dokumendiregister.ee
OtsingAsutusedMCP
Otsing›Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium
Väljaminev kiriAvalik

Letter

Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium · 29. mai 2020
Viit
1.15-5/2020/3231-2
Registreeritud
29. mai 2020
Dokumendi liik
Väljaminev kiri
Adressaat
Finnish Environment Institute (SYKE)
Saabumis/saatmisviis
Outlook
Funktsioon
1.15/S Avalikkussuhete korraldamine
Sari
1.15-5/S Teabenõuded, selgitustaotlused, märgukirjad
Toimik
1.15-5/2020
Vastutaja
Irje Möldre (Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium, Kantsleri valdkond, Energeetika valdkond, Energeetikaosakond)

Failid

  • 📎E-kiri.pdf80 KB
  • 📎ELMAK 2020 EN.pdf440 KB
  • 📎ENMAK 2020 EN.pdf495 KB

Sisu (failidest)

Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications Development Plan of the Estonian Electricity Sector until 2018 1 CONTENTS CONTENTS ...................................................................................................................................... 2 Introduction ................................................................................................................................... 3 1. Bases for Development Plan ..................................................................................................... 5 1.1 Definitions............................................................................................................................... 5 1.2. Relations with Other Strategic Documents ...................................................................... 8 1.3. Implementation of Development Plan of Electricity Sector for 2005- 2015 .............. 11 1.4. Electricity Market Statistics............................................................................................... 13 1.5. Current State of and Forecast for Estonian Electricity Market ................................... 14 1.5.1. Assessment of and forecast for Estonian electricity market ................................ 14 1.5.2. Current state of Estonian electricity market ........................................................... 16 1.5.3. Potential for heat and power cogeneration in Estonia .......................................... 18 1.5.4. Potential of renewable energy sources ................................................................... 18 1.5.5. Balancing of power system ....................................................................................... 19 1.6. Regulations Affecting EU Electricity Market .................................................................. 20 1.6.1. EU energy policy......................................................................................................... 20 1.6.2. Third internal natural gas and electricity market package ................................... 21 1.6.3. Climate and energy package .................................................................................... 21 1.6.4 Prices and market liberalisation on EU electricity market ..................................... 24 1.7. Strategic Choices in Electricity Production .................................................................... 26 1.8. Technological Trends Affecting Strategic Choices in Electricity Production ............ 31 1.9. Export of Electricity ............................................................................................................ 33 2. Development Plan ..................................................................................................................... 34 2.1. Vision and Mission ............................................................................................................. 34 2.1.1. Trends in electricity production................................................................................. 34 2.1.2. Development of transmission network .................................................................... 37 2.1.3. Development of distribution networks ..................................................................... 38 2.2. Structure of Objectives and Measures ........................................................................... 39 2.3 Activities and Measures ..................................................................................................... 41 2.3.1. Measures for ensuring continuous electricity supply ............................................ 41 2.3.2. Measures for ensuring more sustainable power supply and consumption ....... 46 2.3.3. Measures for ensuring justified price of electricity ................................................ 49 3. Monitoring and Management of Implementation of Development Plan ........................... 53 Annexes .......................................................................................................................................... 54 Annex 1 Summary of SWOT analyses................................................................................... 54 Annex 2 Analysis of employment of the scenarios of the development plan ................... 55 2 Introduction The Development Plan of the Electricity Sector for 2008-2018 is a development plan of the respective area which shall be approved by the Government of the Republic and which defines the Government’s strategy in one of the most important fields of energy policy – power engineering. The development plan of the electricity sector shall be prepared on the basis of the Electricity Market Act. Great changes have taken place in the Estonian electricity sector after the adoption of the previous development plan of the electricity sector: the submarine cable Estlink has been completed, the new fluidised bed boilers have been successfully put to use in Narva Power Plants, EU emission trading has been started, the production of renewable electricity has started to develop quickly, the security of supply of natural gas and the resulting energy security of states have risen to the agenda. Power losses have decreased significantly and the export of electricity has increased considerably in the Estonian power system as a whole. Great challenges in the next few years are connected with the development of the electricity markets of Estonia and the Baltic States. The prohibition to use the old units of Narva Power Plants shall be applied as of 2016 and closing of the reactors of Ignalina nuclear power plant in 2009 will require significant investments in the electricity sector. The opening of the electricity market in 2013 at the latest and the application of the new rules of emission trading in 2013 will also have a considerable impact on the development of the electricity market of Estonia. The development of electricity markets requires adequate market regulation in all the three Baltic States. The purpose of the development plan is to direct the undertakings to make investment decisions which are in the national interests on the electricity market. The objective of the state is to ensure continuous, sustainable power supply at a justified price in Estonia. Pursuant to subsection 10 (2) of the State Budget Act and in compliance with Regulation No 302 of the Government of the Republic of 13 December 2005 “Types of Strategic Development Plans, the Procedure for Their Preparation, Amendment, Implementation and Evaluation and Reporting Procedure”, the Government of the Republic approved, by Order No 12 of 10 January 2008; the preparation of the development plan of the electricity sector and appointed the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications as a ministry responsible for and the Ministry of the Environment, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of Social Affairs, the Ministry of Education and Research and the Ministry of Agriculture as the ministries participating in the preparation of the development plan. A working group was formed for the preparation of the development plan of the electricity sector by directive No 6 of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications of 21 January 2008, the objective of which was to prepare a development plan and an implementing plan. An obligation was imposed on the working group to submit the working version and the final report of the development plan of the electricity sector to the organising committee for power engineering and for the preparation of power engineering development plans formed by directive No 17 of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications (hereinafter „committee”; chairman of the committee: Enari Kisel, Deputy Secretary General for Energy of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications) for review on 22 January 2008. In order to involve all the interest groups, the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications organised a series of public energy forums in order to involve the representatives of all the interest 3 groups in the process of the preparation of the development plan for making proposals, defining the objectives and courses of action, consulting with each other and for answering or discussing the arisen questions. Upon the preparation of the development plan of the electricity sector, a strategic environmental assessment of the development plan of the electricity sector was initiated on the basis of clause 33 (1) 1) and subsection 35 (2) of the Environmental Impact Assessment and Environmental Management System Act. 4 1. Bases for Development Plan Electricity sector is regulated by the following legislation: 1. Electricity Market Act1 The Electricity Market Act regulates the generation, transmission, sale, export, import and transit of electricity and the economic and technical management of the power system. The Act prescribes the principles for the operation of the electricity market based on the need to ensure an effective supply of electricity at reasonable prices and meeting environmental requirements and the needs of customers, and balanced, environmentally clean and long-term use of energy sources. 2. Grid Code2 This Regulation regulates the requirements applied to the security of supply of power systems and the technical requirements for electrical installations arising from security of supply. The Regulation prescribes the requirements for the connection of electrical installations to the power network and the rights and obligations of the market participants related to balance responsibility. 3. Quality Requirements for Network Services and Conditions for Decreasing Network Fees in Case of Violation of Quality Requirements3 This Regulation establishes the quality requirements for the network services provided to a customer, producer, line possessor or any other network operator (hereinafter „market participant”) within the service area of a network operator and the conditions for decreasing the network fees in the case of violation of the quality requirements. In addition to sector-specific regulation, the development of the electricity sector is significantly affected by environmental legislation. 1.1 Definitions "balance" means the balance between the amount of electricity purchased and/or supplied to the network by a market participant during a trading period and the amount of electricity sold and/or acquired from the network by the market participant during the same trading period "balance provider" means a person who, pursuant to the procedure provided in the Electricity Market Act and legislation established on the basis thereof, has entered into a balance agreement with a system operator to maintain its balance "power system" means the technical system for the generation and transmission of electricity, which is comprised of power plants located within the territory of Estonia, the network which connects the power plants to one another as well as customers and the power systems of other countries, and the corresponding control, protection and communication systems "power network" means an electrical installation or a part thereof intended for the transmission of electricity to the connection point of a customer or producer 1 Electricity Market Act https://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=12894671 2 Grid Code https://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=12831412 3 Quality Requirements for Network Services https://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=1039867 5 "import of electricity" means the import of electricity from outside the system with the aim of selling or consuming electricity in Estonia "wind turbine" means a system consisting of a turbine, a drive, a generator, a control system and a tower, which converts kinetic wind energy into electric energy "reliability of a power system" means the ability of the power system to ensure joint operation of power plants and power networks in the operation of the power system "power plant" means an operational assembly consisting of one or several generating installations which generates electricity, together with support systems and facilities "distribution network" means a network which is not a transmission network "cogeneration" means cogeneration of heat and power upon combustion of fuel "fluidised bed boiler" means a boiler in which the milling coal is maintained in suspension by a rising current of air during combustion "household customer" means a consumer who uses electricity in his or her household for purposes not related to his or her business or professional activities "primary energy" means energy obtained from a natural source and consumed without transformation into other forms of energy. From the fuel produced in Estonia this includes oil shale, peat, firewood, wood waste and biogas and from the imported fuel this includes coal, natural gas, liquid gas, heavy fuel oil, light heating oil, diesel fuel, motor vehicle petrol and aviation kerosene "transmission network" means the national network with a voltage of at least 110 kV together with alternating current connections with a voltage of over 10 kV with networks of other countries and with other electrical installations, also those operating on medium voltage, necessary to ensure the functioning, administration and development of the system as a whole and with control, protection and communication systems, which form a uniform economic entity "system operator” means a person obliged to ensure security of supply and balance of the system at any moment in time (system responsibility) "peak load of a system" means the maximum load value during the period under review (e.g. a twenty-four hour period, a month, a year) "renewable energy sources" means water, wind, solar, wave, tidal and geothermal energy sources, landfill gas, sewage treatment plant gas, bioenergy "renewable electricity" means electricity generated from non-fossil energy sources such as wind energy, solar energy, wave energy, hydropower, tidal energy, geothermal energy, bioenergy, landfill gas, sewage treatment plant gas "operational security" means the capability of a power network to operate under normal conditions without interruption during a specific period of time "wind farm" means a power plant consisting of several wind turbines and the devices, buildings and structures connecting wind turbines to each other and to the connection point "efficient cogeneration" - means generation of electricity in a combined power and heat production regime based on the demand for heat energy and ensuring energy conservation in accordance with the requirements for efficient cogeneration "security of supply" means the capability of a system to ensure the required high-quality electricity supply to customers during a certain period of time 6 "Grid Code" means legislation which provides for: - the requirements for security of supply; - the technical requirements for electrical installations, arising from security of supply; - the technical and metrological requirements for measurement and measuring equipment; - the procedure for connection to the network and for amendment of the consumption or generation conditions and the procedure for calculation of charges payable to the network operator for connection to the network and for amendment of the consumption or generation conditions; - the conditions for technical co-operation between the transmission network operator and the respective network operators of neighbouring countries; - other conditions prescribed by law "network operator" means an undertaking which owns or possesses a power line or network through which electric power or heat is transmitted or distributed "network losses" means power losses in the distribution network elements 7 1.2. Relations with Other Strategic Documents The strategic planning document of the Estonian energy sector is the National Development Plan of the Energy Sector until 2020 which is under preparation and the sub-strategies of which at present are the development plans of the energy sectors: Sustainable Development Act NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN OF THE ENERGY SECTOR UNTIL 2020 Development Plan National Development Plan for Energy of the Estonian Development Plan Enhancing the Use of Conservation Electricity Sector for the Use of Oil Biomass and Target for 2008-2018 Shale for 2008– Bioenergy for 2007– Programme for 2015 2013 Estonia for 2007–2013 a. National Development Plan for the Use of Oil Shale for 2008–20154: the strategic objective of the plan is to ensure supply of Estonia with oil shale energy and to guarantee the energetic independence of Estonia. One of the strategic objectives of the development plan is to increase the efficiency of the use and mining of oil shale and to reduce the environmental impact accompanying the use and mining, which supports also the measures and activities of the Development Plan of the Electricity Sector upon the enhancement and development of sustainable ways of electricity production. The National Development Plan for the Use of Oil Shale for 2008–2015 was approved by the resolution of the Riigikogu of 21 October 2008. b. Development Plan for Enhancing the Use of Biomass and Bioenergy for 2007–20135: the objective of the plan is to create favourable conditions for the development of the production of domestic biomass and bioenergy in order to decrease the dependence of Estonia from imported resources and fossil fuels and to reduce pressure on the natural environment by using the earth resources effectively and sustainably. The abovementioned objectives support the objectives of the Development Plan of the Electricity Sector to enhance sustainable ways of electricity production and to reduce the environmental impact accompanying electricity production. c. Energy Conservation Target Programme for 2007- 20136 defines the targets for saving fuel and energy in Estonia for 2007-2013 and establishes the measures required for achieving the targets. The objective of the programme is to ensure more efficient use of fuels and energy in Estonia, which is of significant importance for the achievement of the objectives of the 4 National Development Plan for the Use of Oil Shale for 2008–2015 http://www.envir.ee/232764 5 Development Plan for Enhancing the Use of Biomass and Bio energy for 2007–2013 http://www.agri.ee/index.php?id=11014 6 Energy Conservation Target Programme for 2007- 2013 http://www.mkm.ee/index.php?id=221420 8 Development Plan of the Electricity Sector upon enhancement of sustainable electricity production and consumption. The Development Plan of the Electricity Sector for the new period is related to several strategic documents which have already been approved: d. Estonian National Strategy on Sustainable Development "Sustainable Estonia 21"7 supports in general the increase of the production of energy based on renewable natural resources. Estonian energy sector shall be reorganised by developing preferentially and supporting activities which promote energy conservation. Based on the objectives of the strategy, measures have been planned in the Development Plan of the Electricity Sector for supporting the ways of sustainable energy production. e. National Strategic Reference Framework for the EU Structural Funds for 2007-20138 establishes an objective to use energy more efficiently which would enable to prevent potential shortage of energy in future and thus provide international competitive and security advantages for the state in the longer run. More attention should be paid to the control of the increase of energy consumption and the increase of the efficiency of energy consumption and energy conservation by the end consumer. Based on the objectives of the strategy, measures have been planned in the Development Plan of the Electricity Sector for increasing more economical electricity supply and consumption. f. Estonian Environmental Strategy until 20309 provides for the objective of the energy sector to produce electricity in an amount, which satisfies the consumption needs in Estonia, and to develop versatile, sustainable production technologies based on different energy sources and with little environmental load, which enable to produce electricity also for export. The Development Plan of the Electricity Sector helps to implement the objectives set out in the Estonian Environmental Strategy by application of concrete measures and activities. g. Estonian Environmental Activity Plan for 2007-201310: the objective is to slow down and stabilise the increase of energy consumption by ensuring at the same time satisfaction of the needs of the people, i.e. by ensuring preservation of the amount of primary energy upon increase of consumption. The measures and activities for ensuring continuous electricity supply have been planned in the Development Plan of the Electricity Sector. h. Estonian Housing Development Plan for 2007- 201311 provides measures for the improvement of energy conservation in apartment buildings and for raising awareness in order to improve the housing fund which supports the objective to increase the economy of electricity consumption provided for in the Development Plan of the Electricity Sector. 7 Estonian National Strategy on Sustainable Development "Sustainable Estonia 21" https://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=940717 8 National Strategic Reference Framework for the EU Structural Funds for 2007-2013 http://www.fin.ee/sf2007 9 Estonian Environmental Strategy until 2030 http://www.envir.ee/1045989 10 Estonian Environmental Activity Plan for 2007-2013 http://www.envir.ee/1045989 11 Estonian Housing Development Plan for 2007- 2013 http://www.mkm.ee/index.php?id=1733 9 i. Estonian Energy Technology Programme for 2007-201312 determines the main priorities upon the development of energy technologies in Estonia. The priorities are the development of new energy technologies based mainly on renewable energy resources and the development of oil shale technologies, both of which have a direct impact on the development of the electricity sector and support the objectives, measures and activities of the Development Plan of the Electricity Sector. j. Estonian Action Plan for Economic Growth and Employment for 2008- 2011 13 establishes the objective of the energy sector to ensure security of supply of energy, to develop environment- friendly power engineering and to increase energy efficiency. For Estonia the key issues are oil shale power industry, increase of ecological compatibility, increase of the share of renewable energy and improvement of energy efficiency. The increase of energy efficiency contributes to environment-friendly power engineering (more efficient energy consumption – smaller environmental impact) and the increase of security of supply (smaller energy consumption – smaller need for imported energy), which coincide with the objectives of the Development Plan of the Electricity Sector upon the increase of energy efficiency. 12 Estonian Energy Technology Programme http://www.hm.ee/index.php?03242 13 Estonian Action Plan for Economic Growth and Employment for 2008- 2011 http://www.riigikantselei.ee/?id=5864 10 1.3. Implementation of Development Plan of Electricity Sector for 2005- 2015 The "Development Plan of the Estonian Electricity Sector for 2005-2015" (hereinafter "development plan of the electricity sector of the previous period") was approved by the Government of the Republic Order No 5 of 3 January 2006. The strategic objective of the development plan of the electricity sector of the previous period is to ensure optimum functioning and development of the Estonian power system under market economy conditions and supplying of the consumers with electricity in conformity with the requirements at as low prices as possible in the long term. An overview is given below on the objectives established in the development plan of the electricity sector of the previous period for 2005-2015 and on the achievement thereof. Table 1. Overview of the performance of the tasks provided for in the development plan of the electricity sector of the previous period Objective Achievement Achieved target value or objective, as at 200714 Ensuring the operational Achieved: The operational security and In 2005 there were 246 trippings, security and immunity of immunity of the Estonian power system has including 40 trippings with the Estonian power system improved constantly over the years. In order interruptions; in 2006 there were 169 and the security of to achieve the objective, OÜ Põhivõrk has trippings, including 23 trippings with consumer supply at least at made significant investments in the interruptions. the level of 2005 construction of new substations and lines and in the maintenance of old substations and lines over the past few years. Ensuring complete Achieved: The methods for the calculation modernisation of the power of the prices for network services take into network in approximately account the need to modernise the every thirty years in the transmission network in every thirty years transmission network and in and the distribution network in every forty approximately every forty years. During the years 2000 – 2006 five years in the distribution substations were renovated each year on an network average. Reduction of transmission Achieved: During the years 2001-2005 and distribution losses transmission losses decreased by 13.2 % and distribution losses decreased by 15 %. Ensuring the existence of Achieved: Estonia has been continuously The available net installed capacity of local generating power to able to cover its electricity consumption the power plants is 2760 MW. cover the domestic needs and has also exported electricity. In 2007, 7180 GWh of electric energy electricity consumption was consumed domestically, there needs were 1354 GWh network losses (thus 8534 GWh for gross consumption) and 2765 GWh of electricity was exported (1001 GWh in 2006). Establishment of new Achieved: In 2007, the submarine cable interconnections with the Estlink was put into operation between power systems of the Estonia and Finland which has considerably neighbouring states and increased power trading between the states enhancement of of the region. international cooperation 14 Upon pointing out the trend (increase/decrease), the year 2000 has been taken as the reference level (unless indicated otherwise) for the purpose of comparing with the levels indicated in the development plan of the previous period. 11 Objective Achievement Achieved target value or objective, as at 200714 Ensuring that by 2010 Trend towards achievement of the In 2007 renewable electricity formed renewable electricity forms objective: By 2006 the share of renewable 1.75 % of the gross consumption. 5.1 % of the gross electricity had increased; the estimated consumption output of the new projects of renewable electricity production which will be completed by 2010 exceeds the established objective. Ensuring that by 2020 the Trend towards achievement of the 10.2 % of the gross consumption of electricity produced in objective: The cogeneration support electric energy and 27 % of thermal cogeneration stations forms schemes implemented in 2007 have energy was produced in cogeneration 20 % of the gross facilitated the construction of new regime. consumption cogeneration stations; the share of 18 cogeneration stations were in cogeneration is increasing. operation. Development of the Achieved: In order to improve the The efficiency of the old boilers was 30 technologies which use efficiency of energy production of Narva %, the efficiency of the new boilers energy resources more Power Plants, new power units based on amounts to 36 %. efficiently fluidised bed technology were installed in 2005, as a result of which the use of oil shale and the amount of atmospheric emissions have decreased to a considerable extent. Keeping the rate of increase Achieved: the rate of the increase of In 2005: GDP growth 9.2 %, increase of of electricity consumption electricity consumption has been constantly final consumption of electricity 2.2 % at least twice as low as GDP more than twice as low as the rate of real 2006: GDP growth 10.4 %, increase of growth GDP growth; it exceeded the established final consumption of electricity 7.5 % objective only in 2006. 2007: GDP growth 6.3 %, increase of final consumption of electricity 3.8 % Ensuring that know-how is The field of power engineering has become available in the field of more popular at the universities, new power engineering, ensuring specialities and areas of specialisation have efficient technology been opened. The new areas of development and transfer of specialisation are distributed generation of technology, research and electricity, use of alternative energy innovation in the state. sources, optimisation of larger systems and energy trading. While the development plan of the electricity sector of the previous period indicated that the most feasible trend economically would be to increase the share of natural gas in electricity production, the problems concerning gas supplies in 2005 and the price increase which was significantly higher than expected have considerably decreased the attractiveness of this variant. The construction of power plants operating only on natural gas in Estonia is justified only if there is a clear alternative fuel or if these are used only for covering the peak load. As an experience from the implementation of the development plan of the electricity sector of the previous period it shall be noted that implementation of the electricity market requires that the state give very clear signals for investment to energy undertakings in order to ensure the desired structure of electricity production. It is important that there is a variety of different producers in the electricity market: it shall be possible to produce electricity from several different energy sources by as many different producers as possible as cheaply as possible and in an environmentally- friendly way without market concentration. 12 1.4. Electricity Market Statistics Estonia has been continuously able to cover its domestic electricity consumption needs and has also exported electricity. According to the system operator, the available net capacity of the power plants was approximately 1800 MW by the beginning of 2008; the actual potential net production during peak consumption in winter was 2076 MW (as a result of the repairs of the generating installations, breakdowns and the possibility of production depending on the existence water and wind resources). In 2007, 7180 GWh of electric energy was consumed domestically, there were 1354 GWh network losses (thus 8534 GWh for gross consumption) and 2765 GWh of electricity was exported. In 2007, the gross production of electricity was 12,188 GWh (including autoproduction of the power plants). According to the statistical survey "Energy balance 2007" prepared by the Statistical Office (hereinafter "Energy balance 2007", available on the website www.stat.ee), 11,402 GWh of electricity was produced on the basis of oil shale, 350 GWh on the basis of natural gas, 235 GWh on the basis of shale gas, 22 GWh on the basis of hydro power, 91 GWh on the basis of wind power, 36 GWh on the basis of other renewable energy sources and 22 GWh on the basis of peat (see Figure 1). In 2007, 93.6 % of electricity was produced from oil shale. Electricity production by energy source in 2007 Oil shale 0.7% Natural gas 0.2% Shale gas 1.9% Wind power 0.3% 0.2% Hydropower 6.4% 0.2% Biomass and biogas 93.6% 2.9% Peat Shale and fuel oil Figure 1. 12 188 GWh of electricity was produced in 200715 As compared to 2006, electricity production increased by approximately one fourth in 2007. The production increase resulted from the increased export of electricity. While in 2006 electricity was exported in the amount of 1001 GWh, in 2007, 2765 GWh of electricity was exported. Nearly fifty per cent of it was transmitted to the Nordic countries through the submarine cable Estlink and export to Latvia increased 1.5 times. Production of electricity from renewable energy sources has increased constantly. 22 hydroelectric power plants and 12 wind farms operated in Estonia in 2007. In 2007, the share of the production of renewable electricity was 1.75 % of the gross consumption. The estimated output of the new projects of renewable electricity production which will be completed by 2010 exceeds significantly the established objective – to ensure that by 2010 the share of renewable electricity would be 5.1 15 Data of 2007 of the Statistical Office, „Energy balance 2007” 13 %. The use of renewable energy for electricity production is facilitated by the amendments to the Electricity Market Act which entered into force at the beginning of 2007 and which, inter alia, establish new legal basis for supporting entry of renewable energy producers and cogeneration producers into the market. 18 cogeneration stations operated in Estonia in 2007. According to "Energy balance 2007", 10.2 % of the gross consumption of electricity (electricity consumption and network losses) was produced in cogeneration regime. The cogeneration support schemes implemented in 2007 have also facilitated the construction of new cogeneration stations, as a result of which the share of cogeneration is increasing. In order to improve the efficiency of oil shale energy production , new power units based on fluidised bed technology were introduced in Narva Power Plants, which have reduced the environmental impact to a considerable extent – as compared to 2004, the total amount of SO2 emissions decreased by 20 %, the amount of CO2 emissions from combustion of fuels by 6.9%. 1.5. Current State of and Forecast for Estonian Electricity Market This Development Plan is based on the research and analysis carried out in the past few years. The main conclusions of the most important research and analysis are given below. 1.5.1. Assessment of and forecast for Estonian electricity market According to the report on the security of supply of the Estonian power system prepared by OÜ Põhivõrk 16, problems concerning coverage of peak demand may arise in Estonia already from the year 2012. These problems will become more severe in 2016 in connection with the requirement not to use the old units of Narva Power Plants in the present form. From the electricity production capacity used at present it will be possible to keep in operation the two new fluidised bed combustion units of Narva Power Plants, the second power unit of Iru Power Plant and small stations from 2016. The capacity of wind turbines cannot be taken into account in the capacity balance. OÜ Põhivõrk has predicted that the peak load will increase 1.6 % to 3.8 % a year, the increase of 2.3 % of peak demand is predicted as a base scenario. At the same time the peak demand depends considerably on the temperature, in the presented forecasts the average degree level is presumed. 16 OÜ Põhivõrk, http://www.pohivork.ee/ 14 MW 3500 3000 2500 2000 1500 1000 500 Year 0 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 I scenario 1475 1418 1471 1527 1585 1644 1706 1769 1835 1903 1974 2047 2124 2203 2285 2370 2458 2549 2644 2742 2844 2950 3060 II scenario 1475 1395 1423 1453 1483 1513 1540 1568 1595 1624 1653 1682 1712 1739 1767 1795 1823 1852 1882 1912 1942 1973 2004 III scenario 1475 1403 1440 1479 1519 1559 1599 1639 1681 1723 1767 1811 1857 1900 1945 1990 2037 2084 2133 2183 2234 2286 2339 I scenario II scenario III scenario Figure 2. Peak load forecasts of OÜ Põhivõrk for 2004-2025 Considering that the peak load of the system in 2015 will be approximately 1800 MW, there will be capacity shortage of approximately 1228 MW. According to OÜ Põhivõrk, the potential new projects in the next years are: 2x225 up to 2x300 MWel oil shale units based on fluidised bed technology in the years 2011-2012, 110 MWel emergency reserve in Iru power plant by 2011, 140 MWel regulation reserve in Iru power plant by 2011, 23 MWel cogeneration station operating on biofuel in Ahtme power plant by 2009. In order to cover the peak loads in winter, it is also possible to use old oil shale units if desulphurisation and denitrification systems are installed. The wind turbines constructed in parallel shall have also adequate power reserve. At the end of 2008 Väo cogeneration station was completed near Tallinn, the electrical and thermal capacities of which are 25MW and 50MW respectively. The planned electricity production is up to 190 GWh and the planned heat production 500 GWh a year. It has been planned to complete the new cogeneration unit of Iru power plant based on the recovery of waste and operating in the group of Eesti Energia by the end of 2011. The planned electrical capacity of the new cogeneration unit is 17 MW and the planned thermal capacity is 50MW. According to OÜ Põhivõrk, electricity consumption will increase 1.8-3.5 % a year, 2.3 % a year as the most probable scenario. Annual economic growth of 3-7 % is presumed in the forecast. 15 GWh 16000 14000 12000 10000 8000 6000 4000 2000 Year 0 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 I scenario 6900 7160 7431 7711 8002 8304 8613 8934 9266 9611 9968 1033 1072 1112 1153 1196 1241 1287 1335 1384 1436 1489 1545 9 8644 6900 7042 7188 7336 7488 7642 7778 7916 8057 8200 8345 8494 4 87823 8921 7 90636 9207 2 9354 3 95022 9653 9 98075 9963 9 1012 3 II scenario 1 6900 7085 7274 7469 7669 7875 8073 8277 8487 8701 8921 9146 9378 9597 9821 1005 1028 1052 1077 1102 1128 1154 1181 III scenario 0 5 5 1 3 0 4 3 Figure 3. Forecasts of total electricity consumption from the transmission network for 2004-2025 1.5.2. Current state of Estonian electricity market The report on the current state of the electricity and gas market in Estonia prepared in 2008 by the Estonian Competition Authority 17 gives an overview of the development of the electricity market in Estonia. According to the Estonian Competition Authority, the electricity production and sales market in Estonia is very concentrated and orientated at one type of fuel – approximately 94 % of all the electricity is produced from oil shale. In 2007, Eesti Energia AS produced 95.3 % of the total amount of electricity. In addition to 95 % of the production market, OÜ Jaotusvõrk with the market share of 86 % belongs also to the group of Eesti Energia AS. As compared to other states, Estonia is in a good state as for electricity market legislation, the rights and obligations of the electricity market regulator have been regulated by the Electricity Market Act. In its report the Estonian Competition Authority has assessed also the independence of OÜ Põhivõrk as the system operator and has given a positive assessment thereto. The functions of the management board and the supervisory board of the undertaking are well-defined; the supervisory board cannot affect the decisions of the management board with respect to other market participants; no cases of discrimination of market participants by OÜ Põhivõrk have been detected, goods and services are purchased on an equal basis from both, the undertakings belonging to the group and undertakings not belonging to the group; the website of the undertaking is one of the best ones among the energy undertakings. In order to differentiate the activities better, the Estonian Competition Authority has recommended as a proposal to establish a sales company as a separate legal person in the group of Eesti Energia AS which would avoid the potential conflict of interests between a sales company and OÜ Põhivõrk. It is also recommended to define more precisely the criteria for removal of members of the management board. 17 Estonian Competition Authority, Estonian Electricity and Gas Market Report 2008 http://www.konkurentsiamet.ee/?id=10836 16 In the open electricity market it is important to ensure independence of the activities of the system operator, regulator and network operators. In the relevant comparisons prepared by the European Commission Estonian electricity market regulation stands out for its transparency and proper organisation, there are also no examples of the discrimination of undertakings on the electricity market. In the debates on the draft electricity market Directive introduction of the requirement of separation of the transmission network from vertically integrated electricity groups has been proposed. In principle, Estonia has supported the proposal on condition that it is applied in a non- discriminative way and it does not include the obligation to privatise the transmission network enterprise (i.e. both of the enterprises may belong to the state). SWOT analysis has been used below for assessing the Estonian electricity sector. Table 2. SWOT analysis of the Estonian electricity sector Strengths: Weaknesses: 1. Strong electrical interconnections with Latvia, 1. Small electricity market with few suppliers; Russia and Finland; 2. Old age of the power plants; 2. Strong and well-developed transmission network; 3. Concentration of electricity production in one 3. The present level of production capacities ensures region ; electricity supply at any moment in time; 4. Extensive environmental impact of oil shale fired 4. Efficient cooperation between the Baltic States and power plants; very high share of oil shale in the Finnish transmission network operators; electricity production; 5. Transparent and proper market regulation. 5. Insufficient technical quality of distribution networks; 6. Inadequately justified level of aid for renewable and cogeneration electricity; 7. Weak and non-transparent price signals for investments into the capacities of the new generation; 8. Insufficient electrical interconnections between the Baltic region and the rest of the Member States of the European Union. Opportunities: Threats: 1. Interest of the market participants to develop and 1. Potential shortage of production capacity since make investments in the electricity market; 2016; 2. To establish a versatile and balanced power system 2. Potential dominant position of electricity with within a relatively short period of time; dumping elements from Russia; 3. To increase the use of renewable energy sources to a 3. Negative effect of emission trading on the energy justified extent; balance; 4. To increase the production of cogeneration 4. Potential steep increase of electricity prices upon electricity; opening of the electricity market; 5. To construct plants intended for covering the peak 5. Possibility of extensive network failures and/or load based on domestic fuel. power-cuts; 6. Overloading in the Russian transmission system may affect the functioning of the electricity market and the power systems. 17 1.5.3. Potential for heat and power cogeneration in Estonia18 Estonia has set a national aim to cover 20 % of the gross consumption of electricity in 2020 on the basis of cogeneration. As at 2007, there were 18 cogeneration stations in Estonia, three of which complied with the criteria of efficient cogeneration 19 and produced 10.2 % of the gross consumption of electricity. According to the surveys undertaken, the potential of cogeneration is relatively big in Estonia, there are economic and technical conditions for that - a functioning district heating network, energy-intensive local industry, the existence of gaseous fuel and a developed gas network, the availability of biofuels, the increase of electricity consumption, the need for innovations of technology, increased requirements for the environment. The restricting factor is the absence of constant thermal input. The new cogeneration stations would operate mainly on biofuels. Peat, firewood, logging and wood waste are local fuels having significant energetic potential which could be used sustainably in small cogeneration stations. 1.5.4. Potential of renewable energy sources According to the survey of the Tallinn University of Technology20, the potential of Estonian renewable energy primarily means combined heat and power production based on biofuel and wind power; at the same time small-scale hydropower industry is developed. In order to achieve the 5.1 % objective set for 2010, 300-360 GWh of electricity should be produced on the basis thereof. The following solutions were proposed in the survey: • increasing of the capacities of hydroelectric power plants up to 10 MW which would enable to produce 45…55 GWh of electricity with an average annual quantity of water; • making use of the technologically practical potential of replacing firewood boilers of boiler plants by combined heat and power appliances by installing 31 MW of electrical capacity which would enable to produce additionally up to 830 GWh of heat and 164 GWh of power from firewood on the basis of cogeneration. Electricity produced from biogas – approximately 3 MW – and electricity produced on the basis of black liquor (the production depends on the profitability of the production in Estonia) will be added thereto; • increasing of the capacity of wind farms up to 50 MW with the annual production of 123 GWh. In 2007, renewable electricity formed 1.75 % of gross consumption. Since the estimated electricity production of the cogeneration stations and wind turbines under construction may exceed 18 Tallinn University of Technology "Potential for Efficient Heat and Power Cogeneration in Estonia" 2007, "Reference Values of Efficient Cogeneration and Potential for Heat and Power Cogeneration in Estonia" 2005, http://www.mkm.ee/index.php?id=8098 19 Regulation No 30 of the Minister of Economic Affairs and Communications of 3 May 2007 "Requirements for Efficient Cogeneration", https://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=12825847 20 Tallinn University of Technology "Possibilities for Increasing the Share of Renewable Energy Sources in Electricity generation in Estonia" 2003, Reports "Promotion of Use of Electricity Produced from Renewable Energy Sources" 2005, 2007, http://www.mkm.ee/index.php?id=8098 18 800 GWh, the share of renewable energy may exceed 10 % of gross consumption in 2010. Thus, the results of the survey are out-of-date and a new survey needs to be conducted. 1.5.5. Balancing of power system The balance between electricity production and consumption is one of the most important conditions for functioning of a power system. The absence of balance brings about frequency variation and may cause blackout of the whole system. Balance of a power system means that the amount of electricity produced and imported into the system shall be equal to the amounts of electricity consumed and exported from the system at any moment in time. The absence of balance (imbalance) is usually caused by the following: • as a result of unexpected changes in consumption, usually in connection with rapid temperature variations; • in case of changes in wind speed; • as a result of emergency switching off of the power plants or transmission equipment; • increase of consumption in connection to an especially cold winter and other extraordinary unforeseeable cases. All the described cases affect the power system during a relatively short period of time (from a couple of hours up to one day) in each specific case. The balance of the power system is achieved through the system of balance providers. Each market participant shall belong to the balance area of one balance provider. Balance providers are responsible for the balance of their balance area at any moment in time. In case of the occurrence of imbalance, they shall promptly take measures for achieving balance. The system operator shall be responsible for the elimination of imbalance: a. for a short period of time i.e. during the current and the following hour. It is usually not possible for the balance providers to balance their balance area during the current or the following trading period (hour), since pursuant to the market rules additional supplies may be provided only as of the second following hour. It shall be possible for a system operator to balance the Estonian power system quickly (within a quarter of an hour) and to keep the balance up to the end of the following hour. Since a real-time regulating market cannot be established in our region due to the small number of hydroelectric power plants, the only possibility for a system operator (OÜ Põhivõrk) is to construct a relevant power plant which would enable to balance the system in a short period of time; b. in extraordinary unforeseeable cases which is especially likely during winter peak load. For this purpose, the system operator shall have spare production capacity available which could be activated if necessary. Since such events are not frequent and they last a short period of time, it is not economically reasonable to make market based investments into such a power plant. The system operator may solve the balancing of the system in case of such events either through the regulation plant operated thereby, through the existing power plants on the basis of the relevant contracts or in combination of the both; c. as a result of emergency switching off of the power plants or transmission equipment. For this purpose, the transmission networks of the states belonging to the unified power system have concluded a contract pursuant to which each transmission network shall increase production in its power system within fifteen minutes in accordance with the agreed formula and keep the level for twelve hours. For this purpose, the system 19 operator shall construct the relevant so-called emergency power plant. This plant shall not be used for balancing an imbalance caused by other reasons, since in the latter case the system operator would not be able to perform the contractual obligations thereof upon the occurrence of an emergency. Since in both, variant a) and variant b) the power plant (so-called regulation plant of the system operator) and in variant c) the emergency power plant are activated relatively seldom for a relatively short periods of time, the power plants to be constructed should have as low investment expenses as possible, the cost of energy production is not important. The investment into the emergency power plant shall be financed from the tariff of OÜ Põhivõrk. A balance provider shall always be financially responsible for the imbalance of the balance area thereof in accordance with the terms and conditions of the balance agreement concluded with the system operator. In addition to that, a balance provider shall promptly take measures for restoring balance upon the occurrence of imbalance and at the request of the system operator. These measures mean primarily procurement of additional supplies from other market participants. However, it is not possible to eliminate imbalance by additional supplies momentarily, since agreement with the counterparty and the system operator takes a certain amount of time and, as a rule, entry into force thereof is possible as of the second following trading period. Although wind turbines must have also concluded open supply contracts (usually) with a balance provider, wind turbines have their own specifics which bring about their additional obligations upon balancing the system. Since wind speed may change quickly and it is relatively hard to foresee it, the imbalance caused by wind turbines affects the balance of the power system in a very negative way. The seriousness of the problem is directly connected with the total capacity of the wind turbines. So far the maximum production of wind turbines has remained below 30MW which is in the same range as the imbalance permitted to the Estonian power system by the contract concluded between the transmission networks of other states belonging to the unified power system and thus, it has not caused any problems. However, the Development Plan includes scenarios where the planned total capacity of wind turbines is from a couple of hundred to 1200 MW. Regulation power plants are required for balancing the production of these wind turbines. 1.6. Regulations Affecting EU Electricity Market 1.6.1. EU energy policy In March 2007, the European Council adopted the EU’s Action Plan for Energy Policy 2007-2009 (hereinafter EU energy policy), the objectives of which are: • increasing security of supply; • ensuring the competitiveness of European economies and the availability of affordable energy; • promoting environmental sustainability and combating climate change. In order to achieve the objectives established in the action plan for energy policy, the European Union has fixed highly ambitious quantified targets on energy efficiency, the use of renewable energy sources and biofuels, including environmentally safe carbon capture and storage by 2020: • achieving at least a 20 % reduction of greenhouse gas emissions compared to the base year 1990 (by 2005 the greenhouse gas emissions had been reduced by 6 %); 20 • increasing the share of renewable energy to 20 % of the final consumption of primary energy (in 2005 the average share in EU was 8.5 %); • achieving 20 % more efficient use of energy in the final consumption of primary energy; • increasing the share of biofuels up to 10 % in transport fuels provided that economically expedient second-generation biofuels are developed. 1.6.2. Third internal natural gas and electricity market package21 The planned amendments to the electricity market have a direct impact on the structure of the Estonian electricity market. In this context, Estonia is open to justified requirements on the electricity market, including separation of transmission networks from the vertically integrated energy group provided that this is required from analogous groups in the whole European Union and this does not include the requirement of privatisation of the transmission network. At the same time such a separation of undertakings shall not deteriorate the financial capability of the energy undertakings. The functioning of the Estonian electricity market is affected also by the organisation of the offsetting mechanism of international electricity transit by the European Union which is discriminating Estonia at present. Therefore work must be continued for the development of the system so that it would be suitable for all the Member States. On the opening electricity market of the European Union it is very important for Estonia to regulate the terms and conditions of the import of electricity from third countries, since at present significant competitive advantages have been provided for these producers as compared to EU producers (in the EU there are more strict requirements for the environment and nuclear safety, fuel price differences, emission trading). Since the Baltic States have very strong interconnections with the Russian power system, there are no technical restrictions for the import of electricity. Thus, regulative restrictions shall ensure equal treatment of producers on the electricity market. 1.6.3. Climate and energy package The so-called "Climate and Energy Package"22 published by the European Commission 23 January 2008 plays an important role in the options of Estonian electricity production; the most important parts of it for Estonia are the draft amendment to the Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Directive, the draft Renewable Energy Directive and the draft Carbon Capture and Storage Directive. The Climate and Energy Package was confirmed by the European Council on 11-12 December 2008 and approved by the European Parliament on 17 December 2008. The emissions of greenhouse gases (GHG) shall be reduced in two parts – within the framework of the trading scheme of permissible GHG emissions (hereinafter "ETS" - emission trading scheme) and through state obligations in the sectors not included in the scheme. The reduction of emissions within the framework of ETS is achieved by the scheme of allocation of allowances (quotas). As of 2013 the permissible quantity of total annual emission allowances shall decrease by a linear factor of 1.74 % in order to reduce the emissions covered by the scheme by 21 % by 2020 compared to the level in 2005. Member States may exclude small installations 21 http://ec.europa.eu/energy/gas_electricity/third_legislative_package_en.htm 22 Climate package http://ec.europa.eu/climateaction/key_documents/index_en.htm 21 with annual emission of less than 25,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide and a rated thermal input below 35 MW from ETS. It is planned to replace the national allocation plans by auctioning or free allocation of permissible emissions through single EU-wide rules. In the scheme of allocation of emissions, organisation of auctions, which should increase the price of an allowance and thus motivate the undertakings to apply cleaner technologies, becomes most important. 88 % of the total quantity of allowances to be auctioned will be distributed among Member States according to their share of the verified Community scheme emissions either a) as of 2005 or b) the average for the period 2005-2007, whichever is higher. In case of Estonia the average verified emissions for the period 2005-2007 is higher (13.4 million tons). The rest of the 10% and 2% of the total quantity of allowances to be auctioned shall be allocated according to the principle of solidarity, economic growth and early reduction. The European Commission will publish the estimated number of allowances to be auctioned by the end of 2010. The electricity production sector – representing a large part of emissions – would be subject to auctioning from the start of the new ETS in 2013. However, Member States may grant transitional free allocations for small installations which were engaged in the production of electricity on 31 December 2008 or for small installations for which an investment process had been initiated for the same date if one of the following conditions is met: − the national electricity network was not, in 2007, directly or indirectly connected to the network interconnected system (central European power system) operated by the Union for the Coordination of the Transmission of Electricity (UCTE); or − where the national electricity network was, in 2007, only directly or indirectly connected to the network operated by the Union for the Coordination of the transmission of electricity (UCTE) through a single line with a capacity of less than 400 MW; or − where, in 2006, more than 30 percent of electricity was produced from a single fossil fuel, and, where in 2006 the gross domestic product per capita at market prices did not exceed 50 % of the average gross domestic product per capita of the EU. • Free allowances shall be allocated on the basis of an investment plan. Transitional free allocations shall be deducted from the quantity of allowances the Member State would otherwise auction. Free allowances shall be allocated for a specified term and limited in quantity: in 2013, the total transitional free allocation shall not exceed 70 % of the annual average verified emissions in 2005-2007 from such generators for the amount corresponding to gross final national consumption pursuant to verified emissions in 2005-2007 of the Member State concerned and shall gradually decrease thereafter, resulting in no free allocation in 2020. Free allowances shall be allocated to electricity production on the basis of the relevant activity plan of the Member State, an application shall also be submitted to the European Commission. Proceeding from the abovementioned conditions, the option to allocate free allowances in the transitional period for modernisation of electricity production applies also to Estonia. Partial allocation of free allowance may turn out to be necessary upon the development of new electricity production capacities in Narva Power Plants. • Free allowances shall be allocated for the production of heat in district heating boiler plants through high efficiency cogeneration the quantity of which shall decrease by a linear factor of 1.74% a year starting in 2013. Other industrial sectors with no risk of carbon leakage will step up to auctioning gradually; in the period 2013-2020 the share of allowances will increase from 20% to 70% of the European Community reference and the system of auctioning will be fully implemented by 2027. 22 Auctions shall be organised by Member States and the revenues would be received by Member States. The auctions shall be based on the principles of openness, transparency, harmonised approach and non-discrimination. For example, each operator operating in the European Union may buy allowances in any Member State. By 30 June 2010 at the latest, the European Commission shall adopt a Regulation which regulates the timing, organisation and other aspects of auctions. • The auctioning process will generate significant revenues for Member States, which will help towards the process of adjustment to a low carbon economy, supporting research and development and innovation in areas like renewables and carbon capture and storage, helping developing countries, and helping the less well-off to invest in energy efficiency. Member States shall use at least 50% of their auctioning income for that purpose. Member States shall notify the European Commission of the use of auctioning income. • In the climate package specific attention has been paid to industrial sectors exposed to the risk of carbon leakage, the international competitiveness of which may deteriorate significantly as a result of the implementation of the prerequisite for the climate package. The European Commission shall prepare analysis of such sectors (mainly energy-intensive industries) by the end of 2009 and the relevant list of industries shall be approved by the European Council. The European Commission shall present proposals for the required further action with respect to these sectors at the European Union level not later than by 30 June 2010. Installations in industrial sectors or sub-sectors which are exposed to a significant risk of carbon leakage will be allocated, in the period 2013-2020, 100% of allowances free of charge at the level of the benchmark of the best technology available. • It is important to point out that in its impact assessment of the negotiations on an international climate change agreement and upon the presentation of further action, the European Commission shall take account of the impact of carbon leakage on Member States’ energy security, where there are cross-border electricity connections with third countries and where the electricity connections with the internal market of the rest of the European Union are insufficient. Taking into account, for example, the nature of the cross-border electricity connections of Estonia and depending on the results of the international climate change agreement, this may mean a possibility to establish common measures at the European Union level for the regulation of the import of electricity produced in third countries, e.g. by including import in the emission trading system. The reduction of GHG emissions in the sectors outside the ETS will be achieved through national obligations to reduce GHG. In the sectors not covered by the EU ETS such as buildings, transport, agriculture, waste and industrial installations the emissions of which are lower from the quantities prescribed for accession to the ETS, the obligations to reduce emission are shared between Member States according to GDP per capita. In case of the abovementioned sectors, EU aims to reduce emissions by 10% compared to 2005. For Estonia it is permitted to increase emissions in the abovementioned sectors by up to 11% by 2020. For the purposes of organisation of the distribution and use of the income received within the framework of the emission trading scheme, a concept of the relevant organisational structure shall be adopted in Estonia in 2010. When the concept is agreed upon and approved, principles shall be adopted for the implementation of the updated emission trading scheme in Estonia, including the principles for the organisation of allowance auctions and for the distribution and use of the income received from the allowance auctions. The objective of the Renewable Energy Directive is to establish a common framework for the promotion of the use of energy from renewable sources. One of the most important elements in the Directive is national renewable energy targets, which determine the percentage of the consumption 23 of renewable energy to be achieved by each Member State by 2020 with an aim to increase the overall EU share of renewable energy to 20% by 2020. Thereby indicative interim targets have been established which are calculated as an average for a two-year period. By 2020 the share of energy from renewable sources shall form 25% of the total final consumption in Estonia. The share of energy from renewable sources is calculated as the ratio of consumption of energy from renewable sources over total final consumption. According to the Directive, final consumption includes energy consumption of different economic sectors and energy consumption in the energy sector together with losses. It is up to Member States to decide on which possibilities of renewable energy production to focus. Also, more attention shall be paid on the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and the increase of security of power supply in the transport sector. The objective of the Carbon Capture and Storage Directive is to ensure that carbon capture and storage is used as a means of mitigating climate change and that this is carried out in a secure and responsible way. Carbon dioxide capture and storage (hereinafter "CCS") is a means of mitigating climate change. It consists of the capture of carbon dioxide from industrial installations, its transport to a storage site and its injection into a suitable geological formation for the purposes of permanent storage. The purpose of geological storage is permanent containment of CO2 in such a way as to prevent or reduce negative effects on the environment and any resulting risk to human health. Although no separate free allowances have been prescribed for carbon dioxide capture and storage (except up to 300 million tons up to the end of 2015 set aside in the new entrants reserve for supporting EU demonstration projects), the Emissions Trading Directive enables Member States to use in the years 2013-2016 the income received from the auction of allowances for the promotion of the construction of highly efficient power plants, including the construction of new power plants enabling carbon dioxide capture and storage. In case of new installations with the efficiency exceeding the efficiency values provided for power plants in Annex 1 to the Commission decision 2007/74/EC (e.g. the reference value for separate production of electricity from oil shale is 39.0%), Member States may bear up to 15% of the total cost of the investments related to the new installations enabling carbon dioxide capture and storage. 1.6.4 Prices and market liberalisation on EU electricity market The electricity markets of the Member States of the European Union were opened to commercial consumers on 1 July 2004 and to all the consumers on 1 July 2007. Pursuant to the accession treaty between Estonia and the European Union, Estonia shall open 35% of its electricity market by 2009 at the latest and 100% by 2013 at the latest. In connection with the opening of the electricity markets, electricity undertakings of other states will enter the market beside Estonian undertakings. The entry into market of new undertakings will increase competitiveness on the electricity market, but also uncertainty with respect to the structure of production capacities and the location thereof. Because of this it is important to make preparations for ensuring adequate functioning of the open electricity market. At present the electricity prices on the electricity markets of the EU states surrounding Estonia are somewhat higher. The electricity price will increase considerably in the region in the next few years after closing of the Ignalina nuclear power plant and the construction of new production 24 capacities in Estonia and Latvia. The application of the new EU emission trading rules and the environmental investments in power plants also increase pressure on the price in Estonia. The price of electricity in Estonia will be determined to a considerable extent by the price quotations of the Nordic power exchange Nord Pool. Thus a significant increase of electricity prices may be expected in Estonia after the construction of new power plants and opening of the electricity market. The price of the production of electricity may increase 2-3 times depending on the price of the allowances, which means that the average electricity price for the final consumer, including connection charges and supports, increases 1.5 to 2 times. On an open market, electricity prices are not insomuch based on the costs as on the relation between supply and demand and market sharing (efficiency). In this context, it shall be ensured that the undertakings dominating the market do not abuse their position and that the market would be shared evenly between the competing undertakings. Power exchange should send the best price signals to the electricity market; however, even here there may be a risk, as in the example of the Nordic countries, that the undertakings with significant market power manipulate with the exchange. In the context of Estonia, the issues concerning the terms and conditions of import of the electricity from third countries should definitely be settled in case of the establishment of power exchange, otherwise incorrect signals may be sent to market participants as a result of the functioning of the power exchange. 25 1.7. Strategic Choices in Electricity Production The need to reorganise electricity production in Estonia derives from several circumstances: 1. the need to reduce emissions from electricity production to the environment; 2. the obligations assumed by the EU accession treaty to reduce SO2 emissions of Narva Power Plants in 2012 and 2016; 3. the need for more sustainable use of oil shale resources; 4. the need to make electricity price in Estonia more competitive arising from the impact of emission trading. In the following, 5 different scenarios are given describing the ways Estonia could structure electricity production in Estonia. The economic and CO2 intensity assessments in the given analysis have been conducted by Eesti Energia AS. It is presumed in the calculations that Estonia shall be able to cover its peak demand, approximately 1800 MW as of 2016. It is presumed in all the scenarios that after 2016 the electricity short shall be produced by the old oil shale units whereto SO2 capture equipment shall be installed. It is also presumed that after the improvement of the hydraulic transport of oil shale ash depositing of oil shale ash will not be deemed to be depositing of liquid waste after 15 July 2009. The analysis has been made with a vision for the year 2018. It is obvious that it is not possible to realise all the visions (e.g. the construction of a nuclear power plant) by 2018, but all these scenarios may be achieved gradually. In case of all the scenarios, the existing fluidised bed combustion units would operate and approximately 200 MW cogeneration stations would operate on different fuels in 2018. The following options of generation of electricity are discussed below: • electricity from on-shore and off-shore wind turbines, • import of nuclear energy from Lithuania, Finland or the production of nuclear energy in Estonia, • electricity from additional oil shale fluidised bed combustion units; • electricity from pulverised combustion units with oil shale purification equipment; • electricity from gas turbines based on different fuels (natural gas, light heating oil, shale oil and shale gas, liquid gas or liquefied gas, liquid biofuels) with an aim to balance the instability of wind energy production, cover the peaks and maintain the reserves; • from coal fired combined cycle power plants. The CO2 allowance prices of 25 EUR and 50 EUR and the cost of investments and fuels in 2007 have been used as a presumption. 1.7.1 Scenario A: 400 oil shale, 1200 nuclear energy, 250 wind turbines According to this scenario, a gas turbine of approximately 100 MW and wind turbines approximately of 250 MW would be constructed in Estonia in addition to the existing fluidised bed combustion units and cogeneration stations of approximately 200 MW based on different fuels. In addition, Estonian electricity demand would be covered by the participation of the nuclear power plants in Lithuania and/or Finland and/or a small nuclear power plant to be constructed in Estonia (in the total amount of 1200 MW) 26 Main estimates of this scenario: Price of electricity in 2025 Price of electricity in 2025 Amount of CO2 emission (CO2 at the price of 25 (CO2 at the price of 50 investments from electricity EUR/t) EUR/t) production 100 cents/kWh 110 cents/kWh 4.3 billion EUR= 0.17 t/MWh 67.3 billion EEK Scenario A 2500 160 140 2000 120 100 1500 cents/kWh el MW 80 1000 60 Imported oil shale electricity or oil shale electricity with purification equipment On-shore wind turbines 40 Gas turbine 500 Cogeneration station Oil shale units 20 Nuclear power plant Full price of the production portfolio (CO2 price 50 €/t) Full price of the production portfolio (CO2 price 25 €/t) 0 0 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 Years SWOT analysis: Strengths Weaknesses 1. Low CO2 emission from electricity 1. Significant dependence on the import of production, little dependency on CO2 electricity allowance price 2. Insufficient flexibility: not enough peak load 2. Low estimated price of electricity capacities and balance capacities 3. Very big amount of investments 4. Long period of implementation, what would be an interim solution? 5. The need of reserve capacity for a nuclear power plant 6. CO2 emissions from electricity production are very high until the completion of the nuclear power plant 7. No know-how and legislation in the nuclear energy sector in Estonia Opportunities Threats 1. Opportunity to become one of the states 1. The elimination of big production units may with the most clean energy production in the have a significant impact on electricity world supply in Estonia 2. Little dependency on the world market 2. Dependency on imported electricity makes it prices of fossil energy carriers easy to influence electricity supply and 3. Potential large-scale export of electricity prices, domestic income therefrom is minimum 3. Potential too high concentration of the market 27 1.7.2 Scenario B: 400 oil shale, 1200 wind turbines and gas turbines According to this scenario, on-shore and off-shore wind turbines of 1200 MW would be installed in addition to the existing fluidised bed combustion units and cogeneration stations of approximately 200 MW based on different fuels. The variation of the production of the wind turbines would be balanced by gas turbines, where shale oil and shale gas, liquid gas or liquefied gas, light heating oil and liquid biofuels would be used in addition to natural gas in different plants. Main estimates of this scenario: Price of electricity in 2018 Price of electricity in 2018 Amount of CO2 emission (CO2 at the price of 25 (CO2 at the price of 50 investments from electricity EUR/t) EUR/t) production 140 cents/kWh 155 cents/kWh 3.5 billion EUR= 0.36 t/MWh 54.8 billion EEK Scenario B 3500 180 160 3000 140 2500 120 2000 cents/kWh el 100 MW 80 1500 60 1000 Imported oil shale electricity or oil shale electricity with purification equipment On-shore wind turbines Off-shore wind turbines 40 Gas turbine 500 Cogeneration station Oil shale units 20 Full price of the production portfolio (CO2 price 50 €/t) )Full price of the production portfolio (CO2 price 25 €/t) 0 0 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 Years SWOT analysis: Strengths Weaknesses 1. Relatively low CO2 emission from 1. High estimated electricity price as compared electricity production, little dependency on to other scenarios CO2 allowance price 2. Big investments in infrastructure 2. Distributed electricity production 3. Significant dependence on the world market prices of energy carriers Opportunities Threats 1. Opportunity to become a state with the 1. Vulnerability in case of difficulties of biggest share of wind power in the world supply of natural gas and liquid fuel markets 2. By using shale oil in the gas turbines the 2. Presumes application of very good state could make a profit on the increase of regulating automatics the world market prices of energy carriers. 3. Possibilities arise for external manipulation of the price of electricity 4. It has not been proven yet whether shale oil can be used in a gas turbine 28 1.7.3 Scenario C: 800 oil shale, 400 wind turbines and gas turbines, 400 nuclear energy According to this scenario, supplementary fluidised combustion units (2x300 MW) would be installed, wind turbines of approximately 400 MW and gas turbines of 400 MW based on different fuels would be constructed in addition to the existing fluidised bed combustion units and cogeneration stations of approximately 200 MW based on different fuels and purification equipment would be installed in old oil shale units by 2015. The latter would be replaced by a nuclear power plant with the best possible technology and with the capacity of 400 MW in Estonia or a holding in the Finnish and/or Lithuanian nuclear power plant by 2025. Main estimates of this scenario: Price of electricity in 2025 Price of electricity in 2025 Amount of CO2 emission (CO2 at the price of 25 (CO2 at the price of 50 investments from electricity EUR/t) EUR/t) production 125 cents/kWh 140 cents/kWh 3.5 billion EUR= 0,41 t/MWh 54.8 billion EEK Scenario C 3000 180 160 2500 140 2000 120 cents/kWh el 100 MW 1500 80 1000 60 Imported oil shale electricity or oil shale electricity with purification equipment On-shore wind turbines Off-shore wind turbines Gas turbine 40 Cogeneration station 500 New oil shale unit Oil shale units Nuclear power plant 20 Full price of the production portfolio (CO2 price 50 €/) Full price of the production portfolio (CO2 price 25 €/ 0 0 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 Years SWOT analysis: Strengths Weaknesses 1. The varied energy portfolio supports the 1. CO2 emissions from electricity production development of competition on the market are very high until the completion of the 2. Little dependency on the imported energy nuclear power plant sources 2. No know-how and legislation in the nuclear energy sector in Estonia Opportunities Threats 1. By using shale oil in the gas turbines the 1. It has not been proven yet whether shale oil state could make a profit on the increase of can be used in a gas turbine the world market prices of energy carriers. 2. Potential need to grant state aid to oil shale plants until the completion of the nuclear power plant One potential scenario which can be analysed here is the construction of a coal fired power plant instead of an oil shale fired power plant. The good availability of coal on international markets at a 29 reasonable price speaks in favour of the use of coal. High CO2 content should be pointed out as a negative aspect, but due to extensive use it is likely that the technologies for carbon capture will be first developed for coal fired power plants. Price of electricity in 2025 Price of electricity in 2025 Amount of CO2 emission (CO2 at the price of 25 (CO2 at the price of 50 investments from electricity EUR/t) EUR/t) production 130 cents/kWh 148 cents/kWh 3.5 billion EUR= 0,39 t/MWh 54.8 billion EEK Scenario C2 3000 180 160 2500 140 2000 120 el 100 cents/kWh MW1500 80 1000 60 Imported oil shale electricity or oil shale electricity with purification equipment Off-shore wind turbines On-shore wind turbines 40 Gas turbine 500 Cogeneration station New coal unit Oil shale units 20 Nuclear power plant Full price of the production portfolio (CO2 price 50 €/) Full price of the production portfolio (CO2 price 25 €/ 0 ) 0 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 Years SWOT analysis: Strengths Weaknesses 1. Varied energy portfolio (supports the 1. CO2 emissions from electricity production development of competition on the market) are very high until the completion of the 2. Little dependency on the imported energy nuclear power plant sources 2. The dependency of coal price on the world market prices Opportunities Threats 1. By using shale oil in the gas turbines the 1. It has not been proven yet whether shale oil state could make a profit on the increase of can be used in a gas turbine the world market prices of energy carriers. 2. It is likely that carbon capture technologies will be first applied to coal 1.7.4 Scenario D: 1200 oil shale, 400 wind turbines and gas turbines According to this scenario, wind turbines of 400 MW and gas turbines of 400 MW on different fuels shall be installed and new oil shale units of approximately 800 MW shall be installed in Narva Power Plants in addition to the existing fluidised bed combustion units and cogeneration stations of approximately 200 MW based on different fuels. 30 Main estimates of this scenario: Price of electricity in 2018 Price of electricity in 2018 Amount of CO2 emission (CO2 at the price of 25 (CO2 at the price of 50 investments from electricity EUR/t) EUR/t) production 120 cents/kWh 148 cents/kWh EUR 3 billion = 0.67 t/MWh EEK 46.9 billion Scenario D 3000 180 160 2500 140 2000 120 cents/kWh el 100 MW 1500 80 1000 60 Imported oil shale electricity or oil shale electricity with purification equipment On-shore wind turbines Off-shore wind turbines 40 Gas turbine 500 Cogeneration station New oil shale unit 20 Oil shale units Full price of the production portfolio (CO2 price 50 €/) Full price of the production portfolio (CO2 price 25 €/ 0 ) 0 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 Years SWOT analysis: Strengths Weaknesses 1. The smallest amount of required 1. Very high CO2 emissions from electricity investments production, significant dependency of the 2. Little dependency on the world market price on the CO2 allowance price prices of energy carriers 2. Continuing electricity production in one 3. Very good security of supply geographical area 3. Very high environmental impact Opportunities Threats 1. Be the biggest producer of electricity from 1. The significant increase of the CO2 oil shale allowance price makes electricity price 2. The state may gain considerable profit from considerably higher than forecasted the increase of electricity prices in this 2. Significant dependence on the development region. and cost of CO2 sequestration technologies 3. Potential need to grant state aid to the oil shale sector 4. It has not been proven yet whether shale oil can be used in a gas turbine. 1.8. Technological Trends Affecting Strategic Choices in Electricity Production The strategic choices of Estonia may be affected by several technological developments. The most important ones of these are described below: 31 • Electrical energy storage technologies Equipment which would enable to store the energy generated by wind turbines during windy periods and generate electricity during windless periods would promote significantly more extensive use of wind power. At present the main problem of such accumulators is storage losses, but this possibility shall definitely be taken into account upon the development of the technology. • CO2 sequestration technologies The main challenge of the use of fuels rich in CO2 is to develop technologies for post-combustion capture (or pre-combustion chemical separation), transport and storage of CO2. Such technologies are currently under development; the main challenge is their high cost and power consumption. In the context of Estonia, it is important to find a technology suitable for oil shale which might be very different from the technologies applied to coal. • Nuclear technologies At present generation III and III+ reactors are built in the world. Reactors which would also use reactive waste in the electricity production process are deemed to be generation IV nuclear reactors. The development of such reactors would mitigate the problems of the radioactive waste from nuclear power plants. The best existing technology shall be taken into account when constructing a nuclear power plant in Estonia. • Use of shale oil in gas turbines Oil shale is not suitable for use in gas turbines in the present form due to its abrasivity. In order to solve these problems, a way has to be found for purifying shale oil from abrasive particles either in purification equipment or for obtaining purer fractions by supplementary refining. • Use of supercritical parameters upon combustion of fuels The use of supercritical parameters enables to increase the efficiency of electricity production, reduce emissions and the consumption of fuel to a considerable extent. Upon the development of the technology it is not known at present how the materials used will sustain the supercritical parameters in a long run and at present the price of these boilers is considerably higher than the one of traditional boilers. • Coal fired power plant The application of technology of coal combustion – the construction of a combined cycle power plant with pre-gasification - the efficiency of which has already been proved should also be assessed as one alternative. The use of coal may be practical due to good availability and big resources of the fuel on condition that an efficient solution can be applied for CO2 capture. Since at present technologies for CO2 capture from coal plants are under development, the technological solution may be found for coal earlier than for other fuels. • Use of wood in oil shale fired fluidised bed boilers One possibility upon the use of fluidised bed boilers is the use of wood chips together with the main fuel. This would result in the agreed reduction of CO2 emissions. The application of this option would also affect the competitiveness of oil shale to a considerable extent. 32 1.9. Export of Electricity One of the strategic choices of Estonia is also whether to be a state exporting electricity or not. The scenarios described above are based mainly on covering the domestic needs of Estonia. In 2007 2765 GWh of electricity was exported from Estonia to Finland, Latvia and Lithuania, which forms approximately 30% of the domestic electricity consumption of Estonia. According to this indicator, Estonia is a state with the biggest share of export in the European Union. By analysing the relation between the supply and demand of electricity in the neighbouring states, it can be seen that there will be a significant shortage of electricity in the Baltic region (mainly in Latvia) after closing of the Ignalina nuclear power plant which is planned to be covered by import of electricity from Russia. However, Russia does not have not enough electricity for export during peak consumption. The situation may be alleviated by the completion of the nuclear power plant in Lithuania, but the time for the completion of the plant is uncertain. The construction of production capacities for export of electricity is not prescribed in the investment plans for electricity production in Estonia, thus, after 2015, Estonia should focus mainly on covering the needs of the domestic market. At the same time it is clear that upon opening of electricity markets the undertakings are interested in maximising their profit and selling electricity to the consumers who pay more, without giving preference to any states. Therefore it shall be ensured by regulation that the first priority of the producers located in Estonia would be covering of the needs of Estonian electricity consumers and that only the surplus amount of electricity may be sold for export. Upon export of oil shale electricity, the damage caused to the environment shall be compensated and the investments required for the reduction and prevention of the adverse environmental impacts thereof shall be covered. In order to exploit the potential of the export of wind electricity, a clear scheme shall be prescribed in the new Renewable Energy Directive indicating how to trade the so-called green energy allowances. It is in the interests of Estonia to implement a scheme which would enable trading renewable energy on the basis of the guarantee of origin at a justified price in the whole European Union. 33 2. Development Plan 2.1. Vision and Mission Vision: The Estonian power system is a system with varied and sustainable electricity production which is very well interconnected with the neighbouring countries and which ensures power supply to consumers at a justified electricity price at any moment in time. Mission: The mission of the Estonian electricity sector is to ensure continuous, sustainable electricity supply at a justified price for the inhabitants of Estonia: 1. In order to ensure continuous electricity supply, regulations shall be adopted which would give rise to the construction of power plants with the structure of energy sources prescribed in this Development Plan and to guaranteeing of high-quality electricity supply. 2. In order to ensure sustainable electricity supply and consumption, regulations shall be adopted which would ensure the interest of electricity consumers, producers and transporters in saving electricity and the use of more environment-friendly solutions. At the same time these trends should not bring about unjustified increase of the import of energy sources. Work should also be continued for the development of technologies for carbon- free combustion of fossil fuels. Upon the development of sustainable electricity supply, awareness of the public of the possible solutions and technologies shall be increased and implementation of new solutions shall be promoted. 3. For the purpose of supply of electricity at a justified price, the state shall adopt regulations which would ensure adequate electricity prices on the electricity market to be opened, avoid market distortions and abuse of the market position by undertakings. The development of nuclear energy is important for the purpose of ensuring competitive price of electricity. 2.1.1. Trends in electricity production By assessing the abovementioned scenarios on the basis of the strategic environmental impact assessment statement the preferred solution for Estonia would be scenario C proceeding from the economic or security considerations and scenario B proceeding from the environmental considerations. 34 Comparison of scenarios Security of supply Scenario B Scenario C Price Environment Reference: Calculations of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications on the basis of the strategic environmental impact assessment statement The positive aspects of these scenarios shall be combined in order to achieve the most optimal result. For that purpose, the capacity of wind turbines and gas turbines shall be increased and the capacity of oil shale power plants shall be reduced in scenario C. It shall also be taken into account that the use of gas turbines with refined shale oil depends on the completion of the refinery and testing of the relevant gas turbines. Until the completion of such plants the peak demand in Estonia shall be covered by old oil shale units in some of which desulphurisation and denitrification systems shall be installed. In parallel preparations for the construction of a nuclear power plant shall continue and a decision concerning the expediency of the construction of the plant shall be made not later than by 2013. The construction of an additional fluidised bed combustion unit or increasing of the capacity of wind turbines and gas turbines may be considered as an alternative. By combining the scenarios B and C, the development of the net capacities and new connections in the Estonian electricity production would be as follows: 35 Development of net capacity in Estonian power system 2010-2025 3500 3000 2500 2000 MW 1500 1000 500 0 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 Nuclear power plant Combined heat and power Old oil shale units Oil shale CFB-units Oil shale with deSOx and deNOx Balancing units for wind power Peak reserves Disturbance reserves Peak consumption 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 Cogeneration plants 150 200 220 240 260 260 260 260 260 260 260 260 260 260 260 260 Oil shale plants 1660 1660 1630 1630 1630 2170 1520 1520 920 920 920 920 920 920 920 920 - old 1280 1280 640 640 640 640 - fluidised bed 380 380 380 380 380 920 920 920 920 920 920 920 920 920 920 920 - with purification 600 600 600 600 600 600 equipment On-shore wind farms* 150 200 200 400 400 400 400 400 400 400 400 400 400 400 400 400 Off-shore wind farms* 200 200 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 Balancing units for 200 400 400 400 600 600 900 900 900 900 900 900 900 900 wind power - including gas turbines 200 200 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 500 based on shale oil Peak reserves** 100 100 100 100 100 300 300 300 300 300 300 300 300 300 300 Disturbance reserves** 100 200 300 300 300 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 600 Nuclear power plant 600 600 600 Total guaranteed 1810 1960 2150 2470 2590 3230 2980 2980 2980 2980 2980 2980 2980 3580 3580 3580 production capacity Taking account of 1620 1800 1990 2310 2430 3070 2710 2710 2710 2710 2710 2710 2710 2980 2980 2980 criterion n-1 Taking account of 1430 1580 1830 2150 2270 2910 2440 2440 2440 2440 2440 2440 2440 2710 2710 2710 criterion n-2 * - The capacities are not taken into account in the total guaranteed production capacity. ** - Unit capacities of up to 100 MW Thus, the capacity of cogeneration plants shall be increased to 300 MW (with the net capacity of 260 MW at the peak time) by 2014, oil shale fluidised bed combustion units of 2x300 MW (net capacity of 270 MW) shall be constructed by the end of 2015, desulphurisation and denitrification systems (net capacity of 4x150 MW) shall be installed in four of the existing old oil shale units of 200 MW by 2012, the capacity of on-shore wind turbines shall be increased to 400 MW by 2013. The decisions concerning the investments in all these capacities shall be made before the end of 2010. 36 It is practical to increase the capacity of wind farms off shore. Production capacities shall be constructed in the range of the capacity of the wind turbines which would balance the instability of the production of the wind turbines and also cover the consumption peaks. Partial closure of the units with purification equipment of Narva Power Plants may be considered after putting shale oil fired gas turbines into service presumably in 2018. The need for increasing the capacity of emergency power plants in 2016 is due to the completion of the submarine cable Estlink 2 (with the estimated capacity of 600 MW). The capacity of these plants can also be used for ensuring the nuclear power plant capacity reserve. All the gas turbine stations shall be able to use at least 2 types of fuels, preferably domestic resources. The production of each power plant depends on the market situation in the relevant year, which is why it is almost impossible to forecast the structure of electricity production thereof. The regulation on electricity market shall ensure that the structure of production capacities is diversified in Estonia and that we have enough production capacities in case it is not possible to buy electricity at a lower price from anywhere else. In order to implement the scenario, the construction of these plants shall be ensured by national regulations, support schemes, state aid, fiscal policy and legislative measures. The relevant amendments in legislation shall be prepared by 2012 as a preliminary work for the construction of a nuclear power plant. The environmental impact caused by the implementation of the scenarios of electricity production has been assessed in the strategic environmental impact assessment statement of the draft development plan. The abovementioned statement is attached in the Annex to the draft development plan. 2.1.2. Development of transmission network The main task of OÜ Põhivõrk as a system operator is to ensure long-term smooth operation of the Estonian power system. In connection with the establishment of the new structure of production capacities, the transmission network operator shall ensure that the new production capacities will be connected to the network. At the same time it is obvious that it is not practical, based on the market, to construct all the peak and reserve capacities in Estonia and the transmission network operator shall organise the required competitions for that purpose and ensure the availability and operation of the justified capacity of these plants in case of system disturbances. According to the preferred scenario of production capacities, OÜ Põhivõrk shall organise competitions for securing the required emergency and peak load capacities of up to 600 MW. The investment and maintenance costs of these plants would be covered from the transmission network tariffs, the costs of use, however, would be covered on the bases of the market prices. In addition, increase of the share capital of OÜ Põhivõrk could be considered in case of significant increase of investment obligations. For the purpose of the construction of regulating capacities, the Electricity Market Act shall be amended in order to create conditions for the construction of such plants proceeding from the strategic interests of Estonia. Further integration of the power system of Estonia and also of the Baltic States with the power system of the European Union is of determinative importance in the light of ensuring the operation of the EU electricity market and increasing of security of supply. In this context it is necessary to 37 continue cooperation with the Latvian and Lithuanian transmission network operators for the connection of Estlink 2, the Baltic-Swedish and the Baltic-Polish power networks and for the synchronisation of the power networks of the Baltic States with the Central-European power network UCTE. The latter would not mean total separation from the Russian power system, but the construction of converter stations for all or some of the existing connections. 2.1.3. Development of distribution networks There are 40 distribution network enterprises in Estonia as at 1 January 2008. Upon opening of the electricity market, an additional important function of the distribution networks will be communication of information to the market participants. Thereby the distribution network operators must not discriminate any market participants. The technical level of distribution networks has improved from year to year; however, the quality of the network services does not comply with the contemporary requirements in smaller places yet. The quality requirements for network services introduced in 2005 together with contractual penalties have given a good signal for network undertakings for the improvement of the quality of their services and for setting investment priorities. In the places where it is expensive to connect residential buildings to the distribution network a programme for supporting their connection is under implementation in cooperation with the local governments. The distribution network tariff rate is sufficient at present to invest in the development of the networks; the flexible longer-period price regulation applied has also had positive results. Distribution losses have decreased constantly (7.8% in 2007). 38 2.2. Structure of Objectives and Measures Arising from the problems concerning the Estonian electricity sector and proceeding from the mission and vision of the policy of the electricity sector, the objectives and measures of this Development Plan are as follows: 1. Objective: Continuous supply of electricity is ensured for consumers located in Estonia Measures: 1.1. Construction of peak and emergency reserve capacities following a competition organised by the system operator 1.2. Promotion of the construction of power production capacities in Estonia conforming to the trends of the Development Plan, granting of state aid for that purpose, if necessary 1.3. Creation of preconditions for the construction of new international connections 1.4. Analysis and development of the quality requirements for network services, improvement of the quality of network services 1.5. Ensuring electricity supply for all interested persons 2. Objective: Power supply and consumption of the consumers located in Estonia has become more sustainable Measures: 2.1. Supporting sustainable methods of electricity production 2.2. Updating of legislation with an aim to enhance the efficiency of electricity undertakings 2.3. Implementation of innovative power network solutions 2.4. Raising of awareness of saving electricity 3. Objective: Power supply at a justified price has been ensured for consumers located in Estonia Measures: 3.1. Opening of the electricity market, establishment of power exchange 3.2. Development of honest competition rules and ensuring that the competition rules are complied with 3.3.Taking external costs gradually into account in the price of electricity in the framework of the ecological tax reform 3.4. Analysis of the efficiency of support schemes for renewable and cogeneration electricity, correction thereof, if necessary 3.5. Drawing up and entry into force of legislation concerning nuclear power plants A draft implementing plan for 2009-2012 and an estimate of the cost up to 2018 has been prepared for the implementation of the development plan. The draft implementing plan is available on the homepage of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications at http://www.mkm.ee/index.php?id=321328. The cost of the activities planned in the framework of the abovementioned measures shall be indicated by year in the implementing plan which shall be submitted to the Government of the Republic within three months after approval of the National Development Plan of the Energy 39 Sector until 2020 by the Riigikogu. It is planned to finance the activities in the framework of the Development Plan of the Electricity Sector in the total amount of 17.5 billion kroons until 2018, including the cost of the measures in the total amount of 16,850,000 kroons in 2009, the total amount of 45,850,000 in 2010, the total amount of 763,800,000 kroons in 2011, the total amount of 964,100,000 in 2012 and the total amount of 15,668,600,000 kroons in the period from 2013 to 2018. 40 2.3 Activities and Measures 2.3.1. Measures for ensuring continuous electricity supply Objective 1 Continuous supply of electricity is ensured for Baseline Target consumers located in Estonia Indicator 1 The ratio between the available net capacity of approximately >110% power plants and the maximum net consumption 136% (2007) 23 (2018) of electricity during a winter period (October- March) exceeds 110%, but does not exceed 140%. Indicator 2 The annual average duration of the power cuts Transmission Decreasin caused by the failures at the place of network 7.468 g trend consumption indicates a decreasing trend. min Distribution network 201.280 min (2007) 24 Indicator 3 By 2018 the total capacity of the power Approximately At least connections between the Baltic States and the 11.7% 80% European Union will form at least 80% of the (2007) (2018) connection capacities between the Baltic States and third countries MEASURE 1.1 Construction of peak and emergency reserve capacities following a competition organised by the system operator BACKGROUND The experience of the world electricity markets shows that electricity OF THE markets do not give signals for the construction of peak load and quickly MEASURE responding emergency capacities. Therefore the system operators shall have power plants for peak and emergency reserves, the cost of the construction of which shall be covered by the tariffs of the network services, the operation costs thereof, however, shall be covered by electricity sellers. Production capacity balancing plants or energy storage units (e.g. pumped storage power stations) are often used for such purpose. In order not to increase significantly the dependence of Estonia on natural gas, the balancing production capacities based on different fuels (e.g. light heating oil, shale oil and shale gas, biofuels) shall be constructed. PERFORMANCE 1. Balancing production capacities based on 2015 INDICATORS different fuels have been constructed MOST - The system operator shall determine the number, capacity, fuel and IMPORTANT location of the plants ACTIVITIES - Organisation of competition in compliance with the Electricity Market Act - Construction of the required power plants 23 Reference: Estonian Competition Authority 24 Reference: Estonian Competition Authority 41 Results and indicators Target value for 2018 or deadline OUTPUT 1. The terms and conditions of procurement have July 2009 INDICATORS been prepared by OÜ Põhivõrk and approved by the Estonian Competition Authority 2. The competition has been organised and the July 2010 constructers have been selected 3. The new peak and emergency reserve power December 2015 plants have been constructed RESPONSIBLE OÜ Põhivõrk, Estonian Competition Authority MEASURE 1.2 Promotion of the construction of power production capacities in Estonia conforming to the trends of the Development Plan, granting of state aid for that purpose, if necessary BACKGROUND As a rule, power plants are constructed according to the market demand. OF THE However, not a single new power plant has been constructed on open MEASURE electricity markets without state support (either in the form of investment support, state or market guarantee, fixed buying-in price or aid, etc.). In order to ensure the establishment of the structure of the production capacities provided for in the Development Plan, state support schemes shall be prepared for the construction of the required power plants. In order to continue production of electricity from oil shale, 2 new units with the unit capacity of 300 MW shall be constructed in addition and desulphurisation systems shall be installed in up to four old units. The need for the use of state aid shall be prescribed for the construction of new capacities. The construction of different regulating power plants shall be supported analogously. The sales revenue received by the state from the emission trading auctions of emission allowances starting from 2013 and planned to be directed into a fund, which will be established on the basis of the relevant Act and with an aim to ensure energy security and the improvement of energy efficiency, shall be used for granting state aid. Depending of the sales price of the allowance on the auction, the annual revenue of the state may amount to 12 billion kroons. An organisational structure25 which is planned to be established and the concept of which is planned to be developed by the end of 2009 will be the manager of the fund. The use of the finances of the fund will be as follows: -[at least 30%] of the fund’s resources will be used for the investments in energy saving, the development of carbon capture technologies and solving the potential social problems; -[at least 20%] will be used for environmental investments related to power engineering and for co-financing of new connections; -up to [50%] will be used for supporting the preparatory work in the field of nuclear energy and for granting undertakings state aid related to energy 25 The establishment of the organisational structure is under discussion and no final decision has been made concerning the establishment of the structure. 42 security, if necessary. The state aid scheme shall ensure justified rate of return to the persons making investments in energy security (persons renovating oil shale power plants) in open market conditions in case the market price does not ensure an adequate rate of return to them. According to the document "The Bases of the Security Policy of the Republic of Estonia”, the electricity market regulation and the development of the relevant infrastructure shall ensure to consumers the level of security of supply of electricity which does put the performance of the important functions of the state at danger26. PERFORMANCE 1. The structure of the production capacities 2015 INDICATORS proceeding from energy security has been ensured MOST - Analysis of the requirement for support and defining of the principles of IMPORTANT the support scheme ACTIVITIES - Submission of the notice of state aid by the European Commission - Development of a legislative support scheme for the construction of new production capacities, if necessary - Implementation of the support scheme as required - Construction of 2x 300 MW units in Narva Power Plants - Supplying 4 old units with desulphurisation systems Results and indicators Target value for 2018 or deadline OUTPUT 1. The analysis of the need to support and the July 2009 INDICATORS principles of the investments in power plants has been conducted 2. The notice of state aid has been submitted by September 2009 the European Commission 3. Legislation has been drawn up and has July2010 entered into force for the purpose of granting aid to electricity producers ensuring energy security, if necessary 4. The supply scheme has been implemented, if January 2013 necessary 5. 2x 300 MW units have been constructed in 2015 Narva Power Plants 6. Desulphurisation systems have been installed 2012 to 4 old units RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, Ministry of Finance, Estonian Competition Authority, OÜ Põhivõrk MEASURE 1.3 Creation of preconditions for the construction of new international connections BACKGROUND The interconnections of the Baltic States with the other EU countries are so OF THE far limited to the 350 MW submarine cable Estlink (the maximum MEASURE consumption of the Baltic States exceeds 4500 MW). The construction of 26 The Bases of the Security Policy of the Republic of Estonia http://www.kmin.ee/?op=body&id=119 43 Estlink 2, the interconnections between Lithuania-Poland and Baltic States- Sweden are projects necessary for the Estonian power system for increasing security of supply which require also political support. It is recommended to construct the interconnection between Lithuania and Poland as a synchronous connection by replacing the connections in the directions of Russia and Byelorussia by asynchronous connections. Both of the new connections should be constructed by transmission network operators in order to ensure better operation of the electricity market. PERFORMANCE 1. Estlink 2 has been put into service 2014 INDICATORS 2. Readiness for synchronous operation with January 2018 the Central-European and asynchronous operation with the Russian power system has been ensured 3. Unrestricted access to Estlink 1 has been 2013 ensured to all the parties MOST - Negotiations on the conditions of the construction of new IMPORTANT interconnections with the relevant transmission network operators and ACTIVITIES state institutions - Participation in drawing up of the activity plan of the Baltic interconnections - Performance of the required research, environmental assessment and procurements Results and indicators Target value for 2018 or deadline OUTPUT 1. The conditions for the construction of new 2010 INDICATORS interconnections have been negotiated with the transmission network operators and state institutions 2. The development plan of the Baltic July2009 interconnections has been completed; the readiness of the EU has been achieved for co-financing the projects important to Estonia (e.g. Estlink 2) 2010 3. Construction contracts have been concluded with the suppliers with respect to Estlink 2 RESPONSIBLE OÜ Põhivõrk, Estonian Competition Authority, Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, Ministry of Foreign Affairs MEASURE 1.4 Analysis and development of the quality requirements for network services, improvement of the quality of network services BACKGROUND Quality requirements for network services (the permissible number of power OF THE supply interruptions, voltage deviations, requirements for service, MEASURE contractual penalties, etc.) have been established by Regulation No 104 of the Minister of Economic Affairs and Communications. The quality of network services has improved significantly in the last few years, which is why the trends for further improvement of the quality shall also be reviewed. PERFORMANCE 1. The quality of Estonian network services 2010 44 INDICATORS complies with the new quality requirements. MOST - Conducting of the analysis of compliance with the quality requirements IMPORTANT and potential ACTIVITIES - Amendment of the Regulation of the Minister of Economic Affairs and Communications Results and indicators Target value for 2018 or deadline OUTPUT 1. Analysis completed September2009 INDICATORS 2. The required amendments to the Regulation July 2010 have been enforced RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, network operators, Estonian Competition Authority MEASURE 1.5 Ensuring electricity supply for all interested persons BACKGROUND Electricity supply shall be ensured for residential buildings used throughout OF THE the year at the expense of the person requesting electricity supply. The MEASURE problem mostly lies in the connection fee which is especially high in case of the residential buildings located far from the lines. The bases for the calculation of the network charges provided for in the Electricity Market Act in force do not allow supporting of natural persons in payment of the connection fees taking into consideration the purposes of regional policy. The Ministry of the Interior prepared a motion to amend the Electricity Market Act, which was adopted on 19 December 2008. The Ministry of the Interior drew up the corresponding programme of connection supports based on the purposes of regional policy. Enterprise Estonia is the coordinator of the programme. PERFORMANCE 1. Connection to the power network has been 100% INDICATORS ensured for the entitled subjects of the December2011 support schemes (2007: 0%). MOST - Development of national support schemes, planning of finances from the IMPORTANT state budget ACTIVITIES Results and indicators Target value for 2018 or deadline OUTPUT 1. The support schemes have been drawn up July 2009 INDICATORS and implemented. RESPONSIBLE Ministry of the Interior, distribution network operators 45 2.3.2. Measures for ensuring more sustainable power supply and consumption Objective 2 Power supply and consumption of the Baseline Target consumers located in Estonia has become more sustainable Indicator 1 The share of renewable electricity in gross 1.75% 5.1% (2010) consumption is increasing and will reach at least (2007)27 15% (2015) 5.1% by 2010 and at least 15% by 2015. Indicator 2 The share of cogeneration electricity will be least 10.2% 20% (2020) 20% of the gross consumption in 2020 (2007)28 Indicator 3 The level of power transmission losses below 3% of<3% of 3%, the share of distribution losses below 7%, transmission transmission below 6% from 2015 losses losses 7.8% of<6% of distribution distribution losses (2007)29losses (from 2015) Indicator 4 Electricity consumption per capita in households 1320 kWh EL27 does not exceed the average level in the (2007)30 (2018) European Union Indicator 5 The amount of atmospheric emissions of CO2 15.7 mill. t 5 mill. t will not exceed 5 million tons in 2020. (2007)31 (2018) Indicator 6 Decrease of the share of oil shale electricity in 93.6% <70% the gross production of electricity (2007)32 (2018) MEASURE 2.1 Supporting sustainable methods of electricity production BACKGROUND Sustainable methods of electricity production are more expensive in the OF THE present international legal environment and not competitive without state MEASURE support. Therefore different states have supported the production of electricity by various measures. In Estonia, support has been granted partially to the production of renewable electricity and cogeneration electricity. However, not all the potential producers of renewable electricity receive support. PERFORMANCE 1. Increase of the share of renewable and 5.1% of INDICATORS cogeneration electricity renewable (2007: renewable electricity 1.75%, electricity (2010) cogeneration electricity 10.2%) MOST - Analysis of the need for supporting and the extent of electricity 27 Reference: Statistics Estonia 28 Reference: Statistics Estonia 29 Reference: Statistics Estonia 30 Reference: Eurostat 31 Reference: Ministry of the Environment, Statistics Estonia 32 Reference: Statistics Estonia 46 IMPORTANT production methods ACTIVITIES - Preparation of motions to amend to the relevant legislation, if necessary Results and indicators Target value for 2018 or deadline OUTPUT 1. Analysis has been completed 2011 INDICATORS 2. The motions to amend the legislation have 2012 been submitted to the Government of the Republic RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, Ministry of the Finance, Ministry of the Environment, Estonian Competition Authority MEASURE 2.2 Updating of legislation with an aim to enhance the efficiency of electricity undertakings BACKGROUND The existing legislation provides for a definite framework for undertakings, OF THE but situations occur on the market, where electricity undertakings are not MEASURE motivated to make investments for the improvement of sustainability or to act sustainably, since they cannot increase their profit due to the principles of price regulations. The situation could be improved, e.g. by the application of a longer regulation period. PERFORMANCE 1. Increase of the amount of investments in the Increasing trend INDICATORS increase of the efficiency of electricity undertakings (2007: 1.5 billion33). MOST - Analysis of the investment behaviour of electricity undertakings IMPORTANT - Preparation of motions to amend legislation as required ACTIVITIES Results and indicators Target value for 2018 or deadline OUTPUT 1. Analysis has been completed 2011 INDICATORS 2. The motions to amend legislation have been 2012 submitted to the Government of the Republic, if necessary RESPONSIBLE Estonian Competition Authority, Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications MEASURE 2.3 Implementation of innovative power network solutions BACKGROUND In case of distributed electricity production and addition of unstable OF THE electricity producers, better solutions shall be found for the integration of MEASURE these producers into the network. The power measurement systems based on innovative infotechnological solutions allow the consumers to receive more exact information on the consumption structure and current prices and allow the consumers and network operators to control electricity demand, if necessary. Network operators shall have economic motivation for the application of such solutions. PERFORMANCE 1. 1/3 of electricity consumers have innovative 2010 33 Estonian Competition Authority http://www.konkurentsiamet.ee/ 47 INDICATORS measurement systems 2. All the electricity consumers have innovative 2013 measurement systems MOST - Amendment of the Grid Code as required IMPORTANT ACTIVITIES Results and indicators Target value for 2018 or deadline OUTPUT 1. Grid Code has been amended 2010 INDICATORS VASTUTAJAD Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, network operators, Estonian Competition Authority MEASURE 2.4 Raising of awareness of saving electricity BACKGROUND In order to increase the efficiency of electricity consumption and production, OF THE the availability of the relevant information shall be ensured for the MEASURE industries, the public sector and the households. The development of the activity of energy auditors, performed by KREDEX in Estonia, is also related to raising awareness of saving electricity. A suitable solution shall be found for the performance of the abovementioned functions by establishing the corresponding organisational structure. PERFORMANCE 1. The domestic final consumption does not until 2015 INDICATORS exceed the level of 2007 (2007: 7180 GWh) MOST - Analysis of energy audits and development of the activity of energy IMPORTANT auditors ACTIVITIES - Organisation of electricity saving campaigns Results and indicators Target value for 2018 or deadline OUTPUT 1. Analysis of energy audits has been periodical INDICATORS completed and implemented in the development of the activity of energy auditors 2. One electricity saving campaign has been annually until conducted each year 2018 RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, energy auditors, Kredex Foundation 48 2.3.3. Measures for ensuring justified price of electricity Objective 3 Power supply at a justified price has been Baseline Target ensured for consumers located in Estonia Indicator 1 35% of the electricity market opened in 2009, 13% (2007) 35% (2009) fully opened in 201334 at the latest 100% (2013) Indicator 2 The market share of one electricity seller in the 95% Eesti 40% (2018) common market area does not exceed 40% in Energia 2018. (2007)35 MEASURE 3.1 Opening of the electricity market, establishment of power exchange BACKGROUND The Estonian electricity market will open 35% in 2009, it will be fully open OF THE in 2013 at the latest. Alongside with the opening of the electricity market the MEASURE Baltic region of the Nordic power exchange can be launched, which would continuously give price signals to the electricity market. PERFORMANCE 1. Launching of the Baltic region of the Nordic 2013 INDICATORS power exchange MOST - Deregulation of the electricity price IMPORTANT - Preparation for launching the Baltic region of the Nordic power ACTIVITIES exchange - Full opening of the Estonian electricity market - Preparation of market participants for free market Results and indicators Target value for 2018 or deadline OUTPUT 1. Electricity price has been deregulated 2013 INDICATORS 2. The preparation for the Baltic region of the 2011 Nordic power exchange has been completed 3. Estonian electricity market is fully open 2013 4. At least 1000 market participants have been 2013 trained RESPONSIBLE OÜ Põhivõrk, Estonian Competition Authority, Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications MEASURE 3.2 Development of honest competition rules and ensuring that the competition rules are complied with BACKGROUND Honest competition between undertakings shall be ensured on an opening OF THE market in order to avoid unjustified preference of equivalent producers. The MEASURE same competition conditions shall apply to all the market participants. In order to avoid market distortions, cooperation with other EU countries is necessary for drawing up similar regulations. 34 Reference: Estonian Competition Authority 35 Reference: Estonian Competition Authority 49 In order to avoid influencing of the transmission network operator by other participants, independence of the transmission network operator from the commercial interests of other undertakings shall be ensured. Proceeding from the principles of the new Electricity Market Directive, it is rational to separate OÜ Põhivõrk from Eesti Energia AS. PERFORMANCE 1. Equal competition conditions have been 2010 INDICATORS provided for all the market participants. MOST - Analysis of the potential of the import of electricity IMPORTANT - Analysis of the market distortions and deviations of the electricity ACTIVITIES market - Regulation of market distortions which occur as a result of unjustified price advantages of electricity originating from third countries - Separation of OÜ Põhivõrk from Eesti Energia AS and 100% into the direct state ownership Results and indicators Target value for 2018 or deadline OUTPUT 1. Analysis of the potential of import of 2009 INDICATORS electricity has been completed 2. Analysis of market distortions and deviations 2010 of the electricity market has been completed 3. Market distortions have been regulated 2011 4. OÜ Põhivõrk has been brought 100% into 2010 the direct ownership of the state RESPONSIBLE OÜ Põhivõrk, Estonian Competition Authority, Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications MEASURE 3.3 Taking external costs gradually into account in the price of electricity in the framework of the ecological tax reform BACKGROUND The environmental impact of the use of fossil fuels shall be reduced OF THE constantly and the corresponding amendments shall be made in legislation MEASURE by giving the electricity producers signals by the gradual application of either tax rates or duties. Upon the development of taxes, the development of other taxes and rules of emission trading shall also be taken into account. Gradual application of tax rates or duties may cause considerable increase of the electricity price. It is planned to apply for financial resources from the Fund of Wise Decisions for carrying out the analysis. PERFORMANCE 1. The rates of environmental taxes complying INDICATORS with the rules of emission trading ensure constant reduction of environmental impacts MOST - Analysis of the effect of environmental taxes and excise duties IMPORTANT - Making changes in tax and excise duty rates, if necessary ACTIVITIES Results and indicators Target value for 2018 or deadline OUTPUT 1. Analysis has been completed 2012 INDICATORS 2. Tax and excise duty rates have been changed, if necessary 50 RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, Ministry of Finance, Ministry of the Environment MEASURE 3.4 Analysis of the efficiency of support schemes for renewable and cogeneration electricity, correction thereof, if necessary BACKGROUND The Electricity Market Act provides for the supports for renewable and OF THE cogeneration electricity, the purposefulness/efficiency of which shall be MEASURE assessed on an ongoing basis. A decision concerning the justification of these supports can be made on the basis of the actual costs of the new plants put into operation, especially in a situation, where the price of the competing electricity producers is going to increase considerably due to the price of fuels and CO2 allowances. Too big supports would enable unjustified profitability and increase of the price for the consumers of electricity. PERFORMANCE 1. Increase of the share of renewable and 5.1% (2010) INDICATORS cogeneration electricity (renewable electricity 15% (2015) 2007:1.75%)36 MOST - Analysis of the efficiency of the level of support for renewable and IMPORTANT cogeneration electricity ACTIVITIES - Making amendments to legislation, if necessary Results and indicators Target value for 2018 or deadline OUTPUT 1. Analysis has been completed July 2010 INDICATORS 2. Amendments have been made to legislation January 2011 RESPONSIBLE Estonian Competition Authority, Ministry f Economic Affairs and Communications MEASURE 3.5 Drawing up and entry into force of legislation concerning nuclear power plants BACKGROUND The construction of a nuclear power plant in Estonia as an economically OF THE justified alternative in a longer run presumes long-term preliminary work. MEASURE In order to ensure the technical and economic viability of the construction of a nuclear power plant, the corresponding legislation shall be prepared. A nuclear energy agency shall be established in connection with nuclear safety. PERFORMANCE 1. The legal basis concerning nuclear power 2012 INDICATORS plants has been established MOST - Drawing up legislation concerning nuclear power plants and submission IMPORTANT thereof to the Government of the Republic ACTIVITIES - Establishment and functioning of the institutions related to nuclear safety Results and indicators Target value for 2018 or deadline OUTPUT 1. The draft legislation on nuclear power plants December 2010 INDICATORS have been submitted to the Government of the Republic 2. The institutions related to nuclear safety 2012 36 Reference: Statistics Estonia 51 have been established and are functioning RESPONSIBLE Ministry of the Environment, Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, Ministry of Social Affairs, Ministry of Defence, Ministry of the Interior, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Ministry of Education and Research 52 3. Monitoring and Management of Implementation of Development Plan The description of the management structure of the Development Plan of the Electricity Sector has been prepared pursuant to Regulation No 302 of the Government of the Republic of 13 December 2005 “Types of Strategic Development Plans, the Procedure for Their Preparation, Amendment, Implementation and Evaluation and Reporting Procedure”. This Development Plan shall be implemented through the activities of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, the Ministry of the Environment, the Ministry of Education and Research, the Ministry of Social Affairs, the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of the Interior, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Estonian Competition Authority and in cooperation with energy undertakings and network operators. Every three years, the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications shall prepare a development plan for the electricity sector and submit it to the Government of the Republic for approval pursuant to the requirement provided for in subsection 2 (1) of the Electricity Market Act. The development plan for the electricity sector shall include an implementing plan for 2009-2012 and an estimate of the cost up to 2018 which shall be submitted by the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications to the Government of the Republic together with the development plan for the electricity sector. The development plan shall be implemented on the basis of the implementing plan of the development plan, which shall set out the specifics, the extent and organisational arrangements of the measures to be implemented. The Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications shall be responsible for direct implementation of the development plan and assess the efficiency of the activities on ongoing basis in accordance with the output indicators set out in the development plan. The supervision of implementation is based on regular assessment of the efficiency of the measures and subactivities contained in the development plan, on the basis of which the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications shall report to the Government of the Republic on the achievement of the established objectives and make propositions for the amendment or termination of the development plan, if necessary. The report on the development plan shall be submitted as part of the report on the development plan of the energy sector. Pursuant to the provisions of §2 of the Electricity Market Act, the development plan shall be amended in 2012. 53 Annexes Annex 1 Summary of SWOT analyses The Estonian power system has been constructed as part of the unified northwestern system of the former Soviet Union. Estonia belongs to a unified synchronised system together with Russia, Byelorussia, Latvia and Lithuania. The Estonian electricity market is small and characterised by concentration on and orientation at one type of fuel. In 2006, 90.2% of electricity was generated from oil shale, 5.6% from natural gas and the rest of the energy from other energy sources. Thus, Estonia is independent from the import of fuel upon the production of electricity; if necessary, the whole electricity supply can be covered by domestic fuels and energy sources. However, the production of electricity is controlled by the biggest energy undertaking Eesti Energia, which owns 96% of the constructed capacities and which produced 95.3% of electricity in 2006. As a positive aspect of the electricity sector it should be mentioned that there is a very strong power transmission infrastructure in all of the three Baltic States, which is the only region in the European Union where there is no shortage of interconnection capacities, i.e. there are no so-called bottlenecks. Estonia has power interconnections with Russia and Latvia and since the end of 2006 also a direct current link (submarine cable) with Finland. The market share of OÜ Jaotusvõrk forms approximately 85% of the service market. According to the report of the Energy Market Inspectorate, the Estonian distribution networks have the highest potential for saving losses. OÜ Jaotusvõrk has set an objective in its strategy to make 7% reduction in electricity losses by 2010. Oil shale fired power plants have an extensive environmental impact. In 2005 the quantity of waste in the energy sector amounted to 67.1% of the quantity of waste produced in the whole Estonia. Since the oil shale mines and undertakings using oil shale are located mainly in the Ida-Virumaa and Lääne-Virumaa, the emissions accompanying oil shale processing and the use of natural resources have an adverse effect right on the environment of these counties and on the health of the people living there. The electricity market is characterised by efficient cooperation between the transmission network operators of the Baltic States and Finland. Estlink 1 has been constructed and put into operation as a result of the cooperation. In 2007, the transmission network operators of Finland, Estonia and Latvia signed a contract for starting the establishment of a unified electricity market of the Nordic countries and the Baltic States. As the first task of the project, the parties agreed to establish a separate price area in the southern end of the Estonian-Finnish submarine cable Estlink. This enables more efficient market-oriented use of the submarine cable Estlink. The year 2016, when all the electricity production shall be harmonised with the EU requirements, as a result of which there will be a shortage of production capacities in the amount of approximately 1580 MW, will be of critical importance from the point of view of the Estonian electricity sector. Upon the development of the electricity sector in the next years, the use of renewable energy sources and the production of cogeneration electricity shall be increased to a rational extent by taking all the environmental impacts and socio-economical factors of a life cycle into account in the use of energy sources. Peat, waste and biofuel have a significant energetic potential for the operation of small sustainable cogeneration stations. 54 Annex 2 Analysis of employment of the scenarios of the development plan Approximately 8000 people are employed currently in the Eesti Energia group, from whom 1700 are directly connected with the generation of electricity and 3400 with oil shale mining. Decrease in the employment by approximately 1000 people, including 500 in oil shale mining and the rest in electricity generation, can be expected in the next few years. This is connected with the increase of efficiency and is not due to the reduction of production capacities. Table 1. Number of employees as at the end of the financial year Number of employees 2000/1 2001/2 2002/3 2003/4 2004/5 2005/6 2006/7 Eesti Põlevkivi 5601 4913 4617 4680 4458 4036 3754 Narva Power Plants 1852 1829 1837 1861 1855 1772 1794 Reference: Annual reports of Eesti Põlevkivi and Narva Power Plants Table 2. Distribution of employees by age as at 26.06.2008 Number of employees up to 24 25-34 35-44 45-54 55-64 over 64 total Eesti Põlevkivi 133 443 779 1378 648 13 3394 Narva Power Plants 49 225 422 513 432 18 1659 Reference: Eesti Energia 26.06.2008 The adverse effect accompanying the reduction of the number of employees will be mitigated by the usual movement of employees out of the undertaking (retirement, for other reasons). According to the data concerning the period from April 2006 to June 2008, more than 10% of the employees left Narva Power Plants and approximately 20% of the employees left Eesti Põlevkivi in a year. The high mobility is due to the decrease of the number of employees in the undertaking and does not reflect only the so to say common mobility. Rather few people of pensionable age (at least 63 years of age) leave employment as this group forms also a relatively small share. Due to the nature of the work many employees leave the undertaking already before they attain the official pensionable age. The employees changing jobs move to several different specialities; most often the employees who have left Eesti Energia find new jobs in general construction or in the transport sector. Additional impacts on employment in case of different alternatives Construction of wind turbines At present Eesti Energia has wind turbines with the capacity of approximately 50MW; there are 5 employees directly connected with them. The maintenance service of the wind turbines is outsourced. Each wind turbine (with the capacity of approximately 2MW) shall undergo maintenance four times a year, which means one day of work of two people. The estimated need for labour force is more or less the same in case of off-shore wind turbines37, although their maintenance is more expensive due to poor accessibility. During the construction of wind turbines Estonian labour force will be engaged in the construction of the foundations and installation of the wind turbines; towers, generators and other components of wind turbines will be produced abroad. The share of general construction forms approximately 25% of the cost of a wind turbine. Together with the construction of wind turbines gas turbines shall be constructed for capacity fluctuations. These are automatically operating stations which need minimum labour force. It is necessary to use labour force temporarily upon the construction of the station. Nuclear power plant Based on the experience of Finland, 250 highly qualified jobs could be created in Estonia upon the construction of a nuclear power plant, from which 10-15 would be nuclear physicists and chemists. 37 2 persons 1 day every six months, 2 persons 4 days every year. 55 Since the construction period is long, it is possible to train the persons with the required skills and knowledge. In addition, there will be demand for 50 person-years of employment with respect to outsourced services. It is also necessary to establish a nuclear safety agency, where e.g. 40 people are employed in Lithuania. At present there is a radiation centre in Estonia with 30 employees, who can be reprofiled. The estimated labour force demand in the construction phase is 21,000 person-years of employment, which would be divided into approximately 8 years. If Estonia decides to participate in the project of the nuclear power plant in Lithuania or Finland, it would not bring abut significant demand for labour force for Estonia. Construction of oil shale units The construction time of an oil shale unit is approximately 30 months; the maximum of 1000, but more likely fewer employees would be connected with it. In the previous construction, 2/3 of the employees were from Estonia, there rest were from abroad. In addition to the construction of new oil shale units, installation of new purification equipment for old units is under consideration. Impact of the alternative scenarios of the electricity sector on employment Employment in power industry is most affected by changes in oil-shale-based electricity production. According to the scenarios, the available capacity of the oil shale units will be reduced by approximately 300MW in the period 2013-2014, which will bring about the estimated loss of 150-200 jobs38. This corresponds to the common amount of employees leaving the undertaking and thus, no significant impacts are expected in connection with the abovementioned changes. Only the decrease of the demand for labour force arising from a change in production capacities has been taken into account here; the loss of jobs accompanying the increase of the efficiency of operation mentioned above will be added to it. The decrease of the production of electricity based on oil shale should not have a significant impact on the capacity of oil shale mining, since there is sufficient demand for oil shale for the production of oil. It is presumed that the mining capacities not used for electricity production will be used by oil producers and thus, there will be also demand for labour force. If the total capacity of oil shale mining was limited (e.g. by a development plan), it would bring about bigger changes in the number of employees. Significant reduction of the production of electricity from oil shale has been forecasted by 2016. Depending on the remaining capacity of oil-shale-based electricity production the number of employees will decrease by 400-900 employees (see table 3). The new production capacities to be constructed (gas turbines, wind turbines) need a minimum amount of employees for operation. If it is planned to construct a nuclear power plant, it will be necessary, until the completion of the nuclear power plant (in 2025), either to import the lacking electricity or to produce electricity in the existing oil shale fired power plants by installing purification equipment in the plants. In case of the scenarios B and D, import of the lacking electricity may be considered more likely, since there is a short-term (a couple of years) demand for it. The installation of purification equipment may be considered in case of other alternatives, since the demand for either imported or oil shale electricity with purification equipment will last for approximately ten years. If the production of electricity from oil shale with purification equipment is continued, the estimated decrease of employees will be approximately 200-400 employees, in case of scenario B, however, 800-900 employees . These numbers exceed the number of usual movement of employees (approximately 38 In oil shale fired power plants the number of employees does not change in one to one correspondence with the change in the units/capacity, since there are several devices serving the whole complex which need to be serviced. The decrease of labour force may be forecasted with respect to repairs and administrative staff. In August-September a comparative analysis with coal fired plants should be completed, on the basis of which more detailed assessment of the changes in the number of employees could be provided. It has been presumed in the abovementioned analysis that the elasticity between the number of employees and a change in the capacity of oil shale fired power plants is 0.9. 56 200 people a year). It may also be presumed that in addition to direct decrease of the number of jobs, it will be accompanied by an indirect effect (the decrease of the number of jobs in servicing branches). If a nuclear power plant was built in Estonia, there would be an additional demand for approximately 260 employees, but this only around 2025. There would be no additional demand upon the construction of the nuclear power plant in another state. Eesti Energia wishes to increase the production of oil from oil shale, which, however, will not create a significant number of new jobs (capital intensive production, the number of jobs created would remain probably under 100). Although the decrease of the number of employers will be partially compensated by the movement of employees to the labour market, this still means the decrease of the number of jobs. At the same time a considerable decrease of the number of potential employees (0.5-1% a year) is expected after 2012 due to demographic trends. According to the assessments, the number of employees in north-eastern Estonia will decrease by approximately 3 thousand people in the period 2010-2015, by 5 thousand more (approximately 40% of them men)39 in the period 2015-2020. Table 3. Different scenarios and estimated impacts on employment Scenarios Current MW state A1 A2 B C1 C2 D Oil shale 2000 400 400 400 800 800 1200 Oil shale with purification equipment* 1200 1200 0 400 400 0 Cogeneration stations 200 200 200 200 200 200 200 Wind turbines 50 250 250 1200 400 400 400 Gas turbine 100 100 1200 400 400 400 Nuclear energy in Estonia 1200 400 Nuclear energy abroad 1200 400 Change in the number of employees Approxi mately - -800 ... -400 ... -400 ... -400 ... By 2016 200 Ca -200 -900 -500 -500 -500 -800 ... -800 ... -800 ... -600 ... -600 ... -400 ... By 2016 in case of import* -900 -900 -900 -700 -700 -500 Approxi mately - -800 ... -800 ... -300 ... -600 ... -400 ... By 2025 600 -900 -900 -400 -700 -500 * In the basic version it has been taken into account that, in case of long-term shortage of energy, purification equipment will be installed for the oil shale units, the required energy will not be imported. The estimated impacts on the number of employees are indicated in the row "By 2016 in case of import". 39 Based on population projection of Statistics Estonia until 2050, variant 4. Population 2005-2006. Statistics Estonia 2007. In order to find the number of potential employees, it has been presumed that the employment rates by sex and by age group will remain on the current level. 57 National Development Plan of the Energy Sector until 2020 CONTENTS CONTENTS .................................................................................................................................... 2 Introduction ................................................................................................................................. 3 1. Bases for Development Plan ............................................................................................... 5 1.1. Definitions ........................................................................................................................... 6 1.2. Relations with Other Development Strategic Documents ........................................... 8 1.3. Overview of the Implementation of the Development Plan of the Previous Period .................................................................................................................................................... 11 1.4. Overview of the Situation of the Energy Sector .......................................................... 15 1.4.1. Statistical survey........................................................................................... 15 1.4.2. Assessment of and forecast for Estonian energy market ............................. 18 1.4.2.1. Electricity market ............................................................................................... 18 1.4.2.2. Natural gas market ............................................................................................ 19 1.4.2.3. Heat market ........................................................................................................ 19 1.4.2.4. Liquid fuel market .............................................................................................. 20 1.4.2.5. Local solid fuels market .................................................................................... 22 1.4.2.6 Oil shale market .................................................................................................. 22 1.4.3. National energy conservation policy ............................................................. 23 1.5. EU Energy Regulation..................................................................................................... 24 1.5.1 EU’s third internal natural gas and electricity market package ...................... 24 1.5.2. EU climate and energy package ................................................................... 25 1.5.3. European Strategic Energy Technology Plan ............................................... 28 1.6. Comparison of the Estonian Energy Sector with Other States ................................ 30 1.7. Infrastructure..................................................................................................................... 35 1.8. Energy Prices ................................................................................................................... 36 1.9. Trends of Regional Energy Markets ............................................................................. 37 1.10. Assessment of the Estonian Energy Sector .............................................................. 38 2. Development Plan ................................................................................................................... 40 2.1. Vision and Mission ........................................................................................................... 40 2.2. Structure of Objectives and Measures ......................................................................... 41 2.3. Strategic Objectives of the Energy Sector ................................................................... 43 2.3.1. Measures for ensuring continuous energy supply ........................................ 43 2.3.2. Measures for ensuring sustainable energy supply and consumption ........... 49 2.3.3. Measures for ensuring justified energy price ................................................ 56 3. Monitoring and Management of Implementation of the Development Plan ................... 61 3.1. Owner Policy of the State in the Energy Sector .......................................................... 61 Annexes ........................................................................................................................................ 64 Annex 1. Summary of SWOT analyses ............................................................................... 64 Annex 2. Objectives of the national development plans and strategies related to the energy sector ............................................................................................................................ 65 Annex 3. Relations between future and prepared development plans directing the energy sector ............................................................................................................................ 72 2 Introduction In the current century several processes have taken place in the world power industry which have also influenced significantly the development of the Estonian energy sector. The increase of fuel prices on the world markets, gradual liberalisation of energy markets, activation of EU emission trading, worsening of energy supply problems, rising of energy security issues and rapid development of renewable energy have altered also the Estonian energy market to a significant extent. The energy sector trends approved by the European Council provide long-term guidelines for the development of the sector in the European Union. The objective set for 2020 is to achieve a 20 % reduction of greenhouse gas emissions compared to 1990 and a 30% reduction, if other big industrialized countries join the initiative. Another objective established was to increase the share of renewable energy sources up to 20% in energy consumption and the share of biofuels up to 10 % in transport fuels provided that second-generation biofuels are developed successfully. The aim is also to achieve a 20% reduction in energy consumption by 2020. By now Estonia has reduced emissions of greenhouse gases more than 50% compared to 1990; the share of renewable energy sources formed 18% in total energy consumption in 2005. The use of biofuels in Estonia is low at present, but interest in the use of biofuels is increasing constantly. Final energy consumption is somewhat increasing due to economic growth, but at a much slower pace than economic growth. Heat consumption and heat and electricity losses have decreased to a considerable extent in the Estonian energy system as a whole thanks to investments in energy efficiency. Regardless of extremely rapid economic growth, the consumption of primary energy has started to decrease in Estonia. This is supported, among other things, by the decrease in the export volumes. The volume of energy demand in the Estonian economy has decreased to a considerable extent in the last five years. The potential of energy efficiency in the energy system as a whole is approximately 20%, for the gradual achievement of which an energy conservation programme has been prepared as an implementing plan of this development plan. The submarine cable Estlink put into operation in 2007 connected the electricity markets of the Baltic States with the electricity markets of the Nordic countries. Several new renewable electricity plants and cogeneration stations, which increase significantly the efficiency of the Estonian energy system, are under construction. Cooperation has been started between undertakings for the development of the projects of the new nuclear power plant in Lithuania; possibilities to participate in the construction of the 6th nuclear reactor in Finland have been studied. Preliminary work is carried out for further renovation of Narva Power Plants. Storage technologies for shale oil production waste have been developed; preliminary work is carried out for the construction of new shale oil production equipment. There is an increasing interest in the world in the Estonia’s experience in the production of shale oil. The supply problems which arose in January 2006 gave a sign of the bottlenecks of the existing gas system upon growing demand and in extraordinary weather conditions. The prices of liquid fuels, natural gas and wood fuels have also increased considerably, which is mainly due to steep increase in demand in the world’s and regional fuel markets. 3 Great challenges in the next few years are connected with the development of the electricity markets of Estonia and the Baltic States. The prohibition to use the old units of Narva Power Plants shall be applied as of 2016 and closing of the reactors of Ignalina nuclear power plant in 2009 will require significant investments in the electricity sector, the development of electricity markets requires adequate market regulation in all the three Baltic States. The development plan of the electricity sector shall be prepared in order to solve the essential problems of this sector. The aim of the National Development Plan of the Energy Sector is to combine the specific development plans of the sector and to set the general objectives of energy policy until 2020. Pursuant to subsection 10 (2) of the State Budget Act and in compliance with Regulation No 302 of the Government of the Republic of 13 December 2005 “Types of Strategic Development Plans, the Procedure for Their Preparation, Amendment, Implementation and Evaluation and Reporting Procedure”, the Government of the Republic approved, by Order No 13 of 10 January 2008, the preparation of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector and appointed the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications as a ministry responsible for and the Ministry of the Environment, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of Social Affairs, the Ministry of Education and Research and the Ministry of Agriculture as the ministries participating in the preparation of the Development Plan. As an essential national issue the Development Plan of the Energy Sector is subject to approval in the Riigikogu pursuant to subsection 12 (6) of the Sustainable Development Act. The implementing plan of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector prepared at present for the years 2009–2012 shall be approved by the Government of the Republic after approval of the Development Plan in the Riigikogu. A working group was formed for the preparation of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector by directive No 3 of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications of 18 January 2008, the objective of which was to prepare a development plan and an implementing plan. An obligation was imposed on the working group to submit the working version and the final report of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector to the organising committee for power engineering and for the preparation of power engineering development plans formed by directive No 17 of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications (hereinafter „committee”; chairman of the committee: Enari Kisel, Deputy Secretary General for Energy of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications) for review on 22 January 2008. In order to involve all the interest groups, the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications organised a series of public energy forums in order to involve the representatives of all the interest groups in the process of the preparation of the development plan for making proposals, defining the objectives and courses of action, consulting with each other and for answering or discussing the arisen questions. Upon the preparation of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector, a strategic environmental assessment of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector was initiated on the basis of clause 33 (1) 1) and subsection 35 (2) of the Environmental Impact Assessment and Environmental Management System Act. The Environmental Board approved the strategic environmental assessment by letter No 6-8/3061 dated 26 February 2009 and the corresponding report has been annexed to the Development Plan. 4 1. Bases for Development Plan The energy sector is regulated by the following legislation: 1. Sustainable Development Act1 The Sustainable Development Act provides for the basis of the national strategy of sustainable development and the basis of sustainable use of natural resources. The objective of the sustainable use of the natural environment and natural resources is to ensure living environment which satisfies the people and the resources required for the development of economy without causing substantial damage to the natural environment and by maintaining natural diversity. In the geographical and industrial sectors where the contamination of the natural environment and the use of natural resources are likely to disrupt natural balance or endanger the maintenance of biodiversity, the development is directed on the basis of a development plan initiated by the state. A development plan shall be prepared for directing the development of energy, transport, agriculture, forestry, tourism and chemical, building materials and food industries. 2. Electricity Market Act 2 The Electricity Market Act regulates the generation, transmission, sale, export, import and transit of electricity and the economic and technical management of the power system. The Act prescribes the principles for the operation of the electricity market based on the need to ensure an effective supply of electricity at reasonable prices and meeting environmental requirements and the needs of customers, and balanced, environmentally clean and long-term use of energy sources. 3. Natural Gas Act3 The Natural Gas Act regulates the activities related to the import, transmission, distribution and sale of natural gas by way of gas networks, and connection to networks. The abovementioned activities shall be co-ordinated and conform to the principles of objectivity, equal treatment and transparency in order to ensure a secure, reliable and effective gas supply at a justified price in compliance with environmental requirements and the needs of the final customer. 4. District Heating Act4 The District Heating Act regulates the activities related to the production, distribution and sale of heat by way of district heating networks and connection to networks. The abovementioned activities shall be co-ordinated and conform to the principles of objectivity, equal treatment and transparency in order to ensure a secure, reliable and effective heat supply at a justified price in compliance with environmental requirements and the needs of the final customer. 5. Liquid Fuel Act 5 The Liquid Fuel Act provides, for the purpose of guaranteeing the accrual of fuel excise duty and the quality of more widely used motor fuels, the bases and procedure for handling of liquid fuel, liability for the violation of this Act and organisation of exercise of state supervision. The technical and safety requirements for equipment, construction works and measuring instruments used in the handling of liquid fuel are not regulated by the Liquid Fuel Act. 1 Sustainable Development Act https://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=874359 2 Electricity Market Act https://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=12894671 3 Natural Gas Act https://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=12894929 4 District Heating Act https://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=12894819 5 Liquid Fuel Act https://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=12895249 5 6. Liquid Fuel Stocks Act 6 This Act provides the bases for the establishment, maintenance and holding of compulsory liquid fuel stocks. Liquid fuel stocks means the quantities of petroleum products determined by this Act and at the disposal or under the control of the state, which are established in order to ensure national security and the survival of the population of the state, to perform obligations assumed under international agreements relating to the supply of energy and fuel, and to prevent an adverse effect on economic activities or to mitigate the effect of disturbances in the event of disturbances in the supply of petroleum products. 7. Energy Efficiency of Equipment Act7 The Energy Efficiency of Equipment Act regulates the requirements for the energy efficiency and energy labelling of certain types of household appliances, heating equipment and installations, registration of equipment and counselling upon the replacement thereof and the bases of and procedure for their conformity assessment and attestation in order to increase the efficiency of the consumption of energy and other essential resources. In addition to sector-specific regulation, the development of the energy sector is significantly affected by environmental legislation. 1.1. Definitions "bioenergy" means part of renewable energy, which in its turn is part of total energy. Bioenergy is defined as energy produced from biomass – heat, electricity and biofuels; "biofuels" means liquid or gaseous fuel for transport: bioethanol, biodiesel, biogas, biomethanol, biomethylether, bio-ETBE, bio-MTBE, synthetic biofuels, biohydrogen and pure vegetable oil (based on Article 2.2. of Directive 2003/30/EC of the European Parliament); "biomass" means the biodegradable fraction of products, waste and residues from agriculture (including vegetal and animal substances), forestry and related industries, as well as the biodegradable fraction of industrial and municipal waste; "power system" means the technical system for the generation and transmission of electricity, which is comprised of power plants located within the territory of Estonia, the network which connects the power plants to one another as well as customers and the power systems of other countries, and the corresponding control, protection and communication systems; "reliability of a power system" means the ability of the power system to ensure joint operation of power plants and power networks in the operation of the power system; "import of electricity" means the import of electricity from outside the system with the aim of selling or consuming electricity in Estonia; "energy efficiency" means an indicator characterising the efficient consumption of energy and other essential resources upon the normal use of equipment; "district heating" means the production of heat and the distribution thereof through a network with the aim of supplying final customers with heat by way of district heating systems; 6 Liquid Fuel Stocks Act https://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=12794210 7 Energy Efficiency of Equipment Act https://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=12742155 6 "district heating region" means an area determined by a comprehensive plan within which consumer installations are provided with heat by way of district heating in order to ensure a secure, reliable and effective heat supply at a justified price in compliance with environmental requirements and the needs of the final customer; "fluidised bed boiler" means a boiler in which the milling coal is maintained in suspension by a rising current of air during combustion; "primary energy" means energy obtained from a natural source and consumed without transformation into other forms of energy. From the fuel produced in Estonia this includes oil shale, peat, firewood, wood waste and biogas and from the imported fuel this includes coal, natural gas, liquid gas, heavy fuel oil, light heating oil, diesel fuel, motor vehicle petrol and aviation kerosene; "renewable energy sources" means water, wind, solar, wave, tidal and geothermal energy sources, landfill gas, sewage treatment plant gas, biomass; "renewable energy" means energy generated from non-fossil energy sources such as wind energy, solar energy, wave energy, hydropower, tidal energy, geothermal energy, bioenergy, landfill gas, sewage treatment plant gas; "renewable electricity" means electricity generated from non-fossil energy sources such as wind energy, solar energy, wave energy, hydropower, tidal energy, geothermal energy, bioenergy, landfill gas, sewage treatment plant gas; "operational security" means the capability of a power network to operate under normal conditions without interruption during a specific period of time; "security of supply" means the capability of a system to ensure the required high-quality electricity supply to customers during a certain period of time; "liquid fuel" means a liquid flammable substance which can be used as the source of energy for heat engines and other energy conversion devices suitable for such purposes, or liquefied petroleum gas used in motor vehicles which is gaseous under standard conditions, that is, at a pressure of 0.1 MPa and a temperature of 15 °C; "network operator" means an undertaking which owns or possesses a power line or network, a heating pipeline or network, a gas pipeline or network, or a liquid fuel pipeline or network through which electric power, heat, network gas or liquid fuel is transmitted, transported or distributed; "network losses" means power losses in the distribution network elements. 7 1.2. Relations with Other Development Strategic Documents The Development Plan of the Energy Sector is the basis for the development plans of the electricity, oil shale, biomass and bioenergy sectors (Diagram 1) and the energy conservation target programme concerning energy conservation issues: Sustainable Development Act NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN OF THE ENERGY SECTOR UNTIL 2020 Development Plan National Development Plan for Energy of the Estonian Development Plan Enhancing the Use of Conservation Electricity Sector for the Use of Oil Biomass and Target until 2018 Shale for 2008– Bioenergy for 2007– Programme for 2015 2013 Estonia for 2007–201 Diagram 1. Relations of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector with other development plans a. The Development Plan of the Estonian Electricity Sector until 20188 sets the strategic objectives for the development of the electricity sector within ten years by describing the objectives and the measures for the achievement thereof with regard to guaranteeing power supply, reduction of the burden on the environment, creation of international energy links, opening of the electricity market and increase of electricity consumption. The same objectives are of significant importance also in this Development Plan of the Energy Sector. b. The National Development Plan for the Use of Oil Shale for 2008–20159: the strategic objective of the plan is to ensure supply of Estonia with oil shale energy and to guarantee the energetic independence of Estonia. In addition, the development plan raises the issues for finding possibilities in the longer term for gradual reduction of the annual volume of the use of oil shale up to the volume of 15 million tons a year by 2015. The strategic objective set out in the Development Plan for the Use of Oil Shale to increase the efficiency of the use and extraction of oil shale supports the objective of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector to ensure sustainable energy supply and consumption in Estonia. The National Development Plan for the Use of Oil Shale for 2008–2015 was approved by the resolution of the Riigikogu of 21 October 2008”. 8 Development Plan of the Estonian Electricity Sector until 2018 http://www.mkm.ee/index.php?id=321328 9 National Development Plan for the Use of Oil Shale for 2008–2015 http://www.envir.ee/232764 8 c. The Development Plan for Enhancing the Use of Biomass and Bioenergy for 2007–201310: the objective of the plan is to create favourable conditions for the development of the production of domestic biomass and bioenergy in order to decrease the dependence of Estonia on imported resources and fossil fuels and to reduce pressure on the natural environment. The objective of the development plan is to reduce the dependence of Estonia on imported energy resources and to enhance the use of biomass as a raw material for energy which coincides with the objective of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector to guarantee continuous energy supply by diversification of energy sources and more even distribution in the energy balance. d. The Energy Conservation Target Programme for 2007- 201311 defines the targets for saving fuel and energy in Estonia for 2007-2013 and establishes the measures required for achieving the targets. The objective of the programme is to ensure more efficient use of fuels and energy in Estonia, which is of significant importance for the achievement of the objectives of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector in the areas of energy conservation and energy efficiency. In addition to the documents listed above, the Development Plan is related to the following strategic documents: e. The Estonian National Programme for Reduction of the Emission Levels of Pollutants Released into Ambient Air by Stationary and Mobile Sources of Pollution for 2006–201512 (draft), covers the possible ways of reduction of emission levels of pollutants in 2006–2015. The measures and activities planned in this Development Plan of the Energy Sector contribute to the objective provided for in the abovementioned programme upon reduction of the emission levels of pollutants released into ambient air. f. The Estonian Research and Development and Innovation Strategy 2007-2013 “Knowledge-based Estonia”13 focuses on the sustainable development of the society through research, development and innovation, which contributes to the achievement of the objectives of the long-term Estonian strategy on sustainable development "Sustainable Estonia 21". The strategy focuses, among other things, on the preferential development of the energy sector by launching the national research and development programme (National Energy Technology Programme – ETP). In order to achieve the objective of sustainable research and development established in the strategy, measures have been planned in the Development Plan of the Energy Sector for obtaining knowledge in nuclear energy and for the promotion of education and research in the energy sector. g. The Estonian Energy Technology Programme14 sets out the priorities related to the energy sector and provides systematic information to the decision-makers for making decisions related to energy. The priorities of the Energy Technology Programme are oil shale technologies and new energy technologies based mainly on renewable energy sources. The implementation of the 10 Development Plan for Enhancing the Use of Biomass and Bioenergy for 2007–2013 http://www.agri.ee/index.php?id=11014 11 Energy Conservation Target Programme for 2007- 2013 http://www.mkm.ee/index.php?id=352791 12 Draft Estonian National Programme for Reduction of Emission Levels of the Pollutants Released into the Ambient Air by Stationary and Mobile Sources of Pollution for 2006–2015 http://www.envir.ee/462236 13 Estonian Research and Development and Innovation Strategy 2007-2013 “Knowledge-based Estonia” http://www.hm.ee/index.php?03242 14 Estonian Energy Technology Programme http://www.hm.ee/index.php?03242 9 programme enables to obtain a better overview of the use of the financial funds allocated for the energy sector, decrease duplication and improve cooperation between the ministries in the field of energy. The Estonian Energy Technology Programme is closely connected with the biotechnology programme under preparation, the objective of which is to map the development potential and different activities in the Estonian biotechnology sector and to coordinate common objectives and activities. The biotechnology sector is directly connected with the creation of competitive biofuels (creation of economically expedient production potential for second- generation biofuels). h. The Estonian Environmental Strategy until 203015 provides for the objective of the energy sector to produce electricity in an amount, which satisfies the consumption needs in Estonia, and to develop versatile, sustainable production technologies based on different energy sources and with little environmental load, which enable to produce electricity also for export. Based on the objectives set out in the environmental strategy, measures have been planned in the Development Plan of the Energy Sector for the development of energy technologies in the forthcoming years. i. The Estonian Environmental Activity Plan for 2007-201316 (Implementing Plan of the Estonian Environmental Strategy until 2030): the objective is to slow down and stabilise the consumption of energy, while ensuring that the needs of people are met, i.e. to ensure prevention of the increase of the share of primary energy upon increase of consumption. j. The Estonian National Strategy on Sustainable Development "Sustainable Estonia 21"17 supports in general the increase of the production of energy based on renewable natural resources by developing preferentially and supporting activities which promote energy conservation. These objectives are also reflected directly in the Development Plan of the Energy Sector, the aim of which is to ensure continuous, efficient, sustainable energy supply and consumption at a justified price in Estonia. k. The Estonian Housing Development Plan for 2008–201318 provides measures for the improvement of energy conservation in apartment buildings and for raising awareness in order to improve the housing stock, which is of significant importance upon achieving the objectives of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector in the area of energy conservation. l. The Estonian Action Plan for Economic Growth and Employment for 2008- 201119 establishes the objective of the energy sector to ensure security of supply of energy, to develop environment-friendly power engineering and to increase energy efficiency. For Estonia the key issues are increase of ecological compatibility of oil shale power industry, increase of the share of renewable energy and improvement of energy efficiency. The increase of energy efficiency contributes to environment-friendly power engineering (more efficient energy consumption – smaller environmental impact) and the increase of security of supply (smaller energy consumption – smaller need for imported energy). The objectives of the abovementioned plan coincide with the objectives of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector with respect to security of energy supply and energy efficiency. 15 Estonian Environmental Strategy until 2030 http://www.envir.ee/1045989 16 Estonian Environmental Activity Plan for 2007-2013 http://www.envir.ee/1045989 17 Estonian National Strategy on Sustainable Development "Sustainable Estonia 21" https://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=940717 18 Estonian Housing Development Plan for 2008- 2013 http://www.mkm.ee/index.php?id=345312 19 Estonian Action Plan for Economic Growth and Employment for 2008- 2011 http://www.riigikantselei.ee/?id=5864 10 m. The National Strategic Reference Framework for the EU Structural Funds for 2007- 201320 establishes an objective to use energy more efficiently which would enable to prevent potential shortage of energy in future and thus provide international competitive and security advantages for the state in the longer run. According to the implementation plan for the development of housing the following areas shall be supported within the framework of the priority axis of the development of the energy sector: 1) more extensive use of renewable energy sources; 2) use of alternative energy sources in transport; 3) ambient air protection and mitigation of climate changes; 4) development of energy conservation in housing (including informing the residents of the possibilities of energy conservation in residential buildings). The development trends provided for in the strategy are also reflected in the measures of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector for diversification of energy supplies. n. The Bases of the Security Policy of the Republic of Estonia (2004) 21 brings out the strong linkage of Estonian gas and power systems with the monopolistic energy systems and energy suppliers outside Estonia as a significant risk factor. On the basis of the foregoing, the construction of new energy connections in the Member States of the European Union has been planned in the Development Plan of the Energy Sector. o. The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change22 and Kyoto Protocol ratified in October 200223, the objective of which is to reduce greenhouse gas emissions during the years 2008-2012. The protocol establishes an objective for Estonia to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 8% compared to the reference level of 1990. In connection with this the National Development Plan for the Reduction of Greenhouse Gas Emissions is being updated. The measures planned in this Development Plan of the Energy Sector ensure reduction of air pollution contributing to climate change. p. The Action Plan for Energy Policy for Europe 2007–2009 the objectives of which are increasing of security of energy supply, ensuring competitive and affordable energy in Europe and combating climate change in order to achieve environmental sustainability. Measures and activities have been planned in the Development Plan of the Energy Sector for the diversification of energy supply, the development of sustainable use of energy and implementation of new energy technologies in order to achieve the objectives established in the Development Plan. The National Development Plan of the Energy Sector until 2020 shall be implemented through the development plans and implementing plans of different sub-sectors. The abovementioned development plans and implementing plans cover largely the measures required for the organisation of the energy sector. This plan includes additional aspects to be developed and establishes cross-sectoral objectives for efficiency gains upon use of energy. 1.3. Overview of the Implementation of the Development Plan of the Previous Period 20 National Strategic Reference Framework for the EU Structural Funds for 2007-2013 http://www.fin.ee/sf2007 21 Bases of the Security Policy of the Republic of Estonia (2004) http://www.kmin.ee/?op=body&id=119 22 United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change http://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=24655 23 Kyoto Protocol ratified in October 2002 https://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=760682 11 The currently valid Long-term Public Fuel and Energy Sector Development Plan until 2015 approved by the Riigikogu on 15 December 2004 (hereinafter "development plan of the previous period") gives an overview of the situation of the fuel and energy sector, establishes the strategic objectives and the principles for the development thereof, the development trends and the priority activities. The following table shows an overview of the objectives established in the abovementioned development plan and the achievement thereof: Table1. Overview of the achievement of the objectives of the development plan of the previous period Objective Achievement Achieved target value or objective, as at 200724 Ensuring the existence of Achieved: Estonia has been continuously The available installed capacity of the local generating power to able to cover its electricity consumption thermal power stations is 2760 MW, cover the domestic needs and has also exported electricity. the installed capacity of wind power electricity consumption stations and hydroelectric power needs stations is 58MW and 5MW respectively. The export of electricity formed 22% (2765 GWh) of the total amount of electricity generated. Ensuring liquid fuel stocks Achieved: In 2005 the Estonian Oil Based on the data of 2007, there was in compliance with law Stockpiling Agency was established, which 146 439 t of liquid fuel stocks in has ensured the establishment of the fuel Estonia (the required 45 days’ stocks is stocks prescribed by law through contracts 116 507 t). and by ensuring the fuel stocks in reserve The objective is to ensure 90 days’ storage facilities. liquid fuel stocks by 2010 pursuant to the Liquid Fuel Stocks Act. Ensuring that by 2010 Trend towards achievement of the Renewable electricity formed renewable electricity forms objective: by 2006 the share of renewable approximately 1.75 % of the gross 5.1 % of the gross electricity had increased; the estimated consumption. consumption output of the new projects of renewable electricity production which will be completed by 2010 exceeds the established objective. Ensuring that by 2020 the Trend towards achievement of the 12 % of the gross consumption of electricity produced in objective: The cogeneration support electric energy and 27 % of thermal cogeneration stations forms schemes implemented in 2007 have energy was produced in cogeneration 20 % of the gross facilitated the construction of new regime. consumption cogeneration stations; the share of 18 cogeneration stations were in cogeneration is increasing. operation. 24 Upon pointing out the trend (increase/decrease), the year 2000 has been taken as the reference level (unless indicated otherwise) for the purpose of comparing with the levels indicated in the development plan of the previous period. 12 Objective Achievement Achieved target value or objective, as at 200724 Ensuring that, in the open Trend towards achievement of the The total amount of CO2 decreased by market conditions, the objective: the new fluidised bed boilers 53%25 compared to the base year 1990 competitiveness of the completed in 2004 have reduced the (arising from the Kyoto Protocol). domestic market of oil environmental impact to a considerable shale production is extent; the production of shale oil has The amount of the specific emissions of preserved and its efficiency become more competitive as the prices of SO2 per one unit of production (GWh) is increased, and applying petroleum fuels rise. of an oil shale fired power plant modern technologies which decreased by 7% compared to 2005 reduce harmful (purification equipment and 2 power environmental impact units based on CFB technology were Ensuring compliance with Trend towards achievement of the installed.). the environmental objective: energy undertakings have requirements established by generally complied with the established the state environmental requirements, but the issues related to oil shale ash generated and the increase of the use of solid waste need to be solved. In 2006, a project was commenced for the renovation of ash disposal and ash dumps from the EU Cohesion Fund. Investments are made for compliance with the environmental requirements. Increasing the efficiency of Trend towards achievement of the There were 3884 TJ of thermal energy energy consumption in the objective: the Estonian energy system has losses26, which has decreased by 20% heat, energy and fuel become more efficient; network losses compared to the base year. There were sectors have decreased clearly in the last years. 4875 TJ of electric energy losses (2000: However, the final consumption of energy 4463 TJ). increased. 230,318 TJ of primary energy was used in 2007, which is 17.1% more compared to 2000. Until 2010, maintaining the Trend towards achievement of the In 2007, the supplies of primary energy volume of primary energy objective: the achievement of the (total consumption) were 230,318 TJ, consumption at the level of established ambitious objective has been which is 7.4% more compared to 2003 2003 very successful taking into consideration (213,220 TJ). The increase of the the estimated lower economic growth. This volume of the consumption of primary indicator depends to a significant extent on energy resulted from the increased the volume of export of electricity. export of electricity in 2007 (2765 GWh). In 2004, the level of 2003 was exceeded by 2.6%, in 2005 by 0.6%. Ensuring that modern Trend towards achievement of the In 2008, the average competition to the know-how and specialists objective: the field of power engineering specialities of power engineering at the are constantly available in has become more popular at the Tallinn University of Technology was all fields of the fuel and universities, new specialities and areas of 2.2 The biggest competition 3:1 was in energy sector to promote specialisation have been opened. electrical power engineering; in the technology development speciality of thermal power engineering within the state and enable the competition was 1:1. In 2000, the transfer of the modern competition was 2.1, but the number of energy technology student places increased: in 2000, there were 40 places, in 2008 there were 114 25 transmission, storage and distribution losses 13 Objective Achievement Achieved target value or objective, as at 200724 places in the faculty of power engineering and 38 places in thermal power engineering in the Bachelor’s studies. In 2008, there were 74 student places in the faculty of power engineering and 23 places in thermal power engineering in the Master’s studies. Establishment of Trend towards achievement of the The submarine cable Estlink has been preconditions for the objective: In 2007, Estlink was put into completed. construction of connections operation, preliminary work is carried out with the energy systems of with respect to the gas pipeline the Nordic countries and Balticconnector between Estonia and Central European countries Finland, an additional power connection Estlink 2 and a Lithuanian-Polish power connection. The prerequisite for these connections is the establishment of a favourable framework of investments. Definition of the use of oil Achieved: the National Development Plan - shale as the national for the Use of Oil Shale for 2008–2015 was strategic energy resource, approved by the Riigikogu on 21 October including assessment of the 2008. possibilities to use shale oil and oil shale gas upon implementation of the principle of distributed energy production Development of the tax Ongoing process: the new rates and In June 2006, the new rates and system which integrally principles of excise duties have been principles of excise duties and the regulates power applied, the rates of environmental charges principles for the establishment thereof engineering and the for the energy sector have been established were applied by the Alcohol, Tobacco, environment, taking by the Environmental Charges Act (entered Fuel and Electricity Excise Duty Act account of the impact of the into force 1 January 2006). Amendment Act. implementation By the amendments to the Alcohol, mechanisms of the Kyoto Tobacco, Fuel and Electricity Excise Protocol Duty Act approved in 2007 new rates of excise duty were established for motor fuels from 1 January 2008, excise duty was also imposed on natural gas and electricity. Preparation and approval of Achieved: the Development Plan of the - the development plan of the Estonian Electricity Sector 2005–2015 was electricity sector approved by the Government of the Republic on 3 January 2006. Development of measures Partially achieved: exemption from excise - to enable the use of duty has been applied for the use of renewable liquid fuels, in biofuels, the mandatory terms and particular biodiesel, in the conditions for the use of biofuels are under transport sector preparation. The Development Plan for Enhancing the Use of Biomass and Bioenergy for 2007–2013 has been approved by the Government of the Republic. Preparation and approval of Achieved: basic research of the - 14 Objective Achievement Achieved target value or objective, as at 200724 the Estonian development development strategy for energy strategy for energy technology has been carried out (Estonian technology Development Strategy of Energy Related Technologies), on the basis of which the National Energy Technology Programme was prepared and approved by the Government of the Republic on 12 December 2007. Development and approval Achieved: the Energy Conservation Target - of the development plan for Programme for 2007- 2013 was approved the rationalisation of by the Government of the Republic on 1 energy consumption and November 2007. The Environmental improvement of the Activity Plan for 2007-2013, which has efficiency of energy been prepared based on the objectives and production and distribution courses of action set out in the Estonian and the reduction of Environmental Strategy until 2030, has environmental impact been completed and was approved by the Government of the Republic on 22 February 2007. 1.4. Overview of the Situation of the Energy Sector 1.4.1. Statistical survey The rapid development of economy has had an impact on the increase of energy consumption in Estonia: during the period 2000 – 2007 final energy consumption increased by 28% (GDP increased approximately by 71% during the same period). Therefore energy production has also increased continuously. 230,318 TJ of primary energy was used in 2007, which is 17.1% more compared to 2000. In order to inhibit the increase of energy consumption, it is important to increase the efficiency of the energy system and energy conservation by the end consumers, especially in the heat sector, which has the biggest potential for energy conservation. Estonian energy networks have become more efficient – thermal energy losses upon transmission, storage and distribution decreased by 20% compared to 2000. In 2007 there were 4875 TJ (2000: 4463 TJ) of electric energy losses. 15 SKP energiamahukuse trend Eestis (EEK2000 vääringus) 50 45 40 35 toe/EEK2000 30 25 20 15 10 5 0 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 Reference: calculations on the basis of the data of the Statistical Office The ratio of energy supply to GDP is improving in Estonia, this especially in the last years. Besides this trend there is another remarkable trend which is unique in the world: regardless of very rapid economic growth, the consumption of primary energy has decreased in Estonia. Püsihindades SKP ja primaarenergia tarbimise trendid Eestis 80% SKP muutus 70% püsihindades 60% võrreldes 2000. aastaga 50% 40% 30% Primaarenergia 20% tarbimise muutus 10% võrreldes 2000. 0% aastaga 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 Reference: calculations on the basis of the data of the Statistical Office By analysing the causes of this trend it can be seen that thermal energy consumption and energy losses in the heat and power networks have started to decrease in Estonia during the last years. Thus, the investments made upon the renovation of houses and the construction of new well- insulated houses and in particular upon the renovation of heat networks have decreased the total energy demand to a considerable extent. The increase of electricity consumption has been relatively modest and has depended greatly on the formation of new energy-intensive industries. The increase of the consumption of primary energy in 2007 resulted from the threefold increase 16 of export of electricity through the submarine cable Estlink to the Nordic countries; in 2007 the export of electricity to Latvia increased 1.5 times compared to 2006. Domestic fuels (oil shale, peat, wood) still play an important role in energy supply; the share of domestic fuels in the primary energy resources has remained within 65% during the last decade. The existence of domestic fuel supplies has provided security upon supplying with energy, however, imported fuel formed 34% of the primary energy resources. Natural gas imported from Russia and petroleum fuels imported from Lithuania and Russia formed the biggest share of imported fuels. In 2006, approximately 20% of primary energy was exported. Eesti primaarenergia ekspordi/impordi saldo 350000 300000 250000 200000 TJ 150000 100000 50000 0 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 Import prima arenergiana Sise tarbim is eks sise maine prima arenergia E ksport primaa rene rgiana Lõppta rbimine Reference: calculations on the basis of the data of the Statistical Office 12,189 GWh of electricity was produced in 2007, from which 93.6% was electricity produced from oil shale, the rest mainly natural gas and oil shale gas and wind power. In 2007, the final consumption of electricity was 7180 GWh, which has increased by 24% compared to 2000. The export of electricity formed 22% (2765 GWh) of the total amount of electricity produced and import formed 4.8% (345 GWh) of the total domestic consumption of electricity. 3570 GWh of thermal energy was produced in 2007, the installed electrical capacity of thermal power stations was 2760MW and thermal capacity 2542MW, the installed capacity of wind farms and hydroelectric power plants was 58 MW and 5 MW respectively. The final consumption of thermal energy (32644,8 TJ in 2007) increased by 6% compared to 2000. Pursuant to the accession treaty between Estonia and the European Union, Estonia shall, as an exception, open 35% of its electricity market by 31 December 2008, the electricity market shall be open to all consumers by 31 December 2012. Directive 2003/55/EC concerning the internal market in natural gas provides for opening of the internal market for natural gas on the same principles as the Directive concerning the electricity market. The Natural Gas Act valid in Estonia provides the required framework for the opening of the market and for the implementation of the principles of the European Union. Pursuant to legislation the internal market in natural gas was fully open in Estonia by July 2007. 17 Although Estonia set an objective to achieve the indicative share of 2% of biofuels and other renewable fuels for use in transport by 2005 and 5.75% by 2011 (as calculated according to the energy content of the fuels), according to the Tax and Customs Board, the share of the consumption of biodisel formed only 0.06% of the total consumption of petrol and diesel fuel (1,052,000,000 litres) in 2007. In 2007 there were four handlers of biofuel in Estonia who released for consumption the total of 665,309 litres of biofuel27, most of which was sold to the undertakings of other Member States (Sweden, Latvia and Germany). 1.4.2. Assessment of and forecast for Estonian energy market 1.4.2.1. Electricity market According to the Estonian Competition Authority28, the electricity production and sales market in Estonia is very concentrated and orientated at one type of fuel – approximately 94 % of all the electricity is produced from oil shale, whereas the share of other fuels is very modest. In essence electricity production is controlled by the biggest energy undertaking – Eesti Energia AS, who owns 96% of the installed capacity and who produced 95.3 % of the total amount of electricity. In addition to 95 % of the production market, OÜ Jaotusvõrk with the market share of 86 % belongs also to the group of Eesti Energia AS. Also, the biggest oil shale producer AS Eesti Põlevkivi belongs to the group. As compared to other states, Estonia is in a good state as for electricity market legislation. Regulation of the Estonian electricity market commenced by entry into force of the Energy Act in 1998. Since 2003 the energy market has been regulated by separate Acts: the Electricity Market Act, the Natural Gas Act, the District Heating Act and the Liquid Fuel Act. The rights and obligations of the electricity market regulator and of the market participants have been regulated by the Electricity Market Act. The closed market and the price regulation cause market distortions, there is practically no functioning electricity market. The so-called climate package29 published by the European Commission on 23 January 2008 plays an important role in the options of Estonian electricity production; the most important parts of the climate package for Estonia are the draft amendment to the Greenhouse Gas Emissions Trading Directive, the draft Renewable Energy Directive and the draft Carbon Capture and Storage Directive. In connection with the opening of the electricity markets, electricity undertakings of other states will enter the market beside Estonian undertakings. The entry into market of new undertakings will increase competitiveness on the electricity market, but also uncertainty for the state with respect to the structure of production capacities and the location thereof. Because of this it is important to make preparations for ensuring adequate functioning of the open electricity market. A more detailed overview of the electricity sector has been provided in the Development Plan of the Electricity Sector. 27 Ministry of Finance 2008, Monitoring Report Concerning State Aid for Biofuels 28 Estonian Competition Authority, Estonian Electricity and Gas Market Report 2008, http://www.konkurentsiamet.ee/?id=10836 29 Climate package http://ec.europa.eu/climateaction/key_documents/index_en.htm 18 1.4.2.2. Natural gas market According to the Estonian Competition Authority, the natural gas market is open, but in essence pro forma open in Estonia, and there is no efficient competition in the gas market30. Estonia has connections only with Russia and Latvia and the only gas supplier in all the three Baltic States is Russia. Thus, there is no real competition between the sellers. In Finland the situation is also similar to that of the Baltic States, since all natural gas is imported thereto also from Russia. AS Eesti Gaas has a dominant position both in wholesale and retail sale of gas, since AS Eesti Gaas is in essence the only importer and reseller of gas (AS Nitrofert imports gas exclusively for its own needs). The retail market share of AS Eesti Gaas is 93%. Besides the network operator AS EG Võrguteenus that belongs to AS Eesti Gaas group there are 26 smaller independent distribution network operators, but the small network operators, buy gas, without an exception, from AS Eesti Gaas. 1003 million m3 of natural gas was consumed in 2007, which is 0.5% less compared to 2006. Approximately 20% of this gas was consumed by AS Nitrofert. According to the Estonian Competition Authority, the gas consumers are well protected by legislation, the gas supply risks are related to the supply from a single source – Russia. In the peak period of gas consumption gas is supplied mainly from the Latvian storage. The risk of gas supply has increased to some extent, since, unlike in the last years, since spring 2008 most of the gas stored in the Latvian gas storage is not owned by AS Eesti Gaas any more but by Gazprom. In order to ensure the security of gas supply, gas undertakings shall be able to use natural gas supplies which may be located also abroad. In order to increase the security of gas supply, the possibilities for the construction of new cross-border connections, the liquid and liquefied gas terminals shall be examined and the conditions for entering the market shall be improved and, if necessary, obligations shall be provided for network owners by law. In addition, the possibilities to use compressed, natural and liquid gas in transport shall be examined. 1.4.2.3. Heat market During the period 1995–2003 heat consumption decreased by 24.6%. In connection with the general economic growth heat consumption increased by 1-2% a year during 2004–2005, during 2006–2007 heat consumption decreased by 3% as a result of economic slowdown. In 2007, 46% of the heat in the district heating systems was produced on the basis of natural gas. District heating forms 71% of the heat consumed in Estonia31. Over the past few years the prices of district heating have increased significantly due to the price rises on liquid fuel markets. Bigger district heating undertakings using natural gas shall have the possibility to use reserve fuel32, if necessary. Upon heat consumption, special attention shall be paid on the continuous development of energy conservation measures. Significant progress has been made in reducing heat network losses, 30 Estonian Competition Authority, Estonian Electricity and Gas Market Report 2008, http://www.konkurentsiamet.ee/?id=10836 31 Reference: Statistical Office, Energy Balance 2007 32 District Heating Act https://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=12894819 19 during the period 1995–2005 heat losses decreased by approximately 28%. This has been facilitated by the development of regulation, increased energy prices and sufficient investment capacity of undertakings. Several challenges have arisen with respect to the functioning of the district heating market. The following are some examples of bottlenecks: 1. The present regulation directed at a natural monopoly does not facilitate undertakings to make investment decisions to change energy sources, but is directed at covering the costs of the existing equipment and energy resources. This brings about a situation where even the wrong investment decisions made by an undertaking shall be paid up by the consumers. Undertakings are not interested in taking into use cheaper solutions, which would reduce heat price, since they wish to protect the investments, which have already been made, and there is no economic interest to make new investments. 2. Supervision over heat price is fragmented. The Estonian Competition Authority exercises price supervision over major undertakings. Price supervision over smaller heat producers shall be exercised by the local governments, who, however, often do not have sufficient competence for exercising supervision. Cases have occurred, where heat price has been determined based on political, not economic considerations. 3. The regulation does not enable undertakings to respond to the rapid changes in the world market fuel prices at an acceptable speed. 4. Sometimes the decisions made at the local government level do not coincide with the trends of the national energy policy. The determinative trend on the district heating market in the next few years is more extensive use of combined heat and power production and diversification of the production portfolio. The use of heat pumps has increased constantly as a positive trend in local heat supply. Estonia is among the first three states in the world as for the use of heat pumps per capita. As a second local solution local fuels have been preferred, the use of which enhances the development of Estonian economy. A national development plan shall be prepared for even and integral development of the whole heat sector. 1.4.2.4. Liquid fuel market The retail market of liquid fuels has functioned well in Estonia. The wholesale market of liquid fuels has concentrated to Mazeikiu Nafta, but there are no big risks of market abuse taking into account the distribution of the retail market. The Estonian Oil Stockpiling Agency established by the state has established liquid fuel stocks in compliance with the Liquid Fuel Stocks Act33. The establishment of fuel stocks arising from the EU requirements prescribed by the Act, which form 90 days’ average domestic gross consumption in the previous year, shall be completed by 2010 (55 days' stocks has been established by now). The existence of 15 days’ stocks shall be ensured in Estonia, the rest of the 33 Liquid Fuel Stocks Act https://www.riigiteataja.ee/ert/act.jsp?id=12794210 20 Estonian stocks may be stored in Finland, Sweden and Denmark. In order to comply with the IEA requirements, the amount of liquid fuel stocks shall correspond to at least 90 days’ net import of crude oil and liquid fuels in the previous year. It is also necessary to prepare a programme for limiting the consumption of liquid fuels in the case of serious supply shortages and legislation for communicating information to the IEA. The European Commission gives priority34 to the development and extension of the second- generation biofuels in transport with an aim of increasing the share of environment-friendly fuels and achieving 10% mandatory minimum share of biofuels in motor fuels by 2020. In 2007, the share of biodiesel formed only 0.06% of the total consumption of petrol and diesel duel35. In order to promote the use of biofuels in transport, exemption from excise duty has been prescribed for biofuels in the Alcohol, Tobacco and Fuel Excise Duty Act until expiry of the permit issued by the European Commission on 1 Janary 2010. Application of exemption from excise duty has been an impulse for the commencement of activties of several undertakings producing biofuel. According to the biofuel reports submitted to the Tax and Customs Board, there were four handlers of biofuel in Estonia in 2007 who released for consumption the total of 665,309 litres of biofuel. While in 2007 the total consumption of petrol and diesel fuel was 1,052,000,000 litres , the share of the consumption of biodisel formed only 0.06% of the total consumption of petrol and diesel fuel. In 2007, the weighted average sales price of biofuel (in 100% concentration) for the final consumer or the aquirer was 15.8 kroons, VAT included. In the case of the abovementioned sales price, lower energy value of biofuel (ca 38.6 MJ/kg) compared to fossil diesel fuel (energy value approximately 43 MJ/kg) was also taken into account. In 2007, the price of the fossil diesel fuel sold in gas stations in Estonia was approximately 13.71 kroons, including taxes. 36. According to the National Audit Office, the consumers do not have any guarantee as for the quality of the biofuels used currently in transport and thus readiness to use biofuels. 37. Estonia has taken a position that the objective to use 10% of biofuels is mandatory only if economically expedient biofuels which comply with the EU sustainability criteria for biofuels are developed. Biomass, from which foodstuffs are produced, would not be used as a raw material for biofuels any more and sustainability requirements for production shall be complied with. Estonia seconds permission for the use of peat upon the production of biofuels in Estonia provided that the sustainability requirements are complied with. According to the survey38 carried out, the potential measures for the development of the market of biofuels are the following; - excemption of biofuels from excise duty, 34 Strategic Energy Technology Plan (SET-Plan) http://europa.eu/scadplus/leg/en/lvb/l27079.htm 35 Ministry of Finance 2008, Monitoring Report Concerning State Aid for Biofuels 36 Ministry of Finance 2008, Monitoring Report Concerning State Aid for Biofuels 37 National Audit Office Report no OSN-2-6/06/25, 28.04.2006 ”State Action upon Dealing with Issues Concerning Rape and Biodiesel” 38 HeiVäl Consulting ”Measures to Be Taken in Order to Increase the Share of Biofuel in the Fuel Used in Transport” http://www.mkm.ee/index.php?id=352180 21 - requirement of mandatory sales of biofuel, - mandatory use of biofuels in public transport, - supporting the purchase of buses adapted for biofuels, - supporting the installation of biofuel filling stations for buses, - direct supports to the producers of biofuel and/or biomass in proportion to the volume of production, - state aid for the preparation of the infrastructure of biofuels. According to the summary of the impact of the measures, the disadvantages of the production of biomass in Estonia include lack of stable demand, high price of the raw material of biofuels, competition with the food industry for the raw material - rape and absence of infrastructure for the preparation of 5- or 10%-biofuels. 1.4.2.5. Local solid fuels market Increase in the price of liquid fuels on the world market has brought about increase in the price of wood fuels and peat. At the same time these domestic fuels are more and more competitive on the heat and electricity market. The previous export of these resources is being gradually replaced by domestic consumption. Several new cogeneration stations using wood, peat and also waste will be completed in the next few years, which will increase significantly demand for these resources, which in its turn may lead to rise in the price of these resources. Potential incineration of wood waste in Narva oil shale boilers contributes to the reduction of the environmental impact of electricity production. Increase of the use of these domestic energy resources is important for the sake of the diversity of energy balance, environmental protection, employment and market stability. The use of oil shale for electricity production is decreasing gradually by providing more opportunities for the production of shale oil and oil shale chemicals. 1.4.2.6 Oil shale market 2.994 million tons of oil shale was used for the production of shale oil and shale gas and other chemical products in Estonia in 2007. In 2007, the total of 417 thousand tons of shale oil was produced, the total of 77 thousand tons of shale oil was used for domestic consumption and 360 thousand tons of shale oil was exported (the total shale oil resource in 2007: 472 thousand tons) 39. The demand for shale oil products has increased significantly and the possibilities to construct new production capacities have become attractive in connection with the increase of the world market prices of crude oil. The price of thermal energy based on shale oil has increased considerably on the Estonian market. The potential of the production of shale oil in Estonia in future will depend on the permitted volumes of oil shale extraction and the amount of oil shale required for the production of electricity. The priority for Estonia is to ensure the amount of oil shale necessary for supplying the state with electricity, the rest of the oil shale may be used for the production of shale oil and chemical products. 39 Reference: Statistics Estonia, Energy Balance 2007 22 However, upon the production of shale oil, it shall be ensured that the old production equipment will be gradually replaced by new and environment-friendly technologies in order to produce more highly valued oil and chemical products. The state shall also review the basis of taxation of the production of shale oil proceeding from the changed situation of the world market and based on the results of the analysis, make amendments to legislation, if necessary. Upon the development of research in the field of oil shale it is important to export Estonian know-how in the field of the production of shale oil and chemical products to other interested states and to facilitate placing of these products on external markets. Estonian local oil shale resource is too limited for the development of a large-scale industry. 1.4.3. National energy conservation policy The objective of the national energy conservation policy is to ensure efficient use of energy resources, their long-term availability at optimal prices and to alleviate the environmental damage and risks related to the use of energy. Programmes for the promotion of the Estonian energy sector have been implemented consistently since restoration of the independence of Estonia. The first source document of activities related to energy conservation – the Energy Conservation Programme of Estonia – was approved on 24 July 1992; the currently valid Energy Conservation Target Programme for 2007-201340 was approved by the Government of the Republic on 5 November 2007. The Implementation Plan for the Energy Conservation Target Programme for 2007-2009 was prepared on the basis of the Energy Conservation Target Plan. The Sustainable Energy Division of the Energy Department of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications is responsible for the implementation of the energy conservation policy. During the period 2001–2006 the implementation of the Implementation Plan for the Energy Conservation Target Programme was financed in the total amount of 5.255 million kroons, in addition investments of local governments directed at the energy conservation have been supported from the state budget (in the total amount of 52.09 million kroons during the period 2001–2007) and foreign aid has been received for the implementation of the energy conservation policy. Support has been allocated to local governments for the modernisation of the district heating systems and buildings managed thereby and also for the implementation of the reconstruction projects of apartment houses within the housing policy of the state and for the development of the rental housing fund by the local governments. The Energy Efficiency Consulting Centre has operated at the Credit and Export Guarantee Fund KredEx since 2006, the direct task of which is to enhance the awareness of the owners and possessors of apartment houses in the field of energy conservation and to support investments in energy conservation. The most effective investments for the improvement of energy efficiency were made by energy undertakings during the period between 2001–2005. Introduction of new type of boilers and putting into operation of new cogeneration capacities improved energy efficiency of the power plants; network losses have decreased as a result of the reconstruction of power transmission and distribution networks. So far the investments of the local governments directed at saving of fuels and energy supported by the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications have been monitored in the course of 40 Energy Conservation Target Programme for 2007–2013 http://www.mkm.ee/index.php?id=352791 23 implementation of the Estonian energy conservation policy. The estimated savings of the projects implemented between 2002–2006 have varied between 1.1.. 6.8 TJ; in 2006 the final consumption of energy was 114,709 TJ. At the same time the state implements several other measures, the energy conservation effect of which is higher. Monitoring of efficiency of the national policy expressed in energy conservation requires major improvement in Estonia. Energy conservation policy in other states has indicated that more efficient use of fuels and energy improves the competitiveness of economy, increases energy security, has a positive impact on the external balance, employment and environmental awareness of people. Impact on the environment will decrease, investments into expensive energy infrastructure projects will be reduced. 1.5. EU Energy Regulation 1.5.1 EU’s third internal natural gas and electricity market package On 19 September 200741, the European Commission submitted to Council and the European Parliament a package consisting of the following drafts: a) a proposal for a Directive amending Directive 2003/54/EC on common rules for the internal electricity-market; b) a proposal for a Directive amending Directive 2003/55/EC concerning common rules for the internal market in natural gas; c) a proposal for a Regulation establishing an Agency for the Cooperation of EU Energy Regulators; d) a proposal for a Regulation amending Regulation 1228/2003/EC on conditions for access to the network for cross-border exchanges in electricity; e) a proposal for a Regulation amending Regulation 1775/2005/EC on conditions for access to the natural gas transmission networks. As envisaged by the Commission, the proposed drafts should strengthen the internal market in electricity and gas and ensure full and efficient opening of these markets in the European Union. The most important proposals of the Commission include separation of the ownership of supply and production operations from transmission network operations, enhancement of cooperation between the market regulators and transmission network operators of the Member States, establishment of a new agency for the cooperation of EU energy regulators (market regulators), development of cross-border trade in energy and establishment of control over the share of capital originating from third countries in the EU transmission network undertakings. From the point of view of Estonia it is important to solve the problems arisen on energy markets integrately by avoiding causing of new problems. Thus, all the aspects of domestic market, competition policy, emission trading, external trade and security shall be taken into account. In addition, in the electricity market sector it is important to settle the issue of restricting the import of electricity from third countries. Thus, the objectives established by the package for the European Union as a whole are positive from the point of view of Estonia, but the requirements established in the package shall be clear and unambiguous and take the peculiarities of the Baltic region into consideration. 41 http://ec.europa.eu/energy/strategies/2008/2008_01_climate_change_en.htm 24 1.5.2. EU climate and energy package In March 2007, the European Council adopted the EU’s Action Plan for Energy Policy 2007- 2009 (hereinafter EU energy policy), the objectives of which are: • increasing security of supply; • ensuring the competitiveness of European economies and the availability of affordable energy; • promoting environmental sustainability and combating climate change. In the package of measures i.e. the so-called climate package (consists of 4 directives and 1 decision) developed for the implementation of the EU energy policy published on 23 January 200842, the most important target values are the ones established for energy efficiency, the use of renewable energy sources and biofuels, including for environmentally safe carbon capture and storage for 2020: • achieving at least a 20 % reduction of greenhouse gas emissions compared to the base year 1990 (by 2005 the greenhouse gas emissions had been reduced by 6 %); • increasing the share of renewable energy to 20 % of the final consumption of primary energy (in 2005 the average share in EU was 8.5 %); • achieving 20 % more efficient use of energy in the final consumption of primary energy; • increasing the share of biofuels up to 10 % in transport fuels provided that second- generation biofuels are developed. The Climate and Energy Package was confirmed by the European Council on 11-12 December 2008 and approved by the European Parliament on 17 December 2008. The emissions of greenhouse gases (GHG) shall be reduced in two parts – within the framework of the trading scheme of permissible GHG emissions (hereinafter "ETS" - emission trading scheme) and through state obligations in the sectors not included in the scheme. The reduction of emissions within the framework of ETS is achieved by the scheme of allocation of allowances (quotas). As of 2013 the permissible quantity of total annual emission allowances shall decrease by a linear factor of 1.74 % in order to reduce the emissions covered by the scheme by 21 % by 2020 compared to the level in 2005. Member States may exclude small installations with annual emission of less than 25,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide and a rated thermal input below 35 MW from ETS. It is planned to replace the national allocation plans by auctioning or free allocation of permissible emissions through single EU-wide rules. In the scheme of allocation of emissions, organisation of auctions, which should increase the price of an allowance and thus motivate the undertakings to apply cleaner technologies, becomes most important. 88 % of the total quantity of allowances to be auctioned will be distributed among Member States according to their share of the verified Community scheme emissions either a) as of 2005 or b) the average for the period 2005-2007, whichever is higher. In case of Estonia the average verified emissions for the period 2005-2007 is higher (13.4 million tons). The rest of the 10% and 2% of the total quantity of allowances to be auctioned shall be allocated according to the principle of solidarity, economic 42 Climate package http://ec.europa.eu/climateaction/key_documents/index_en.htm 25 growth and early reduction. The European Commission will publish the estimated number of allowances to be auctioned by the end of 2010. The electricity production sector – representing a large part of emissions – would be subject to auctioning from the start of the new ETS in 2013. However, Member States may grant transitional free allocations for small installations which were engaged in the production of electricity on 31 December 2008 or for small installations for which an investment process had been initiated for the same date if one of the following conditions is met: − the national electricity network was not, in 2007, directly or indirectly connected to the network interconnected system (central European power system) operated by the Union for the Coordination of the Transmission of Electricity (UCTE); or − where the national electricity network was, in 2007, only directly or indirectly connected to the network operated by the Union for the Coordination of the Transmission of Electricity (UCTE) through a single line with a capacity of less than 400 MW; or − where, in 2006, more than 30 percent of electricity was produced from a single fossil fuel, and, where in 2006 the gross domestic product per capita at market prices did not exceed 50 % of the average gross domestic product per capita of the EU. • Free allowances shall be allocated on the basis of an investment plan. Transitional free allocations shall be deducted from the quantity of allowances the Member State would otherwise auction. Free allowances shall be allocated for a specified term and limited in quantity: in 2013, the total transitional free allocation shall not exceed 70 % of the annual average verified emissions in 2005-2007 from such generators for the amount corresponding to gross final national consumption pursuant to verified emissions in 2005-2007 of the Member State concerned and shall gradually decrease thereafter, resulting in no free allocation in 2020. Free allowances shall be allocated to electricity production on the basis of the relevant activity plan of the Member State, an application shall also be submitted to the European Commission. Based on the abovementioned conditions, the option to allocate free allowances in the transitional period for modernisation of electricity production applies also to Estonia. Partial allocation of free allowance may turn out to be necessary upon the development of new electricity production capacities in Narva Power Plants. • Free allowances shall be allocated for the production of heat in district heating boiler plants and through high efficiency cogeneration, the quantity of which shall decrease by a linear factor of 1.74% a year starting in 2013. Other industrial sectors with no risk of carbon leakage will step up to auctioning gradually; in the period 2013-2020 the share of allowances will increase from 20% to 70% of the European Community reference and the system of auctioning will be fully implemented by 2027. Auctions shall be organised by Member States and the revenues would be received by Member States. The auctions shall be based on the principles of openness, transparency, harmonised approach and non-discrimination. For example, each operator operating in the European Union may buy allowances in any Member State. By 30 June 2010 at the latest, the European Commission shall adopt a Regulation which regulates the timing, organisation and other aspects of auctions. • The auctioning process would generate significant revenues for Member States, which would help towards the process of adjustment to a low carbon economy, supporting research and development and innovation in areas like renewables and carbon capture and storage, helping 26 developing countries, and helping the less well-off to invest in energy efficiency. Member States shall use at least 50% of their auctioning income for that purpose. Member States shall notify the European Commission of the use of auctioning income. • In the climate package specific attention has been paid to industrial sectors exposed to the risk of carbon leakage, the international competitiveness of which may deteriorate significantly as a result of the implementation of the prerequisite for the climate package. The European Commission shall prepare analysis of such sectors (mainly energy-intensive industries) by the end of 2009 and the relevant list of industries shall be approved by the European Council. The European Commission shall present proposals for the required further action with respect to these sectors at the European Union level not later than by 30 June 2010. Installations in industrial sectors or sub-sectors which are exposed to a significant risk of carbon leakage will be allocated, in the period 2013-2020, 100% of allowances free of charge at the level of the benchmark of the best technology available. • It is important to point out that in its impact assessment of the negotiations on an international climate change agreement and upon the presentation of further action, the European Commission shall take account of the impact of carbon leakage on Member States’ energy security, where there are cross-border electricity connections with third countries and where the electricity connections with the internal market of the rest of the European Union are insufficient. Taking into account, for example, the nature of the cross-border electricity connections of Estonia and depending on the results of the international climate change agreement, this may mean a possibility to establish common measures at the European Union level for the regulation of the import of electricity produced in third countries, e.g. by including import in the emission trading system. The reduction of GHG emissions in the sectors outside the ETS will be achieved through national obligations to reduce GHG. In the sectors not covered by the EU ETS such as buildings, transport, agriculture, waste and industrial installations the emissions of which are lower from the quantities prescribed for accession to the ETS, the obligations to reduce emission are shared between Member States according to GDP per capita. In case of the abovementioned sectors, EU aims to reduce emissions by 10% compared to 2005. For Estonia it is permitted to increase emissions in the abovementioned sectors by up to 11% by 2020. For the purposes of organisation of the distribution and use of the income received within the framework of the emission trading scheme, a concept of the relevant organisational structure shall be adopted in Estonia in 2010. When the concept is agreed upon and approved, principles shall be adopted for the implementation of the updated emission trading scheme in Estonia, including the principles for the organisation of allowance auctions and for the distribution and use of the income received from the allowance auctions. The objective of the Renewable Energy Directive is to establish a common framework for the promotion of the use of energy from renewable sources. One of the most important elements in the Directive is national renewable energy targets, which determine the percentage of the consumption of renewable energy to be achieved by each Member State by 2020 with an aim to increase the overall EU share of renewable energy to 20% by 2020. Thereby indicative interim targets have been established which are calculated as an average for a two-year period. By 2020 the share of energy from renewable sources shall form 25% of the total final consumption in Estonia. The share of energy from renewable sources is calculated as the ratio of consumption of energy from renewable sources over total final consumption. According to the Directive, final 27 consumption includes energy consumption of different economic sectors and energy consumption in the energy sector together with losses. It is up to Member States to decide on which possibilities of renewable energy production to focus. Also, more attention shall be paid on the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions and the increase of security of power supply in the transport sector. The objective of the Carbon Capture and Storage Directive is to ensure that carbon capture and storage is used as a means of mitigating climate change and that this is carried out in a secure and responsible way. Although no separate free allowances have been prescribed for carbon dioxide capture and storage (except up to 300 million tons up to the end of 2015 set aside in the new entrants reserve for supporting EU demonstration projects), the Emissions Trading Directive enables Member States to use in the years 2013-2016 the income received from the auction of allowances for the promotion of the construction of highly efficient power plants, including the construction of new power plants enabling carbon dioxide capture and storage. In case of new installations with the efficiency exceeding the efficiency values provided for power plants in Annex 1 to the Commission decision 2007/74/EC (e.g. the reference value for separate production of electricity from oil shale is 39.0%), Member States may bear up to 15% of the total cost of the investments related to the new installations enabling carbon dioxide capture and storage. 1.5.3. European Strategic Energy Technology Plan In order to achieve the objectives specified in the EU energy policy, an obligation was imposed on the European Commission to prepare the European Strategic Energy Technology Plan (SET- Plan) 43 in order to promote energy efficient and low carbon energy technology in the European economy. The Commission published a communication on the European Strategic Energy Technology Plan on 22 November 2007. The Commission has, in cooperation with the Member States defined 6 priority areas planned to be developed expeditiously: • initiative in wind energy, • initiative in solar energy, • initiative in bioenergy, • initiative in capture, transport and storage of CO2, • initiative in the European power network and • initiative in nuclear energy. A challenge has been set on the basis of the European Strategic Energy Technology Plan to develop the technologies of sustainable second-generation biofuels, CO2 capture, transport and storage and to double the power generation capacity of the largest wind turbines, to introduce large-scale photovoltaic and concentrated solar power solutions, to establish a single and smart European electricity grid (for the integration of renewable and decentralised production), to bring more efficient equipment (heat pumps, fuel cells) to the market and to maintain competitiveness in nuclear technology by finding waste management solutions. The European Strategic Energy Technology Plan pursues the following: 43 European Strategic Energy Technology Plan http://europa.eu/scadplus/leg/en/lvb/l27079.htm 28 a) the transformation of the governance of the energy research and innovation system through the engagement and the commitment of all stakeholders in a coherent programme; b) a strategic planning that orients the research and innovation efforts towards technologies and measures with the greatest potential to deliver the European energy policy targets; c) a more effective implementation, execution and management of all activities across the whole innovation process; d) a cost-effective and results-oriented allocation and increase of means. In order to direct the activities of Estonia in the energy sector, the analysis ”Estonian Development Strategy of Energy Related Technologies”44 was completed in spring 2007, which points out the development trends of energy technology important for Estonia and the need to increase the implementation of measures supporting research and development. The development trends pointed out in this analysis include the development of the integral process of oil shale (from extraction up to the final consumer) and research and development of new, mainly renewable energy resources. In addition to oil shale technologies and new technologies based mainly on renewable energy sources, energy conservation shall be studied. The Estonian Energy Technology Programme45 was prepared on the basis of the research, where the measures and activities of the development trends of the energy sector are discussed in more detail. 44 SWOT Consulting, HeiVäl Consulting ”Estonian Development Strategy of Energy Related Technologies” 2007 http://www.mkm.ee/index.php?id=352180 45 Estonian Energy Technology Programme http://www.hm.ee/index.php?03242 29 1.6. Comparison of the Estonian Energy Sector with Other States Energy dependency. Energy dependency indicates the ratio of the net import of energy sources to the total consumption of energy. As for this indicator, Estonia is one of the most independent states among the states of the European Union (ranking 5th with the 28.5% share in 2004), Natural gas and liquid fuels are imported to Estonia, wood fuels and oil shale are exported. EL riikide energiasõltuvus 2006. aastal 100 80 60 40 20 0 E U K K 27 Y X SP IT Z FI E T L O O HU BU K A BE LV E PT LT NL PL T W C A C U D LU FR IR R SV ES M SL G R E EL G S -20 -40 Reference: International Energy Agency IEA The European Union as a whole depends on imported energy sources to the extent of approximately 50% and this trend is increasing. Estonia is one of the few Member States whose energy dependence has decreased year by year. Energy dependency does not reflect the Member States’ export-import balance of electricity. In 2005, -in Estonia export of electricity formed approximately one fifth of electricity used; this indicator ranked third among the Member States of the European Union after Lithuania and Bulgaria. This fact has also a significant impact on all the other indicators discussed hereafter, since this electricity was produced to a great extent from oil shale, which increased primary energy demand of Estonia, however, this energy was not used in Estonia. 30 Elektri ekspordi/im pordi osakaal elektri tarbim isest EL liikm esriikides 2005. aastal 30% 20% 10% 0% -10% -20% -30% -40% -50% -60% BU UK DK AU HU CY BE SVK FRA CZ IRE NL ROM GER ESP GRE LUX PL MT PT EST SWE LAT IT FI SLO LIT Reference: International Energy Agency IEA Share of natural gas. Estonia is 100% dependent on the import of natural gas from Russia; at the same time natural gas forms less than 15% of the energy balance in Estonia. This is a relatively low indicator compared to other Member States of the European Union. Maagaasi osakaal EL riikide energiabilansis 50 45 40 35 30 % 25 20 15 10 5 0 D 00 4 D 05 04 LX 04 LT 05 E 04 PL 04 FI 5 LV 05 SP 05 G 005 UK 05 IT 05 B 05 A 04 IE 04 S 05 FR 0 5 C 05 M 0 05 04 SE 0 4 SK 005 C 04 PT 05 0 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 2 2 2 2 T T K E E V Y NL Z T HU R Reference: International Energy Agency IEA GDP energy intensity. GDP energy intensity is often used in the comparison of the energy sectors of different states. This indicator shows the amount of energy used in the state’s economy or in other words the amount of primary energy (energy included in all the used energy sources) used per one unit of the gross domestic product (GDP) (measured in monetary units) in a year. This indicator is significantly influenced by the structure of economy (especially the share of energy intensive industry in the state’s economy), the import/export ratio of energy sources (as a 31 rule, the states, which extract and export energy sources, have higher energy intensity, the states, which import energy sources, have lower energy intensity), the basis for GDP calculation (current or constant prices, purchasing power parity46), changes in the exchange rate of the currency used during a definite period of time (e.g. changes in the exchange rate of USD/EUR by year), the climate (as a rule, the amount of fuel used is bigger in a colder climate) etc.. Thus, GDP energy intensity cannot be used as a measurement of comparison of the efficiency of the energy sector of different states, it provides, however, an assessment of the energy intensity of the state's economy. SKP energiamahukus EL liikmeriikides 2005. aastal (toe/SKP kohta $2000 vääringus) 1400 1200 1000 toe/$2000 800 600 400 200 0 ce m n s lic he rg ia ry om c nd Sw e Be in d Cz Lith d a k y s m Po m l ria ta ia a Bu ia ia ly ga nd li e ru ar an n c ni an ni Ita a en ar an tv do N bou iu ga al ub ub e an ed la la st Sp rtu ua to m yp re rla La lg m M nl lg ov Po Ire Au ng un ov ep ep Fr Es en G C Fi er Sl H Ko R R R D xe G et h ak Lu d ec te ni Sl U Reference: International Energy Agency IEA Based on the data of the International Energy Agency (the data cover 137 countries in the world), in 2005 the GDP energy intensity of Estonia was 458 toe/USD in the current prices of 2000. With this indicator Estonia rose from the 66th place to 59th place among the examined states. Estonia rose to the 20th place among the Member States of the European Union by passing Poland and Hungary in a year. Hong Kong (90 toe/USD) hold the first place in the world and Congo (3380 toe/USD) hold the last place. Taking purchasing power parity into consideration, Estonia shared the 76th place in the world as for GDP energy intensity, Estonia was on the 24th place among the Member States of the European Union. Hong Kong holds the first place and Iraq the last place according to this indicator. 46 "Purchasing power parity" means the exchange rate of currencies which equalizes the purchasing power of different currencies 32 SKP energiam ahukus ostujõu pariteetsuse alusel EL liikm esriikides 2005. aastal 350 300 250 200 toe/$2000 150 100 50 0 Germany Hungary Denmark Cyprus Luxemburg Greece Malta Italy France Latvia Ireland Sweden Portugal Netherlands Romania Spain Poland Austria Bulgaria Lithuania Slovak republic Estonia Czech Republic United Kingdom Finland Slovenia Belgium Reference: International Energy Agency IEA Energy demand per capita means the ratio of the total primary energy consumption to the number of inhabitants of a state. The welfare of a state in the energy supply of people is assessed on the basis of this indicator, however, in the comparison with other states this indicator is influenced by the same factors that distort the level of the domestic primary energy consumption in general and which are relatively unrelated to the welfare of people being compared (the share of energy intensive industry, export/import of energy carriers, climate). At the same time regularity can be seen here - the states with better welfare are at the top of this ranking and poorer states at the bottom of the ranking. As for energy demand per capita, in 2005 Estonia was on the 32nd place with 3.79 toe per capita among the states analysed by the International Energy Agency, which is the same place as last year. The first top three in the world are Qatar with 19.47 toe per capita (thanks to the export of petroleum products), Iceland with 12.25 toe per capita (thanks to energy intensive metal industry) and Bahrain with 11.18 toe per capita. The last three among the studied states were Senegal, Eritrea and Bangladesh (with 0.26, 0.18 and 0.17 toe per capita respectively). 33 Primaarenergia tarbimine inimese kohta (toe/capita) 2005. aastal 20 15 toe/cap 10 5 0 m ia h in d en nd d ar k a l ia ea ga es an ar ni n do n a at tv ed la la itr ua hr m to ne ad nl Q La ng e Ire Sw Er Ba en th Es Fi Ic Se gl 1 Ki 60 Li 33 D 6 an 2 14 3 23 32 13 5 d 36 53 13 B ite 7 Un 13 31 Reference: International Energy Agency IEA Carbon dioxide emissions per capita indicate to a great degree the pollution intensity of the energy sector of the state, since most of the CO2 emissions of a state are related to energy facilities. As for CO2 emission, Estonia is a state which is in one of the worst condition in the world (holds the 125th place) due to CO2 intensive oil shale use, export of electricity and cold climate. The assessment of this indicator points out a trend that the states exporting energy sources, states located in a cold climate or states with energy intensive industry are more CO2 intensive. CO2 heitmed inimese kohta maailma riikides 2005. aastal 30 29,38 25,1 25 20 CO2/capita 15 11,81 10,56 10 8,77 5,64 5 3,93 3,19 0,04 0,07 0,08 0 ia ue go d a k a en in vi a r it ni ata lan ar op wa i a an biq on d to m t hr La Q we hi in hu Ku Es Ba en 1C am Et 8F 8 S 62 Lit D 7 13 5 6 oz 2 83 13 11 12 13 8 74 3M 10 Reference: International Energy Agency IEA The CO2 intensity of the energy sector is calculated by dividing these emissions by the amount of primary energy. The Estonian energy sector is one of the most CO2 intensive countries among EU countries. 34 CO2 heitmed primaarenerg ia tarbimise kohta EL riikides 2005. aastal 3,5 3 2,5 2 1,5 1 0,5 0 y De i a en ta l m Hu ic m y Ki i a ce s a a Ro rg um Re y us nia ia Po a ga k c ce nd d Ge n Be d ar nd l tvi i bl bli Lu man i ar lan ai Ne ve n an n al I ta u ar str an do ed ee pr ng an la la pu rtu to rl a pu lgi nm bo M La Sp lg m Au Po Cy hu ng Ire Gr Fin Es Sw Fr r o Re Bu the Sl Lit xe ak d h ec it e ov Un Cz Sl Reference: International Energy Agency IEA At the same time the climatic conditions, the export/import ratio and the structure of the energy sources used should be studied also here in the interests of the comparability of data. For example, at the top of this ranking there are nuclear-weapon states (Sweden, Lithuania, France, Finland), states with great hydro resources (Sweden, Latvia) and states importing electricity (Latvia, Finland) – in all these cases covering of electricity demand is not accompanied by CO2 emissions. 1.7. Infrastructure Estonia has power transmission connections with Russia and Latvia and since the end of 2006 also a direct current link (submarine cable) with Finland. 330 kV lines with the total capacity of 1050 MW run from Narva to Russia and a 330 kV line with the capacity of 500 MW runs from Southern Estonia to Russia, the transmission capacity of the same line in the Russia-Estonia direction is 400 MW. Also, 330 kV lines with the capacity of 750 MW run from Southern Estonia to Latvia. There is a very strong power transmission infrastructure in all the three Baltic States, which is the only region in the European Union where there is no shortage of interconnection capacities. At the same time there are relatively few power connections between the Baltic States and other EU countries (the only connection is the 350 MW Estlink between Finland and Estonia). Since in essence there are no other connections with the market, the area can be viewed primarily as the Baltic electricity market, where Russia not belonging to the European Union and to some extent also Finland can participate. Analogously with the power system the gas supply system has also been constructed during the period of the former Soviet Union and it formed historically part of the gas supply system of the Soviet Union of that time. Estonia has interconnections only with Russia and Latvia, which is 35 why Estonia is in the same situation as the other Baltic States and Finland, where there are no interconnections with the other Member States of the European Union and where the only source of supply is Russia. The Second Strategic Energy Review47 of the European Union published by the European Commission on 13 November 2008 points out the need to develop the energy infrastructure between the Member States in order to improve energy supply security of the Member States and the situation of energy security. The European Commission has made, among the priorities of the development of cross-border infrastructure, a proposal for the preparation of the Baltic Interconnection Plan (BIP), one of the objectives of which is to connect the Baltic States as an isolated energy market with the internal electricity and gas market of the European Union. The preparations for the Interconnection Plan started at the end of 2008 and will continue during the first half of 2009; the Plan should be completed by the Swedish EU Presidency (during the second half of 2009). 1.8. Energy Prices Crude oil prices have increased significantly on the world market over the past few years due to rapid economic growth of the Asian countries and tensions in the Near-East and Africa. In connection with this the prices of other internationally traded energy carriers (mainly natural gas, coal, wood) and new energy facilities have increased. The launched emission trading has also had a significant impact on the energy prices in Europe. In Estonia, the price increase of petroleum fuels and natural gas has given rise to the price increases of local energy resources (oil shale, wood). On a liberal energy market the sellers of energy sources maximise their income depending on the market situation. It is difficult to predict energy price for energy consumers on a liberal market, at the same time an efficiently operating market provides opportunity to receive offers from different energy sellers, which ensures better transparency of the market. Changes in Brent crude oil spot prices 1999–2008 Reference: Nordea e-Markets 47 http://ec.europa.eu/energy/strategies/2008/2008_11_ser2_en.htm 36 Bensiini ja diiselkütuste hinnam uutused Rotterdam is 2002 -2008 (ilma ma ksude ta) 800 700 600 500 EUR /m3 Ben siin 95 400 Diisel 300 200 100 0 2 3 3 4 5 6 6 7 8 8 02 4 05 07 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 00 .20 20 .20 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 .2 . 01 07 01 07 01 07 07 01 07 01 07 01 07 01 Reference: Estonian Oil Stockpiling Agency Estonia cannot influence the price of the energy carriers in the world, which is why ways have to be found so that these trends could bring profit to the state. The state of Estonia as the owner of the resources has increased the taxes related to the resources at a considerably high rate, but at a much slower rate than the rate of increase of energy prices on the world market. Liberalisation of the electricity market will tie the electricity prices in Estonia more with the developments of the world market. The electricity market to be opened in 2013 will provide the consumers an opportunity to select electricity suppliers. In order to establish a justified energy price, sufficient competition shall be ensured between undertakings. On a too concentrated market (where the market share of one undertaking exceeds 40%) undertakings may start abusing their market position and push the prices up for a short period of time without good reason. Therefore it is necessary to organise energy markets in such a way that international competition and internal competition would not enable energy undertakings to manipulate with the price. At the same time international competition should not favour producers with unjustified competitive advantages from other countries. Competitive advantages in the form of different supports have been created for renewable energy and cogeneration energy producers on open electricity markets, which in their turn increase the electricity price. The level of these prices shall ensure reasonable rate of return on investments and shall not create unjustified competitive advantages. 1.9. Trends of Regional Energy Markets Upon the development of regional energy markets, Estonia cooperates actively with its neighbouring states. The objective of this cooperation is to ensure higher security of energy 37 supply and more efficient operation of the energy markets. Closer cooperation takes place with the other Baltic States and the Nordic countries. At present the Baltic States use a diverse set of energy sources based mainly on the Estonian oil shale, Latvian hydro resources and Lithuanian nuclear energy, which are supplemented by imported natural gas and petroleum products and local and renewable energy sources, the use of which is gradually increasing. In addition to that, the underground gas storage in Latvia and the oil refinery in Mažeikiai are important facilities that help to ensure the security of energy supply in the Baltic States. According to the Baltic Energy Strategy48, the objectives for increasing the security of energy supply of the Baltic States are integration of the power and natural gas systems into the energy systems of the European Union, construction of new production capacities, modernisation of power systems, construction of a liquefied natural gas and liquid gas terminal in the region, accelerated introduction of local and renewable energy sources, increasing of energy efficiency. 1.10. Assessment of the Estonian Energy Sector SWOT analysis has been used below for assessing the Estonian energy sector. Strengths: Weaknesses: 1. Little dependency on the imported energy sources. 1. Low energy efficiency in buildings, in the transport 2. A diverse set of energy sources in the primary sector, in district heating systems and in the oil energy supply. shale sector. 3. Energy production capacities are sufficient at 2. Dominating share of oil shale in the energy balance. present for satisfying the demand in Estonia. 3. Small and influencable energy market. 4. Existence of unique know-how in the energy sector. 4. Insufficient financing of education, research and 5. Well-functioning liquid fuel markets. development. 6. An attractive liquid fuel transit route. 5. There is a dominating natural gas supplier on the 7. Possibility to use alternative fuels. market. 8. Adequately developed natural gas infrastructure 6. Natural gas supply contracts with detrimental terms (taking into account the possibilities to use the and conditions. Latvian storage). 7. The current low level of the use of liquid biofuels. 9. Strong energy companies. 8. The establishment of the security stockpile of liquid 10. Big renewable energy resources. fuel has not been completed yet, thus, causing 11. Functioning legal environment and market potential vulnerability in the case of supply supervision. disruptions. 9. Transit/supply of politically influenced liquid fuels. 10. The national analytical basis of the energy sector has been poorly developed. 11. Insufficient/no power and gas connections between the Baltic region and the rest of the Member States of the European Union. Opportunities: Threats: 1. An efficient and transparent framework regulating 1. Deterioration of the security of energy supply. long-term energy supply can be created by more 2. Insufficiency of the stimuli prescribed by the clear political signals. legislation of the states. 2. An attractive investment environment can be 3. Absence of common EU foreign policy in the 48 Baltic Energy Strategy http://www.mkm.ee/index.php?id=9066 38 designed on the basis of adequate market prices. energy sector (fragmentation of energy markets). 3. It is possible to increase the state’s income from the 4. Opposition of the local population and the local international energy market by a more flexible governments to new energy facilities. energy taxation system. 5. Vulnerability of energy systems and increase of 4. Making use of the existing energy conservation energy prices caused by global trends. potential will reduce energy demand and the need 6. Slow modernisation of district heating systems. for production capacities. 7. Shortage of qualified specialists. 5. Economically justified use of local and renewable 8. Risk of natural gas supply disruption. energy sources available reduces energy 9. Increased dependency of the Baltic region on dependency. natural gas supply after closing of the Ignalina 6. New connections enable to reduce the risk of supply nuclear power plant. disruptions. 10. Concentration of the liquid fuel market. 7. Modernisation of the existing district heating 11. Potential disruptions in the supply of crude oil and systems for the purpose of the development of the products thereof. combined heat and power production. 12. Potential adverse environmental impact of liquid 8. Introduction of new energy sources and technologies fuel transit or energy facilities bordering Estonia. in due time. 9. Potential construction of liquid gas and/or liquefied natural gas import-export terminal in the Baltic region. 10. Development of the use of alternative fuels (shale oil, biofuels). 11. More efficient use of liquid fuel storages. 39 2. Development Plan 2.1. Vision and Mission VISION The efficient and innovative energy sector supports the sustainable and balanced development of Estonia. MISSION The mission of the Estonian energy sector is to ensure continuous, efficient, sustainable energy supply at a justified price and sustainable energy consumption. 1. In order to ensure continuous energy supply, the use of energy sources shall be diversified by supporting, among others, local energy sources upon the production of energy. By 2020 the share of any energy source in the energy balance shall not exceed 50%. It is also important to have several strong energy supply channels from other states, reliable grids and to stockpile fuel and production capacity supplies in a reasonable amount. 2. In order to ensure sustainable energy supply and consumption, energy efficiency shall be improved by energy producers, transporters and consumers, the share of renewable energy sources and cogeneration shall be increased in the energy balance up to the optimal level, which does not cause damage to the environment. Estonia shall participate in the development of technologies for carbon-free combustion of fossil fuels. Upon the development of sustainable energy supply and consumption, the awareness of the public of the possible solutions and innovative technologies shall be increased and implementation of new solutions shall be promoted. 3. For the purpose of supply of energy at a justified price, regulations shall be developed, which would prevent market distortions and abuse of the market position by energy undertakings. At the same time the price of energy carriers shall lead to reasonable investments in energy conservation. The activities directed at the export of energy products and know-how shall be in the interests of the Estonian population and create as big additional value as possible for the state of Estonia. 40 2.2. Structure of Objectives and Measures Arising from the problems concerning the Estonian energy sector and based on the mission and vision of the policy of the energy sector, the objectives and measures of this Development Plan are as follows: 1. Objective: Continuous energy supply is ensured for the Estonian population. Measures: 1. 1. Diversification of energy supply through the construction of new connections and more even distribution of energy sources in the energy balance. 1.2. Supplementing legislation in the field of security of supply. 1.3. Coordination of implementation of the energy policy of local governments. 1.4. Cooperation with other Member States of the European Union for the purpose of the development of common foreign policy in the energy sector. 1.5. Establishment and maintenance of fuel stocks. 2. Objective: Energy supply and consumption is more sustainable in Estonia. Measures: 2.1. Development of energy conservation. 2.2. Improvement of the efficiency of the use of oil shale. 2.3. Development of energy technologies. 2.4. Preparation and implementation of the activity plan of renewable energy. 2.5. Preparation and implementation of the national development plan of the heat sector. 2.6. Implementation of the new EU regulations concerning sustainable energy. 3. Objective: Energy supply at a justified price has been ensured for consumers. Measures: 3.1. Elimination of competition deviations and market distortions on the energy market. 3.2. Development of optimal organisational arrangements for the development of the energy sector and emission trading. 3.3. Creation of knowledge in the field of nuclear energy and preparation and entry into force of the corresponding legislation. 3.4. Analysis of the alternatives of the taxation of the energy sector. 3.5. Promotion of education and research in the energy sector. A draft implementing plan for 2009-2012 and an estimate of the cost up to 2020 has been prepared for the implementation of the Development Plan. The draft implementing plan is available on the homepage of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications at http://www.mkm.ee/index.php?id=321327. The planned cost of the abovementioned measures and activities shall be indicated by year in the implementing plan which shall be submitted to the Government of the Republic within three months after approval of the National Development Plan of the Energy Sector until 2020 by the Riigikogu. It is planned to finance the activities in the framework of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector presumably in the amount of approximately 32 billion kroons until 2020, including the cost of the measures in the total amount of 3,600,000 kroons in 2009, the total amount of 936,050,000 kroons in 2010, the total amount of 1,884,250,000 krooni in 2011, the total amount 41 of 1,683,150,000 in 2012 and the total amount of 27,709,600,000 kroons in the period from 2013 to 2020. 42 2.3. Strategic Objectives of the Energy Sector Several objectives related to the energy sector have been established in different national development plans, which are set out in Annex 2. The strategic objectives established in addition for the achievement of the main objective of this Development Plan and the measures and activities planned for the achievement of these objectives are described below. 2.3.1. Measures for ensuring continuous energy supply Objective 1 Continuous energy supply is ensured for the Baseline Target Estonian population Indicator 1 There is no energy supply interruption in Estonia 0 0 under normal conditions which would influence (2007) 49 (2020) more than 10,000 consumers over 2 hours. Indicator 2 There is no energy supply interruption in Estonia 0 0 caused by force majeure which would influence (2007) 50 (2020) more than 20,000 consumers over 5 hours. Indicator 3 Increase of the satisfaction of consumers with the 67% 85% continuity of energy supply (2007) 51 (2011) The following measures shall be taken in order to ensure continuous energy supply: Measure 1.1 Diversification of energy supply through the construction of new connections and more even distribution of energy sources in the energy balance BACKGROUND In 2005 oil shale formed 45% of the internal energy balance (i.e. excluding OF THE export of energy products) of Estonia. Such a big share of one fossil energy MEASURE source in the state’s energy balance is not practical due to energy security and climate considerations, since it is connected with the risks concerning security of supply, environmental protection and energy market. Therefore the share of other energy sources shall be increased in the energy balance and infrastructures shall be established for more extensive energy trading with the other Member States of the European Union; oil shale power industry shall, however, be developed in order to ensure security of supply.. One of the possibilities to diversify the energy portfolio is to develop nuclear power industry. The development of nuclear power industry is discussed in measure 3.3. Preparation up the Baltic Interconnection Plan within 2009 in cooperation with the other Member States bordering the Baltic Sea and the European 49 Reference: Estonian Competition Authority 50 Reference: Estonian Competition Authority 51 Reference: Annual Report of AS Eesti Energia 2007/2008 43 Commission provides conditions for the development of the infrastructure of electricity and natural gas in the Baltic States, including by using EU co- financing upon financing important projects. PERFORMANCE 1. The share of oil shale in the energy balance < 30% (2020) INDICATORS based on the demand in Estonia in 2020 (2007: 45%) 2. The share of other energy sources in the each <20% (2020) Estonian energy balance in 2020 (2007: petroleum fuels 19.7%, natural gas 14.6%, wood 14.6%) MOST - Development and implementation of support schemes for renewable IMPORTANT energy sources ACTIVITIES - Development and implementation of support schemes for cogeneration - Construction of new electricity infrastructures from the Baltic States to other EU counties - Construction of new natural gas infrastructures from the Baltic States to other EU counties - Construction of new liquid gas and/or liquefied natural gas infrastructures Results and indicators Target value or deadline OUTPUT 1. The support scheme for renewable energy 2011 INDICATORS has been improved. 2. The support scheme for cogeneration has 2011 been improved and implemented. 3. New electricity connections, including 2018 Estlink 2, have been constructed from the 2014 (Estlink 2) Baltic States to other EU countries. 4. New natural gas connections have been 2018 constructed from the Baltic States to other EU countries. 5. New liquid gas and/or liquefied natural gas 2018 infrastructures have been constructed in the Baltic region. RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, Ministry of the Environment, OÜ Põhivõrk, AS EG Võrguteenus Measure 1.2 Supplementing legislation in the field of security of supply BACKGROUND In Estonia the security of supply and the quality of network services are OF THE regulated by the subordinate legislation of the Electricity Market Act, the MEASURE Natural Gas Act, the Liquid Fuel Stocks Act and the District Heating Act. Most of the requirements of these Acts are complied with by the undertakings already. 44 PERFORMANCE 1. Improvement of the quality indicators of by 10% INDICATORS network services (2015) 52 MOST - Analysis of the provisions concerning security of supply of legislation IMPORTANT regulating the energy sector and adequacy of the effect thereof ACTIVITIES - Preparation up and entry into force of necessary amendments to legislation Results and indicators Target value or deadline OUTPUT 1. Analysis completed December 2009 INDICATORS 2. Amendments to legislation have been July 2010 submitted to the Government of the Republic; the amendments have entered into force RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, network operators, Estonian Competition Authority Measure 1.3 Coordination of implementation of the energy policy of local governments BACKGROUND The objective of the local governments and county governments in the OF THE energy sector is to direct the implementation of the national energy policy MEASURE on the local level. The national energy policy trends and the planned changes often do not reach the local level at present and the ministries do not have information concerning the problems and trends of the local level. For years the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications has organised information days for the representatives of county governments once a year. The Ministry will continue the organisation of information days in cooperation with the Estonian Competition Authority until the establishment of the planned organisational structure, which will continue and expand informing in the field of energy policy at the level of county governments and local governments. The establishment of the corresponding structure is planned as an activity of measure 3.2.. PERFORMANCE 1. The percentage of local governments (all the Increasing trend INDICATORS local governments), whose representative has attended the energy policy information days (2007: 63%) MOST - Informing in the field of energy policy through the organisational IMPORTANT structure to be established that will be engaged in the development of the ACTIVITIES energy sector and emission trading - Specification of the functions of the county energy advisor Target value for Results and indicators 2020 or deadline OUTPUT 1. Information days for employees of county Since 2010 INDICATORS and local governments engaged in the energy 52 Quality Indicators of Network Services on the homepage of the Estonian Competition Authority http://www.konkurentsiamet.ee/?id=10976 45 sector organised by the organisational structure to be established take place once in a quarter. July 2009 2. The functions of a county energy advisor have been set out and are complied with. RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, Ministry of the Interior, Association of Estonian Cities, Association of Municipalities of Estonia Measure 1.4 Cooperation with other Member States of the European Union for the purpose of the development of common foreign policy in the energy sector BACKGROUND One of the most important priorities of the European Union is to develop OF THE foreign policy of the energy sector, which would be the basis in relations MEASURE with third countries. Such a common policy document shall definitely take into account the interests of the Estonian energy security and be based on the provisions of the Baltic Energy Strategy. The bases of the security policy of Estonia53 concerning the energy sector shall be updated on an ongoing basis. PERFORMANCE 1. Estonian interests are protected in the EU INDICATORS energy policy MOST - Clear and effective expression of the interests of Estonia upon the IMPORTANT development of the EU foreign policy in the energy sector ACTIVITIES - Updating of the bases of the security policy of Estonia concerning the energy sector on an ongoing basis Results and indicators Target value for 2020 or deadline OUTPUT 1. The common EU foreign policy document in INDICATORS the energy sector taking account of the interests of Estonia has been approved. July 2009 2. The bases of the security policy of Estonia concerning the energy sector have been updated RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Ministry of Defence, Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, State Chancellery, Ministry of the Environment Measure 1.5 Establishment and maintenance of fuel stocks BACKGROUND The Estonian Oil Stockpiling Agency, which commenced its activities in OF THE 2005, has continuously completed the stocks in compliance with the MEASURE requirements provided for in the EU accession treaty and the Liquid Fuel Stocks Act and has ensured efficient maintenance of these stocks. Estonia shall have ensured 90 days’ liquid fuel stocks by 2010 based on the average 53 The Bases of the Security Policy of the Republic of Estonia http://www.mod.gov.ee/?op=body&id=119 46 consumption of the previous year. In addition to that it shall also be kept in mind that the liquid fuel stocks shall comply with the obligations arising from accession to OECD and the International Energy Agency (IEA) and legislation shall be supplemented correspondingly. In connection with the terms and conditions of accession to IEA, a programme shall be developed and approved for limiting liquid fuel consumption in the case of serious supply shortages. Alongside with this legislation shall be supplemented arising from the obligation to participate in the Emergency Sharing System (ESS) and Co-ordinated Emergency Response Measures (CERM) and the obligation to communicate information. Also, the need to establish a legislative requirement for the establishment of gas fuel and other fuel stocks shall be analysed. PERFORMANCE 1. The liquid fuel stocks complying with the January 2010 INDICATORS EU requirements have been established and are maintained. 2. The liquid fuel stocks complying with the 2012 IEA requirements have been established and are maintained. MOST - Analysis of the needs for the establishment of supplementary stocks IMPORTANT arising from the IEA requirements ACTIVITIES - Establishment of the liquid fuel stocks complying with the EU requirements - Establishment of the liquid fuel stocks complying with the IEA requirements - Development of a programme for limiting the consumption of liquid fuels in the case of serious supply shortages in compliance with the terms and conditions of IEA - Analysis of legislation proceeding from accession to IEA and amendment of legislation, if necessary Results and indicators Target value for 2020 or deadline OUTPUT 1. Analysis concerning the need to establish January 2011 INDICATORS supplementary stocks arising from the IEA requirements has been completed. 2. Liquid fuel stocks complying with the EU 2010 requirements have been established. 3. Liquid fuel stocks complying with the IEA 2012 requirements have been established. 4. A programme for limiting the consumption 2010 of liquid fuels in the case of serious supply shortages complying with the terms and conditions of IEA has been developed and approved; in the future the programme shall be updated periodically. 5. Analysis of legislation proceeding from 2010 accession to IEA has been completed and 47 legislation has been amended, if necessary. RESPONSIBLE Estonian Oil Stockpiling Agency, Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications 48 2.3.2. Measures for ensuring sustainable energy supply and consumption Objective 2 Energy supply and consumption is more Baseline Target sustainable in Estonia Indicator 1 Increasing of the share of renewable energy in 17.5% 25% the final consumption of energy (2006) 54 (2020) Indicator 2 Increasing of the share of cogeneration in the 10.2% 20% gross consumption of electricity (2007) 55 (2020) Indicator 3 As a result of the energy conservation measures 5TJ 9.8PJ applied in the state the total of 9.8PJ is saved in (2007) 56 (2016) 2016 (i.e. 9% of the average consumption of the years 2001–2005 arising from Directive 2006/32/EC) Indicator 4 Reduction of network losses (losses as a ratio to Electricity Decreasing gross production) 11.1% trend (2007) Heat 10.6% (2007) 57 Indicator 5 Reduction of the amount of primary energy used 124,438 TJ Decreasing for Estonian internal demand (2007) 58 trend Indicator 6 The share of fuels based on renewable energy 0.06% 10% sources forms 10% of transport fuels in 2020. (2007) 59 (2020) Indicator 7 CO2 emissions of the energy sector have 15.7 million 7.85 million decreased twice in 2020 compared to 2007. t (2007) 60 t (2020) Measure 2.1 Development of energy conservation BACKGROUND The following national development documents contribute to sustainable OF THE energy use in the corresponding field: MEASURE 1. Energy Conservation Target Programme for 2007- 2013, 2. Estonian Housing Development Plan for 2008-2013, 3. Transport Development Plan for 2006–2013, 4. Development Plan for Enhancing the Use of Biomass and Bioenergy for 2007–2013 54 Reference: Statistics Estonia 55 Reference: Statistics Estonia 56 Reference: Energy Conservation Target Programme for 2007- 2013 57 Reference: Statistics Estonia 58 Reference: Statistics Estonia 59 Reference: Ministry of Finance 2008, Monitoring Report Concerning State Aid for Biofuels 60 Reference: Estonian Action Plan for Economic Growth and Employment for 2008- 2011 49 5. National Development Plan for the Use of Oil Shale for 2008–2015 6. Development Plan of the Estonian Electricity Sector until 2018 7. Estonian Environmental Strategy until 2030 8. Estonian Action Plan for Economic Growth and Employment for 2008- 2011 These documents set out detailed objectives, action plans and implementing plans (see Annex 2). The main priority is to inform the population of the possibilities to save energy and the economic and environmental impacts thereof and to help to make decisions and investments which promote energy conservation in the business, state and private sector. The most important activities in the area of energy conservation in the abovementioned development documents are: improvement of the availability of information concerning energy conservation, ensuring the existence of experts in the field of energy conservation, supporting expert assessment and energy audits of constructions in apartment buildings (Energy Conservation Target Programme); supporting reconstruction and renovation work of apartment buildings directed at energy conservation (Housing Development Plan); supporting investments in the renovation of the heating lines of district heating networks (structural funds); optimisation of oil shale extraction capacities (Development Plan for the Use of Oil Shale); creation of favourable conditions for the development of domestic biomass and bioenergy (Development Plan for Enhancing the Use of Biomass and Bioenergy); stimulation of the use of environment-friendly technologies (Transport Development Plan). PERFORMANCE 1. All the objectives established in the 2020 INDICATORS development documents have been achieved by the due date. MOST - Implementation of the measures related to energy conservation set out in IMPORTANT the established development plans of the corresponding sector (see ACTIVITIES Annex 2) - Supplementing of the Energy Conservation Target Programme for 2007- 2013 Results and indicators Target value for 2020 or deadline OUTPUT 1. The energy conservation measures In compliance with the INDICATORS established in the development plans of provisions of the the respective sector have been development plan of implemented. the respective sector 2. The Energy Conservation Target 2010 Programme for 2007- 2013 has been supplemented. RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, Ministry of the Environment, Credit and Export Guarantee Fund KredEx Measure 2.2. Improvement of the efficiency of the use of oil shale 50 BACKGROUND Production of electricity from oil shale shall be continued in the interests of OF THE energy security of Estonia, but this should be carried out in a more environment- MEASURE friendly way. More strict environmental requirements shall be applied gradually to oil-shale-fired power plants. In order to comply with the requirements, the plants shall invest in new technologies, the development of infrastructures and purification equipment. Granting of state aid to Narva Power Plants may be necessary for the construction of the equipment. The maximum annual capacity of oil shale extraction in Estonia provided in the National Development Plan for the Use of Oil Shale is 20 million tons with an objective to reduce it to 15 million tons. According to the trends of the Development Plan of the Electricity Sector, up to 10 million tons of oil shale is used annually for the production of oil shale electricity and shale oil for Estonia; this amount will decrease to a significant extent after the completion of a potential nuclear power station. In order to achieve this, the technologies of electricity production shall be modernised and the efficiency of the use of shale oil and gas upon the production of electricity shall be studied. Potential importing of electricity through new connections on an open electricity market would reduce significantly the need to use oil shale for the production of electricity; however, by using oil shale for wind power balancing production capacities may increase the share of oil shale. As for the oil shale ash generated upon the production of electricity from oil sale, the maximum possible recovery of the oil shale ash shall be ensured and the minimum environmental impact of depositing and environmental safety shall be ensured upon depositing. The amount of oil shale remaining from electricity production can be sold in accordance with the world market demand. The products produced from Estonian oil shale should be sold by maximising from both, the company and the state revenue resources by applying also new technologies. The experience of Estonia upon the production of shale oil and oil shale chemicals is of more and more interest on the world market, this knowledge shall also be sold. PERFORMANCE 1. The amount of oil shale used remains below 2020 INDICATORS the amount provided for in the Development Plan for the Use of Oil Shale (15 million tons by 2015). MOST - Setting out the extent and principles of granting state aid for the IMPORTANT construction of new units by the necessary contracts ACTIVITIES - Construction of two new fluidised bed combustion units - Installation of desulphurisation and denitrification systems - Implementation of the National Development Plan for the Use of Oil Shale for 2008–2015 - Increasing the recovery of oil shale ash 51 - Increasing the environmental safety of depositing of oil shale ash - Contributing to spreading knowledge concerning oil shale in the world Results and indicators Target value for 2020 or deadline OUTPUT 1. The principles and contracts of state aid have July 2010 INDICATORS been set out. 2. The new fluidised bed combustion units have 2015 been constructed. 3. Purification equipment has been installed in 2015 old units continuing operation. 4. The National Development Plan for the Use 2015 of Oil Shale has been implemented. 5. The share of the recovery of oil shale ash has 3 times higher increased (2007: 3.8% of the total amount) 6. Depositing of oil shale ash complies with the 2010 requirements RESPONSIBLE Narva Power Plants, Ministry of the Environment, Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications Measure 2.3 Development of energy technologies BACKGROUND The equipment used currently for the production of shale oil and gas have OF THE been developed before 1980, some equipment originate from 1930. As a MEASURE result of development work several new more efficient technical solutions have been developed, but large-scale production thereof has not been started yet. Also, post-treatment of oil shale products shall be developed with an objective to expand the areas of use thereof. The outdated technologies with big environmental impact shall be discarded after the application of the new solutions. In November 2007, the Government of the Republic approved the principles of the Energy Technology Programme. On 18 December 2008 the Government of the Republic approved the Energy Technology Programme updated by the programme committee. The priority areas of development set out in the programme are the following: 1. Development of oil shale technologies, including: • Environmentally sound extraction of oil shale without losses • Development of CO2 – free oil shale electricity production • Development of a gas turbine using shale oil and/or liquid biofuel for regulating electrical capacity • Development of new shale oil production technology • Development of combined shale oil and electricity production technology • Production of diesel fuel or the components thereof from oil shale • Development of the areas of application of the waste generated upon processing of oil shale – ash, mine waste • More efficient use of heat resource 52 • Verification of technologies in compliance with the EU scheme 2. Development of new technologies based mainly on renewable energy sources, including: • Solar energy • Fuel cells and electrolysers • Development and application of the production technology of second-generation biofuels • Development of electrical energy storage and wind power balancing technologies • Development of energy technologies based on the treatment of biomass and biodegradable waste • Development of the transmission and distribution networks and optimisation of the energy system The programme is managed by the programme manager, who coordinates the projects of the relevant sector with different implementing agencies. Arising from the need to create knowledge in the field of nuclear energy, the Energy Technology Programme shall also be supplemented with the corresponding activity. PERFORMANCE 1. Post-treatment of shale oil is functioning. 2016 INDICATORS MOST - Development of shale oil and chemicals post-treatment technologies IMPORTANT - Promotion of application of more efficient shale oil and gas production ACTIVITIES equipment - Carrying out projects of the programme of oil shale technologies and new technologies based mainly on renewable energy sources - Supplementing the Energy Technology Programme with the priority development trend of nuclear energy Results and indicators Target value for 2020 or deadline OUTPUT 1. The development of at least 3 new oil shale 2015 INDICATORS technologies has been supported61. 2. New equipment has been put into operation. 2012 3. The Energy Technology Programme Since 2009 achieves the objectives and interim objectives approved by the Government of the Republic. March 2009 4. The Energy Technology Programme has been supplemented with the nuclear energy trend. RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, Ministry of the Environment, Enterprise Estonia, universities, energy undertakings 61 Development trends in oil shale technologies, Estonian Energy Technology Programme http://www.hm.ee/index.php?03242 53 Measure 2.4 Preparation and implementation of the activity plan of renewable energy BACKGROUND Arising from the proposed Renewable Energy Directive, each Member State OF THE shall prepare a renewable energy activity plan, which shall set out activities MEASURE for the achievement of the objectives and interim objectives established by the Directive. The Member States are intended to update the plan also, if they fail to achieve the established interim objectives concerning renewable energy. This activity plan shall, among others, map the potential areas in Estonia for the production of renewable energy and provide guidelines for making use of the potential of renewable energy more effectively. By now the Development Plan for Enhancing the Use of Biomass and Bioenergy has been prepared, which directs the aspects of the production of bioresource. The principles of the use of liquid biofuels in transport are under discussion at the EU level. Taking into account the regulations concerning the liquid biofuels used in transport arising from the Renewable Energy Directive, the relevant sector shall be regulated also in Estonia. PERFORMANCE 1. Estonia has achieved all the objectives and Until 2020 INDICATORS interim objectives concerning renewable energy arising from the proposed Directive62 MOST - Initiation and preparation of the Renewable Energy Activity Plan IMPORTANT - Approval of the Renewable Energy Activity Plan ACTIVITIES Results and indicators Target value for 2020 or deadline OUTPUT 1. The Renewable Energy Activity Plan has April 2010 INDICATORS been prepared. 2. The Renewable Energy Activity Plan has July 2010 been approved. RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, Ministry of the Environment, Ministry of Agriculture Measure 2.5 Preparation and implementation of the national development plan of the heat sector BACKGROUND District heating is used widely in Estonia, at the same time several problems OF THE have arisen upon the development of market relations in this sector (the MEASURE issues of price coordination, the impact of the monopolistic character of the market, the impact of local governments on price formation, the indicators of efficiency, etc.). The relatively high dependency of district heating on natural gas (over 48% in 2006) and the substantial price increase of district heating arising from the prices of energy carriers causes the need to diversify energy sources. At the same time in several areas district heating undertakings are not able to make the required investments. The extent of the types of local heat production (heat pumps, local and imported energy sources) and the desired development trends shall be 62 Renewable Energy Directive http://ec.europa.eu/climateaction/key_documents/index_en.htm 54 defined more clearly in the development plan of the heat sector. PERFORMANCE 1. More balanced shares of energy sources upon The share of one INDICATORS the production of heat (2007: 46% natural gas). energy source does not exceed 30% (2020) MOST - Mapping and analysis of the problems of the district heating sector IMPORTANT - Initiation and preparation of the development plan of the heat sector ACTIVITIES - Amendment of the District Heating Act Results and indicators Target value for 2020 or deadline OUTPUT 1. Analysis has been completed, January 2010 INDICATORS 2. The development plan has been prepared and December 2011 approved. 3. Amendments to the District Heating Act September 2009 have been submitted to the Government of the Republic. RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, Ministry of the Interior, Ministry of the Environment, Estonian Competition Authority, Association of Estonian Cities, Association of Municipalities of Estonia, by involving interest groups Measure 2.6 Implementation of the new EU regulations concerning sustainable energy BACKGROUND Regulations for the provision of requirements for the eco-design and energy OF THE efficiency of several equipment are under preparation in the European MEASURE Union, upon the transposition of which the efficiency requirements shall be established for different equipment using energy. PERFORMANCE 1. Estonia complies with the efficiency 2020 INDICATORS requirements for different equipment using energy provided for in the EU regulations concerning eco-design and energy efficiency of equipment. MOST - Transposition of Directives and implementation of Regulations IMPORTANT - Analysis of the efficiency of the equipment used; if necessary, making ACTIVITIES amendments arising therefrom Results and indicators Target value for 2020 or deadline OUTPUT 1. The Directives have been transposed and the INDICATORS Regulations have been implemented by the due date. 2. The analysis has been completed; if July 2012 necessary, amendments arising therefrom have been made. RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications 55 2.3.3. Measures for ensuring justified energy price Objective 3 Energy supply at a justified price has been Baseline Target ensured for consumers Indicator 1 In 2015, the rate of return on investments of WACC= WACCEL energy undertakings (WACC of network 6.77 (2007) 2015 63 operators) is at the average level of similar EU undertakings. Indicator 2 The share of the energy sector in the GDP is 3% <3% below the level of 2005. (2005) 64 (2018) Measure 3.1 Elimination of competition deviations and market distortions on the energy market BACKGROUND Significant competition deviations and market distortions have occurred in OF THE several states upon the liberalisation of energy markets. As a result of the MEASURE deviations and distortions the markets are unjustly concentrated and some undertakings have become unjustly enriched. In order to ensure efficient operation of the market, open and transparent operation and efficient supervision of the energy market shall be ensured. PERFORMANCE 1. Decreasing number of interferences with 2020 INDICATORS competition related to undertakings of the 0 energy sector (2008: 1) MOST - Continuous analysis of the functioning of the energy market IMPORTANT - Amendment of legislation, if necessary ACTIVITIES Results and indicators Target value for 2020 or deadline OUTPUT 1. Analysis of the functioning of the energy annually INDICATORS market has been completed. 2. Amendments have been made to the as required legislation, if necessary. RESPONSIBLE Estonian Competition Authority, Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications Measure 3.2Development of optimal organisational arrangements for the development of the energy sector and emission trading BACKGROUND In Estonia, several different foundations are engaged in the development OF THE activities of the energy sector: Enterprise Estonia – EAS (Estonian Energy MEASURE Technology Programme), the Credit and Export Guarantee Fund KredEx (supporting projects of energy efficiency of buildings, energy audits), the 63 Reference: “Estonian Electricity and Gas Market Report 2008“, Estonian Competition Authority - WACC- weighed average cost of capital 64 Reference: Statistics Estonia 56 Environmental Investments Centre – EIC (supports for investments in the energy sector). An optimal organisational solution shall also be developed for the preparation of the auctioning system of emission allowances trading starting from 2013, the organisation of the auctions and for using part of the revenues received as a result of the auctions for granting state aid for energy consumers and producers. An operational solution shall be found for more effective and efficient fulfilment of the abovementioned tasks, taking, among others, into account the division of roles between the public sector and the private sector. Arising from this it shall be ensured that the local governments are regularly and effectively informed of the development trends of the national energy policy, of the functions of the local governments related to the national energy policy and the possibilities for effective implementation thereof. The main functions for the performance of which an optimal solution shall be found are the following: a. continuous detailed analysis of the trends of the energy sector; b. improvement of awareness concerning energy efficiency in the industry and services sectors and in the public sector, c. analysis of energy audits and implementation of the approved proposals arising therefrom; d. management of the energy technology programme; e. coordination of the national energy policy in cooperation with the county governments and local governments; f. organisation of emission allowances auctions from 2013; g. cooperation with energy agencies performing similar functions in other states and with the International Energy Agency; h. granting state aid to energy consumers and producers, if necessary. MOST - Development of alternative solutions of the organisational arrangements IMPORTANT of the tasks, selection of the optimal solution ACTIVITIES - If necessary, updating the legal framework required for introducing the optimal organisational solution, ensuring effective functioning of the solution - Development and implementation of the principles of emission allowances auctions and distribution of revenue Results and indicators Target value for 2020 or deadline OUTPUT 1. The most optimal solution has been selected January 2010 INDICATORS from the organisational arrangement solutions; the arising description of functions has been submitted to the Government of the Republic for approval in principle. 2. The organisational structural unit has been July 2010 established. 3. The principles of emission allowances 2012 auctions and distribution of revenue have been developed and implemented. 57 RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, Ministry of the Environment, Ministry of Finance Measure 3.3 Creation of knowledge in the field of nuclear energy and preparation and entry into force of the corresponding legislation BACKGROUND Nuclear power engineering as one of the economically most efficient OF THE potential options for covering the Estonian electricity demand after 2020 MEASURE presumes substantial political preliminary work at the state level, the development of the people who undergo the corresponding training and the establishment of the legal basis. Regardless of the decision concerning the construction of a nuclear power plant, legislation shall be established which would provide for the conditions and process of the construction of a nuclear power plant in Estonia and the establishment of the required structures, if necessary. The activities of the measure shall be planned in the framework of the Energy Technology Programme. PERFORMANCE 1. The legal basis for nuclear energy has been 2012 INDICATORS established. MOST - Establishing the speciality of nuclear power engineering in the power IMPORTANT engineering study programme ACTIVITIES - Mapping of the need for legislation in the field of nuclear energy - Preparation and submission of draft legal acts in the field of nuclear energy and/or amendments thereto to the Government of the Republic - Approval of the legal acts in the field of nuclear energy by the Riigikogu Results and indicators Target value for 2020 or deadline OUTPUT 1. The speciality of nuclear power engineering 2011 INDICATORS has been established in the study programmes of Estonian educational July 2009 institutions. 2. The need for legislation in the field of December 2010 nuclear energy has been mapped. 3. The draft legal acts in the field of nuclear energy and or motions to amend the legal 2012 acts have been prepared and submitted to the Government of the Republic. 4. The legal acts in the field of nuclear energy have been adopted. RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, Ministry of the Environment, Ministry of Social Affairs, Ministry of Education and Research, Ministry of the Interior, Ministry of Defence, Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Ministry of Justice Measure 3.4 Analysis of the alternatives of the taxation of the energy sector BACKGROUND Energy and environmental taxes have a significant impact on the OF THE development trends of the energy sector. The current principles of taxation 58 MEASURE shall be valid until the end of 2009. In connection with the application of the new principles of emission trading from 2013, the combined effect thereof with the valid taxation system shall be analysed. In order to finance the abovementioned analysis, it is planned to apply for financial resources from the Fund of Wise Decisions. PERFORMANCE 1. The principles of the combined effect of the 2011 INDICATORS emission trading and taxation system have been updated. MOST - Analysis of the combined effect of the new principles of emission IMPORTANT trading launched from 2013 and the existing taxation system ACTIVITIES - Preparation of the required amendments to legislation Results and indicators Target value for 2020 or deadline OUTPUT 1. Analysis of the combined effect of the new April 2011 INDICATORS principles of emission trading and the existing taxation system has been completed. 2. Motions to amend legal acts have been 2011 submitted to the Government of the Republic. RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, Ministry of Finance, Ministry of the Environment Measure 3.5 Promotion of education and research in the energy sector BACKGROUND The popularity of the field of power engineering has increased year by year, OF THE however, the present number of persons who complete vocational training, MEASURE Bachelor’s and Master’s study in this field is not sufficient to ensure the required number of employees in the energy sector. At the same time the state has not mapped clearly state commissioned education. Now state commissioned education can be provided for more clearly in the light of the trends of the development plans. The activities of the measure shall be planned within the framework of the Energy Technology Programme. PERFORMANCE 1. The number of persons who have completed 308 INDICATORS Master’s study in power engineering is twice (2015) as big in 2015 as in 2007 ( 2007: 154 faculty of power engineering at the Tallinn University of Technology + thermal power engineering at the Tallinn University of Technology + Estonian University of Life Sciences) MOST - Analysis of state commissioned education in the field of power IMPORTANT engineering ACTIVITIES - Preparation and provision of state commissioned education in the field of power engineering at the universities Results and indicators Target value for 2020 or deadline OUTPUT 1. Analysis has been completed. 2010 59 INDICATORS 2. State commissioned education has been 2011, hereafter formed and updated periodically. periodically RESPONSIBLE Ministry of Education and Research, Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications 60 3. Monitoring and Management of Implementation of the Development Plan The description of the management structure of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector has been prepared pursuant to Regulation No 302 of the Government of the Republic of 13 December 2005 “Types of Strategic Development Plans, the Procedure for Their Preparation, Amendment, Implementation and Evaluation and Reporting Procedure”. The Government of the Republic appointed the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications as a ministry responsible for the preparation of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector. The function of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications is to coordinate the preparation, amendment, implementation, evaluation and reporting of the Development Plan. Pursuant to subsection 12 (6) of the Sustainable Development Act, the Development Plan of the Energy Sector as an essential national issue is subject to approval in the Riigikogu. An implementing plan shall be appended to the Development Plan of the Energy Sector, which shall at first be prepared for the years 2009–2012 and which shall be submitted to the Government of the Republic by the Minister of Economic Affairs and Communications within three months after approval of the Development Plan by the Riigikogu. Pursuant to Regulation No 302 of the Government of the Republic, once a year the Minister of Economic Affairs and Communications shall submit to the Government of the Republic a report on the implementation of the Development Plan of the Energy Sector, the achievement of the objectives established in the development plan and implementing plan and the effectiveness of the application of the measures, according to which it shall be decided whether the development plan shall be supplemented or terminated. The Development Plan of the Energy Sector shall be implemented on the basis of a periodically updated implementing plan, which shall set out the specifics, the extent and organisational arrangements of the measures to be implemented at first by measures planned for the first four years. The Development Plan shall be implemented through the activities of the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications, the Ministry of the Environment, the Ministry of Social Affairs, the Ministry of Education and Research, the Ministry of Finance, the Ministry of the Interior, the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the Ministry of Justice, the Estonian Competition Authority, OÜ Põhivõrk, AS EG Võrguteenus, the Estonian Oil Stockpiling Agency and Narva Power Plants and in cooperation with the Association of Estonian Cities, the Association of Municipalities of Estonia, the National Audit Office of Estonia, the undertakings and interest groups. 3.1. Owner Policy of the State in the Energy Sector The owner policy of the state of Estonia in the energy sector shall ensure the protection of the interests of the state in strategic issues. The state shall consequently have control in the most important strategic undertakings. 61 Electricity sector Pursuant to the Electricity Market Act, ensuring electricity supply of the state is the function of the system operator (OÜ Põhivõrk). The right and obligation to control the operation of the power system and to ensure sufficient electricity production capacities, to organise competitions for the construction of new production capacities, if necessary, have been granted to and imposed on the system operator by legislation. The new draft Electricity Market Directive under preparation prescribes proprietary distinction of the system operator in order to ensure as high independence of the activity of the system operator as possible. The system operator shall treat all the market participants equally and honestly. Although the activity of OÜ Põhivõrk has been assessed as independent and transparent in various analyses, there is always an increased risk of influencing the decisions in the case of a system operator belonging to a group. Since the system operator belongs to the group of one market participant (Eesti Energia AS), independence is not always ensured, especially in a situation, where the group may be partially owned by private capital in future. Therefore it is rational to bring OÜ Põhivõrk from the group of Eesti Energia AS 100% into direct state ownership by 2010, by ensuring that the financial capability of the group will not deteriorate thereby. In order to ensure independence, it shall be ensured that there would be no conflict of interests at the level of the general meeting. Pursuant to the indicative schedule it is planned to bring OÜ Põhivõrk 100% into state ownership in 2010. Natural gas It is also important to ensure independence of the transmission network operator from the sellers on the natural gas market, although in the conditions of Estonia competition is significantly limited on this market. Competition on this market can be increased by the construction of terminals of liquefied natural gas and liquid gas. The draft amending the Natural Gas Directive under preparation prescribes proprietary distinction of the system operator as the main option. Therefore possibilities shall be sought also for the distinction of the proprietary relations of the natural gas system operator. In order to do that, different options for increasing the independence of the system operator shall be analysed. Heat sector The specificity of the Estonian district heating undertakings compared to other states is a relatively big share of private capital on the district heating market. As a rule, the contribution of private capital has been justified itself, but the total privatisation of the district heating sector has created private monopolies, which have started to protect strongly their positions without increasing efficiency. The most important problem of the heat sector is the dependence of the consumers on the investments made by the undertakings, which do not direct the undertakings to find cheaper solutions, but to protect their market from potential cheaper solutions. Legislation, which does 62 not give the undertakings an indication for seeking better solutions and through this for increasing the value of an undertaking, is definitely also a problem. In the district heating sector it is rational not to privatise the district heating undertakings totally, but to maintain the holding of the local governments in these undertakings. Fuel market On the liquid fuel market it is important to ensure the liquid fuel stocks in the case of difficulties of supply on the world market, complying thereby with the international regulations. The state shall maintain 100% ownership of the Estonian Oil Stockpiling Agency established for that purpose in order to have control over the existence and location of the stocks. On the oil shale market the options of the ownership of AS Eesti Põlevkivi shall be analysed. Most of the rights of oil shale extraction belong to AS Eesti Põlevkivi, but different undertakings, including the subsidiary undertakings of Eesti Energia AS who is 100% owner of AS Eesti Põlevkivi, are engaged in the processing. The ownership and structure of the undertaking shall ensure equal treatment of the consumers and the maximum revenue from the sales of the resource of the state as the owner of the resource. The resource policy of the state shall be analysed in order to ensure fair compensation to the state for the resource, decrease of the impact on the environment and economic development. The abovementioned analysis is planned within the framework of measure 3.3. upon analysing the alternatives of the taxation of the energy sector and the planned deadline for the completion of the analysis is 2012. 63 Annexes Annex 1. Summary of SWOT analyses The existence of the stocks of domestic fuels (oil shale, peat and wood), the share of which has remained around 65% in the primary energy resources during the last decade, has provided security upon supplying with energy. One third of the primary energy resources was formed by imported fuels, from which natural gas imported from Russia and diesel fuel imported from Lithuania and Russia formed the biggest share. 90.2% of electricity was produced from oil shale, 5.6% from natural gas and other energy sources in 2006. Thus, upon the production of electricity Estonia is independent from the import of fuel; it is possible to cover the total electricity supply by the domestic fuels and energy sources, if necessary. Estonia has a sufficiently developed natural gas infrastructure. Estonia has the total of three connections: from Narva and Värska to Russia and from Karksi to Latvia with the total capacity 11,000 thousand m3 in a twenty-four hour period. The gas transmission system has sufficient transmission capacity in Estonia and there will be no shortage of transmission capacity until 2015. The Estonian energy market is small and the electricity and gas supply systems do not have interconnections with the other Member States of the European Union. Estonian gas market is in essence under the control of one undertaking - AS Eesti Gaas. In addition to the network operators belonging to the group of AS Eesti Gaas, there are 30 smaller network operators, who, however, buy gas from AS Eesti Gaas; electricity production is controlled by the biggest energy undertaking Eesti Energia AS, who owns 96% of the installed capacities and who produced 95.3% of the electricity in 2006. The amount of energy consumed for the heating, ventilation, cooling, lighting of residential buildings and supply thereof with hot water is remarkable. Although reconstruction has become more active, undertakings invest more and more in new production equipment and new cars and buses are also procured, there is no statistical information or analysis which would confirm the improvement of energy efficiency as a result of the investments. The transport infrastructure servicing the transit of liquid fuels has been rather well developed in Estonia. In intense competition the logistics and transportation companies have raised the service quality to the level competing with Finland. The Association of Port Operators encompasses the majority of Estonian transit companies. The weakness of the transit sector is the one-sidedness of the goods in transit – crude oil and petroleum products dominate. Such a transit has a very high risk, since it depends to a great part on the economic policy decisions of the Russian authorities. Transportation of large amounts of crude oil poses a great danger also to the environment and the security of the residents. The main function of the Estonian Oil Stockpiling Agency (OSPA) is to establish and manage the 90 days’ liquid fuel stocks of the Republic of Estonia. The establishment of the security stockpile has not been completed yet, thus, causing potential vulnerability in the case of supply disruptions. The strength of the Estonian energy sector lies in the functioning legal environment and market supervision. The Estonian Competition Authority operates as the energy market regulator, whose function is to exercise state supervision over compliance with the requirements arising from legislation regulating the areas of activity of the Authority and in case of violation of these requirements, to apply enforcement powers of the state. Annex 2. Objectives of the national development plans and strategies related to the energy sector Development Objective Measure and activities Indicator plan Development 1. Continuous supply of 1.1. Construction of peak and 1. The ratio of the available Plan of the electricity is ensured for emergency reserve capacities net capacity of power plants Estonian consumers located in Estonia following a competition to the maximum net Electricity Sector organised by the system consumption of electricity until 2018 operator during a winter period 1.2. Promotion of the (October-March) exceeds construction of power 110%, but does not exceed production capacities in Estonia 140%. conforming to the trends of the 2. The annual average Development Plan, granting of duration of the power cuts state aid for that purpose, if caused by the failures at the necessary place of consumption 1.3. Creation of preconditions indicates a decreasing trend. for the construction of new 3. By 2018 the total capacity international connections of the power connections 1.4. Analysis and development between the Baltic States and of the quality requirements for the European Union will network services, improvement form at least 80% of the of the quality of network connection capacities services between the Baltic States and 1.5. Ensuring electricity supply third countries. for all interested persons 2. Power supply and 2.1. Supporting sustainable 1. The share of renewable consumption of the consumers methods of electricity electricity in gross located in Estonia has become production consumption is increasing more sustainable 2.2. Updating of legislation with and will reach at least 5.1% an aim to enhance the efficiency by 2010 and at least 15% by of electricity undertakings 2015. 2.3. Implementation of 2. The share of cogeneration innovative power network electricity will be least 20% solutions of the gross consumption in 2.4. Raising of awareness of 2020. saving electricity 3. The share of power transmission losses below 3%, the share of distribution losses below 7%, below 6% from 2015 4. Electricity consumption per capita in households does not exceed the average level in the European Union. 5. The amount of atmospheric emissions of CO2 does not exceed 5 million tons in 2020. 6. Decrease of the share of oil shale electricity in the gross production of electricity 65 Development Objective Measure and activities Indicator plan 3. Power supply at a justified 3.1. Opening of the electricity 1. 35% of the electricity price has been ensured for market, establishment of power market opened in 2009, fully consumers located in Estonia. exchange opened in 2013 at the latest 3.2. Development of honest 2. The market share of one competition rules and ensuring electricity seller in the that the competition rules are common market area does complied with not exceed 40% in 2018. 3.3 Taking external costs gradually into account in the price of electricity in the framework of the ecological tax reform 3.4. Analysis of the effectiveness of support schemes for renewable and cogeneration electricity, correction thereof, if necessary 3.5. Preparation and entry into force of legislation concerning nuclear power plants National 1. To ensure supply of Estonia 1.1. Defining the interest of the Development with oil shale energy and to state and changing the terms Plan for the Use guarantee the energetic and conditions for issuing of Oil Shale for independence of Estonia extraction permits 2008–2015 1.2. Implementation of legal (draft) regulations for the reduction of the use of oil shale 1.3. Ensuring sustainability of the use of oil shale 2. To increase the efficiency of 2.1. Optimisation of the The upper limit of oil shale the use and extraction of oil extraction capacity excavation up to 15 million shale 2.2.Promotion of applied t/y – deadline 2015 research and product development in the field of oil shale 2.3. Reviewing the principles of the environmental charges of oil shale extraction and use 2.4. Promotion of education and research Activity: ordering of analysis required for strategic planning of the energy sector and the electricity sector (finding and using alterative energy sources for ensuring sufficient production capacity in order to reduce the share of oil shale). 66 Development Objective Measure and activities Indicator plan Development Primary objective: to create 1. The share of district heat Plan for favourable conditions for the produced from renewable Enhancing the development of the production sources in the total produced Use of Biomass of domestic biomass and district heat is 33% (2013) and Bioenergy bioenergy in order to decrease 2. The share of biofuels in for 2007–2013 the dependence of Estonia on consumption is 6% (2013) imported resources and fossil 3. The share of electricity fuels and to reduce pressure on produced in biomass-based the natural environment by cogeneration regime in using the earth resources domestic electricity effectively and sustainably and consumption is 3% (2013) to promote employment in rural areas Objective 3: to ensure 3.9. Imposition of obligations The measure will be implementation of the Activity: the impact of imposing implemented starting from instruments required for the mandatory proportion of 2008, if suitable. market organisation transport biofuels on the fuel market will be analysed Energy 1. To make the information 1.1. Counselling of local The share of class A Conservation concerning the saving of fuels governments upon planning the appliances realized on the Target and energy more accessible for development of the energy market of electrical Programme for and usable by energy sector and the related sectors equipment and light bulbs 2007- 2013 consumers, organisers of the 1.2. Mapping of the need for (the estimated share in 2006 - energy sector and energy counselling of undertakings in 50%, target for 2013 – at undertakings and to make the the field of energy conservation least 75%) consumers prefer sustainable and counselling of the equipment undertakings 1.3. Development of new methods for dissemination of information in the field of energy conservation 1.4. Popularisation of consumption solutions and equipment which promote energy conservation 2.To ensure that lifelong 2.1.Providing in-service training The number of non- education in the field of energy courses in the field of energy governmental organisations conservation is provided to conservation for specialists providing training in the field specialists engaged in the 2.2. Analysis of technical of energy conservation issues concerning the solutions contributing to (the estimated number in operation of buildings and rational use of fuels and energy 2006 - 3, target in 2013 – at facilities and to increase the 2.3. Development of the least 6) number of non-governmental provision of energy services organisations providing training in energy conservation 67 Development Objective Measure and activities Indicator plan 3. To improve possibilities for 3.1. Imposing energy Investments made in the financing investments directed conservation obligation on projects directed at saving at saving fuels and energy and energy undertakings fuels and energy as a result to support projects directed at 3.2. Stimulation of raising of of the measures applied by saving fuels and energy initial capital required for the state during the period investments and development of 2007-2013 (total: 1.5 billion loan products directed thereat kroons) 3.3. Improvement of efficiency upon the production and transmission of energy 3.4. Supporting small-scale projects of local governments directed at energy conservation 3.5. Increasing the quality and energy conservation of the housing stock 4. To ensure transposition of 4.1. Transposition of the Number of infringement and assessment of the Directives 2002/91/EC, proceedings concerning efficiency of the 2005/32/EC and 2006/32/EC legislation on energy implementation of the EU 4.2. Supporting implementation conservation initiated by the Directives on saving fuels and of the Commission Action Plan European Commission and in energy for Energy Efficiency force with respect to Estonia COM(2006)545 (1 in 2007, target 0 in 2010) 4.3. International cooperation upon improvement of the efficiency of energy use Transport 5. To minimise the adverse 5.1. Application of the principle 1. The share of internalised Development effect of the transport sector on of internalisation of external external costs 75% Plan for 2006– the environment and health costs 2. The share of new 2013 5.2. Stimulation of the use of passenger cars with CO2 environment-friendly emission below 120 mg/km technologies among the cars entered in the 5.3. Prevention and mitigation register in Estonia has of the consequences of the increased to 30% adverse impact caused by 3. The share of heavy goods transport vehicles complying with Euro 3 standard among the total amount of heavy goods vehicles has increased to 50% by 2013 4.Decrease of the impact of environmental emergencies by 20% by 2013 5. Decrease of the number of people living in areas with the daily noise level exceeding 55 dB by 20% by 2013 as a result of noise mitigation measures 6. 20% increase of satisfaction with the prevention and elimination of adverse effects on the environment 68 Development Objective Measure and activities Indicator plan Estonian 5.3.1. To produce electricity in 1.1. Assessment of the 1. The amount of greenhouse Environmental an amount, which satisfies the availability of existing energy gases emitted in the course of Strategy until consumption needs in Estonia, resources and energy production (absolute 2030 and to develop versatile, preparation of long-term plans value) ↔ – the absolute sustainable production for their utilisation value of greenhouse gas technologies based on different 1.2. Drafting and emissions remains on the energy sources and with little supplementation of legislation level of the year 2005. environmental load, which concerning ambient 2. Emissions of air pollutants enable to produce electricity air protection and development (SO2, NOX, PMX, VOC, also for export of an ambient air monitoring heavy metals) system in the course of energy 1.3. Supporting of research and production – the amounts of development activities and pilot emissions are reduced at least projects related to new energy to a level that conforms to production methods EU requirements (tons per 1.4. Modernisation of existing year) ↓ production basis to bring it into 3. The relative share of conformity to environmental various fuel types in energy requirements (incl. electricity) 1.5. Introduction of renewable production (%): and other alternative energy – by 2015 the relative share sources of oil shale in the production of electricity amounts to less than 90%; - by 2015 the relative share of electricity produced on the basis of renewable energy sources and consumed in Estonia will increase to at least 8%; - by 2020 the relative share of electricity produced in combined heat and power plants and consumed in Estonia will increase to at least 20%. 69 Development Objective Measure and activities Indicator plan 5.3.2 To slow down and 2.1. Drawing up and 1. Intensity of energy stabilise the consumption of implementation of regulations consumption (thousand energy, while ensuring that the and support schemes to enhance toe/EEK million)↓, base level needs of people are met, i.e. to energy conservation and 0.03 thousand toe/EEK ensure the preservation of the manage the consumption of million volume of primary energy energy, incl. development in 2. Fuel prices (EEK/ton or while consumption grows compliance with the EEK/m3) ↔ legislation of the European 3. Prices of electricity Union (EEK/MWh) ↔, base level 2.2. Supporting research and EEK 765/MWh development activities and pilot 4. Fuel and energy losses projects related to the (TJ) ↓ optimisation of energy systems 5. Energy consumption per 2.3. Upgrading of energy unit of GDP (considering the systems to reduce power and purchasing power parity) – heat losses primary energy consumption 2.4. Increasing the awareness of volume will remain at the energy conservation level of the year 2003 until 2.5. Integration of energy 2010. Base level in 2003: conservation in other sectors, 20.0 TJ per PPP. including analysis of the impact of current legislation underlying the grant of state benefits Estonian 2. To develop high quality and 2.1. Increasing the quality and Result by 2013: the share of Housing sustainable housing stock energy efficiency of the housing apartment buildings falling Development stock into the highest energy Plan for 2008– efficiency category is 10 % 2013 Estonian Action Sub-objective 3: to increase 3.1. Improving availability of 1. Electricity losses from Plan for energy efficiency information in the field of the network and from Economic energy saving and ensuring company equipment. Growth and energy saving skills and Electricity losses as a ratio to Employment for expertise (2008–2013) gross production ((i.e. 2008- 2011 3.2. Supporting evaluation of including auxiliary energy of construction works and energy the power plant) – the auditing and renovation and estimated level 9% by 2011 reconstruction directed at (2006: 11.07%) energy saving of apartment 2. Energy intensity of the buildings built before 1990 economy 3.3. Drawing up legislation for The ratio of primary energy the application of the energy supply to GDP – 0.842 conservation requirements for toe/MEUR i.e. -13% energy undertakings (2008– compared to 2006 (2006: 2009) 0.967 toe/MEUR) 3.4. Supporting investments in 3. Energy saved by the renovation of heating implementing energy pipelines of district heating conservation measures in Estonia networks (2008–2013) Energy saved by energy 3.5. Drawing up guidelines for conservation measures environment-friendly public implemented by the initiative procurements (2008–2011) of the public and private sector in TJ – energy savings by implementing planned energy conservation 70 Development Objective Measure and activities Indicator plan measures: 1000 TJ (2007: savings: 5TJ) 71 Annex 3. Relations between future and prepared development plans directing the energy sector Sustainable Development Act NATIONAL DEVELOPMENT PLAN OF THE ENERGY SECTOR UNTIL 2020 Development National Development Energy Development National Plan of the Developme Plan for Conservation Plan for Development Estonian nt Plan for Enhancing Target Renewable Plan of the Electricity the Use of the Use of Programme for Energy Heat Sector Sector until Oil Shale Biomass and Estonia for 2018 for 2007– Bioenergy for 2007–201 2015 2007–2013 72 Saatja: MKM info <[email protected]> Saadetud: 29.05.2020 08:24 Adressaat: MKM info <[email protected]> Teema: FW: Documentation Request #2 From: Irje Möldre Sent: Thursday, May 28, 2020 6:23 PMTo: MKM info <[email protected]>Subject: ED: Documentation Request #2 ________________________________ Saatja: Irje MöldreSaadetud: 28. mai 2020 18:18Adressaat: Teema: FW: Documentation Request #2 Dear Marja Helena Sivonen! Please forgive us delay of answering and find documents asked in the attachment. Development plan up to 2030 is available in English Our final NECP could be found here ec.europa.eu National energy and climate plans (NECPs) Please contact in the future regarding further questions and energy issues with workers of Energy Department . With very best regards Irje Möldre Energy Department Ministry of Economic Affairs and Communications From: Sivonen Marja <> Sent: Thursday, May 14, 2020 10:02 AMTo: Laura Viilup <>Subject: Documentation Request #2 Dear Ms. Viilup, I approached you earlier this spring regarding locating couple of Estonian Government Strategy documents. Once again I want to thank you for your help locating the documents and referring to a contact for more information. However, I have not received any reply from Ms. Reisner. Now I kindly ask if you have any knowledge of English versions available of these two documents of the Estonian Government and if they would have publication dates: * * Thank you in advance. Best regards, Marja Helena Sivonen Researcher Climate Change Programme Finnish Environment Institute (SYKE) Address: Latokartanonkaari 11, 00790 Helsinki, Finland Email: Tel. +358 50 531 7292 Other affiliations: PhD Candidate, Tampere research group for Cultural and Political Sociology (TCuPS), Tampere University
Allikas: Majandus- ja Kommunikatsiooniministeerium dokumendiregister →
dokumendiregister.eeAsutusedEesti avalike dokumendiregistrite otsing · nimistu.ee andmetel