-----Original Message-----
From: EC ARES NOREPLY <
[email protected]>
Sent: esmaspäev, 28. mai 2018 11:23
To: KOSKARU-NELK Kaie (Rahandusministeerium = Ministry of Finance) <
[email protected]>
Cc: VIIKMAA Karin (Rahandusministeerium = Ministry of Finance) <
[email protected]>; SIRULI
Kaur (Rahandusministeerium = Ministry of Finance) <
[email protected]>; Esindus EL juures
üldaadress <
[email protected]>
Subject: Ares(2018)2724436 - Warning letter - Programme for the Support of the Most Deprived
Persons Fund 2014-2020" – 2014EE05FMOP001 - 2nd level Intermediate Body “Foundation Innove”.
Veuillez trouver ci-joint le document Ares(2018)2724436 concernant "Warning letter - Programme
for the Support of the Most Deprived Persons Fund 2014-2020" – 2014EE05FMOP001 - 2nd level
Intermediate Body “Foundation Innove”." envoyé par M/Mme GUIN Muriel le 25/05/2018.
Please find attached document Ares(2018)2724436 regarding "Warning letter - Programme for the
Support of the Most Deprived Persons Fund 2014-2020" – 2014EE05FMOP001 - 2nd level
Intermediate Body “Foundation Innove”." sent by Mr/Ms GUIN Muriel on 25/05/2018.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Note: This e-mail was automatically generated by the European Commission's central mail
registration system.
Replies by e-mail must be addressed to the original sender GUIN Muriel
(mailto:
[email protected]).
Remarque : Cet e-mail a été généré automatiquement par le système d'enregistrement central du
courrier de la Commission européenne.
Toute réponse éventuelle par e-mail doit être adressée à l'expéditeur en personne, à savoir GUIN
Muriel (mailto:
[email protected]).
Ref. Ares(2018)2724436 - 25/05/2018
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion DG
Directorate C: Social Affairs
C5 unit: Finland, Latvia, Estonia, Lithuania
Brussels,
EMPL / (2018)
Subject: Programme for the Support of the Most Deprived Persons Fund
2014-2020" – 2014EE05FMOP001
2nd level Intermediate Body “Foundation Innove”.
Warning letter
Ref.: Annual Control Report submitted by the Estonian Audit Authority
on 21 February 2018 through SFC2014 (our ref. Ares(2018)984465 of
21/02/2018)
Dear Mrs Koskaru-Nelk,
I refer to the annual control report for the accounting year from 1 July 2016 to 30 June
2017, dated 21 February 2018, submitted pursuant to Article 48(c) of Regulation (EC)
No 223/2014 (hereinafter the "2017 ACR" for the above mentioned programme).
I am writing to inform you that the analysis of this information reveals clear evidence to
suggest a significant deficiency in the functioning of the management and control system
(hereafter "the system") of the programme in question, namely for the projects regarding
“the purchase and transport of food” and “the distribution of the food by the partnership
organisation to the target group”, both managed by the 2nd level Intermediate Body
“Foundation Innove”, for which corrective measures need to be taken.
These deficiencies are linked to the “adequate management verifications" of the
management and control system implemented by the 2nd level Intermediate Body. The
deficiencies are detailed below and generally relate to compliance with Articles 28(c),(h),
32(4) (a), (5) and (6) of Regulation (EU) No 223/2014.
In the 2017 ACR, the audit authority reported the results of the audits of operations,
showing that the implementation of the projects "Food procurement and transport to the
storage facility" and "Finding partner organizations and distributing food aid to the target
group" was not in full compliance with the legislation in force. The public procurement
procedure concluded in February 2015 for these projects in the 2015-2017 period
Mrs Kaie Koskaru-Nelk
Deputy Secretary-General for Fiscal Policy
Ministry of Finance
Suur-Ameerika 1
Tallinn 10122, Estonia
European Commission B-1049 Brussels – Belgium / Europese Commissie, B-1049 Brussel -Belgie - Tel.(+32-2) 299.11.11
Tel. direct line (+32- 2) 229 - 60013 - Office: J-27 02/219. E-mail:
[email protected]
contained restrictive and discriminatory selection criteria in the contract notice, thus
creating an unfair competitive situation for foreign tenderers in comparison with
tenderers established in the country. The audit authority assessed the impact of this
finding at 10% of the expenditure related to this procurement procedure. In the 2017
ACR, the audit authority also stated that the new public procurement procedure organised
in the fall of 2017 for the implementation of these projects in 2018-2020 would contain
similar restrictive and discriminatory selection criteria. These shortcomings in the public
procurement procedure have not been detected during the management verifications
performed by the 2nd level Intermediate Body, showing that the management and control
system for key requirement n° 4 could be affected by serious weaknesses regarding the
verification of public procurement procedures.
In the accounts submitted on 21 February 2018, due to the audit authority’s findings, a
10% flat rate correction has been applied on the expenditure declared in the 2016/2017
accounting year in relation to the above mentioned procurement procedure, in the amount
of 222.686,00 EUR. No corrections have been applied however on the related
expenditure declared in accounting year 2015/2016, nor on the expenditure declared in
the current accounting year 2017/2018.
In view of the above, the management and control system of the programme in question
cannot be considered effective in fulfilling the regulatory requirements concerning the
adequacy of the management verifications carried out under management and control
system implemented by the intermediate body.
In this context, the Estonian authorities are invited to report on the implementation of the
following preventive and corrective measures to improve the functioning of the
management and control system of the 2nd level Intermediate Body for the future and of
the necessary financial corrections for the established systems deficiencies and
irregularities for the past.
1. The functioning of the management and control system should be improved, notably
with regard to the above-mentioned requirement of adequate management verifications,
in order that the identified deficiencies cease to exist;
2. if necessary, the appropriate financial corrections1 should be made for the expenditure
already declared to the Commission;
3. the audit authority should review the adequacy of the preventive and corrective
measures taken and report to the Commission.
The national authorities may take other measures if these have an equivalent remedial
and preventive effect.
The measures to improve the functioning of the management and control system for the
future must be such as to prevent the recurrence of the identified deficiencies and may be
subject to verification by the Commission services.
The Estonian authorities are also requested to provide confirmation, with regard to future
applications for payment under the programme in question, that the expenditure declared:
(i) results from a management and control system that is free from the deficiencies
identified and complies with the requirements of all applicable rules; (ii) the potentially
affected expenditure is not declared.
1
The financial correction to offset the financial risk linked to the deficiencies of the management and
control systems in the past may take the form of a flat-rate or extrapolated correction.
2
Due to these deficiencies I herewith warn you that the Commission may interrupt the
deadline for any future interim payments containing expenditure for the two projects
under the programme in question, including the payment of the balance following the
annual clearance of accounts, until the issues referred to above are resolved and the
Commission has sufficient assurance on the legality and regularity of the expenditure for
the programme in question.
The Commission will end the warning as soon as we have established, on the basis of the
elements provided by the Estonian authorities, that the necessary preventive and
corrective measures to remedy the situation have been taken by the national authorities.
Furthermore, pursuant to Article 50(8) of Regulation (EU) No 223/2014 , if the irregular
expenditure is not corrected at the time of the submission of the assurance package for
the programme in question or if the affected expenditure is not excluded from the
accounts while the assessment of the legality and regularity of that expenditure is
ongoing, the audit authority may not be in a position to issue an unqualified opinion on
the accounts and therefore the Commission may not be in a position to accept the
accounts, and in which case it will notify you the reasons and the actions which are
required to be undertaken.
Yours faithfully
Muriel Guin
Head of Unit
c.c.: Ms Kaja Tael
Ambassador
Permanent Representation of Estonia to the European Union
Rue Guimard 11/13
Brussels 1040, Belgium
Mr Kaur Siruli
Head of the Financial Control Department
Ministry of Finance
Suur-Ameerika 1
Tallinn 10122, Estonia
Ms Karin Viikmaa
Head of the European Union Payments Department
Ministry of Finance
Suur-Ameerika 1
Tallinn 10122, Estonia
Mr J. Korte, DG Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion,
Director-General
Mr F. Merchan Cantos, DG Employment, Social Affairs and
Inclusion, Directorate G
3
Mr S. de Keersmaecker, DG Employment, Social Affairs and
Inclusion, G.1
Mr M. Schelfhout, DG Employment, Social Affairs and
Inclusion, G.2
Ms M. Geleng, DG Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion,
acting Directorate C
Ms A. Martinez Sarasola, DG Regional and Urban Policy, D.5
4
Electronically signed on 25/05/2018 18:01 (UTC+02) in accordance with article 4.2 (Validity of electronic documents) of Commission Decision 2004/563
Tere
Edastan Euroopa Komisjoni kirja.
Reg. number: 10.2-12.F/928
Reg. kuupäev: 28.05.2018
Sisu: Programme for the Support of the Most Deprived Persons Fund 2014-2020" –
2014EE05FMOP001
2nd level Intermediate Body “Foundation Innove”.
Warning letter
Heade soovidega
Tiiu Noobel
sekretär EV AEEL juures