Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
Survey of policy responses to new forms of work: questionnaire
What is the objective of this survey? With your help, we want to capture the most up-to-date evidence on
recent and emerging policy responses to new forms of work across EU and OECD member countries. We will
use this evidence to draw out trends, good practice, and case studies of practical relevance for policymakers, in
an international conference in Paris on 7th Nov 2018 and a subsequent report (to be shared with respondents in
early 2019). This presents a major opportunity for policymakers to access information on what other countries
are doing to address emerging – and often, shared – challenges associated with new forms of work.
What do we mean by new forms of work? Many countries have seen recent growth in technology-facilitated
forms of work, such as crowd work and on-demand work via apps and platforms; but there has also been growth
in other new forms of work, like casual work (on-call, voucher-based and zero-hour contracts, as well as
mini/flexi-jobs). While the use of these contracts may bring advantages, including flexibility for both employers
and employees, concerns are being voiced around job quality and the potential negative impact of excessive
and/or improper use (in cases where workers are misclassified) of such contracts on equality, productivity and
growth, and the fairness of competition among firms. Several countries have also seen growth in dependent and
false self-employment1, which raise similar concerns.
What do we mean by policy responses? We aim to capture recent and emerging public policy across:
employment regulation (e.g. how should these workers be classified?), social protection (e.g. how do we ensure
adequate coverage?), working conditions (e.g. how do we ensure fair and safe working conditions?), collective
bargaining (e.g. how can workers in these new forms of work be given collective voice?) and skills (e.g. how to
promote lifelong learning among those in new forms of work?). While the focus of this survey is on policies
developed in response to the emergence of new forms of work, we also encourage you to note policies that,
although not specifically targeted towards those in new forms of work, are likely to have a significant impact
on these workers.
How should you answer this questionnaire? Please use the spaces provided to describe each
policy/intervention, its underlying objectives and its effectiveness (if evidence exists), as well as the type of
contract it applies to. If you wish to refer to legislation (or revisions to such), please cite the number/identifier
and the year in which it was passed (or revised). For any additional information, we encourage you to share
contact details of the individual most familiar with the policy, to link to external sources of information and/or
to attach documents to your email.
Who should answer this questionnaire? We have sent this questionnaire to Ministries of Labour, and in some
cases, to specialised teams with responsibility for the future of work. For certain questions, it may be necessary
to coordinate responses within the Ministry or with another government department at the national or sub-
national level. In these cases, we encourage you to share this questionnaire more widely. We can offer assistance
in compiling the responses.
As the success of this project will depend on the information you provide, we would like to express in advance
our gratitude for your cooperation and the time taken to complete this questionnaire.
Please return the questionnaire to
[email protected] by Friday 29th June 2018. For any queries or help
completing the questionnaire, please contact Marguerita by email or by telephone (+331.85.55.47.89).
Background questions
1
In the case of (economically) dependent self-employed, the individual will be genuinely self-employed but dependent for
the majority of their income on one single client. In order for the relationship to be considered false (or bogus) self-
employment, there needs to be a deliberate attempt at hiding a genuine employment relationship in order to avoid labour
regulations and/or tax obligations (either on the part of the employer, the worker, or both).
PAGE 1 OF 8
i. While many countries have experienced recent growth in the forms of employment underlined in the text
above, the exact contract types, trends and challenges vary across countries. Please use the space below to
describe what forms of employment are being discussed in the policy arena in your country.
Click here to enter text.
ii. Thinking again about discussions within the policy arena, what topics/issues related to new forms of work
would you say capture the most attention (i.e. in government, the legislature, the media)? This might include
both opportunities and challenges (e.g. classification, social protection, tax) associated with new forms of
work.
iii. If there is no (or negligible) discussion within the policy arena in your country about new forms of work,
please give your own opinion on why this might be.
1. Addressing worker classification
New forms of work have often developed at the fringes of existing labour market regulation and many countries
are struggling with how such workers should be classified: are they employees, are they self-employed, or do
they lie somewhere in between? Is existing labour market regulation still fit for purpose?
Please describe any recent or forthcoming public policy developed in your country with the aim of addressing
worker classification issues, such as:
a. Clarifying/revising/updating definitions of employment relationships, e.g. what it means to be an employee,
self-employed, or even an employer (e.g. in tripartite employment relationships, cases involving an
intermediary); harmonising definitions across legal/policy areas (e.g. labour, tax, social protection)…
b. Creating new employment categories. Several countries have a worker category in between “employee”
and “self-employed” which gives access to some, though not all, rights and protections enjoyed by
employees, e.g. “workers” in the United Kingdom, TRADE in Spain, CoCoCo and CoCoPro in Italy.
Does such a category exist in your country already or is there talk of introducing one? If so, for what
purpose (for labour law, tax law, social protection, ensuring collective bargaining rights etc.)?
c. Helping firms and workers identify employment relationships, e.g. by providing better guidance and
information on contractual status, online tools/tests…
d. Making it easier for workers to challenge their employment status, e.g. the presumption of an employment
relationship and placing the burden of proof on the employer (rather than the employee), reducing court
fees, reducing risks to workers, protecting workers against retaliation…
e. Strengthening penalties to encourage compliance, e.g. greater penalties if firms continue to breach the law
in repeated, comparable cases; retroactive payment of taxes and social security contributions; blanket
application of tribunal judgements to an entire workforce…
f. Strengthening the labour inspectorate’s capacity to monitor and detect breaches, e.g. increased
responsibilities and resources, innovative methods to inspect those working from home/on platforms…
g. Any other policies with the aim of tackling misclassification of workers
PAGE 2 OF 8
2. Addressing incentives to use new forms of work
In some countries, tax and/or employment regulation have created incentives for employers and/or individuals
to replace standard forms of employment with non-standard ones (e.g. large differences in tax burdens between
employees and the self-employed, incentivising misclassification and false self-employment). Some countries
have attempted to address these incentives.
Please describe any recent or forthcoming public policy developed in your country with this aim, such as:
a. Reducing discrepancies between different forms of employment in terms of pay, tax, social protection,
working conditions…
b. Introducing measures to encourage hiring on standard contracts by making them more attractive relative
to non-standard contracts, e.g. easing of obligations associated with standard contracts for employers,
making non-standard contracts more costly for employers (e.g. higher social security contributions)…
c. Any other policies with the aim of addressing incentives to use new forms of work
3. Regulating the use of new forms of work
One potential policy response to new forms of work is to attempt to regulate their use which could restrict or
even prohibit their use. For example, most countries have regulated the use of temporary contracts, agency work
and zero-hour contracts. Some platforms are permitted to operate in some countries, but not in others.
Please describe any recent or forthcoming public policy developed in your country with this aim, such as:
a. Regulating the operation of platforms (including limiting or prohibiting their operation)
b. Regulating the use of non-standard employment contracts, e.g. restricting the total period or the number of
renewals; prohibiting their use for permanent needs or core activities of the firm…
c. Regulating the use of clauses in employment contracts, e.g. arbitration agreements under which workers
may waive rights to litigation, exclusivity clauses…
d. Any other policies with the aim of regulating the use of new forms of work
4. Improving working conditions
Concerns have been raised in some countries about working conditions in new forms of work. Please describe
any recent or forthcoming public policy developed in your country with the aim of ensuring fair and safe
working conditions for those in new forms of work, such as:
a. Ensuring workers are aware of their rights, responsibilities, working conditions and employer liability, e.g.
public information campaigns, requiring firms to provide written confirmation of worker status,
clarification in tripartite employment relationships…
b. Addressing working time and promoting predictability/stability in work schedules, e.g. guaranteed
minimum working hours; enabling workers to plan ahead and take time off when needed; ensuring
schedules are clear ahead of time and do not change with minimal notice; measures to improve work-life
balance…
PAGE 3 OF 8
c. Encouraging fair pay, e.g. extension of minimum wage legislation to non-standard forms of employment
(e.g. independent/own-account workers), ensuring equal pay for non-standard workers who do substantially
the same work as standard workers for the same company, price regulation, requiring higher pay for non-
standard workers to cover lower levels of social protection, compensating workers for hours in which they
make themselves available for work…
d. Addressing occupational safety and health (OSH), e.g. ensuring that firms inform non-standard workers of
hazards and safety procedures, measures to guarantee the same safe and healthy working conditions for
non-standard workers as for standard workers, making platforms responsible for workers’ OSH…
e. Protecting non-standard workers from discrimination, e.g. by buyers of the goods/services, by
platforms/employers, within algorithms…
f. Requiring platforms/employers to cover employer liability, e.g. in case of workplace accident …
g. Strengthening the labour inspectorate’s capacity to monitor working conditions and ensure compliance in
new forms of work, e.g. increased responsibilities and resources, innovative methods to inspect those
working from home/on platforms…
h. Making it easier for workers to take legal action over working conditions, e.g. reducing court costs,
protecting workers against retaliation; greater penalties if firms continue to breach the law in repeated,
comparable cases; permitting class-action lawsuits…
i. Any other policies with the aim of improving working conditions
5. Strengthening social protection2
Social protection systems have often been designed with full-time, permanent, dependent employees in mind,
leaving other workers at a potential disadvantage – either because they are formally excluded from a
scheme/programme (statutory access) or because they have difficulties in meeting eligibility criteria or
contribution thresholds (effective access). Some countries have taken steps to update and revise their social
protection system in order to ensure adequate social protection for those in new forms of work.
Please describe any recent or forthcoming public policy developed in your country with this aim, such as:
a. Extending statutory access to existing social protection schemes/programmes for those in new forms of
work
b. Improving effective access to social protection schemes/programmes, e.g. by adjusting rules and thresholds
of existing schemes/programmes (e.g. earnings/hours/minimum contribution thresholds) so that eligibility
conditions are more easily met; changing how self-employment earnings are assessed, subsidising
contributions of non-standard workers…
2
Social protection may include benefits such as healthcare and sickness benefits, maternity/paternity benefits, old age and
survivor’s pensions, unemployment benefits and social assistance, long-term care benefits, invalidity, accidents at work
and occupational injury benefits, family benefits etc.
PAGE 4 OF 8
c. Creating specially designed schemes/programmes to address particular characteristics/challenges of new
forms of work (and potentially certain occupations/industries, e.g. similar to the social protection scheme
for artists in Germany).
d. Decoupling social protection from contributions and/or employment status and increasing reliance on tax-
financed/universal benefits (e.g. state pensions, social assistance, universal health care, basic income)
e. Enhancing the portability of benefits so that entitlements are not lost when individuals move jobs, e.g. by
linking them to individuals rather than to the employer/job, creation of a digital worker identity…
f. Simplifying administrative procedures for registering and/or contributing, e.g. by improving information
provision, removing administrative burdens, assigning responsibility for social protection to one
administrative body…
g. Improving the monitoring of work activity for assessing entitlement of platform workers and other non-
standard workers to unemployment benefits
h. Any other policies with the aim of ensuring adequate social protection
6. Strengthening workers’ voice
Those in new forms of work may face specific barriers to collective representation, resulting in an asymmetry
in bargaining power between workers and employers with potential negative consequences for job quality.
Competition law may prohibit self-employed contractors from unionising and negotiating collectively. In the
platform economy, workers on the same platform might not necessarily have any contact with one another if
they are working alone and separated by different geographies, or even languages and legal contexts.
Please describe any recent or forthcoming public policy developed in your country with the aim of strengthening
workers’ voice in new forms of work, such as:
a. Ensuring the right to freedom of association
b. Extending existing collective bargaining agreements (or signing new ones) to cover workers in new forms
of work (e.g. platform workers)
c. Allowing independent/own-account workers to bargain collectively without violating competition/anti-trust
law, e.g. revising the law, adding statutory exemptions to the law…
d. Promoting alternative arrangements for worker representation and discourse, e.g. supporting the setting
up of worker centres or professional associations specific to new forms of work, promoting online models
of worker voice (e.g. information-sharing forums/tools, platforms that enable workers to review employers),
models for worker-employer relations (e.g. conferences, roundtables, workplace councils)…
e. Any other policies with the aim of strengthening workers’ voice
PAGE 5 OF 8
7. Public Employment Services (PES) responses to new forms of work
New forms of employment offer opportunities for PES (e.g. new opportunities for job placement) but also bring
new challenges (how to ensure sustainable job outcomes, reach out to employers, adjust training, etc.).
Please describe any recent or forthcoming public policy developed in your country linking PES and new forms
of work, such as:
a. Using new forms of work to tackle unemployment or for worker activation more generally, e.g. considering
it “gainful employment”
b. Providing/adjusting guidance, training and support for those considering platform work or other new forms
of work
c. Engaging with employers, including collecting information on what jobs/vacancies exist in new forms of
work, understanding their needs, providing services to employers…
d. Targeting PES services to those in new forms of work, i.e. helping them to attain more sustainable
employment
e. Any other policies linking PES and new forms of work
8. Investing in skills
Workers in non-standard forms of employment tend to participate less in lifelong learning. Employers may see
less reason to invest in training for those in new forms of work – particularly where working relationships are
short-lived, or if individuals work for several employers at once. At the same time, workers may have less access
to public subsidies for lifelong learning if they have been designed for standard, full-time employees on open-
ended contracts. New forms of work may therefore require new approaches to lifelong learning.
Please describe any recent or forthcoming public policy developed in your country with the aim of developing
and recognising the skills of those in new forms of work, such as:
a. Designing skills policies and programmes targeted specifically at those in new forms of work, e.g. vouchers,
tax incentives, subsidies, loans, provision of training, guidance…
b. Adapting existing policies or programmes to make lifelong learning more accessible/attractive to those in
new forms of work, e.g. subsidies, vouchers, tax incentives, loans or privileged access for those on non-
standard contracts; facilitating shorter/different pathways to training (e.g. blended learning, distance
provision, Massive Open Online Courses (MOOCs), Stackable/Modular and Micro-Credentials); adjusting
the content of training…
c. Changing how training in new forms of work is financed, e.g. by an employer levy, by tax, by the individual…
d. Enhancing the portability of training rights by linking training to the individual rather than to the
employer/job, e.g. individual learning accounts…
PAGE 6 OF 8
e. Facilitating the recognition of skills, e.g. offering validation of acquired experience to non-standard
workers; enabling platform workers to share approval ratings with third parties and/or promoting the
portability of such ratings from one platform to another…
f. Any other policies with the aim of developing and recognising skills
9. Improving data collection
Existing data sources like household surveys and tax records may not allow the identification of individuals
working in new forms of work. This lack of information about the prevalence of new forms of work and the
characteristics of the individuals engaged in them hinders the development of an adequate policy response.
Please describe any recent or forthcoming public policy developed in your country with the aim of improving
data collection on those in new forms of work, such as:
a. Updating/augmenting existing data sources, like adding new questions and/or changing definitions in
national statistics, household surveys, etc.
b. Better use of existing data, including tax and social security data, linking of administrative data with survey
data, etc.
c. Accessing/using private data sources, like platform/employer data
d. Developing new data collection exercises like ad hoc surveys of non-standard workers
e. Any other policies with the aim of improving data collection
10. Improving coordination
Addressing the challenges associated with new forms of work often requires coordinated policy intervention
across different areas. In some countries, there have been efforts to bring different parties together to discuss
the potential issues and opportunities, and the best policy response.
Please describe any efforts in your country to encourage coordination between government, social partners,
industry and workers on new forms of work, e.g. setting up of dedicated working groups, forums, participating
in international activities…
11. Other
Please use this space to describe any other recent or forthcoming public policy developed in your country
related to new forms of work, or to leave any other comment you deem relevant for this project.
Thank you for taking the time to reply to this questionnaire.
PAGE 7 OF 8
Please provide your own contact details (and the contact details of any others that have contributed to filling
this questionnaire) in case we have any queries concerning the information provided.
Name: Name:
Organisation: Organisation:
Job title: Job title:
Telephone number: Telephone number:
Email address: Email address:
Name: Name:
Organisation: Organisation:
Job title: Job title:
Telephone number: Telephone number:
Email address: Email address:
Please return the questionnaire to
[email protected] by Friday 29th June 2018.
PAGE 8 OF 8