Didier Reynders Your Ref: 10.06.2020 No
European Commissioner
for Justice Our Ref: 11.06.2020 No 24.1-2/20-
European Commission 0069/3910-2
Rue de la Loi / Wetstraat 200
1049 Brussels BELGIUM
Adina-Iona Vălean
European Commissioner
for Transport
European Commission
Rue de la Loi / Wetstraat 200
1049 Brussels BELGIUM
Letter of Recommendations
Dear Commissioner Reynders,
Dear Commissioner Valean,
We would like to thank you for the letter as regards the Recommendation of the Commission on
vouchers offered to passengers and travellers as an alternative to reimbursement for cancelled
package travel and transport services in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic.
I would like to emphasize that just like in the other countries across Europe, also Estonian travel
industry faces serious difficulties due to the crisis caused by the spread of COVID-19 pandemics
and travel restrictions. Therefore, our travel industry has been standing still and almost all travels
have been cancelled.
In your letter you have referred that while recognising the serious impact that the COVID-19
pandemic has had on carriers, organisers of package tours and providers of tourism services, the
Recommendation on vouchers recalls that the Union’s rules under the passenger rights Regulations
and the Package Travel Directive remain applicable in the current COVID-19 context. In case of
cancellation of transport services or a package tour, passengers or travellers have the right to be
reimbursed in money within the prescribed legal timeline (within 7 days to one month for
passengers, depending on the transport mode, or 14 days for package travellers).
Estonia has an approach that respects the travellers´ right to be reimbursed as the result of cancelled
holidays. Thus, Estonia did not implement unilaterally any divergent measures which would
reduce the travellers´ rights. Vouchers as an alternative way of refunding were and are accepted in
case there is a traveller´s consent and if vouchers are protected from the insolvency of a tour
operator (i.e vouchers are covered by security of an organiser). Vouchers can provide some
flexibility for both tour organisers and travellers. But we also see that enormous financial pressure
for travel industry remains as the majority of travellers for various reasons do not choose for
vouchers. We are afraid that in the long term, this solution may not be viable for travel sector as
the instruments in Package Travel Directive were not designed to address worldwide situations
such as that brought by COVID-19. Aiming to help the sector to overcome the crisis Estonia has
introduced relevant support schemes for travel industry, both in the form of direct financial support
and loans, in addition to general business support measures. Unfortunately, due to liquidity
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / ESTONIA
Phone: +372 625 6342 / Fax: +372 631 3660 / E-mail:
[email protected] / http://www.mkm.ee
problems and increased liabilities we have also faced several insolvencies in the sector.
For these reasons we have requested changes to the Package Travel Directive, which would
temporarily facilitate the difficult situation for travel industry. Our proposition was temporarily
postponing the deadline for refunds or allowing organisers of package travel to issue vouchers
instead of reimbursement in money. Our concern is that in those circumstances where travels are
ceased or significantly restricted in one way or another, the travel industry is not capable to fulfil
its obligation to reimburse travellers all payments for cancelled packages within 14 days as
required in the package travel directive (EU) 2015/2302. Due to the worldwide pandemics, the
travelling industry faces serious liquidity problems and it is almost impossible to compensate
travellers within such limited period. We believe that within the EU we should have a coordinated
response in due time on those issues so that to ensure that all travellers and tour operators are
treated equally and to also ensure the viability of the travel sector and the level playing field for
all operators. For now, our proposed changes to the Directive to address the current crisis are
already too late and would no longer offer solution for the industry as many Member States have
introduced different divergent measures on their national level.
We would also like to emphasize that air transport sector plays the major role in economic growth
and connectivity. The reduction in air traffic has severely impacted the entire sector. In this context,
the Commission’s recommendations on vouchers help to avoid the imminent insolvency of a
number of European air carriers and, for most passengers, the fact that the ticket price for a
cancelled flight would not be fully reimbursed. As for Estonia, there are no air carriers holding
Estonian air operator certificate or operating licence that would have been impacted by the
COVID-2 outbreak and at the same time would benefit from recommended vouchers. However,
the Estonian economy is significantly related to the future of air operators and the existence of
high-quality air connections. For this reason, enabling flexibility for the aviation sector and the
viability of the sector is of fundamental importance to the Estonian economy. In this current crisis,
it remains important to ensure the high protection of consumers rights in addition to maintaining
the sustainability of the aviation sector. The interests of Estonian air passengers need adequate
protection. In this light, we welcome the decision on temporary alternative solution for making
vouchers more attractive for passengers following the respect of flexibility and the protection
against the insolvency of the air carriers.
We sincerely hope that the tourism industry can exit this crisis as more informed, insured and
sustainable. Our citizens benefit fully from experience, knowledge and values that tourism
destinations in Europe can provide.
Thank you for your cooperation.
Yours sincerely,
Kristi Talving
Deputy Secretary General
Evelin Kuuse
+372 625 6353
[email protected]
2 (2)