Lennuamet
Kristjan Telve
Keskkonnaagentuur edastab teile e-posti teel järgmise dokumendi:
Piiriülese aeronavigatsiooniteenuse osutamine (13.09.2016 22:26:35 nr
12-38/16/1321-2)
Dokumendil on juurdepääsupiirang:
Alus: Avalik
Algus:
Lõpp:
Lugupidamisega
Sigrid Timm
Koostaja: Tiina Josepson,
[email protected], 666 0930
Palun saata kinnitus kättesaamise kohta e-posti aadressile:
[email protected]
Kristjan Telve Teie 15.08.2016 nr 4.7-11/16/2727-1
Lennuamet
[email protected] Meie 13.09.2016 nr 12-38/16/1321-2
Piiriülese aeronavigatsiooniteenuse osutamine
Lugupeetud Kristjan Telve
Esitame Eesti-Läti piiriülest teenust käsitleva projektdokumendi. Dokument koosneb
tasuvusanalüüsist, teenuse nõuetele vastavuse tagamise analüüsist, tegevuskavast,
riskianalüüsist, ühiskaardi koostamise juhendist, Läti Keskkonna, Geoloogia ja Meteoroloogia
Keskuse aeronavigatsiooniteenuse osutamist tõendavatest dokumentidest.
Dokumendid on koostatud inglise keeles ja kajastavad mõlema aeronavigatsiooniteenuse
osutaja tegevusi.
Lugupidamisega
(digitaalselt allkirjastatud)
Taimar Ala
direktor
Lisa: BSWC feasibility analysis.pdf
EST-LAT cooperation time schedule.pdf
MoU, NAMCON, final.pdf
NAMCon Work Plan 2016.pdf
SWOT analysis for BSWC_2016.pdf
BSWC vastavus nõuetele, ICAO Annex 3.pdf
Template of chart.pdf
BSWC_instructions.pdf
LV-EST chart risk analysis_V2.pdf
ANSP_sertificat_2010_LEGMC.pdf
ISO_sertifikats_ENG_LEGMC.pdf
Tiina Josepson
666 0930
[email protected]
Mustamäe tee 33 / 10616 Tallinn / Telefon 666 0901 / Faks 666 0909 /
[email protected] / www.keskkonnaagentuur.ee
Registrikood 70009540
LATVIAN-ESTONIAN COMMON SIGNIFICANT
WEATHER CHART FOR LOW LEVEL FLIGHTS
FEASIBILITY ANALYSIS
August 2016
1
1 Legal background
According to the 1944 Chicago Convention on International Civil Aviation Annex 3
“Meteorological Service for International Air Navigation” the member states of International Civil
Aviation Organization must provide for aviation users the meteorological information which is
reflected in Annex 3.
In European level, the member states of EU have to fulfil of the Commission Implementing
Regulation (EU) No 1035/2011 of 17 October 2011 laying down common requirements for the
provision of air navigation services.
Estonian Environment Agency (ESTEA) and Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology
Centre (LEGMC) are both certified aviation meteorological service providers and conform to
requirements of abovementioned regulation. Both organizations are under regular oversight of civil
aviation administrations.
LEGMC and ESTEA are members of Nordic Aviation Meteorological Consortium (NAMCon). The
basic document of NAMCon is Memorandum of Understanding signed by all members of NAMCon
in June 2014 (Attachment 1). The consortium consists of aviation service providers of seven
countries: Island, Norway, Denmark, Sweden, Finland, Latvia and Estonia.
The article 3 constitutes the aim and purpose of NAMCon:
The purpose of this MoU is to facilitate a framework in order to explore the possibilities for long
term cooperation between the Parties for the cost-efficient and coordinated supply of
meteorological services for civil aviation within the NAMCon Area. The emphasis shall be improved
quality, efficiency and cooperation in combination with rationality. The cooperation aim to re-use
infrastructure, harmonize services and improve availability of data.
Also, the purpose is that all operational aviation meteorological tasks inside the NAMCon area
should be solved in cooperation between the 7 countries and they must be coordinated to avoid
duplication and unnecessary services.
The NAMCon consortium has to date already achieved cross-border TAF and SIGMET production
between Denmark and Sweden, cross-border SWC production between Sweden and Finland and a
joint aviation weather briefing portal developed by Danish Meteorological Institute.
The current Project is remarkable activity towards the implementation of international
regulations and agreements.
2
2. The analysis of consolidation of the Significant Weather Charts for Low Level Flights of
Estonia and Latvia.
The idea of consolidation of the Baltic significant weather charts has been discussed among the
NAMCon/NordAvimet co-operation for over couple of years. Since the formation of the NAMCon
cooperation within the Nordic and Baltic countries, the BSWC consolidation have been on the
agenda. The first step of realisation of cooperation between LEGMC and ESTEA began in 2016
January.
The activity is reflected in the NAMCon working plan 2016, (Attachment 2), which is approved by
Nordic Steering Committee, activity No 2.1 2.1 Joint aviation weather service production sub-
activity No 2.1.1 Combination of SWC chart production between members is the initial tasks for
common initiative to start compose and issue common in turn the significant weather chart for low
level flights – SIGWX LL.
To further deepen the cooperation in the NAMCon community, the Latvian Environment, Geology
and Meteorology Centre (hereafter LEGMC) and the Estonian Environment Agency (hereafter
ESTEA) decided to investigate the possibility of consolidation their Significant Weather Charts and
to make the production of SIGWX LL charts more harmonized and user friendly. Considering all
abovementioned LEGMC and ESTEA came to the conclusion to start work towards preparation a
common Baltic Significant Weather Chart (BSWC).
3. Description of current situation
LEGMC and ESTEA have been producing SWC for a long time and the charts have been similar
but not identical. There were differences in the chart area, lead times and interpretation of symbols
and lines.
The Latvian and Estonian MET service providers are currently producing significant weather charts
for almost the same geographical area. They are both covering the whole airspace from SFC to FL
100. There are some differences in the content of the maps and in validity times and lead times.
The Latvian chart is issued four times (validity time: 06:00, 09:00, 12:00, 15:00 UTC) with a lead
time of 3 hours and the Estonian chart is issued five times (validity time: 06:00, 09:00, 12:00, 15:00,
18:00 UTC) hours with a lead time of 4 hours per day.
In any case there has to be a harmonisation of the content of the charts and if there was an
understanding concerning the validity times, issuance and lead times the both MET providers came
up with a suggestion for content and content.
4. The planning phase and working arrangement of BSWC
The planning phase is reflected in the time schedule (Attachment 3).
The main activities of planning phase:
the definition of the new product;
identification of differences;
3
common instructions;
training of staff;
implementation of new software;
information exchange plan;
schedule to divide the operational workload;
approval from NSA’s.
The chart areas in the existing charts are similar to each other, but to cover the requirements from
both countries without making the area too large. After discussions decided that the chart area
extended more to the south and approximately 5 degrees to the west comparing to current area of
chart (Attachment 4).
The working group which actually fully implemented the new chart began working at the beginning
of this year.
The working group had face-to-face meetings and teleconferences in between. The working
language of the working group and between the production units is English.
Specialists from both sides have been in the loop during the whole process to harmonise tools and
templates and to determine tools for the dissemination product between MET offices and to the
users. Also the staff, aviation meteorologists on LEGMC and ESTEA, is giving a significant impact
on the development process.
5. Consultations with users
ESTEA conducted a written consultation with users (including the general aviation community)
operating in Estonia in January-February 2016. No negative comments were received.
LEGMC conducted a written consultation with airlines operating in Latvia in January/February
2016. No negative comments were received.
6. Communication and training
The consolidation of working instructions and procedures is other challenging and demanding task
for the working group. Both organisations had working instructions for their own charts. These
instructions are the basis for the new common instructions. The instruction is in English. Each
organisation translates the instruction to their national language where necessary.
7. Operational tools and dissemination methods
For preparation of chart the both organisations are using following weather forecasting tools.
ESTEA: GisMeteo, Messir Vision, SmartMet;
LEGMC: SmartMet.
Dissemination methods are described in instruction.
4
8. Preparation of Contracts
The NAMCon consortium is working under a Memorandum of Understanding, but the operational
cooperation between ESTEA and LEGMC needs a more legally binding contract. A draft of
subcontracting agreement has prepared, stating the general responsibilities of both parties. A draft
of Service Level Agreement (SLA) is also prepared stating the details of the operations, such as
quality control and dissemination methods and also referring to the common working procedures.
9. Benefits
1. The BSWC Project creates an opportunity to modernize the chart layout, visual impression
and meteorological content;
2. The first step towards establishment of back-up office capability between Latvian and
Estonian aviation meteorological service providers;
3. For Estonian aviation users the geographical area of the chart is more comprehensive;
4. For both organizations the saving of working time will give the possibility to use the
forecaster in product development process;
5. Implementation of additional products for low level flights;
6. Experience of operational staff in cross-border cooperation;
7. SWL chart is available to clients earlier (from -1h30min to 3h) than before (LEGMC);
8. There is no duplication of charts for the same time and the same area;
9. Coordinated analysis of synoptical situations;
10. International cooperation (SES, NAMCon, NEFAB);
11. More efficient use of human resources.
10. Conclusion
Considering all abovementioned, the ESTEA and LEGMC decided to start the production of Baltic
Significant Weather Chart for Low Level flights.
11. Attachments
1. Memorandum of Understanding concerning the creation and development of the Northern
Europe Aviation Meteorology Consortium (NAMCon)
2. NAMCon work plan 2016
3. Action plan and time schedule for consolidation Latvian and Estonian SWC
4. Common chart template
5
Action Plan for consolidation of Latvian and Estonian SIGWX LL
Responible
person Responible person Side currently
Activity (ESTEA) (LEGMC) Deadline Deliverables Responsibility responsible Progress Remarks
I Common SIGWX chart Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris Tentative 01.12.2016
1 Formulate the working group Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris WG - forecasters
WG - IT specialists
WG - Legal work
2 Write down the differences in the product Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris EST Done
2.1. Identify the differences EST Done
2.2. Find the solution for problem areas: Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris Done
2.2.1 symbols LAT/EST Done
2.2.2 issue times & periods of validity LAT/EST Done
2.2.3 area LAT/EST Done
2.2.4 Icing and turbulence criteria LAT/EST Done
2,3 Once agreed on map layout, modernize chart layout Janis Veveris 08.04.2016 NEW template LAT Done
2,4 Description on new product Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris LAT Done
2,5 Information about planned changes in 2016 to CAAs Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris May of 2016 LAT/EST Done
Set up common way of producing the chart, common instructions and
3 timetable for division of work LAT/EST
3.1. common instructions in english Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris August of 2016 draft instructions v1 LAT/EST on going
3.2. Procedures for producing SWL chart Natalia Verbenko Janis Veveris August of 2016 LAT/EST on going
Procedures for ANSPs to report for technical/quality problems with SWL
3.3. chart Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris October of 2016 LAT/EST
3,4 Timetable for division of work (draft version) Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris april of 2016 Done
4 Roadmap for the new product to be operational Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris December 2016 LAT/EST on going
October/November of
5 Workshop for staff to discuss new product and common working methods Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris 2016 LAT/EST
6 Apply permissions from CAAs and communication with ANSPs Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris LAT/EST
August/September
6.1. risk analysis (description of changes) and other information Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris 2016 LAT/EST on going
7 Consultations with users Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris January/June of 2016 LAT/EST Done
8 Test the dissemination paths WG-IT WG- IT September of 2016 LAT/EST
9 Legal work Tiina Josepson WG- Legal work LAT/EST
9,1 Service level agreement and subcontractiong agreement Tiina Josepson WG- Legal work August of 2016 LAT/EST on going
9,2 Changes in agreement with ANSPs Tiina Josepson WG- Legal work August of 2016 LAT/EST on going
Natalia
10 Aviation users -Information about changes: Verbenko LAT/EST
10.1. preparation of user guide Janis Veveris 2016 LAT/EST
10,2 LEGMC and ESTEA homepages WG- IT 2016 LAT/EST
10,3 ANSPs briefing home pages, AIP amendments, etc Natalia Verbenko Janis Veveris September of 2016 LAT/EST
11 Choose common comunication tool for forecasters Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris September of 2016 LAT/EST
Janis
Veveris/Kaspars September/october
12 Training of forecasters Natalia Verbenko Olders 2016 LAT/EST
September/october
12,1 preparation of SWL chart Natalia Verbenko Kaspars Olders 2016 LAT/EST
September/october
12,2 Procedures for cooperation and communication with ANSPs Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris 2016 LAT/EST
comunication about synoptic situation and areas with difficult weather September/october
12,3 between EE and LV Natalia Verbenko Janis Veveris 2016 LAT/EST
Start of communications about synoptic situations daily between EE and
13 LV Natalia Verbenko Janis Veveris October of 2016 LAT/EST
14 Implementation of common SWL chart production Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris 1 December of 2016 LAT/EST
15 Monitoring the performance and be ready to intervene Tiina Josepson Janis Veveris Onward
Memorandumof Understanding
concerning
the creation and developmentof the Northern Europe Aviation
MeteorologYConsortium(NAMCon)
Preamble
Consideringtherestructuringof the Europeanairspacein a Single EuropeanSky and
the creationof FunctionalAirspaceBlocks(FAB).
Consideringthat five out of sevenPartiesare designatedfor aviation meteorology
servicesfor their own country.
Consideringthe SES2+andthe possibilitiesof costefficient,improvedandharmonized
services.
servicesfor civil aviation,includingmeteorological
Taking into accounlthe SMHI-DMI cooperationin the DK/SE FAB and the creationof
NEFAB.
NAMCon shall cover the combinedareaof Sondrestrom(exceptSoutherntip of
Sondrestrom FIR, southof 63"30'NaboveFL195,whereMET servicesaredeliveredby
Canada),Reykjavik,Bodo Oceanic,Norway,Kobenhavn,Sweden,Riga,Tallinn and
FinlandFlight InformationRegions(FIRs)(theNAMCon Area).
NAMCon shall improvethe efficiency,reliabilityand accessto aviationweather
productsand servicesfor airspaceusersin Northern Europeand improve the position of
its membersin the future marketfor weatherservices
2 Parties
The DanishMeteorologicalInstitute(DMI),
the EstonianEnvironmentAgency (EIEA),
the FinnishMeteorologicalInstitute(FMI),
the IcelandicMeteorologicalOffice flMO),
the Latvian EnvironmentGeologyand MeteorologyCentre(LEGMC),
the NorwegianMeteorologicalInstitute (MET Norway)
and
the SwedishMeteorologicalandHydrologicalInstitute(SMHD.
Above mentionedinstituteswill hereinaftercollectivelybe referredto as the Parties.
of I jndentanding
i\,lumurandrur 25April2014
NAl\,lConl.ilestilfl(late
3 Purpose/Aim
The purposeof this MoU is to facilitatea frameworkin orderto explorethe possibilities
for longterm cooperationbetweenthe Partiesfor the cost- efficient and coordinated
supplyof meteorologicalservicesfor civil aviationwithin the NAMCon Area. The
emphasisshallbe improvedquality,efficiencyandcooperationin combinationwith
rationality. The cooperationaim to re-useinfrastructure,harmonizeservicesand
improveavailabilityof data.
The future provision of servicesunderthe NAMCon nameshall be regulatedin a
CooperationAgreementbetweenthe Parties
4 The Consortium
The consortiumis initiated by the Nordic MeteorologicalDirector's Meeting (NMD)
who handedover the responsibilityto the NordMet SteeringCommittee(NOSC) to
function as the SteeringGroup for the Consortium.The Termsof Referenceis attached
to this MoU asAppendixA.
The ConsortiumStrategyoutlinesthe key operatingprinciples and objectivesof the
Consortium.The projectsand work packagesof the consortiumare presentedin
separateProjectPlans.NOSC authorizesthe work and approvesthe reportsof
NAMCon. NOSC may delegatetasksto be performedby the NordAviMet group or the
ConsortiumManager.The Chair of NOSC actsasthe Executiveof NAMCon.
The ConsortiumManageris appointedby NOSC baseda separateTerms of Reference
and a VacancyNotice openfor all employeesof NAMCon members.The Consortium
Managershall remain an employeeof his/herparentorganizationwith separatefunding
by all contributingmembers.The ConsortiumManagerreportsto NOSC and actsasthe
secretaryof NordAviMet meetings.ConsortiumManageris responsiblefor the
developmentand presentationfor approvalof reports,plans, strategies,budgetsand
presentationsrelatedto the work NAMCon. ConsortiumManagerhasthe authorityto
approveand delegatework of developmentprojectsto task teamsand subgroupssetup
to deliver on NAMCon objectives.The ConsortiumManagerfunctionsas the Project
Managerfor NAMCon developmentprojects.
5 Duration
This MoU shall enter into force when it hasbeensignedby the Partiesand shall run for
an indefiniteperiodof time. The MoU shall,however,coverthe time periodfrom the
commencement of the Project.
Shouldthe Partiesagreethat the cooperationneedsto be stipulatedmore specificthis
MoU may be substitutedby a formal CooperationAgreement. This MoU shall,
however,be substitutedby a formal CooperationAgreement,at the very latest,when
the coordinatedprovision of servicesfor the NAMCon Area is started.
6 Gost distribution/sharing
The participationat this stageshall be on the Partiesown account.This includes,but are
not limited to participationin meetings,travel etc.
Commoncosts,suchas costsfor the ConsortiumManageretc. shall be distributedin
accordancewith the following formula:
DMI, FMI, MET Norway and SMHI pays20 o/oeach,
IMO pays l0 %o,and
EtEA and LEGMC paYs5 Yoeach.
Servicessuppliedfrom one Party to anotherPartyto this MoU for national official duty
shall,giventhat it is providedunderNAMCon name,be providedon a costrecovery
basis.
7 Development,informationetc.
The future developmentof the cooperationstipulatedin this MoU will be decidedby
NordMET and/orNOSC.
Transparencyand confidentiality
EachPartywill haveobligationsundertheir nationallegislationregardingPublic Sector
Information.The majority of informationexchangedin this Projectwill, as a main rule,
be Publiclnformation.
The Partieswill, in accordancewith the party'snationallaws,keepcompletely
confidentialthe ConfidentialInformation disclosedby the otherparty, and shall not
publish,disseminate, distribute,disclose,sell,assignor otherwisemakeuseof any
ConfidentialInformation of the otherparty exceptin connectionwith and in
considerationfor the cooperationstipulatedin this MoU.
For the purposeof this Agreement,ConfidentialInformation shall meaninformation
'Confidential' or, basedon
exchangedbetweenthe Partiesthat is explicitly markedas
the natureof the information, if it is apparentfor the receivingParty that the exchanged
informationis of delicatenature.
Eachparty'sshallnot be liablefor breachof this obligationwith respectto the
ConfidentialInformation if the party can documentthat: (i) it was in the public domain
at or subsequentto the time it was communicatedto the receivingparty by the
disclosingpartythroughno fault of the receivingparty;(ii) it was rightfully in the
receivingparfy'spossession free of any obligationof confidence;(iii) it was developed
by employeesor agentsof the receivingparty independentlyof and without referenceto
any informationcommunicatedto receivingparty by disclosingparty; or (iv) the
communicationwas in responseto a valid order by a court or other governmentalbody,
or was otherwiserequiredby law.
9 IPR
NAMCon membersshall retainthe IntellectualPropertyRights for the information
providedto NAMCon purposes.Any productsdevelopedpurely for NAMCon purposes
shallremainthe propertyof the Consortium.All Partiesshallhavean exclusiveand
unrestrictedlicenseto any productsdevelopedthroughNAMCon for any purposes.
10 Miscellaneous
10.1 Amendments
Any amendmentsor alterationsto this MoU shall be in written form and signedby the
Partiesin orderto be valid.
10.2 Language
The languageof this MoU shall be English. Shouldthe MoU appearin translationsto
other languagesthe English versionshall prevail beforethe translations.
10.3 Disputes
Any disputesbetweenthe Partiesconcerningthis MoU, its interpretationor the
cooperationstipulatedherein shall be solvedamicablythroughnegotiationsbetweenthe
Parties'representatives in NOSC. If they cannotagreeon a solutionthe matter shall be
referredto the Director Generalsof the concernedPartiesfor final settlement.
This Memorandum of Understanding has been executed in seven originals of which the
Parties have taken one each.
In Oslo, Norway on 28 April2014
F\'rr
,"r.,rl.4esrc-l
11,* W tnI
I
d"nfu,{ry/ A* fu fr,t'to
t*nt"tr
NAMCON WORK PLAN 2016
Version 1.1
5 February 2016
Page 1 of 16
The annual work plans for the development work towards the vision, mission and strategic objectives
of NAMCon are derived from the approved NAMCon Strategic Plan 2015-2019. This Work Plan is
developed by the NordAvimet group and proposed for approval to the NORDMET Steering Committee
(NOSC).
2. NAMCon cooperation
1. NAMCon is the best provider of
increases efficiency, innovation 3. NAMCon is an inspiring
meteorology services for aviation
and provides added value to its community
customers in Northern Europe
members
1.1 Harmonised products and 2.1 Joint aviation weather service 3.1 Exchange of personnel and
production processes production ideas
1.2 Backup of service provision
2.2 Consolidated development of 3.2 Competitive advantage from
capabilities between forecast
products and services new ideas
centres
1.3 Common quality and safety 2.3 Coordinated marketing and
management and staff representation
competency principles for service
provision
Figure 1: NAMCon Strategic Objectives and Work Packages
And the corresponding Activities under each Work Package for 2016 are:
1.1.1 Common NAMCon 1.2.1 Development of 1.3.1 Joint AMP
1.1.2 Development of 1.2.2 Feasibility studies 1.2.3 Backup
manual for generic legal framework Competencies
joint production process for quantification of arrangement
interpretation of and agreements for Assessment Framework
descriptions benefits and risks implementation projects
international regulation service provision on-going development
1.3.2 Joint TAF 1.3.3 Harmonisation of
2.1.1 Combination of 2.1.2 Common civil
Verification System QMS practices and 2.1.3 Cross-border TAF 2.1.4 Joint specialised
SWC chart production aviation weather
Maintenance and development of joint production product generation
between members briefing portal
Development quality principles
2.2.3 Development,
2.1.6 Regional 2.1.7 Virtual regional 2.2.1 Development of 2.2.2 Development of
2.1.5 Cross-border validation and
4DWxCube (MET-GATE- natural hazards warning automatic SWC LLF production system
SIGMET production verification of reliable
NORTH) centres for aviation production tool for NAMCon region
AUTO-TAF
2.2.4 Joint a) 2.3.2 Joint aviation
development of weather 2.2.5 Dissemination of 2.3.1 NAMCon weather service 3.1.1 Enhanced mobility 3.1.2 Register and
production tools & b) OPMET information in Consortium marketing and of staff within NAMCon process for collection of
research on aviation GML format (IWXXM) Management communications member NMHSs issues, risks and quality
weather management strategy
3.2.2 Joint education and
3.2.1 Joint innovation
training initiatives
process development
Figure 2: NAMCon Activities for 2016. Activities highlighted in green are activities that will be implemented in
2016, the activities in orange as initiated as required and the activities highlighted in red are not foreseen to be
started in 2016.
Page 2 of 16
PRIORITY PROJECTS
1. Joint SWC production between Estonia and Latvia – Activity 2.1.1
2. Production of EKVG TAF moved from DMI to MET Norway or IMO – Activity 2.1.3
3. Greenland SIGMET watch & production moved from DMI to IMO – Activity 2.1.5
4. Bodø Oceanic FIR watch & production moved from MET Norway to IMO – Activity 2.1.5
5. Volcanic Ash SIGMETs for the NAMCON region produced jointly by IMO and MET Norway –
Activity 2.1.5
6. Enabling operational backup between all NAMCon MWOs for SIGMET and TAF – Activity
1.2.3
7. Operational SIGMET cross-border coordination – Activity 2.1.5
8. Common TAF production portal – Activity 2.2.4.a
9. Potential common LLF production for all NAMCon countries – Activity 2.2.2
10. TAF and SIGMET manual for NAMCon countries – Activity 1.1.1
ACTIVITIES
1.1 Harmonised products and production processes
Harmonisation is a key requirement for regional service provision and contributes directly to the
consistency of information received by the airspace users. NAMCon carries out activities aiming at
having a common process and understanding of regulatory requirements in the services and products
produced by its members.
1.1.1 Common NAMCon manual for interpretation of international regulation
A. Description of work
This work is carried out in order to improve harmonisation of service delivery based
on the common international requirements from ICAO and EASA/EU. The work shall be based
on the valid legislation and international regulation as reflected by the operational practices
and airspace user needs in each country. A working group will draft the manual with face-to-
face meetings and teleconferences. This project is a priority project for NAMCon in 2016.
B. Deliverables
Joint NAMCon production manual based on existing EU and international regulation, including
the following products
TAF
SIGMET
C. Timetable
Completed by end 2016
D. Team Responsible for Work
Team Leader: Anette Levin / SMHI
Team Members: Simo Neiglick / FMI, Janis Veveris/LVGMC, Majken Demant / DMI, Natalia
Verbenko/ESTEA, Björn Sævar Einarsson/IMO, Reidun Holmøy/MET Norway
E. Resource requirement
450h
1.1.2 Development of joint production process descriptions
A. Description of work
Page 3 of 16
This work is carried out to develop a joint production strategy for the NAMCon area
and to consider the overall view of service provision regionally, the basis of the cooperation,
future scenarios of service provision, role of regional centres, service descriptions and
processes and the required feasibility studies for quantification of benefits and risks associated
with the aforementioned considerations.
B. Deliverables
Description of current production processes of TAF, SIGMET and low-level forecast
including system architecture and descriptions of work
Consider the overall view of service provision regionally, the basis of the cooperation,
future scenarios of service provision, role of regional centres, service descriptions and
processes
Cost-benefit analysis, risk assessment
C. Timetable
Description of current production processes available by Apr 2016
D. Team Responsible for Work
Team Leader: Ole O. Kristensen/DMI
Team Members: Jarkko Hirvonen/FMI, Janis Veveris/LVGMC, Anna Karin Åqvist/SMHI, Tiina
Josepsson/ESTEA, Björn Einarsson/IMO, Hans Henrik Fremming/MET Norway
E. Resource requirement
150h
1.2.1 Development of generic legal framework and agreements for service provision
A. Description of work
This work is carried out to assist the NAMCon efforts for cross-border cooperation and
joint production of aviation weather services.
B. Deliverables
The group shall consider the following questions
Is a NAMCon legal status needed to avoid issues with anti-competition law
Can NAMCon be developed into a Joint Venture between the participating NMSs
Role of non-designated members
Sub-contracting agreements for cross-border cooperation for backup of services
Administration/legal issues for NAMCon portal, shifting responsibility between MWOs
for SIGMET
New membership requests to NAMCon, e.g. LGS and Lithuania
C. Timetable
By the end of 2016
D. Team Responsible for Work
NOSC LECO Team
E. Resource requirement
300h
1.2.3 Backup arrangement implementation projects
A. Description of work
Page 4 of 16
A major effort is expected in this activity in 2016. The work will focus on creating the
technical and organizational capability for the operational backup of service delivery between
NAMCon members. The work will be centred on SIGMET and TAF capability and as a result of
this work; each NAMCon MWO should have an operational backup ability to another NAMCon
member MWO.
B. Deliverables
Technical capability in place between MWOs to issue and disseminate SIGMET and TAF
messages
Forecasters trained on the conditions of MWO to be backed up
Priority lists per member on the products to be delivered in case a backup is needed
Service level agreements to describe the backup process
C. Timetable
Completed by end 2016
D. Team Responsible for Work
Team Leader: Majken Demant/DMI
Team Members: Jarkko Hirvonen/FMI, Janis Veveris/LVGMC, Anette Sang/SMHI, Natalia
Verbenko/ESTEA, Björn Einarsson/IMO, Hans Henrik Fremming/MET Norway
E. Resource requirement
600h
1.3 Common quality and safety management and staff competency principles for service
provision
Managing quality and safety are required practices for MET service providers and by harmonising
these procedures, NAMCon can further enhance the harmonisation of its service provision and
improve on quality management through best practices and peer review.
1.3.1 Joint AMP Competencies Assessment Framework on-going development
A. Description of work
This work is towards the on-going development and deployment of the joint AMP
competencies assessment framework. The work will ensure comparable competency
requirements between NAMCon members and improve the exchange of personnel between the
different services.
B. Deliverables
Develop and carry out assessments of competency assessors in member institutions
C. Timetable
By the end of 2016
D. Team Responsible for Work
Team Leader: NN
Team Members: Antti Pelkonen/FMI, Janis Veveris/LVGMC, Majken Demant/DMI, Natalia
Verbenko/ESTEA, Björn Einarsson/IMO, Knut Restad/MET Norway Per-Ove Ganerlöv/SMHI
E. Resource requirement
150h
Page 5 of 16
1.3.2 Joint TAF Verification System Maintenance and Development
A. Description of work
This work is a continuation of the development of a joint TAF verification system
currently operational at FMI. The work follows a separate long-term development roadmap to
constantly improve the system. Close collaboration with the group on Annex 3 TAF
interpretation manual.
B. Deliverables
Improved functioning of the TAF verification system
1. Forecaster-specific results available
2. Use of the changeability index in verification
3. Annual, monthly and daily statistics
4. How to consider COR, CNL and AMD TAFs
5. Improving PROB groups in the verification
6. Integration / information on the NAMCon portal (2016+)
Written report on progress
C. Timetable
Reports early April and late September each year
D. Team Responsible for Work
Team Leader: Tomas Fyrby/SMHI
Team Members: Tero Koivunen/FMI, Mads C. Jessen/DMI, Natalia Verbenko/ESTEA, Björn
Sævar Einarsson/IMO, Jürgen Schulze/MET Norway, Sintija Moldengauere / LEGMC, Jukka
Raittila/FMI
E. Resource requirement
780h
1.3.3 Harmonisation of QMS and SMS practices and development of joint quality principles
A. Description of work
This work is carried out to ensure a comparable level of quality within NAMCon for
service provision and to harmonise quality and safety processes in view of any joint
production efforts. In 2016, the work will concentrate on Safety Management Systems (SMS)
and risk management methods.
B. Deliverables
Collection of risk management methodology in place in member institutions
C. Timetable
By the end of 2016
D. Team Responsible for Work
Team Leader: Knut Restad/Met Norway
Team Members: Majken Demant/DMI, Tero Lassila/FMI, Annette Sang/SMHI, Björn Sævar
Einarsson /IMO, Tiina Josepson/ESTEA, Janis Veveris/LVGMC
E. Resource requirement
150h
2.1 Joint aviation weather service production
Page 6 of 16
The joint production of services to airspace users is at the heart of the NAMCon cooperation. The
consortium will continue with key projects showcasing the value of the cooperation, thereby reducing
costs and improving mutual backup capacity between members.
2.1.1 Combination of SWC chart production between members
A. Description of work
This activity includes all separate projects aiming for the joint production of significant
weather charts between members. The activity will be further divided into subtasks depending
on the individual members involved in the work. Work includes the identification of
differences in the products, joint proposal for a common product, end user consultation,
regulator approval, staff training and operational start of joint production.
B. Deliverables
1. Between ESTEA and LEGMC
2. Combination of the SMHI/FMI NSWC and MET Norway chart production
3. Combination of the SMHI/FMI NSWC and DMI chart production
Written report on progress
C. Timetable
EST-LAT by 2016
SWE-FIN-NOR by 2017
SWE-FIN-DEN by 2017
D. Team Responsible for Work
Team Leader: Janis Veveris/LEGMC
Team Members: Tiina Josepson/ESTEA, Hans Henrik Fremming/MET Norway, Ole
Kristensen/DMI
E. Resource requirement
450h
2.1.2 Common civil aviation weather briefing portal
A. Description of work
Further development and maintenance of the joint NAMCon Briefing Portal for
airspace users including additional data feeds and products based on the separate detailed
project plan developed by DMI.
B. Deliverables
NAMCon Aviation Weather Briefing portal development
Written report on progress
C. Timetable
Upgrade in 2016
D. Team Responsible for Work
Team Leader: Anne Marie Munch Jørgensen/DMI
Development team by DMI
E. Resource requirement
1000h
Page 7 of 16
2.1.3 Cross-border TAF production
A. Description of work
The activity is linked to 1.1.2 and 1.2.1 and should work in parallel to forward the
work. For 2016, the consortium has identified the EKVG TAF currently produced by DMI as a
cross-border initiative.
B. Deliverables
Handover, necessary backup procedures, training and technical development to move EKVG
production from DMI to MET Norway.
C. Timetable
By end of 2016
D. Team Responsible for Work
Team Leader: Reidun Holmøy/MET Norway
Team Members: Majken Demant/DMI
E. Resource requirement
450h
2.1.5 Cross-border SIGMET production
A. Description of work
This activity aims at the realisation of regional SIGMET provision and the necessary
steps to achieve that goal. The team shall develop guidance and operational practices for
improved coordination across borders, common SIGMET authoring tools and a virtual SIGMET
office with a single view and edit functions of all valid SIGMETs in the NAMCon area. The team
shall identify necessary development work to and begin work where possible in order to have
a harmonised warning provision system for NAMCon. Work is connected to action 2.1.7, 1.1.1
and 1.1.2 and should be handled in close coordination.
Two shifts over oceanic FIRs are envisaged, moving SIGMET responsibilities to Iceland,
which already watches over large ocean areas for SIGMETs and one joint NAMCON-wide
forecasting responsibility for Volcanic Ash SIGMETs to be produced from IMO are envisaged.
B. Deliverables
1. SIGMET coordination between all NAMCon countries and the UK Met Office operational
2. Greenland SIGMET watch & production moved from DMI to IMO
3. Bodø Oceanic FIR watch & production moved from MET Norway to IMO
4. Volcanic Ash SIGMETs for the NAMCON region produced jointly by IMO and MET
Norway
Written reports on progress
C. Timetable
2016-2017
Written report on progress
D. Team Responsible for Work
Team Leader: Hans Henrik Fremming/MET Norway
Team Members: Anu Lång/FMI, Björn Sævar Einarsson/IMO, Maria Lundblad/SMHI, Ole O.
Kristensen/DMI, Janis Veveris/LEGMC, Tiina Josepson/ESTEA
E. Resource requirement
Page 8 of 16
800h
2.1.6 Regional 4DWxCube (MET-GATE-NORTH)
A. Description of work
This work is essential to create a joint database for the exchange of MET Objects and
GML messages for use by production in NAMCon member institutes and for customers. The
MET-GATE-NORTH shall be a database with all OPMET information in IWXXM format and the
MET Objects created by LLF, SWC and SIGMET production systems used by members. The
work will be strongly linked to the NAMCON SESAR Deployment Project foreseen to be
implemented 2017-2020.
B. Deliverables
Development project plan including resource requirement and timetable available
C. Timetable
By the end of 2016
D. Team Responsible for Work
Team Leader: Roope Tervo / FMI
Team Members:
E. Resource requirement
300h
2.2 Consolidated development of products and services
The NAMcon production system should in the years ahead be prepared to deliver weather data in
digital form to the MET-GATE in a SWIM-compliant architecture. Therefore, the production tools
should be able to store all products as digital information layers. Besides preparing for the SWIM era,
there are several benefits of having the products in digital format. The digital format opens up
possibilities for more automatisation and information layers that are stored when making one product
could be used to produce other products. In addition, it will be possible to offer a very dynamic self-
briefing solution on the portal.
The aim of this work is to develop a concept for a common digital production system for NAMCon. The
system will be semi-automatic, where as much information as possible is produced automatically as
long as the quality is not compromised. The concept can be adopted in the development of the
following NAMCon products: LLF production system, Significant Weather Chart, SIGMET and other
weather warnings and natural hazard warnings. TAF production and various other products should
also be considered.
2.2.1 Development of automatic SWC production tool
A. Description of work
This work is carried out to improve cost efficiency and production capabilities in
NAMCon members. The work is dependent of the work done in 2.2.2, 2.1.1, 1.2.1 and 2.1.6. The
system shall be designed in such a way that every NAMCon member can produce SWC for any
part of the NAMCon area, and such that the end product is visually identical independent of
where it is produced. The work will be strongly linked to the NAMCON SESAR Deployment
Project foreseen to be implemented 2017-2020.
B. Deliverables
Page 9 of 16
Definition of data exchange format to enable the exchange of MET objects created for the SWC
charts between members
Database of SWC MET objects in cooperation with 2.1.6
C. Timetable
Data exchange description available by end of 2016
D. Team Responsible for Work
Team Leader: Knut Restad/MET Norway
Team Members: Lars Unnerstad/SMHI, Klaus Haikarainen/FMI, Mikko Visa/FMI, Mads
Jessen/DMI
E. Resource requirement
160h
2.2.2 Development of LLF production system for NAMCon region
A. Description of work
This work is carried out to improve low-level forecast quality, cost efficiency and
production capabilities in NAMCon members. The work builds on the existing work carried out
by the DK-SE consortium led by SMHI. The system shall operate regardless of national and FIR
borders and produce GAMET messages from a graphical interface for the NAMCon area. The
work is connected to work carried out in actions 2.2.1 and 2.1.1. The work will be strongly
linked to the NAMCON SESAR Deployment Project foreseen to be implemented 2017-2020.
B. Deliverables
New LLF system for the production of graphical and text-based products for low-level area
forecasts and warnings in use by all NAMCon members
C. Timetable
Production system operational and in use by DMI and SMHI
Transition plans for the implementation of the LLF forecast in the other five NAMCON
members
D. Team Responsible for Work
Team Leader: Peter Karlsson/SMHI
Team Members: Mikael Carlborg/SMHI, Daniel Thorgersen/SMHI, Lars Unnerstad, Emilie
Hörnqvist/SMHI, Mads Jessen/DMI, Jesper Olsson/DMI, Klaus Haikarainen/FMI
E. Resource requirement
1000h
2.2.4.a Joint development of weather production tools
2.2.4.b Joint research on aviation weather phenomena
A. Description of work
a. To combine the development teams working on aviation products in order to avoid
overlap of development effort on aviation weather production systems and to coordinate
development resources. The work will be strongly linked to the NAMCON SESAR Deployment
Project foreseen to be implemented 2017-2020.
b. To bring together the aviation research experts from member institutions to develop
a coordinated research approach to icing, turbulence, nowcasting, NWP, freezing precipitation,
fog, visibility and low clouds
Page 10 of 16
B. Deliverables
a. Development
Survey of what tools would be available for the consortium, what development is
currently going on and planned in terms of production tools in the member
countries
Joining current development resources and work where needed
Plan for joint development of production systems in connection with action 1.1.2
Implementation of the joint TAF production portal as developed by SMHI
b. Research
Survey of existing research benefiting aviation weather service provision (e.g. fog,
freezing phenomena, post-processing, visibility, gusts, lightning strike risk for
airplanes) carried out in member countries
Proposal for a joint aviation weather research plan to be incorporated in the 2017
Work Plan
C. Timetable
Ongoing, reports in April and September
D. Team Responsible for Work
a. Development
Team Leader: Audun Christofferson/MET Norway
Team Members: Klaus Haikarainen/FMI, Lars Unnerstad/SMHI, Majken Demant/DMI, Ingvar
Kristinsson/IMO, Henri Kaukver/ESTEA, Juris Braucs /LEGMC
b. Research
Team Leader:
Team Members: Juha Kilpinen/FMI, Andreas Luhamaa/ESTEA, Lise S. Graf and Knut Helge
Midtbø/MET Norway, Jaakko Nuottokari/NAMCon, NN/SMHI, Ingvar Kristinsson/IMO,
NN/DMI
E. Resource requirement
640h
2.2.5 Dissemination of OPMET information in GML format
A. Description of work
This work is carried out to ensure future compatibility with the IWXXM data format
moving into digital product delivery considering the IWXXM implementation deadline of
November 2018. The work will be strongly linked to the NAMCON SESAR Deployment Project
foreseen to be implemented 2017-2020.
B. Deliverables
IWXXM(GML) OPMET translator
Data models for SWC and LLF in GML
C. Timetable
Work completed by 2018
D. Team Responsible for Work
Team Leader: Roope Tervo / FMI
Team Members: Kim R. Rasmussen/DMI, Juris Braucs /LEGMC, Peter Karlsson/SMHI
Vigfús Gíslason/IMO
Page 11 of 16
E. Resource requirement
320h
2.3.1 NAMCon Consortium Management
A. Description of work
Consortium management includes the work of the Consortium Manager and related
meetings of the NordAvimet and its members including travel, website, social media and
outreach activities with the aim of progressing the NAMCon objectives according to its
approved strategy. In 2016, a special focus will be on SESAR Deployment Project management
and managing the cross-border initiatives.
B. Deliverables
Progress Reports ahead of NOSC meetings
NordAvimet meeting minutes
Annual Financial Report
Work Plans
Presentations
Website
Social media outreach
C. Timetable
Ongoing with regular deliverables
D. Team Responsible for Work
NAMCON Executive: Jussi Kaurola/NOSC Chair
Consortium Manager: Jaakko Nuottokari/FMI
NordAvimet Members: Tiina Josepsson/ESTEA, Ole O. Kristensen/DMI, Søren
Broderssen/DMI, Kari Österberg/FMI, Jarkko Hirvonen/FMI, Björn Sævar Einarsson/IMO,
Janis Veveris/LEGMC, Hans Henrik Fremming/MET Norway, Knut Restad/MET Norway, Anna
Karin Åqvist/SMHI, Maria Lundblad/SMHI, Anette Sang/SMHI
E. Resource requirement
152 working days
3.2 Competitive advantage from new ideas
People and the continuous development of the expertise of NAMCon staff create excellence. Joining
forces to offer education and training initiatives to the consortium members and especially
operational aviation weather forecasters are major steps towards cost-efficient professional
development.
3.2.2 Joint education and training initiatives
A. Description of work
This work is carried out to improve the access and quality of continuous professional
training courses for operational aviation weather forecasters. Joint education initiatives will
harmonise education standards and promote cross-border dialogue between forecasters and
contribute towards a shared quality standard.
B. Deliverables
Promote and share courses organised by members
Page 12 of 16
Established common database / web portal with best training materials
C. Timetable
Database ready by end of 2016
D. Team Responsible for Work
Team Leader: Björn Sævar Einarsson/IMO
Team Members: Majken Demant/DMI, Antti Pelkonen/FMI, Knut Restad/MET Norway, Björn
Sævar Einarsson/IMO, Anette Sang/SMHI
E. Resource requirement
150h
Page 13 of 16
NAMCon BUDGET for 2016
DETAILED RESOURCE BUDGET PER ACTION FOR 2016
Lead
Action Work(h) Member
1.1.1 Common NAMCon manual for interpretation of international regulation 450 DMI
1.1.2 Development of joint production strategy 150 DMI
1.2.1 Development of generic legal framework and agreements for service provision 300 FMI
1.2.3 Backup arrangement implementation projects 600 DMI
1.3.1 Joint AMP Competencies Assessment Framework on-going development 150 DMI
1.3.2 Joint TAF Verification System Maintenance and Development 780 FMI
1.3.3 Harmonisation of QMS and SMS practices and development of joint quality principles 150 MET Norway
2.1.1 Combination of SWC chart production between members 450 LEGMC
2.1.2 Common civil aviation weather briefing portal 1000 DMI
2.1.3 Cross-border TAF production 450 MET Norway
2.1.5 Cross-border SIGMET production 800 MET Norway
2.1.6 Regional 4DWxCube (MET-GATE-NORTH) 300 FMI
2.2.1 Development of automatic SWC production tool 160 MET Norway
2.2.2 Development of LLF production system for NAMCon region 1000 SMHI
2.2.4 Joint a) development of weather production tools & b) research on aviation weather 640 MET Norway
2.2.5 Dissemination of OPMET information in GML format (IWXXM) 320 FMI
3.2.2 Joint education and training initiatives 150 IMO
Grand Total 7850
The numbers given above are working hours of the concerned experts in their respective workplaces.
The Project Staff of the Northern Europe Aviation Meteorology Consortium (NAMCon) consists experts
appointed by each of the seven NAMCon members.
STAFFING BUDGET FOR 2016
Member Budgeted Staff Contribution (h) Equal Staff Contribution (h)
DMI 1930 1570
ESTEA 590 392,5
FMI 1600 1570
MET.no 1080 1570
SMHI 1640 1570
IMO 420 785
LEGMC 590 392,5
Total 7850 7850
The equal staff contribution is based on the 4-4-4-4-2-1-1 ratio between members as for other costs in
the consortium. True allocation of work may differ significantly from the provided budget.
FINANCIAL BUDGET
Page 14 of 16
Monetary contributions to NAMCon include mainly the costs for the Consortium Manager, travel and a
small discretionary sum for various costs.
NAMCon Budget 2016
Expenses
Unit Cost Total
Units #
A. Work Cost
Consortium Chief (60%) days 152 825,79 € 125 520,08 €
B. Travel Costs
B.1 Flight/Train/Taxi Costs no. 10 500,00 € 5 000,00 €
B.2 Accommodation days 28 180,00 € 5 040,00 €
B.3 Allowances days 32 63,00 € 2 016,00 €
C. Administrative Costs
C.1 Presentation Material 80,00 €
C.2 Hospitality (coffee, etc.) 1 200,00 €
C.3 April NordAvimet mtg 800,00 €
D. Contingency 1 200,00 €
Grand Total 140 856,08 €
Income
Member subscirptions
Percentage
Finland 20% 28 171,22 €
Sweden 20% 28 171,22 €
Norway 20% 28 171,22 €
Denmark 20% 28 171,22 €
Iceland 10% 14 085,61 €
Latvia 5% 7 042,80 €
Estonia 5% 7 042,80 €
Grand Total 140 856,08 €
Total Balance 0,00 €
The increase in the daily unit cost reflects the change in the annual administrative overhead according
to FMI financial guidelines from 2015. The working days have been increased from 128 to 152 to
reflect the foreseen additional work put in the management of SESAR Deployment Projects. There will
also be no paternity leaves planned for 2016 for the consortium manager.
Page 15 of 16
The Consortium Manager foresees the following missions in 2016 related to NAMCon work
1. World ATM Congress 2016, 8-10 Mar 2016, Madrid, Spain (1000€)
2. ICAO METG/26, 20-23 Sep 2016, Paris, France (1200€)
3. NordAvimet meeting, 11-12 Oct 2016, Copenhagen, Denmark (1000€)
4. Eurocontrol/EASA/SESAR/NEFAB/DK-SE FAB meetings as they are confirmed
Additional missions as required by members and work plan
The Member Subscriptions shall be invoiced once every year at the end of the calendar year. A cost
report shall be provided once accounts have been closed for the calendar year, usually in February.
Page 16 of 16
2016
SWOT analysis for Baltic Significant Weather Chart (BSWC)
Strengths Weaknesses
ESTEA ESTEA
Workload is proportionally divided between offices Communication between forecasters (briefing) takes additional time
Office X is backup Office for Y in case of emergency Need to follow continiously and strictly the time schedule (not to forget or duplicate the
Less workload in shifts when no production of SIGWX chart. Possible use chart`s issuing)
the vacated time for other tasks
HIRLAM and other forecast models/output development
LEGMC
Communication between forecasters (briefing) takes additional time
Human factor: forecasters may lose their willingness to coordinate frontal analysis as it
LEGMC is other office responibility to make frontal analysis
Workload is proportionally divided between both offices
Minimized forecaster overload at the end of night shifts
Not complicated work timetable for forecasters
BSWC production schedule (night/day charts) changes every 2 weeks
Opportunities Threats
ESTEA ESTEA
Efficient use of human resources Failure of communication means between ESTEA and LEGMC
Office X is backup Office for Y in case of emergency
The same period of schedule is already in use and being positively
experienced in Finland and Sweden
LEGMC
LEGMC 2 week absence of drawing SWL chart combined with vacation can lead to reduction of
It is possible to plan additional vacations or training events based on SWL preparing skills of forecasters in some rare cases
forecaster load of operational work Forecasters may lose their willingness to coordinate frontal analysis as it is responsibility
Efficient use of human resources of other office to make frontal analysis
2016
Strengths Weaknesses
ESTEA ESTEA
- There is no duplication of charts for the same time and the same area - Change of issuing time (1 hour later) may lead to overload work at the end of shift,
- Coordinated frontal analysis changes in shift duration and/or division the work between two forecasters (f.ex., 09 and
- International cooperation (SES, NAMCon projects). Competitive service. 18 UTC charts)
LEGMC - forecasters need constantly coordinate common understanding of weather situation
- There is no duplication of charts for the same time and the same area (takes additional time for consultations)
- Coordinated frontal analysis LEGMC
- International cooperation (SES, NAMCon, NEFAB), - Change of issuing time (1h 30 min earlier) may lead to significant change in shift roster,
- More efficiant use of human resources leading to overload of the forecaster at the end of night shift. Different shift roster to the
forecaster for aerodromes (regarding GAMET forecast) depending on which office
produce BSWC
- forecasters need constantly coordinate common understanding of weather situation
(takes additional time for consultations)
MET Office X issues night charts (06 and 09UTC),
MET Office Y issues day charts (12, 15 and 18UTC) for the certain period.
Then interchange.
Opportunities Threats
ESTEA ESTEA
- Less workload in shifts when charts are issued by other MET Office - Communication between ESTEA and LEGMC does not work
(forecasters can do short breaks, more time for profound weather analysis) - Depending on staff and weather situation stress increases that can lead to making
- Office X is backup Office for Y in case of emergency mistakes or delays
- International cooperation within NEFAB - Changes in duration of shifts leads to overtime hours, that does not save resources
LEGMC - Cost recovery decreases due to reduction of chart`s output
- More time for forecasters to work outside operational work (international LEGMC
working groups, product development, etc.) - Communication between ESTEA and LEGMC forecasters does not work
- Back-up in case of emergency - Cooperation between LEGMC and ESTEA IT specialists to resolve operationally
technical problems may be difficult
2016
Strengths Weaknesses
ESTEA ESTEA
Availability of backup service provision Decreasing in weather description details over limited areas
Cross-border cooperation (SES, NEFAB, NAMCon) Upper wind and temperature forecast is not a part of chart (is issued as separate product)
Improvement of service provision
LEGMC
LEGMC New SWL chart is based more on model outputs than actual weather conditions (due to
More robust and safe service provision (for back-up purposes) 3h lead time)
Exchange of best work practises between both offices Probably changes in client’s IT systems will be needed as there are time, when new
Cross-border cooperation (SES, NEFAB, NAMCon) SWL chart is distributed, but old SWL chart is valid and in force
The base for closer cooperation between offices in the future BSWC harmonisation with other products for low level flights needed (GAMET)
SWL chart is available to clients earlier (from -1h30min to 3h) than before
Common Baltic Significant Weather Chart (ESTEA – LEGMC) (General analysis)
Opportunities Threats
ESTEA ESTEA
Implementation of additional products for low level flights Insufficient level of IT support
Experience of operational staff in cross-border cooperation Limited resources of communication means for dissimination of specific product
(graphical formats)
Non-conformity of product due to use in MET Offices software with different capacity
LEGMC
Experience of operational staff in cross-border cooperation will increase the LEGMC
cooperation in other areas as well (like SIGMET coordination) Insufficient level of IT support
Remarkable step forward to show that meteorological offices can cooperate Separate product dissemination systems
to avoid duplication of products and increase productivity and safety of the Non-conformity of product due to differences in software versions
services
Analysis of compliance of requirements
Requirement: Annex 3 to the Convention on International Civil Aviation
Meteorological Service for International Air Navigation
Chapter 6. FORECASTS
6.5 Area forecasts for low-level flights
ICAO Annex 3 requirement Baltic SWC Compliance
6.5.1 When the density of traffic operating below Agreed with users Yes
flight level 100 (or up to flight level 150 in
mountainous areas, or higher, where necessary)
warrants the routine issue and dissemination of
area forecasts for such operations, the frequency
of issue, the form and the fixed time or period of
validity of those forecasts and the criteria for
amendments thereto shall be determined by the
meteorological authority in consultation with the
users.
6.5.2 When the density of traffic operating below
flight level 100 warrants the issuance of AIRMET
information in accordance with 7.2.1, area
forecasts for such operations shall be prepared in
a format agreed upon between the meteorological
authorities concerned. When abbreviated plain
language is used, the forecast shall be prepared as
a GAMET area forecast, employing approved
ICAO abbreviations and numerical values;
when chart form is used, the forecast shall be Upper wind and upper-air
prepared as a combination of forecasts of upper temperature:
wind and upper-air temperature, and of SIGWX
phenomena. The area forecasts shall be issued to https://www.northavimet.com/model-
cover the layer between the ground and flight data/weather-maps/
level 100 (or up to flight level 150 in mountainous
FL020, FL025, FL050 and FL100
areas, or higher, where necessary) and shall
wind charts for Northern Europe: Yes
contain information on en-route weather
phenomena hazardous to low-level flights, in
support of the issuance of AIRMET information,
and additional information required by low-level
flights.
SIGWX phenomena: Baltic SWC
6.5.3 Area forecasts for low-level flights prepared Charts are issued for fixed time 06, Yes
in support of the issuance of AIRMET 09, 12, 15, 18 UTC as agreed with
information shall be issued every 6 hours for a local users
period of validity of 6 hours and transmitted to
meteorological watch offices and/or aerodrome
meteorological offices concerned not later than
one hour prior to the beginning of their validity
period.
Appendix 5
4. CRITERIA RELATED TO
AREA FORECASTS FOR LOW-LEVEL FLIGHTS
4.3 Content of area forecasts for low-level flights in chart form
ICAO Annex 3 requirement Baltic SWC Compliance
4.3.1 When chart form is used for area forecasts https://www.northavimet.com/model- Yes
for low-level flights, the forecast of upper wind data/weather-maps/
and upper-air temperature shall be issued for
points separated by no more than 500 km (300 FL020, FL025, FL050 and FL100
NM) and for at least the following altitudes: wind charts for Northen Europe:
600, 1 500 and 3 000 m (2 000, 5 000 and 10
000 ft), and 4 500 m (15 000 ft) in mountainous
areas.
4.3.2 When chart form is used for area forecasts The BSWC issued by either the Yes
for low-level flights, the forecast of SIGWX Estonian Environment Agency
phenomena shall be issued as low-level SIGWX (ESTEA) or the Latvian
forecast for flight levels up to 100 (or up to
flight level 150 in mountainous areas, or higher, Environment, Geology and
where necessary). Meteorology Centre (LEGMC)
according to a predetermined
schedule is SWC LL (low level, SFC
– 10000FT).
Low-level SIGWX forecasts shall include the Yes
following items:
a) the phenomena warranting the issuance of a The chart is kept as consistent as
SIGMET as given in Appendix 6 and which are possible with valid aviation weather
expected to affect low-level flights; messages (SIGMET, GAMET,
and AIRMET, TAF, ARS, METAR)
within the chart area.
b) the elements in area forecasts for low-level SIGWX charts and their content is in Yes
flights as given in Table A5-3 except elements accordance with ICAO Annex 3 –
concerning: Meteorological Service for
1) upper winds and temperatures; and
International Air Navigation (see
2) forecast QNH
Annex 3 Table A5-3 “Template for
GAMET” below and Baltic SWC
work instructions).
ICAO Annex 3 requirement (Mandatory Elements) Baltic SWC
Compliance
Location indicator of FIR/CTA Yes
Identification Yes
Location indicator of aerodrome meteorological office or Yes
meteorological watch office
Name of the FIR/CTA or part thereof Yes
Pressure centres and fronts Yes
Upper winds and temperatures Yes
(https://www.northavimet.com/model-
data/weather-maps/)
Cloud Yes
Freezing level Yes
Forecast QNH Yes
Volcanic eruptions Yes
Example chart
NAMCon BSWC instruction / LEGMC & ESTEA – v1.1
Baltic SWC work instructions
1 Introduction
Area forecasts of meteorological information describing significant weather (SIGWX) conditions
in-flight/en-route may be presented in chart form as a Significant Weather Chart (SWC).
There are 3 different types of SIGWX charts based on their vertical extent:
SWC L (low level), surface-FL100 (FL150 in mountain areas)
SWC M (medium level), FL100-FL250
SWC H (high level), above FL250 (-FL630)
World Area Forecast Centres (WAFC) in London and Washington publish SIGWX charts for
medium and high levels.
The BSWC issued by either the Estonian Environment Agency (ESTEA) or the Latvian
Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre (LEGMC) according to a predetermined schedule
is SWC L (low level, SFC – 10000FT).
SIGWX charts and their content is in accordance with ICAO Annex 3 – Meteorological Service for
International Air Navigation.
The area covered by the chart includes the Baltic countries, Denmark, Southern part of Norway,
Sweden and Finland, Northern part of Germany and Poland, Western part of Russia and Belarus. It
is provided for flights within this area. The BSWC is a nowcasting product with a much shorter
leading time (3h) than the WAFC SWCs (15-21h), which allows the forecast to be based on more
recent observations and model data, as well as offering additional detail within the Baltic sea area. .
The BSWC is issued 5 times a day:
o Issued for fixed time 06, 09, 12, 15 and 18 UTC
o Issued (at the latest): 03, 06, 09, 12 and 15 UTC, respectively (i.e. 3h lead time)
o Describes forecast situation during validity time: 1h30min before and 1h30min after
fixed time
Monitored forecast, i.e. an amended chart, is issued when necessary
o SWC AMD (”amendment”; weather phenomena), or SWC COR (”correction”;
technical)
o The chart is kept as consistent as possible with valid aviation weather messages
(SIGMET, GAMET, AIRMET, TAF, ARS, METAR…) within the chart area
2 Chart description and content
2.1. Cloud description
The content of the clouds when their base is below FL100, it is stated in the following order: cloud
amount, type, and base / top height.
Cloud amount
1. CB cloud amount
In SWL chart all CB clouds shall be indicated using the following abbreviations:
ISOL – isolated, max spatial coverage less than 50% of the area affected;
OCNL - occasional, max spatial coverage 50-75% of the area affected;
FRQ - frequent, little or no separation between adjacent clouds, max spatial coverage greater
than 75% of the area affected;
EMBD – may be used in any (above mentioned) the quantitative characteristics of the cloud,
indicating that the CB clouds are hidden in the cloud layers and they can not be easily
recognized. These clouds can be hidden / not extend outside of the cloud layer.
2. Cloud amount, except for CB clouds
Cloud amount, except for CB / TCU should be described using abbreviations
FEW (1/8-2/8), SCT (3/8-4/8), BKN (5/8-7/8) and OVC (8/8).
Cloud Types
Cloud type must be specified. Only the following types of clouds are indicated SWL chart: AS,
AC, NS, SC, ST, CU, CB, TCU.
The abbreviation "LYR" ("layer" or "layered" - layer or multiple clouds) may be used alone or
in addition with cloud forms: AS, AC, NS, SC, ST.
The cloud base and top.
The height of cloud base and cloud top are indicated by a single number value, in hectofeet
above surface below FL050 and in flight levels above FL050. Cloud top value should be
placed above the value of cloud base. Generally, for low clouds below 1500ft the height should
be indicated at 100ft resolution, for higher clouds at 500ft resolution.
XXX symbol is used, if the height of cloud top is more than 10000 feet.
Significant clouds are:
Widespread1 BKN (including SCT/BKN) or OVC clouds with cloud base below
1000ft;
CB clouds.
The term “widespread” is used to indicate a spatial coverage of more than 75 percent of the area
concerned.
1
(EUR eANP, VOLUME II, PART V – METEOROLOGY, EXAMPLE FOR SPECIFIC
REGIONAL REQUIREMENTS)
Clouds (except for CB)
One cloud group should be used as prevailing in every weather zone. Additional cloud group can be
used, if there is an abbreviation that specify it´s location.
To specify a particular cloud location following abbreviations can be used:
LCA – locally,
COT – at the coastal areas,
VAL - lowlands, over the lowlands,
MAR – over the sea,
LAN – inland,N, NE, E, SE, S, SW, W, NW – specified with one of eight compass directions in
relation to the weather zone.
In every weather zone clouds should be as homogenous as possible.
Example
Figure 1: Example of cloud descriptions.
2.2. Demarcation of weather zones
Weather zones are delineated on the chart using the green scalloped line.
The idea of the weather zones are to divide chart area in weather zones with similar meteorological
conditions based on instrumental meteorological conditions or visual meteorological conditions.
Instrument meteorological conditions (IMC) describe weather conditions that require pilots to fly
primarily by reference to instruments, and therefore under Instrument Flight Rules (IFR).
Visual meteorological conditions (or VMC) are weather conditions in which pilots have sufficient
visibility to fly the aircraft maintaining visual separation from terrain and other aircraft. Visual
flight rules (VFR) are applied.
Basis on demarcation of weather zones typically can be
Areas of widespread
significant precipitation (causing a significant reduction of visibility (below 5 km)),
OCNL/FRQ CB, or OCNL/FRQ EMBD/OBSC CB clouds (with or without
thunderstorm/hail)
Visibility < 5km
Cloud ceiling (BKN or OVC) < 1000ft.
The amount of CB clouds should always be defined by either isolated (ISOL), occasional (OCNL)
or frequent (FRQ), and additionally by embedded (EMBD) or obscured (OBSC) when required
(ISOL/OCNL/FRQ EMBD/OBSC). The base and top of SIGWX CB clouds are marked as with
other phenomena (top over base).
Weather phenomenon causing visibility <5 km could be precipitations, mist, fog, haze or blowing
snow.
Visibility on the chart is always indicated in four numbers (see example below).
Example
Figure 2: Example of cloud and visibility descriptions.
Table 1: Widespread phenomena which are shown on SWL chart and their symbols.
Widespread significant phenomenon Symbol
Rain (RA, +RA), rain showers
Drizzle (DZ, +DZ; often also -DZ)
Sleet (SNRA, +SNRA; often also -SNRA),
showers
Snow (SN, +SN; often also -SN), snow showers
Small hail (SHGS, +SHGS; possibly also –
SHGS)
Snow grains (-SG, SG, +SG)
Freezing rain or Freezing drizzle (-FZRA,
FZRA, +FZRA), (-FZDZ, FZDZ, +FZDZ)
Ice pellets (-PL, PL, +PL)
Hail shower (-SHGR, SHGR, +SHGR)
Moderate or severe icing
Moderate or severe turbulence
Occasional/ frequent or embedded and/or
OCNL/FRQ CB
obscured cumulonimbus (CB) or towering
ISOL/OCNL/FRQ EMBD/OBSC CB/TCU
cumulus (TCU)
Thunderstorm (ISOL/OCNL/FRQ TS[GR],SQL
TS, OBSC/EMBD TS[GR])
Fog
Mist
Haze
Blowing snow
Example
Figure 3: Weather area with rain and EMBD CBs.
2.3. Icing
Only moderate or severe icing conditions2 are forecast on the chart, except for those
occurring in convective clouds, because CB symbol imply moderate or greater icing. Feeble icing is
considered non-significant and is not forecast (no icing symbol on the chart implies NIL ICE or
FBL ICE within the cloud area in question).
Icing conditions may occur in cloud (INC), and/or as freezing precipitation (FZRA, FZDZ).
For icing in cloud the forecasted moderate and/or severe icing layer is indicated with three numbers,
top over base. If the icing top and/or the icing base is the same as that of the associated cloud, icing
symbol can be used alone without specifying the base or the top of the icing.
For freezing precipitation the icing intensity and freezing layer depth should be marked. Freezing
precipitations implies moderate or greater icing).
2
ICAO Annex 3 (18th ed., July 2013) references APP 5-13/table A5-3 (SWC L: icing)
2.4. Turbulence
Only low-level turbulence is indicated on SWL charts.
Widespread moderate or severe turbulence3 is forecasted on SWL chart.
The forecast turbulent layer is indicated similar to other phenomena, top over base, see example
(figure 4).
Figure 4: Example of moderate low level turbulence.
2.5. Surface fronts and pressure centres
Surface weather fronts4 are described using standard cold front, warm front, occluded front
symbols.
Front symbols indicate their position at the surface. Upper fronts are not marked on the chart. The
movement direction of fronts is indicated with an arrow crossing the front in question.
The approximate movement speed of fronts is indicated in knots (kt, not marked) at 5kt resolution,
stationary frontal system is indicated by .
The forecast position of pressure centres is marked with an “X” with the corresponding letter L
(low pressure) or H (high pressure) on top, and their forecast QNH pressure in hPa.
The approximate movement direction of low and high pressures is indicated with an arrow and their
movement speed in knots.
33
ICAO Annex 3 (18th ed., July 2013) references: APP 1-14 (turbulence symbols); APP 2-2/1.3.3; APP 5-13/table A5-3
(SECN I)
4
ICAO Annex 3 (18th ed., July 2013) references: APP 1-14 (front/pressure symbols); APP 5-13/table A5-3 (SECN II)
Notes
QNH is surface air pressure reduced to mean sea level using the ICAO Standard Atmosphere (ISA),
which may differ from model surface pressure (QFF, which is reduced isothermally) by several hPa,
when the conditions differ significantly from ISA (typically e.g. in cold wintertime high pressure
areas).
Also the position of QNH lows and highs may differ significantly from QFF pressure centres,
which should be taken into account when placing the L or H symbols on the chart. QNH is also
quite strongly dependant on altitude, which may create “artificial” QNH lows or highs over
mountains. Such artificial QNH pressure centres should not be marked on the chart.
Examples
Figure 5: Warm front, cold front, occluded front, high and low pressure symbols.
2.6. 0°C level
The 0°C level5 is indicated based on air mass temperatures. If there are multiple 0°C levels at
different heights, the highest 0°C level is shown first, and the sub-zero layer below it is indicated
separately with the lowest 0°C level as its base (e.g. 0°: FL050, <0°: 020-030; see the example
figures below).
“0°: SFC” means that the 0°C level is at (or only a couple of hundred feet above) the surface, or that
T<0°C in the whole troposphere (no 0°C level).
The 0°C level should be a representative value for the area over which it is placed. The heights are
indicated at 500ft resolution.
Notes
Several 0°C level symbols should be placed on the chart based on air mass differences, while
keeping chart readability in mind.
Examples
Figure 6: 0°C level symbol examples. In the right example there are multiple 0°C levels: the highest
0°C level is at FL050, and there’s also a sub-zero layer from 2000ft up to 3000ft.
5
ICAO Annex 3 (18th ed., July 2013) references: APP 1-14 (0°C symbol); APP 5-13/table A5-3 (SECN II); [no 0°C level
should actually be described by NIL, instead of SFC]
Figure7: Sounding examples with the corresponding 0°C level information boxes.
2.7. Strong surface wind speed >30kt
When the mean wind speed (at the surface) within a widespread area exceeds 30kt, the forecast
mean wind speed is indicated on the chart as a numerical value over the area concerned. The
symbol is used both on land and at sea.
The symbol for widespread strong surface wind6 is , where the mean wind speed is
presented in knots.
Notes
Strong surface wind speed is recommended to be forecast at 5kt resolution.
In order to keep the chart as easy as possible to interpret the number of symbols used should be kept
to a minimum (i.e. use 35kt for forecast mean winds of 31-34kt, and for higher wind speeds it can
be rounded up or down depending on the situation and what seems more representative, e.g. round
up when the wind is increasing during/after the chart’s valid time).
The strong surface wind speed symbol does not imply low level turbulence, it only shows the mean
wind speed in an area (possible turbulence is marked separately).
2.8. Volcanic ash and radioactive clouds7
When volcanic ash (VA) is advected into the chart area, a separate VA information text box is
placed on the side of the chart. The VA text box contains the VA symbol, eruption details (volcano
name, location and eruption time), and the text “CHECK SIGMET, ADVISORIES FOR VA,
ASHTAM AND NOTAM FOR VA”.
VA information text box template can be found on the side of the Adobe Illustrator BSWC
template, from where it can be copied onto the chart.
In the case of release of radioactive materials into the atmosphere within the chart area, the
RDOACT symbol is placed at the radioactive accident/source site, and a separate
RDOACT CLD information text box is placed on the side of the chart. The text box contains the
radioactive materials in the atmosphere symbol, source details (location and release time), and the
text “CHECK SIGMET AND NOTAM FOR RDOACT CLD”.
RDOACT CLD information text box template can be found on the side of the Adobe Illustrator
BSWC template, from where it can be copied onto the chart.
6
ICAO Annex 3 (18th ed., July 2013) references: APP 1-14 (strong wind symbol); APP 5-13/table A5-3 (SECN I)
7
ICAO Annex 3 (18th ed., July 2013) references: APP 1-14 (VA & RDOACT CLD text boxes)
Examples
Figure8: An example of the VA information text box to be placed on the side of the chart,
when VA is advected into the chart area.
Figure9: An example of the RDOACT CLD information text box to be placed on the side of
the chart. Additionally the RDOACT symbol is placed on the chart at the radioactive source
site (unless the RDOACT CLD is advected from elsewhere into the chart area).
2.9. Symbols, abbreviations, definitions
LCA Locally
MAR At sea
COT At the coast
LAN Inland
MON Above mountains
VAL In valleys
Note: Phenomena described by any of the above abbreviations generally need not be delineated.
LYR Layered clouds
Widespread Covering >75% of marked area. In some cases can be used if area affected is greater
than 100km x 100km
RDOACT CLD Radioactive cloud
Notes.
All other abbreviations can be found in ICAO DOC 8400 “ICAO Abbreviations and Codes”
3 Chart amendment criteria and corrections
The BSWC should be monitored closely and kept as consistent as possible with valid SIGMET,
GAMET, AIRMET and TAF messages, as well as observed weather (METAR, ARS, AIREP, other
observations) within the chart area during its validity period. In case of significant changes in the
weather situation described on the chart an amended (AMD) chart is issued.
Even though the charts are valid ±1,5h around the chart fixed time, in practice the monitoring
period extends until the next chart is issued, i.e. the monitoring period is -3h…0h of the validity
time or from the time of issue till the next chart is issued.
The chart amendment (AMD) criteria8 are:
1. Appearance of non-forecasted SIGMET phenomena
a. severe turbulence (SEV TURB)
b. severe icing (SEV ICE, SEV ICE (FZRA))
c. thunderstorm (with or without hail) that is
i. widespread (FRQ, SQL TS/TSGR)
ii. embedded within other clouds or otherwise obscured (EMBD/OBSC
TS/TSGR)
d. volcanic ash (VA)
e. radioactive cloud (RDOACT CLD)
2. Appearance of non-forecasted (or no longer forecasted) widespread
a. moderate turbulence (MOD TURB)
b. moderate icing (MOD ICE)
c. visibility <5km
d. BKN/OVC cloud ceiling <1000ft
8
ICAO Annex 3 (18th ed., July 2013) references: 6-3/6.5.1, APP 5-8/4.2, APP 8-4/4.3.1 (SWC L)
3. Appearance of OCNL/FRQ CB, or OCNL/FRQ EMBD/OBSC CB, when no CB clouds had
been forecasted
4. Inaccurate vertical (~5000ft or more) or horizontal extent (~200km or more) of significant
phenomena
The chart issuing office (LEGMC or ESTEA) is responsible for amending any charts it has issued.
The amended chart is identified by the letters AMD in the title of the chart (below the valid time).
In case of a technical error in an issued chart (e.g. typos), a correction chart is issued with an
updated issue time, and identified by the letters COR in the title of the chart (below the valid
time).
Appendices
A1 Example chart
A3 Weather information coordination between ESTEA and LEGMC
Weather information exchange plan
To ensure the consistency between the services provided in both countries and to ensure efficient
and reliable BSWC production despite it being produced in two different MET services it is
essential that exchange of views on aviation weather analysis and forecasts are exchanged regularly
between the partners.
This plan describes the schedule for coordinating weather information:
06 UTC chart:
Issue time 03 UTC. The party in backup mode (not responsible for producing BSWC) will provide
general weather outlook to the party in production mode (responsible for producing BSWC) before
01:30 UTC. The party in production mode will provide the almost ready, preliminary map (in
pdf/.ai, if sending it via email) for comments latest at 02.30 UTC. If no comments are given latest
at 02.50 UTC then the BSWC can be considered as ready for issuance. If there are any comments
they should be dealt with immediately between 02.30-02.50 UTC to avoid late issuance of the chart.
09 UTC chart:
Issue time 06 UTC. General weather outlook should be sent before 04:30 UTC and dealing with the
comments of almost ready map between 05.30-05.50 UTC.
12 UTC chart:
Issue time 09 UTC. General weather outlook should be sent before 07:30 UTC and dealing with the
comments of almost ready map between 08.30-08.45 UTC.
15 UTC chart:
Issue time 12 UTC. General weather outlook should be sent before 10:30 UTC and dealing with the
comments of almost ready map between 11.30-11.45 UTC.
18 UTC chart:
Issue time 15 UTC. General weather outlook should be sent before 13:30 UTC and dealing with the
comments of almost ready map between 14.30-14.45 UTC.
The relevant information is a brief general outlook on visibility, ceiling, SIGWX (ICE, TURB,
FZRA/FZDZ, CB, TS) in your own area for the next chart. The WX outlook can also be
provided in chart form (pdf/.ai).
Occurrence of VA and RADOACT CLD, as well as other SIGMET phenomena, should be notified
immediately. Also if either one of the parties are unable to carry out its responsibility to produce
the BSWC then the other party should be immediately informed and asked if they could start
working as backup to produce the BSWC.
The means of communication can be by Skype, email or telephone.
ESTEA, Tallinn:
Skype: aviamet
E-mail address:
[email protected]
Phone: +372 666 0932, mob. +372 5328 5262
LEGMC, Riga:
Skype: legmc_avio
E-mail address:
[email protected]
Phone LEGMC-Riga: +371 67032638 or +371 67142005
General weather outlook email template
Figure . Editable email template for weather comments in own area. Comments are e-mailed to the
chart producer 4h30min before next chart’s valid time.
Risk analysis for Baltic Significant Weather Chart
Activity/ Hazard / Component of risk Description of risk Risk mitigation measures Additional risk reduction Responsibili
Probability
function Factor of risk measures ties
Level of
Impact
Score
risk
Procedures Instructions for Chart is not comply with 4 2 8 Instructions for preparing, issuing and Communication of ESTEA and Head of
operational staff are international standards (M2) (T1) dissemination of SIGWX charts are in LEGMC focal points once a month. ESTEA and
outdated or absent (ICAO Annex 3, EASA conformance with current ICAO LEGMC
requirements) standards (Annex 3). Review to be Meteorologi
Unimportant
Different offices (Riga or done once a year. cal service
Tallinn) issue the chart in Instructions are approved by Estonian
different mode and Latvian Meteorological Services
Significant weather chart for low level flights (SIGWX SFC – 10000 FT)
Non-compliance with and CAAs.
chart issuing timetable Timetable to be review and approve
every month.
Aviation Meteorological service provision
Equipment Infotechnology and Software for preparing 5 3 15 ESTEA and LEGMC use the same Update of software and/or use of ESTEA,
telecommunications charts is not compliant (M3) (T2) software for preparing charts (Adobe back-up workstations (MESSIR or KEMIT,
with requirements Illustrator) and the same workstation other SmartMet, etc.) LEGMC
Unimportant
(absence of forecasting SmartMet for visualising
fields, software is not meteorological information.
upgrade/update)
Communication`s failure 6 3 18 In the instruction additional to main ESTEA and LEGMC both stationary ESTEA,
Conditional
(e-mail, telephone, fax) (M3) (T2) product distribution channel (e-mail) and mobile phone numbers are KEMIT,
there are also back-up (ftp server) Use available in instruction. In case of LEGMC
alternative (back-up) facilities complete communication failure
according to instruction each office has a capability to
produce SWL chart for themselves.
Use of different 3 4 12 Recommend to use ECMWF and If necessary, weather briefing of MET service
Unimportant
forecasting models can (M2) (T2) HIRLAM models. operational staff to discuss the responsible
lead to distinction in weather situation. for issuing
frontal analysis chart
(due to
timetable)
Communication tools 5 2 10 In the instruction additional to main ESTEA,
Unimportant
and product distribution (M3) (T1) product distribution channel (e-mail) LEGMC
channels are not safe there are also back-up (ftp server) Use
alternative (back-up) facilities
according to instruction
Human Competence of staff Wrong interpretation of 5 1 5 Workshops with operational staff (at Self-improvement (on-line training: ESTEA
resources information due to lack (M3) (T1) least 2 times per year) EUMETRAIN Weather briefings, MET
of competence Training in Regional training centers COMET programm) Service,
Competence assessment (at least LEGMC MET
once per 3 years) service
OJT for 4-6 months (young specialist)
Implemented QMS. Requirements are
in operational instructions.
Unimportant
Non-compliance with Compliance with chart issuing time as Non-compliance cases for LEGMC LEGMC
chart issuing time part of QMS. Every month report is forecasters are recorded as part of
(delayed forecasts etc.) made by LEGMC. monthly error analysis and in
forecaster’s portfolio.
Non-issue of chart due Each office has a capability to produce Other forecasts are available to LEGMC,
to unexpected human the SWL chart themself. The office not users (TAF, TREND). LEGMC issue ESTEA
problems (health, lack of capable of issuing the chart shall GAMET forecast for weather
technical skills, etc.). immidiately inform the partner office. conditions in RIGA FIR
No consistency between Procedure of coordination of forecasts LEGMC,
Meteorological forecasts between offices in their home FIR. ESTEA
issued by different offices
Resources Lack of resources Lack of human resources 3 3 9 This cooperation between MET offices ESTEA,
(M2) (T2) has a potential to avoid duplication of LEGMC
Unimportant
work and to produce forecasts and
use human resources more effectively.
If the users do not need the product,
the offices can stop the production.
Lack of funding (cost 8 4 32 Participation in International ESTEA,
Important
recovery) (M4) (T2) Every year review of aviation projects (e.g. SESAR DP) LEGMC
meteorological servises cost rates