Egidijus Purlys
Ministry of Energy of the Republic
of Lithuania Our Ref: 22.05.2020 No 17-4/2020/3365-1
Gedimino av. 38
LT-01104, Vilnius
Reply to the consultation on Capacity
Remuneration Mechanism for Lithuania
Dear Mr. Purlys,
The Lithuanian Ministry for Energy launched a public consultation in terms of the planned
Capacity Remuneration Mechanism. The public hearing of the measure was held on the 12th May
2020 with a view to collect any written comments by 22nd May 2020. Please find the written
comments from the Estonian side as follows.
As an overall argument we note that the mechanism should have lowest possible distortion effect
on the whole region. Therefore, the mechanism at hand must be well justified and based on
transparent criteria. Furthermore, if the mechanism is proven to be needed, the outcome must
ensure a minimum distortion on the electricity market. Taking into account the information
provided within the framework of the consultation and the overspill effect of the measure at
hand, Estonia needs further information to assess the effect of the measure to the local
electricity market.
The latest ENTSO-E adequacy analysis (MAF2019) does not show an adequacy problem for
Lithuania exceeding Lithuanian adequacy standard of 8 hours per year. However, during the
consultation a national analysis was mentioned, which concludes an adequacy problem in
Lithuania. Based on Regulation (EU) 2019/943, if national analysis shows an adequacy problem
and EU study does not, then the differences between the studies should be analyzed and published.
Hence, please provide us with a copy of the relevant analysis.
Secondly, based on Regulation (EU) 2019/943, effects of the capacity mechanism need to be
consulted with the stakeholders of neighboring countries. We urge including also market
participants (i.e. producers) in the public consultation, as they are also relevant stakeholders.
In order to assess the impact of the capacity mechanism to particular Member State, it is important
to know the details of cross-border participation in the mechanism. Could you please describe
more the details of cross-border participation and point us to the material on cross-border
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / ESTONIA
Phone: +372 625 6342 / Fax: +372 631 3660 / E-mail:
[email protected] / http://www.mkm.ee
participation details?
Regulation (EU) 2019/943 Article 21(2) are stated that before introducing capacity mechanisms,
the Member States concerned shall conduct a comprehensive study of the possible effects of such
mechanisms on the neighboring Member States by consulting at least its neighboring Member
States to which they have a direct network connection and the stakeholders of those Member
States. Therefore, according the regulation the involvement of direct neighboring countries is the
minimum requirement, meaning that involvement of wider region is possible and favorable.
Taken into account that Baltic States are in one synchronous area, the electricity systems are
strongly linked together, both from technical side as well as from market side (connected with
each other through several AC power lines, common synchronization task, common balancing
market, etc) it seems that from technical perspective as well as from market perspective it would
make sense if additionally to direct neighboring countries the market participants from the
whole Baltic region could participate in Lithuanian CRM auction.
Also, it is unclear if the market participants offering CRM from neighboring countries have to
have the production also in the neighboring country or they can be suppliers having the production
unit in other country (for example supplier in Latvia who has power plants in Estonia). Could you
please elaborate on that?
With best regards,
Timo Tatar
Deputy Secretary General for Energy
Rein Vaks
+372 625 6347
[email protected]
Copy to:
Estonian Competition Authority
Elering AS
2 (2)