Saatja: Ute Koczy <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 14.10.2021 11:02
Adressaat: Ute Koczy <
[email protected]>
Teema: World Bank Action Day 2021: Letter to Governors and Executive
Directors to end all Actions to Promote Coal, Oil and Gas
Dear Governors to the World Bank,
It is my honor to share with you this joint letter from international
civil society.
Yours sincerely,
Ute Koczy
*************************Ute KoczyUrgewald e.V.M +49 171 707 6028T +49
2583 30492 - 0
skype: ute-koczy
Von-Galen Straße 448336 SassenbergTwitter:
@urgewald************************
Civil Society Groups
#World Bank Ac on Day 2021
October 14, 2021
Open Le er
To the Governors and Execu ve Directors of the World Bank Group
CC: David Malpass,
President of the World Bank Group
Dear Governors and Execu ve Directors,
The drama c news from the IPCC Working Group 1 report released this year about the state
of the world's climate breakdown prompts us to ask you to fill the World Bank Group with
new management, from the top down. It is high me for the World Bank Group to
immediately end all ac ons that promote coal, oil and gas, and to support countries on a just
transi on to renewable, resilient and inclusive development pathways. Unfortunately, to
this day, direct and indirect WBG support con nues to flow into fossil energies and into
propping up fossil fuel industry profits, with damaging results to communi es and country
economies.
The failure of the WBG to posi on itself with science and jus ce when it comes to climate
change mi ga on undermines the mission of the ins tu on. This is, no doubt, in part a
reflec on of a diversity of poli cal posi ons on the WBG Board. However, it is also a factor
of an established culture and bias among WBG management that has contributed to the
perpetua on of fossil fuel dependent development pathways globally, despite advances in
climate and energy science, technology, policies and best prac ces, and despite long- me
calls from civil society globally for a paradigm shi . The WBG's investments and policy advice
have been a significant normalizing force in dirty and harmful global development pathways,
limi ng for far too long the terms and parameters of the conversa on of what is possible,
what is needed, and what is desired by the people who the World Bank is mandated to serve
when it comes to the energy systems powering countries' development.
While Presidents of the World Bank are appointed and accountable to the Board, they are
hardly mere puppets: they have the ability to steer the strategic direc on of the WBG, and
therefore, the choice of personnel makes all the difference, and leads us to conclude:
personnel is policy. Unfortunately, the WBG's management has failed repeated calls for
serious and just ac on on climate change.
In 2017, nine mul lateral development banks (MDB), including the World Bank, commi ed
to align their financial flows with the goals of the Paris Agreement. Earlier this year, over 150
organiza ons sent a le er calling on World Bank President David Malpass to adopt a whole-
of-ins tu on approach to end all its support for fossil fuels. However, the recently released
CCAP allows the WB to keep suppor ng fossil fuels for 2-4 more years, takes a selec ve
approach at phasing out fossil fuels ignoring the science and economics around fossil gas,
and fails to address areas of policy based lending and financial intermediaries. It also allows
the WB to con nue to invest in false solu ons like carbon trading--which requires offsets
through the use of unproven technologies or tree planta ons across the globe, contribu ng
to land-grabbing from communi es in the Global South. It also allows support for carbon
capture and storage (CCS), an approach supported by major polluters because it allows them
to keep pollu ng, through costly, unproven, and dangerous technologies, shi ing
responsibility away from polluters and governments' need to regulate them. The CCAP also
places excessive emphasis on the mobiliza on of private finance, an approach that has
ques onable efficacy and development impacts, which makes it harder for civil society and
the WB itself to hold them accountable, and whose fiduciary mandates to increase
shareholder return are fundamentally misaligned with incen ves to make the energy
transi on an equitable one.
In order for the WBG group to make the bold and urgent changes needed to decarbonize its
ac vi es, support countries to reach universal energy access, and adapt to climate change,
shareholders must overhaul the management. Personnel must be put in place with the
vision, exper se, and demonstrable commitment to address climate change from a public
interest perspec ve. Empty pla tudes and noncommi al catch words, unproven market-
centric theories of change, and delayed plans mired with loopholes will no longer suffice.
To this end, we ask the WBG to immediately embark on a process to renew its management,
beginning with the replacement of World Bank President David Malpass, and to
develop strict climate and social jus ce qualifica ons for any personnel responsible for
working on climate and energy policies at the WBG, with meaningful input from civil society.
Since the Paris Climate Agreement (2016-2020), the World Bank Group has provided:
$12 billion in direct project finance for fossil fuels in over 35 countries (see Table 1);
$10-$20 billion annually given as government budget support – represen ng a huge fossil
fuel loophole as the World Bank does not restrict spending on fossil fuels, including coal
expansion. From 2016 to 2019, 81 countries received budget support.
Billions more in fossil fuel-enabling infrastructure, such as transmission lines to evacuate
power from new coal-fired plants. Examples: in India, Indonesia, and Pakistan mega coal
power projects would not have gone forward without the World Bank-funded transmission
lines.
Fossil-friendly policy reforms in at least 18 countries that increased fossil fuel profits –
driving billions into new fossil fuel investments. Examples: tax breaks for coal and gas in
Mozambique; tax breaks favoring oil and coal in Colombia; and higher electricity tariffs
resul ng in higher profits for new coal-fired plants in Pakistan.
Technical assistance in over a dozen countries aimed at increasing fossil fuel investments.
Examples: Pakistan’s Thar lignite coal fields – the largest in Asia; Mozambique’s coal and
liquified natural gas (LNG) blocks; and Brazil’s pre-salt offshore oil fields.
These figures are based on data collected from World Bank Group websites and project
documents. It is true that the World Bank has ambi ons to invest in renewable energies
widely. We want to see this supported even more strongly.
However, at the same me, fossil-friendly policies are being promoted unno ced. This leads
to more calamitous natural disasters, driving increasing numbers of people into flight and
poverty. Any allowance of further investments in coal, oil and gas by the bank is an economic
risk and an affront to the human rights of those communi es saddled with the impacts.
The reasons for an immediate and comprehensive phase-out of all fossil fuel produc on are
obvious. But this needs a fresh start, star ng with the president of the World Bank and
extending into the bank's management that has con nued with fossil policies.
We hope that you will understand the urgency of our request and respond to us with this in
mind.
Sincerely yours,
AbibiNsroma Founda on Ghana
Africa Coal Network Africa
Alliance for Empowering Rural Communi es Ghana
Alliance for Rural Democracy (ARD) Liberia
Arab Watch Coali on MENA
Arabwatchcoali on Egypt
Asian Peoples' Movement on Debt and Development (APMDD) Asia
Associa on Jeunes pour Jeunes Morocco
Associa on LaSiesta Mohammedia Morocco
Associa on of Ethical Shareholders Germany Germany
Associa on Tunisienne de Droit du Déveleloppement Tunisia
ATED (Associa on Talassemtane pour l'environnement et Morocco
développement)
Balkan Green Founda on Kosovo
BankTrack Netherlands
Both ENDS Netherlands
Centre for Alterna ve Development Zimbabwe
Centre for Ci zens Conserving Environment (CECIC) Uganda Uganda
Centre for Financial Accountability India
CLEAN (Coastal Livelihood and Environmental Ac on Network) Bangladesh
CLIMATE ACTION NETWORK ZIMBABWE Zimbabwe
Climate Watch Thailand Thailand
Community Empowerment and Social Jus ce Network (CEMSOJ) Nepal
Community Resource Centre Thailand
Daughters of Mumbi Global Resource Center Kenya
Espace de Solidarité et de Coopéra on de l'Oriental (ESCO) Morocco
Euro-Mediterranean Resoruces Network United Kingdom
Forest Peoples Programme United Kingdom
Founda on for Environmental Management and Campaign Tanzania
Against Poverty
Freedom from Debt Coali on (Philippines) Philippines
Friends of the Earth Finland Finland
Friends of the Earth US United States
Friends with Environment in Development Uganda
Fundación Ambiente y Recursos Naturales (FARN) Argen na
Gender Ac on Global
GIFSEP Nigeria
Global Rights Nigeria
Green Advocates Interna onal Liberia
Green Alterna ve Georgia
groundWork, Friends of the Earth South Africa South Africa
Growthwatch India
Inclusive Development Interna onal United States
Interna onal Accountability Project Interna onal
Just Finance Interna onal Denmark
Jus ça Ambiental (Friends of the Earth Mozambique) Mozambique
Jus ce Ins tute Guyana
Lekeh Development Founda on Nigeria
Life A er Coal Campaign South Africa
Lumiere Synergie pour le Developpement Senegal
Milieudefensie - Friends of the Earth Netherlands The Netherlands
Money Rebellion United Kingdom
NGO Forum on ADB Asia (Regional: HQ
Philippines)
Oil Change Interna onal United States
Oil Workers' Rights Protec on Organiza on Public Union Baku, Azerbaijan
Organisa on pour la protec on de l'environnement Guinéen Guinée
OPEG
Oyu Tolgoi Watch Mongolia
Phenix Center Jordan
PowerShi e.V. Germany
Project HEARD Netherlands
PRUDENT STEWARDS FOUNDATION (PSF) Zimbabwe
Recourse Netherlands
Réseau Camerounais des Organisa ons des Droits de l'Homme Cameroun
(RECODH)
Resonate! Yemen Yemen-Sana'a
Rivers without boundaries Mongolia
Society for Threatened Peoples Germany
South Asian People's Ac on on Climate Crisis (SAPACC) India
Strategic Youth Network for Development Ghana
Studies and economic Media Center Yemen
The Oakland Ins tute United States
Urgent Ac on Fund for Women's Human Rights US
urgewald e.V. Germany
Wedyan Associa on For Society Development Yemen
WEED - World Economy, Ecology & Development e.V. Germany
Yemeni Observatory for Human Rights Yemen
Youth for Green Communi es (YGC) Uganda
ZIDAWU MONITORING FORUM Zimbabwe
( العراقIraq)
( منظمه شؤون المراه والطفلWomen's and Children's Affairs Org.)
Table 1. World Bank Group Fossil Fuel Finance since Paris Climate Agreement1
Loans & Technical
Equity Total
Guarantee Assistance
Type of Opera on (million (million Countries
s (million (million
US$) US$)
US$) US$)
Afghanistan, Argen na, Brazil,
2 Colombia, Guyana, Egypt, Ghana, India,
Upstream Oil and Gas
Kenya, Mexico, Mauritania,
(explora on, $534 $697 $131 $1,362
Mozambique, Nigeria, Paraguay, Russia,
produc on)
Senegal, Tanzania, & other undisclosed
Sub-Saharan Africa
Oil Refineries $530 $120 $650 Argen na, Egypt, Nigeria, Turkey
Azerbaijan (gas), Turkey (gas), Nigeria
Oil & Gas Exports
(oil), Colombia (oil), Kazakhstan (oil &
(pipelines; port $1,963 $245 $50 $2,258
gas), Kenya (transac on advisor, oil
facili es)
pipeline)
Oil & Gas fuel purchases $540 $540 Mauritania (oil), Ukraine (gas)
(imports)
Bangladesh (dual-fuel), Iraq (dual-fuel),
Oil Power Genera on Jordan (dual-fuel), Kenya (HFO), Senegal
$945 $230 $1,175
(HFO & dual oil/gas) (HFO), Sierra Leone, The Gambia (HFO),
& La n America
Liquefied Petroleum Gas
$75 $75 Bangladesh, Pakistan, Ukraine
(LPG)
Liquefied Natural Gas Bangladesh, Brazil, China, El Salvador,
(LNG) Processing & LNG- $764 $226 $2 $992 India, Pakistan, Panama, Senegal, Sierra
to-Power Leone
Afghanistan, Armenia, Bangladesh, Cote
Gas Power and Heat D'Ivoire, Ghana, Indonesia, Jordan,
$3,767 $358 $22 $4,148
Genera on Mexico, Mozambique, Myanmar,
Nigeria, Russia, Turkey, Uzbekistan
Gas Processing of oil
$158 $158 Iraq
field-associated gas
Gas Storage or
$600 $30 $630 India, Turkey
Distribu on (domes c)
Afghanistan (TA), Kenya (cap ve coal
Coal (power and mining) $45 $54 $533 $152 plant), Mozambique (TA), Myanmar
(cap ve coal plant)
$1,96 $12,08
Total $9,920 $205
0 5
Source: All data collected from World Bank Group webpages by Heike Mainhardt for Urgewald, August 2020
Note: G20 countries are underlined.
1 The UN Paris Climate Agreement was adopted on December 12, 2015. These data represent World Bank Group
investments approved up to August 12, 2020. This table does not include finance from investments made through financial
intermediaries, or through budget support. The World Bank Group includes the Interna onal Development Associa on
(IDA), the Interna onal Bank for Reconstruc on and Development (IBRD), the Interna onal Finance Corpora on (IFC) and
the Mul lateral Investment Guarantee Agency (MIGA).
2 Upstream oil and gas includes $750 million in new investments/technical assistance and $300 million in exis ng equity.
3 Technical Assistance that targeted coal mining in Mozambique also targeted oil and/or gas, thus the $53 million for coal is
not added to the overall total to avoid double coun ng. Furthermore, the finance for technical assistance in Afghanistan
was provided by the donor-funded Afghanistan Reconstruc on Trust Fund. Thus, no finance was included in this table as it
does not come from the World Bank’s budget.