European Aviation Safety Agency
Notice of Proposed Amendment 2016-15
Instructions for continued airworthiness:
certification maintenance requirements
RMT.0252 (MDM.056) — 23.11.2016
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This Notice of Proposed Amendment (NPA) addresses a regulatory coordination issue related to harmonisation of the
current EASA CS-25 and AMC 25-19 with the FAA AC 25-19A in relation to the Certification Maintenance Requirements
(CMRs).
The specific objective is to mitigate the risks linked to different CMR documents with different identification means and
follow-up procedures because of the lack of harmonisation between the FAA AC and the EASA AMC.
This NPA proposes an amendment to CS-25, which includes a revision of AMC 25-19.
The proposed amendments are expected to clarify the CMRs.
Action area: Maintenance organisations; service providers; continuing airworthiness management organisations (CAMOs)
Affected rules: ED Decision 2003/2/RM (CS-25)
Affected stakeholders: Large aeroplane operators and manufacturers
Driver: Level playing field Reference: None
Rulemaking group: Yes Impact assessment: None Procedure: Standard
20.6.2016 23.11.2016 2017/Q2
TE.RPRO.00034-005 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 1 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
Table of contents
Table of contents
1. Procedural information .............................................................................................................................. 3
1.1. The rule development procedure...................................................................................................... 3
1.2. The structure of this NPA and related documents ............................................................................ 3
1.3. How to comment on this NPA ........................................................................................................... 3
1.4. The next steps in the procedure........................................................................................................ 3
2. Explanatory Note........................................................................................................................................ 4
2.1. Overview of the issue to be addressed ............................................................................................. 5
2.2. Objectives .......................................................................................................................................... 5
2.3. Summary of the regulatory impact assessment (RIA) ....................................................................... 5
2.4. Overview of the proposed amendments .......................................................................................... 5
3. Proposed amendments .............................................................................................................................. 6
3.1. Draft certification specifications (CSs) ............................................................................................... 6
3.2. Draft acceptable means of compliance (AMC) and guidance material (GM).................................... 7
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA) ........................................................................................................ 24
5. References ................................................................................................................................................ 25
5.1. Affected CSs, AMC and GM ............................................................................................................. 25
5.2. Reference documents...................................................................................................................... 25
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 2 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
1. Procedural information
1. Procedural information
1.1. The rule development procedure
The European Aviation Safety Agency (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Agency’) developed this NPA in
line with Regulation (EC) No 216/20081 (hereinafter referred to as the ‘Basic Regulation’) and the
Rulemaking Procedure2.
This rulemaking activity is included in the Agency’s Rulemaking Programme for 2016–20203 under
RMT.0252 (former MDM.056).
The text of this NPA has been developed by the Agency based on the input of the Rulemaking Group
RMT.0252 (MDM.056). It is hereby submitted to all interested parties for consultation 4.
The cover page contains the major milestones of this rulemaking activity to date and provides an
outlook of the timescales of the next steps.
1.2. The structure of this NPA and related documents
Chapter 1 of this NPA contains the procedural information related to this task. Chapter 2 (Explanatory
Note) explains the core technical content. Chapter 3 contains the proposed text for the new
requirements.
1.3. How to comment on this NPA
Please submit your comments using the automated Comment-Response Tool (CRT) available at
http://hub.easa.europa.eu/crt/5.
The deadline for the submission of comments is 23 January 2017.
1.4. The next steps in the procedure
The Agency will publish the related comment-response document (CRD) together with the decision.
The decision will contain the associated certification specification (CSs) and acceptable means of
compliance (AMC).
1
Regulation (EC) No 216/2008 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 February 2008 on common rules in the field of
civil aviation and establishing a European Aviation Safety Agency, and repealing Council Directive 91/670/EEC, Regulation (EC)
No 1592/2002 and Directive 2004/36/EC (OJ L 79, 19.3.2008, p. 1).
2
The Agency is bound to follow a structured rulemaking process as required by Article 52(1) of the Basic Regulation. Such process
has been adopted by the Agency’s Management Board and is referred to as the ‘Rulemaking Procedure’. See Management Board
Decision No 01-2012 of 13 March 2012 concerning the procedure to be applied by the Agency for the issuing of Opinions,
Certification Specifications and Guidance Material (Rulemaking Procedure).
3
https://www.easa.europa.eu/document-library/rulemaking-programmes/2016-2020-rulemaking-programme
4
In accordance with Article 52 of the Basic Regulation and Articles 5(3) and 6 of the Rulemaking Procedure.
5
In case of technical problems, please contact the CRT webmaster (
[email protected]).
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 3 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
2. Explanatory Note
2. Explanatory Note
Although in the European Union regulatory system provisions related to Instructions for Continued
Airworthiness (ICA) are included in Annex I (Part 21) to Commission Regulation (EU) No 748/20126, in
the relevant CSs for products, and in Annex I (Part-M) and Annex II (Part-145) to Commission
Regulation (EU) No 1321/20147, experience has shown that there is too much room for interpretation
in the current rules and standards, leading to implementation differences and potential safety risks.
The above-mentioned issue and all the complex consequences are addressed by the Agency in the
rulemaking task RMT.0252 (former MDM.056).
The main issues that were initially addressed by the Rulemaking Group are the following:
— What information/documents/manuals are considered as ICA and how they are
approved/accepted by the aviation authorities.
— What happens with the information/documents/manuals which are not considered as ICA. What
is the level of approval/acceptance and who is responsible for their content.
— How does the Maintenance Review Board (MRB) process fit with the approval/acceptance of ICA
(this task was cancelled in mid 2015).
— To whom (e.g. operators, maintenance organisations) and when this information (ICA and non-
ICA) should be made available.
— How this information (ICA and non-ICA) is used by operators/maintenance organisations and
who can introduce changes.
At the same time, the FAA and TCCA were also developing an Advisory Circular related to ICA, so it was
considered beneficial for industry and certifying authorities to produce harmonised regulatory material
in order to increase efficiency. RMT.0252 was therefore split in five subtasks of common interest as
follows:
Subtask 1:
— Definition and identification of ICA (to be provided during the certification process).
— Completeness of ICA (during the certification process).
— Level of involvement of the competent authority (during the certification process).
Subtask 2:
— Availability of ICA (to owners, operators, maintenance organisations, etc.).
Subtask 3:
— MRB scheduling information (task afterwards cancelled).
6
Commission Regulation (EU) No 748/2012 of 3 August 2012 laying down implementing rules for the airworthiness and
environmental certification of aircraft and related products, parts and appliances, as well as for the certification of design and
production organisations (OJ L 224, 21.8.2012, p. 1).
7
Commission Regulation (EU) No 1321/2014 of 26 November 2014 on the continuing airworthiness of aircraft and aeronautical
products, parts and appliances, and on the approval of organisations and personnel involved in these tasks (OJ L 362, 17.12.2014, p. 1).
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 4 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
2. Explanatory Note
Subtask 4:
— Acceptance/approval of ICA by other than the competent authority.
Subtask 5:
— Certification Maintenance Requirements (CMRs).
This NPA addresses Subtask 5 in order to ensure regulatory coordination related to the harmonisation
of the current EASA CS-25/AMC 25-19 with the FAA AC 25-19A for CMRs. Furthermore, to mitigate the
risks linked to different CMR documents with different identification means and follow-up procedures.
2.1. Overview of the issue to be addressed
In October 2011 the FAA updated AC 25-19 to version A in relation to CMRs. This has introduced a lack
of harmonisation with the current AMC 25-19 version. As a result, applicants issue two different CMR
documents, with different identification means and follow-up procedures, which may not be
sustainable in the long term. Considering this a high-priority issue, the Agency has decided to create
Subtask 5 of rulemaking task RMT.0252 (MDM.056) with the aim to harmonise the two documents.
2.2. Objectives
The overall objectives of the EASA system are defined in Article 2 of the Basic Regulation. This proposal
will contribute to the achievement of the overall objectives by addressing the issues outlined in
Chapter 2 of this NPA.
The specific objective of this proposal is the harmonisation of the EASA AMC 25-19 with the FAA
AC 25-19A, and the improvement of instructions and guidance in the AMC, thus ensuring a better
harmonisation of the CMR development process among applicants, and the reduction of the risk of
inadequate task identification and follow-up.
2.3. Summary of the regulatory impact assessment (RIA)
This NPA does not create new requirements for applicants. It addresses a regulatory coordination issue
related to the harmonisation of the current EASA AMC 25-19 with the FAA AC 25-19A for CMRs, and
proposes an amendment to CS-25 (which includes a revision of AMC 25-19).
There is, therefore, no need to develop any RIA.
2.4. Overview of the proposed amendments
This NPA proposes amendments to CS 25.1309, CS-25 Appendix H, and AMC 25-19 in order to improve
the guidance material in relation to CMRs.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 5 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
3. Proposed amendments
The text of the amendment is arranged to show deleted text, new or amended text as shown below:
(a) deleted text is struck through;
(b) new or amended text is highlighted in grey;
(c) an ellipsis (…) indicates that the remaining text is unchanged.
3.1. Draft certification specifications (CSs)
CS 25.1309 is amended as follows:
‘CS 25.1309 Equipment, systems and installations
The requirements of this paragraph, except as identified below, are applicable, in addition to specific
design requirements of CS-25, to any equipment or system as installed in the aeroplane. Although this
paragraph does not apply to the performance and flight characteristic requirements of Subpart B and
the structural requirements of Subparts C and D, it does apply to any system on which compliance with
any of those requirements is dependent. Certain single failures or jams covered by CS 25.671(c)(1) and
CS 25.671(c)(3) are excepted from the requirements of CS 25.1309(b)(1)(ii). Certain single failures
covered by CS 25.735(b) are excepted from the requirements of CS 25.1309(b). The failure effects
covered by CS 25.810(a)(1)(v) and CS 25.812 are excepted from the requirements of CS 25.1309(b). The
requirements of CS 25.1309(b) apply to powerplant installations as specified in CS 25.901(c).
(a) The aeroplane equipment and systems must be designed and installed so that:
(1) Those required for type certification or by operating rules, or whose improper functioning
would reduce safety, perform as intended under the aeroplane operating and environmental
conditions.
(2) Other equipment and systems are not a source of danger in themselves and do not
adversely affect the proper functioning of those covered by sub-paragraph (a)(1) of this
paragraph.
(b) The aeroplane systems and associated components, considered separately and in relation to other
systems, must be designed so that:
(1) Any catastrophic failure condition:
(i) is extremely improbable; and
(ii) does not result from a single failure; and
(2) Any hazardous failure condition is extremely remote; and
(3) Any major failure condition is remote.
(c) Information concerning unsafe system operating conditions must be provided to the crew to enable
them to take appropriate corrective action. A warning indication must be provided if immediate
corrective action is required. Systems and controls, including indications and annunciations, must be
designed to minimise crew errors, which could create additional hazards.
(d) Electrical wiring interconnection systems must be assessed in accordance with the requirements of
CS 25.1709.
(e) A Certification Maintenance Requirement is a maintenance action which is necessary for achieving
the safety objectives of CS 25.1309(b). Certification Maintenance Requirements must be published in
the Airworthiness Limitations Section of the Instructions for Continued Airworthiness required by
CS 25.1529.’
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 6 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
CS-25 Appendix H is amended as follows:
‘Appendix H
Instructions for Continued Airworthiness
(…)
H25.4 Airworthiness Limitations sSection
(a) The Instructions for Continued Airworthiness must contain a section titled Airworthiness Limitations
that is segregated and clearly distinguishable from the rest of the document. This section must set
forth –
(1) Each mandatory replacement time, structural inspection interval, and related structural
inspection procedure approved under CS 25.571, and
(2) Reserved
(3) Any mandatory replacement time of EWIS components as defined in CS 25.1701 (see
AMC Appendix H 25.4(a)(3)), and
(4) Each Certification Maintenance Requirement established to comply with any of the
applicable requirements of CS-25 (see AMC 25-19).
(b) If the Instructions for Continued Airworthiness consist of multiple documents, the section required
by this paragraph must be included in the principal manual. This section must contain a legible
statement in a prominent location that reads: ‘The Airworthiness Limitations Section is approved and
variations must also be approved’.’
(…)
3.2. Draft acceptable means of compliance (AMC) and guidance material (GM)
AMC 25-19 is amended as follows:
‘AMC 25-19
Certification Maintenance Requirements
1 PURPOSE
This AMC is similar to FAA Advisory Circular AC 25–19 dated 28 November 1994.
This Acceptable Means of Compliance (AMC) provides guidance on the selection, documentation, and
control of Certification Maintenance Requirements (CMRs). For those aeroplanes whose initial
maintenance programme is developed under the Maintenance Review Board (MRB) process, this
document This AMC also provides a rational basis for coordinating the Maintenance Review Board
(MRB) and CMR selection processes, if the MRB process is used. in order to minimise the impact of
CMRs on aeroplane operators. The applicant should ensure that the maintenance tasks and intervals
identified in the system safety analyses to support compliance with CS 25.1309 and other system safety
requirements (such as CS 25.671, 25.783, 25.901, and 25.933) are protected against unintentional
changes during service. It is recognised that, fFor those aeroplanes whose initial maintenance
programme is developed under a different process than the MRB process, the coordination and
documentation aspects have to be adapted to the particular case. Like all acceptable means of
compliance, this AMC is not, in itself, mandatory, and does not constitute a requirement. It is issued to
This AMC describes an acceptable means, but not the only means, for selecting, documenting, and
managing CMRs. Terms such as "shall" and "must" are used only in the sense of ensuring applicability of
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 7 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
this particular method of compliance when the acceptable method means of compliance described
herein is used.
2 RELATED CERTIFICATION SPECIFICATIONS
CS 25.1309 and CS 25.1529 of the Certification Specifications (CS).
a. CS 25.671 Control Systems — General
b. CS 25.783 Fuselage Doors
c. CS 25.901 Powerplant Installation
d. CS 25.933 Reversing Systems
e. CS 25.1309 Equipment, Systems and Installation
f. CS 25.1529 Instructions for Continued Airworthiness
3 RELATED DOCUMENTS
a. AC 25.1309–1A, System Design and Analysis.
b. Acceptable Means of Compliance AMC 25.1309, System Design and Analysis.
c. AC 121–22A, Maintenance Review Board (MRB) Procedures.
ATA Maintenance Steering Group (MSG-3), AirlineOperator/Manufacturer Maintenance Program
Scheduled Maintenance Development Document, Available from Air Transport Association Airlines offor
America, 1301 Pennsylvania Avenue – Suite 1100, Washington, DC 20004–1707.
4 BACKGROUND NOT USED
CMRs have been in use since the early 1970’s, when the industry began using quantitative approaches
to certify systems to the requirements of CS 25.1309 and other requirements requiring safety analyses.
CMRs have been established on several aeroplanes certified in Europe and in other countries, and are
being planned for use on aeroplanes currently under development.
5 CERTIFICATION MAINTENANCE REQUIREMENTS (CMR) DEFINITION
A CMR is a required periodic scheduled maintenance task, established during the design certification of
the aeroplane systems as an operating limitation of the type certificate (TC) or supplemental type
certificate (STC). The CMRs are a subset of the Instructions for Continued Airworthiness (ICA) identified
during the certification process. A CMRs usually results from a formal, numerical analysis conducted to
show compliance with the requirements applicable to catastrophic and hazardous failure conditions, as
defined in paragraph 6d below. There are two types of CMRs, as defined in paragraph 12 of this AMC.
Compliance may also result from a qualitative, engineering judgment-based analysis.
a. The CMRs are required tasks, and associated intervals, developed to achieve compliance with
CS 25.1309 and other requirements requiring safety analyses (such as CS 25.671, 25.783, 25.901, and
25.933). A CMR is usually intended to detect safety-significant latent failures which that would, in
combination with one or more other specific failures or events, result in a hazardous or catastrophic
failure condition. A CMR can also be used to establish a required task to detect an impending wearout
of an item whose failure is associated with a hazardous or catastrophic failure condition. A CMR may
also be used to detect a latent failure that would, in combination with one specific failure or event,
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 8 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
result in a major failure condition, where the system safety analysis (SSA) identifies the need for a
scheduled maintenance task.
b. It is important to note that CMRs are derived from a fundamentally different analysis process than
the maintenance tasks and intervals whichthat result from the Maintenance Steering Group MSG-3
analysis associated with Maintenance Review Board (MRB) activities (if the MRB process is used). MSG–
3 analysis activity produces maintenance tasks which are performed for safety, operational, or
economic reasons, involving both preventative maintenance tasks, which are performed before failure
occurs (and are intended to prevent failures), as well as failure-finding tasks. CMRs, on the other hand,
are failurefinding tasks only, and exist solely to limit the exposure to otherwise hidden failures. Although
CMR tasks are failure-finding tasks, use of potential failure-finding tasks, such as functional checks and
inspections, may also be appropriate. Both types of analysis may produce equivalent maintenance tasks
and intervals; it is not always appropriate to address a Candidate Certification Maintenance
Requirement (CCMR) with a Maintenance Review Board Report (MRBR) task.
c. CMRs are designed to verify that a certain failure has or has not occurred, and do not provide any
preventative maintenance function. indicate that corrective maintenance or repair is necessary if the
item has failed, or identify the need to inspect for impending failures (e.g. heavy wear or leakage).
Because the exposure time to a latent failure is a key element in the calculations used in a safety
analysis performed to show compliance with CS 25.1309, limiting the exposure time will have a
significant effect on the resultant overall failure probability of the system. The intervals for CMR tasks
interval should be designated in terms of flight hours, cycles, or calendar time, as appropriate.
d. The type certification process assumes that the aeroplane will be maintained in a condition of
airworthiness at least equal to its certified or properly altered condition. The process described in this
AMC is not intended to establish normal routine maintenance tasks (e.g. greasing, fluid-level checks,
etc.) that should be defined through the MSG-3 analysis process. Also, this process is not intended to
establish CMRs for the purpose of providing supplemental margins of safety for concerns arising late in
the type design approval process. Such concerns should be resolved by appropriate means, which are
unlikely to include CMRs not established via normal safety analyses.
e. CMRs should not be confused with required structural inspection programmes, which that are
developed by the type certificateTC applicant to meet the inspection requirements for damage
tolerance, as required by CS 25.571 or CS 25.1529, and Appendix H25.4 (Airworthiness Limitations
sSection). CMRs are to be developed and administered managed separately from any structural
inspections programmes.
6 OTHER DEFINITIONS
The following terms apply to the system design and analysis requirements of CS 25.1309(b) and (c), and
to the guidance material provided in this AMC (for a complete definition of these terms, refer to the
applicable specifications and acceptable means of compliance requirements and guidance material,
(ie.g. AC 25.1309–1A and/or the EASA AcceptableMeans of Compliance AMC 25.1309)):C 25.1309–1A
and AMC 25.1309 are periodically revised by the FAA/EASA and are the controlling documents for
definition of these terms. The terms listed below are derived from this guidance material and are
included to assist in the use of this document.
a. Failure
A loss of function, or a malfunction, of a system or a part thereof.
b. Failure Condition
The effect on the aeroplane and its occupants, both direct and consequential, caused or contributed to
by one or more failures, considering relevant adverse operational or environmental conditions.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 9 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
Failure Conditions may be classified according to their severities as follows:
(1) Minor Failure Conditions: Failure Conditions which would not significantly reduce aeroplane safety,
and which involve crew actions that are well within their capabilities. Minor Failure Conditions may
include, for example, a slight reduction in safety margins or functional capabilities, a slight increase in
crew workload, such as routine flight plan changes, or some inconvenience to occupants.
(2) Major Failure Conditions: Failure Conditions which would reduce the capability of the aeroplane or
the ability of the crew to cope with adverse operating conditions to the extent that there would be, for
example, a significant reduction in safety margins or functional capabilities, a significant increase in crew
workload or in conditions impairing crew efficiency, or discomfort to occupants, possibly including
injuries.
(3) Hazardous Failure Conditions: Failure Conditions, which would reduce the capability of the aeroplane
or the ability of the crew to cope with adverse operating, conditions to the extent that there would be:
(i) A large reduction in safety margins or functional capabilities;
(ii) physical distress or higher workload such that the flight crew cannot be relied upon to perform their
tasks accurately or completely, or
(iii) serious or fatal injury to a relatively small number of the occupants.
(4) Catastrophic Failure Conditions: Failure Conditions, which would prevent the continued safe flight
and landing of the aeroplane.
(c) Probability Terms
When using qualitative or quantitative assessments to determine compliance with CS 25.1309(b), the
following descriptions of the probability terms used in the requirement and in the acceptable means of
compliance listed above have become commonly accepted aids to engineering judgement:
(1) Probable Failure Conditions: Probable Failure Conditions are those anticipated to occur one or more
times during the entire operational life of each aeroplane. Probable Failure Conditions are those having
a probability of the order of 1 x 10–5 or greater. Minor Failure Conditions may be probable.
(2) Improbable Failure Conditions: Improbable Failure Conditions are divided into two categories as
follows:
(i) Remote: Unlikely to occur to each aeroplane during its total life but may occur several times when
considering the total operational life of a number of aeroplanes of the same type. Improbable (Remote)
Failure Conditions are those having a probability of the order of 1 x 10 –5 or less, but greater than of the
order of 1 x 10–7. Major Failure Conditions must be no more frequent than Improbable (Remote).
(ii) Extremely Remote. Unlikely to occur when considering the total operational life of all aeroplanes of
the same type, but nevertheless has to be considered as being possible. Improbable (Extremely Remote)
Failure Conditions are those having a probability of the order of 1 x 10 –7 or less, but greater than of the
order of 1 x 10–9. Hazardous Failure Conditions must be no more frequent than Improbable (Extremely
Remote).
(3) Extremely Improbable Failure Conditions: Extremely Improbable Failure Conditions are those so
unlikely that they are not anticipated to occur during the entire operational life of all aeroplanes of one
type, and have a probability of the order of 1 x 10–9 or less. Catastrophic Failure Conditions must be
shown to be Extremely Improbable.
d. Qualitative
Those analytical processes that assess system and aeroplane safety in a subjective, non-numerical
manner, based on experienced engineering judgement.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 10 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
e. Quantitative
Those analytical processes that apply mathematical methods to assess system and aeroplane safety.
a. Catastrophic. Refer to AMC 25.1309.
b. Crew. The cabin crew, or flight crew, as applicable.
c. Failure. Refer to AMC 25.1309.
d. Failure Condition. Refer to AMC 25.1309.
e. Failure Effect Category 5 task (FEC5). Refer to ATA MSG-3, Operator/Manufacturer Scheduled
Maintenance Development.
f. Failure Effect Category 8 task (FEC8). Refer to ATA MSG-3, Operator/Manufacturer Scheduled
Maintenance Development.
g. Hazardous. Refer to AMC 25.1309.
h. Latent Failure. Refer to AMC 25.1309.
i. Major. Refer to AMC 25.1309.
j. Qualitative. Refer to AMC 25.1309.
k. Quantitative. Refer to AMC 25.1309.
l. Significant Latent Failure. A latent failure that would, in combination with one or more other specific
failures or events, result in a hazardous or catastrophic failure condition.
m. Task. Short description (e.g. descriptive title) of what is to be accomplished by a procedure.
Example: ‘Operational check of the static inverter’.
n. Wearout. A condition where a component is worn beyond a predetermined limit.
7 SYSTEM SAFETY ASSESSMENTS (SSA)
CS 25.1309(b) provides general requirements for a logical and acceptable inverse relationship between
the probability and severity of each Failure Condition, and AMC 25.1309, sub-paragraph 9 b.(1) specifies
that compliance should be shown primarily by analysis. In recent years there has been an increase in the
degree of system complexity and integration, and in the number of safety–critical functions performed
by systems. This increase in complexity has led to the use of structured means for showing compliance
with the requirements of CS 25.1309.
a. CS 25.1309(b) specifies required safety levels in qualitative terms, and AMC 25.1309, subparagraph 9
b.(1) specifies that a safety assessment should must be conducted to show compliance. Various
assessment techniques have been developed to assist help applicants and the Agency in determining
that a logical and acceptable inverse relationship exists between the probability and the severity of each
failure condition. These techniques include the use of service experience data of similar, previously
approved systems, and thorough qualitative and quantitative analyses.
b. In addition, difficulties have been experienced in assessing the acceptability of some designs,
especially those of systems, or parts of systems, that are complex, that have a high degree of
integration, that use new technology, or that perform safety-critical functions. These difficulties led to
the selective use of rational analyses to estimate quantitative probabilities, and the development of
related criteria based on historical data of accidents and hazardous incidents caused or contributed to
by failures. These criteria, expressed as numerical probability ranges associated with the terms used in
CS 25.1309(b), became commonly accepted for evaluating the quantitative analyses that are often used
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 11 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
in such cases to support experienced engineering and operational judgment and to supplement
qualitative analyses and tests.
NOTE: See Acceptable Means of Compliance AMC 25.1309, System Design and Analysis, for a complete
description of the inverse relationship between the probability and severity of failure conditions, and
the various methods of showing compliance with CS 25.1309.
8 DESIGN CONSIDERATIONS RELATED TO CANDIDATE CMRs SIGNIFICANT LATENT FAILURES
A decision to create a candidate CMR should follow the guidelines given in AMC 25.1309 (i.e. the use of
candidate CMRs in lieu of practical and reliable failure monitoring and warning systems to detect
significant latent failures when they occur does not comply with CS 25.1309(c)).
a. The applicant should implement practical and reliable failure monitoring and indication systems to
detect significant latent failures. A practical failure monitoring and warning indication system is one,
which that is considered to be within the state-of-the-art technology. A reliable failure monitoring and
warning indication system is one, which would not result in either excessive failures of a genuine
warning, or excessive or untimely false warnings, which can s ometimes be more hazardous than lack of
provision for, or failures of, genuine but infrequent warnings. should utilise the current state-of-the-art
technology to minimise the probability of falsely detecting and indicating non-existent failures.
Experienced judgment should be applied when determining whether or not a failure monitoring and
warning indication system would be practical and reliable. Comparison with similar, previously approved
systems is sometimes helpful. Appendix 1 outlines some design considerations that should be observed
in any decision to create a candidate CMR.
b. The decision to create a CCMR should be made according to the guidelines given in AMC 25.1309 and
paragraph 10 of this AMC, as well as the design considerations provided in Appendix 1 to this AMC.
9 OVERVIEW IDENTIFICATION OF CANDIDATE CMRs (CCMRs) THE CERTIFICATION MAINTENANCE
REQUIREMENTS DEVELOPMENT PROCESS
a. Figure 1 illustrates the relationship between the certification process and the MRB process
inestablishing scheduled maintenance tasks. Those tasks related to the certification process, as wellas
those derived through MSG–3 analysis, must be identified and documented as illustrated. The details of
the process to be followed in defining, documenting, and handling CMRs are given in paragraphs 9b
through 12 below. shows the development process of CMRs. The details of the process to be followed in
defining, documenting, and handling CMRs are given in paragraphs 10 through 13.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 12 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
Figure 1 — CMR development process
Certification Process
TC application
Note 1: The CCMRs should be accepted by the
Agency.
Note 2: The disposition activity involves the
OEM, the Agency, and an optional Advisory Design
Committee (e.g. CMCC). The disposition of each
CCMR should be accepted by the Agency.
Note 3: Discussion and feedback with ISC in
order to revise, if justified, the MSG-3 analyses System Safety Analyses
and the associated MRBR tasks intents/intervals. (25.1309, 25.671, 25.783,
Note 4: Where the SSA identifies the need for a 25.901, 25.933, etc.)
scheduled maintenance task, the CMR (Paragraph 10)
designation may also be used to detect a latent
failure that would, in combination with one
specified failure or event, lead to a major failure
condition. This CMR designation may be 1
necessary if an adequate scheduled maintenance
task has not been identified in other Instructions
CCMRs
for Continued Airworthiness.
4
2 Disposition of
scheduled maintenance
3 Disposition of each task identified for major
ISC/MRB CCMR failure conditions
(Paragraph 11) (Paragraph 11)
CCMRs
accomodated
ALS: Airworthiness Limitations Section by CMRs
a compatible
MRBR task
CMR: Certification Maintenance Requirement
CCMR: Candidate Certification Maintenance
Certification
Requirement
Authority
approval
ISC: Industry Steering Committee
MRB: Maintenance Review Board
CMR
TC: Type Certificate documentation
(ALS)
TCDS: Type Certificate Data Sheet
Reference
TCDS
Certification Process
b. Candidate CMRs
(1) Tasks that are candidates for selection as CMRs usually come from safety analyses (e.g.
System Safety Assessments (SSA), which may establish the need for tasks to be carried out periodically
to comply with CS 25.1309 and other requirements requiring this type of analysis). Tasks may be
selected from those intended to detect latent failures, which would, in combination with one or more
specific failures or events, lead to a Hazardous or Catastrophic Failure Condition.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 13 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
(2) Other tasks, not derived from formal safety analyses but based on properly justified
engineering judgement, may also be candidates for CMRs. The justification must include the logic
leading to identification as a candidate CMR, and the data and experience base supporting the logic.
10 CERTIFICATION MAINTENANCE COORDINATION COMMITTEE (CMCC) IDENTIFICATION OF CANDIDATE
CMRs (CCMRs)
a. In order to grant operators of the aeroplane an opportunity to participate in the selection of CMRs
and to assess the candidate CMRs and the proposed MRB tasks and intervals in an integrated process,
the type certificate (TC) applicant should convene a Certification Maintenance Coordination
Committee (CMCC) (see Figure 1). This committee should be made up of manufacturers, operator
representatives designated by the Industry Steering Committee (ISC) Chairperson, Agency Certification
Specialist(s) and the MRB Chairperson.
b. As early as possible in the design phase of the aeroplane programme, and at intervals as necessary,
the CMCC should meet to review candidate CMRs, their purpose, criticality, and other relevant factors.
During the CMCC’s discussions, participants’ experience may suggest alternatives to a given CMR,
which would satisfy the intent of the CMR, while allowing reduced operational impact. In addition,
where multiple tasks result from a quantitative analysis, it may be possible to extend a given interval at
the expense of one or more other intervals, in order to optimise the required maintenance activity.
However, if a decision is made to create a CMR, then the CMR task interval shall be based solely on the
results of the safety analysis.
c. The CMCC would function as an advisory committee for the TC applicant. The results of the CMCC
(proposed CMRs to be included on the type design definition and proposed revisions to MRB tasks
and/or intervals) would be forwarded by the TC applicant to the ISC for their consideration. Revisions
to proposed MRB tasks and/or intervals accepted by the ISC will be reflected in the MRB report
proposal. Revisions to proposed MRB tasks and/or intervals rejected by the ISC will result in CMR tasks.
Subsequent to the ISC’s consideration, the TC applicant will submit the CMR document, as defined in
paragraph 12 of this AMC, to the Agency for final review and approval.
a. The SSA should address all significant latent failures.
b. Credit may be taken for correct flight crew performance of the periodic checks required to
demonstrate compliance with CS 25.1309(b). Unless these flight crew actions are accepted as normal
airmanship, they should be included in the approved Aeroplane Flight Manual procedures. Similarly,
credit may be taken from self-initiated checks (e.g. power-up built-in test). In both cases, these
significant latent failures do not need a CCMR.
c. Tasks that are candidates for selection as CMRs usually come from safety analyses (e.g. SSA), which
establish whether there is a need for tasks to be carried out periodically to comply with CS 25.1309,
and other requirements (such as CS 25.671, 25.783, 25.901, and 25.933) requiring this type of analysis.
The SSA should identify as CCMRs the maintenance tasks intended to detect significant latent failures.
Tasks may also be selected from those intended to inspect for impending failures due to wearout.
d. As the safety analysis may be qualitative or quantitative, some task intervals may be derived in a
qualitative manner (e.g. engineering judgment and service experience). As per AMC 25.1309,
numerical analysis supplements, but does not replace, qualitative engineering and operational
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 14 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
judgments. Therefore, other tasks that are not derived from numerical analysis of significant latent
failures, but are based on properly justified engineering judgment, can also be candidates for CMRs.
The justification should include the logic leading to identification of CCMRs, and the data and
experience base supporting the logic.
e. In some situations, a catastrophic or hazardous failure condition might meet the quantitative
probability objective, yet containing one or more components that, as per the quantitative analysis,
do not require a periodic maintenance task to meet that objective (i.e. could be failed latent for the life
of the aeroplane). In such cases, the SSA should include a qualitative assessment to determine whether
a periodic maintenance task is needed.
Unless otherwise substantiated, a CCMR should be identified to:
— reduce exposure to a single failure or event that would cause a failure condition,
— ensure availability of backup or emergency systems,
— ensure availability of equipment/systems required to be installed as per CS 25.
f. For failure conditions involving multiple significant latent failures, the SSA should identify a CCMR for
each significant latent failure unless otherwise justified (e.g. one CCMR may cover multiple significant
latent failures).
g. For each identified CCMR, the applicant should indicate:
— the failure mode to be detected,
— the failure condition of concern,
— the intended maintenance task, and
— the task interval (the allowable value coming from the SSA or other relevant analysis).
11 SELECTION OF CMRs
a. The candidate Each CCMRs should be reviewed by the CMCC and a determination made as to
whether or not it should be a CMR. status is necessary and, if so, whether to categorise the CMR as
One Star or Two Star, as defined in paragraph 12 of this AMC. To reach this decision, the following
should be considered by the CMCC:
(1) CMR status does not need to be applied if the CCMR is satisfied by:
(i) Maintenance actions considered to be routine maintenance activity (and which are also identified as
MRB tasks) based on engineering judgement and experience on similar aeroplane types, or (ii) Tasks
included in the approved Aeroplane Flight Manual.
(2) CMRs remaining after application of paragraph 11a(1) should be categorised as either One Star
or Two Star CMRs. The following should be considered in assigning One Star or Two Star status:
(i) The degree of conservatism taken in the classification of the Failure Condition consequences.
(ii) (ii) The degree of conservatism taken in the individual failure rates and event occurrence rates
used.
(iii) The margin between safety analysis calculated maximum interval and the interval selected
through the MRB process.
(iv) The sensitivity of the Failure Condition probability to interval escalation.
(v) The proximity of the calculated maximum interval to the aeroplane life.
b. For operators with approved escalation practices or an approved reliability programme, dat a
collection and analytical techniques are used to make adjustments to an operator’s maintenance
programme. It has been demonstrated that the management of a maintenance programme does not
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 15 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
give rise to undue escalations. Therefore, escalation of Two Star CMR task intervals within an
operator’s maintenance programme ensures that Two Star CMRs will be properly managed by the
operator with adequate controls.
Paragraphs 11.a through e provide the criteria and guidance for CMR selection or non-selection. The
applicant may seek additional inputs from an advisory committee, as described in Appendix 2, before
proposing CMRs to the Agency for final review and approval.
a. The applicant should provide sufficient information to enable an understanding of the failure
conditions and the failure or event combinations that result in the CCMR. CCMRs are evaluated in the
context of the failure conditions in which they are involved, e.g. whether the significant latent failure is
part of a dual failure, or more.
b. The CMR designation should be applied in the case of catastrophic dual failures where one failure is
latent. The CMR designation should also be applied to tasks that address wearout of a component
involved in a catastrophic failure condition that results from two failures.
c. In all other cases, the CMR designation may not be necessary if there is a compatible MRBR task to
accommodate the CCMR, provided that the applicant has the means in place to ensure that the SSA
assumptions are protected in service. Appendix 3 provides examples of acceptable means of
protection. Any means should be presented to the Agency for acceptance.
These means of protection should address future evolutions proposed by the applicant or by the
operator. In this respect, these means should ensure that in service:
— the compatible MRBR task would not be changed to the extent that the CCMR task intent is
adversely affected, and
— the compatible MRBR task would not be escalated beyond the interval that would otherwise be
required by a CMR.
The TC applicant should adequately describe the selected means of protection in the associated
technical publication in order for the operator to be aware of the process to be followed in case of
evolution of compatible MRBR tasks that are included in the operator’s aircraft maintenance program
(AMP).
d. The rationale for the disposition of each CCMR should be presented to the Agency for acceptance.
e. Since the MSG-3 logic may not consider a failure condition containing three or more failures, it is
possible that there is no MRBR task identified for a CCMR.
f. Where the SSA identifies the need for a scheduled maintenance task, the CMR designation may also
be used to detect a latent failure that would, in combination with one specified failure or event, lead to
a major failure condition. This CMR designation may be necessary if an adequate scheduled
maintenance task has not been identified in other Instructions for Continued Airworthiness.
g. In the case where the SSA does not specify an interval shorter than the life of the aeroplane, an
interval may be established considering factors that influence the outcome of the failure condition,
such as the nature of the fault, the system(s) affected, field experience, or task characteristics.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 16 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
12 DOCUMENTATION AND HANDLING OF CMRs
CMRs should be listed in a separate CMR document, which is ref erenced in the Type Certificate Data Sheet.
The latest version of the CMR document should be controlled by a EASA-approved log of pages. In this way,
changes to CMRs following certification will not require an amendment to the Type Certificate Data Sheet. The
CMR document should clearly identify the two types of CMR tasks, which are handled as follows:
a. One Star CMRs (*) – The tasks and intervals specified are mandatory and cannot be changed, escalated, or
deleted without the approval of the Agency.
b. Two Star CMRs (**) – Task intervals may be adjusted in accordance with an operator ’s approved escalation
practices or an approved reliability programme, but the task may not be changed or deleted without prior
Agency approval.
c. All minimum initial scheduled maintenance tasks, and CMRs, should reside in an MRB report to ensure that
the operator’s maintenance planning personnel are aware of all requirements. The CMR document should be
included as Appendix 1 or A (the first appendix) to the MRB report. The MRB report should include a note
indicating that the CMR document is the controlling document for all CMR tasks. When a CMR task
corresponds to an MRB task, whatever the respective intervals, this fact should be highlighted, for example, by
flagging the task in the CMR appendix of the MRB report.
a. CMRs are considered functionally equal to airworthiness limitations, therefore they should be included in
the Airworthiness Limitations Section of the Instructions for Continued Airworthiness.
b. The CMR data location should be referenced in the type certificate data sheet (TCDS). The latest version of
the applicant CMR documentation should be controlled by a log of pages approved by the Agency. In this way,
changes to CMRs following certification will not require an amendment to the TCDS.
d.c. Since CMRs are based on statistical averages and reliability rates, an ‘exceptional short-term extension’ for
a single CMR intervals may be made on one aeroplane for a specific period of time without jeopardising risking
safety. Any exceptional short-term extensions to CMR intervals (both one star and two star) must be defined
and fully explained in the applicant CMR documentation. The local competent authority must be notified as
soon as practicable if concur with any exceptional short-term extensions allowed by the applicant CMR
documentation has before they take place using procedures established with the competent authority in the
operators’ manuals. The exceptional short-term extension process is applicable to CMR intervals. It should not
be confused with the operator’s ‘short-term escalation’ program for normal maintenance tasks described in
the operators’ manuals.
(1) The term ‘"exceptional short-term extension"’ is defined as an increase in a CMR interval which
that may be needed to cover an uncontrollable or unexpected situation. Any allowable increase must
be defined either as a percentage of the normal interval, or a stated number of flight hours, flight
cycles, or calendar days. If no exceptional short-term extension is to be allowed for a given CMR, this
restriction should be stated in the applicant CMR documentation.
(2) Repeated use of exceptional short-term extensions, either on the same aeroplane or on similar
aeroplanes in an operator's fleet, should not be used as a substitute for good management practices.
Exceptional short-term extensions must not be used for fleet systematic CMR interval escalation.
(3) The applicant CMR documentation should state that the Agency competent authority must
approve, prior to its use, any desired exceptional short-term extension not explicitly listed in the CMR
document.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 17 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
13 POST-CERTIFICATION CHANGES TO CMRs
Any post-certification changes to CMRs should be reviewed by the CMCC, and must be approved by the
Agency, which approved the type design.
a. Since the purpose of a CMR is to limit the exposure time to a given significant latent failure as part of an
engineering analysis of overall system reliability, instances of a CMR task repeatedly finding that no failure has
occurred may not be sufficient justification for deleting the task or increasing the time between repetitive
performances of the CMR task. In general, One Star CMRs are not good candidates for escalation under an
operator’s reliability programme. A One Star CMR task change or interval escalation could only be made if
world fleet service experience indicates that certain assumptions regarding component failure rates made
early during the engineering analysis were overly conservative, and a re-calculation of system reliability with
revised failure rates of certain components reveals that the task or interval may be changed. The introduction
of a new CMR or any change to an existing CMR should be reviewed by the same entities that were involved in
the process of CCMR/CMR determination (ref. paragraphs 10 and 11) at the time of initial certification.
To allow operators to manage their own maintenance programs, it is important that they be afforded the
same opportunity for participation they were afforded during the initial certification of the aeroplane.
b. The introduction of a new Any post-certification changes to CMRs or any change to an existing CMR should
must be reviewed approved by the Agency, same process used during initial certification. It is important that
operators be afforded the same opportunity to participate they received during the original certification of the
aeroplane, in order to allow the operators to manage their own maintenance programmes. which approved
the type design.
c. In the event that later data provide sufficient basis for a relaxation of a CMR (less restrictive actions to be
required), the change may be documented by a EASA-approved change to the CMR document. Since the
purpose of a CMR is to limit the exposure time to a given significant latent failure, or a given wearout, as part
of an engineering analysis of the overall system safety, instances of a CMR task repeatedly finding that no
failure has occurred may not be sufficient justification for deleting the task or increasing the time between
repetitive performances of the CMR task. In general, a CMR task change or interval escalation could only be
made if experience with aircraft fleet in service worldwide indicates that certain assumptions regarding
component failure rates made early during the engineering analysis were too conservative, and a recalculation
of the system’s reliability with revised failure rates of certain components reveals that the task or interval may
be changed.
d. If the requirements later data provides a sufficient basis for the relaxation of an existing CMR must be
increased (less restrictive actions to be performed required), it will be mandated by an airworthiness directive
(AD).the change may be documented by a revision to the applicant CMR documentation and approved by the
Agency.
e. After initial aeroplane certification, the only basis for adding a new CMR is in association with certification of
design changes. If the Agency determines that the requirements of an existing CMR must be increased (more
restrictive actions to be required), the new requirements will be mandated by an Airworthiness Directive (AD)
and the applicant CMR documentation will be revised to include the change.
f. A Nnew CMRs that are unrelated to in-service events may be created as part of a design change should be a
part of the approved data for th at change, and added to the CMR document. and they should be documented
and approved by the Agency. New CMRs can arise in situations such as:
(1) Certification of design changes, or
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 18 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
(2) Updates to the applicant’s certification compliance documentation. These may result from
regulation changes, AD actions on similar systems or aeroplanes, awareness of additional hazardous or
catastrophic failure conditions, revised failure rates, consideration of extended service goals, etc.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 19 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
APPENDIX 1
SUPPLEMENTAL GUIDANCE FOR USE OF CMRs USE
The underlying goal of any system design should be an absolute minimum number of CMRs, with none as the
goal. However the final determination of system design, and ul timately the number of CMRs, after safety and
reliability are assured, should be based on the total cost of ownership of the system (or the aeroplane), with
due regard to weight, reliability, initial and recurring costs.
1. The manufacturer should choose a system design that minimises the number of significant latent failures,
with the ultimate goal being that no such failures exist if it is practical to do so. A practical and reliable failure
monitoring and indication system should be considered as the first means to detect the significant latent
failure. If the cost of adding practical and reliable failure monitoring and/or warning to a indication system is
high, and the added maintenance burden cost of a CMR is low, addition of a CMR may be the solution of
choice for both the type certificate applicant and the operator, provided all applicable regulations are met.
Substituting a CMR with an MRBR task does not necessarily reduce maintenance costs.
2. The decision to create a CMR should may include a rigorous trade-off of the cost, weight, or complexity of
providing an alerting mechanism or device that will expose detect the latent failure, versus the requirement
for the operator to conduct a maintenance or inspection task at fixed intervals.
3. The following points should be considered in any decision to create a CMR in lieu of design change:
a. What is the magnitude of the changes to the system and/or aeroplane needed to add a reliable failure
monitoring or warning device and indication system that would expose detect the hidden failure? What is
the cost in added system complexity?
b. Is it possible to introduce a self-test on power-up?
c. Is the failure monitoring and warning indication system reliable? False warnings must be considered, as
well as a lack of warnings.
d. Does the failure monitoring and warning indication system itself need a CMR due to its latent failure
potential?
(…)
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 20 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
APPENDIX 2
ROLE OF THE CERTIFICATION MAINTENANCE COORDINATION COMMITTEE (CMCC)
1. The CMCC functions as an advisory committee for the applicant and proposes the disposition of each
presented CCMR. The Agency is the authority that ultimately approves CMRs as operating limitations of
the type certificate as per Part-21.
2. In order to grant aeroplane operators the opportunity to participate in the selection of CMRs, and to
assess the CCMRs and the proposed MRBR tasks and intervals in an integrated process, the applicant
should convene a CMCC as early as possible in the design phase of the aeroplane program, and at
intervals as necessary. This CMCC should comprise manufacturer representatives (typically
maintenance, design, and safety engineering personnel), operator representatives designated by the
Industry Steering Committee (ISC) chairperson, Agency certification specialist(s), and the MRB
chairperson(s). The Agency certification specialist(s) participation in the CMCC is necessary to provide
regulatory guidance to the disposition of CCMRs.
3. The CMCC should review CCMRs and their purposes, the failure conditions and their classifications, the
intended tasks and their intervals, and other relevant factors. In addition, where multiple tasks result
from a quantitative analysis, it may be possible to extend a given interval at the expense of one or more
other intervals, in order to optimise the required maintenance activity. However, once a decision is
made to create a CMR, then the CMR interval should be based solely on the results of the SSA. In the
case where the SSA does not specify an interval shorter than the life of the aeroplane, then the CMR
interval may be proposed by CMCC considering factors that influence the outcome of the failure
condition, such as the nature of the fault, the system(s) affected, field experience, or task
characteristics.
4. The CMCC should address all CCMRs. Alternatively, the applicant may coordinate with the Agency to
define a subset of CCMRs to be presented to the CMCC.
5. The CMCC discusses compatible tasks (if any) that the MRB generated. The CMCC may select an MRBR
task in lieu of a CMR in accordance with paragraph 11 of this AMC.
6. The CMCC may request the ISC to review selected CMCC results (e.g. proposed revised MRBR tasks
and/or intervals). Upon ISC review, the proposed revised MRBR tasks and/or intervals accepted by the
ISC are reflected in the MRBR proposal, and the proposed revised MRBR tasks and/or intervals rejected
by the ISC result in CMRs. Following the ISC’s consideration, the applicant submits the CMRs to the
Agency for final review and approval.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 21 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
APPENDIX 3
MEANS OF PROTECTION AGAINST FUTURE EVOLUTIONS
PROPOSED BY THE DESIGN APPROVAL HOLDER (DAH) — EXAMPLES
1. With reference to paragraph 11.c, this Appendix provides examples to facilitate the implementation of
the means to ensure that the SSA assumptions are protected against unintentional changes during
service.
2. These examples describe acceptable means, but not the only means. Any means should be presented to
the Agency for acceptance.
EXAMPLE 1 — Publishing the CCMRs as airworthiness limitations
a. The CMR designation may not be necessary if there is a compatible MRBR task to accommodate the
CCMR, provided that the DAH publishes the CCMR as an airworthiness limitation.
b. The compatible MRBR task and its interval are not airworthiness limitations. The status of the
compatible MRBR task with regard to the MRB process remains unchanged.
c. Traceability between the CCMR and the compatible MRBR task should be provided in the Airworthiness
Limitations Section (ALS) of the Instructions for Continued Airworthiness to ensure that the CCMR is
respected during in-service operation of the aircraft and future evolution of the maintenance program.
Table 1 illustrates one possible means for traceability.
CCMR task reference CCMR interval Compatible MRBR task reference
CCMR task #NN 60 months MRBR task #XX
CCMR task #MM 10 000 FH MRBR task #YY
… … …
Appendix 3 — Table 1
d. Should the DAH change the compatible MRBR task to the extent that the corresponding CCMR task
intent is adversely affected, this corresponding CCMR task is not accommodated anymore. Therefore,
the DAH could either propose to change the compatible MRBR reference, if feasible, or create a new
CMR in line with the intent of the previously referenced CCMR limitation. These changes to the ALS
require Agency approval.
e. Should the DAH escalate the interval of the compatible MRBR task beyond the corresponding CCMR
limitation, this corresponding CCMR is not accommodated anymore and the DAH needs to create a CMR
in order to satisfy the corresponding CCMR limitation. Alternatively, the DAH could assess the feasibility
of escalation of the interval of the corresponding CCMR by re-evaluating the system safety assumptions
that lead to the CCMR at the time of initial certification. These changes to the ALS require Agency
approval.
f. Furthermore, the DAH shall describe in the ALS what the operator needs to observe when changing the
operator’s aircraft maintenance program (AMP). For tasks included in AMP, which are based on
compatible MRBR tasks, the following applies:
1. Should the operator propose to change a task to the extent that the corresponding CCMR task
intent is adversely affected, this corresponding CCMR task is not accommodated anymore.
Therefore, the operator needs to propose to include a mandatory task in the AMP in order to
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 22 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
3. Proposed amendments
satisfy the intent of the referenced CCMR limitation. These changes to the AMP require approval
of the competent authority responsible for the oversight of the operator.
2. Should the operator propose to escalate the interval of a task, the corresponding CCMR limitation
must not be exceeded.
EXAMPLE 2 — Uniquely identifying the compatible MRBR tasks
a. The CMR designation may not be necessary if there is a compatible MRBR task to accommodate the
CCMR, provided that the DAH uniquely identified each compatible MRBR task in the existing MRBR task
listing. Table 2 illustrates one possible means for marking.
Failure effect Interval Tracking
MRBR task reference MRBR task description
category (FEC)
MRBR task #XX Functional check of […] FEC 8 60 months
MRBR task #YY Detailed inspection of […] - 72 months EWIS
MRBR task #ZZ Operational check of […] FEC 8 10 000 FH CCMR
… … … … …
Appendix 3 — Table 2
b. The purpose of the marking and the policies to be observed for appropriate change control of the
marked MRBR tasks should be stated in the MRB report.
c. The status of the compatible MRBR task with regard to the MRB process remains unchanged.
d. Should the DAH change the marked MRBR task to the extent that the corresponding CCMR task intent is
adversely affected, the DAH needs to create a CMR to satisfy the initial CCMR task intent. This change to
the ALS requires Agency approval.
e. For future escalations of MRBR tasks, the DAH should have procedures in place to ensure that these
escalations do not increase the interval of the marked MRBR task beyond the corresponding CCMR
interval.
f. However, should the DAH escalate the marked MRBR task beyond the CCMR interval, the DAH needs to
create a CMR in order to satisfy the corresponding CCMR. This change to the ALS requires Agency
approval. Alternatively, the DAH could assess the feasibility of escalation of the interval of the
corresponding CCMR by re-evaluating the system safety assumptions that lead to the CCMR at the time
of initial certification. This change to the CCMR interval requires Agency involvement in accordance with
the process described in paragraph 11.
g. Furthermore, the DAH shall describe in the MRBR what the operator needs to observe when changing
the operator’s aircraft maintenance program (AMP). For tasks included in the AMP, which are based on
marked MRBR tasks, the following applies:
1. Should the operator propose to change a task intent, the operator should ask for the DAH’s
confirmation that this change does not adversely affect the corresponding CCMR task intent.
These changes to the AMP require approval of the competent authority responsible for the
oversight of the operator.
2. Should the operator propose to escalate the interval of a task, the operator should ask for the
DAH’s confirmation that this escalation does not increase the interval beyond the corresponding
CCMR interval. These changes to the AMP require approval of the competent authority
responsible for the oversight of the operator.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 23 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA)
4. Regulatory impact assessment (RIA)
This NPA does not propose new requirements for applicants. It addresses a regulatory coordination
issue related to the harmonisation of the current EASA AMC 25-19 with the FAA AC 25-19A in relation
to CMRs, and proposes an amendment to CS-25 (which includes a revision of AMC 25-19).
There is, therefore, no need to develop any RIA.
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 24 of 25
An agency of the European Union
European Aviation Safety Agency NPA 2016-15
5. References
5. References
5.1. Affected CSs, AMC and GM
— Decision No. 2003/2/RM of the Executive Director of the European Aviation Safety Agency of
17 October 2003 on certification specifications, including airworthiness codes and acceptable
means of compliance, for large aeroplanes (« CS-25 »), as amended
5.2. Reference documents
— FAA Advisory Circular 25-19A ‘Certification Maintenance Requirements’
TE.RPRO.00034-004 © European Aviation Safety Agency. All rights reserved. ISO 9001 certified.
Proprietary document. Copies are not controlled. Confirm revision status through the EASA intranet/internet. Page 25 of 25
An agency of the European Union