Report to Governors
World Bank Group
IBRD-IFC Capital Package and the Forward Look:
Implementation Update
September 2021
ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS
AfCFTA Africa Continental Free Trade Area IDA International Development
AMC Asset Management Company Association
AS Advisory Services IFC International Finance Corporation
ASA Advisory Services and Analytics IMPACT Impact Measurement and
BOP Base of the Pyramid Performance Assessment
CAO Compliance Advisor Ombudsman Comparison Tool
CCDR Country Climate and Development IPF Investment Project Financing
Report J-CAP Joint Capital Markets Program
CODB Cost of Doing Business LICs Low-Income Countries
CPF Country Partnership Framework LTF Long-Term Finance
CPSD Country Private Sector Diagnostic MDBs Multilateral Development Banks
CSC Corporate Scorecard MICs Middle-Income Countries
DPO Development Policy Operation MIGA Multilateral Investment Guarantee
DSC Deployable Strategic Capital Agency
DSSI G20 Debt Service Suspension MSEs Micro and Small Enterprises
Initiative PSW Private Sector Window
EMDEs Emerging Market and Developing SALL Sustainable Annual Lending Level
Economies SALL-adj Buffer-adjusted Sustainable Annual
ETC Extended-Term Consultant Lending Level
FCS Fragile and Conflict-Affected SBL Single Borrower Limit
Situations SCDs Systematic Country Diagnostics
FCV Fragility, Conflict and Violence SCI Selective Capital Increase
FSF Financial Sustainability Framework SDFP Sustainable Development Finance
FTCF Fast-Track COVID-19 Facility Policy
FY Fiscal Year SDGs Sustainable Development Goals
GCI General Capital Increase SEFF Strategic External Funds Framework
GDI Graduation Discussion Income SLL Statutory Lending Limit
GHG Greenhouse Gas SMEs Small and Medium Enterprises
GHP Global Health Platform SSA Sub-Saharan Africa
GPG Global Public Goods WB World Bank
GTFP Global Trade Finance Program WBG World Bank Group
IBRD International Bank for WSMEs Women-led Small and Medium
Reconstruction and Development Enterprises
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. INTRODUCTION................................................................................................................ 1
II. IMPLEMENTATION OF THE POLICY PACKAGE IN THE CONTEXT OF THE
FORWARD LOOK ...................................................................................................................... 1
A. Serving All Clients .................................................................................................................... 1
B. Leading on Global Issues .......................................................................................................... 4
C. Creating Markets ..................................................................................................................... 12
D. Improving the Business Model................................................................................................ 14
III. IMPLEMENTATION OF THE FINANCIAL PACKAGE ........................................... 17
A. Capital Increase ....................................................................................................................... 17
B. IBRD Loan Pricing Measures ................................................................................................. 18
C. Administrative Expense .......................................................................................................... 18
D. Balance Sheet Optimization .................................................................................................... 21
E. Income Transfers ..................................................................................................................... 23
IV. MONITORING AND REPORTING MECHANISMS .................................................. 23
A. Ongoing Monitoring and Reporting ........................................................................................ 23
B. Independent Assessment ......................................................................................................... 24
Annex 1: Table on Capital Package Commitments and Implementation Status.................. 25
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1.WBG COVID-19 response since April 2020 and progress on policy commitments 2
Figure 2. IBRD Budget Anchor ................................................................................................. 20
Figure 3. IFC Budget Coverage Ratio....................................................................................... 21
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1. World Bank: Progress towards Capital Package Budget Commitments ($ millions) .... 20
Table 2. FY19-24 IFC’s Efficiency Savings & Economies of Scale ($ millions) ........................ 21
LIST OF BOXES
Box 1. Notable Examples of WBG effort on Global Issues ........................................................... 8
This page is intentionally left blank.
-1-
I. INTRODUCTION
1. This paper provides a progress update to the World Bank Group (WBG) Governors
on the implementation of the policy and financial commitments made in the 2018
International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD) and International Finance
Corporation (IFC) Capital Packages1 within the context of the Forward Look, since the last
update in September 2020. While progress is reported to Executive Directors throughout the year
via a range of corporate reports and tailored engagements, this paper aggregates overall progress.
The table at Annex 1 shows the implementation status of each commitment.
II. IMPLEMENTATION OF THE POLICY PACKAGE
2. This update highlights the significant progress made over the last three years on the
implementation of the Capital Package commitments across all four pillars of the Forward
Look agenda. While the WBG assistance over last year pivoted to address the health threat and
the socio-economic impact of the COVID-19 crisis, a clear line of sight was maintained to the
long-term Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and the 2030 agenda. The simplified
operational framework for the WBG COVID-19 crisis response incorporates the IBRD-IFC
Capital Package and IDA19 policy package commitments and selectively addresses demand-
driven country programs. The WBG COVID-19 crisis response envisioned a significant scale-up
in support for the 15-month period ending June 2021. It focused on helping countries address the
crisis and transition to recovery through a combination of saving lives threatened by the
coronavirus, protecting the poor and vulnerable, maintaining the foundations for the private sector,
and strengthening the policies and institutions for resilience based on transparent, sustainable debt
and investments.2 Beginning April 2020, the Fast-Track COVID-19 Facility (FTCF) enabled the
Bank to have crisis response programs running in over 100 countries in a matter of just a few
weeks utilizing the Multiphase Programmatic Approach (MPA). This was followed up with a
dedicated vaccine envelope for developing countries to finance the purchase and deployment of
COVID-19 vaccines, tests, and treatments for their citizens. Along with these, the Bank and IFC
continued to make progress on the policy commitments made under the Capital Package.
A. Serving All Clients
World Bank Group
3. The WBG continued to support all client countries, particularly countries in the lower
to middle range of the income spectrum. WBG financing to client countries reached $110
billion3 in Fiscal Year (FY) 2021. IBRD and International Development Association (IDA)
reached a record of $67 billion in FY21, including resources from the IBRD crisis buffer (see
paragraph 36 for details) and by frontloaded IDA19 resources as part of a strong crisis response.
1
See Sustainable Financing for Sustainable Development: World Bank Group Capital Package Proposal prepared by
the WBG for the April 21, 2018 Development Committee Meeting, DC2018-0002/2, April 17, 2018.
2
Saving Lives, Scaling-up Impact and Getting Back on Track: World Bank Group COVID-19 Crisis Response
Approach Paper, June 2020.
3
Includes IBRD, IDA, IFC (long-term finance, short-term finance, and core mobilization), Recipient-executed trust
funds (RETF) commitments, and MIGA gross issuance.
-2-
Such response has been particularly focused on the poorest countries, with IDA commitments
representing more than half of overall IBRD and IDA financing, and financing to below
Graduation Discussion Income (GDI) countries reaching $57 billion (86 percent of total WB
financing). In FY21, World Bank (WB) financing to Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA) stood at $27
billion, while support to Fragility, Conflict and Violence (FCV) affected countries has increased
steadily, reaching about $15 billion, compared to $7 billion in FY18. WB financing to small states
was about $1.1 billion in FY21. IFC had a record delivery amid unstable market conditions in
FY21, reaching $31.7 billion in total financing, including $15.9 billion of COVID-19 response
funding. IFC recorded its second highest investment in SSA at $6 billion, while IFC’s Upstream
pipeline reached $16.4 billion by FY21 end, of which 48 percent is in IDA and Fragile and
Conflict-Affected Situations (FCS). The Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency (MIGA)
committed $5.2 billion of guarantees in FY21 of which $512 million was in SSA.
Figure 1.WBG COVID-19 response since April 2020 and progress on policy commitments
4. The WBG Country Engagement guidance has been updated effective July 1st, 2021,
to strengthen WBG interventions to improve overall outcome orientation. This builds on the
updates already carried out in September 2018 considering the Capital Package agreement but now
-3-
emphasizes "indirect pathways” (i.e., interventions that go beyond physical investment) more
specifically across all countries, and sharpens the focus on WBG contributions to high-level
outcomes over time in a complex environment. In FY21, one Country Engagement product for a
country above-GDI was delivered to the WBG Board. The Montenegro Systematic Country
Diagnostic (SCD) update considers the need to have stronger public institutions and rule of law to
strengthen economic resilience and reduce vulnerabilities in the country. The low volume of
Country Engagement products in FY21 was due to the deferral guidance by Management in July
2020 for Country Partnership Frameworks (CPFs) ending in FY20 (and some before FY20) and
FY21 as a result of the pandemic, delaying the delivery of most CPFs/Country Engagement Notes
(CENs) by 12-18 months.
IBRD
5. IBRD continues to prioritize financing to below-GDI countries, while pursuing strong
and selective engagements in above-GDI countries. As part of the IBRD policy package, IBRD
committed to a gradual increase in the share of non-crisis financing to countries below-GDI to 70
percent by FY30, and an average share of 67 percent over FY19-30. The share of IBRD lending
to below-GDI borrowing countries stood at 69 percent in FY21 and was on average 72 percent
during FY19-FY21. Lending in FY21 also included the use of additional resources from the crisis
buffer to support the exceptional crisis response, in line with the governance set forth in the
Financial Sustainability Framework.4 In FY21, a total of $2.1 billion of IBRD financing was
provided to support recent IDA graduates and blend countries.5 IBRD substantially increased its
financing for Small States, reaching a record level of $316 million (compared to an annual average
of $127 million in FY16-FY20). IBRD financing benefited seven Small States, including $200
million for two IBRD graduates (the Bahamas and Barbados) which were granted exceptional
access given the unique circumstances and high vulnerabilities of their largely undiversified small
island economies. The Capital Package commitment of introducing a higher increase in Single
Borrower Limit (SBL) for below-GDI countries was implemented in FY19 and continues to guide
annual SBL discussions. For FY22, the Executive Directors approved SBL levels of $24.9 billion
and $21.2 billion for below and above GDI countries respectively, an increase of $1.4 billion and
$0.7 billion from FY21 levels.6 Engagement in above-GDI countries has been selective, with
interventions focused on strengthening policies and institutions required for IBRD graduation and
in areas contemplated in the Capital Package, as well as on supporting countries’ response to the
COVID-19 pandemic.
4
IBRD Financial Sustainability Framework Implementation Approach, December 13, 2018, R2018-0251/2.
5
Recent IDA graduates refer to countries that graduated in the two most recent IDA replenishments (i.e., IDA18
and IDA19). In addition, IDA graduates whose eligible IDA credits were accelerated during or after IDA17 and who
made eligible requests as provided for in IDA credit agreements were provided liquidity relief through the
suspension of the acceleration of their IDA credit repayments in FY21 and FY22 to fund their social and economic
responses to the COVID-19 pandemic, creating fiscal space and easing the burden during this crisis.
6
In June 2021, the Executive Directors approved a temporary relief from the SBL surcharge which was viewed as
acting as a significant disincentive in full utilization of the lending headroom by the larger countries for mounting a
forceful response to the pandemic. While the revenue impact for IBRD from the measure is expected to be limited, it
provides some of the worst affected borrowers with additional surcharge-free lending space.
-4-
IFC
6. IFC remains committed to the long-term development goals under the 2030 Capital
Package commitments, while also pursuing urgent priorities in supporting the health and
economic crises caused by the pandemic. Since the onset of the pandemic in April 2020 through
June 2021, IFC delivered over $43 billion or 91 percent of its $47 billion commitment goal.7 IFC
has implemented a rapid and robust response to COVID-19 through several initiatives intended to
support private sector clients8 including (i) the FTCF9 which provides trade and liquidity financing
to existing financial institutions and real sector clients; (ii) the Base of the Pyramid (BOP) program,
an expansion of the FTCF into microfinance and small-business banking; and (iii) the Global
Health Platform (GHP), a facility dedicated to supporting access to critical healthcare products
and services, expanding manufacturing and delivery capacities for healthcare products including
vaccines, and strengthening resilience of health systems through diversification of regional and
local supply chains. The pandemic highlighted the critical importance of the ability to respond to
supply chain disruptions for sustaining economic activity. IFC continues to play a key role in trade
finance and supply chain financing programs providing necessary support via banks and financial
intermediaries to support global trade.
7. IFC’s investment and Upstream programs cover the spectrum of clients in both
IDA/FCS and non-IDA countries. With the investment program composition mirroring market
developments at the country and sector level, IFC is witnessing higher demand for long-term
finance from certain non-IDA markets which are emerging faster from the economic crisis,
whereas IDA/FCS countries are driving a growing share of demand for short-term finance. IFC’s
Upstream engagement encompasses not only IDA/FCS markets but also Middle-Income Countries
(MICs), to support impactful projects with strong market creation and replication potential. Sharp
declines in government revenues and additional spending on stimulus packages with a surge in
fiscal deficits and record-high debt levels in many countries have made mobilizing private capital,
especially in MICs, vital to boost growth, create jobs, and lay the foundations for a resilient
recovery. Further, IFC continues to promote private sector development across key sectors in
Small States focusing on Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs), offering tools like risk-sharing
facilities and first loss guarantees as well as supporting investment climate and private sector
participation via Advisory Services (AS).
B. Leading on Global Issues
The Forward Look and Capital Package built on the WBG’s unique ability to combine global
coverage, convening power, knowledge and finance to effectively lead on global development
7
Denoted as IFC’s financial capacity for the period between Q4FY20 and FY21 in the Board paper “WBG
Additional Response to the COVID-19 Crisis: Addressing the Economic and Social Implications” (SecM2020-0079)
8
Base of the Pyramid (BOP) projects helped expand the FTCF into microfinance and small-business banking. The
Global Health Platform (GHP), a facility dedicated to supporting access to critical healthcare products and services,
expanding manufacturing and delivery capacities for healthcare products including vaccines, and strengthening
resilience of health systems through diversification of regional and local supply chains, was launched in July 2020.
The GHP has reached $1.2 billion in commitments from eight projects, with $0.7 billion in own account and $0.5
billion in mobilization, as of June 2021.
9
Proposed Investment in IFC Fast Track COVID-19 Facility, IFC/R2020-0052
-5-
issues. Since then, the WBG has also focused on providing global support for COVID-19 response,
particularly vaccines and debt sustainability.
Global Development Issues
8. The WBG continues to play a leadership role in promoting innovative responses to
global development issues. The Bank moved quickly to commit resources and establish a vaccine
financing framework to support countries to plan for their vaccine purchase and deployment needs.
In October 2020, the Board approved a $12 billion commitment of resources under this framework
as additional financing to the Global COVID-19 emergency health response MPA, and an
additional $8 billion was pledged in June 2021 to bring the total committed vaccine financing to
$20 billion. As of July 2021, the World Bank (WB) has supported 54 countries with $4.4 billion
in approved financing from this envelope for specific projects to help vaccine purchase and
deployment as well as strengthening country systems for effective vaccine roll-out. The WBG has
also worked closely with global partners to produce, finance, and deploy COVID-19 vaccines,
notably with WHO and with COVAX, and is co-chairing a Joint Task Force on COVID-19
Vaccine, Therapeutics and Diagnostics for Developing Countries with the WHO, IMF, and WTO
to track, coordinate, and advance delivery of COVID-19 health tools. Under the Global Health
Platform, IFC is providing financing to companies to boost the manufacturing and supply of
medical equipment, vaccines and therapeutics, health services and PPEs and also focusing on
building the resilience in domestic markets, by growing local manufacturing capacity and building
private-public health service delivery systems. To date, the program has enabled vaccine
manufacturing projects in Asia and Africa. The latter investment is the largest ever pharmaceutical
project financed by IFC and the largest mobilization for a healthcare investment. IFC has made
important strides in impact investing. IFC launched the Joint Impact Indicators in March 2021,
which provide investors with tools to measure and report on their activities across sectors, themes,
and/or categories. The IFC-led Impact Investing principles have become the industry standard for
good impact practice.
9. COVID-19 has exacerbated the challenges to domestic resource mobilization (DRM),
with tax revenues declining 12 percent in real terms in 2020.10 Low-and middle-income countries
(LMICs) have been hit hardest, with the decline in tax revenue of 15 percent, while many
additional countries are expected to see their tax-to-GDP levels fall below 15 percent. Fiscal
measures undertaken by several countries to soften the pandemic’s impact (deferral of tax
payments, waivers, suspensions, etc.) could potentially lead to permanent revenue losses or take
several years to reverse. The World Bank supports DRM reforms in client countries through
Development Policy Operations (DPOs), investment lending, technical assistance, and knowledge
tools. Currently, 94 lending operations with a total commitment of $2.8 billion and 139 active
Advisory Services and Analytics (ASAs) support DRM reforms in countries. Key areas of support
include: (i) assessment and adjustment of tax system progressivity; (ii) reform of tax expenditures
to bring in more revenue; (iii) introduction of environment and health taxation; (iv) promotion of
exchange of information and capacity building on transfer pricing, audits and risk management;
(v) strengthen tax administrations via improving the IT infrastructure and taxation of ecommerce.
The Platform for Collaboration on Tax is encouraging collective action for strengthening tax
10
For 68 countries (17 High-Income countries and the rest Low-and-Middle income countries) for which data is
available.
-6-
systems in developing countries to boost revenues to accomplish the 2030 agenda. The Global Tax
Program continues to support the efforts on tax reforms with DRM engagements in 64 countries
with $80 million of funding secured. Box 1 highlights a relevant WB project that supports DRM.
10. The WBG remains firmly committed to advancing international tax transparency
and minimizing the concealment of funds involved in Illicit Financial Flows (IFFs) which may
reduce government revenue and thus resources available for development purposes. IFFs remain
a threat to many countries as they are often linked to corruption, tax evasion, organized crime, and
international commercial fraud. To ensure that client countries can effectively identify and tackle
IFFs, the Bank is providing assistance to help countries conduct IFF assessments that include
efforts to comply with anti-money laundering/combating the financing of terrorism standards,
combating tax crimes elements, and supporting policy action to strengthen the legal frameworks
and practices. Disruptions caused by COVID-19 have slowed some projects, but adjustments made
to delivery approaches have allowed the Bank to sustain progress in implementation. Efforts also
include IFC’s screening of projects to detect misconduct and illicit flows in addition to those
requiring compliance with legal standards set by member states.
FCV
11. Of the total WB financing to FCV affected countries, 85 percent was in SSA countries
in FY21, including the full re-engagement in Sudan after nearly three decades. Sudan cleared its
arrears to IDA in March 2021, paving the way for the country to access nearly $2 billion in IDA
grants until end FY22. The WB is also investing $5 billion in transformative initiatives across 11
African countries in the Sahel, Lake Chad and Horn of Africa and in Yemen, with IDA grants
amounting to $0.6 billion to continue the support for the crisis response and food security. In FY21,
IFC deployed $1.1 billion of financing to LIC-IDA and FCS countries. IFC continues to increase
staffing resources and deploy a range of financing tools in FCS countries, including leveraging the
IDA PSW, which continues to be the main blended finance facility for mobilizing private
investments in priority countries. IFC is also scaling up special advisory funding and
implementation facilities for FCS, such as the Conflict Affected States in Africa (CASA) initiative.
In August 2021, the World Bank’s Executive Directors approved an updated Operational Policy
on Development Cooperation and Fragility, Conflict, and Violence following up from the WBG
institutional strategy for FCV approved in 2020.11
Debt Sustainability
12. The World Bank is playing a leading role on the global development issue of debt
sustainability and transparency. Together with the IMF, the World Bank has been providing
technical support for the implementation of the G20 Debt Service Suspension Initiative (DSSI)
and its extension through December 2021. As of end-June 2021, 47 DSSI eligible countries were
provided with much needed liquidity and fiscal space, amounting to $10.3 billion in debt service
suspension during May 2020 to June 2021. WB support on the DSSI has included monitoring
11
The operational policy updates and reaffirms the core principles of the Bank involvement – i) Emphasis on
recovery, reconstruction and development; ii) No political interference; iii) Assistance to non-members if benefiting
Bank and members as a whole; iv) Peacebuilding activities consistent with Bank mandate; and v) Due regard to
sanctions impact.
-7-
spending, enhancing public debt transparency, and promoting prudent borrowing through the
Sustainable Development Finance Policy (SDFP). Enhancing debt transparency has been a
cornerstone of the WB’s work program on public debt. Under the DSSI, transparency was
enhanced through the publication of detailed public and publicly guaranteed debt service data on
a dedicated DSSI website. Public debt issues have been mainstreamed into WB operations and
country-specific work and technical assistance on debt transparency has been scaled up. As a
result, the number of IDA countries with published debt reports increased significantly. Debt
reporting heatmaps for public debt and domestic borrowing have been developed, complemented
by guidance to borrowers and creditors through analytical products. The latter include a note on
public sector debt definitions, a framework to assess collateralized borrowing, and a forthcoming
transparency flagship report. Creditor outreach included guidance to official bilateral creditors on
implementing sustainable lending practices, and the publication of the creditor self-diagnostic tool
to identify areas of improvement.
13. The World Bank, jointly with the IMF, has also provided technical support for the
implementation of the Common Framework for Debt Treatments beyond DSSI, and
enhanced focus on debt sustainability and debt transparency through the SDFP. Launched
by the G20 in November 2020, the Common Framework provides a structure for coordination and
cooperation on debt treatments for up to 73 DSSI-eligible countries. The framework seeks broad
participation by official bilateral and private creditors, with fair burden sharing and can provide
debt treatments tailored to specific country needs. For countries with unsustainable debt, the
Framework can help reduce the net present value of debt to restore sustainability. For countries
with sustainable debt but liquidity issues, it can provide a deferral of a portion of debt service
payments that can ease financing pressures. Launched in FY21, IDA’s SDFP aims to incentivize
countries (through IDA’s annual allocations) to move towards transparent, sustainable financing
and promotes coordination between IDA and other creditors. A key pillar of the SDFP is the
establishment of Policy and Performance Actions (PPAs) to help IDA countries facing debt
vulnerabilities to tackle them by actions that aim at strengthening fiscal sustainability, debt
management, and debt transparency.12
14. With respect to the private sector non-performing debt resolution, IFC has made
strides in implementing distressed asset platforms as well as essential corporate debt
restructuring and insolvency regimes in close collaboration with other WBG institutions. In
particular, IFC is using its full suite of products – including scarcely used instruments such as
extending loans to refinance existing debt and investing equity by purchasing existing shares –
selectively, and as appropriate, to aid the pandemic recovery. Upstream efforts are focused on
solvency and debt resolution frameworks so non-performing loans (NPLs) can be resolved quickly
allowing a speedier resumption of bank lending.
12
For specifics on the countries required to establish PPAs see –Sustainable Development Finance Policy of the
International Development Association, 23 April 2020.
http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/967661593111569878/Sustainable-Development-Finance-Policy-of-the-
International-Development-Association
-8-
Climate
15. The WBG continues to make a leading contribution to the global climate agenda and
has substantially scaled up its financing to address climate change and its impacts in line
with the 2030 agenda. The $21.2 billion FY21 climate co-benefits for the WB was 23 percent
higher than in FY20 and the highest levels of climate finance by the WB since monitoring of co-
benefits began. In FY21, IBRD climate co-benefits reached 33 percent of total financing including
COVID-19 operations and 38 percent excluding COVID-19 operations. IDA’s climate co-benefits
in FY21 remained at 31 percent of total financing (including COVID-19 operations) and reached
38 percent (excluding COVID-19 operations). Three-fourths of co-benefits generated by the Bank
was on operations in middle income countries. Several Bank operations used innovative techniques
to help countries advance their climate related goals (See Box 1). IBRD and IFC maintained 100
percent compliance with climate risk screening in FY21. In addition, IBRD and IFC investment
operations in key emission producing sectors incorporated the shadow price of carbon in economic
analyses and applied GHG accounting, with annual disclosure of GHG emissions.
Box 1. Notable Examples of WBG effort on Global Issues
Climate
‘Mexico: Environmental Sustainability and Urban Development for a More Resilience Recovery Project’, is
part of the Government of Mexico’s broader, COVID-19 recovery effort. Through reforms that promote
Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emissions trading, black carbon reduction, and forest protection, this DPO will
provide key economic incentives for environmental sustainability and expand public investment in climate-
resilient urban infrastructure, benefiting 2.8 million farmers, 165,000 households, and 1.1 million people in
urban areas.
The Fiji Recovery and Resilience First DPO with a Cat-DDO supports Fiji's recovery from the impact of the
pandemic and tropical cyclones through reforms that aim to enhance the country's economic, social and
climate resilience. This project incorporates measures to improve the climate resilience of Fiji’s coastal and
marine areas, buildings and strengthen the effectiveness and efficiency of social assistance programs.
IFC issued a loan to South Africa’s Absa Bank, which was the first in Africa to comply with the International
Capital Markets Association’s (ICMA) Green Loan Principles. IFC also issued its first-ever blue loan to
support a global plastic resin manufacturer in achieving its goal of recycling 50 billion plastic bottles every
year by 2025. At the end of FY21, IFC signed a Green Loan with Basrah Gas Company in Iraq to support one
of the largest gas flaring reduction projects in the world. In parallel, IFC provided a loan to the water utility
in Izmir, Turkey, for upgrades to its treatment and supply infrastructure. This was IFC’s first sustainability-
linked loan globally, and one of the first climate adaptation investments in the region.
Gender
The Crisis Response and Recovery DPO for Guatemala supports reforms to promote financial inclusion of
female-headed households and self-employed entrepreneurs and firms through targeted cash transfers and soft
loans. The Rapid Support for Micro and Small Enterprises (MSEs) IPF in Turkey responds to the significant
financial challenges that women-led enterprises faced during the pandemic, by earmarking a fixed amount of
reimbursable support financing for female-owned or majority-female-employee manufacturing MSEs.
In Angola, the Girls Empowerment and Learning for All Project is working to address a large and rapidly
growing population of out-of-school children and youth, particularly girls, a situation further exacerbated by
COVID-19. The project provides incentives for girls to transition from primary to secondary level by offering
registration bonuses and scholarships.
-9-
The Air Pollution Management and Climate Change Project for Cairo addresses occupational sex segregation,
barriers to more and better jobs for women in solid waste management, and women’s mobility and safety in
public transport, through a series of specific and sequenced interventions.
The Banking on Women program (BOW) has been successful in financing women and women-owned SMEs.
This included a $169 million IFC investment with ACLEDA (Cambodia), of which $85 million is earmarked
for WSMEs.
IFC also agreed to provide a $70 million loan to Panama’s Global Bank to increase housing finance for women
and support women-owned businesses in the country. The loan is IFC’s first investment focused on housing
for women, who tend to lack the real estate collateral that financial institutions require.
Regional Integration
In FY21, the Board approved the $380 million Southern Africa Trade and Connectivity Project that will
support Malawi and Mozambique in increasing regional trade coordination, reducing trade costs and time,
developing regional value chains, and improving access to investment and infrastructure.
IFC’s work on regional integration is implemented not only through regional and sub-regional broad
initiatives, but also specific projects, such as Bolt Technology, a global mobility platform with operations in
SSA; and Vantage IV Fund, which supports market creation by strengthening the private credit ecosystem and
increasing funding market activity.
IFC also supported Medlog, a project that promotes trade and regional integration by improving market access
for shippers, especially SMEs, as well as reducing logistic costs including through the adoption of new
technologies.
Vaccines
In the area of vaccine procurement, the Bank is working closely with the African Union Vaccine Acquisition
Trust (AVAT), with a partnership announced on June 21, 2021 for Bank financing to be used through the
regional vaccine acquisition initiative to accelerate vaccination in Africa.
Under the GHP, IFC invested $435 million dedicated to vaccines, including Aspen Pharmacare in South
Africa and Fosum Pharma in China, supporting the manufacturing and distribution of COVID-19 vaccines
and other related medical products.
Domestic Resource Mobilization
The comprehensive tax reform lending project in Uzbekistan which couples focus on modernizing tax
administration with the technical assistance on tax policy and drafting of the tax code showcases WB efforts
in this area.
16. IFC continues the strong emphasis on climate investments. In FY21, IFC’s climate
program was a record-high $4 billion, 32 percent of own-account LTF. This strong performance
is attributable mostly to IFC’s efforts to mainstream climate throughout its operations effectively
diversifying its portfolio to include areas beyond renewables such as climate-smart cities and blue
finance. Several notable climate projects were committed in FY21 (See Box 1). MIGA’s climate
finance volume achieved a record 26 percent of gross guarantee issuance.
17. In FY21, the WBG announced its new Climate Change Action Plan (CCAP) for 2021-
25 which broadens WBG efforts to help countries integrate their climate and development
goals. It provides major increases in climate finance, including a commitment to achieve 35
percent in direct climate finance for the WBG, as an average over the Plan’s five-year duration. At
least 50 percent of IDA and IBRD climate finance will support adaptation. Additionally, all IBRD
- 10 -
projects with over 20 percent climate co-benefits are required to include a climate results indicator.
The Country Climate and Development Report (CCDR), a new core diagnostic tool, will help
countries align climate action and development efforts and will provide a strong analytical base to
inform WBG country engagements. In IBRD countries, CCDRs will typically have a significant
focus on a combination of stronger fiscal and price incentives (e.g., energy subsidy reform) and
support to energy efficiency including through private sector interventions. Crucially, a “Just
Transition” is needed to reduce inequality and promote inclusive growth. The WBG will align its
financing flows with the objectives of the Paris Agreement to support country climate
commitments; IBRD will align all new operations starting July 1, 2023. IFC is targeting 85 percent
alignment by 2023 and 100 percent alignment by 2025. The WBG continues to work with other
Multilateral Development Banks (MDBs) to identify conceptual gaps and areas for enhancements
to adaptation methodology.
Gender
18. IBRD continues to support clients to close gender gaps, though the COVID-19 crisis
presents new challenges. It works within the gender strategy for WBG, whose ambitions are
aligned with the 2030 agenda. In FY21, IBRD exceeded the Capital Package target for FY23 of
55 percent of its operations contributing to narrowing gender gaps (“gender-tagged”), with 84
percent out of 117 operations meeting the gender tag. These included all available financing
instruments across all Global Practices as well as 67 projects that specifically address the
challenges arising from the COVID-19 pandemic. Furthermore, the share of IBRD operations with
financial sector components that include specific actions to close gender gaps reached 56 percent
in FY21, against a target of 60 percent by FY23. Increasingly, IBRD operations are taking a multi-
faceted approach to identifying and responding to a gender gap and doing so by employing women
as agents of change. Under the context of enhancing resilience against the impacts of climate
change and natural disaster, the Resilient Kerala Program includes activities in disaster
management, water, agriculture, and road sectors to improve women’s access to post-disaster
adaptive safety net payment and promote women’s decision-making platform and capabilities in
disaster management. The Second Ho Chi Minh City DPO is a governance project which addresses
prevalence of sexual harassment of women and girls in transport-related areas through improving
personal safety and service quality, thereby increasing female ridership of public transport services
(Box 1 provides more examples).
19. IFC continues to actively implement the WBG Gender Strategy (2016-2023) and has
made strides in integrating gender across its operations and within country-focused
strategies. To align with the 2030 agenda, as part of the Capital Package, IFC agreed to quadruple
the amount of annual financing dedicated to women and women-led Small and Medium
Enterprises (WSMEs) and in FY21, IFC delivered $0.4 billion (30 percent of the 2030 target) to
that end. The Banking on Women (BOW) program has mobilized and invested over $3 billion in
financial institutions, specifically to finance women and women-owned SMEs. IFC has also made
significant progress on the other gender metrics, exceeding its FY21 target of investing in financial
institutions targeting women by committing $1.6 billion in FY21 (62 percent of the 2030 target),
increasing the share of women nominee directors on boards of companies into which IFC invests
equity to 54 percent (exceeding the 50 percent 2030 target), and flagging its investment and
- 11 -
advisory projects with gender components. In FY21, MIGA also developed an approach to gender,
laying out its proposed implementation of the WBG Gender Action Plan.
Knowledge
20. The WBG continued to strengthen its knowledge and convening role to support the
design and sharing of development solutions for greater impact. As part of the Capital
Package, Management presented to the Board a document entitled Realizing the World Bank
Group’s Knowledge Potential for Effective Development Solutions: A Strategic Framework in
FY21 Q3. WBG knowledge work, both global and at the country level, underpins the institution’s
operational engagements and is an important development service in itself. The Framework puts
renewed emphasis on the interdependence between knowledge and financing, to generate
development solutions in a timely, contextualized, and integrated way for Bank’s clients. It also
seeks to fortify the WBG’s position as the reference of choice on global development issues,
providing more credible, substantive and impactful solutions that are critical to achieve the 2030
agenda. The Framework highlights a need to remain strongly focused on knowledge to support
country outcomes, to serve client countries faced with ever more complex challenges, including
reversing setbacks from the COVID-19 pandemic and in pursuing green, resilient, and inclusive
development in a context of limited fiscal space. Moving forward, the Framework lays out an
agenda based on three pillars (strengthening systems, incentives, and human capital) and two
cross-cutting issues (improving metrics and technology platforms). WBG Management’s
implementation of this Framework will be continuous and adaptive. Management has also
developed and shared with Executive Directors a Table of Key Actions to implement the Strategic
Framework for Knowledge.
21. Drawing on its operational experience, IFC delivered a number of thematic reports,
including on opportunities for firms in emerging markets (a report on applications of Artificial
Intelligence in different industries), mobilization of private finance (a report on the use of
concessional blended finance) and on scaling impact investing (the ‘Growing Impact’ report with
an update on the global market size and case studies of impact investor practice). IFC also led
work to harmonize impact measurement, including the launch of the Joint Impact Indicators for
Climate, Gender and Jobs in March 2021.
Regional Integration
22. The WBG continued its strong support for regional integration and trade facilitation.
FY21 was a strong year for regional analytical work, technical assistance and lending to support
both policy reforms and investments. For the Africa Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA), the
WBG provided on-demand training and capacity building for the AfCFTA Secretariat and trade
negotiators on trade topics related to the negotiations. In collaboration with the World Trade
Organization (WTO), German Corporation for International Cooperation GmbH (GIZ) and
International Trade Centre (ITC) data on regulatory barriers to services trade was also collected
for more than 20 African countries. A study on ‘Making the most of the African Continental Free
Trade Area: Leveraging trade and foreign direct investment to boost growth and poverty reduction’
deepened an earlier WBG analysis on the impacts of the AfCFTA on growth and poverty reduction
by considering the potential gains arising from greater FDI flows and deeper integration beyond
- 12 -
trade. A ‘Horn of Africa Regional Economic Memorandum’ highlights the opportunities and
challenges for regional economic integration to support job creation and economic transformation
in the Horn of Africa. The ‘Lake Chad Regional Economic Memorandum’ diagnoses challenges
the Lake Chad region is facing to accelerate inclusive economic growth by exploring opportunities
to promote economic efficiency alongside spatial inclusion (Box 1 includes examples of notable
projects related to regional integration).
23. IFC is supporting regional integration through broad regional and sub-regional
initiatives, such as Sahel Irrigation, Digital Infrastructure Initiative, and Scaling Solar as
well as through specific investments and focused Upstream projects. For example, under the
Central America Regional Agribusiness Trade Logistics Project, IFC has developed a regional
system to facilitate the mutual recognition of sanitary registries for food and beverages, which has
reduced time and cost to trade these products. IFC also promotes regional cross-border investments
by mobilizing leading regional companies and financial institutions to other countries in the region
and beyond. For example, IFC is supporting south-south investments of Indian companies by
financing the expansion of Suguna, a leading poultry producer and pioneer of contract farming, in
Bangladesh and Kenya.
Global Public Goods Fund
24. IBRD continues to support the delivery of GPGs through the Fund for Innovative
GPG Solutions (the “GPG Fund”). During FY20-21, four projects that promote innovative
solutions to addressing climate change mitigation and adaptation and preventing spillover effects
of FCV situations were selected to receive $55 million in GPG funding. Projects were selected
based on additionality, innovation, replicability and sustainability criteria. IBRD Executive
Directors approved the first project (Colombia: Resilient and Inclusive Housing Project) in May
2021 for $15 million.13 The project aims to improve the quality of housing and public space for
vulnerable households, including households headed by women and also including migrants from
Venezuela, in 25 selected municipalities. The $15 million GPG Fund grant supplemented an IBRD
loan of $100 million and benefited from a $21.7 million grant from the Global Concessional
Financing Facility (GCFF). In August 2021, Governors approved a $20 million transfer14 from
IBRD surplus to the GPG Fund.
C. Creating Markets
25. With public sector balance sheets increasingly strained, the COVID-19 pandemic has
given new urgency to the need to maximize financing from all sources for development as
well as the imperative of strengthening markets for sustainable private sector investment.
The Cascade approach is a critical tool to support alignment and sequencing of public and private
sector actions and to deliver on the 2030 agenda. Efforts continue to embed the Cascade approach
13
Allocation decisions for the rest of the projects will be finalized as they obtain Board approval.
14
Last year, in light of the COVID-19 response needs in the West Bank and Gaza (WB&G), Governors approved that $25
million of the planned $45 million transfer from surplus to the GPG Fund be allocated to the Trust Fund for Gaza and West Bank
(TFGWB) to strengthen the Bank’s response to COVID-19 in the West Bank and Gaza. While the intention at that time was to
return to the normal approach of $55 million for the TFGWB and $45 million for the GPG Fund this year, in light of the recent
conflict in Gaza and exceptional challenges faced by the Palestinian Territories, an allocation between the TFGWB and the GPG
Fund similar to that of last year was approved, with TFGWB and GPG receiving $80 million and $20 million respectively.
- 13 -
in WBG operations including through the country planning cycle and staff incentive structures.
Working together through the Cascade approach, the WBG is making progress towards prioritizing
private sector investments wherever possible to ensure scarce public fiscal resources are used to
support green, resilient and inclusive development (GRID) projects that cannot be financed
through private sector solutions.
Collaboration on Upstream
26. The pandemic has emphasized the importance of enhanced collaboration in the WBG,
and particularly, the added urgency to accelerate IFC’s Upstream engagement, a vital tool
of market creation. WBG sector groups in Agribusiness, Housing, Transport, Power, among
others meet regularly to develop joint approaches to promote sustainable private sector solutions.
In addition, the WBG, working together, has vastly improved its country engagement, key
interventions in priority areas as well as in crisis response and preparedness. IFC teams are
systematically collaborating with the World Bank to provide input into the design of DPOs to
embed reforms paving the way for private sector activity.
27. IFC has made strides in accelerating its Upstream work. Dedicated IFC Upstream staff
have increased from four in FY19 to 283 in FY21, in addition to IFC’s Equitable Growth, Finance
and Institutions (EFI) staff who have been reintegrated into IFC’s operations. Country-driven
resource allocation has been implemented to hardwire links among country strategies, budget, and
delivery. Further Upstream engagement is being monitored carefully with robust metrics to track
delivery and resource efficiency. The Upstream pipeline grew considerably in FY21, to $16.4
billion and 331 projects, from $4.9 billion at the start of the fiscal year. As of June 2021, own-
account commitments enabled by Upstream amounted to $1.6 billion from 39 projects. Funding
for Upstream is also attracting external partners. Notable examples include a $21.5 million regional
climate platform for South Asia in partnership with the EU to provide flexible five-year funding
for Asia, and a $150 million MoU with the Rockefeller Foundation for concessional financing to
support distributed renewable energy.
Private Capital Mobilization (PCM)
28. IBRD will redouble its efforts, in close collaboration with MIGA and IFC, to increase
its private capital mobilization ratio to 25 percent on average over FY19-FY30, as envisioned
in the Capital Package. IBRD’s Mobilization Ratio declined from 9 percent on average between
FY19-FY20 to about 6.5 percent on average between FY19-FY21 due to limited private sector
appetite to invest in FY21, given the uncertainty and economic downturn induced by the pandemic.
Post COVID-19, the WBG’s role to expand the resources available to fund development projects
by mobilizing cross border and domestic private capital is more critical than ever. To enhance
efficiencies and the effectiveness of the delivery of PCM at the WBG, Management is working in
a number of areas, including to support the development of (i) programmatic approaches to
crowding-in institutional investors; (ii) scalable solutions to mobilize capital for the climate
transition and the GRID agenda; and (iii) ways to expand use of existing products such as
guarantees to mobilize private capital for public sector borrowers through international and
domestic capital markets, particularly in the context of increased credit downgrades due to
COVID-19 crisis. In addition, WBG teams are pursuing ideas to scale up public private solutions
for clean energy, water and transport. WB teams are developing programs to support, post crisis,
- 14 -
SOEs’ creditworthiness improvement and asset recycling to maximize access to long-term
financing for WB clients. WB, IFC and MIGA are coordinating efforts to (i) leverage domestic or
regional financial intermediaries through bespoke risk sharing facilities for green infrastructure for
SMEs (e.g., rooftop solar, e-mobility); and (ii) to operationalize IDA PSW Risk Mitigation Facility
(RMF) guarantee window to support IFC/MIGA investments and lending in IDA and FCVs.
Furthermore, the WB sustainable finance and Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG)
technical assistance program is helping our clients mobilize private capital for sustainable
investments by helping financial regulators “green the financial system”, facilitating the issuance
of market-based sustainable financial transactions (Green, Social and Sustainability bonds), and
improving their engagement with investors on ESG issues. IBRD also transfers financial risk from
natural disasters risk to international capital markets through catastrophe (cat) bonds. IBRD has
intermediated more than $5 billion worth of cat risk from our client countries to international cat
bond investors.
29. In addition to crowding-in private co-financiers for public sector projects (WB PCM),
the WB helps catalyze private capital investments via Maximizing Finance for Development
enabling activities such as lending that improves the enabling environment for expanding private
investments; and collaborating upstream with IFC and MIGA on the policy and regulatory reforms
necessary to spur private investments in Emerging Market and Developing Economies (EMDEs).
The Bank also indirectly helps clients access private capital through its technical assistance
programs that support market-based sustainable transactions and the intermediation program for
disaster risk financing transactions.15
30. IFC delivered a strong mobilization program in FY21 – $10.8 billion from 100
projects in 44 countries. While market headwinds significantly curtailed the risk appetite of IFC’s
mobilization partners in the first half of FY21, improvements in market conditions and increasing
closings of long-term infrastructure projects supported a significant mobilization rebound in the
second half of FY21. However, due to the increase in own account commitments, the Mobilization
ratio declined to 0.87x in FY21 from 0.97x in FY20. Over the four years that PCM has been
reported (2016-2019), 16 IFC has contributed an average of 60 percent of the WBG PCM, which
accounted for 46 percent of total PCM achieved by the MDBs in low- and middle-income countries
and averaged $31 billion per year. Mobilizing investors is a cornerstone of the IFC 3.0 strategy,
and IFC has worked with a wide range of market counterparts to develop mobilization platforms
and products. MIGA’s mobilization in FY21 was $4.7 billion.
D. Improving the Business Model
World Bank Group
31. The WBG is making progress towards a “Better WBG” in line with the Capital
Package commitment of improving financial sustainability and achieving productivity gains
while also addressing rising cost pressures in an expanding business context, particularly in Low-
15
The Program has supported a number of ground-breaking emerging market transactions (worth $1.6 billion
equiv.) such as the first green sukuk in the world, the first emerging market sovereign green bond, (Fiji), the first
sovereign green bonds issued in Africa (Nigeria) and MENA (Egypt), the first blue bonds issued in the world, etc.
16
Mobilization of Private Finance by Multilateral Development Banks and Development Finance Institutions, January 2021.
- 15 -
Income Countries (LICs), FCS, and Small States, as well as more complex operations including
those in response to the COVID-19 crisis. By end of FY20, the Bank had already restructured the
Practice Groups and Regions to enhance the alignment of accountability for country program
outcomes, simplify decision making, sharpen our focus on knowledge, and better harness its
technical capacity and knowledge to support country clients and contribute to the GPGs.
32. In the area of compensation, management continued to curtail increases in senior
management pay in FY21 and is implementing a competitiveness study in FY22. The
competitiveness study will evaluate the impact of the current compensation methodology on the
WBG Employee Value Proposition, including any recruitment and retention challenges. It will
inform the Board’s discussion on whether changes to the current compensation methodology may
be warranted.
33. The WBG continues adapting its services to staff in light of the evolving working
arrangements during the COVID-19 crisis. With the suspension of most mission travel in FY21,
operational teams have leveraged new technology solutions such as a cloud-based digital project
management platform, drone technology, and virtual reality to prepare and supervise projects
remotely, especially in high-risk locations. Staff productivity remained high due to the enhanced
digital workplace and over 58,000 managed devices for staff across the globe. In addition,
cybersecurity has remained a top priority, with over 114 million cyber-attacks blocked in FY21.
The Bank has also piloted new workplace standards in headquarters and country offices with an
increased focus on staff health and safety, sustainability, and flexibility. Moreover, the security
and health units have continued to ramp up its support in helping staff and their families stay safe
amid rapidly evolving risks and threats in different regions.
34. While the implementation of the Global Footprint agenda is progressing, the Bank
continues to face challenges to staff deployment due to COVID-19 related restrictions to
travel and relocations. Under its IDA19 commitment, the Bank agreed to increase its footprint in
IDA FCS countries and nearby locations by 150 GE+ regular/open/term staff and Extended-Term
Consultants (ETCs) by the end of FY23. This target was revised to 100 in view of the shortened
IDA19 period of 2 years. Measured against a baseline of 650, the number of Bank GE+
open/term/ETC staff working in IDA19 FCS or staff based in nearby locations whose work
programs are dedicated mostly to FCV reached 696 at the end of FY21, representing an increase
in net footprint of 46. At the end of FY21 Q4, 44.8 percent of Bank open/term staff were based
outside of the US. Increasing dedicated resources, especially to FCS, deploying a range of
financing tools, and accelerating Upstream continue to anchor IFC’s approach to boosting program
growth in IDA and FCS countries. In line with this strategy, IFC continued to increase resources
to priority areas, increasing staffing dedicated to FCS countries by 60 percent from FY19 to FY21-
end.
Trust Funds
35. The Bank updated its Trust Fund Policy, effective January 2021, the first time in 12
years, to reflect changes in trust fund practices and procedures, and support ongoing reforms
of WB trust funds and Financial Intermediary Funds (FIFs), particularly with its explicit
reference to aid fragmentation when considering new funds. The WB trust fund reform, which
- 16 -
aims at reducing fragmentation and organizing the trust fund portfolio around a limited number of
Umbrella 2.0 Programs, advanced further. In FY21 teams identified 72 Umbrella 2.0 programs,
which are designed to closely align with the Bank’s priorities and enhance complementarity with
core resources, while giving management better oversight over their use. A Strategic External
Funds Framework (SEFF) exercise launched in FY21 supported management in furthering the
evolution to a more strategy-driven approach to fundraising. The progress made on the Umbrella
rollout and TF consolidation as well as the SEFF process made it possible for the Bank to work
without an IDA moratorium. Based on the plans laid out in the SEFFs, 90 percent of future
fundraising will be channeled through the 70+ Umbrella 2.0 programs. Management also
developed a new cost recovery framework for trust funds that is simpler, easier to understand and
communicate, allows for greater predictability, and further strengthens the Bank’s financial
sustainability. The new framework became effective for trust funds established after January 1,
2021.
IBRD
36. In FY21, IBRD was able to scale up its response to COVID-19 by utilizing the crisis
buffer under the Financial Sustainability Framework (FSF). In the second half of FY20, IBRD
used the space afforded under its non-crisis lending ceiling, or sustainable annual lending level
adjusted for crisis buffer (“SALL-adj”) of $28 billion. This was followed in FY21 with $30.5
billion of lending – comprising $25 billion SALL-adj for FY21 and $5.5 billion crisis buffer (of
the $10 billion available for the year). The buffer usage enabled IBRD to lean forward to support
its clients in combatting the pandemic’s dire impact while respecting the prudential considerations
underlying the FSF. The buffer size is decided by Executive Directors every year and balances the
need to maximize regular lending aimed at achieving the long-term development goals and
maintaining a capacity to mount a credible response to crisis situations. As the negative effects of
the pandemic spill over into FY22 and the vaccine deployment efforts continue to lag in many
countries, the IBRD lending ceiling of $37.5 billion for FY22 would allow IBRD to continue
leaning forward in aiding borrowers with their recovery efforts. While adhering to the principles
of the FSF, IBRD remained flexible in the application of lending terms to address the extraordinary
context of the pandemic.17
IFC
37. IFC’s business model continued to evolve with a commitment to boosting program
delivery, improving its financial sustainability, and enhancing accountability. IFC has
continued measures to reshape its staffing pyramid as well as implementing streamlined
procedures for the COVID-19 response facilities and innovations in new business, portfolio, and
analytics, such as virtual appraisals, which significantly reduced processing times and improved
efficiencies. IFC strengthened its regional capacity by establishing a fourth regional Vice-
Presidential Unit (VPU) anchored by Turkey and including the Middle East, Central Asia
(Kazakhstan, Kyrgyz Republic, Tajikistan, Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan), Afghanistan, and Pakistan.
17
In June 2020, the default harder terms applicable to buffer were softened, coupled with an average 8-year
repayment maturity restriction for some operations. Post a mid-year review and borrower feedback on the maturity
limit constraining borrowers in their debt sustainability goals and efforts to foster a greener and more resilient
recovery, the maturity limit was revised to an average of 12 years.
- 17 -
This new structure is designed to draw senior management attention to priority countries and
enhance IFC’s delivery in IDA and the most fragile markets. The augmented regional matrix will
enhance program delivery, boost impact at the country level in all regions and ensure financial
sustainability. Another major achievement in FY21 was the adoption of a new policy strengthening
IFC’s independent accountability mechanism – the Compliance Advisor Ombudsman (CAO).
Engaging with communities is central to achieving IFC’s development objectives. The new CAO
policy is an important step in enhancing IFC’s accountability and maintaining its leadership in
environmental and social sustainability.
38. IFC has continued to use operational and financial strategies to optimize the use of
capital. IFC’s FSF aims to preserve the Corporation’s triple-A rating, using capital efficiently to
support investments aligned with strategy, and provide sustainable income to cover operating
expenses. IFC uses economic capital as a common currency of risk, and as a measure to reflect the
different risk profile of its different investment products. In addition to its internal capital adequacy
framework, which uses Deployable Strategic Capital (DSC) as the primary metric, IFC also
monitors its capital adequacy position under the rating agencies’ methodologies. Furthermore, a
balanced portfolio enables IFC to ensure sound financial footing and long-term sustainability. As
projects in MICs have historically demonstrated higher return on capital, a robust and continuing
program in MICs enables IFC to take on intrinsically riskier ventures in IDA countries and FCS
markets.
III. IMPLEMENTATION OF THE FINANCIAL PACKAGE
39. To support the ambitious policy commitments, the Capital Package included a
balanced financing package that comprised a significant capital increase and substantial
internal measures for enhancing the financial capacity of IBRD and IFC. Significant progress
has been made in implementing all components of the financing package over the last three years.
A. Capital Increase
40. Since the Development Committee endorsed a capital increase for both IBRD and
IFC at the 2018 Spring Meetings, six Resolutions were submitted to the Board of Governors
for voting on June 7, 2018. These include two authorizing the IBRD General Capital Increase
(GCI) and Selective Capital Increase (SCI) adopted by IBRD’s Board of Governors on October 1,
2018,18 and four authorizing IFC’s Conversion of Retained Earnings, SCI, GCI19 and Amendment
to IFC’s Articles of Agreement adopted by IFC’s Board of Governors on April 16, 2020.
a. The subscription period for IBRD’s GCI and SCI commenced on October 2, 2018 and will
close on October 1, 2023, five years from the Resolutions adoption date. A majority of
member countries by shareholding have started the subscription process, with eight
18
On October 1, 2018, IBRD’s Board of Governors adopted the two IBRD Resolutions (IBRD Resolutions No. 663
and 664, for GCI and SCI respectively).
19
On April 16, 2020 IFC’s Board of Governors adopted the following four IFC Resolutions: Resolutions No. 270
(2018 Conversion of Retained Earnings and General Capital Increase), Resolution No. 271 (2018 Selective
Capital Increase), Resolution No. 272 (2018 General Capital Increase) and Resolution No. 273 (Amendment to
the Articles of Agreement of the Corporation).
- 18 -
countries already fully subscribed to their allocations. As of June 30, 2021, 191,701 shares
had been subscribed, adding $2.8 billion to IBRD’s paid-in capital and $20.3 billion to
callable capital. As of June 30, 2021, 38.5 percent20 of total allocated shares had been
subscribed. During FY21, paid-in capital increased by $1.2 billion.
b. The subscription period for IFC’s GCI and SCI commenced on April 16, 2020 and will
close on April 15, 2023, three years from the effective date of the Resolutions. Whilst the
payment period for the SCI will end on April 15, 2023, member countries have two
additional years, until April 15, 2025 to make payments for the shares subscribed under the
GCI. As of June 30, 2021, 62 countries have subscribed a total of $3.2 billion (of which
$2.4 billion subscribed in FY21) and paid in capital of $1.2 billion (bulk of which was paid
in FY21). Percentage of subscriptions as of June 30, 2021 is 59 percent.21
41. In light of the criticality of the capital increase to IBRD and IFC’s ability to ramp up
their financing to respond to the COVID-19 crisis, member countries are encouraged to
accelerate their subscriptions and payments within the subscription periods. As IBRD’s Equity
to Loans (E/L) ratio is trending close to the prudential minimum, timely subscriptions would serve
to solidify the strength of the capital base as IBRD leans forward to serve its clients. With more
than half of the original five-year subscription period over, the IBRD capital subscription level
lags at 38.5 percent. Members are strongly encouraged to submit their subscription documents and
frontload payments to subscribe and pay for the shares allocated under the IBRD capital increases
and the IFC capital increases.
B. IBRD Loan Pricing Measures
42. The Capital Package included a set of loan pricing measures aimed at boosting
IBRD’s income and reserve retention, while introducing a differentiated approach based on
country income levels. These pricing measures were approved by the Executive Directors and
went into effect from July 1, 2018.22 Recent IDA graduates, blend countries, Small States, and
FCS countries are exempt from the pricing increase. In FY21, the pricing measures contributed
$23 million to IBRD’s income, totaling $39 million over FY19-21.23 As the exposure from the
loans accruing this higher price increases over time, the incremental revenue from these are
expected to increase as well. In line with the Capital Package, these incremental revenues are
excluded from the IDA transfer formula to contribute fully to building IBRD’s lending capacity
until FY28.
C. Administrative Expense
43. Management is tracking the implementation of the Capital Package budget
commitments under a comprehensive monitoring and reporting framework that was
reviewed by the Executive Directors in FY20. This framework set out a baseline against which
20
This represents paid shares only. Paid shares plus the shares that are not yet paid but subscribed through
documents represent 83.9% of total allocated shares.
21
Includes paid shares plus shares subscribed through subscription documents.
22
Implementation of IBRD Pricing Measures included in 2018 Capital Package, May 31, 2018, R2018-0128.
23
Certain operations under COVID-19 response were provided commitment fee and front-end fee waivers. These
amounted to $3 million in FY21 and did not have a material impact on IBRD’s financial sustainability.
- 19 -
budget commitments are being assessed. A supporting methodology has been established to
calculate the validated efficiency savings and economies of scale gains. Progress on the
administrative expense commitments is monitored and reported to the Executive Directors after
the end of each FY on a retrospective basis based on the framework agreed with the Executive
Directors in FY20.
World Bank
44. The World Bank has continued to make significant progress towards achieving the
Capital Package budget commitments through efficiency measures and economies of scale, and
by containing expenditure growth despite increasing costs of doing business from delivering a
more extensive and more complex range of services to countries at the lower end of the income
spectrum, fragile and conflict-affected countries and small states. Building on the successful
implementation of the Expenditure Review which achieved $340 million of savings by FY18, the
Bank has committed under the Capital Package to (a) achieve additional cumulative $1.1 billion
in efficiency ($400 million) and economies of scale ($700 million) savings by FY30; and (b)
comply with tight targets of the IBRD budget anchor which is to fall gradually to the 50 to 60
percent range in the FY28-FY30 timeframe. Gross efficiency savings achieved in FY19-21 amount
to $309 million, with net24 efficiency savings of $117 million,25 and economies of scale26 achieved
amount to an additional $98 million. Actual net efficiency savings and economies of scale realized
for FY21 exceeded the planned amount by $6 million and $44 million, respectively. Lending
project size increases and larger financing commitments in FY21 enabled the higher economies of
scale savings.
45. Management is committed to identify new efficiencies and deliver on the economies
of scale and productivity improvements, including capitalizing on adjustments in the post-
COVID operating model. This is reflected in the efficiency measures already built in the FY22-
FY24 WB budget trajectory presented in the FY22 Budget Document27 that will bring gross
efficiency savings to $1,001 million in FY19-24 and the targets for net efficiencies savings and
economies of scale to $716 million for FY19-24 (see Table 1). Out of this, $525 million is expected
to be achieved through net efficiencies alone, significantly above the $400 million target to 2030.
Furthermore, $93 million from additional economies of scale have been reflected in the FY22-
FY24 budget trajectory. Economies of scale tend to start low and build up over time as volume
24
Net of funding to absorb new cost pressures.
25
The World Bank has put in place efficiency measures in the areas of corporate procurement, real estate and facilities,
compensation and workforce structure, travel, events and food measures, project portfolio management in operations
and other areas. Additional cost avoidance, while not counted as part of the $400 million of efficiency savings, also
resulted from efficiency efforts, and include, among others, cost avoidance through corporate procurement measures
($26 million in FY19-FY21) and staff compensation methodology ($35 million in FY19-FY21).
26
Economies of scale are being leveraged by containing the direct and overhead costs on the Bank’s growing lending
volumes, as well as from productivity improvements and gains, such that costs do not increase at the same rate as the
increase in lending and portfolio volumes. As detailed in the Capital Package budget commitments monitoring
framework shared with the Executive Directors in FY20, economies of scale and productivity improvements have
three key elements, focusing on non-operational units (Institutional, Governance, and Administrative units),
supporting costs (Program and Practice Management) for operational units and average direct operational costs in
relation to lending/portfolio increases, including the evolution in the average cost of lending, taking into account
evolving costs of doing business.
27
FY22 World Bank Budget, May 28, 2021, R2021-0104.
- 20 -
increase effects take time to work their way into operational programs, and the data confirm this
expected trend.
46. Due to COVID-19 restrictions and office closures, additional temporary savings were
realized in FY21 in units’ budgets and in central accounts, mostly in the areas of travel and
conference/meeting/hospitality/printing/utility related expenditures, which, net of COVID-19
related cost pressures (health, IT, local consultants, etc.), resulted in a $223 million underrun in
the administrative budget. While contributing to the strengthening of the Bank’s financial capacity,
these temporary savings are not counted toward the Capital Package budget efficiency
commitments as they are considered for FY21 as of a temporary nature.
Table 1. World Bank: Progress towards Capital Package Budget Commitments ($ millions)
1
FY19 includes reclassification of Efficiency Adjustment in Operations as reported in the FY21 Budget Document
2
Formerly labeled as “Savings from the Board of Governors”
3
Global footprint cost pressures are excluded, and amount is net of incremental cost recoveries from external funds ($5m in FY21, $20m in FY22, $35m in FY23, $40m in FY24) and
redeployments ($15m for FY21 and FY22 each, $26m for FY23 and FY24 each)
Figure 2. IBRD Budget Anchor
47. The World Bank has also met its
IBRD Budget Anchor targets (the ratio
of administrative expenses over loan
spread income) in FY19 through FY21
and is on track to meet the targets for
FY22-24. The IBRD anchor was 66
percent for FY21. The IDA budget anchor
has also improved and is expected to
improve further by FY24 under the
planned budget trajectory.
- 21 -
IFC
Figure 3. IFC Budget Coverage Ratio
48. IFC has contained growth
in its administrative budget
through WBG and IFC-specific
expenditure control and efficiency
measures, despite the increasing
cost of doing business (CODB)
resulting from the implementation
of IFC 3.0, particularly expanding
operations in low-income IDA and
FCS countries. Since FY19, IFC
has realized a total of $183 million of efficiency savings, primarily from the FY19 workforce
planning (WFP) exercise, and expects to realize additional cumulative savings, including
economies of scale, of approximately $177 million over FY22-24. Key components of efficiency
savings and economies of scale from FY19 to FY24 are presented in Table 2.
Table 2. FY19-24 IFC’s Efficiency Savings & Economies of Scale ($ millions)
FY19A FY20A FY21A FY22E FY23E FY24E
Workforce structure and grade mix change 8 45 50 41 37 36
Productivity gains - 4 3 4 5 5
Global Real Estate and Facilities - 4 5 3 3 4
Corporate Procurement, Cost Optimization, and Other 53 9 2 10 4 5
Economies of Scale - - - - 10 10
Total 61 62 60 58 59 60
Cumulative Total 61 123 183 241 300 360
49. Having achieved Budget Coverage ratio targets in FY17-FY19, IFC saw an increase
in the ratio in FY20 and FY21 to 92 percent and 98 percent, respectively. This is the result of
the need for additional budget resources to back the implementation of IFC 3.0, including
Upstream, with its long-term strategic approach and higher upfront investment, and reduced
operational inflows due to contracting spreads on loan and fee income (see Figure 3). As IFC ended
FY21 with a strong program of $23.3 billion in total LTF commitments, and as investments in
Upstream start to yield financial upside, this is expected to lead to a positive trend in portfolio
growth as commitments are disbursed in future years. In turn, this is expected to positively impact
net interest income and therefore, also the Budget Coverage ratio.
D. Balance Sheet Optimization
50. The WB continued to pursue balance sheet optimization measures, to optimize existing
resources while safeguarding the soundness of the Bank’s balance sheet.
a. Active portfolio management: Available resources for lending are being freed up by
reprioritization of the pipeline, realigning country programs to emerging priorities, and
redirecting the portfolio where possible, including through cancellations and
- 22 -
restructurings. In FY20, IBRD/IDA cancellations totaled $9 billion, allowing resources to
be redirected towards COVID-19 response. This was the highest level of cancellations in
over a decade, 2.5 times the average annual cancelled amount over FY10-FY19. As a
result, in FY21 cancellations were significantly lower at $5 billion but, having opened up
lending space, allowed IBRD/IDA commitments to meet the Management targets for the
COVID-19 response. Proactive management of problem projects continues; nevertheless,
the pandemic resulted in a slight increase in problem projects from 12 percent of total
operations in FY20, to 13 percent in FY21.
b. IBRD capital adequacy framework: The five-yearly review of IBRD’s strategic capital
adequacy framework was completed in FY20, with the Executive Directors approving to
maintain the policy minimum E/L ratio at 20 percent. Management also concluded a review
of IBRD’s Statutory Lending Limit (SLL) in FY20 and recommended maintaining the
existing SLL. Management will continue to monitor the projected headroom of IBRD’s
lending against the SLL annually as part of the annual review of IBRD’s long-term
sustainable annual lending level (SALL).
c. Balance sheet optimization: Management continues to seek ways to prudently increase
the efficiency of IBRD’s use of its balance-sheet equity. These various initiatives have
centered at looking at the MDB-system, at the IBRD portfolio level, and at the level of
specific borrowers with the view of increasing overall financing while protecting IBRD’s
financial soundness. Management has also committed to exploring IDA-specific options to
optimize shareholder capital investment in the WBG (measures to maximize the reach of
donor contributions have been proposed and are being deliberated upon as part of the
IDA20 discussions). During FY21, Management briefed the Board on various initiatives
to optimize IBRD/IDA’s balance sheet through a technical briefing.
51. For IFC, delivering on both the Capital Package commitments and IFC 3.0 requires
further shifts to challenging and complex markets, and consequently, a higher CODB. To do
this in a sustainable manner, IFC resources will be judiciously deployed toward creating markets,
Upstream work and the implementation of the Cascade. As such, the continuation of operational
and financial strategies to optimize the Corporation’s balance sheet, including mobilization, asset
sales, and the application of a “portfolio approach” to investments remain critical.
a. Balanced and diversified portfolio approach: Management has strengthened the
governance of IFC’s debt and equity portfolio through dedicated monthly Operations
Committee meetings focusing on IFC’s Investment Portfolio.
b. Equity investments: As of May 28, 2020, IFC’s Equity Approach28 has been fully
implemented and is centered around four pillars: (i) large standalone equity investments
where IFC can influence through significant ownership stakes in sectors where it has the
knowledge and expertise to create value for investees; (ii) equity investments made
alongside debt; (iii) increased use of mezzanine instruments; and (iv) investment in private
equity and venture capital funds in smaller markets and IDA and FCS countries. The
enhanced approach in terms of project selection also incorporates a more active
28
Equity Approach is described in the “Update on IFC Equity Approach Implementation & IFC Asset Management
Company (“AMC”)”
- 23 -
management of core equity holdings as well as intensified effort to declutter the portfolio
from non-core exposures. In FY21, capitalizing on a favorable market environment for
equities, IFC executed 294 equity sales (including partial exits) generating proceeds of $2.4
billion and realized gains (cash basis) of $439 million.
c. Equity Mobilization: Following the successful completion of the merger of the IFC Asset
Management Company (AMC) into IFC in FY20, as discussed in the report to the IFC
Board of Directors titled “Update on IFC Equity Approach Implementation & IFC Asset
Management Company (“AMC”)” as of May 28, 2020, IFC indicated that it will develop
two tracker funds – a direct fund and a fund of funds. IFC’s interest in launching the
Tracker Funds was further strengthened by the COVID-19 pandemic and the resulting need
for equity capital in EMDEs at a time when other investors have pulled away from these
markets. As such, over FY21 the AMC team has been working on developing these funds.
A paper discussing the concept of these funds, their structure, governance and
management, as well their fit with IFC’s approach to equity and equity mobilization, is
planned for discussion with the Board in the near future.
E. Income Transfers
52. As part of the Capital Package, shareholders agreed to extend the IDA18 formula for
IBRD’s income transfers into the future, balancing WBG solidarity with financial prudence
for IBRD. The formula approach more closely connects IBRD’s long-term financial strength with
IDA transfer levels, allowing for higher transfers when IBRD is in a stronger financial position
while also reducing the impact of downside income volatility on IBRD’s reserve retention. Post a
mid-year review of IBRD’s financial outlook, IBRD transferred $331 million to IDA in February
2021 (which was temporarily held in the Surplus account for a few months in light of the
uncertainty brought by the pandemic), thereby boosting IDA’s capital position. A lower allocable
income in FY21 (mainly due to higher loss provisioning requirement) and the application of the
income transfer formula has led to the figure of $274 million as transfer to IDA (pending Board of
Governors approval) from the FY21 allocable income.
53. A key component of the Capital Package was the suspension of IFC income
designations to IDA after IDA18. New designations to IDA have been suspended, effective
FY20. $213 million of designations approved in FY18 and FY19 were transferred in FY21,
fulfilling IFC’s IDA18 commitment.
IV. MONITORING AND REPORTING MECHANISMS
A. Ongoing Monitoring and Reporting
54. Systems for monitoring and reporting progress on the Capital Package commitments
have been put in place. This has resulted in an enhanced reporting matrix, provided in Annex 1,
which shows each commitment along with specific targets and implementation status. The
enhanced matrix now introduces progress against targets for longer-term operational
commitments, such as the share of lending going to below-GDI countries and the share of financing
with climate Co-Benefits. This reporting matrix is updated annually after the close of each FY to
capture FY-end reporting data. In addition, Executive Directors receive more frequent updates
- 24 -
through the Quarterly Operations Update, and critical indicators are integrated into and made
public through the Corporate Scorecard, the apex reporting tool on WBG performance.
55. IFC’s Corporate Scorecard (CSC) remains a critical tool for aligning IFC’s
operations with its 2030 Capital Package commitments. IFC will present its FY22 CSC
covering FY22-FY24 to the Executive Directors during the IFC Operations Report update.
Additional updates and progress on the Capital Package are provided on an ongoing basis in the
IFC Strategy and Business Outlook paper in April and the Budget Paper in June.
B. Independent Assessment
56. An independent assessment of progress on Capital Package commitments will be
conducted five years after the capital increase. This independent assessment will supplement
ongoing monitoring by Management and Executive Directors.
- 25 -
Annex 1: Table on Capital Package Commitments and Implementation Status1
COMMITMENTS INSTITUTION SUGGESTED IMPLEMENTATION INDICATOR TARGET LATEST VALUE/STATUS
FINANCING PACKAGE
A. CAPITAL INCREASE
● Complete
IBRD Resolutions approved in
IBRD/IFC Capital increase resolutions approved by the Governors
October 2018 and IFC Resolutions
IBRD: Increase of $7.5 billion paid-in capital and $52.6
approved in April 2020
billion callable capital
Percentage of capital subscriptions and amount of paid-in
IFC: Increase of $5.5 billion in paid-in capital IBRD Monitored 38.5% and $2.8 billion as of end FY21
capital received
Percentage of capital subscriptions received (Instrument of
IFC Subscription submitted, not requiring payment) and amount Monitored 59% and $1.2 billion as of end FY21
of paid-in capital received
B. PRICING
● Complete2
Implement IBRD loan pricing measure starting FY19 IBRD Loan pricing measures implemented starting FY19
Effective July 1, 2018
Incremental IBRD revenues generated from the Impact reported and reflected in annual income allocation recommendations in
● Implemented
pricing measure to be fully retained in IBRD, i.e. IBRD annual IBRD Net Income Allocation paper starting FY19
excluded from the IDA transfer formula, until FY28 Incremental IBRD revenues generated from pricing $3, 13 and 23 million in FY19, FY20
Monitored
measure retained in IBRD and FY21 respectively.
Continue existing IFC risk-based and market-based
IFC As reported in Portfolio Risk Review (PRR) Report ● Implemented
pricing policy
C. BUDGET EFFICIENCY
79%, 74% and 66% for FY19, FY20
95%-75% for FY19-
IBRD Budget Anchor within a target zone of 50-60% and FY21 respectively (FY20 and
IBRD Budget anchor % FY21
by FY30 FY21 better than the budget anchor
50%-60% by FY30
target zone agreed for FY19-FY21)
$117 million net efficiency savings
($309 million gross savings) and $98
million economies of scale savings
Achieve $1.8 billion of cumulative further efficiency
achieved for FY19-FY21.
gains and economy of scale benefits by FY30 WB Cumulative savings FY19-FY30 $1.1 billion
$525 million net efficiency savings
($1,001 million gross savings) and
$191 million economies of scale
savings expected for FY19-FY24
1
This table reports the implementation status of commitments under the 2018 IBRD/IFC Capital Package (as set out in Sustainable Financing for Sustainable Development:
World Bank Group Capital Package Proposal prepared by the WBG for the April 21, 2018 Development Committee Meeting, DC2018-0002/2, April 17, 2018). Implementation
indicators listed in italics are not explicit commitments but are variables being monitored that flow from the listed commitments. A monitored indicator has no associated target
specified in the Capital Package, and progress is only tracked and reported for interim information.
2
Loan pricing measures committed in Capital Package pertains to differentiated approach based on countries’ income levels for the regular lending program.
- 26 -
COMMITMENTS INSTITUTION SUGGESTED IMPLEMENTATION INDICATOR TARGET LATEST VALUE/STATUS
$183 million savings achieved for
FY19-FY21
IFC Cumulative savings FY19-FY30 $0.7 billion
$360 million savings expected for
FY19-FY24
D. BALANCE SHEET OPTIMIZATION
Core Mobilization to
Continue an active IFC mobilization strategy to 3
IFC Amount raised in core mobilization reach 0.92x by $10.8 billion/0.87x in FY21
conserve capital
FY30
New equity approach has been fully
Progress in implementing equity strategy
implemented.
Seven milestones4 supporting IFC's
Continue an active portfolio management approach Number of new portfolio management approaches used other efforts to have a stronger
including innovative approaches and IFC equity sales IFC influence as an equity partner.
and maintain a balanced portfolio Executed 294 equity sales (including
partial exits) generating proceeds of
Amount of equity sales executed
$2.4 billion and realized gains (cash
basis) of $439 million in FY21.
● Complete
Implement recommendations from external capital
IBRD Recommendations from external capital adequacy framework review implemented Recommendations implemented in
adequacy framework review
January 2020
● Complete
Review IBRD Statutory Lending Limit (SLL) IBRD Review of SLL completed
Review completed in March 2020
IDA Capital Value Protection program
Explore IDA-specific options to further optimize implemented in November 2019;
IDA IDA balance sheet optimization measure explored and implemented
shareholder capital investments in the WBG further options being explored as part
of IDA20 discussions
E. INCOME TRANSFERS
● Implemented
(FY19: $259 million transferred.
Use IDA transfer formula to derive annual IBRD
IBRD The use of agreed formula to derive amount of IDA transfer from IBRD FY20: $331 million transferred.
income transfer to IDA
FY21: $274 million [pending
Governors approval])
Suspend IFC transfers to IDA starting from IDA19 IFC IFC transfer to IDA suspended starting from IDA19 ● Implemented
Extend use of revised approach to IFC designations for
The use of designations formula agreed with the Board in November 2016 for annual ● Implemented
annual designations to advisory services including the IFC
designations for advisory services $161 million in FY21
Creating Markets Advisory window
3
IFC core mobilization ratio of 0.92x by FY30 is an implicit target based on an explicit target of $25 billion own account and $48 billion total own account and mobilization.
4
(a) ensured Equity specialization of investment staff and increased the size of the IFC Equity team, including Global Equity Heads (“GEHs”) in each industry group; (b) the
portfolio construction framework that CPM, the GEHs, and our macroeconomic research team have developed helps IFC match sector and country drivers to investment and
divestment decisions; (c) identified core equity investments and developed new procedures to manage these assets; (d) promptly filled company Board seats allocated to IFC;
(e) integrated macroeconomic research in the Equity project lifecycle; (f) enhanced the focus of senior management on Equity; and (g) established a more proactive equity
sales program.
- 27 -
COMMITMENTS INSTITUTION SUGGESTED IMPLEMENTATION INDICATOR TARGET LATEST VALUE/STATUS
POLICY PACKAGE
A. SERVING ALL CLIENTS
Prioritize IBRD support to IDA graduates and new Subject to borrower demand. $2.1
100% of IDA
blends aiming to make available resources to replace IBRD financing for recent IDA graduates relative to IDA billion of IBRD financing was
IBRD financing for IDA
100% of IDA financing for IDA graduates financing prior to graduation provided to support recent IDA
graduates
graduates and blend countries in FY21
Aim for a gradual and linear rise in IBRD share of 69% in FY21 (includes use of crisis
70% by FY30;
non-crisis lending to countries below GDI to reach buffer);
IBRD % of financing to countries below GDI 67% average over
70% by FY30. Target an average share of 67 percent 72% average in FY19-FY21(FY21
FY19-FY30
over the FY19-FY30 period. includes use of crisis buffer)
Expand commitments in IDA and FCS countries and 40% by FY30;
25% in FY21;
reach up to 40% of all IFC commitments by FY30, IFC % of own account commitments in IDA17/FCS countries 32.5% average over
24.7% average in FY19-FY21
averaging 32.5% over FY19-FY30 FY19-FY30
Utilize replenished PSW resources to increase share of
IFC commitments in Low Income IDA and IDA-FCS
% of total annual commitments to Low Income IDA17 and 15-18% by FY26;
countries to 15-18% and 15-20% of total annual IFC 8% in FY21
FCS counties 15-20% by FY30
commitments by FY26 and FY30 respectively (subject
to the continuation and sizing of the PSW)
● Implemented
Higher SBL increase for countries below the GDI IBRD Higher SBL increase for below-GDI than above-GDI countries introduced Differentiated approach introduced
starting FY19
IBRD price discount for below-GDI countries, with
Price discount for below-GDI countries and exemptions for blends and recent IDA ● Complete
blends and recent IDA graduates exempted from the IBRD
graduates implemented as part of Capital Package pricing measures Effective July 1, 2018
price increase
● Implemented
Systematic analysis and assessment of the key elements SCD and Country Engagement
of the IBRD graduation policy reflected in CPFs and Guidance updated in September 2018
updated in Performance and Learning Reviews and further updated in July 2021;
SCD and Country Engagement Guidance updated and Capital Package agreement
(PLRs) of above-GDI countries. New IBRD activities IBRD Capital Package agreement reflected in
reflected in new CPFs for above-GDI countries
will have a primary focus on interventions to one SCD Update for above-GDI
strengthen policies and institutions required for countries (In July 2020, due to the
sustainable IBRD graduation pandemic, decision to defer CPF ending
in FY20 and FY21 by 12-18 months.)
Selective private sector investments in Upper Middle- ● Complete
Income Countries by IFC, following a rigorous IFC Adoption of new additionality framework New additionality framework adopted
approach to additionality. in FY19
Double IBRD base allocation for Small States, subject
IBRD Base allocation for Small States doubled ● Complete
to prudential limits
● Complete
Exempt Small States from the IBRD price increase IBRD Small States exempt from Capital Package pricing increase
Effective July 1, 2018
- 28 -
COMMITMENTS INSTITUTION SUGGESTED IMPLEMENTATION INDICATOR TARGET LATEST VALUE/STATUS
Promotion of regional approach to IFC investments in
the middle- to upper-income small states and
IFC New approach incorporated in relevant papers and reports ● Complete
leveraging of de-risking tools for the lower-income and
FCV ones
B. LEADING ON GLOBAL ISSUES
● Complete
Incorporate crisis response into IBRD Financial Crisis buffer introduced Crisis buffer implemented as part of
IBRD FSF starting FY20
Sustainability Framework
Annual approved amount of crisis buffer / resulting SALL- $5 billion / $28 billion (FY22)
Monitored
adj level $15 billion buffer over FY21-22
Strengthen IFC partnership with WB and others to ● Implemented
Joint FCV strategy to
ensure a coordinated approach to crisis management IFC IFC’s FCS Strategy integrated into WBG FCV Strategy WBG FCV Strategy presented to the
the Board
and FCV Board in FY20
At least 30% average
Increasing the IBRD climate co-benefit target of 28
over FY20-FY23; 33% including COVID-19 operations
percent by FY20 to an average of at least 30% over
IBRD Share of climate co-benefits in total commitments (%) ambition maintained and 38% excluding COVID-19
FY20-FY23, with this ambition maintained or
or higher in FY24- operations
increasing to FY305
FY30
IFC aims to increase climate investments share to 35% 35% by FY30
Share of climate investments as a % of LTF own account
of commitments by FY30, reaching an average of 32% IFC 32% average in 32% in FY21
commitments
between FY20 and FY30 FY20-FY30
● Implemented
IBRD Annual % of operations screened for climate risk 100%
All operations screened for Climate risk 100% in FY21
Annual % of projects screened for climate risk within the ● Implemented
IFC 100%
sectors where climate risk screening was mainstreamed 100% in FY21
Annual % of investment operations in key emission
● Implemented
producing sectors incorporating shadow carbon price in 100%
100% in FY21
Investment operations in key emission producing IBRD economic analysis and applying GHG accounting
sectors to incorporate the shadow price of carbon in ● Implemented
economic analysis and to apply GHG accounting, with Annual disclosure of related GHG emissions GHG emissions disclosed in
annual disclosure of GHG emissions Corporate Scorecard
Annual % of eligible projects incorporating shadow carbon ● Implemented
100% by FY20
pricing 100% in FY21
IFC
Annual % of eligible projects applying GHG accounting ● Implemented
100% by FY20
and disclosure 100% in FY21
5
In achieving this higher level of co-benefits IBRD will need to be cognizant of the trade-offs within its lending portfolio. Climate co-benefits are largely available from sectors
such as energy and extractives, transport, environment and natural resources, water and sanitation, agriculture, urban, rural and social development. Lending to such sectors will
need to be balanced with other priority areas, such as education, health, social protection, and building institutions to support inclusive growth and sustainable graduation.
Furthermore, tilting financing towards lower income countries alters the ratio of mitigation versus adaptation in WBG climate financing towards adaptation.
- 29 -
COMMITMENTS INSTITUTION SUGGESTED IMPLEMENTATION INDICATOR TARGET LATEST VALUE/STATUS
The MDB Adaptation Working Group
is reviewing the Adaptation Finance
(Co-Benefits) Tracking Methodology
In co-operation with other MDBs, review the
Progress in reviewing and improving methodology for computing climate co- and identifying conceptual gaps and
methodology used for computing climate co-benefits IBRD
benefits to improve capturing of adaptation benefits areas for enhancement. The Group is
with a view to better capturing adaptation benefits
expected to provide final conclusions
on the methodology review by end of
2021.
Flag all IFC projects with gender component by 2020 IFC All projects with gender component flagged as applicable In progress
Increase share of IBRD operations that narrow gender 55% by FY23
gaps (“gender tagged”) to 55% by FY23, with IBRD % of operations that are “gender-tagged” (>=55% FY24- 84% in FY21 out of 117 operations
ambition maintained or increasing to FY30 FY30)
Increase share of IBRD operations with financial
sector components that include specific actions to close % of operations with financial sector components that 60% by FY23
gender gaps in access to and use of financial services to IBRD include specific actions to close gender gaps in access to and (>=60% FY24- 56% in FY21
60% by FY23, with ambition maintained or increasing use of financial services FY30)
to FY30
Quadruple the amount of annual financing dedicated Amount of annual financing dedicated to women and Reach $1.4 billion
IFC $0.42 billion in FY21
to women and women-led SMEs women-led SMEs per annum by FY30
$2.6 billion in annual commitments to financial Amount of money committed to financial institutions
IFC $2.6 billion by FY30 $1.6 billion in FY21
institutions specifically targeting women by 2030 targeting women
50% share of women directors IFC nominates to 50% of women
IFC % of women directors IFC nominates to boards 54% in FY21
Boards of companies where it has a board seat directors by FY30
● Complete
Strategic Framework for the WBG
Develop a strategic framework for knowledge Strategic framework for knowledge generation and sharing developed and presented
IBRD presented to the Board in FY21Q3.
generation and sharing to the Board
Implementation of this Framework
will be continuous and adaptive.
Several ASAs completed to inform
Supporting inclusive and sustainable regional policy dialogue and provide analytical
Progress in supporting regional integration through projects and ASA
integration through connective infrastructure and IBRD underpinnings for regional integration
complementary policy and institutional reforms operations. Dedicated programs to
foster connectivity and trade.
Dedicate part of IBRD income in surplus to provide ● Implemented
Establish an IBRD fund that uses IBRD surplus income to provide concessional
concessional financing for GPGs IBRD Fund for Innovative GPG
financing for GPGs
IBRD Solutions launched in FY20
- 30 -
COMMITMENTS INSTITUTION SUGGESTED IMPLEMENTATION INDICATOR TARGET LATEST VALUE/STATUS
$45 million FY19 allocation (Oct
2019), $20 million FY20 allocation,
Annual amount of funding dedicated to GPG fund from $20 million FY21 allocation.
Monitored
IBRD Surplus Since inception, $55 million of total
amount of funding dedicated to GPG
funds allocated to projects
C. CREATING MARKETS
Increase IBRD Private Mobilization Ratio to 25% on 25% on average over
IBRD IBRD private mobilization ratio 6.5% on average over FY19-FY21
average over FY19-FY30 FY19-FY30
Scale up private sector solutions by 1) deepening WBG
collaboration for policy reform to eliminate obstacles
to private investment; 2) using advisory services for Pipeline of upstream projects 331 upstream pipeline projects at
IFC
upstream project preparation as well as de-risking FY21-end
tools where needed to build up the pipeline of bankable
projects
D. IMPROVING INTERNAL GOVERNANCE
● Complete
Introduce an IBRD financial sustainability framework IBRD New IBRD Financial Sustainability Framework introduced
FSF introduced in FY20
Continue application of the existing IFC framework
and improve certain aspects of the framework through
1) formal review and reaffirmation of the DSC policy ● Implemented
IFC Continued application of the existing IFC framework with relevant enhancements
range annually; 2) keeping abreast with evolving Implemented in July 2019
standards in risk and capital models; and 3)
establishing more granular policy ratios.
Revise Staff Compensation Methodology to control
● Complete
salary growth and pursue other Human Resources IBRD/IFC Revised Staff Compensation Methodology adopted
Effective starting FY19
measures
E. REPORTING AND MONITORING
Progress against commitment targets to be provided
IBRD/IFC Regular updates to the Board ● Implemented
via regular updates to the Board
Independent Assessment of progress towards the
targets will be conducted after five years, subsequent IBRD/IFC Methodology for assessment to be developed Future Deliverable
to the capital increase.
Saatja: wbggovernorsportal <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 14.10.2021 01:39
Adressaat: Governors Portal <
[email protected]>
Teema: IBRD-IFC Capital Package and the Forward Look: Implementation
Update
TO GOVERNORS, ALTERNATE GOVERNORS AND MEMBER COUNTRIES OF THE WORLD BANK
GROUP:Please find attached a copy of the report entitled IBRD-IFC Capital
Package and the Forward Look: Implementation Update. This report provides
a progress update to the World Bank Group Governors on the implementation
of the policy and financial commitments made in the 2018 IBRD and IFC
Capital Package, within the context of the Forward Look, since the last
update in September 2020.Best regards,
Corporate SecretariatWorld Bank Group*** This is an automated message.
Please do not reply directly to this email. Please send all your
questions/queries to ***
NOTICE: This email and any file transmitted with it are for official use
only and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom
they are addressed and may not be disclosed without the prior written
consent of the World Bank Group. Please notify the sender immediately by
email if you have received this email by mistake and delete this email
from your system. If you are not the intended recipient, you are notified
that disclosing, copying, distributing or taking any action in reliance
on this email or its contents is strictly prohibited.