Audit report form v.5
AUDIT OF OPERATION REPORT
Central Baltic INTERREG V A Cross-border Co-operation Programme 2014 – 2020
AUDIT NUMBER: CB-26/2021
Date of final audit report 21.01.2022
Contradictory procedure 08.12.2021-21.12.2021 (first) 12.01.2022-19.01.2022 (second)
Accounting period 01/07/2020 – 30/06/2021
Progress report No 5.1 in the amount of 306 501.67€
Audit scope
Audited 100%
Andreas Kalm, Auditor of II Audit Unit Financial Control Department of Ministry of
Auditor(s)
Finance of Estonia Suur-Ameerika 1, 10129 Tallinn, Estonia;
Hiiu Municipality
Development Department
Audited organisation
Mr. Sven Kriggulson
& contact information
Phone: +372 5624 7818
Email:
[email protected]
Place of the audit Hiiu Development Department
Persons present during the audit Mr. Sven Kriggulson
Date of on-the-spot checks 12/11/2021
Full project name Contemporary harbours with soft energy technology
Project Number & Acronym CB616 – Smart Marina
Priority Axis 3. Well-connected Central Baltic region
SO 3.2 Improved services of existing small ports to improve local and regional
Specific Objective
mobility and contribute to tourism development
Reporting Period 01/02/2020 – 31/07/2020
Name of the Lead Partner Åland Development Center
Project duration
01/02/2018 – 30/04/2021
(start and end dates)
Based on the audit work performed we have obtained reasonable assurance that the
expenditure declared under the audited operation “CB616 – Smart Marina” within
priority axis 3 in the reference year 01/07/2020 – 30/06/2021 is, in all material
AUDIT aspects, legal and regular.
CONCLUSION The auditor made two minor findings without a financial impact regarding carrying
out public procurements and one minor finding regarding the on-the-spot checks of
the first level control. The summarized list of findings identified during the audit
is presented in the following table and report.
Page 1
Audit report form v.5
Number
Total Financial Total Financial
of Nature of the findings
Impact Impact ERDF
findings
The auditors identified issues with processing the extension for
No financial No financial
the contract by the project partner (Minor finding, without
1 impact impact
financial impact)
The auditors identified issues with setting and resolving the
No financial No financial
criteria for the public procurement by the project partner (Minor
2 impact impact
finding, without financial impact)
The auditors identified issues in carrying out on-the-spot checks
No financial No financial
by the first level controllers (Minor finding, without financial
3 impact impact
impact)
Page 2
Audit report form v.5
PART 1 – AUDIT SCOPE
According to Article 127 of Regulation (EU) No 1303/2013 the audit authority is responsible to carry out
audits of operations based on supporting documents constituting the audit trail and verify the legality and
regularity of expenditure declared to the Commission, including the following aspects:
a) that the operation was selected in accordance with the selection criteria for the Operational
Programme, was not physically completed or fully implemented before the beneficiary submitted
the application for funding under the Operational Programme, has been implemented in accordance
with the approval decision and fulfilled any conditions applicable at the time of the audit concerning
its functionality, use, and objectives to be attained.
b) that the expenditure declared to the Commission corresponds to the accounting records and that
the required supporting documentation demonstrates an adequate audit trail.
c) that for expenditure declared to the Commission determined in accordance with Articles 67(1)(b)
and (c) and 109 of Regulation (EU) No 1303/2013 and Article 14(1) of Regulation (EU) No 1304/2013,
outputs and results underpinning payments to the beneficiary have been delivered, participant data
or other records related to outputs and results are consistent with the information submitted to the
Commission and that the required supporting documentation demonstrates an adequate audit trail.
PART 1.1 – LIMITATION OF SCOPE
The conclusions of the audit are based on the analysis of the procedure in place, information and documents
gathered and interviews conducted in the audited bodies as well as the tests performed during the audit
following the checklist for the audit areas.
PART 1.2 – AUDIT METHODOLOGY
The audit is carried out in compliance with internationally accepted auditing standards and the audit
strategy, which is approved by the audit authority and group of auditors representing each Central Baltic
INTERREG VA Programme Member State.
The audit process comprises of three stages:
a) Preparation and planning of the audit
In this stage legal regulations and other documentation, including from the management verification
ex Regulation (EU) No 1299/2013, Article 23(4), needed for familiarising with the selected
operations were collected and analysed. Also, interviews or checklists which were needed for the
planning of the audit, familiarising with the functioning of the system, project file’s structure, the
objectives, and the status of implementation of the operations, the risk encountered during the
implementation as well as those inherent to the type of operations.
b) Fieldwork
At this stage a whole range of interviews with responsible staff were conducted, documents were
gathered, and testing was performed. To attain the audit objectives during the audit we tested all
applicable audit areas. We performed the audit using the checklists for the several audit areas which
enabled us to verify the requirements laid down in European and national legislation.
The assurance about the achievement of the project’s objectives was attained via documentation
uploaded to the programme’s information system (eMS), e-mail conversation with the project
partner, on-the-spot checks and photos of the project outputs.
Page 3
Audit report form v.5
c) Reporting
This stage encompassed activities related to the preparation of the Draft Report and the
contradictory procedure where auditee has been granted 10 working days to reflect on the audit
report, the inclusion of their replies and comments and the submission of the Final Report.
Provide the actual schedule of the contradictory procedure as following
Preliminary report (version 1): 08.12.2021
Preliminary report (version 2): 12.01.2022
Final report: 21.01.2022
PART 2 – FINANCIAL DATA OF OPERATION
Financial data of audited partner must be listed
PART 5.1 – BUDGET (EUR)
Audited Partners approved budget Granted in total for % Payments included %
the partner in the payment
claim
ERDF € 260 526.42 85% € 260 526.42 85%
Public funding (total) € 20 885.41 15% € 45 975.25 15%
Private funding € 25 089.84 € 25 089.84
Income € 0.00 0% € 0.00 0%
TOTAL PARTNER BUDGET € 306 501.67 100% € 306 501.67 100%
Audited expenditure (according to the Sample)1
Total amount audited Ineligible
Budget Line (combining milestones)
1. Staff costs € 22 700.46 € 0.00
2. Office and administration € 3 405.06 € 0.00
3. Travel and accommodation € 759.95 € 0.00
4. External expertise and services € 0.00 € 0.00
5. Equipment € 0.00 € 0.00
6. Infrastructure and works € 279 636.20 € 0.00
Total amount audited € 306 501.67 € 0.00
PART 3 – FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
PART 3.1 GENERAL
During the audit we identify and document audit findings. We categorise these findings by reference to the
level of importance. The categories which we use to classify our findings are as follows:
Findings which have a financial impact above EUR 250 (ERDF) or any other high-
Major
risk deficiencies.
1
Costs outside the sample were not audited
Page 4
Audit report form v.5
Findings for which action should be taken to ensure full compliance but have a
Minor limited financial impact (below EUR 250 (ERDF)), no financial consequences or
no high-risk character.
All audit findings are reported in the final audit report, even if the Member States participating in the
Programme may decide that neither the lead beneficiary nor the Programme's MA is obliged to recover an
amount unduly paid which does not exceed EUR 250, per operation and accounting year, not including
interest, in contribution from the Funds and the EMFF, as all the irregular amounts detected are to be taken
into account for the calculation of the annual Total Error Rate of the Programme.
PART 3.2 FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS PER BUDGET LINE
In this paragraph the findings and recommendations per audit area are included.
E. Procurement procedures
AUDIT FINDING NO 1 (NON-SIGNIFICANT2) –
The beneficiary has not extended the procurement contract duration correctly in a simplified
procurement No. 216731.
The Project partner Hiiu Municipality (the beneficiary) has carried out a simplified procurement with a
reference no 216731 “Construction of Orjaku harbour service house” electronically in the e-procurement
register (published on 17.12.2019). Construction contract was awarded on 18.02.2020. The beneficiary
submitted a notice to the register on the modification of the public contract on 08.10.2020, extending the
duration of the contract from 15.06.2020 to 30.11.2020. According to the explanation of the beneficiary,
they extended the procurement contract based on a verbal agreement on modification of the contract
was made beforehand, on 30.04.2020.
The beneficiary sent additional correspondence to the auditors, which would indicate the discussion
considering the possible extension of the contract took place in March 2020, but the auditors did not find
that this correspondence reflects a specific agreement to extend the contract, nor was there any discussion
of specific terms of extension.
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
In auditors’ opinion the beneficiary has not extended the contract duration correctly. Formalizing the
extension only after the original contract would have ended may have serious risks to the contract parties
themselves, regarding agreements or disagreements of specific details of the contract or its extension.
This may also pose serious risks to the eligibility of the amounts financed from the programme’s funds.
1) Recommendation to the auditee:
It is recommended to the beneficiary to always formalize any extensions to contracts as soon as possible
and always before the end of the original contract. It is also recommended to note that any oral
2
Significant findings are those that have or may have a financial impact (i.e., ineligible expenditure). Non-significant findings are those that have no
financial impact but whose correction will help the beneficiary to lower risks while implementing the project.
Page 5
Audit report form v.5
agreements between parties cannot be considered as evidence and that any discussions about such
agreements carried out via e-mail should be as detailed as possible to be considered evidence.
Auditee response:
Auditee agrees that all contract changes have to be formalized accordingly to current legalization.
Auditee emphasizes that its actions were only in the best interest of procuring entity to ensure the
procurement to be successful and to get the contractual works to be done accordingly to the procurement
documents and legalizations.
E. Procurement procedures
AUDIT FINDING NO 2 (NON-SIGNIFICANT3) – The beneficiary has not correctly set or fulfilled the criterion
in an open procurement No 215663.
The Project partner Hiiu Municipality (the beneficiary) has carried out an open procurement with a
reference no 215663 “Construction of Soela harbour service house” electronically in the e-procurement
register (published on 7.11.2019). Construction contract was awarded on 18.02.2020. According to the
original contract point 3.2, the deadline for final delivery of the object of the contract was 15.06.2020.
The contract notice part II point 1.4 stated the following:
- the transfer of the object to the contracting authority presupposes the existence of a partial
usage permit for the first floor of the utility block and for the boat storage room, which is
acquired by the builder.
However, Annex 1 of the technical specifications of the procurement document contains a list of works
excluded from the scope of the procurement. The document also stated that electrical work and related
obligations were excluded from the procurement.
A usage permit could not be applied for until the electrical work has been carried out properly. According
to the explanations of the beneficiary, the electrical work was carried out by NGO Soela Sadama Selts
(the co-financier of the beneficiary) itself and there were shortcomings in the execution of the electrical
work as well as in the time schedule. The usage permit was issued only on 20.07.2021.
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
In auditor’s opinion the criterion contained in the contract notice has not been set or fulfilled correctly.
The auditor points out that there was no valid reason for even using this criterion in the contract notice,
as the electrical works were not in the scope of the contract. Additionally, once the criterion had been set,
the co-financier should have taken all the precautions to fulfil this task correctly by the same time the
contract was set to be ended. Setting and fulfilling this kind of criterion incorrectly may pose serious risks
to the eligibility of the amounts financed from the programme’s funds.
1) Recommendation to the auditee:
3
Significant findings are those that have or may have a financial impact (i.e., ineligible expenditure). Non-significant findings are those that have
no financial impact but whose correction will help the beneficiary to lower risks while implementing the project.
Page 6
Audit report form v.5
It is recommended to the beneficiary to never set out criteria that are not part of the contract or fulfillable
by the contractor. If that kind of criterion is set, however, it is recommended to take all precautions to
fulfil it in time.
Auditee response:
Auditee understands the seriousness of the situation and although Auditee, acting as procuring entity,
tried to be thorough and precise in procurement details such misstatement in procurement documents
occurred due to re-writing and decreasing the procurement volume three times.
Throughout the contracted procurement both parties acknowledged this was a misstatement from behalf
of procuring entity and it was not reasonable to push contractor to fulfil criteria that was not possible to
achieve within the scope of this procurement.
A. Audit trail and supporting documents
AUDIT FINDING NO 3 (NON-SIGNIFICANT4) – Issues in carrying out on-the-spot checks by the first level
controllers.
According to the Central Baltic Programme manual point 3.9, the FLCs will carry out on-the-spot checks.
On-the-spot-check means that the controller visits the project and verifies that certain purchases of
services and products of the approved application have taken place during the project implementation.
The project “Smart Marina” involved investments in infrastructure. There were three investments within
the scope of the audit. Two of them were the construction of harbour service houses, first in Hiiumaa,
second in Saaremaa. And the third was the reconstruction of the concrete berth in Hiiumaa. The auditors
themselves carried out on-the-spot operations on both islands on 12.11.2021.
The on-the-spot checklist of the FLC was sent to the auditors by email and contained two on-the-spot
checks by date. First on-the-spot check took place on 07.05.2018 and the second on 07.05.2021. One
checklist has been prepared including both the two on-the-spot checks. According to the checklist, the
date of final completion of the checklist was 07.05.2018, which is indicating that the dates on the checklist
are mixed. According to the explanation of the FLC contact person, photos made on on-the-spot operations
were included in the last period of the eMS. The photos in the eMS system mostly contained small
investments made in the project and EU logos on them. There were no photos of infrastructure
investments. In communicating with the first level control, the auditors learned that the person who
carried out on-the-spot operations was no longer working at State Shared Service Centre5.
The auditors found the following inconsistencies in relation to the on-the-spot checks made by FLC:
The on-the-spot checklist was not added to the eMS system. The auditors received a checklist upon request
by email. The checklist itself contained two on-the-spot checks by date, but it was not possible to
determine exactly what was checked and when. According to the checklist, the first on-the-spot check took
place on 07.05.2018 and the second on 07.05.2021. The date of final completion of the checklist is marked
as 07.05.2018, although on-the-spot operations have been carried out according to the same checklist on
07.05.2021. Thus, there is also a contradiction in the dates.
The auditors found out that no photos of infrastructure investments were included in the eMS system or
with the checklist. Photos were then requested by the auditors by email. First, FLC sent the auditors photos
4 Significant findings are those that have or may have a financial impact (i.e., ineligible expenditure). Non-significant findings are those that have no
financial impact but whose correction will help the beneficiary to lower risks while implementing the project.
5 State Shared Service Centre- Riigi Tugiteenuste keskus, public authority to which organization the FLC belongs
Page 7
Audit report form v.5
of the infrastructure objects in Hiiumaa. Comparing the photos obtained with those taken during the
auditor's own on-the-spot operations on 12.11.2021, it can be said that the photos provided by the FLC
were obviously taken later and not during either of the original on-the-spot checks done by the FLC. The
auditors reached the same conclusion with the photos of the harbour in Saaremaa.
Also asking for photos of the on-site operations on the investments made in Saaremaa, after a while the
auditors received a request from a local board member of the Soela harbour. The inquiry asked if it would
be possible to forward the auditor's own photos taken on 12.11.2021, as State Shared Service Centre
officials would like to see them. This also implies that the FLC had no infrastructure photos of their own
on-the-spot checks, but they did not wish to state that.
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS:
In view of the above, the auditors have doubts as to whether the FLC's on-site operations were properly
carried out. The on-the-spot checklist has not been properly filled out for either of the dates specified
and there are no pictures of the infrastructure objects added.
Recommendation to the First Level Control
It is recommended to internally perform quality checks on the completed documentation of on-the-spot
inspections from time to time to ensure their uniform quality. It is also recommended to confirm clearly
so if some documentation is found missing.
First Level Control response:
It is agreed that FLC does not have to add separate on-the-spot checklists to the eMS. If necessary and
asked, we send the on-the-spot checklist to the JS/MA.
As explained via e-mail on November 18th, there has been one on-the-spot check in this project – that
took place on May 7th, 2021. Unfortunately, an old version of checklist was used and therefore there is
an old date left on the filled form.
To save time and resources, the on-the-spot procedure was asked to carry out by a project-coordinator
(same department, different division) who lives and works in Hiiumaa – as probably part of a
communication error and lack of this kind of experience, the photos that were taken during the on-the-
spot check on May 7th did not meet the program requirements. The photos were taken of the purchased
items and infrastructure, but not all items were photographed under the angle, that also showed the
notification of the program. After finding that out during the audit procedure, FLC asked the Project
Partner to send additional photos. FLC considers that the possibility of correcting such errors is reasonable
and does not change the content of the costs incurred by the partner. There was no doubt, that the works
and purchases related to the project had been completed and support was used for its intended purpose.
PART 4 - FOLLOW-UP
This audit report is compiled for use of the Audit Authority of the Central Baltic INTERREG VA 2014-2020
Programme and will be used to draw conclusions about the functioning of the Management and Control
Systems of the above-mentioned Programme. Information in the report will be disclosed to relevant parties
involved of management of the EU funds, including Commission services.
Parties responsible of audit finding follow-up:
1. Findings with Financial impact – The Audit Authority (AA) will inform the Managing Authority (MA)
to take necessary actions to correct shortcomings in the system.
a. Deductions will be made by the MA.
Page 8
Audit report form v.5
b. Confirmation of deductions will be made by the AA.
c. If needed follow-up audit will be done by Group of Auditor (GoA) members.
2. Findings without the Financial impact
a. The MA will be informed, and evaluation will be done if further actions are needed.
b. Confirmation of actions will be followed-up by the AA and if needed by the GoA members.
Upon request from the MA the Auditee is responsible to implement the recommendations and deliver the
proof to the MA.
Audit Manager: Andreas Kalm
Signed electronically
Audit Supervisor: Mart Pechter
Signed electronically
Page 9
Hr Hergo Tasuja
Hiiumaa Vallavalitsus Meie 21.01.2022 nr 10-5/924-1
[email protected]
Projektiauditi lõpparuande
edastamine
Austatud härra vallavanem
Edastame Teile Kesk-Läänemere INTERREG V-A programmi projekti nr CB616 „Smart
Marina“ projektiauditi lõpparuande nr CB-26/2021.
Täname Teid meeldiva koostöö ja osutatud abi eest.
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Kaur Siruli
osakonnajuhataja
Lisa: Auditi lõpparuanne üheksal (9) leheküljel
Sama:
Pr Imbi Uusjärv, Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus (
[email protected])
Pr Merike Niitepöld, Managing Authority / The Regional Council of Southwest Finland
(
[email protected])
Mart Pechter 611 3152
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 611 3558 /
[email protected] / www.rahandusministeerium.ee
registrikood 70000272