Saksamaa Liitvabariigi Suursaatkond 12.03.2018
[email protected] 10.04.2018 Our ref. 1.4-5/866-2
Mobile working, home office and teleworking
Dear Ms Müller
Ministry of Social Affairs received your inquiry about mobile working, home office and
teleworking. Please find our answers to the questions included in your letter.
1. Which definitions exist for mobile working, home office and teleworking?
The Employment Contract Act (ECA) paragraph 6 section 4 defines teleworking as a
situation where employee does work, which is usually done in the employer’s enterprise,
outside the place of performance of the work, including at the employee’s place of residence.
2. Are there legal regulations concerning mobile working, home office and
teleworking?
The ECA paragraph 6 section 4 stipulates that if employer and employee agree that the
employee will be teleworking, the written employment contract must include that the duties
are performed by way of teleworking. However, there are no other legal regulations
concerning mobile working, home office or teleworking.
The Civil Service Act (paragraph 67 section 3) which applies to officials, stipulates that the
possibility for flexible working time may be prescribed in the acts governing working time,
including the performance of functions outside the office location or teleworking in so far as
the service interests permit.
2a. According to the legal regulations, do employees have a claim to mobile working,
home office and teleworking?
There is no explicit right for employee to request mobile working, home office or teleworking.
2b. Does the employer have the right to reject the employee’s wish for mobile working,
home office and teleworking?
There are no specific regulations on this matter. Since according to law employee does not
have a right to request mobile working, home office and teleworking, employer is not
obligated to consider employee’ request (hence the employer has the right to reject
employee’s wish).
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / ESTONIA / +372 626 9301 /
[email protected] / www.sm.ee / Reg. no
70001952
2c. In case of rejection, does the employer have to justify her/his decision to the
employee or can the employee demand it?
There is no explicit obligation for employer to justify her/his decision to the employee.
However, based on the principle of good faith and obligation of the employer to act loyally
with regard to an employee, the employer has to consider employee’s request for mobile
working, home office or teleworking and in case of rejection, justify the decision. Although, it
must be noted that there is no supervision over applying the principle of good faith and there
are no penalties foreseen for violation of this principle.
2d. Are there regulations concerning the employee’s private use of company devices?
There are no regulations on this matter.
3. Are there other (non-legal) regulations/ agreements regarding mobile working, home
office and teleworking?
In June 2017, the Estonian Trade Union Confederation and the Estonian Employers’
Confederation concluded an agreement that includes recommended principles for
teleworking. The agreement is not legally binding. The agreement is available in Estonian
only: https://www.employers.ee/wp-content/uploads/Kaugtoo_raam-final.pdf
4. Are there data/analyses about size and lines of business offering mobile working,
home office and teleworking?
In 2015 Statistics Estonia conducted the Estonian Work Life Survey for the second time (the
first survey was conducted in 2009).1 Both employees and employers were interviewed in
organisations with 5 and more employees. In total 4778 employees and 848 employers
answered the survey.
The employers were asked if their organisation offers employees the possibility to work
outside the regular workplace (at home, at the library, in a remote office or elsewhere),
excluding work which involves moving between different locations, clients or partners. In total
18% of employers offered teleworking in 2015. The percentage of employers offering
teleworking by the size, owner and sector of the organisation is presented in Table 1. The
fields of activity where offering telework is most common are information and communication
(79% of employers offer telework) and financial and insurance activities (77%).
Table 1. Percentage of employers offering telework by size, owner and sector of
activity
Employers who
offer teleworking,
%
Number of 5-9 16%
employees 10-49 19%
50-249 19%
250+ 29%
Type of owner Private 18%
Voluntary (NGO-s) 29%
Public 14%
Sector Primary 11%
Secondary 14%
Tertiary 20%
Source: Statistics Estonia, Estonian Work Life Survey 2015
1
The report with summaries in English can be accessed here:
http://www.sm.ee/sites/default/files/content-
editors/Ministeerium_kontaktid/Uuringu_ja_analuusid/eesti_tooelu_uuring_2015.pdf
2 (3)
Technicians and Associate Professionals 17%
19%
Services and Sales Workers 9%
8%
12%
5.Skilled
Are Workers,
there data/analyses about
Craft and Related Trades the employees’ use of mobile
Workers 17% working, home office
and teleworking?
Plant and Machine Operators and Assemblers 8%
13%
According to the Estonian Work Life Survey 2015, 20% of employees had worked partially or
all of theirElementary
working Occupations,
time outside of Forces
Armed their employer’s offices
9% in the last four weeks (at home, at
the library, in a remote office or elsewhere). Men 7% telework more than women ( 24% of men
and 16% of women) and employees aged 0% 25–49
5% telework
10% 15% more
20% than
25% older
30% and
35% younger
40%
employees (23% of employees aged 25–49 and 14%–15% of employees aged 15–24
and 49+). Teleworking is most common 2015 among
2009 managers and professionals (see
Graph 1).
Managers and Professionals 38%
38%
Technicians and Associate Professionals 17%
19%
Services and Sales Workers 9%
8%
Skilled Workers, Craft and Related Trades Workers 12%
17%
Plant and Machine Operators and Assemblers 8%
13%
Elementary Occupations, Armed Forces 9%
7%
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40%
2015 2009
Graph 1. Percentage of employees who have teleworked in the last four weeks by
occupation
Source: Statistics Estonia, Estonian Work Life Survey 2015
Other sources of statistics on mobile working, home office and teleworking in Estonia are the
European Labour Force Survey (Eurostat) and European Working Conditions Survey
(Eurofound).
Yours sincerely,
Thea Treier
Head of the Working Life Development
Department
Liis Tõnismaa 6269 805
[email protected]
3 (3)
Aili Petti
Teema: FW: Inquiry about mobile working, home office and teleworking
Manused: Mobile working, home office and teleworking.pdf
From: Liis Tõnismaa
Sent: Tuesday, April 10, 2018 10:50 AM
To: '
[email protected]' <
[email protected]>
Subject: Inquiry about mobile working, home office and teleworking
Dear Ms Müller,
Please find attached our response to inquiry about mobile workng, home office and teleworking conducted by the
German Federal Ministry of Labour and Social Affairs.
Best regards,
Liis Tõnismaa
Tööelu arengu osakonna nõunik
Sotsiaalministeerium
Suur-Ameerika 1, Tallinn 10122
(+372) 626 9805
1