online media (e.g. social media, branded
Effective policies are implemented by the government to education websites, online games, competitions and
restrict exposure and power of promotion of unhealthy apps)
foods to children including adolescents through online and Where the promotion is specifically through other
social media. non-broadcast media than online and social media,
this should be captured in ‘PROMO3 and PROMO5’.
Where the promotion is specifically in a children’s
setting, this should be captured in ‘PROMO4’.
Effective means that the policies are likely to reduce
overall exposure of children, including adolescents to
unhealthy food advertising over the day.
INDICATOR (PROMO) 3: Effective policies are implemented Non-broadcast media promotion includes: print (e.g.
by the government to restrict exposure and power of children’s magazines), on/around public transport
promotion of unhealthy foods to children including (e.g. signage, posters and billboards), cinema
adolescents through non-broadcast media other than advertising, product placement and brand
packaging and online/social media. integration (e.g. in television shows and movies),
direct marketing (e.g. provision of show bags,
samples or flyers), or point-of-sale (POS) displays
Non-broadcast media is excluding the media covered
through other indicators like online and social media
(PROMO2) and packaging (PROMO5)
Where the promotion is specifically in a children’s
setting, this should be captured in ‘PROMO4’
Effective means that the policies are likely to reduce
overall exposure of children, including adolescents to
unhealthy food advertising over the day.
INDICATOR (PROMO) 4: Effective policies are implemented Children’s settings include: areas in and around
by the government to ensure that unhealthy foods are not schools, preschools/ kindergartens, daycare centres,
commercially promoted to children including adolescents children’s health services (including primary care,
in settings where children gather (e.g. preschools, schools, maternal and child health or tertiary settings), sport,
sport and cultural events). recreation and play areas/ venues/ facilities and
cultural/community events where children are
commonly present.
Includes restrictions on marketing in government-
owned or managed facilities/venues (including
within the service contracts where management is
outsourced)
Includes restriction on unhealthy food sponsorship in
sport (e.g. junior sport, sporting events, venues)
Effective means that the policies are likely to reduce
overall exposure of children, including adolescents to
unhealthy food advertising over the day.
INDICATOR (PROMO) 5: Effective policies are implemented Includes product design and packaging (e.g. use of
by the government to ensure that unhealthy foods are not celebrities or cartoons, competitions and give-
commercially promoted to children, including adolescents aways)
on food packages Where the promotion is specifically in a children’s
setting, this should be captured in ‘PROMO4’
Effective means that the policies are likely to reduce
overall exposure of children, including adolescents to
unhealthy food advertising over the day.
DOMAIN 4- FOOD PRICES - Food pricing policies (e.g., taxes and subsidies) are aligned with health outcomes by helping
to make the healthy eating choices the easier, cheaper choices
Indicator definitions - please take these into account in the SCOPE (FOR INFORMATION ONLY)
rating process This colum provides the type evidence collected for this
indicator (as well as the evidence that will not be taken into
account).
INDICATOR (PRICES) 1: Taxes or levies on healthy foods are Includes exemptions from excise tax, ad valorem tax
minimised to encourage healthy food choices (e.g. low or or import duty.
no sales tax, excise, value-added or import duties on fruit Includes differential application of excise tax, ad
and vegetables) valorem tax or import duty.
Excludes subsidies (see ‘PRICES3’) or food purchasing
welfare support (see ‘PRICES4’)
INDICATOR (PRICES) 2: Taxes or levies on unhealthy foods Includes differential application of excise tax, ad
(e.g. sugar-sweetened beverages, foods high in nutrients of valorem tax or import duty on high calorie foods or
concern) are in place and increase the retail prices of these foods that are high in nutrients of concern
foods by at least 10% to discourage unhealthy food
choices, and these taxes are reinvested to improve
population health
INDICATOR (PRICES) 3: The intent of existing subsidies on Includes agricultural input subsidies, such as free or
foods, including infrastructure funding support (e.g. subsidised costs for water, fertiliser, seeds,
research and development, supporting markets or electricity or transport (e.g., freight) where those
transport systems), is to favour healthy rather than subsidies specifically target healthy foods
unhealthy foods. Includes programs that ensure that farmers receive a
certain price for their produce to encourage
increased food production or business viability
Includes grants or funding support for food
producers (i.e. farmers, food manufacturers) to
encourage innovation via research and development
where that funding scheme specifically targets
healthy food
Includes funding support for wholesale market
systems that support the supply of healthy foods
Includes population level food subsidies at the
consumer end (e.g. subsidising staples such as rice or
bread)
Excludes incentives for the establishment of, or
ongoing support for, retail outlets (including
greengrocers, farmers’ markets, food co-ops, etc.
See ‘RETAIL2’).
Excludes subsidised training, courses or other forms
of education for food producers - Excludes the
redistribution of excess or second grade produce
Excludes food subsidies related to welfare support
(see ‘PRICES4’)
Should be in line with population nutrition goals
related to the prevention of obesity and diet-related
NCDs (e.g., reducing intake of nutrients of concern,
and should not related to micronutrient deficiencies)
INDICATOR (PRICES) 4: The government ensures that food- Includes programs such as ‘food stamps’ or other
related income support programs are for healthy foods schemes where individuals can utilise government-
administered subsidies, vouchers, tokens or
discounts in retail settings for specific food
purchasing.
Excludes general programs that seek to address food
insecurity such as government support for, or
partnerships with, organisations that provide free or
subsidised meals (including school breakfast
programs) or food parcels or redistribute second
grade produce for this purpose.
Excludes food subsidies at the consumer end (e.g.
subsidising staples at a population level – see
‘PRICES3’)
DOMAIN 5 - FOOD PROVISON - The government ensures that there are healthy food service policies implemented in
government-funded settings to ensure that food provision encourages healthy food choices, and the government actively
encourages and supports private companies to implement similar
Indicator definitions - please take these into account in the SCOPE (FOR INFORMATION ONLY)
rating process This colum provides the type evidence collected for this
indicator (as well as the evidence that will not be taken into
account).
INDICATOR (PROV) 1: The government ensures that there Includes early childhood education and care services
are clear, consistent policies (including nutrition standards) (0-5 years).
implemented in schools and early childhood education Schools include government and non-government
services for food service activities (canteens, food at primary and secondary schools (up to age 18 years)
events, fundraising, promotions, vending machines etc.) to Includes policies and nutrition standards to provide
provide and promote healthy food choices. and promote healthy food choices or to limit or
restrict the provision or promotion of unhealthy
food choices
Includes policies that relate to school meals
programs, where the program is partly or fully
funded, managed or overseen by the government
Excludes programmes in schools that are targeted to
children of low socioeconomic groups only (as these
would be covered under PRICES4)
INDICATOR (PROV) 2: The government ensures that there Public sector settings include: - Government-funded
are clear, consistent policies in other public sector settings or managed services where the government is
for food service activities (canteens, food at events, responsible for the provision of food, including
fundraising, promotions, vending machines, etc.) to public hospitals and other in-patient health services
provide and promote healthy food choices. (acute and sub-acute, including mental health
services), residential care homes, aged and disability
care settings, custodial care facilities, prisons and
home/community care services - Government-
owned, funded or managed services where the
general public purchase foods including health
services, parks, sporting and leisure facilities,
community events etc. - Public sector workplaces
Includes private businesses that are under contract
by the government to provide food
Excludes ‘public settings’ such as train stations,
venues, facilities or events that are not funded or
managed by the government (see ‘RETAIL4’)
Excludes school and early childhood settings (see
‘PROV1’)
Includes policies and nutrition standards to provide
and promote healthy food choices or to limit or
restrict the provision or promotion of unhealthy
food choices
Includes the strategic placement of foods and
beverages in cabinets, fridges, on shelves or near the
cashier
Includes the use of signage to highlight healthy
options or endorsements (such as traffic lights or a
recognised healthy symbol)
Includes modifying ingredients to make foods and
drinks healthier, or changing the menu to offer
healthier options
Excludes public procurement standards (see
‘PROV3’)
INDICATOR (PROV) 3: The government ensures that there Includes standards for the public sector which
are clear, consistent public procurement standards in encourage the procurement of healthy foods
public sector settings for food service activities to provide Includes standards for the public sector which
and promote healthy food choices. discourage the procurement of unhealthy foods
Includes public sector settings as defined in PROV 1
and PROV 2
INDICATOR (PROV) 4: The Government ensures that there Includes support for early childhood education
are good support and training systems to help schools and services as defined in ‘PROV1’
other public sector organisations and their caterers meet Public sector organisations include settings defined
the healthy food service policies and guidelines in ‘PROV2’
Support and training systems include guidelines,
toolkits, templates (e.g. policy/guidelines or
contracts), recipes and menu planning tools, expert
advice, menu and product assessments, online
training modules, cook/caterer/other food service
staff information and training workshops or courses
INDICATOR (PROV) 5: The Government actively encourages For the purpose of this indicator, ‘private companies’
and supports private companies to provide and promote includes for-profit companies and extends to non-
healthy foods and meals in their workplaces government organisations (NGOs) including not-for-
profit/charitable organisations, community-
controlled organisations, etc.
Includes healthy catering policies, fundraising,
events - Includes support and training systems
including guidelines, toolkits, templates (e.g.
policy/guidelines or contracts), recipes and menu
planning tools, expert advice, menu and product
assessments, online training modules,
cook/caterer/other food service staff information
and training workshops or courses (where relevant
to the provision of food in a workplace)
Excludes the provision or promotion of food to
people not employed by that organisation (e.g.
visitors or customers)
Excludes support for organisations to provide staff
education on healthy foods
DOMAIN 6 - FOOD IN RETAIL - The government has the power to implement policies and programs to support the
availability of healthy foods and limit the availability of unhealthy foods in communities (outlet density and locations)
and in-store (product placement)
Indicator definitions - please take these into account in the SCOPE (FOR INFORMATION ONLY)
rating process This colum provides the type evidence collected for this
indicator (as well as the evidence that will not be taken into
account).
INDICATOR (RETAIL) 1: Zoning laws and policies are Includes the consideration of public health in
implemented to place limits on the density or placement of State/Territory Planning Acts that guide the policies,
quick serve restaurants or other outlets selling mainly priorities and objectives to be implemented at the
unhealthy foods in communities and/or access to these local government level through their planning
outlets (e.g. opening hours). schemes
Includes the consideration of public health in
State/Territory subordinate planning instruments
and policies
Includes a State/Territory guideline that sets the
policy objective of considering public health when
reviewing and approving fast food planning
applications.
Includes limitations to access of unhealthy food
outlets (i.e. opening hours)
Excludes laws, policies or actions of local
governments
INDICATOR (RETAIL) 2: Zoning laws and policies are Outlets include supermarkets, produce markets,
implemented to encourage the availability of outlets farmers’ markets, greengrocers, food cooperatives
selling fresh fruit and vegetables and/or access to these Includes fixed or mobile outlets
outlets (e.g. opening hours, frequency i.e. for markets) . Excludes community gardens, edible urban or
backyard gardens (usually regulated by local
governments)
Includes policies that support local governments to
reduce license or permit requirements or fees to
encourage the establishment of such outlets
Includes State/Territory policies to streamline and
standardise planning approval processes or reduce
regulatory burdens for these outlets
Includes actions to improve access to healthy food
outlets (i.e. opening hours; frequency i.e. for
markets)
Includes the provision of financial grants or subsidies
to outlets
INDICATOR 3 (RETAIL 3): The Government ensures existing Food stores include supermarkets, convenience
support systems are in place to encourage food stores to stores (including ‘general stores’ or ‘milk bars’),
promote the in-store availability of healthy foods and to greengrocers and other speciality food retail outlets
limit the in-store availability of unhealthy foods Support systems include guidelines, resources or
expert support
Includes all settings with food retail stores, including
but not exclusive to; train stations, venues, facilities
or events frequented by the public etc.
Excludes settings owned or managed by the
government (see ‘PROV2’ and ‘PROV4’)
Includes the strategic placement of foods and
beverages in cabinets, fridges, on shelves or near the
cashier - Includes the use of signage to highlight
healthy options or endorsements (such as traffic
lights or a recognised healthy symbol)
Includes offering healthier food and drink products,
or changing the menu or store layout to offer more
healthy options
Includes decreasing the offer of unhealthy food and
drink products
Excludes reformulation and labelling in relation to
nutrients of concern (COMP1; LABEL4)
INDICATOR (RETAIL 4): The government ensures existing Food service outlets include for-profit quick service
support systems are in place to encourage the promotion restaurants, eat-in or take-away restaurants, pubs,
and availability of healthy foods in food service outlets and clubs
to discourage the promotion and availability of unhealthy Support systems include guidelines, resources or
foods in food service outlets expert support
Includes settings such as train stations, venues,
facilities or events frequented by the public
Excludes settings owned or managed by the
government (see ‘PROV2’ and ‘PROV4’)
Includes the strategic placement of foods and
beverages in cabinets, fridges, on shelves or near the
cashier - Includes the use of signage to highlight
healthy options or endorsements (such as traffic
lights or a recognised healthy symbol)
Includes modifying ingredients to make foods and
drinks more healthy, or changing the menu to offer
more healthy options
Excludes reformulation and labelling in relation to
nutrients of concern (COMP2; LABEL4)
DOMAIN 7 - FOOD TRADE AND INVESTMENT - The government ensures that trade and investment agreements protect
food sovereignty, favour healthy food environments, are linked with domestic health and agricultural policies in ways
that are consistent with health objectives, and do not promote unhealthy food environments.
Indicator definitions - please take these into account in the SCOPE (FOR INFORMATION ONLY)
rating process This colum provides the type evidence collected for this
indicator (as well as the evidence that will not be taken into
account).
INDICATOR (TRADE) 1: The Government undertakes risk Includes policies or procedures that guide the
impact assessments before and during the negotiation of undertaking of risk impact assessments before or
trade and investment agreements, to identify, evaluate during negotiation to assess risks and benefits in
and minimize the direct and indirect negative impacts of relation to public health and population nutrition
such agreements on population nutrition and health Includes policies or procedures that guide the
evaluation of trade and investment agreements after
an agreement is finalised to monitor the impact for
the purpose of informing future negotiations or
reviews
Includes policies or procedures that guide public
consultation procedures before and during
negotiations
Any trade or economic agreements still considered
active
INDICATOR (TRADE) 2: The government adopts measures Includes provisions in trade or economic agreements
to manage investment and protect their regulatory that protect the capacity of government to
capacity with respect to public health nutrition implement domestic policy in relation to food
environments. This includes protections with respect
to tariffs, non-tariff measures (such as quotas,
regulations, standards, testing, certification,
licensing procedures) and measures related to
foreign direct investment
Binding commitments made under Trade and
Investment Agreements (TIA’s) can constrain the
way countries can regulate goods, services, and
investments to promote public interests (including
public health) in a way that is upstream from
domestic policy processes.
DOMAIN 8 - LEADERSHIP - The political leadership ensures that there is strong support for the vision, planning,
communication, implementation and evaluation of policies and actions to create healthy food environments, improve
population nutrition, and reduce diet-related inequalities
Indicator definitions - please take these into account in the SCOPE (FOR INFORMATION ONLY)
rating process This colum provides the type evidence collected for this
indicator (as well as the evidence that will not be taken into
account).
INDICATOR (LEAD 1): There is strong, visible, political Visible support includes statements of intent,
support (at the head of government or state/ ministerial election commitments, budget commitments,
level) expressed at both national as well as international establishing priorities and targets, demonstration of
level for improving food environments, population support in the media, other actions that
nutrition, diet related NCDs and their related inequalities" demonstrate support for new or strengthened policy
Documents that contain evidence of strong political
support include media releases, speeches, pre-
election policy papers, introduction of a bill, State-
level strategic plans with targets or key performance
indicators
INDICATOR (LEAD 2): Clear population intake targets have
been established by the government for the nutrients of Includes targets which specify population intakes
concern and / or relevant food groups to according to average reductions in percentage or
meet WHO and national recommended dietary intake volume (e.g. mg/g) for salt/sodium, saturated fat,
levels trans fats or added or free sugars*Typically requires
the government to establish clear dietary guidelines
on the maximum daily intake of nutrients of concern
**Free sugar is defined as is the sugar no longer in
its naturally-occurring state (i.e., no longer in whole
fruits, vegetables, unsweetened dairy, and grains)
and can be consumed as is or incorporated into
other foods. Examples include table sugar, syrup,
honey, fruit juice and nectars. Added sugar is defined
as the free sugar that has been added to foods,
however regulatory definitions vary widely under
different jurisdictions, some of which are currently
under review. These differ from naturally occurring
sugars, defined as the sugar found naturally within
whole foods (i.e., within whole fruits, vegetables,
dairy, and some grains).
INDICATOR (LEAD 3): Clear, interpretive, evidenced- Food-based dietary guidelines should be for both
informed food based dietary guidelines have been genders and key age groups including infants and
established and implemented. pregnant women
Evidence-informed includes extensive review of up-
to-date research and mechanisms to seek expert
input
Evidence includes ways the FBDG have been used to
develop/implement policies to improve diets
INDICATOR (LEAD 4): There is a comprehensive, Includes documented plans with specific actions and
transparent, up-to-date implementation plan linked to interventions (i.e. policies, programs, partnerships)
national needs and priorities, to improve food Plans should be current (i.e. maintain endorsement
environments , reduce the intake of the nutrients of by the current government and/or are being
reported against)
concern to meet WHO and national recommended dietary Plans should refer to actions to improve food
intake levels, and reduce diet-related NCDs environments (as defined in the policy domains
above) and should include both policy and program
strategies
Excludes overarching frameworks that provide
general guidance and direction
Includes priority policy and program strategies,
social media marketing for public awareness and
threat of legislation for voluntary approaches.
INDICATOR (LEAD 5): Government priorities have been Frameworks, strategies or implementation plans
established to reduce inequalities or protect vulnerable specify aims, objectives or targets to reduce
populations in relation to diet, nutrition, obesity and NCDs inequalities including taking a preventive approach
that addresses the social and environmental
determinants of health
Frameworks, strategies or implementation plans
identify vulnerable populations or priority groups
Implementation plans specify policies or programs
that aim to reduce inequalities for specific
population groups
Excludes priorities to reduce inequalities in
secondary or tertiary prevention
DOMAIN 9 - GOVERNANCE: Governments have structures in place to ensure transparency and accountability, and
encourage broad community participation and inclusion when formulating and implementing policies and actions to
create healthy food environments, improve population nutrition, and reduce diet-related inequalities
Indicator definitions - please take these into account in the SCOPE (FOR INFORMATION ONLY)
rating process This colum provides the type evidence collected for this
indicator (as well as the evidence that will not be taken into
account).
INDICATOR (GOVER)1: There are procedures in place to Includes government policies, guidelines, codes of
restrict commercial influences on the development of conduct or other mechanisms to guide actions and
policies related to food environments where they have decision-making by government employees, for
conflicts of interest with improving population nutrition. example conflict of interest declaration procedures
for example: restricting lobbying influences. Includes procedures to manage partnerships with
private companies or peak bodies representing
industries that are consulted for the purpose of
developing policy, for examples committee
procedural guidelines or terms of reference.
Includes publicly available, up to-to-date registers of
lobbyist and/ or their activities
INDICATOR (GOVER) 2: Policies and procedures are Includes policies, procedures or guidelines to
implemented for using evidence in the development of support government employees in the use of
food and nutrition policies evidence for policy development including best
practice evidence review methodology (including
types and strength of evidence needed) and policy
implementation in the absence of strong evidence
(where the potential risk or harms of inaction are
great).
Includes policies, procedures or guidelines that
stipulate the requirements for the establishment of a
scientific or expert committee to inform policy
development.
Includes the use of evidence-based models,
algorithms and tools to guide policy development or
within policy to guide implementation (e.g. nutrient
profiling model)
Includes government resourcing of evidence and
research by specific units, either within or across
government departments
INDICATOR (GOVER) 3: Policies and procedures are Includes policies or procedures that guide the use of
implemented for ensuring transparency in the consultation in the development of food policy
development of food and nutrition policies Includes policies or procedures to guide the online
publishing of private sector and civil society
submissions to government around the development
of policy and subsequent government response to
these.
Includes policies or procedures to guide the online
publishing of scoping papers, draft and final policies
Include policies or procedures to guide public
communications around all policies put forward but
not progressed
INDICATOR (GOVER) 4: The government ensures public Includes policies and procedures to guide the timely,
access to comprehensive nutrition information and key online publishing of government budgets,
documents (e.g. budget documents, annual performance performance reviews, audits, evaluation reports or
reviews and health indicators) for the public the findings of other reviews or inquiries
Includes ‘freedom of information’ legislation and
related processes to enable the public access to
government information on request, with minimal
restrictions and exemptions
Includes policies or procedures to guide the timely,
online publishing of population health data captured
/ owned by government
DOMAIN 10 - MONITORING AND INTELLIGENCE - The government’s monitoring and intelligence systems (surveillance,
evaluation, research and reporting) are comprehensive and regular enough to assess the status of food environments,
population nutrition and diet-related NCDs and their inequalities, and to measure progress on achieving the goals of
nutrition and health plans
Indicator definitions - please take these into account in the SCOPE (FOR INFORMATION ONLY)
rating process This colum provides the type evidence collected for this
indicator (as well as the evidence that will not be taken into
account).
INDICATOR (MONIT 1): Monitoring systems, implemented Includes monitoring systems funded fully or in part
by the government, are in place to regularly monitor food by government that are managed by an academic
environments(especially for food composition for nutrients institution or other organisation
of concern, food promotion to children, and nutritional Includes regular monitoring and review of the impact
quality of food in schools and other public sector settings), of policies implemented by the government on food
against codes / guidelines / standards / targets environments (as relevant to the individual State /
Territory, and described in the policy domains
above), in particular:
1. Monitoring of compliance with voluntary
food composition standards related to
nutrients of concern in out-of-home meals
(as defined in the ‘Food composition’
domain)
2. Monitoring of compliance with food labelling
regulations (as defined in the ‘Food labelling’
domain above)
3. Monitoring of unhealthy food promoted to
children via broadcast and non-broadcast
media and in children’s settings (as defined
in the ‘Food promotion’ domain above)
4. Monitoring of compliance with food
provision policies in schools, early childhood
services and public sector settings (as
defined in the ‘Food provision’ domain
above)
INDICATOR (MONIT 2): There is regular monitoring of adult Includes monitoring of adult and child intake in line
and childhood nutrition status and population intakes with X Countries Food Guide and dietary
against specified intake targets or recommended daily recommendations
intake levels Includes monitoring of adult and child intake of
nutrients of concern and noncore/discretionary
foods including sugar-sweetened beverages (even if
there are no clear intake targets for all of these)
‘Regular’ is considered to be every five years or more
frequently
INDICATOR (MONIT 3): There is regular monitoring of adult Anthropometric measurements include height,
and childhood overweight and obesity prevalence using weight and waist circumference
anthropometric measurements ‘Regular’ is considered to be every five years or more
frequently
INDICATOR (MONIT4): There is regular monitoring of the Diet-related NCD risk factors and NCDs include,
prevalence of NCD metabolic risk factors and occurrence amongst others, hypertension,
rates (e.g. prevalence, incidence, mortality) for the main hypercholesterolemia, Type 2 Diabetes,
diet-related NCDs cardiovascular disease (including ischaemic heart
disease, cerebrovascular disease and other diseases
of the vessels), diet-related cancers
disease and other diseases of the vessels), diet-
related cancers
May be collected through a variety of mechanisms
such as population surveys or a notifiable diseases
surveillance system
INDICATOR (MONIT 5): Major programs and policies are Includes any policies, guidelines, frameworks or tools
regularly evaluated to assess their effectiveness and that are used to determine the depth and type
contributions to achieving the goals of the nutrition and (method and reporting) of evaluation required
health plans Includes a comprehensive evaluation framework and
plan that aligns with the key preventive health or
nutrition implementation plan
The definition of a major programs and policies is to
be defined by the relevant government department
Evaluation should be in addition to routine
monitoring of progress against a project plan
or program logic
INDICATOR (MONIT 6) Progress towards reducing health Monitoring of overweight and obesity and main diet-
inequalities or health impacts in vulnerable populations related NCDs includes stratification or analysis of
and social and economic determinants of health are population groups where there are the greatest
regularly monitored. health inequalities including Indigenous peoples and
socio-economic strata
Includes reporting against targets or key
performance indicators related to health inequalities
DOMAIN 11 - FUNDING AND RESOURCES - Sufficient funding is invested in 'Population Nutrition Promotion' (estimated
from the investments in population promotion of healthy eating and healthy food environments for the prevention of
obesity and diet-related NCDs, excluding all one-on-one promotion (primary-care, antenatal services, maternal and
child nursing services etc.), food safety, micronutrient deficiencies (e.g. folate fortification and undernutrition) to create
healthy food environments, improved population nutrition, reductions in obesity, diet-related NCDs and their related
inequalities.
Indicator definitions - please take these into account in the SCOPE (FOR INFORMATION ONLY)
rating process This colum provides the type evidence collected for this
indicator (as well as the evidence that will not be taken into
account).
INDICATOR (FUND) 1: The ‘population nutrition’ budget, as 'Population nutrition' includes promotion of
a proportion of total health spending and/or in relation to healthy eating, and policies and programs that
the diet-related NCD burden sufficiently contributes to support healthy food environments for the
reducing diet-related NCD's prevention of obesity and diet-related NCDs
The definition excludes all one-on-one and group-
based promotion (primary care, antenatal services,
maternal and child nursing services etc.), food
safety, micronutrient deficiencies (e.g. folic acid
fortification) and undernutrition
Includes estimates for the budget allocated to the
unit within the Department of Health that has
primary responsibility for population nutrition.
The workforce comprises anyone whose primary
role relates to population nutrition and who is
employed full time, part time or casually by the
Department of Health or contracted by the
Department of Health to perform a population
nutrition-related role (including consultants or
funding of a position in another government or
nongovernment agency). The number of full time
equivalent persons in the workforce will be
reported in ‘FUND4
Excludes budget items related to physical activity
promotion.
INDICATOR (FUND) 2: Government funded research is Includes the clear identification of research
targeted for improving food environments, reducing priorities related to improving food environments,
obesity, NCDs and their related inequalities reducing obesity, NCDs and their related
inequalities in health or medical research strategies
or frameworks
Includes identifying research projects conducted or
commissioned by the government specifically
targeting food environments, prevention of obesity
or NCDs (excluding secondary or tertiary
prevention)
It is limited to research projects committed to or
conducted within the last 12 months
Excludes research grants administered by the
government (including statutory agencies) to a
research group where the allocation of a pool of
funding was determined by an independent review
panel
Excludes evaluation of interventions (this is
explored in ‘MONIT5’ and should be part of an
overall program budget)
INDICATOR (FUND) 3: There is a statutory health Agency was established through legislation
promotion agency in place that includes an objective to Includes objective to improve population nutrition
improve population nutrition with a secure funding stream in relevant legislation, strategic plans or on agency
website
Secure funding stream involves the use of a
hypothecated tax or other secure source
DOMAIN 12 - PLATFORMS AND INTERACTION: There are coordination platforms and opportunities for synergies across
government departments, levels of government, and other sectors (NGOs, private sector, and academia) such that
policies and actions in food and nutrition are coherent, efficient and effective in improving food environments,
population nutrition, diet-related NCDs and their related inequalities
Indicator definitions - please take these into account in the SCOPE (FOR INFORMATION ONLY)
rating process This colum provides the type evidence collected for this
indicator (as well as the evidence that will not be taken into
account).
INDICATOR (PLAT) 1: There are robust coordination Includes cross-government or cross-departmental
mechanisms across departments and levels of government governance structures, committees or working
(national, state and local) to ensure policy coherence, groups (at multiple levels of seniority), agreements,
alignment, and integration of food, obesity and diet- memoranda of understanding, etc
related NCD prevention policies across governments. Includes cross-government or cross-departmental
shared priorities, targets or objectives
Includes strategic plans or frameworks that map
the integration and alignment of multiple policies
or programs across governments and across
departments
Includes cross-government or cross-departmental
collaborative planning, implementation or
reporting processes, consultation processes for the
development of new policy or review of existing
policy
INDICATOR (PLAT) 2: There are formal platforms (with The commercial food sector includes food
clearly defined mandates, roles and structures) for regular production, food technology, manufacturing and
interactions between government and the commercial processing, marketing, distribution, retail and food
food sector on the implementation of healthy food policies service, etc. For the purpose of this indicator, this
and other related strategies. extends to commercial non-food sectors (e.g.
advertising and media, sports organisations,
land/housing developers, private childcare,
education and training institutes) that are
indirectly related to food
Includes established groups, forums or committees
active within the last 12 months for the purpose of
information sharing, collaboration, seeking advice
on healthy food policies
Includes platforms to support, manage or monitor
private sector pledges, commitment or agreements
Includes platforms for open consultation
Includes platforms for the government to provide
resources or expert support to the commercial
food sector to implement policy
Excludes joint partnerships on projects or co-
funding schemes
Excludes platforms to engage with industry in
relation to development of policies.
Excludes initiatives covered by ‘RETAIL3’ and
‘RETAIL4’
INDICATOR (PLAT) 3: There are formal platforms (with Civil society includes community groups and
clearly defined mandates, roles and structures) for regular consumer representatives, NGOs, academia,
interactions between government and civil society on the professional associations, etc.
development, implementation and evaluation of healthy Includes established groups, forums or committees
food policies and other related strategies. active within the last 12 months for the purpose of
information sharing, collaboration, seeking advice
Includes platforms for consultation on proposed
plans, policy or public inquiries
Excludes policies or procedures that guide
consultation in the development of food policy (see
‘GOVER3’)
INDICATOR (PLAT) 4: The governments work with a Systems-based approaches may include policies
system-based approach with (local and national) within other domains of health
organisations/partners/groups to improve the healthiness May include a social-determinants of health
of food environments at a national level. approach
May bring together multiple departments or
ministries to approach health
Includes multiple levels of government
Aim of a systems-based approach is:
o resourcing and supporting a dedicated,
reflective and skilled workforce at a state
and/or local level to engage, activate and
influence at multiple levels of the system
to combat obesity and chronic disease
o building relationships with prevention
partners across the system, and across
sectors and industries, to strengthen
positive health outcomes on multiple
fronts
o capturing and feeding back knowledge and
data on progress, impact and effectiveness
and calling for new types of research,
policy and practice collaborations
o allocating resources based on best possible
investment to effect change and
population need, seeding long term change
by resourcing local governments to lead
action towards public health
o building leadership for sustained
prevention across the system to drive
effective and long lasting change.
DOMAIN 13 - HEALTH IN ALL POLICIES - Processes are in place to ensure policy coherence and alignment, and that
population health impacts are explicitly considered in the development of government policies
Indicator definitions - please take these into account in the SCOPE (FOR INFORMATION ONLY)
rating process This colum provides the type evidence collected for this
indicator (as well as the evidence that will not be taken into
account).
INDICATOR (HIAP) 1: There are processes in place to ensure Includes policies, procedures, guidelines, tools and
that population nutrition, health outcomes and reducing other resources that guide the consideration and
health assessment of nutrition, health outcomes and
inequalities or health impacts in vulnerable populations reducing health inequalities or health impacts in
are considered and prioritised in the development of all vulnerable populations prior to, during and
government policies relating to food following implementation of food-related policies
Includes the establishment of cross-department
governance and coordination structures while
developing food-related policies
INDICATOR (HIAP) 2: There are processes e.g. Health Includes a government-wide HiAP strategy or plan
Impact Assessment’s (HIAs) to assess and consider health with clear actions for non-health sectors
impacts during the development of other non-food policies Includes policies, guidelines, tools and other
resources that guide the consideration and
assessment of health impacts prior to, during and
following implementation of non-food related
policies (e.g. HIAs or health lens analysis)
Includes the establishment of cross-department or
cross-sector governance and coordination
structures to implement a HiAP approach
Includes workforce training and other capacity
building activities in healthy public policy for non-
health departments (e.g. agriculture, education,
communications, trade)
Includes monitoring or reporting requirements
related to health impacts for non-health
departments
Definitions
• Food: refers to food and non-alcoholic beverages. It excludes breastmilk or breastmilk
substitutes.
• Food environments: the collective physical, economic, policy and socio-cultural surrounding,
opportunities and conditions that influence people’s food and beverage choices and
nutritional status.
• Government: includes any government departments and, where appropriate, other
agencies (i.e. statutory bodies such as offices, commissions, authorities, boards, councils,
etc). Plans, strategies or actions by local government should not be included, although
relevant information can be noted in the ‘context/comments’ sections.
• Government implementation: refers to the intentions and plans of the government and
actions and policies implemented by the government as well as government funding for
implementation of actions undertaken by non-governmental organisations, academic
institutions, private companies (including consultants), etc.
• Healthy/unhealthy food: Categorisation of foods as healthy / unhealthy are in accordance
with the WHO and EU guidelines). Where it is not clear which category to use, categorisation
of foods should be informed by rigorous criteria or the use of a nutrient profiling model.
• Nutrients of concern: salt (sodium), saturated fat, trans fat, added sugar
• Systems-based approaches: This may include policies within other domains of health, a
social-determinants of health approach, bringing together multiple departments or
ministries to approach health and includes multiple levels of government.
• Policy actions: A broad view of “policy” is taken so as to include all government policies,
plans, strategies and activities. Only current policy actions are considered, generally defined
as policy activity of the previous 12 months (except where otherwise specified). Evidence of
policy implementation takes consideration of the whole policy cycle, from agenda-setting,
through to policy development, implementation and monitoring. A broad view of relevant
evidence was taken, to include, inter alia:
Evidence of commitments from leadership to explore policy options
Allocation of responsibility to an individual/team (documented in a work
plan, appointment of new position)
Establishment of a steering committee, working group, expert panel, etc.
Review, audit or scoping study undertaken
Consultation processes undertaken
Evidence of a policy brief/proposal that has been put forward for
consideration
Preparation of a regulatory or economic impact assessment, health impact
assessment, etc.
Regulations / legislation / other published policy details
Monitoring data
Policy evaluation report