1
Contact details
Date: Organization:
Country: Respondent:
Field of Social insurance:
Are social insurance systems adapted to new forms of work
produced by digital platforms?
The disruptive potential of current and future changes to labour markets for social security are major. Much of the
financing of social security is built on the model of contributions to schemes shared by the State, employer and
employee or by the self-employed. (Konkolewsky 2016.)
Digitalization has been at the center of this transformation. Many digital platforms understand themselves as online
marketplaces, and they could eventually have a transformative impact by efficiently matching a larger pool of workers
with consumers of their services (McKinsey 2016). Today relatively few engage in gainful activity via them. McKinsey
and JP Morgan (2016) find that only 4 percent of working-age population has used digital platforms to generate income.
However, their share has increased very rapidly over the last years (JP Morgan Chase 2016).
In this questionnaire we will analyze the current regulatory framework of platform work from the point of view of
statutory social insurance, but not labour or tax law. In this questionnaire platforms should be understood as websites
and apps that exchange labour (in the broad sense of human work). We exclude websites that mainly exchange goods
and facilities (like eBay) from the scope of our questionnaire.
Certain countries have residence based social insurance. This being the case, several questions can be answered easily
(for instance by inscribing ”not affected”). However, also in these cases all the questions about ”contributions” to be
paid out of platform work, could be relevant.
As no questionnaire can be totally exhaustive, at the end of this questionnaire you will find an open text box for possible
comments regarding any other issues that your institution would like to point out.
2
PART I
Sample cases of platform work
In this part we study the sample cases of existing platforms and analyze how statutory social insurance works currently.
The three sample cases are presented in detail here below. Platform work is understood in the questionnaire as
websites and apps through which buyers and sellers of labour ( in the broad sense of human work) transact digitally.
That is, for the platform we assume that the worker and employer are matched digitally; the payment is conducted
digitally via the platform. Depending on the sample case, the result of the work can be delivered either digitally
(case 1) or locally (case 2).
One of the distinctive features of the ”Sample cases” is the fact that the platform worker is not continuously working
for ”one” employer/user/customer, but usually performing a lot of timely limited small jobs (”gigs”) for many different
users. That is why we are using in the following the term ”gig worker”.
Case 1: Digitally delivered platform work
Usually digital online platforms do not consider themselves as employers but rather as marketplaces that connect
the buyers and sellers of labor. This auto definition has been a big source of conflict as regulators may classify
platforms as employers and requires them to act accordingly. This often leads to a situation where participants
of the gig economy operate in the gray area between the categories of employee and self-employed. In many
ways, this is critical as the distinction between “independent” and “dependent” work can be crucial for the
inclusion of workers in different branches of social security and its specific features.
In case 1 we will analyze a gig worker who engages into gainful activity via a digital platform and delivers the
output of her labour digitally. As such this type of work can be conducted from anywhere in the world creating
challenges for national statutory social insurance systems. Assuming that the worker would perform this type
of work in your home country analyze statutory social insurance according the following case.
Execution of “virtual tasks” in exchange for monetary compensation – work performed via the internet – such
as design (interior, graphic, webpage etc); software development; translation; check restaurant reviews,
• delivered by an individual (service) “provider”,
• to various (not only one!) private or commercial “users”
• via a (typically commercial, performing for fees) “digital platform”, such as: Amazon Mechanical Turk
(MTurk), Upwork, CoContest, 99design, Unbabel, Fiverr, Fivesquid, Clickworker (here, the users are often
big companies).
1. In terms of social insurance is this kind of gig worker regarded as a self-employed or an employee? Or other
(please specify)?
2. Are there any requirements to the buyer of labour concerning social insurance?
3
3. As digital work is done on Internet, escaping the traditional regulatory framework, reporting is often dependent
on the conscientiousness of the individual. What kind of follow-up mechanisms exist to ensure that the person
insures her/his gainful activities in line with his legal obligations?
4. Can all the insurance related requirements and bureaucratic measures (taking out an insurance, payments etc.)
be done digitally?
a) Who would be responsible for paying the insurance contributions?
b) Are the contributions paid by withheld at source?
5. Very often gig work is a complement, a side income. In this case, assuming that the gig work only is a side income;
would it change the requirement for statutory social insurance if the person were already insured through another
employment:
a) As an employee?
b) As an entrepreneur, as self-employed?
4
6. Bearing in mind that gig work is often a side income, what are the thresholds regarding statutory social insurance
(please refer to them as €/month) for the self-employed?
Need to be insured If need to be insured then
Risk
No Yes threshold € / month
Disability/invalidity benefits in cash
Old age pensions
Compensation in case of occupational injuries and occupational
diseases
Occupational Safety and Health (OSH) inspection and preventive
intervention
Parental (leave) benefits
Unemployment benefits
Healthcare
– Benefits in kind such as Inpatient and outpatient treatment;
Medicines, medical devices, therapeutic products; Early screening,
Health promotion and prevention (vaccination, cancer screening,
prophylaxis)
– Benefits in cash sickness benefit
Long-term Care
– Benefits in kind such as Inpatient and outpatient treatment,
Medicines, medical devices, therapeutic products
– Benefits in cash care allowance
Social Inclusion benefits in cash (for instance social aid/social
assistance) in this respect:
– Benefits linked to active participation in the labour market
("workfare") – in contrast to universal social inclusion benefits
– Means testing of social inclusion benefits against income drawn
out of platform work – general or special thresholds?
Case 2: Locally delivered platform work (Foodora)
In this case the platform also makes the link between the client and the provider, but the service is physically
delivered. The client doesn’t necessarily choose the provider. The platform makes the prices and distributes
the work to the providers (employees or independent).
The platforms where work is delivered locally might have some more degree of control that it exerts on the
execution of work than those platforms where work is conducted digitally. Also, national authorities have
more power to govern work that is conducted locally. Therefore issues related to conformity with regulations
(paying contributions justly, right form of employment category) arise more often in this kind of platform work.
The food delivery service platform Foodora is active in most of ESIP member countries. Using the foodora app,
website or the corporate platform, customers can browse local restaurants; place an order that will be delivered
by a bike courier or delivery driver. In the Foodora platform individuals (self-employed or employees) seek
for employment to deliver the orders. Their business model varies between countries and cities, in some cases
they are formally employed by foodora and in some they are not.
In this example, Foodora takes the commands from the clients, makes the prices of the services and distributes
the orders to the providers who collect the food commands by the restaurants and deliver them to the clients.
5
7. In terms of social insurance is this kind of gig worker (working for Foodora) regarded as a self-employed or an
employee? Or other (please specify)?
8. Are there any requirements to the buyer of labour concerning social insurance?
a) Is the respective activity of the ”provider” in this function covered by statutory insurance or other form social
security – branch by branch If yes: is it mandatory, or voluntary?
b) Who has to pay the contributions – the provider, the user, the platform?
c) What is the basis for the calculation of the contributions? For instance: The incoming gross fees, or the net
income, maybe after deduction of tax-allowable or professional deductions
9. As digital work is done on Internet, escaping the traditional regulatory framework, reporting is often dependent
on the conscientiousness of the individual, what kind of follow-up mechanisms exist to ensure that the person
insures her/his gainful activities properly?
10. Can all the insurance related requirements and bureaucratic measures (taking out an insurance, payments etc.)
be done digitally? Who would be responsible for paying the insurance contributions? Are the contributions paid
by withheld at source?
11. Very often gig work is a complement, a side income. In this case, assuming that the gig work only is a side income;
would it change the requirement for statutory social insurance if the person were already insured through another
employment:
a) As an employee?
b) As an entrepreneur, as self-employed?
6
12. Bearing in mind that gig work is often a side income, what are the thresholds regarding statutory social insurance
(please refer to them as €/month)?
Need to be insured If need to be insured then
Risk
No Yes threshold € / month
Disability/invalidity benefits in cash
Old age pensions
Compensation in case of occupational injuries and occupational
diseases
Occupational Safety and Health (OSH) inspection and preventive
intervention
Parental (leave) benefits
Unemployment benefits
Healthcare
– Benefits in kind such as Inpatient and outpatient treatment;
Medicines, medical devices, therapeutic products; Early screening,
Health promotion and prevention (vaccination, cancer screening,
prophylaxis)
– Benefits in cash sickness benefit
Long-term Care
– Benefits in kind such as Inpatient and outpatient treatment,
Medicines, medical devices, therapeutic products
– Benefits in cash care allowance
Social Inclusion benefits in cash (for instance social aid/social
assistance) in this respect:
– Benefits linked to active participation in the labour market
("workfare") – in contrast to universal social inclusion benefits
– Means testing of social inclusion benefits against income drawn
out of platform work – general or special thresholds?
Case 3: Uber, transport of people
If any company has been at the forefront in the era of digital platforms, it has been Uber. Uber is a company
providing ride sharing services, often being able to provide cheaper rides than traditional taxis. Put it simply,
Uber’s online platform enables passengers to find drivers to arrange a ride. Traditionally taxi services have
been locally and geographically regulated creating barriers to entry. Currently, Uber is present in all European
countries and it is therefore important to look at how different countries are regulating this platform.
The case Uber is not fundamentally different from case 2, but it is one of the most famous platforms and in
different countries, there are several cases that are still in progress before courts. So it is interesting to have a
special focus on it.
As for case 2 the platform makes the link between the clients and the providers, sets the prices, distributes
the work to the provider, and the service is physically delivered. The platform also evaluates the quality of the
labour and service.
7
13. Are drivers in a classical environment (taxi) treated differently compared to drivers working over digital platforms
when it comes to social security (see risks)? If yes – what is the reasoning?
14. Requirements concerning social insurance
a) Is the respective activity of the ”provider” in this function covered by statutory insurance or other form social
security – branch by branch. If yes: is it mandatory, or voluntary?
b) Who has to pay the contributions – the provider, the user, the platform?
c) What is the basis for the calculation of the contributions? For instance: The incoming gross fees, or the net
income, maybe after deduction of tax-allowable or professional deductions.
15. As digital work is done on Internet, escaping the traditional regulatory framework, reporting is often dependent
on the conscientiousness of the individual, what kind of follow-up mechanisms exist to ensure that the person
insures her/his gainful activities properly?
16. Can all the insurance related requirements and bureaucratic measures (taking out an insurance, payments etc.)
be done digitally? Who would be responsible for paying the insurance contributions? Are the contributions paid
through withhold tax?
17. Very often gig work is a complement, a side income. In this case, assuming that the gig work only is a side income;
would it change the requirement for statutory social insurance if the person were already insured through another
employment:
a) As an employee?
b)As an entrepreneur, as self-employed?
8
18. If they are considered as self-employed against which risks do they have to be insured?
Need to be insured If need to be insured then
Risk
No Yes threshold € / month
Disability/invalidity benefits in cash
Old age pensions
Compensation in case of occupational injuries and occupational
diseases
Occupational Safety and Health (OSH) inspection and preventive
intervention
Parental (leave) benefits
Unemployment benefits
Healthcare
– Benefits in kind such as Inpatient and outpatient treatment;
Medicines, medical devices, therapeutic products; Early screening,
Health promotion and prevention (vaccination, cancer screening,
prophylaxis)
– Benefits in cash sickness benefit
Long-term Care
– Benefits in kind such as Inpatient and outpatient treatment,
Medicines, medical devices, therapeutic products
– Benefits in cash care allowance
Social Inclusion benefits in cash (for instance social aid/social
assistance) in this respect:
– benefits linked to active participation in the labour market
("workfare") – in contrast to universal social inclusion benefits
– means testing of social inclusion benefits against income drawn
out of platform work – general or special thresholds?
9
PART II
Public policy choices, on-going debates and legislative proposals
Although every country has their unique way of organizing statutory social insurance and very often solutions
of other countries are not transposable elsewhere as such, it is of vital importance to hear about on-going
debates, policy initiatives and even legislative proposals. Good practices in some of our member organizations
might help other members to find good solutions to be implemented in their own systems.
1. In your opinion, which are the most widely discussed online platforms in your country? Could you name a few
and their field of business? What kind of jobs do they offer?
2. Are there any innovative practice in your country regarding platform work and social insurance?
a) E.g. that seeks to ensure that gig workers are properly insured
b) Any policy/method that “nudges” gig workers to pay for contributions?
3. Are there any legislative proposals in the pipeline that target platform work? Are trade unions or employer
organizations active in discussing gig economy?
4. What kind of initiatives have been implemented / discussed to facilitate digital platforms to operate?
5. Are there any on-going debates concerning gig work and how it should be regulated? Any serious discussions
of creating a new “status” in social insurance?
6. Are there any awareness raising campaigns regarding platform work and social insurance? If yes, who is the
main audience and what are the main targets of these campaigns?
10
PART III
Quantitative dimension of platform work
According to Kässi and Lehdonvirta (2016) it is widely recognized both in the research literature as well as among
policy makers that existing economic statistics are not well suited to measuring the online gig economy. Existing
labour market statistics in particular are missing online work because of definitional and measurement issues.
Statistical agencies count as employed anyone gainfully employed for at least one hour either in a week or a
day (Hussmanns 2007). Kässi and Lehdonvirta (2016) point out that this measure is problematic as it does not
capture any incremental effects of online work – if someone already has a job and does a second job online,
their efforts are not captured in employment statistics. Also, it is also not clear to what extent online workers
choose to report their earnings to tax agencies, especially if the earnings are small.
The Oxford Online Labour Index has some data but not on a national level.
However, to be able to analyze the size of the phenomenon more quantitative data is needed. One possible
source could be the annual financial reports of the relevant platforms.
1. Are there data/estimates on how many people are registered to different online platforms? Do any data exists on
the amount of the buyer of the labour service? Any data on hours worked through platform?
2. Are there data/estimates how many of these people are active in the online platforms?
3. Are there data on job postings in online platforms?
4. Are there any other statistics/quantitative data used in your country to evaluate the popularity of platform work?
5. What kind of initiatives have been implemented to improve the quantitative measure of platform work?
11
PART IV
National regulations related to work in private households and “homework”
Majority of digitally delivered platform work can be done from anywhere, very often this kind of work is conducted
at home. Therefore it is important to assess the existing regulations concerning “telework” or “homework”.
1. To what extent is homework/telework covered in your country by labour inspections and occupational health
and safety rules/inspections?
2. Are there any rules charging a private household-owner who is using at a low scale a household-attendant with
employer like responsibilities?*
* The sense of this question is to understand if there are any examples for “micro-jobs”, commissioned by private end users, that are legally held
to constitute an employment-like status, including the responsibility to pay social contributions.
Any other issues you would like to point out regarding this questionnaire or the future of work:
12
References
JP Morgan Chase Institute (2016) Paychecks, paydays, and the online platform economy: Big data on income volatility,
February 2016
https://www.jpmorganchase.com/corporate/institute/document/jpmc-institute-volatility-2-report.pdf
(retrieved 13.3.2017)
Konkolewsky, Hans-Horst (2016) Does Uber signal the end of social security? ILO blog post
https://iloblog.org/2016/07/28/does-uber-signal-the-end-of-social-security/ (retrieved 25.2.2017)
Kässi, Otto & Lehdonvirta, Vili (2016) Online Labour Index: Measuring the Online Gig Economy for Policy and Research.
Paper presented at Internet, Politics & Policy 2016, Oxford, UK, 22-23 September.
http://ilabour.oii.ox.ac.uk/online-labour-index/
McKinsey Global Institute (2016) Independent Work: Choice, Necessity, and the Gig Economy, October 2016
http://www.mckinsey.com/global-themes/employment-and-growth/independent-work-choice-necessity-and-the-gig-
economy (retrieved 13.3.2017)
Palun registreerige! Tänan.
From: Väänänen Niko [mailto:
[email protected]]
Sent: Wednesday, April 4, 2018 3:40 PM
To: Triin Uusberg <
[email protected]>
Subject: Questionnaire on digital platform work
Dear Mrs. Uusberg,
I am writing to you on behalf of European Social Insurance Platform (ESIP). We are an alliance of
statutory social insurers in the EU. We are currently working on a questionnaire on digital platform
work and what challenge it may pose to social insurance.
We have drafted a questionnaire that has been sent to our members and they have responded to
them. However, we lack a member from Estonia and therefore I approach you if the Ministry could
consider in answering the questionnaire on behalf of Estonia. Estonia’s reputation when it comes
to digitalization is well known and many of our members would like to see how your country deals
with this issue that is becoming bigger and bigger on the EU agenda. I know, at first look the
questionnaire looks long but it is rather quick to answer.
If you have time to answer the questionnaire, we would be glad to share with you our final results
once we have compiled all the answers.
Please do not hesitate to contact me in case of any questions.
Wishing you a nice day,
Best regards,
Niko Väänänen
Senior Advisor
Finnish Centre for Pensions | Planning Department
[email protected]
Tel. + 358 29 411 2325
Mobile + 358 50 521 9249
FI-00065 ELÄKETURVAKESKUS, Finland
twitter: @NikoVaananen
Etk.fi – About Pensions for Experts