Task Force 4: Managing change and digital transformation in health care
The mandate for Task Force 4 of the Digital Health Society is focused on digital
transformation, and managing change by health and social-care organizations. Change can
be full of unknowns when attempted, and the task force’s leader, Richard Corbridge, said
many people are afraid of the high cost of digital implementation in health care because of
two main challenges.
“First, digital is still a ‘nice to have’, but the case for change has not yet been made well
enough in health, whereas it has been well demonstrated in every other ‘business’ in the
world,” said Corbridge, who has been both the Chief Information Officer for the Health
Service Executive in Ireland and Chief Executive Officer for eHealth Ireland since 2014.
“Secondly, in times of doing more for less, digital has not been seen as a place to invest to
save – it needs to be! We need to create a place to share stories, to share failings and
successes and to try to reassure funding decision makers and policy makers that digital
health done right is the answer to an increasingly unaffordable health-care system.
“An aging population, a population with increased comorbidities – which are one or more
additional diseases or disorders that co-occur with a primary issue – and the increase in rare
disease definitions; that means without digital health-care systems, we will not be able to
cope. Delivery models will fail,” he said.
Corbridge, who has more than 20 years of experience in the health and clinical research
information sectors, and has focused on the issues of health-care strategy and technology,
said there are plenty of success stories that are providing some glimpses of what the future
of digitally transformed health care might look like.
“The successes that have been the most exciting have been the projects that are creating
foundations to build on for the future,” he said. “For example, a genomic sequencing
project for epilepsy treatment in Ireland, the Great North Care Record in Newcastle in the
U.K., open standards-based solutions for patient portals in Leeds in the U.K., Cloud First at
the Royal Brompton Hospital in London, the use of Skype for clinical connectivity in the Mid
Cheshire hospitals – all of them stand out for me.
“Perhaps the most exciting change, though, is one that has grown and evolved the most
over the last five years is clinical engagement – the role of the Chief Clinical Information
Officer role in what we do in health care with technology is at last placing what we can do
for clinicians in the hands of the clinicians.”
Corbridge said there are three main reasons that barriers, or areas of resistance to change,
have slowed progress towards digital transformation.
“The bottlenecks have been caused first by fear – a clinical fear that digital will be invasive
to the way they deliver care to patients. Second, policy decisions and the flip-flop nature of
political intervention in digital health.
“Third, the marketplace itself for digital health has been built around a number of ‘mega
vendors’, which up until recently have stifled innovation and new ways of working. Digital
transformation has spent as much as two decades finding ways around these bottlenecks
and only now has started to come together across Europe to consider common solutions to
these issues.”
The task force’s work is evolving, and Corbridge said he believes the framework, content,
and toolkit of models and instruments that have already been developed and published so
far provides a foundation to build the next level of achievements in the digital
transformation of health care. Its goal, he said, is to continue to take feedback and grow
what has been developed.
“We want the toolkit to be a ‘crowd sourced’ solution that anyone can add to,” Corbridge
said.
“Anyone who is interested in our work can get in touch via the Digital Health Society
website [LINK1]. Anyone implementing a digital change can use and improve upon the
toolkit that is there, and that is how we would like the task force to grow.”
Task Force 4
Objectives
This Task Force is focused on the adaptation of health and social care organizations to
digitization, especially new practices such as telemedicine, mobility, data collection, decision
support, patient-health literacy and knowledge.
To achieve digital transformation, a number of steps have to be taken by health and social-
care services managers and teams. These include (but are not limited to) re-designing
organizations and workflows, investing in new technologies and tools, communicating
internally and externally about these changes, training the workforce, and monitoring and
assessing the impact. Change is also required in patients’ expectations as the consumers of
these health services.
Task Force 4 is focused on what needs to be done to achieve a digital transformation, as
well as developing a toolkit of models and instruments that can be used at a country/region
level, or at a health and social-care provider level to manage the changes.
1
https://echalliance.com/?page=digitalhealthsociety
The Digital Health Society: Working to transform health care through digital technologies
The Digital Health Society is an international coalition founded by the Ministry of Social
Affairs of Estonia [LINK]1 and the European Connected Health Alliance (ECHAlliance [LINK]2)
in 2017, focused on the digital transformation of health-care systems.
Digital technologies, and the ability to share and process data across different systems and
platforms, has evolved radically over the past decade. European policy-makers have
implemented strategies and passed legislation that has altered the landscape of what is
possible in terms of sharing data.
There has been significant momentum in the European Union in the last year towards
creating a so-called “Digital Single Market” for data, and treating the free flow of data as a
“fifth freedom” of the European Union’s internal market. The aim of the free movement of
data, articulated in the Estonian Presidency of the European Union in the second half of
2017, is “to make Europe the place where (digital) innovation happens first.” [LINK3]
The focus of the Digital Health Society is to encourage this vision by helping push and shape
change in the area of health care. The DHS is made up of interested stakeholders in the
fields of digital health that share a belief in the benefits of achieving the digital
transformation of health-care systems.
The ecosystem of digital health includes companies, policy makers, education and research
entities, funders, health and social care providers, and third-sectors associations and
charities, focused on the well-being of patients and citizens. The Digital Health Society acts
as a way for all the stakeholders in health care to take a holistic approach to the
development of digital health services.
The DHS Declaration [LINK4], a consensus statement of purpose created by all its
stakeholders, was signed in October 2017 during and after a high-level e-health conference
of the Estonian EU presidency.
The Declaration focuses on three goals for the free flow of data in health care. First,
increased access and safety in health care can only be achieved through empowered citizens
and adequate data availability at the point of care. Second, that sustainability of health
systems will be supported by a value-based approach. Finally, a belief that new economic
opportunities, jobs and investment that will be created using data-driven health-care
innovation.
The Declaration’s signatory groups have formed four task forces comprised of the DHS
stakeholders, each of them responsible for focusing on areas that advance the DHS
Declaration. Each of the task forces are charged with finding ways to overcome the barriers
1
https://www.sm.ee/en
2
https://echalliance.com/
3
https://www.eu2017.ee/sites/default/files/inline-files/EU2017_FMD_visionpaper.pdf
4
https://echalliance.com/general/custom.asp?page=DHSDeclaration
that prevent the utilization of digital technologies in health care, and ways of maximizing
the utilization of data without territorial or system restraints.
Task Force 1 [LINK5], chaired by Erik Gerritsen, the Secretary General at the Ministry of
Health, Welfare and Sport of Netherlands, is focused on with interoperability standards of
systems and developing a protocol for digital health care.
Dr. Angela Brand, of the University of Maastricht in the Netherlands, is leading Task Force 2
[LINK6]. That task force is charged with highlighting models of effective citizen ownership
and control of their own health data, as well articulating a good-governance model for data
that extends beyond the health sector into a global context.
Task Force 3 [LINK7] is focused on the legal framework that would facilitate the free flow of
medical data around the European Union and their second use. Bleddyn Rees, an
ECHAlliance Director and international health care lawyer who consults on the topic for the
Osbourne Clarke legal firm, is chairing this task force.
Digital transformation, and managing change by health- and social-care organizations is the
focus of Task Force 4 [LINK8], headed by Richard Corbridge, who has been both the Chief
Information Officer for the Health Service Executive in Ireland and Chief Executive Officer
for eHealth Ireland since 2014.
Brian O’Connor, a founder of the DHS and Chair of the ECHAlliance, said the Digital Health
Society is always open to new contributors to its work and signatories to the DHS
Declaration[LINK9], as long as they are a “doer” – someone that will concretely contribute –
and not just want to talk about the issues under discussion.
“The task forces will report in June,” he said. “The purpose is to give practice advice on the
four issues of the task forces and give that to all regions and member states in Europe, and
indeed, elsewhere. Because internationally, we have had requests from governments
outside of Europe to see if we can set up the Digital Health Society in their country and link
it into the European Digital Health Society.
“You’ve got to sign up as a ‘doer’ to one of the groups, then you have to turn up and
contribute – your thinking and your experience and your good and bad news.”
The Digital Health Society’s formal origins [LINK10] begin with a May 2017 meeting in
Valletta, Malta, during the Maltese EU presidency, and formalized in the second half of the
year with the Estonian presidency of the EU underway.
“It was introduced first as an idea to support the traditional EU presidential activities on
policy matters,” said Ain Aaviksoo, a DHS founder, and the former Deputy Secretary General
5
Task Force 1 webpage
6
Task Force 2 webpage
7
Task Force 3 webpage
8
Task Force 4 webpage
9
http://echalliance.com/surveys/?id=DHSDeclarationsign%20
10
History - timeline
for E-services and Innovation at the Ministry of Social Affairs of Estonia, as well as the
chairman of the supervisory board of the Estonian E-Health Foundation.
“E-health means technology to me; the Digital Health Society is not. We are talking about a
new channel – a digital channel – in health care focused on improving the service parts of
health care. If someone needs and wants a service, there’s a people and organization that
can make that happen. We offered the Estonian EU Presidency as a platform to achieve
that,” he said.
The Estonian EU Presidency in the second half of 2017 focused on the rights of citizens to
access, manage and control their health data electronically in a safe and secure manner, and
the better use of health data, particularly in the areas of research and innovation; those
issues were focused on by Estonian president Kersti Kaljulaid in her keynote address at the
end of the presidency. [LINK11]
Estonia already uses an effective electronic system, the X-Road [LINK12], which allows
various electronic databases, both in the public and private sector, to communicate with
each other, using the identification of its user only once. One of the results is that Estonians
have a common e-health record that every patient can access online and every doctor
treating the patient can review and amend it, and give digital prescriptions that are portable
within the country.
“The Digital Health Society is aiming at finding the next set of converging interests, making
those happen and delivering it to the European citizen as quickly as possible,” Aaviksoo said.
“The Digital Health Society has shown its presence in China, in the U.S. and Canada, so if this
format of working with various stakeholders – with task forces solving specific problems –
works and can deliver, the ambition is that it could be something that helps solve problems,
defined through the eyes of people, more efficiently than usual.
“We want to create a fast-track playing field that is level for everyone. And it works both
ways. I want the best innovation to come into my country, because I know that one nation
cannot innovate everything itself, or bare the costs. And I want anything developed in my
country to be able to be applied elsewhere.
“It is complex,” Aaviksoo said. “Many countries need to change their laws. But there is a real
desire to get something done. People in different positions who want more effective
implementation of digital solutions in health care would get some inspiration from what has
been achieved already.”
11
https://www.eu2017.ee/news/insights/closing-keynote-president-estonia-kersti-kaljulaid-health-digital-
society-digital-society-health
12
Estonian X-Road
’Actions, not words’: The origins and future of the Digital Health Society
The Digital Health Society was born out of a morning meeting in a small, crowded, too-hot
conference room in May of 2017 in Valletta, Malta. The meeting drew people that were
attending a series of conferences that were part of an e-health week held during the
Maltese EU Presidency.
“It was an ad-hoc meeting; it wasn’t even announced in the program,” said Ain Aaviksoo, a
DHS founder, and the former Deputy Secretary General for E-services and Innovation at the
Ministry of Social Affairs of Estonia, as well as the chairman of the supervisory board of the
Estonian E-Health Foundation.
“At first there were about 15 to 20 people. It was a brainstorming session, but we though
we could kick off the Estonian Presidency in the second half of 2017 right there. As time
went on, the room got filled with people, and half the people had to stand,” he said. “There
were people there from different government agencies there, but representatives from all
sorts of other groups. There was a real unexpected interest toward this.”
During the meeting, Aaviksoo addressed what would become a core issue of the Estonian
EU Presidency in the second half of 2017 – the idea that data should be treated as a
separate freedom of the EU – a “fifth freedom” – together with the existing four freedoms
of the internal market set out in the Treaty of the Functioning of the European Union
(TFEU). [LINK1]
This concept is an extension of the Union’s push towards what the European Commission
calls a Digital Single Market for the EU, aiming to open up digital opportunities for people
and business, and enhance Europe’s position as a world leader in the digital economy.
[LINK2]
“Ain Aaviksoo gave a passionate pitch about acknowledging the ‘fifth freedom’, the free
flow of data. He also pitched the idea of creating a manifesto that people could pledge their
support to,” said Herko Coomans, Secretary of the Digital Health Society’s Task Force 1 on
Interoperability, and the international adviser for the Netherlands’ National Health
Information Council.
“Erik Gerritsen, the Secretary General of the Dutch Ministry of Health, Welfare and Sport,
listened patiently to Mr. Aaviksoo’s pitch and the first positive replies and then said, ‘We
could probably work on wording a document for months, but I already agree with
everything you want to achieve. So could we focus on actions and not just words? Can we
go from coalitions of the willing towards coalitions of the doing?’”
1
https://www.eu2017.ee/sites/default/files/inline-files/EU2017_FMD_visionpaper.pdf
2
https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en
That idea resonated with who would become the founding members of the Digital Health
Society present in Malta, and they invited Gerritsen to lead one of the four task forces set
up to look into key challenges to the digital transformation of health care.
“At the end of the day, by the time we had a declaration, there were more than 100
different organizations involved,” Aaviksoo said. “And we had a mix of groups that normally
don’t work together – of policy-making, and a layer of patient organizations.”
The DHS Declaration was opened to co-endorsement and co-signature of all interested
organizations during and after a high-level e-health conference held during the Estonian EU
Presidency in October of 2017.
“We had 700 people from all over Europe and further afield there,” said Brian O’Connor, the
Chair of the European Connected Health Alliance and one of the founders of the Digital
Health Society. “Bluntly, the fact that we had 700 people at the end of the conference was
the best I’ve ever seen. Generally these conferences end with hardly anybody in the room,
because everyone is off getting their flights. In this case, the room was packed.
“The Estonians did a brilliant job during their presidency. It was one of the most active
presidencies that I’ve ever seen. Now they need to go capitalize on it. They need to go out
there and say, ‘You know, this is really good.’”
The closing address [LINK3] of the Estonian EU Presidency by President Kersti Kaljulaid kept
e-health in the spotlight, and focused on the challenges and possibilities of digital
transformation in that sector.
The Tallinn Declaration [LINK4] was signed in October to reinvigorate Europe’s efforts to
advance the Digital Single Market, and set out a five-year road map for the development of
e-government at both the national and EU levels.
With the Bulgarian EU Presidency underway in the first half of 2018, nations, organizations
and businesses are now grappling with the passage of the General Data
Protection Regulation (GDPR) by the European Parliament in April 2016 [LINK5].
The GDPR is designed to harmonize data privacy laws across Europe, protect and empower
all EU citizens’ data privacy, and to reshape the way organizations across the region
approach it. The enforcement date for the new regulation begins on 25 May.
“Governments have a responsibility, starting in May, to give all of us access to our data,“
O’Connor said. “And a lot of them aren’t ready. We as citizens need to be informed about
the rights that we have to access our data, wherever we are, and by what means we want.
“That doesn’t happen at the moment in Europe. It’s actually quite difficult to access your
data, particularly across borders. Because every health system is national; it’s not run by
3
https://www.eu2017.ee/news/insights/closing-keynote-president-estonia-kersti-kaljulaid-health-digital-
society-digital-society-health
4
https://www.eu2017.ee/news/insights/tallinn-declaration-egovernment-ministerial-meeting-during-
estonian-presidency
5
https://www.eugdpr.org/
Brussels. So there’s a national control of your health service. So that doesn’t translate into a
lot of collaboration across borders. We believe we can assist governments to change their
legislation to accommodate the new reality of GDPR.”
While such topics such as intellectual property and mobile phone roaming fees in the EU get
most of the headlines about the development of a common digital market, health and social
care is considered one of the most important areas, the DHS founders said. And when it
comes to economic development, life sciences are globally perceived as one of the most
important growth areas in the future.
The Digital Health Society is focusing its energy on practical-use cases for digital technology
and transformation. For example, in September 2017, patient data was shared across
national borders with some of the 23 Centers of Excellence spread across Europe focused on
infectious diseases. Pharmaceuticals and prescriptions are another area of heavy current
activity. The DHS is also working with interested partners in China, the United States, and
Canada.
“Many countries in Europe have an e-health strategy,“ O’Connor said. They have come
together with the DHS to learn the lessons – ‘If I have a strategy, how to I implement it?
What obstacles and problems are there?’
“We hope to be able to take the Digital Health Society legacy and bring that in in various
ways to the Bulgarian and Austrian presidencies. We already have an agreement from the
Romanian presidency for the DHS to be part of their presidency. The Finns have already
said, ’Yes, we want this as well.’ So this is not going to be something that dies, but a thread
that is going to run through future presidencies,“ he said.
“At long last, we have something that is real.”
Concepts
“Digital Single Market” – The European Commission has called for a Digital Single Market for
the EU, aiming to open up digital opportunities for people and business, and enhance
Europe’s position as a world leader in the digital economy
“Fifth freedom” – A concept from the Estonian EU Presidency; data should be treated as a
separate freedom of the EU, together with the existing four freedoms of the internal market
set out in the Treaty of the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU)
GDPR – The General Data Protection Regulation, which will go into effect in May. It is
designed to harmonize data privacy laws across Europe, to protect and empower all EU
citizens’ data privacy, and to reshape the way organizations across the region approach it
Timeline of EU presidencies
1st half 2017: Malta
2nd half 2017: Estonia
1st half 2018: Bulgaria
2nd half 2018: Austria
1st half 2019: Romania
2nd half 2019: Finland
Estonia’s ‘X-Road’ system provides a glimpse of the future of e-health services
If Estonia has developed its own international “brand identity” in the years since its re-
independence in 1991 and its accession to the European Union in 2004, it is of “e-Estonia” –
one of the most wired and technologically advanced countries in the world.
Estonians were early adopters of mobile phone technology and public WiFi, and the country
is known the cradle of Skype. Now, local innovation has pushed in the direction of
interoperability of e-services – allowing different distinct systems to communicate and
exchange data and transactions.
No development has been bigger for Estonia, and possibly more of a glimpse of the
possibilities in this area than its digital, so-called “X-Road” system.
Any resident of Estonia, or any foreign individual who set up an ID with the country’s “e-
residency” [LINK1] program, is issued a microchipped, state-issued national identification
card. This card acts as a legal proof of online identity. Nowadays, people use the card to do
such things as vote in elections, file their taxes, and access their medical records from the
comfort of their own home or office, using a computer or a smart device.
The X-Road system [LINK2] makes it all work. It is a citizen-centered state and service-
oriented information system that allows various electronic databases, both in the public and
private sector, to communicate with each other, using the identification of its user only
once. It’s been estimated that the system has saved Estonians approximately 800 years of
working time every year.
Estonia’s health-care system has been revolutionized by the system, particularly in the area
of electronic health records. Estonia has a common e-health record for nearly all of its
citizens and residents, which every patient can access online and every doctor treating the
patient can review and amend it.
Brian O’Connor, the Chair of the European Connected Health Alliance and one of the
founders of the Digital Health Society, said when the first organizational meetings of the
DHS took place in 2017, there were plenty of international partners and groups that were
interested in working with Estonia because of the success of the X-Road system.
“Estonia has a great reputation internationally for doing real things in e-health with their e-
health services platform,” O’Connor said. “I say this honestly – I think Estonia has more than
even Estonia realizes it has. They utilize the service here, they see also the weaknesses in it
– users always see weaknesses – but to the outside world, and indeed to the Estonian
population, the e-services platform works. They trust it, they use it. But when they go
abroad to promote it, they are self-conscious that there are weaknesses in it, so they are
less good at selling it and promoting it than an outsider would be.
1
https://e-resident.gov.ee/
2
https://e-estonia.com/solutions/interoperability-services/x-road/
“They are very modest about what they’ve done. They see it as a job that they need to do.
Part of what’s come out of the Estonian European Union presidency in the fall of 2017 and
the development of the Digital Health Society is that many, many countries are not at the
advanced stage that Estonia is at yet, and they want to get involved. For all the local
concerns or misgivings here in Estonia, the outside world that has studied it goes – ‘I wish
we had that here.’
“Many EU presidencies end with a whimper, and no one remembers it after a time. With its
focus on the creation of a Digital Single Market – treating data as a separate freedom of the
EU together with the existing four freedoms of the internal market – the Estonian
presidency has a chance to be different. The Digital Single Market will capture and maintain
its reputation,” he said.
In Estonia, e-health records retrieve information through the X-Road as necessary from
various providers – each of which might be using different systems – and present it in a
standardized format that is available by an e-Patient portal.
Doctors who are treating the patient can also access the record. From there, they can read
test results as they are entered, image files such as X-rays or CAT scans, and do so from
remote locations far away from a hospital. Doctors can also read time-critical information,
such as blood type, allergies, and recent treatments. The system also compiles generalized
data for national statistics, so the Estonian health ministry can measure health trends, track
possible pandemics, and see how its resources are being spent.
Health information is kept completely secure through KSI Blockchain technology [LINK3],
which also ensures the integrity of the data. Information is only accessible to individuals
authorized by the patient, and computer logs store any access of the data.
Other European countries, including Ireland, O’Connor’s home, have started experimenting
with a digital identification system like the one Estonia has adopted. Ireland now has a
unique identifier number for all of its citizens, although O’Connor said it doesn’t have the
software infrastructure to make full use of it yet, which is why the success of Estonia’s X-
Road system is so appealing to other countries.
“The majority of European health-care systems are not as advanced as Estonia,” he said.
“People in my home country recognize that, as do other places. The Nordic countries have
invested heavily in the idea of connectivity, because the broadband a Wi-Fi fundamentals
are good.
“But there are other countries out there that are going, ‘If I am about to spend a lot of
money in digital infrastructure, I don’t want to make the same mistakes as other countries
or take as long. Can I make a great leap forward? Can I just buy something? If you know that
there is a solution that works, why am I going to go through the 27 steps that other
countries have gone through to get there?’
3
https://e-estonia.com/solutions/security-and-safety/ksi-blockchain/
Prescriptions are also part of the Estonian e-health record, and doctors can give a patient a
virtual one through the X-Road system that can be filled anywhere around the country. It’s
the hope of members of the Digital Health Society that this kind of information sharing can
be expanded on a bilateral, or multilateral, basis inside the European Union.
Currently, there are plans being developed to make the prescription system operable
between Finland and Estonia starting in July.
“Though the Digital Health Society, Estonians are regarded as leaders,” O’Connor said. “The
Estonians can continue to contribute their knowledge, their experience, and their, ‘Oh, for
God’s sake, don’t do that, we tried that, it didn’t work’ experience, which will save other
countries time and money. Estonia doesn’t have to do anything but package what it’s got,
and walk into a room of customers. There might be others who want to walk into Estonia
and offer something that will improve its systems.
“The system is meant to be practical. It’s made to embrace society in Europe, and
fundamentally change the way that we think and act on these matters. That’s the long-term
goal. To do that successfully and implement them, you have to have examples where it’s
been successful. Estonia leaps to mind.”
Estonia’s Virtual Road
The “X-Road” is the backbone of Estonian e-services. It allows citizens and residents to
access the country’s various public and private databases, and conduct online transactions
and business. As of the 1st of March, the X-Road included:
895 institutions and enterprises
694 public sector institutions
1,648 interfaced information systems
349 member-installed security servers
2,375 services that can be used via the X-Road
Roughly 52,000 organizations as indirect users of X-Road services
E-health care in Estonia
Due to the X-Road, in health care in Estonia:
95% of health data is digitized
99% of prescriptions are digital
100% of health care is electronically billed
97% of patients have a country-wide digital health care record
There are 500,000 queries by doctors every year
There are 300,000 queries by patients every year
Task Force 2: Working to keep citizens in charge of data governance
Task Force 2 of the Digital Health Society is led by Dr. Angela Brand, a full professor in the
Department of International Health at Maastricht University in the Netherlands.
Health-related data generated by new technologies is an essential part of the current bio-
economy, which is essentially defined as economic activities related to biological products
and processes. Correspondingly, the task force’s work is focused on citizen-controlled data
governance and data donors, which are seen as an important priority.
“What needs to be changed in the current models for governing data – for better health and
health care – are based on an outdated assumption of data protection and data security,”
said Brand, who is also the director of the European Centre for Public Health Genomics at
Maastricht University.
“This does not work for the future. We need to think about other models and what is
missing. We came to the conclusion that what is missing is a good governance model.”
In the view of Task Force 2, a good model for governance of health-care related data would
allow for the free flow of non-personal data, and also access to and the re-use of date for
future – and possibly unknown – purposes.
“It should go beyond health data and IT solutions for health,“ Brand said. “It is also
important to understand that data is a central part of health research, health care, and
health improvement. We need the data to improve.
“It’s not only the blood, but the oil.”
Brand said there are already many technical tools that are in line with the implementation
of citizen control of data and good governance models. She referred to examples such as
Blockchain and Bitcoin, the use of artificial intelligence, the European Open Science Cloud,
as well as an integrated health-care standard in the EU, which is in the purview of DHS’s
Task Force 1.
“We have political commitment and tools,” she said. “In many approaches, in many
strategies, the citizen-centered approach is no longer the question. We have policies like
health, or policies where health is an issue, like trade, security, and so on. Then we have the
cross-border health-care directive, which is a frame which we can already use.
“We have European frameworks and principles in place, for example the common values
and principles of solidarity and proportionality. We have the Digital Single Market strategy,
where citizens should have access to their own health data. Under the Estonian presidency
in 2017 there was a discussion of the ‘fifth freedom’ of data to cross borders, which could
lead to a true data society. That would be a major step forward.”
The task force is looking for governance models that put the citizen in the driver’s seat, and
makes the best use of technological innovations and health data – for both the individual’s
benefit and for the common good.
Health data cooperatives, which use a voluntary, self-governing association of people in a
joined-owned and democratically-controlled enterprise, is one good way, Brand said.
“With health-data cooperatives, health is maybe the most crucial part in it,” she said. “That
would mean that the citizen is a creator, a natural interpreter, the controller, the owner,
and also the sharer of the data for primary and secondary use for all kinds of purposes in a
trusted entity, even beyond the health sector. That is a unique selling point here.”
Health data cooperatives have been pushed by a “My Data” movement, which has recently
held conferences in Tallinn and Helsinki, and has a declaration [LINK1] that has been signed
by many institutions and stakeholders in health that are interested in empowering
individuals with their personal data.
“On the one hand, we have many data sources, and we have data-using services, whether
they were public or private,“ Brand said. “In the middle, there could be an operator. And in
our case, the idea is that this operator could be the data cooperative where the persons and
citizens are members of these cooperatives.
“Citizens are in the driver’s seat in a cooperative model – it’s a truly democratic solution for
Europe and beyond, also globally. It includes all various types of data donors, which are in
the topic of our task force – whether these are citizens, patients, companies, or
administration. One person in the cooperative has one vote, then the data can be stored in
an intelligent cloud.
“Cooperatives are already established, not only in Europe, but globally. In Europe all legal
problems have been solved. We even have cooperatives in the health sector, for example in
health promotion. There is a chance for the horizontal use of health data, and that’s very
much in line with our health policies. It’s balancing personal benefit and the common good,
and they the only model that we can think about that can insure such a balance, with many
possible business models,” she said.
Task Force 2 is also focusing on finding funding sources and examining pilot projects for
emulation.
“Pilots could be very general proofs of concepts, but also very concrete,” Brand said. “We
could develop a tool box for health data cooperatives. It could also be business-to-business
money initiatives, like the literal knowledge banks. One could think of cross-border pilots –
the implementation of a cooperative across borders.
“Then, depending on the various stakeholders, whether they are public or private, and the
local needs, one can think about a lot of initiatives so to start very small, and could be scaled
up. It could be questions around health that are neighborhood management, hospital
1
https://mydata.org/declaration/
management, or very disease-specific patient groups. With rare diseases, self-help groups
would be one example.
“The beauty of a pilot project one could try how it complies with existing other initiatives,
for example just recently a collaboration for oncology data was launched,” she said. “There
are many possibilities.”
Task Force 2
Objectives
Mapping and review of existing good governance models for citizen-owned and citizen-
controlled data.
Development of a European good governance model for citizen-owned and citizen-
controlled data. In the global context, taking that beyond the health sector.
Task Force 2’s final report will include a road map and an action plan to deliver a structure
for organization and governance, plus an analysis of public and private funding
opportunities for projects.
Task Force 3: Breaking down the legal barriers for medical data
Task Force 3 of the Digital Health Society project is focused on the legal framework that
would facilitate the free flow of medical data around the European Union and their second
use.
This task force is led by Bleddyn Rees, an ECHAlliance Director and international health care
lawyer who consults on the topic for the Osbourne Clarke legal firm.
While the EU can pass legislation and has a range of legal powers that can influence the use
of healthcare data in Europe (such as the General Data Protection Regulation – GDPR –
which comes into force in May)[LINK1], it is not able to harmonize health and social care
laws across the Union.
For now, it is up to the countries of the EU to work out legal harmonization between them.
However, it took Finland and Estonia, for instance, five years to smooth out legal differences
to allow health data – for example, pharmacy prescriptions – to be shared between the two
nations, as they will do now this year. Rees says that it does not have to be this way for
everyone.
“I’m a passionate believer that the law can be a force for good, that regulation can be a
force for good, he said. “It doesn’t have to be about stopping things happening, it can be
about facilitating things happening. The problem is that the European Union doesn’t have
any power to harmonize health laws, so national health systems become insular. They are
not leveraging the global learning, the global business environment.
“So the idea is to create through an international treaty a convention that allows countries
to start to harmonize, if they so choose, some of the fundamental rights around data for
citizens and patients, and to facilitate that flow of data for the benefit of individuals, and
society as a whole,” Rees said.
Task Force 3’s task is to explore ways to promoting simplicity and transparency in data-
sharing.
“For patients and families it’s simple – they want to access and control their medical
information,” Rees said. “But national health systems are complex and data protection laws
– including the new GDPR law – are also complex.
“Task Force 3 is trying to create a set of principles which could become law which make the
process of accessing and controlling health data as simple, clear and transparent as possible
for the benefit of people, clinical staff who treat them and researchers.”
Rees said there have already been notable successes in data sharing in the EU, pointing to
an episode in the Netherlands where a motorway crash on the border caused ambulances
1
https://www.eugdpr.org/
from a number of countries to respond, but had no access to the health records of the
victims. That has since been resolved.
“In both Finland and Catalonia there are examples of much better access for citizens to their
health data, but comparatively these are small scale examples of what Task Force 3 would
like to see happen,” he said.
“We would like to see a set of clear principles which allow health data to cross borders
and genuinely create a single digital market for health data amongst those regions or
countries who chose to get involved. It will allow bigger data sets to be created – registries,
for example, in diabetes – England does not have one but Scotland does. This makes no
sense.
“With more data – from multiple regions and countries – and analytics, there should be
greater understanding, and new tests or treatments developed. Economic benefits are
possible, such as new jobs and growth in GDP, as European business
emerge developing analytics, digital platforms and services for health and care.”
Rees said that in countries that have embraced digital technologies in public services, the
easier it is to see digital health delivery as a real benefit. In countries that still primarily
operate on a paper-based system, skepticism creates greater challenges.
“The key to this is communication – it’s about explaining to people what the benefits are
about the use of data and its transfer in a very practical way,” he said. “So just not about
research, but how it is going to help you, your mother, your father, get the services they
need in the most convenient manner. Once people understand the limitations on paper, the
benefits from the digital-enabling health-care system, the quicker people will buy into it.
That’s the whole concept behind the Digital Health Society. This is something for you and I,
for our children, for our parents, just makes sense. Why wouldn’t you do this?”
Rees said that Estonian presidency of the EU during the second half of 2017 was extremely
important in getting momentum behind the free flow of data at a national government
level, and getting the European Commission and member states engaged in the idea.
“The options are being discussed including how other Presidencies may pick up the Estonian
baton,” he said.
Rees said if someone is interested in contributing, they should sign the DHS Declaration
[LINK2] and initiate contact with the task force.
“Legal expertise, especially in national data protection in European countries, is helpful but
anyone who has an interest in health data and its use – whether from a policy, industry, or
health and care services background – there is a place for you,” Rees said.
“The future of health care, making health-care systems sustainable, is about using data. It’s
about learning from data. Whether that’s developing new services, whether it’s about
research and understanding the causes of disease, but it’s also about enriching the
2
https://echalliance.com/page/DHSDeclaration
understanding by adding, if you like, data from smart cities – data that isn’t purely health
care,” he said.
“We can then learn from that to develop systems that are patient-centric, that are people-
centric, and that keep people well. It’s about well-being as much as it is about disease. But
the fundamental driver of this is data, and the flow and use of that data.”
Task Force 3
Objectives
This Task Force is exploring whether it is possible to promote health and social care laws
across two or more regions and EU member states, to promote the free flow and the second
use of health and social care data.
The purpose of such laws would be to contribute to the development of:
Improved health outcomes
New research and innovation in health and social care products and services
Improved prevention and well-being
Services and products
Task Force 1: Striving to improve the interoperability of digital health-care systems
The Digital Health Society has four task forces focused on different aspects of making free
movement of data in Europe a reality.
These task forces call themselves the “Coalition of the Doing”, and are actively trying to find
ways to improve the cooperation between the 28 nation-states in Europe, and relevant
stakeholders in business, science, medicine, and academia. Each of the task forces are
charged finding ways to overcome the barriers that prevent the utilization of digital
technologies and the free flow of data in health care.
The first task force of the DHS is concerned with interoperability standards and developing a
digital healthcare protocol. It’s chaired by Erik Gerritsen, the Secretary General at the
Ministry of Health, Welfare and Sport of Netherlands, who was heavily involved in the
creation of the Digital Health Society in May 2017.
Gerritsen said that improving cross-border exchange of health data has several layers,
where improving the sharing of information will lead to benefits for citizen health care.
“Most importantly, it means that data follows the person,” he said. “If someone is in need of
health care abroad, the professionals should be able to access all relevant and necessary
data in a safe and secure and trustworthy way. This doesn’t mean that personal health data
is available for anyone anywhere, but that access is controlled, privacy is respected, and all
communication is secure and that everyone can trust the source and quality of the data.
“If we widen the scope of ‘health data’ just a little, it becomes all the data related to your
personal health, which includes your state of mind, the impact of your environment, the
food you eat, your activity patterns, et cetera. This personal health data is being generated
by sensors everywhere, and should be treated with the same level of trust as in the first
meaning. And here too, this trust should be universal, across borders.”
Data itself is convenient, but is fairly worthless without any context, Gerritsen said. The
work of Task Force 1 is focused on finding ways to make it valuable by improving
interoperability between systems that allow it to turn into actionable information.
“The raw data of the number of steps you take every day doesn’t say much, but combining it
with context and other data such as weight, activity patterns, health goals, and treatment
plans will make it valuable,” he said. “Within the boundaries of the universal trust, adding
value to personal and professional health data can come from anywhere.
“The benefits for public health are potentially huge. Being able to combine health-care,
social, personal health, and environmental data will create insights in the effects of human
behavior on health to an unprecedented extent. With these insights, actionable feedback on
health consequences of lifestyle choices can be instantly provided.
“Here, trust is key as well. Is that data used to help you make healthy choices, or to punish
you for making unhealthy ones? With data, these consequences become transparent, it’s
how we deal with it – that will make the difference,” Gerritsen said.
Innovation in health care is more than about a particular innovation of a product or process,
the task force believes. It is also about creating the means for society to experiment, adopt
and integrate these new ways of working.
“It means that all stakeholders need to find ways to relate to each other, around a common
and shared set of values and mechanisms that safeguard the trust of the people,” Gerritsen
said.
“This means that every stakeholder needs to re-evaluate their methods and instruments,
and how they support and augment these common values. For instance, companies need to
develop new successful business models that embrace respect for privacy and data
portability, governments need to create legal frameworks that allow for responsible
experimentation and short development cycles, and researchers need to embrace that they
don’t need to have all the raw data to be able to do meaningful research.”
Gerritsen, who has held the post of Secretary General at the Ministry of Health, Welfare and
Sport of the Netherlands since June 2015, said that there has already been a lot of work
done by people and organizations to improve interoperability in health-care information
systems.
Standards have been developed and implement that allow systems to communicate with
each other, and health-care professionals around the globe have created some common
structures and language so they can correctly interpret the messages they send to one
another. These structures have been constructed to break down the barriers caused by
borders, cultures, and languages.
Also, laws have been passed in several nations that make the use of these standards
mandatory in the realm of health care, Gerritsen said. They are now being listed as
requirements in procurement of new health-care systems, so vendors make sure their
systems use the new standards. There has also been international frameworks and research
and development programs initiated that focus around interoperability of health-care
systems.
“And all this and more has been done without any interference from the task force,” he
said. “In fact, we believe all that does not need the task force to be successful. This task
force focuses on bringing together what everyone has achieved and that has proven its
worth in daily practice. It’s truly a ‘Coalition of the Doing’, that doesn’t ask people to do
anything new, but that shares what works.”
Gerritsen said there are already many great examples of successful interoperability
solutions from around Europe, and beyond.
“The Danish Sundhedsdatastyrelsen, the Health data Authority, has a legal mandate to set a
list of national standards that are mandatory to use,” he said. “They also have reference
architectures on how to implement them.
“With an overview of which interoperability standards are in use for what and where – for
instance, all hospitals in the Netherlands use IHE XDS to exchange medical images – we can
show who is already interoperable with who.
“The United States has the Interoperability Standards Advisory, a list of best-of-breed
standards and where they should be used. Some are federally required, others in certain
states and again others are emerging and still very much in development,” Gerritsen said.
Task Force 1 hopes to bring these local, regional and national success stories into the
international, cross-border context, and focus on where cross-border interoperability is
actually needed most.
“Electronic medication prescriptions and patient summaries are already being worked on
across Europe, but there are many other use cases that can help inspire other to learn and
actually adopt,” Gerritsen said. “For instance, the Dutch are working hard on a set of
interoperability standards for personal health data called MedMij, where others are also
working on the similar use cases.”
Gerritsen said he believes interoperability is such a big and complex topic that the Digital
Health Society sees the challenge of having a lasting impact and speeding up digital
adoption as somewhat akin to a social movement, where the actions of a few can inspire
the actions of many.
“We lead this task force by example,” he said. “But those who follow our initiative are the
true leaders. We are the lone nut dancing on the hill in the famous ‘How to start a
movement’ TED Talk from American entrepreneur Derek Sivers.
“It is those who join us that turn the lone nut into a real movement. Our approach is to
gather the people who have success stories of working interoperability solutions in this task
force and share them. And together we will define the next steps, making this task force not
a Dutch initiative, but a real ‘Coalition of the Doing’.
“We hope to accomplish two things by the end of the year – to have a good overview of the
successes of the ‘Doers’ – which interoperability standards are already in use for what and
where exactly,” Gerritsen said. “We want to show a map you can click on to see with whom
you can already communicate, without having made any new arrangements. And most
importantly, we want to have created a group of like-minded leaders that is willing to be the
shining example for everyone on how to make health care interoperable.”
If people are interested in working with the task force, they can sign the DHS Declaration
[LINK1] can join the Task Force group on the ECHAlliance website[LINK2], and contact the
1
https://echalliance.com/general/custom.asp?page=DHSDeclaration
2
https://echalliance.com/?page=digitalhealthsociety
task force secretary, Herko Coomans (
[email protected]). Most importantly, Gerritsen
said, is that you have to determine how you want to be a leader in the task force.
“Share your success,” he said. “This means that on a very practical level, you should be
willing to format your success in use cases, translate the lists of standards into English – the
common language we use in the task force, and make some time available to discuss the
next steps with the rest of the members.”
Task Force 1
Objectives
The Digital Health Society aims to enhance the cross-border exchanges of health data
between the European regions and countries. A major challenge is to organize the
interoperability of the information systems of health-care services in these different areas.
This task force is focused on identifying the ways of delivering convergence in Europe, based
on success stories and verified case studies, leading to enabling the free flow of data
through different health care systems. It is focused on mapping where and which
interoperability standards are being used and for which purpose, with a specific focus on
cross-border exchanges.
Deliberately independent and agnostic from other organizations, Task Force 1 will compile
stories, but also highlight analyses of the impact on health-care systems in order to drive
adoption and commitment from other regions, countries, health-care providers, and other
stakeholders in Europe.