Artificial Intelligence enabling
the economy post COVID-19
– The European Way on AI
Discussion paper for D9+ meeting, the 22th of June 2020
Copenhagen, Denmark
Introduction
During the outbreak of COVID-19, artificial intelligence’s potential and benefits have been emphasized
by the unprecedented challenges represented by crisis. Both member states and the Commission has
developed and deployed artificial intelligence as an efficient solution to relevant challenges. AI has helped
diagnose as well as treat patients more precisely and spot complicated patterns in large data sets for the
potential identification of a vaccine.
Solutions based on artificial intelligence are also frequently looked upon as having an enormous potential
for businesses attempting to turn the tides after being severely affected by COVID-19. For example,
artificial intelligence can both help in terms of monitoring the spread, thereby making it possible to safely
re-open our societies and businesses, as well as optimising business operations.
Going beyond the solutions needed here and now, artificial intelligence will also play a significant role in
restarting our economy in the years to come across sectors, industries and business models. COVID-19
has disrupted supply chains, decreased global demand and will undoubtedly have lasting effects.
Businesses of tomorrow are expected to be resilient, dynamic, sustainable - to effectively cope with future
crisis and economic shocks. In general, digital firms perform better and are more dynamic than non-
digital ones – thereby making them more agile and robust in potential downturns. In the long run a more
adaptive and robust industry in Europe would contribute to a stronger competitiveness and a more
resilient economy. Artificial intelligence is therefore a natural part of the formula to restart the economy.
A coherent, innovation-friendly Single Market for AI could contribute significantly to rebooting growth
and jobs in the European economy.
However, the increased application of artificial intelligence has also reinforced the need for trustworthy
artificial intelligence, as some applications of artificial intelligence can pose risks. For example, if trained
with unfit and insufficient data, the outcome of the artificial intelligence could entail risk of bias or
misleading results. In some cases, such results would be merely harmless, in other potentially fatal.
Artificial intelligence is one of the most promising technologies for our future. It can help change our
lives and societies for the better, strengthen our competitiveness as well as tackle some of the most
pressing issues of our time. Reminded of the vast potentials of artificial intelligence as well as its possible
risks, it seems more important than ever that the EU is able to harness the full potential of artificial
intelligence as well as to shape the transformation in the European way - where innovative and
trustworthy artificial intelligence are two sides of the same coin.
Before COVID-19, McKinsey found that “if Europe on average develops and
diffuses artificial intelligence according to its current assets and digital
position relative to the world, it could add 20 percent to its combined
economic output by 2030.”1 At the time, COVID-19 was not on the horizon,
however, the latest forecast predicted a decrease by 7.5 percent in the EU’s
GDP during 2020 - even worse than the financial crisis in 2009.
Therefore, we must put all our energy into the acceleration of artificial
intelligence in order to achieve at least a part of the potential economic
output.
The Commission’s approach: The European way
From the outset of the crisis, the European Commission acknowledged the potential of artificial
intelligence during the outbreak of COVID-19 by dedicating 56 million Euros to medical technologies,
digital tools as well as artificial intelligence-analytics in order to respond to COVID-191. Furthermore,
the Commission also launched the “AI-ROBOTICS vs. COVID-19”-initiative in collaboration with the
European Alliance, aimed at creating a platform for easily accessible and applicable artificial intelligence-
and robotics-solutions to combat COVID-192.
Artificial intelligence was a high priority for the European Commission before the outbreak of COVID-
19 and is even more pressing now., The process towards the EU’s adoption of a legal framework for
artificial intelligence is hence already underway – making Europe one of the first regions in the world to
do so. In its recovery plan, the European Commission proposes to direct massive investments towards
AI and other key technologies through i.e. the Recovery and Resilience Facility as well as mobilising
private investments, emphasizing that such technologies are key to Europe's future.
Work is now moving forward with the public consultation on the white paper being finalised. The results
of the public consultation are expected to provide a valuable input to the European Commission in its
preparation for a proposal which is set to be presented in the beginning of 2021 at the latest.
its white paper, the European Commission presents a two-tiered European approach to artificial
approach. An investment-oriented approach which aims at mobilising resources along the entire value
chain to achieve an ecosystem of excellence. A regulatory approach, including a concrete legislative
proposal on how to address high risk for individuals and societies, should ensure that citizens trust the
usage of artificial intelligence and provide the legal certainty for innovation in order to achieve an
ecosystem of trust. The twin objective is to promote the development and uptake of artificial intelligence
in an ethical and human-centric manner.
On this basis, the time is ripe for the D9+ to convene and discuss common interests concerning the
elements of the white paper as well as reach out to other likeminded member states in order to strive for
a possible joint position for the European Commission to take into account in its further work.
1 The European Commission: https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/news/coronavirus-response-eu56-million-solutions-
using-medical-technologies-digital-tools-and
2 The European Commission: https://ec.europa.eu/digital-single-market/en/news/join-ai-robotics-vs-covid-19-initiative-european-
ai-alliance
How to ensure trustworthy AI, while not stifling innovation?
With the aim of accelerating artificial intelligence, we must foster an ethical and human-centric use of
artificial intelligence. Besides this objective, a future European regulatory framework should also aim at
of creating a genuinely single market for artificial intelligence based on a coordinated approach which
avoids future fragmentation resulting from diverse national regulatory regimes. Likewise, a new regulatory
framework must be effective in achieving the intended goals without being overly prescriptive with the
risk of creating disproportionate burdens, especially for SMEs. In order to achieve this balance, the
European Commission has proposed a risk-based approach where the use of “high-risk “artificial
intelligence is subject to mandatory requirements depending on the level of risk. All other artificial
intelligence would be subject to a voluntary labelling scheme.
The European Commission’s considerations as well as the white paper’s elements resonate with a
proportionate and risk-based regulatory framework, but the main building blocks such as defining “high-
risk” artificial intelligence, establishing new requirements, certifying and enforcing such requirements as
well as making a voluntary labelling scheme relevant for citizens need further elaboration in order to
establish an operational framework.
The importance of an operable framework must not be underestimated, especially with respect to
establishing a clear and limited definition of “high risk” artificial intelligence, thereby covering
applications which can actually cause serious risks. It was frequently highlighted as one of the prime
objectives of the upcoming framework by various Danish stakeholders in the consultation process, as
uncertainty could lead to the result of unnecessarily stifling innovation. The General Data Protection
Regulation has illustrated this point, as the EU was able to set new global privacy standards, but where
subsequent demand for guidance proved vital in order to navigate the rules. Furthermore, as artificial
intelligence is a fast-evolving technology, the regulatory framework will need to be able to accommodate
new business models and applications, which are not yet invented, but probably will be in the very near
future. This challenge calls for a framework, which is digital-by-default as well as futureproof. Carefully
considering the user-perspective and ensuring legal certainty will therefore be crucial in order to establish
an operational regulatory framework for artificial intelligence.
COVID-19 has furthermore highlighted the need for adaptability as well as to enhance trustworthy
artificial intelligence at a general level and not only for the applications which pose serious risks. How to
go about this without stifling innovation? And how do we incentivize companies to actively develop
responsible and ethical solutions as a competitive parameter thereby establishing a first mover advantage
for European businesses in the global competition?
Trust, innovation as well as legal certainty are pertinent to the wider uptake of artificial intelligence as
well as scalability across borders. It is therefore essential to find the right balance in the risk-based
approach between minimizing risk and facilitating the development of new solutions for societal
challenges as well as to execute this in a clear, operable and futureproof regulatory framework.
No single market for artificial intelligence without strengthening the
underlying ecosystem
Besides paving the way towards a single market for artificial intelligence through a regulatory framework,
there are a number of barriers for the development and uptake of artificial intelligence that must be
addressed if the EU will be able to fully seize the opportunities which the technology has to offer. This
includes a strengthened focus on fostering vibrant ecosystems through mobilising resources along the
entire value chain, fostering cooperation and partnerships, upskilling the workforce for the digital
economy as well as making investment, data and testing facilities available across the EU.
One of the grave challenges is the access to data across the EU. Facilitating this access is indisputable a
precondition for a successful single market for artificial intelligence, as the development of artificial
intelligence and possibility to scale across borders and innovate in a larger home market are strictly
dependent on the access to high-quality, standardised data. For data to move seamlessly across borders
and domains, soft infrastructures based on technical and legal frameworks rather than actual, physical
data pools are needed. This will enable decentralised data sharing, where businesses can easily share data
among each other, thereby also furthering the availability of data and contributing to strengthening
Europe’s digital capacities and competitiveness.
If we truly want to reap the benefits of artificial intelligence post COVID-19 and position ourselves at
the forefront of the digital economy, we must be ambitious in our priorities and continue to improve our
abilities to develop and deploy responsible, ethical and secure artificial intelligence, making this a
trademark for the EU.
Taking these perspectives into consideration, we would like to engage in a discussion on the following
questions:
With the regulatory approach of the white paper in mind, what is in your view the best
approach in order to achieve a proportionate and risk-based framework for artificial
intelligence, for example through defining which artificial intelligence applications pose high
risk, setting ex-ante requirements and establishing a governance structure?
What are the most important framework conditions which must be improved in order to
accelerate the development and uptake of artificial intelligence (i.e. facilitating data access
and sharing) in the EU as well as promote trustworthy artificial intelligence?
MINISTER FOR INDUSTRY,
BUSINESS AND FINANCIAL
AFFAIRS
Dear colleagues, MINISTRY OF INDUSTRY,
BUSINESS AND FINANCIAL
It is my great pleasure to announce to you the programme and discussion AFFAIRS
note (enclosed with this e-mail) for the D9+ taking place on Skype for Busi-
Slotsholmsgade 10-12
ness. The theme of the meeting will be “Artificial Intelligence Enabling the 1216 Copenhagen K
Economy post COVID-19 – the European Way for AI”. Denmark
I look forward to seeing you all at the first D9+-meeting in cyberspace for Tlf. +45 33 92 33 50
an exciting discussion on Europe’s way ahead to become a leader in the Fax. +45 33 12 37 78
CVR-nr. 10092485
development of responsible AI.
EAN nr. 5798000026001
[email protected]
www.em.dk
Yours sincerely,
Simon Kollerup
1. maj 2020
20/00603-3
Programme for D9+ on the 22nd of May, 2020
09.45-10.00 Connection-check via Skype for Business.
10.00-10.10 Introduction
10.10-10.40 Input from businesses:
The Danish Start-Up Association and Corti – Risk-
based AI as seen by a Danish company, using AI to
aid emergency workers in detecting cardiac arrests.
Google – Risk-based AI as seen by a company work-
ing to advance AI for everyone.
10.40-12.10 Ministerial discussion (see discussion note)
12.10-12.30 AOB
Choice of the next D9+-host
Conclusions
Saatja: Johan Amby (EM-DEP) <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 08.06.2020 12:50
Adressaat: Eva Tarselius Hallgren <
[email protected]>;
Gribnau, F.J.A. (Fleur) <
[email protected]>; Max Gindt
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; Evelin Kuuse
<
[email protected]>; Kadi Avingo <
[email protected]>; MKM info
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
Michalowska Anna <
[email protected]>; Zagranica
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
Silver Tammik <
[email protected]>; Christman Roos
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
Schurink, S.M. (Soschanne <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; Eoin Cuddihy
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>; Silver Tammik
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
<
[email protected]>; <
[email protected]>;
'Veronika Kadlecova' <
[email protected]>
Koopia: Tine Nielsen Hertz (EM-DEP) <
[email protected]>; Anne Hedeager Bentsen
(EM-DEP) <
[email protected]>; Stefan Højvang Christensen (EM-DEP)
<
[email protected]>
Teema: D9+: Discussion note and programme
Dear colleagues
The D9+ is approaching and we are looking forward to welcoming you on
Skype for Business on the 22nd of June. Please find enclosed the
discussion note and programme for the meeting as well as a letter from
the Minister of Industry.
We would appreciate if you can confirm your delegation by Wednesday the
17th of june, upon which we will send out the link for the D9+-meeting as
well as a list of participants.
Best regards,Johan
Johan Amby (EM-DEP) Head of Section Slotsholmsgade 10-121216 Copenhagen
KDenmark
Tel. +45 33 92 33 50Tel. Dir. +45 91 33 72 57Mobile +45 91 33 72 57
EAN5798000026001______________________________
The Ministry of Industry, Business and Financial Affairs is responsible
for processing the personal data we receive from you. You can read more
about how we process your personal data on our website
https://eng.em.dk/about-us/privacy-policy/.
The Ministry of Industry, Business and Financial Affairs would like to
point out that this email and any attachments are confidential. If you
are not the intended recipient, please inform the sender right away by
replying to this email and then delete the email. If you have received
this email in error, we would like to inform you that any copying,
disclosure or distribution of this email may be illegal.