Brussels, 1 October 2021
Dear Finance Minister,
CAN Europe recommendations on ECOFIN Council Conclusions on Climate Finance
On Tuesday 5 October 2021 you will adopt Council Conclusions on climate finance at Economic
and Financial Affairs Council. The EU and each of its Member States should get behind a
political outcome at COP26 that advances a fair approach to 1.5°C (Fair for 1.5°C). Finance is a
key component of this. Delivery on the $100 billion climate finance goal, new finance
commitments and fair negotiation outcomes on finance are needed to unlock global action to
keep 1.5°C within reach, to support developing countries deliver their climate plans and adapt to
increasing impacts, and to progress the negotiations. With women and low income communities
in developing countries hardest hit by climate impacts, finance must also be targeted and
responsive to their needs.
Recent IPCC reports and the UNFCCC NDC Synthesis report have outlined the urgency for
action. Climate finance commitments should aim to address the clear emissions, adaptation and
finance gaps to limiting temperature rise, adapting, and addressing losses and damages, and
put an end to financing that undermines Paris Agreement goals. Taking timely action on finance
and investments now will reduce economic and non-economic costs from the increasing
impacts of climate change, reduce the risk of stranded assets and economic shocks, and
support sustainable development: benefits of early action clearly outweigh the costs of inaction.
Moreover developing countries are facing debt distress which has been exacerbated by the
COVID-19 and the climate crises. Strong action on debt is necessary to enable a global green
recovery. The EU should aim to support the achievement of the $100 billion in a manner that is
sensitive to this, commit to substantially increase grant financing and commit to only using
highly concessional loans, as well as take action on debt relief.
To address these issues we would like to call on the EU and its Member States to:
- Support a clear and reliable climate finance delivery plan underpinned by commitments
including from the EU and its Member States which ensures delivery of at least USD
600bn of climate finance over the 2020-2025 period, with at least 50% going to adapta-
tion; the plan must spell out a clear commitment to reaching $50 billion for adaptation fi-
nance annually; and ensure that finance is delivered exclusively on concessional terms,
with a majority provided as grants
- To rebuild trust EU Member States should commit to further increases in climate finance
to ensure they deliver their fair share by 2025, setting out increases in finance that are
new and additional, including a timebound commitment to achieve at least 50% adapta-
tion finance, and with improvements to gender-responsiveness
Climate Action Network Europe asbl Climate Action Network (CAN) Europe is Europe's leading NGO coalition
Rue d’Edimbourg 26, 1050 Brussels, Belgium fighting dangerous climate change. With over 170 member organisations
Tel: +32 (0) 2 89 44 670 from 38 European countries, representing over 1.500 NGOs and more
E-mail:
[email protected] than 47 million citizens, CAN Europe promotes sustainable climate,
www.caneurope.org energy and development policies throughout Europe.
- On loss and damage, the EU should advance a timely and full operationalisation of the
Santiago Network through a COP decision on loss and damage and in the framework of
the UNFCCC, and support a mandate to pursue work on sources for new and additional
finance
- Learning lessons on the $100 billion goal to inform deliberations on the new post-2025
climate finance goal, the EU should support a proper assessment of how to reflect, and
respond to, the different needs, including in scope and nature, by setting up specific sub-
goals of adaptation, mitigation, and loss and damage finance
- EU Member States and public financial institutions should immediately rule out any new
direct and indirect international public finance, to coal, oil and gas projects across the
entire value chain (extraction, transport, distribution and power generation and associ-
ated infrastructure), including through export credit agencies.
More details of CAN Europe’s specific recommendations are provided in an annex to this letter.
We also call on the EU to explicitly welcome and support the recent V20 Climate Vulnerables’
Finance Summit outcomes, and to support the COP 26: A Five Point Plan for Solidarity,
Prosperity and Fairness.
We hope that you can take these recommendations into consideration,
Yours sincerely,
Wendel Trio
Director, CAN Europe
Climate Action Network Europe asbl
www.caneurope.org
Annex: CAN Europe recommendations to the EU on climate finance
for COP26
The $100 billion climate finance commitment
For the COP to deliver credible progress on climate action it will be important to see clear
commitments by all developed countries, including the EU, to demonstrate when the USD
$100bn goal will be met, going beyond the Article 9.5 reports, and that the goal will be met and
exceeded through to 2025, and how developed countries will compensate for the money they
haven’t delivered.
A recent OECD Report indicated climate finance provided and mobilised in 2019 at $79.6 billion
and adaptation at 25% of this showing that contributor countries are off-track to deliver on the
USD $100 billion by 2020. The “delivery plan” worked on by ministers from Germany and
Canada will therefore be essential in terms of re-building trust in developed countries’
commitments and should be delivered well before COP26.
CAN supports an approach where developed countries commit to a multi-year pledge of $500bn
over 2020-24, as the V20 has suggested, and $600bn over 6 years when the year 2025 is
included. The plan must provide clear articulation of how the aggregate will be met by achieving
well beyond $100bn a year between 2022-2025 to make up for earlier gaps.
As the UNSG has rightfully pointed out, 50% of all climate finance must go to adaptation, which
is also agreed in the Paris Agreement where countries commit to balancing climate finance for
adaptation and mitigation. This means that the delivery plan must spell out a clear commitment
to reaching $50 billion for adaptation finance annually, ensuring that this is delivered exclusively
on concessional terms, with a majority provided as grants.e
The plan should also include a special focus on delivering finance to Least Developed Countries
(LDCs), Small Island Developing States (SIDSs) and strengthening gender responsiveness.
New climate finance commitments from EU Member States and institutions
The Commission President’s announcement of a further €4 billion from 2021-27 for international
climate finance was an important signal, and she rightly called for more international action.
Coming from the EU budget this finance is not new and additional. The EU should ensure that
this extra money goes to support adaptation, which can offer multiple development co-benefits
and prevent costs from future climate impacts. All contributors now need to do their bit. EU
Member States should announce, before COP26, new pledges for increasing climate finance
levels in line with their fairshare. All climate finance must be new and additional (ie. on top of
ODA commitments), include increased proportions of adaptation finance to address the
adaptation finance gap, and strengthen their gender responsiveness. We welcome the
commitments of a number of EU Member States via the Champions Group on Adaptation
Finance, and call on more countries to make specific time-bound commitments to achieve at
Climate Action Network Europe asbl
www.caneurope.org
least 50% of their overall reported climate finance as adaptation, and to increase grants-based
public finance. This should also inform the creation of the new branch of the EIB focused on
development finance, which should commit to achieving 50% adaptation finance in order to
become a ‘development climate bank’.
New sources of international climate finance from the EU should include revenues from
environmental, carbon and other forms of taxation, which have a huge role to play in
incentivising polluters to reduce emissions. Revenues from carbon pricing and taxation in the
‘Fit for 55%’ package, including from the Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism, the Energy
Taxation Directive, and the Emissions Trading System should be earmarked to provide new and
additional sources of climate finance to scale up climate finance to developing countries as well
as support a just transition towards a climate-neutral society in Europe. Direct or indirect fuel
subsidies in all sectors including, energy generation, maritime transport, aviation and fisheries
should also be eliminated and the finance channeled into climate finance.1
Deliberations on the Post-2025 goal
CAN Europe looks forward to the initiation of deliberations on setting the new post-2025
collective quantified goal on climate finance. In our view this should allow for proper assessment
of how to reflect, and respond to, the different needs, including in scope and nature, by setting
up specific subgoals of adaptation, mitigation, and loss and damage finance. The process
should also lead to clear definitions of climate finance and to strict reporting rules so as to
ensure that the goal is not undermined by over-reporting. The EU should play a progressive role
in generating a procedural decision on the process around the post-2025 goal at COP26 that
will in its scope, structure and components answer to the specific and different financing needs
for adaptation, mitigation and loss and damage in different contexts, including by:
● designing a goal matrix rather than a single number, with sub-targets for specific
purposes (including a sub-target on adaptation, loss and damage, financial
instruments and other elements)
● considering qualitative elements or sub-goals
● allocations are determined on a science- and developing country needs-basis
● Ensure that the room for creative accounting is minimized - fossil fuels should never
again count as climate finance, only grant element of loans, guarantees etc. should
count, over-reporting by donors should be eliminated, and transparency ensured.
● Adding provisions to ensure regular adjustment of the goal to reflect changing
circumstances, needs and lessons learnt, e.g. in conjunction with the Global
Stocktake or the regular NDC enhancements.
1
59 NGOs and business organisations have called on the EU to use the review of the Energy Taxation Directive to
remove public subsidies to fossil fuel consumption https://stopfossilfuelsubsidies.eu/sffs-statement/
Climate Action Network Europe asbl
www.caneurope.org
Financing for Loss and Damage
The new EU Adaptation Strategy recognises the problem of increasing losses and damages
from climate impacts in the EU and internationally. Because of its significance and separate
anchoring in Article 8 of the Paris Agreement, loss and damage deserves distinct attention and
commitment to distinct outcomes in the EU’s positioning at the UNFCCC, and distinct financing
that is new and additional to existing commitments. Failing to address loss and damage in
developing countries only exacerbates debt distress, and pushes people further into poverty
when governments cannot afford to re-build. The EU should advance a timely and full
operationalisation of the Santiago Network through a COP decision on loss and damage and in
the framework of the UNFCCC, and support the following points:
● COP26 should give a clear mandate to the Warsaw International Mechanism’s Executive
Committee to undertake work on pursuing sources of finance (such as levies on air and
maritime transport, a climate damages tax on fossil fuel exploration) which could raise
new and additional finance for loss and damage at a scale addressing the needs of vul-
nerable developing countries.
● Adequate structure and funding for the Santiago Network on Loss and Damage: estab-
lishment of a secretariat/coordinating body that can adequately assist vulnerable devel-
oping countries, as well as sufficient funding - both for the network's operational capacity
and for catalysing action and support on L&D.
● The agenda balance, including a permanent agenda item on loss and damage from
COP26 onwards to operationalise Article 8 under the Paris Agreement, would demon-
strate the political will to move forward with solutions and will be a critical deliverable
which the EU should support.
Ending international public finance for fossil fuels
Urgent action is needed to ensure 2021 marks the end of international direct or indirect public
finance to fossil fuels including sectors such as maritime transport, aviation and fisheries. This
would free up significant support for clean energy and a just and equitable transition worldwide.
This is why 200+ organizations from over 40 countries have recently released a statement
calling on governments worldwide, including the EU, to accelerate action on this agenda.
Ahead of the Glasgow Climate Change Conference, governments and public finance institutions
- national and regional development banks, as well as export credit agencies - have a clear task
to promote a climate-safe, equitable transition towards clean energy. The EU, building on the
EIB’s Energy Lending Policy, and intentions in the Foreign Affairs Council Conclusion on
Climate and Energy Diplomacy (Jan 2021), should take decisive action to phase out all fossil
fuel finance and leverage similar action from other big emitters. The EU must utilise its role on
the boards of MDBs and DFIs, and at the G20, to leverage additional commitments to end fossil
fuel finance and deliver just transition plans from government coalitions. G20 countries must
commit to developing clear national roadmaps to phase out all fossil fuel subsidies (including tax
concessions, direct budgetary support, export credits and funds through bilateral and domestic
DFIs and MDBs) by 2025 at the latest, and align investments with the long-term goals of the
Paris Agreement. The EU must also ensure action on EU budget funds, delivering on ’do no
harm’ by ensuring no support goes to fossil gas or any other fossil fuel projects and associated
Climate Action Network Europe asbl
www.caneurope.org
infrastructure, in both its external action and domestic programmes. EU Member States and
public finance institutions should:
● Immediately rule out any new international public finance, to coal, oil and gas projects
across the entire value chain (extraction, transport, distribution and power generation),
including through export credit agencies.
● Avoid loopholes that allow indirect public finance for fossil fuels to continue through as-
sociated infrastructure, technical assistance, or financial intermediaries.
● Ensure a whole-of-government approach to ending public finance for fossil fuels as part
of efforts to align public finance with the Paris goals and improve transparency and re-
porting standards
● Re-channel international public finance for fossil fuels into international climate finance.
Global Green Recovery
With the EU having agreed its own recovery package with a stronger focus on climate action
and ‘do no harm’, it needs to take further action in multilateral spaces to support a global green
recovery. Putting the world on a 1.5 pathway requires meaningful debt relief and cancellation,
fixing the fiscal crisis facing developing countries, and enabling them to access capital to
facilitate green recovery and to meet climate and Agenda 2030 commitments. The EU should
work with the G7, G20, the Paris Club and multilateral development banks to find avenues to
achieve this, including Special Drawing Rights to support climate action from the IMF. Action is
also needed in these spaces to address barriers to adaptation and resilience investment. Many
climate vulnerable countries are also setting out visions and action plans on green recovery and
accompanying partnerships for cooperation and support, including the Climate Vulnerable
Forums’ V20 Summit and Communique, and the African Union’s Green Recovery Action Plan,
which would benefit from the EU’s engagement, and vice versa. The EU should also work
through the Coalition of Finance Ministers for Climate Action to foment discussion of new
approaches to meeting the needs of climate vulnerable countries.
Climate Action Network Europe asbl
www.caneurope.org
Saatja: Keit Pillak <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 04.10.2021 13:43
Adressaat: RAM Info <
[email protected]>
Teema: FW: CAN Europe letter: ECOFIN Council Conclusions Climate Finance
COP26
From:
[email protected] <
[email protected]> Sent:
Monday, October 4, 2021 1:24 PMTo: Rahandusminister
<
[email protected]>Subject: CAN Europe letter: ECOFIN Council Conclusions
Climate Finance COP26
To the attention of the Finance Minister,Please find attached a letter
from the Director of Climate Action Network Europe to the Minister
regarding the ECOFIN Council Meeting on Tuesday 5 October. You can find a
generic copy of the letter sent to all EU ministers .
Please get in touch should you have any questions.
Thanks and kind regards,
--
Rachel Simon - Climate & Development Policy Coordinator
Climate Action Network (CAN) Europe
**Please note I do not work on Fridays**
Due to the Corona pandemic, the CAN Europe team is tele-working. Please
contact me on my mobile.
Skype: rac.simon Mobile: +32 489716340 Find us online at and
on Twitter at
Climate Action Network (CAN) Europe is Europe's leading NGO coalition
fighting dangerous climate change. With over from 38 European countries,
representing over 1.500 NGOs and more than 47 millions citizens, CAN
Europe promotes sustainable climate, energy and development policies
throughout Europe.
Sent via