Finantsinspektsioon Meie 01.10.2021 nr 13-1.1/6843-1
[email protected]
Konsultatsioonidokument
Solventsus II paketi kohta
22. septembril 2022 avaldas Euroopa Komisjon Solventsus II paketi, mis sisaldab
ettepanekuid Solventsus II direktiivi muutmiseks ja uue kindlustusandjate finantsseisundi
taastamise ja kriisilahenduse direktiivi kehtestamiseks. Solventsus II pakett on leitav
järgmiselt lingilt: https://ec.europa.eu/info/publications/210922-solvency-2-
communication_en
Käesolev konsultatsioonidokumendi eesmärk on koondada seotud osapoolte esmased
arvamused esitatud ettepanekute kohta. Teiepoolse sisendi koostamise toetamiseks oleme
omalt poolt käesoleva kirja lisades 1 ja 2 esitanud küsimused üldise seisukoha kujundamiseks
ja võimalike mõjude hindamiseks.
Lisaks palume teil nimetada Finantsinspektsiooni esindajad, kes kuuluksid Solventsus II
menetluses siseriiklikku töörühma, aidates kujundada Eesti seisukohti enne EL nõukogu
kohtumisi ja kirjalikes menetlustes. Vastav koostöö on äärmiselt oluline, tagamaks, et
Solventsus II ja uued kriisimeetmed peegeldavad mh Eesti huve.
Lisades 3 ja 4 on tabelid, kuhu saate vajadusel lisada kõik muud tähelepanekud direktiivide
tekstides olevate sõnastuste kohta.
Palume tagasisidet hiljemalt 15. oktoobriks 2021.
Lugupidamisega
(allkirjastatud digitaalselt)
Siiri Tõniste
osakonnajuhataja
Suur-Ameerika 1 / 10122 Tallinn / 611 3558 /
[email protected] / www.rahandusministeerium.ee
registrikood 70000272
Lisa 1: Küsimused Solventsus II direktiivi muudatuste kohta.
Lisa 2: Küsimused kindlustusandjate finantsseisundi taastamise ja kriisilahenduse direktiivi
ettepaneku kohta.
Lisa 3. Kommentaaride tabel „IRR table ddl 20 10 2021“
Lisa 4. Kommentaaride tabel „Solvency table ddl 20 10 21“.
Kristiina Kubja 6113658,
[email protected]
2
LISA 1. Küsimused Solventsus II direktiivi muudatuste kohta.
Muudatuste eesmärk ja mõju
1. Milline on teie üldhinnang Solventsus II direktiivi muudatuste kohta?
Vastus:
2. Mis ulatuses mõjutavad direktiivi muudatused FI tegevust?
Vastus:
Proportsionaalsus
Artiklis 4 muudetakse piirmäärasid mikrokindlustusandjate määratlemiseks, kes Solventsus II
direktiivi kohaldamisalasse ei kuulu. Eesti kohaldab riigisisese otsuse kohaselt Solventsus II
reegleid kõikidele kindlustusandjatele.
3. Kas te nõustute direktiivi artiklis 4 esitatud piirmäärade muutmisega, mis laiemat pilti vaadates
tähendaks, et Euroopas on rohkem väikeseid kindlustusandjaid, kellele Solventsus II reeglid ei
pruugi kohalduda?
Vastus:
4. Kas teie hinnangul tuleks Solventsus II reegleid Eestis ka edaspidi kõikidele kindlustusandjatele
kohaldada? Kui mitte, siis millistele tingimustele vastav režiim võiks Eestis
mikrokindlustusandjatele kohalduda?
Vastus:
Artiklites 29a–29c on määratletud madala riskiprofiiliga kindlustusandja ja asjaolud, kuidas nende
suhtes proportsionaalsuse nõuded kohalduvad. Artikli 29d kohaselt saavad proportsionaalsust
rakendada järelevalveasutuse nõusolekul ka kindlustusandjad, kes ei ole madala profiiliga. Artiklis
29e on ette nähtud teavitamiskohustused.
5. Kas nõustuste artiklites 29a–29e kirjeldatud lähenemisega? Kas kirjeldatud protseduurid
proportsionaalsuse rakendamiseks on asjakohased ja selged? Kas kirjeldatud kriteeriumid on
asjakohased ja selged?
Vastus:
6. Kui palju on Eesti kindlustusandjaid, kes oleks viidatud kriteeriumide põhjal madala
riskiprofiiliga?
Vastus:
Uus artikkel 213a näeb ette proportsionaalsuse nõuete rakendamise kindlustusgrupi tasandil
(madala riskiprofiiliga grupi määratlemine).
7. Kas teil on tähelepanekuid viidatud artikli kohta? Kas teie hinnangul tuleks grupid jagada madala
riskiprofiiliga gruppideks?
Artikli 41 muudatusega lubatakse madala riskiprofiiliga kindlustusandja võtmeisikul täita mitut
võtmefunktsiooni. Samuti võivad nad artikli 45 kohaselt ORSA esitada aastase intervalli asemele
iga kahe aasta tagant (sama kehtib kaptiividele).
8. Kas nõustuste esitatud juhtimissüsteemi leevendustega?
3
Artikli 109 kohaselt võivad kindlustusandjad standardvalemi puhul kasutada lihtsustatud arvutusi.
9. Kas te toetate artikli 109 muudatusi?
Järelevalve kvaliteet
10. Kas nõustuste artikli 25 täiendusega, et igast tegevusloa andmise keeldumisest tuleb ka EIOPA-
t teavitada ning artikli 26 täiendusega, et tegevusloa andmisel saab ka ühishinnanguid otsuse
tegemisel anda?
Vastus:
Aruandlus
11. Kas teil on tähelepanekuid artikli 35 uue lõike 5a kohta?
Vastus:
Uus artikkel 35a peegeldab varem artikli 35 lõigetes 6-9 sätestatut, kuid kui järelevalveasutus
hindab edaspidi, kas anda aruannete esitamisel leevendusi, siis prioriteetsemad on madala
riskiprofiiliga kindlustusandjad (hetkesõnastus, et prioriteetsemad on väikesed ettevõtted). Lisaks
on ette nähtud leevendused kaptiividele.
12. Kui palju on FI seni rakendanud võimalust anda aruandluse esitamisel leevendusi vastavalt
KindlTS §-le 124?
Vastus:
13. Kas teil on tähelepanekuid uue artikli 35a kohta?
Vastus:
14. Kas teil on kommentaare artiklis 35b sätestatud tähtaegade osas?
Vastus:
15. Kas te pooldate solventsus ja finantsseisundi aruande osana oleva bilansiaruande auditeerimist
nii nagu on ette nähtud uutes artiklites 51a ja 256c?
Vastus:
16. Kas teie arvates on õige, et madala riskiprofiiliga kindlustusandjatel seda kohustust pole?
Vastus:
17. Mida arvate artikli 112 muudatusest, et kui kindlustusandja kasutab SCR arvutamisel
sisemudelit, siis ta peab esitama hinnangu SCR kohta ka standardvalemi põhjal? Kehtiv sõnastus,
et järelevalve võib nõuda selle esitamist. Mis on Eestis hetkeseis sisemudeli kasutamise või loa
taotlemise osas?
Vastus:
Pikaajalised garantiimeetmed
18. Artikli 77a ekstrapoleerimise sätted asendatakse uute sätetega. Kas on tähelepanekuid uue
meetodi osas?
Vastus:
4
19. Kas teil on kommentaare seoses artiklis 77d tehtavate muudatustega (volatiilsuse
kohandamine)?
Vastus:
20. Mis ulatuses võivad artiklite 77a ja 77d muudatused mõjutada Eesti kindlustusandjaid?
Vastus:
21. Mida arvate artikli 106 lõike 3 muudatusest, et senise 10% asemel võib sümmeetrilise
kohandamise tulemusel saadud aktsiariski kapitalinõude määr erineda kohandamata määrast 17%?
Vastus:
Makrousaldatavusnõuded
22. Mida arvate artikli 45 täiendustest seoses ORSA hindamise põhimõtetega ja artikli 132
täiendamisest seoses kindlustusandja investeerimisstrateegiatega (makromajanduslike aspektide
sisse toomine)?
Vastus:
Direktiivi on lisatud uued artiklid 144a–144c seoses likviidsusriski juhtimise ja järelevalveliste
meetmetega.
23. Mida arvate likviidsusplaani koostamise kohustusest? Kas nõustuste, et madala riskiprofiiliga
kindlustusandja seda koostama ei peaks?
Vastus:
24. Kas teil on tähelepanekuid seoses järelevalveasutuse võimalusega sekkuda, kui kindlustusandja
ei tegele nõuetekohaselt likviidsuse nõrkustega? Kas te nõustute välja pakutud järelevalve
õigustega?
Vastus:
25. Mida arvate järelevalvemeetmetest artiklis 144c erakorralise turuülese šoki tingimuste kohta?
Vastus:
Euroopa Rohekokkulepe
Direktiivis on uus artikkel 45, mille kohaselt peavad kindlustusandjad kindlaks määrama kõik
olulised kliimamuutustega seotud riskid ja vajaduse korral hindama pikaajaliste kliimamuutuste
stsenaariumide mõju endale. Madala riskiprofiiliga kindlustusandjad on stsenaariumianalüüsist
vabastatud.
26. Mida arvate uuest artiklist ja madala riskiprofiiliga kindlustusandjate välistamisest sellest
kohustusest?
Vastus:
Kindlustusgrupid
Ettepanek sisaldab ka mitmeid kindlustusgrupi järelevalve muudatusi, sealhulgas kindlustusgrupi
kapitalinõuete arvutusmeetodis.
27. Kas kindlustusgrupi järelevalve teemades on muudatusi, mida tahaksite eriti välja tuua?
Vastus:
5
Piiriülene järelevalve
Artiklis 33a on kasutusel termin „oluline piiriülene tegevus“ ehk kui kindlustusandja piiriülesed
kindlustusmaksed (sh filiaali kaudu) moodustavad rohkem kui 5% kogumaksetes.
28. Kui suur protsent Eesti kindlustusandjaid tegeleb olulise piiriülese tegevusega ettenähtud
määratluse järgi?
Vastus:
29. Mida arvate artiklis 159a sätestatud täiendavatest teabevahetamise nõuetest järelevalveasutuste
vahel ja kohapealsest ühis-kontrollist, kui kindlustusandja solventsuspositsioon tekitab host
järelevalveasutusele muret?
Vastus:
30. Mida arvate EIOPA rollist (kaasamine kohapealsesse kontrolli ja erimeelsuste lahendamine)
käesoleva artikli puhul?
Vastus:
Muu
31. Kas teil on täiendavaid tähelepanekuid seoses muudatustega, mis on tehtud Solventsus II
direktiivi, kuid pole eespool välja toodud?
Vastus:
LISA 2. Küsimused kindlustusandjate finantsseisundi taastamise ja kriisilahenduse direktiivi
ettepaneku kohta.
Direktiivi eesmärk
1. Kas nõustute üldiselt, et uus kriisilahenduse direktiiv on vajalik? Palun hinnata seda vajadust nii
Eesti kontekstis kui ka laiemalt, EL kindlustusandjate vaates (mh kellel võivad potentsiaalselt olla
Eesti kliendid).
Vastus:
Kriisilahendusasutus
2. Kõigi eelduste kohaselt tuleks kindlustuse kriisilahendusasutus analoogselt pangandusele FI
juurde. Kas te oskate praeguses etapis hinnata, mida see võiks tähendab FI-le seoses tööjõuressursi
ja kõikvõimalike kuludega? Hinnanguliselt mitu protsenti võiks tõusta kindlustusandjate
järelevalvetasud?
Vastus:
Proportsionaalsus
Artikli 4 kohaselt võib järelevalveasutus või kriisilahendusasutus määrata kindlustusandjad, kes
saavad teatud leevendusi seoses direktiivi kohaldamisega (nt kavade detailsusega).
3. Kas nõustute, et teatud kindlustusandjatele on ette nähtud leevendused (lõike 1 punktid a-d)?
Vastus:
6
4. Kas teil on ettepanekuid määratluse osas, kelle suhtes leevendused kohalduvad? Kas need
kriteeriumid peaksid direktiivi tasandil selgemad olema?
Vastus:
Kriisiennetuskavad
Ettepaneku artikli 5 kohaselt ei pea kriisiennetuskava koostama madala riskiprofiiliga
kindlustusandjad ja need, kes kuuluvad gruppi, mille puhul tehakse grupiülene kava. Ülejäänud
kindlustusandjate osas on pädeval asutusel otsustusõigus, kes kava koostavad, kuid lõpptulemus on,
et 80% turust peaks seda siiski koostama.
5. Mida arvate sellest, et 80% turust peab kava koostama või see võiks jääda täielikult järelevalve
otsustada, kes peaks kava koostama ja kes mitte, sõltumata protsendist? Kas nõustute, et kava ei pea
igal juhul koostama madala riskiprofiiliga kindlustusandjad ja need, kes kuuluvad gruppi?
Vastus:
6. Kas teil on ettepanekuid ennetuskava sisu osas?
Vastus:
7. Mida arvate sellest, et asjakohastel juhtudel (oluline piiriülene tegevus) edastab järelevalveasutus
need kavad ka host järelevalveasutusele?
Vastus:
8. Mida arvate järelevalveasutuse kohustusest kava hinnata ja õigusest võtta kasutusele vajalikud
meetmed, kui kava ei ole nõuetekohaselt koostatud (artikkel 6)? Kas kriisilahendusasutusel peaks
kava nõuetekohasuse hindamise osas suurem sõnaõigus olema?
Vastus:
Kriisilahenduskava
Artikli 9 kohaselt peavad kriisilahendusasutused iga kindlustusandja kohta koostama
kriisilahenduskava. Siiski on ette nähtud leevendus, et kava tuleks koostada 70% turu kohta,
sealjuures ei pea seda tegema madala riskiprofiiliga kindlustusandja ja gruppi kuuluva
kindlustusandja kohta.
9. Mida arvate kriisilahenduskava koostamise kohustusest ja välistustest, kelle kohta seda koostama
ei pea?
Vastus:
10. Kas teil on ettepanekuid kriisilahenduskava sisu osas?
Vastus:
Kriisilahenduskõlblikkus
11. Mida arvate artiklites 13-16 sätestatud kriisilahenduskõlbulikkuse hindamisest?
Vastus:
Kriisilahendus
12. Kas nõustuste, et kriisilahendus peaks käivituma ainult artiklites 19 ja 20 sätestatud
tingimustel?
7
Vastus:
Artiklites 23 ja 24 on ette nähtud kriisilahenduse eesmärgil väärtuse hindamise sätted ning nõuded
hindajale ja hindamisele.
13. Kas on tähelepanekuid seoses viidatud artiklitega?
Vastus:
Kriisilahendusmeetmed
Direktiivi artiklites 26–39 on sätestatud kriisilahendusmeetmed ja nõuded seoses nende
meetmetega.
14. Mida arvate solvent run off vahendist?
Vastus:
15. Mida arvate asset and liability separation vahendist?
Vastus:
16. Mida arvate sale of business vahendist?
Vastus:
17. Mida arvate the bridge undertaking vahendist?
Vastus:
18. Mida arvate the write-down or conversion vahendist?
Vastus:
Kriisilahendusasutuse õigused
19. Kas teil on ettepanekuid seoses artiklites 40–51 sätestatud kriisilahendusasutuse õigustega?
Vastus:
Kaitsemeetmed
20. Kas teie hinnangul on artiklites 53–60 sätestatud kaitsemeetmed piisavad või vastupidiselt
vajalikud?
Vastus:
Piiriülene kriisilahendus
21. Kas nõustute, et piiriülese kriislahenduse koordineerimiseks moodustatakse vastavad
kolleegiumid?
Vastus:
22. Kas teil on muid tähelepanekuid seoses piiriülese kriisilahendusega?
Vastus:
Üldine tähelepanek
23. Ettepanekus on palju eeskuju võetud panganduse kriisilahenduse mudelist. Kas teie hinnangul
on ettepanekus sätteid, mille puhul ei ole asjakohane võtta eeskuju pangandusest?
8
Vastus:
9
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2021/0295 (COD)
Proposal for a
DIRECTIVE OF THE EUROPEAN
PARLIAMENT AND OF THE COUNCIL
amending Directive 2009/138/EC as regards
proportionality, quality of supervision,
reporting, long-term guarantee measures,
macro-prudential tools, sustainability risks,
group and cross-border supervision
(Text with EEA relevance)
THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND THE
COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION,
Having regard to the Treaty on the Functioning
of the European Union, and in particular Article
53(1), Article 62 and Article 114 thereof,
1
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Having regard to the proposal from the
European Commission,
After transmission of the draft legislative act to
the national parliaments,
Having regard to the opinion of the European
Economic and Social Committee1,
Acting in accordance with the ordinary
legislative procedure,
Whereas:
(1) Directive 2009/138/EC of the European
Parliament and of the Council2 has created more
1
OJ C […], […], p. […].
2
Directive 2009/138/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 November 2009 on the taking-up and pursuit of the business of Insurance and Reinsurance
(Solvency II) (OJ L 335, 17.12.2009, p. 1.).
2
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
risk-based and more harmonised prudential
rules for the insurance and reinsurance sector.
Some of the provisions of that Directive are
subject to review clauses. The application of
that Directive has substantially contributed to
strengthening the financial system in the Union
and rendered insurance and reinsurance
undertakings more resilient to a variety of risks.
Although very comprehensive, that Directive
does not address all identified weaknesses
affecting insurance and reinsurance
undertakings.
(2) The Covid-19 pandemic has caused
tremendous socio-economic damage and left the
EU economy in need of a sustainable, inclusive
and fair recovery. This has made the work on
the Union’s political priorities even more
urgent, in particular ensuring that the economy
3
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
works for people and attaining the objectives of
the European Green Deal. The insurance and
reinsurance sector can provide private sources
of financing to European businesses and can
make the economy more resilient by supplying
protection against a wide range of risks. With
this dual role, the sector has a great potential to
contribute to the achievement of the Union’s
priorities.
(3) As underlined in the Commission’s
Communication of 24 September 2020 ‘A
Capital Markets Union for people and
businesses’3, incentivising institutional
investors, in particular insurers, to make more
long-term investments will be instrumental in
supporting re-equitisation in the corporate
sector. To facilitate insurers’ contribution to the
3
COM/2050/590 final
4
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
financing of the economic recovery of the
Union, the prudential framework should be
adjusted to better take into account the long-
term nature of the insurance business. In
particular, when calculating the Solvency
Capital Requirement under the standard
formula, the possibility to use a more favourable
standard parameter for equity investments
which are held with a long-term perspective
should be facilitated, provided that insurance
and reinsurance undertakings comply with
sound and robust criteria, that preserve
policyholder protection and financial stability.
Such criteria should aim to ensure that insurance
and reinsurance undertakings are able to avoid
forced selling of equities intended to be held for
the long term, including under stressed market
conditions.
5
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(4) In its Communication of 11 December
2019 on the European Green Deal4, the
Commission made a commitment to integrate
better into the Union’s prudential framework the
management of climate and environmental risks.
The European Green Deal is the Union’s new
growth strategy, which aims to transform the
Union into a modern, resource-efficient and
competitive economy with no net emissions of
greenhouse gases by 2050. It will contribute to
the objective of building an economy that works
for the people, strengthening the Union’s social
market economy, helping to ensure that it is
future-ready and that it delivers stability, jobs,
growth and investment. In its proposal of 4
March 2020 for a European Climate Law, the
Commission proposed to make the objective of
climate neutrality and climate resilience by 2050
4
COM(2019)640 final
6
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
binding in the Union. That proposal was
adopted by the European Parliament and by the
Council and it entered into force on 29 July
20215. The Commission’s ambition to ensure
global leadership by the EU on the path towards
2050 was reiterated in the 2021 Strategic
Foresight Report6, which identifies the building
of resilient and future-proof economic and
financial systems as a strategic area of action.
(5) The EU sustainable finance framework
will play a key role in meeting the targets of the
European Green Deal and environmental
regulation should be complemented by a
sustainable finance framework which channels
finance to investments that reduce exposure to
5
Regulation (EU) 2021/1119 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 June 2021 establishing the framework for achieving climate neutrality and amending
Regulations (EC) No 401/2009 and (EU) 2018/1999 (‘European Climate Law’) (OJ L 243, 9.7.2021, p. 1).
6
COM(2021)750 final
7
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
these climate and environmental risks. In its
Communication of 6 July 2021 on a Strategy for
Financing the Transition to a Sustainable
Economy7, the Commission committed to
propose amendments to Directive 2009/138/EC
to consistently integrate sustainability risks in
risk management of insurers by requiring
climate change scenario analysis by insurers.
(6) Directive 2009/138/EC excludes certain
undertakings from its scope, due to their size.
Following the first years of application of
Directive 2009/138/EC and with a view to
ensuring that it does not unduly apply to
undertakings of reduced size, it is appropriate to
review those exclusions by increasing those
thresholds, so that more small insurance
undertakings that fulfil certain conditions are
7
COM(2021)390
8
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
not subject to that Directive. However,
undertakings benefitting from such increased
thresholds should have the option to keep or
seek authorisation under Directive 2009/138/EC
in order to benefit from the single license
provided therein.
(7) Directive 2009/138/EC does not apply to
an assistance activity where the conditions of
Article 6(1) of that Directive are fulfilled. The
first condition states that the assistance is to be
related to accidents or breakdowns involving a
road vehicle which occurs in the territory of the
Member State of the undertaking providing
cover. That provision could mean a requirement
of authorisation as insurer for providers of
assistance of road vehicles in the event of an
accident or breakdown that occurs just across
the border and may unduly disrupt assistance.
9
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
For this reason, it is appropriate to review that
condition. Therefore, the condition under
Article 6(1), point (a), of Directive 2009/138/EC
should be also extended to accidents or
breakdowns, involving the road vehicle covered
by that undertaking, that occur occasionally in a
neighbouring country.
(8) Insurance and reinsurance undertakings
can submit an application for authorisation in
any Member State. Information on previous
applications and the outcomes of the assessment
of such applications could provide essential
information for the assessment of their
application. Therefore, the supervisory authority
should be informed by the applicant insurance
or reinsurance undertaking about previous
rejections or withdrawals of authorisation in
another Member State.
10
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(9) Prior to the granting of authorisation, the
supervisory authority of the home Member State
should consult the supervisory authorities of any
Member States concerned. In view of increased
cross-border insurance activities, it is necessary
to enhance the convergent application of Union
law in cases of cross-border insurance activity
and the exchange of information between the
supervisory authorities, in particular before
authorisations are granted. Therefore, where
several supervisory authorities need to be
consulted, any supervisory authority concerned
should be allowed to request a joint assessment
of an application for authorisation from the
supervisory authority of the Member State
where the authorisation process is ongoing.
11
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(10) Directive 2009/138/EC should be
applied in accordance with the proportionality
principle. To facilitate the proportionate
application of the Directive to undertakings
presenting a lower risk profile than the average
undertaking, and to ensure that they are not
subject to disproportionately burdensome
requirements, it is necessary to provide risk-
based criteria that allow for their identification.
(11) Undertakings complying with the risk-
based criteria should be able to be classified as
low-risk profile undertakings pursuant to a
simple notification process. Where, within one
month after such notification, the supervisory
authority does not oppose the classification for
duly justified reasons linked to the assessment
of the relevant criteria, that undertaking should
be deemed as low-risk profile undertaking.
12
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Once classified as a low-risk profile
undertaking, in principle, it should
automatically benefit from identified
proportionality measures on reporting,
governance, revision of written policies, own-
risk solvency assessment and disclosure
requirements.
(12) It is appropriate that proportionality
measures are available also to undertakings that
are not classified as low-risk profile
undertakings, but for which some of the
requirements of Directive 2009/138/EC are too
costly and complex, in view of the risks
involved in the business carried out by such
undertakings. Those undertakings should be
permitted to use proportionality measures based
on a case-by-case analysis and following prior
approval by their supervisory authorities.
13
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(13) A proper implementation of the
proportionality principle is crucial to avoiding
excessive burden on insurance and reinsurance
undertakings. Supervisory authorities need to be
regularly informed of the use of proportionality
measures. For this reason, insurance and
reinsurance undertakings should annually report
to their supervisory authorities information on
the proportionality measures they use.
(14) Captive insurance undertakings and
captive reinsurance undertakings which only
cover risks associated with the industrial or
commercial group to which they belong, present
a particular risk profile that should be taken into
account when defining some requirements, in
particular on own-risk and solvency assessment,
disclosures and the related empowerments for
14
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the Commission to further specify the rules on
such empowerments. Moreover, captive
insurance undertakings and captive reinsurance
undertakings should also be able to benefit from
the proportionality measures when they are
classified as low-risk profile undertakings.
(15) It is important that insurance and
reinsurance undertakings maintain a healthy
financial position. For that purpose, Directive
2009/138/EC provides for financial supervision
with respect to an undertaking’s state of
solvency, the establishment of technical
provisions, its assets and its eligible own funds.
However, the system of governance of an
undertaking is also an important factor in
ensuring that the undertaking maintains its
financial health. To that end, supervisory
authorities should be required to carry out
15
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
regular reviews and evaluations of the system of
governance as part of their financial supervision
of insurance and reinsurance undertakings.
(16) Cooperation between the supervisory
authority of the home Member State that
granted authorisation to an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking and the supervisory
authorities of the Member States where that
undertaking pursues activities by establishing
branches or by providing services, should be
strengthened in order to better prevent potential
problems and to enhance the protection of
policyholders across the Union. This
cooperation should include more information
coming from the supervisory authority of the
home Member State, in particular regarding the
outcome of the supervisory review process
related to the cross-border activity.
16
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(17) Supervisory authorities should be
entitled to receive from each supervised
insurance and reinsurance undertaking and their
groups, at least every three years, a regular
narrative report with information on the
business and performance, system of
governance, risk profile, capital management
and other relevant information for solvency
purposes. In order to simplify this reporting
requirement for insurance and reinsurance
groups, it should be possible, subject to certain
conditions, to submit the information of the
regular supervisory report relating to the group
and its subsidiaries in an aggregated way for the
whole group.
(18) It should be ensured that low-risk profile
undertakings are prioritised when supervisors
17
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
grant exemptions and limitations to reporting.
For this type of entities, the process of
notification that applies for the classification as
low-risk profile undertakings should ensure that
there is enough certainty as regards the use of
exemptions and limitations to reporting.
(19) Reporting and disclosure deadlines
should be clearly laid down in Directive
2009/138/EC. However, it should be recognised
that extraordinary circumstances such as
sanitary emergencies, natural catastrophes and
other extreme events could make it impossible
for insurance and reinsurance undertakings to
submit such reports and disclosures, within the
established deadlines. To this end, the
Commission should be empowered to extend the
deadlines under such circumstances.
18
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(20) Directive 2009/138/EC provides that
supervisory authorities are to assess whether any
new person appointed to manage an insurance
or reinsurance undertaking or to perform a key
function are fit and proper. However, those who
manage the undertaking or perform a key
function should be fit and proper on a
continuous basis. Supervisory authorities should
therefore have the power to react and, where
appropriate, to remove the person concerned
from the relevant position, in the case of non-
compliance with the fit and proper
requirements.
(21) As insurance activities may trigger or
amplify risks for financial stability, insurance
and reinsurance undertakings should incorporate
macroprudential considerations and analysis in
their investment and risk management activities.
19
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
This could include taking into account the
potential behaviour of other market participants,
macroeconomic risks, such as credit cycle
downturns or reduced market liquidity, or
excessive concentrations at market level in
certain asset types, counterparties or sectors.
(22) Insurance and reinsurance undertakings
should factor any relevant macroprudential
information provided by the supervisory
authorities in their own-risk and solvency
assessment. The supervisory authorities should
analyse the own-risk and solvency assessment
supervisory reports of undertakings within their
jurisdictions, aggregate them and provide input
to undertakings on the elements that should be
considered in their future own-risk and solvency
assessments, particularly as regards
macroprudential risks. Member States should
20
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
ensure that, where they entrust an authority with
a macroprudential mandate, the outcome and the
findings of macroprudential assessments by the
supervisory authorities are shared with that
macroprudential authority.
(23) In line with the Insurance Core
Principles adopted by the International
Association of Insurance Supervisors, national
supervisory authorities should be able to
identify, monitor and analyse market and
financial developments that may affect
insurance and reinsurance undertakings, and
insurance and reinsurance markets, and should
use that information in the supervision of
individual insurance or reinsurance
undertakings. Those tasks should, where
appropriate, use information from, and insights
gained by, other supervisory authorities.
21
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(24) Authorities with a macroprudential
mandate are in charge of the macroprudential
policy for their national insurance and
reinsurance market. The macroprudential policy
can be pursued by the supervisory authority or
by another authority or body entrusted with this
purpose.
(25) Good coordination between supervisory
authorities and the relevant bodies and
authorities with a macroprudential mandate is
important for identifying, monitoring and
analysing possible risks to the stability of the
financial system that may affect insurance and
reinsurance undertakings, and for taking
measures to effectively and appropriately
address those risks. Cooperation between
22
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
authorities should also aim to avoid any form of
duplicative or inconsistent actions.
(26) Directive 2009/138/EC requires
insurance and reinsurance undertakings to have,
as an integrated part of their business strategy, a
periodic own-risk and solvency assessment.
Some risks, such as climate change risks, are
difficult to quantify or they materialise over a
period that is longer than the one used for the
calibration of the Solvency Capital
Requirement. Those risks can be better taken
into account in the own-risk and solvency
assessment. Where insurance and reinsurance
undertakings have material exposure to climate
risks, they should be required to carry out,
within appropriate intervals and as part of the
own-risk and solvency assessment, analyses of
the impact of long-term climate change risk
23
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
scenarios on their business. Such analyses
should be proportionate to the nature, scale and
complexity of the risks inherent in the business
of the undertakings. In particular, while the
assessment of the materiality of exposure to
climate risks should be required from all
insurance and reinsurance undertakings, long-
term climate scenario analyses should not be
required for low-risk profile undertakings.
(27) Directive 2009/138/EC requires the
disclosure, at least, annually, of essential
information through the solvency and financial
condition report. That report has two main types
of addressees: policyholders and beneficiaries
on the one hand, and analysts and other market
participants on the other hand. In order to
address the needs and the expectations of those
two different groups, the content of the report
24
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
should be divided into two parts. The first part,
addressed mainly to policyholders and
beneficiaries, should contain the key
information on business, performance, capital
management and risk profile. The second part,
addressed to analysts and other market
participants, should contain detailed information
on the system of governance, specific
information on technical provisions and other
liabilities, the solvency position as well as other
data relevant for specialised analysts.
(28) It is possible for insurance and
reinsurance undertakings to adjust the relevant
risk-free interest rate term structure for the
calculation of the best estimate in line with the
spread movements of their assets after
supervisory approval (‘matching adjustment’) or
in line with the average spread movement of
25
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
assets held by insurance and reinsurance
undertakings in a given currency or country
(‘volatility adjustment’). The part of the
solvency and financial condition report
addressed to policyholders should only contain
the information that is expected to be relevant to
the decision-making of an average policyholder.
While insurance and reinsurance undertakings
should publicly disclose the impact of not
applying the matching adjustment, the volatility
adjustment and the transitional measures on
risk-free interest rates and on technical
provisions on their financial positions, such
disclosure should not be assumed to be relevant
to the decision-making of an average
policyholder. The impact of such measures
should therefore be disclosed in the part of the
solvency and financial condition report
26
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
addressed to market participants and not in the
part addressed to policyholders.
(29) Disclosure requirements should not be
excessively burdensome for insurance and
reinsurance undertakings. To this end, some
simplifications and proportionality measures
should be included in Directive 2009/138/EC, in
particular when they do not jeopardise the
readability of the data provided by insurance
and reinsurance undertakings.
(30) In order to guarantee the highest degree
of accuracy of the information disclosed to the
public, a substantial part of the solvency and
financial condition report should be subject to
audit. Such audit requirement should cover the
balance sheet assessed in accordance with the
27
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
valuation criteria set out in Directive
2009/138/EC.
(31) The burden of the auditing requirement
does not seem to be justified for low-risk profile
undertakings, which are not expected to be
relevant for the financial stability of the Union
and whose policyholders are not numerous. One
of the criteria that low-risk profile undertakings
are required to meet is that they be small in size.
To alleviate this burden, an exclusion from this
requirement should be granted.
(32) It should be acknowledged, that,
although beneficial, the auditing requirement
would be an additional burden for every
undertaking. Therefore, annual reporting and
disclosure deadlines for insurance and
reinsurance undertakings and for insurance and
28
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
reinsurance groups should be extended in order
to give those undertakings sufficient time to
produce audited reports.
(33) It should be ensured that the methods for
calculating technical provisions of contracts
with options on guarantee are proportionate to
the nature, scale and complexity of the risks
faced by the insurer. In this regard, some
simplifications should be provided.
(34) The determination of the relevant risk-
free interest rate term structure should balance
the use of information derived from relevant
financial instruments with the ability of
insurance and reinsurance undertakings to hedge
interest rates derived from financial instruments.
In particular, it can happen that smaller
insurance and reinsurance undertakings do not
29
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
have the capacities to hedge interest rate risk
with instruments other than bonds, loans or
similar assets with fixed cash-flows. The
relevant risk-free interest rate term structure
should therefore be extrapolated for maturities
where the markets for bonds are no longer deep,
liquid and transparent. However, the method for
the extrapolation should make use of
information derived from relevant financial
instruments other than bonds, where such
information is available from deep, liquid and
transparent markets for maturities where the
bond markets are no longer deep, liquid and
transparent. To ensure certainty and harmonised
application while also allowing for timely
reaction to changes in market conditions, the
Commission should adopt delegated acts to
specify how the new extrapolation method
should apply.
30
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(35) The determination of the relevant risk-
free interest rate term structure has a significant
impact on the solvency position in particular for
life insurance undertakings with long-term
liabilities. In order to avoid a disruption to the
existing insurance business and to allow for a
smooth transition to the new extrapolation
method, it is necessary to provide for a phasing
in measure and a transitional measure. The
transitional measures should aim to avoid
market disruption and provide a transparent path
to the final extrapolation method.
(36) Directive 2009/138/EC provides for a
volatility adjustment, which seeks to mitigate
the effect of exaggerations of bond spreads and
is based on reference portfolios for the relevant
currencies of insurance and reinsurance
31
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertakings and, in the case of the euro, on
reference portfolios for national insurance
markets. The use of a uniform volatility
adjustment for entire currencies or countries can
lead to benefits in excess of a mitigation of
exaggerated bond spreads, in particular where
the sensitivity of relevant assets of those
undertakings to changes in credit spreads is
lower than the sensitivity of the relevant best
estimate to changes in interest rates. In order to
avoid such excessive benefits from the volatility
adjustment, the volatility adjustment should be
subject to supervisory approval and its
calculation should take into account
undertaking-specific characteristics related to
the spread sensitivity of assets and the interest
rate sensitivity of the best estimate of technical
provisions. In light of the additional safeguards,
insurance and reinsurance undertakings should
32
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
be allowed to add up to an increased proportion
of 85% of the risk-corrected spread derived
from the representative portfolios to the basic
risk-free interest rate term structure.
(37) Directive 2009/138/EC provides for a
country component in the volatility adjustment
that aims to ensure that exaggerations of bond
spreads in a specific country are mitigated.
However, the activation of the country
component is based on an absolute threshold
and a relative threshold with respect to the risk-
adjusted spread of the country, which can lead
to cliff-edge effects and therefore increase the
volatility of own funds of insurance and
reinsurance undertakings. In order to ensure that
exaggerations of bond spreads in a specific
Member State whose currency is the euro are
mitigated effectively, the country component
33
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
should be replaced by a macro component
which is to be calculated based on the
differences between the risk adjusted spread for
the euro and the risk adjusted spread for the
country. In order to avoid cliff-edge effects, the
calculation should avoid discontinuities with
respect to the input parameters.
(38) In order to take account of developments
in the investment practices of insurance and
reinsurance undertakings, the Commission
should be empowered to adopt delegated acts to
set out criteria for the eligibility of assets to be
included in the assigned portfolio of assets
where the nature of the assets could lead to
diverging practices with respect to the criteria
for the application and the calculation of the
matching adjustment.
34
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(39) In order to ensure that the same
treatment is applied to all insurance and
reinsurance undertakings calculating the
volatility adjustment, or to take account of
market developments, the Commission should
be empowered to adopt delegated acts
specifying the calculation of undertaking-
specific elements of the volatility adjustment.
(40) For the purposes of calculating their own
funds under Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 of
the European Parliament and of the Council8,
institutions which belong to financial
conglomerates that are subject to Directive
2002/87/EC of the European Parliament and of
8
Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 June 2013 on prudential requirements for credit institutions and investment firms and
amending Regulation (EU) No 648/2012 (OJ L 176, 27.6.2013, p. 1).
35
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the Council9 may be permitted not to deduct
their significant investments in insurance or
reinsurance undertakings, provided that certain
criteria are met. There is a need to ensure that
prudential rules applicable to insurance or
reinsurance undertakings and credit institutions
allow for an appropriate level-playing field
between banking-led and insurance-led financial
groups. Therefore, insurance or reinsurance
undertakings should also be permitted not to
deduct from their eligible own funds
participations in credit and financial institutions,
subject to similar conditions. In particular, either
group supervision in accordance with Directive
2009/138/EC or supplementary supervision in
accordance with Directive 2002/87/EC should
9
Directive 2002/87/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 December 2002 on the supplementary supervision of credit institutions, insurance undertakings
and investment firms in a financial conglomerate and amending Council Directives 73/239/EEC, 79/267/EEC, 92/49/EEC, 92/96/EEC, 93/6/EEC and 93/22/EEC, and
Directives 98/78/EC and 2000/12/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council (OJ L 35, 11.2.2003, p. 1).
36
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
apply to a group encompassing both the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking and the
related institution. In addition, the institution
should be an equity investment of strategic
nature for the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking and supervisory authorities should
be satisfied as to the level of integrated
management, risk management and internal
controls regarding the entities in the scope of
group supervision or supplementary
supervision.
(41) The existing limits imposed on the level
of the symmetric adjustment restrict the ability
of this adjustment to mitigate potential pro-
cyclical effects of the financial system and to
avoid a situation in which insurance and
reinsurance undertakings are unduly forced to
raise additional capital or sell their investments
37
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
as a result of unsustained adverse movements in
financial markets, such as the ones triggered by
the Covid-19 pandemic. Therefore, the
symmetric adjustment should be amended so
that it allows for larger changes to the standard
equity capital charge and further mitigates the
impact of sharp increases or decreases in stock
markets.
(42) To enhance the proportionality within
the quantitative requirements, insurance and
reinsurance undertakings should be granted the
possibility to calculate the capital requirement
for immaterial risks in the standard formula with
a simplified approach for a period of no more
than three years. Such a simplified approach
should allow undertakings to estimate the
capital requirement for an immaterial risk on the
basis of an appropriate volume measure which
38
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
varies over time. This approach should be based
on common rules and subject to common
criteria for the identification of immaterial risks.
(43) Insurance and reinsurance undertakings
that use the matching adjustment have to
identify, organise and manage the assigned
portfolio of assets and obligations separately
from other parts of the business and should
therefore not be permitted to meet risks arising
elsewhere in the business using the assigned
portfolio of assets. However, the separated
management of the portfolio does not result in
an increase in correlation between the risks
within that portfolio and those within the rest of
the undertaking. Therefore, insurance and
reinsurance undertakings which use the
matching adjustment should be allowed to
calculate their Solvency Capital Requirement
39
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
based on the assumption of full diversification
between the assets and liabilities of the portfolio
and the rest of the undertaking, unless the
portfolios of assets covering a corresponding
best estimate of insurance or reinsurance
obligations form a ring-fenced fund.
(44) As part of the supervisory review
process, it is important for supervisory
authorities to be able to compare information
across the companies they supervise. Partial and
full internal models allow to capture the
individual risk of a company better and
Directive 2009/138/EC allows insurance and
reinsurance undertakings to use them for
determining capital requirements without
limitations stemming from the standard formula.
However, partial and full internal models make
comparisons across companies more difficult
40
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
and supervisory authorities would therefore
benefit from access to the outcome of the
calculation of standard formula capital
requirements. All insurance and reinsurance
undertakings should therefore regularly report
such information to their supervisors.
(45) Directive 2009/138/EC provides for the
possibility for insurance and reinsurance
undertakings to calculate their Solvency Capital
Requirement with an internal model subject to
supervisory approval. Where an internal model
is applied, that Directive does not prevent the
insurance and reinsurance undertaking from
taking into account the effect of credit spread
movements on the volatility adjustment in its
internal model. As the use of the volatility
adjustment can lead to benefits in excess of a
mitigation of exaggerated bond spreads in the
41
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
calculation of the best estimate, such excessive
benefits can also distort the calculation of the
Solvency Capital Requirement where the effect
of credit spread movements on the volatility
adjustment is taken into account in the internal
model. In order to avoid such distortion, the
Solvency Capital Requirement should be
floored, where supervisory authorities allow
insurance and reinsurance undertaking to take
into account the effect of credit spread
movements on the volatility adjustment in their
internal model, at a level below which benefits
on the Solvency Capital Requirement in excess
of a mitigation of exaggerated bond spreads are
expected to occur.
(46) Insurance and reinsurance undertakings
should be incentivised to build resilience for
crisis situations. Where insurance and
42
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
reinsurance undertakings take into account the
effect of credit spread movements on the
volatility adjustment in their internal model,
while also considering the effect of credit spread
movements on the macro volatility adjustment,
this could undermine in a severe manner any
incentives to build up resilience for crisis
situations. Insurance and reinsurance
undertakings should therefore be prevented
from taking into account a macro volatility
adjustment in their internal model.
(47) National supervisory authorities should
be able to collect relevant macroprudential
information on the investment strategy of
undertakings, analyse it together with other
relevant information that might be available
from other market sources, and incorporate a
macroprudential perspective in their supervision
43
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
of undertakings. This could include supervising
risks related to specific credit cycles, economic
downturns and collective or herding behaviour
in investments.
(48) Directive 2009/138/EC provides for an
extension of the recovery period in cases of
breaches of the Solvency Capital Requirement
where the European Insurance and Occupational
Pensions Authority (EIOPA) has declared the
existence of exceptional adverse situations. The
declarations can be made following requests by
national supervisory authorities, who are
required to consult the European Systemic Risk
Board (ESRB) where appropriate before the
request. The consultation with the ESRB in a
decentralised manner by national supervisory
authorities is less efficient than a consultation
with the ESRB in a centralised manner by
44
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
EIOPA. In order to ensure an efficient process,
it should be EIOPA, and not the national
supervisory authorities, that consults the ESRB
before the declaration of the existence of
exceptional adverse situations, where the nature
of the situation allows such prior consultation.
(49) Directive 2009/138/EC requires
insurance and reinsurance undertakings to
inform the supervisory authority concerned
immediately where they observe a failure to
comply, or a risk of non-compliance in the
following three months, with the Minimum
Capital Requirement. However, that Directive
does not specify when the non-compliance with
the Minimum Capital Requirement or the risk of
non-compliance in the following three months
can be observed and undertakings could delay
informing supervisory authorities until the end
45
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
of the relevant quarter when the calculation of
the Minimum Capital Requirement to be
formally reported to the supervisory authority
takes place. In order to ensure that supervisory
authorities receive timely information and are
able to take necessary action, insurance and
reinsurance undertakings should be required to
immediately inform the supervisory authorities
of a failure to comply with the Minimum
Capital Requirement or a risk of non-
compliance also where this has been observed
on the basis of estimations or calculations
between two dates of official calculations of the
Minimum Capital Requirement, in the relevant
quarter.
(50) The protection of the interests of insured
persons is a general objective of the prudential
framework that should be pursued by competent
46
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
supervisory authorities at every stage of the
supervisory process, including in case of
breaches or likely breaches of requirements by
insurance or reinsurance undertakings that may
give rise to the withdrawal of authorisation.
That objective should be pursued before the
withdrawal of authorisation, and in
consideration of any legal implication for
insured persons that may derive from it, after
the withdrawal of authorisation as well.
(51) National supervisory authorities should
be equipped with tools to prevent the
materialisation of risks for the financial stability
in insurance markets, limit pro-cyclical
behaviours by insurance and reinsurance
undertakings and mitigate negative spillover
effects within the financial system and into the
real economy.
47
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(52) Recent economic and financial crises, in
particular the crisis ensuing from the Covid-19
pandemic, have demonstrated that a sound
liquidity management by insurance and
reinsurance undertakings can prevent risks for
the stability of the financial system. For this
reason, insurance and reinsurance undertakings
should be required to strengthen liquidity
management and planning, especially in the
context of adverse situations affecting a large
part or the totality of the insurance and
reinsurance market.
(53) Whenever undertakings with particularly
vulnerable profiles, such as those having liquid
liabilities or holding illiquid assets, or with
liquidity vulnerabilities which can affect the
overall financial stability, do not appropriately
48
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
remedy the situation, national supervisory
authorities should be able to intervene to
reinforce their liquidity position.
(54) Supervisory authorities should have the
necessary powers to preserve the solvency
position of specific insurance or reinsurance
undertakings during exceptional situations such
as adverse economic or market events affecting
a large part or the totality of the insurance and
reinsurance market, in order to protect
policyholders and preserve financial stability.
Those powers should include the possibility to
restrict or suspend distributions to shareholders
and other subordinated lenders of a given
insurance or reinsurance undertaking before an
actual breach of the Solvency Capital
Requirement occurs. Those powers should be
applied on a case-by-case basis, respect
49
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
common risk-based criteria and not undermine
the functioning of the internal market.
(55) As the restriction or the suspension of
distribution of dividends and other bonuses
would affect, even on a temporary basis, the
rights of shareholders and other subordinated
creditors, supervisory authorities should duly
take into account the principle of proportionality
and necessity when taking such measures.
Supervisory authorities should also ensure that
none of the measures adopted entails
disproportionate adverse effects on the whole or
parts of the financial system in other Member
States or in the Union as a whole. In particular,
supervisory authorities should only restrict
capital distributions within an insurance and
reinsurance group in exceptional circumstances,
and when duly justified to preserve the stability
50
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
of the insurance market and of the financial
system as a whole.
(56) Recent failures of insurance and
reinsurance undertakings operating cross-border
have underlined the need for supervisory
authorities to be better informed on activities
conducted by undertakings. Therefore,
insurance and reinsurance undertakings should
be required to notify the supervisory authority
of their home Member State any material
changes affecting their risk profile in relation to
their ongoing cross-border insurance activities,
and that information should be shared with the
supervisory authorities of the host Member
States concerned.
(57) Under Directive 2009/138/EC, as
amended by Directive (EU) 2019/2177 of the
51
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
European Parliament and of the Council10,
EIOPA has the power to set up and coordinate
collaboration platforms to enhance collaboration
between the relevant supervisory authorities
where an insurance or reinsurance undertaking
carries out, or intends to carry out, activities
which are based on the freedom to provide
services or the freedom of establishment.
However, in view of the complexity of the
supervisory issues dealt with within those
platforms, in several cases, national supervisory
authorities fail to reach a common view on how
to address issues related to an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking which is operating on a
cross-border basis. In the event that the
supervisory authorities involved in the
10
Directive (EU) 2019/2177 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 18 December 2019 amending Directive 2009/138/EC on the taking-up and pursuit of the business
of Insurance and Reinsurance (Solvency II), Directive 2014/65/EU on markets in financial instruments and Directive (EU) 2015/849 on the prevention of the use of the
financial system for the purposes of money-laundering or terrorist financing (OJ L 334, 27.12.2019, p. 155).
52
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
collaboration platforms cannot reach an
agreement on issues related to an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking which is operating on a
cross-border basis, EIOPA should have the
power to settle the disagreement in accordance
with Article 19 of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010.
(58) Under Directive 2009/138/EC, insurance
or reinsurance undertakings are not required to
provide information on the conduct of their
business to the supervisory authorities of the
host Member States in a timely manner. Such
information may only be obtained by requesting
it to the supervisory authority of the home
Member State. However, such an approach does
not ensure access to information in a reasonable
period of time. Therefore, the supervisory
authorities of the host Member States, like the
53
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
supervisory authority of the home Member
State, should also have the power to directly
request information to insurance or reinsurance
undertakings in a timely manner.
(59) Where an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking carries out significant cross-border
activities in a host Member State, the
supervisory authority of that Member State
should have the power to request basic
information from the supervisory authority of
the home Member State on the solvency
position of that insurance or reinsurance
undertaking. Where the supervisory authority of
the host Member State has serious concerns
regarding that solvency position, it should have
the power to request the carrying out of a joint
on-site inspection together with the supervisory
authority of the home Member State, where
54
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
there is a significant non-compliance with the
Solvency Capital Requirement. EIOPA should
be invited to participate. In this regard, EIOPA
should indicate as soon as practicable whether it
intends to participate. Where supervisory
authorities disagree on the opportunity to carry
out a joint on-site inspection, EIOPA should
have the power to settle the disagreement in
accordance with Article 19 of Regulation (EU)
No 1094/2010.
(60) In order to be identified as an insurance
holding company, a parent company should in
particular have, as its main business, the
acquisition and holding of participations in
subsidiary undertakings, where those subsidiary
undertakings are exclusively or mainly
insurance or reinsurance undertakings, or
third‑country insurance or reinsurance
55
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertakings. Currently, supervisory authorities
have different interpretations as to the meaning
of “exclusively or mainly” in that context.
Therefore, a clarification of that concept should
be provided, similar to the clarification provided
in Regulation (EU) No 575/2013, as amended
by Regulation (EU) 2019/876 of the European
Parliament and of the Council11, for the banking
sector. Subsidiary undertakings should be
considered as “mainly insurance or reinsurance
undertakings or third-country insurance or
reinsurance undertakings” where such firms
represent more than 50% of the insurance
holding company’s equity, consolidated assets,
revenues, personnel or other indicator
11
Regulation (EU) 2019/876 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 May 2019 amending Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 as regards the leverage ratio, the net stable
funding ratio, requirements for own funds and eligible liabilities, counterparty credit risk, market risk, exposures to central counterparties, exposures to collective investment
undertakings, large exposures, reporting and disclosure requirements, and Regulation (EU) No 648/2012 (OJ L 150 7.6.2019, p. 1).
56
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
considered relevant by the supervisory
authority.
(61) In some cases, several insurance and
reinsurance undertakings form a de facto group
and behave as such, although they do not meet
the definition of a group as set out in Directive
2009/138/EC. Therefore, Title III of that
Directive does not apply to such insurance and
reinsurance undertakings. In such cases, in
particular for horizontal groups with no capital
links between different undertakings, the group
supervisors should have the power to identify
the existence of a group. Objective criteria
should also be provided to make such an
identification.
(62) Insurance and reinsurance groups are
free to decide on the specific internal
57
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
arrangements, distribution of tasks and
organisational structure within the group as they
see fit to ensure compliance with Directive
2009/138/EC. However, in a few cases, such
arrangements and organisational structures can
jeopardise effective group supervision.
Therefore, group supervisors should have the
power - in exceptional circumstances and after
consulting EIOPA and the other supervisory
authorities concerned - to require changes to
those arrangements or organisational structures.
Group supervisors should duly justify their
decision and explain why the existing
arrangements or structures obstruct and
jeopardise effective group supervision.
(63) Group supervisors may decide to
exclude an undertaking from group supervision,
in particular when such an undertaking is
58
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
deemed of negligible interest with respect to the
objectives of group supervision. EIOPA has
noted diverging interpretations on the criterion
of negligible interest, and has identified that, in
some cases, such exclusions result in complete
waivers of group supervision or in supervision
at the level of an intermediate parent company.
It is therefore necessary to clarify that such
cases should only occur in very exceptional
circumstances and that group supervisors should
consult EIOPA before making such decisions.
Criteria should also be introduced so that there
is more clarity as to what should be deemed as
negligible interest with respect to the objectives
of group supervision.
(64) There is a lack of clarity regarding the
types of undertakings for which Method 2,
namely a deduction and aggregation method as
59
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
defined in Article 233 of Directive
2009/138/EC, may be applied when calculating
group solvency, which is detrimental to the
level-playing field in the Union. Therefore, it
should be clearly specified which undertakings
may be included in the group solvency
calculation through Method 2. Such method
should only apply to insurance and reinsurance
undertakings, third‑country insurance and
reinsurance undertakings, undertakings
belonging to other financial sectors, mixed
financial holding companies, insurance holding
companies, and other parent undertakings the
main business of which is to acquire and hold
participations in subsidiary undertakings, where
those subsidiary undertakings are exclusively or
mainly insurance or reinsurance undertakings,
or third-country insurance or reinsurance
undertakings.
60
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(65) In some insurance or reinsurance groups,
an intermediate parent undertaking other than an
insurance or reinsurance undertaking or a third-
country insurance or reinsurance undertaking
acquires and holds participations in subsidiary
undertakings where those undertakings are
exclusively or mainly third-country insurance or
reinsurance undertakings. Under current rules, if
those intermediate parent undertakings do not
hold a participation in at least one insurance or
reinsurance subsidiary undertaking which has its
head office in the Union, they are not treated as
insurance holding companies for the purpose of
group solvency calculation, although the nature
of their risks are very similar. Therefore, rules
should be amended so that such holding
companies of third-country insurance or
reinsurance undertakings are treated in the same
61
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
manner as insurance holding companies for the
purpose of group solvency calculation.
(66) Directive 2009/138/EC, and
Commission Delegated Regulation (EU)
2015/3512 provide four methods of inclusion in
the group solvency calculation of undertakings
belonging to other financial sectors, including
methods 1 and 2 set out in Annex I to Directive
2002/87/EC. This leads to inconsistent
supervisory approaches and an uneven playing
field, and generates undue complexity.
Therefore, rules should be simplified so that
undertakings belonging to other financial
sectors always contribute to the group solvency
by using the relevant sectoral rules regarding the
calculation of own funds and capital
12
Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35 of 10 October 2014 supplementing Directive 2009/138/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council on the taking-up
and pursuit of the business of Insurance and Reinsurance (Solvency II) (OJ L 12, 17.1.2015, p. 1).
62
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
requirements. Those own funds and capital
requirements should simply be aggregated to the
own funds and capital requirements of the
insurance and reinsurance part of the group.
(67) Under current rules, participating
insurance and reinsurance undertakings are
granted limited possibilities to use simplified
calculations for the purpose of determining their
group solvency when method 1, namely
accounting consolidation-based method, is used.
This generates disproportionate burden, in
particular when groups hold participations in
related undertakings that are very small in size.
Therefore, subject to prior supervisory approval,
participating undertakings should be allowed to
integrate related undertakings whose size is
immaterial in their group solvency by using
simplified approaches.
63
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(68) The concept of encumbrance which
should be taken into account when classifying
own-fund items into tiers is not specified. In
particular, it is unclear how that concept applies
to insurance holding companies and mixed
financial holding companies which do not have
policyholders and beneficiaries as direct clients.
Therefore, minimum criteria should be
introduced to allow for the identification of
cases where an own-fund item issued by an
insurance holding company or a mixed financial
holding company is clear of encumbrances.
(69) The scope of the undertakings which
should be taken into account when calculating
the floor for the group Solvency Capital
Requirement should be consistent with the
scope of undertakings contributing to the
64
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
eligible own funds that are available to cover the
consolidated group Solvency Capital
Requirement. Therefore, when calculating the
floor, third-country insurance and reinsurance
undertakings, insurance holding companies,
third‑country insurance holding companies and
mixed financial holding companies should be
taken into account.
(70) The formula for calculating the
minimum consolidated group Solvency Capital
Requirement may lead to situations where that
minimum is close, or even equal, to the
consolidated group Solvency Capital
Requirement. In such cases, non-compliance
with that minimum may occur although
compliance with the consolidated group
Solvency Capital Requirement is ensured. Such
unintended consequence should be avoided.
65
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Therefore, the calculation formula should be
amended so that, similarly to individual
insurance and reinsurance undertakings, the
minimum consolidated group Solvency Capital
Requirement is never higher than 45% of the
consolidated group Solvency Capital
Requirement.
(71) For the purpose of group solvency
calculation, insurance holding companies and
mixed financial holding companies should be
treated as insurance or reinsurance undertakings.
This implies calculating notional capital
requirements for such undertakings. However,
such calculations should never imply that
insurance holding companies and mixed
financial holding companies are required to
comply with those notional capital requirements
at the individual level.
66
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(72) There is no legal provision specifying
how to calculate group solvency when a
combination of Method 1 and Method 2 is used.
This leads to inconsistent practices and
uncertainties, in particular in relation to the way
of calculating the contribution to the group
Solvency Capital Requirement of insurance and
reinsurance undertakings included through
Method 2. Therefore, it should be clarified how
group solvency is to be calculated when a
combination of methods is used. In order to
avoid material increases in capital requirements,
it should be clarified that, for the purpose of
calculating the consolidated group Solvency
Capital Requirement, no equity risk capital
charge is to be applied to such holdings. For the
same reason, currency risk charge should only
be applied to the value of those holdings that is
67
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
in excess of the Solvency Capital Requirements
of those related undertakings. Participating
insurance or reinsurance undertakings should be
allowed to take into account diversification
between that currency risks and other risks
underlying the calculation of the consolidated
group Solvency Capital Requirement.
(73) Currently, group supervisors may
determine thresholds above which intra-group
and risk concentration are deemed significant
based on Solvency Capital Requirements,
technical provisions, or both. However, other
risk-based quantitative or qualitative criteria, for
instance eligible own funds may also be
appropriate for determining the thresholds.
Therefore, group supervisors should have more
flexibility when defining a significant intra-
68
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
group transaction or a significant risk
concentration.
(74) Group supervisors may miss important
information on intra-group transactions that are
not required to be reported under current rules,
in particular those involving third-country
insurance and reinsurance undertakings,
insurance holding companies and mixed
financial holding companies. Therefore, the
definition of ‘intra-group transactions to be
reported’ should be reviewed. In addition, group
supervisors should have the power to tailor the
definition of ‘intra-group transactions to be
reported’ so that it better fits the specificities of
each group.
(75) Insurance holding companies and mixed
financial holding companies can be parent
69
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertakings of insurance or reinsurance groups.
In that case, the application of group supervision
is required on the basis of the consolidated
situation of such holding companies. As the
insurance or reinsurance undertakings controlled
by such holding companies are not always able
to ensure compliance with the requirements on
group supervision, it is necessary to ensure that
group supervisors have the appropriate
supervisory and enforcement powers to ensure
compliance by groups with Directive
2009/138/EC. Therefore, similar to amendments
to Directive 2013/36/EU of the European
Parliament and of the Council13 introduced by
Directive (EU) 2019/878 of the European
Parliament and of the Council14 for credit and
13
Directive 2013/36/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 June 2013 on access to the activity of credit institutions and the prudential supervision of credit
institutions and investment firms, amending Directive 2002/87/EC and repealing Directives 2006/48/EC and 2006/49/EC (OJ L 176, 27.6.2013, p. 338).
14
Directive (EU) 2019/878 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 20 May 2019 amending Directive 2013/36/EU as regards exempted entities, financial holding
companies, mixed financial holding companies, remuneration, supervisory measures and powers and capital conservation measures (OJ L 150, 7.6.2019, p. 253).
70
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
financial institutions, group supervisors should
have a minimum set of powers over holding
companies, including the general supervisory
powers that are applicable to insurance and
reinsurance undertakings for the purpose of
group supervision.
(76) Where insurance and reinsurance
undertakings are part of a group whose parent
undertaking has its head office in a third country
that is not deemed equivalent or temporarily
equivalent in accordance with Article 260 of
Directive 2009/138/EC, exercising group
supervision is more challenging. Group
supervisors may decide to apply so-called “other
methods” in accordance with Article 262 of that
Directive. However, those methods are not
clearly defined and the objectives that those
other methods should achieve are uncertain.
71
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Therefore, the purpose of the other methods
should be further specified, including a
minimum set of measures that group supervisors
should consider.
(77) Commission Delegated Regulation (EU)
2019/98115 introduced a preferential treatment
for long-term investments in equity. The
duration-based equity risk submodule, which
also aims at reflecting the lower risk of
investing over a longer time horizon, but is of
very limited use in the Union, is subject to
criteria that are stricter than those applicable to
long-term equity investments. Therefore, the
new prudential category of long-term equity
investments appears to obviate the need for the
existing duration-based equity risk submodule.
15
Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2019/981 of 8 March 2019 amending Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35 supplementing Directive 2009/138/EC of the European
Parliament and of the Council on the taking-up and pursuit of the business of Insurance and Reinsurance (Solvency II) (OJ L 161, 18.6.2019, p. 1).
72
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
As there is no need to keep two distinct
preferential treatments which have the same
objective of rewarding long-term investments,
the duration-based equity risk submodule should
be deleted. However, in order to avoid a
situation whereby those amendments lead to
adverse effects, a grandfathering clause should
be provided for with respect to insurers which
are currently applying the duration-based equity
risk submodule.
(78) Achieving the environmental and
climate ambitions of the Green Deal requires the
channelling of large amounts of investments
from the private sector, including from
insurance and reinsurance companies, towards
sustainable investments. The provisions of
Directive 2009/138/EC on the capital
requirements should not impede sustainable
73
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
investments by insurance and reinsurance
undertakings but should reflect the full risk of
investments in environmentally harmful
activities. While there is not sufficient evidence
at this stage on risk differentials between
environmentally or socially harmful and other
investments, such evidence may become
available over the next years. In order to ensure
an appropriate assessment of the relevant
evidence, EIOPA should monitor and report by
2023 on the evidence on the risk profile of
environmentally or socially harmful
investments. Where appropriate, EIOPA’s
report should advise on changes to Directive
2009/138/EC and to the delegated and
implementing acts adopted pursuant to that
Directive. EIOPA may also inquire whether it
would be appropriate that certain environmental
risks, other than climate change-related, should
74
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
be taken into account and how. For instance, if
evidence so suggests, EIOPA could analyse the
need for extending scenario analyses as
introduced by this Directive in the context of
climate change-related risks to other
environmental risks.
(79) Climate change is affecting and will
affect at least over the next decades the
frequency and severity of natural catastrophes
which are likely to further aggravate due to
environmental degradation and pollution. This
may also change the exposure of insurance and
reinsurance undertakings to natural catastrophe
risk and render invalid the standard parameters
for natural catastrophe risk set out in Delegated
Regulation (EU) 2015/35. In order to ensure that
there is no persistent discrepancy between the
standard parameters for natural catastrophe risk
75
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
and the actual exposure of insurance and
reinsurance companies to such risks, EIOPA
should review regularly the scope of the natural
catastrophe risk module and the calibrations of
its standard parameters. For that purpose,
EIOPA should take into account the latest
available evidence from climate science and,
where discrepancies are found, it should submit
an opinion to the Commission accordingly.
(80) The requirements set out in Article
308b(12) of Directive 2009/138/EC should be
amended to ensure consistency with the banking
framework and a level playing field in the
treatment of exposures to Member States'
central governments or central banks
denominated and funded in the domestic
currency of any Member State. For this purpose,
a grandfathering regime for such exposures
76
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
should be introduced to exempt the relevant
exposures from spread and market concentration
risk capital charges, provided that the exposures
were incurred before 1 January 2020.
(81) In some cases, insurance or reinsurance
groups heavily rely on the use of the transitional
measure on the risk-free interest rates and of the
transitional measure on technical provisions.
This may misrepresent the actual solvency
position of the group. Therefore, insurance or
reinsurance groups should be required to
disclose the impact on their solvency position of
assuming that own funds stemming from those
transitional measures are not available to cover
the group Solvency Capital Requirement.
Supervisory authorities should also have the
power to take appropriate measures so that the
use of the measures appropriately reflects the
77
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
financial position of the group. Those measures
should however not affect the use by related
insurance or reinsurance undertakings of those
transitional measures when calculating their
individual Solvency Capital Requirement.
(82) Directive 2009/138/EC provides for
transitional measures for the risk-free interest
rates and on technical provisions which are
subject to supervisory approval and which apply
with respect to contracts that give rise to the
insurance and reinsurance obligations that were
concluded before 2016. While the transitional
measures should encourage undertakings to
move as timely as possible towards compliance
with that Directive, the application of
transitional measures approved for the first time
long after 2016 are likely to slow down the path
to compliance with that Directive. Such
78
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
approval of the use of those transitional
measures should therefore be restricted to cases
where an insurance or reinsurance undertaking
becomes for the first time subject to the rules of
Directive 2009/138/EC and, where an
undertaking has accepted a portfolio of
insurance or reinsurance contracts and the
transferring undertaking applied a transitional
measure with respect to the obligations relating
to that portfolio, before the transfer.
(83) The United Kingdom became a third
country on 1 February 2020 and Union law
ceased to apply to and in the United Kingdom
on 31 December 2020. Given that Directive
2009/138/EC has several provisions that address
the specifics of particular Member States, where
such provisions specifically concern the United
79
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Kingdom, they have become obsolete and
should therefore be deleted.
(84) Directive 2009/138/EC should therefore
be amended accordingly,
HAVE ADOPTED THIS DIRECTIVE:
Article 1
Amendments to Directive 2009/138/EC
Directive 2009/138/EC is amended as follows:
(1) in Article 2(3), point (a) (iv) is replaced
by the following:
80
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘(iv) types of permanent health insurance not
subject to cancellation currently existing in
Ireland;’;
(2) in Article 4(1), points (a) and (b) are
replaced by the following:
‘(a) the undertaking’s annual gross written
premium does not exceed EUR 15 000 000;
(b) the total of the undertaking’s technical
provisions, gross of the amounts recoverable
from reinsurance contracts and special purpose
vehicles, as referred in Article 76, does not
exceed EUR 50 000 000;’;
(3) Article 6 is amended as follows:
81
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) In paragraph 1, point (a) is replaced by
the following:
‘(a) the assistance is provided in the event of an
accident or breakdown involving a road vehicle
when the accident or breakdown occurs in the
territory of the Member State of the undertaking
providing cover or neighbouring countries;’;
(b) paragraph 2 is replaced by the following:
‘2. In the cases referred to in paragraph 1, (b)(i)
and (b)(ii), the condition that the accident or
breakdown must have happened in the territory
of the Member State of the undertaking
providing cover shall not apply where the
beneficiary is a member of the body providing
cover and the breakdown service or conveyance
of the vehicle is provided simply on
82
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
presentation of a membership card, without any
additional premium being paid, by a similar
body in the country concerned on the basis of a
reciprocal agreement.’;
(c) paragraph 3 is deleted;
(4) in Article 8, point (3) is deleted;
(5) Article 13 is amended as follows:
(a) in point (7), point (b) is deleted;
(b) the following points (10a), (10b),
(10c) and (10d) are inserted:
‘(10a) ‘low-risk profile undertaking’ means an
insurance and reinsurance undertaking that
83
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
meets the conditions set out in Article 29a and
has been classified as such in accordance with
Article 29b;
(10b) ‘audit firm’ means an audit firm within
the meaning of Article 2, point (3), of Directive
2006/43/EC of the European Parliament and of
the Council*;
(10c) ‘statutory auditor’ means a statutory
auditor within the meaning of Article 2, point
(2) of Directive 2006/43/EC of the European
Parliament and of the Council*;
(10d) ‘low-risk profile group’ means a group
that complies with the conditions laid down in
Article 213a and has been classified as such by
the group supervisor pursuant to paragraph 2 of
that Article;
84
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
* Directive 2006/43/EC of the European Parliament and
of the Council of 17 May 2006 on statutory audits of
annual accounts and consolidated accounts, amending
Council Directives 78/660/EEC and 83/349/EEC and
repealing Council Directive 84/253/EEC (OJ L 157,
9.6.2006, p. 87).’;
(c) points (15) and (16) are replaced by the
following:
‘(15) ‘parent undertaking’ means a parent
undertaking as referred to in Article 22(1) and
(2) of Directive 2013/34/EU of the European
Parliament and of the Council*, as well as an
undertaking which supervisory authorities shall
consider as parent undertaking in accordance
with Article 212 of this Directive;
85
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘(16) ‘subsidiary undertaking’ means any
subsidiary undertaking as referred to in Article
22(1) and (2) of Directive 2013/34/EU,
including subsidiaries thereof, as well as an
undertaking which supervisory authorities are to
consider as subsidiary undertaking in
accordance with Article 212 of this Directive;
* Directive 2013/34/EU of the European
Parliament and of the Council of 26 June 2013 on the
annual financial statements, consolidated financial
statements and related reports of certain types of
undertakings, amending Directive 2006/43/EC of the
European Parliament and of the Council and repealing
Council Directives 78/660/EEC and 83/349/EEC (OJ L
182, 29.6.2013, p. 19).’;
(d) in point (18), the words ‘Article 1 of
Directive 83/349/EEC’ are replaced by the
86
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
words ‘Article 22(1) and (2) of Directive
2013/34/EU’;
(e) point (19) is replaced by the following:
‘(19) ‘intra-group transaction’ means any
transaction by which an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking, a third-country
insurance or reinsurance undertaking, an
insurance holding company or a mixed financial
holding company relies, either directly or
indirectly, on other undertakings within the
same group or on any natural or legal person
linked to the undertakings within that group by
close links, for the fulfilment of an obligation,
whether or not contractual, and whether or not
for payment;’;
(f) point (22) is amended as follows:
87
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(i) in point (a), the words ‘Article 4(1)(14)
of Directive 2004/39/EC’ are replaced by the
words ‘Article 4(1), point (21), of Directive
2014/65/EU of the European Parliament and of
the Council*;
___________________________________
* Directive 2014/65/EU of the European Parliament and
of the Council of 15 May 2014 on markets in financial
instruments and amending Directive 2002/92/EC and
Directive 2011/61/EU, (OJ L 173, 12.6.2014, p. 349).’;
(ii) in point (b)(i), the words ‘Directive
2004/39/EC’ are replaced by the words
‘Directive 2014/65/EU’;
(g) point (25) is amended as follows:
88
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(i) in point (a), the words ‘Article 4 (1), (5)
and (21) of Directive 2006/48/EC’ are replaced
by the words ‘Article 4(1), points (1), (18) and
(26), of Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 of the
European Parliament and of the Council*;
______________________________
* Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 of the European
Parliament and of the Council of 26 June 2013 on
prudential requirements for credit institutions and
investment firms and amending Regulation (EU) No
648/2012, (OJ L 176, 27.6.2013, p. 338).’;
(ii) in point (c), the words ‘Directive
2004/39/EC’ are replaced by the words
‘Directive 2014/65/EU’;
(h) point (27) is amended as follows:
89
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(i) in point (c), point (ii) is replaced by the
following:
‘(ii) a net turnover, within the meaning of
Article 2, point (5), of Directive 2013/34/EU, of
EUR 13 600 000;’;
(ii) the words ‘Directive 83/349/EEC’ are
replaced by the words ‘Directive 2013/34/EU’;
(i) the following point (41) is added:
‘(41) ‘regulated undertaking’ means ‘regulated
entity’ within the meaning of Article 2(4) of
Directive 2002/87/EC or an institution for
occupational retirement provision within the
meaning of Article 6(1) of Directive (EU)
2016/2341.’;
90
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(6) in Article 18(1), the following point (i) is
added:
‘(i) to indicate whether a request in another
Member State for an authorisation to take up the
business of direct insurance or reinsurance or to
take up the business of another regulated
undertaking or insurance distributor has been
rejected or withdrawn, and the reasons for the
rejection or withdrawal.’;
(7) in Article 23(1), the following point (f)
is added:
‘(f) the market where the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking concerned intends to
operate;’;
91
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(8) in Article 24(2), second subparagraph,
the words ‘Directive 2004/39/EC’ are replaced
by the words ‘Directive 2014/65/EU’;
(9) in Article 25, the following paragraph is
added:
‘Each refusal of an authorisation, including the
identification of the applicant undertaking and
the reasons for refusal shall be notified to the
European Supervisory Authority (European
Insurance and Occupational Pensions Authority)
(‘EIOPA’) established by Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010 of the European Parliament and of
the Council*. EIOPA shall keep an updated
database with such information and grant access
to the database to supervisory authorities.
92
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
*Regulation (EU) No 1094/2010 of the
European Parliament and of the Council of 24
November 2010 establishing a European
Supervisory Authority (European Insurance and
Occupational Pensions Authority), amending
Decision No 716/2009/EC and repealing
Commission Decision 2009/79/EC (OJ L 331,
15.12.2010, p. 48).’;
(10) in Article 25a, the words ‘the European
Supervisory Authority (European Insurance and
Occupational Pensions Authority) (‘EIOPA’)
established by Regulation (EU) No 1094/2010
of the European Parliament and of the Council6’
are replaced by the word ‘EIOPA’;
(11) in Article 26, the following paragraph 4
is added:
93
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘4. Where several supervisory authorities need
to be consulted pursuant to paragraph 1, any
supervisory authority concerned may request the
supervisory authority of the home Member State
to jointly assess the application for
authorisation. The supervisory authority of the
home Member State shall consider the
conclusions of the joint assessment when taking
its final decision.’;
(12) Article 29 is amended as follows:
(a) paragraphs 3 and 4 are replaced by the
following:
‘3. Member States shall ensure that the
requirements laid down in this Directive are
applied in a manner which is proportionate to
the nature, scale and complexity of the risks
94
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
inherent in the business of an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking, in particular those
classified as low-risk profile undertakings.
4. The delegated acts and the regulatory and
implementing technical standards adopted by
the Commission shall take into account the
principle of proportionality, thereby ensuring
the proportionate application of this Directive,
in particular in relation to low-risk profile
undertakings.
The draft regulatory technical standards
submitted by EIOPA in accordance with
Articles 10 to 14 of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010, the draft implementing technical
standards submitted in accordance with Article
15 of that Regulation, and the guidelines and
recommendations issued in accordance with
95
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 16 of that Regulation, shall ensure the
proportionate application of this Directive, in
particular in relation to low-risk profile
undertakings.’;
(b) the following paragraphs 5 and 6 are
added:
‘5. The Commission may adopt delegated acts
specifying or adapting the criteria laid down in
Article 29a(1), points (e), (f) and (h).
6. In order to ensure consistent supervisory
practices in the application of proportionality,
EIOPA shall develop guidelines to facilitate
common supervisory tools and further
specifying the methodology to be used when
classifying insurance and reinsurance
undertakings as low-risk profile undertakings.’;
96
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(13) the following Articles 29a to 29e are
inserted:
‘Article 29a
Criteria for identifying low-risk profile
undertakings
1. Member States shall ensure that insurance
and reinsurance undertakings are classified as
low-risk profile undertakings, according to the
process set out in Article 29b, where, for two
consecutive financial years prior to such
classification, they meet the following criteria:
(a) For life insurance undertakings and for
insurance undertakings pursuing both life and
non-life insurance activities in accordance with
Article 73 whose technical provisions related to
97
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the life insurance activities represent 20% or
more of the total technical provisions gross of
the amounts recoverable from reinsurance
contracts and special purpose vehicles, as
referred to in Article 76, and whose annual
gross written premium income related to the
non-life insurance activities represents less than
40% of the total annual gross written premium,
all of the following criteria shall be met:
(i) the interest rate risk submodule referred
to in Article 105(5), point (a), is not higher than
5 % of the technical provisions, gross of the
amounts recoverable from reinsurance contracts
and special purpose vehicles, as referred to in
Article 76;
(ii) business underwritten in Member States
other than the home Member State where the
98
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertaking received its authorisation in
accordance with Article 14 is not higher than
5 % of its total annual gross written premium;
(iii) technical provisions, gross of the
amounts recoverable from reinsurance contracts
and special purpose vehicles, as referred to in
Article 76, are not higher than EUR 1 000 000
000;
(iv) investments in non-traditional
investments do not represent more than 20% of
total investments;
(v) the business of the undertaking does not
include reinsurance operations exceeding 50 %
of its annual total gross written premium
income.
99
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
The criteria laid down in points (ii) and (v) shall
not apply to captive insurance undertakings or
captive reinsurance undertakings.
(b) For non-life insurance undertakings, and
for insurance undertakings pursuing both life
and non-life insurance activities in accordance
with Article 73 whose annual gross written
premium income related to the non-life
insurance activities represent 40% or more of its
total annual gross written premium income and
whose technical provisions related to the life
insurance activities represent less than the 20%
of its total technical provisions gross of the
amounts recoverable from reinsurance contracts
and special purpose vehicles, as referred to in
Article 76, all of the following criteria shall be
met:
100
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(i) the average combined ratio net of
reinsurance of the last three years is less than
100 %;
(ii) business underwritten in Member States
other than the home Member State where the
undertaking received its authorisation in
accordance with Article 14 is not higher than
5 % of its total annual gross written premium;
(iii) the annual gross written premium is not
higher than EUR 100 000 000;
(iv) the sum of the annual gross written
premiums in classes 3 to 7, 14 and 15 of Section
A of Annex I is not higher than 30 % of total
annual written premiums of non-life business;
101
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(v) investments in non-traditional
investments do not represent more than 20% of
total investments;
(vi) the business of the undertaking does not
include reinsurance operations exceeding 50 %
of its total gross written premium income.
The criteria laid down in points (ii) and (vi)
shall not apply to captive insurance
undertakings or captive reinsurance
undertakings.
(c) For insurance undertakings pursuing
both life and non-life insurance activities in
accordance with Article 73 whose technical
provisions related to the life insurance activities
represent 20% or more of its total technical
provisions gross of the amounts recoverable
102
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
from reinsurance contracts and special purpose
vehicles, as referred to in Article 76, and whose
annual gross written premium income related to
the non-life insurance activities represents 40%
or more of its total annual gross written
premium income, all of the following criteria
shall be met:
(i) the interest rate risk submodule referred
to in Article 105(5), point (a), is not higher than
5 % of the technical provisions, gross of the
amounts recoverable from reinsurance contracts
and special purpose vehicles, as referred to in
Article 76;
(ii) the average combined ratio net of
reinsurance of the last three years is less than
100 %;
103
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(iii) technical provisions, gross of the
amounts recoverable from reinsurance contracts
and special purpose vehicles, as referred to in
Article 76, are not higher than EUR 1 000 000
000;
(iv) the annual gross written premium is not
higher than EUR 100 000 000;
(v) business underwritten in Member States
other than the home Member State where the
undertaking received its authorisation in
accordance with Article 14 is not higher than
5 % of its total annual gross written premium;
(vi) the sum of the annual gross written
premium in classes 3 to 7, 14 and 15 of Section
A of Annex I is not higher than 30 % of total
annual written premiums of non-life business;
104
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(vii) investments in non-traditional
investments do not represent more than 20% of
total investments;
(viii) the business of the undertaking does not
include reinsurance operations exceeding 50 %
of its annual total gross written premium
income.
The criteria laid down in points (v) and (viii)
shall not apply to captive insurance
undertakings or captive reinsurance
undertakings.
For the purpose of this Article, traditional
investments shall consist of bonds, equities,
cash and cash equivalents and deposits and total
investments shall consist of all assets, including
105
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
derivatives, and excluding investments covering
unit-index linked contracts, excluding property
for own use, excluding plant and equipment for
own use, excluding property under construction
for own used.
2. For insurance and reinsurance undertakings
which have obtained authorisation in
accordance with Article 14 for less than two
years, compliance with the criteria set out in
paragraph 1 of this Article shall be assessed
only with respect to the last financial year prior
to the classification.
3. The following insurance and reinsurance
undertakings shall never be classified as low-
risk profile undertakings:
106
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) undertakings using an approved partial
or full internal model to calculate the Solvency
Capital Requirement, in accordance with the
requirements for full and partial internal models
set out in Chapter VI, Section 4, Subsection 3;
(b) undertakings which are parent
undertakings of an insurance group within the
meaning of Article 212, to which group
supervision applies in accordance with Article
213(2), point (a) or (b), unless the group is
classified as a low-risk profile group.
Article 29b
Process of classification for undertakings
complying with the criteria
1. Member States shall ensure that
insurance and reinsurance undertakings
107
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
complying with the conditions set out in Article
29a(1) and (3) may notify the supervisory
authority of such compliance with a view to be
classified as low-risk profile undertakings.
2. The notification referred to in paragraph
1 of this Article shall be submitted by the
insurance and reinsurance undertaking to the
supervisory authority of the Member State that
granted the prior authorisation referred to in
Article 14. That notification shall include all of
the following:
(a) evidence of the compliance with all
criteria set out in Article 29a applicable to that
undertaking;
(b) a declaration that the undertaking does
not plan any strategic change that would lead to
108
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
non-compliance with the criteria set out in
Article 29a within the next three years;
(c) an early identification of the
proportionality measures the undertaking
expects to implement, in particular if the best
estimate simplification is intended to be used
and whether the undertaking plans to use the
simplified method to calculate technical
provisions laid down in Article 77(7).
3. The supervisory authority may oppose
the classification as low-risk profile undertaking
within one month of receipt of the notification
referred to in paragraph 1 of this Article on
grounds related exclusively to the non-
compliance with the conditions foreseen under
Article 29a. A decision of the supervisory
authority to oppose to the classification shall be
109
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
done in writing and state the reasons of the
supervisory authority’s disagreement. Absent
such decision, the insurance undertaking shall
be classified as low-risk profile undertaking as
of the end of the one month opposition period or
an earlier date where the supervisory authority
has issued a decision earlier confirming
compliance with criteria.
4. With respect to requests received by
supervisory authorities within the first six
months of [OP please insert date = entry into
application of this Directive], the period referred
to in paragraph 2 shall be extended to two
months.
5. The insurance and reinsurance
undertakings shall be classified as low-risk
profile undertaking for as long as such
110
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
classification does not cease in accordance with
this paragraph.
Where a low-risk profile undertaking no longer
complies with any of the criteria set out in
Article 29a(1) it shall inform the supervisory
authority without delay. Where such non-
compliance continuously persists over two
consecutive years, the undertaking shall notify
the supervisory authority of this situation, and
will cease to be classified as low-risk profile
undertaking as from the third financial year.
When a low-risk profile undertaking no longer
complies with any of the conditions set out in
Article 29a(3), that undertaking shall notify the
supervisory authority without delay and will
cease to be classified as low-risk profile
111
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertaking as from the following financial
year.
Article 29c
Use of proportionality measures by
undertakings classified as low-risk profile
1. Member States shall ensure that, without
prejudice to specific requirements set out in
each proportionality measure, insurance and
reinsurance undertakings classified as low-risk
profile undertakings may use all the
proportionality measures provided for in Article
35(5a), Article 41, Article 45(1b), Article 45(5),
Article 45a(5), Article 51(6), Article 51a(1),
Article 77(7) and Article144a(4), and any
proportionality measure provided for in the
delegated acts adopted pursuant to this
Directive.
112
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. Where the supervisory authority has
serious concerns in relation to the risk profile of
a low-risk profile undertaking, the supervisory
authority may, in exceptional circumstances,
request the undertaking concerned to refrain
from using one or several proportionality
measures listed in paragraph 1 provided this is
justified in writing on consideration of the
impact on the organisation of the undertaking
and the specificities or change of its risk profile.
Article 29d
Use of proportionality measures by
undertakings not classified as low-risk profile
undertakings
1. Member States shall ensure that insurance
and reinsurance undertakings that are not
113
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
classified as low-risk profile undertakings may
use any proportionality measure provided for in
Article 35(5a), Article 41, Article 45(1b),
Article 45(5), Article 77(7) and Article144a(4)
and any proportionality measure provided for in
the delegated acts adopted pursuant to this
Directive, subject to prior approval from the
supervisory authority.
The insurance or reinsurance undertaking shall
submit a request in writing for approval to the
supervisory authority. That request shall include
all of the following:
(a) the list of the proportionality measures
intended to be used and the reasons why their
use is justified in relation to the nature, scale
and complexity of the risks inherent in the
business of the undertaking;
114
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) any other material information regarding
the risk profile of the undertaking;
(c) a declaration that the undertaking does
not plan any strategic change that would have an
impact on the risk profile of the undertaking
within the next three years.
2. The supervisory authority shall, within two
months of receipt, assess the request and inform
the undertaking of its approval or rejection, as
well as of the proportionality measures granted.
Where the supervisory authority approves the
use of proportionality measures under certain
terms or conditions, the approval decision shall
contain the reasons for those terms and
conditions. A decision of the supervisory
authority to oppose the use of one or several
115
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
proportionality measures listed in the request
submitted by the undertaking shall be done in
writing, and state the reasons for the supervisory
authority’s decision. Such reasons shall be
linked to the risk profile of the undertaking,
3. The supervisory authority may request any
further information that is necessary to complete
the assessment. The assessment period referred
to in paragraph 2 shall be suspended for the
period between the date of request for
information by the supervisory authorities and
the receipt of a response thereto by the
concerned undertaking. Any further requests by
the supervisory authority shall not result in a
suspension of the assessment period.
4. With respect to requests received by
supervisory authorities within the first six
116
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
months of [OP please insert date = date of
application of this Directive], the period referred
to in paragraph 2 shall be four months.
5. Approval to use proportionality measures
may be amended or withdrawn at any point in
time if the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking’s risk profile has changed. The
authority shall state in writing the reasons of its
decision accordingly.
Article 29e
Monitoring of the use of proportionality
measures
1. Member States shall require insurance and
reinsurance undertakings using proportionality
measures to report annually to their supervisory
authorities information on the proportionality
117
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
measures used as part of the information to be
provided for supervisory purposes referred to in
Article 35.
2. Insurance and reinsurance undertakings
applying any proportionality measure referred to
in Article 29c(1) or Article 29d(1) by [OP
please insert date = entry into force of this
Directive] may continue to apply such measures
without applying requirements set out in
Articles 29b, 29c and 29d , for a period not
exceeding four financial years.’;
(14) in Article 30(2), the first subparagraph is
replaced by the following:
‘Financial supervision pursuant to paragraph 1
shall include verification, with respect to the
entire business of the insurance and reinsurance
118
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertaking, of its system of governance, of its
state of solvency, of the establishment of
technical provisions, of its assets and of the
eligible own funds, in accordance with the rules
laid down or practices followed in the home
Member State under provisions adopted at
Union level.’;
(15) the following Article 33a is inserted:
‘Article 33a
Supervisory cooperation between home and
host supervisory authorities
1. In the event of significant cross-border
activities carried out by insurance and
reinsurance undertakings under the right of
establishment or the freedom to provide
services, the supervisory authority of the home
119
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Member State shall cooperate with the
supervisory authority of the host Member State
to assess whether the insurance undertaking has
a clear understanding of the risks that it faces, or
may face, in the host Member State.
This cooperation shall cover at least the
following aspects:
(a) the system of governance including the
ability of the head office’s management to
understand the cross-border market specificities,
risk management tools, internal controls in place
and compliance procedures for the cross-border
business;
(b) outsourcing arrangements and distribution
partnerships;
120
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) business strategy and claims handling;
(d) consumer protection.
2. The supervisory authority of the home
Member State shall, in a timely manner, inform
the supervisory authority of the host Member
State about the outcome of its supervisory
review process related to the cross-border
activity where potential issues of compliance
with the provisions applicable in the host
Member State have been identified.
3. For the purpose of this Article, ‘significant
cross-border activities’ are insurance and
reinsurance activities carried out by an
insurance or reinsurance undertaking under the
right of establishment and those carried out
under the freedom to provide services in a given
121
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
host Member State, which exceed 5 % of the
annual gross written premium of the
undertaking, measured with reference to the last
available financial statement of the
undertaking.’;
(16) Article 35 is amended as follows:
(a) in paragraph 1, the first sentence is
replaced by the following:
‘Member States shall require insurance and
reinsurance undertakings to submit to the
supervisory authorities the information which is
necessary for the purposes of supervision,
taking into account the objectives of supervision
laid down in Articles 27 and 28 and the general
principles of supervision laid down in Article
29.’;
122
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the following paragraph 5a is inserted:
‘5a. Taking into account the information
required in paragraphs 1 and 2 and the
principles set out in paragraphs 3 and 4,
Member States shall ensure that insurance and
reinsurance undertakings submit to the
supervisory authorities a regular supervisory
report that comprises information on the
undertaking's business and performance, system
of governance, risk profile, valuation for
solvency purposes and capital management over
the reporting period.
The frequency of the regular supervisory report
shall be:
123
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) every three years, for low-risk profile
undertakings;
(b) at least every three years for insurance
and reinsurance undertakings other than low-
risk profile undertakings.’;
(c) paragraphs 6, 7 and 8 are deleted;
(d) paragraph 9 is replaced by the following:
‘9. The Commission shall adopt delegated acts
in accordance with Article 301a specifying the
information referred to in paragraphs 1 to 4 of
this Article and criteria for limited supervisory
reporting for captive insurance undertakings and
reinsurance captive undertakings considering
the nature, scale and complexity of the risks of
these specific types of undertakings with a view
124
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
to ensuring, to the appropriate extent,
convergence of supervisory reporting.’;
(e) in paragraph 10, the first subparagraph is
replaced by the following:
‘In order to ensure uniform conditions of
application of this Article, EIOPA shall develop
draft implementing technical standards on
regular supervisory reporting with regard to the
templates for the submission of information to
the supervisory authorities referred to in
paragraphs 1 and 2, including the risk-based
thresholds establishing the trigger for reporting
requirements when applicable or any exemption
of specific information for certain types of
undertakings such as captive insurance and
reinsurance undertakings considering the nature,
125
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
scale and complexity of the risks of specific
types of undertakings.’;
(f) paragraph 11 is deleted;
(g) the following paragraph 12 is added:
‘12. By [OP please insert date = 2 years after
publication date], EIOPA shall submit to the
Commission a report on potential measures,
including legislative changes, to develop an
integrated data collection to:
(a) reduce areas of duplications and
inconsistencies between the reporting
frameworks in the insurance sector and other
sectors of the financial industry; and
126
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) improve data standardisation and
efficient sharing and use of data already
reported within any Union reporting framework
by any relevant competent authority, both Union
and national.
EIOPA shall prioritise, but not limit itself to
information concerning the areas of collective
investment undertakings and derivatives
reporting.
When preparing the report referred to in the first
subparagraph, EIOPA shall work in close
cooperation with the other European
Supervisory Authorities and the European
Central Bank and shall, where relevant, involve
the national competent authorities.’;
(17) the following Article 35a is inserted:
127
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘Article 35a
Exemptions and limitations to quantitative
regular supervisory reporting granted by
supervisory authorities
‘1. Without prejudice to Article 129(4), where
the predefined periods referred to in Article
35(2), point (a)(i) are shorter than one year the
supervisory authorities concerned may limit
regular supervisory reporting, where:
(a) the submission of that information would be
overly burdensome in relation to the nature,
scale and complexity of the risks inherent in the
business of the undertaking;
(b) the information is reported at least annually.
128
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
That limitation to regular supervisory reporting
shall be granted only to undertakings that do not
represent more than 20 % of a Member State’s
life and non-life insurance and reinsurance
market respectively, where the non-life market
share is based on gross written premiums and
the life market share is based on gross technical
provisions.
When determining the eligibility of
undertakings for those limitations, supervisory
authorities shall give priority to low-risk profile
undertakings.
2. The supervisory authorities concerned may
limit regular supervisory reporting, or exempt
insurance and reinsurance undertakings from
reporting on an item-by-item basis, where:
129
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) the submission of that information would be
overly burdensome in relation to the nature,
scale and complexity of the risks inherent in the
business of the undertaking;
(b) the submission of that information is not
necessary for the effective supervision of the
undertaking;
(c) the exemption does not undermine the
stability of the financial systems concerned in
the Union; and
(d) the undertaking is able to provide the
information upon request.
Supervisory authorities shall not exempt from
reporting, on an item-by-item basis, insurance or
reinsurance undertakings that are part of a group
130
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
within the meaning of Article 212(1), point (c),
unless the undertaking can demonstrate to the
satisfaction of the supervisory authority that
reporting on an item-by-item basis is
inappropriate, given the nature, scale and
complexity of the risks inherent in the business
of the group and taking into account the
objective of financial stability.
The exemption from reporting on an item-by-
item basis shall be granted only to undertakings
that do not represent more than 20 % of a
Member State’s life and non-life insurance or
reinsurance market respectively, where the non-
life market share is based on gross written
premiums and the life market share is based on
gross technical provisions. When determining
the eligibility of undertakings for those
limitations or exemptions, supervisory
131
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
authorities shall give priority to low-risk profile
undertakings.
3. Captive insurance undertakings and captive
reinsurance undertakings shall be exempted
from regular supervisory reporting on an item-
by-item basis where the predefined periods
referred to in Article 35(2), point (a)(i), are
shorter than one year, provided that they comply
with both of the following conditions:
(a) all insured persons and beneficiaries are
any of the following:
– legal entities of the group of which the
captive insurance undertaking or captive
reinsurance undertaking is part,
132
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
– natural persons eligible to be covered
under that group’s insurance policies, provided
that the business covering those natural persons
remains below 5% of technical provisions;
(b) the insurance obligations and the
insurance contracts underlying the reinsurance
obligations of the captive insurance undertaking
or captive reinsurance undertaking do not
consist of any compulsory third-party liability
insurance.’
4. For the purposes of paragraphs 1 and 2, as
part of the supervisory review process, in
respect of undertakings classified as low-risk
profile undertakings, supervisory authorities
shall assess whether the submission of
information would be overly burdensome in
relation to the nature, scale and complexity of
133
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the risks of the undertaking, taking into account,
at least:
(a) the market risks that the investments of
the undertaking give rise to;
(b) the level of risk concentrations;
(c) possible effects of the management of
the assets of the undertaking on financial
stability;
(d) the systems and structures of the
undertaking to provide information for
supervisory purposes and the written policy
referred to in paragraph 5.
5. For the purposes of paragraphs 1 and 2, as
part of the supervisory review process, in
134
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
respect of undertakings not classified as low-
risk profile undertakings, supervisory authorities
shall assess whether the submission of
information would be overly burdensome in
relation to the nature, scale and complexity of
the risks of the undertaking, taking into account,
at least:
(a) the volume of premiums, technical
provisions and assets of the undertaking;
(b) the volatility of the claims and benefits
covered by the undertaking;
(c) the total number of classes of life and
non-life insurance for which authorisation is
granted;
135
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(d) the appropriateness of the system of
governance of the undertaking;
(e) the level of own funds covering the
Solvency Capital Requirement and the
Minimum Capital Requirement;
(f) whether the undertaking is a captive
insurance undertaking or a captive reinsurance
undertaking only covering risks associated with
the industrial or commercial group to which it
belongs.
6. In order to ensure the coherent and consistent
application of paragraphs 1 to 5 of this Article,
EIOPA shall issue guidelines in accordance with
Article 16 of Regulation (EU) 1094/2010 to
further specify:
136
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) the methods for determining the market
shares referred to in paragraph 1, second
subparagraph, and in paragraph 2, third
subparagraph, of this Article;
(b) the process to be used by the supervisory
authorities to inform the insurance and
reinsurance undertakings about any limitation or
exemption referred to in this Article.’;
(18) the following Article 35b is inserted:
‘Article 35b
Reporting deadlines
1. Member States shall ensure that insurance
and reinsurance undertakings submit the
information referred to in Article 35(1) to (4) on
137
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
an annual or less frequent basis within 16 weeks
following the undertaking's financial year end.
2. Member States shall ensure that insurance
and reinsurance undertakings submit the
information referred to in Article 35(1) to (4) on
a quarterly basis no later than five weeks after
the end of each quarter.
3. Member States shall ensure that insurance
and reinsurance undertakings submit the regular
supervisory report referred to in Article 35(5a)
no later than 18 weeks after the undertaking's
financial year ends.
4. The Commission may adopt delegated acts in
accordance with Article 301a to change the
deadlines laid down in paragraphs 1, 2, and 3 of
this Article, provided that the change is
138
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
necessary due to sanitary emergencies, natural
catastrophes or other extreme events.’;
(19) in Article 36(2), point (a) is replaced by
the following:
‘(a) the system of governance, including the fit
and proper requirements, as set out in Article 42
and the own-risk and solvency assessment, as
set out in Chapter IV, Section 2;’;
(20) Article 37 is amended as follows:
(a) in paragraph 1, the following point (e) is
added:
‘(e) the insurance or reinsurance undertaking
applies one of the transitional measures referred
139
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
to in Articles 308c and 308d and all of the
following conditions are met:
(i) the undertaking would not comply with the
Solvency Capital Requirement without
application of the transitional measure;
(ii) the undertaking has failed to submit to the
supervisory authority either the initial phasing-
in plan within the required period as set out in of
Article 308e, second paragraph, or the required
annual report as set out the third paragraph of
that Article.’;
(b) in paragraph 2, the third subparagraph is
replaced by the following:
‘In the circumstances set out in paragraph 1,
points (d) and (e), the capital add-on shall be
140
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
proportionate to the material risks arising from
the deviation and respectively the non-
compliance referred to in those points.’;
(21) Article 41 is amended as follows:
(a) in paragraph 1, the third subparagraph is
replaced by the following:
‘The system of governance shall be subject to
regular internal review. Such internal review
shall include an assessment on the adequacy of
the composition, effectiveness and internal
governance of the administrative, management
or supervisory body taking into account the
nature, scale and complexity of the risks
inherent in the undertaking’s business.’;
(b) the following paragraph 2a is inserted:
141
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘2a. Member States shall require that insurance
and reinsurance undertakings appoint different
persons to carry-out the key functions of risk
management, actuarial, compliance and internal
audit, and that each such function is performed
in an independent manner from the other in
order to avoid conflict of interests.
When the undertaking has been classified as a
low-risk profile undertaking, the persons
responsible for the key functions of risk
management, actuarial and compliance function
may also perform any other key function
different from internal audit, any other non-key
function or be a member of the administrative,
management or supervisory body provided that
the following conditions are met:
142
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) potential conflicts of interests are properly
managed;
(b) the combination of functions or the
combination of a function with the condition of
membership of the administrative, management
or supervisory body does not compromise the
person’s ability to carry out her or his
responsibilities.’;
(c) paragraph 3 is replaced by the following:
‘3. Insurance and reinsurance undertakings shall
have written policies in relation to at least risk
management, internal control, internal audit,
remuneration and, where relevant, outsourcing.
They shall ensure that those policies are
implemented.
143
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Those written policies shall be reviewed at least
annually. They shall be subject to prior approval
by the administrative, management or
supervisory body and be adapted in view of any
significant change in the system or area
concerned. Low-risk profile undertakings may
perform a less frequent review, at least every
three years, unless the supervisory authority
concludes, based on the specific circumstances
of that undertaking, that a more frequent review
is needed.’;
(22) Article 42 is amended as follows:
(a) paragraph 3 is replaced by the following:
‘3. Insurance and reinsurance undertakings shall
notify their supervisory authority if any of the
persons referred to in paragraphs 1 and 2 no
144
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
longer fulfil the requirements referred to in
paragraph 1 or have been replaced for that
reason.’;
(b) the following paragraph 4 is added:
‘4. Where a person who effectively runs the
undertaking or has other key functions does not
fulfil the requirements set out in paragraph 1,
the supervisory authorities shall have the power
to require the insurance and reinsurance
undertaking to remove such person from that
position.’;
(23) Article 44 is amended as follows:
(a) paragraph 2 is amended as follows:
(i) point (e) is replaced by the following:
145
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘(e) operational risk management, including
cyber security as defined in Article 2, point (1),
of Regulation (EU) 2019/881 of the European
Parliament and of the Council*;
* Regulation (EU) 2019/881 of the European
Parliament and of the Council of 17 April 2019 on
ENISA (the European Union Agency for
Cybersecurity) and on information and
communications technology cybersecurity
certification and repealing Regulation (EU) No
526/2013 (Cybersecurity Act) (OJ L 151, 7.6.2019,
p. 15).’;
(ii) the following subparagraph is added:
‘Where insurance or reinsurance undertakings
apply the volatility adjustment referred to in
146
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 77d, their liquidity plans shall take into
account the use of the volatility adjustment and
assess whether liquidity constraints may arise
which are not consistent with the use of the
volatility adjustment.’;
(b) paragraph 2a is amended as follows:
(i) the first subparagraph is amended as
follows:
– in point (b), point (i) is replaced by the
following:
‘(i) the sensitivity of their technical provisions
and eligible own funds to the assumptions
underlying the calculation of the matching
adjustment, including the calculation of the
147
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
fundamental spread referred to in Article 77c(1),
point (b);’;
– in point (b), point (iii) is deleted;
– point (c) is replaced by the following:
‘(c) where the volatility adjustment referred to
in Article 77d is applied, the sensitivity of their
technical provisions and eligible own funds to
changes in the economic conditions that would
affect the risk corrected spread referred to in
Article 77d(3).’;
(ii) the third subparagraph is replaced by the
following:
‘Where the volatility adjustment referred to in
Article 77d is applied, the written policy on risk
148
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
management referred to in Article 41(3) shall
take account of the volatility adjustment.’;
(24) Article 45 is amended as follows:
(a) in paragraph 1, second subparagraph, the
following points (d), (e) and (f) are added:
‘(d) consideration and analysis of the
macroeconomic situation, and possible
macroeconomic and financial markets’
developments, and, upon a reasoned request of
the supervisory authority, macroprudential
concerns, that may affect the specific risk
profile, the approved risk tolerance limits, the
business strategy, the underwriting activities or
the investment decisions, and the overall
solvency needs referred to in point (a) of the
undertaking;
149
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(e) consideration and analysis of the activities of
the undertaking that may affect the
macroeconomic and financial markets’
developments, and have the potential to turn
into sources of systemic risk;
(f) the overall capacity of the undertaking to
settle its financial obligations towards
policyholders and other counterparties when
those obligations fall due, even under stressed
conditions.’;
(b) the following paragraphs 1a and 1b are
inserted:
‘1a. For the purpose of paragraph 1, points (d)
and (e), macroeconomic and financial markets’
150
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
developments shall include, at least, changes in
the following:
(a) the level of interest rates and spreads;
(b) the level of financial market indices;
(c) inflation;
(d) interconnectedness with other financial
market participants;
(e) climate change, pandemics, other mass-scale
events and other catastrophes, which may affect
insurance and reinsurance undertakings.
For the purpose of the paragraph 1, point (d),
macroprudential concerns shall include, at least,
151
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
plausible unfavourable future scenarios and
risks related to the credit cycle and economic
downturn, herding behaviour in investments or
excessive exposure concentrations at the
sectoral level.
1b. Member States shall ensure that the analysis
required under paragraph 1, point (d), is
commensurate to the nature of risks as well as
the scale and complexity of the activities of
undertakings. Member States shall ensure that
insurance and reinsurance undertakings that are
classified as low-risk profile undertakings,
pursuant to Article 29c, and undertakings which
have obtained prior supervisory approval,
pursuant to Article 29d, are not obliged to
conduct the analysis referred to in paragraph 1,
point (e).’;
152
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) the following paragraph 2b is inserted:
‘2b. Where the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking applies the volatility adjustment
referred to in Article 77d, the assessment
referred to in paragraph 1 of this Article shall, in
addition, include the significance with which the
risk profile of the undertaking concerned
deviates from the assumptions underlying the
volatility adjustment.’;
(d) paragraph 5 is replaced by the following:
‘5. Insurance and reinsurance undertakings shall
perform the assessment referred to in paragraph
1 annually, and without any delay following any
significant change in their risk profile.
153
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
By way of derogation from the first
subparagraph of this paragraph, insurance
undertakings may perform the assessment
referred to in paragraph 1 at least every two
years and without any delay following any
significant change in their risk profile, unless
the supervisory authority concludes based on the
specific circumstances of the undertaking that a
more frequent assessment is needed, where
either of the following conditions is met:
(a) the insurance undertaking is classified as low
risk profile undertaking;
(b) the insurance undertaking is an insurance
captive undertaking or a reinsurance captive
undertaking that complies with all of the
following criteria:
154
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(i) all insured persons and beneficiaries are legal
entities of the group of which the captive
insurance undertaking or captive reinsurance
undertaking is part or natural persons eligible to
be covered under that group’s insurance policies
and the business covering natural persons
eligible to be covered under the group insurance
policies remains below 5% of technical
provisions;
(ii) the insurance obligations and the insurance
contracts underlying the reinsurance obligations
of the captive insurance undertaking or captive
reinsurance undertaking do not consist of any
compulsory third-party liability insurance.
The exemption from the annual assessment shall
not prevent the undertaking from identifying,
155
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
measuring, monitoring, managing and reporting
risks on a continuous basis.’;
(e) the following paragraph 8 is added:
‘8. For the purpose of paragraph 1, points (d)
and (e), of this Article, where authorities other
than the supervisory authorities are entrusted
with a macroprudential mandate, Member States
shall ensure that the supervisory authorities
share the findings of their macroprudential
assessments of the own-risk and solvency
assessment by insurance and reinsurance
undertakings, as referred to in Article 45, with
the relevant national authorities with a
macroprudential mandate.
Member States shall ensure that supervisory
authorities cooperate with any national
156
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
authorities with a macroprudential mandate to
analyse the results and, where applicable, to
identify any macroprudential concerns on how
undertakings may affect macroeconomic and
financial markets’ developments.
Member States shall ensure that the supervisory
authorities share any macroprudential concerns
and relevant input parameters relevant for the
assessment with the undertaking concerned.’;
(25) the following Article 45a is inserted:
‘Article 45a
Climate change scenario analysis
1. For the purposes of the identification and
assessment of risks referred to in Article 45(2),
the undertaking concerned shall also assess
157
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
whether it has any material exposure to climate
change risks. The undertaking shall demonstrate
the materiality of its exposure to climate change
risks in the assessment referred to in Article
45(1).
2. Where the undertaking concerned has
material exposure to climate change risks, the
undertaking shall specify at least two long-term
climate change scenarios, including the
following:
(a) a long-term climate change scenario where
the global temperature increase remains below
two degrees Celsius;
(b) a long-term climate change scenario where
the global temperature increase is equal to or
higher than two degrees Celsius.
158
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
3. At regular intervals, the assessment referred
to in Article 45(1) shall contain an analysis of
the impact on the business of the undertaking of
the long-term climate change scenarios
specified pursuant to paragraph 2 of this Article.
Those intervals shall be proportionate to the
nature, scale and complexity of the climate
change risks inherent in the business of the
undertaking, but be no longer than three years.
4. The long-term climate change scenarios
referred to in the paragraph 2 shall be reviewed,
at least every three years, and updated where
necessary.
5. By way of derogation from paragraphs 2, 3
and 4, insurance and reinsurance undertakings
that are classified as low-risk profile
159
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertakings shall neither be required to specify
climate change scenarios nor to assess their
impact on the business of the undertaking.’;
(26) Article 51 is amended as follows:
(a) paragraph 1 is replaced by the following:
‘1. Member States shall, taking into account the
information required in paragraph 3 of this
Article and the principles set out in Article
35(4), require insurance and reinsurance
undertakings to disclose publicly, on an annual
basis, a report on their solvency and financial
condition.
The solvency and financial condition report
shall contain two separate parts. The first part
shall consist of information addressed to
160
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
policyholders and beneficiaries, and the second
part shall consist of information addressed to
other market participants. The two parts shall be
disclosed separately or jointly indicating clearly
that the solvency and financial condition report
consists of both parts.’;
(b) paragraph 1a is replaced by the
following:
‘1a. The part of the solvency and financial
condition report consisting of information
addressed to policyholders and beneficiaries
shall contain the following information:
(a) a description of the business and the
performance of the undertaking; and
161
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) a brief description of the capital
management and the risk profile of the
undertaking.’;
(c) the following paragraphs 1b and 1c are
inserted:
‘1b. The part of the solvency and financial
condition report consisting of information
addressed to other market participants shall
contain the following information, either in full
or by way of references to equivalent
information, both in nature and scope, disclosed
publicly under other legal or regulatory
requirements:
(a) a description of the system of governance;
162
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) a description, separately for assets, technical
provisions, and other liabilities, of the bases and
methods used for their valuation;
(c) a description of the capital management and
the risk profile, including at least the following:
(i) the structure and amount of own funds, and
their quality;
(ii) the amounts of the Solvency Capital
Requirement and of the Minimum Capital
Requirement;
(iii) for insurance and reinsurance undertakings
relevant for the financial stability of the
financial systems in the Union, information on
risk sensitivity;
163
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(iv) the option set out in Article 304 used for the
calculation of the Solvency Capital
Requirement;
(v) information allowing a proper understanding
of the main differences between the underlying
assumptions of the standard formula and those
of any internal model used by the undertaking
for the calculation of its Solvency Capital
Requirement;
(vi) the amount of any non-compliance with the
Minimum Capital Requirement or any
significant non-compliance with the Solvency
Capital Requirement during the reporting
period, even if subsequently resolved, with an
explanation of its origin and consequences as
well as any remedial measures taken.
164
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
1c. Where the matching adjustment referred to
in Article 77b is applied, the description referred
to in paragraph 1b, points (b), (c)(i) and (c)(ii),
of this Article shall also describe the matching
adjustment and the portfolio of obligations and
assigned assets to which the matching
adjustment is applied, as well as a quantification
of the impact of a change to zero of the
matching adjustment on the undertaking’s
financial position.
The description referred to in paragraph 1b,
points (b), (c)(i) and (c) (ii), of this Article shall
also contain a statement on whether the
volatility adjustment referred to in Article 77d is
used by the undertaking and, where the
volatility adjustment is used, it shall disclose the
following information:
165
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) a quantification of the impact of a change to
zero of the volatility adjustment on the
undertaking's financial position;
(b) for each relevant currency or, as applicable,
country, the volatility adjustment calculated in
accordance with Article 77d and the
corresponding best estimates for insurance or
reinsurance obligations.’;
(d) paragraph 2 is replaced by the following:
‘2. The description referred to in paragraph 1b,
point (c)(i), shall include an analysis of any
significant changes as compared to the previous
reporting period and an explanation of any
major differences in relation to the value of such
elements in financial statements, and a brief
description of the capital transferability.
166
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
The disclosure of the Solvency Capital
Requirement referred to in paragraph 1b, point
(c)(ii), of this Article shall show separately the
amount calculated in accordance with Chapter
VI, Section 4, Subsections 2 and 3 and any
capital add-on imposed in accordance with
Article 37 or the impact of the specific
parameters the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking is required to use in accordance
with Article 110, together with concise
information on its justification by the
supervisory authority concerned.
The disclosure of the Solvency Capital
Requirement shall be accompanied, where
applicable, by an indication that its final amount
is still subject to supervisory assessment.’;
167
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(e) the following paragraphs 3 to 8 are
added:
‘3. Captive insurance undertakings shall not be
required to disclose the part addressed to
policyholders and beneficiaries and they shall
only be required to include in the part addressed
to other market participants the quantitative data
required by the implementing technical standard
referred to in Article 56 provided that these
undertakings meet the following conditions:
(a) all insured persons and beneficiaries are
legal entities of the group of which the captive
insurance undertaking is part or natural persons
eligible to be covered under that group’s
insurance policies and the business covering
natural persons eligible to be covered under the
168
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
group insurance policies remains below 5% of
technical provisions;
(b) the insurance obligations of the captive
insurance undertaking do not consist of any
compulsory third-party liability insurance.
4. Captive reinsurance undertakings shall not be
required to disclose the part addressed to
policyholders and beneficiaries. Such
undertakings shall only be required to include
the quantitative data required by the
implementing technical standards referred to in
Article 56, and the part addressed to other
stakeholders provided that these undertakings
meet the following conditions:
(a) all insured persons and beneficiaries are
legal entities of the group of which the captive
169
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
reinsurance undertaking is part or natural
persons eligible to be covered under that
group’s insurance policies and the business
covering natural persons eligible to be covered
under the group insurance policies remains
below 5% of technical provisions; ;
(b) the insurance contracts underlying the
reinsurance obligations of the captive
reinsurance undertaking do not relate to any
compulsory third-party liability insurance;
(c) loans in place with the parent or any group
company, including groups cashpools do not
exceed 20 % of total assets held by the captive
reinsurance undertaking;
170
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(d) the maximum loss resulting from the gross
technical provisions can be deterministically
assessed without using stochastic methods.
5. By way of derogation from paragraph 1,
reinsurance undertakings may not disclose the
part of the solvency and financial condition
report addressed to policyholders and
beneficiaries.
6. By way of derogation from paragraph 1b of
this Article, insurance undertakings that are
classified as low-risk profile undertakings may
disclose only the quantitative data required by
the implementing technical standards referred to
in Article 56 in the part of the solvency and
financial condition report consisting of
information addressed to other market
participants, provided that they disclose a full
171
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
report containing all the information required in
this Article every three years.
7. Member States shall ensure that insurance
and reinsurance undertakings submit the
information referred to in this Article on an
annual or less frequent basis within 18 weeks
after the undertaking's financial year end.
8. As part of the report referred to in paragraph
1 of this Article, insurance and reinsurance
undertakings shall be required to disclose the
impact of using, for the purposes of determining
the technical provisions pursuant to Article 77,
the risk-free interest rate term structure
determined without the application of the
transitional for the extrapolation as referred to
Article 77e(1), point (aa), instead of the relevant
risk-free interest rate term structure.
172
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
However, by way of derogation from the first
subparagraph, the disclosure requirement shall
not apply to a currency for which one of the
following applies:
(i) the share of future cash flows associated with
insurance or reinsurance obligations in that
currency relative to all future cash flows
associated with insurance or reinsurance
obligations does not exceed 5 %;
(ii) with respect to future cash flows associated
with insurance or reinsurance obligations in that
currency, the share of future cash-flows
pertaining to maturities where the relevant risk-
free interest rate term structure is extrapolated
relative to all future cash flows associated with
173
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
insurance or reinsurance obligations does not
exceed 10 %.’;
(27) the following Article 51a is inserted:
‘Article 51a
Audit requirements
1. For insurance and reinsurance undertakings
other than low-risk profile undertakings and
captive insurance undertakings and captive
reinsurance undertakings, the balance sheet
disclosed as part of the solvency and financial
condition report or as part of the single solvency
and financial condition report shall be subject to
an audit.
2. Member States may extend the obligation laid
down in paragraph 1 to captive insurance
174
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertakings and captive reinsurance
undertakings.
3. The audit shall be carried out by a statutory
auditor or an audit firm, in accordance with the
applicable international standards, unless this
Directive, or delegated acts adopted pursuant to
it establish other principles and requirements for
the assessment of any item of the balance sheet.
Statutory auditors and audit firms, when
performing this task, shall comply with the
duties of auditors set out in Article 72.
4. A separate report, including a description of
the nature, and the results, of the audit, prepared
by the statutory auditor or the audit firm shall be
submitted together with the solvency and
financial condition report to the supervisory
175
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
authority by the insurance and reinsurance
undertakings.’;
(28) Article 52 is amended as follows:
(a) in paragraph 1, the following points (e)
and (f) are added:
‘(e) the number of insurance and reinsurance
undertakings, divided by low-risk profile
undertakings and others, using simplifications or
other proportionality measures and the
proportionality measures used by each
undertaking;
(f) the number of groups, divided by low-risk
profile group and others, using simplifications
or other proportionality measures and the
proportionality measures used by each group.’;
176
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) in paragraph 2, the following point (f) is
added:
‘(f) for each Member State, the number of
insurance and reinsurance undertakings and the
number of groups, divided by low-risk profile
undertakings and others using simplifications or
other proportionality measures and the
simplifications and other proportionality
measures used by each undertaking.’;
(c) paragraph 3 is replaced by the following:
‘3. EIOPA shall provide the information
referred to in paragraph 2 to the European
Parliament, to the Council and to the
Commission, together with a report outlining
the degree of supervisory convergence in the
177
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
use of capital add-ons and in the use of
proportionality measures between supervisory
authorities in the different Member States.’;
(29) in Article 53, paragraph 4 is replaced by
the following:
‘4. Paragraphs 1 and 2 of this Article shall not
apply to the information referred to in Article
51(1), point (c).’;
(30) in Article 56, the first paragraph is
replaced by the following:
‘The Commission shall adopt delegated acts, in
accordance with Article 301a, that further
specify the information that insurance and
reinsurance undertakings are required to
disclose. The Commission may adopt delegated
178
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
acts in accordance with Article 301a to change
the deadlines laid down in Article 51(7),
provided that a change is necessary due to
sanitary emergencies, natural catastrophes and
other extreme events.’;
(31) in Article 58(3), points (a) and (b) are
replaced by the following:
‘(a) situated or regulated outside the Union; or
(b) a natural or legal person not subject to
supervision under this Directive, Directive
2009/65/EC of the European Parliament and of
the Council*, Directive 2013/36/EU , or
Directive 2014/65/EU.
______________________________________
179
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
* Directive 2009/65/EC of the European Parliament
and of the Council of 13 July 2009 on the
coordination of laws, regulations and administrative
provisions relating to undertakings for collective
investment in transferable securities (UCITS) (OJ L
302, 17.11.2009, p. 32).’;
(32) in Article 60(1), point (a), the words
‘point 2 of Article 1a of Directive 85/611/EEC’
are replaced by the words ‘Article 2(1), point
(b), of Directive 2009/65/EC’;
(33) in Article 62, first paragraph, the first
sentence is replaced by the following:
‘Where the influence exercised by the persons
referred to in Article 57 is likely to operate
against the sound and prudent management of
an insurance or reinsurance undertaking,
180
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Member States shall require the supervisory
authority of the home Member State of that
undertaking in which a qualifying holding is
held, sought or increased to take appropriate
measures to put an end to that situation.’;
(34) in Article 63, second paragraph, the
words ‘Directive 2004/39/EC’ are replaced by
the words ‘Directive 2014/65/EU’;
(35) in Article 72(1), the words ‘Article 51 of
Directive 78/660/EEC, Article 37 of Directive
83/349/EEC or Article 31 of Directive
85/611/EEC’ are replaced by the words ‘Article
34 or 35 of Directive 2013/34/EU or Article 73
of Directive 2009/65/EC’;
(36) in Article 77, the following paragraphs 6
and 7 are added:
181
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘6. Where insurance and reinsurance contracts
include financial options and guarantees, the
methods used to calculate the best estimate shall
appropriately reflect that the present value of
cash flows arising from those contracts may
depend both on the expected outcome of future
events and developments and on potential
deviations of the actual outcome from the
expected outcome in certain scenarios.
7. Notwithstanding paragraph 6, insurance and
reinsurance undertakings that are classified as
low-risk profile undertakings may use a prudent
deterministic valuation of the best estimate for
life obligations with options and guarantees that
are not deemed material.’;
(37) Article 77a is replaced by the following:
182
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘Article 77a
Extrapolation of the relevant risk-free
interest rate term structure
1. The determination of the relevant risk-free
interest rate term structure referred to in Article
77(2) shall make use of, and be consistent with,
information derived from relevant financial
instruments. That determination shall take into
account relevant financial instruments of those
maturities where the markets for those financial
instruments are deep, liquid and transparent.
The relevant risk-free interest rate term structure
shall be extrapolated for maturities longer than
the first smoothing point. The first smoothing
point for a currency shall be the longest maturity
for which all of the following conditions are
met:
183
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) the markets for financial instruments of that
maturity are deep, liquid and transparent;
(b) the percentage of outstanding bonds of that
or a longer maturity among all outstanding
bonds denominated in that currency is
sufficiently high.
The extrapolated part of the relevant risk-free
interest rate term structure shall be based on
forward rates converging smoothly from one or
a set of forward rates in relation to the longest
maturities for which the bonds can be observed
in a deep, liquid and transparent market to an
ultimate forward rate.
The extrapolated part of the relevant risk-free
interest rates shall take into account information
184
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
from financial instruments other than bonds for
maturities where the relevant risk-free interest
rate term structure is extrapolated and where the
markets for those financial instruments are deep
liquid and transparent.
2. For the purpose of paragraph 1, second
subparagraph, any parameters determining the
speed of the convergence of the forward rates
towards the ultimate forward rate of the
extrapolation may be chosen such that on [OP
please insert date = application date] the risk-
free interest rate term structure is sufficiently
similar to the risk-free interest rate term
structure on that date determined in line with the
rules for the extrapolation applicable on [OP
please insert date = one day before date of
application]. Those parameters of the
extrapolation shall be decreased linearly at the
185
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
beginning of each calendar year, during a
transitional period. The final parameters of the
extrapolation shall be applied as of 1 January
2032.
The transitional mechanism set out in the first
subparagraph shall not affect the determination
of the depth, liquidity and transparency of
financial markets and the first smoothing point
referred to in paragraph 1.’;
(38) Article 77d is amended as follows:
(a) paragraph 1 is replaced by the following:
‘1. An insurance and reinsurance undertaking
may apply a volatility adjustment to the relevant
risk-free interest rate term structure to calculate
the best estimate referred to in Article 77(2)
186
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
subject to prior approval by the supervisory
authorities where all of the following conditions
are met:
(a) the volatility adjustment for a given currency
is applied in the calculation of the best estimate
of all insurance and reinsurance obligations of
the undertaking denominated in that currency
where the relevant risk-free interest rate term
structure used to calculate the best estimate for
those obligations does not include a matching
adjustment as referred to in Article 77b;
(b) the undertaking demonstrates to the
satisfaction of the supervisory authority that it
has adequate processes in place to calculate the
volatility adjustment pursuant to paragraphs 3
and 4 of this Article.’;
187
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the following paragraphs 1a and 1b are
inserted:
‘1a. Notwithstanding paragraph 1 of this Article,
insurance and reinsurance undertakings who
applied a volatility adjustment to the relevant
risk-free interest rate term structure to calculate
the best estimate referred to in Article 77(2)
before [OP please insert date = one year before
application date] may, without prior approval by
the supervisory authority, continue applying a
volatility adjustment provided that they comply
with paragraph 1, points (a) and (b), of this
Article as of [OP please insert date = application
date].
1b. Member States shall ensure that supervisory
authorities have the power to require an
insurance and reinsurance undertaking to stop
188
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
applying a volatility adjustment to the relevant
risk-free interest rate term structure to calculate
the best estimate referred to in Article 77(2)
where the undertaking no longer meets the
conditions set out in paragraph 1 of this Article.
When an undertaking restores compliance with
paragraph 1, points (a) and (b), of this Article, it
may request prior approval to the supervisory
authorities to apply a volatility adjustment to the
relevant risk-free interest rate term structure to
calculate the best estimate pursuant to paragraph
1 of this Article.’;
(c) paragraphs 2 to 4 are replaced by the
following:
‘2. For each relevant currency, the volatility
adjustment to the relevant risk-free interest rate
term structure shall be based on the spread
189
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
between the interest rate that could be earned
from a reference portfolio of investments in debt
instruments for that currency and the rates of the
relevant basic risk-free interest rate term
structure for that currency.
The reference portfolio of investments in debt
instruments for a currency shall be
representative for the assets which are
denominated in that currency and which
insurance and reinsurance undertakings are
invested in to cover the best estimate for
insurance and reinsurance obligations
denominated in that currency.
3. The amount of the volatility adjustment to
risk-free interest rates for a currency shall be
calculated as follows:
190
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
𝑉𝐴𝑐𝑢 = 85% ∙ 𝐶𝑆𝑆𝑅𝑐𝑢 ∙ 𝑅𝐶𝑆𝑐𝑢
Where:
(a) VAcu is the volatility adjustment for a
currency cu;
(b) CSSRcu is the credit spread sensitivity ratio
of an insurance or reinsurance undertaking for
the currency cu;
(c) RCScu is the risk-corrected spread for the
currency cu.
CSSRcu shall not be negative and not be higher
than one. It shall take values lower than one
where the sensitivity of the assets of an
insurance or reinsurance undertaking in a
currency to changes in credit spreads is lower
191
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
than the sensitivity of the technical provisions of
that undertaking in that currency to changes in
interest rates.
RSCcu shall be calculated as the difference
between the spread referred to in paragraph 2
and the portion of that spread that is attributable
to a realistic assessment of expected losses or
unexpected credit or other risk of the assets.
VAcu shall apply to the relevant risk-free interest
rates of the term structure that are not derived
by means of extrapolation in accordance with
Article 77a. Where the extrapolated part of the
relevant risk-free interest rates takes into
account information from financial instruments
other than bonds pursuant to Article 77a(1),
VAcu shall also apply to risk-free interest rates
derived from those financial instruments. The
192
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
extrapolation of the relevant risk-free interest
rate term structure shall be based on those
adjusted risk-free interest rates.
4. For the euro, the volatility adjustment shall be
increased by a macro volatility adjustment. The
macro volatility adjustment shall be calculated
as follows:
𝑉𝐴𝐸𝑢𝑟𝑜,𝑚𝑎𝑐𝑟𝑜 = 85% ∙ 𝐶𝑆𝑆𝑅𝐸𝑢𝑟𝑜
∙ max(𝑅𝐶𝑆𝑐𝑜 − 1.3 ∙ 𝑅𝐶𝑆𝐸𝑢𝑟𝑜 ; 0)
∙ 𝜔𝑐𝑜
Where:
(a)VAEuro,macro is the macro volatility adjustment
for a country co;
193
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) CSSREuro is the credit spread sensitivity ratio
of an insurance or reinsurance undertaking for
the euro;
(c) RCSco is the risk-corrected spread for the
country co;
(d) RCSEuro is the risk-corrected spread for the
euro;
(e) wco is the country adjustment factor for
country co.
CSSREuro shall be calculated as the credit spread
sensitivity ratio of an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking for the euro in accordance with
paragraph 3.
194
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
RCSco shall be calculated in the same way as the
risk-corrected spread for the euro under
paragraph 3, but based on a reference portfolio
that is representative for the assets which
insurance and reinsurance undertakings are
investing in to cover the best estimate for
insurance and reinsurance obligations of
products sold in the insurance market of that
country and denominated in euro.
RSCEuro is calculated as the risk-corrected
spread for the euro in accordance with
paragraph 3.
The country adjustment factor referred to in
point (e) shall be calculated as follows:
∗
𝑅𝐶𝑆𝑐𝑜 − 0.6%
𝜔𝑐𝑜 = max (min ( ; 1) ; 0)
0.3%
195
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Where RSCco* is the risk-corrected spread for
the country co as referred to in the first
subparagraph, point (d), multiplied by the
percentage of investments in debt instruments
relative to total assets held by insurance and
reinsurance undertakings authorised in country
co.’;
(39) Article 77e is amended as follows:
(a) paragraph 1 is amended as follows:
(i) the following point (aa) is inserted:
‘(aa) for the purposes of the disclosures
pursuant to Article 51(8), a relevant risk-free
interest rate term structure without any matching
adjustment or volatility adjustment and
196
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
determined without the application of the
transitional for the extrapolation as set out in
paragraph 2 of that Article;’;
(ii) point (c) is replaced by the following:
‘(c) for each relevant currency and national
insurance market a risk-corrected spread
referred to in Article 77d(3) and (4)
respectively;’;
(iii) following point (d) is added:
‘(d) for each relevant Member State, the
percentage of investments in debt instruments
relative to total assets held by insurance and
reinsurance undertakings authorised in the
country as referred to in Article 77d(4).’;
197
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the following paragraph 1a is inserted:
‘1a. EIOPA shall lay down and publish, at least
on an annual basis, for each relevant currency
and each maturity where the markets for
relevant financial instruments or bonds of that
maturity are deep, liquid and transparent, the
percentage of bonds with that or a longer
maturity among all bonds denominated in that
currency as referred to in Article 77a(1);’;
(c) in paragraph 2, the first subparagraph is
replaced by the following:
‘In order to ensure uniform conditions for the
calculation of technical provisions and basic
own funds, the Commission may adopt
implementing acts which set out, for each
relevant currency, the technical information
198
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
referred to in paragraph 1 of this Article and the
first smoothing point pursuant to Article 77a(1).
Those implementing acts may make use of the
information published by EIOPA pursuant to
paragraph 1 of this Article.’;
(d) in paragraph 3, the second subparagraph
is replaced by the following:
‘With respect to currencies where the risk-
corrected spread referred to in paragraph 1,
point (c), is not set out in the implementing acts
referred to in paragraph 2, no volatility
adjustment shall be applied to the relevant risk-
free interest rate term structure to calculate the
best estimate. With respect Member States
whose currency is the euro and where the risk-
corrected spread referred to in paragraph 1,
point (c), and the percentage referred to in
199
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
paragraph 1, point (d), are not set out in the
implementing acts referred to in paragraph 2, no
macro volatility adjustment shall be added to the
volatility adjustment.’;
(e) the following paragraph 4 is added:
‘4. For the purposes of paragraph 2 of this
Article, a first smoothing point for a currency
set out in an implementing act shall not be
modified, unless an assessment of the
percentages of bonds with maturity larger than
or equal to a given maturity among all bonds
denominated in that currency indicates a
different first smoothing point pursuant to
Article 77a(1) and the percentage set out in
delegated acts referred to in Article 86(1), point
(b) (iii) for at least two consecutive years.’;
200
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(40) Article 86 is amended as follows:
(a) paragraph 1 is amended as follows:
(i) the following point (aa) is inserted:
‘(aa) the prudent deterministic valuation
referred to in Article 77(7) as well as the
conditions under which that valuation may be
used to value the best estimate of technical
provisions with options and guarantees.’;
(ii) point (b) is replaced by the following:
‘(b) the methodologies, principles and
techniques for the determination of the relevant
risk-free interest rate term structure to be used to
calculate the best estimate referred to in Article
77(2), in particular:
201
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(i) the formula for the extrapolation referred to
in Article 77a(1), including the parameters that
determine the convergence speed of the
extrapolation;
(ii) the method for the determination of the
depth, liquidity and transparency of bond
markets referred to in Article 77a(1);
(iii) the percentage below which the share of
bonds with maturities longer than or equal to a
given maturity among all bonds shall be
regarded as low for the purposes of Article
77a(1);’;
(iii) point (i) is replaced by the following:
202
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘(i) methods and assumptions for the calculation
of the volatility adjustment referred to in Article
77d, including the following:
(i) a formula for the calculation of the spread
referred to in paragraph 2 of that Article;
(ii) a formula for the calculation of the credit
spread sensitivity ratio referred to in paragraphs
3 and 4 of that Article ;
(iii) for each relevant asset class, the percentage
of the spread that represents the portion
attributable to a realistic assessment of expected
losses or unexpected credit or other risks of the
assets as referred to in Article 77d(3);
(iv) the transitional mechanism as referred to in
Article 77a(2);’;
203
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the following paragraph 1a is inserted:
‘1a. The Commission may adopt delegated acts
in accordance with Article 301a laying down
criteria for assets to be eligible to be included in
the portfolio of assets referred to in Article
77b(1), point (a).’;
(c) the following paragraph 2a is inserted:
‘2a. In order to ensure uniform conditions of
application of Article 77(7), EIOPA shall
develop draft implementing technical standards
specifying the set of scenarios to be used for the
prudent deterministic valuation of the best
estimate for life obligations referred to in that
paragraph.
204
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
EIOPA shall submit those draft implementing
technical standards to the Commission by [OP
please insert date = 12 months after entry into
force].
Power is conferred on the Commission to adopt
those implementing technical standards in
accordance with Article 15 of Regulation (EU)
No 1094/2010.’;
(41) Article 92 is amended as follows:
(a) paragraph 1a is replaced by the
following:
‘1a. The Commission shall adopt delegated
acts in accordance with Article 301a specifying
the treatment of participations, within the
meaning of Article 212(2), third subparagraph,
205
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
in financial and credit institutions with respect
to the determination of own funds, including
approaches to deductions from the basic own
funds of an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking of material participations in credit
and financial institutions.
Notwithstanding the deductions of participations
from the own funds eligible to cover the
Solvency Capital Requirement as specified in
the delegated act adopted pursuant to the first
subparagraph, for the purpose of determining
the basic own funds as referred to in Article 88,
supervisory authorities may permit an insurance
or reinsurance undertaking not to deduct the
value of its participation in a credit or financial
institution, provided that all of the following
conditions are met:
206
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) the insurance or reinsurance undertaking
is in one of the circumstances described in point
(i) or (ii) of this point:
(i) the credit or financial institution and the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking belong to
the same group, as defined in Article 212, to
which group supervision applies in accordance
with Article 213(2), points (a), (b) and (c), and
the related credit or financial institution is not
subject to the deduction referred to in Article
228(6);
(ii) supervisory authorities require or permit
insurance or reinsurance undertakings to apply
technical calculation methods in accordance
with Part II of Annex I to Directive 2002/87/EC,
and the credit or financial institution is included
in the same supplementary supervision under
207
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
that Directive as the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking;
(b) supervisory authorities are satisfied as to
the level of integrated management, risk
management and internal control regarding the
undertakings in the scope of group supervision
referred to in point (a)(i) of this subparagraph or
in the scope of supplementary supervision
referred to in point (a)(ii) of this subparagraph;
(c) the related participation in the credit or
financial institution is an equity investment of
strategic nature as specified in the delegated act
adopted pursuant to Article 111(1), point (m).’;
(b) paragraph 2 is replaced by the following:
208
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘2. Participations in financial and credit
institutions as referred to in paragraph 1a shall
comprise the following:
(a) participations which insurance and
reinsurance undertakings hold in:
(i) credit institutions and financial institutions
within the meaning of Article 4(1), points (1)
and (26), of Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 ,
(ii) investment firms within the meaning of
Article 4(1), point 1, of Directive 2014/65/EU’;
(b) Additional Tier 1 instruments referred to in
Article 52 of Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 and
Tier 2 instruments referred to in Article 63 of
that Regulation, as well as Additional Tier 1 and
Tier 2 instruments within the meaning of Article
209
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
9 of Regulation (EU) No 2019/2033, which
insurance and reinsurance undertakings hold in
respect of the entities referred to in point (a) of
this paragraph in which they hold a
participation.’;
(42) in Article 95, the second subparagraph is
replaced by the following:
‘For that purpose, insurance and reinsurance
undertakings shall, where applicable, refer to the
list of own-funds items referred to in Article
97(1).’;
(43) in Article 96, the first paragraph is
replaced by the following:
210
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘Without prejudice to Article 95 and Article
97(1) for the purposes of this Directive the
following classifications shall be applied:
(1) surplus funds falling under Article 91(2)
shall be classified in Tier 1;
(2) letters of credit and guarantees which are
held in trust for the benefit of insurance
creditors by an independent trustee and provided
by credit institutions authorised in accordance
with Directive 2013/36/EU shall be classified in
Tier 2;
(3) any future claims which mutual or mutual-
type associations of shipowners with variable
contributions solely insuring risks listed in
classes 6, 12 and 17 in Part A of Annex I may
have against their members by way of a call for
211
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
supplementary contributions, within the
following 12 months, shall be classified in Tier
2.’;
(44) in Article 106, paragraph 3 is replaced
by the following:
‘3. The symmetric adjustment made to the
standard equity capital charge covering the risk
arising from changes in the level of equity
prices shall not result in an equity capital charge
being applied that is more than 17 percentage
points lower or higher than the standard equity
capital charge.’;
(45) Article 109 is replaced by the following:
‘Article 109
Simplifications in the standard formula
212
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
1. Insurance and reinsurance undertakings may
use a simplified calculation for a specific sub-
module or risk module where the nature, scale
and complexity of the risks they face justifies it
and where it would be disproportionate to
require all insurance and reinsurance
undertakings to apply the standardised
calculation.
For the purposes of this paragraph, simplified
calculations shall be calibrated in accordance
with Article 101(3).
2. Without prejudice to paragraph 1 of this
Article and to Article 102(1), where an
insurance or reinsurance undertaking calculates
the Solvency Capital Requirement and a risk
module or sub-module does not represent a
213
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
share of more than 5 % of the Basic Solvency
Capital Requirement referred to in Article 103,
point (a), the undertaking may use a simplified
calculation for that risk module or sub-module
during a period of no more than three years
following that calculation of the Solvency
Capital Requirement.
3. For the purposes of paragraph 2, the sum over
the shares, relative to the Basic Solvency
Capital Requirement, of each risk module or
sub-module where the simplified calculations
pursuant to paragraph 2 are applied shall not
exceed 10 %.
The share of a risk module or sub-module
relative to the Basic Solvency Capital
Requirement referred to in the first
subparagraph shall be that share as calculated
214
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the last time when the risk module or sub-
module was calculated without a simplified
calculation pursuant to paragraph 2.’;
(46) Article 111(1) is amended as follows:
(a) points (l) and (m) are replaced by the
following:
‘(l) the simplified calculations provided for
specific risk modules and sub-modules referred
to in Article 109(1) and for immaterial risk
modules and sub-modules referred to in Article
109(2), as well as the criteria that insurance and
reinsurance undertakings, including captive
insurance undertakings and captive reinsurance
undertakings, shall be required to fulfil in order
to be entitled to use simplifications, as set out in
Article 109(1);
215
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(m) the approach to be used with respect to
qualifying holdings within the meaning of
Article 13(21) in the calculation of the Solvency
Capital Requirement, in particular the
calculation of the equity risk sub-module
referred to in Article 105(5), taking into account
the likely reduction in the volatility of the value
of those qualifying holdings arising from the
strategic nature of those investments and the
influence exercised by the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking on those investees;’;
(b) the following subparagraph is added:
‘For the purpose of the first subparagraph, point
(h), the methods and adjustments to be used to
reflect the reduced scope for risk diversification
of insurance and reinsurance undertakings
216
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
relating to ring-fenced funds shall not apply to
the portfolios of assets that are not ring-fenced
funds and that are assigned to cover a
corresponding best estimate of insurance or
reinsurance obligations as referred to in Article
77b(1), point (a).’;
(47) in Article 112, paragraph 7 is replaced
by the following:
‘7. After having received approval from
supervisory authorities to use an internal model,
and each time they report the result of a
calculation of the Solvency Capital Requirement
pursuant to Article 102(1), insurance and
reinsurance undertakings shall provide the
supervisory authorities with an estimate of the
Solvency Capital Requirement determined in
217
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
accordance with the standard formula, as set out
in Subsection 2.’;
(48) in Article 122, the following paragraph 5
is added:
‘5. Member States may allow insurance and
reinsurance undertakings to take into account
the effect of credit spread movements on the
volatility adjustment calculated in accordance
with Article 77d in their internal model, only
where:
(a) the method to take into account the effect of
credit spread movements on the volatility
adjustment for the euro does not take into
account a possible increase of the volatility
adjustment by a macro volatility adjustment
pursuant to Article 77d(4);
218
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the Solvency Capital Requirement is not
lower than any of the following:
(i) a notional Solvency Capital Requirement
calculated as the Solvency Capital Requirement,
except that the effect of credit spread
movements on the volatility adjustment is taken
into account in accordance with the
methodology used by EIOPA for the purposes
of the publication of technical information
pursuant to Article 77e(1), point (c);
(ii) a notional Solvency Capital Requirement
calculated in accordance with (i), except that the
representative portfolio for a currency referred
to in Article 77d(2), second subparagraph, is
determined on the basis of the assets in which
the insurance and reinsurance undertaking is
219
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
investing instead of the assets of all insurance or
reinsurance undertakings with insurance or
reinsurance obligations denominated in that
currency.
For the purpose of the first subparagraph, point
(b), the determination of the representative
portfolio for a given currency shall be based on
the undertaking’s assets dominated in that
currency and used to cover the best estimate for
insurance and reinsurance obligations
denominated in that currency.’;
(49) Article 132 is amended as follows:
(a) in paragraph 3, second subparagraph, the
words ‘Directive 85/611/EEC’ are replaced by
the words ‘Directive 2009/65/EC’;
220
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the following paragraphs 5, 6 and 7 are
added:
‘5. Member States shall ensure that insurance
and reinsurance undertakings take account of
possible macroeconomic and financial markets’
developments and, at the request of the
supervisory authority, macroprudential concerns
when they decide on their investment strategy.
6. Insurance and reinsurance undertakings shall
assess the extent to which their investment
strategy may affect macroeconomic and
financial markets’ developments and have the
potential to turn into sources of systemic risk,
and incorporate such considerations as part of
their investment decisions.
221
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
7. For the purpose of paragraphs 5 and 6 of this
Article, macroeconomic developments and
macroprudential concerns shall have the same
meaning as in Article 45.’;
(50) in Article 133(3), the words ‘Directive
85/611/EEC’ are replaced by the words
‘Directive 2009/65/EC’;
(51) Article 138(4) is amended as follows:
(a) the first subparagraph is replaced by the
following:
‘In the event of exceptional adverse situations
affecting insurance and reinsurance
undertakings representing a significant share of
the market or of the affected lines of business,
as declared by EIOPA, the supervisory authority
222
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
may extend, for affected undertakings, the
period set out in paragraph 3, second
subparagraph, by a maximum period of seven
years, taking into account all relevant factors
including the average duration of the technical
provisions.’;
(b) in the second subparagraph, the first
sentence is replaced by the following:
‘Without prejudice to the powers of EIOPA
under Article 18 of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010, for the purposes of this paragraph
EIOPA shall, following a request by the
supervisory authority concerned and, where
appropriate, after consulting the ESRB, declare
the existence of exceptional adverse situations.’;
(52) Article 139 is replaced by the following:
223
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘Article 139
Non-Compliance with the Minimum Capital
Requirement
1. Insurance and reinsurance undertakings shall
inform the supervisory authority immediately
where they observe that the Minimum Capital
Requirement is no longer complied with, or
where there is a risk of non-compliance in the
following three months.
For the purpose of the first subparagraph of this
paragraph, the requirement to inform the
supervisory authority shall apply irrespective of
whether the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking observes the failure to comply with
the Minimum Capital Requirement or the risk of
non-compliance during a calculation of the
224
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Minimum Capital Requirement pursuant to
Article 129(4) or during a calculation of the
Minimum Capital Requirement between two
dates when such calculation is reported to the
supervisory authority pursuant to Article 129(4).
2. Within one month from the observation of
non-compliance with the Minimum Capital
Requirement or from the observation of the risk
of non-compliance, the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking concerned shall submit, for
approval by the supervisory authority, a short-
term realistic finance scheme to restore, within
three months of that observation, the eligible
basic own funds, at least to the level of the
Minimum Capital Requirement or to reduce its
risk profile to ensure compliance with the
Minimum Capital Requirement.
225
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
3. If a winding-up proceeding is not opened
within two months of receipt of the information
referred to in paragraph 1, the supervisory
authority of the home Member State shall
consider restricting or prohibiting the free
disposal of assets of the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking. It shall inform the
supervisory authorities of the host Member
States accordingly. At the request of the
supervisory authority of the home Member
State, those authorities shall take the same
measures. The supervisory authority of the
home Member State shall designate the assets to
be covered by such measures.
4. EIOPA may develop guidelines for the
actions that supervisory authorities should take
when they observe a failure to comply with the
226
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Minimum Capital Requirement or the risk of
non-compliance referred to in paragraph 1.’;
(53) in Article 144, the following paragraph 4
is added:
‘4. In the event of withdrawal of authorisation,
Member States shall ensure that insurance and
reinsurance undertakings continue to be subject
to the general rules and objectives of the
insurance supervision set out in Title I, Chapter
III, until any winding-up proceedings are
opened.’;
(54) in Title I, the following chapter is
inserted:
‘CHAPTER VIIA
Macroprudential tools
227
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 144a
Liquidity risk management
1. Member States shall ensure that the liquidity
risk management of insurance and reinsurance
undertakings referred to in Article 44(2), point
(d), ensure they maintain adequate liquidity to
settle their financial obligation towards
policyholders and other counterparties when
they fall due, even under stressed conditions.
2. For the purpose of paragraph 1, Member
States shall ensure that insurance and
reinsurance undertakings draw up and maintain
a liquidity risk management plan projecting the
incoming and outgoing cash flows in relation to
their assets and liabilities. Member States shall
ensure that insurance and reinsurance
228
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertakings develop a set of liquidity risk
indicators to identify, monitor and address
potential liquidity stress.
3. Member States shall ensure that insurance
and reinsurance undertakings submit to the
supervisory authorities the liquidity risk
management plan as part of the information
referred to in Article 35(1).
4. Member States shall ensure that insurance
and reinsurance undertakings that are classified
as low-risk profile undertakings pursuant to
Article 29c and insurance or reinsurance
undertakings which have obtained prior
approval from the supervisory authority
pursuant to Article 29d are not obliged to draw
up a liquidity risk management plan as referred
to in paragraph 2 of this Article.
229
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
5. Member States shall ensure that, where
insurance and reinsurance undertakings apply
the matching adjustment referred to in Article
77b or the volatility adjustment referred to in
Article 77d, they may combine the liquidity risk
management plan referred to in paragraph 3 of
this Article with the plan required in accordance
with Article 44(2), third subparagraph.
6. In order to ensure consistent application of
this Article, EIOPA shall develop draft
regulatory technical standards to further specify
the content and the frequency of update of the
liquidity risk management plan.
EIOPA shall submit those draft regulatory
technical standards to the Commission by [OP
230
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
please add date = 12 months after entry into
force].
Power is conferred on the Commission to adopt
the regulatory technical standards referred to in
the first subparagraph in accordance with
Articles 10 to 14 of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010.
Article 144b
Supervisory powers to remedy liquidity
vulnerabilities in exceptional circumstances
1. As part of the regular supervisory review,
supervisory authorities shall monitor the
liquidity position of insurance and reinsurance
undertakings. Where they identify material
liquidity risks, they shall inform the concerned
insurance or reinsurance undertaking of this
231
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
assessment. The insurance or reinsurance
undertaking shall explain how it intends to
address those liquidity risks.
2. Member States shall ensure that supervisory
authorities have the necessary powers to require
undertakings to reinforce their liquidity position
when liquidity risks or deficiencies are
identified. Such powers shall be applied where
there is sufficient evidence regarding the
existence of liquidity risk vulnerabilities and the
absence of effective remedies taken by the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking.
The measures taken by supervisory authorities
on the basis of this paragraph shall be reviewed
at least once a year by the supervisory authority
and be removed when the undertaking has taken
effective remedies.
232
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
3. Member States shall ensure that supervisory
authorities have the power to temporarily
suspend redemption rights of policyholders on
life insurance policies of undertakings facing
significant liquidity risks that may cause a threat
to the protection of policyholders or to the
stability of the financial system.
Such a power shall only be exercised in
exceptional circumstances, as a last resort
measure. Before exercising such a power, the
supervisory authority shall take into account
potential unintended effects on financial
markets and on the rights of policyholders,
including in a cross-border context.
The application of the measure referred to in the
first subparagraph shall last three months.
233
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Member States shall ensure that the measure can
be renewed if the underlying reasons that justify
it are still present and it is no longer applied
when those reasons are no longer present.
Without prejudice to Article 144c (6), Member
States shall ensure that the insurance and
reinsurance undertakings concerned do not
make distributions to shareholders and other
subordinated creditors, and do not pay bonuses
or other variable remuneration until the
suspension of redemption rights is lifted by the
supervisory authorities.
Member States shall ensure that authorities with
a macroprudential mandate, where different
from the supervisory authorities, are duly
informed of the supervisory authority's intention
to make use of the power referred to in this
234
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
paragraph, and are appropriately involved in
assessing the potential unintended effects
referred to in the second subparagraph.
Member States shall ensure that supervisory
authorities shall notify EIOPA and ESRB
whenever the power referred to in paragraph 3 is
exercised to address a risk for the stability of the
financial system.
4. The power referred to in paragraph 3 may be
exercised in relation to all undertakings
operating in that Member State where the
exceptional circumstances referred to in
paragraph 3 affect the whole or a significant part
of the insurance market.
Member States shall appoint an authority to
exercise the power referred to in this paragraph.
235
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Where the appointed authority is different from
the supervisory authority, the Member State
shall ensure proper coordination and exchange
of information between the different authorities.
In particular, authorities shall be required to
cooperate closely and to share all the
information that may be necessary for the
adequate performance of the duties entrusted to
the authority appointed pursuant to this
paragraph.
5. Member States shall ensure that the authority
referred to in paragraph 4, second subparagraph,
shall notify EIOPA and, where the measure is
taken to address a risk to the stability of the
financial system, the ESRB of the use of the
power referred to in paragraph 4.
236
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
The notification shall include a description of
the measure applied, its duration, and a
description of the reasons and risks that
motivated the use of the power, including the
reasons why it was considered effective and
proportionate in relation to its negative effects
on policyholders.
6. In order to ensure consistent application of
this Article, EIOPA shall, after consulting the
ESRB, develop guidelines to:
(a) provide further guidance on measures to
address deficiencies in liquidity risk
management and on the form, activation and
calibration of powers that supervisory
authorities may exercise to reinforce the
liquidity position of undertakings when liquidity
237
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
risks are identified and are not adequately
remedied by these undertakings;
(b) specify the existence of exceptional
circumstances that may justify the temporary
suspension of redemption rights;
(c) specify the conditions for ensuring the
consistent application of the temporary
suspension of redemption rights across the
Union and the aspects to consider for equally
and adequately protecting policyholders in all
home and host jurisdictions.
Article 144c
Supervisory measures to preserve the
financial position of undertakings during
exceptional market-wide shocks
238
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
1. Without prejudice to Article 141, Member
States shall ensure that supervisory authorities
have the power to take measures to preserve the
financial position of individual insurance or
reinsurance undertakings during periods of
exceptional sector-wide shocks that have the
potential to threaten the financial position of the
undertaking concerned or the stability of the
financial system.
2. During periods of exceptional sector-wide
shocks, supervisory authorities shall have the
power to require undertakings with a
particularly vulnerable risk profile to take at
least the following measures:
(a) restrict or suspend dividend distributions to
shareholders and other subordinated creditors;
239
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) restrict or suspend other payments to
shareholders and other subordinated creditors;
(c) restrict or suspend share buy-backs and
repayment or redemption of own fund items;
(d) restrict or suspend bonuses or other variable
remuneration.
Member States shall ensure that the relevant
national bodies and authorities which have a
macroprudential mandate are duly informed of
the national supervisory authority's intention to
make use of this Article, and are appropriately
involved in the assessment of exceptional
sector-wide shocks in accordance with this
paragraph.
240
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
3. The application of the measures referred to in
paragraph 2 of this Article shall duly take into
account the proportionality criteria referred to in
Article 29(3), and the existence of any
preventively agreed risk tolerance limits and
thresholds for internal capital planning.
4. The application of measures referred to in
paragraph 2 of this Article shall take into
account the evidence resulting from the
supervisory process and a forward-looking
assessment of the solvency and financial
position of the undertakings concerned, in line
with the assessment referred to in Article 45(1),
second subparagraph, points (a) and (b).
5. The application of the measures referred to in
paragraph 2 shall last for as long as the
underlying reasons that justify the measure are
241
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
present. Those measures shall be reviewed
every three months and shall be removed as
soon as the underlying conditions that motivated
the measures are over.
6. For the purpose of this Article, significant
intra-group transactions referred to in Article
245(2) including intra-group dividend
distributions, shall only be suspended or
restricted where they are a threat to the solvency
or liquidity position of the group or of one of the
undertakings within the group. The supervisory
authority of a related undertaking shall consult
the group supervisor before suspending or
restricting transactions with the rest of the
group.
7. In order to ensure consistent conditions of
application of this Article, EIOPA shall, after
242
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
consulting the ESRB, develop implementing
technical standards to specify the existence of
exceptional sector-wide shocks.
EIOPA shall submit those draft implementing
technical standards to the Commission by [OP
please add date = 12 months after entry into
force].
Power is conferred on the Commission to adopt
those implementing technical standards in
accordance with Article 15 of Regulation (EU)
No 1094/2010.’;
(55) in Article 145, paragraph 2 is amended
as follows:
(a) point (c) is replaced by the following:
243
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘(c) the name of a person who possesses
sufficient powers to bind, in relation to third
parties, the insurance undertaking;’;
(b) the second subparagraph is deleted;
(56) Article 149 is replaced by the following:
‘Article 149
Changes in the nature of the risks or
commitments
1 The procedure provided for in Articles 147
and 148 shall apply to any change which an
insurance undertaking intends to make to the
information referred to in Article 147.
2. Where there is a change in the business
pursued by the insurance undertaking under the
244
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
freedom to provide services that is materially
affecting its risk profile or materially
influencing the insurance activities in one or
more host Member States, the insurance
undertaking shall inform the supervisory
authority of the home Member State
immediately. The supervisory authority of the
home Member State shall inform the
supervisory authorities of the host Member
States concerned without delay.’;
(57) in Article 152a, paragraph 2 is replaced
by the following:
‘2. The supervisory authority of the home
Member State shall notify EIOPA and the
supervisory authority of the relevant host
Member State if it identifies deteriorating
financial conditions or other emerging risks,
245
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
including those concerning consumer
protection, posed by an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking carrying out activities which are
based on the freedom to provide services or the
freedom of establishment and which may have a
cross-border effect. The supervisory authority of
the host Member State may also notify EIOPA
and the supervisory authority of the relevant
home Member State where it has serious and
reasoned concerns with regard to consumer
protection. The supervisory authorities may
refer the matter to EIOPA and request its
assistance where no bilateral solution can be
found.’;
(58) in Article 152b, following paragraphs 5
and 6 are added:
246
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘5. Where two or more relevant authorities of a
collaboration platform disagree about the
procedure or content of an action to be taken, or
inaction, in relation to an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking, EIOPA may, at the
request of any relevant authority or on its own
initiative, assist the authorities in reaching an
agreement in accordance with Article 19(1) of
Regulation (EU) No 1094/2010.
6. In the event of disagreement within the
platform and where there are serious concerns
about negative effects on policyholders or about
the content of an action or inaction to be taken
in relation to an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking, EIOPA may decide, on its own
initiative, to initiate and coordinate on-site
inspections. It shall invite the supervisory
authority of the home Member State as well as
247
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
other relevant supervisory authorities of the
collaboration platform to participate in those on-
site inspections.’;
(59) Article 153 is replaced by the following:
‘Article 153
Timeframe and language of information
requests
The supervisory authority of the host Member
State may require the information which it is
entitled to request with regard to the business of
an insurance undertaking operating in the
territory of that Member State either from the
supervisory authority of the home Member State
of that undertaking or from the insurance
undertaking. That information shall be supplied
within a reasonable period of time in the official
248
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
language or languages of the host Member
State, or in another language accepted by the
supervisory authority of the host Member State.
Where the supervisory authority of the host
Member State addresses the insurance
undertaking directly, it shall inform the
supervisory authority of the home Member State
about the information request.’;
(60) the following Article 159a is inserted:
‘Article 159a
Additional requirements related to
significant cross-border activities
1. The supervisory authority of the home
Member State shall, upon the request of the
supervisory authority of a host Member State,
submit all of the following information received
249
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
in accordance with Article 35, in relation to
insurance or reinsurance undertakings with
significant cross-border activities in the territory
of that host Member State:
(a) the Solvency Capital Requirement;
(b) the Minimum Capital Requirement;
(c) the amount of eligible own funds to
cover the Solvency Capital Requirement;
(d) the amount of eligible basic own funds
to cover the Minimum Capital Requirement.
For the purposes of this Article, ‘significant
cross-border activities’ means insurance and
reinsurance activities carried out under the right
of establishment and those carried out under the
250
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
freedom to provide services in a Member State
for which the annual gross written premium
exceeds 5 % of the annual gross written
premium of the undertaking, measured with
reference to the last available financial
statements of the undertaking.
2. Where an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking does not comply with or is likely
not to comply with the Minimum Capital
Requirement in the following three months, or
where there is a significant non-compliance with
the Solvency Capital Requirement, and in the
absence of appropriate measures by the
supervisory authority of the home Member State
to appropriately remedy such situation, the
supervisory authority of the host Member State
in which that undertaking has significant cross-
border activities, may request the supervisory
251
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
authority of the home Member State to carry out
jointly an on-site inspection of the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking, explaining the reasons
for such a request.
The supervisory authority of the home Member
State shall accept or refuse the request referred
to in the first subparagraph within one month of
its receipt.
3. Where the supervisory authority of the home
Member State accepts to carry out a joint on-site
inspection, it shall invite EIOPA to participate
in the joint on-site inspection.
After the conclusion of the joint on-site
inspection, the supervisory authorities
concerned shall reach joint conclusions within
two months. The supervisory authority of the
252
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
home Member State shall take into account such
joint conclusions when deciding on the adequate
supervisory responses.
Where the supervisory authorities disagree on
the conclusions of the joint on-site inspection,
either of them may, within two month following
the expiry of the period referred to in the second
subparagraph , and without prejudice to the
supervisory actions and powers to be taken by
the supervisory authority of the home Member
State to address the non-compliance with the
Solvency Capital Requirement or the non-
compliance or likely non-compliance with the
Minimum Capital Requirement, refer the matter
to EIOPA and request its assistance in
accordance with Article 19 of Regulation (EU)
No 1094/2010. The matter shall not be referred
to EIOPA after the expiry of the two-month
253
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
period referred to in this subparagraph nor after
an agreement on joint conclusions has been
reached between supervisory authorities in
accordance with the second subparagraph.
If, within the two-month period referred to in
the third subparagraph, any of the supervisory
authorities concerned has referred the matter to
EIOPA in accordance with Article 19 of
Regulation (EU) No 1094/2010, the supervisory
authority of the home Member State shall defer
the adoption of the final conclusions of the joint
on-site inspection and await any decision that
EIOPA may take in accordance with Article
19(3) of that Regulation, and shall adopt the
conclusions in conformity with EIOPA's
decision. All supervisory authorities concerned
shall recognise those conclusions as
determinative.
254
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
4. Where the supervisory authority of the home
Member State refuses to carry out a joint on-site
inspection, it shall explain in writing the reasons
for such refusal to the requesting supervisory
authority.
Where supervisory authorities disagree with the
reasons for refusal, they may refer the matter to
EIOPA and request its assistance in accordance
with Article 19 of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010 within one month after notification
of the decision by the supervisory authority of
the home Member State. In that case, EIOPA
may act in accordance with the powers
conferred on it by that Article. ’;
(61) Article 212 is amended as follows:
255
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) paragraph 1 is amended as follows:
(i) in point (a), the words ‘Article 12(1) of
Directive 83/349/EEC’ are replaced by ‘Article
22(7) of Directive 2013/34/EU’;
(ii) in point (b), the words ‘Article 12(1) of
Directive 83/349/EEC’ are replaced by ‘Article
22(7) of Directive 2013/34/EU’;
(iii) point (c) is amended as follows:
– point (i) is replaced by the following:
‘(i) consists of a participating undertaking, its
subsidiaries, the entities in which the
participating undertaking or its subsidiaries hold
a participation and undertakings that are
managed by the participating undertaking or its
256
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
subsidiaries jointly with one or more
undertakings that are not part of the group, as
well as undertakings linked to each other by a
relationship as set out in Article 22(7) of
Directive 2013/34/EU and their related
undertakings; or’;
– the following point (iii) is added:
‘(iii) consists of a combination of points (i) and
(ii);’;
(iv) point (f) is replaced by the following:
‘(f) ‘insurance holding company’ means a
parent undertaking which is not a mixed
financial holding company and the main
business of which is to acquire and hold
participations in subsidiary undertakings, where
257
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
those subsidiary undertakings are exclusively or
mainly insurance or reinsurance undertakings,
or third-country insurance or reinsurance
undertakings, at least one of such subsidiary
undertakings being an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking; the subsidiary undertakings are
mainly insurance or reinsurance undertakings or
third-country insurance or reinsurance
undertakings where more than 50 % of the
parent undertaking’s equity, consolidated assets,
revenues, personnel or other indicator
considered relevant by the supervisory authority
are associated with subsidiaries that are
insurance or reinsurance undertakings,
third-country insurance or reinsurance
undertakings insurance holding companies or
mixed financial holding companies;’;
(v) the following point (fa) is inserted:
258
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘(fa) ‘holding company of third-country
insurance and reinsurance undertakings’ means
a parent undertaking other than an insurance
holding company or a mixed financial holding
company within the meaning of Article 2(15) of
Directive 2002/87/EC, the main business of
which is to acquire and hold participations in
subsidiary undertakings, where those subsidiary
undertakings are exclusively or mainly third-
country insurance or reinsurance undertakings.’;
(b) in paragraph 2, the first subparagraph is
replaced by the following:
‘For the purposes of this Title, the supervisory
authorities shall also consider as a parent
undertaking any undertaking which, in the
opinion of the supervisory authorities,
259
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
effectively exercises a dominant influence over
another undertaking, including where this
influence is exercised through centralised
coordination, over the decisions of the other
undertaking.’;
(c) the following paragraphs 3, 4, 5 and 6
are added:
‘3. For the purposes of this Title, the
supervisory authorities shall also consider that
two or more insurance or reinsurance
undertakings form a group within the meaning
of paragraph 1, point (c), where in the opinion
of the supervisory authorities, those
undertakings are managed on a unified basis.
Where such a group is subject to group
supervision in accordance with Article 213(2),
260
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
points (a), (b) and (c), the group shall designate
one of those undertakings as a parent
undertaking which shall be responsible for
complying with this Title. The other
undertakings referred to in the first
subparagraph shall be considered as subsidiary
undertakings.
4. Where a group is identified in accordance
with paragraphs 2 and 3, and where a parent
undertaking or a subsidiary undertaking of that
group is also the ultimate participating
undertaking of another group within the
meaning of paragraph 1, point (c), that other
group shall be considered as included in the
scope of the group identified in accordance with
paragraphs 2 and 3.
261
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Supervisory authorities may apply paragraphs 2
and 3 to extend the scope of a group within the
meaning of paragraph 1, point (c).
5. When identifying a relationship between at
least two undertakings referred to in paragraphs
2 and 3, supervisory authorities shall consider
all of the following factors:
(a) control or ability of a natural person or
an undertaking to influence decisions, including
financial ones, of an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking, in particular due to the holding of
capital or voting rights, representation in the
administrative, management or supervisory
body, or being among the persons who
effectively run an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking or who have other key, critical or
important functions;
262
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) strong reliance of an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking on another undertaking
or legal person, due to the existence of material
financial or non-financial transactions or
operations;
(c) evidence of coordination between two or
more undertakings of financial decisions,
strategies, or processes.
6. Where the group fails to designate a parent
undertaking in accordance with paragraph 3,
second subparagraph, the supervisory
authorities shall designate a parent undertaking
which is to be responsible for complying with
this Title. The other undertakings in such group
shall be considered as subsidiary undertakings.
263
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
When designating in accordance with the first
subparagraph, supervisory authorities shall
consider the following factors:
(a) the amount of technical provisions of
each undertaking;
(b) the annual gross written premiums of
each undertaking;
(c) the number of related insurance or
reinsurance undertakings of each undertaking.
Supervisory authorities shall regularly assess
whether the designation remains appropriate.
Where this is not the case, the supervisory
authorities shall designate another parent
undertaking. That other authority shall be
responsible for complying with this Title.’;
264
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(62) Article 213 is amended as follows:
(a) in paragraph 2, the introductory wording
is replaced by the following:
‘Member States shall ensure that group
supervision applies when a group includes any
of the following:’;
(b) the following paragraph 2a is inserted:
‘2a. The scope of the group to which group
supervision applies pursuant to paragraph 2 of
this Article shall be identified in accordance
with Article 212.’;
(c) the following paragraphs 3a, 3b and 3c
are inserted:
265
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘3a. In the cases referred to in paragraph 2, point
(b), the insurance holding company or mixed
financial holding company shall ensure that all
of the following conditions are fulfilled:
(a) the internal arrangements and
distribution of tasks within the group are
adequate for the purpose of complying with this
Title and, in particular, are effective to:
(i) coordinate all the subsidiary
undertakings of the insurance holding company
or mixed financial holding company including,
where necessary, through an adequate
distribution of tasks among those undertakings;
266
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(ii) prevent or manage intra-group conflicts;
and
(iii) enforce the group-wide policies set by
the parent insurance holding company or parent
mixed financial holding company throughout
the group;
(b) the structural organisation of the group
of which the insurance holding company or
mixed financial holding company is part does
not obstruct or otherwise prevent the effective
supervision of the group and its subsidiary
insurance and reinsurance undertakings, taking
into account, in particular:
267
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(i) the position of the insurance holding
company or mixed financial holding company in
a multi-layered group;
(ii) the shareholding structure; and
(iii) the role of the insurance holding
company or mixed financial holding company
within the group.
3b. Where the conditions set out in paragraph
3a, point (a), are not satisfied, the group
supervisor shall have the power to require the
insurance holding company or mixed financial
holding companies to change internal
arrangements and distributions of tasks within
the group.
268
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Where the conditions set out in paragraph 3a,
point (b), are not satisfied, the insurance holding
company or mixed financial holding company
shall be subject to appropriate supervisory
measures by the group supervisor to ensure or
restore, as the case may be, continuity and
integrity of group supervision and compliance
with the requirements laid down in this Title. In
particular, Member States shall ensure that
supervisory authorities have the power to
require the insurance holding company or mixed
financial holding company to structure the
group in a way which enables the relevant
supervisory authority to effectively exercise
group supervision. Such a power shall only be
exercised in exceptional circumstances, after
consulting EIOPA and, where applicable, other
supervisory authorities concerned and shall be
duly justified to the group.
269
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
3c. In the cases referred to in paragraph 2,
points (a) and (b), of this Article where the
structural organisation of a group which consist
of undertakings linked to each other by a
relationship as set out in Article 22(7) of
Directive 2013/34/EU and their related
undertakings, or which is identified on the basis
of Article 212(3) of this Directive, is such that it
obstructs or prevents the effective supervision of
that group or it prevents that group from
complying with this Title, the group shall be
subject to appropriate supervisory measures to
ensure or restore, as the case may be, continuity
and integrity of group supervision and
compliance with this Title. In particular,
Member States shall ensure that supervisory
authorities have the power to require the
establishment of an insurance holding company
270
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
or a mixed financial holding company which
has its head office in the Union, or the
establishment of an undertaking in the Union
which effectively exercises, through centralised
coordination, a dominant influence over the
decisions, including financial decisions, of the
insurance or reinsurance undertakings that are
part of the group. In that case, that insurance
holding company, mixed financial holding
company or undertaking which effectively
exercises centralised coordination shall be
responsible for complying with this Title.’;
(d) in paragraph 5, the words ‘Directive
2006/48/EC’ are replaced by the words
‘Directive 2013/36/EU’;
(63) the following Article 213a is inserted:
271
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘Article 213a
Use of proportionality measures at the level
of the group
1. Groups within the meaning of Article 212
that are subject to group supervision in
accordance with Article 213(2), points (a) and
(b), shall be classified as low risk profile groups
by their group supervisor, following the
procedure set out in paragraph 2 of this Article
where they meet all the following criteria at the
level of the group for the last two financial
years:
(a) where at least one insurance or reinsurance
undertaking in the scope of the group is not a
non-life undertaking, all of the following criteria
shall be met:
272
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(i) the interest rate risk submodule referred to in
Article 105(5), point (a), is not higher than 5 %
of the group technical provisions, gross of the
amounts recoverable from reinsurance contracts
and special purpose vehicles, as referred to in
Article 76;
(ii) the return on investments, excluding
investments held for insurance obligations with
index-linked and unit-linked benefits, is higher
than the average guaranteed interest rates;
(iii) the total of the technical provisions of the
group defined as gross of the amounts
recoverable from reinsurance contracts and
special purpose vehicles is not higher than EUR
1 000 000 000;
273
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) where at least one insurance or reinsurance
undertaking in the scope of the group is not a
life undertaking, all of the following criteria
shall be met:
(i) the averaged combined ratio net of
reinsurance of the last three financial years is
less than 100 %
(ii) the annual gross written premium of the
group is not higher than EUR 100 000 000;
(iii) the sum of the annual gross written
premiums in classes 3 to 7 and classes 14 and 15
of Section A of Annex I is not higher than 30%
of total annual written premiums of non-life
business of the group;
274
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) business underwritten by insurance and
reinsurance undertakings in the scope of the
group which have their head offices in Member
States other than the Member State of the group
supervisor is not higher than 5 % of the total
annual gross written premium of the group;
(d) business underwritten by the group in
Member States other than the Member State of
the group supervisor is not higher than 5 % of
its total annual gross written premium;
(e) investments in non-traditional investments
do not represent more than 20% of total
investments;
(f) the business of the group does not include
reinsurance operations exceeding 50 % of its
275
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
total gross written premium income of the
group.
2. Article 29b shall apply mutatis mutandis at
the level of the ultimate parent insurance or
reinsurance undertaking, insurance holding
company or mixed financial holding company
3. Groups to which group supervision applies in
accordance with Article 213(2), points (a) and
(b), for less than two years shall take into
account only the last financial year when
assessing whether they meet the criteria set out
in paragraph 1 of this Article.
4. Without prejudice to paragraph 1, groups
which use an approved partial or full internal
model to calculate their group Solvency Capital
276
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Requirement shall never be classified as low
risk profile groups.
5. The ultimate parent insurance or reinsurance
undertakings, the insurance holding companies,
or the mixed financial holding companies shall
consider, in its assessment of compliance with
the criteria defined in paragraph 1, the business
plans for the next three financial years.
6. Articles 29c, 29d and 29e shall apply mutatis
mutandis.’;
(64) Article 214 is amended as follows:
(a) paragraph 1 is replaced by the following:
‘1. The exercise of group supervision in
accordance with Article 213 shall not imply that
277
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the supervisory authorities are required to play a
supervisory role in relation to the third-country
insurance undertaking, the third-country
reinsurance undertaking or the mixed-activity
insurance holding company taken individually.’;
(b) in paragraph 2, the following
subparagraph is inserted after the first
subparagraph:
‘When assessing whether an undertaking is of
negligible interest with respect to the objectives
of group supervision pursuant to the first
subparagraph, point (b), the group supervisor
shall ensure that all the following conditions are
met:
(i) the size of the undertaking, in terms of
total assets and of technical provisions, is small
278
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
in comparison with that of other undertakings of
the group and the group as a whole;
(ii) the exclusion of the undertaking from
the scope of group supervision would have no
material impact on the group solvency;
(iii) the qualitative and quantitative risks,
including those stemming from intragroup
transactions, that the undertaking poses or may
pose to the whole group, are immaterial.’;
(c) the following paragraph 3 is added:
‘3. Where the exclusion of one or more
undertakings from the scope of group
supervision in accordance with paragraph 2 of
this Article would result in a case that would not
trigger the application of group supervision
279
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
under Article 213(2), points (a), (b), and (c), the
group supervisor shall consult EIOPA and,
where applicable, other supervisory authorities
concerned before taking the decision on
exclusion. Such decision shall only be taken in
exceptional circumstances and shall be duly
justified to EIOPA and, where applicable, other
supervisory authorities concerned. The group
supervisor shall regularly reassess whether its
decision remains appropriate. Where that is no
longer the case, the group supervisor shall notify
EIOPA and, where applicable, other supervisory
authorities concerned that it will start exercising
group supervision.
Before excluding the ultimate parent
undertaking from group supervision pursuant to
paragraph 2, point (b), the group supervisor
shall consult EIOPA, and where applicable,
280
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
other supervisory authorities concerned, and
shall assess the impact of exercising group
supervision at the level of an intermediate
participating undertaking on the solvency
position of the group. In particular, such an
exclusion shall not be possible if it would result
in a material improvement in the solvency
position of the group.’;
(65) Article 220 is amended as follows:
(a) in paragraph 1, the words ‘set out in
Articles 221 to 233’ are replaced by the words
‘set out in Articles 221 to 233a’;
(b) in paragraph 2, the second subparagraph
is replaced by the following:
281
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘However, Member States shall allow their
supervisory authorities, where they assume the
role of group supervisor with regard to a
particular group, to decide, after consulting the
other supervisory authorities concerned and the
group itself, to apply to that group method 2 in
accordance with Articles 233 and 234, or, where
the exclusive application of method 1 would not
be appropriate, a combination of methods 1 and
2 in accordance with Articles 233a and 234.’;
(c) the following paragraph 3 is added:
‘3. Without prejudice to the treatment of
undertakings referred to in Article 228(1),
supervisory authorities may only decide to apply
method 2 pursuant to paragraph 2, second
subparagraph, of this Article to insurance and
reinsurance undertakings, third-country
282
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
insurance and reinsurance undertakings,
insurance holding companies, mixed financial
holding companies, and holding companies of
third-country insurance and reinsurance
undertakings.’;
(66) in Article 221, the following paragraph
1a is inserted:
‘1a. By way of derogation from paragraph 1
of this Article, for the sole purpose of Article
228, irrespective of whether method 1 or
method 2 is used, ‘proportional share’ means the
proportion of the subscribed capital that is held,
directly or indirectly, by the participating
undertaking in the related undertaking.’;
(67) in Article 222, paragraph 4 is replaced
by the following:
283
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘4. The sum of the own funds referred to in
paragraphs 2 and 3 shall not exceed the
contribution of the related insurance or
reinsurance undertaking to the group Solvency
Capital Requirement.’;
(68) in Article 226, the following paragraph 3
is added:
‘3. For the purposes of paragraphs 1 and 2,
holding companies of third-country insurance
and reinsurance undertakings shall also be
treated as insurance or reinsurance
undertakings.’;
(69) in Article 227(1), first subparagraph, the
words ‘and Article 233a’ are inserted after the
words ‘Article 233’;
284
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(70) Article 228 is replaced by the following:
‘Article 228
Treatment of specific related undertakings
from other financial sectors
1. Irrespective of the method used in accordance
with Article 220 of this Directive, for the
purpose of calculating the group solvency, the
participating insurance or reinsurance
undertaking shall take into account the
contribution to the group eligible own funds and
to the group Solvency Capital Requirement of
the following undertakings:
(a) credit institutions or investment firms
within the meaning of Article 4(1), point (1) or
(2), of Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 ;
285
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) UCITS management companies within
the meaning of Article 2(1), point (b), of
Directive 2009/65/EC and investment
companies authorised pursuant to Article 27 of
that Directive provided that they have not
designated a management company pursuant to
that Directive;
(c) alternative investment fund managers
within the meaning of Article 4(1), point (b), of
Directive 2011/61/EU;
(d) undertakings other than regulated
undertakings which carry one or more of the
activities referred to in Annex I to Directive
2013/36/EU where those activities constitute a
significant part of their overall activity;
286
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(e) institutions for occupational retirement
provision within the meaning of Article 6, point
(1) of Directive (EU) 2016/2341.
2. The contribution to the group eligible own
funds of the related undertakings referred to in
paragraph 1 of this Article shall be calculated as
the sum of the proportional share of the own
funds of each undertaking, where those own
funds are calculated as follows:
(a) for each undertaking referred to in
paragraph 1, point (a), of this Article in
accordance with the relevant sectoral rules, as
defined in Article 2, point (7), of Directive
2002/87/EC;
(b) for each related undertaking referred to
in paragraph 1, point (b), of this Article in
287
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
accordance with Article 2(1), point 1, of
Directive 2009/65/EC;
(c) for each related undertaking referred to
in paragraph 1, point (c), of this Article in
accordance with Article 4(1), point (ad), of
Directive 2011/61/EU;
(d) for each related undertaking referred to
in paragraph 1, point (d), of this Article in
accordance with the relevant sector rules as
defined in Article 2, point (7), of Directive
2002/87/EC if they were regulated entities
within the meaning of Article 2(4) of that
Directive;
(e) for each related undertaking referred to
in paragraph 1, point (e), of this Article the
available solvency margin calculated in
288
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
accordance with Article 17a of Directive (EU)
2016/2341.
For the purpose of the first subparagraph of this
paragraph, the amount of own funds of each
related undertaking corresponding to non-
distributable reserves and other items identified
by the group supervisor as having a reduced
loss-absorbency capacity, as well as preference
shares, subordinated mutual members account,
subordinated liabilities, and deferred tax assets,
that are included in the own funds in excess to
the own fund requirements calculated in
accordance with paragraph 3, shall not be taken
into account, unless the participating insurance
or reinsurance undertaking is able to justify, to
the satisfaction of the group supervisor, that
those items can be made available to cover the
group Solvency Capital Requirement. When
289
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
determining the composition of the excess own
funds, the participating insurance or reinsurance
undertaking shall take into account that certain
requirements of some related undertakings shall
only be met with Common Equity 1 capital or
Additional Tier 1 capital within the meaning of
Regulation (EU) No 575/2013.
3. The contribution to the group Solvency
Capital Requirement of the related undertakings
referred to in paragraph 1 shall be calculated as
the sum of the proportional share of the capital
requirement or notional capital requirement of
each related undertaking, where that capital
requirement or notional capital requirement is
calculated as follows:
290
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) for related undertakings referred to in
paragraph 1, point (a), of this Article in
accordance with the following:
(b) for each investment firm which is
subject to own fund requirements in accordance
with Regulation (EU) 2019/2033, the sum of the
requirement laid down in Article 11 of that
Regulation, the specific own funds requirements
referred to in Article 39(2), point (a), of
Directive (EU) 2019/2034, or the local own
funds requirements in third countries;
(c) for each credit institution, the higher of
the following:
– the sum of the requirement laid down in
Article 92(1), point (c), of Regulation (EU) No
575/2013, including measures referred to in
291
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Articles 458 and 459 of that Regulation, the
specific own funds requirements to address risks
other than the risk of excessive leverage referred
to in Article 104 of Directive 2013/36/EU, the
combined buffer requirement defined in Article
128, point (6), of that Directive, or any the local
own funds requirements in third countries;
– the sum of the requirements laid down in
Article 92(1), point (d), of Regulation (EU) No
575/2013, including measures referred to in
Articles 458 and 459 of that Regulation, the
specific own funds requirements to address the
risk of excessive leverage referred to in Article
104 of Directive 2013/36/EU, the leverage ratio
buffer requirement laid down in Article 92(1a)
of Regulation (EU) No 575/2013, or the local
own funds requirements in third countries
292
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
insofar as those requirements are to be met by
Tier 1 capital;
(d) for each related undertaking referred to
in paragraph 1, point (b), of this Article, in
accordance with Article 7(1), point (a), of
Directive 2009/65/EC;
(e) for each related undertaking referred to
in paragraph 1, point (c), of this Article, in
accordance with Article 9 of Directive
2011/61/EU;
(f) for each related undertaking referred to
in paragraph 1, point (d), of this Article, the
capital requirement with which the related
undertaking would have to comply under the
relevant sector rules as defined in Article 2,
point (7), of Directive 2002/87/EC if it was a
293
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
regulated entity within the meaning of Article 2,
point (4), of that Directive;
(g) for each related undertaking referred to
in paragraph 1, point (e), of this Article, the
required solvency margin calculated in
accordance with Article 17b of Directive (EU)
2016/2341.
4. Where several related undertakings referred
to in paragraph 1 form a subgroup which is
subject to a capital requirement on a
consolidated basis in accordance with one of the
Directives or Regulations referred to in
paragraph 3, the group supervisor may allow
calculating the contribution of those related
undertakings to the group eligible own funds as
the proportional share of that subgroup’s own
funds instead of applying paragraph 2, points (a)
294
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
to (e), to each individual undertaking belonging
to that subgroup. In that case, the participating
insurance or reinsurance undertaking shall also
calculate the contribution of those related
undertakings to the group Solvency Capital
Requirement as the proportional share of that
subgroup’s capital requirement, instead of
applying paragraph 3, points (a) to (e), to each
individual undertaking belonging to that
subgroup.
For the purposes of the first subparagraph of this
paragraph, paragraphs 2 and 3, shall apply
mutatis mutandis to the subgroup.
5. Notwithstanding paragraphs 1 to 4,
Member States shall allow their supervisory
authorities, where they assume the role of group
supervisor with regard to a particular group, to
295
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
decide, at the request of the participating
undertaking or on their own initiative, to deduct
any participation as referred to in paragraph 1,
points (a) to (d) from the own funds eligible for
the group solvency of the participating
undertaking.’;
(71) in Title III, Chapter II, Section 1,
Subsection 3, the following Article 229a is
added:
‘Article 229a
Simplified calculations
1. For the purposes of Article 230, the group
supervisor, after consulting the other
supervisory authorities concerned, may allow
the participating insurance or reinsurance
undertaking to apply a simplified approach to
296
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
participations in related undertakings that are
immaterial.
The application of the simplified approach,
referred to in the first subparagraph, to one or
several related undertakings shall be duly
justified by the participating undertaking to the
group supervisor, considering the nature, scale
and complexity of the risks of the related
undertaking or undertakings.
Member States shall require the participating
undertaking to assess, on an annual basis,
whether the use of the simplified approach is
still justified, and shall publicly disclose, in its
group solvency and financial condition report,
the list and size of the related undertakings
subject to that simplified approach.
297
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. For the purpose of paragraph 1, the
participating insurance and reinsurance
undertaking shall demonstrate, to the
satisfaction of the group supervisor, that the
application of the simplified approach to
participations in one or several related
undertakings is sufficiently prudent to avoid an
underestimation of risks stemming from that
undertaking or from those undertakings when
calculating the group solvency.
When applied to a third-country insurance or
reinsurance undertaking which has its head
office in a country that is not equivalent or
provisionally equivalent within the meaning of
Article 227, the simplified approach shall not
result in a contribution of the related
undertaking to the group Solvency Capital
Requirement that is lower than the capital
298
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
requirement of that undertaking, as laid down by
the third country concerned.
The simplified approach shall not be applied to
a related third-country insurance or reinsurance
undertaking, where the participating insurance
or reinsurance undertaking has no reliable
information on the capital requirement as laid
down in that third country.
3. For the purposes of paragraph 1, related
undertakings shall be deemed immaterial where
the book value of each of them represents less
than 0,2 % of the group’s consolidated accounts
and the sum of the book values of all such
undertakings represents less than 0,5 % of the
group’s consolidated accounts.’;
(72) Article 230 is amended as follows:
299
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) paragraph 1 is replaced by the following:
‘1. The calculation of the group solvency of
the participating insurance or reinsurance
undertaking shall be carried out on the basis of
the consolidated accounts.
The group solvency of the participating
insurance or reinsurance undertaking is the
difference between the following:
(a) the sum of the own funds eligible to
cover the Solvency Capital Requirement,
calculated on the basis of consolidated data, and
the contribution to the group eligible own funds
of related undertakings referred in Article
228(1), where that contribution is calculated in
accordance with Article 228(2) or (4);
300
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the sum of the Solvency Capital
Requirement at group level calculated on the
basis of consolidated data and the contribution
to the group Solvency Capital Requirement of
the related undertakings referred in Article
228(1), where that contribution is calculated in
accordance with Article 228(3) or (4).
For the purposes of the second subparagraph,
holdings in related undertakings referred to in
Article 228(1) shall not be included in the
consolidated data.
Title I, Chapter VI, Section 3, Subsections 1, 2
and 3 and Title I, Chapter VI, Section 4,
Subsections 1, 2 and 3 shall apply for the
calculation of the own funds eligible for the
Solvency Capital Requirement and of the
301
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Solvency Capital Requirement at group level
based on consolidated data. In particular, an
own fund item that is issued by a participating
undertaking shall not be considered clear of
encumbrances within the meaning of Article
93(2), second subparagraph, point (c), if the
repayment of this item cannot be refused to its
holder when a related insurance or reinsurance
undertaking is wound up.’;
(b) paragraph 2 is amended as follows:
(i) in the second subparagraph, the
following points (c) and (d) are added:
‘(c) the proportional share of the local capital
requirements, at which the authorisation would
be withdrawn, for related third-country
insurance and reinsurance undertakings;
302
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(d) the proportional share of the notional
Minimum Capital Requirement of the insurance
holding companies and mixed financial holding
companies.’;
(ii) the third subparagraph is replaced by the
following:
‘For the purposes of paragraph 2, second
subparagraph, point (d), of this Article, the
notional Minimum Capital Requirement of an
insurance holding company and of a mixed
financial holding company shall be equal to
35 % of its notional Solvency Capital
Requirement, where the notional Solvency
Capital Requirement is calculated in accordance
with Article 226(1), second subparagraph.’;
303
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(iii) the fourth subparagraph is deleted;
(c) the following paragraph 3 is added:
‘3. Participating insurance and reinsurance
undertakings shall comply with their minimum
consolidated group Solvency Capital
Requirement, which is the lowest of the
following:
(a) 45 % of the outcome of the calculation
referred to in paragraph 1, second subparagraph,
point (b);
(b) the outcome of the calculation referred
to in paragraph 2, second subparagraph.
That minimum shall be covered by eligible
basic own funds as determined in accordance
304
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
with Article 98(4), and calculated on the basis
of consolidated data. For that purpose, holdings
in related undertakings referred to in Article
228(1) shall not be included in the consolidated
data.
For the purposes of determining whether such
eligible own funds qualify to cover the
minimum consolidated group Solvency Capital
Requirement, the principles set out in Articles
221 to 229 shall apply mutatis mutandis. Article
139(1) and (2) shall apply mutatis mutandis.’;
(73) in Article 232, first subparagraph,
introductory wording, the words ‘referred to in
Article 37(1), points (a) to (d),’ shall be replaced
by the words ‘referred to in Article 37(1), points
(a) to (e)’;
305
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(74) Article 233 is amended as follows:
(a) in paragraph 1, point (b) is replaced by
the following:
‘(b) the value in the participating insurance
or reinsurance undertaking of related
undertakings referred to in Article 220(3) and in
Article 228(1) and the aggregated group
Solvency Capital Requirement, as provided for
in paragraph 3.’;
(b) paragraph 2 is amended as follows:
(i) point (b) is replaced by the following:
‘(b) the proportional share of the
participating insurance or reinsurance
undertaking in the own funds eligible for the
306
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Solvency Capital Requirement of each
individual related insurance or reinsurance
undertaking.’;
(ii) the following point (c) is added:
‘(c) the contribution to the group eligible
own funds of related undertakings referred in
Article 228(1), where that contribution is
calculated in accordance with Article 228(2) or
Article 228(4);
(c) paragraph 3 is amended as follows:
(i) point (b) is replaced by the following:
‘(b) the proportional share of the Solvency
Capital Requirement of each individual related
insurance or reinsurance undertaking.’
307
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(ii) the following point (c) is added:
‘(c) the contribution to the group Solvency
Capital Requirement of related undertakings
referred in Article 228(1), where that
contribution is calculated in accordance with
Article 228(3) or Article 228(4).’;
(75) the following Article 233a is inserted:
‘Article 233a
Combination of methods 1 and 2
1. The group solvency of the participating
insurance or reinsurance undertaking shall be
the difference between the following:
(a) the sum of the following:
308
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(i) for undertakings to which method 1 is
applied, the own funds eligible to cover the
Solvency Capital Requirement, calculated on
the basis of consolidated data;
(ii) for each related insurance or reinsurance
undertaking to which method 2 is applied, the
proportional share of the own funds eligible for
its Solvency Capital Requirement;
(iii) the contribution of related undertakings
referred to in Article 228(1), calculated in
accordance with Article 228(2) or Article
228(4); and
(b) the sum of the following:
309
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(i) for undertakings to which method 1 is
applied, the consolidated group Solvency
Capital Requirement, calculated in accordance
with Article 230(2) on the basis of consolidated
data;
(ii) for each insurance or reinsurance
undertaking to which method 2 is applied, the
proportional share of its Solvency Capital
Requirement;
(iii) the contribution of related undertakings
referred to in Article 228(1), calculated in
accordance with Article 228(3) or Article
228(4).
2. For the purposes of paragraph 1, point
(a) (i), and paragraph 1, point (b) (i) of this
Article, holdings in related undertakings
310
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
referred to in Article 228(1) shall not be
included in the consolidated data.
3. For the purposes of paragraph 1, point
(a) (i), and paragraph 1, point (b)t (i) of this
Article, holdings in related undertakings
referred to in Article 220(3) to which method 2
is applied shall not be included in the
consolidated data.
For the purposes of paragraph 1, point (b) (i), of
this Article, the value of holdings in
undertakings referred to in Article 220(3) to
which method 2 is applied, in excess of their
own Solvency Capital Requirement, shall be
included in the consolidated data when
calculating the sensitivity of assets and
liabilities to changes in the level or in the
volatility of currency exchange rates (‘currency
311
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
risk’). However, the value of those holdings
shall not be assumed to be sensitive to changes
in the level or in the volatility of market prices
of equities (‘equity risk’).
4. Article 233(4) shall apply mutatis
mutandis for the purpose of paragraph 1, points
(a)(ii) and (b)(ii), of this Article.
5. Article 231 shall apply mutatis mutandis
in the case of an application for permission to
calculate the consolidated group Solvency
Capital Requirement, as well as the Solvency
Capital Requirement of insurance and
reinsurance undertakings in the group, on the
basis of an internal model, submitted by an
insurance or reinsurance undertaking and its
related undertakings, or jointly by the related
undertakings of an insurance holding company.
312
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
6. Participating insurance and reinsurance
undertakings shall comply with their minimum
consolidated group Solvency Capital
Requirement, which is the minimum of the
following:
(a) 45 % of the sum of the consolidated
group Solvency Capital Requirement referred to
in paragraph 1, point (b)(i), and of the
contribution referred to in paragraph 1, point
(b)(iii);
(b) the outcome of the calculation referred
to in Article 230(2), second subparagraph.
The minimum consolidated group Solvency
Capital Requirement shall be covered by
eligible basic own funds as determined in
313
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
accordance with Article 98(4), calculated on the
basis of consolidated data. For the purpose of
that calculation, holdings in related undertakings
referred to in Article 228(1) shall not be
included in the consolidated data.
For the purpose of determining whether such
eligible own funds qualify to cover the
minimum consolidated group Solvency Capital
Requirement, the principles set out in Articles
221 to 229 shall apply mutatis mutandis. Article
139(1) and (2) shall apply mutatis mutandis.
7. In determining whether the amount
calculated in paragraph 1, point (b)(ii), of this
Article appropriately reflects the risk profile of
the group with regard to undertakings referred
to in Article 220(3) to which Method 2 is
applied, the supervisory authorities concerned
314
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
shall pay particular attention to any specific
risks existing at group level which would not be
sufficiently covered because they are difficult to
quantify.
Where the risk profile of the group with regard
to undertakings referred to in Article 220(3) to
which Method 2 is applied deviates significantly
from the assumptions underlying the aggregated
group Solvency Capital Requirement referred to
in Article 233(3), a capital add-on to the amount
calculated in paragraph 1, point (b)(ii), of this
Article may be imposed.
Article 37(1) to (5), together with the delegated
acts and implementing technical standards
adopted in accordance with Article 37(6), (7)
and (8), shall apply mutatis mutandis.’;
315
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(76) Article 234 is replaced by the following:
‘Article 234
Delegated acts for technical principles and
methods in Articles 220 to 229, the simplified
approach in Article 229a, and the application
of Articles 230 to 233a
The Commission shall adopt delegated acts in
accordance with Article 301a specifying the
following:
(a) the technical principles and methods set out
in Articles 220 to 229;
(b) the technical details to the simplified
approach set out in Article 229a(1), as well as
the criteria based on which supervisory
316
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
authorities may approve the use of the
simplified approach;
(c) the application of Articles 230 to 233a,
reflecting the economic nature of specific legal
structures.
The Commission may adopt delegated acts in
accordance with Article 301a specifying the
criteria based on which the group supervisor
may approve the application of the simplified
approach set out in Article 229a(2).’;
(77) in Article 244(3), the third subparagraph
is replaced by the following:
‘In order to identify significant risk
concentration to be reported, the group
supervisor, after consulting the other
317
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
supervisory authorities concerned and the group,
shall impose appropriate thresholds based on
Solvency Capital Requirements, technical
provisions, eligible own funds, other
quantitative or qualitative risk-based criteria
deemed appropriate or a combination thereof.’;
(78) Article 245 is amended as follows:
(a) in paragraph 1, the words ‘paragraphs 2
and 3’ are replaced by the words ‘paragraphs 2,
3 and 3a’;
(b) the following paragraph 3a is inserted:
‘3a. In addition to intragroup transactions within
the meaning of Article 13, point (19), for the
purpose of paragraphs 2 and 3 of this Article,
where justified, supervisory authorities may
318
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
require groups to also report intragroup
transactions that involve undertakings other than
insurance and reinsurance undertakings, third-
country insurance and reinsurance undertakings,
insurance holding companies and mixed
financial holding companies.’;
(79) Article 246 is amended as follows:
(a) paragraph 1 is replaced by the following:
‘1. The requirements set out in Title I, Chapter
IV, Section 2 shall apply mutatis mutandis at the
level of the group. The system of governance of
the group shall cover participating insurance or
reinsurance undertakings, parent insurance
holding companies or parent mixed financial
holding companies, as well as to all related
undertakings in the scope of the group within
319
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the meaning of Article 212 which is subject to
group supervision in accordance with Article
213(2), points (a), (b) and (c). The system of
governance of the group shall also cover all
undertakings that are managed by the
participating undertaking or its subsidiaries
jointly with one or more undertakings that are
not part of the same group.
Without prejudice to the first subparagraph of
this paragraph, the risk management and
internal control systems and reporting
procedures shall be implemented consistently in
all the undertakings included in the scope of
group supervision pursuant to Article 213(2),
points (a) and (b), so that those systems and
reporting procedures can be controlled at the
level of the group.
320
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Member States shall ensure that the
administrative, management or supervisory
body of the ultimate parent insurance or
reinsurance undertaking, insurance holding
company mixed financial holding company
which has its head office in the Union, or the
designated participating undertaking in
accordance with Article 212(3), has the ultimate
responsibility for the compliance, by the group
to which group supervision applies in
accordance with Article 213(2), points (a), (b)
and (c), with the laws, regulations and
administrative provisions adopted pursuant to
this Directive. The administrative, management
or supervisory body of each insurance and
reinsurance undertaking within the group shall
remain responsible for its own compliance with
all requirements, as specified in Article 40 and
Article 213(1), second subparagraph.
321
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
The risk management system shall cover at least
all insurance and reinsurance activities
conducted within the group, as well as material
non-insurance activities. It shall also cover the
risks stemming from those activities to which
the group is or could be exposed, and their
interdependencies.
Without prejudice to the first subparagraph of
this paragraph, the risk management and
internal control systems and reporting
procedures shall be implemented consistently in
all the undertakings included in the scope of
group supervision pursuant to Article 213(2),
points (a) and (b), so that those systems and
reporting procedures can be controlled at the
level of the group.’;
322
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) in paragraph 2, the following
subparagraphs are added :
‘The participating insurance or reinsurance
undertaking, the insurance holding company or
the mixed financial holding company shall
regularly monitor the activities of its related
undertakings, including related undertakings
referred to in Article 228(1) and non-regulated
undertakings. That monitoring shall be
commensurate with the nature, scale and
complexity of the risks that the related
undertakings generate or could generate at the
level of the group.
The participating insurance or reinsurance
undertaking, the insurance holding company or
the mixed financial holding company shall have
written policies at the level of the group, and
323
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
shall ensure consistency with the group policies
of the written policies of all regulated
undertakings in the scope of the group. It shall
also ensure that group policies are implemented
in a consistent manner by all regulated
undertakings in the scope of the group.’;
(c) in paragraph 4, first subparagraph, the
second sentence is replaced by the following:
‘The own-risk and solvency assessment
conducted at group level shall cover at least all
insurance and reinsurance activities conducted
within the group, as well as material non-
insurance activities. It shall also cover the risks
stemming from those activities to which the
group is or could be exposed, and their
interdependencies. It shall be subject to
324
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
supervisory review by the group supervisor in
accordance with Chapter III.’;
(d) the following paragraph 5 is added:
‘5. Member States shall require the participating
insurance or reinsurance undertaking, the
insurance holding company or the mixed
financial holding company to ensure that the
group has robust governance arrangements
which include a clear organisational structure
with well-defined, transparent and consistent
lines of responsibility and segregation of duties
within the group. The system of governance of
the group shall endeavour to prevent conflicts of
interest, or where this is not possible, shall
manage them.
325
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
The persons who effectively run an insurance or
reinsurance group are the persons who
effectively run the parent or participating
undertaking referred to in paragraph 1, second
subparagraph.
Member States shall require the participating
insurance or reinsurance undertaking, the
insurance holding company or the mixed
financial holding company to identify the
persons responsible for other key functions
within the insurance or reinsurance group that is
subject to group supervision in accordance with
Article 213(2), points (a), (b) and (c). The
administrative, management or supervisory
body referred to in paragraph 1, second
subparagraph, of this Article shall be
responsible for the activities carried out by those
persons.
326
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Where the persons who effectively run an
insurance or reinsurance group or are
responsible for other key functions are also the
persons who effectively run one or several
insurance or reinsurance undertakings or other
related undertakings, or are responsible for other
key functions within any of those undertakings,
the participating undertaking shall ensure that
the roles and responsibilities at group level are
clearly segregated from those applicable at the
level of each individual undertaking.’;
(80) in Title III, the following Chapter IIA is
inserted:
‘CHAPTER IIA
Macroprudential rules at group level
327
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 246a
Liquidity Risk Management at group level
1. Member States shall require
participating insurance and reinsurance
undertakings, insurance holding companies and
mixed financial holding companies to draw up
and maintain a liquidity risk management plan
at the level of the group. Article 144a shall
apply mutatis mutandis.
2. By way of derogation from Article 144a,
Member States shall ensure that insurance or
reinsurance subsidiaries which are in the scope
of group supervision in accordance with Article
213(2), points (a) and (b), are exempted from
the drawing up and maintaining a liquidity risk
management plan at individual level whenever
the liquidity risk management plan pursuant to
328
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
paragraph 1 of this Article covers the liquidity
management and liquidity needs of the
subsidiaries concerned.
Member States shall require each individual
insurance or reinsurance undertaking benefitting
from the exemption pursuant to first
subparagraph to submit the parts of the liquidity
risk management plan covering the situation of
the whole group and their own situation to its
supervisory authority.
3. Notwithstanding paragraph 2,
supervisory authorities may require an insurance
or reinsurance subsidiary to draw up and
maintain a liquidity risk management plan at
individual level whenever they detect a specific
liquidity vulnerability or the liquidity
management plan at group level does not
329
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
include appropriate information which the
supervisory authority having authorised the
subsidiary requires comparable undertakings to
provide for the purpose of monitoring their
liquidity position.
4. In order to ensure consistent application
of this Article, EIOPA shall develop regulatory
technical standards to further specify the content
and frequency of update of the liquidity risk
management framework plan at group level.
EIOPA shall submit those draft regulatory
technical standards to the Commission by [PO
please add date = 12 months after entry into
force].
Power is conferred on the Commission to adopt
the regulatory technical standards referred to in
330
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the first subparagraph in accordance with
Articles 10 to 14 of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010.
Article 246b
Other macroprudential rules
Articles 144b and 144c shall apply mutatis
mutandis at the level of the participating
insurance or reinsurance undertaking, insurance
holding company or mixed financial holding
company.’;
(81) in Article 252, first paragraph, the words
‘a credit institution as defined in Directive
2006/48/EC or an investment firm as defined in
Directive 2004/39/EC’ are replaced by the
words ‘a credit institution as defined in
331
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 or an investment
firm as defined in Directive 2014/65/EU’;
(82) in Article 254, the following paragraph 3
is added:
‘3. The participating insurance and reinsurance
undertaking, the insurance holding company and
the mixed financial holding company shall
submit to the group supervisor the information
referred to in this Article on an annual basis
within 20 weeks after the undertaking's financial
year end, and, when the information referred to
in this Article is required on quarterly basis,
within 11 weeks after the end of each quarter.’;
(83) Article 256 is amended as follows:
(a) paragraph 1 is replaced by the following:
332
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘1. Member States shall require participating
insurance and reinsurance undertakings,
insurance holding companies and mixed
financial holding companies to disclose
publicly, on an annual basis, a report on
solvency and financial condition at the level of
the group. This report shall contain information
about the group addressed to other market
participants, as referred to in Article 51(1b).
Articles 51, 53, 54 and 55 shall apply mutatis
mutandis.
Member States shall ensure that the
participating insurance and reinsurance
undertakings, the insurance holding company or
the mixed financial holding company disclose
the information referred to in this Article on an
333
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
annual or less frequent basis within 24 weeks
after the undertaking's financial year end.’;
(b) in paragraph 2, point (b) is replaced by
the following:
‘(b) the information for any of the subsidiaries
within the group, which information must be
individually identifiable, including both parts of
the solvency and financial condition report, and
must be disclosed in accordance with Articles
51, 53, 54 and 55.’;
(c) paragraph 4 is replaced by the following:
‘4. The Commission shall adopt delegated acts
in accordance with Article 301a further
specifying the information which must be
disclosed in the single solvency and financial
334
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
condition report referred to in paragraph 2 of
this Article and the solvency and financial
condition report at the level of the group
referred to in paragraph 1 of this Article.’;
(d) in paragraph 5, the first subparagraph is
replaced by the following:
‘5. In order to ensure uniform conditions of
application in relation to the single and group
solvency and financial condition report, EIOPA
shall develop draft implementing technical
standards on the procedures and templates for,
and the means of, disclosure of the single and
group solvency and financial report as laid
down in this Article.’;
(84) the following Articles 256b and 256c are
inserted:
335
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘Article 256b
Group regular supervisory report
1. Member States shall require participating
insurance and reinsurance undertakings,
insurance holding companies and mixed
financial holding companies to submit to the
supervisory authorities, on an annual basis, a
regular supervisory report at the level of the
group. Article 35(5a) shall apply mutatis
mutandis.
Member States shall ensure that insurance and
reinsurance undertakings submit the information
referred to in this Article on an annual or less
frequent basis in 24 weeks after the
undertaking's financial year end.
336
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. A participating insurance or reinsurance
undertaking, an insurance holding company or a
mixed financial holding company may, subject
to the agreement of the supervisory authorities
concerned, provide a single regular supervisory
report which shall comprise the following:
(a) the information at the level of the group
which shall be reported in accordance with
paragraph 1;
(b) the information for any of the subsidiaries
within the group, which shall be individually
identifiable, shall be reported in accordance
with Article 35(5a) and it shall not result in less
information than the one it would be provided
by insurance and reinsurance undertakings
submitting regular supervisory report in
accordance with Article 35(5a).
337
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Before granting the agreement in accordance
with the first subparagraph, the group supervisor
shall consult and duly take into account any
views and reservations of the members of the
college of supervisors. The non-agreement by
the national supervisory authorities concerned
shall be duly justified. If the single regular
supervisory report in accordance with paragraph
2 is approved by the college of supervisors, each
individual insurance and reinsurance
undertaking shall submit the single regular
supervisory report to its supervisory authority.
Each supervisory authority shall have the power
to supervise the specific part of the single
regular supervisory report to the relevant
subsidiary. If the single regular supervisory
report submitted is not satisfactory for the
338
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
national supervisory authorities, such approval
can be withdrawn.
4. Where the report referred to in paragraph 2
fails to include information which the
supervisory authority that authorised a
subsidiary within the group requires comparable
undertakings to provide, and where the omission
is material, the supervisory authority concerned
shall have the power to require the subsidiary
concerned to report the necessary additional
information.
5. Where the supervisory authority having
authorised a subsidiary within the group
identifies any non-compliance with Article
35(5a) or requests any amendment or
clarification regarding the single regular
supervisory report it shall also inform the
339
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
college of supervisors and the group supervisor
shall submit to the participating insurance or
reinsurance undertaking, the insurance holding
company or the mixed financial holding
company the same request.
6. The Commission shall adopt delegated acts in
accordance with Article 301a further specifying
the information which shall be reported.
Article 256c
Audit requirements
1. Member States shall require a participating
insurance or reinsurance undertaking, an
insurance holding company or a mixed financial
holding company of a group, to be subject to an
audit the consolidated balance sheet disclosed as
part of the group solvency and financial
340
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
condition report or as part of the single solvency
and financial condition report.
2. A separate report, including the identification
of the type of assurance as well as the results of
the audit, prepared by the audit firm shall be
submitted to the group supervisory authority
together with the solvency and financial
condition report or the single solvency and
financial condition report by the participating
insurance or reinsurance undertakings, the
insurance holding company or the mixed
financial holding company.
3. Where there is a single solvency and financial
condition report, the audit requirements imposed
on a related insurance or reinsurance
undertaking shall be complied with and the
report referred to in Article 51a(4) shall be
341
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
submitted to the supervisory authority of that
undertaking by the participating insurance or
reinsurance undertaking, the insurance holding
company or the mixed financial holding
company.
4. Article 51a shall apply mutatis mutandis.’;
(85) Article 257 is replaced by the following:
‘Article 257
Fit and proper requirements for persons who
effectively run an insurance holding company
or a mixed financial holding company or who
have other key functions
Member States shall require those who
effectively run the insurance holding company
or the mixed financial holding company, and
342
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
where applicable, the persons who are
responsible for other key functions, to be fit and
proper to perform their duties.
Article 42 shall apply mutatis mutandis.’;
(86) Article 258 is amended as follows:
(a) paragraph 2 is replaced by the following:
‘2. Supervisory authorities shall be given all
supervisory powers to take measures in relation
to insurance holding companies and mixed
financial holding companies that are necessary
to ensure that groups to which group
supervision is applied in accordance with
Article 213(2), points (a), (b) and (c), comply
with all the requirements laid down in this Title.
343
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Those powers shall include the general
supervisory powers referred to in Article 34.
Without prejudice to their provisions on
criminal law, Member States shall impose
sanctions on, or adopt measures relating to,
insurance holding companies and mixed
financial holding companies which infringe
laws, regulations or administrative provisions
brought into force to transpose this Title, or in
relation to the person effectively managing
those companies. The supervisory authorities
shall cooperate closely to ensure that such
sanctions or measures are effective, in particular
where the central administration or main
establishment of an insurance holding company
or mixed financial holding company is not
located in the same Member State as its head
office.’;
344
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the following paragraphs 2a and 2b are
inserted:
‘2a. Where the group supervisor has
established that the conditions set out in Article
213(3a) are not met or have ceased to be met,
the insurance holding company or mixed
financial holding company shall be subject to
appropriate supervisory measures to ensure or
restore, as the case may be, continuity and
integrity of group supervision and to ensure
compliance with the requirements laid down in
this Title. In the case of a mixed financial
holding company, the supervisory measures
shall, in particular, take into account the effects
on the financial conglomerate as a whole as well
as on its related regulated undertakings.
345
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2b. For the purposes of paragraphs 1 and 2a
of this Article, Member States shall ensure that
the supervisory measures which may be applied
to insurance holding companies and mixed
financial holding companies include, at least,
the following:
(a) suspending the exercise of voting rights
attached to the shares of the subsidiary
insurance or reinsurance undertaking held by the
insurance holding company or mixed financial
holding company;
(b) issuing injunctions, sanctions or penalties
against the insurance holding company, the
mixed financial holding company or the
members of the administrative, management or
supervisory body of those companies;
346
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) giving instructions or directions to the
insurance holding company or mixed financial
holding company to transfer to its shareholders
the participations in its subsidiary insurance and
reinsurance undertakings;
(d) designating on a temporary basis another
insurance holding company, mixed financial
holding company or insurance or reinsurance
undertaking within the group as responsible for
ensuring compliance with the requirements set
out in this Title;
(e) restricting or prohibiting distributions or
interest payments to shareholders;
(f) requiring insurance holding companies or
mixed financial holding companies to divest
from or reduce holdings in insurance or
347
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
reinsurance undertakings or other related
undertakings referred to in Article 228(1);
(g) requiring insurance holding companies or
mixed financial holding companies to submit a
plan on return, without delay, to compliance.
The group supervisor shall consult other
supervisory authorities concerned and EIOPA
before taking any of the measures referred to in
the first subparagraph, where those measures
affect undertakings which have their head
offices in more than one Member State.’;
(87) Article 262 is amended as follows:
(a) paragraph 2 is replaced by the following:
348
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘2. Member States shall allow their supervisory
authorities to apply other methods which ensure
appropriate supervision of the insurance and
reinsurance undertakings belonging to a group
within the meaning of Article 212, and to which
group supervision applies in accordance with
Article 213(2), point (c). Those methods shall
be agreed by the group supervisor, identified in
accordance with Article 247, after consulting
the other supervisory authorities concerned.
The methods referred to in the first
subparagraph shall allow the objectives of the
group supervision as specified in this Title to be
achieved. Those objectives shall include the
following:
(a) preserving the capital allocation and the
composition of own funds of insurance and
349
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
reinsurance undertakings and preventing
material intra-group creation of capital where
such intra-group capital creation is financed out
of the proceeds of debt or other financial
instruments that do not qualify as own funds
items by the parent company;
(b) assessing and monitoring the risks stemming
from undertakings both inside and outside the
Union, and limiting the risk of contagion from
those undertakings and from other non-
regulated undertakings to insurance and
reinsurance undertakings within the group, and
to the subgroup the ultimate parent undertaking
of which is an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking, an insurance holding company or a
mixed financial company that has its head office
in the Union, as referred to in Article 215,
where such a subgroup exists.
350
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
The methods referred to in the first
subparagraph shall be appropriately justified,
documented, and notified to the other
supervisory authorities concerned, EIOPA and
the Commission.’;
(b) the following paragraph 3 is added:
‘3. For the purposes of paragraph 2 of this
Article, the supervisory authorities concerned
may in particular apply one or several of the
following methods to insurance and reinsurance
undertakings, insurance holding companies and
mixed financial holding companies that are part
of a group which is subject to group supervision
in accordance with Article 213(2), point (c):
351
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) designating one insurance or reinsurance
undertaking that shall be responsible for
compliance with the requirements set out in this
Title, where the insurance and reinsurance
undertakings that belong to the group do not
have a common parent undertaking in the
Union;
(b) requiring the establishment of an
insurance holding company which has its head
office in the Union, or a mixed financial holding
company which has its head office in the Union
where the insurance and reinsurance
undertakings that belong to the group do not
have a common parent undertaking in the
Union, and applying this Title to the insurance
and (reinsurance undertakings in the group
headed by that insurance holding company or
mixed financial holding company;
352
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) where several insurance and reinsurance
undertakings that belong to the group form a
subgroup whose parent undertaking has its head
office in the Union, in addition to applying this
Title to this subgroup, taking additional
measures or imposing additional requirements,
including requirements referred to in points (d),
(e), and (f) of this subparagraph and enhanced
supervision of risk concentration within the
meaning of Article 244 and of intragroup
transactions within the meaning of Article 245,
with the aim of achieving the objective referred
to in paragraph 2, second subparagraph, point
(b), of this Article;
(d) requiring the members of the
administrative, management or supervisory
body of the ultimate parent undertaking in the
353
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Union to be independent from the ultimate
parent undertaking outside the Union;
(e) prohibiting, limiting, restricting,
monitoring or requiring prior notification of
transactions, including dividend distributions
and coupon payments on subordinated debt,
where such transactions are or could be a threat
to the financial or solvency position of
insurance and reinsurance undertakings within
the group, and involve, on the one hand, an
insurance or reinsurance undertaking, an
insurance holding company which has its head
office in the Union or mixed financial holding
company which has their head office in the
Union, and, on the other hand, an undertaking
belonging to the group which has its head office
outside the Union; where the group supervisor
in the Union is not one of the supervisory
354
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
authorities of the Member State in which a
related insurance or reinsurance undertaking has
its head office, the group supervisor in the
Union shall inform those supervisory authorities
of its findings with a view to enabling them to
take the appropriate measures;
(f) requiring information on the solvency
and financial position, the risk profile, and the
risk tolerance limits of parent undertakings
which have their head office outside the Union,
including, where applicable, reports on those
topics which are submitted to the administrative,
management or supervisory body or the
supervisory authorities of those third-country
parent undertakings.’;
(88) in Article 265, the following paragraph
1a is inserted:
355
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘1a. Member States shall also ensure that,
where the parent undertaking of one or more
insurance or reinsurance undertakings is a credit
institution, an investment firm, a financial
institution, a UCITS management company, an
alternative investment fund manager, an
institution for occupational retirement provision
or a non-regulated undertaking which carries
one or more of the activities referred to in
Annex I to Directive 2013/36/EU where those
activities constitute a significant part of its
overall activity, the supervisory authorities
responsible for the supervision of those
insurance or reinsurance undertakings exercise
general supervision over transactions between
those insurance or reinsurance undertakings and
the parent undertaking and its related
undertakings.’;
356
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(89) Article 301a is amended as follows:
(a) paragraph 2 is amended as follows:
(i) the second subparagraph is replaced by
the following:
‘The delegation of power referred to in Articles
29, 35b and 256b shall be conferred on the
Commission for a period of four years from [OP
please insert date = entry into force of this
amending Directive].’;
(ii) the following subparagraph is added:
‘The delegation of power referred to in the first
and second subparagraphs shall be tacitly
extended for periods of an identical duration,
357
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
unless the European Parliament or the Council
opposes such extension not later than three
months before the end of each period.’;
(b) paragraph 3 is replaced by the following:
‘3. The delegation of power referred to in
Articles 17, 29, 31, 35, 35b, 37, 50, 56, 75, 86,
92, 97, 99, 109a, 111, 114, 127, 130, 135, 143,
172, 210, 211, 216, 217, 227, 234, 241, 244,
245, 247, 248, 256, 256b, 258, 260 and 308b
may be revoked at any time by the European
Parliament or by the Council.’;
(c) paragraph 5 is replaced by the following:
‘5. A delegated act adopted pursuant to Article
17, 29, 31, 35, 35b, 37, 50, 56, 75, 86, 92, 97,
99, 109a, 111, 114, 127, 130, 135, 143, 172,
358
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
210, 211, 216, 217, 227, 234, 241, 244, 245,
247, 248, 256, 256b, 258, 260 or 308b shall
enter into force only if no objection has been
expressed either by the European Parliament or
by the Council within a period of three months
of notification of that act to the European
Parliament and to the Council or if, before the
expiry of that period, the European Parliament
and the Council have both informed the
Commission that they will not object. That
period shall be extended by three months at the
initiative of the European Parliament or of the
Council.’;
(90) Article 304(2) is replaced by the
following;
‘2. As of [OP please insert date = date of
application of this amending Directive] life
359
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
insurance undertakings may continue to apply
the approach referred to in paragraph 1 of this
Article only in respect of assets and liabilities to
which supervisory authorities approved the
application of the duration-based equity sub-
module before [OP please insert date =
application date of this amending Directive].’;
(91) the following Article 304a is inserted:
‘Article 304a
Reviews as regards sustainability risk
1. EIOPA, after consulting the ESRB, shall
assess, on the basis of available data and the
findings of the Platform on Sustainable Finance
referred to in Article 20 of Regulation (EU)
2020/852 of the European Parliament and of the
Council* and the EBA in the context of its work
360
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
under the mandate set out in Article 501c, point
(c), of Regulation (EU) 575/2013 whether a
dedicated prudential treatment of exposures
related to assets or activities associated
substantially with environmental or social
objectives would be justified. In particular,
EIOPA shall assess the potential effects of a
dedicated prudential treatment of exposures
related to assets and activities which are
associated substantially with environmental
and/or social objectives or which are associated
substantially with harm to such objectives on
the protection of policy holders and financial
stability in the Union.
EIOPA shall submit a report on its findings to
the Commission by 28 June 2023. Where
appropriate, the report shall consider a possible
prudential treatment of exposures related to
361
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
assets and activities which are associated
substantially with environmental or social
objectives or which are associated substantially
with harm to such objectives and be
accompanied by an assessment of the impact of
the proposed amendments on insurance and
reinsurance undertakings.
2. EIOPA shall review at least every three years,
with respect to natural catastrophe risk, the
scope and the calibration of the standard
parameters of the non-life catastrophe sub-
module of the Solvency Capital Requirement
referred to in Article 105(2) , third
subparagraph, point (b). For the purpose of
those reviews, EIOPA shall take into account
the latest available relevant evidence on climate
science and the relevance of risks in terms of the
risks underwritten by insurance and reinsurance
362
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
companies that use the standard formula for the
calculation of the non-life catastrophe sub-
module of the Solvency Capital Requirement.
The first review pursuant to the first
subparagraph shall be completed by [OP please
insert date = two years after entry into force of
this Directive].
Where EIOPA finds, during a review pursuant
to the first subparagraph, that, due to the scope
or the calibration of the standard parameters of
the non-life catastrophe risk sub-module, there
is a significant discrepancy between the part of
the Solvency Capital Requirement relating to
natural catastrophes and the actual natural
catastrophe risk that insurance and reinsurance
undertakings face, EIOPA shall submit an
363
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
opinion on natural catastrophe risk to the
Commission.
An opinion on natural catastrophe risk
submitted to the Commission pursuant to the
third subparagraph shall consider the scope or
the calibration of the standard parameters of the
non-life catastrophe sub-module of the Solvency
Capital Requirement in order to remedy the
discrepancy found and be accompanied by an
assessment of the impact of the proposed
amendments on insurance and reinsurance
undertakings.
*
Regulation (EU) 2020/852 of the European
Parliament and of the Council of 18 June 2020
on the establishment of a framework to facilitate
sustainable investment, and amending
364
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Regulation (EU) 2019/2088 (OJ L 198,
22.6.2020, p. 13).’;
(92) in Article 305, paragraphs 2 and 3 are
deleted;
(93) Article 308a is deleted;
(94) Article 308b is amended as follows:
(a) paragraphs 5 to 8 are deleted;
(b) paragraph 12 is replaced by the
following:
’12. Notwithstanding Article 100, Article 101(3)
and Article 104, Member States shall ensure that
the standard parameters to be used when
365
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
calculating the market risk concentration and the
spread risk sub-modules in accordance with the
standard formula shall be the same in relation to
exposures to Member States' central
governments or central banks incurred before 1
January 2020 and denominated and funded in
the domestic currency of any Member State as
the ones that would be applied to such
exposures denominated and funded in their
domestic currency;’;
(c) in paragraph 17, the following
subparagraphs are inserted after the first
subparagraph:
‘Where an insurance or reinsurance group, or
any of its subsidiary insurance or reinsurance
undertakings is applying the transitional
measure on the risk-free interest rates referred to
366
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
in Article 308c or the transitional measure on
technical provisions referred to in Article 308d,
the participating insurance or reinsurance
undertaking, the insurance holding company or
the mixed financial holding company shall
publicly disclose, as part of its report on the
group solvency and financial condition referred
to in Article 256, and in addition to the
disclosures referred to in Articles 308c(4), point
(c), and Article 308d(5), point (c), the
quantification of the impact on its financial
position of assuming that the own funds
stemming from the application of those
transitional measures cannot effectively be
made available to cover the Solvency Capital
Requirement of the participating undertaking for
which the group solvency is calculated.
367
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Where an insurance or reinsurance group
materially relies on the use of the transitional
measures referred to in Articles 308c and 308d
in such a manner that it misrepresents the actual
solvency position of the group, even where the
group Solvency Capital Requirement would be
complied with without the use of those
transitional measures, the group supervisor shall
have the power to take appropriate measures,
including the possibility to reduce the amount of
own funds stemming from the use of those
transitional measures that may be deemed
eligible to cover the group Solvency Capital
Requirement.’;
(95) Article 308c is amended as follows:
(a) the following paragraph 1a is inserted:
368
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘1a. After [OP please insert date = date of
application of this amending Directive],
supervisory authorities shall only approve a
transitional adjustment to the relevant risk-free
interest rate term structure in the following
cases:
(a) during a period of 18 months preceding the
approval, the rules of this Directive applied for
the first time to the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking requesting the approval after being
exempted from the scope of this Directive
pursuant to Article 4;
(b) during a period of six months preceding the
approval, the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking requesting the approval received
authorisation to accept a portfolio of contracts,
pursuant to Article 39, where the transferring
369
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
insurance or reinsurance undertaking applied the
transitional adjustment to the relevant risk-free
interest rate term structure with respect to that
portfolio of contracts prior to the transfer.’;
(b) in paragraph 4, point (c) is replaced by
the following:
‘(c) within the part of their report on their
solvency and financial condition consisting of
information addressed to other market
participants referred to in Article 51(1b),
publicly disclose all of the following:
(i) the fact that they apply the transitional risk-
free interest rate term structure;
370
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(ii) the quantification of the impact of not
applying this transitional measure on their
financial position;
(iii) where the undertaking would comply with
the Solvency Capital Requirement without
application of this transitional measure, the
reasons for the application of this transitional
measure;
(iv) an assessment of the dependency of the
undertaking on this transitional measure and,
where applicable, a description of the measures
taken or planned by the undertaking to reduce or
remove the dependency.’;
(96) Article 308d is amended as follows:
(a) the following paragraph 1a is inserted:
371
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘1a. After [OP please insert date = date of
application of this amending Directive],
supervisory authorities shall only approve a
transitional deduction to technical provisions in
the following cases:
(a) during a period of 18 months preceding the
approval, the rules of this Directive applied for
the first time to the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking requesting the approval after being
exempted from the scope of this Directive
pursuant to Article 4;
(b) during a period of six months preceding the
approval, the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking requesting the approval accepted a
portfolio of contracts, pursuant to Article 39,
where the transferring insurance or reinsurance
372
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertaking applied the transitional adjustment
to the relevant risk-free interest rate term
structure with respect to that portfolio of
contracts prior to the transfer.’;
(b) in paragraph 5, point (c) is replaced by
the following:
‘(c) within the part of their report on their
solvency and financial condition consisting of
information addressed to other market
participants referred to in Article 51(1b),
publicly disclose all of the following:
(i) the fact that they apply the transitional
deduction to the technical provisions;
373
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(ii) the quantification of the impact of not
applying that transitional deduction on their
financial position;
(iii) where the undertaking would comply with
the Solvency Capital Requirement without
application of this transitional measures, the
reasons for the application of this transitional
measure;
(iv) an assessment of the dependency of the
undertaking on this transitional measure and,
where applicable, a description of the measures
taken or planned by the undertaking to reduce or
remove the dependency.’;
(97) in Article 309(1), the fourth
subparagraph is deleted;
374
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(98) in Article 311, the second paragraph is
deleted;
(99) Annex III is amended in accordance with
the Annex to this Directive;
Article 2
Transposition
1. Member States shall adopt and publish,
by [OP please insert date = 18 months after
entry into force], the laws, regulations and
administrative provisions necessary to comply
with this Directive. They shall immediately
communicate the text of those measures to the
Commission.
375
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
They shall apply those measures from [OP
please insert date = 18 months and one day after
entry into force].
When Member States adopt those measures,
they shall contain a reference to this Directive or
be accompanied by such a reference on the
occasion of their official publication. Member
States shall determine how such reference is to
be made.
2. Member States shall communicate to the
Commission the text of the main provisions of
national law which they adopt in the field
covered by this Directive.
Article 3
Entry into force
376
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
This Directive shall enter into force on the
twentieth day following that of its publication in
the Official Journal of the European Union.
Article 4
Addressees
This Directive is addressed to the Member
States.
Done at Brussels,
For the European Parliament For the Council
The President The President
ANNEX
377
Commission proposal (ST 11763/21 – COM(2021) 581 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Solvency amending directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Annex III is amended as follows:
(1) in section A. “Forms of non-life
insurance undertaking”, point (27) is deleted;
(2) in section B. “Forms of life insurance
undertaking”, point (27) is deleted;
(3) in section C. “Forms of reinsurance
undertaking”, point (27) is deleted.
End End
378
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2021/0296 (COD)
Proposal for a DIRECTIVE OF THE
EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND OF THE
COUNCIL
establishing a framework for the recovery
and resolution of insurance and reinsurance
undertakings and amending Directives
2002/47/EC, 2004/25/EC, 2009/138/EC, (EU)
2017/1132 and Regulations (EU) No
1094/2010 and (EU) No 648/2012
(Text with EEA relevance)
THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT AND THE
COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION,
Having regard to the Treaty on the Functioning
of the European Union, and in particular Article
114 thereof,
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Having regard to the proposal from the
European Commission,
After transmission of the draft legislative act to
the national parliaments,
Having regard to the opinion of the European
Central Bank1,
Having regard to the opinion of the European
Economic and Social Committee2,
Acting in accordance with the ordinary
legislative procedure,
1
OJ C , , p. .
2
OJ C , , p. .
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Whereas:
(1) Distress of insurance undertakings can
have substantial repercussions on the economy
and social welfare in Member States should
such distress lead to a disruption of the
protection provided to policy holders,
beneficiaries or injured parties. The role of
reinsurance undertakings in the economy, their
interconnectedness with primary insurance
undertakings and financial markets more
broadly, as well as the relatively concentrated
reinsurance market require an appropriate
framework to deal with their distress or failure
in an orderly fashion. The recovery and
resolution of both primary insurance
undertakings and reinsurance undertakings
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
should therefore be addressed, taking into
account their respective specificities.
(2) The global financial crisis of 2008
exposed the vulnerabilities of the financial
sector and its interconnectedness. Causes of
distress and failure appeared to be linked,
amongst others, to the evolution of financial
markets and to the intrinsic nature of insurance
or reinsurance activities. In that regard,
underwriting risks, that is under-provisioned
claims, mispricing, that is underestimated
premiums, asset-liability mismanagement and
investment losses are often referred to as main
sources of concern for insurance and
reinsurance undertakings. In that context,
taxpayer money has been used to restore the
deteriorated financial conditions of several
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
insurance undertakings. Although Directive
2009/138/EC of the European Parliament and of
the Council 3 aimed at strengthening the
financial system in the Union and the resilience
of insurance and reinsurance undertakings, it did
not completely eliminate the possibility of
failures of such insurance and reinsurance
undertakings. High market volatilities and
prolonged low levels of interest rates could be
particularly harmful for the profitability and
solvency position of insurance and reinsurance
undertakings. The sensitivity of insurance and
reinsurance undertakings to market and
economic developments therefore calls for
particular caution and an adequate framework to
manage, including in a pre-emptive manner,
3
Directive 2009/138/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 November 2009 on the taking-up and pursuit of the business of Insurance and Reinsurance
(Solvency II), (OJ L 335, 17.12.2009, p. 1).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
potential deteriorations of the financial positions
of such undertakings. Some recent failures and
near-failures, in particular of a cross-border
nature, illustrated weaknesses of the current
framework that need to be addressed to organise
adequately the orderly exit from the market of
insurance or reinsurance undertakings.
(3) Activities, services or operations
performed by insurance or reinsurance
undertakings that cannot be substituted easily
within a reasonable timeframe, or at a
reasonable cost for policy holders, beneficiaries
or injured parties, need to be seen as critical
functions that need to be continued. Such
activities, services or operations can be critical
at Union, national or regional level. The
continuity of insurance or reinsurance protection
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
is often preferable to the winding down of a
failing undertaking as such continuity delivers
the most favourable outcome for policy holders,
beneficiaries or injured parties. It is therefore
crucial that adequate tools are available to
prevent failures and, where failures occur, to
minimise negative repercussions by preserving
the continuity of those critical functions.
(4) Ensuring effective resolution of failing
insurance and reinsurance undertakings within
the Union is an essential element in the
completion of the internal market. The failure of
such undertakings has an impact not only on
policy holders and possibly the real economy
and financial stability of the markets on which
those insurance and reinsurance undertakings
operate directly, but also on the trust in the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
internal market for insurance. The completion of
the internal market in financial services has
reinforced the interplay between the different
national financial systems. Insurance and
reinsurance undertakings are active on financial
markets to manage their investment portfolio
and the risks related to their activities. They are
interrelated through their derivative operations
with the interbank and other financial markets
that are, in essence, pan-European. In that
context, the inability of Member States to
address the failure of an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking and resolve it in a way
that is predictable and harmonised and would
effectively prevent broader systemic damage,
can undermine the stability of financial markets
and, consequently, the internal market in the
field of financial services.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(5) The global financial crisis of 2008
highlighted the need to develop an appropriate
recovery and resolution framework for
insurance and reinsurance undertakings. At
international level, the Financial Stability Board
(‘FSB’) developed, in October 2014, Key
4
Attributes on effective resolution regimes
for any insurance undertaking that could be
systemically significant or critical if it fails. In
June 2016, the FSB released complementary
guidance on developing effective resolution
strategies and plans for systemically important
insurers5. In parallel, the International
Association of Insurance Supervisors (‘IAIS’)
adopted in November 2019 Insurance Core
4
Financial Stability Board, Key Attributes of Effective Resolution Regimes for Financial Institutions, 2014.
5
Financial Stability Board, Developing Effective Resolution Strategies and Plans for Systemically Important Insurers, 2016.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Principles for all insurance and reinsurance
undertakings, a Common Framework for
Internationally Active Insurance Groups
detailing standards for pre-emptive recovery
planning, and actions that authorities are
expected to take towards an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking that would exit the
market and enter into resolution 6. Those
developments should be taken into account
when laying down a framework for the recovery
and resolution of failing insurance and
reinsurance undertakings.
(6) Many insurance and reinsurance
undertakings are operating beyond national
borders. A lack of coordination and cooperation
between public authorities to prepare and
6
International Association of Insurance Supervisors, Insurance Core Principles and Common Framework for the Supervision of Internationally Active Insurance Groups, 2019.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
manage the distress or failure of an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking operating across
borders would undermine Member States’
mutual trust, result in a suboptimal outcome for
policy holders, beneficiaries and injured parties
and affect the credibility of the internal market
for insurance.
(7) There is currently no harmonisation of
the procedures at European Union level for
resolving insurance or reinsurance undertakings
in a coordinated manner. Instead, considerable
substantive and procedural differences between
national laws, regulations and administrative
provisions that govern the failure of insurance
and reinsurance undertakings are observed
across Member States. In addition, corporate
insolvency procedures may not always be
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
appropriate for insurance or reinsurance
undertakings, as those procedures may not
always ensure an adequate continuation of the
critical functions for policy holders,
beneficiaries and injured parties, the real
economy or the financial stability as a whole.
(8) It is necessary to ensure the continuity of
the critical functions of failing insurance or
reinsurance undertakings, or of insurance or
reinsurance undertakings that are likely to fail,
while minimising the impact of such an
undertaking’s failure on the economy and
financial system. It is therefore necessary to lay
down a framework to provide authorities with a
credible set of tools to intervene sufficiently
early and quickly in insurance or reinsurance
undertakings that are failing or likely to fail.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Such framework should ensure that shareholders
bear losses first and that creditors bear losses
after shareholders, provided that no creditor
incurs greater losses than they would have
incurred if the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking had been wound up under normal
insolvency proceedings in accordance with the
no creditor worse off principle.
(9) The framework to be laid down should
enable authorities to ensure the continuity of
insurance protection for policy holders,
beneficiaries and injured parties, transfer viable
activities and portfolios of the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking where appropriate, and
apportion losses in a manner that is fair and
predictable. Those objectives should help avoid
unnecessary losses or social hardship falling on
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
policy holders, beneficiaries and injured parties,
mitigate negative impacts on the real economy,
minimise negative effects on financial markets
and minimise the costs for taxpayers.
(10) The review of Directive 2009/138/EC,
and in particular the introduction of more risk-
sensitive capital requirements, strengthened
supervision, enhanced liquidity monitoring and
better tools for macro-prudential policies,
should further reduce the likelihood of failures
of insurance or reinsurance undertakings and
enhance the resilience of those undertakings to
economic stress, whether caused by systemic
disturbances or by events specific to the
individual undertaking. Nevertheless, despite a
sound and robust prudential framework,
situations of financial distress cannot be
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
completely excluded. Member States should
therefore be prepared and have adequate
recovery and resolution tools in place to handle
situations involving both systemic crises and
failures of individual undertakings. Such tools
should include mechanisms that enable
authorities to deal effectively with undertakings
that are failing or likely to fail. The use of such
tools and the exercise of such powers should
take into account the circumstances in which the
failure occurs.
(11) Some Member States have already
introduced pre-emptive recovery planning
requirements, and mechanisms to resolve failing
insurance or reinsurance undertakings.
However, the absence of common conditions,
powers and processes for the recovery and
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution of insurance or reinsurance
undertakings across the Union is likely to
constitute barriers to the smooth operation of the
internal market and hinder cooperation between
national authorities when dealing with
distressed or failing cross-border groups of
undertakings. That is particularly true where
different approaches mean that national
authorities do not have the same level of control
or the same ability to resolve insurance or
reinsurance undertakings. Those differences in
recovery and resolution regimes may affect the
level playing field and potentially create
competitive distortions between undertakings.
Those barriers should be eliminated and rules
should be adopted to ensure that the internal
market is not undermined. To that end, rules
governing the pre-emptive recovery and
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution of insurance or reinsurance
undertakings should be made subject to
common minimum harmonisation rules. In order
to ensure consistency with existing Union
legislation in the area of insurance services, the
pre-emptive recovery and resolution regime
should apply to insurance or reinsurance
undertakings that are subject to the prudential
requirements laid down in Directive
2009/138/EC.
(12) The failure of an entity affiliated to a
group can rapidly impact the solvency and the
operations of the whole group. It is therefore
necessary to have in place group pre-emptive
recovery and resolution planning requirements.
In addition, authorities should possess effective
means of action with respect to those entities to
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
impose remedial actions that take into account
the financial soundness of all group entities,
address impediments to resolvability in a group
context and produce a consistent resolution
scheme for the group as a whole, in particular in
a cross-border context. The pre-emptive
recovery and resolution planning and
resolvability requirements and the resolution
regime should therefore also apply to parent
undertakings, holding companies and other
group entities, including branches of insurance
and reinsurance undertakings that are
established outside the Union.
(13) It is necessary to ensure the suitability
and effectiveness of the recovery and resolution
framework while avoiding unnecessary
administrative burdens and costs on
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertakings and authorities. The
implementation of such recovery and resolution
framework should therefore be proportionate to
the nature, scale and complexity of the
undertaking concerned, and of its activities and
services. Regarding the scope of the recovery
and resolution planning requirements,
authorities should determine, on the basis of a
harmonised set of risk-based criteria, which
undertakings are subject to the planning
requirements. To foster trust in the insurance
and reinsurance single market and to foster a
level playing field, a minimum degree of
preparedness should be achieved through laying
down a minimum market coverage level. That
minimum market coverage level should
however take into account the differences
between recovery on the one hand and
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution on the other, and the existence or
absence of a public interest for taking resolution
action.
(14) For the same reason, authorities should,
where appropriate, apply different or reduced
pre-emptive recovery and resolution planning
and information requirements on an
undertaking-specific basis, and at a lower
frequency of updates. Authorities should, when
applying such simplified obligations, take into
account the nature, size, complexity and
substitutability of an undertaking’s business, its
shareholding structure and legal form, its risk
profile, its degree of interconnectedness to other
regulated undertakings or to the financial system
in general. Authorities should also take into
account whether the failure and subsequent
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
winding up of the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking under normal insolvency
proceedings would be likely to have a
significant negative effect on policy holders,
financial markets, other undertakings, or the
wider economy. Authorities should report to
EIOPA on the application of such simplified
obligations on an annual basis.
(15) For an orderly resolution process, and to
avoid conflicts of interest, Member States
should appoint public administrative authorities
or authorities entrusted with public
administrative powers to perform the functions
and tasks in relation to the recovery and
resolution framework. Member States should
ensure that adequate resources are allocated to
those resolution authorities. Where a Member
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
State designates a resolution authority that has
other functions, adequate structural
arrangements should be put in place to separate
those functions from the functions related to
resolution and to ensure operational
independence. Such separation should not
prevent the resolution function from having
access to any information it requires for the
exercise of its duties under the recovery and
resolution framework, or for cooperation
between different authorities involved in the
application of the recovery and resolution
framework.
(16) In light of the consequences that the
failure of an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking may have on policy holders, the
financial system and the economy of a Member
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
State, and in light of the possible need to use
public funds to deal with such failure, the
Ministries of Finance or other relevant
ministries in the Member States should be
closely involved, at an early stage, in the
process of crisis management and resolution.
(17) It is necessary to deal in an efficient
manner with deteriorating financial positions of
insurance and reinsurance undertakings, or
breaches of regulatory requirements by those
undertakings, and to prevent the escalation of
problems. Supervisory authorities should
therefore have the power to impose preventive
measures. Such preventive powers should,
however, be consistent with the ladder of
intervention and the supervisory powers already
provided for in Directive 2009/138/EC for
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
similar circumstances, including supervisory
powers provided for in the Supervisory Review
Process laid down in Article 36 of Directive
2009/138/EC. Such preventive powers should
neither lead to a new pre-defined intervention
trigger ahead of the Solvency Capital
Requirement, laid down in Title I, Chapter VI,
Section 4 of that Directive. Supervisory
authorities should assess each situation
individually and decide upon the need for
preventive measures based on the
circumstances, the situation of the undertaking
and their supervisory judgment.
(18) It is essential that groups, or where
applicable, individual undertakings, prepare and
regularly update pre-emptive recovery plans that
set out actions to be taken by those groups or
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertakings to restore their financial position
following a significant deterioration of that
position that could pose a risk to their viability.
Insurance and reinsurance undertakings should
therefore identify a set of quantitative and
qualitative indicators that would trigger the
activation of remedial actions envisaged in such
pre-emptive recovery plans. Such indicators
should help insurance and reinsurance
undertakings to take remedial actions in the best
interest of their policy holders and should not
lay down new regulatory prudential
requirements. Pre-emptive recovery plans
covering all material legal entities within the
group should be detailed and should be based on
realistic assumptions that are applicable in a
range of robust and severe scenarios. Those pre-
emptive recovery plans should be an integral
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
part of an undertaking’s system of governance.
Existing tools may serve as an input when
preparing such pre-emptive recovery plans,
including the own risk and solvency assessment,
contingency plans or liquidity risk management
plans. The requirement to prepare a pre-emptive
recovery plan should, however, be applied
proportionately and should be without prejudice
to the development and submission of a realistic
recovery plan as required by Article 138(2) of
Directive 2009/138/EC. Where relevant, the
elements of the pre-emptive recovery plan could
inform or serve as a basis to develop the
recovery plan required by Article 138(2) of
Directive 2009/138/EC.
(19) It is necessary to ensure an adequate
degree of preparedness for crisis situations.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Ultimate parent undertakings or individual
insurance or reinsurance undertakings should
therefore be required to submit their pre-
emptive recovery plans to supervisory
authorities for a complete assessment, including
the assessment of whether those plans are
comprehensive and could feasibly restore an
undertaking or group’s viability in a timely
manner, even in periods of severe financial
stress. Where an undertaking presents a pre-
emptive recovery plan that is not adequate,
supervisory authorities should be empowered to
require that undertaking to take measures
necessary to redress the material deficiencies of
the plan.
(20) Resolution planning is an essential
component of effective resolution. Resolution
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
authorities should therefore have all the
information necessary to identify critical
functions and ensure their continuation.
Insurance and reinsurance undertakings have
privileged knowledge of their own functioning
and any problems arising from it, and resolution
authorities should therefore draw up resolution
plans on the basis of, inter alia, the information
provided by the undertakings concerned. In
order to avoid unnecessary administrative
burdens, resolution authorities should primarily
retrieve the necessary information from the
supervisory authorities.
(21) Low risk profile undertakings should,
due to their low risk profile, not be obliged to
draw up separate pre-emptive recovery plans,
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
nor should they be subject to resolution
planning.
(22) In order to anticipate the possible
interaction of remedial and resolution measures
and to enhance the crisis preparedness and the
resolvability of groups, any group treatment for
pre-emptive recovery and resolution planning
should apply to all group entities subject to
group supervision. The pre-emptive recovery
and resolution plans should take into account
the financial, technical and business structure of
the group concerned and its degree of internal
interconnectedness.
(23) Group pre-emptive recovery and
resolution plans should be prepared for the
group as a whole and should identify measures
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
in relation to both an ultimate parent
undertaking and individual subsidiaries that are
part of that group. The extent to which
subsidiaries are considered in the group pre-
emptive recovery and resolution plans should,
however, be proportionate to their relevance to
the group and to policy holders, the real
economy and the financial system in the
Member States where those subsidiaries operate.
The resolution authorities of the Member States
where a group has subsidiaries should be
involved in the drawing up of any resolution
plans. The authorities concerned, acting within
the supervisory or resolution colleges, should
make every effort to reach a joint decision on
the assessment and adoption of those plans.
However, adequate crisis preparedness should
not be affected by an absence of a joint decision
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
within the supervisory or resolution colleges. In
such cases, each supervisory authority
responsible for a subsidiary should have the
possibility to require a pre-emptive recovery
plan for the subsidiaries under its jurisdiction
and make its own assessment of the pre-emptive
recovery plan. For the same reasons, each
resolution authority responsible for a subsidiary
should, for the subsidiaries under its
jurisdiction, draw up and keep updated a
resolution plan. The drawing up of individual
pre-emptive recovery and resolution plans for
undertakings that are a part of a group should
remain exceptional, duly justified and apply the
same standards that are applied to comparable
undertakings in the Member State concerned.
Where individual pre-emptive recovery and
resolution plans for undertakings that are a part
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
of a group are prepared, the authorities
concerned should aim to achieve, to the extent
possible, consistency with pre-emptive recovery
and resolution plans for the rest of the group.
(24) In order to keep all authorities concerned
fully and permanently informed, supervisory
authorities should transmit any pre-emptive
recovery plans and any changes thereto to the
resolution authorities concerned and resolution
authorities should transmit any resolution plans
and any changes thereto to the supervisory
authorities concerned.
(25) Based on an assessment of the
resolvability of insurance or reinsurance
undertakings, resolution authorities should have
the power to require, either directly or indirectly
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
through the supervisory authority, that insurance
or reinsurance undertakings change their
structure and organisation. Resolution
authorities should also be able to take necessary
but proportionate measures to reduce or remove
any material impediments to the application of
resolution tools and to ensure the resolvability
of the entities concerned. Resolution authorities
should assess the resolvability of insurance or
reinsurance undertakings at the level of those
undertakings where it is expected that, in
accordance with the group resolution plan,
resolution actions would be taken. The
resolution authorities’ ability to request changes
to the structure and organisation of an insurance
or reinsurance undertaking, or to take measures
to reduce or remove any material impediments
to the application of resolution tools and to
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
ensure the resolvability of the undertakings
concerned, should not go beyond what is
necessary to simplify the structure and
operations of the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking concerned in order to improve that
undertaking’s resolvability.
(26) The implementation of actions outlined
in a pre-emptive recovery plan or a resolution
plan may have effects on staff of insurance or
reinsurance undertakings. Those plans should
therefore contain procedures for informing and
consulting employee representatives throughout
the recovery and resolution processes where
appropriate. Those procedures should take into
account collective agreements, other
arrangements provided for by social partners,
and national and Union law on the involvement
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
of trade unions and workers’ representatives in
company restructuring processes.
(27) Effective recovery and resolution of
insurance and reinsurance undertakings or group
entities operating across the Union requires
cooperation among supervisory authorities and
resolution authorities within supervisory and
resolution colleges at all stages of the process,
from the preparation of pre-emptive recovery
and resolution plans to the actual resolution of
an undertaking. Where authorities disagree on
decisions to be taken with regard to groups and
undertakings, the European Supervisory
Authority (European Insurance and
Occupational Pensions Authority) (‘EIOPA’),
established by Regulation (EU) No 1094/2010
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
of the European Parliament and of the Council7
should, as a last resort, play a mediation role.
(28) During the recovery and preventive
phases, shareholders should retain full
responsibility and control of the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking. They should no longer
retain such a responsibility once the undertaking
has been put under resolution. The resolution
framework should therefore provide for a timely
entry into resolution, that is before an insurance
or reinsurance undertaking is balance sheet or
cash flow insolvent, before all equity has been
fully wiped out, or before the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking is unable to comply
with its payment obligations as they come due.
7
Regulation (EU) No 1094/2010 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 24 November 2010 establishing a European Supervisory Authority (European Insurance
and Occupational Pensions Authority), amending Decision No 716/2009/EC and repealing Commission Decision 2009/79/EC (OJ L 331, 15.12.2010, p. 48).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Resolution should be initiated where a
supervisory authority, after having consulted a
resolution authority, or after having been
consulted by a resolution authority, determines
that an insurance or reinsurance undertaking is
failing or likely to fail and alternative measures
would not prevent such a failure within a
reasonable timeframe. An insurance or
reinsurance undertaking should be considered to
be failing or likely to fail in any of the following
circumstances: (i) where the undertaking
breaches or is likely to be in breach of the
Minimum Capital Requirement (‘MCR’) laid
down in Title I, Chapter VI, Section 4, of
Directive 2009/138/EC and where there is no
reasonable prospect of compliance being
restored; (ii) where the undertaking no longer
fulfils the conditions for authorisation or where
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the undertaking fails seriously to comply with
its legal obligations under the laws and
regulations to which it is subject or is likely to
seriously fail to comply with its legal
obligations under the laws and regulations to
which it is subject in the near future in a way
that would justify the withdrawal of the
authorisation; (iii) where the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking is or is likely to be
unable to pay its debts or other liabilities in the
near future, including payments to policy
holders or beneficiaries as they fall due; or (iv)
where the insurance or reinsurance undertaking
requires extraordinary public financial support.
(29) The use of resolution tools and powers
may disrupt the rights of shareholders and
creditors of insurance and reinsurance
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertakings. In particular, the power of the
resolution authorities to transfer the shares or all
or part of the assets of an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking to a private purchaser
without the consent of shareholders affects the
property rights of shareholders. In addition, the
power to decide which liabilities to transfer out
of a failing undertaking to ensure the continuity
of services and to avoid adverse effects on
policy holders, beneficiaries and injured parties,
the real economy or financial stability as a
whole, may affect the equal treatment of
creditors. Any resolution tool should therefore
be applied only to those insurance or
reinsurance undertakings that are failing or
likely to fail, and only where it is necessary to
pursue the resolution objectives in the general
interest. In particular, resolution tools should be
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
applied only where the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking cannot be wound up under normal
insolvency proceedings without unduly
affecting the protection of policy holders,
beneficiaries and claimants or destabilising the
financial system. In addition, resolution
measures should be necessary to ensure the
rapid transfer and continuation of critical
functions and there should be no reasonable
prospect for any alternative private solution,
including any increase of capital by the existing
shareholders or by any third party sufficient to
restore the full viability of the entity without
having effect on insurance claims. Any
interference with the rights of shareholders and
creditors that results from resolution action
should be compatible with the Charter of
Fundamental Rights of the European Union (the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Charter). In particular, where creditors within
the same class are treated differently in the
context of resolution action, such distinctions
should be justified in the public interest and be
proportionate to the risks being addressed and
should be neither directly nor indirectly
discriminatory on the grounds of nationality.
(30) When applying resolutions tools and
exercising resolution powers, resolution
authorities should take all appropriate measures
to ensure that resolution action is taken in
accordance with the principle that insurance
claims are affected after shareholders and that
other creditors have borne their share of the
losses. In addition, resolution authorities should
ensure that the costs of the resolution of
insurance or reinsurance undertakings are
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
minimised and that creditors of the same class
are treated in an equitable manner.
(31) The write-down or conversion of capital
instruments, debt instruments and other eligible
liabilities should provide for an internal loss
absorption mechanism. That mechanism,
combined with transfer tools that aim at
maintaining continuity of insurance coverage
for the benefit of policy holders, beneficiaries
and injured parties, should allow for the
achievement of the resolution objectives and
should limit to a great extent the impact of a
failure of an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking on policy holders. There may be
extreme cases, however, where the resolution of
an insurance or reinsurance undertaking may
require the intervention of specific national
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
schemes, in particular an insurance guarantee
scheme or a resolution fund, to provide for
complementary loss absorbing and restructuring
resources or, as a last resort, extraordinary
public financing. The necessary safeguards that
aim to protect creditors should also reflect the
existence of such specific national schemes,
which in turn have to comply with the Union
State aid framework. The write-down or
conversion tool should be applied before the use
of any extraordinary public financial support.
(32) Interference with property rights should
not be disproportionate. Affected shareholders
and creditors of insurance and reinsurance
undertakings, including policy holders should
therefore not incur greater losses than they
would have incurred if the insurance or
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
reinsurance undertaking had been wound up at
the time that the resolution decision was taken.
In the event of a partial transfer of assets and
liabilities of an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking under resolution to a private
purchaser or to a bridge undertaking, the
residual part of the undertaking under resolution
should be wound up under normal insolvency
proceedings. Shareholders and creditors who are
left in the winding up proceedings of an
insurance or reinsurance undertaking should be
entitled to receive in payment of, or
compensation for, their claims in the winding up
proceedings not less than what they would have
recovered if the whole insurance or reinsurance
undertaking had been wound up under normal
insolvency proceedings.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(33) To protect the rights of shareholders and
creditors, it is necessary to lay down clear
obligations concerning the valuation of the
assets and liabilities of the undertaking under
resolution and concerning the valuation of the
treatment that shareholders and creditors would
have received if the undertaking had been
wound up under normal insolvency proceedings.
It is therefore necessary to lay down that, before
any resolution action is taken, a fair and realistic
valuation of the assets and liabilities of the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking is carried
out. Such a valuation should be subject to a right
of appeal. However, due to the nature of
resolution action and its close link with the
valuation, such appeal should only be possible
where it is simultaneously directed against the
resolution decision. In addition, it is necessary
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
to lay down that, after resolution tools have
been applied, a comparison is made between the
treatment that shareholders and creditors have
actually received and the treatment they would
have received under normal insolvency
proceedings. That ex-post comparison should be
challengeable apart from the resolution decision.
Shareholders and creditors that have received
less than the amount that they would have
received under normal insolvency proceedings
should be entitled to the payment of the
difference.
(34) It is important that losses are recognised
upon failure of the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking. The valuation of assets and
liabilities of failing insurance or reinsurance
undertakings should be based on fair, prudent
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
and realistic assumptions at the moment that the
resolution tools are applied. The value of
liabilities should, however, not be affected in
the valuation by the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking’s financial state. It should be
possible, in exceptional cases of urgency, that
resolution authorities make a rapid valuation of
the assets or the liabilities of a failing insurance
or reinsurance undertaking. That valuation
should be provisional and should apply until an
independent valuation is carried out. EIOPA
should establish a framework of principles to be
used in conducting such valuations and should
allow for different specific methodologies to be
applied by resolution authorities and
independent valuers, as appropriate.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(35) When taking resolution actions,
resolution authorities should take into account
and follow the measures provided for in the
resolution plans unless resolution authorities
assess, taking into account circumstances of the
case, that resolution objectives will be achieved
more effectively by taking actions that are not
provided for in the resolution plans.
(36) Resolution tools should be designed and
suitable to counter a broad set of largely
unpredictable scenarios, taking into account that
there could be a difference between a single
insurance or reinsurance undertaking in crisis
and a broader systemic crisis. Resolution tools
should therefore cover each of those scenarios,
including the solvent run-off of the undertaking
under resolution until its termination, the sale of
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the business or shares of the undertaking under
resolution, the setting up of a bridge
undertaking, the separation of assets and
liabilities from the impaired or under-
performing portfolios of the failing undertaking,
and the write-down or conversion of capital
instruments and other eligible liabilities of the
failing insurance or reinsurance undertaking.
(37) Where resolution tools have been used to
transfer insurance portfolios to a sound entity,
which could be a private sector purchaser or a
bridge undertaking, the residual part of the
undertaking should be liquidated within an
appropriate time frame. The length of that time
frame should be based on the need for the
failing insurance or reinsurance undertaking to
provide services or support to enable the private
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
sector purchaser or bridge undertaking to carry
out the activities or services acquired by virtue
of that transfer.
(38) The sale of business tool should enable
resolution authorities to effect a sale of the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking or parts of
its business to one or more purchasers without
the consent of shareholders. When applying the
sale of business tool, authorities should make
arrangements for the marketing of that insurance
or reinsurance undertaking or part of its
business in an open, transparent and non-
discriminatory process, while maximising the
sale price as much as possible. Where, for
reasons of urgency, such a process is
impossible, authorities should take steps to
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
redress detrimental effects on competition and
on the internal market.
(39) Any net proceeds from the transfer of
assets or liabilities of the undertaking under
resolution when applying the sale of business
tool should benefit the undertaking left in the
winding up proceedings. Any net proceeds from
the transfer of shares or other instruments of
ownership issued by the undertaking under
resolution when applying the sale of business
tool should benefit the owners of those shares or
other instruments of ownership. Proceeds should
be calculated net of the costs arisen from the
failure of the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking and from the resolution process.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(40) Information concerning the marketing of
a failing insurance or reinsurance undertaking
and negotiations with potential acquirers prior to
the application of the sale of business tool are
likely to be sensitive and may pose risks for the
trust in the insurance market. It is therefore
important to ensure that the disclosure to the
public of such information, which is required by
Regulation (EU) No 596/2014 of the European
Parliament and of the Council8, can be delayed
for the time necessary to plan and structure the
resolution of the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking.
(41) A bridge undertaking is an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking that is wholly or
8
Regulation (EU) No 596/2014 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 April 2014 on market abuse (market abuse regulation) and repealing Directive 2003/6/EC
of the European Parliament and of the Council and Commission Directives 2003/124/EC, 2003/125/EC and 2004/72/EC (OJ L 173, 12.6.2014, p. 1).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
partially owned by one or more public
authorities or controlled by the resolution
authority. The main purpose of a bridge
undertaking is to ensure that critical functions
continue to be provided to the policy holders of
the failing insurance or reinsurance undertaking.
A bridge undertaking should therefore be
operated as a viable going concern and should
be put back on the market as soon as conditions
are appropriate, or be wound up in case the
bridge undertaking is not viable.
(42) The asset and liability separation tool
should enable authorities to transfer assets,
rights or liabilities of an undertaking under
resolution to a separate vehicle in order to
remove, manage and wind down such assets,
rights or liabilities. To prevent an undue
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
competitive advantage for the failing insurance
or reinsurance undertaking, the asset and
liability tool should be used only in conjunction
with other tools.
(43) An effective resolution regime should
ensure that insurance or reinsurance
undertakings can be resolved in a way that
minimises the negative impact of a failure on
policy holders, taxpayers, the real economy and
financial stability. The write-down or
conversion should ensure that, before insurance
claims are affected, shareholders and creditors
of a failing insurance or reinsurance undertaking
suffer losses first and bear an appropriate part of
the costs arising from the failure of the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking as soon as
a resolution power is used. The write-down or
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
conversion tool should thus give shareholders
and creditors of insurance or reinsurance
undertakings and, to a certain extent, policy
holders, a stronger incentive to monitor the
health of an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking during normal circumstances.
(44) It is necessary to ensure that resolution
authorities have the necessary flexibility, in a
range of circumstances, to place the undertaking
in resolution in a solvent run-off, to transfer its
assets, rights and liabilities in the best
conditions for policy holders, or to allocate
remaining losses. It is therefore appropriate to
lay down that resolution authorities should be
able to apply the write-down or conversion tool
both where the objective is to resolve the failing
insurance or reinsurance undertaking as an
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertaking in solvent run-off, and where
critical insurance services are transferred while
the residual part of the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking ceases to operate and is wound up.
In that context, the restructuring of insurance
liabilities may be warranted to ensure the
continuation of a material portion of the
insurance coverage and where that is deemed in
the best interest of the policy holders.
(45) Where there is a realistic prospect that
the undertaking’s viability may be restored and
policy holders are not suffering any losses in the
resolution process, the write-down or
conversion tool could be used to restore the
undertaking under resolution to a going concern.
In such case, the resolution through write-down
or conversion should be accompanied by the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
replacement of the management, except where
the retention of the management is appropriate
and necessary for the achievement of the
resolution objectives.
(46) It is not appropriate to apply the write-
down or conversion tool to claims as far as they
are secured, collateralised or otherwise
guaranteed as such write-down or conversion
could be ineffective or due to the potential
negative impact of such write-down or
conversion on financial stability. However, in
order to ensure that the write-down or
conversion tool is effective and achieves its
objectives, it is desirable that it can be applied to
as wide a range of the unsecured liabilities of a
failing insurance or reinsurance undertaking as
possible. Nevertheless, it is appropriate to
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
exclude certain kinds of unsecured liabilities
from the scope of application of the write-down
or conversion tool. Thus, to ensure the
continuity of critical functions, the write-down
or conversion tool should not be applied to
certain liabilities to employees of the failing
insurance or reinsurance undertaking or to
commercial claims that relate to goods and
services critical to the daily functioning of the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking. To honour
pension entitlements and pension amounts owed
or owing to pension trusts and pension trustees,
the write-down or conversion tool should not be
applied to a failing insurance or reinsurance
undertaking’s liabilities to a pension scheme. To
reduce the risk of systemic contagion, the write-
down or conversion tool should neither be
applied to liabilities arising from a participation
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
in payment systems which have a remaining
maturity of less than seven days, or to liabilities
to insurance or reinsurance undertakings, credit
institutions and investment firms, with the
exception of entities that are part of the same
group, with an original maturity of less than
seven days.
(47) The protection of policy holders,
beneficiaries or injured parties is one of the
main objectives of resolution. Insurance claims
should therefore only be subject to the
application of the write-down or conversion tool
as a last resort measure and resolution
authorities should carefully consider the
consequences of a potential write-down of
insurance claims stemming from insurance
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
contracts held by natural persons and micro,
small and medium-sized enterprises.
(48) Resolution authorities should be able to
exclude or partially exclude liabilities in a
number of circumstances where it is not
possible to write-down or convert such
liabilities within a reasonable timeframe, where
the exclusion is strictly necessary and
proportionate to achieve the resolution
objectives, or where the application of the write-
down or conversion tool would cause a
destruction in value such that losses borne by
other creditors would be higher than if those
liabilities were not excluded. Where those
exclusions are applied, the level of write-down
or conversion of other eligible liabilities may be
increased to take account of such exclusions,
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
subject to the ‘no creditor worse off than under
normal insolvency proceedings’ principle being
respected. At the same time, Member States
should not be required to finance resolution
from their general budget.
(49) As a rule, resolution authorities should
apply the write-down or conversion tool in a
way that respects the pari passu treatment of
creditors and the statutory ranking of claims
under applicable insolvency law. Losses should
therefore first be absorbed by regulatory capital
instruments and should be allocated to
shareholders either through the cancellation or
transfer of shares or through severe dilution.
Where that is not sufficient, subordinated debt
should be converted or written down. Senior
liabilities should only be converted or written
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
down where the subordinate debt has been
converted or written down entirely.
(50) Exemptions of liabilities, inter alia for
payment and settlement systems, employee or
trade creditors, or preferential ranking, should
equally apply in third countries and the Union.
To ensure that liabilities can be written-down or
converted in third countries, it is necessary to
lay down that contractual provisions governed
by the law of third countries recognise that
possibility. Such contractual terms should not be
required for liabilities exempted from the
application of the write-down or conversion
tool, or where the law of the third country or a
binding agreement concluded with that third
country allow the resolution authority of the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Member State concerned to apply the write-
down or conversion tool.
(51) Shareholders and creditors should
contribute, to the extent necessary, to the loss
allocation mechanism of a failing undertaking.
Therefore, Member States should ensure that
Tier 1, Tier 2 and Tier 3 capital instruments
fully absorb losses at the point of non-viability
of the issuing insurance or reinsurance
undertaking. Accordingly, resolution authorities
should be required to write-down those
instruments in full, or to convert them, where
applicable, to Tier 1 instruments, at the point of
non-viability and before any resolution action is
taken. For that purpose, the point of non-
viability should be understood as either the
point at which the resolution authority
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
concerned determines that the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking meets the conditions
for resolution, or the point at which the
resolution authority concerned decides that the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking would
cease to be viable if those capital instruments
were not written down or converted. Those
requirements should be recognised in the terms
governing the instrument, and in any prospectus
or offering documents published or provided in
connection with the instruments.
(52) Resolution authorities should have all
the necessary legal powers that, in different
combinations, may be exercised when applying
the resolution tools in order to ensure effective
execution of resolution. Those legal powers
should include the power to transfer shares in,
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
or assets, rights or liabilities of, a failing
insurance or reinsurance undertaking to another
entity, including another undertaking or a bridge
undertaking, the power to write-down or cancel
shares, or write-down or convert liabilities of a
failing insurance or reinsurance undertaking, the
power to replace the management and the power
to impose a temporary moratorium on the
payment of claims. Ancillary powers are
needed, including the power to require
continuity of essential services from other parts
of a group.
(53) It is not necessary to prescribe the exact
means through which the resolution authorities
should intervene in the failing insurance or
reinsurance undertaking. Resolution authorities
should have the choice between taking control
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
through a direct intervention in the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking or through executive
order. They should decide according to the
circumstances of the case.
(54) It is necessary to lay down procedural
requirements to ensure that resolution actions
are properly notified and made public.
Information obtained by resolution authorities
and their professional advisers during the
resolution process is, however, likely to be
sensitive and should therefore be subject to an
effective confidentiality regime before the
resolution decision is made public. Any
information provided in respect of a decision
before it is taken, be it on whether the
conditions for resolution are satisfied, on the use
of a specific tool or of any action during the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
proceedings, must be presumed to have effects
on the public and private interests concerned by
the action. It is therefore necessary to ensure
that there are appropriate mechanisms for
maintaining the confidentiality of such
information, including on the content and details
of recovery and resolution plans and the result
of any assessment carried out in that context.
(55) Resolution authorities should have
ancillary powers to ensure the effectiveness of
the transfer of shares or debt instruments and
assets, rights and liabilities to a third party
purchaser or a bridge undertaking. In particular,
to facilitate a transfer of insurance claims
without affecting the overall risk profile of the
related portfolio and of the associated technical
provisions and capital requirements, the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
economic benefits provided by reinsurance
agreements should be preserved. Resolution
authorities should therefore have the ability to
transfer insurance claims together with their
corresponding reinsurance rights. That ability
should also include the power to remove third
parties rights from the transferred instruments or
assets, the power to enforce contracts and the
power to provide for the continuity of
arrangements vis-à-vis the recipient of the
transferred assets and shares. The right of a
party to terminate a contract with an
undertaking under resolution, or a group entity
thereof, for reasons other than the resolution of
the failing insurance or reinsurance undertaking
should also remain unaffected. In addition,
resolution authorities should have the ancillary
power to require the residual insurance or
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
reinsurance undertaking that is being wound up
under normal insolvency proceedings to provide
services that are necessary to enable the
undertaking to which assets or shares have been
transferred by virtue of the application of the
sale of business tool or the bridge undertaking
tool to operate its business.
(56) According to Article 47 of the Charter,
everyone whose rights and freedoms guaranteed
by the law of the Union are violated has the
right to an effective remedy before a tribunal.
The decisions taken by resolution authorities
should therefore be subject to a right of appeal.
(57) Crisis management measures taken by
resolution authorities may require complex
economic assessments and a large margin of
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
discretion. Resolution authorities are
specifically equipped with the expertise needed
for making such assessments and for
determining the appropriate use of the margin of
discretion. It is therefore important to ensure
that the complex economic assessments made
by resolution authorities in that context are used
as a basis by national courts when reviewing the
crisis management measures concerned.
However, the complex nature of those
assessments should not prevent national courts
from examining whether the evidence relied on
by the resolution authority is factually accurate,
reliable and consistent, whether that evidence
contains all relevant information which should
be taken into account in order to assess a
complex situation and whether it is capable of
substantiating the conclusions drawn therefrom.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(58) In order to deal with situations of
urgency, it is necessary to provide that the
lodging of any appeal does not result in
automatic suspension of the effects of the
challenged decision and that the decision of the
resolution authority is immediately enforceable
with a presumption that its suspension would be
against the public interest.
(59) It is necessary to protect third parties
that have acquired assets, rights and liabilities of
the institution under resolution in good faith by
virtue of the exercise of the resolution powers
by the authorities. It is equally necessary to
ensure the stability of the financial markets. A
right of appeal against a resolution decision
should therefore not affect any subsequent
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
administrative act or transaction concluded on
the basis of an annulled decision. In such cases,
remedies for a wrongful decision should be
limited to the award of compensation for the
damages suffered by the affected persons.
(60) Crisis management measures may be
required to be taken urgently due to serious
financial stability risks in the Member State
concerned and the Union. Any procedure under
national law relating to the application for ex-
ante judicial approval of a crisis management
measure and a court’s consideration of such an
application should therefore be swift. Member
States should ensure that the authority
concerned can take its decision immediately
after a court has given its approval. That
possibility should be without prejudice to the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
right of interested parties to make an application
to the court to set aside the decision. However,
such possibility should only be granted for a
limited period after the resolution authority has
taken the crisis management measure in order
not to unduly delay the application of the
resolution decision.
(61) Efficient resolution and the need to
avoid conflicts of jurisdiction require that no
normal insolvency proceedings for a failing
insurance or reinsurance undertaking be opened
or continued whilst a resolution authority is
exercising its resolution powers or applying
resolution tools, except at the initiative of, or
with the consent of, the resolution authority. It is
therefore necessary to lay down that certain
contractual obligations can be suspended for a
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
limited period to enable resolution authorities to
apply the resolution tools. That possibility
should not, however, apply to obligations in
relation to systems designated by a Member
State as referred to in Directive 98/26/EC of the
European Parliament and of the Council9,
including central counterparties. Directive
98/26/EC reduces the risk associated with
participation in payment and securities
settlement systems, in particular by reducing
disruption in the event of the insolvency of a
participant in such a system. It is necessary to
ensure that those protections continue to apply
in crisis situations and that appropriate certainty
for operators of payment and securities systems
and other market participants is maintained. A
9
Directive 98/26/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 19 May 1998 on settlement finality in payment and securities settlement systems (OJ L 166, 11.6.1998,
p. 45).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
crisis prevention measure or a crisis
management measure should therefore not, per
se, be deemed to constitute insolvency
proceedings within the meaning of Directive
98/26/EC, provided that the substantive
obligations under the contract concerned
continue to be performed.
(62) It is necessary to ensure that resolution
authorities, when transferring assets and
liabilities to a private sector purchaser or a
bridge undertaking, have an adequate period of
time to identify contracts that need to be
transferred. It should therefore be possible for
resolution authorities to restrict counterparties’
rights to close out, accelerate or otherwise
terminate financial contracts before the transfer
is made. Such restrictions should allow
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution authorities to obtain a true picture of
the balance sheet of the failing insurance or
reinsurance undertaking without the changes in
value and scope that an extensive exercise of
termination rights would entail, and should help
to avoid creating market instability. Interference
with the contractual rights of counterparties
should however be restricted to the minimum
extent necessary. Any restrictions on
termination rights imposed by resolution
authorities should therefore only apply in
relation to crisis management measures or
events directly linked to the application of such
measures. Rights to terminate arising from any
other default, including failure to pay or deliver
margin, should thus remain.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(63) It is necessary to preserve legitimate
capital market arrangements in the event of a
transfer of some, but not all, of the assets, rights
and liabilities of a failing insurance or
reinsurance undertaking. It is therefore
appropriate to lay down safeguards to prevent
the splitting of linked liabilities or linked rights
and contracts, including contracts with the same
counterparty covered by security arrangements,
title transfer financial collateral arrangements,
set-off arrangements, close out netting
agreements, and structured finance
arrangements. Where such safeguards apply,
resolution authorities should be bound to
transfer all linked contracts within a protected
arrangement, or leave them all with the residual
failing insurance or reinsurance undertaking.
Those safeguards should ensure that the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
regulatory capital treatment of exposures
covered by a netting agreement for the purposes
of Directive 2009/138/EC is not affected.
(64) In order to provide financial stability to
the insurance and reinsurance undertaking a
moratorium on surrender rights of policy
holders should be introduced. Such a
moratorium and the ensuing financial stability
for the undertaking concerned should provide
the resolution authorities with sufficient time to
valuate those undertakings and to assess which
resolution tools should be applied. Such a
moratorium should also ensure equal treatment
of policy holders, and thus avoid potential
adverse financial impacts on policy holders that
would not be among the first ones to surrender
their policy. Because one of the objectives of
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution is the continuation of insurance
cover, policy holders should continue to make
any obligatory payments under the insurance
contracts concerned, including in the case of
annuities.
(65) Ensuring that resolution authorities have
the same resolution tools and powers at their
disposal will facilitate coordinated action in the
event of a failure of a cross-border group.
Further action, however, is necessary to promote
cooperation and prevent fragmented national
responses. To agree to a group resolution
scheme when resolving group entities,
resolution authorities should therefore be
required to consult each other and cooperate in
resolution colleges. To provide for a forum for
discussion and reaching such agreement,
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution colleges should be established around
the core of the existing supervisory colleges
through the inclusion of resolution authorities
and the involvement of competent ministries,
EIOPA and, where appropriate, authorities
responsible for the insurance guarantee
schemes. Resolution colleges should not be
decision-making bodies, but platforms
facilitating decision-making by national
authorities, while it should be for the national
authorities concerned to take the joint decisions.
(66) Resolution of cross-border groups
should strike a balance between, on the one
hand, the need for procedures that take into
account the criticality of the situation and allow
for efficient, fair and timely solutions for the
group as a whole and, on the other hand, the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
necessity to protect policy holders, the real
economy and financial stability in all the
Member States where the group operates. The
different resolution authorities should therefore
share their views in the resolution college and
any resolution actions proposed by the group
resolution authority should be prepared and
discussed amongst different resolution
authorities in the context of the group resolution
plans. In order to facilitate swift and joint
decisions wherever possible, resolution colleges
should also take into account the views of the
resolution authorities of all the Member States
in which the group is active.
(67) Resolution actions by the group
resolution authority should always take into
account their impact on policy holders, the real
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
economy and financial stability in the Member
States where the group operates. Resolution
authorities of the Member State in which a
subsidiary undertaking is established should
therefore have the possibility to object, as a last
resort and in duly justified cases, to the
decisions of the group resolution authority
where those resolution authorities are of the
opinion that the resolution actions and measures
are not appropriate, either because of the need to
protect policy holders, the real economy and
financial stability in that Member State, or
because of obligations that comparable
undertakings in that Member States are subject
to.
(68) Group resolution schemes should
facilitate coordinated resolution, which is more
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
likely to deliver the best result for all
undertakings of a group. Group resolution
authorities should therefore propose group
resolution schemes and submit those schemes to
the resolution college. Resolution authorities
that disagree with a group resolution scheme or
decide to take independent resolution action
should explain to the group resolution authority
and other resolution authorities covered by the
group resolution scheme the reasons for their
disagreement and notify those reasons, together
with details of any independent resolution action
they intend to take. Any resolution authority that
decides to depart from the group resolution
scheme should duly consider the potential
impact of such departure on policy holders, the
real economy and financial stability in the
Member States where the other resolution
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
authorities are located and the potential effects
of such departure on other parts of the group.
(69) To ensure coordinated action at group
level, resolution authorities should be invited to
apply, within a group resolution scheme, the
same tool to entities belonging to the group that
meet the conditions for resolution. Group
resolution authorities should thus have the
power to apply the bridge undertaking tool at
group level to stabilise a group as a whole and
to transfer ownership of subsidiaries to the
bridge undertaking with a view to the onward
sale of such subsidiaries, either as a package or
individually, when market conditions are
appropriate. In addition, the group-level
resolution authority should have the power to
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
apply the write-down or conversion tool at
parent level.
(70) Effective resolution of internationally
active insurance and reinsurance undertakings
and groups requires cooperation between
Member States and third-country resolution
authorities. For that purpose, where it is justified
by the situation at hand, EIOPA should be
empowered to develop and enter into non-
binding framework cooperation arrangements
with authorities of third countries in accordance
with Article 33 of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010. For the same reason, national
authorities should be permitted to conclude
bilateral arrangements with third country
authorities in line with EIOPA’s framework
cooperation agreements. The development of
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
such bilateral arrangements should ensure
effective planning, decision-making and
coordination in respect of such internationally
active insurance and reinsurance undertakings.
In order to create a level playing field, such
bilateral arrangements should be reciprocal,
with resolution authorities recognising and
enforcing each other’s proceedings, unless any
exception that allows for rejection of
recognition of third country resolution
proceedings applies.
(71) Cooperation between resolution
authorities should take place both with regard to
subsidiaries of Union or third-country groups as
with regard to branches of Union or third-
country insurance and reinsurance undertakings.
Subsidiaries of third-country groups are
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertakings established in the Union and are
therefore fully subject to Union law, including
the application of any resolution tools. It is
necessary, however, that Member States retain
the right to act in relation to branches of
insurance and reinsurance undertakings having
their head office in third countries, where the
recognition and application of third-country
resolution proceedings relating to a branch
would endanger the real economy or financial
stability in the Union, or where Union policy
holders would not receive equal treatment with
third-country policy holders. In those
circumstances, Member States should have the
right, after having consulted their resolution
authorities, to refuse recognition of third-
country resolution proceedings.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(72) EIOPA should promote convergence of
the practices of resolution authorities through
guidelines that are issued in accordance with
Article 16 of Regulation (EU) No 1094/2010.
More in particular, EIOPA should specify all of
the following: (a) the application of simplified
obligations for certain undertakings; (b) the
methods to be used when determining the
market shares and the criteria for the scope of
pre-emptive recovery planning; (c) a minimum
list of qualitative and quantitative indicators and
a range of scenarios for pre-emptive recovery
plans; (d) the criteria for the identification of
critical functions; (e) the details on the measures
to address or remove impediments to
resolvability and the circumstances in which
each measure may be applied; and (f) how
information should be provided in summary or
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
collective form for the purpose of
confidentiality requirements.
(73) Technical standards in financial services
should facilitate consistent harmonisation and
adequate protection of policy holders, investors
and consumers across the Union. As a body
with highly specialised expertise, it would be
efficient and appropriate, to entrust EIOPA with
the development of draft regulatory and
implementing technical standards which do not
involve policy choices, for submission to the
Commission.
(74) The Commission should, where
provided for in this Directive, adopt draft
regulatory technical standards developed by
EIOPA by means of delegated acts pursuant to
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 290 TFEU, in accordance with Articles
10 to 14 of Regulation (EU) No 1094/2010 to
specify the following elements: (a) the
information to be contained in the pre-emptive
recovery plans; (b) the content of resolution
plans and the content of group resolution plans;
(c) the matters and criteria for the assessment
for resolvability; (d) different elements on
valuation, including the methodology for
calculating the buffer for additional losses to be
included in provisional valuations and the
methodology for carrying out the valuation of
difference in treatment; (e) the contents of the
contractual term to be included in financial
contract governed by third-country law; (f) the
operational functioning of resolution colleges.
The Commission should, where provided for in
this Directive, adopt draft implementing
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
technical standards developed by EIOPA by
means of implementing acts pursuant to Article
291 TFEU, in accordance with Article 15 of
Regulation (EU) No 1094/2010 to specify the
procedures, content and minimum set of
standard forms and templates for the provision
of information for the purpose of resolution
plans and cooperation from the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking.
(75) Directive 2009/138/EC provides for the
mutual recognition and enforcement in all
Member States of decisions concerning the
reorganisation or winding up of insurance
undertakings. That Directive ensures that all
assets and liabilities of the undertaking,
regardless of the country in which they are
situated, are dealt with in a single process in the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
home Member State and that creditors in the
host Member States are treated in the same way
as creditors in the home Member State. In order
to achieve an effective resolution, the provisions
on reorganisation and winding-up laid down in
Directive 2009/138/EC should apply in the
event of use of the resolution tools, both where
those instruments are applied to insurance and
reinsurance undertakings and where they are
applied to other entities covered by the
resolution regime. Those provisions should
therefore be amended accordingly.
(76) Directive 2004/25/EC of the European
Parliament and of the Council10, Directive
2007/36/EC of the European Parliament and of
10
Directive 2004/25/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 21 April 2004 on takeover bids, (OJ L 142, 30.4.2004, p. 12).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the Council11 and Directive (EU) 2017/1132 of
the European Parliament and of the Council12,
contain rules on the protection of shareholders
and creditors of undertakings that fall within the
scope of those Directives. In a situation where
resolution authorities need to act rapidly, those
rules might hinder effective resolution action
and application of resolution tools and powers
by resolution authorities. Derogations under
Directive 2014/59/EU of the European
Parliament and of the Council13 and Regulation
(EU) 2021/23 of the European Parliament and
11
Directive 2007/36/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 11 July 2007 on the exercise of certain rights of shareholders in listed companies (OJ L 184, 14.7.2007,
p. 17).
12
Directive (EU) 2017/1132 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 June 2017 relating to certain aspects of company law (OJ L 169, 30.6.2017, p. 46).
13
Directive 2014/59/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 15 May 2014 establishing a framework for the recovery and resolution of credit institutions and
investment firms and amending Council Directive 82/891/EEC, and Directives 2001/24/EC, 2002/47/EC, 2004/25/EC, 2005/56/EC, 2007/36/EC, 2011/35/EU, 2012/30/EU
and 2013/36/EU, and Regulations (EU) No 1093/2010 and (EU) No 648/2012, of the European Parliament and of the Council (OJ L 173, 12.6.2014, p. 190).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
of the Council14 should therefore be extended to
actions taken in the context of the resolution of
insurance and reinsurance undertakings. In order
to guarantee the maximum degree of legal
certainty for stakeholders, such derogations
should be set out clearly, should be narrow, and
should only be used in the public interest and
when resolution triggers are met.
(77) To provide adequate information sharing
and access to all concerned authorities, it is
necessary to ensure that resolution authorities
are represented in all relevant fora and that
EIOPA benefits from the expertise necessary to
carry out the tasks related to the recovery and
resolution of insurance and reinsurance
14
Regulation (EU) 2021/23 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 December 2020 on a framework for the recovery and resolution of central counterparties and
amending Regulations (EU) No 1095/2010, (EU) No 648/2012, (EU) No 600/2014, (EU) No 806/2014 and (EU) 2015/2365 and Directives 2002/47/EC, 2004/25/EC,
2007/36/EC, 2014/59/EU and (EU) 2017/1132 (OJ L 22, 22.1.2021, p. 1).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertakings. Therefore, Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010 should be amended to designate
resolution authorities as competent authorities
as referred to in that Regulation. Such
assimilation between resolution authorities and
competent authorities is consistent with the
functions attributed to EIOPA pursuant to
Article 25 of Regulation (EU) No 1094/2010 to
contribute and participate actively in the
development and coordination of recovery and
resolution plans.
(78) It is necessary ensure that insurance and
reinsurance undertakings, those who effectively
control their business, and their administrative,
management or supervisory body comply with
their obligations in relation to the resolution of
such undertakings. It is equally necessary to
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
ensure that those undertakings, those who
effectively control their business, and their
administrative, management or supervisory
body are subject to similar treatment across the
Union. Member States should therefore be
required to provide for administrative sanctions
and other administrative measures which are
effective, proportionate and dissuasive. Such
administrative sanctions and other
administrative measures should satisfy certain
essential requirements in relation to addressees,
criteria to be taken into account when applying
an administrative sanction or other
administrative measure, publication of
administrative sanctions or other administrative
measures, key penalising powers and levels of
administrative fines. Subject to strict
professional secrecy, EIOPA should maintain a
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
central database of all administrative sanctions
or other administrative measures and
information on the appeals reported to it by
supervisory authorities and resolution
authorities.
(79) Member States should not be required to
lay down rules for administrative sanctions or
other administrative measures for infringements
of this Directive which are subject to national
criminal law. However, the maintenance of
criminal sanctions rather than administrative
sanctions or other administrative measures for
infringements should not reduce or otherwise
affect the ability of resolution authorities and
supervisory authorities to cooperate, access and
exchange information in a timely manner with
resolution authorities and supervisory
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
authorities in other Member States, including
after any referral of the infringements concerned
to the competent judicial authorities for
prosecution.
(80) Since the objective of this Directive,
namely the harmonisation of the rules and
processes for the resolution of insurance and
reinsurance undertakings, cannot be sufficiently
achieved by the Member States, but can rather,
by reason of the effects of a failure of any
undertaking in the whole Union, be better
achieved at Union level, the Union may adopt
measures, in accordance with the principle of
subsidiarity as set out in Article 5 of the Treaty
on European Union. In accordance with the
principle of proportionality, as set out in that
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article, this Directive does not go beyond what
is necessary in order to achieve that objective.
(81) When taking decisions or actions under
this Directive, supervisory authorities and
resolution authorities should always have due
regard to the impact of their decisions and
actions on policy holders, the real economy and
financial stability in other Member States and
should give consideration to the significance of
any subsidiary undertaking or of cross-border
activities for policy holders, the financial sector
and the economy of the Member State where
such a subsidiary undertaking is established or
the activities are carried out, even in cases
where the subsidiary undertaking or the cross-
border activities concerned are of lesser
importance for the group.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
HAVE ADOPTED THIS DIRECTIVE:
TITLE I
SUBJECT MATTER AND SCOPE,
DEFINITIONS AND DESIGNATION OF
RESOLUTION AUTHORITIES
Article 1
Subject matter and scope
1. This Directive lays down rules and
procedures for the recovery and resolution of
the following entities:
(a) insurance and reinsurance undertakings
that are established in the Union and fall within
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the scope of Article 2 of Directive
2009/138/EC;
(b) parent insurance and reinsurance
undertakings established in the Union;
(c) insurance holding companies and mixed
financial holding companies that are established
in the Union;
(d) parent insurance holding companies and
parent mixed financial holding companies
established in a Member State;
(e) Union parent insurance holding
companies and Union parent mixed financial
holding companies;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(f) branches of insurance and reinsurance
undertakings that are established outside the
Union and that fulfil the conditions laid down in
Articles 72 to 77.
Resolution authorities and supervisory
authorities shall, when establishing and applying
the requirements laid down in this Directive and
when using the different tools at their disposal
in relation to an entity referred to in the first
subparagraph, take account of the nature of the
business of that entity, its shareholding
structure, legal form, risk profile, size, legal
status, interconnectedness to other institutions or
to the financial system in general, and the scope
and complexity of the entity’s activities.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. Member States may adopt or maintain
rules that are stricter or additional to those laid
down in this Directive and in the delegated and
implementing acts adopted on the basis of this
Directive, provided that those rule are of general
application and do not conflict with this
Directive and with the delegated and
implementing acts adopted on its basis.
Article 2
Definitions
1. For the purposes of this Directive, the
definitions laid down in Article 212, points (a)
to (d) and (f) to (h), of Directive 2009/138/EC
shall apply.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. For the purposes of this Directive, the
following definitions shall apply:
(1) ‘resolution’ means the application of a
resolution tool or a tool referred to in Article
26(3) to achieve one or more of the resolution
objectives referred to in Article 18(2);
(2) ‘parent insurance holding company in a
Member State’ means an insurance holding
company as defined in Article 212(1), point (f),
of Directive 2009/138/EC which is established
in a Member State and which is not a subsidiary
undertaking of an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking, insurance holding company or
mixed financial holding company authorised or
set up in the same Member State;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(3) ‘Union parent insurance holding
company’ means a parent insurance holding
company in a Member State which is not a
subsidiary undertaking of an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking, another insurance
holding company or mixed financial holding
company authorised or set up in any Member
State;
(4) ‘parent mixed financial holding
company in a Member State’ means a mixed
financial holding company as defined in Article
212(1), point (h), of Directive 2009/138/EC
which is established in a Member State, which
is not itself a subsidiary undertaking of an
insurance or reinsurance undertaking, an
insurance holding company or mixed financial
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
holding company authorised or set up in that
same Member State;
(5) ‘Union parent mixed financial holding
company’ means a parent mixed financial
holding company in a Member State that is not a
subsidiary undertaking of an undertaking
authorised in any Member State or of another
insurance holding company or mixed financial
holding company set up in any Member State;
(6) ‘resolution objectives’ means the
resolution objectives referred to in Article 18(2);
(7) ‘resolution authority’ means an authority
designated by a Member State in accordance
with Article 3;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(8) ‘supervisory authority’ means a
supervisory authority as defined in Article 13,
point (10), of Directive 2009/138/EC;
(9) ‘resolution tool’ means a resolution tool
referred to in Article 26(3);
(10) ‘resolution power’ means a power
referred to in Articles 40 to 52;
(11) ‘competent ministries’ means finance
ministries or other ministries of the Member
States which are responsible for economic,
financial and budgetary decisions at the national
level in accordance with national competencies
and which have been designated pursuant to
Article 3(7);
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(12) ‘senior management’ means those
natural persons who exercise executive
functions within an undertaking and who are
responsible, and accountable to the
administrative, management or supervisory
body, for the day-to-day management of the
undertaking;
(13) ‘cross-border group’ means a group
having group entities established in more than
one Member State;
(14) ‘extraordinary public financial support’
means State aid within the meaning of Article
107(1) TFEU, or any other public financial
support at supra-national level, which, if
provided for at national level, would constitute
State aid that is provided to preserve or restore
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the viability, liquidity or solvency of an
insurance or reinsurance undertaking or entity
referred to in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), or of
a group of which such an undertaking or entity
forms part;
(15) ‘group entity’ means a legal person that
is part of a group;
(16) ‘pre-emptive recovery plan’ means a
pre-emptive recovery plan drawn up and
maintained by an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking in accordance with Article 5;
(17) ‘group pre-emptive recovery plan’
means a group pre-emptive recovery plan drawn
up and maintained in accordance with Article 7;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(18) ‘significant cross-border activities’
means insurance and reinsurance activities
carried out under the right of establishment and
those carried out under the freedom to provide
services in a given host Member State for which
the annual gross written premium exceeds 5 %
of the annual gross written premium of the
undertaking, measured with reference to the last
available financial statement of the undertaking;
(19) ‘critical functions’ means activities,
services or operations performed by an
insurance or reinsurance undertaking for third
parties that cannot be substituted within a
reasonable time or at a reasonable cost, and
where the inability of the insurance and
reinsurance undertaking to perform the
activities, services or operations would be likely
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
to have a significant impact on the financial
system and the real economy in one or more
Member States, including by affecting the social
welfare of a large number of policy holders,
beneficiaries or injured parties or by giving rise
to systemic disruption or by undermining
general confidence in the provision of insurance
services;
(20) ‘core business lines’ means business
lines and associated services which represent
material sources of revenue, profit or franchise
value for an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking or for a group of which an
insurance or reinsurance undertaking forms part;
(21) ‘financing arrangement’ means an
arrangement officially recognised by a Member
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
State providing financing through contributions
from insurance and reinsurance undertakings in
the territory of that Member State to ensure the
effective application by the resolution authority
of the resolution tools referred to in Article
26(3) and the powers referred to in Articles 40
to 52;
(22) ‘own funds’ means own funds as defined
in Article 87 of Directive 2009/138/EC;
(23) ‘resolution action’ means the decision to
place an insurance or reinsurance undertaking or
an entity as referred to in Article 1(1), points (b)
to (e), under resolution pursuant to Article 19 or
20, the application of a resolution tool as
referred to in Article 26(3), or the exercise of
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
one or more resolution powers as referred to in
Articles 40 to 52;
(24) ‘resolution plan’ means a resolution plan
for an insurance or reinsurance undertaking
drawn up in accordance with Article 9;
(25) ‘group resolution’ means either of the
following:
(a) the taking of resolution action at the
level of a parent undertaking or of an insurance
or reinsurance undertaking subject to group
supervision, or
(b) the coordination of the application of the
resolution tools referred to in Article 26(3) and
the exercise of the resolution powers referred to
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
in Articles 40 to 52 by resolution authorities in
relation to group entities that meet the
conditions for resolution referred to in Article
19(1) or Article 20(3);
(26) ‘group resolution plan’ means a plan for
group resolution drawn up in accordance with
Articles 10 and 11;
(27) ‘group resolution authority’ means the
resolution authority in the Member State in
which the group supervisor is situated;
(28) ‘group resolution scheme’ means a plan
drawn up for the purposes of group resolution in
accordance with Article 70;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(29) ‘resolution college’ means a college
established in accordance with Article 68 to
carry out the tasks referred to in paragraph 1 of
that Article;
(30) ‘normal insolvency proceedings’ means
collective insolvency proceedings which entail
the partial or total divestment of a debtor and
the appointment of a liquidator or an
administrator normally applicable to insurance
and reinsurance undertakings under national law
and either specific to those undertakings or
generally applicable to any natural or legal
person;
(31) ‘debt instruments’ means bonds and
other forms of transferrable debt, instruments
creating or acknowledging a debt, and
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
instruments giving rights to acquire debt
instruments;
(32) ‘insurance claims’ means insurance
claims as defined in Article 268(1), point (g), of
Directive 2009/138/EC;
(33) ‘parent undertaking in a Member State’
means a parent undertaking as defined in Article
13, point (15), of Directive 2009/138/EC
established in a Member State;
(34) ‘college of supervisors’ means a college
of supervisors as defined in Article 212(1) point
(e), of Directive 2009/138/EC and established in
accordance with Article 248 of Directive
2009/138/EC;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(35) ‘Union State aid framework’ means the
framework established by Articles 107, 108 and
109 TFEU and regulations and all Union acts,
including guidelines, communications and
notices, made or adopted pursuant to Article
108(4) or Article 109 TFEU;
(36) ‘winding-up’ means the realisation of
assets of an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking or entity referred to in Article 1(1),
points (b) to (e);
(37) ‘asset and liability separation tool’
means the mechanism for effecting a transfer by
a resolution authority of assets, rights or
liabilities of an undertaking under resolution to
an asset and liability management vehicle in
accordance with Article 30;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(38) ‘asset and liability management vehicle’
means a legal person that meets the
requirements laid down in Article 30(2);
(39) ‘write-down or conversion tool’ means
the mechanism for effecting the exercise by a
resolution authority of the write-down or
conversion powers in relation to liabilities of an
undertaking under resolution in accordance with
Article 34;
(40) ‘sale of business tool’ means the
mechanism for effecting a transfer by a
resolution authority of shares or other
instruments of ownership issued by an
undertaking under resolution, or assets, rights or
liabilities, of an undertaking under resolution to
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
a purchaser that is not a bridge undertaking, in
accordance with Article 31;
(41) ‘bridge undertaking’ means a legal
person that meets the requirements laid down in
Article 32(2);
(42) ‘bridge undertaking tool’ means the
mechanism for transferring shares or other
instruments of ownership issued by an
undertaking under resolution or assets, rights or
liabilities of an undertaking under resolution to
a bridge undertaking, in accordance with Article
32;
(43) ‘solvent run-off tool’ means the
mechanism for withdrawing the authorisation of
an undertaking under resolution to conclude
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
new insurance or reinsurance contracts and for
limiting its activity to the exclusive
administration of its existing portfolio until its
termination and liquidation under normal
insolvency proceedings in accordance with
Article 27;
(44) ‘instruments of ownership’ means
shares, other instruments that confer ownership,
instruments that are convertible into or give the
right to acquire shares or other instruments of
ownership, and instruments representing
interests in shares or other instruments of
ownership;
(45) ‘shareholders’ means shareholders or
holders of other instruments of ownership;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(46) ‘transfer powers’ means the powers
specified in Article 40(1), points (d) or (e), to
transfer shares, other instruments of ownership,
debt instruments, assets, rights or liabilities, or
any combination of those items from an
undertaking under resolution to a recipient;
(47) CCP a CCP as defined in Article 2, point
(1), of Regulation (EU) No 648/201215;
(48) ‘write-down or conversion powers’
means the powers referred to in Article 34(2)
and in Article 40(1), points (f) to (j);
(49) ‘secured liability’ means a liability
where the right of the creditor to payment or
15
Regulation (EU) No 648/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 4 July 2012 on OTC derivatives, central counterparties and trade repositories, OJ L 201,
27.7.2012, p. 1.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
other form of performance is secured by a
charge, pledge or lien, or collateral
arrangements including liabilities arising from
repurchase transactions and other title transfer
collateral arrangements;
(50) ‘Tier 1 instruments’ means basic own-
fund items that meet the conditions laid down in
Article 94(1) of Directive 2009/138/EC;
(51) ‘Tier 2 instruments’ means basic and
ancillary own-fund items that meet the
conditions laid down in Article 94(2) of
Directive 2009/38/EC;
(52) ‘Tier 3 instruments’ means basic and
ancillary own-fund items that meet the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
conditions laid down in Article 94(3) of
Directive 2009/38/EC;
(53) ‘eligible liabilities’ means the liabilities
and capital instruments that do not qualify as
Tier 1, Tier 2 or Tier 3 instruments of an
insurance and reinsurance undertaking or entity
referred to in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), and
that are not excluded from the scope of the
write-down or conversion tool pursuant to
Article 34, paragraphs 5 or 6;
(54) ‘insurance guarantee scheme’ means a
scheme officially recognised by a Member State
and financed through contributions from
insurance and reinsurance undertakings
guaranteeing the payment of eligible insurance
claims, in part or in full, to eligible policy
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
holders, insured parties and beneficiaries where
an insurance undertaking is unable or likely to
become unable to fulfil its obligations and
commitments resulting from its insurance
contracts;
(55) ‘relevant capital instruments’ means Tier
1, Tier 2 and Tier 3 instruments;
(56) ‘conversion rate’ means the factor that
determines the number of shares or other
instruments of ownership into which a liability
of a specific class will be converted, by
reference either to a single instrument of the
class in question or to a specified unit of value
of a debt claim;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(57) ‘affected creditor’ means a creditor
whose claim relates to a liability that is reduced
or converted to shares or other instruments of
ownership by the exercise of the write-down or
conversion power pursuant to the use of the
write-down or conversion tool;
(58) ‘recipient’ means the entity to which
shares, other instruments of ownership, debt
instruments, assets, rights or liabilities, or any
combination of those items are transferred from
an undertaking under resolution;
(59) ‘business day’ means a day other than a
Saturday, a Sunday or a public holiday in the
Member State concerned;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(60) ‘termination right’ means a right to
terminate a contract, a right to accelerate, close
out, set-off or net obligations or any similar
provision that suspends, modifies or
extinguishes an obligation of a party to the
contract or a provision that prevents an
obligation under the contract from arising that
would otherwise arise;
(61) ‘undertaking under resolution’ means
any of the entities referred to in Article 1, points
(a) to (e), in respect of which a resolution action
is taken;
(62) ‘Union subsidiary undertaking’ means
an insurance or reinsurance undertaking which
has its head office in a Member State and which
is a subsidiary undertaking of a third-country
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
insurance or reinsurance undertaking or a third-
country parent undertaking;
(63) ‘ultimate parent undertaking’ means a
parent undertaking in a Member State of a group
which is subject to group supervision in
accordance with Article 213(2), points (a) or
(b), of Directive 2009/138/EC, which is not a
subsidiary undertaking of another insurance or
reinsurance undertaking, an insurance holding
company or a mixed financial holding company
that is authorised and set up in any Member
State;
(64) ‘third-country insurance or reinsurance
undertaking’ means a third-country insurance
undertaking or a third-country reinsurance
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertaking as defined in Article 13, points (3)
and (6), of Directive 2009/138/EC;
(65) ‘third-country resolution proceedings’
means an action under the law of a third country
to manage the failure of a third-country
insurance or reinsurance undertaking or a third-
country parent undertaking that is comparable,
in terms of objectives and anticipated results, to
resolution actions under this Directive;
(66) ‘Union branch’ means a branch located
in a Member State of a third-country insurance
or reinsurance undertaking;
(67) ‘relevant third-country authority’ means
a third-country authority responsible for
carrying out functions comparable to those of
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution authorities or supervisory authorities
pursuant to this Directive;
(68) ‘title transfer financial collateral
arrangement’ means a title transfer financial
collateral arrangement as defined in Article
2(1), point (b), of Directive 2002/47/EC of the
European Parliament and of the Council16;
(69) ‘netting arrangement’ means an
arrangement under which a number of claims or
obligations can be converted into a single net
claim, including close-out netting arrangements
under which, on the occurrence of an
enforcement event (however or wherever
defined) the obligations of the parties are
accelerated so as to become immediately due or
16
Directive 2002/47/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 6 June 2002 on financial collateral arrangements (OJ L 168, 27.6.2002, p. 43).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
are terminated, and in either case are converted
into or replaced by a single net claim, including
‘close-out netting provisions’ as defined in
Article 2(1), point (n)(i), of Directive
2002/47/EC and ‘netting’ as defined in Article
2, point (k), of Directive 98/26/EC;
(70) ‘set-off arrangement’ means an
arrangement under which two or more claims or
obligations owed between the undertaking under
resolution and a counterparty can be set off
against each other;
(71) ‘financial contracts’ means financial
contracts as defined in Article 1(1), point (100),
of Directive 2014/59/EU;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(72) ‘crisis prevention measure’ means the
exercise of powers to direct the removal of
deficiencies or impediments to recoverability
under Article 6(5) of this Directive, the exercise
of powers to address or remove impediments to
resolvability under Article 15 or 16 of this
Directive, the application of any measures under
Article 137, Article 138, paragraphs 3 and 5,
Article 139(3) and Article 140 of Directive
2009/138/EC and the application of a preventive
measure under Article 141 of Directive
2009/138/EC;
(73) ‘crisis management measure’ means a
resolution action, the appointment of a special
manager under Article 42 or the appointment of
a person under Article 52(1);
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(74) ‘designated national macroprudential
authority’ means the authority entrusted with the
conduct of macroprudential policy referred to in
Recommendation B1 of the Recommendation of
the European Systemic Risk Board of 22
December 2011 on the macroprudential
mandate of national authorities (ESRB/2011/3);
(75) ‘regulated market’ means a regulated
market as defined in Article 4(1), point (21), of
Directive 2014/65/EU of the European
Parliament and of the Council17.
(76) ‘insurance undertaking’ means an
insurance undertaking as defined in Article 13,
point (1), of Directive 2009/138/EC;
17
Directive 2014/65/EU of the European Parliament and of the Council of 15 May 2014 on markets in financial instruments and amending Directive 2002/92/EC and Directive
2011/61/EU (OJ L 173, 12.6.2014, p. 349).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(77) ‘reinsurance undertaking’ means
reinsurance undertaking as defined in Article
13, point (4), of Directive 2009/138/EC;
(78) ‘credit institution’ means a credit
institution as defined in Article 4(1), point (1),
of Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 of the
European Parliament and of the Council18;
(79) ‘investment firm’ means an investment
firm as defined in Article 4(1), point (2), of
Regulation (EU) No 575/2013;
(80) ‘low risk profile undertaking’ means a
low risk profile undertaking as defined in
18
Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 26 June 2013 on prudential requirements for credit institutions and investment firms and
amending Regulation (EU) No 648/2012 (OJ L 176, 27.6.2013, p. 1).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 13, point (10a), of Directive
2009/138/EC;
(81) ‘subsidiary undertaking’ means a
‘subsidiary undertaking’ as defined in Article
13, point (16), of Directive 2009/138/EC;
(82) ‘parent undertaking’ means a parent
undertaking as defined Article 13, point (15), of
Directive 2009/138/EC;
(83) ‘branch’ means a branch as defined in
Article 13, point (11), of Directive
2009/138/EC;
(84) ‘administrative, management or
supervisory body’ means an administrative,
management or supervisory body as defined in
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 1, point (43), of Commission Delegated
Regulation (EU) 2015/3519.
Article 3
Designation of resolution authorities and
competent ministries
1. Each Member State shall designate one
or, exceptionally, more resolution authorities
that are empowered to apply the resolution tools
and exercise the resolution powers.
2. Resolution authorities shall be national
central banks, competent ministries, public
19
Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2015/35 of 10 October 2014 supplementing Directive 2009/138/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council on the taking-up
and pursuit of the business of Insurance and Reinsurance (Solvency II), (OJ L 012 17.1.2015, p. 1).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
administrative authorities or authorities
entrusted with public administrative powers.
3. Where a resolution authority is entrusted
with other functions, adequate structural
arrangements shall be in place to avoid conflicts
of interest between the functions entrusted to the
resolution authority pursuant to this Directive
and all other functions entrusted to that
authority, without prejudice to the exchange of
information and cooperation obligations
required by paragraph 6.
In order to achieve the goals referred to in
subparagraph 1, arrangements shall be put in
place to ensure effective operational
independence, including separate staff, reporting
lines and decision making processes of the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution authority from any supervisory or
other functions of that resolution authority.
4. The requirements laid down in
paragraph 3 shall not preclude that:
(a) reporting lines converge at the highest
level of an organisation that subsumes different
functions or authorities;
(b) staff may, under predefined conditions,
be shared between the other functions entrusted
to the resolution authority to meet temporarily
high workloads, or for the resolution authority
to be able to avail itself of the expertise of
shared staff.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
5. Resolution authorities shall adopt and
make public the internal rules they have in place
to ensure compliance with the requirements set
out in paragraphs 3 and 4, including rules
regarding professional secrecy and information
exchanges between the different functional
areas.
6. Member States shall require that
authorities exercising supervision and resolution
functions and persons exercising those functions
on their behalf cooperate closely in the
preparation, planning and application of
resolution decisions, both where the resolution
authority and the supervisory authority are
separate entities and where the functions are
carried out in the same entity.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
7. Each Member State shall designate a
single ministry which is responsible for
exercising the functions entrusted to the
competent ministry under this Directive.
8. Where the resolution authority in a
Member State is not the competent ministry, the
resolution authority shall inform the competent
ministry of the decisions taken pursuant to this
Directive without undue delay and, unless
otherwise laid down in national law, not
implement any decisions that have a direct fiscal
impact without having obtained the approval of
that competent ministry.
9. A Member State that designates more
than one resolution authority shall provide
EIOPA with a fully reasoned notification for
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
doing so and shall clearly allocate functions and
responsibilities between those authorities,
ensure adequate coordination between them and
designate a single authority as a contact
authority for the purposes of cooperation and
coordination with the relevant authorities of
other Member States.
10. Member States shall inform EIOPA of
the national authority or authorities designated
as resolution authorities and, where relevant, the
contact authority and, where relevant, their
specific functions and responsibilities. EIOPA
shall publish the list of those resolution
authorities and contact authorities.
11. Without prejudice to Article 65, Member
States may limit the liability of the resolution
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
authority, the supervisory authority and their
respective staff in accordance with national law
for their acts and omissions in the course of
discharging their functions under this Directive.
TITLE II
PREPARATION
CHAPTER I
Pre-emptive recovery and resolution planning
Section 1
General provisions
Article 4
Simplified obligations for certain
undertakings
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
1. Taking into account the impact that the
failure of the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking could have, due to the nature of its
business, its shareholding structure, its legal
form, its risk profile, size and legal status, its
interconnectedness to other regulated
undertakings or to the financial system in
general, the scope and the complexity of its
activities, and whether its failure and subsequent
winding up under normal insolvency
proceedings would be likely to have a
significant negative effect on financial markets,
on other undertakings, on policy holders, on
funding conditions, or on the wider economy,
supervisory and resolution authorities shall
determine whether simplified obligations can
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
apply for certain insurance and reinsurance
undertakings and groups with respect to:
(a) the contents and details of pre-emptive
recovery and resolution plans provided for in
Articles 5 to 7;
(b) the date by which the first pre-emptive
recovery and resolution plans are to be drawn up
and the frequency for updating recovery and
resolution plans, which may be lower than the
frequency provided for in Article 5(4), Article
7(5), Article 9(5) and Article 11(3);
(c) the content and level of detail of the
information required from undertakings
pursuant to Article 5(6), Article 10(2) and
Article 12(1);
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(d) the level of detail for the assessment of
resolvability provided for in Articles 13 and 14.
2. EIOPA shall, by [PO – add 18 months
after entry into force], issue guidelines in
accordance with Article 16 of Regulation (EU)
No 1094/2010 to specify the eligibility criteria
referred to in paragraph 1.
3. Member States shall require the
supervisory authorities or the resolution
authorities, as applicable, to provide EIOPA, on
an annual basis and for each Member State
separately, with all of the following
information:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) the number of insurance and reinsurance
undertakings and groups subject to pre-emptive
recovery planning and resolution planning
pursuant to Articles 5, 7, 9 and 10;
(b) the number of insurance and reinsurance
undertakings and groups benefitting from
simplified obligations referred to in paragraph 1
of this Article;
(c) quantitative information on the
application of the criteria referred to in
paragraph 1;
(d) a description of the simplified
obligations applied on the basis of the criteria
referred to in paragraph 1 as compared to the
full obligations, together with the volume of
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
capital requirements, premiums, technical
provisions and assets, respectively measured as
percentages of the total volume of capital
requirements, premiums, technical provisions
and assets of the insurance and reinsurance
undertakings of the Member States or of all the
groups, as applicable.
4. EIOPA shall publicly disclose, on an
annual basis and for each Member State
separately, all of the following information:
(a) the number of insurance and reinsurance
undertakings and groups subject to pre-emptive
recovery planning and resolution planning
pursuant to Articles 5, 7, 9 and 10;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the number of insurance and reinsurance
undertakings and groups benefitting from
simplified obligations referred to in paragraph 1
of this Article;
(c) quantitative information on the
application of the criteria referred to in
paragraph 1 of this Article;
(d) a description of the simplified
obligations applied on the basis of the eligibility
criteria referred to in paragraph 1 as compared
to the full obligations, together with the volume
of capital requirements, premiums, technical
provisions and assets, respectively measured as
percentages of the total volume of capital
requirements, premiums, technical provisions
and assets of the insurance and reinsurance
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertakings of the Member States or of all the
groups, as applicable;
(e) and an assessment of any divergences
regarding the implementation of paragraph 1 of
this Article at national level.
Section 2
Pre-emptive recovery planning
Article 5
Pre-emptive recovery plans
1. Member States shall ensure that
insurance and reinsurance undertakings that are
not part of a group subject to pre-emptive
recovery planning pursuant to Article 7 and that
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
meet the criteria laid down in paragraphs 2 or 3,
draw up and keep updated a pre-emptive
recovery plan. Such pre-emptive recovery plan
shall contain measures to be taken by the
undertaking concerned to restore its financial
position where that position has significantly
deteriorated.
The drawing up, the keeping up-to-date and
application of pre-emptive recovery plans shall
be considered to be part of the system of
governance within the meaning of Article 41 of
Directive 2009/138/EC.
2. The supervisory authority shall subject
insurance and reinsurance undertakings to pre-
emptive recovery planning requirements on the
basis of their size, business model, risk profile,
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
interconnectedness, substitutability and, in
particular, cross-border activity.
Supervisory authorities shall ensure that at least
80% of the Member State’s life and non-life and
reinsurance market respectively, where the non-
life market share is based on gross written
premiums and the life market share is based on
gross technical provisions, shall be subject to
pre-emptive recovery planning requirements
pursuant to this Article.
In the calculation of the market coverage level
referred to in subparagraph 2, the subsidiary
insurance or reinsurance undertakings of a
group may be taken into account where those
subsidiary insurance or reinsurance
undertakings are part of a group for which the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
ultimate parent undertaking is drawing up and
maintaining a group pre-emptive recovery plan
referred to in Article 7.
3. Any insurance or reinsurance
undertaking which is subject to a resolution plan
pursuant to Article 9 shall be subject to pre-
emptive recovery planning requirements.
Low risk profile undertakings, however, shall
not be subject to pre-emptive recovery planning
requirements on an individual basis.
4. EIOPA shall issue guidelines in
accordance with Article 16 of Regulation (EU)
No 1094/2010 to further specify the methods to
be used when determining the market shares
referred to in paragraph 2, and the criteria, in
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
particular as regards cross-border activity,
referred to in paragraph 2, first subparagraph.
5. Supervisory authorities shall ensure that
insurance and reinsurance undertakings update
their pre-emptive recovery plans at least
annually and after a change to the legal or
organisational structure of the undertaking
concerned, or to its business or its financial
situation, which could have a material effect on,
or necessitates a material change to, the pre-
emptive recovery plan.
6. Pre-emptive recovery plans shall not
assume any access to or receipt of extraordinary
public financial support.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
7. Member States shall require that pre-
emptive recovery plans contain all of the
following:
(a) a summary of key elements of the plan,
including material changes to the most recently
filed plan;
(b) a description of the undertaking or the
group;
(c) a framework of indicators referred to in
paragraph 8;
(d) a description of how the pre-emptive
recovery plan has been drawn-up, how it will be
updated and how it will be applied;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(e) a range of remedial actions;
(f) a communication strategy.
8. Member States shall require that
insurance and reinsurance undertakings as
referred to in paragraph 1 assess the credibility
and feasibility of pre-emptive recovery plans, in
particular the framework of indicators referred
to in paragraph 8 and the remedial actions,
against a range of scenarios of severe
macroeconomic and financial stress relevant to
the insurance or reinsurance undertaking’s
specific conditions, including system-wide
events, idiosyncratic stress events likely to
materially affect their asset and liability profile,
and combinations of such stress events.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
9. Member States shall require that
insurance and reinsurance undertakings ensure
that their pre-emptive recovery plans contain a
framework of qualitative and quantitative
indicators that identify the points at which
remedial actions should be considered. Those
indicators may include criteria relating to, inter
alia, capital, liquidity, asset quality,
profitability, market conditions, macro-
economic conditions and operational events.
Indicators relating to the capital position shall as
a minimum contain any breach of the Solvency
Capital Requirement laid down in Title I,
Chapter VI, Section 4, of Directive
2009/138/EC.
Member States shall require that supervisory
authorities ensure that insurance and reinsurance
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertakings put in place appropriate
arrangements for the regular monitoring of the
indicators referred to in the first subparagraph.
An insurance or reinsurance undertaking as
referred to in paragraph 1 that decides to take a
remedial action contained in the pre-emptive
recovery plan or decides to refrain from taking
such remedial action although an indicator as
referred to in the first subparagraph has been
met, shall notify such decision to the
supervisory authority without delay.
10. The administrative, management or
supervisory body of an insurance and
reinsurance undertaking as referred to in
paragraph 1 shall assess and approve the pre-
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
emptive recovery plan before submitting it to
the supervisory authority for review.
11. EIOPA shall, by [PO – add 18 months
after entry into force], issue guidelines in
accordance with Article 16 of Regulation (EU)
No 1094/2010 to specify further the minimum
list of qualitative and quantitative indicators
referred to in paragraph 7, first subparagraph,
point (c) and, in cooperation with the European
Systemic Risk Board (ESRB), the range of
scenarios referred to in paragraph 8.
12. EIOPA shall develop draft regulatory
technical standards further specifying, without
prejudice to Article 4, the information that an
insurance or reinsurance undertaking as referred
to in paragraph 1 is to include in the pre-
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
emptive recovery plan, including the remedial
actions referred to in paragraph 7, first
subparagraph, point (e) and their
implementation.
EIOPA shall submit those draft regulatory
technical standards to the Commission by [PO –
add 18 months after entry into force].
Power is delegated to the Commission to adopt
the regulatory technical standards referred to in
the first subparagraph in accordance with
Articles 10 to 14 of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010.
Article 6
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Review and assessment by supervisory
authorities of pre-emptive recovery plans
1. Supervisory authorities shall, within six
months of the submission of each pre-emptive
recovery plan as referred to in Article 5 and
Article 7, review that plan and assess the extent
to which it satisfies the requirements laid down
in Article 5 and, where applicable, Article 7,
and all of the following :
(a) whether the implementation of the
arrangements proposed in the plan is reasonably
likely to maintain or restore the viability and
financial position of the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking or of the group;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) whether the plan and specific options
within the plan are reasonably likely to be
implemented quickly and effectively in
situations of financial stress;
(c) whether the plan and specific options
within the plan are reasonably likely to avoid to
the maximum extent possible any significant
adverse effect on the financial system, including
in scenarios which would lead other insurance
and reinsurance undertakings to implement pre-
emptive recovery plans within the same period.
2. Supervisory authorities shall provide
resolution authorities with all pre-emptive
recovery plans they have received. Resolution
authorities may examine the pre-emptive
recovery plan to identify any actions in the pre-
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
emptive recovery plan which may adversely
impact the resolvability of the insurance or
reinsurance undertakings concerned and make
recommendations to the supervisory authority
with regard to those matters.
3. Where an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking carries out significant cross-border
activities, the home supervisory authority shall,
upon the request of a host supervisory authority,
provide the pre-emptive recovery plan to that
host supervisory authority. The host supervisory
authority may examine the pre-emptive
recovery plan to identify any actions in the pre-
emptive recovery plan which may adversely
impact policy holders, the real economy or the
financial stability in its Member State and make
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
recommendations to the home supervisory
authority with regard to those matters.
4. Supervisory authorities that, after having
assessed the pre-emptive recovery plan,
conclude that there are material deficiencies in
that plan, or material impediments to its
implementation shall notify the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking concerned, or the
ultimate parent undertaking concerned, of the
content of their assessment and require the
undertaking concerned to submit, within two
months, a revised plan demonstrating how those
deficiencies or impediments are addressed. The
period of two months may be extended by one
month where the supervisory authority so
agrees.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Before requiring an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking to resubmit a pre-emptive recovery
plan, the supervisory authority shall give the
undertaking the opportunity to state its opinion
on that requirement.
A supervisory authority that finds that the
deficiencies and impediments have not been
adequately addressed in the revised plan may
instruct the undertaking to make specific
changes to the plan.
5. Where the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking fails to submit a revised pre-
emptive recovery plan, or where the supervisory
authority comes to the conclusion that the
revised pre-emptive recovery plan does not
adequately remedy the deficiencies or potential
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
impediments identified in its original
assessment, and where it is not possible to
adequately remedy the deficiencies or
impediments through a direction to make
specific changes to the plan, the supervisory
authority shall require the undertaking to
identify within a reasonable timeframe changes
the undertaking can make to its business in
order to address the deficiencies in the pre-
emptive recovery plan or impediments to the
implementation of that plan.
Where the insurance or reinsurance undertaking
fails to identify such changes within the
timeframe set by the supervisory authority, or
where the supervisory authority concludes that
the actions proposed by the undertaking would
not adequately address the deficiencies or
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
impediments, the supervisory authority may
take a reasoned decision to direct the
undertaking to take any measures it considers to
be necessary and proportionate, taking into
account the seriousness of the deficiencies and
impediments and the effect of the measures on
the undertaking’s business.
The reasoned decision referred to in the second
subparagraph shall be notified in writing to the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking and shall
be subject to a right of appeal.
Article 7
Group pre-emptive recovery plans
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
1. Member States shall ensure that ultimate
parent undertakings draw up and submit to the
group supervisor a group pre-emptive recovery
plan.
Group pre-emptive recovery plans shall consist
of a pre-emptive recovery plan for the group
headed by the ultimate parent undertaking. The
group pre-emptive recovery plan shall identify
remedial actions that may be required to be
implemented at the level of that ultimate parent
undertaking and individual subsidiaries.
2. The group pre-emptive recovery plan
contain remedial actions to achieve the
stabilisation of the group, or of any insurance or
reinsurance undertaking of the group, when the
group or any of its insurance or reinsurance
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertakings is in a situation of stress so as to
address or remove the causes of the distress and
restore the financial position of the group or the
undertaking that is part of the group in question,
at the same time taking into account the
financial position of other group entities.
The group pre-emptive recovery plan shall
contain arrangements to ensure the coordination
and consistency of proportionate measures to be
taken at the level of the group and the group
entities.
3. The group pre-emptive recovery plan,
and any plan drawn up for an individual
subsidiary insurance or reinsurance undertaking,
shall contain the elements specified in Article 5.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
The group pre-emptive recovery plan shall
identify whether there are obstacles to the
implementation of remedial actions within the
group, including at the level of individual
entities covered by the plan, and whether there
are substantial practical or legal impediments to
the prompt transfer of own funds or the
repayment of liabilities or assets within the
group.
4. Supervisory authorities may require
subsidiary insurance or reinsurance
undertakings or the entities referred to in Article
1(1), points (c) and (d), to draw up and submit
pre-emptive recovery plans in the following
situations:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) no group pre-emptive recovery plan
exists;
(b) the supervisory authority concerned
demonstrates that the concerned entity is not
sufficiently considered by a group pre-emptive
recovery plan in light of the significance of the
entity in question in the Member State
concerned and in light of the obligations that
comparable undertakings in that Member State
are subject to.
5. The group supervisor shall, provided that
the confidentiality requirements laid down in
Articles 64 are in place, transmit the group pre-
emptive recovery plans to:
(a) EIOPA;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the relevant supervisory authorities
which are members of or participate in the
supervisory college as referred to in Article
248(3) of Directive 2009/138/EC;
(c) the group resolution authority;
(d) the resolution authorities of the
subsidiaries.
6. The administrative, management or
supervisory body of the entity drawing up the
group pre-emptive recovery plan pursuant to
paragraph 1 or paragraph 4 shall assess and
approve the group pre-emptive recovery plan
before submitting it to the group supervisor for
review.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 8
Review and assessment by the group
supervisor of group pre-emptive recovery
plans
1. The group supervisor shall, after having
consulted the relevant supervisory authorities
which are members of or participate in the
supervisory college as referred to in Article
248(3) of Directive 2009/138/EC, review the
group pre-emptive recovery plan and assess the
extent to which it satisfies the requirements and
criteria laid down in Articles 6 and this Article.
That assessment shall be made in accordance
with the procedure established in Article 6 and
with this Article and shall take into account the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
potential impact of the remedial actions on
policy holders, the real economy and financial
stability in all the Member States where the
group operates.
2. The group supervisor shall endeavour to
reach a joint decision, as referred to in Article
17, within the college of supervisors on:
(a) the review and assessment of the group
pre-emptive recovery plan and whether a
recovery plan on an individual basis is to be
drawn up for insurance and reinsurance
undertakings that are part of the group, as laid
down in Article 7(3);
(b) the application of the measures referred
to in Article 6, paragraphs (3) and (4).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Section 3
Resolution planning
Article 9
Resolution plans
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities, after having consulted the
supervisory authority, draw up a resolution plan
for each insurance and reinsurance undertaking
that meets the criteria laid down in paragraph 2,
that is not part of a group subject to resolution
planning pursuant to Articles 10 and 11. The
resolution plan shall provide for the resolution
actions which the resolution authority may take
where the insurance or reinsurance undertaking
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
meets the conditions for resolution referred to in
Article 19(1) or Article 20(3).
2. Resolution authorities shall draw up
resolution plans for insurance and reinsurance
undertakings to be selected on the basis of their
size, business model, risk profile,
interconnectedness, substitutability and the
likely impact of the failure on policy holders.
When selecting the insurance and reinsurance
undertakings subject to resolution planning, the
resolution authority shall in particular take into
account the cross-border activity of the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking and the
existence of critical functions.
Resolution authorities shall ensure that at least
70% of the Member State’s life and non-life and
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
reinsurance market respectively, where the non-
life market share is based on gross written
premiums and the life market share is based on
gross technical provisions, shall be subject to
resolution planning. In the calculation of the
market coverage level, the subsidiaries of a
group may be taken into account where those
subsidiaries are covered in the group resolution
plan referred to in Article 10.
Low risk profile undertakings shall not be
subject to resolution planning requirements on
an individual basis.
3. Where the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking concerned carries out significant
cross-border activities, home resolution
authorities shall, upon the request of a host
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
supervisory or resolution authority, provide the
draft resolution plan to that host supervisory or
resolution authority. The host supervisory or
resolution authority may examine the draft
resolution plan to identify any actions in the
draft resolution plan which may adversely
impact policy holders, the real economy or the
financial stability in its Member State and make
recommendations to the home resolution
authority with regard to those matters.
4. When specifying the options for
application of resolution tools and powers,
resolution plans shall take into consideration
relevant resolution scenarios, including the
scenario where the failure of the insurance and
reinsurance undertaking is idiosyncratic or
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
occurs at a time of broader financial instability
or system wide events.
Resolution plans shall not assume any
extraordinary public financial support besides,
where available, the use of insurance guarantee
schemes or of any financing arrangements.
5. Resolution authorities shall review, and
where necessary update, resolution plans at least
annually and after any material change to the
legal or organisational structure of the insurance
or reinsurance undertaking or to its business or
its financial position that could have a material
effect on the effectiveness of the plan or
otherwise necessitate a revision of the resolution
plan.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Insurance and reinsurance undertakings and
supervisory authorities shall promptly
communicate to the resolution authorities any
event that necessitates a revision or update of
the resolution plan.
6. Without prejudice to Article 4,
resolution plans shall set out options for
applying the resolution tools and resolution
powers to the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking. Resolution plans shall contain,
quantified whenever appropriate and possible,
all of the following:
(a) a summary of the key elements of the
plan;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) a summary of the material changes to the
undertaking that have occurred after the latest
resolution-related information was filed;
(c) a demonstration of how critical functions
and core business lines could be legally and
economically separated, to the extent necessary,
from other functions so as to ensure continuity
upon the failure of the undertaking;
(d) an identification of those assets which
would be expected to qualify as collateral;
(e) an estimation of the timeframe for
executing each material aspect of the plan;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(f) a detailed description of the assessment
of resolvability carried out in accordance with
Article 13;
(g) a description of any measures required
pursuant to Article 15 to address or remove
impediments to resolvability identified as a
result of the assessment carried out in
accordance with Article 13;
(h) an explanation as to how the resolution
options could be financed without the
assumption of any extraordinary public financial
support besides, where available, the use of
insurance guarantee schemes or of any financing
arrangements;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(i) a detailed description of the different
resolution strategies that could be applied in
light of the different possible scenarios and the
applicable timescales;
(j) a description of critical
interdependencies;
(k) an analysis of the impact of the
resolution plan on the employees of the
undertaking, including an assessment of any
associated costs, and a description of envisaged
procedures to consult staff during the resolution
process, taking into account national systems for
dialogue with social partners where applicable;
(l) a plan for communicating with the media
and the public;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(m) a description of essential operations and
systems necessary for maintaining the
continuous functioning of the undertaking’s
operational processes;
(n) where applicable, any opinion expressed
by the undertaking in relation to the resolution
plan.
Information referred to in point (a) shall be
disclosed to the insurance and reinsurance
undertaking concerned.
7. The resolution authority shall transmit
the resolution plans and any changes thereto to
the supervisory authorities concerned.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
8. EIOPA shall develop draft regulatory
technical standards further specifying, without
prejudice to Article 4, the contents of the
resolution plan.
EIOPA shall submit those draft regulatory
technical standards to the Commission by [PO –
add 18 months after entry into force].
Power is delegated to the Commission to adopt
the regulatory technical standards referred to in
the first subparagraph in accordance with
Articles 10 to 14 of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010.
9. EIOPA shall, by [PO – add 18 months
after entry into force], issue guidelines in
accordance with Article 16 of Regulation (EU)
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
No 1094/2010 to specify further criteria for the
identification of critical functions.
Article 10
Group resolution plans
1. Member States shall ensure that group
resolution authorities draw up group resolution
plans.
2. The group resolution plan shall:
(a) set out the resolution actions that are to
be taken in respect of each entity where
measures will be necessary to ensure the
continuity of critical functions;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) examine the extent to which the
resolution tools referred to in Article 26(3)
could be applied and the resolution powers
exercised in a coordinated manner and identify
any potential impediments to a coordinated
resolution;
(c) where a group contains entities
incorporated in third countries, identify
appropriate arrangements for cooperation and
coordination with the relevant authorities of
those third countries and the implications for
resolution within the Union;
(d) identify measures, including the legal
and economic separation of particular functions
or business lines, that are necessary to facilitate
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
group resolution, taking into account intra-group
interdependencies;
(e) identify available sources of funding to
finance the group resolution actions and, where
the use of insurance guarantee schemes or of
any financing arrangement would be required,
set out principles for sharing responsibility for
that financing between sources of funding in
different Member States. The group resolution
plan shall not assume any extraordinary public
financial support;
(f) contain the elements laid down in Article
9(6).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
3. The group resolution authority shall
transmit group resolution plans and any changes
thereto to the supervisory authorities concerned.
4. EIOPA shall develop draft regulatory
technical standards specifying the contents of
group resolution plans, taking into account the
diversity of business models of groups in the
internal market.
EIOPA shall submit those draft regulatory
technical standards to the Commission by [PO –
add 18 months after entry into force].
Power is delegated to the Commission to adopt
the regulatory technical standards referred to in
the first subparagraph in accordance with
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Articles 10 to 14 of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010.
Article 11
Requirements and procedure for group
resolution plans
1. Member States shall ensure that ultimate
parent undertakings shall submit to the group
resolution authority the information that may be
required by Article 12. That information shall
concern the ultimate parent undertaking and to
the extent required each of the group entities
including the entities referred to in Article 1(1),
points (b) to (e).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
The group resolution authority shall, provided
that the confidentiality requirements laid down
in this Directive are in place, transmit the
relevant information provided in accordance
with this paragraph to:
(a) EIOPA;
(b) the resolution authorities which are
members of the resolution college;
(c) the relevant supervisory authorities
which are members of or participate in the
supervisory college as referred to in Article
248(3) of Directive 2009/138/EC.
2. Member States shall ensure that in
resolution colleges, group resolution authorities,
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
acting jointly with the resolution authorities
referred to in paragraph 1, second subparagraph,
point (b), and after having consulted the
supervisory authorities concerned which are
members of or participate in the supervisory
college as referred to in Article 248(3) of
Directive 2009/138/EC, draw up and maintain
group resolution plans. Group resolution
authorities may, at their discretion, and subject
to them meeting the confidentiality
requirements laid down in Article 77 of this
Directive, involve in the drawing up and
maintenance of group resolution plans third-
country resolution authorities of jurisdictions in
which the group has established subsidiary
insurance or reinsurance undertakings or
insurance holding companies or significant
branches.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
3. Member States shall ensure that group
resolution plans are reviewed, and where
appropriate updated, at least annually, and after
any change to the legal or organisational
structure, to the business or to the financial
position of the group including any group entity,
that could have a material effect on or require a
change to the plan.
4. The adoption of the group resolution
plan shall take the form of a joint decision, as
referred to in Article 17, of the group resolution
authority and the resolution authorities of the
subsidiary insurance and reinsurance
undertakings and of the entities referred to in
Article 1(1), points (b) to (e).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 12
Information for the purpose of resolution
plans and cooperation from the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities have the power to require
insurance and reinsurance undertakings or the
ultimate parent undertaking, as applicable, to:
(a) cooperate as much as necessary in the
drawing up of resolution plans or group
resolution plans;
(b) provide them, either directly or through
the supervisory authority, with all of the
information necessary to draw up and
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
implement resolution plans or group resolution
plans.
2. Supervisory authorities in the Member
States concerned shall cooperate with resolution
authorities to verify whether some or all of the
information referred to in paragraph 1 is already
available and shall provide that information to
those resolution authorities. Resolution
authorities shall obtain all relevant information
from supervisory authorities before requesting
information from insurance and reinsurance
undertakings.
3. EIOPA shall develop draft implementing
technical standards to specify procedures and a
minimum set of standard forms and templates
for the provision of the information referred to
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
in this Article, and to specify the content of such
information.
EIOPA shall submit those draft implementing
technical standards to the Commission by [PO –
add 18 months after entry into force].
Power is conferred on the Commission to adopt
the implementing technical standards referred to
in the first subparagraph in accordance with
Article 15 of Regulation (EU) No 1094/2010.
CHAPTER II
Resolvability
Article 13
Assessment of resolvability
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities, after having consulted the
supervisory authority, assess the extent to which
insurance or reinsurance undertakings that are
not part of a group are resolvable without the
assumption of any extraordinary public financial
support besides, where available, the use of
insurance guarantee schemes or of any financing
arrangements.
An insurance or reinsurance undertaking shall
be deemed resolvable where it is feasible and
credible for that undertaking to be liquidated
under normal insolvency proceedings, or for the
resolution authority to resolve that undertaking
by applying to it the different resolution tools
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
referred to in Article 26(3) and resolution
powers referred to in Articles 40 to 52.
2. Resolution authorities shall make the
resolvability assessment referred to in paragraph
1 at the same time as, and for the purposes of,
the drawing up and updating of the resolution
plan in accordance with Article 9.
3. EIOPA shall develop draft regulatory
technical standards to specify the matters and
criteria for the assessment of the resolvability of
insurance and reinsurance undertakings or
groups provided for in paragraph 1 and in
Article 14.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
EIOPA shall submit those draft regulatory
technical standards to the Commission by [PO –
add 18 months after entry into force].
Power is conferred on the Commission to adopt
the draft regulatory technical standards referred
to in the first subparagraph in accordance with
Articles 10 to 14 of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010.
Article 14
Assessment of resolvability for groups
1. Member States shall ensure that group
resolution authorities, together with the
resolution authorities of subsidiaries, after
having consulted the group supervisor and the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
supervisory authorities of such subsidiaries,
assess the extent to which groups are resolvable
without the assumption of any extraordinary
public financial support besides, where
available, the use of insurance guarantee
schemes or of any financing arrangements.
2. A group shall be deemed resolvable
where it is feasible and credible for the
resolution authorities either to wind up group
entities under normal insolvency proceedings, to
resolve that group by applying resolution tools
to, and exercising resolution powers with
respect to, group entities where they can be
easily separated in a timely manner, or by any
other means provided for under national law.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
The resolution colleges referred to in Article 68
shall take into account the assessment of group
resolvability when discharging their functions.
3. Group resolution authorities shall make
the resolvability assessment of groups at the
same time as, and for the purposes of, the
drawing up and updating of the group resolution
plans in accordance with Article 10. The
assessment shall be made under the decision-
making procedure laid down in Article 11.
Article 15
Power to address or remove impediments to
resolvability
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
1. Member States shall ensure that where
the assessment carried out in accordance with
Articles 13 or 14 reveals that there are
substantive impediments to the resolvability of
the insurance or reinsurance undertaking
concerned, the resolution authority shall notify
that insurance or reinsurance undertaking and
the supervisory authority concerned thereof in
writing.
2. The requirement for resolution
authorities to draw up resolution plans and for
the relevant resolution authorities to reach a
joint decision in accordance with Article 17 on
group resolution plans referred to in Article 9(1)
and Article 11(4) respectively shall be
suspended following the notification referred to
in paragraph 1 of this Article until the measures
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
to remove the substantive impediments to
resolvability have been accepted by the
resolution authority pursuant to paragraph 3 of
this Article or decided upon pursuant to
paragraph 4 of this Article.
3. Within four months of the date of receipt
of a notification referred to in paragraph 1, the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking shall
propose to the resolution authority possible
measures to address or remove the substantive
impediments identified in the notification.
The timeline for the implementation of the
measures referred to in the first subparagraph
prepared by the undertaking concerned shall
take into account the reasons for the substantive
impediment.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
The resolution authority, after having consulted
the supervisory authority, shall assess whether
the measures referred to in the first
subparagraph effectively address or remove the
substantive impediment concerned.
4. Resolution authorities that find that the
measures proposed by an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking in accordance with
paragraph 3, first subparagraph, do not
effectively reduce or remove the impediments
concerned, shall, either directly, or indirectly
through the supervisory authority, require the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking concerned
to take any of the alternative measures referred
to in paragraph 5, and notify such measures in
writing to that entity, which shall propose a plan
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
to comply with those requirements within one
month after having received such notification.
When identifying alternative measures,
resolution authorities shall demonstrate how the
measures proposed by the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking would not be able to
remove the impediments to resolvability and
how the alternative measures proposed are
proportionate in removing those impediments.
Resolution authorities shall take into account the
effect of the measures on the business of the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking, its
stability and its ability to contribute to the
economy.
5. The alternative measures referred to in
paragraph 4 shall be any of the following:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) require the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking to revise any intra-group financing
agreements or review the absence thereof, or
draw up service agreements, whether intra-
group or with third parties;
(b) require the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking to limit its maximum individual and
aggregate exposures;
(c) impose specific or regular additional
information requirements relevant for resolution
purposes;
(d) require the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking to divest specific assets or to
restructure liabilities;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(e) require the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking to limit or cease specific existing or
proposed activities;
(f) restrict or prevent the development of
new or existing business lines or sale of new or
existing products;
(g) require the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking to change the reinsurance strategy;
(h) require changes to legal or operational
structures of the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking or any group entity, either directly
or indirectly under its control, so as to reduce
complexity to ensure that critical functions may
be legally and operationally separated from
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
other functions through the application of the
resolution tools;
(i) require an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking or a parent undertaking to set up a
parent insurance holding company in a Member
State or a Union parent insurance holding
company;
(j) where an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking is the subsidiary of a mixed-activity
insurance holding company, require that the
mixed-activity insurance holding company sets
up a separate insurance holding company to
control the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking, where necessary to facilitate the
resolution of the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking and to avoid that the application of
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution tools and the exercise of resolution
powers has an adverse effect on the non-
financial part of the group.
6. Before identifying any alternative
measure referred to in paragraph 5, the
resolution authority, after having consulted the
supervisory authority, shall duly consider the
potential effect of such measure on the
soundness and stability of that particular
insurance or reinsurance undertaking’s ongoing
business and on the internal market.
7. A notification or decision made pursuant
to paragraph 1 or 4:
(a) shall contain the reasons for the
assessment or determination in question;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) shall indicate how the notification or
decision complies with the requirement for
proportionate application laid down in
paragraph 4, second subparagraph;
(c) shall be subject to a right of appeal.
8. EIOPA shall, by [PO – add 18 months
after entry into force], issue guidelines in
accordance with Article 16 of Regulation (EU)
No 1094/2010 to specify further details on the
measures provided for in paragraph 5 and the
circumstances in which each measure may be
applied.
Article 16
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Power to address or remove impediments to
resolvability: group treatment
1. A group resolution authority, together
with the resolution authorities of subsidiaries,
after having consulted the supervisory college,
shall consider the assessment referred to in
Article 14 within the resolution college and
shall take all reasonable steps to reach a joint
decision as referred to in Article 17 on the
application of measures identified in accordance
with Article 15(4) in relation to all relevant
group entities.
2. The group resolution authority, in
cooperation with the group supervisor and with
EIOPA, in accordance with Article 25(1) of
Regulation (EU) No 1094/2010, shall prepare
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
and submit a report to the ultimate parent
undertaking and to the resolution authorities of
subsidiaries, which shall provide that report to
the subsidiaries within their remit. The report
shall be prepared after having consulted the
supervisory authorities, and shall analyse the
substantive impediments to the effective
application of the resolution tools referred to in
Article 26(3) and the exercise of the resolution
powers referred to in Articles 40 to 52 in
relation to the group. The report shall
recommend any proportionate and targeted
measures that, in the view of the group
resolution authority, are necessary or
appropriate to remove those impediments,
considering the impact of those measures on the
group's business model.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
3. Within four months of the date of receipt
of the report, the ultimate parent undertaking
may submit observations and propose to the
group resolution authority alternative measures
to remedy the impediments identified in the
report.
The resolution authority, after having consulted
the supervisory authority, shall assess whether
those measures effectively address or remove
the substantive impediment.
4. The group resolution authority shall
communicate any measure proposed by the
ultimate parent undertaking to the authorities
that are members of or participate in the
resolution college. The group resolution
authorities and the resolution authorities of the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
subsidiaries, after having consulted the
supervisory authorities, shall do everything
within their power to reach a joint decision, as
referred to in Article 17, within the resolution
college regarding the identification of
substantive impediments, and where necessary,
regarding the assessment of the measures
proposed by the ultimate parent undertaking and
the measures required by the authorities in order
to address or remove the impediments. When
doing so, they shall take into account the
potential impact of the measures in all Member
States where the group operates.
CHAPTER III
Joint decisions
Article 17
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Joint decisions
1. Group supervisors, supervisory
authorities, group resolution authorities and
resolution authorities shall endeavour to reach
the joint decisions referred to in Article 8(2),
Article 11(4) and Article 16(4), as applicable,
within 4 months of the date of:
(a) the transmission by the group supervisor
of the group pre-emptive recovery plan in
accordance with Article 7(4);
(b) the transmission by the group resolution
authority of the information referred to in the
Article 11(1), second subparagraph;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) the submission of any observations by
the ultimate parent undertaking or at the expiry
of the four-month period referred to in Article
16(3), whichever the earlier.
EIOPA may, at the request of a supervisory
authority or a resolution authority, assist the
group supervisors, supervisory authorities,
group resolution authorities and resolution
authorities in reaching a joint decision in
accordance with Article 31(2), point (c), of
Regulation (EU) No 1094/2010.
2. In the absence of a joint decision within
the period referred to in paragraph 1 on any of
the matters listed in the second subparagraph,
the group supervisor or the group resolution
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
authority, as applicable, shall make its own
decision on those matters.
The matters referred to in the first subparagraph
are the following:
(a) the review and assessment of the group
pre-emptive recovery plan referred to in Article
8;
(b) any measures the ultimate parent
undertaking is required to take in accordance
with Article 6, paragraphs 3 and 4;
(c) the group resolution plan referred to in
Article 10;
(d) the measures referred to in Article 16.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
The decision made by the group supervisor or
the group resolution authority, as applicable,
shall be fully reasoned and shall take into
account the views and reservations of other
supervisory authorities or resolution authorities,
as applicable, expressed during the four-month
period. The decision shall be provided to the
ultimate parent undertaking and to the other
authorities concerned.
3. In the absence of a joint decision within
the period referred to in paragraph 1 between
the supervisory authorities or resolution
authorities on any of the matters listed in the
second subparagraph, each supervisory
authority or resolution authority, as applicable,
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
of a subsidiary shall make its own decision on
those matters.
The matters referred to in the first subparagraph
are the following:
(a) whether a recovery plan on an individual
basis is to be drawn up for the insurance or
reinsurance undertakings under its jurisdiction
as referred to in Article 8(2);
(b) the application at subsidiary level of the
measures referred to in Article 6, paragraphs 3
and 4;
(c) the identification of the material
impediments, and where necessary, the
assessment of the measures proposed by the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
ultimate parent undertaking and the measures
required by the authorities in order to address or
remove the impediments, as referred to in
Article 16(1).
4. In the absence of a joint decision
between the resolution authorities on the
adoption of the group resolution plan, as
referred to Article 11(4), within the four month
period referred to in paragraph 1, each
resolution authority responsible for a subsidiary
shall make its own decision and shall draw up
and keep updated a resolution plan for the
entities under its jurisdiction. Each resolution
authority shall notify its decision to the other
members of the resolution college.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
5. Each of the decisions of supervisory or
resolution authorities in accordance with
paragraphs 3 or 4 shall be fully reasoned and
shall take into account the views and
reservations of the other supervisory authorities,
resolution authorities or group authorities, as
applicable.
6. The supervisory authorities or resolution
authorities that do not disagree with a decision
as referred to in paragraphs 3 and 4 may reach a
joint decision on a group pre-emptive recovery
plan or group resolution plan covering group
entities under their jurisdictions.
7. Where, by the end of the four-month
period referred to in paragraph 1, any of the
supervisory authorities or resolution authorities
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
concerned has referred a matter to EIOPA in
accordance with Article 19 of Regulation (EU)
No 1094/2010, the group supervisor, the group
resolution authority, the supervisory authority or
the resolution authority concerned, as
applicable, shall defer its decision under
paragraphs 2, 3 and 4, await any decision that
EIOPA may take in accordance with Article
19(3) of that Regulation, and take its decision in
accordance with the decision of EIOPA. The
four-month period referred to in paragraph 1
shall be deemed to be the conciliation phase as
referred to in Article 19(2) of that Regulation.
EIOPA shall take its decision within one month.
The matter shall not be referred to EIOPA after
the end of the four-month period referred to in
paragraph 1 or after a joint decision has been
reached. In the absence of an EIOPA decision
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
within one month after the referral to EIOPA
was made, the decision of the group supervisor,
group resolution authority, supervisory authority
or resolution authority for the group or the
subsidiary at an individual level, as applicable,
shall apply.
8. The joint decision referred to in Articles
8(2), Article 11(4), Article 16(4) and paragraph
6 of this Article and the decisions referred to in
paragraphs 2, 3 and 4 of this Article shall be
recognised as conclusive and applied by the
other supervisory authorities or resolution
authorities concerned in the Member States
concerned.
9. Where joint decisions are taken pursuant
to Article 11(4) and, in respect of group
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution plans, paragraph 6 of this Article and
where a resolution authority assesses that the
subject matter of a disagreement regarding
group resolution plans impinges on the fiscal
responsibilities of its Member State, the group
resolution authority shall initiate a reassessment
of the group resolution plan.
TITLE III
RESOLUTION
CHAPTER I
Resolution objectives, conditions for resolution
and general principles
Article 18
Resolution objectives
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities, when applying the
resolution tools referred to in Article 26(3) and
exercising the resolution powers referred to in
Articles 40 to 52, have regard to the resolution
objectives listed in paragraph 2, and choose the
tools and powers that best achieve the objectives
that are relevant in the circumstances of the
case.
2. The resolution objectives referred to in
paragraph 1 are:
(a) protecting policy holders, beneficiaries
and claimants;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) maintaining financial stability, in
particular, by preventing contagion and by
maintaining market discipline;
(c) ensuring the continuity of critical
functions;
(d) protecting public funds by minimising
reliance on extraordinary public financial
support.
Member States shall ensure that resolution
authorities, when pursuing the resolution
objectives, seek to minimise the cost of
resolution and avoid destruction of value unless
necessary to achieve those resolution objectives.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
3. The resolution objectives referred to in
paragraph 2 are of equal significance, and
Member States shall ensure that resolution
authorities balance them as appropriate to the
nature and circumstances of each case.
Article 19
Conditions for resolution
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities take a resolution action in
relation to an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking only where all of the following
conditions are met:
(a) the supervisory authority, after having
consulted the resolution authority, or subject to
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the conditions laid down in paragraph 2, the
resolution authority after having consulted the
supervisory authority, has determined that the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking is failing
or likely to fail;
(b) there is no reasonable prospect that any
alternative private sector measures or
supervisory action, including preventive and
corrective measures, would prevent the failure
of the undertaking within a reasonable
timeframe;
(c) resolution action is necessary in the
public interest.
2. Member States shall provide that
resolution authorities, after having consulted the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
supervisory authority, have the necessary tools
for making the determination under paragraph 1,
point (a) including, in particular, adequate
access to any relevant information. The
supervisory authority shall provide the
resolution authority without delay with any
relevant information that the latter requests in
order to perform its assessment.
3. For the purposes of paragraph 1, point
(a), an insurance or reinsurance undertaking
shall be failing or likely to fail in any of the
following circumstances:
(a) the insurance or reinsurance undertaking
is in breach or likely to be in breach of the
Minimum Capital Requirement referred to in
Title I, Chapter VI, Section 5, of Directive
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2009/138/EC and there is no reasonable
prospect of compliance being restored;
(b) the insurance or reinsurance undertaking
no longer fulfils the conditions for authorisation
or fails seriously in its obligations under the
laws and regulations to which it is subject, or
there are objective elements to support that the
undertaking will, in the near future, seriously
fail its obligations in a way that would justify
the withdrawal of the authorisation;
(c) the insurance or reinsurance undertaking
is unable to pay its debts or other liabilities,
including payments to policy holders or
beneficiaries, as they fall due, or there are
objective elements to support a determination
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
that the undertaking will, in the near future, be
in such a situation;
(d) extraordinary public financial support is
required.
4. For the purposes of paragraph 1, point
(c), a resolution action shall be in the public
interest where such action is necessary for the
achievement of, and is proportionate to, one or
more of the resolution objectives listed in
Article 18(2) and winding up the institution
under normal insolvency proceedings would not
meet those objectives to the same extent.
Article 20
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Conditions for resolution with regard to
parent undertakings and holding companies
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities may take resolution action
in relation to an entity referred to in Article 1(1),
points (b) to (e), where that entity meets the
conditions laid down in Article 19(1).
2. Where the subsidiary insurance or
reinsurance undertakings of a mixed-activity
insurance holding company are held directly or
indirectly by an intermediate insurance holding
company, Member States shall ensure that
resolution actions for the purposes of group
resolution are taken in relation to the
intermediate insurance holding company, and
shall not take resolution actions for the purposes
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
of group resolution in relation to the mixed-
activity insurance holding company.
3. Subject to paragraph 2, resolution
authorities may take resolution action with
regard to any of the entities referred to in Article
1(1), points (c) to (e), even where those entities
do not meet the conditions laid down in
paragraph 1, where all of the following
conditions apply:
(a) one or more of the subsidiary insurance
or reinsurance undertakings comply with the
conditions established in Article 19(1);
(b) the assets and liabilities of the subsidiary
insurance or reinsurance undertakings are such
that their failure threatens another insurance or
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
reinsurance undertaking of the group or the
group as a whole, or the insolvency law of the
Member State requires that groups be treated as
a whole;
(c) resolution action with regard to the
entities referred to in Article 1(1), points (c) to
(e) is necessary for the resolution of the
subsidiary insurance or reinsurance
undertakings or for the resolution of the group
as a whole.
Article 21
Insolvency proceedings in respect of
undertakings that are not subject to
resolution action
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Member States shall ensure that insurance or
reinsurance undertakings that meet the
conditions laid down in Article 19(1), points (a)
and (b), but not the condition laid down in
Article 19(1), point (c), and that meet the
Minimum Capital Requirement laid down in
Title I, Chapter VI, Section 5, of Directive
2009/138/EC, are wound up in an orderly
manner in accordance with normal insolvency
proceedings which ensure an orderly exit from
the market.
Article 22
General principles governing resolution
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities, when they apply
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution tools referred to in Article 26(3) and
exercise resolution powers referred to in
Articles 40 to 52, take all appropriate measures
to ensure that the resolution action is taken in
accordance with the following principles:
(a) the shareholders of the undertaking
under resolution bear first losses;
(b) creditors of the undertaking under
resolution bear losses after the shareholders in
accordance with the order of priority of their
claims under normal insolvency proceedings,
save as expressly provided for otherwise in this
Directive;
(c) the administrative, management or
supervisory body and the senior management of
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the undertaking under resolution are replaced,
except where the retention, in whole or in part,
of that body or the senior management is
considered necessary for the achievement of the
resolution objectives;
(d) the administrative, management or
supervisory body and the senior management of
the undertaking under resolution provide all
assistance necessary for the achievement of the
resolution objectives;
(e) natural and legal persons are made liable
under civil or criminal law for their
responsibility for the failure of the undertaking
under resolution;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(f) except where otherwise provided for in
this Directive, creditors of the same class are
treated in an equitable manner;
(g) no shareholder or creditor incurs greater
losses than they would have incurred if the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking had been
wound up under normal insolvency proceedings
in accordance with the safeguards in Articles 53
to 55;
(h) resolution action is taken in accordance
with the safeguards in this Directive.
2. Where the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking is part of a group, resolution
authorities shall apply the resolution tools
referred to in Article 26(3) and exercise the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution powers referred to in Articles 40 to
52 in a way that minimises, in particular in the
countries where the group operates:
(a) the impact on other group entities and on
the group as a whole;
(b) the adverse effects on policy holders, the
real economy and financial stability in the
Union and in its Member States..
3. When applying the resolution tools
referred to in Article 26(3) and exercising the
resolution powers referred to in Articles 40 to
52, Member States shall ensure that they comply
with the Union State aid framework, where
applicable.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
4. Where the resolution tools referred to in
Article 26(3) are applied, the entity to which
those tools are applied shall be considered the
subject of bankruptcy proceedings or analogous
insolvency proceedings for the purposes of
Article 5(1) of Council Directive 2001/23/EC20.
5. When applying the resolution tools
referred to in Article 26(3) and exercising the
resolution powers referred to in Articles 40 to
52, resolution authorities shall inform and
consult employee representatives of the
undertaking concerned where appropriate.
6. Resolution authorities shall apply the
resolution tools referred to in Article 26(3) and
20
Council Directive 2001/23/EC of 12 March 2001 on the approximation of the laws of the Member States relating to the safeguarding of employees' rights in the event of
transfers of undertakings, businesses or parts of undertakings or businesses ( OJ L 82, 22.3.2001, p. 16).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
exercise the resolution powers referred to in
Articles 40 to 52 without prejudice to provisions
on the representation of employees in
management bodies as provided for in national
law or practice.
CHAPTER II
Valuation
Article 23
Valuation for the purposes of resolution
1. Resolution authorities shall ensure that
any resolution action is taken on the basis of a
valuation ensuring a fair, prudent and realistic
assessment of the assets, liabilities, rights and
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
obligations of insurance or reinsurance
undertakings.
2. Before the resolution authority places an
insurance or reinsurance undertaking under
resolution, it shall ensure that a first valuation is
carried out to determine whether the conditions
for resolution under Article 19(1) or Article
20(3) are met.
3. After the resolution authority has
decided to place an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking under resolution, it shall ensure that
a second valuation is carried out to:
(a) inform the decision on the appropriate
resolution action to be taken;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) ensure that any losses of the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking are fully recognised at
the moment the resolution tools are applied;
(c) inform the decision on the extent of the
cancellation or dilution of instruments of
ownership;
(d) inform the decision on the extent of the
write-down or conversion of any unsecured
liabilities, including debt instruments;
(e) where the bridge undertaking tool
referred to in Article 32 is applied, inform the
decision on the assets, liabilities, rights and
obligations or instruments of ownership that
may be transferred to the bridge undertaking,
and inform the decision on the value of any
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
consideration that may be paid to the insurance
or reinsurance undertaking under resolution or,
where relevant, to the holders of the instruments
of ownership;
(f) where the sale of business tool referred
to in Article 31 is applied, inform the decision
on the assets, liabilities, rights and obligations
or instruments of ownership that may be
transferred to the third party purchaser and to
inform the resolution authority’s understanding
of what constitutes commercial terms for the
purposes of Article 31.
4. The valuations referred to in paragraphs
2 and 3 of this Article may be subject to an
appeal in accordance with Article 65 only
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
together with the decision to apply a resolution
tool or to exercise a resolution power.
Article 24
Requirements for valuation
1. Member States shall ensure that the
valuations referred to in Article 23 are carried
out by any of the following:
(a) a person independent from any public
authority and from the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking;
(b) the resolution authority, where those
valuations cannot be carried out by a person as
referred to in point (a).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. The valuations referred to in Article 23
shall be considered definitive where they have
been carried out by the person referred to in
paragraph 1, point (a), of this Article and all the
requirements laid down in paragraphs 3 to 5 of
this Article are fulfilled.
3. Without prejudice to the Union State aid
framework, where applicable, a definitive
valuation shall be based on prudent assumptions
and shall not assume any potential provision of
extraordinary public financial support from the
point in time at which resolution action is taken.
4. A definitive valuation shall be
supplemented by the following information held
by the insurance or reinsurance undertaking or
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
entity referred to in Article 1(1), points (b) to
(e):
(a) an updated financial statement and an
updated Solvency II economic valuation of the
balance sheet of the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking or entity referred to in Article 1(1),
points (b) to (e);
(b) a report on the financial position of the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking, including
an evaluation by an independent actuarial
function of the technical provisions referred to
in Title I, Chapter VI, Section 2 of Directive
2009/138/EC of insurance or reinsurance
undertaking or entity referred to in Article 1(1),
points (b) to (e);
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) any additional information on the market
and accounting values of the assets, technical
provisions, referred to in Title I, Chapter VI,
Section 2 of Directive 2009/138/EC, and other
liabilities of insurance or reinsurance
undertaking or entity referred to in Article 1(1),
points (b) to (e).
5. A definitive valuation shall indicate the
subdivision of the creditors in classes in
accordance with their priority levels under the
applicable insolvency law. The definitive
valuation shall also contain an estimation of the
treatment that each class of shareholders and
creditors would have been expected to receive if
the insurance or reinsurance undertaking or
entity referred to in Article 1(1), points (b) to
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(e), were wound up under normal insolvency
proceedings.
The estimate referred to in the first
subparagraph shall not prejudice the valuation
referred to in Article 54.
6. EIOPA shall develop draft regulatory
technical standards to specify:
(a) the circumstances in which a person is
deemed to be independent from both the
resolution authority and the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking for the purposes of
paragraph 1 of this Article;
(b) the methodology for assessing the value
of the assets and liabilities of the insurance or
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
reinsurance undertaking in the context of
resolution;
(c) the separation of the valuations under
Articles 23 and 54 of this Directive.
EIOPA shall submit those draft regulatory
technical standards to the Commission by [PO –
add 18 months after entry into force].
Power is delegated to the Commission to adopt
the regulatory technical standards referred to in
the first subparagraph in accordance with
Articles 10 to 14 of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010.
Article 25
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Provisional and definitive valuations
1. Valuations as referred to in Article 23
that do not meet the requirements laid down in
Article 24(2) shall be considered provisional
valuations.
Provisional valuations shall contain a buffer for
additional losses and an appropriate justification
for that buffer.
2. Resolution authorities that take
resolution action on the basis of a provisional
valuation shall ensure that a definitive valuation
is carried out as soon as possible.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
The resolution authority shall ensure that the
definitive valuation referred to in the first
subparagraph:
(a) allows for full recognition of any losses
of the insurance or reinsurance undertaking in
its books;
(b) informs a decision to write back
creditors’ claims or to increase the value of the
consideration paid, in accordance with
paragraph 3.
3. Where the definitive valuation’s estimate
of the net asset value of the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking is higher than the
provisional valuation’s estimate of the net asset
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
value of the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking, the resolution authority may:
(a) increase the value of the claims of
affected creditors which have been written down
or restructured;
(b) require a bridge undertaking to make a
further payment of consideration in respect of
the assets, liabilities, rights and obligations to
the insurance or reinsurance undertaking under
resolution or, as the case may be, to the owners
of the instruments of ownership.
4. EIOPA shall develop draft regulatory
technical standards to specify, for the purposes
of paragraph 1 of this Article, the methodology
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
for calculating the buffer for additional losses to
be included in provisional valuations.
EIOPA shall submit those draft regulatory
technical standards to the Commission by [PO –
add 18 months after entry into force].
Power is delegated to the Commission to adopt
the regulatory technical standards referred to in
the first subparagraph in accordance with
Articles 10 to 14 of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010.
CHAPTER III
Resolution tools
Section 1
General principles
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 26
General provisions on resolution tools
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities have the necessary powers
to apply the resolution tools to insurance and
reinsurance undertakings and to entities referred
to in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), that meet the
conditions for resolution referred to in Article
19(1) or Article 20(3).
2. Where a resolution authority decides to
apply a resolution tool to an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking or an entity referred to
in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), and that
resolution action would result in losses being
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
borne by creditors, in particular policy holders,
or would result in their claims being
restructured or converted, the resolution
authority shall exercise the power to write down
or convert capital instruments and eligible
liabilities in accordance with Article 34
immediately before or together with the
application of the resolution tool.
The conversion of eligible liabilities into capital
instruments shall not apply to insurance claims.
3. The resolution tools referred to in
paragraph 1 are the following:
(a) the solvent run-off tool;
(b) the sale of business tool;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) the bridge undertaking tool;
(d) the asset and liability separation tool;
(e) the write-down or conversion tool.
Subject to paragraph 5, resolution authorities
may apply the resolution tools individually or in
any combination, except for the asset and
liability separation tool, which may only be used
together with another resolution tool.
4. Where only the sale of business and the
bridge undertaking tool are used, and where
those tools are used to transfer only part of the
assets, rights or liabilities of the undertaking
under resolution, the residual insurance or
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
reinsurance undertaking or entity referred to in
Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), from which the
assets, rights or liabilities have been transferred,
shall be wound up under normal insolvency
proceedings. Such winding up shall be done
within a reasonable timeframe, having regard to
any need for that residual insurance or
reinsurance undertaking or entity referred to in
Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), to provide services
or support pursuant to Article 43 to enable the
recipient to carry out the activities or services
acquired by virtue of that transfer, and any other
reason that the continuation of the residual
insurance or reinsurance undertaking or entity
referred to in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), is
necessary to achieve the resolution objectives
referred to in Article 18 or comply with the
principles referred to in Article 22.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Where the solvent run-off tool is used and
where the net asset value of the undertaking
under resolution in solvent run-off has become
negative, the residual insurance or reinsurance
undertaking shall be wound up under normal
insolvency proceedings.
5. The resolution authority may recover
any reasonable expenses properly incurred in
connection with the use of the resolution tools
or exercising the resolution powers in one or
more of the following ways:
(a) as a deduction from any consideration
paid by a recipient to the undertaking under
resolution or, as the case may be, to the owners
of the shares or other instruments of ownership;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) from the undertaking under resolution,
as a preferred creditor;
(c) from any proceeds generated as a result
of the termination of the operation of the bridge
undertaking, the asset and liability management
vehicle or the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking in solvent run-off, as a preferred
creditor.
6. Member States shall ensure that rules of
national insolvency law on the voidability or
unenforceability of legal acts detrimental to
creditors do not apply to transfers of assets,
rights or liabilities from an undertaking under
resolution to another entity by virtue of the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
application of a resolution tool or the exercise of
a resolution power.
7. Member States may confer upon
resolution authorities additional tools and
powers exercisable where an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking or entity referred to in
Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), meets the
conditions for resolution referred to in Article
19(1) or Article 20(3), provided that:
(a) when applied to a cross-border group,
those additional tools and powers do not pose
obstacles to effective group resolution;
(b) those tools and powers are consistent
with the resolution objectives referred to in
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 18 and the general principles governing
resolution laid down in Articles 18 and 22.
Section 2
The solvent run-off tool
Article 27
The solvent run-off tool
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities have the power to
withdraw the authorisation of the undertaking
under resolution to write new insurance or
reinsurance contracts and place the undertaking
under resolution in a solvent run-off procedure
to terminate the activities of that undertaking.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. Resolution authorities shall ensure that
an insurance or reinsurance undertaking under
resolution in a solvent run-off is capable of
retaining adequately trained and competent staff
to ensure the orderly continuation of its
insurance activities in run-off until its
liquidation.
3. Resolution authorities shall monitor, in
close cooperation with supervisory authorities,
the costs and expenses of an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking under resolution to
preserve its value and marketability.
4. Resolution authorities shall, in close
cooperation with supervisory authorities, assess
intended changes to the composition of assets,
monitor closely reinsurance arrangements and
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
require, at least on a quarterly basis,
independent actuarial reviews of the technical
provisions and reserves.
5. In application of the solvent run-off tool,
resolution authorities shall restrict or prohibit
any remuneration of equity and instruments
treated as equity, including dividend payments,
and shall restrict or prohibit any payments of
variable remuneration and discretionary pension
benefits.
6. Resolution authorities shall take a
decision that an undertaking under resolution in
solvent run-off has to be liquidated in any of the
following cases, whichever occurs first:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) the undertaking under resolution in
solvent run-off merges with another entity;
(b) all or substantially all of the assets,
rights or liabilities of the undertaking under
resolution in solvent run-off are sold to a third
party purchaser;
(c) the assets of the undertaking under
resolution in solvent run-off are completely
wound down and its liabilities are completely
discharged;
(d) the net asset value of the undertaking
under resolution in solvent run-off has become
negative.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
7. Where the operations of an undertaking
under resolution in solvent run-off are
terminated in the circumstances referred to in
paragraph 6, point (b), the residual insurance or
reinsurance undertaking shall be wound up
under normal insolvency proceedings.
Subject to Article 26(6), any proceeds generated
as a result of the termination of the operation of
the insurance or reinsurance undertaking in run-
off shall benefit its shareholders.
Section 3
the asset and liability separation tool, the sale of
business tool, and the bridge undertaking tool
Article 28
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Principles for the application of the asset and
liability separation tool, the sale of business
tool, and the bridge undertaking tool
1. Member States shall ensure that, subject
to Article 31, paragraphs 5 and 6 and Article 65
, resolution authorities have the power to use the
asset and liability separation tool, the sale of
business tool, and the bridge undertaking tool
without obtaining the consent of the
shareholders of the undertaking under resolution
or any third party, other than the purchaser or
the bridge undertaking, and without complying
with any procedural requirements under
company or securities law, other than those laid
down in Article 29.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. Subject to Article 26(7), any
consideration paid by the purchaser or the
bridge undertaking shall benefit:
(a) the owners of the shares or of other
instruments of ownership, where such shares or
such other instruments of ownership issued by
the undertaking under resolution have been
transferred from the holders of those shares or
instruments to the purchaser or the bridge
undertaking;
(b) the undertaking under resolution, where
some or all of the assets or liabilities of the
undertaking under resolution have been
transferred to the purchaser or the bridge
undertaking.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
3. Subject to Article 26(7), any
consideration paid by an asset and liability
management vehicle as referred to in Article
30(2) in respect of the assets, rights or liabilities
acquired directly from the undertaking under
resolution shall benefit the undertaking under
resolution. Consideration may be paid in the
form of debt issued by the asset and liability
management vehicle.
4. Transfers made by using the asset and
liability tool, the sale of business tool or the
bridge undertaking tool shall be subject to the
safeguards referred to in Title III, Chapter V.
5. Resolution authorities may use the asset
and liability separation tool, the sale of business
tool and the bridge undertaking tool more than
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
once to make supplemental transfers where
necessary to achieve the resolution objectives
referred to in Article 18.
6. Member States shall ensure that the
purchaser or the bridge undertaking referred to
in paragraph 1 may continue to exercise the
rights of membership and access to, where
relevant, payment, clearing and settlement
systems, stock exchanges and insurance
guarantee schemes of the undertaking under
resolution, provided that it meets the
membership and participation criteria for
participation in such systems.
In cases where not all criteria listed in the first
subparagraph are met, Member States shall
ensure that:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) membership or participation in payment,
clearing and settlement systems, stock
exchanges and insurance guarantee schemes is
not denied on the ground that the purchaser or
the bridge undertaking does not possess a rating
from a credit rating agency, or that such rating is
not commensurate with the rating levels
required to be granted access to such systems or
schemes;
(b) where the purchaser or the bridge
undertaking does not meet the membership or
participation criteria of a payment, clearing or
settlement system, stock exchange or insurance
guarantee scheme, the rights referred to in the
first subparagraph are exercised for a period of
time specified by resolution authorities, not
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
exceeding 24 months, and renewable on
application by the purchaser or the bridge
undertaking to the resolution authority.
7. Without prejudice to Title III, Chapter
V, shareholders or creditors of the undertaking
under resolution and other third parties whose
assets, rights or liabilities are not transferred by
using the asset and liability tool, the sale of
business tool or the bridge undertaking tool,
shall not have any rights or claims over or in
relation to the assets, rights or liabilities
transferred or over or in the administrative,
management or supervisory body or senior
management of the bridge undertaking or the
assets and liabilities management vehicle.
Article 29
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Procedural requirements regarding sales of
business, assets, rights or liabilities in
resolution
1. Subject to paragraph 3 of this Article,
Member States shall ensure that, where
resolution authorities seek to apply the sale of
business tool, or sell a bridge undertaking, or its
assets, rights or liabilities, the undertaking under
resolution, the bridge undertaking or the assets,
rights, liabilities, shares or other instruments of
ownership concerned are marketed in
accordance with the criteria set out in paragraph
2. Pools of rights, assets, and liabilities may be
marketed separately.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. Without prejudice to the Union State aid
framework, where applicable, the marketing
criteria referred to in paragraph 1 are the
following:
(a) marketing shall be as transparent as
possible and shall not materially misrepresent
the assets, rights, liabilities, shares or other
instruments of ownership of the undertaking or
bridge undertaking that a resolution authority
intends to transfer;
(b) marketing shall not unduly favour, or
discriminate between, potential purchasers;
(c) marketing shall be free from any conflict
of interest;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(d) marketing shall not confer any unfair
advantage on a potential purchaser;
(e) marketing shall take account of the need
to effect a rapid resolution action;
(f) marketing shall aim at maximising, as
far as possible, the sale price for the shares or
other instruments of ownership, assets, rights or
liabilities involved.
The principles referred to in this paragraph shall
not prevent resolution authorities from soliciting
particular potential purchasers.
Any public disclosure of the marketing of the
undertaking under resolution or entity referred
to in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), or of the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
bridge undertaking that would otherwise be
required in accordance with Article 17(1) of
Regulation (EU) No 596/2014 may be delayed
in accordance with Article 17, paragraph 4 or 5
of that Regulation.
3. Resolution authorities may decide not to
comply with the requirement to market a sale
where they determine that compliance with the
requirements laid down in paragraph 2 would be
likely to undermine one or more of the
resolution objectives referred to in Article 18.
Article 30
The asset and liability separation tool
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities have the power to transfer
assets, rights or liabilities of an undertaking
under resolution or a bridge undertaking to one
or more asset and liability management
vehicles.
2. For the purposes of the asset and liability
separation tool, an asset and liability
management vehicle shall be a legal person that
meets all of the following requirements:
(a) it is wholly or partially owned by one or
more public authorities which may include the
resolution authority and is controlled by the
resolution authority;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) it has been created for the purpose of
receiving some or all of the assets, rights and
liabilities of one or more undertakings under
resolution or a bridge undertaking.
3. The asset and liability management
vehicle shall manage the portfolios transferred
to it with a view to maximise their value
through a sale of those portfolios or an orderly
wind down.
4. Member States shall ensure that the
operation of an asset and liability management
vehicle respects the following requirements:
(a) the resolution authority concerned has
approved the asset and liability management
vehicle’s constitutional documents;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) subject to the asset and liability
management vehicle’s ownership structure, the
resolution authority concerned either appoints or
approves the vehicle’s administrative,
management or supervisory body;
(c) the resolution authority concerned
approves the remuneration of the members of
the administrative, management or supervisory
body and specifies their responsibilities;
(d) the resolution authority concerned
approves the strategy and risk profile of the
asset and liability management vehicle.
5. Resolution authorities may exercise the
power specified in paragraph 1 to transfer
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
assets, rights or liabilities only in conjunction
with other resolution tools as referred to in
Article 26(3) and where any of the following
situations occurs:
(a) the situation of the particular market for
those assets, rights or liabilities is such that the
liquidation of those assets, rights or liabilities
under normal insolvency proceedings could
have an adverse effect on one or more financial
markets;
(b) such a transfer is necessary to facilitate
the use of the solvent run-off tool or to ensure
the proper functioning of the undertaking under
resolution or a bridge undertaking;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) such a transfer is necessary to maximise
liquidation proceeds.
6. When applying the asset and liability
separation tool, resolution authorities shall, in
accordance with Article 23 and in accordance
with the Union State aid framework, determine
the consideration for which assets, rights and
liabilities are transferred to the asset and
liability management vehicle. This paragraph
shall not prevent the consideration having
nominal or negative value.
7. Where resolution authorities have
applied the bridge undertaking tool, asset and
liability management vehicles may, subsequent
to the application of the bridge undertaking tool,
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
acquire assets, rights or liabilities from the
bridge undertaking.
8. Resolution authorities may transfer
assets, rights or liabilities from the undertaking
under resolution to one or more asset and
liability management vehicles on more than one
occasion and transfer assets, rights or liabilities
back from one or more asset and liability
management vehicles to the undertaking under
resolution in any of the following situations:
(a) the possibility that the assets, rights or
liabilities might be transferred back is stated
expressly in the instrument under which the
transfer was made;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the assets, rights or liabilities do not fall
within the classes of, or meet the conditions for
transfer of, assets, rights or liabilities specified
in the instrument under which the transfer was
made.
In either of the cases referred in points (a) and
(b), the transfer back may be made within any
period, and shall comply with any other
conditions, stated in that instrument for the
relevant purpose.
The undertaking under resolution shall be
obliged to take back any assets, rights or
liabilities transferred in accordance with points
(a) and (b).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
9. The objectives of an asset and liability
management vehicle shall not imply any duty or
responsibility to shareholders or creditors of the
undertaking under resolution. The members of
the administrative, management or supervisory
body or senior management of the asset and
liability management vehicle shall have no
liability to such shareholders or creditors for
acts and omissions in the discharge of their
duties, unless such acts or omissions implied
gross negligence or serious misconduct under
national law which have directly affected the
rights of such shareholders or creditors.
Member States may further limit the liability of
an asset and liability management vehicle, and
of the members of its administrative,
management or supervisory body or senior
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
management for acts and omissions in the
discharge of their duties.
Article 31
The sale of business tool
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities have the power to transfer
to a purchaser other than a bridge undertaking:
(a) shares or other instruments of ownership
issued by an undertaking under resolution;
(b) all or any assets, rights or liabilities of an
undertaking under resolution.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. A transfer made pursuant to paragraph 1
shall be made on commercial terms, having
regard to the circumstances, and in accordance
with the Union State aid framework.
Resolution authorities shall take all reasonable
steps to obtain commercial terms for the transfer
that are conform with the valuation conducted
under Article 23, having regard to the
circumstances of the case.
3. Resolution authorities may, with the
consent of the purchaser, revert the executed
transfers where justified by the circumstances of
the case. The undertaking under resolution or
the original owners shall be obliged to take back
any transferred shares or other instruments of
ownership, or assets, rights or liabilities.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
4. Purchasers shall be required to have the
appropriate authorisation to carry out the
business they acquire when a transfer as referred
to in paragraph 1 is made. Supervisory
authorities shall ensure that any application for
such authorisation shall be considered, in
conjunction with the transfer, in a timely
manner.
5. By way of derogation from Articles 57
to 62 of Directive 2009/138/EC, where a
transfer of shares or of other instruments of
ownership by virtue of an application of the sale
of business tool would result in the acquisition
of or increase in a qualifying holding in an
insurance or reinsurance undertaking as referred
to in Article 57(1) of Directive 2009/138/EC,
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the supervisory authority of that insurance or
reinsurance undertaking shall carry out the
assessment required under those Articles in a
timely manner that does not delay the
application of the sale of business tool and
prevent the resolution action from achieving the
resolution objectives referred to in Article 18 of
this Directive.
6. Member States shall ensure that where
the supervisory authority has not completed the
assessment referred to in paragraph 5 from the
date of the transfer, the following shall apply:
(a) such a transfer of shares or other
instruments of ownership to the acquirer shall
have immediate legal effect;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) during the assessment period and during
any divestment period provided for in point (f),
the acquirer’s voting rights attached to such
shares or other instruments of ownership shall
be suspended and vested solely in the resolution
authority, which shall have no obligation to
exercise any such voting rights and which shall
have no liability whatsoever for exercising or
refraining from exercising any such voting
rights;
(c) during the assessment period and during
any divestment period provided for in point (f),
the penalties and other measures for infringing
the requirements for acquisitions or disposals of
qualifying holdings laid down in Article 62 of
Directive 2009/138/EC shall not apply to such a
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
transfer of shares or other instruments of
ownership;
(d) promptly upon completion of its
assessment, the supervisory authority shall
notify the resolution authority and the acquirer
in writing of whether it approves or, in
accordance with Article 58(4) of Directive
2009/138/EC, opposes such a transfer of shares
or other instruments of ownership to the
acquirer;
(e) where the supervisory authority
approves such a transfer of shares or other
instruments of ownership to the acquirer, the
voting rights attached to such shares or other
instruments of ownership shall be deemed to be
fully vested in the acquirer immediately upon
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
receipt by the resolution authority and the
acquirer of such an approval from the
supervisory authority;
(f) where the supervisory authority opposes
such a transfer of shares or other instruments of
ownership to the acquirer:
(i) the voting rights attached to such shares
or other instruments of ownership as provided
for in point (b) shall remain in full force and
effect;
(ii) the resolution authority may require the
acquirer to divest such shares or other
instruments of ownership within a divestment
period determined by the resolution authority
having taken into account prevailing market
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
conditions;(iii) where the acquirer does not
comply with the request provided for in point
(ii), the supervisory authority, with the consent
of the resolution authority, may impose on the
acquirer penalties and other measures for
infringing the requirements for acquisitions or
disposals of qualifying holdings laid down in
Article 62 of Directive 2009/138/EC.
7. For the purposes of exercising the rights
to provide services or to establish itself in
another Member State in accordance with
Directive 2009/138/EC, the purchaser shall be
considered to be a continuation of the
undertaking under resolution, and may continue
to exercise any such right that was exercised by
the undertaking under resolution in respect of
the assets, rights or liabilities transferred.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 32
Bridge undertaking tool
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities have the power to transfer
to a bridge undertaking:
(a) shares or other instruments of ownership
issued by one or more undertakings under
resolution;
(b) all or any assets, rights or liabilities of
one or more undertakings under resolution.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. The bridge undertaking shall be a legal
person that meets all of the following
requirements:
(a) it is wholly or partially owned by one or
more public authorities which may include the
resolution authority or, where applicable, an
insurance guarantee scheme and is controlled by
the resolution authority;
(b) it is created for the purpose of receiving
and holding some or all of the shares or other
instruments of ownership issued by an
undertaking under resolution or some or all of
the assets, rights and liabilities of one or more
undertakings under resolution with a view to
achieve the resolution objectives and selling the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertaking or entity referred to in Article 1(1),
points (b) to (e).
3. When applying the bridge undertaking
tool, resolution authorities shall ensure that the
total value of liabilities transferred to the bridge
undertaking does not exceed the total value of
the rights and assets transferred from the
undertaking under resolution.
4. Following an application of the bridge
undertaking tool, resolution authorities may,
where justified by the circumstances, revert the
executed transfers, and the undertaking under
resolution or the original owners shall be
obliged to take back any transferred assets,
rights or liabilities, or shares or other
instruments of ownership, where justified by the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
circumstances of the case, in any of the
following situations:
(a) the possibility that the specific shares or
other instruments of ownership, assets, rights or
liabilities might be transferred back is stated
expressly in the instrument by which the
transfer was made;
(b) the specific shares or other instruments
of ownership, assets, rights or liabilities do not
fall within the classes of, or meet the conditions
for transfer of shares or other instruments of
ownership, assets, rights or liabilities specified
in the instrument by which the transfer was
made.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
A transfer back as referred to in the first
subparagraph may be made within any period
and shall comply with any other conditions
stated in the instrument by which the transfer
was made.
5. Following an application of the bridge
undertaking tool, resolution authorities may
transfer shares or other instruments of
ownership, or assets, rights or liabilities from
the bridge undertaking to a third party
purchaser.
6. A bridge undertaking shall be considered
to be a continuation of the undertaking under
resolution, and be able to continue to exercise
any right that was exercised by the undertaking
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
under resolution in respect of the assets, rights
or liabilities transferred.
A bridge institution shall not conclude new
insurance contracts or change existing insurance
contracts in a way that could increase the
insurance claims of the bridge undertaking.
7. The objectives of a bridge undertaking
shall not imply any duty or responsibility to
shareholders or creditors of the undertaking
under resolution, and the members of the
administrative, management or supervisory
body or senior management shall have no
liability to such shareholders or creditors for
acts or omissions in the discharge of their
duties, unless the act or omission implies gross
negligence or serious misconduct in accordance
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
with national law which have directly affected
the rights of such shareholders or creditors.
Member States may further limit the liability of
a bridge undertaking and of the members of its
administrative, management or supervisory
body or senior management in accordance with
national law for acts and omissions in the
discharge of their duties.
Article 33
Operation of a bridge undertaking
1. Member States shall ensure that the
operation of a bridge undertaking respects the
following requirements:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) the resolution authority has approved the
bridge undertaking’s constitutional documents;
(b) subject to the bridge undertaking’s
ownership structure, the resolution authority
either appoints or approves the bridge
undertaking’s administrative, management or
supervisory body;
(c) the resolution authority approves the
remuneration of the members of the
administrative, management or supervisory
body and determines their responsibilities;
(d) the resolution authority approves the
strategy and risk profile of the bridge
undertaking;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(e) the bridge undertaking is authorised in
accordance with Directive 2009/138/EC and has
the necessary authorisation under the applicable
national law to carry out the activities or
services that it acquires by virtue of a transfer
made pursuant to Article 40 of this Directive;
(f) the bridge undertaking complies with the
requirements of, and is subject to supervision in
accordance with Directive 2009/138/EC;
(g) the operation of the bridge undertaking
complies with the Union State aid framework
and the resolution authority may specify
restrictions on its operations accordingly.
Notwithstanding the provisions referred to in
points (d) and (e) of the first subparagraph and
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
where necessary to meet the resolution
objectives referred to in Article 18, a bridge
undertaking may be established and authorised
without complying with Directive 2009/138/EC
for a short period of time at the beginning of its
operation. To that end, the resolution authority
shall submit a request in that sense to the
supervisory authority. Where the supervisory
authority decides to grant such an authorisation,
it shall indicate the period for which the bridge
undertaking is waived from complying with the
requirements of Directive 2009/138/EC.
2. Subject to any restrictions imposed by
Union or national competition rules, the
management of the bridge undertaking shall
operate the bridge undertaking to achieve the
resolution objectives referred to in Article 18
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
and to sell the undertaking under resolution and
its assets, rights or liabilities to one or more
private sector purchasers as soon as market
conditions are appropriate.
3. Resolution authorities shall decide that
an entity is no longer a bridge undertaking in
any of the following situations, whichever
occurs first:
(a) the bridge undertaking merges with
another entity;
(b) the bridge undertaking ceases to meet
the requirements of Article 32(2);
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) all or substantially all of the bridge
undertaking’s assets, rights or liabilities are sold
to a third party purchaser;
(d) the bridge undertaking’s assets are
completely wound down and its liabilities are
completely discharged.
4. Where the operations of a bridge
undertaking are terminated in the situation
referred to in paragraph 3, point (c), the bridge
undertaking shall be wound up under normal
insolvency proceedings.
Subject to Article 26(7), any proceeds generated
as a result of the termination of the operation of
the bridge undertaking shall benefit the
shareholders of the bridge undertaking.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Section 4
The write-down or conversion tool
Article 34
Objective and scope of the write-down or
conversion tool
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities may apply the write-down
or conversion tool to meet the resolution
objectives referred to in Article 18 for any of the
following purposes:
(a) to recapitalise an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking or an entity as referred
to in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), that meets
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the conditions for resolution referred to in
Articles 19(1) and 20(3) to the extent sufficient
to apply the solvent run-off tool referred to in
Article 27 and to maintain its authorisation
under Directive 2009/138/EC;
(b) to convert to equity or reduce the
principal amount of claims, including insurance
claims, or debt instruments that are transferred:
(i) to a bridge undertaking to provide
capital for that bridge institution; or
(ii) under the asset and liability separation
tool referred to in Article 30 or the sale of
business tool referred to in Article 31.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
When applying the write-down or conversion
tool to insurance claims, resolution authorities
may also restructure the terms of the related
insurance contracts to achieve the resolution
objectives referred to in Article 18 more
effectively.
2. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities determine the amount by
which capital instruments, debt instruments and
other eligible liabilities must be written down or
converted for the purposes in paragraph 1 on the
basis of the valuation carried out in accordance
with Article 23.
3. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities may apply the write-down
or conversion tool to all liabilities of insurance
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
or reinsurance undertakings or entities referred
to in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), maintaining
their current legal form or considering a change
of their legal form where necessary.
4. Member States shall ensure that the
write-down or conversion tool may be applied
to all capital instruments and all liabilities of an
insurance or reinsurance undertaking or entity
referred to in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), that
are not excluded from the scope of that tool
pursuant to paragraphs 5 or 6 of this Article.
5. Resolution authorities shall not apply the
write-down or conversion tool in relation to the
following liabilities whether they are governed
by the law of a Member State or of a third
country:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) secured liabilities;
(b) liabilities to credit institutions,
investment firms and insurance or reinsurance
undertakings, except for entities that are part of
the same group, with an original maturity of less
than seven days;
(c) liabilities with a remaining maturity of
less than seven days, owed to either systems or
operators of systems designated in accordance
with Directive 98/26/EC or to their participants
and arising from the participation in such a
system, or to CCPs authorised in the Union
pursuant to Article 14 of Regulation (EU) No
648/2012 of the European Parliament and of the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Council21 and third-country CCPs recognised by
ESMA pursuant to Article 25 of that
Regulation;
(d) a liability to any one of the following:
(i) an employee, in relation to accrued
salary, pension benefits or other fixed
remuneration, except for the variable component
of remuneration that is not regulated by a
collective bargaining agreement;
(ii) a commercial or trade creditor arising
from the provision to the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking or entity referred to in
Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), of goods or
21
Regulation (EU) No 648/2012 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 4 July 2012 on OTC derivatives, central counterparties and trade repositories (OJ L 201,
27.7.2012, p. 1).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
services that are critical to the daily functioning
of its operations, including IT services, utilities
and the rental, servicing and upkeep of
premises;
(iii) tax and social security authorities,
provided that those liabilities are preferred
under the applicable law;
(iv) insurance guarantee schemes arising
from contributions due in accordance with
applicable national laws.
Point (a) of the first subparagraph shall not
prevent resolution authorities, where
appropriate, from applying the write-down or
conversion tool to any part of a secured liability
or a liability for which collateral has been
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
pledged that exceeds the value of the assets,
pledge, lien or collateral against which it is
secured.
6. In exceptional circumstances, where the
write-down or conversion tool is applied,
resolution authorities may exclude or partially
exclude certain liabilities from the application of
the write-down or conversion tool in any of the
following situations:
(a) it is not possible to write down or
convert that liability within a reasonable time,
notwithstanding the good faith efforts of the
resolution authority;
(b) the exclusion is strictly necessary and is
proportionate to achieve the continuity of
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
critical functions and core business lines in a
manner that maintains the ability of the
undertaking under resolution to continue key
operations, services and transactions;
(c) the exclusion is strictly necessary and
proportionate to avoid giving rise to widespread
contagion, in a manner that could cause a
serious disturbance to the economy of a
Member State or of the Union; or
(d) the application of the write-down or
conversion tool to those liabilities would cause a
destruction in value such that the losses borne
by other creditors would be higher than if those
liabilities were excluded from the application of
the write-down or conversion tool.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 35
Treatment of shareholders and holders of
other instruments of ownership when
applying the write-down or conversion tool
1. Member States shall ensure that, when
applying the write-down or conversion tool
referred to in Article 34, resolution authorities
take, in respect of shareholders and holders of
other instruments of ownership, one or both of
the following actions:
(a) cancel existing shares or other
instruments of ownership, or transfer them to
creditors whose claims have been converted;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) provided that the valuation carried out
under Article 23 shows that the undertaking
under resolution has a positive net value, dilute
existing shareholders and holders of other
instruments of ownership by converting relevant
capital instruments or debt instruments issued
by the undertaking under resolution, or other
eligible liabilities of the undertaking under
resolution ,into shares or other instruments of
ownership pursuant to the application of the
write-down or conversion tool.
With regard to point (b) of the first
subparagraph, the conversion shall be conducted
at a rate of conversion that severely dilutes
existing holdings of shares or other instruments
of ownership.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. When considering which of the actions
referred to in paragraph 1 to take, resolution
authorities shall have regard to:
(a) the valuation carried out in accordance
with Article 23;
(b) the amount by which the resolution
authority has assessed that Tier 1 items must be
reduced and relevant capital instruments must
be written down or converted pursuant to
Article 37(1).
3. By way of derogation from Articles 57
to 62 of Directive 2009/138/EC, where the
conversion of capital instruments, debt
instruments issued by the undertaking under
resolution, or other eligible liabilities of the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertaking under resolution, would result in
the acquisition of or increase in a qualifying
holding in an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking as referred to in Article 57(1) of
Directive 2009/138/EC, supervisory authorities
shall carry out the assessment required under
those Articles in a timely manner that does not
delay the conversion of capital instruments, or
prevent resolution action from achieving the
relevant resolution objectives referred to in
Article 18.
4. Where the supervisory authority of the
that undertaking has not completed the
assessment required under paragraph 3 on the
date of the conversion of the capital instruments,
Article 31(6) shall apply to any acquisition of or
increase in a qualifying holding by an acquirer
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resulting from the conversion of capital
instruments.
Article 36
Rate of conversion of debt to equity
Member States shall ensure that, when
resolution authorities exercise the tools
specified in Article 34(1) and the powers
specified in Article 40(1), point (g), they may
apply a different conversion rate to different
classes of capital instruments and liabilities in
accordance with one or both of the following
principles:
(a) the conversion rate represents
appropriate compensation to the affected
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
creditor for any loss incurred by virtue of the
exercise of the write-down or conversion
powers;
(b) the conversion rate applicable to
liabilities that are considered to be senior under
applicable insolvency law are higher than the
conversion rate applicable to subordinated
liabilities.
Article 37
Additional provisions governing the write-
down or conversion tool
1. Resolution authorities shall apply the
write-down or conversion tool in accordance
with the priority of claims applicable under
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
normal insolvency proceedings, in a way that
produces the following results:
(a) Tier 1 items are reduced first in
proportion to the losses and to the extent of their
capacity and the resolution authority takes one
or both of the actions specified in Article 35(1)
in respect of holders of Tier 1 instruments;
(b) the principal amount of Tier 2
instruments is written down or converted into
Tier 1 instruments or both, to the extent required
to achieve the resolution objectives referred to
in Article 18 or to the extent of the capacity of
the relevant capital instruments, whichever is
lower;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) the principal amount of Tier 3
instruments is written down or converted into
Tier 1 instruments or both, to the extent required
to achieve the resolution objectives referred to
in Article 18 or to the extent of the capacity of
the relevant capital instruments, whichever is
lower;
(d) the principal amount of, or outstanding
amount payable in respect of, the rest of eligible
liabilities in accordance with the hierarchy of
claims in normal insolvency proceedings,
including the ranking of insurance claims
provided for in Article 275(1) of Directive
2009/138/EC, is written down or converted into
Tier 1 instruments or both, to the extent required
to achieve the resolution objectives referred to
in Article 18.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Where the level of write-down based on the
provisional valuation as referred to in Article 25
is found to exceed requirements when assessed
against the definitive valuation as referred to in
Article 24(2), a write-up mechanism may be
applied to reimburse creditors and,
subsequently, shareholders to the extent
necessary.
When deciding on whether liabilities are to be
written down or converted into equity,
resolution authorities shall not convert one class
of liabilities, while a class of liabilities that is
subordinated to the class remains unconverted
into equity or not written down.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Member States shall ensure that all claims
resulting from own funds items have, in national
laws governing normal insolvency proceedings,
a lower priority ranking than any claim that does
not result from an own funds item. For the
purposes of this subparagraph, to the extent that
an instrument is only partly recognised as an
own funds item, the whole instrument shall be
treated as a claim resulting from an own funds
items and shall rank lower than any claim that
does not result from an own funds item.
2. Where the principal amount of a relevant
capital instrument or the principal amount of a
debt instrument or other eligible liability is
written down, the following shall apply:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) the reduction resulting from the
application of the write-down or conversion tool
shall be permanent, subject to any write up in
accordance with the reimbursement mechanism
referred to in paragraph 1;
(b) no liability to the holder of the relevant
capital instrument, the debt instrument or other
eligible liability shall remain under or in
connection with that amount of the instrument,
which has been written down, except for any
liability already accrued, and any liability for
damages that may arise as a result of an appeal
challenging the legality of the exercise of the
write-down power;
(c) no compensation shall be paid to any
holder of the relevant capital instrument, the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
debt instrument or other eligible liability other
than in accordance with paragraph 3.
3. In order to effect a conversion of the
capital instruments, debt instruments or other
eligible liabilities concerned in accordance with
paragraph 1, points (b) and (c), resolution
authorities may require insurance or reinsurance
undertakings and entities referred to in Article
1(1), points (b) to (e), to issue Tier 1
instruments to the holders of the capital
instruments, debt instruments or other eligible
liabilities concerned.
The capital instruments, debt instruments or
other eligible liabilities concerned may only be
converted where all of the following conditions
are met:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) the Tier 1 instruments are issued by the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking, by the
entity referred to Article 1(1), points (b) to (e),
or by the parent undertaking with the agreement
of the relevant resolution authority;
(b) the Tier 1 instruments are issued prior to
any issuance of shares or other instruments of
ownership by that insurance or reinsurance
undertaking or that entity referred to in Article
1(1), points (b) to (e), for the purposes of
provision of own funds by the State or a
government entity;
(c) the Tier 1 instruments are awarded and
transferred without delay following the exercise
of the conversion power;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(d) the conversion rate that determines the
number of Tier 1 instruments that are provided
in respect of each relevant capital instrument,
debt instrument or other eligible liability
complies with Article 36.
4. For the purposes of the provision of Tier
1 instruments in accordance with paragraph 3,
the resolution authority may require insurance
or reinsurance undertakings and entities referred
to in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), to maintain at
all times the necessary prior authorisation to
issue the relevant number of Tier 1 instruments.
Article 38
Effect of write-down or conversion
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
1. Member States shall ensure that, where a
resolution authority applies the write-down or
conversion tool and powers in accordance with
Article 34(1) and Article 40(1), points (f) to (j),
the reduction of principal or outstanding amount
due, conversion or cancellation takes effect and
is immediately binding on the undertaking under
resolution and affected creditors and
shareholders.
2. The resolution authority shall complete
or require the completion of all the
administrative and procedural tasks necessary to
give effect to the application of the write-down
or conversion tool, including:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) the amendment of all registers
concerned;
(b) the delisting, or removal from trading of
shares or other instruments of ownership or debt
instruments;
(c) the listing, or admission to trading of
new shares or other instruments of ownership;
(d) the relisting or readmission of any debt
instruments which have been written down,
without having to issue a prospectus as required
by Regulation (EU) 2017/1129 of the European
Parliament and of the Council22.
22
Regulation (EU) 2017/1129 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 14 June 2017 on the prospectus to be published when securities are offered to the public or
admitted to trading on a regulated market, and repealing Directive 2003/71/EC (OJ L 168, 30.6.2017, p. 12).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
3. Where a resolution authority reduces to
zero the principal amount of, or outstanding
amount payable in respect of, a liability by
means of the power referred to Article 40(1),
point (f), that liability and any obligations or
claims arising in relation to it that are not
accrued at the time when the power is exercised
shall be treated as discharged for all purposes,
and shall not be provable in any subsequent
proceedings in relation to the undertaking under
resolution or any successor entity in any
subsequent winding up.
4. Where a resolution authority reduces in
part, but not in full, the principal amount of, or
outstanding amount payable in respect of, a
liability by means of the power referred to in
Article 40(1), point (f):
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) the liability shall be discharged to the
extent of the amount reduced;
(b) the instrument concerned or the
agreement that created the original liability shall
continue to apply in relation to the residual
principal amount of, or outstanding amount
payable in respect of the liability, subject to any
modification of the amount of interest payable
to reflect the reduction of the principal amount,
and any further modification of the terms that
the resolution authority might make by means of
the power referred to in Article 40(1), point (k).
Article 39
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Removal of procedural obstacles for write-
down or conversion
1. Where the write-down or conversion
tool is applied, Member States shall, where
applicable, require the insurance and
reinsurance undertakings and entities referred to
in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), to maintain at
all times a sufficient amount of authorised share
capital or of other Tier 1 instruments to ensure
that those undertakings and entities are not
prevented from issuing sufficient new shares or
other instruments of ownership to ensure that
the conversion of liabilities into shares or other
instruments of ownership can be carried out
effectively.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Resolution authorities shall assess compliance
with the requirement laid down in paragraph 1
in the context of the development and
maintenance of the resolution plans in
accordance with Article 9 and Article 10.
2. Member States shall ensure that there are
no procedural impediments to the conversion of
liabilities to shares or other instruments of
ownership that exist by virtue of their
instruments of incorporation or statutes,
including pre-emption rights for shareholders or
requirements for the consent of shareholders to
an increase in capital.
CHAPTER IV
Resolution powers
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 40
General powers
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities have all the powers
necessary to apply the resolution tools referred
to in Article 26(3) to insurance and reinsurance
undertakings and to entities referred to in
Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), that meet the
conditions for resolution laid down in Articles
19(1) or 20(3), as applicable. In particular,
resolution authorities shall have the following
resolution powers, which they may exercise
individually or in any combination:
(a) the power to require any person to
provide any information required for the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution authority to decide upon and prepare
a resolution action, including updates and
supplements of information provided in the
resolution plans and including information to be
provided through on-site inspections;
(b) the power to take control of an
undertaking under resolution and exercise all the
rights and powers conferred upon the
shareholders, other owners and the
administrative, management or supervisory
body of the undertaking under resolution;
(c) the power to withdraw the authorisation
to write new insurance or reinsurance contracts
and to place an undertaking under resolution
into an orderly solvent run-off procedure and
terminate its activities;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(d) the power to transfer shares or other
instruments of ownership issued by an
undertaking under resolution;
(e) the power to transfer to another entity,
with the consent of that entity, rights, assets or
liabilities of an undertaking under resolution;
(f) the power to restructure insurance claims
or reduce, including to reduce to zero, the
principal amount of or outstanding amount due
in respect of debt instruments and eligible
liabilities, including insurance claims, of an
undertaking under resolution;
(g) with the exception of insurance claims,
the power to convert debt instruments and
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
eligible liabilities of an undertaking under
resolution into ordinary shares or other
instruments of ownership of that undertaking or
entity referred to in Article 1(1), points (b) to
(e), of a relevant parent undertaking or of a
bridge undertaking to which assets, rights or
liabilities of the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking or the entity referred to in Article
1(1), points (b) to (e), are transferred;
(h) the power to cancel debt instruments
issued by an undertaking under resolution,
except for secured liabilities subject to Article
34(5);
(i) the power to reduce, including to reduce
to zero, the nominal amount of shares or other
instruments of ownership of an undertaking
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
under resolution and to cancel such shares or
other instruments of ownership;
(j) the power to require an undertaking
under resolution or a relevant parent
undertaking to issue new shares or other
instruments of ownership or other capital
instruments, including preference shares and
contingent convertible instruments;
(k) the power to amend or alter the maturity
of debt instruments and other eligible liabilities
issued by an undertaking under resolution or
amend the amount of interest payable under
such instruments and other eligible liabilities, or
the date on which the interest becomes payable,
including by suspending payment for a
temporary period;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(l) the power to close out and terminate
financial contracts, or derivatives as defined in
Article 2 point (5), of Regulation (EU) No
648/2012 of the European Parliament and of the
Council;
(m) the power to remove or replace the
administrative, management or supervisory
body and senior management of an undertaking
under resolution;
(n) the power to require the supervisory
authority to assess the buyer of a qualifying
holding in a timely manner by way of
derogation from the time-limits laid down in
Article 58 of Directive 2009/138/EC.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. Member States shall take all necessary
measures to ensure that, when applying the
resolution tools referred to in Article 26(3) and
exercising the resolution powers referred to in
paragraph 1 of this Article, resolution
authorities are not subject to any of the
following requirements that would otherwise
apply by virtue of national law or contract or
otherwise:
(a) subject to Article 3(8) and Article 65(1),
requirements to obtain approval or consent from
any person either public or private, including the
shareholders, the creditors or the policy holders
of the undertaking under resolution;
(b) prior to the exercise of the power,
procedural requirements to notify any person,
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
including any requirement to publish any notice
or prospectus or to file or register any document
with any other authority.
Point (b) of the first subparagraph is without
prejudice to the requirements laid down in
Articles 61 and 63 and any notification
requirements under the Union State aid
framework.
3. Member States shall ensure that, to the
extent that any of the powers listed in paragraph
1 of this Article are not applicable to an entity
within the scope of Article 1(1) of this Directive
as a result of its specific legal form, resolution
authorities shall have powers which are as
similar as possible, including in terms of their
effects.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
4. Member States shall ensure that, when
resolution authorities exercise the powers laid
down in paragraph 3, the safeguards provided
for in Chapter V of this Directive, or safeguards
that deliver the same effect, shall be applied to
the persons affected, including shareholders,
creditors, policy holders and counterparties.
Article 41
Ancillary powers
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities, when exercising a
resolution power, have the power to do all of the
following:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) subject to Article 58, provide for a
transfer to take effect, free from any liability or
encumbrance affecting the financial
instruments, rights, assets or liabilities
transferred;;
(b) remove rights to acquire any additional
shares or other instruments of ownership;
(c) require the authority concerned to
discontinue or suspend the admission to trading
on a regulated market or the official listing of
financial instruments pursuant to Directive
2001/34/EC of the European Parliament and of
the Council23;
23
Directive 2001/34/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 28 May 2001 on the admission of securities to official stock exchange listing and on information to
be published on those securities (OJ L 184, 6.7.2001, p. 1).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(d) provide for the recipient to be treated as
if that recipient were the undertaking under
resolution for the purposes of any rights or
obligations of, or actions taken by, the
undertaking under resolution, including, subject
to the application of the sale of business tool
and the bridge undertaking tool referred to in
Articles 31 and 32, any rights or obligations
relating to participation in a market
infrastructure;
(e) require the undertaking under resolution
or the recipient to provide each other with
information and assistance;
(f) cancel or modify the terms of a contract
to which the undertaking under resolution is a
party, or substitute a recipient as a party;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(g) transfer any reinsurance rights covering
transferred insurance claims without the consent
of the reinsurance undertaking where the
resolution authority transfers assets and
liabilities of the undertaking under resolution in
whole or in part to another entity.
For the purposes of point (a), any right of
compensation provided in accordance with this
Directive shall not be considered to be a liability
or an encumbrance.
2. Resolution authorities shall exercise the
powers specified in paragraph 1 where they
consider such exercise to be appropriate to
ensure that a resolution action is effective or to
achieve one or more resolution objectives.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
3. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities exercising a resolution
power have the power to provide for continuity
arrangements necessary to ensure that the
resolution action is effective and, where
relevant, to ensure that the business transferred
may be operated by the recipient. Such
continuity arrangements shall include, in
particular:
(a) the continuity of contracts entered into
by the undertaking under resolution, so that the
recipient assumes the rights and liabilities of the
undertaking under resolution relating to any
financial instrument, right, asset or liability that
has been transferred and is substituted for the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertaking under resolution, expressly or
implicitly in all relevant contractual documents;
(b) the substitution of the recipient for the
undertaking under resolution in any legal
proceedings relating to any financial instrument,
right, asset or liability that has been transferred.
4. The powers referred to in paragraph 1,
point (d), and paragraph 3, point (b), shall not
affect the following:
(a) the right of an employee of the
undertaking under resolution to terminate a
contract of employment;
(b) subject to Articles 47, 48 and 49, any
right of a party to a contract to exercise rights
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
under the contract, including the right to
terminate, where entitled to do so in accordance
with the terms of the contract by virtue of an act
or omission by the undertaking under resolution
prior to the relevant transfer, or by the recipient
after the completion of the transfer concerned.
Article 42
Special management
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities may appoint a special
manager to replace the administrative,
management or supervisory body of the
undertaking under resolution. Member States
shall further ensure that the special manager has
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the qualifications, ability and knowledge to
carry out his or her functions.
2. The special manager shall have all the
powers of the shareholders and of the
administrative, management or supervisory
body of the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking. The special manager shall only
exercise those powers under the control of the
resolution authority. The resolution authority
may limit the actions of the special manager or
require prior consent for certain acts.
The resolution authority shall make public the
appointment referred to in paragraph 1 and the
terms and conditions attached to that
appointment.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
3. The special manager shall have the
statutory duty to take all the measures necessary
to promote the resolution objectives referred to
in Article 18 and implement resolution actions
taken by the resolution authority. In the event of
inconsistency or conflict with any other duty of
management laid down in the statutes of the
undertaking or in national law, that statutory
duty shall override such other duty.
4. Member States shall require that the
special manager shall draw up reports for the
appointing resolution authority that appointed
them at regular intervals set by the resolution
authority and at the beginning and the end of
their mandate. Those reports shall describe in
detail the financial situation of the undertaking
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
under resolution and state the reasons for the
measures taken.
5. The resolution authority may remove the
special manager at any time.
Article 43
Power to require the provision of operational
services and facilities
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities have the power to require
an undertaking under resolution, or any of its
group entities, to provide any operational
services or facilities that are necessary to enable
a recipient to operate effectively the business
transferred to it effectively, including where the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertaking under resolution or relevant group
entity has entered into normal insolvency
proceedings.
2. Member States shall ensure that their
resolution authorities have powers to enforce
obligations imposed, pursuant to paragraph 1,
on group entities established in their territory by
resolution authorities established in other
Member States.
3. The operational services and facilities
provided in accordance with paragraphs 1 and 2
shall be on the following terms:
(a) where the operational services and
facilities were provided to the undertaking under
resolution under an agreement before resolution
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
action was taken and for the duration of that
agreement, on the same terms;
(b) where there is no agreement or where
the agreement has expired, on reasonable terms.
Article 44
Power to enforce crisis management
measures by other Member States
1. Member States shall ensure that, where a
transfer of shares, other instruments of
ownership, or assets, rights or liabilities includes
assets that are located in a Member State other
than the State of the resolution authority, or
includes rights or liabilities under the law of a
Member State other than the State of the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution authority, the transfer has effect in or
under the law of that other Member State.
2. Member States shall provide the
resolution authority that has made, or intends to
make, the transfer, with all reasonable assistance
to ensure that the shares or other instruments of
ownership or assets, rights or liabilities are
transferred to the recipient in accordance with
any applicable requirements of national law.
3. Member States shall ensure that
shareholders, creditors and third parties that are
affected by a transfer of shares, other
instruments of ownership, assets, rights or
liabilities as referred to in paragraph 1, are not
entitled to prevent, challenge, or set aside the
transfer under any provision of law of the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Member State where the assets are located or of
the law governing the shares, other instruments
of ownership, rights or liabilities.
4. Member States shall ensure that the
principal amount of capital instruments, debt
instruments or other eligible liabilities is
reduced, or that such liabilities or instruments
are converted, in accordance with the exercise
of write-down or conversion powers by a
resolution authority of another Member State to
an undertaking under resolution, where the
relevant liabilities or instruments:
(a) are governed by the law of the Member
State other than the Member State of the
resolution authority that exercised the write-
down or conversion powers;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) are owed to creditors located in the
Member State other than the Member State of
the resolution authority that exercised the write-
down or conversion powers.
5. Member States shall ensure that
creditors that are affected by the exercise of
write-down or conversion powers referred to in
paragraph 4 are not entitled to challenge the
reduction of the principal amount of the
instrument or liability or its conversion, as the
case may be, under any provision of law of the
Member State other than the Member State of
the resolution authority that exercised the write-
down or conversion powers.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
6. Each Member State shall ensure that all
of the following is determined in accordance
with the law of the Member State of the
resolution authority:
(a) the right for shareholders, creditors and
third parties to challenge, by way of appeal as
laid down in Article 65, a transfer of shares,
other instruments of ownership, assets, rights or
liabilities referred to in paragraph 1 of this
Article;
(b) the right for creditors to challenge, by
way of appeal as laid down in Article 65, the
reduction of the principal amount, or the
conversion, of an instrument or liability covered
by paragraph 4 points (a) or (b), of this Article;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) the safeguards for partial transfers, as
referred to in Chapter V, in relation to the
assets, rights or liabilities referred to in
paragraph 1.
Article 45
Power in respect of assets, rights, liabilities,
shares and other instruments of ownership
located in or governed by the law of third
countries
1. Member States shall provide that, in
cases in which resolution action involves action
taken in respect of assets located in a third
country or shares, other instruments of
ownership, rights or liabilities governed by the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
law of a third country, resolution authorities
may require that:
(a) the person exercising control over the
undertaking under resolution and the recipient
take all steps necessary to ensure that the
resolution action becomes effective;
(b) the person exercising control over the
undertaking under resolution hold the shares,
other instruments of ownership, assets or rights
or discharge the liabilities on behalf of the
recipient until the resolution action becomes
effective;
(c) the reasonable expenses of the recipient
properly incurred in carrying out any action
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
required under points (a) and (b) are met in any
of the ways referred to in Article 26(5).
2. In order to facilitate potential action
pursuant to paragraph 1 of this Article, Member
States shall require insurance or reinsurance
undertakings and entities referred to in Article
1(1), points (b) to (e), to include into the related
agreements contractual terms by which
shareholders, creditors or parties to the
agreement creating the liability recognise that
the liability may be subject to write-down or
conversion powers and agree to be bound by
any reduction of the principal or outstanding
amount due, conversion or cancellation that is
effected by the exercise of those powers by a
resolution authority.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Member States shall ensure that resolution
authorities may require insurance or reinsurance
undertakings and entities as referred to in
Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), to provide those
resolution authorities with a reasoned legal
opinion by an independent legal expert
confirming the legal enforceability and
effectiveness of such contractual terms.
3. Where a resolution authority assesses
that, in spite of all the necessary steps taken by
the person exercising control over the
undertaking under resolution in accordance with
paragraph 1, point (a), it is highly unlikely that
the resolution action will become effective in
relation to certain assets located in a third
country or certain shares, other instruments of
ownership, rights or liabilities governed by the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
law of a third country, the resolution authority
shall not proceed with the resolution action.
Where the resolution authority has already
ordered the resolution action, that order shall be
void in relation to the assets, shares, instruments
of ownership, rights or liabilities concerned.
Article 46
Exclusion of certain contractual terms
1. A crisis prevention measure or a crisis
management measure taken in relation to an
entity, including the occurrence of any event
directly linked to the application of such a
measure, shall not, per se, under a contract
entered into by the entity concerned, be deemed
to be an enforcement event within the meaning
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
of Directive 2002/47/EC or insolvency
proceedings within the meaning of Directive
98/26/EC, provided that the substantive
obligations under that contract, including
payment and delivery obligations and the
provision of collateral, continue to be
performed.
In addition, a crisis prevention measure or a
crisis management measure shall not, per se, be
deemed to be an enforcement event within the
meaning of Directive 2002/47/EC or insolvency
proceedings within the meaning of Directive
98/26/EC under a contract entered into by:
(a) a subsidiary, where the parent
undertaking or any group entity guarantees or
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
otherwise supports the obligations under that
contract; or
(b) any entity of a group, where the contract
contains cross-default provisions.
2. Where third country resolution
proceedings are recognised pursuant to Article
73, or, in the absence of such recognition, where
a resolution authority so decides, third country
resolution proceedings shall for the purposes of
this Article constitute a crisis management
measure.
3. Provided that the substantive obligations
under the contract, including payment and
delivery obligations, and provision of collateral,
continue to be performed, a crisis prevention
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
measure, or a crisis management measure,
including any event directly linked to the
application of such a measure, shall not, per se,
make it possible for anyone to:
(a) exercise any termination, suspension,
modification, netting or set-off rights, including
in relation to a contract entered into by:
(i) a subsidiary, where the obligations under
the contract are guaranteed or otherwise
supported by a group entity;
(ii) any group entity, where the contract
contains cross-default provisions;
(b) obtain possession, exercise control or
enforce any security over any property of the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
insurance or reinsurance undertaking or the
entity referred to in Article 1(1), points (b) to
(e), concerned or any group entity in relation to
a contract which contains cross-default
provisions;
(c) affect any contractual rights of the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking or the
entity referred to in Article 1(1), points (b) to
(e), concerned or any group entity in relation to
a contract which contains cross-default
provisions.
4. Paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 shall not affect the
right of a person to take an action as referred to
in paragraph 3, points (a), (b) or (c) where that
right arises by virtue of an event other than the
crisis prevention measure, the crisis
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
management measure, or by virtue of any event
directly linked to the application of such a
measure.
5. A suspension or restriction under
Articles 47 or 48 shall not constitute non-
performance of a contractual obligation for the
purposes of paragraphs 1 and 3 of this Article
and of Article 49(1).
6. The provisions contained in this Article
shall be considered to be overriding mandatory
provisions within the meaning of Article 9 of
Regulation (EC) No 593/2008 of the European
Parliament and of the Council24.
24
Regulation (EC) No 593/2008 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 June 2008 on the law applicable to contractual obligations (Rome I) (OJ L 177, 4.7.2008,
p. 6).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 47
Power to suspend certain obligations
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities have the power to suspend
any payment or delivery obligations pursuant to
any contract to which an undertaking under
resolution is a party from the publication of a
notice of the suspension in accordance with
Article 63(3) until midnight in the Member
State of the resolution authority of the
undertaking under resolution at the end of the
business day following that publication.
2. A payment or delivery obligation that
would have been due during the suspension
period referred to in paragraph 1 shall be due
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
immediately upon expiry of the suspension
period.
3. Where an undertaking under resolution’s
payment or delivery obligations under a contract
are suspended in accordance with paragraph 1,
the payment or delivery obligations of the
undertaking under resolution’s counterparties
under that contract shall be suspended for the
same period of time.
4. Any suspension under paragraph 1 shall
not apply to payment and delivery obligations
owed to the following:
(a) systems and operators of systems
designated in accordance with Directive
98/26/EC;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) CCPs authorised in the Union pursuant
to Article 14 of Regulation (EU) No 648/2012
and third-country CCPs recognised by ESMA
pursuant to Article 25 of that Regulation.
5. When exercising a power under this
Article, resolution authorities shall have regard
to the impact the exercise of that power might
have.
The resolution authorities shall set the scope of
that power having regard to the circumstances
of each case.
Article 48
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Power to restrict the enforcement of security
interests
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities have the power to restrict
secured creditors of an undertaking under
resolution from enforcing security interests in
relation to any assets of that undertaking from
the publication of a notice of the restriction in
accordance with Article 63(3) until midnight in
the Member State of the resolution authority of
the undertaking under resolution at the end of
the business day following that publication.
2. Any restriction under paragraph 1 shall
not apply to:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) security interest of systems or operators
of systems designated for the purposes of
Directive 98/26/EC;
(b) CCPs authorised in the Union pursuant
to Article 14 of Regulation (EU) No 648/2012
and third-country central counterparties
recognised by ESMA pursuant to Article 25 of
that Regulation.
3. Where Article 60 applies, resolution
authorities shall ensure that any restrictions
imposed pursuant to the power referred to in
paragraph 1 of this Article are consistent for all
group entities in relation to which a resolution
action is taken.
Article 49
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Power to temporarily suspend termination
rights
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities have the power to suspend
the termination rights of any party to a contract
with an undertaking under resolution from the
publication of the notice in accordance with
Article 63(3) until midnight in the Member
State of the resolution authority of the
undertaking under resolution at the end of the
business day following that publication,
provided that the payment and delivery
obligations and the provision of collateral
continue to be performed.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities have the power to suspend
the termination rights of any party to a contract
with a subsidiary of an undertaking under
resolution where any of the following applies:
(a) the obligations under that contract are
guaranteed or are otherwise supported by the
undertaking under resolution;
(b) the termination rights under that contract
are based solely on the insolvency or financial
condition of the undertaking under resolution;
(c) in the case of a transfer power that has
been or may be exercised in relation to the
undertaking under resolution, either:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(i) all the assets and liabilities of the
subsidiary relating to that contract have been or
may be transferred to and assumed by the
recipient; or
(ii) the resolution authority provides in any
other way adequate protection for such
obligations.
The suspension of the termination rights shall
take effect from the publication of the notice in
accordance with Article 63(3) until midnight in
the Member State where the subsidiary of the
undertaking under resolution is established on
the business day following that publication.
3. Any suspension under paragraph 1 or 2
shall not apply to:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) systems or operators of systems
designated for the purposes of Directive
98/26/EC; or
(b) CCPs authorised in the Union pursuant
to Article 14 of Regulation (EU) No 648/2012
and third-country central counterparties
recognised by ESMA pursuant to Article 25 of
that Regulation.
4. A person may exercise a termination
right under a contract before the end of the
period referred to in paragraph 1 or 2 where that
person receives notice from the resolution
authority that the rights and liabilities covered
by the contract shall not be:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) transferred to another entity; or
(b) subject to write-down or conversion in
accordance with Article 34(1), point (a).
5. Where a resolution authority exercises
the power specified in paragraph 1 or 2 of this
Article to suspend termination rights, and where
no notice has been given pursuant to paragraph
4 of this Article, those termination rights may be
exercised on the expiry of the period of
suspension, subject to Article 46, as follows:
(a) where the rights and liabilities covered
by the contract have been transferred to another
entity, a counterparty may exercise those
termination rights in accordance with the terms
of that contract only on the occurrence of any
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
continuing or subsequent enforcement event by
the recipient;
(b) where the rights and liabilities covered
by the contract remain with the undertaking
under resolution and the resolution authority has
not applied the write-down or conversion tool to
that contract for the purpose laid down in
Article 34(1), point (a) , a counterparty may
exercise those termination rights in accordance
with the terms of that contract on the expiry of a
suspension referred to in paragraph 1 of this
Article.
Article 50
Contractual recognition of resolution stay
powers
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
1. Member States shall require insurance
and reinsurance undertakings and entities
referred to in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), to
include in any financial contract which they
enter into and which is governed by third-
country law, terms by which the parties
recognise that the financial contract may be
subject to the exercise of powers by the
resolution authority to suspend or restrict rights
and obligations under Articles 47, 48, and 49,
and recognise that they are bound by the
requirements of Article 46.
2. Member States may also require that
ultimate parent undertakings ensure that their
third-country subsidiaries which are insurance
and reinsurance undertakings or entities referred
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
to in Article 1(1) points (b) to (e), include, in the
financial contracts referred to in paragraph 1,
terms to exclude that the exercise of the power
of the resolution authority to suspend or restrict
rights and obligations of the ultimate parent
undertaking, in accordance with paragraph 1,
constitutes a valid ground for early termination,
suspension, modification, netting, exercise of
set-off rights or enforcement of security
interests on those contracts.
3. Paragraph 1 shall apply to any financial
contract which:
(a) creates a new obligation, or materially
amends an existing obligation after the entry
into force of the provisions adopted at national
level to transpose this Article;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) provides for the exercise of one or more
termination rights or rights to enforce security
interests to which Article 46, 47, 48 or 49 would
apply if the financial contract were governed by
the laws of a Member State.
4. The fact that an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking or an entity as referred to in Article
1(1), points (b) to (e), does not include in its
financial contracts the contractual terms referred
to in paragraph 1 of this Article shall not
prevent the resolution authority from applying
the powers referred to in Articles 46, 47, 48 or
49 in relation to that financial contract.
5. EIOPA shall develop draft regulatory
technical standards to specify the contents of the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
contractual term referred to in paragraph 1,
taking into account the different business
models of insurance and reinsurance
undertakings and entities.
EIOPA shall submit those draft regulatory
technical standards to the Commission by [PO –
add 18 months after entry into force].
Power is delegated to the Commission to adopt
the regulatory technical standards referred to in
the first subparagraph in accordance with
Articles 10 to 14 of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010.
Article 51
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Power to temporarily suspend redemption
rights
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities have the power to
temporarily restrict or suspend redemption
rights of policy holders in relation to life
insurance contracts written by the undertaking
under resolution, provided that the substantive
obligations under the contracts, and in particular
payment obligations for the benefit of policy
holders, beneficiaries or injured parties,
continue to be performed.
2. The power referred to in paragraph 1
shall only be used as long as necessary to
facilitate the application of one or more of the
resolution tools referred to in Article 26(3). That
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
power shall be valid for the period of time
specified in the notice of suspension published
in accordance with Article 63(3).
Article 52
Exercise of the resolution powers
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities are able to exercise control
over the undertaking under resolution, so as to:
(a) operate and conduct the activities and
services of the undertaking under resolution
with all the powers of its shareholders and
administrative, management or supervisory
body;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) manage and dispose of the assets and
property of the undertaking under resolution.
The control referred to in the first subparagraph
may be exercised directly by the resolution
authority or indirectly by a person or persons
appointed by the resolution authority. Member
States shall ensure that voting rights conferred
by shares or other instruments of ownership of
the undertaking under resolution cannot be
exercised during the period of resolution.
2. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities, subject to the right of
appeal referred to in Article 65(1), are able to
take a resolution action through executive order
in accordance with national administrative
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
competences and procedures, without exercising
control over the undertaking under resolution.
3. Resolution authorities shall decide in
each particular case whether it is appropriate to
carry out the resolution action through the
means specified in paragraph 1 or in paragraph
2, having regard to the resolution objectives
referred to in Article 18 and the general
principles governing resolution referred to in
Article 22, the specific circumstances of the
undertaking under resolution in question and the
need to facilitate the effective resolution of
cross-border groups.
4. Resolution authorities shall not be
deemed to be shadow directors or de facto
directors under national law.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
CHAPTER V
Safeguards
Article 53
Treatment of shareholders and creditors in
the case of partial transfers and application
of the write-down or conversion tool
1. Member States shall ensure that, where
one or more resolution tools as referred to in
Article 26(3) have been applied, except in a
situation described in the second subparagraph,
and where resolution authorities transfer only
parts of the rights, assets and liabilities of the
undertaking under resolution, the shareholders
and the creditors whose claims have not been
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
transferred, receive in satisfaction of their
claims at least as much as what they would have
received if the undertaking under resolution had
been wound up under normal insolvency
proceedings at the time when the decision
referred to in Article 62 was taken.
2. Member States shall ensure that, where
one or more resolution tools as referred to in
Article 26(3) have been applied and where
resolution authorities apply the write-down or
conversion tool, the shareholders and creditors
whose claims have been written down or
converted to equity do not incur greater losses
than they would have incurred if the
undertaking under resolution had been wound
up under normal insolvency proceedings
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
immediately at the time when the decision
referred to in Article 62 was taken.
Article 54
Valuation of difference in treatment
1. For the purposes of assessing whether
shareholders and creditors would have received
better treatment if the undertaking under
resolution had entered into normal insolvency
proceedings, Member States shall ensure that an
independent person caries out a valuation as
soon as possible after the resolution action or
actions have been effected. That valuation shall
be distinct from the valuation carried out under
Article 23.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. The valuation in paragraph 1 shall
determine:
(a) the treatment that shareholders and
creditors, or the relevant insurance guarantee
schemes, would have received if the
undertaking under resolution with respect to
which the resolution action or actions have been
effected had entered normal insolvency
proceedings at the time when the decision
referred to in Article 62 was taken;
(b) the actual treatment that shareholders
and creditors have received, in the resolution of
the undertaking under resolution;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) whether there is any difference between
the treatment referred to in point (a) and the
treatment referred to in point (b).
3. The valuation shall:
(a) assume that the undertaking under
resolution with respect to which the resolution
action or actions have been effected, would have
entered normal insolvency proceedings at the
time when the decision referred to in Article 62
was taken;
(b) assume that the resolution action or
actions had not been effected;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) disregard any provision of extraordinary
public financial support to the undertaking
under resolution.
4. EIOPA shall develop draft regulatory
technical standards specifying the methodology
for carrying out the valuation in this Article, in
particular the methodology for assessing the
treatment that shareholders and creditors would
have received if the undertaking under
resolution had entered insolvency proceedings
at the time when the decision referred to in
Article 62 was taken.
Power is delegated to the Commission to adopt
the regulatory technical standards referred to in
the first subparagraph in accordance with
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Articles 10 to 14 of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010.
Article 55
Safeguard for shareholders and creditors
Member States shall ensure that where the
valuation carried out under Article 54
determines that any shareholder or creditor
referred to in Article 53, or, where relevant, the
insurance guarantee scheme in accordance with
the applicable national law, has incurred greater
losses than it would have incurred in a winding
up under normal insolvency proceedings, it is
entitled to payment of the difference.
Article 56
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Safeguard for counterparties in partial
transfers
1. Member States shall ensure appropriate
protection of the following arrangements and of
the counterparties to the following
arrangements:
(a) security arrangements, under which a
person has by way of security an actual or
contingent interest in the assets or rights that are
subject to transfer, irrespective of whether that
interest is secured by specific assets or rights or
by way of a floating charge or similar
arrangement;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) title transfer financial collateral
arrangements, under which collateral to secure
or cover the performance of specified
obligations is provided by a transfer of full
ownership of assets from the collateral provider
to the collateral taker, on terms providing for the
collateral taker to transfer assets where those
specified obligations are performed;
(c) set-off arrangements, under which two
or more claims or obligations owed between the
undertaking under resolution and a counterparty
can be set off against each other;
(d) netting arrangements;
(e) unit-linked policies or other ring-fenced
portfolios;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(f) reinsurance agreements;
(g) structured finance arrangements,
including securitisations and instruments used
for hedging purposes which form an integral
part of the cover pool and which according to
national law are secured, and involve the
granting and holding of security by a party to
the arrangement or a trustee, agent or nominee.
The form of protection that is appropriate, for
the classes of arrangements specified in points
(a) to (g) of this paragraph and shall be chosen
in accordance with Articles 57 to 60.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. Member States shall ensure that the
protections specified in paragraph 1 apply in the
following circumstances:
(a) a resolution authority transfers some but
not all of the assets, rights or liabilities of an
undertaking under resolution to another entity
or, in the exercise of a resolution tool as referred
to in Article 26(3), from a bridge undertaking or
asset and liability management vehicle to
another person;
(b) a resolution authority exercises the
powers specified in Article 41(1), point (f).
3. The requirement under paragraph 1 shall
apply irrespective of the number of parties
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
involved in the arrangements and of whether the
arrangements:
(a) are created by contract, trusts or other
means, or arise automatically by operation of
law;
(b) arise under or are governed in whole or
in part by the law of another Member State or of
a third country.
Article 57
Protection for financial collateral, set off and
netting agreements, and reinsurance
agreements
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
1. Member States shall ensure that there is
appropriate protection for title transfer financial
collateral arrangements, set-off and netting
arrangements, and reinsurance agreements so as
to prevent the transfer of some, but not all, of
the rights and liabilities that are protected under
a title transfer financial collateral arrangement, a
set-off arrangement, a netting arrangement or a
reinsurance agreement between the undertaking
under resolution and another person and the
modification or termination of rights and
liabilities that are protected under such a title
transfer financial collateral arrangement, a set-
off arrangement, a netting arrangement or a
reinsurance agreement through the use of
ancillary powers.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
For the purposes of the first subparagraph, rights
and liabilities are to be treated as protected
under a title transfer financial collateral
arrangement, a set-off and netting arrangement
and a reinsurance agreement where the parties
to the arrangement or arrangement are entitled
to set-off or net those rights and liabilities.
2. Notwithstanding paragraph 1, where
necessary to better achieve the resolution
objectives referred to in Article 18 and in
particular to ensure a better protection of policy
holders, resolution authorities may transfer,
modify or terminate assets, rights or liabilities
that are part of a title transfer financial collateral
arrangement, a set-off and netting arrangement,
or a reinsurance agreement.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 58
Protection for security arrangements
1. Member States shall ensure that there is
appropriate protection for liabilities secured
under a security arrangement to prevent one or
more of the following:
(a) the transfer of assets against which the
liability is secured, unless that liability and
benefit of the security are also transferred;
(b) the transfer of a secured liability, unless
the benefit of the security are also transferred;
(c) the transfer of the benefit of the security,
unless the secured liability is also transferred;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(d) the modification or termination of a
security arrangement through the use of
ancillary powers, where the effect of that
modification or termination would be that the
liability ceases to be secured.
2. Notwithstanding paragraph 1, where
necessary in order to better achieve the
resolution objectives referred to in Article 18
and in particular ensure a better protection of
policy holders, resolution authority may
transfer, modify or terminate assets, rights or
liabilities that are part of the same arrangement.
Article 59
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Protection for structured finance
arrangements and other ring-fenced
portfolios
1. Member States shall ensure that there is
appropriate protection for structured finance
arrangements or other ring-fenced portfolios,
including arrangements referred to in Article
56(1), points (e) and (g), to prevent either of the
following:
(a) the transfer of some, but not all, of the
assets, rights and liabilities which constitute or
form part of a structured finance arrangement or
other ring-fenced portfolios, including the
arrangements referred to in Article 56(1), points
(e) and (g), to which the undertaking under
resolution is a party;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the termination or modification through
the use of ancillary powers of the assets, rights
and liabilities which constitute or form part of a
structured finance arrangement or other ring-
fenced portfolios, including arrangements
referred to in Article 56(1), points (e) and (g), to
which the undertaking under resolution is a
party.
2. Notwithstanding paragraph 1, where
necessary to better achieve the resolution
objectives referred to in Article 18 and in
particular to ensure a better protection of policy
holders, resolution authorities may transfer,
modify or terminate assets, rights or liabilities
that are part of the same arrangement.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 60
Partial transfers: protection of trading,
clearing and settlement systems
1. Member States shall ensure that the
application of a resolution tool as referred to in
Article 26(3) does not affect the operation of
systems and rules of systems covered by
Directive 98/26/EC, where the resolution
authority does either of the following:
(a) transfers some, but not all of the assets,
rights or liabilities of an undertaking under
resolution to another entity;
(b) uses the ancillary powers referred to in
Article 41 to cancel or amend the terms of a
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
contract to which the undertaking under
resolution is a party or to substitute a recipient
as a party.
2. A transfer, cancellation or amendment as
referred to in paragraph 1 of this Article shall
not:
(a) revoke a transfer order in contravention
of Article 5 of Directive 98/26/EC;
(b) modify or negate the enforceability of
transfer orders and netting as required by
Articles 3 and 5 of Directive 98/26/EC, the use
of funds, securities or credit facilities as
required by Article 4 of that Directive or the
protection of collateral security as required by
Article 9 of that Directive.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
CHAPTER VI
Procedural obligations
Article 61
Notification requirements
1. Member States shall require the
administrative, management or supervisory
body of an insurance or reinsurance undertaking
or any entity as referred to in Article 1(1), points
(b) to (e), to notify the supervisory authority
where those bodies consider that the insurance
or reinsurance undertaking or the entity referred
to in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), is failing or
likely to fail, within the meaning specified in
Article 19(3).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. Supervisory authorities shall inform the
resolution authorities concerned of:
(a) any notifications received under
paragraph 1 of this Article, under Articles 136,
138(1) and 139(1) of Directive 2009/138/EC;
(b) any actions the supervisory authority
requires the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking or any entity referred to in Article
1(1), points (b) to (e), to take pursuant to the
exercise of the powers it has under Article 15 or
16 of this Directive, and under Article 137,
Article 138, paragraphs 3 and 5, Article 139(3),
and Articles 140, 141 and 144 of Directive
2009/138/EC;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) any extension of the recovery period
pursuant to Article 138(4) of Directive
2009/138/EC.
The supervisory authorities shall also provide
the resolution authorities with a copy of the
recovery plan that the insurance or reinsurance
undertaking or any entity referred to in Article
1(1), points (b) to (e), has submitted pursuant to
Article 138(2) of Directive 2009/138/EC, a copy
of the finance scheme submitted by the
insurance or reinsurance undertaking, or any
entity referred to in Article 1(1), points (b) to
(e), pursuant to Article 139(2) of Directive
2009/138/EC and the supervisory authorities’
opinion on those documents, as applicable.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
3. A supervisory authority or resolution
authority that determines that the conditions
referred to in Article 19(1), points (a) and (b),
are met in relation to an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking or an entity referred to
in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), shall
communicate that determination without delay
to the following authorities, if different:
(a) the resolution authority for that
undertaking or entity;
(b) the supervisory authority for that
undertaking or entity;
(c) the supervisory authority of any Member
State where that undertaking or entity carries
out significant cross border activities ;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(d) the resolution authority of any Member
State where that undertaking or entity carries
out significant cross border activities;
(e) the insurance guarantee scheme to which
an insurance undertaking is affiliated, where
applicable and where necessary to enable the
functions of the insurance guarantee scheme to
be discharged;
(f) where applicable, the group resolution
authority;
(g) the competent ministry;
(h) where applicable, the group supervisor;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(i) the European Systemic Risk Board and
the designated national macroprudential
authority.
Article 62
Decision of the resolution authority
1. On receiving a communication from the
supervisory authority pursuant to Article 61(3),
or on its own initiative, the resolution authority
shall determine whether the conditions of
Article 19(1) or Article 20(3) are met in respect
of the insurance or reinsurance undertaking or
the entity referred to in Article 1(1), points (b)
to (e), in question.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. A decision to take or not to take
resolution action in relation to an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking or an entity as referred
to in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), shall contain
the following information:
(a) the reasons for that decision;
(b) the resolution action that the resolution
authority intends to take, including, where
appropriate, the determination to apply for
winding up, the appointment of an administrator
or any other measure under applicable normal
insolvency proceedings or, subject to Article
26(8), under national law.
Article 63
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Procedural obligations of resolution
authorities
1. Member States shall ensure that, as soon
as reasonably practicable after taking a
resolution action, resolution authorities comply
with the requirements laid down in paragraphs 2
and 3.
2. Resolution authorities shall notify the
undertaking under resolution and the following
authorities, if different, of the resolution action
referred to in paragraph 1:
(a) the supervisory authority for the
undertaking under resolution;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the supervisory authority of any branch
of the undertaking under resolution;
(c) the central bank of the Member State in
which the undertaking under resolution is
established;
(d) where applicable, the insurance
guarantee scheme to which the undertaking
under resolution is affiliated;
(e) where applicable, the group resolution
authority;
(f) the competent ministry;
(g) where applicable, the group supervisory
authority;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(h) the designated national macroprudential
authority and the European Systemic Risk
Board ;
(i) the Commission, the European Central
Bank, EIOPA, ESMA and EBA;
(j) where the undertaking under resolution
is an institution as defined in Article 2, point
(b), of Directive 98/26/EC, the operators of the
systems in which it participates.
3. The resolution authority shall publish or
ensure the publication of a copy of the order or
instrument by which the resolution action is
taken, or a notice summarising the effects of the
resolution action, including the effects on policy
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
holders and, where applicable, the terms and
period of suspension or restriction referred to in
Articles 47, 48 and 49, by the following means:
(a) on its official website;
(b) on the website of the supervisory
authority, if different from the resolution
authority, and on the website of EIOPA;
(c) on the website of the undertaking under
resolution;
(d) where the shares, other instruments of
ownership or debt instruments of the
undertaking under resolution are admitted to
trading on a regulated market, the means used
for the disclosure of regulated information
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
concerning the undertaking under resolution in
accordance with Article 21(1) of Directive
2004/109/EC of the European Parliament and of
the Council25.
4. Where the shares, instruments of
ownership or debt instruments are not admitted
to trading on a regulated market, the resolution
authority shall ensure that the documents
providing proof of the instruments referred to in
paragraph 3 are sent to the shareholders and
creditors of the undertaking under resolution
that are known through the registers or
databases of the undertaking under resolution
and which are available to the resolution
authority.
25
Directive 2004/109/EC of the European Parliament and of the Council of 15 December 2004 on the harmonisation of transparency requirements in relation to information
about issuers whose securities are admitted to trading on a regulated market and amending Directive 2001/34/EC (OJ L 390, 31.12.2004, p. 38).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 64
Confidentiality
1. Member States shall ensure that the
requirements of professional secrecy shall be
binding in respect of the following persons,
authorities and bodies and that no confidential
information is disclosed by any of them:
(a) resolution authorities;
(b) supervisory authorities and EIOPA;
(c) competent ministries;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(d) special managers appointed in
accordance with Article 42 of this Directive;
(e) potential acquirers that have been
contacted by the supervisory authorities or
solicited by the resolution authorities,
irrespective of whether that contact or
solicitation was made as a preparation for the
use of the sale of business tool, and irrespective
of whether the solicitation resulted in an
acquisition;
(f) auditors, accountants, legal and
professional advisors, valuers and other experts
directly or indirectly engaged by the resolution
authorities, supervisory authorities, competent
ministries or by the potential acquirers referred
to in point (e);
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(g) bodies which administer insurance
guarantee schemes;
(h) the body in charge of the financing
arrangements;
(i) central banks and other authorities
involved in the resolution process;
(j) a bridge institution or an asset
management vehicle;
(k) any other person who provides or has
provided services directly or indirectly,
permanently or occasionally, to persons referred
to in points (a) to (j);
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(l) senior management, members of the
administrative, management and supervisory
body, and employees of the bodies or entities
referred to in points (a) to (j) before, during and
after their appointment.
2. Without prejudice to the generality of
the requirements under paragraph 1, Member
States shall ensure that the persons referred to in
paragraph 1 shall be prohibited from disclosing
confidential information received during the
course of their professional activities, or
received from a supervisory authority or
resolution authority in connection with that
authority’s functions , to any person or
authority, unless in the following situations:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) the disclosure is made in the exercise of
their functions under this Directive;
(b) the disclosure is made in summary or
collective form in such a way that individual
insurance or reinsurance undertakings or any of
the entities referred to in Article 1(1), points (b)
to (e), cannot be identified;
(c) the disclosure is made with the express
and prior consent of the authority, the insurance
or reinsurance undertaking or the entity referred
to in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e),which
provided the information.
Member States shall ensure that the persons
referred to in paragraph 1 assess the possible
effects of disclosing information on the public
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
interest in relation to financial, monetary or
economic policy, on the commercial interests of
natural and legal persons, on the purpose of
inspections, on investigations and on audits.
The procedure for assessing the effects referred
to in the second subparagraph shall include a
specific assessment of the effects of any
disclosure of the contents and details of
recovery and resolution plan as referred to in
Articles 5, 7, 9, 10 and 12 and the result of any
assessment carried out under Articles 6, 8 and
13.
Member States shall ensure that any person or
entity referred to in paragraph 1 shall be subject
to civil liability in the event of an infringement
of this Article.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
3. Member States shall ensure that the
persons referred to in paragraph 1, points (a),
(b), (c), (g), (i) and (j) have internal rules in
place to ensure compliance with the
confidentiality requirements laid down in
paragraphs 1 and 2, including rules to secure
secrecy of information between persons directly
involved in the resolution process.
4. Paragraphs 1 to 3 of this Article shall not
prevent:
(a) employees and experts of the bodies or
entities referred to in points paragraph 1, points
(a) to (i), from sharing information among
themselves within each body or entity;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) resolution authorities and supervisory
authorities, including their employees and
experts, from sharing information with each
other and with other Union resolution
authorities, other Union supervisory authorities,
competent ministries, central banks, insurance
guarantee schemes, authorities responsible for
normal insolvency proceedings, authorities
responsible for maintaining the stability of the
financial system in Member States through the
use of macroprudential rules, persons charged
with carrying out statutory audits of accounts,
EIOPA, or, subject to Article 77, third-country
authorities that carry out functions that are
equivalent to the functions carried out by
resolution authorities, or, subject to strict
confidentiality requirements, to a potential
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
acquirer for the purposes of planning or carrying
out a resolution action.
5. Member States may authorise the
exchange of information with any of the
following:
(a) subject to strict confidentiality
requirements, any other person where necessary
for the purposes of planning or carrying out a
resolution action;
(b) parliamentary enquiry committees in
their Member State, courts of auditors in their
Member State and other entities in charge of
enquiries in their Member State, under
appropriate conditions;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) national authorities responsible for
overseeing payment systems, the authorities
responsible for normal insolvency proceedings,
the authorities entrusted with the public duty of
supervising other financial sector entities, the
authorities responsible for the supervision of
financial markets, credit institutions and
investment firms and inspectors acting on their
behalf, the authorities of Member States
responsible for maintaining the stability of the
financial system in Member States through the
use of macroprudential rules, the authorities
responsible for protecting the stability of the
financial system, and persons charged carrying
out statutory audits.
6. Paragraphs 1 to 5 of this Article shall be
without prejudice to national law concerning the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
disclosure of information for the purpose of
legal proceedings in criminal or civil cases.
7. EIOPA shall, by [PO – add 18 months
after entry into force], issue guidelines in
accordance with Article 16 of Regulation (EU)
No 1094/2010 to specify how information
should be provided in summary or collective
form for the purposes of paragraph 2.
CHAPTER VII
Right of appeal and exclusion of other actions
Article 65
Ex-ante judicial approval and rights to
challenge decisions
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
1. Member States may require that a
decision to take a crisis prevention measure or a
crisis management measure is subject to ex-ante
judicial approval, provided that in respect of a
decision to take a crisis management measure,
in accordance with national law, the procedure
relating to the application for approval and the
court’s consideration is expeditious.
2. Member States shall provide in national
law for a right of appeal against a decision to
take a crisis prevention measure or a decision to
exercise any power, other than a crisis
management measure, under this Directive.
3. Member States shall ensure that all
persons affected by a decision to take a crisis
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
management measure, have the right to appeal
against that decision.
Member States shall ensure that the review of a
crisis management measure is expeditious and
that national courts use the economic
assessments of the facts carried out by the
resolution authority as a basis for their own
assessment.
4. The right to appeal referred to in
paragraph 3, shall be subject to the following
requirements:
(a) the lodging of an appeal shall not entail
any automatic suspension of the effects of the
challenged decision;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the decision of the resolution authority
shall be immediately enforceable and shall give
rise to a rebuttable presumption that a
suspension of its enforcement would be against
the public interest.
Where it is necessary to protect the interests of
third parties acting in good faith who have
acquired shares, other instruments of ownership,
assets, rights or liabilities of an undertaking
under resolution by virtue of the use of
resolution tools as referred to in Article 26(3) or
through the exercise of resolution powers by a
resolution authority, the annulment of a decision
of a resolution authority shall not affect any
subsequent administrative acts or transactions
concluded by the resolution authority concerned
which were based on the annulled decision. In
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
that case, remedies for a wrongful decision or
action by the resolution authorities shall be
limited to compensation for the loss suffered by
the applicant as a result of the annulled decision
or act.
Article 66
Restrictions on other proceedings
1. Without prejudice to Article 62(2), point
(b), Member States shall ensure with respect to
an undertaking under resolution or an insurance
or reinsurance undertaking or an entity referred
to in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), in relation to
which the conditions for resolution referred to in
Article 19(1) or Article 20(3) have been
determined to be met, that normal insolvency
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
proceedings shall not be commenced except at
the initiative of the resolution authority and that
a decision placing an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking or an entity referred to in Article
1(1), points (b) to (e), into normal insolvency
proceedings shall be taken only with the consent
of the resolution authority.
2. For the purposes of paragraph 1,
Member States shall ensure that:
(a) supervisory authorities and resolution
authorities are notified without delay of any
application for the opening of normal
insolvency proceedings in relation to an
insurance or reinsurance undertaking or an
entity referred to in Article 1(1), points (b) to
(e), irrespective of whether that undertaking or
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
entity is under resolution or whether a decision
has been made public in accordance with Article
63, paragraphs 3 and 4;
(b) the application for the opening of normal
insolvency proceedings is not determined unless
the notifications referred to in point (a) have
been made and either of the following occurs:
(i) the resolution authority has notified the
authorities responsible for normal insolvency
proceedings that it does not intend to take any
resolution action in relation to the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking or the entity referred to
in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e);
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(ii) a period of seven days beginning with
the date on which the notifications referred to in
point (a) were made has expired.
3. Without prejudice to any restriction on
the enforcement of security interests imposed
pursuant to Article 48, Member States shall
ensure that, if necessary for the effective
application of the resolution tools referred to in
Article 26(3) and the resolution powers referred
to in Chapter IV of Title III, resolution
authorities may request a court to apply a stay
for an appropriate period of time in accordance
with the objective pursued, on any judicial
action or proceeding in which an undertaking
under resolution is or becomes a party.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
TITLE IV
CROSS-BORDER GROUP RESOLUTION
Article 67
General principles regarding decision-
making involving more than one Member
State
Member States shall ensure that, when making
decisions or taking action pursuant to this
Directive which may have an impact in one or
more other Member States, their authorities
have regard to the following general principles:
(a) when taking resolution action, decision-
making shall be efficient and resolution costs
shall be kept as low as possible;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) decisions shall be made and action shall
be taken in a timely manner and with due
urgency when required;
(c) resolution authorities, supervisory
authorities and other authorities shall cooperate
with each other to ensure that decisions are
made and action is taken in a coordinated and
efficient manner;
(d) the roles and responsibilities of relevant
authorities within each Member State are
defined clearly;
(e) due consideration shall be given to the
interests, potential impact of any decisions,
actions or inactions and negative effects on
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
policy holders, financial stability, fiscal
resources, insurance guarantee schemes and
negative economic and social effects in all the
Member States where the ultimate parent
undertaking and its subsidiaries operate or
where they carry out significant cross-border
activities;
(f) due consideration shall be given to the
objectives of balancing the interests of the
various Member States involved and of avoiding
unfairly prejudicing or unfairly protecting the
interests of particular Member States;
(g) resolution authorities, when taking
resolution actions, shall take into account and
follow the group resolution plans referred to in
Article 11, unless the resolution authorities
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
consider, taking into account the circumstances
of the case, that the resolution objectives
referred to in Article 18 will be achieved more
effectively by taking actions which are not
provided for in the resolution plans;
(h) a proposed decision or action shall be
transparent whenever that decision or action is
likely to have implications on the policy
holders, real economy, financial stability, fiscal
resources, and, where relevant, insurance
guarantee schemes and financing arrangements
of any Member State concerned.
Article 68
Resolution colleges
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
1. Group resolution authorities shall
establish resolution colleges to carry out the
tasks referred to in Articles 10, 11, 14, 16, 70
and 71, and, where appropriate, to ensure
cooperation and coordination with third-country
resolution authorities.
In particular, resolution colleges shall provide a
framework for the group resolution authority,
the other resolution authorities and, where
appropriate, supervisory authorities and group
supervisors concerned, to perform the following
tasks:
(a) exchanging information that is relevant
for the development of group resolution plans
and for the application to groups of resolution
powers;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) developing group resolution plans
pursuant to Articles 10 and 11;
(c) assessing the resolvability of groups
pursuant to Article 14;
(d) exercising powers to address or remove
impediments to the resolvability of groups
pursuant to Article 16;
(e) deciding on the need to establish a group
resolution scheme as referred to in Article 70 or
71;
(f) reaching the agreement on a group
resolution scheme proposed in accordance with
Article 70 or 71;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(g) coordinating public communication of
group resolution strategies and schemes;
(h) coordinating the use of any insurance
guarantee schemes or financing arrangements.
In addition, resolution colleges may be used as a
forum to discuss any issues relating to cross-
border group resolution.
2. The following shall be members of the
resolution college:
(a) the group resolution authority;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the resolution authorities of each
Member State in which a subsidiary covered by
group supervision is established;
(c) the resolution authorities of Member
States where a parent undertaking of one or
more undertakings of the group that is an entity
as referred to in Article 1(1), points (b), (d) or
(e), are established;
(d) the group supervisor and the supervisory
authorities of the Member States where the
resolution authority is a member of the
resolution college;
(e) the competent ministries, where the
resolution authorities which are members of the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution college are not the competent
ministries;
(f) where relevant, the authority that is
responsible for the insurance guarantee scheme
of a Member State, where the resolution
authority of that Member State is a member of
the resolution college;
(g) EIOPA, subject to paragraph 4.
(h) the resolution authorities in Member
States where the insurance or reinsurance
undertakings of the group carry out significant
cross-border activities.
For the purposes of point (g), EIOPA shall
contribute to promoting and monitoring the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
efficient, effective and consistent functioning of
resolution colleges and convergence across
resolution colleges. EIOPA shall be invited to
attend the meetings of the resolution college for
that purpose. EIOPA shall not have any voting
rights.
For the purposes of point (h), the participation
of the resolution authorities shall be limited to
achieving the objectives of an efficient
exchange of information.
3. The resolution authorities of third
countries where a parent undertaking or an
undertaking established in the Union has a
subsidiary insurance or reinsurance undertaking
or a branch that would be considered to be
significant were it located in the Union may be
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
invited to participate in the resolution college as
observers, provided that those authorities are
subject to confidentiality requirements that are,
in the opinion of the group resolution authority,
equivalent to those laid down in Article 77.
4. The group resolution authority shall be
the chair of the resolution college. In that
capacity it shall:
(a) establish written arrangements and
procedures for the functioning of the resolution
college, after having consulted the other
members of the resolution college;
(b) coordinate all activities of the resolution
college;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) convene and chair all the meetings of the
resolution college and keep all members of the
resolution college fully informed in advance of
the organisation of meetings of the resolution
college, of the main issues to be discussed and
of the items to be considered;
(d) notify the members of the resolution
college of any planned meetings so that they can
request to participate;
(e) decide which members and observers
shall be invited to attend particular meetings of
the resolution college, on the basis of specific
needs, taking into account the relevance of the
issue to be discussed for those members and
observers;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(f) keep all of the members of the college
informed, in a timely manner, of the decisions
and outcomes of those meetings.
Notwithstanding point (e), resolution authorities
shall be entitled to participate in resolution
college meetings whenever matters subject to
joint decision-making or relating to a group
entity located in their Member State are on the
agenda.
5. Group resolution authorities shall not be
obliged to establish a resolution college if other
groups or colleges perform the same functions
and carry out the same tasks specified in
paragraph 1 and comply with all the conditions
and procedures, including those covering
membership and participation in resolution
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
colleges, laid down in this Article and in Article
69. In such a case, all references to resolution
colleges in this Directive shall be understood as
references to those other groups or colleges.
6. EIOPA shall develop draft regulatory
standards to specify the operational functioning
of the resolution colleges for the performance of
the tasks referred to in paragraph 1.
EIOPA shall submit those draft regulatory
technical standards to the Commission by [PO –
add 18 months after entry into force].
Power is delegated to the Commission to adopt
the regulatory standards referred to in the first
subparagraph in accordance with Articles 10 to
14 of Regulation (EU) No 1094/2010.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 69
Information exchange
1. Subject to Article 64, resolution
authorities and supervisory authorities shall
provide one another on request with all the
information relevant for the exercise of the other
authorities’ tasks under this Directive.
2. The group resolution authority shall
coordinate the flow of all relevant information
between resolution authorities. In particular, the
group resolution authority shall provide the
resolution authorities in other Member States
with all the relevant information in a timely
manner to facilitate the exercise of the tasks
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
referred to in Article 68(1), second
subparagraph, points (b) to (h).
3. A resolution authority shall not transmit
information that has been provided by a third-
country supervisory or resolution authority
unless that third-country supervisory or
resolution authority has consented to such
transmission.
Resolution authorities shall not be obliged to
transmit such information if the third-country
supervisory or resolution authority has not
consented to its onward transmission.
Article 70
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Group resolution involving a subsidiary of
the group
1. A resolution authority that decides that
an insurance or reinsurance undertaking or any
entity as referred to in Article 1(1), points (b) to
(e), that is a subsidiary of a group, meets the
conditions for resolution laid down in Article
19(1) or Article 20(3), shall notify the following
information without delay to the group
resolution authority, if different, to the group
supervisor, and to the members of the resolution
college for the group in question:
(a) the decision that the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking or any entity referred to
in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), meets the
conditions laid down in Article 19 or 20;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the resolution actions or insolvency
measures that the resolution authority considers
to be appropriate for that insurance or
reinsurance undertaking or that entity referred to
in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e).
2. On receiving the notification referred to
in paragraph 1, the group resolution authority,
after having consulted the other members of the
resolution college concerned, shall assess the
likely impact of the resolution actions or other
measures notified in accordance with paragraph
1, point (b), on the group and on group entities
in other Member States, and whether the
resolution actions or other measures would
make it likely that the conditions for resolution
referred to in Article 19(1) or Article 20(3)
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
would be satisfied in relation to a group entity in
another Member State.
3. Where the group resolution authority
assesses that the resolution actions or other
measures notified in accordance with paragraph
1, point (b), would not make it likely that the
conditions laid down in Article 19(1) or Article
20(3) would be satisfied in relation to a group
entity in another Member State, the resolution
authority responsible for the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking or the entity referred to
in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), may take the
resolution actions or other measures that it
notified in accordance with paragraph 1, point
(b), of this Article.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
4. Where the group resolution authority
assesses that the resolution actions or other
measures notified in accordance with paragraph
1, point (b), would make it likely that the
conditions laid down in Article 19(1) or 20(3)
would be satisfied in relation to a group entity in
another Member State, the group resolution
authority shall, no later than 24 hours after
receiving the notification referred to in
paragraph 1, propose a group resolution scheme
and submit that scheme to the resolution
college. That 24-hour period may be extended
with the consent of the resolution authority
which made the notification referred to in
paragraph 1.
5. In the absence of an assessment by the
group resolution authority within 24 hours, or a
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
longer period that has been agreed, after having
received the notification referred to in paragraph
1, the resolution authority which made the
notification referred to in paragraph 1 may take
the resolution actions or other measures that it
notified in accordance with point (b) of that
paragraph.
6. The group resolution scheme referred to
in paragraph 4 shall:
(a) outline the resolution actions that the
resolution authorities concerned should take in
relation to the ultimate parent undertaking or
particular group entities to meet the resolution
objectives referred to in Article 18 and to
comply with the general principles governing
resolution referred to in Article 22;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) specify how the resolution actions
referred to in point (a) should be coordinated;
(c) establish a financing plan which takes
into account the group resolution plan and the
principles for sharing responsibility laid down in
that group resolution plan in accordance with
Article 10(2), point (e).
7. Subject to paragraph 8, the group
resolution scheme shall take the form of a joint
decision of the group resolution authority and
the resolution authorities responsible for the
subsidiaries that are covered by the group
resolution scheme.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
EIOPA may, at the request of a resolution
authority, assist the resolution authorities in
reaching a joint decision in accordance with
Article 31(2), point (c) of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010.
8. A resolution authority that disagrees
with the group resolution scheme proposed by
the group resolution authority or that considers
that, for reasons of protection of policy holders,
the real economy and financial stability, it needs
to take independent resolution actions or
measures other than those proposed in the group
resolution scheme in relation to an insurance or
reinsurance undertaking or an entity referred to
in of Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), shall:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) set out in detail the reasons for the
disagreement or the reasons to depart from the
group resolution scheme;
(b) notify the group resolution authority and
the other resolution authorities that are covered
by the group resolution scheme of the reasons
referred to in point (a);
(c) inform the group resolution authority
and the other resolution authorities that are
concerned by the group resolution scheme about
the resolution actions or measures it will take.
When setting out the reasons for its
disagreement, a resolution authority shall take
into consideration the group resolution plans
referred to in Article 11, the potential impact of
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the actions or measures it will take on policy
holders, the real economy and financial stability
in the Member States concerned, and the
potential effect of these resolution actions or
measures on other parts of the group.
9. Resolution authorities that do agree with
the group resolution scheme proposed by the
group resolution authority may reach a joint
decision on a group resolution scheme covering
group entities in their respective Member States
without the participation of the disagreeing
resolution authorities.
10. The joint decisions referred to in
paragraph 7 and 9 and the resolution actions or
measures taken in accordance with paragraph 8
shall be recognised as conclusive and applied by
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
the resolution authorities in the Member States
concerned.
11. Authorities shall take all actions and
measures referred to in this Article without
delay, and with due regard to the urgency of the
situation.
12. Where a group resolution scheme is not
implemented, resolution authorities shall, when
taking resolution actions in relation to any group
entity, cooperate closely within the resolution
college to achieve a coordinated resolution
strategy for all the group entities that are failing
or likely to fail.
13. Resolution authorities that take any
resolution action in relation to any group entity
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
shall inform the members of the resolution
college regularly and fully about those actions
or measures and their on-going progress.
Article 71
Group resolution involving an ultimate
parent undertaking
1. A group resolution authority that decides
that an ultimate parent undertaking for which it
is responsible meets the conditions referred to in
Article 19(1) or Article 20(3) shall notify the
information referred to in Article 70(1), points
(a) and (b), to the group supervisor and to the
other members of the resolution college of the
group in question without delay.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
The resolution actions or insolvency measures
referred to in Article 70(1), point (b), may
include the implementation of a group
resolution scheme drawn up in accordance with
Article 70(6) in any of the following
circumstances:
(a) the resolution actions or other measures
at parent level notified in accordance with
Article 70(1), point (b), make it likely that the
conditions laid down in Article 19(1) or Article
20(3) would be fulfilled in relation to a group
entity in another Member State;
(b) resolution actions or other measures at
parent level only are not sufficient to stabilise
the situation or are not likely to provide an
optimum outcome;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) the resolution authorities have
determined that one or more subsidiaries for
which they are responsible meet the conditions
referred to in Article 19(1) or Article 20(3);
(d) resolution actions or other measures at
group level will benefit the subsidiaries of the
group in a way that makes a group resolution
scheme appropriate.
2. Where the actions or measures proposed
by the group resolution authority under
paragraph 1 do not contain a group resolution
scheme, the group resolution authority shall take
its decision after having consulted the members
of the resolution college.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
3. Where the actions or measures proposed
by the group resolution authority under
paragraph 1 do contain a group resolution
scheme, the group resolution scheme shall take
the form of a joint decision of the group
resolution authority and the resolution
authorities responsible for the subsidiaries that
are covered by the group resolution scheme.
EIOPA may, at the request of a resolution
authority, assist the resolution authorities in
reaching a joint decision in accordance with
Article 31(2), point (c) of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010.
4. A resolution authority that disagrees
with or departs from the group resolution
scheme proposed by the group resolution
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
authority or considers that, for reasons of
financial stability, it needs to take independent
resolution actions or measures other than those
proposed in the group resolution scheme in
relation to an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking or entity as referred to in Article
1(1), points (b) to (e) shall:
(a) set out in detail the reasons for the
disagreement or the reasons to depart from the
group resolution scheme;
(b) notify the group resolution authority and
the other resolution authorities that are covered
by the group resolution scheme of the reasons
referred to in point (a);
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) inform the group resolution authority
and the other resolution authorities that are
covered by the group resolution scheme about
the actions or measures it intends to take.
When setting out the reasons for its
disagreement, the resolution authority
concerned shall give consideration to the group
resolution plans referred to in Article 11, the
potential impact of the actions or measures it
will take on financial stability in the Member
States concerned and the potential effect of the
resolution actions or measures on other parts of
the group.
5. Resolution authorities that do agree with
the group resolution scheme proposed by the
group resolution authority may reach a joint
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
decision on a group resolution scheme covering
group entities in their respective Member States
without the participation of the disagreeing
resolution authorities.
6. The joint decision referred to in
paragraph 3 or 5 and the actions and measures
referred to in paragraph 4 shall be recognised as
conclusive and applied by the resolution
authorities in the Member States concerned.
7. Authorities shall perform all actions and
measures referred to in paragraphs 1 to 6
without delay, and with due regard to the
urgency of the situation.
8. Where a group resolution scheme is not
implemented, resolution authorities shall, when
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
taking resolution action in relation to any group
entity, cooperate closely within the resolution
college to achieve a coordinated resolution
strategy for all affected group entities.
9. Resolution authorities that take
resolution action in relation to any group entity
shall inform the members of the resolution
college regularly and fully about those actions
or measures and their on-going progress.
TITLE V
RELATIONS WITH THIRD COUNTRIES
Article 72
Agreements with third countries
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
1. In accordance with Article 218 TFEU,
the Commission may submit to the Council
proposals for the negotiation of agreements with
one or more third countries regarding the means
of cooperation between the resolution
authorities and the third country authorities
concerned, amongst others to share information
sharing in connection with recovery and
resolution planning in relation to insurance and
reinsurance undertakings, third country
insurance and reinsurance undertakings, and
groups.
2. The agreements referred to in paragraph
1 shall seek to ensure the establishment of
processes and arrangements between resolution
authorities and the third country authorities
concerned for cooperation in carrying out some
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
or all of the tasks and exercising some or all of
the powers referred to in Article 76.
3. Member States may enter into bilateral
agreements with a third country regarding the
matters referred to in paragraphs 1 and 2 until
the entry into force of an agreement referred to
in paragraph 1 with the relevant third country to
the extent that such bilateral agreements are not
inconsistent with this Title.
Article 73
Recognition and enforcement of third-
country resolution proceedings
1. This Article shall apply in respect of
third-country resolution proceedings unless and
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
until an international agreement as referred to in
Article 72(1) enters into force with the third
country concerned. It shall also apply following
the entry into force of an international
agreement as referred to in Article 72(1) with
the third country concerned to the extent that
recognition and enforcement of third-country
resolution proceedings is not governed by that
agreement.
2. The resolution authority concerned shall
decide whether to recognise and enforce, except
as provided for in Article 74, third-country
resolution proceedings relating to a Union
subsidiary or a Union branch of a third-country
insurance or reinsurance undertaking or a parent
undertaking.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
The decision shall give due consideration to the
interests of each Member State where a third-
country insurance or reinsurance undertaking or
parent undertaking operates, and in particular on
the other parts of the group and on the policy
holders, the real economy and the financial
stability in those Member States.
3. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities are, as a minimum,
empowered to do the following:
(a) exercise the resolution powers in relation
to the following:
(i) assets of a third-country insurance or
reinsurance undertaking or parent undertaking
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
that are located in their Member State or
governed by the law of their Member State;
(ii) rights or liabilities of a third-country
insurance or reinsurance undertaking that are
booked by the Union branch in their Member
State or governed by the law of their Member
State, or where claims in relation to such rights
and liabilities are enforceable in their Member
State;
(b) perfect, including to require another
person to take action to perfect, a transfer of
shares or other instruments of ownership in a
Union subsidiary established in that Member
State;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) exercise the powers in Article 47, 48 or
49 in relation to the rights of any party to a
contract with an entity referred to in paragraph 1
of this Article, where such powers are necessary
in order to enforce third-country resolution
proceedings; and
(d) render unenforceable any right to
terminate, liquidate or accelerate contracts, or
affect the contractual rights, of entities referred
to in paragraph 1 and other group entities, where
such a right arises from resolution action taken
in respect of the third-country insurance or
reinsurance undertaking, parent undertaking of
such entities or other group entities, whether by
the third-country resolution authority itself or
otherwise pursuant to legal or regulatory
requirements as to resolution arrangements in
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
that country, provided that the substantive
obligations under the contract, including
payment and delivery obligations, and provision
of collateral, continue to be performed.
4. Resolution authorities may take, where
necessary in the public interest, resolution
action with respect to a parent undertaking
where the relevant third-country authority
determines that an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking that is a subsidiary of that parent
undertaking and that is incorporated in that third
country meets the conditions for resolution
under the law of that third country. To that end,
Member States shall ensure that resolution
authorities are empowered to use any resolution
power in respect of that parent undertaking, and
Article 46 shall apply.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
5. The recognition and enforcement of
third-country resolution proceedings shall be
without prejudice to any normal insolvency
proceedings under national law applicable,
where appropriate, in accordance with this
Directive.
Article 74
Right to refuse recognition or enforcement of
third-country resolution proceedings
The resolution authority may refuse to recognise
or to enforce third-country resolution
proceedings pursuant to Article 73 if it
considers:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) that the third-country resolution
proceedings would have adverse effects on
financial stability in the Member State in which
the resolution authority is based or that the
proceedings would have adverse effects on
financial stability in another Member State;
(b) that independent resolution action under
Article 75 in relation to a Union branch is
necessary to achieve one or more of the
resolution objectives referred to in Article 18;
(c) that creditors would not receive the same
treatment as third-country creditors with similar
legal rights under the third-country home
resolution proceedings;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(d) that recognition or enforcement of the
third-country resolution proceedings would have
material fiscal implications for the Member
State; or
(e) that the effects of such recognition or
enforcement would be contrary to the national
law.
Article 75
Resolution of Union branches
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities have the powers necessary
to act in relation to a Union branch that is not
subject to any third-country resolution
proceedings or that is subject to third-country
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
proceedings and one of the circumstances
referred to in Article 74 applies.
Member States shall ensure that Article 46
applies to the exercise of such powers.
2. Member States shall ensure that the
powers required in paragraph 1 may be
exercised by resolution authorities where the
resolution authority considers that action is
necessary in the public interest and one or more
of the following conditions is met:
(a) the Union branch no longer meets, or is
likely not to meet, the conditions imposed by
national law for its authorisation and operation
within that Member State and there is no
prospect that any private sector, supervisory or
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
relevant third-country action would restore the
branch to compliance or prevent failure in a
reasonable timeframe;
(b) the third-country insurance or
reinsurance undertaking is, in the opinion of the
resolution authority, unable or unwilling, or is
likely to be unable, to pay its obligations to
Union creditors, or obligations that have been
created or booked through the branch, such as
payments to policy holders or beneficiaries, as
they fall due and the resolution authority is
satisfied that no third-country resolution
proceedings or insolvency proceedings have
been or will be initiated in relation to that third-
country insurance or reinsurance undertaking in
a reasonable timeframe;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(c) the relevant third-country authority has
initiated third-country resolution proceedings in
relation to the third-country insurance or
reinsurance undertaking, or has notified to the
resolution authority its intention to initiate such
a proceeding.
3. Where a resolution authority takes an
independent action in relation to a Union
branch, it shall have regard to the resolution
objectives referred to in Article 18 and take the
action in accordance with the following
principles and requirements, insofar as they are
relevant:
(a) the principles set out in Article 22;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the requirements relating to the
application of the resolution tools in Title III,
Chapter II.
Article 76
Cooperation with third-country authorities
1. This Article shall apply in respect of
cooperation with a third country unless and until
an international agreement as referred to in
Article 72(1) enters into force with the relevant
third country. It shall also apply following the
entry into force of an international agreement
provided for in Article 72(1) with the relevant
third country to the extent that the subject matter
of this Article is not governed by that
agreement.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. EIOPA may conclude non-binding
framework cooperation arrangements with
relevant third-country authorities. The
framework cooperation agreements shall
establish processes and arrangements between
the participating authorities for sharing
information necessary for and cooperation in
carrying out some or all or the following tasks
and exercising some or all of the following
powers in relation to insurance or reinsurance
undertakings or groups:
(a) the development of resolution plans in
accordance with Articles 9 to 12 and similar
requirements under the law of the relevant third
countries;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) the assessment of the resolvability of
such insurance and reinsurance undertakings
and groups, in accordance with Articles 13 and
14 and similar requirements under the law of the
relevant third countries;
(c) the application of powers to address or
remove impediments to resolvability pursuant to
Articles 15 and 16 and any similar powers under
the law of the relevant third countries;
(d) the application of preventive measures
pursuant to Article 141 of Directive
2009/138/EC and similar powers under the law
of the relevant third countries;
(e) the application of resolution tools as
referred to in Article 26(3) and exercise of
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution powers and similar powers
exercisable by the relevant third-country
authorities.
3. Supervisory or resolution authorities,
where appropriate, may conclude cooperation
arrangements in line with the EIOPA framework
arrangement referred to in paragraph 2 with
relevant third country authorities.
4. Member States shall notify EIOPA of
any cooperation arrangements that resolution
authorities and supervisory authorities have
concluded in accordance with this Article.
Article 77
Exchange of confidential information
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities, supervisory authorities
and competent ministries exchange confidential
information, including pre-emptive recovery
plans drawn up and maintained in accordance
with Articles 5 and 7, with relevant third-
country authorities only if the following
conditions are met:
(a) those third-country authorities are
subject to requirements and standards of
professional secrecy at least considered to be
equivalent, in the opinion of all the authorities
concerned, to those imposed by Article 64.
(b) the information is necessary for the
performance by the relevant third-country
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
authorities of their resolution functions under
national law that are comparable to those under
this Directive and, subject to point (a), is not
used for any other purposes.
For the purposes of point (a), in so far as the
exchange of information relates to personal
data, the handling and transmission of such
personal data to third-country authorities shall
be governed by the applicable Union and
national data protection law.
2. Where confidential information
originates in another Member State, resolution
authorities, supervisory authorities and
competent ministries shall not disclose that
information to relevant third-country authorities
unless the following conditions are met:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) the relevant authority of the Member
State where the information originated (the
originating authority) agrees to that disclosure;
(b) the information is disclosed only for the
purposes permitted by the originating authority.
TITLE VI
PENALTIES
Article 78
Administrative penalties and other
administrative measures
1. Without prejudice to the powers of
resolution and supervisory authorities laid down
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
in this Directive and Directive 2009/138/EC and
the right of Member States to provide for and
impose criminal penalties referred to in the
second subparagraph, Member States shall lay
down rules on administrative penalties and other
administrative measures applicable where the
national provisions transposing this Directive
have not been complied with, and shall take all
measures necessary to ensure that they are
implemented.
Member States that decide not to lay down rules
for administrative penalties or other
administrative measures for infringements
which are subject to national criminal law shall
communicate to the Commission the criminal
law provisions concerned.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
The administrative penalties and other
administrative measures shall be effective,
proportionate and dissuasive.
2. Member States shall ensure that in the
event of an infringement, administrative
penalties or other administrative measures can
be applied, subject to the conditions laid down
in national law, to the members of the
administrative, management or supervisory
body, and to other natural persons who under
national law are responsible for the
infringement.
3. The powers to impose administrative
penalties and other administrative measures
provided for in this Directive shall be attributed
to resolution authorities or to supervisory
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
authorities, depending on the type of
infringement. Resolution authorities and
supervisory authorities shall have all
information-gathering and investigatory powers
that are necessary for the exercise of their
respective functions. In the exercise of their
powers to impose administrative penalties or
other administrative measures, resolution
authorities and supervisory authorities shall
cooperate closely to ensure that administrative
penalties or other administrative measures
produce the desired results and coordinate their
action when dealing with cross-border cases.
4. Resolution authorities and supervisory
authorities shall exercise their administrative
powers to impose penalties and other
administrative measures in accordance with this
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Directive and national law in any of the
following ways:
(a) directly;
(b) in collaboration with other authorities;
(c) under their responsibility by delegation
to other authorities;
(d) by application to the competent judicial
authorities.
5. Member States shall ensure that
decisions taken by the resolution authorities and
supervisory authorities in accordance with this
Title are subject to a right of appeal.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 79
Specific provisions on administrative
penalties and other administrative measures
1. Member States shall ensure that their
laws, regulations and administrative provisions
provide for administrative penalties and other
administrative measures at least in respect of the
following situations:
(a) an infringement of Articles 5 or 7 by
failing to draw up, maintain and update pre-
emptive recovery plans and group pre-emptive
recovery plans;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) an infringement of Article 12 by failing
to provide all the information necessary for the
development of resolution plans;
(c) an infringement of Article 61(1) by the
failure of the administrative, management or
supervisory body of an insurance or reinsurance
undertaking or an entity as referred to in Article
1(1), points (b) to (e), to notify the supervisory
authority when that undertaking or that entity is
failing or likely to fail.
2. Member States shall ensure that, in the
cases referred to in paragraph 1, the
administrative penalties and other administrative
measures that can be applied include at least the
following:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(a) a public statement indicating the natural
person, insurance or reinsurance undertaking,
the entity as referred to in Article 1(1), points
(b) to (e), an ultimate parent undertaking or
other legal person responsible for the
infringement and the nature of the infringement;
(b) an order requiring the natural or legal
person responsible to cease the conduct and to
desist from a repetition of that conduct;
(c) a temporary ban on any member of the
administrative, management or supervisory
body or senior management of the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking or an entity as referred
to in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), or any other
natural person who is held responsible, to
exercise functions in an insurance or reinsurance
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
undertaking or an entity as referred to in Article
1(1), points (b) to (e);
(d) in the case of a legal person,
administrative fines of up to 10 % of the total
annual turnover of that legal person in the
preceding business year;
(e) in the case of a natural person,
administrative fines of up to EUR 5 000 000, or
in the Member States where the Euro is not the
official currency, the corresponding value in the
national currency on [PO – please add date of
entry into force of this Directive];
(f) administrative fines of up to twice the
amount of the benefit derived from the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
infringement where that benefit can be
determined.
For the purposes of point (d), where the legal
person is a subsidiary of a parent undertaking,
the relevant turnover shall be the total annual
turnover resulting from the consolidated
accounts of the ultimate parent undertaking in
the preceding business year.
Article 80
Publication of administrative penalties and
other administrative measures
1. Member States shall ensure that
resolution authorities and supervisory
authorities publish on their official website at
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
least any administrative penalties and other
administrative measures imposed by those
authorities for infringing the national provisions
transposing this Directive where such
administrative penalties or other administrative
measures have not been the subject of an appeal
or where the right of appeal has been exhausted.
Such publication shall be made without undue
delay after the natural or legal person is
informed of that administrative penalty or other
administrative measure. The publication shall
contain information on the type and nature of
the infringement and the identity of the natural
or legal person on whom the administrative
penalty or other administrative measure is
imposed.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Where Member States permit publication of
administrative penalties and other administrative
measures against which there is an appeal,
resolution authorities and supervisory
authorities shall, without undue delay, publish
on their official websites information on the
status of that appeal and the outcome thereof.
2. Where the resolution authority or
supervisory authority considers that the
publication of the identity of the legal persons,
or identity or personal data of natural persons
would be disproportionate following a case-by-
case assessment conducted on the
proportionality of the publication of such data,
or where such a publication would jeopardise
the stability of financial markets or an ongoing
investigation, the resolution authority or
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
supervisory authority shall do any of the
following:
(a) defer the publication of the decision
imposing the administrative penalty or other
administrative measures until the reasons for
that deferral cease to exist;
(b) publish the decision imposing the
administrative penalty or other administrative
measures on an anonymous basis in accordance
with national law where such anonymous
publication would ensure the effective
protection of the personal data concerned;
(c) not publish the decision imposing the
administrative penalty or other administrative
measures where the resolution authority or
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
supervisory authority is of the opinion that
publication in accordance with point (a) or (b)
would be insufficient to ensure either of the
following:
(i) that the stability of financial markets is
not jeopardised;
(ii) the proportionality of the publication of
such data with regard to measures which are
deemed to be of a minor nature.
Resolution authorities and supervisory
authorities shall ensure that any publication in
accordance with this Article shall remain on
their official website for a period of at least five
years after its publication. Personal data
contained in the publication shall only be kept
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
on the official website of the resolution
authority or the supervisory authority for the
period which is necessary according to
applicable data protection rules.
Article 81
Maintenance of central database by EIOPA
1. Subject to the professional secrecy
requirements referred to in Article 64, resolution
authorities and supervisory authorities shall
inform EIOPA of all administrative penalties
and other administrative measures imposed by
them under Article 79 and of the status of that
appeal and outcome thereof.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
EIOPA shall maintain and keep updated a
central database of penalties and other
administrative measures reported to it by
resolution authorities, solely to enable those
resolution authorities to exchange information,
which shall be accessible to those resolution
authorities only.
EIOPA shall maintain and keep updated a
central database of penalties and other
administrative measures reported to it by
supervisory authorities, solely to enable those
supervisory authorities to exchange information,
which shall be accessible to those supervisory
authorities only.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. EIOPA shall maintain and keep updated
a webpage with the following information or
links to that information:
(a) each resolution authority’s publication of
penalties;
(b) each supervisory authority’s publication
of penalties under Article 80;
(c) the period for which each Member State
publishes penalties.
Article 82
Effective application of penalties and exercise
of powers to impose penalties by supervisory
authorities and resolution authorities
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Member States shall ensure that when
determining the type of administrative penalties
or other administrative measures and the level
of administrative fines, the supervisory
authorities and resolution authorities take into
account all relevant circumstances, including
where appropriate:
(a) the gravity and the duration of the
infringement;
(b) the degree of responsibility of the natural
or legal person responsible;
(c) the financial strength of the natural or
legal person responsible;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(d) the amount of profits gained or losses
avoided by the natural or legal person
responsible, insofar as those profits or losses can
be determined;
(e) the losses for third parties, including
policy holders, caused by the infringement,
insofar those losses can be determined;
(f) the level of cooperation of the natural or
legal person responsible with the supervisory
authority and the resolution authority;
(g) previous infringements by the natural or
legal person responsible.
For the purposes of point (c), the indicators of
financial strength of a natural or legal person
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
shall include the total turnover of the
responsible legal person or the annual income of
the responsible natural person.
TITLE VII
AMENDMENTS TO DIRECTIVES
2002/47/EC, 2004/25/EC, 2009/138/EC, (EU)
2017/1132 AND TO REGULATIONS (EU) No
1094/2010 AND (EU) No 648/2012
Article 83
Amendments to Directive 2009/138/EC
Directive 2009/138/EC is amended as follows:
(1) Article 141 is replaced by the following:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘Article 141
Supervisory powers in deteriorating financial
conditions
1. Following a notification pursuant to
Article 136 or following the identification of
deteriorating financial conditions pursuant to
Article 36(3), where the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking’s decisions, including
financial ones, would result in the following
three months or already result in non-
compliance with any of the items referred to in
Article 36(2), points (a) to (e), the supervisory
authorities shall have the power to take the
necessary measures to restore compliance.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
2. The measures referred to in paragraph 1
shall be proportionate to the risk and to the
extent of non-compliance with regulatory
requirements, and may contain the following:
(a) requiring the administrative,
management, or supervisory body of the
undertaking to update the pre-emptive recovery
plan drawn up in accordance with Article 5 of
Directive (EU) xx/xx of the European
Parliament and of the Council*1, where the
circumstances are different from the
assumptions set out in that plan;
(b) requiring the administrative,
management, or supervisory body of the
undertaking to take measures set out in the pre-
emptive recovery plan drawn up in accordance
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
with Article 5 of Directive (EU) xx/xx [PO,
please insert the number of the IRRD]. Where
the plan is updated pursuant to point (a), the
measures taken shall contain any updated
measures;
(c) requiring the administrative,
management, or supervisory body of an
undertaking that does not have in place a pre-
emptive recovery plan as referred to in Article 5
of Directive (EU) xx/xx [PO, please insert the
number of the IRRD] , to identify the causes of
the non-compliance or likely non-compliance
with regulatory requirements and to identify
suitable measures and a timeframe for the
implementation of those regulatory
requirements;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(d) requiring the administrative,
management, or supervisory body of the
undertaking to suspend or restrict variable
remuneration and bonuses, distributions on own
fund instruments or repayment or repurchase of
own fund items.
3. Where the solvency position of the
undertaking continues to deteriorate following a
notification as referred to in Articles 138(1) or
139(1), the supervisory authorities shall have
the power to take all measures, including those
referred to in paragraph 2, which are necessary
to safeguard the interests of policy holders in the
case of insurance contracts, or the obligations
arising out of reinsurance contracts.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Those measures shall be proportionate and thus
reflect the level of the deterioration of the
solvency position of the insurance or
reinsurance undertaking concerned.
_______________________________________
__________________________
*1 Directive (EU) xx/xx of the European Parliament and of the
Council [PO, please insert reference to the IRRD].’;
(2) in Article 267, the following
subparagraphs are added:
‘In the event of an application of the resolution
tools referred to in Article 26(3) of Directive
(EU) xx/xx [PO, please insert the number of the
IRRD] and exercise of the resolution powers
referred to in Chapter IV, Title III, of that
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Directive , this Title shall also apply to
reinsurance undertakings and the entities
referred to in Article 1(1), points (b) to (e), of
that Directive.
Articles 270 and 272 of this Directive shall not
apply where Article 63 of Directive (EU) xx/xx
[PO, please insert the number of the IRRD]
applies.
Article 295 of this Directive shall not apply
where Article 64 of Directive (EU) xx/xx [PO,
please insert the number of the IRRD] applies.’;
(3) Article 268(1) is amended as follows:
(a) point (a) is replaced by the following:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘(a) ‘competent authorities’ means either the
administrative or judicial authorities of the
Member States that are competent for
reorganisation measures or for the winding-up
proceedings, or a resolution authority as defined
in Article 2(2), point (7), of Directive (EU)
xx/xx [PO, please insert the number of the
IRRD] in respect of reorganisation measures
taken pursuant to that Directive;’;
(b) point (c) is replaced by the following:
‘(c) ‘reorganisation measures’ means
measures involving any intervention by the
competent authorities which are intended to
preserve or restore the financial situation of an
insurance undertaking and which affect pre-
existing rights of parties other than the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
insurance undertaking itself, including the
suspension of payments or enforcement
measures or the reduction of claims, the
application of the resolution tools referred to in
Article 26(3) of Directive (EU) xx/xx [PO,
please insert the number of the IRRD] and the
exercise of resolution powers referred to in
Chapter IV, Title III, of Directive (EU) xx/xx
[PO, please insert the number of the IRRD];’.
Article 84
Amendments to Directive 2002/47/EC
Directive 2002/47/EC is amended as follows:
(1) in Article 1, paragraph 6 is replaced by
the following:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘6. Articles 4 to 7 of this Directive shall not
apply to any restriction on the enforcement of
financial collateral arrangements or any
restriction on the effect of a security financial
collateral arrangement, any close out netting or
set-off provision that is imposed by virtue of
Title IV, Chapter V or VI of Directive
2014/59/EU of the European Parliament and of
the Council*2, or of Title V, Chapter III, Section
3, or Chapter IV of Regulation (EU) 2021/23 of
the European Parliament and of the Council*3,
or of Title III, Chapter III, Section 4, or Chapter
IV of Directive (EU) xx/xx of the European
Parliament and of the Council*4, or to any such
restriction that is imposed by virtue of similar
powers in the law of a Member State to
facilitate the orderly resolution of any entity as
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
referred to in paragraph 2, point (d), of this
Article which is subject to safeguards at least
equivalent to those set out in Title IV, Chapter
VII of Directive 2014/59/EU and in Title V,
Chapter V of Regulation (EU) 2021/23;
_______________________________________
_______________________
*2
Directive 2014/59/EU of the European Parliament and of the
Council of 15 May 2014 establishing a framework for the recovery and
resolution of credit institutions and investment firms and amending
Council Directive 82/891/EEC and Directives 2001/24/EC, 2002/47/EC,
2004/25/EC, 2005/56/EC, 2007/36/EC, 2011/35/EU, 2012/30/EU and
2013/36/EU, and Regulations (EU) No 1093/2010 and (EU) No
648/2012, of the European Parliament and of the Council (OJ L 173,
12.6.2014, p. 190).
*3 Regulation (EU) 2021/23 of the European Parliament and of
the Council of 16 December 2020 on a framework for the recovery and
resolution of central counterparties and amending Regulations (EU) No
1095/2010, (EU) No 648/2012, (EU) No 600/2014, (EU) No 806/2014
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
and (EU) 2015/2365 and Directives 2002/47/EC, 2004/25/EC,
2007/36/EC, 2014/59/EU and (EU) 2017/1132 (OJ L 22, 22.1.2021, p.
1).
*4 [PO, please insert reference to the IRRD].’;
(2) Article 9a is replaced by the following:
‘Article 9a
Directive 2008/48/EC, Directive 2014/59/EU,
Directive (EU) xx/xx and Regulation (EU)
2021/23
This Directive shall be without prejudice to
Directive 2008/48/EC, Directive 2014/59/EU,
Directive (EU) xx/xx of the European
Parliament and of the Council*5 [PO, please
insert the number of the IRRD] and Regulation
(EU) 2021/23.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
_______________________________________
________________
*5
Directive xx/xx/EU of the European Parliament
and of the Council [PO, please insert reference to the
IRRD]’.
Article 85
Amendment to Directive 2004/25/EC
In Article 4(5) of Directive 2004/25/EC, the
following subparagraph is added:
‘Member States shall ensure that Article 5(1) of
this Directive does not apply in the case of
application of resolution tools, powers and
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
mechanisms provided for in Title IV of
Directive 2014/59/EU, in Title V of Regulation
(EU) 2021/23 of the European Parliament and
of the Council*6 or in Title III of Directive (EU)
xx/xx of the European Parliament and of the
Council*7 [PO, please insert the number of the
IRRD].
_______________________________________
____________________
*6 Regulation (EU) 2021/23 of the European Parliament and of
the Council of 16 December 2020 on a framework for the recovery and
resolution of central counterparties and amending Regulations (EU) No
1095/2010, (EU) No 648/2012, (EU) No 600/2014, (EU) No 806/2014
and (EU) 2015/2365 and Directives 2002/47/EC, 2004/25/EC,
2007/36/EC, 2014/59/EU and (EU) 2017/1132 (OJ L 22, 22.1.2021, p.
1).
*7 Directive xx/xx/EU of the European Parliament and of the
Council [PO, please insert reference to the IRRD]’.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Article 86
Amendments to Directive 2007/36/EC
In Article 1 of Directive 2007/36/EC, paragraph
4 is replaced by the following:
‘4. Member States shall ensure that this
Directive does not apply in the case of the use of
resolution tools, powers and mechanisms
provided for in Title IV of Directive
2014/59/EU of the European Parliament and of
the Council*8, in Title V of Regulation (EU)
2021/23 of the European Parliament and of the
Council*9 or in Title III of Directive (EU) xx/xx
of the European Parliament and of the
Council*10 [PO, please insert the number of the
IRRD].
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
_______________________________________
_______________
*8 Directive 2014/59/EU of the European Parliament and of the
Council of 15 May 2014 establishing a framework for the recovery and
resolution of credit institutions and investment firms and amending
Council Directive 82/891/EEC and Directives 2001/24/EC, 2002/47/EC,
2004/25/EC, 2005/56/EC, 2007/36/EC, 2011/35/EU, 2012/30/EU and
2013/36/EU, and Regulations (EU) No 1093/2010 and (EU) No
648/2012, of the European Parliament and of the Council (OJ L 173,
12.6.2014, p. 190).
*9 Regulation (EU) 2021/23 of the European Parliament and of
the Council of 16 December 2020 on a framework for the recovery and
resolution of central counterparties and amending Regulations (EU) No
1095/2010, (EU) No 648/2012, (EU) No 600/2014, (EU) No 806/2014
and (EU) 2015/2365 and Directives 2002/47/EC, 2004/25/EC,
2007/36/EC, 2014/59/EU and (EU) 2017/1132 (OJ L 22, 22.1.2021, p.
1).
*10 Directive XX/XX/EU of the European Parliament and of the
Council [PO, please insert reference to the IRRD]’.’
Article 87
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Amendment to Directive (EU) 2017/1132
Directive (EU) 2017/1132 is amended as
follows:
(1) in Article 84, paragraph 3 is replaced by
the following:
‘3. Member States shall ensure that Article
49, Article 58(1), Article 68(1), (2) and (3), the
first subparagraph of Article 70(2), Articles 72
to 75, 79, 80 and 81 of this Directive do not
apply in the case of application of the resolution
tools, powers and mechanisms provided for in
Title IV of Directive 2014/59/EU of the
European Parliament and of the Council*11, in
Title V of Regulation (EU) 2021/23 of the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
European Parliament and of the Council*12 or in
Title III of Directive (EU) xx/xx of the
European Parliament and of the Council*13.
_______________________________________
_______________
*11 Directive 2014/59/EU of the European Parliament and of the
Council of 15 May 2014 establishing a framework for the recovery and
resolution of credit institutions and investment firms and amending
Council Directive 82/891/EEC and Directives 2001/24/EC, 2002/47/EC,
2004/25/EC, 2005/56/EC, 2007/36/EC, 2011/35/EU, 2012/30/EU and
2013/36/EU, and Regulations (EU) No 1093/2010 and (EU) No
648/2012, of the European Parliament and of the Council (OJ L 173,
12.6.2014, p. 190).
*12 Regulation (EU) 2021/23 of the European Parliament and of
the Council of 16 December 2020 on a framework for the recovery and
resolution of central counterparties and amending Regulations (EU) No
1095/2010, (EU) No 648/2012, (EU) No 600/2014, (EU) No 806/2014
and (EU) 2015/2365 and Directives 2002/47/EC, 2004/25/EC,
2007/36/EC, 2014/59/EU and (EU) 2017/1132 (OJ L 22, 22.1.2021, p.
1).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
*13 Directive (EU) XX/XX of the European Parliament and of
the Council [PO, please insert reference to the IRRD].’;
(2) Article 86a is amended as follows:
(a) in paragraph 3, point (b) is replaced by
the following:
‘(b) the company is subject to resolution
tools, powers and mechanisms provided for in
Title IV of Directive 2014/59/EU, in Title V of
Regulation (EU) 2021/23 or in Title III of
Directive (EU) xx/xx [PO, please insert the
number of the IRRD].’;
(b) in paragraph 4, point (c) is replaced by
the following:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘(c) the subject of crisis prevention measures
as defined in point (101) of Article 2(1) of
Directive 2014/59/EU, in point (48) of Article 2
of Regulation (EU) 2021/23 or in point (75) of
Article 2(2) of Directive (EU) xx/xx [PO, please
insert the number of the IRRD].’;
(3) in Article 87, paragraph 4 is replaced by
the following:
‘4. Member States shall ensure that this
Chapter does not apply to companies which are
the subject of the application of resolution tools,
powers and mechanisms provided for in Title IV
of Directive 2014/59/EU, in Title V of
Regulation (EU) 2021/23 or in Title III of
Directive (EU) xx/xx [PO, please insert the
number of the IRRD].’;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(4) Article 120 is amended as follows:
(a) in paragraph 4, point (b) is replaced by
the following:
‘(b) the company is subject to resolution
tools, powers and mechanisms provided for in
Title IV of Directive 2014/59/EU, in Title V of
Regulation (EU) 2021/23 or in Title III of
Directive (EU) xx/xx [PO, please insert the
number of the IRRD].’;
(b) in paragraph 5, point (c) is replaced by
the following:
‘(c) the subject of crisis prevention measures
as defined in point (101) of Article 2(1) of
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Directive 2014/59/EU, in point (48) of Article 2
of Regulation (EU) 2021/23 or in point (75) of
Article 2(2) of Directive (EU) xx/xx [PO, please
insert the number of the IRRD].’;
(5) Article 160a is amended as follows:
(a) in paragraph 4, point (b) is replaced by
the following:
‘(b) the company is subject to resolution
tools, powers and mechanisms provided for in
Title IV of Directive 2014/59/EU, in Title V of
Regulation (EU) 2021/23 or in Title III of
Directive (EU) xx/xx [PO, please insert
reference to the IRRD].’;
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(b) in paragraph 5, point (c) is replaced by
the following:
‘(c) the subject of crisis prevention measures
as defined in point (101) of Article 2(1) of
Directive 2014/59/EU, in point (48) of Article 2
of Regulation (EU) 2021/23 or in point (75) of
Article 2(2) of Directive (EU) xx/xx [PO, please
insert reference to the IRRD].’.
Article 88
Amendment to Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010
Regulation (EU) No 1094/2010 is amended as
follows:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
(1) in Article 4, in point (2), point (i) is
replaced by the following:
‘(i) supervisory authorities as defined in
Article 13, point (10) of Directive 2009/138/EC,
resolution authorities as defined in Article 2,
point (7), of Directive (EU) xx/xx of the
European Parliament and of the Council*14, and
competent authorities as defined in Article 6,
point (8), of Directive (EU) 2016/2341 of the
European Parliament and of the Council*15 and
as referred to in Directive (EU) 2016/97 of the
European Parliament and of the Council*16;’
(2) in Article 40(6), the following
subparagraph is added:
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
‘For the purposes of acting within the scope of
Directive (EU) xx/xx [PO, please insert the
number of the IRRD], the member of the Board
of Supervisors referred to in point (b) of
paragraph 1 may, where appropriate, be
accompanied by a representative from the
resolution authority in each Member State, who
shall be non-voting.
_______________________________________
__________________________
*14 [PO, please insert the reference to the IRRD].
*15 Directive (EU) 2016/2341 of the European Parliament and of
the Council of 14 December 2016 on the activities and supervision of
institutions for occupational retirement provision (IORPs) (OJ L 354,
23.12.2016, p. 37).
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
*16 Directive (EU) 2016/97 of the European Parliament and of
the Council of 20 January 2016 on insurance distribution (OJ L 26,
2.2.2016, p. 19).’.
Article 89
Amendment to Regulation (EU) No 648/2012
In Article 81(3) of Regulation (EU) No
648/2012, the following point is added:
‘(r) the resolution authorities designated
under Article 3 of Directive (EU) xx/xx of the
European Parliament and of the Council*17.
_______________________________________
________________________
*17 [PO, please insert the reference to the IRRD].’.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
TITLE VIII
FINAL PROVISIONS
Article 90
EIOPA Resolution Committee
1. EIOPA shall create a permanent internal
committee pursuant to Article 41 of Regulation
(EU) No 1094/2010 to prepare EIOPA decisions
as referred to in Article 44 of that Regulation,
including decisions about draft regulatory
technical standards and draft implementing
technical standards concerning tasks that have
been conferred on resolution authorities in
accordance with this Directive. That internal
committee shall be composed of the resolution
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
authorities referred to in Article 3 of this
Directive.
2. For the purposes of this Directive,
EIOPA shall cooperate with EBA and ESMA
within the framework of the Joint Committee of
the European Supervisory Authorities
established in Article 54 of Regulation (EU) No
1093/2010, of Regulation (EU) No 1094/2010
and of Regulation (EU) No 1095/2010.
3. For the purposes of this Directive,
EIOPA shall ensure structural separation
between the resolution committee and other
functions referred to in Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010. The resolution committee shall
promote the development and coordination of
resolution plans and develop methods for the
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
resolution of entities as referred to in Article
1(1) of this Directive that are failing.
Article 91
Cooperation with EIOPA
1. Member States shall ensure that the
supervisory and resolution authorities cooperate
with EIOPA for the purposes of this Directive in
accordance with Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010.
2. Member States shall ensure that the
supervisory and resolution authorities, without
delay, provide EIOPA with all the information
necessary to carry out its duties in accordance
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
with Article 35 of Regulation (EU) No
1094/2010.
Article 92
Transposition
1. Member States shall adopt and publish,
by [PO – add 18 months after entry into force]
at the latest, the laws, regulations and
administrative provisions necessary to comply
with Articles 1 to 87, 90 and 91 of this
Directive. They shall forthwith communicate to
the Commission the text of those provisions.
Articles 88 and 89 shall, however, be binding in
their entirety and directly applicable in all
Member States.
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
They shall apply Articles 1 to 87, 90 and 91
from [PO – add 18 months and one day after
entry into force].
When Member States adopt Articles 1 to 87, 90
and 91, they shall include a reference to this
Directive or be accompanied by such a
reference on the occasion of their official
publication. Member States shall determine how
such reference is to be made.
2. Member States shall communicate to the
Commission the text of the main provisions of
national law which they adopt in the field
covered by this Directive.
Article 93
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
Entry into force
This Directive shall enter into force on the
twentieth day following that of its publication in
the Official Journal of the European Union.
Article 94
Addressees
This Directive is addressed to the Member
States.
Done at Brussels,
For the European Parliament For the Council
The President The President
Commission proposal (ST 11764/21 – COM(2021) 582 final) Deadline: 20 October 2021 cob
Proposal for a Insurance Recovery and Resolution directive
Important: In order to guarantee that your comments appear accurately, please do not modify the table format by adding/removing/adjusting/merging/splitting cells and rows. This would hinder the
consolidation of your comments.
Commission proposal Drafting Suggestions Comments
End End