11-<<-'"
ROTTERDAM CONVEN'!10N
Food and Agriculture
Organization of the
United Nations
UN ~··4
.
environmen1
~A~
~
United Nations
Environment Programml
ROTTERDAM CONVENTION
Secretariat ot the Rotterdam ConvenHon Secretariat of the Rotterdam ConvenHon
United Nations Environment Programme Food and Agriculture Organizatio n 01 the United Nations
International Environment House I Viale delle Terme di Caracalla. 00153 Rome. Italy
11-13. Chemin des Anemones. CH 12 19 Ch6telaine. Geneva. Switzerland Tel: +390657052061 i Fax: +390657053224 i E-mail: p ic@la o.org
Tel: +41 (0) 229 17 8271 i Fax: +41 (0) 229 178098 i E-mail : oo@brsmea s.org
COMMUNICATION
INVITATION TO COMMENT ON THE REPORT ANALYSING THE LEGAL AND
OPERATIONAL IMPLICATIONS OF PRIORITY ACTIONS TO ENHANCE THE
EFFECTIVENESS OF THE ROTTERDAM CONVENTION
The eighth meeting of the Conference of the Parties to the Rotterdam Convention, in decision RC-8/8,
requested the Secretariat to develop an online survey to gather information on (i) priority actions to enhance the
effectiveness of the Convention, and (ii) key information gaps related to point (i) . Parties have responded to this
survey and the results are available on the Convention website:
http://www. pic.intlImp lementationlEnhancingtheeffectivenessoftheConventionlOnlinesurveyltabidl 621S/langua
ge/en- USlDefault.aspx
Furthermore, the Conference requested the Secretariat to prepare by IS January 2018 a report analysing
the legal and operational implications of the priority actions identified by Parties. Pursuant to paragraph 4 of
decision RC-8 /8, this report is now being made available to Parties and others for comments by 31 March 2018.
The report and comments received thereon will be considered by a working group, with membership composed
of representatives from Parties and open to participation by non-Party States, which is mandated to (i) identify,
on the basis of the above mentioned report and comments received thereon, a set of prioritized recommendations
for enhancing the effectiveness of the Convention, and (ii) develop a report identifying further steps for
consideration by the Conference of the Parties at its ninth meeting.
Parties and others are invited to submit their comments on the attached report to the Secretariat
by email by 31 March 2018 to Ms. Andrea Lechner (
[email protected]) and Ms. Christine
Fuell (
[email protected]). For Parties, one consolidated response should be submitted to the Secretariat
through the Rotterdam Convention Official Contact Point.
If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact us. We thank you in advance for your kind
cooperation.
Secretariat of the Rotterdam Convention
Geneva, IS January 2018
To: Official Contact Points of Parties to the Rotterdam Convention
Observers to the Rotterdam Convention
cc: Representatives of Permanent Missions to the United Nations in Geneva
Permanent representatives to the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
Designated National Authorities of Parties to the Rotterdam Convention
Encl.
Report on legal and operational implications of priority actions to
enhance the effectiveness of the Rotterdam Convention
1
Contents
Abbreviations and acronyms ................................................................................................................... 3
Introduction ............................................................................................................................................. 4
Part I – Background and next steps ......................................................................................................... 4
Part II – Proposed actions and their legal and operational implications .................................................. 5
Category A: The listing process ................................................................................................... 7
1. Actions to improve the adoption of FRAs ............................................................. 7
2. Actions to improve the notifications of FRAs ..................................................... 10
3. Actions to improve the identification of SHPFs .................................................. 11
4. Actions to enhance the process of drafting and adoption of recommendations
and draft DGDs by the CRC ................................................................................ 11
5. Actions to facilitate consensus-finding at the COP ............................................. 14
6. Actions to amend the decision-making process for listing chemicals ................. 18
Category B: The PIC procedure ................................................................................................. 23
1. Actions to improve compliance with the obligation to transmit export
notifications ......................................................................................................... 23
2. Actions to improve Parties’ provision of import responses ................................. 24
3. Actions to improve Parties’ control of chemicals imports ................................... 24
4. Actions to improve the implementation of the PIC procedure in general ............ 26
Category C: Overall effectiveness of the Convention ................................................................ 28
1. Actions to promote awareness at the national level ............................................. 28
2. Actions to improve information-exchange between Parties and the Secretariat
and between Parties ............................................................................................. 29
3. Actions to determine and address non-compliance with the provisions of the
Convention .......................................................................................................... 32
4. Actions to improve Parties’ adoption of national action plans (NAP) ................. 33
5. Actions to improve Parties’ enactment of legislation implementing the
Convention .......................................................................................................... 33
6. Actions to strengthen Parties’ institutions for national implementation .............. 34
7. Actions to improve the availability of technical assistance and capacity-
building in general ............................................................................................... 35
8. Actions to improve the availability of funding for national implementation ....... 39
9. Actions to improve synergies with the Basel and Stockholm Conventions ......... 41
Appendix ............................................................................................................................................... 42
2
Abbreviations and acronyms
COP Conference of the Parties to the Rotterdam Convention
CRC Chemical Review Committee
DGD Decision Guidance Document
DNA Rotterdam Convention designated national authority
EU European Union
FAO Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
FRA final regulatory action
GCI Green Customs Initiative
GRULAC Group of Latin American and Caribbean Countries in the United Nations
HS code Harmonized System Code
HSG Health and Safety Guide
IPCS International Programme on Chemical Safety of the World Health Organization
MEA multilateral environmental agreement
MoU memorandum of understanding
NAP national action plan
NIOSH National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OCP Rotterdam Convention official contact point
OECD Organisation for Economic co-operation and Development
PA priority action
PIC prior informed consent
POPRC Persistent Organic Pollutants Review Committee of the Stockholm Convention
SDG Sustainable Development Goal
SHPF severely hazardous pesticide formulation
TA technical assistance
ToRs terms of reference
WCO World Customs Organization
WTO World Trade Organization
WHO World Health Organization
3
Introduction
1. By decision RC-8/8, the eighth meeting of the Conference of the Parties to the Rotterdam
Convention (COP-8) invited Parties to propose priority actions to enhance the effectiveness of the
Convention and requested the Secretariat to prepare a report analysing the legal and operational
implications of the proposed priority actions.
2. This report is divided into two parts. Part I provides an overview of the survey and the process
for the compilation of the proposed actions from Parties, as well as a summary of the Parties that
provided responses along with some next steps. Part II consists of a tabular summary of the proposed
actions identified by the respondents, as well as related information gaps and potential legal and
operational implications. A full compilation of the submissions is available on the Convention’s
website.1
3. An Appendix to this document provides an overview on the main procedural steps of the
process for listing chemicals in Annex III to the Convention as well as of the prior informed consent
(PIC) procedure.
Part I – Background and next steps
4. In line with decision RC-8/8, the Secretariat developed an online survey in English, French and
Spanish asking Parties:
(a) To describe a maximum of 5 (five) priority actions that could be undertaken to
enhance the effectiveness of the Rotterdam Convention; and
(b) To indicate key information gaps for each of the identified priority actions.
5. Parties were invited to complete the online survey by 31 October 2017, as decided by the COP.
Submissions were received until 15 November 2017.
6. As of 15 November 2017, the Secretariat received 24 responses from Parties to the Rotterdam
Convention (including the European Union (EU) on behalf of its 28 member States), from 33
developed countries (OECD and EU member States) and 18 developing countries or countries with
economies in transition (Africa 2, Asia and Pacific 7, Central and Eastern Europe 2, Latin America
and Caribbean 7). There were no responses from small island developing countries. The response rate
was 32 per cent.2
7. The results of the survey form the basis for the present report.
8. The following table summarizes the level of response per region based on the number of
Parties in each region:
Africa 2 out of 47 Parties Republic of the Congo, Uganda
Asia-Pacific 8 out of 38 Parties Afghanistan, Bahrain, China, Jordan, Kuwait, Sri Lanka,
(includes 1 as Yemen
coordinated
As coordinated response through the EU: Cyprus
response through
the EU)
Central and 13 out of 22 Bosnia and Herzegovina, the former Yugoslav Republic of
Eastern Parties (includes Macedonia
Europe and 11 as coordinated
As coordinated response through the EU: Bulgaria, Croatia,
Central Asia response through
Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Poland,
the EU)
Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia
Latin America 8 out of 28 Parties Colombia, Costa Rica, Ecuador, Honduras, Mexico, Panama,
and Caribbean Peru, Venezuela
Western 20 out of 23 Australia, Canada, Norway, Switzerland
Europe and Parties (includes
1
The compilation of submissions to the survey on priority action to enhance the effectiveness of the Rotterdam
Convention is available at
http://www.pic.int/Implementation/EnhancingtheeffectivenessofRC/Onlinesurvey/tabid/6215/language/en-
US/Default.aspx.
2
As of 15 November 2017, 158 States and the European Union were Parties to the Rotterdam Convention.
4
Others 16 as coordinated As coordinated response through the EU: Austria, Belgium,
response through Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy,
the EU) Luxembourg, Malta, Netherlands, Portugal, Spain, Sweden,
United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland
9. Next Steps: This report and comments received thereon will be considered by a working group
established by decision RC-8/8, with the mandate:
(a) To identify a set of prioritized recommendations for enhancing the effectiveness of the
Convention, and
(b) To develop a report identifying further steps for consideration by the Conference of
the Parties at its ninth meeting.
10. In order to put the elements of the report in context, the Appendix to this document includes a
diagram on the main steps of the process of listing an industrial chemical, a pesticide or a severely
hazardous pesticide formulation (SHPF) in Annex III of the Convention.
11. The diagram specifies the legal basis for each step of the listing process and the PIC procedure,
and the procedural requirements that would need to be met in order to implement the proposed action
within the framework of the Convention (e.g. adoption of a COP decision, developing or amending an
annex of the Convention, amending the text of the Convention).
Part II – Proposed actions and their legal and operational implications
12. A table summarizing the priority actions proposed has been prepared. The proposed actions
have been clustered into the three main categories3 for enhancing the effectiveness of the Convention
identified by decision RC-8/8:
Category A: The listing process
1) Actions to improve the adoption of final regulatory actions (FRA);
2) Actions to improve the notifications of FRAs;
3) Actions to improve the identification of SHPFs;
4) Actions to enhance the process of drafting and adoption of recommendations
and draft decision guidance documents (DGDs) by the Chemical Review
Committee (CRC);
5) Actions to facilitate consensus-finding at the COP;
6) Actions to amend the decision-making process for listing chemicals;
Category B: The PIC procedure
1) Actions to improve compliance with the obligation to transmit export
notifications;
2) Actions to improve Parties’ provision of import responses;
3) Actions to improve Parties’ control of chemicals imports;
4) Actions to improve the implementation of the PIC procedure in general;
Category C: Overall effectiveness of the Convention
1) Actions to promote awareness at the national level;
3
In addition, Norway’s response to the survey (PA-1) includes specific suggestions on how the working group
could proceed in accomplishing this mandate. With regard to the question of membership, Norway mentions that
developing countries may face unique challenges in relation to imports and exports of hazardous chemicals, the
environmentally sound management of those chemicals and the implementation of the Convention. However,
only a limited number of developing country Parties had participated in intersessional work leading up to the eight
meeting of the Conference of the Parties. It is therefore important to consider, as part of this intersessional work
process, information from a broader range of developing countries on the benefits of the Convention, as well as on
actions that would make the Convention more valuable to them. If not provided in response to the survey, such
information could actively be pursued, for example, through the Secretariat. Norway also emphasizes the
importance of narrowing down the list of proposals and options collected so far, which should be the main focus
of the intersessional work ahead. In this context, it seems important to distinguish between proposals that fall
within the scope of the Convention text or mandate of the CRC and those that do not.
5
2) Actions to improve information-exchange between Parties and the Secretariat
and between Parties;
3) Actions to determine and address non-compliance with the provisions of the
Convention;
4) Actions to improve Parties’ adoption of national actions plans;
5) Actions to improve Parties’ enactment of legislation implementing the
Convention;
6) Actions to strengthen Parties’ institutions for national implementation;
7) Actions to improve the availability of technical assistance and capacity-
building in general;
8) Actions to improve the availability of funding for national implementation;
9) Actions to improve synergies with the Basel and Stockholm Conventions.
13. The tabular summary is structured as follows:
Column 1 lists the actions proposed.
Column 2 provides a summary of the proposed action (PA) and the number assigned to it by
the Party (1 to 5).4
Column 3 lists the corresponding key information gaps as identified by Parties.
Column 4 includes a summary of potential legal and operational implications, other than
financial implications. The Secretariat has focused on identifying the proposed actions that fall within
the scope of the Rotterdam Convention, there may be other options for action that fall outside the
scope of the Convention.
4
The full text of the submissions is available in the compilation of answers at
http://www.pic.int/Implementation/EnhancingtheeffectivenessofRC/Onlinesurvey/tabid/6215/language/en-
US/Default.aspx.
6
Category A: The listing process
Ref. Priority actions Summary of priority actions Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
1. Actions to improve the adoption of FRAs
110 Improve – Ecuador (PA-1) proposes measures – High staff turnover in Rotterdam Implementation through the technical assistance (TA) plan and/or as part of
5
information-exchange to improve the exchange of basic Convention official contact points the development of the clearing-house mechanism for information-exchange.
and access to basic information to help Parties present FRA (OCP) (Ecuador)
information by notifications that fulfil the listing criteria. – Impossibility for Parties to check
increased use of The Secretariat should provide tools to whether they have pending activities or
information and developing countries using available outstanding information to submit
communication information and communication (Ecuador)
technology tools technologies (video tutorials, apps, online – Lack of offer of interactive
assessments) to facilitate access to quality trainings to ensure adequate
information as a basis for decision-making. information flow (Ecuador)
111 Improve – Peru (PA-3) proposes that a survey – Lack of reliable and accessible Implementation through a COP decision requesting the Secretariat to
information-exchange to collect information on the health and source of information on regulatory circulate this information (the text of the Convention only requires circulation
on FRAs environmental reasons that purported the measures taken by Parties with respect of a summary).
FRA and the national situation of the to chemicals for which they submitted 6
regulated chemical (registration, an FRA (Peru) Note: The CRC Handbook currently provides that for all notifications that
commercial names, production and import are verified as complete by the Secretariat, a letter is sent to the notifying
volume, uses, concentrations, crops, country with a request to submit the supporting documentation referenced in
available alternatives, etc.) should be their notifications and if possible a focused summary. Focused summaries
circulated to a Party submitting an FRA and, depending on its volume, supporting documentation are translated into
immediately after submission of that FRA English upon receipt, and made available as meeting papers for the CRC.
and not only when a second FRA for the
same chemical has been received from a
different PIC region. That information
could then be shared with all Parties.
112 7 8
Improve national – Peru (PA-1) suggests improving the – Weaknesses in the chemicals Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 15.2 and 16 of the
capacity to generate and national capacity of Parties to generate and registration system and the monitoring Convention.
use information on compile information on health and system for chemical poisoning (Peru)
5
See decision RC-8/12 on the clearing-house mechanism for information exchange.
6
The Handbook of working procedure and policy guidance for the CRC (English) is available at
http://www.pic.int/TheConvention/ChemicalReviewCommittee/Guidance/tabid/1060/language/en-US/Default.aspx.
7
Article 15.2 of the Rotterdam Convention provides that “[e]ach Party shall ensure, to the extent practicable, that the public has appropriate access to information on chemical handling
and accident management and on alternatives that are safer for human health or the environment than the chemicals listed in Annex III.”
8
Article 16 of the Rotterdam Convention provides that Parties with more advanced programmes for regulating chemicals should provide technical assistance, including training, to
other Parties in developing their infrastructure and capacity to manage chemicals throughout their life-cycle.
7
Ref. Priority actions Summary of priority actions Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
health and environmental impacts to allow for the – Environmental monitoring does Activities to assist Parties in improving their capacity to generate and use this
environmental impacts adoption of FRAs on the basis of quality not focus on risk evaluations (Peru) information could also be part of the implementation of the TA plan.
information. – Lack of expertise for bridging
information in support of and FRA Note: For pesticides, the SHPF kit includes guidance on collecting data on
(Peru) pesticide poisoning (English), the guidelines on developing a reporting
system for health and environmental incidents regulating from exposure to
pesticides (English) of the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United
Nations (FAO), the guide for state-based programs on pesticide-related
illness and injury surveillance of the National Institute for Occupational
Safety and Health (NIOSH) and a number of case studies and field tools
9
(English).
Additionally, the Secretariat has developed a Final Regulatory Action
10
Evaluation Toolkit (FRA Evaluation Toolkit) that contains references to
tools for risk evaluation, including on hazard identification and classification,
developed by various agencies, as well as access to risk evaluation of toxic
substances carried out by Parties that have satisfied the criteria of Annex II of
the Convention.
113 11 12
Assist developing – Colombia (PA-1) proposes that – No or limited registration systems Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 15.1 (a) and 16 of the
Parties and Parties with developing countries and countries with and administrative instruments to Convention.
economies in transition economies in transition should receive control the production, import and use
in collecting key technical and financial assistance to realise of chemicals, which makes it difficult Activities to assist Parties in establishing inventories on candidate chemicals
information at the early inventories on uses, risks and to identify the implications of listing. could also be part of the implementation of the TA plan.
national level before incidents at the national level of chemical and
consideration of the products that the Secretariat decides to to implement the PIC procedure for that
chemical by the CRC refer to the CRC. This will enable chemical. This lack of information and
developing countries and countries with uncertainty on capacity makes it
economies in transition to provide relevant difficult to identify alternatives, against
information, actively participate in the the concerns of producers and/or users,
work of the CRC, and adopt informed which may lead to situation where that
positions at the COP. country opposes listing at the COP
9
The FAO Guidelines on Developing a Reporting System for Health and Environmental Incidents Resulting from Exposure to Pesticides, the NIOSH Publication on Pesticide-Related
Illness and Injury Surveillance: A How-To Guide for State-based Programs and the case studies and field tools are available at
http://www.pic.int/Implementation/SeverelyHazardousPesticideFormulations/SHPFKit/AdditionalInformation/tabid/3148/language/en-US/Default.aspx.
10
The Final Regulatory Action Evaluation Toolkit is available at
http://www.pic.int/Implementation/FinalRegulatoryActions/FRAEvaluationToolkit/Introduction/tabid/4976/language/en-US/Default.aspx.
11
Article 15.1 of the Rotterdam Convention provides that “[e]ach Party shall take such measures as may be necessary to establish and strengthen its national infrastructures and
institutions for the effective implementation of this Convention. These measures may include, as required, the adoption or amendment of national legislative or administrative measures
and may also include: (a) The establishment of national registers and databases including safety information for chemicals.”
12
See footnote 8.
8
Ref. Priority actions Summary of priority actions Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
(Colombia)
114 Develop guidance – China (PA-1) suggests that the – Lack of sufficient scientific Implementation through the development of scientific guidance (COP
on bridging information Secretariat publish a guideline document information for the assessments of risk decision).
to support FRAs on the bridging method for risk evaluations associated with the use of chemicals,
with corresponding trainings to improve (particularly in developing countries) Note: Available guidance includes the paper on bridging information in the
13
the ability of chemical risk assessment in (China) CRC Handbook and some guidance available through the FRA Evaluation
14
developing countries and to enable them to – Lack of resources for the Toolkit.
provide a scientific decision basis for FRA assessment of chemicals for which data
notifications. is available (particularly in developing
countries) (China)
115 Develop guidance – Sri Lanka (PA-1) proposes that – Absence of a mechanism to link Implementation through the development of scientific guidance (COP
on using data on although intentional misuse is not a and report cases of pesticide poisoning decision).
pesticide suicides to sufficient criteria for a listing decision other than suicides (Sri Lanka)
identify chemicals for under the Rotterdam Convention, such data Note: The SHPF kit includes guidance on collecting data on pesticide
FRAs could be used as an early warning tool to poisoning (English), the FAO guidelines on developing a reporting system
identify pesticides for FRAs. Sri Lanka’s for health and environmental incidents regulating from exposure to pesticides
notifications of endosulfan (1998) and (English), the NIOSH guide for state-based programs on pesticide-related
paraquat (2011) did not meet listing illness and injury surveillance (English) and a number of case studies and
15
criterion (b)(iii) because Sri Lanka has no field tools.
monitoring system for poisonings other
than in case of suicide.
116 16 17
Train national – Honduras (PA-4) proposes trainings – Lack of resources for conducting Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 15.1 and 16 of the
experts in performing for technical personnel in conducting risk risk evaluations and therefore inability Convention.
risk evaluations to serve evaluations for chemicals that may serves to adopt and submit FRAs (Honduras)
as a basis for FRAs as a basis for FRAs. Activities to assist Parties in performing risk evaluations could also be part
of the implementation of the TA plan.
Note: The resource kit includes a WHO/IPCS publication and projects on risk
assessment methodology (English) and OECD guidelines for testing
18
chemicals (English).
13
The Handbook of working procedure and policy guidance for the CRC (English) is available at
http://www.pic.int/TheConvention/ChemicalReviewCommittee/Guidance/tabid/1060/language/en-US/Default.aspx.
14
The Final Regulatory Action Evaluation Toolkit is available at
http://www.pic.int/Implementation/FinalRegulatoryActions/FRAEvaluationToolkit/Introduction/tabid/4976/language/en-US/Default.aspx.
15
See footnote 9.
16
Article 15.1 of the Rotterdam Convention provides that “[e]ach Party shall take such measures as may be necessary to establish and strengthen its national infrastructures and
institutions for the effective implementation of this Convention.”
17
See footnote 8.
9
Ref. Priority actions Summary of priority actions Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
117 19
Organize – Bosnia and Herzegovina (PA-2) – Lack of a mechanism and Implementation by individual Parties under Article 15.3 of the Convention.
subregional meetings to identifies the organization of a subregional conditions for the adoption of FRAs at
discuss region-specific meeting to discuss options for the the national level, as FRAs from the Activities to assist Parties in resolving regional implementation difficulties
difficulties development of mechanisms and EU are used (Bosnia and Herzegovina) could be part of the implementation of the TA plan.
conditions for the adoptions of FRAs as a Note: In the case of the submitting Party (Bosnia and Herzegovina), the
means to address the country’s difficulties meeting is already planned.
in submitting FRAs.
2. Actions to improve the notifications of FRAs
120 20
Provide Party-to- – Canada (PA-5) believes that a way to – Self-identification of Parties that Implementation by individual Parties under Article 16 of the Convention.
Party assistance to enhance the effectiveness of the wish to obtain support. The process of
adequately document Convention is to provide in-kind support self-identification could be launched at
the decision-making (as offered by Canada) for risk evaluations the upcoming intersessional working
process and documentation of that evaluation and group meeting (Canada)
the national decision-making process, to – Identification of type of
prepare complete notifications of FRAs. support/training needed (webinars, site
This would produce a more comprehensive visits etc.) (Canada)
basis for the work of the CRC and more
robust CRC recommendations.
121 Make available – Switzerland (PA-3) suggests – Few notified FRAs based on risk Implementation through the development of scientific guidance and/or update
commented examples of including in the FRA Evaluation Toolkit a evaluations that are not risk of the FRA Evaluation Toolkit.
risk evaluations not list of commented summaries of risk assessments have so far fulfilled
based on risk evaluations that are not risk assessments criterion (b)(iii) (Switzerland) Note: Available guidance includes the paper on bridging information
21
assessments that fulfil that fulfil criterion (b)(iii). available in the CRC Handbook to assist the CRC in judging the
criterion (b)(iii) acceptability of a notification of FRAs, with respect to criterion (b)(iii),
where the notifying Party has used a risk evaluation from another country.
122 Establish an – Switzerland (PA-3) proposes the – Possible need of some Parties to Implementation through a COP decision requesting the Secretariat to
expert team to assist in establishment of a team of experts that can benefit from assistance when drafting a develop, based on nominations from Parties, a roster of experts willing to
questions related to the be consulted for questions on the FRA notification (Switzerland) provide this service, or through the establishment of a new subsidiary body
submission of FRAs notification of FRAs. by the COP under Article 18(5)(a) of the Convention.
18
The WHO/IPCS and OECD guidance is available at http://www.pic.int/Implementation/RessourcesKit/EvaluatingtheRisksofHazardousChemicals/tabid/1502/language/en-
US/Default.aspx.
19
Article 15.3 of the Rotterdam Convention provides that Parties agree to cooperate, directly or, where appropriate, through competent international organizations, in the
implementation of this Convention at the subregional, regional and global levels.
20
See footnote 8.
21
The Handbook of working procedure and policy guidance for the CRC (English) is available at
http://www.pic.int/TheConvention/ChemicalReviewCommittee/Guidance/tabid/1060/language/en-US/Default.aspx.
10
Ref. Priority actions Summary of priority actions Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
Activities could also be implemented by individual Parties under Articles
22 23
15.3 and 16 of the Convention.
3. Actions to improve the identification of SHPFs
130 24 25
Assist with – Sri Lanka (PA-3) highlights the need – Need for more refined data on Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 15.2 and 16 of the
identifying pesticide for further assistance to finalize a study on acute pesticide poisoning (Sri Lanka) Convention.
formulations that result pesticide formulations leading to acute
in acute poisoning at the poisoning in the occupational context at the Activities to assist Parties with identifying pesticide formulations posing
national level national level. A previous study on the problems under conditions of use could also be part of the
topic could not be finalised because of implementation of the TA plan.
financial constraints, and insufficient
Note: The SHPF kit includes guidance on collecting data on pesticide
coordination, cooperation and commitment
poisoning (English), the FAO the guidelines on developing a reporting
of stakeholders.
system for health and environmental incidents regulating from exposure to
pesticides (English), the NIOSH guide for state-based programs on pesticide-
related illness an d injury surveillance (English) and a number of case studies
26
and field tools.
4. Actions to enhance the process of drafting and adoption of recommendations and draft DGDs by the CRC
140 Strengthen the – Honduras (PA-3) suggests Implementation processes will depend on the type of measures envisaged.
CRC strengthening the subsidiary organs of the
Convention.
141 Increase the – Venezuela (PA-5) proposes Implementation must be in line with Article 18.6 (b) of the Convention (CRC
number of CRC increasing the number of CRC members to is a body with a “limited” number of experts) and requires the adoption of a
27
members include more views and improve COP decision amending paragraph 1 of the Terms of Reference (ToRs) of
information-exchange between the the CRC.
different regions.
142 Increase – Norway (PA-3) suggests
transparency in the strengthening the CRC by further
work of the CRC increasing the transparency of its work, for
22
See footnote 19.
23
See footnote 8.
24
See footnote 7.
25
See footnote 8.
26
See footnote 9.
27
Paragraph 1 of the ToRs states that the CRC is composed of 31 members. The ToRs are set out in decision RC-1/6.
11
Ref. Priority actions Summary of priority actions Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
example through the following actions:
28
Considering the need for Implementation through a COP decision amending paragraph 10 of the
translating/interpreting documents and ToRs of the CRC.
proceedings in all six languages
Considering opening the CRC Implementation through a COP decision supplementing the ToRs of the CRC
for further involvement of observers by or mandating the CRC to complement/amend its working procedures to that
allowing early comments on task group effect.
reports, inviting comments on Decision
Note: The diagram in the Appendix provides an overview on opportunities
Guidance Documents (DGD), and allowing
for non-members to provide comments on task group report and draft DGDs
(e.g. Parties) to participate in intersessional
according to the current procedures.
work
Consider mechanism to ensure Implementation through a COP decision supplementing the ToRs of the CRC
optimal use of information that Parties that or mandating the CRC to complement/amend its working procedures to that
are not members of the CRC and that effect.
submitted an FRA for the considered
chemical may have at their disposition
143 Improve – Australia (PA-4) suggests
consistency of CRC considering ways to improve the
recommendations consistency with strategies and procedures
that strengthen the foundation of the
recommendations. Improving the
predictability in how the CRC operates will
improve the CRC recommendations, COP
decisions, CRC nominations and
compliance with the Convention more
broadly. Potential areas to explore include:
Increasing guidance on CRC Implementation through a COP decision supplementing the ToRs of the CRC
procedures or mandating the CRC to further specify its working procedures to that effect.
Entitling the CRC to seek Implementation through a COP decision supplementing the ToRs of the CRC
information from external experts, private or mandating the CRC to complement/amend its working procedures to that
sector and public interest bodies or non- effect.
member Parties to assist deliberations (as
in Persistent Organic Pollutants Review
28
Paragraph 10 refers to paragraph 17 of the ToRs of the interim CRC, which provides that the meetings are held in English only and draft DGDs to be considered by the CRC and
forwarded to the COP should be available in all six languages. The ToRs of the CRC are set out in decision RC-1/6.
12
Ref. Priority actions Summary of priority actions Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
Committee of the Stockholm Convention
29
(POPRC) )
144 Strengthen – Mexico (PA-2) suggests measures to – Scientific, technical and Implementation through a COP decision supplementing the ToRs of the CRC
technical, scientific strengthen the technical and scientific statistical data prepared by the CRC or mandating the CRC to complement/amend its working procedures to that
information in CRC justification of CRC recommendations, as could be more robust, such as by effect.
recommendation national and international companies have categorically documenting health and
questioned the validity and neutrality of environmental effects associated with
CRC decisions (e.g. case of paraquat). exposure to the candidate chemical
(Mexico)
145 Create a – Mexico (PA-3) proposes that Parties – Some Parties don’t have the Implementation through a COP decision mandating the CRC to
framework for the that do not share the recommendation of institutional capacity to defend their complement/amend its working procedures or work practice to that effect.
discussion of objections the CRC could back up their position with opposition to the recommendation
to the recommendation sufficient anticipation, so that the CRC and (Mexico) The CRC procedures cannot however create new obligations on Parties that
at the CRC level other Parties can evaluate the objections – Some Parties lack inter- are not in the Convention text. This would require following the amendment
and reformulate the recommendation, and ministerial coordination to take procedure enshrined in the Convention.
that Parties may consider the objections collective and consensual decisions
before the COP. (Mexico)
– No obligation on Parties that
oppose a listing recommendation to
support their position with technical
and scientific evidence (Mexico)
146 Supplement the – Norway (PA-4) proposes to
information available in strengthen the information exchange under
the DGD the Convention, including by:
30
Encouraging Parties to share Implementation by individual Parties under Article 14.1 (a) of the
additional information and where possible, Convention, for example, in combination with a COP decision encouraging
to include such information in DGDs; Parties to share information for the DGDs and/or establishment of
mechanisms to facilitate collection/submission of that information.
Including information from Implementation through a COP decision mandating the CRC to collect this
other MEAs and IGOs in the DGDs where information and complement the working procedures, if necessary.
relevant and possible.
Note: The CRC working papers for preparing DGDs for banned or severely
29
See in particular paragraphs 10 to 14 of the ToRs of the POPRC. The ToRs were adopted by decision SC-1/7 and amended by decisions SC-4/20 and SC-5/11 and are available for
downloading on the Stockholm Convention website at http://chm.pops.int/TheConvention/POPsReviewCommittee/OverviewandMandate/tabid/2806/Default.aspx
30
Article 14.1 of the Rotterdam Convention provides that each Party shall facilitate: (a) The exchange of scientific, technical, economic and legal information concerning the chemicals
within the scope of the Convention, including toxicological, ecotoxicological and safety information; (b) The provision of publicly available information on domestic regulatory
actions relevant to the objectives of the convention; and (c) The provision of information to other Parties, directly or through the Secretariat on domestic regulatory actions that
substantially restrict one or more uses of the chemical, as appropriate.
13
Ref. Priority actions Summary of priority actions Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
restricted chemicals and for SHPFs already provides for the inclusion of
information from IGOs including results of international reviews such as
those of WHO/IPCS/JMPR/IARC.
5. Actions to facilitate consensus-finding at the COP
150 Promote a shared – Mexico (PA-4) proposes that the – Lack of resources to organize Implementation through public awareness activities and materials,
understanding of the Secretariat offer training and disseminate trainings and disseminate information
listing procedure information on the implications of listing a (Mexico)
chemical in Annex III, as the business – Some information materials and
sector considers that listing implies a webinars are only available in English
prohibition on trade. (Mexico)
– Switzerland (PA-5) proposes – Misconception among some
awareness-raising activities to increase the stakeholders that the Rotterdam
understanding about the purpose and value Convention restricts trade when it is in
of the Rotterdam Convention and the reality about information-sharing to
implications of listing. Sustainable promote a transparent and effective
Development Goals (SDGs) related to trading system (Switzerland)
sound chemicals management could be
used to promote the activities.
– Colombia (PA-2) proposes measures – Need for improved understanding Implementation through existing and/or new measures to enhance
to ensure that the WTO recognize and of and commitment to the information-exchange with the WTO (MoU, joint TA activities, awareness-
undertake to inform its members of the implementation of the Convention and raising events during WTO meetings, etc.). The implementation process will
benefits of the PIC procedure, as regards the rational management of chemicals depend on the type of measures envisaged.
competitiveness, sustainability, and by actors involved in the trade of
rational management of chemicals. chemicals (Colombia) Note: The Secretariat has sought observer status in the WTO Committee on
31
Colombia, in particular, suggests exploring Trade and Environment (CTE), as requested by the COP (the request is
the possibilities for signing a memorandum pending). It also participates on an ad hoc basis and upon invitation in
of understanding (MoU) with the WTO meetings of that body when relevant.
with regard to exchange and dissemination
of information on the implementation of
the Rotterdam Convention.
151 Clarify the basis – Australia (PA-5) suggests examining – Lack of information on the Implementation through a COP decision mandating the Secretariat or an
for listing decisions at the factors considered by Parties in making factors considered by Parties when intersessional working group to collect the information and analyse the
the Conference their listing decisions and whether these making a listing decision at COPs. relationship between the CRC and COP.
factors align with the Convention’s goals. Information on decision factors may
Information on listing factors could serve provide insight on how to progress
as a basis for an analysis on the future listings. (Australia)
relationship between the CRC and the COP
31
See decisions RC-1/15, RC-4-10 and RC-5/13.
14
Ref. Priority actions Summary of priority actions Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
in the listing process, with the aim to
reduce work duplications, minimise the re-
production of positions and improve
timeliness in decision-making.
– Mexico (PA-5) proposes the – Lack of a methodology and Implementation through a COP decision mandating the elaboration of a
elaboration of a methodology to guide technical and scientific criteria for methodology, or adopting a methodology prepared by the intersessional
Parties in taking national decisions on Parties to back up their opposition to working group.
listing, taking into account environmental, the listing of a chemical (Mexico)
commercial, agricultural production and – Lack of a methodology on how
health aspects to favour balanced decision- CRC members should inform their
making. The Latin American and region on the different themes
Caribbean Countries’ (GRULAC) discussed and to collect scientific
representatives in the CRC rarely inform information in the region for
the region about discussions and work consideration by the CRC (Mexico)
progress between the COPs. Mexico
suggests, in particular, that the
intersessional working group could
propose a draft decision on the adoption of
a methodology to COP-9.
152 Promote a shared – Australia (PA-2) suggests addressing – Lack of information on which Implementation through, for instance:
understanding of key disagreements and misunderstanding of the terms require further clarification the intersessional working group, as part of its mandate to
terminology of the Convention’s mechanisms, processes and (Australia) identify a set or prioritized recommendations for the COP,
Convention decision-making functions, by making key – Lack of information on how other 32
as a follow-up to decision RC-8/14,
terminology of the listing process less conventions have dealt with similar through a new COP decision, tasking the Secretariat to undertake
ambiguous. To better enable Parties to issues (Australia) such an analysis.
consider the issue, Australia proposes an
analysis on whether other Conventions
were confronted with a similar issue and
how they dealt with it. Possible solutions
may include:
Developing policy on key Implementation through a COP decision mandating an intersessional working
terminology; group to clarify key terminology (e.g. development of a glossary of terms for
possible adoption by the COP).
Educating Parties on key Implementation through public awareness activities and materials.
terminology;
32
Paragraph 10 (a) of decision RC-8/14 on synergies in preventing and combating illegal traffic and trade in hazardous chemicals and wastes requests the Secretariat to “seek, subject
to the availability of resources, comments from parties and others on further areas, including areas common to two or three of the conventions, in which legal clarity could be improved
as a means of preventing and combating illegal traffic and trade in hazardous chemicals and wastes and, based on those comments, to prepare a report, including recommendations, for
consideration by the Conference of the Parties at its next meeting”.
15
Ref. Priority actions Summary of priority actions Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
33
Providing more clarity in the Implementation through a COP decision amending the Convention text.
text of the Convention.
The amendment enters into force after ratification, acceptance or approval by
at least three-fourth of the Parties. Only Parties that have
ratified/accepted/approved the amendment will be bound by its entry into
force. All other Parties continue to be bound by the original Convention text.
If ratified/accepted/approved by all Parties, all Parties will be bound by the
new Convention text. The clarifications could fulfil their purpose of
enhancing the shared understanding of the procedures under the Convention
and their operation.
If not ratified/accepted/approved by all Parties, which is the more likely
scenario, not all Parties will be bound by the same Convention text
153 Improve the – Bahrain (PA-3) suggests analysing – The European Commission Implementation by a COP decision mandating the Secretariat to make the
understanding of the the impact of listing on the market, publication that is being prepared publication of the European Commission available to all Parties, upon its
effects of listing on including an assessment of the scope of should be made available to all Parties completion.
trade that impact. (Bahrain)
– Bahrain (PA-4) further proposes a – Need to solicit information from Implementation through a COP decision mandating the Secretariat to conduct
study based on Party consultations as to industry on what factors hinder the a survey to gather information from industry on export impediments for listed
how listing impacts on industry and other export market of listed substances substances.
actors. (Bahrain)
– Canada (PA-4) proposes more work – Lack of information on situations Implementation through a COP decision mandating the Secretariat to
to determine what effects on trade other where listed pesticides become undertake further work on the topic.
than those identified in the Secretariat ineligible for funded projects (Canada)
study (UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.8/INF/21) – Lack of information on whether Note: A first study of information on the impacts of listing chemicals in
result when a substance is listed. Criticism the listing of a chemical triggers Annex II to the Rotterdam Convention considered at COP-8 is available in
of the study stressed that although listing prohibitions or restrictions or whether it document UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.8/INF/21.
may not lead to an official ban, there may does not affect trade among those
be indirect effects such as the ineligibility Parties that decide to continue using the
of a listed pesticide for certain funded chemical (Peru)
projects. – Lack of realistic picture of the
– Peru (PA-2) proposes the impacts of listing a chemical in Annex
development of a study on impacts III, including whether listing triggers
resulting from the listing of a chemical in bans at the national level, whether
Annex III and prohibitions or restrictions listing results in an increase of FRAs
that may be triggered by the listing. and whether listing stimulates the
33
The procedure for proposing and adopting amendments to the Convention text is set out in Article 21 of the Rotterdam Convention. The amendment must be proposed by a Party and
communicated to all Parties at least six months before the COP meeting (Article 21.1 and 21.2 of the Convention). The COP then decides on the adoption of the amendment by
consensus, or, if all efforts have been exhausted by a three-fourth majority (Article 21.3 of the Convention). Following the adoption, the amendment is communicated to all Parties.
16
Ref. Priority actions Summary of priority actions Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
– Switzerland (PA-4) proposes a study development and use of alternatives
on the impacts of listing, providing a (Switzerland)
realistic picture of what happens when a
chemical is listed.
154 34
Permit a flexible – The EU and its member States (PA- – Lack of information on the legal Implementation through a COP decision amending Article 22.5 (c), 2nd
entry into force of the 3) propose amending the Convention to options for and consequences of such 35
sentence, of the Convention: The amendment either provides for the
PIC procedure for allow for flexibility with regard to the an amendment (EU and its member possibility for the COP to decide on different dates for the entry into force of
individual States entry into force and/or acceptance of listing States) the decision amending Annex III (option A), or it provides for the possibility
decisions by individual Parties. The – Lack of information on to opt out (i.e. addition of text similar to Article 22.3 (b) of the Stockholm
national needs of some Parties could be procedural requirements and steps for Convention36) (option B).
taken into account in the listing decision, implementation (EU and its member
for example by providing for the deferred States) The amendment enters into force after ratification, acceptance or approval by
entry into force of the decision for that – Lack of information on the at least three-fourth of the Parties. Only Parties that have
Party or including a possibility to opt out timeline for implementing the ratified/accepted/approved the amendment will be bound by it. All other
of the listing. The EU and its member amendment (EU and its member States) Parties continue to be bound by the original Convention text.
States suggest that the wording could be – Lack of information on practical If ratified/accepted/approved by all Parties, the amendment would enable the
amended as follows: “The amendment consequences for the implementation COP to decide on different dates of entry into force of the amendment for any
shall enter into force on the date(s) to be for the Convention (EU and its member given individual Party or groups of Parties (option A), or the Convention
specified in the decision” or “the States) would provide the possibility for a Party to notify the depositary that it is
amendment shall enter info force as unable to accept the amendment (option B), thereby establishing variations in
specified in the decision”. the dates of coming into effect of the obligations associated with the PIC
procedure (Article 10).
If the amendment comes into effect without being ratified/accepted/approved
by all Parties, which is the more likely scenario, the possible legal and
operational implications may need to be further explored. The preliminary
information in the following paragraphs answers the request for the
Secretariat to present in the present report information on the legal and
operational implications of this scenario. Parties may however wish to
request the Secretariat to seek the views of Parties on the matter, and/or to
34
The procedure for proposing and adopting amendments to the Convention text is set out in Article 21 of the Rotterdam Convention. The amendment must be proposed by a Party and
communicated to all Parties at least six months before the COP meeting (Article 21.1 and 21.2 of the Convention). The COP then decides on the adoption of the amendment by
consensus, or, if all efforts have been exhausted by a three-fourth majority (Article 21.3 of the Convention). Following the adoption, the amendment is communicated to all Parties.
35
Article 22.5 (c) of the Rotterdam Convention provides that “[a] decision to amend Annex III shall forthwith be communicated to the parties b the Depositary. The amendment shall
enter into force for all Parties on a date to be specified in the decision.”
36
Article 22.3 (b) of the Stockholm Convention provides that “[a]ny Party that is unable to accept an additional annex shall so notify the depositary, in writing, within one year from
the date of communication by the depositary of the adoption of the additional annex. The depositary shall without delay notify all Parties of any such notification received. A Party may
at any time withdraw a previous notification of non-acceptance in respect of any additional annex, and the annex shall thereupon enter into force for that Party subject to subparagraph
(c).”
17
Ref. Priority actions Summary of priority actions Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
seek a legal opinion from the Office of Legal Affairs of the United Nations.
The preliminary view is that if the amendment enters into force without being
ratified/accepted/approved by all Parties, it will create two separate sets of
rights and obligations for Parties. For Parties bound by the original Article
22.5 (c), the decision amending Annex III would come into force on a date to
be specified in the decision.
For Parties bound by the amended Article 22.5 (c), the implications depend
on the nature of the amendment:
If option A is followed, the COP could decide on different dates of entry into
force of the amendment to Annex III for individual Parties or groups of
Parties that have ratified/accepted/approved the amendment to Article 22.5
(c). If this decision to amend Annex III can be taken by consensus, by all
Parties to the Convention, the existence of two parallel sets of rights and
obligations would not impair the listing process. However, if the decision to
amend Annex III cannot be taken by consensus by all Parties to the
Convention, it would appear that two distinct decisions to list a chemical in
Annex III would need to be adopted.
If option B is followed, the decision to list a chemical in Annex III would not
be affected as it is the Convention text that would give the possibility to a
Party bound by the amended Article 22.5 (c) to notify the depositary that it is
unable to accept the amendment.
Under both options A and B, the amended Article 22.5 (c) would establish
variations in the dates of coming into effect of the obligations associated with
the PIC procedure (Article 10).
6. Actions to amend the decision-making process for listing chemicals
160 37
Subject chemicals – Canada (PA-1) proposes continued Implementation by individual Parties under Article 14.1 of the Convention,
to a voluntary PIC use of Article 14 to as a means for Parties for example in combination with a COP decision inviting Parties to inform
procedure, where a to implement a voluntary PIC mechanism other Parties of their decisions regarding import and management of
(qualified) majority of for substances that have no yet achieved chemicals for which listing in Annex III could not be decided.
Parties agrees to their consensus.
listing Note: The COP has previously adopted decisions with respect to chemicals
for which listing in Annex III could not be decided to encourage Parties to
make use of all available information to assist others, in particular developing
Parties and Parties with economies in transition, to make informed decisions
regarding import and management of the substance and to inform other
37
See footnote 30.
18
Ref. Priority actions Summary of priority actions Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
Parties of those decisions using the information-exchange provisions of
38
Article 14.
– The EU and its member States (PA- – Lack of information on the legal Implementation through COP decisions inviting Parties to apply the PIC
2) propose the adoption of standalone options for and consequences of such procedure on a voluntary basis. This approach requires a new decision for
decision at the Conference of the Parties an amendment (EU and its member each chemical for which consensus could not be reached.
that invite Parties to apply the PIC States)
procedure on a voluntary basis to – Lack of information on
chemicals for which consensus could not procedural requirements and steps for
be reached. Parties would have the implementation (EU and its member
possibility to subscribe to that voluntary States)
procedure either during the Conference or – Lack of information on the
later on. The voluntary procedure would timeline for implementing the
apply until the next Conference. Such a amendment (EU and its member States)
mechanism has the advantages of ensuring – Lack of information on practical
that chemicals are kept on the agenda of consequences for the implementation
the Conference of the Parties and of for the Convention (EU and its member
allowing all Parties that support the listing States)
to apply the PIC procedure and benefit
from the control procedures established by
the Convention. The decision could also
mandate the Secretariat to exercise certain
responsibilities with regard to the
implementation of the voluntary PIC
procedure.
39 40
– The EU and its member States (PA- – Lack of information on the legal Implementation through a COP decision adopting an additional annex.
4) suggest amending the Convention to options for and consequences of such
establish a new Annex for chemicals for an amendment (EU and its member The new annex enters into force one year after its notification. Only Parties
which it is not possible to reach consensus States) that did not declare that they are unable to accept the additional annex will be
in order to subject them to a voluntary PIC – Lack of information on
38
See, for example, decisions RC-3/3 and RC-4/4 (on chrysotile asbestos), RC-4/6 (on endosulfan), RC-6/8 (on liquid formulations containing paraquat, RC-8/6 (on carbosulfan), and
RC-8/7 (on fenthion).
39
The procedure for proposing and adopting new annexes to the Convention text is set out in Article 22 of the Rotterdam Convention. The new annex must be proposed by a Party and
communicated to all Parties at least six months before the COP meeting (Article 22.3 (a) of the Convention). The COP then decides on the adoption of the new annex by consensus, or,
if all efforts have been exhausted by a three-fourth majority (Article 22.3 (a) of the Convention). Following the adoption, the new annex is communicated to all Parties. Parties that are
unable to accept an additional annex must so notify the Depositary, in writing, within one year from the date of communication (Article 22.3 (b) of the Convention).
40
Article 22.1 of the Rotterdam Convention provides that “Annexes shall be restricted to procedural, scientific, technical or administrative matters”. The annex would need to be
legally grounded in the Convention text. The scenario is distinct from the case of the adoption of the Annexes VIII an IX to the Basel Convention, which were an elaboration of an
existing annex (Annex I). Determination of the legal basis in the Convention text for the suggested voluntary PIC mechanism may require further analysis of the different articles of the
Convention that could serve as a basis for its adoption (e.g. the obligations of Article 14 on information exchange or an amendment to the Convention).
19
Ref. Priority actions Summary of priority actions Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
procedure. Chemicals would automatically procedural requirements and steps for bound by the new annex upon its entry into force.
be listed in this new annex if the implementation (EU and its member
Conference of the Parties failed to list States) Parties would also need to consider the procedure for amending the new
them. – Lack of information on the annex each time there is a failure to reach consensus on a listing if the
timeline for implementing the intention is for this procedure to derogate from the Convention text (Article
amendment (EU and its member States) 22.3).
– Lack of information on practical
consequences for the implementation
for the Convention (EU and its member
States)
161 Subject chemicals – Australia (PA-1) proposes to further – Lack of information on whether Implementation through the intersessional working group, as part of its
to the PIC procedure, consider options to amend the listing other conventions amended their text to mandate to identify a set or prioritized recommendations for the COP, or
where a (qualified) process for Annex III, including the address similar problems and what the through the COP, tasking the Secretariat to undertake such an analysis.
majority of Parties proposal to allow for the listing decision to practical outcome of those amendments
agrees to their listing be taken by a three-fourth majority as a was (Australia)
measure of last resort, or to add a new
annex for chemicals that did not reach
consensus. To better enable Parties to
consider the issue, Australia proposes an
analysis on whether other conventions
were confronted with a similar issue and
how they dealt with it.
41 42
– Bahrain (PA-1) suggests changing – Lack of analysis as to why Implementation through a COP decision amending Article 22.5 (b) of the
the decision-making for listing, to ensure consensus could not be reached in Convention.
that no State as veto power to oppose specific cases (Bahrain)
listing, where a vast majority supports the – Lack of information on Parties’ The amendment enters into force after ratification, acceptance or approval by
listing. views, rationales and barriers moving at least three-fourth of the Parties. Only Parties that have
– Canada (PA-2) highlights the need forward (Canada) ratified/accepted/approved the amendment will be bound by its entry into
for a robust and informed discussion on the – Lack of information on legal force. All other Parties (max. one fourth of the Parties) continue to be bound
legal and operational impacts, challenges aspects related an amendment of the by the original Convention text.
as well as benefits, of allowing for listing procedure (Ecuador) If ratified/accepted/approved by all Parties, all Parties will be bound to apply
chemicals to be listed by vote by amending – Lack of legal opinions on the the PIC procedure upon entry into force of the decision amending Annex III.
the text of the Convention. consequences of the amendment (EU
– Ecuador (PA-1) proposes to change and its member States) If not ratified/accepted/approved by all Parties, which is the more likely
the voting procedure, because the efforts of – Lack of information on scenario, the possible legal and operational implications may need to be
41
The procedure for proposing and adopting amendments to the Convention text is set out in Article 21 of the Rotterdam Convention. The amendment must be proposed by a Party and
communicated to all Parties at least six months before the COP meeting (Article 21.1 and 21.2 of the Convention). The COP then decides on the adoption of the amendment by
consensus, or, if all efforts have been exhausted by a three-fourth majority (Article 21.3 of the Convention). Following the adoption, the amendment is communicated to all Parties.
42
Article 22.5 (b) of the Rotterdam Convention provides that “[t]he Conference of the Parties shall take its decision on adoption by consensus”.
20
Ref. Priority actions Summary of priority actions Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
some countries to provide studies on the procedural requirements and steps for further explored. The preliminary information in the following paragraphs
effects of those substances did not have the the implementation of the amendment answers the request for the Secretariat to present in the present report
expected impact on the COP. Ecuador (EU and its member States) information on the legal and operational implications of this scenario. Parties
recalls that the object of including – Lack of information on the may however wish to request the Secretariat to seek the views of Parties on
chemicals in Annex III is to address human timeline for implementing the the matter, and/or to seek a legal opinion from the Office of Legal Affairs of
health and environmental problems, not to amendment (EU and its member States) the United Nations.
guarantee commercial interests. – Lack of information on practical
– The EU and its member States (PA- consequences for the implementation The preliminary view is that if the amendment enters into force without being
5) suggest the adoption of an amendment for the Convention (EU and its member ratified/accepted/approved by all Parties, it will create two separate sets of
to the Convention to the effect to change States) rights and obligations for Parties. The impact of this dual regime will not
the listing procedure and allow for a raise implications in practice if the decision amending Annex III is adopted
majority vote as a measure of last resort by consensus. If however Parties are unable to reach agreement by consensus
where it is impossible to reach consensus. on amending Annex III, then only the Parties bound by the amended Article
The new voting mechanism should ensure 22.5 (b) could proceed with decision-making by voting, and if a decision is
that a majority decision is binding for all adopted to list a chemical, only those Parties would be bound by the decision
Parties that have ratified the amendment. listing the chemical and the obligations associated with the PIC procedure
43
All decisions adopted by consensus would (Article 10).
be handled by the normal procedure. Note: Available information includes the thought starter on “Ensuring the
– Switzerland (PA-1) suggests continued effectiveness of the Rotterdam Convention”
exploring, in a process including Parties (UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.4/13) and the documentation on the amendments
only, how different options of amending proposed at COP8 (UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.8/16/Add.1).
the Convention could increase its
effectiveness. This should include the
option of amending the listing process to
enable voting.
– Yemen (PA-3) proposes amending
the procedure for amending Annex III. If
also refers to the option of increased
information-exchange through the
Secretariat.
162 44
Subject chemicals – Mexico (PA-1) suggests modifying – Lack of understanding of the Implementation through a COP decision by amending Articles 22.4 and
to the PIC procedure, the decision-making process for listing complexities involved in modifying 45
22.5 of the Convention.
43
A similar situation may also occur under the Stockholm Conventions, for example. The Stockholm Convention allows for the possibility to list new POPs by a three-quarter majority
43 43
decision. Individual Parties may, however, opt out of any amendment by notifying their objection to the Secretariat. Where a Party has made such a notification, the Convention
regime does not apply to that Party for that specific chemical.
44
The procedure for proposing and adopting amendments to the Convention text is set out in Article 21 of the Rotterdam Convention. The amendment must be proposed by a Party and
communicated to all Parties at least six months before the COP meeting (Article 21.1 and 21.2 of the Convention). The COP then decides on the adoption of the amendment by
consensus, or, if all efforts have been exhausted by a three-fourth majority (Article 21.3 of the Convention). Following the adoption, the amendment is communicated to all Parties.
21
Ref. Priority actions Summary of priority actions Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
where a (qualified) chemicals to align it with the listing Article 22.5 to align it with Article 21.3 The amendment enters into force after ratification, acceptance or approval by
majority of Parties process under the Stockholm Convention of the Stockholm Convention (Mexico) at least three-fourth of the Parties. Only Parties that have
agrees to their listing, to avoid that some chemicals remain ratified/accepted/approved the amendment will be bound by its entry into
with the possibility to unlisted for several COPs. force. All other Parties continue to be bound by the original Convention text.
opt out
If ratified/accepted/approved by all Parties, the amendment will create two
separate sets of rights and obligations for each newly listed chemical, unless
none of the Parties chooses to opt out of a decision listing a specific
46
chemical.
If not ratified/accepted/approved by all Parties, which is the more likely
scenario, the possible legal and operational implications may need to be
further explored. The preliminary information in the following paragraphs
answers the request for the Secretariat to present in the present report
information on the legal and operational implications of this scenario. Parties
may however wish to request the Secretariat to seek the views of Parties on
the matter, and/or to seek a legal opinion from the Office of Legal Affairs of
the United Nations.
The preliminary view is that if the amendment enters into force without being
ratified/accepted/approved by all Parties, it would appear to create three
separate sets of rights and obligations for Parties. The first set would apply to
those Parties that have not ratified/accepted/approved the amendment of
Articles 22.4 and 22.5. They would only bound by the obligations associated
with the PIC procedure (Article 10) if Parties reach agreement by consensus
on amending Annex III.
However, if Parties are unable to reach agreement by consensus on amending
Annex III, the Parties that ratified/accepted/approved the amendment of
Articles 24 and 22.5 could proceed with decision-making by voting. If a
decision is adopted to list a chemical, a Party that has
ratified/accepted/approved the amendment of Articles 22.4 and 22.5 would be
bound by the decision to list the chemical and the obligations associated with
the PIC procedure (Article 10) (second set of rights and obligations), unless it
decides to opt out (third set of rights and obligations).
45
Article 22.4 ab initio of the Rotterdam Convention makes reference to “Except in the case of Annex III”. Article 22.5 of the Rotterdam Convention provide that “[t]he Conference of
the Parties provides for the special procedure to amend Annex III.
46 46
This is also the situation of the Stockholm Conventions, for example. The Stockholm Convention allows for the possibility to list new POPs by a three-quarter majority decision.
Individual Parties may, however, opt out of any amendment by notifying the Depositary that they are unable to accept it. Where a Party has made such a notification, the Convention
regime does not apply to that Party for that specific chemical.
22
Category B: The PIC procedure
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
1. Actions to improve compliance with the obligation to transmit export notifications
210 Encourage – The Democratic Republic of the Implementation through public awareness activities and materials.
producer countries to Congo (PA-3) proposes measures to
transmit export encourage pesticide producer countries to Could potentially be included in the general review mandate of the compliance
notifications to notify exports in a responsible manner committee proposed to be established in terms of Article 17 (see PA 330).
developing countries before exporting hazardous chemicals to Note: The Convention only requires that an exporting State transmits an export
before exporting developing countries. notification if that State has severely restricted or banned the chemical that is
dangerous chemicals 47
exported. RC-7/2 requested the Secretariat to provide assistance to Parties, upon
request, in implementing Articles 11.2(c) and 12.
211 Assist – The Democratic Republic of the Implementation through the TA plan or technology transfer.
importing Parties to Congo (PA-4) proposes that Rotterdam
acquire the Convention Designated national authorities
necessary logistic (DNAs) be equipped with the necessary
means to promptly logistical means (computer, internet
acknowledge receipt connection) to provide real-time replies to
of export export notifications.
notifications
212 Send only one – Kuwait (PA-2) proposes that – Notifications should only be sent The proposal would benefit from further elaboration.
notification per chemical notifications should not be sent once to avoid confusions (Kuwait)
chemical several times even where the Party has Note: The Convention obliges exporting Parties to resend an export notification
responded, as this creates confusion before the first export in every calendar year, if it has adopted a major change to
because the chemical is studies with each the FRA in question, or if it did not receive an acknowledgement of receipt by the
notification a new. importing Party within 30 days of notification. The obligation to notify before the
48
first export in any calendar year may be waived by the importing Party.
47
See Article 12.1 of the Rotterdam Convention.
48
See Article 12 of the Rotterdam Convention.
23
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
2. Actions to improve Parties’ provision of import responses
220 49
Expedite – Bosnia and Herzegovina (PA-1) – Different regulatory regimes in Implementation by individual Parties under Article 15.1 of the Convention.
national process to identifies the preparation and submission of different parts of the country and
adopt import and import response for each listed corresponding delays in the process of Activities to assist Parties in expediting national processes for the adoption of
responses chemical as a priority action at the national adopting national import responses import responses could also be part of the TA plan.
level. (Bosnia and Herzegovina) Could potentially be included in the general review mandate of the compliance
committee proposed to be established in terms of Article 17 (see PA 330).
221 Create new – Yemen (PA-5) proposes the creation – Lack of capacity in developing
mechanisms to assist of mechanisms to help Parties, in particular countries, such as inadequate IT
developing countries developing countries, adopt and give effect equipment, limited ability to access
with adopting and to their import decisions. This includes: background materials, limited data
enforcing import interpretation capacity, and limited access
responses to decision support systems (Yemen)
– Insufficient information relevant to
Greater efforts to ensure that Implementation processes will depend on the type measures envisaged.
developing countries, such as information
scientific information in synthesized and 50
on alternatives (Yemen) Note: The resource kit includes the health and safety guides (HSGs) that provide
presented in a clear way to be useful to
– Limited sharing of information concise information, using non-technical language, for decision-makers on risks
decision-makers and non-specialist
within the region, which is made more from exposure to chemicals, together with practical advice on medical and
stakeholders. 51
difficult by frequent changes of OCPs administrative issues.
(Yemen)
A platform for information- – Lack of mechanism to assist Could be implemented in the context of the development of the clearing-house
sharing about national regulatory decisions countries, particularly developing mechanism for information exchange.
on chemicals and pesticides should be made countries in implementing the
available in all six languages to help Parties Convention (Yemen)
learn more about the characteristics of
potentially hazardous chemicals that may
be imported.
3. Actions to improve Parties’ control of chemicals imports
230 52 53
Train national – Ecuador (PA-2) suggests providing – Lack of knowledge on standards for Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 15.1 and 16 of the
authorities with training to customs and commercial import controls for chemicals (Ecuador) Convention.
49
See footnote 16.
50
The resource kit is available at http://www.pic.int/Implementation/ResourceKit/tabid/1064/language/en-US/Default.aspx.
51
The reference and link to the HSGs is available in Section E.3 of the resource kit at
http://www.pic.int/Implementation/RessourcesKit/SourcesofInformationonHazardousChemicals/tabid/1503/language/en-US/Default.aspx.
52
See footnote 16.
24
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
respect to the authorities with respect to the development – Lack of exchange of experiences Activities to train customs and commercial authorities could also be part of the
development of of standards for identifying pesticides and with other countries on the application of TA plan.
import standards hazardous chemicals at import controls, import controls for chemicals (Ecuador)
based on experiences in other countries. Note: Decisions RC-8/14 requested the Secretariat to support Parties, upon
request and within available resources, on matters pertaining to the
implementation and enforcement of the provisions aimed at controlling the export
and import of chemicals, including the development and updating of national
legislation or other measures. Training activities organized by the Rotterdam
Convention Secretariat targeting customs authorities are carried out through the
Green Customs Initiative (GCI). Furthermore, relevant information on the
Rotterdam Convention has been made available through the World Customs
Organization (WCO) training centres, customs enforcement network and website.
– Afghanistan (PA-4) proposes the – Lack of information on production, The specific issue of pollution standards for imported goods falls outside the
development of national standards for trade and uses of chemicals (Afghanistan) scope of the Rotterdam Convention.
goods (e.g. consumer goods) containing – Lack of information on
chemicals. hazardousness (Afghanistan)
– Lack of information on supply
chains (Afghanistan)
231 54 55
Assist with the – Jordan (PA-4) identifies the need at – Lack of financial and technical Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 15.1 and 16 of the
development of trade the national level to establish a mechanism capacity to carry out studies on the risks Convention.
control mechanisms to restrict trade in chemicals as a result of of chemicals (Jordan)
their listing. Activities to assist Parties with establishing trade control mechanisms could also
be part of the TA plan.
232 56 57
Assist with the – Afghanistan (PA-3) identified the – Lack of information on chemicals Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 15.1 and 16, through the
development and need for analytical laboratories to analyse and their adverse effects (Afghanistan) TA plan and/or technology transfer.
operation of and detect hazardous materials in imported – Lack of data on chemical release
analytical goods, including established procedure to (Afghanistan) Note: Training activities organized by the Rotterdam Convention Secretariat
laboratories for conduct the analyses (protocols on the – Lack of data on soil, water, waste targeting customs authorities are carried out under the TA plan and through the
import controls collection of samples, drafting of technical sludge, etc. contamination (Afghanistan) GCI. Furthermore, relevant information on the Rotterdam Convention has been
reports, safe management at Customs) – Lack of monitoring data to inform made available through the WCO training centres, customs enforcement network
policies (Afghanistan) and website. Available guidance includes the fact sheet on the role of customs in
the implementation of the Rotterdam Convention, the training manual for customs
53
See footnote 8.
54
See footnote 16.
55
See footnote 8.
56
See footnote 16.
57
See footnote 8.
25
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
officers on hazardous chemicals and wastes under the Basel, Rotterdam and
58
Stockholm conventions, the case studies on customs-related aspects of the
Rotterdam convention, the green customs guide to multilateral environmental
agreements (MEAs), and the manual on compliance with and enforcement of
MEAs.
233 Assign HS – Sri Lanka (PA-5) proposes to assign – Poor customs awareness (Sri The assignation of HS codes falls within the mandate of the WCO (the Secretariat
codes to all Harmonized System codes (HS codes) for Lanka) already requested the assignment of HS codes for all newly listed chemicals, this
compounds listed in the full spectrum of compounds listed in work is ongoing).
Annex III Annex III, for better identification of 59
pesticides. Note: The list of assigned HS codes is available on the Convention website.
4. Actions to improve the implementation of the PIC procedure in general
240 Promote and – Norway (PA-4) proposes to
improve the PIC strengthen the information exchange under
circular the Convention, including by:
Promoting a more active use of Implementation through public awareness activities and materials.
the PIC Circular at the national level
Note: The resource kit includes the user’s guide for the PIC circular (Arabic,
English, French, Russian, Spanish)
Improving the format of the PIC Implementation through the Secretariat.
circular to make it more user-friendly.
241 Improve – Australia (PA-3) proposes review and – Lack of information on support As regards the lack of information on other Conventions, implementation could
support mechanisms further improvement of support mechanisms used under other be:
for the mechanisms for developing countries to conventions providing for a PIC through the intersessional working group, as part of its mandate to
implementation of implement the PIC procedure and procedure and their success (Australia) identify a set or prioritized recommendations for the COP,
the PIC procedure in associated administrative processes, such as through the COP, tasking the Secretariat to gather such information
developing countries by: and undertake such an analysis
potentially included in the general review mandate of the compliance
committee proposed to be established in terms of Article 17 (see PA 330)
60
Providing support Implementation by individual Parties under Article 16 of the Convention and
through the TA plan.
58
The training manual for customs officers on hazardous chemicals and wastes under the Basel, Rotterdam an Stockholm Conventions is available at
http://synergies.pops.int/Implementation/TechnicalAssistance/ToolsandMethodologies/ManualforCustomsOfficers/tabid/4457/language/en-US/Default.aspx. All other guidance
documents mentioned in the note are available at http://www.pic.int/Implementation/Customs/DocumentsLinks/tabid/1614/language/en-US/Default.aspx.
59
See http://www.pic.int/TheConvention/Chemicals/HarmonizedSystemCodes/tabid/1159/language/en-US/Default.aspx.
60
See footnote 8.
26
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
Increasing education and Implementation through public awareness activities and materials.
awareness campaigns
Note: The resource kit includes a leaflet on the Rotterdam Convention and the
PIC procedure (English, French, Spanish), and a leaflet on international trade
control measures under the Basel, Rotterdam and Stockholm Conventions.
Furthermore, the Guidance to DNAs on the operation of the Rotterdam
Convention (Arabic, English, French, Russian, Spanish) includes a chapter on the
61
PIC procedure.
62
Parties offering mentoring or Implementation by individual Parties under Article 16 of the Convention.
secondments
Developing model regulatory Implementation through the TA plan.
frameworks
Could potentially be included in the mandate of the compliance committee
proposed to be established in terms of Article 17 (See PA 330).
Note: Available guidance materials include the Guide on the Development of
National Laws (Arabic, Chinese, English, French, Russian, Spanish) and three
legal case studies on implementation (Arabic, Chinese, English, French, Russian,
63
Spanish). Furthermore, decision RC-8/14 requested the Secretariat to support
Parties, upon request and within available resources, on matters pertaining to the
implementation and enforcement of the provisions aimed at controlling the export
and import of chemicals, including the development and updating of national
legislation or other measures, and to develop examples of the integration of the
provisions of the Basel, Rotterdam and Stockholm conventions into national legal
frameworks and to organize training activities, subject to the availability of
resources and in collaboration with partners, to assist Parties, particularly
developing-country Parties and Parties with economies in transition, in the
development of national legislation and other measures to implement and enforce
the provisions of the convention aimed at controlling the export and import of
chemicals and wastes covered under the conventions.
61
See http://www.pic.int/Implementation/ResourceKit/tabid/1064/language/en-US/Default.aspx.
62
See footnote 8.
63
The mentioned guidance documents are available in the resource kit at http://www.pic.int/Implementation/RessourceKit/tabid/1064/language/en-
US/Default.aspx#GUIDANCEINFO.
27
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
242
Create an – Costa Rica (PA-3) proposes setting – Need for greater flexibility in the Could be implemented in the context of the development of the clearing-house
online system for up an online system for the management of PIC system (Costa Rica) mechanism for information exchange.
managing requests request for prior consent and respective
for prior consents answers. Note: Some of the PIC procedures are already available as only system, such as
64 65
and respective for the submission of import responses and FRA notifications .
answers
Category C: Overall effectiveness of the Convention
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
1. Actions to promote awareness at the national level
310 Raise – Costa Rica (PA-1) proposes training – Lack of understanding by DNAs Implementation through public awareness activities and materials.
awareness on the to DNAs and OCPs on the Rotterdam and OCPs of some aspects of the
Convention and its Convention and synergies with the Basel Note: The resource kit includes the guidance document to DNAs on the operation
Convention (Costa Rica) 66
objectives and Stockholm Conventions. of the Rotterdam Convention (Arabic, English, French, Russian, Spanish).
– Often times authorities are unaware
– The EU and its member States (PA-1) of the obligations derived from the
suggest enhancing the implementation of Convention and no one is responsible for
the Convention by improving the following-up on the theme (Honduras)
transparency of the implementation of the – Lack of technical assistance from
Convention at the national level and by the RC Secretariat for awareness
raising awareness on the obligations of campaign s for stakeholders covering
Parties and stakeholders. Furthermore aims, objectives and requirements of the
stakeholders (exporters, users) could be Convention (Uganda)
involved in the national implementation – Inadequate awareness on MEA
process to ensure that they are fully aware including the Rotterdam Convention
of the consequences and benefits of listing a (Uganda)
chemical. – Inadequate integration of MEAs
– Honduras (PA-1) proposes ongoing
regulating chemicals into educational
trainings for DNAs and OCPs on Parties’
programs (Uganda)
obligations under the Convention.
– Norway (PA-5) proposes awareness-
64
See http://www.pic.int/Procedures/ImportResponses/FormandInstructions/tabid/1165/language/en-US/Default.aspx.
65
See http://www.pic.int/Procedures/NotificationsofFinalRegulatoryActions/FormandInstructions/tabid/1182/language/en-US/Default.aspx.
66
The Guidance to DNAs on the Operation of the Rotterdam Convention is available at http://www.pic.int/Implementation/RessourceKit/tabid/1064/language/en-
US/Default.aspx#GUIDANCEINFO.
28
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
raising activities to ensure that relevant
stakeholders (national governments,
industry, etc.) have correct information on
the Convention and its objectives.
– Uganda (PA-1) proposes actions to
ensure the understating of the aims,
objectives and requirements of the
Convention.
– Uganda (PA-3) highlights that the
general awareness on MEAs, including the
Rotterdam Convention is low. The scarcity
of awareness materials at the national level,
their complexity, the lack of a national
communication strategy, and the failure to
include MEAs into educational programs
contribute to the low level of public
awareness.
311 67 68
Awareness on – The Democratic Republic of the Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 14.1 and 15.2 of the
risks associated with Congo (PA-5) proposes measures to equip Convention and through public awareness activities and materials.
chemicals DNAs with the necessary means to raise
awareness on the risks associated with Note: Several documents developed under Rotterdam can be used for awareness-
handling pesticides and hazardous raising at the national level, including the guide to protect children from
chemicals. pesticides (Arabic, English, French, Spanish, Russian, Portuguese), the e-learning
course on pesticide management and child labour prevention (English, French,
Spanish) and the leaflet on sustainable alternatives to endosulfan in coffee farms
(Arabic, English, Chinese, French, Russian, Spanish, Portuguese). The resource
kit also includes the IPCS health and safety guide. Furthermore, guidance
materials on vulnerable groups will be made available and disseminated as part of
the current TA plan.
2. Actions to improve information-exchange between Parties and the Secretariat and between Parties
320 69
Improve – Norway (PA-4) proposes to Implementation by individual Parties under Article 14.1 of the Convention.
information- strengthen the information exchange under
exchange the Convention, including by exploring new Activities to assist Parties in improving information-exchange could be
ways for information exchange among implemented in the context of the development of the clearing-house mechanism
parties in line with article 14 (e.g. for information exchange.
67
See footnote 30.
68
See footnote 7.
69
See footnote 30.
29
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
workshops, websites, etc.) for Parties to
share information (open data, databases,
tools, etc.) supporting implementation at the
national level.
70 71
– Panama (PA-1) suggests improving – Little real-time information- Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 14.1 and 15.3 of the
the information-exchange between the exchange between Parties and the Convention.
Parties and the Secretariat and between Secretariat and between Parties
Activities to assist Parties in improving information-exchange could be
Parties by establishing regional networks – Lack of online platform to submit
implemented in the context of the development of the clearing-house mechanism
for information-exchange. These would national information. The use of for information exchange.
directly communicate with the Secretariat regular channels for information
and other regional networks. transmission delays access to that
information
72
– Costa Rica (PA-2) proposes the – Different opinions on the Implementation by individual Parties under Article 15.3 of the Convention.
organization of regional meetings of DNAs implementation of the Convention
and OCPs on the implementation of the The organization of regional meetings could also be part of the
Convention. implementation of the TA plan.
73
– The EU and its member States (PA-1) Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 14.1 of the Convention.
propose enhancing the implementation of
the Convention by improving information Activities to assist Parties in improving information-exchange could be
exchange on chemicals that are listed or implemented in the context of the development of the clearing-house mechanism
recommended for listing, such as for information exchange.
information on FRAs to ban or severely
restrict chemicals, including risk
evaluations of Parties carried out in the
context of FRA notifications and export
notifications.
321 Ensure that – Venezuela (PA-2) proposes that the – Lack of technical assistance to Implementation through the Secretariat.
information from Secretariat proactively approaches Parties establish unified criteria for completing
Parties is sought (i,e. send comments) before submission Note: Available guidance includes the Guidance to complete the form for
the forms (Venezuela)
proactively deadlines expire, in particular to address notification for FRAs to ban or severely restrict a chemical (English).
– Lack of awareness on the
doubts on how to fill in forms, including by restrictions pertaining to the notification
establishing unified criteria for completion of updates of contact information
and evaluation of the forms, and to ensure
70
See footnote 30.
71
See footnote 19.
72
See footnote 19.
73
See footnote 30.
30
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
timely update of contact information for (Venezuela)
OCPs and DNAs.
322 74 75
Improve – Kuwait (PA-3) proposes – Lack of examples, reports and Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 14.1 and 16 of the
availability of dissemination of detailed information on presentation on those countries (Kuwait) Convention.
information on how developed countries deal with the
chemicals various aspects of chemicals management, Additional measures to improve the dissemination of such information could be
management systems including exports and imports of chemicals. implemented in the context of the development of the clearing-house mechanism
in developed for information exchange.
countries
323 Develop an – Venezuela (PA-1) suggests improving – Lack of server capacity to include Could be implemented in the context of the development of the clearing-house
online library to information-exchange mechanism, by high number of digital documents mechanism for information exchange.
facilitate access to creating an online library to provide easy (Venezuela)
scientific studies on access to scientific studies on risks
risks associated with associated with chemicals subject to
chemicals international trade.
324 76 77
Improve – Bahrain (PA-2) proposes measures to – Identification of available Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 14.1 and 15.2 of the
information on improve information on alternatives. alternatives and evaluation of their Convention, for example in combination with a COP decision mandating the
alternatives to – Canada (PA-1) suggests sharing relative costs and efficacy (Canada) Secretariat to solicit and consolidate information on alternatives from Parties.
candidate chemicals information, preferably collected from – The lack of information on
or listed chemicals Parties, on alternatives to substances technically and economically viable As alternatives could potentially be as dangerous, or even more dangerous, than
recommended for listing. Canada sees value alternatives represents a challenge for listed chemicals, the COP might need to consider mechanisms to evaluate
78
in the continued and further use of Article regulatory authorities to adopt an FRA proposed alternatives.
14, to share information. Parties could also (Peru) Note: Information on alternatives is included in DGDs. Given that available
be encouraged to share information on – Lack of alternatives to listed alternatives constantly evolve, the working paper on preparing internal proposals
alternatives to substances recommended for chemicals that could be used locally and decision guidance documents for banned or severely restricted chemicals, as
listing. (Jordan) well as the working paper on preparing internal proposals and decision guidance
– The EU and its member States (PA-1) 79
documents for severely hazardous pesticide formulations propose to include
propose enhancing the implementation of
sources of information rather than a list of specific recommendations in the DGDs
the Convention by improving information
and to provide updated references to additional sources of information on the
exchange on alternatives to chemicals that
74
See footnote 30.
75
See footnote 8.
76
See footnote 30.
77
See footnote 7.
78
In the case of the Stockholm Convention, the COP has tasked the POPRC to evaluate the alternative to avoid recommending potentially (more) dangerous chemicals.
79
Both working papers are set out in the Handbook of working procedure and policy guidance for the CRC (English) available at
http://www.pic.int/TheConvention/ChemicalReviewCommittee/Guidance/tabid/1060/language/en-US/Default.aspx.
31
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
are listed or recommended for listing. Rotterdam Convention website.
– Peru (PA-4) suggests establishing a
list of alternatives for Annex III chemicals
and chemicals that are candidates for
inclusion in Annex III and to disseminate
the information through different channels
(national and regional workshops, written
communications to involved authorities,
etc.).
– Jordan (PA-3) suggests providing The focus of the Convention is information-exchange rather than development of
safer and economical alternatives to the alternatives.
chemicals listed in Annex III.
3. Actions to determine and address non-compliance with the provisions of the
Convention
330 Adopt a – Canada (PA-3) proposes the adoption – Lack of compliance information Implementation through the adoption of a compliance mechanism under Article
compliance of a facilitative compliance mechanism. The and thus difficulties to evaluate the 17 of the Rotterdam Convention. The process involves a COP decision approving
mechanism mechanism would allow for discussion of effectiveness of the different aspects of the procedure and/or institutional mechanism for determining non-compliance.
individual challenges and more systemic the Convention (Canada)
problems and lead to a better understanding
of the Convention’s effectiveness. The
adoption could proceed on the text agreed at
COP 7.
– Switzerland (PA-2) proposes that the
COP adopt a compliance procedure.
331 Adopt a – Sri Lanka (PA-4) proposes the – Lack of compliance mechanism Implementation through the adoption of a compliance mechanism under Article
compliance establishment of a compliance to prevent illegal transports (Sri Lanka) 17 of the Rotterdam Convention. The process involves a COP decision approving
mechanism to mechanism to address cases of illegal the procedure and/or institutional mechanism for determining non-compliance.
address cases of traffic, such as exports under false HS
illegal traffic codes.
332 Establish tools – Panama (PA-2) proposes establishing – Lack of compromise at the political Implementation through the adoption of a compliance mechanism under Article
to measures tools to measure Parties’ compliance with and technical level (Panama) 17 of the Rotterdam Convention. The process involves a COP decision approving
compliance their obligations under the Convention, to the procedure and/or institutional mechanism for determining non-compliance.
better allocate available funding.
32
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
4. Actions to improve Parties’ adoption of national action plans (NAP)
340 80 81
Assist with the – Uganda (PA-1) proposes the – Lack of national action plan or Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 15.1 and 16 of the
development of development of a national action plan or strategy for the implementation Convention.
national action plans strategy for the implementation of the (Uganda)
Activities to assist Parties in developing NAPs could also be part of and the TA
Rotterdam Convention. plan, or involve the development/updating of guidance.
Could potentially be included in the mandate of the compliance committee
proposed to be established in terms of Article 17 (see PA 330).
– Yemen (PA-4) proposes the – Lack of guidance on NAPs in all Implementation through a COP decision mandating the development/updating of
development of guidance on the six languages (Yemen) guidance, which could be part of the implementation of the TA plan.
identification of elements of NAPs in all
six languages, including the availability
of assistance to implement those plans in
all languages. National and subregional
meetings should be convened and
technical assistance provided in all
languages.
5. Actions to improve Parties’ enactment of legislation implementing the Convention
350 82 83
Assist with the – Afghanistan (PA-1) identifies the – Lack of information on required Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 15.1 and 16 of the
development of development of secondary legislation and regulatory steps to ensure that the risks Convention.
implementing regulations on the sound management of associated with chemicals are properly
legislation chemicals as a national priority action for addressed (Afghanistan) Activities to assist Parties with the development of implementing legislation
the enhancement of the effectiveness of the – Lack of capacity for policy making could be part of the implementation of the TA plan, or involve the
Convention. This involves the review of and regulatory action (Afghanistan) development/updating of guidance based on a COP decision.
existing frameworks against international – Lack of information on the current Could potentially be included in the general review mandate of the compliance
obligations as well as drafting legislation, chemicals situation (Afghanistan) committee proposed to be established in terms of Article 17 (see PA 330).
where gaps were identified (e.g. PIC – Overlapping legislation on
procedure). pesticides and industrial chemicals (The Note: Available guidance materials include the Guide on the Development of
– The Democratic Republic (PA-1) of former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia) National Laws (Arabic, Chinese, English, French, Russian, Spanish) and three
the Congo proposes that developing legal case studies on implementation (Arabic, Chinese, English, French, Russian,
countries and countries with economies in Spanish). Furthermore, decision RC-8/14 requested the Secretariat to support
80
See footnote 16.
81
See footnote 8.
82
See footnote 16.
83
See footnote 8.
33
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
transition receive financial assistance to Parties, upon request and within available resources, on matters pertaining to the
develop and build awareness of legal implementation and enforcement of the provisions aimed at controlling the export
frameworks and regulatory and and import of chemicals, including the development and updating of national
administrative measures to implement the legislation or other measures, and to develop examples of the integration of the
Convention. provisions of the Basel, Rotterdam and Stockholm conventions into national legal
– The former Yugoslav Republic of frameworks and to organize training activities, subject to the availability of
Macedonia (PA-3) identifies the need for a resources and in collaboration with partners, to assist Parties, particularly
gap analysis of existing legislation developing-country Parties and Parties with economies in transition, in the
chemicals and pesticides against the development of national legislation and other measures to implement and enforce
obligations of the Rotterdam Convention. the provisions of the convention aimed at controlling the export and import of
chemicals and wastes covered under the conventions.
6. Actions to strengthen Parties’ institutions for national implementation
360 Establishment – Afghanistan (PA-2) proposes the – Lack of information on safety and The establishment of such units is not a requirement under the Rotterdam
84
of specialist unit for establishment of national specialists units socio-economic aspects of the use of Convention. However, Article 15.1 of the Convention requires Parties to take
chemicals to for chemicals and waste management chemicals (Afghanistan) such measures as necessary to establish and strengthen national infrastructure and
translate similar to those that had been established – Lack of information chemical institution for the effective implementation of the Convention.
international for ozone-depleting substances and climate properties and risks (Afghanistan)
obligations into finance, to provide targeted efforts on Activities to assist Parties in building institutional capacity could also be part of
– Lack of information on risk
national-level action translating international commitments and management and worker safety
the implementation of the TA plan.
obligations into national-level actions (e.g. (Afghanistan) 85
Note: The Special Programme on Chemicals and Waste aims to strengthen
data collection, inter-ministerial – Unavailability of information to national institutions and to promote the mainstreaming of the sound management
coordination, GIS database, work plans). downstream, government authorities and of chemicals and waste. Key activities supported by the programme provide
the general public (Afghanistan) countries to advance institutional capacity for the implementation of the Basel,
– Lack of expertise on diagnosis of Rotterdam and Stockholm Conventions, the Minamata Convention and SAICM.
chemicals illness due to exposure
(Afghanistan)
– Lack of technical expertise for
chemicals management (Afghanistan)
84
See footnote 16.
85
See http://web.unep.org/chemicalsandwaste/special-programme
34
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
361 86
Improve – Jordan (PA-2) proposes measures to – Weak communication between the Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 15.1 of the Convention.
coordination strengthen national coordination to the OCP and the local DNAs (Jordan)
between government effect that hazard and risk assessments of – Lack of communication between Activities to assist Parties in improving institutional coordination could also be
authorities and priority chemicals lead to decision-making the many institutions involved in the part of the TA plan.
stakeholders on whether to ban or restrict those implementation of the Convention (The
involved in the chemicals. former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia)
implementation – The former Yugoslav Republic of – Lack of strong and sustainable
Macedonia (PA-1) identifies the need for communication system among the
the development of procedures or different DNAs: The Ministry of
mechanisms for inter-institutional Environment and Physical Planning (
interaction and communication among the DNA for implementation in general), the
public and private sectors, academia and Ministry of Agriculture (DNA for
decision-makers. pesticides), and the Ministry of Health
– The former Yugoslav Republic of (DNA for industrial chemicals) (The
Macedonia (PA-2) suggests establishing former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia)
strong and sustainable communication – Lack of understanding of
systems between OCPs and DNAs. weaknesses and opportunities in the
– The former Yugoslav Republic of implementation of the Convention and
Macedonia (PA-4) suggests organizing joint information-exchange between
activities with all stakeholders for a better stakeholders (The former Yugoslav
implementation of the main Convention Republic of Macedonia)
provisions. – Inadequate inter-Ministerial
– Uganda (PA-1) proposes measures coordination and collaboration on
to foster sectoral cooperation among the implementation processes (Uganda)
stakeholders in the implementation process.
7. Actions to improve the availability of technical assistance and capacity-building in general
370 Translate the – Yemen (PA-1) proposes the – The resource kit is not fully Implementation through translation of tools or guidance, which could be part of
electronic resource development of an electronic resource kit to available in all six languages (Yemen) the implementation of the TA plan.
kit into all UN promote ratification and implementation in
languages all six official UN languages. The toolkit
should be regularly updated on and
complemented with new documents, taking
into account the experience of Parties. As
many documents as possible should be
made available in all languages.
371 87 88
Train national – Kuwait (PA-1) proposes training in – Lack of understanding how reports Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 15.1 and 16 of the
officers in writing writing reports for all aspects of the must be written for different aspects of
86
See footnote 16.
35
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
notifications and Convention. the Convention and whether there is an Convention.
other submissions official formula that should be followed
required under the (Kuwait) Activities to assist Parties in writing notifications could also be part of the
Convention implementation of the TA plan.
372 89 90
Improve – Peru (PA-5) proposes the – Lack guidance on managing risks Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 15.2 and 16 of the
Parties capacity to development of guidelines to identify, associated with registered highly Convention.
control risks evaluate and control the risks associated hazardous pesticides according to
associated with with highly hazardous pesticides to help national circumstances (Peru) Activities to assist Parties in controlling risks associated with chemicals could
chemicals developing countries and countries with – Lack of information on plant also be part of the TA plant.
economies in transition to take action in protection regulations (Afghanistan)
pursuit of the 2020 goal. – Lack of emergency plans for
– Afghanistan (PA-5) suggests actions chemical disasters (Afghanistan)
to better protect persons handling chemicals – Lack of information on measures to
and pesticides (protective equipment, reduce exposure and emissions
analytical capacity, training), including (Afghanistan)
ensure environmentally sound management – Lack of information on appropriate
of clinical wastes and establish expired technology (Afghanistan)
pesticide stores.
373 91 92
Provide – The EU and its member States (PA-1) – Lack of information on the main Implementation by individual Parties under Articles 15.1 and 16 of the
capacity-building suggest enhancing the implementation of difficulties of Parties in implementing Convention.
and technical the Convention by improving Parties’ the Convention (EU and its member
assistance capacity to properly implement and fully States) Activities to assist Parties in developing national capacity for chemicals
management could also be part of the implementation of the TA plan, and/or
participate in the Convention processes – Lack of information on the main
(participation in CRC, submission and implemented in the context of the development of the clearing–house mechanism
capacity gaps of Parties (EU and its
notification of FRAs, adoption of import for information exchange (e.g. Yemen, PA-2 (d)).
member States)
responses) and to implement chemicals – Lack of information on the main
management measures, including the information gaps of Parties (EU and its
capacity to use internationally available data member States)
on chemicals and conduct risk evaluations. – Lack of information on best
– Jordan (PA-1) proposes technical approaches to address those gaps (EU and
assistance and capacity-building for the its member States)
87
See footnote 16.
88
See footnote 8.
89
See footnote 7.
90
See footnote 8.
91
See footnote 16.
92
See footnote 8.
36
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
implementation of the Convention, such as – Lack of technical capabilities and
programs for scientific and technical laboratory equipment (Jordan)
training of personnel, including customs – Weak monitoring capacity
personnel. (practical, analytical and technical) for
– Norway (PA-2) proposes that chemicals of concern (Jordan)
options that help improve the effectiveness – Lack of technical assistance and
of the Convention and at the same time capacity building (Sri Lanka)
assist Parties in implementing the – Lack of financial mechanism to
Convention should be prioritized. It is provide support to developing countries
important to strengthen Parties’ capacity for (Bahrain)
submission FRAs and listing proposal for – Lack of database on Rotterdam
SHPFs, as well as import responses. Convention chemicals used in the country
Norway suggests that technical assistance (Uganda)
programs take into consideration the needs – Inadequate technical capacity to
of developing countries identified in implement the Rotterdam Convention
UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.8/INF/25 and other (Uganda)
documents under agenda item 5(a) – Inadequate infrastructure to support
considered at COP8. implementation processes (Uganda)
– Sri Lanka (PA-2) identifies the need – Increased efforts to provide
for more technical assistance and capacity financial resources for technical
building to address a number of challenges assistance activities and projects aimed at
at the national level, such as the limited risk improving national chemicals
assessment skills and capacity, insufficient management capacity (Venezuela)
mechanisms to effectively control the influx – Lack of availability of awareness
of chemicals, absence of proper regulatory trainings in all six languages (Yemen)
mechanisms, poor awareness on hazards – Lack of availability of trainings,
associated with chemicals, insufficient
information and documents in all six
cooperation among stakeholder, and
languages (Yemen)
insufficient monitoring of health and
environmental impacts.
– Bahrain (PA-5) proposes an
increase in capacity building activities.
– Uganda (PA-2) proposes actions to
increase the Parties’ in-country technical
capacity to meet the Convention
obligations, such as the consolidation of a
data on listed industrial chemicals with
outstanding import responses, the
consolidation of data on the status of
chemicals (usage, manufacture, formulation
and import), the establishment of
mechanisms for interaction between
37
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
ministries, the public and private sectors,
academia and decision-makers, measures to
overcome capacity constrains in the
government, the collection of technical
information for decision-making on
pesticides and industrial chemicals, and the
establishment of an effective infrastructure
to monitor chemicals and pesticide
poisoning.
– Venezuela (PA-3) proposes improved
technical and financial assistance for the
safe management of chemicals that are
subject to international trade. Assistance
could be directed towards technical training
to strengthen the institutional capacity of
laboratories and Customs and risk analyses
for chemicals at the national level, taking
into account the bio-physical aspects of the
country.
– Yemen (PA-2) suggests promoting
technical assistance for the development of
infrastructure and capacity for chemicals
management:
Parties with more advanced
chemical programmes should provide
technical assistance, including training, to
other Parties that are developing their
infrastructure and capacity.
Trainings and awareness-raising
meetings should be organized for new
Parties and Parties experiencing difficulties
in meeting their obligations under the
Convention.
Training programs and
information documents should be made
available in all six languages.
A platform for information-
sharing about national regulatory decisions
on chemicals and pesticides should be made
available in all six languages.
38
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
374 93
Promote – Panama (PA-1) suggests promoting – Lack exchange on information and Implementation by individual Parties under Article 16 of the Convention, for
technology transfer technology transfer from developed standards pertaining to tools and example, in combination with a COP decision encouraging BCRC/SCRCs to take
to developing countries to developing countries, to technologies (Panama) measures to promote technology transfer.
countries improve risk evaluations, chemical analyses – Inadequate infrastructure and
and chemicals management systems. facilities for research on MEA issues
– Uganda (PA-4) highlights the need for (Uganda)
increased technology transfer and the – Low technology transfer (Uganda)
problem of limited research capacity. – Insufficient research on MEA
Inadequate infrastructure and facilities for issues (Uganda)
research affect the capacity of relevant
institutions to conduct research on
chemicals. In addition, the government’s
policy to scale down expenditure to achieve
macroeconomic stability has affected the
availability of researchers. Finally, the poor
research-extension linkage and weak
mechanisms for technology dissemination
have led to limited application of research
findings.
8. Actions to improve the availability of funding for national implementation
380 Establish – Ecuador (PA-3) proposes the – Existing financial mechanisms Implementation by individual Parties contributing the Special Voluntary Trust
sustainable financial establishment of a predictable and cover some chemicals conventions, but Fund for the Rotterdam Convention.
mechanism adequately resourced financial mechanism, not the implementation of the Rotterdam
with sufficient new and additional funds to Convention (Ecuador) The COP could also consider revisiting its decision RC-7/8 on the
allow developing countries and countries implementation of the integrated approach to financing.
with economies in transition to comply with As the Rotterdam Convention does not provide for a financial mechanism, the
the obligations under the Convention. establishment of a financial mechanism would require amending the
– The Democratic Republic of the Convention
94
Congo (PA-2) proposes that DNAs receive
financial support to monitor chemicals and Establishing a new Rotterdam Convention mechanism with compulsory
pesticide poisonings and cooperate with the contributions or providing for an obligation on developed Parties and Parties with
Secretariat on the notification of FRAs. more advanced chemical programmes to provide financial assistance (e.g.
through existing mechanisms) requires a COP decision amending the Convention
text.
The amendment would enter into force after ratification, acceptance or approval
93
See footnote 8.
94
See, for example, the amendment to Article 16 of the Convention proposed at COP-8. The text of the proposed amendment is available in document
UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.8/16/Add.1.
39
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
by at least three-fourth of the Parties. Only Parties that have
ratified/accepted/approved the amendment will be bound by it. All other Parties
would continue to be bound by the original Convention text which does not
include a binding obligation on developed Parties and Parties with advanced
chemical programmes to provide financial assistance.
Note: The Secretariat has conducted two studies on possible options for lasting
and sustainable financial mechanisms, available in UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.2/10
and UNEP/FAO/RC/COP.3/13.
381 Raise – The EU and its member States (PA-1) Implementation through public awareness activities and materials.
awareness on suggest enhancing the implementation of
existing financial the Convention by improving awareness on
mechanisms the integrated approach to financing sound
management of chemicals and wastes
(UNEP), including the special programme
to support developing countries and
countries with economies in transition in
strengthening institutional capacity for the
implementation of, among others, the
Rotterdam Convention, as well as the joint
Technical Assistance Programme managed
by the Secretariat.
382 Establish a – Honduras (PA-2) proposes the Implementation through the TA plan.
– Need for support for the
mechanism to help establishment of a mechanism to assist with formulation of national projects to
formulate project formulating national and regional projects implement the Convention and new
submissions aimed at ensuring an effective application amendments (for funding purposes)
of the Convention. – Lack of funding to ensure sound
– Uganda (PA-5) highlights the need to chemicals management (Uganda)
address the lack of funding for the
implementation of the Rotterdam
Convention, including by ensuring that
development partners fulfil their financial
commitments to implement programs and
projects for the development of sound
chemicals management capacity. In Uganda
chemicals management is not a high priority
in government expenses. Furthermore,
relevant sectors experienced difficulties in
preparing timely and acceptable proposals
in accordance with guidelines provided by
funding agencies.
40
Ref. Priority action Summary of priority action Key information gaps Legal and operational implications
9. Actions to improve synergies with the Basel and Stockholm Conventions
390 Organize joint – The former Yugoslav Republic of – Lack of joint activities to share Implementation through a COP decision.
activities to enhance Macedonia (PA-5) proposes the experience on synergies at the national,
the cooperation and organization of joint activities to enhance regional and international level (The
coordination among cooperation and coordination between the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia)
the three Basel, Rotterdam and Stockholm
conventions Conventions at the national, regional and
international level.
41
Appendix
Procedural steps of the listing process and prior informed consent
procedure under the Rotterdam Convention
The following diagram provides an overview on the main steps of the process for listing chemicals in
Annex III and the prior informed consent procedure of the Rotterdam Convention. Each step is
highlighted in a colour that indicates the basis for the described action, which also allows conclusion
about the required steps to amend that step:
(a) Steps highlighted in orange have their source in the Convention text;
(b) Steps highlighted in brown have their source in the text of an Annex to the Convention;
(c) Steps highlighted in yellow have their source in the rules of procedure of the COP (See
decision RC-1/1);
(d) Steps highlighted in pink have their source in the terms of reference (ToR) of the CRC
(See decision RC-1/6);
(e) Steps highlighted in blue have their source in the CRC Handbook95;
(f) Steps highlighted in green have their source in internal practice of the Secretariat.
Diagram – Procedural steps of the listing process and PIC procedure under the Rotterdam
Convention
Proposals for SHPFs Final regulatory actions for chemicals
Parties SHPF causes problems under Adoption of an FRA for a chemical Adoption of a FRA for a chemical
conditions of use in the territory of (ban or severe restriction) (substantial restriction)
a developing country or country The Party adopting the FRA must
with economy in transition from provide export notification to
importing Party (see Annex V, RC) Possibility to inform other Parties
and ensure adequate labelling of through the Secretariat on a
Proposal to the Secretariat exports and enclosure of safety voluntary basis
The proposal must include data sheets, where applicable
adequately documented
information on a list of criteria (See
Annex IV, Part 1 RC)
Notification to the Secretariat
The notification must be made as
soon as possible and no later than
90 days after FRA has taken effect
and contain the information on a
list of criteria (See Annex I RC)
where available.
Secretariat Verification of whether the Verification of whether the Information circulated in PIC
proposal contains the required notification contains the required Circular, Part B of Appendix VI
information information
For complete proposals, a summary A summary of all complete
is circulated to all Parties notifications and information
The summary is published in the PIC regarding those notifications which
Circular: Appendix II (proposals for are not complete is circulated to all
inclusion) Parties
The summary is published in the PIC
Circular: Appendix I (new
Collection of additional information notifications), Appendix V
on the proposal (reference list for previous
Additional information is to be notifications)
collected on a list of criteria (See
Annex IV, Part 2 RC)
Call for information from Parties
and observers through website
95
The Handbook of working procedure and policy guidance for the CRC is available at
http://www.pic.int/TheConvention/ChemicalReviewCommittee/Guidance/tabid/1060/language/en-
US/Default.aspx.
42
Secretariat Proposal and related information Where at least one other
forwarded to CRC notification from another PIC region
(continued)
The proposals, supporting for the same chemical has been
documentation and collected received and verified as being
information is circulated to CRC complete, request to notifying
members and made available on Parties to submit supporting
the website at least 8 weeks before documentation and, if possible, a
the meeting. focused summary.
Translation of summaries and,
depending on its volume,
supporting documentation into
English
Submission of notifications to CRC
The notifications (including
supporting documentation) are
circulated to CRC members and
made available on the website at
least 8 weeks before the meeting
Initial assessment by Secretariat of
notification against listing criteria
and classification in three priority
levels submitted to the Bureau for
preliminary review
CRC CRC bureau members provide initial comments as to whether each
(Bureau) notifications/proposals meets the listing criteria which form the basis of report
by Bureau to the CRC
Establishment of a task group consisting of one or two coordinators (one chair
and one drafter according to recent practice) and a group of CRC members for
each SHPF and chemical
CRC Individual task group members review the notifications and supporting
(task group) documentation and complete analysis table
Coordinator(s) prepare-s first draft report circulated to task group for review,
comments and finalization of report
Secretariat Publication of draft task group report on the website for comments from all
CRC members and observers 2 weeks before CRC meeting
Compilation of comments received is prepared and made available at task
group meeting
CRC Meeting immediately prior to the CRC meeting to review comments and finalize
(task group) the report, indicating which comments have been taken up. The meeting is
open to all CRC members and observers. The final report is made available to
the CRC meeting as a conference room paper.
CRC Review of notifications/proposals at meeting against listing criteria and
(all members) recommendation to COP whether the chemical/SHPF should be listed in Annex
III
The listing criteria for CRC consideration are defined in Annex II and IV
respectively
The CRC must make every effort to achieve consensus and may, as a last resort
adopt the recommendation by a two-thirds majority of members present and
voting
Preparation of rationale summarizing how the decision was reached
For chemicals/SHPF found to meet the listing criteria, establishment of a
drafting group for the DGD
43
CRC Preparation of internal proposal for DGD and circulation to the group for
(drafting group) comments
Preparation of revised internal proposal and circulation to all CRC members and
observers for information and comments
Secretariat Preparation of tabular summary of comments for review
CRC Incorporation of comments from CRC members as appropriate and take note of
(drafting group) comments from observers and preparation of draft DGD
Secretariat Translation of draft DGD in the 6 official UN languages
Distribution of draft DGD in 6 UN official languages together with tabular
summary of comments to CRC as meeting document
CRC Finalization and approval of draft DGD at a meeting
(all members) The DGD should at a minimum be based on the information specified in Annex
I, or, as the case may be Annex Iv, and include information on uses of the
chemical in a category other than the category for which the FRA applies
Secretariat Translation of approved draft DGD in the 6 official UN languages, if necessary
Recommendation and draft DGD submitted to COP for decision on listing
Summary of the CRC deliberations, including rationale of recommendation and
tabular summary of comments received and how they were addressed are
made available on the website
COP Decision on whether to list the chemical/SHPF and adoption of DGD
Secretariat Communication to the depositary of the decisions(s)
Depositary Communication to Parties of adoption of the amendment(s) by the depositary
and notification of entry into force
Secretariat Communication of listing decision and related DGD to all parties
Parties Communication of final import response accompanied by a description and if
possible the text of the legislative/administrative measures upon which it is
based or an interim response, as soon as possible, and in any event no later
than 9 months after communication of the depositary notification containing
the listing decision and the COP adopted DGD
Secretariat Circulation of import responses received, including description of
legislative/administrative measures on which the decisions have been based,
where available, and cases of failure to transmit a response (PIC circular /
website)
Written request to adopt final
import response, or an interim
response where not submitted
after 9 months
Assistance to provide a
response within further 6
months
44
Communicate to Ensure Ensure adequate Advice and
Parties and ensure compliance with labelling of assistance to
compliance by export exported importing Parties
exporters with restrictions in chemicals/SHPF upon request and
import decisions cases where the and enclosure of as appropriate to
no later than 6 importing safety data obtain further
months after country has not sheets, where information to
their circulation submitted a applicable. strengthen their
by Secretariat response chemical
management
capacities
45
Dear DNA colleagues,
The Secretariat of the Rotterdam Convention invited Parties and observers to comment on the
report analysing the legal and operational implications of priority actions to enhance the
effectiveness of the Rotterdam Convention. Report and Call for comments are attached to this
mail.
You can send your comments by 31 March 2018 at:
[email protected] and
[email protected].
Kind regards,
Suzana
Suzana Andrejevic Stefanovic
Šef Odseka
Odsek za upravljanje hemikalijama
Sektor za planiranje i upravljanje u životnoj sredini
Omladinskih brigada 1 -
11070 Novi Beograd
Telefon: 011/7155-221
eMail:
Suzana.A.Stefanovic@ek
ologija.gov.rs
Web:
www.ekologija.gov.rs
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Ovaj eMail je proveren preko GFI MailEssential paketa. Cuvajte prirodu, ne stampajte ovaj eMail. Signature added
by CodeTwo Exchange Rules.