Audit report form v.5
AUDIT OF OPERATION REPORT
Central Baltic INTERREG V A Cross-border Co-operation Programme 2014 – 2020
AUDIT NUMBER: CB-25/2021
Date of final audit report 10/12/2021
Contradictory procedure 25/11/2021
Accounting period 01/07/2020 – 30/06/2021
Audit scope Progress report No. 3.1 and 30 168.07 EUR, audited 100 %
Elis Kõrvek, Audit Manager, Lead Auditor of II Audit Unit, Financial Control
Department of Ministry of Finance of Estonia Suur-Ameerika 1, 10129 Tallinn,
Estonia
Auditor(s)
Kaisa Kallas, Audit Supervisor, Head of the II Audit Unit, Financial Control
Department of Ministry of Finance of Estonia Suur-Ameerika 1, 10129 Tallinn,
Estonia
MTÜ Eesti Maaturism
Audited organisation Vilmsi 53G, 10147 Tallinn
& contact information Katrin Papp
[email protected], +372 6009999
Place of the audit MTÜ Eesti Maaturism (ERTO)
Persons present during the audit Raili Mengel, project coordinator
Date of on-the-spot checks 23.09.2021
Full project name Long distance cross-border hiking trail “The Forest Trail”
Project Number & Acronym CB779 – Forest Trail
Priority Axis 2. Sustainable use of common resources
SO 2.1 Natural and cultural resources developed into sustainable tourist
Specific Objective
attractions
Reporting Period 01.04.2020 - 30.09.2020
Name of the Lead Partner Latvian Country Tourism Association
Project duration
01/04/2019 - 31/12/2021
(start and end dates)
Based on the audit work performed we have obtained reasonable assurance that the
expenditure declared under the audited operation CB779 – FOREST TRAIL within
priority axis 2 in the reference year 01/07/2020 – 30/06/2021 is, in most material
AUDIT
aspects, legal and regular.
CONCLUSION
However, the auditors made a minor finding without a financial impact in regard to
calculating and reporting fuel costs. The summarized list of findings identified
during the audit is presented in the following table and report.
Number
Total Financial Total Financial
of Nature of the finding(s)
Impact Impact ERDF
findings
Page 1
Audit report form v.5
Fuel costs are not calculated and reported according to the
1 € 0.00 € 0.00 internal policy of the beneficiary (Minor finding, without financial
impact)
Page 2
Audit report form v.5
PART 1 – AUDIT SCOPE
According to Article 127 of Regulation (EU) No 1303/2013 the audit authority is responsible to carry out
audits of operations on the basis of supporting documents constituting the audit trail and verify the legality
and regularity of expenditure declared to the Commission, including the following aspects:
a) that the operation was selected in accordance with the selection criteria for the Operational
Programme, was not physically completed or fully implemented before the beneficiary submitted
the application for funding under the Operational Programme, has been implemented in accordance
with the approval decision and fulfilled any conditions applicable at the time of the audit concerning
its functionality, use, and objectives to be attained;
b) that the expenditure declared to the Commission corresponds to the accounting records and that
the required supporting documentation demonstrates an adequate audit trail;
c) that for expenditure declared to the Commission determined in accordance with Articles 67(1)(b)
and (c) and 109 of Regulation (EU) No 1303/2013 and Article 14(1) of Regulation (EU) No 1304/2013,
outputs and results underpinning payments to the beneficiary have been delivered, participant data
or other records related to outputs and results are consistent with the information submitted to the
Commission and that the required supporting documentation demonstrates an adequate audit trail.
PART 1.1 – LIMITATION OF SCOPE
The conclusions of the audit are based on the analysis of the procedure in place, information and documents
gathered and interviews conducted in the audited bodies as well as the tests performed in the course of the
audit following the checklist for the audit areas.
PART 1.2 – AUDIT METHODOLOGY
The audit is carried out in compliance with internationally accepted auditing standards and the audit
strategy, which is approved by the audit authority and group of auditors representing each Central Baltic
INTERREG VA Programme Member State.
The audit process comprises of three stages:
a) Preparation and planning of the audit
In this stage legal regulations and other documentation, including from the management verification
ex Regulation (EU) No 1299/2013, Article 23(4), needed for familiarising with the selected
operations were collected and analysed. Also, interviews or checklists which were needed for the
planning of the audit, familiarising with the functioning of the system, project files structure, the
objectives and the status of implementation of the operations, the risk encountered during the
implementation as well as those inherent to the type of operations.
b) Fieldwork
At this stage a whole range of interviews with responsible staff were conducted, documents were
gathered and testing was performed. In order to attain the audit objectives during the audit we
tested all applicable audit areas. We performed the audit using the checklists for the several audit
areas which enabled us to verify the requirements laid down in European and national legislation.
The assurance about the achievement of the project’s objectives was attained via documentation
uploaded to the programme’s information system (eMS), e-mail conversation with the project
partner and photos of the project outputs.
Page 3
Audit report form v.5
c) Reporting
This stage encompassed activities related to the preparation of the Draft Report and the
contradictory procedure where auditee has been granted 10 working days to reflect on the audit
report, the inclusion of their replies and comments and the submission of the Final Report.
Provide the actual schedule of the contradictory procedure as following
Preliminary report: 25.11.2021
Final report: 10.12.2021
PART 2 – FINANCIAL DATA OF OPERATION
Financial data of audited partner must be listed
PART 2.1 – BUDGET (EUR)
Audited Partners approved budget Granted in % Payments included %
total for the in the payment
partner claim
ERDF € 130,689.70 79% € 23,832.77 79%
Public funding (total) € 0.00 0% € 0.00 0%
Private funding €34,740.30 21% € 6,335.30 21%
Income € 0.00 0% € 0.00 0%
TOTAL PARTNER BUDGET € 165,430.00 100% € 30,168.07 100%
Audited expenditure (according to the Sample, report 3.1)1
Total amount audited Ineligible detected in
(combining audit scope
Budget Line milestones)
1. Staff costs € 20,047.50 € 0.00
2. Office and administration € 3,007.11 € 0.00
3. Travel and accommodation € 1,391.71 € 0.00
4. External expertise and services € 5,721.75 € 0.00
5. Equipment € 0.00 € 0.00
6. Infrastructure and works € 0.00 € 0.00
Total amount audited € 30,168.07 € 0.00
1
Costs outside the sample were not audited
Page 4
Audit report form v.5
PART 3 – FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
PART 3.1 GENERAL
During the audit we identify and document audit findings. We categorise these findings by reference to the
level of importance. The categories which we use to classify our findings are as follows:
Findings which have a financial impact above EUR 250 (ERDF) or any other high-
Major
risk deficiencies.
Findings for which action should be taken to ensure full compliance but have a
Minor limited financial impact (below EUR 250 (ERDF)), no financial consequences or
no high-risk character.
All audit findings are reported in the final audit report, even if the Member States participating in the
Programme may decide that neither the lead beneficiary nor the Programme's MA is obliged to recover an
amount unduly paid which does not exceed EUR 250, per operation and accounting year, not including
interest, in contribution from the Funds and the EMFF, as all the irregular amounts detected are to be taken
into account for the calculation of the annual Total Error Rate of the Programme.
PART 3.2 FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS PER BUDGET LINE
In this paragraph the findings and recommendations per audit area are included.
Accounting and calculating errors at project level
Audit Finding No. 1 – Fuel costs are not calculated and reported according to the internal policy of
the beneficiary (Minor finding)
According to Central Baltic Programme 2014-2020 Programme Manual: „Travel and accommodation
cost should be properly documented in line with the national legislation or internal policy of the partner
organisation“.
The beneficiary has used in the project payment claims different methodology for fuel expense
calculations in case of employees’ private cars used for work travel (0,3 euros per kilometer) and for
company cars (8 liters per 100 kilometers). In case of company cars fuel invoice and route diary are
submitted, but the beneficiary has not calculated and reported the fuel costs as set in the internal policy
(8 liters per 100 kilometers). The beneficiary declared the fuel costs based on invoices and did not take
into account the calculations based on 8 liters per 100 km. Although there were deviations in fuel cost
calculations within the payment claim, the beneficiary has declared fuel cost in a smaller amount than
eligible according to the national legislation and internal policy of the beneficiary. Fuel costs outside
the audit scope were also checked during the audit. Sufficient audit trail exists. Thus, based on the audit
work performed auditors have obtained reasonable assurance that the fuel costs declared are eligible
expenditure.
The auditors would like to point out thet the First Level Control should identify errors in calculating and
repoting of the fuel costs. Appropriate guidance should be given to beneficiaries.
Page 5
Audit report form v.5
Recommendations:
1) Recommendation to the auditee:
It is recommended to calculate and report the fuel costs as set in the internal policy in future
payment claims of the project.
2) Recommendation to the First Level Control
It is recommended to always ascertain that declared fuel costs are calculated and reported in line
with beneficiary’s internal policy and national legislation.
Auditee’s response:
We accept your minor finding. Fuel costs can be calculated and reported according to the internal
policy of ERTO up to 10 liters per 100km if is used ERTO´s car. At the moment ERTO´s Board have
decided that in all existing period projects will be calculated and reported up to 8 liters per 100km
during reporting period.
Using personal car, ERTO pays car compensation 0.30 eurosent per 1km.
First Level Control response:
FLC takes into account the audit recommendation and will pay more attention that the fuel costs
will be calculated and reported in line with beneficiary’s internal policy and national legislation.
PART 4 - FOLLOW-UP
This audit report is compiled for use of the Audit Authority of the Central Baltic INTERREG VA 2014-2020
Programme and will be used to draw conclusions about the functioning of the Management and Control
Systems of the above-mentioned Programme. Information in the report will be disclosed to relevant parties
involved of management of the EU funds, including Commission services.
Parties responsible of audit finding follow-up:
1. Findings with Financial impact – The Audit Authority (AA) will inform the Managing Authority (MA)
to take necessary actions to correct shortcomings in the system;
a. Deductions will be made by the MA;
b. Confirmation of deductions will be made by the AA;
c. If needed follow-up audit will be done by Group of Auditor (GoA) members.
2. Findings without the Financial impact
a. The MA will be informed and evaluation will be done if further actions are needed;
b. Confirmation of actions will be followed-up by the AA and if needed by the GoA members.
Upon request from the MA the Auditee is responsible to implement the recommendations and deliver the
proof to the MA.
Audit Manager: Elis Kõrvek
Signed electronically
Audit Supervisor: Kaisa Kallas
Signed electronically
Page 6
Raili Mengel
MTÜ Eesti Maaturism Meie 13.12.2021 nr 10-5/8841-1
[email protected]
Auditi lõpparuande edastamine
Austatud proua Mengel
Edastame Teile Kesk-Läänemere INTERREG V-A programmi projekti nr CB779 „Forest
Trail“ projektiauditi lõpparuande nr CB-25/2021.
Täname Teid meeldiva koostöö ja osutatud abi eest.
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Kaur Siruli
Finantskontrolli osakonna juhataja
Lisa: Auditi lõpparuanne (6 lehel)
Sama:
Pr Imbi Uusjärv, Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus (
[email protected])
Pr Merike Niitepõld, Managing Authority / The Regional Council of Southwest Finland
(
[email protected])
Teadmiseks:
Pr Mairi Uusen, Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus (
[email protected])
Hr Urmo Merila, Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus (
[email protected])
Elis Kõrvek 611 3197
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 611 3558 /
[email protected] / www.rahandusministeerium.ee
registrikood 70000272