Operating Rules
of the Appointment
Advisory Committee
July 2021
Operating Rules
Of the Appointment Advisory Committee
Effective as from 22 July 2021.
Chapter I – Mission of the Committee
Article 1 – Role
By virtue of Article 23.a.2 and Article 27.8 of the Rules of Procedure, the Appointment Advisory
Committee (“Committee”) shall give non-binding opinions on candidates' suitability to perform the
duties of a member of the Management Committee and of a full member or an observer of the Audit
Committee of the European Investment Bank (“Bank”).
Article 2 – Criteria for assessment
A. General criteria for appointment to the Management Committee and to the
Audit Committee
1. When assessing whether a candidate satisfies the criteria set out in the Rules of Procedure of the
Bank, the Committee shall take into account, notably, the nature, scale and complexity of the
business of the European Investment Bank, the responsibilities inherent to the position, as well
as the gender balance. In this respect, the Management Committee and the Audit Committee
shall possess adequate collective knowledge, skills and experience to carry out their duties as
described in the Rules of Procedure.
2. A candidate shall be considered to be of high integrity and high reputation if there is no evidence
to suggest otherwise and if his or her personal or business conduct does not give rise to any
material doubt about his or her high integrity and high reputation as well as his or her ability to
ensure the sound and prudent management of the Bank. In this respect, account shall be taken
of factors such as convictions or pending prosecutions of a criminal offence as well as relevant
current or past investigations and/or enforcement actions relating to the candidate, or the
imposition of administrative sanctions for non-compliance with any banking or financial services
legislation. The surrounding, including mitigating, circumstances and the seriousness of any
relevant offence or administrative or supervisory action, the time period elapsed and the
candidate’s conduct since the offence and the relevance of the offence or administrative or
supervisory action to the position of member of the Management Committee or of the Audit
Committee should be considered. Also, the cumulative effects of more minor incidents, which
individually do not impinge on a candidate’s reputation but may in sum have a material impact,
should be considered.
3. The assessment of a candidate’s experience shall involve consideration of his or her theoretical
experience attained through education and training and his or her practical experience gained in
Operating Rules of the Appointment Advisory Committee 1
previous occupations. The Committee shall take into account the skills and knowledge acquired
and demonstrated by the professional conduct of the candidate.
4. When assessing the suitability of a candidate, other ancillary criteria relevant for the functioning
of the Management Committee and of the Audit Committee shall be assessed, including its overall
composition, the collective knowledge and expertise required.
B. Specific criteria for appointment to the Management Committee
1. As regards proposals for appointments to the Management Committee, consideration shall be
particularly given to experience in fields such as European Union matters, International Financial
Institutions, financial markets, regulatory framework and requirements, strategic planning, and
understanding of a bank’s business strategy, risk management, creating effective governance,
oversight and controls and interpreting a bank’s financial information, identifying key issues based
on this information and appropriate controls and measures, and the candidate’s ability to perform
his or her duties independently.
C. Specific criteria for appointment to the Audit Committee
1. Full members and observers of the Audit Committee shall be chosen from persons having
independence, competence and integrity. They shall possess financial, audit or banking
supervisory expertise in the private or public sector, and among themselves should cover the
whole range of expertise.
2. The Committee shall include at least two full members or observers having proven experience in
supervisory review and evaluation process, drawn from among current or former members of
banking supervisory authorities in the EU.
3. In addition, consideration shall be given to experience in fields such as Corporate Governance,
Management, Banking, Banking Regulation, Accounting and Financial Reporting, Risk
Management, Conduct, Compliance, Human Resources, Information Technology and the EU
institutional relationships.
Chapter II – Functioning of the Committee
Article 3 – Members
1. Members of the Committee are appointed pursuant to Article 23.a, second paragraph, of the
Rules of Procedure of the Bank.
2. Former members of a governing body of the Bank can be appointed three years after they cease
to be a member of such governing body.
3. Former members of the Bank’s staff cannot be members of the Committee.
2 Operating Rules of the Appointment Advisory Committee
Article 4 – Chair
1. The Committee shall be chaired by one of its members, appointed by such members during their
first meeting.
2. The Chair of the Committee shall have a casting vote in case of equality of votes.
Article 5 – Quorum and deliberations
1. Meetings of the Committee shall be valid if at least three of its members attend the meeting. In
case of written procedure valid votes shall require the votes of at least three members.
2. Opinions shall be adopted by majority of the votes cast.
Article 6 – Meetings
1. Meetings are convened in writing by the Chair and notice is sent together with the relevant
documents not less than one week before the date set for the meeting.
2. The President of the Bank may be asked to attend meetings.
3. Deliberations of the Committee shall take place in camera. The opinions of the Committee shall
be recorded by a secretariat to be organised by the Bank for these purposes.
4. The Committee may meet, vote on and adopt opinions also via written or electronic
correspondence. The Committee may also have recourse to teleconferencing, videoconferencing
or other electronic media on terms that it shall lay down.
Chapter III – Procedure before the Committee
Article 7 – Referral to the Committee
As soon as a Member State presents a candidate to be proposed for appointment as a member of the
Management Committee or as a full member of the Audit Committee, or as soon as the President of
the Bank jointly with the Chair of the Audit Committee present a candidate to be proposed for
appointment as an observer of the Audit Committee, the Secretary General of the Bank shall send that
proposal to the Chair of the Committee.
Article 8 – Request for additional information
1. The Committee may ask the Member State or the President of the Bank and the Chair of the Audit
Committee (in case of Audit Committee observers) presenting the candidate to send such
additional information or other material which the Committee deems necessary for its
deliberations.
Operating Rules of the Appointment Advisory Committee 3
2. In the context of the assessment of the collective knowledge and expertise of the Management
Committee or the Audit Committee pursuant to Article 2.A.4, the Committee shall consult the
President of the Bank for nominations to the Management Committee and the Chair of the Audit
Committee for nominations to the Audit Committee on any potential specific need within the
Management Committee or the Audit Committee at the time of appointment. The Secretary
General shall inform the nominating Member State of any such specific need within the
Management Committee or the Audit Committee at the time of a vacancy.
3. The Committee is authorised to ask for and use any information it deems relevant for the proper
performance of its duties.
Article 9 – Hearing
The Committee may hear the candidate. The hearing shall be confidential.
Article 10 – Addressee of the opinion
1. The Committee shall address its opinion to the Member State presenting the candidate or the
President of the Bank and the Chair of the Audit Committee in case of Audit Committee observers.
2. Should the Member State or the President of the Bank jointly with the Chair of the Audit
Committee (in case of Audit Committee observers), after receiving the opinion of the Committee,
decide to formally present the candidate for appointment, the President of the Bank, the Chair of
the Audit Committee, the Board of Directors and the Board of Governors, as the case may be,
shall be provided with the opinion of the Committee.
Article 11 – Statement of reasons for opinion
1. The opinion of the Committee shall conclude either on a non-objection or on a statement of
reservation with regard to the candidate proposed.
2. The Committee shall give reasons for its opinion. Its opinion shall cover all applicable elements
laid down in Article 2.
Article 12 – Time limitations
1. The Committee shall send its opinion within one month from (i) the receipt of the proposal for
appointment from the Secretary General, (ii) the receipt of any additional information possibly
requested or (iii) the hearing of the candidate, whichever is the latest, and in any event no later
than sixty (60) days from the day the Committee receives the request for its opinion.
2. Should the Committee not send its opinion within this period, the Member State or the President
of the Bank jointly with the Chair of the Audit Committee (in case of Audit Committee observers)
can present the candidate pursuant to Article 11.1 and Article 12.1 of the Statute as well as Article
27.1 and Article 27.6 of the Rules of Procedure.
4 Operating Rules of the Appointment Advisory Committee
Article 13 – Delegation
The Committee may not delegate any of its responsibilities.
Chapter IV – Administrative and Financial provisions
Article 14 – Reporting
The Committee shall report annually to the Board of Governors on its activities.
Article 15 – Financial provisions
Members of the Committee shall be remunerated and compensated for their expenses on the same
basis as members of the Board of Directors.
Article 16 – Modification of the operating rules
The present operating rules are adopted by the Board of Governors.
The Board of Governors delegates any subsequent modification of these operating rules to the Board
of Directors.
Any modification shall be done within the limits set out in the relevant provisions of the Rules of
Procedure and Statute of the Bank.
The Board of Governors will be immediately informed of any modification.
Operating Rules of the Appointment Advisory Committee 5
Operating Rules
of the Appointment
Advisory Committee
July 2021
European Investment Bank
98 -100, boulevard Konrad Adenauer
L-2950 Luxembourg
+352 4379-22000
www.eib.org –
[email protected]
© European Investment Bank, 09/2021 EN
Saatja: CA Secretariat <
[email protected]>
Saadetud: 29.10.2021 11:53
Koopia: CA Secretariat <
[email protected]>; BOIS-WILLAERT Emilie
<
[email protected]>; GEORGES Yannick <
[email protected]>
Teema: Information on amended Operating Rules of the Appointment Advisory
Committee
Confidential
Dear Advisors to the Governors,
We are pleased to send you enclosed the amended Operating Rules (ORs) of
the Appointment Advisory Committee (AAC). May we kindly ask for your
assistance in forwarding the document to your Minister for his/her
information. The amended Operating Rules have also been published on the
EIB Board Portal (see section on Committees reporting to the Board of
Governors).
In July 2021, the Board of Directors has approved two amendments to the
AAC Operating Rules, which remain within the limits set out in Article 16
of the AAC ORs and in the relevant provisions of the Rules of Procedure
and Statute of the Bank.
The amendments to the AAC Operating Rules concern,
· Article 8(2), which was amended to ensure that the nominating
Member State is informed by the Secretary General of any specific need
within the Management Committee or the Audit Committee at the time of a
vacancy; i.e. prior to the AAC assessment process.
· Article 11(2), which was amended so that the AAC shall give
reasons for its opinion when concluding either on a non-objection or on a
statement of reservation with regard to the candidate proposed.
Please note that hard copies of this document will not be delivered by
mail.
Thank you very much in advance for your cooperation.
Kind regards,
Board of Governors Secretariat
General Secretariat / Governing Bodies Department
98-100 boulevard Konrad AdenauerL-2950 Luxembourg
P Please consider the environment before printing this e-mail
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Les informations contenues dans ce message et/ou ses annexes sont
reservees a l'attention et a l'utilisation de leur destinataire et
peuvent etre confidentielles. Si vous n'etes pas destinataire de ce
message, vous etes informes que vous l'avez recu par erreur et que toute
utilisation en est interdite. Dans ce cas, vous etes pries de le detruire
et d'en informer la Banque Europeenne d'Investissement.
The information in this message and/or attachments is intended solely for
the attention and use of the named addressee and may be confidential. If
you are not the intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you have
received this transmittal in error and that any use of it is prohibited.
In such a case please delete this message and kindly notify the European
Investment Bank accordingly.---------------------------------------------
-----------------------