Tere
Edastan. Vastamise tähtaeg on 01.05.2018.
Heade soovidega
Tiiu Noobel
Sekretär
Eesti alaline esindus Euroopa Liidu juures
Rue Guimard 11/13, 1040 Brüssel
Tel: + 32 2227 4337
E-post:
[email protected]
http://www.eu.estemb.be/esindus/personal
From: AviationEmploymentStudy <
[email protected]>
Sent: teisipäev, 20. märts 2018 17:01
To: Ethel Bubõr <
[email protected]>; Helena Pall <
[email protected]>; Tiiu Noobel
<
[email protected]>
Cc: Brannigan, Charlotte <
[email protected]>; Amaral, Sofia
<
[email protected]>
Subject: DG MOVE Aviation Sector studies – Member State survey – response required
Dear Sir/Madam,
The European Commission (DG MOVE) has appointed Ricardo Energy & Environment to undertake the
following studies related to the legal framework in the aviation sector:
a. a fact-finding study on employment and working conditions of aircrews in the EU
internal aviation market to gain an understanding of the level of use of various forms of
atypical employment in the aviation sector and establish the impact on working conditions
b. an ex-post evaluation of Regulation No 1008/2008 on common rules for the
operation of air services in the Community to assess the application, effects and
performance of the Regulation, including its impacts on employment and working conditions
in the sector
Please see the attached letters of support from the European Commission for further information on
each study.
We would like to invite representatives from relevant departments/ministries within your country to
take part in the stakeholder consultation for these studies and respond to the attached questionnaires.
There are two surveys that we would like to circulate to national level contacts within your country:
1. Survey of national labour inspectors – to be sent to the relevant national labour inspectorate in
your country or national body responsible for enforcement of labour legislation in the aviation
sector in your country
2. Survey of employment authorities – to be sent to the relevant employment ministry or national
authority responsible for developing and implementing social policy related to pilots and cabin
crew in your country
Their contribution is crucial for the success of the study. The responses to the survey will be used to help
the European Commission better understand the presence, nature and extent of the issues that pilots
and cabin crew face in terms of their employment and working conditions. Please could you confirm if
you are able to forward this message and the relevant survey questionnaire to the most appropriate
contacts?
Potential respondents should be sent the following:
Two EC letters of support, for studies a) and b) as outlined above; and
Relevant survey questionnaire (either national labour inspector or employment ministry survey)
Completed surveys should be returned by email to
[email protected]. Please note
that both surveys will run for 6 weeks - the deadline for submitting completed surveys is Tuesday 1st
May 2018.
If you have any questions about the surveys or require further information on any of the studies, the
Ricardo team can be reached at
[email protected].
Thank you in advance.
Kind regards,
Sofia Amaral
Consultant – Sustainable Transport
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Email:
[email protected]
Direct Dial: +44 (0)1235 753 048
Reception: +44 (0)1235 753 000
Ricardo Energy & Environment
30 Eastbourne Terrace
London, W2 6LA
Website: ee.ricardo.com
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ----------
Ricardo Energy & Environment, a trading name of Ricardo-AEA Ltd
Registered Office: Shoreham Technical Centre, Shoreham-by-Sea, West Sussex, BN43 5FG, UK
Company Registration No. 08229264
VAT Registration No. 144024745
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------
-----------------
This e-mail and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they are
addressed. If you have received this e-mail in error please notify the sender immediately and delete this e-mail from your system.
Please note that any views or opinions presented in this e-mail are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent those
of Ricardo (save for reports and other documentation formally approved and signed for release to the intended recipient). Only Directors
are authorised to enter into legally binding obligations on behalf of Ricardo. Ricardo may monitor outgoing and incoming e-mails and
other telecommunications systems. By replying to this e-mail you give consent to such monitoring. The recipient should check e-mail and
any attachments for the presence of viruses. Ricardo accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by this e-mail.
"Ricardo" means Ricardo plc and its subsidiary companies.
Ricardo plc is a public limited company registered in England with registered number 00222915.
The registered office of Ricardo plc is Shoreham Technical Centre, Shoreham-by Sea, West Sussex, BN43 5FG.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -------
-----------------
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
DIRECTORATE-GENERAL FOR MOBILITY AND TRANSPORT
Directorate E - Aviation
E.1 - Aviation Policy
Brussels, 16.01.2018
To whom it may concern
Subject: Consultation of stakeholders in relation with the Study on employment and
working conditions of aircrews in the EU internal aviation market.
Dear Sir/Madam,
In its Aviation Strategy adopted on 2nd December 2015, the European Commission
committed to strengthen its analysis on jobs and employment in aviation.
To support the Commission in this exercise, an independent consultancy - Ricardo AEA
Ltd - has been selected to conduct an external study and a targeted consultation of
stakeholders.
The study may include data collection, questionnaires and interviews. The involvement
of stakeholders through an adequate consultation process is fundamental for the
conclusions of this study. I would therefore ask for your active and prompt cooperation
with the consultants.
All information and/or data provided to the consultants will be shared with the European
Commission. Information/data which stakeholders consider as confidential will not be
made publicly available or identifiable; please make sure you clearly mention to the
consultants all confidential elements and provide a non-confidential version as the case
may be.
If you have any question regarding this study, please contact my colleagues Ms Astrid
Nordahl ('
[email protected]) or Ms Noura Rouissi
(
[email protected]).
Yours sincerely,
Commission europeenne/Europese Commissie, 1049 Bruxelles/Brussel, BELGIQUE/BELGIE - Tel. +32 22991111
Survey of national bodies responsible for enforcement of
labour legislation in the aviation sector (labour
inspectorates)
The European Commission has commissioned Ricardo (ee.ricardo.com) to carry out a study to
explore the employment and working conditions of aircrews in the European and international aviation
market. The study aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the different forms of employment of
aircrews, clarify the nature and extent of use of atypical forms of employment and their implications on
working conditions. It should also help understand how the existing EU and national social rules cover
the activities of aircrews and identify any legal challenges in protecting this category of highly mobile
workers.
This survey targets authorities responsible for enforcing national employment and working conditions
legislation in the country (labour inspectorates).
Where specific questions are more relevant to other organisation(s) in your Member State, we would
appreciate if you would forward the survey to them and request that they send their response to
Ricardo (
[email protected]).
1 Background information on your organisation
1.1 Please provide the following information concerning the organisation you
represent.
a. Name of organisation: Click here to enter text
b. Member State: Click here to enter text
c. Contact person name(s): Click here to enter text
d. Email address(es): Click here to enter text
e. Telephone number(s): Click here to enter text
1.2 What are the responsibilities of your organisation in relation to the enforcement
of employment and working conditions in the aviation sector?
Click here to enter text
1.3 How many labour inspections of airlines did you conduct in 2017 (or the most
recent year for which data is available)?
Click here to enter text
2 Use of atypical employment relationships for pilots and cabin
crew - temporary agencies/intermediary organisations and zero-
hour contracts
2.1 Based on your experience, how common is the use of the following forms of
employment among airlines with operating bases1 in your country?
Not
allowed Allowed
Very Very Quite Very Don’t
under my but not
uncommon common common common know
national used
legislation
Pilots hired via temporary
work agencies
Pilots hired via
intermediary organisations
1
Operating base: Places outside principal place of business where the airline bases aircraft and air crew
Page | 1
(e.g. recruitment agencies)
Pilots employed directly by
the airlines
Cabin crew hired via
temporary work agencies
Cabin crew hired via
intermediary organisations
(e.g. recruitment agencies)
Cabin crew employed
directly by the airlines
Other alternative
employment
arrangements, please
indicate: Click here to
enter text
If possible, please name the airlines involved in the different schemes.
Click here to enter text
2.2 If pilots and cabin crew are hired via temporary work agencies and
intermediaries why do you think airlines do that?
Easier to adjust to Don’t
To save on To save To avoid rules on
changes in the know/Not Other
employment costs on taxes employment
market relevant
Click here
to enter text
2.3 Based on your experience, how common is the use of pilots and cabin crew
working on zero-hour contracts (contracts where aircrew staff are only paid for
the duration of the flight and with no minimum paid hours) by airlines with
operating bases in your country?
Not allowed
Allowed
under my Very Very Quite Very Don’t
but not
national uncommon common common common know
used
legislation
Pilots with
zero-hour
contracts
Cabin crew
with zero-
hour
contracts
2.4 Based on your experience, is the use of pilots and cabin crew hired via
temporary work agencies and intermediaries associated with higher than
average levels of non-compliance with the applicable legislation? Please explain.
Higher that average level Don’t
If YES, please explain the nature of
of non-compliance with… NO YES know/Not
infringements identified
relevant
…rules related to social
Click here to enter text
security contributions
…rules on employment
Click here to enter text
legislation
…rules on working
conditions legislation (pay, Click here to enter text
working time, etc)
...tax obligations Click here to enter text
Page | 2
…health and safety
Click here to enter text
standards
Other issues Click here to enter text
2.5 Based on your experience, are there any specific issues/difficulties in the
enforcement of the applicable national legislation in the case of pilots and cabin
crew hired via temporary work agencies and intermediaries in relation to the
following areas?
Issues/difficulties faced in
If YES, please explain the nature of the
enforcing national rules NO YES Don’t know
problems
related to…
…social security
Click here to enter text
contributions
…employment legislation Click here to enter text
… working conditions
legislation (pay, working Click here to enter text
time, etc)
…tax obligations Click here to enter text
…health and safety
Click here to enter text
standards
Other problems Click here to enter text
2.6 Based on your experience, are there any other issues associated with the use of
atypical employment relationships (use of temporary agencies or intermediaries
and zero-hour contracts) in the aviation sector? Please explain.
Click here to enter text
3 Use of atypical employment relationships for pilots and cabin
crew – self-employment
3.1 Based on your experience, how common is the use of self-employed pilots and
cabin crew by airlines with operating bases in your country?
Not
allowed Allowed
Very Very Quite Very Don’t
under my but not
uncommon common common common know
national used
legislation
Pilots hired as self-
employed or via entities
they fully/partly own
Cabin crew hired as
self-employed or via
entities they fully/partly
own
Other arrangement,
please specify: Click
here to enter text
If possible, please name the airlines involved in the different schemes.
Click here to enter text
Page | 3
3.2 Based on your experience, are the use of pilots and cabin crew with a self-
employed status associated with higher than average levels of non-compliance
with the applicable legislation? Please explain.
Higher that average level If YES, please explain the nature of
NO YES Don’t know
of non-compliance with… infringements identified
…national rules related to
Click here to enter text
social security contributions
…national rules on
Click here to enter text
employment legislation
…national rules on working
Click here to enter text
conditions legislation
…tax obligations Click here to enter text
…health and safety
Click here to enter text
standards
Other problems Click here to enter text
3.3 Are you aware of problems/challenges for the authorities in terms of ensuring
that self-employed pilots and cabin crew fulfil their obligations in terms of the
following? Please explain.
If YES, please explain the
NO YES Don’t know nature of the
problems/challenges
Pilots Social security contributions Click here to enter text
Compliance with Click here to enter text
employment/working conditions
legislation
Fulfilment of tax obligations Click here to enter text
Other problems Click here to enter text
Cabin crew Social security contributions Click here to enter text
Compliance with Click here to enter text
employment/working conditions
legislation
Fulfilment of tax obligations Click here to enter text
Other problems Click here to enter text
3.4 Have you found cases of self-employed pilots or cabin crew that did not actually
meet the conditions of self-employment as set out in national legislation (i.e.
bogus self-employment) and were requalified as workers?
NO YES Don’t know
Pilots
Cabin crew
3.5 What were the reasons why pilots or cabin crew identified as self-employed did
not actually meet the conditions of self-employment? Please indicate all that
apply.
Pilots Cabin crew
They did not have sufficient autonomy from the airline/employer – the airline
exercised high level of control in terms of working time and execution of the contract
They could not work for multiple clients (airlines) in parallel
They received a fixed remuneration
They did not have to provide their own material
They provided services for the same airline for long periods
Other, please explain: Click here to enter text
Page | 4
3.6 Are there any other issues associated with the use of self-employment
arrangements? Please explain.
Click here to enter text
4 Use of rules concerning posted workers
Posting refers to the situation where staff is sent by an employer to carry out a service in another EEA
Member State on a temporary basis.
4.1 Based on your experience, how common is the sending of pilots and cabin crew
on a temporary basis by airlines with operating bases in your country under any
of the following situations? Please consider the cases when your country is
sending pilots and cabin crew to another Member State.
Not Very Quite Quite Very Don’t
used uncommon uncommon common common know
Pilots and cabin crews whose
2
home base is in your country
employed on a temporary basis
in an operating base in another
Member State
Pilots and cabin crew whose
home base is in your country that
are used by the airline as part of
3
a wet-leasing agreement to work
in an operating base in another
Member State
Other cases that could be
considered as temporary
placement in another Member
State
Please explain, namely if you have selected “other cases”.
Click here to enter text
If possible, please name the airlines involved in the different schemes.
Click here to enter text
4.2 Based on your experience, how common is the use of pilots and cabin crew on a
temporary basis by airlines with operating bases in your country under any of
the following situations? Please consider the cases when your country is
receiving pilots and cabin crew from another Member State.
Not Very Quite Quite Very Don’t
used uncommon uncommon common common know
Pilots and cabin crew whose home
base is in another Member State
employed on a temporary basis in
an operating base in your country
Pilots and cabin crew whose home
base is in another Member State
that are used by the airline as part
of a wet-leasing agreement to work
in an operating basis in your
country
Other cases that could be
considered as temporary
2
Home base: The location nominated by the operator to the crew member (pilots and cabin crew) from where the crew member normally starts
and ends a duty period or a series of duty periods and where, under normal conditions, the operator is not responsible for the accommodation of
the crew member concerned.
3
Wet-leasing: An agreement between air carriers to lease aircraft with aircrew pursuant to which the aircraft is operated under the air operator
certificate (AOC) of the lessor.
Page | 5
placement in your country
Please explain, namely if you have selected “other cases”.
Click here to enter text
If possible, please name the airlines involved in the different schemes.
Click here to enter text
4.3 Based on your experience, are the rules related to the posting of workers (rules
derived from the application of the Posting of Workers Directive 96/71/EC)
applied by airlines with operating bases in your country for pilots and cabin
crew?
NO YES Don’t know
Rules related to the
sending Member State
Rules related to the host
Member State
Please provide more details in terms of the rules that have been applied.
Click here to enter text
4.4 If you answer NO in Question 4.3, please explain the reasons why you consider
that the rules related to posted workers (derived from the Posting of Workers
Directive 96/71/EC) are not applied by airlines to pilots and cabin crew.
Click here to enter text
4.5 Are you aware of any problems with the application and/or enforcement of the
national regulations related to the posting of workers for pilots and cabin crew?
NO YES Don’t know Please explain the nature of the
problems
Application of the rules Click here to enter text
Enforcement of the rules Click here to enter text
4.6 Are there any other issues associated with the application (or not) of posting of
workers rules in the aviation sector in your country? Please explain.
Click here to enter text
5 Training schemes for pilots
5.1 Are you aware of the use of pilot training schemes that require pilots to
contribute financially in order to be allowed to fly a certain type of aircraft (e.g.
B737) and/or gain requisite flight experience?
NO YES Don’t know
Airlines with their principal
4
place of business in your
country
Airlines with operating
bases in your country
If yes, please describe the main content of those schemes.
Click here to enter text
4
Principal place of business: The head office or registered office of an EU carrier in the Member State within which the principal financial functions
and operational control, including continued airworthiness management, of the EU carrier are exercised
Page | 6
5.2 If you answered YES in Question 5.1, how common is the use of such schemes?
Not Very Quite Quite Very Don’t
used uncommon Uncommon common common know
Airlines with their principal
place of business in your
country
Airlines with operating bases in
your country
If you answered “Not used”, please explain why (e.g. it is not possible under your national law).
Click here to enter text
5.3 Are there any issues/problems in terms of the employment and working
conditions from the use of such training schemes? Please explain.
NO YES Don’t know
If possible, please provide examples.
Click here to enter text
6 Use of multiple operating bases by airlines
6.1 Are there airlines that have operating bases in your country that are different
from their principal place of business?
NO YES If YES, how many? Don’t know
Click here to enter text
If possible, please name the airlines involved in the different schemes.
Click here to enter text
6.2 Are there pilots and cabin crew working for airlines with an operating base in
your country whose home base is outside the EEA providing the following
services?
NO YES Don’t know
Flights within the EEA
Flights between the EEA
and a third country
If possible, please name the airlines involved in the different schemes.
Click here to enter text
6.3 If you answered YES to Question 0, are there any restrictions that apply to the
use of such pilots or cabin crew?
Click here to enter text
6.4 What are the legal requirements (working permits, visas) that apply for non-EEA
pilots and cabin crew in order to work on flights within the EEA?
Click here to enter text
6.5 Do you enforce your national labour legislation on pilots and cabin crew whose
home base is in another EEA Member State but working for an airline with its
principal place of business in your country?
NO YES Don’t know
Please explain the rules that apply and any necessary conditions/criteria that need to apply.
Click here to enter text
Page | 7
6.6 Does your Member State enforce national labour legislation on pilots and cabin
crew whose home base is in your country but working for an airline with its
principal place of business in another country?
NO YES Don’t know
Please explain the rules that apply and any necessary conditions/criteria that need to apply. Please
also explain who is responsible for enforcement in your Member State.
Click here to enter text
6.7 If you answered YES to Question 0, have you received any complaints or
imposed any sanctions regarding those aircrews? Please explain what
infringements were alleged or committed.
Click here to enter text
6.8 Are you aware of the recent decisions by the European Court of Justice (Joined
Cases C-168/16 and C-169/16) on the determination of the place of habitual work
of aircrews and the competent jurisdictions?
NO YES
6.9 If you answered YES to Question 6.8, have the Court decisions had an impact on
the approach followed in enforcing the labour law for pilots and cabin crew
employed by an airline with its principal place of business outside your country
but with the home base in your country? Please explain.
NO YES Don’t know
Please explain the nature of the changes.
Click here to enter text
6.10 Are there any other issues associated with the enforcement of the national
legislation for pilots and cabin crew? Please explain.
Click here to enter text
7 Other issues
7.1 If any, what other organisations in your country have responsibilities related to
the issues discussed in this survey?
Click here to enter text
7.2 Please discuss any other issues you feel are relevant.
Click here to enter text
Thank you for your participation. Please note that we may contact you for clarifications or
additional information in relation to any of the issues raised.
Please return this survey by email to
[email protected]
Page | 8
Survey of national authorities responsible for developing
and implementing social policy related to pilots and cabin
crew
The European Commission has commissioned Ricardo (ee.ricardo.com) to carry out two
studies examining the social conditions in the aviation sector.
The first study is a fact-finding exercise focusing on understanding the level of use of
various forms of atypical employment in the aviation sector and establish the impact on
working conditions.
The second study examines the impacts of the Air Services Regulation 1008/2008 (the
Regulation) on employment and working conditions in the sector. It is part of the broader
evaluation study of the Regulation.
The two studies will help the European Commission better understand the presence, nature
and extent of the issues that pilots and cabin crew face in terms of their employment and
working conditions. It will also help assess whether these are issues related to the
application of the legal framework governing the provision of air services in the European
Economic Area (EEA).
This survey targets authorities responsible for developing and implementing policy related to
employment and working conditions in the aviation sector. It includes questions related to the
topics covered by both studies.
Where specific questions are more relevant to other organisation(s) in your Member State,
we would appreciate if you would forward the survey to them and request that they send their
response to Ricardo (
[email protected]).
1 Background information on your organisation
1.1 Please provide the following information concerning the organisation you
represent.
a. Name of organisation: Click here to enter text
b. Member State: Click here to enter text
c. Contact person name(s): Click here to enter text
d. Email address(es): Click here to enter text
e. Telephone number(s): Click here to enter text
1.2 Please indicate for which of the following aspects your organisation is
responsible and the nature of your responsibilities.
Please select role (you can Please explain the nature of the
select more than one) role
Responsible for development
of policy concerning
employment and working Click here to enter text
conditions covering the
aviation sector
Responsible for other Click here to enter text
aspects of the Regulation
1008/2008
Other role (enforcement,
etc.), please specify: Click Click here to enter text
here to enter text
2 Use of atypical employment relationships for pilots and cabin
crew – temporary agencies/intermediary organisations and zero-
hour contracts
2.1 How common is the use of the following forms of employment among airlines
with operating bases1 in your country?
Very Quite Quite Very Don’t
Not used
uncommon uncommon common common know
Pilots hired via temporary
work agencies
Pilots hired via
intermediary organisations
(e.g. recruitment agencies)
Pilots employed directly by
the airlines
Cabin crew hired via
temporary work agencies
Cabin crew hired via
intermediary organisations
(e.g. recruitment agencies)
Cabin crew employed
directly by the airlines
Other alternative
employment arrangement,
please indicate: Click
here to enter text
If not used, please indicate why (e.g. it is not possible under your national law)
Click here to enter text
2.2 How common is the use of pilots and cabin crew on zero-hour contracts
(contracts where pilots and cabin crew are only paid for the duration of the flight)
by airlines with operating bases in your country?
Very Quite Quite Very Don’t
Not used
uncommon uncommon common common know
Pilots with zero-hour
contracts
Cabin crew with zero-hour
contracts
If not used, please indicate why (e.g. it is not possible under your national law)
Click here to enter text
1
Operating base: Places outside the principal place of business where the airline bases aircraft and aircrew.
2.3 Are you aware of issues/problems raised (e.g. in the form of complaints or court
cases) by pilots or cabin crew employed under the following arrangements in
relation to their working conditions?
Don’t know Please explain the nature of the
No Yes
problem
Pilots and cabin crew hired
Click here to enter text
via temporary agencies
Pilots and cabin crew hired
via intermediary
Click here to enter text
organisations (e.g.
recruitment agencies)
Aircrew staff hired with Click here to enter text
zero-hour contracts
Where appropriate, please provide reference to any relevant court decision.
Click here to enter text
2.4 Are you aware of specific problems/challenges to the application and
enforcement of the following rules by authorities in the case of pilots and cabin
crew hired via temporary work agencies and intermediaries?
If YES, please explain the
Don’t
NO YES nature of the
know
problems/challenges
Pilots National rules related to social Click here to enter text
security contributions
National rules on Click here to enter text
employment/working conditions
legislation
Fulfilment of tax obligations Click here to enter text
Other problems Click here to enter text
Cabin crew National rules related to social Click here to enter text
security contributions
National rules on Click here to enter text
employment/working conditions
legislation
Fulfilment of tax obligations Click here to enter text
Other problems Click here to enter text
2.5 Are there any other issues associated with the use of temporary agencies or
intermediaries for pilots and cabin crew? Please explain
Click here to enter text
3 Use of atypical employment relationships for pilots and cabin
crew – self-employment
3.1 How common is the use of self-employed pilots and cabin crew by airlines with
operating bases in your country?
Very Quite Quite Very Don’t
Not used
uncommon uncommon common common know
Pilots hired as self-
employed or via entities
they fully/partly own
Cabin crew hired as
self-employed or via
entities they fully/partly
own
Other arrangement,
please indicate: Click
here to enter text
If not used, please indicate why (e.g. it is not possible under your national law)
Click here to enter text
3.2 Are you aware of issues/complaints/court cases in relation to the working
conditions of pilots and cabin crew working as self-employed by airlines?
NO YES Don’t know
Pilots
Cabin crew
Please provide examples, including, where appropriate, a reference to any relevant court
decision(s).
Click here to enter text
3.3 Are you aware of problems/challenges for the authorities in terms of ensuring
that self-employed pilots and cabin crew fulfil their obligations in terms of the
following? Please explain.
If YES, please explain the
Don’t
NO YES nature of the
know
problems/challenges
Pilots Social security contributions Click here to enter text
Compliance with Click here to enter text
employment/working conditions
legislation
Fulfilment of tax obligations Click here to enter text
Other problems Click here to enter text
Cabin crew Social security contributions Click here to enter text
Compliance with Click here to enter text
employment/working conditions
legislation
Fulfilment of tax obligations Click here to enter text
Other problems Click here to enter text
3.4 Are you aware of cases of pilots or cabin crew identified as self-employed that
did not actually meet the conditions of self-employment as set out in national
legislation (i.e. bogus self-employment) and were requalified as workers?
NO YES Don’t know
Pilots
Cabin crew
3.5 What were the reasons why pilots or cabin crew identified as self-employed did
not actually meet the conditions of self-employment? Please indicate all that
apply.
Pilots Cabin
crew
They did not have sufficient autonomy from the airline/employer – the airline exercised
high level of control in terms of working time and execution of the contract
They could not work for multiple clients (airlines) in parallel
They received a fixed remuneration
They did not have to provide their own material
They provided services for the same airline for long periods
Other, please explain: Click here to enter text
3.6 Are there any other issues associated with the use of self-employment
arrangements? Please explain.
Click here to enter text
4 Use of rules concerning posted workers
Posting refers to the situation where staff is sent by an employer to carry out a service in
another EEA Member State on a temporary basis under Directive 96/71/EC. Posted workers
should remain in the host Member State temporarily and do not integrate its labour market.
4.1 Based on your experience, how common is the sending of pilots and cabin crew
on a temporary basis by airlines with operating bases in your country under any
of the following situations? Please consider the cases when your country is
sending pilots and cabin crew to another Member State.
Not Very Quite Quite Very
Don’t know
used uncommon uncommon common common
Pilots and cabin
crews whose
2
home base is in
your country
employed on a
temporary basis in
an operating base
in another Member
State
Pilots and cabin
crew whose home
base is in your
country that are
used by the airline
as part of a wet-
leasing
3
agreement to
work in an
operating base in
another Member
State
Other cases that
could be
considered as
temporary
placement in
another Member
State
Please explain, namely if you have selected “other cases”.
Click here to enter text
4.2 Based on your experience, how common is the use of pilots and cabin crew on a
temporary basis by airlines with operating bases in your country under any of
the following situations? Please consider the cases when your country is
receiving pilots and cabin crew from another Member State.
Not Very Quite Quite Very
Don’t know
used uncommon uncommon common common
Pilots and cabin
crew whose home
2
Home base: The location nominated by the operator to the crew member (pilots and cabin crew) from where the crew member normally starts
and ends a duty period or a series of duty periods and where, under normal conditions, the operator is not responsible for the accommodation of
the crew member concerned.
3
Wet-leasing: An agreement between air carriers to lease aircraft with aircrew pursuant to which the aircraft is operated under the air operator
certificate (AOC) of the lessor.
Not Very Quite Quite Very
Don’t know
used uncommon uncommon common common
base is in another
Member State
employed on a
temporary basis in
an operating base
in your country
Pilots and cabin
crew whose home
base is in another
Member State that
are used by the
airline as part of a
wet-leasing
agreement to work
in an operating
basis in your
country
Other cases that
could be
considered as
temporary
placement in your
country
Please explain, namely if you have selected “other cases”.
Click here to enter text
4.3 Based on your experience, are the rules related to the posting of workers (rules
derived from the application of the Posting of Workers Directive 96/71/EC)
applied by airlines with operating bases in your country for pilots and cabin
crew?
NO YES Don’t know
Rules related to the
sending Member State
Rules related to the host
Member State
Please provide more details in terms of the rules that have been applied.
Click here to enter text
4.4 If you answer NO in Question 4.3, please explain the reasons why you consider
that the rules related to posted workers (derived from the Posting of Workers
Directive 96/71/EC) are not applied by airlines to pilots and cabin crew.
Click here to enter text
4.5 Are you aware of any problems with the application and/or enforcement of the
relevant provisions of the Posting of Workers Directive 96/71/EC for pilots and
cabin crew?
NO YES Don’t know Please explain the nature of the
problems
Application of the rules Click here to enter text
Enforcement of the rules Click here to enter text
4.6 How many Portable Document A14 were issued by the authorities in your country
in 2017 (or the most recent year available) to pilots and cabin crew?
Click here to enter text
4
Portable Documents A1 is a formal statement proving that the holder pays social contributions in another EU country.
4.7 Are there any other issues associated with posting of pilots and cabin crew?
Please explain.
Click here to enter text
5 Training schemes for pilots
5.1 Are you aware of the use of pilot training schemes that require pilots to
contribute financially in order to be allowed to fly a certain type of aircraft (e.g.
B737) and/or gain requisite flight experience?
NO YES Don’t know
Airlines with their principal
5
place of business in your
country
Airlines with operating
bases in your country
If yes, please describe the main content of those schemes.
Click here to enter text
5.2 If you answered YES in Question 5.1, how common is the use of such schemes?
Not Very Quite Quite Very Don’t
used uncommon Uncommon common common know
Airlines with their principal
place of business in your
country
Airlines with operating
bases in your country
If you answered “Not used”, please explain why (e.g. it is not possible under your national
law).
Click here to enter text
5.3 Are there any issues/problems in terms of the employment and working
conditions from the use of such training schemes? Please explain.
NO YES Don’t know
If possible, please provide examples.
Click here to enter text
6 Applicable legislation in the case of multiple operating bases
6.1 Are there airlines that have operating bases in your country that are different
from their principal place of business?
NO YES If YES, how many Don’t know
airlines?
Click here to enter text
6.2 Are there pilots and cabin crew working for airlines with an operating base in
your country whose home base is outside the EEA providing the following
services?
NO YES Don’t know
Flights within the EEA
Flights between the EEA
and a third country
5
Principal place of business: The head office or registered office of an EU carrier in the Member State within which the principal financial functions
and operational control, including continued airworthiness management, of the EU carrier are exercised
6.3 Does your national legislation set any restrictions on the use of pilots and cabin
crew whose home base is outside the EEA?
NO YES Don’t know
If you answered “Yes”, please explain what type of restrictions.
Click here to enter text
6.4 What are the legal requirements (e.g. working permits, visas) that apply for non-
EEA pilots and cabin crew in order to work on flights within the EEA?
Click here to enter text
6.5 Do you enforce your national labour legislation on pilots and cabin crew whose
home base is in another EEA Member State but working for an airline with its
principal place of business in your country?
NO YES Don’t know
Please explain the rules that apply and any necessary conditions/criteria that need to apply.
Click here to enter text
6.6 Does your Member State enforce national labour legislation on pilots and cabin
crew whose home base is in your country but working for an airline with its
principal place of business in another country?
NO YES Don’t know
Please explain the rules that apply and any necessary conditions/criteria that need to apply.
Please also explain who is responsible for enforcement in your Member State.
Click here to enter text
6.7 Are you aware of the recent decisions by the European Court of Justice (Joined
Cases C-168/16 and C-169/16) on the determination of the place of habitual work
of aircrews and the competent jurisdictions?
NO YES
6.8 If you answered YES, did the Court decisions lead to changes to the approach
followed in terms of the application of the national labour legislation for pilots
and cabin crew employed by an airline with its principal place of business
outside your country but with the home base in your country?
NO YES Don’t know
Please explain the nature of the changes.
Click here to enter text
6.9 Are there any other issues associated with the applicable legal framework in the
case of pilots and cabin crew presented above?
Click here to enter text
7 Impacts on employment conditions of Regulation 1008/2008
This section focuses on the impacts of Regulation 1008/2008 on employment conditions.
Regulation 1008/2008 does not explicitly address social issues. However, its application has
implications for the employment and working conditions of aircrew staff. The liberalisation of
the market and current market practices (e.g. multiple operating bases, use of wet leasing)
and the use of alternative employment arrangements (temporary agency workers,
subcontracting, self-employed) might have an impact on the employment and working
conditions level in the EEA aviation market and set challenges to the capacity of authorities
to monitor and enforce compliance with the social legislation.
7.1 It is claimed that certain airlines select to obtain their operating licence in a
specific Member State in order to benefit from a more favourable regulatory
regime concerning employment and working conditions (also known as “rule
shopping”). Are you aware of airlines that use this practice?
NO YES Don’t know
What aspects of the Regulation does it concern? If possible, please provide examples.
Click here to enter text
7.2 If you are aware of such practices, how common do you consider it to be among
airlines?
Does not take Very Quite Very Extremely Don’t Not
place uncommon uncommon common common know relevant
If possible, please provide specific examples of airlines you consider are involved in rule
shopping.
Click here to enter text
7.3 In your view, has the multiplication of operational bases by airlines had an
impact on the employment conditions of pilots and cabin crew?
Not at To a limited Yes, but only Yes, to a large To full Don’t Not
all extent partly extent extent know relevant
What aspects of the Regulation does it concern? If possible, please provide examples.
Click here to enter text
7.4 Regarding the rules on ownership and control that limit foreign capital, has the
adoption of the Regulation ensured that employment levels in the EU aviation
market are protected?
Not at To a limited Yes, but only Yes, to a large To full Don’t Not
all extent partly extent extent know relevant
What aspects of the Regulation does it concern? If possible, please provide examples.
Click here to enter text
7.5 Prior to the adoption of Regulation 1008/2008 it was considered that the use of
wet leasing from third countries could undermine employment conditions of
pilots and cabin crew. In your view, has the adoption of Regulation 1008/2008
ensured that, in the case of wet leasing, employment and working conditions for
pilots and cabin crew from third countries are protected?
To a very To a
To some
Not at all limited significant To full extent Don’t know Not relevant
extent
extent extent
Please explain your answer.
Click here to enter text
7.6 Have the time limitations for the wet leasing from third countries provided for in
Regulation 1008/2008 contributed to avoiding deterioration on employment and
working conditions for pilots and cabin crew in your country?
To a very To a
To some
Not at all limited significant To full extent Don’t know Not relevant
extent
extent extent
What aspects of the Regulation does it concern? If possible, please provide examples.
Click here to enter text
7.7 Do any provisions of Regulation 1008/2008 create problems when it comes to
ensuring that employment and working conditions for pilots and cabin crew
based in your country are properly applied?
No YES Don’t know
What aspects of the Regulation does it concern? If possible, please provide examples.
Click here to enter text
7.8 Please add any other comments concerning the direct or indirect impacts of
Regulation 1008/2008 on employment conditions of pilots and cabin crew.
Click here to enter text
8 Other issues
8.1 Please present any other issues you consider relevant.
Click here to enter text
Thank you for your participation. Please note that we may contact you for
clarifications or additional information in relation to any of the issues raised.
Please return this survey by email to
[email protected]