Cross-Border Cooperation Programme
Estonia-Russia
2014-2020
Project No: ER126
Project name: Joint actions for improving local rescue fire
services to protect forests and settlements
in EE-RU border area
Project acronym: LOCAL FIRE
Project Partner Name (LP/PP): Alutaguse Municipality Government (Project
Partner)
Thematic objective: TO 6: Environmental protection, climate
change mitigation and adaptation
Audit No: EVP-5/2021
Audited organization: Alutaguse Municipality Government
Final audit report
25/11/2021
SUMMARY OF AUDIT RESULTS
Audit outcome:
Based on the audit work performed, the auditor has obtained reasonable assurance that the expenditure
declared is generally legal and regular and in compliance with the programme rules.
However, the auditor has made one finding concerning costs incurred outside the project
implementation period.
Audit opinion1: Significant findings.
➢ Finding No 1: The project partner has reported costs that have been incurred outside the
implementation period of the project. Total ineligible costs are €1065.00.
The project audit has been carried out in compliance with the International Standards for the Professional Practice
of Internal Auditing.
We wish to thank the auditee for the assistance and cooperation provided during the audit.
We confirm that the final audit report consists of seven (7) pages.
1
Significant findings are those that have or may have a financial impact (i.e., ineligible expenditure). Non-significant findings are those that have no financial
impact. However, their correction will help the beneficiary to lower risks while implementing the project.
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SUMMARY OF AUDIT RESULTS .............................................................................................................................. 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS ............................................................................................................................................ 3
PART A .................................................................................................................................................................. 4
1. AUDIT OBJECT AND AUDITED EXPENSES ..................................................................................................... 4
2. LIMITATIONS ......................................................................................................................................... 5
PART B .................................................................................................................................................................. 6
AUDIT FINDINGS ...................................................................................................................................... 6
3
PART A
1. Audit object and audited expenses
1.1 GENERAL INFORMATION ABOUT THE AUDIT
Project name: Joint actions for improving local rescue fire services to
protect forests and settlements in EE-RU border area
Project acronym: LOCAL FIRE
Project number: ER126
Strategic and thematic objective: TO 6: Environmental protection, climate change mitigation
and adaptation
Beneficiary audited (LP/PP): Alutaguse Municipality Government (Project Partner)
Contact person of the beneficiary: Taavi Vogt
Date of subsidy contract: 14/06/2019
Audit scope and period: 01/07/2020 – 30/06/2021
1.2 INFORMATION ABOUT THE AUDIT
Basis: - Agreement on financing and implementation of Cross-
Border Cooperation Programme “Estonia-Russia” 2014-
2020
- Audit Authority’s work plan for 2021.
Objective: To provide an audit opinion that:
- The operation was selected in accordance with the
selection criteria for the cross-border programme.
- The expenditure declared to the participating nations and
the Commission corresponds to the accounting records,
and that the required supporting documentation
demonstrates an adequate audit trail.
- For expenditure declared to the participating nations and
the Commission, outputs and results underpinning
payments to the beneficiary have been delivered.
Person(s) carrying out the audit: Mart Pechter, Advisor of the Financial Control Department of
Ministry of Estonia (audit manager)
Audit duration: 08/07/2021 – 25/11.2021
Methodology: Audit manual of the Estonia-Russia Programme
Audit procedures performed at the During the on-the-spot check2, interviews were conducted with
beneficiary audited: the person involved in project implementation and
analysis/evaluation was made of the following:
2 On-the-spot check interviews were in this case conducted virtually over a video call as well as locally.
4
- Project’s actual implementation.
- Documentation related to project implementation.
- Eligibility of costs.
- Arrangement of bookkeeping related to the project.
- Existence of co-financing.
- Use of the logos.
Sampling methodology (if applicable, then The entire audit scope was audited in full (100%).
information shall be provided by the Audit
Authority):
1.3 AUDITED EXPENSES
Total amount of certified expenses subject Report 1 (01/09/2019 – 29/02/2020), in the amount of
to auditor’s opinion based on cost €32 158.50.
documents:
Report 2 (01/03/2020 – 31/08/2020), in the amount of
€114 125.61.
Size of the sample (EUR; %)3: €146 284.11, 100%
Ineligible expenditure identified (EUR): amount:
National
EE-RU CBC Private sector
public Total
contribution contribution
contribution
Ineligible amount (EUR): 808.87 256.13 0.00 1065.00
Ineligible amount outside the audit scope 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
(EUR):
Error rate (%)4: 0.73%
2. Limitations
The audit procedures were carried out in compliance with internationally accepted auditing standards5 and the audit
report was prepared using the principles of independence and objectivity.
Auditor concludes that all data presented during the audit and other oral and written information made available
during the audit presents a true and fair view of the activities performed during the project implementation and are
sufficient to provide an opinion about the project. In case of additional information that was not provided or was not
known to auditor, the conclusions reached by auditor might have been different.
3 If a sample was not used for auditing, the size of the sample is the total population in euros and the share of audited expenses to total population is 100%.
4
Share of ineligible expenses to audited expenses (%). If a sample was used for auditing, the share of ineligible expenses to the sample size shall be used.
5 The International Professional Practices Framework (IPPF) of the Institute of Internal Auditors.
5
PART B
AUDIT FINDINGS
1. Use of funding as intended
The funding has generally been used in the intended manner, in a reasonable and efficient way and in accordance
with the objectives and requirements laid down in the subsidy contract and the programme manual. However, the
auditor has made one finding concerning costs incurred outside the project implementation period.
Finding No 1. The project partner has reported costs that have been incurred outside the
implementation period of the project. Total ineligible costs are €1065.00
In accordance with Estonia – Russia Cross Border Cooperation Programme Guidelines p. 7.3.1 (a), the eligible costs
are incurred during the implementation period of the project. For the project at hand, the implementation period
begins at 01/09/2019, as set by the grant contract.
When presenting the first partner report, the project partner has included the project staff costs for August of 2019
along with the respective taxes on staff costs. Those costs were therefore incurred before the start of the
implementation period, making them ineligible in full.
Based on the information available to the auditor, this mistake was because the signing of the grant contract was
originally planned for an earlier date but was delayed. The project partner had, however, signed the partnership
agreement already in June of 2019 and had formed the project team by the 1st of August.
The ineligible costs are in the total of €1065.00. This includes the EE-RU CBC contribution of €808.87 and the national
public contribution of €256.13.
Risk
Not paying attention to the final approved changes to the project specifications may cause the originally planned
costs become ineligible.
Recommendation to the project partner
The auditor recommends always following the changes made to the project either by cooperation with other project
partners or via the eMS system.
Recommendation to the first level control
The auditor recommends taking a note of any costs incurred outside the implementation period, to see whether they
are exceptions or mistakes by the partner.
Recommendation to the managing authority
The auditor recommends beginning the process for reclaiming the ineligible costs. As the project is still active, there
is also a possibility to deduct those costs from the latest partner report that is not yet approved.
Comments by the project partner
We have no comments, and we agree with the finding.
Comments by the first level control
The FLC agrees with the auditor finding and will deduct ineligible costs from the 4th partner report that is not yet
approved.
Comments by the managing authority
6
The Managing Authority agrees with the finding of the audit, as regards the ineligibility of costs outside the eligibility
period of the project, covering the period before the start of the project. Managing Authority will launch financial
correction procedure to reclaim the ineligible costs, with the possibility to deduct these costs from the latest partner
report, if possible.
2. Accuracy of bookkeeping records
The bookkeeping records for the project are in all material aspects in compliance with the current legislation.
3. Amount and timing of funding
The granting of funding has in all material aspects been made available in the amount foreseen and on time, and the
co-financing has been guaranteed.
4. Carrying out of public procurements
The amounts in the audit scope do not include or necessitate carrying out public procurements.
5. Granting of state aid
The project does not contain state aid.
6. Communication and publicity
When informing and disclosing the use of funding, the beneficiary has in all material aspects followed the current
legislation.
We confirm that the final audit report has seven (7) pages.
Audit manager: Audit supervisor:
Mart Pechter Kaur Siruli
Advisor of the Financial Control Department Head of the Financial Control Department
(Signed electronically) (Signed electronically)
7
Hr Tauno Võhmar
Alutaguse Vallavalitsus Meie 30.11.2021 nr 10-5/8451-1
[email protected]
Projektiauditi lõpparuande
edastamine
Austatud härra vallavanem
Edastame Teile Eesti-Vene piiriülese koostöö programmi projekti „LOCAL FIRE“ (nr
ER126) partneri Alutaguse vald projektiauditi lõpparuande.
Täname Teid auditi jooksul üles näidatud abi ja koostöö eest.
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Kaur Siruli
Finantskontrolli osakonna juhataja
Lisa: Projektiauditi lõpparuanne seitsmel (7) leheküljel.
Sama:
Pr Ege Ello, Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus (
[email protected])
Pr Imbi Uusjärv, Riigi Tugiteenuste Keskus (
[email protected])
Mart Pechter 611 3152
[email protected]
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 611 3558 /
[email protected] / www.rahandusministeerium.ee
registrikood 70000272