TECHNICAL ASSESSMENT AND MONITORING DIRECTORATE
LOANS AND SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT DIRECTORATE
Ms Marge Kaljas
Head of State Treasury Department
Ministry of Finance
Suur-Ameerika 1
10122 Tallinn
Estonia
Email:
[email protected]
October 7, 2021
Subject: Technical Monitoring Review of Public Financial Facility Loan LD 2058 (2020)
Supporting Estonia to tackle the COVID-19 Pandemic
Dear Ms Kaljas,
We would like to thank you and your colleagues for the excellent support and information provided
for the CEB Technical Assessment and Monitoring Directorate’s (TAM) review for the above-
referenced loan which took place via Video-Conference meetings in July. We take this opportunity
to share with you the review’s main conclusions, recommendations and next steps:
• The Public Financial Facility (PFF) loan has co-financed the Government of Estonia’s
supplementary budget to address the socio-economic and health impact of the COVID-19
pandemic, covering grant support to local governments, the extension of internet
connectivity to rural areas, grant support to companies affected by the COVID-10 pandemic
and health-related expenditures.
• The budget expenditure support to local governments has ensured continuity of local
services for communities during the pandemic, and enabled local governments to
accelerate implementation of planned infrastructure works and to ensure adequate
maintenance of local roads. The focus on local government support has contributed to build
the trust and confidence that local governments needed to avoid short-term expenditure
cuts, which would have jeopardized the provision of essential services.
• The additional budget allocated to the extension of internet connection has contributed to
reduce the large urban-rural gap in internet connectivity in Estonia. The measures to
subsidize end-users’ internet connection in low-density, rural areas was driven by the need
to ensure equitable access to distance learning and remote working across the country.
• The grants managed by Enterprise Estonia have compensated small companies and
tourism companies for the economic losses due to the pandemic, ensuring business
continuity and mitigating the economic impact of the pandemic on local employment. A
study carried out by the National Audit Office indicates that the grants have reached the
companies that were most affected by the pandemic, ensuring cost effectiveness and
maximizing the economic impact of the resources.
55, avenue Kléber • F-75116 PARIS • Tél : +33 (0)1 47 55 55 00 • Fax : +33 (0)1 47 55 03 38
Swift : CEFPFRPP • www.coebank.org
• The health expenditures have improved epidemiological surveillance of the pandemic and
contributed to better adapt protection measures, thus reducing the number of affected
people. Strengthening of the epidemiological surveillance capacity allows for better
organization of the health care system, reducing the burden on the infrastructure and the
cost on the economy.
• The comprehensive package of measures approved under the supplementary budget has
allowed the Government of Estonia to quickly respond to the crisis and pave the way for the
long-term recovery. Local governments have demonstrated the capacity to absorb the
additional grant funds, and adjust their investment budget in a short period of time. The
eligibility of the investment grants to local governments has been broadened in 2021 to
include the financing of ongoing investments in order to provide local governments with
more flexibility in the allocation of funds.
• The overall performance of the COVID-19 PFF loan is assessed as highly satisfactory given
the broad scope and impact of the Government’s emergency measures introduced to
support local governments, communities and the private sector in response to the COVID-
19 crisis; the strong institutional and implementation arrangements in place to ensure timely
execution of the measures, and the robust monitoring arrangements, including ex-post
monitoring of the grant support to companies.
We also would like to share with you the following recommendations and next steps for your
consideration:
• Kindly notify the CEB prior to submitting the monitoring report with the final allocation in
case additional expenditure items related to the health sector would need to be co-financed
under the PFF loan; a separate technical review may be carried out for the new
expenditures;
• If CEB funds are allocated to the component managed by the Rural Development
Foundation for on-lending funds to MSMEs via financial intermediaries, a separate
technical review for this component would be carried out in due course.
We look forward to continuing our cooperation, and we remain at your disposal would you require
any further information or assistance.
Yours sincerely,
Elisa Muzzini Karin Lepp
Technical Advisor Country Manager
cc:
Katrin Luts, State Treasury Department, Ministry of Finance, E-mail:
[email protected]
Riina Laigo, European Union and International Cooperation Department, Ministry of Finance,
E-mail:
[email protected]
55, avenue Kléber • F-75116 PARIS • Tél : +33 (0)1 47 55 55 00 • Fax : +33 (0)1 47 55 03 38
Swift : CEFPFRPP • www.coebank.org
2