2 June 2020
Ref.: 06-02-20/DG-28
TO: ALL PARTIES TO THE AGREEMENT RELATING TO THE INTERNATIONAL
TELECOMMUNICATIONS SATELLITE ORGANIZATION
Dear Colleagues,
Thank you for attending today’s ITSO Virtual Meeting: Briefing on Intelsat Bankruptcy. We had
the attendance of 79 Parties with 176 participants. I would also like to thank you for your great
support during the virtual meeting.
As agreed in the meeting, attached with this letter is the PowerPoint presentation made at the
virtual meeting and the sample letter for the support of ITSO’s request for relief of stay. I would
be grateful if the support letter could be addressed to the Director General of ITSO and sent at your
earliest convenience by COB 5 June 2020, Washington DC time, to
[email protected]. Please note that
the support letter can be modified as you wish.
Thank you for your continuing support to ITSO.
Sincerely yours,
Attachments:
“Sample letter”
Mr. Patrick Masambu
Director General & CEO
International Telecommunications Satellite Organization (ITSO)
4400 Jenifer St, NW Suite 332
Washington, DC 20015
This letter is submitted by [name of country] in support of the Motion for Relief of Stay submitted
by the International Telecommunications Satellite Organization (“ITSO”) in the Intelsat
bankruptcy proceeding.
ITSO is vitally important to [name of country] by serving as the mechanism to ensure that the
public services obligations that Intelsat agreed to honor when it was restructured in 2001 are
maintained. The need for this supervisory role is as great today as it has been over the past 19
years during which time ITSO has functioned in this role.
In 2001, as part of the restructuring of the Intelsat’s business operations, which had previously
been performed directly by the international organization, those business activities were
transferred to a private company (Intelsat) subject to certain conditions. One of the most critical
conditions was that ITSO would continue to exist as an international organization, with
responsibility for ensuring that Intelsat adhered to certain Public Service Obligations. This
obligation was embodied in the amended ITSO Agreement, which took effect in 2001, and the
mechanism pursuant to which ITSO performs its supervisory responsibilities is the Public Services
Agreement (“PSA”), which also obligates Intelsat to provide funding for ITSO’s operations.
For the first time in 2019, a dispute arose between ITSO and Intelsat as to the extent of that funding
obligation. That dispute, consistent with the terms of the PSA, is the subject of an arbitration
proceeding, as specified in the PSA, conducted under the auspices of the International Chamber of
Commerce, a globally recognized arbitration body.
The automatic stay that has been entered in the Intelsat bankruptcy proceeding is now preventing
that arbitration from proceeding.
If the stay is not lifted, it will enable Intelsat to starve ITSO of its funding, including specifically
Intelsat obligation to provide funding for ITSO’s upcoming fiscal year, which will begin on July
1, 2020. Failure to lift the stay and allow that arbitration proceeding to continue will prevent ITSO
from performing the intergovernmental oversight functions that it was created to perform and will
effectively force it out of existence, in a manner contrary to the legitimate interests and desires of
its 149 Member States, including the United States. This result would also be directly contrary to
representations made by the United States to the other countries that are members of ITSO in 2001
concerning its commitment to ensuring that the Public Services Obligations would continue to be
met following restructuring.
For all these reasons, [name of country] strongly supports ITSO’s Motion for Relief of Stay and
to allow the arbitration proceeding to continue.
Intelsat bankruptcy
and consequences
on ITSO
PATRICK MASAMBU
ITSO Director General
I N T E L SAT F I L I N G F O R B A N K R U P TC Y
❑ On May 13 2020, Intelsat and certain of its subsidiaries have filed petitions for
voluntary bankruptcy under Chapter 11 of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code in the U.S.
Bankruptcy Court for the Eastern District of Virginia.
❑ Intelsat did not file for bankruptcy because of cash issues but rather to enhance
their financial flexibility and allow them to receive accelerated relocation payments
for clearing C-band spectrum (Intelsat is eligible to receive $4.87 billion within the
spectrum clearing program).
❑ It raises serious and substantial concerns with respect to ITSO long-term viability
and regarding Intelsat’s performance of its Public Service Obligations.
❑ The Director General of ITSO is following up directly with the appropriate
authorities in the United States to express our concerns and will take whatever
measures are necessary to ensure that ITSO’s supervisory responsibilities continue
to meet the expectations from the Parties.
I T S O A R B I T R AT I O N A G A I N S T I N T E L SAT
❑ On November 18 2019, with funding from Intelsat for FY 2020 already 5
months overdue, ITSO submitted a Request for Arbitration to the
International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) with respect to its disputes with
Intelsat, pursuant to the dispute resolution mechanism contained in Article
6 of the PSA.
❑ On February 6 2020, the arbitral tribunal was formed and, on 11 February
2020, ITSO submitted a Request for Interim Measures against Intelsat to
obtain some funding so that ITSO can continue to operate while the
arbitration process takes place.
❑ On March 6 2020, a decision was taken that “the Tribunal would not permit
pre-hearing actions to de facto resolve the dispute by starving ITSO of
funds”.
I T S O A R B I T R AT I O N A G A I N S T I N T E L SAT ( C O N T ’ D )
❑ On March 25 2020, ITSO was granted interim measures for Financial Year
(FY) 2020. As it is clear in the order, the arbitral tribunal has structured the
order in a way that preserves ITSO’s rights and protects the status quo
pending completion of this arbitration.
❑ In May 2020, ITSO submitted to the ICC its 1st Memorial, which is a detailed
presentation of the facts and evidence that support ITSO's claims, and
prepared the request for interim measures for FY 2021.
❑ With these proceedings, the financial issue was handled to ensure ITSO
survival within the arbitration process during FY 2021.
B A N K R U P TC Y ’ S I M P L I C AT I O N O N
T H E A R B I T R AT I O N
❑ On May 13 2020, Intelsat filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy and as a consequence
of the bankruptcy proceeding, there is an automatic stay and ITSO cannot
proceed with the ongoing arbitration against Intelsat in the International
Chamber of Commerce Arbitration proceeding, unless the Bankruptcy court
grants ITSO’s Motion for Relief of Stay.
❑ A Motion for Relief of Stay was submitted by ITSO’s lawyers on May 24 2020
and it is expected that the hearing for this Motion will take place on June 9
2020.
B A N K R U P TC Y ’ S I M P L I C AT I O N O N
T H E A R B I T R AT I O N ( C O N T ’ D )
❑ If the Bankruptcy court denies ITSO’s request, ITSO will not be able to maintain normal
operations due to lack of funds beyond July 1 2020.
❑ Intelsat’s counsel already indicated that Intelsat will object to the motion, confirming
their intention to deprive ITSO of funds and thereby force the organization into closure
due to lack of funds for operations.
❑ The U.S. Notifying Administration has a special role to play given that the FCC licenses
the Parties’ Common Heritage, the United States is the Host Country for ITSO and
Intelsat filed for bankruptcy in the U.S. courts. The Director General is in contact with
the U.S. State Department and the FCC to explore as to what the U.S. Notifying
Administration can do to support ITSO during these proceedings.
❑ To get out of the bankruptcy process, as per prior FCC decisions as well as the ITSO
Agreement, the “new” Intelsat will have to sign a PSA with ITSO or the FCC will not
be able to grant a license to the company.
NEXT STEPS
❑The Reserve Fund had to be used during the arbitration proceeding and, if the
automatic stay is maintained, ITSO will run out of money at the end of June
2020.
❑As a matter of utmost priority the Parties should immediately send to the
Director General a letter of support to ITSO’s request for lifting the stay that the
Director General will forward to the Bankruptcy Court. I would be very pleased to
identify the key considerations that such a letter should address.
❑If the Motion for Relief of Stay submitted by ITSO is denied, the Parties should
consider providing ITSO with a special temporary financial contribution to help
the organization for this interim period of bankruptcy proceeding (loan or grant).
NEXT STEPS (CONT’D)
❑39th Meeting of the Assembly of Parties
• October 19 – 21 2020
• Consideration is being given to a virtual meeting
• AP-39 will need to address crucial matters including the future
of the Organization and the future of the Parties’ Common
Heritage.
THANK YOU
Patrick Masambu
ITSO Director
General