Ref. Ares(2021)6873401 - 09/11/2021
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
DIRECTORATES-GENERAL
EMPLOYMENT, SOCIAL AFFAIRS AND INCLUSION
REGIONAL AND URBAN POLICY
Joint Audit Directorate for Cohesion – DAC -The Director
Brussels
EMPL.REGIO.DAC.5/LB/bjd (2021) 7173923
Sent by email only
Subject: Annual coordination meeting between Commission services and the
audit authority of Estonia for ESIF1 co-financed programmes for the
year 2021
Dear Mr Siruli, Ms Krieger,
Please find attached the final minutes of the meeting held on 21 September 2021 at 10:00
by a video-conference.
Thank you for the cooperation demonstrated by your services during this meeting.
Yours faithfully,
Electronically signed
Franck Sébert
1
Corresponds to all European Structural and Investment Funds except the European Agricultural Fund for
Rural Development (EAFRD).
Mr Kaur Siruli
Audit authority
Financial Control Department
Ministry of Finance
[email protected]
Commission européenne/Europese Commissie, 1049 Bruxelles/Brussel, BELGIQUE/BELGIË - Tel. +32 22991111
Contacts: L. Bumeistere, DG EMPL.REGIO DAC.5
Enclosure: Final minutes
c.c.: D. Correia, Director, DG MARE E
A. Mathison, DG MARE E.1
C. De Buggenoms, Head of Unit DAC.5
A. Martinez Sarasola, DG REGIO D5
M. Guin, DG EMPL D5
C. Arwidi, Head of Unit OLAF C.1
2
Electronically signed on 08/11/2021 19:37 (UTC+01) in accordance with article 11 of Commission Decision C(2020) 4482
Ref. Ares(2021)6873401 - 09/11/2021
EUROPEAN COMMISSION
DIRECTORATES-GENERAL
EMPLOYMENT, SOCIAL AFFAIRS AND INCLUSION
REGIONAL AND URBAN POLICY
Joint Audit Directorate for Cohesion – DAC – The Director
MINUTES OF BILATERAL CO-ORDINATION MEETING BETWEEN THE COMMISSION SERVICES
AND ESTONIAN AUDIT AUTHORITY FOR ESIF PROGRAMMES,
HELD ON 21 SEPTEMBER 2021 BY VIDEO-CONFERENCE
PARTICIPANTS:
FOR THE ESTONIAN AUDIT AUTHORITIES
Ministry of Finance: Mr Kaur SIRULI, Head of Audit Authority
Ms Anu ALBER
Ms Kaisa KALLAS
Mr Mart PECHTER
Ministry of Rural Affaires: Ms Triin VILJASAAR, Principal Auditor, Internal Audit
Ms Margit KRIEGER, Head of Department, Internal Audit
FOR THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION
DAC: Ms Cendrine de BUGGENOMS, Head of Unit DAC.5
Mr Peter MATTHIJS, Team Leader DAC.5
Ms Linda BUMEISTERE, Auditor DAC.5
Mr Dimosthenis KANAKIDIS, Auditor DAC.5
DG EMPL: Ms Riin SALUVEER, Programme Manager EMPL.D.5
Ms Katriin TRALLA, Programme Assistant EMPL.D.5
DG REGIO: Mr Renaldo MANDMETS, Programme Manager REGIO.D.
Mr Edijs OSTROVSKIS, Programme Assistant REGIO.D.5
DG MARE: Mr Ivan BALAREV, Auditor MARE.E.1.002
OLAF Mr Alessandro ANGELINI, OLAF.C.1
Commission européenne/Europese Commissie, 1049 Bruxelles/Brussel, BELGIQUE/BELGIË - Tel. +32 22991111
OPENING OF THE MEETING
The video-conference meeting was chaired by Ms Cendrine de Buggenoms (DAC) who
welcomed the participants and presented the agenda for the meeting. The minutes of the previous
bilateral meeting, held on 22 September 2020 as video-conference, with reference
Ares(2021)3153487 – 11/05/2021 were formally approved.
Ms Cendrine De Buggenoms introduced herself as the new Head of DAC.5 audit unit and Ms
Linda Bumeistere and Mr Dimosthenis Kanakidis as responsible auditors.
1. PERIOD 2021-2027
1.1. Planned changes in the management and control system
The AA indicated that no significant changes in the MCS from the current period are planned.
The draft law will be adopted in the spring of 2022 and the start of the implementation of the
programme is also delayed to mid-2022. Same authorities (MA, AA, CA) will remain, some of
the implementing bodies are to be further merged. Same authorities will oversee the RRF as well.
Additional staff for the AA is not yet planned, however, outsourcing is considered (man-hours
rather than audits).
The MCS for EMFF OP will remain the same as in 2014-2020, possibly the CA might be merged
with the MA (as a separate division).
1.2. SCO schemes under Art. 95 new-CPR
As per the draft programme, not many new SCO’s are foreseen for the 2021-2027 period. The
AA will perform their assessment, if it will be necessary.
A system audit on SCO’s will be performed next year for the EMFF OP. Probably the OP for
the 2021-2027 period will be sent to the Commission second half of 2022.
1.3. Enhanced proportionate control arrangements, Article 83, 84 new- CPR
Ms de Buggenoms informed the AA that for the purposes of the use of enhanced proportionate
control arrangements the Commission performs an assessment of the management and control
systems and its confirmation of the total error rate of its published annual activities report 2020
for the last two accounting years. The assessment is still ongoing and will take into account the
results of the Commission compliance audit mission foreseen for next year.
2. PERIOD 2014-2020
2.1. Assurance packages 2014-2020: feedback from the assessment of the last assurance
package and follow-up to Commission’s audits
i. Audit opinions and state of play of pending issues / Form and content of the annual
control report(s), EC recalculation of TER/RTER and reasons for non-detection (if
needed)
For the Cohesion Policy Funding OP 2014EE16M3OP001, the assessment of the assurance
package 2019-2020 was closed with no observations or comments. The reported TER was 0.75%
and RTER was 0.67%.
2
The Estonian authorities are actively using art.137.2 for withdrawals for ongoing assessments.
The subsequent corrections and re-declaration of expenditure are closely followed-up from the
side of MA, CA and also AA. During the audits of accounts the AA checks the follow-ups done
by the CA and the last system audit of the CA was Cat 1, with a recommendation to describe
their procedures more thoroughly. For the Commission services, it is difficult to obtain assurance
that all necessary corrections have been implemented. It is foreseen to review this process in
DAC.5’s Compliance audit foreseen for next year.
For FEAD OP 2014EE05FMOP001, the assurance package was assessed and accepted without
follow-up needed. There were no issues to be discussed.
For the EMFF OP, the Assurance package was assessed and accepted with no follow-up needed.
There were no issues to be discussed.
ii. Typology of project findings and follow-up of the actions taken
Mr Peter Matthijs presented the typology of errors reported by the AAs for the 2019/2020
accounting year, comparing all MS together and for the Estonian programme separately. For the
Estonian programme, the main types of irregularities are related to deficiencies in Public
Procurement Procedures: 6 of the 10 findings and 94% of the amount of irregularities.
Irregularities in public procurement procedures dominate the Estonian numbers but their
financial impact is still well below the materiality threshold. It was also noted that the numbers
are not comparable with the statistics of other MS due to a very low number of irregularities
detected in Estonia.
Commission services committed to send the statistics of typology of project findings for all MS
and Estonia with the minutes of the meeting.
Ms Cendrine de Buggenoms enquired whether there are any findings related to the conflict of
interest. The AA indicated that such findings are not common, but it can depend on the market.
Overall only for procurements with very high values companies from other countries show
interest to participate.
2.2. National audit strategies 2014-2020
The AA provided the updated national audit strategies (version September 2021) in advance of
the Annual Coordination Meeting (ACM).
For the Cohesion Policy OP (2014EE16M3OP001), the modifications to last year’s Audit
Strategy are limited. For the sample of audits of operations - one common sample for ERDF/CF
and ESF is drawn, but with stratification per Fund (30 units for ERDF/CF; 12 units per ESF).
The AA clarified the revised phrasing in the audit strategy, that “if the declared expenditure
includes a payment to a financial instrument, it is separated from the population and audited
outside the statistical sample”. The AA confirmed that in such case, expenditure of Financial
Instruments would be audited as part of a separate stratum of the statistical sample, with the
results integrated into the overall TER.
It was also clarified that the increase in planned man-days is explained by a correction from the
last year’s actuals and not an increase in staff numbers.
For the EMFF OP, the AA has transmitted an update of the Audit Strategy by mail of 17
September 2021 which did not raise comments from DG MARE
3
i. State of play of implementation of the national audit strategies: Impact of COVID-
19, ongoing audits of operations and system audits changes to the national audit
strategies
The AA delivered a brief presentation on the state of implementation of the audit strategy, audit
plan and the results of the system audits and the sample of audits of operations.
Cohesion Policy Funding OP 2014EE16M3OP001
National system audits
For the Cohesion Policy OP (2014EE16M3OP001) there are three ongoing system audits:
- System audit on CSSS as 2nd level IB, report is being drafted.
- System audit on EIC as 2nd level IB, findings are being drafted.
- Audit of Structural Assistance Register, to assess the compliance of the SFOS with the
requirements set out in legislation and the efficiency of the SFOS development process (KR
6). Findings are in drafting process.
Ongoing audits from previous periods:
- Audit on fraud prevention measures, the report is in drafting stage, and no major issues have
been identified.
- System audit on FEI implementation in 1st and 2nd level IBs: audit was interrupted and is
expected to be discontinued due to rearrangements of loans and grants following the COVID-
19 context and the foreseen merger of Enterprise Estonia and the KredEx Foundation.
In addition 2 analyses were performed - Analysis of the actual results of the audited projects and
Analysis of public procurements related to the COVID crisis. No significant issues have been
identified.
System audit work planned:
- System audit on Enterprise Estonia as 2nd level IB (after merger with KredEx Foundation),
- Audit of the risk management process in MA,
- Various horizontal audits (project selection, double financing risk, set-up of financial
instruments) related to the 2021-27 implementation period.
Audits of operations: for the accounting year 2020-2021, the statistical sample comprises 30
ERDF/CF units and 12 ESF units (unit is payment claim). In addition, the one payment to a
financial instrument will be audited in a separate stratum. At present, 7 audits are finalized, 20
audits are ongoing. No outsourcing of audits of operations has been done this year. So far no
major findings reported. In principle the due-date for finalizing the audits is 31/01/2022. The AA
indicated that on-the-spot audits have restarted after some of the COVID-19 pandemic related
restrictions have been lifted in Estonia.
For the EMFF OP, no system audits will be carried out for this period, as the AA has covered
all KRs in their work. The follow-up of the open recommendations will continue.
For the FEAD programme 2014EE05MOP001, the AA will undertake one system audit
including testing of sample of operations, in November 2021.
4
For the ETC programme Interreg V-A — Estonia–Latvia 2014TC16RFCB050: The AA
indicated that a system audit on the functioning of the Joint Secretary is ongoing. The audit is
focusing on the delegated functions of MA: how MA makes the sample for the on-the-spot
checks, how the annual summary is compiled, MA’s cooperation and monitoring of JS in general
(KR 1,3,4 and 8).
For the audits of operations, a non-statistical sample of 4 operations has been drawn in April
2021, with 1 High Value item. This sample covers 32.34% of total expenditure and 8.7% of
operations. So far, at the Estonian side, 3 audits have been finalised, with no ineligible
expenditure detected, and audit one is ongoing. At Latvian side, 2 audits are finalized and 2 are
being carried. The coordination and cooperation with the Latvian auditors in the Group of
Auditors (GoA) is working well.
ii. Risks related to additional/new funding (e.g. double funding) and sufficient AA’s staff
resources with regard to REACT EU, BAR, RRF, etc.
The AA will be responsible for additional and new funding as indicated above, these will be
treated the same as other funds. Workload and respective staffing needs will be assessed further
next year.
iii. Sampling method applied
For the Cohesion Policy OP (2014EE16M3OP001), taking into account the Commission’s
communications in April 2021, the AA decided to change the sampling method back to MUS
stratified (ERDF/CF and ESF as separate stratums). Separate samples for each stratum i.e. Fund
will be covered (30 for ERDF/CF + 1 for FEI; 12 for ESF). This allows to fully take into account
all audits of operations for the TER (no complementary sample for ESF).
iv. Audits on performance indicators, in particular the verification of aggregation of
data.
The AA confirmed that audits of operations also verify reliability of performance indicators. The
AA does not foresee a separate system audit on the aggregation of these data, considering the
audit work already available on performance indicators.
v. Audit work to be performed with regard to SCOs
The AA performed a national system audit on the MCS for the implementation of simplified cost
reimbursements: (JKS 37-2020). Report was submitted to the Commission in March 2021 with
Cat.2 conclusion and it was accepted by EC without further comments.
The AA committed to send the Commission services a detailed summary on the currently
existing SCO’s in Estonia.
2.3. Outline of Commission audit strategy
Ms Cendrine de Buggenoms presented the DAC.5 audit unit and informed on the Commissions
audit plan that foresees a compliance audit to be performed in the Q1 of 2022, covering
ERDF/CF and ESF.
DG MARE indicated that an audit on FEI is possible in the Q1 2022, but the audit plan for next
year has not been adopted yet.
5
With regard to article 148.2 of CPR, the Commission auditors informed the AA that there is no
intention to apply this article.
2.4. FEAD specific issues
EUCoJ pre-judical ruling dd. 20 May 2021 regarding a conflict between Ministry of Social
Affairs and shared services centre for the State (MA), formerly Innove SA, on the
implementation of a financial correction was discussed. After the meeting the Commission
auditors were informed that the judgement of Tallinn Court of Appeal was released on 24
September 2021. It was confirmed that the Tallin Court of Appeal follows the pre-judical ruling
of the EUCoJ, which made it clear that the contracting authority was not entitled to impose a
requirement for national recognition. No further impact on expenditure declared to the EC as the
10% correction has already been applied.
2.5. ETC/ENI specific issues
Interreg V-A — Estonia–Latvia 2014TC16RFCB050
For last year’s ACR, DG REGIO completed the assessment with no follow-up. Previous
assurance package (2018-2019) was closed with a final position letter on 23/12/2020
(Ares(2020)7891124).
Estonia –Russia Cross-Border Cooperation (CBC) Programme 2014–2020
The AA briefly presented the state of play for this programme co-financed under the European
Neighbourhood Instrument (ENI). ENI-CBC programmes have been moved from DG NEAR to
DG REGIO as from beginning of 2020 onwards.
The Annual Audit Report for 2020 was assessed by the Commission and a letter with 2 comments
was sent. Reply by the AA has been sent on 02/07/2021.
For this year’s sampling, a non-statistical random sample of 2 operations has been drawn,
ensuring a coverage of 10.7% of costs and 8.3 % of operations 2 out of 24). Additionally, out of
two high value items, one has been randomly drawn for auditing. One system audit is ongoing
for the practice and reliability of the programme output indicators.
3. FRAUD PREVENTION AND FRAUD AWARENESS RAISING
The OLAF representative delivered a presentation on the “Potential risks in funding Health
Infrastructure”.
The Commission services committed to send the presentation with the minutes of the meeting
with a disclaimer that it is not to be distributed further or made public.
4. ANY OTHER BUSINESS
Neither party presented other points to discuss in this ACM.
To follow-up: the AA to provide an overview of SCOs (new period and 2014-2020).
Electronically signed on 08/11/2021 19:37 (UTC+01) in accordance with article 11 of Commission Decision C(2020) 4482
6
Saatja: EC DAC5 SECRETARIAT <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 09.11.2021 11:11
Adressaat: RAM Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: Meeting minutes of the Annual coordination meeting between
Commission services and the AA of Estonia for ESIF co-financed programmes
for the year 2021 - Ares(2021)6873401
Manused: 2021 ACM EE Cover Letter for Final Minutes.pdf; 2021 ACM EE
final minutes.pdf
Please find attached document Ares(2021)6873401 from Franck SEBERT (DAC)
dated 09/11/2021.
Please note that no paper copy will follow.
For any questions/comments, please send an email to:
[email protected]
Best regards,
Unit DAC5
DAC – Joint Audit Directorate for Cohesion policy
DG Employment, Social Affairs and Inclusion DG Regional and Urban Policy